Delirium in the ICU and distress after discharge
Delirium is associated with prolonged intensive care unit (ICU) stay: its early recognition,
treatment and prevention are becoming increasingly important. Scales and evaluation
tools for delirium are becoming more diffuse, but a universal tool has not been defined
yet, and probably delirium underrating still permeates the ICU environment. Spronk
[1] investigated, during daily care, intensivists’ and ICU nurses’ skills in identifying
the presence of delirium in ICU patients. In a 3-month period, all patients in the
ICU for more than 48 h were screened daily for delirium both by attending intensivists
and nurses. The Confusion Assessment Method for the ICU (CAM-ICU) was used as a screening
instrument for delirium. During the study period, 46 patients (30 male, 16 female;
median age 73 years) with an ICU stay of 6 days (range 4–11) were evaluated. CAM-ICU
scores were obtained during 425 patient days. Considering the CAM-ICU as the reference
standard, delirium occurred in 50% of the patients with a duration of 3 days (range
1–9). Days with delirium were poorly recognized by doctors (sensitivity 28.0%; specificity
100%) and ICU nurses (sensitivity 34.8%; specificity 98.3%). Recognition did not differ
between hypoactive or active status of the patients involved. Delirium is severely
underrecognized in the ICU in daily care. These data indicated that more attention
should be paid to the implementation of a validated delirium-screening instrument
during daily ICU care.
The pathophysiology of delirium remains elusive. Neurotransmitters and their precursor
large neutral amino acids (LNAAs) may play a role. Pandharipande [2], exploring this
relationship, evaluated if plasma tryptophan (Trp), phenylalanine (Phe) and tyrosine
(Tyr) levels are independent risk factors for delirium in critically ill patients.
This pilot study investigated whether alterations of these amino acids were associated
with a higher risk of transitioning to delirium in critically ill patients. Plasma
LNAA concentrations were determined on days 1 and 3 in mechanically ventilated (MV)
patients from the MENDS trial, a randomized controlled (RCT) trial comparing an alpha2
agonist versus a gamma aminobutyric acid (GABA) agonist to determine delirium rates,
efficacy of sedation, analgesia and cognitive status after ICU discharge. Three independent
variables were calculated by dividing Trp, Phe and Tyr plasma concentrations by the
sum of all other LNAA concentrations. Delirium was assessed daily using the CAM-ICU
assessment method. The 97 patients included in the analysis had a high severity of
illness. After adjusting for confounders, only high or very low tryptophan/LNAA ratios
(P = 0.0003) and tyrosine/LNAA ratios (P = 0.02) were associated with increased risk
of transitioning to delirium. Older age, higher APACHE II scores and increasing fontanel
exposure were also associated with higher probabilities of transitioning to delirium.
The months following the ICU discharge can be stressful for patients and family. One
of the real problems the ICU survivors face in daily life is the distance between
his/her psychological distress and the relatives’ expectations. A cross-sectional
study of 255 patients and 298 relatives tried to clarify this important aspect [3].
A questionnaire for post-ICU patients, tested 4–6 weeks after ICU discharge, included
hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS), impact of event scale (IES), life orientation
test, ICU memory tool and memory of ICU, technical procedures, pain, lack of control
and inability to express needs. Relatives were assessed for their expectations of
the patients’ memories and psychological distress. Twenty-five percent of the patients
reported severe posttraumatic stress symptoms, IES total ≥35. The levels of anxiety
and depression were significantly higher than in the general population; mean anxiety
was 5.6 versus 4.2 (P < 0.001), and mean depression was 4.8 versus 3.5 (P < 0.001).
Relatives expected more psychological distress, and the relatives thought the patient
was less able to express needs than the patients reported (P < 0.001). Older age,
unemployment, respirator treatment, pessimism, memory of pain, lack of control and
inability to express needs were independent predictors of posttraumatic stress symptoms
(P < 0.01).
Neuro-psychological syndromes often observed in critically ill patients may be induced
by the initial injury, but also by the intensive care treatment itself. Two interesting
reviews dealt with this crucial field: Figueroa-Ramos et al. [4] investigated mechanisms
and manifestations of sleep and delirium in ICU patients. The specific clinical features
of sleep disturbances (fragmentation, increase in light sleep, etc.) are presented,
as well as the most common subtypes of delirium, i.e., the hypoactive and mixed-type
delirium. The physiological background is demonstrated to provide a better understanding
of the mechanisms and factors that contribute to sleep deprivation and delirium, guiding
the development of new methods and models for prevention and treatment of these problems.
Davydow et al. [5] presented a systematic review on depression in general ICU survivors.
Fourteen studies from the literature were eligible, and the median point prevalence
of “clinically significant” depressive symptoms was 28%.
Neither the severity of the disease nor sex nor age was a consistent risk factor,
whereas early post-ICU depressive symptoms were a strong predictor for subsequent
depressive syndromes. These were associated with a substantially lower quality of
life. A multidisciplinary approach involving intensivists, primary care physicians
and psychiatrists could ensure prompt, comprehensive evaluation and treatment, reducing
morbidity and improving ICU survivors’ quality of life.
Head trauma: transfusion and ICP treatment
Bleeding and hypotension are two targets in early head trauma management, mainly when
associated with polytrauma. Transfusion practices have been revisited more than once
in the last decades in trauma victims. The optimal hemoglobin concentration in the
early phase is still a matter of debate. The fact that many actors play a role in
the early treatment of traumatic brain injury, i.e., surgeons, intensivists, anesthesiologists
and neurosurgeons, increases the confusion level. Their attitudes toward transfusion
practices for acute traumatic brain injury have been explored using a survey in US
trauma centers [6]. The aim of the research was to determine whether physician specialty
influences the transfusion threshold in patients with acute severe traumatic brain
injury. A scenario-based, multiple-choice instrument administered was mailed to chiefs
of trauma surgery, chairs of neurosurgery, and surgical and neurosurgical ICU directors
at all 187 US level I centers. The hemoglobin value used as a transfusion threshold
for patients with severe acute TBI in several scenarios as well as opinions regarding
the rationale for transfusion has been evaluated. The response rate was 58% (312/534).
Mean time in practice was 17 ± 8 years, and 65% were board certified in critical care.
Neurosurgeons (NS) used a greater mean hemoglobin threshold for transfusion of TBI
patients than trauma surgeons (TS) and non-surgeon intensivists (CC) whether the intracranial
pressure was normal (8.3 ± 1.2, 7.5 ± 1.0 and 7.5 ± 0.8 g/dl; NS, TS and CC, respectively,
P < 0.001) or elevated (8.9 ± 1.1, 8.0 ± 1.1 and 8.4 ± 1.1 g/dl; NS, TS and CC, respectively,
P < 0.001). All three groups commonly believed that secondary ischemic injury is an
important problem following TBI, but fewer neurosurgeons believed that transfusions
have important immunodulatory effects (25, 91 and 83%, P < 0.001). NS prefer more
liberal transfusion of TBI patients than TS and CC, suggesting that actual practice
may depend largely on which specialist is primarily managing care. The observed clinical
equipoise would justify a randomized trial of liberal versus restrictive transfusion
strategies in patients with TBI.
During the ICU stay, intracranial pressure pathophysiology and its treatment become
an important part of the understanding and care of the TBI patients.
Lavinio [7] explored the relationship between the intracranial pressure-volume index
(PVI) and cerebral autoregulation. The PVI, described originally by Marmarou, can
be used to assess the cerebrospinal fluid dynamics and intracranial elastance in critically
ill brain-injured patients. The dependency of PVI on the state of cerebral autoregulation
within the physiologic range of cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) can be described
by mathematical models that account for changes in cerebral blood volume during PVI
testing. This relationship has never been verified clinically using direct PVI measurement
and independent cerebral autoregulation assessment. PVI and cerebral autoregulation
were prospectively assessed in a cohort of 19 comatose patients admitted to an academic
ICU. PVI was measured injecting a fixed volume of 2 ml of 0.9% sodium chloride solution
into the cerebral ventricles through an intraventricular catheter. Cerebral autoregulation
was assessed using transcranial Doppler transient hyperemic response (THR) test. Fifty-nine
PVI assessments and 59 THR tests were performed. Mean PVI was 20.0 (SD 10.2) ml in
sessions when autoregulation was intact (THR test ≥1.1) and 31.6 (8.8) ml in sessions
with defective autoregulation (THR test <1.1) (DeltaPVI = 11.7 ml, 95% CI = 4.7–19.3 ml;
P = 0.002). Intracranial pressure, CPP and brain CT findings were not significantly
different between the measurements with intact and disturbed autoregulation. Cerebral
autoregulation status can affect PVI estimation despite a normal CPP. PVI measurement
may overestimate the tolerance of the intracranial system to volume loads in patients
with disturbed cerebral autoregulation.
Intracranial hypertension after TBI is still a major cause of mortality and morbidity
in the ICU. Recent randomized, controlled trials have failed to demonstrate any beneficial
outcome from therapeutic treatments such as corticosteroids, hypothermia and hypertonic
saline. Ichai [8] investigated the effect of a new hyperosmolar solution based on
sodium lactate versus mannitol in controlling raised ICP. In a prospective, open,
randomized study in an adult ICU, 34 patients with isolated severe TBI and intracranial
hypertension were allocated to receive equally hyperosmolar and isovolumic therapy
(mannitol or sodium lactate). Rescue therapy by crossover to the alternative treatment
was indicated when ICP could not be controlled. Compared to mannitol, the effect of
the lactate solution on ICP was significantly more pronounced (7 vs. 4 mmHg, P = 0.016),
more prolonged (4th-h ICP decrease: −5.9 ± 1 vs. −3.2 ± 0.9 mmHg, P = 0.009) and more
frequently successful (90.4 vs. 70.4%, P = 0.053). Therefore, acute infusion of a
sodium lactate-based hyperosmolar solution is effective in treating intracranial hypertension
following TBI. This effect is significantly more pronounced than that of an equivalent
osmotic load of mannitol. Additionally, in this specific group of patients, long-term
outcome was better in terms of GOS in those receiving it as compared to those receiving
mannitol. Larger trials are warranted to confirm these early findings.
As a second-tier option for controlling ICP, hypothermia is still a “hot” topic. A
trial for answering the question of the real utility of hypothermia in reducing ICP
and ameliorating outcomes, Eurotherm3235, is going to start soon (http://www.eurotherm3235trial.eu).
The debate between using invasive and non-invasive methods for inducing hypothermia
is still open. In a prospective, international, multicenter clinical trial conducted
in four university hospitals, Sahuquillo [9] evaluated the feasibility, safety and
effectiveness of a new method of intravascular temperature management for inducing
moderate hypothermia (MHT). In a 2-year period, 24 patients with severe head injury
and refractory high ICP were treated with MHT (32.5°C) by intravascular methods. Seventeen
were males and seven females, with a median age of 25 years (range 15–60). The median
Glasgow Coma Scale upon admission was 7 (range 3–13), and the median Injury Severity
Score was 22 (range 13–43). A total of 75% of patients presented a diffuse lesion
in the pre-enrollment computed tomography. Median time from injury until reaching
refractory high ICP was 71.5 h after injury (minimum 14 h, maximum 251 h). Twelve
patients (50%) reached this situation within the first 72 h after injury. MHT was
attained in a median time of 3 h. Pre-enrollment median ICP was 23.8 mmHg and was
reduced to 16.8 mmHg upon reaching target temperature. At 6 months after injury, nine
patients had died (37.5%), six were severely disabled (25%), two moderately disabled
(8.3%) and seven had a good recovery (29.2%). Of the nine patients who died, four
had a rebound of ICP during rewarming, one death was attributed to accidental potassium
overload, two to septic shock, one to cardiac arrest of unknown origin and the ninth
to a pulmonary embolism. Intravascular methods to induce MHT combined with precooling
with cold saline at 4°C appear to be feasible and effective in reducing ICP in patients
with high ICP refractory to first-line therapeutic measures.
ICU-acquired weakness and heat stroke sequelae
Hough et al. [10] investigated the incidence and outcomes of ICU-acquired neuromyopathy
and the role of methylprednisolone in survivors of persistent acute lung injury. They
performed a secondary analysis on 128 patients who survived 60 days or hospital discharge
from the acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) Network RCT study of methylprednisolone
versus placebo for persistent ARDS. Forty-three (34%) of these patients had evidence
of ICU-acquired neuromyopathy, which was associated with prolonged mechanical ventilation
and delayed return to home after critical illness. Treatment with methylprednisolone
was not significantly associated with an increase in risk of neuromyopathy (OR 1.5;
95% CI 0.7–3.2). ICU-acquired neuromyopathy was common among survivors of persistent
ARDS and was associated with poorer clinical outcomes. Limitations of this study preclude
definitive conclusions about the causal relationship between corticosteroids and ICU-acquired
neuromuscular dysfunction, but the association appears less strong than before.
As stressed by Herridge in the accompanying editorial [11], ICU-acquired weakness
is common and consequential, but we still know very little about its risk factors,
pathophysiology, natural history and potential treatment. The very first step should
be to acknowledge that we have not been looking hard enough for this problem and are
currently engaged in clinical practices that obscure our ability to diagnose this
problem.
The issue of ICU-acquired weakness was also addressed by Kesler and co-workers [12]
in a retrospective cohort study of MV patients with status asthmaticus. The study
compared asthmatic patients receiving mechanical ventilation before (n = 96) and after
(n = 74) a clinical practice change in 1995 that markedly restricted the use of paralytics.
Even though the duration of neuromuscular paralysis markedly declined, no significant
difference in the incidence of weakness was observed, highlighting that prolonged
deep sedation remains a risk factor for weakness.
During August 2003, France sustained an unusual heat wave that lasted 9 days and caused
epidemic classic heatstroke. The course of early organ dysfunction in a cohort of
patients admitted to the ICU suffering classic heatstroke has been described by Pease
[13]. Clinical and biological data of 22 patients were analyzed. Median body temperature
on admission was 41.1°C. Respiratory, circulatory, hematological, hepatic and renal
function all deteriorated within the first 24 h of admission. ICU mortality was 63.6%.
Cooling time, serum lactate, serum cardiac troponin I and creatinine were significantly
higher in non-survivors. Early ICU mortality (within 7 days of ICU stay) was due to
multiple organ failure. Late ICU mortality was due to neurological disability.
Hemodynamics
Intensive Care Medicine published several articles on cardiovascular problems and
failure in 2009.
The incidence of right ventricular failure (RVF) in patients with ARDS and its impact
on short-term outcome was assessed by Osman et al. [14]. This is a substudy of the
previously published French Pulmonary Artery Catheter (PAC) study. A total of 145
ARDS patients were included in the substudy. The RVF was defined by the concomitant
presence of: (1) a mean pulmonary artery pressure (MPAP) >25 mmHg, (2) a central venous
pressure (CVP) higher than pulmonary artery occlusion pressure (PAOP) and (3) a stroke
volume index <30 ml/m2. RVF was present in 9.6% of patients. Mortality was 68% at
day 90 with no difference between patients with or without RVF. In multivariate analysis,
PaO2/FiO2, mean arterial pressure, arterial pH, SvO2, MPAP and presence of CVP > PAOP,
but not RVF, were independently associated with day-90 mortality. Although PaCO2 did
not seem to influence RVF in Osman’s paper, it seemed to play an important role in
the development in RVF in 11 ARDS patients in the paper by Mekontso Dessap et al.
[15]. RV function was assessed by transesophageal echocardiography. Compared to low
PEEP, PaO2/FiO2 ratio and alveolar recruitment were increased with high PEEP. Alveolar
dead space remained unchanged. High-PEEP strategies induced both higher PaCO2 levels
[71 (60–94) and 75 (53–84), vs. 52 (43–68) mmHg] and lower pH values [7.17 (7.12–7.23)
and 7.20 (7.16–7.25) vs. 7.30 (7.24–7.35)], as well as RV dilatation, LV deformation
and a significant decrease in cardiac index. The decrease in stroke index tended to
be negatively correlated to the increase in alveolar recruitment with high PEEP.
Although a decrease in vascular tone after cardiac surgery occurs frequently, its
mechanism is unknown. Based on data already published in sepsis, Jochberger and co-worker
[16] evaluated arginine vasopressin (AVP) and copeptin plasma concentrations in patients
with vasodilatory shock after cardiac surgery. Both biomarkers were reduced in the
vasodilatory shock group. Furthermore, except during continuous veno-venous hemofiltration,
AVP and copeptin correlated significantly with each other.
Monge Garcia and co-workers [17] evaluated whether arterial pressure response during
a Valsalva maneuver could predict fluid responsiveness in spontaneously breathing
patients. A 10-s Valsalva maneuver was performed before and after volume expansion.
Arterial response during the Valsalva maneuver seems to be a feasible tool for predicting
fluid responsiveness in patients without mechanical ventilatory support.
The research on cardiac arrest has received a new impulse in the last few years. Carr
and co-workers [18] showed that mortality after in-hospital cardiac arrest had decreased
over 5 years in the US. This result is based on a national sample of US hospitals
identifying patients resuscitated after cardiac arrest from 2000 to 2004. A total
of 109,739 patients were identified. Mortality after cardiac arrest was lower at urban,
teaching and large hospitals.
Evaluation of hemodynamic alterations
Significance of hypotension
Hypotension can be life threatening and is one of the most frequent reasons for requesting
ICU admission. Hypotension is associated with a poor outcome, but the level of hypotension
associated with a poor outcome needs to be determined. Two manuscripts addressed this
issue from different perspectives. Marchick et al. [19] evaluated the impact of non-sustained
(less than 60 min) hypotension in a large database of 700 patients admitted with sepsis
to the emergency department (ED) of a single large urban hospital in the USA. Among
these, 150 developed non-sustained hypotension. Mortality increased from 3.6% in the
general population to 10% in patients with non-sustained hypotension. More severe
hypotension was associated with higher mortality, emphasizing that hypotension, even
when transient, should not be neglected in patients with sepsis.
Dunser et al. [20] evaluated the impact of prolonged hypotension in 274 patients with
septic shock. They collected mean and systolic arterial pressure values from the data
management system and computed the hourly time integral for different threshold values.
They observed a curvilinear association between time spent with hypotension and poor
outcome. However, it was quite surprising to notice that even time spent below the
highest mean arterial pressure tested, 75 mmHg, was significantly associated with
a poor outcome. These results suggest that not only the severity of hypotension, but
also time spent even with moderate hypotension is associated with a poor outcome.
How to predict the response to fluids
Fluids are a key component of the resuscitation of critically ill patients, but excessive
fluid administration should also be avoided. Accordingly, techniques to predict the
response to fluids are crucial. Respiratory induced pulse pressure variations (PPV)
have been shown to predict response to fluids. Unfortunately, PPV is sensitive to
tidal volume (TV) [21], as a TV higher than 8 ml/kg is required. The main reason is
that the respiratory changes in pleural/pericardial pressures are low when TV is low.
Vallee et al. [22] hypothesized that correcting PPV for driving pressure, as evaluated
by plateau minus PEEP, could be better predictive of fluid responsiveness than PPV
alone, even in patients with low TV. In opposition to their expectations, correction
of PPV by driving pressure failed to improve the predictive value for fluid responsiveness
in patients with low TV, whereas it effectively did so in patients with high TV. As
highlighted in the accompanying editorial by Lefrant and De Backer [23], transmission
of alveolar pressure to pleural and pericardial space is altered in ARDS patients
who require ventilation with low TV. Accordingly, respiratory driving pressure fails
to reflect respiratory changes in pleural and pericardial pressures that really drive
the changes in left and right ventricular preload.
Passive leg raising (PLR) can also help to predict the response to fluids [24]. This
maneuver evaluates rapid changes in stroke volume in response to an acute change in
posture. Jabot et al. [25] evaluated whether this maneuver should include PLR only,
without movement of the torso, or whether it should also include a rapid shift in
torso position from 30 to 0°, in addition to raising the legs. The authors decomposed
the movement and reported that PLR and torso inclination were responsible for similar
mobilization of blood from the peripheral to the central compartment, as evidenced
by a similar increase in CO with the two movements. They concluded that PLR should
include inclination of the torso from 30 to 0°.
Devices and techniques
Different technologies can be used to estimate CO. One of the major issues when introducing
a new technology is to evaluate its reliability. As no gold standard exists, the new
device is often compared with existing devices/techniques, and often thermodilution
is used as the comparator. Often these comparisons are made at predefined times, but
one of the major issues is to evaluate whether the technique is able to adequately
track changes. No clear methodology exists for this purpose. In a special article,
Squara et al. [26] discussed the various aspects needed to evaluate new devices. In
addition to accuracy and precision (static estimates), response time and accuracy
of estimation of amplitude of the response (dynamic estimates) should also be provided
when introducing new techniques. For this purpose, they proposed to evaluate the changes
in CO occurring after a known intervention and to evaluate response time and amplitude
with new and reference techniques. The definition of clinical acceptability of these
estimates will need to be defined.
CO can be measured by various techniques analyzing the morphology of the arterial
curve. According to the algorithm, it may be necessary to calibrate the system with
an independent measurement of CO. With the LiDCO device, lithium dilution is used
to calibrate the pulse power analysis of the arterial trace, allowing for accurate
continuous measurements of CO. However, this process carries an inherent risk of error,
and great care should be taken when performing calibrations. Cecconi et al. [27] evaluated
the reproducibility of lithium dilution measurements, performing four subsequent lithium
dilution measurements. They observed that the coefficient of variation of a single
measurement was 8%, which implies that the technique is able to detect significant
changes in CO of at least 24%. Averaging two and three lithium boluses decreased the
coefficient of variation to 6 and 5% and the least significant detectable difference
in CO to 17 and 14%, respectively. It did not further improve when additional lithium
injections were performed. The authors concluded that at least three bolus injections
should be performed to calibrate the LiDCO device.
Dancona et al. [28] tested a continuous cardiac output (CO) recording system that
operates on the thermal conservation principle, and they compared it with the reference
standard transit time flow measurement. There was a significant underestimation of
CO with the continuously recording system, but it may be useful to detect trends over
time.
Another important aspect is evaluating whether CO is adequate. Mixed-venous and central
venous (ScvO2) O2 saturations are often used for this purpose. In addition, ScvO2
is used to guide the early resuscitation in septic shock [29]. However, these require
insertion of a central venous line, which is not always easily available in the early
phases of resuscitation. In 40 consecutive patients with severe sepsis, Mesquida et
al. [30] evaluated whether the non-invasive measurement of tissue O2 saturation (StO2)
of the thenar eminence with near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) could predict ScvO2
values. Even though a StO2 value below 75% was associated with aScvO2 lower than 70%
with a high specificity (0.93), many patients with a StO2 value above 75% could still
have a low ScvO2 (sensitivity 0.44). Accordingly, the positive predictive value of
StO2 was high (0.92), whereas the negative predictive value was low (0.52). Accordingly,
when abnormal, this test can easily detect low ScvO2, but a normal StO2 value should
not be considered reassuring.
A new look at the microcirculation
Several studies have reported the implication of the microcirculation in sepsis [31],
cardiac failure [32] and hemorrhagic shock [33], but its implication in other disease
states remains to be demonstrated. Jhanji et al. [34] investigated the sublingual
microcirculation in 25 patients admitted to the ICU after major abdominal surgery.
Microcirculatory perfusion was close to normal on ICU admission, but slightly deteriorated
in the following 8 h in patients developing complications, whereas there was full
normalization in patients who did not develop complications. Global hemodynamic measurements
did not differ between patients developing complications and patients with an uneventful
postoperative course. Even though obtained in a small group of patients, these preliminary
data suggest that microcirculatory alteration may play a key role in the development
of postoperative complications.
When looking at the microcirculation, one is sometimes limited by the scoring systems.
In most articles, semi-quantitative assessment is performed, as automated analysis
still requires multiple human interventions. A limitation for future wide application
at bedside of these techniques of direct visualization of the microcirculation is
that theses semi-quantitative scoring systems need to be performed off-line and are
rather time consuming. Ideally, eyeball evaluation of key microcirculatory features
at bedside should be obtained by analogy with eyeballing of the ejection fraction
at bedside, which has been proven to be as reliable as more cumbersome off-line determinations
[35]. Arnold et al. [36] evaluated whether rapid eyeball evaluation of the microcirculation
(in a point of care fashion) could reliably estimate the microculation, as compared
to off-line analysis. They obtained 205 paired measurements in 18 subjects. There
was no bias between measurements, and agreement between point of care and off-line
analysis was excellent (0.19, representing a percentage error smaller than 10%). The
authors concluded that point of care evaluation of the microcirculation can reliably
assess the sublingual microcirculation.
We are still looking for interventions that could specifically (or at least predominantly)
improve the microcirculation. Vasodilatory agents seem promising, but these have not
been widely tested. Den Uil et al. [32] evaluated the effects of nitroglycerine on
the sublingual microcirculation in 17 patients with heart failure (n = 8) or cardiogenic
shock (n = 9). More importantly, they evaluated the dose response to this agent, using
incremental doses up to 133 μg/min. They observed that all patients improved their
microcirculation with nitroglycerin, but that the dose required to achieve this effect
varied widely among patients. More importantly, even though nitroglycerin was also
associated with systemic effects, the improvement in microvascular perfusion occurred
at lower doses than the systemic effects, suggesting that this agent could be used
to specifically improve the microcirculation at doses not resulting in significant
hypotension.
How to treat hemodynamic alterations
The quest for the ideal fluid for hemodynamic resuscitation is still ongoing. In particular,
there is still a huge discussion going on about the potential benefits and risks of
colloid solutions, and in particular of starches. This issue was raised in the Journal
in a pro-con debate between Hartog and Reinhart [37] defending the contra side and
Boldt [38] defending the pro side. Hartog and Reinhart raised the issue of storage
of hydroxyethylstarch (HES) molecules in the reticulo-endothelial system and skin,
which may lead to pruritus. In addition, they highlighted that nephrotoxicity has
been suggested to occur in several randomized trials and that the volume-expanding
capacities of these solutions may be lower than the expected 4–1. They concluded that
in the absence of a clearly demonstrated beneficial effect and in the presence of
potential side effects, one should refrain from using these solutions. Boldt supported
the opposite point of view. This author highlighted that the side effects, especially
nephrotoxicity, have been observed using only hyperoncotic HES of large molecular
weight. Based on data from small interventional trials, he suggested that new-generation
HES may not be associated with nephrotoxicity and that there is no reason to ban these
new solutions.
In a before and after trial, Schabinski et al. [39] compared the effects of a predominantly
HES- and predominently non-HES-based fluid therapy on renal function in surgical patients.
In this single center, the authors compared the cohort of patients admitted between
January and June 2005 receiving a fluid therapy mostly based on HES and a cohort of
patients admitted from January to June 2006 receiving mostly gelatins as part of their
fluid resuscitation. The two cohorts were relatively well balanced both in numbers
(1,383 vs. 1,528) and main diagnoses (even though there were more cardiac surgery
and neurosurgery and fewer digestive tract surgery patients in the gelatin group).
The incidence of renal failure did not differ between the two groups (5.8 and 5.6%).
By multivariate analysis, the authors identified that a cumulative dose of either
HES or gelatin of at least 33 ml/kg body weight was associated with an increased incidence
of renal failure and death, but again without a difference between the two groups.
Finally, Boldt et al. [40] evaluated the influence of the ionic content of fluid solutions.
These authors compared a HES solution dissolved in 9% saline and another solution
of the same HES dissolved in a balanced solution. Saline solutions present the disadvantage
of carrying an excess of chloride anions compared to sodium, which can generate hyperchloremic
acidosis. Balanced solutions contain equivalent amounts of anions and cations,but
both sodium and chloride are present in physiologic ranges, electrical neutrality
being provided by additional lactate or acetate. The authors randomized 50 elderly
patients submitted to cardiac surgery and evaluated the impact of these two solutions
on inflammatory response. They reported that patients treated with HES in balanced
solution, compared to HES in saline solution, had lower levels of interleukin 6 and
10 and soluble intracellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1), representing a blunted
inflammation and endothelial activation after surgery. In addition, markers of kidney
injury (NGAL and alpha-GST) increased less in the balanced group, whereas creatinine
was not affected in either group, suggesting a better preserved kidney integrity.
Experimental studies
Sepsis
Permissive hypercapnia is a frequent practice in patients ventilated for an ARDS.
However, effects of respiratory acidosis on cell functions are not well known. Morisaki
et al. [41] induced hypercapnic acidosis by ventilating rabbits with an atmosphere
enriched with CO2. Hypercapnia was associated with a reduction of gastric intramucosal
pH and a reduced intestinal vascular permeability after endotoxin infusion. Interestingly,
hypercapnic acidosis did not influence endotoxin-induced gut neutrophil recruitment,
suggesting that the observed protective effects might be independent of neutrophils.
Using a similar approach, Gnaegi et al. [42] demonstrated that moderate hypercapnia
prevented the deterioration of gut tissue energetics in endotoxemic rats. Endotoxic
rats had a decrease in ATP and an increase in lactate concentrations in the gut, changes
that were largely prevented by hypercapnia. Interestingly, this preventive effect
of hypercapnia was not observed on liver energetic parameters. Oppositely, hypocapnia
worsened shock induced by endotoxin, as well as bioenergenetic parameters measured
in the circulation. In a gut ischemia/reperfusion model in rats, Di Paola et al. [43]
demonstrated that glycyrrhizin, a component of licorice with anti-oxidant effects,
protected against gut injury. Glycyrrhizin significantly decreased gut inflammation
and neutrophil recruitment induced by a clamping and release of the splanchnic arteries,
most probably by decreasing oxidative stress in this model.
Until now, the relevance of sepsis and endotoxemic models in mice has suffered from
the fact that the animals were not resuscitated with fluids. Zanotti-Cavazzoni et
al. [44] showed that, similarly to larger animals, the cardiovascular performance
was profoundly influenced by fluid resuscitation in mice submitted to cecal ligation
and puncture (CLP) and treated with antibiotics. Using echocardiography, these authors
demonstrated that fluid infusion increased both left ventricular stroke volume and
CO and prevented mortality in a dose-dependent manner. These results stress the importance
of introducing fluid resuscitation in murine models to better mimic human septic shock
and confirm the beneficial effects of early fluid loading in this condition. Baumgart
et al. [45] investigated the possible role of Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD-1) in
the cardiovascular response of mice submitted to CLP and resuscitated with fluids.
The overexpression of SOD-1 in genetically modified mice did not ameliorate sepsis-related
impairment of myocardial norepinephrine responsiveness, possibly because of the lack
of increase in tissue catalase and mitochondrial SOD activity observed in this model.
Using a rat endotoxic shock model described in Intensive Care Medicine in 2008 [46],
Hagiwara et al. [47] investigated the effect of losartan, an antagonist of the type-1
angiotensin II receptor, on lung injury. Circulating pro-inflammatory cytokines and
the alarmin HMGB-1 [48, 49] were markedly reduced in endotoxemic rats receiving losartan.
Losartan also inhibited the LPS-mediated decrease in angiotensin-converting enzyme
2 activity and the labeling of this enzyme in the lung. In addition, losartan reduced
pro-inflammatory activity induced by endotoxin in murine macrophages, suggesting a
protective and anti-inflammatory role for antagonists of the type-1 angiotensin II
receptor. Interest in vasopressin has increased recently with the VASST study of the
treatment of septic shock in association with norepinephrine. Rehberg et al. [50]
compared vasopressin and terlipressin in a fecal peritonitis model causing fulminant
septic shock in sheep resuscitated with fluids and norepinephrine. Compared to vasopressin,
terlipressin reduced the positive net fluid balance, increased central venous oxygen
saturation and prolonged survival, but increased liver enzymes, a finding consistent
with splanchnic ischemia. Clearly terlipressin was not equivalent to vasopressin and
requires further testing before being proposed as a first-line drug in human septic
shock. In another study, Wolff et al. [51] tested the modulation of the brain gene
expression by iNOS inhibitors versus norepinephrine in endotoxin-treated rats. Using
a microarray technique followed by a validation using PCR, these authors found that
endotoxin induced a marked modification in the brain gene expression of chemokines
and endothelial cell-specific proteins, mainly within the hypoccampus. Whereas norepinephrine
treatment somewhat increased chemokine expression in the brain, the iNOS inhibitor
had no effect. These results show that LPS-induced shock has a pro-inflammatory effect
on the brain, principally on the hypoccampus, an effect that is further upregulated
by the co-administration of norepinephrine. A large debate exists on the possible
beneficial effects of treating septic shock patients with high-volume hemofiltration.
Sykora et al. [52] tested a high versus low volume hemofiltration protocol in a hyperdynamic
septic shock porcine peritonitis model. Hemofiltration was associated with less requirement
of norepinephrine. However, neither low- nor high-volume hyperfitration induced a
significant change in microvascular, metabolic, endothelial and lung functions compared
with a non-filtrated control group of sheep in this model. Given the antiinflammatory
and antiapoptotic properties of levosimendan, Scheiermann and colleagues [53] reported
the effects of intravenous and nebulized levosimendan administration 3 h after the
induction of CLP-induced sepsis in rats. They demonstrated a higher mean arterial
pressure, arterial BE and pH; an increase in survival rate; a reduction in IL 6 and
IL1β levels in plasma; and a reduction in cleaved caspase-3 concentration in the spleen
in both treatment groups as compared to the control group. However, the mechanisms
by which the administration of levosimendan improve cell viability and thus survival
are still not understood. There are reports showing significant improvement of the
cardiac index in sepsis or even refractory septic shock as a result of improving cardiac
contractility by levosimendan rather than the anti-apoptotic effects. This concept
is open for further studies.
Leukocyte reprogramming with a dominant immunosuppressive phenotype is a hallmark
of sepsis and is believed to play a significant role in the propensity of septic patients
to acquire nosocomial infections. In a series of elegant experiments, Leendertse et
al. [54] tested the hypothesis that a sublethal peritonitis (CLP) would influence
the capacity of mice to clear a second bacterial infection caused by vancomycin-resistant
enterococci (VREs). VREs did not induce the local inflammatory reaction required for
their clearance when injected intraperitoneally in mice previously rendered septic
by CLP. VRE bacterial loads were found increased in the peritoneum and in distant
organs when compared with mice with a sham operation. This study highlights the critical
importance of bacteria-induced inflammation as a key mechanism required for the clearance
of bacteria. When the inflammatory reaction is small or absent due to a previous sepsis
injury, the immune system is paralyzed and inefficient in fighting against a secondary
bacterial infection, a situation that is reminiscent of that of human septic shock
patients at high risk of developing (severe) nosocomial infections from commensal
bacteria. Mediators responsible for the immune anergy observed during septic shock
are not very well known. Although circulating anti-inflammatory cytokines such as
IL-10 have been implicated in this phenomenon, it has also recently become apparent
that immune deactivating cells such as CD4(+)CD25(+)Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells (Tregs)
are increased during sepsis and may play a role in the so-called sepsis-associated
“immune paralysis.” Venet et al. [55] investigated whether Tregs participated in lymphocyte
anergy during septic shock. They showed that the proliferation capacity of T cells
was markedly impaired by the presence of Tregs. An inverse correlation was observed
between the number of circulating Tregs and the proliferation of target T cells. They
elegantly showed in septic mice that the ex vivo silencing of Foxp3, a Treg protein
essential for their “immunosuppressive” effects, restored the proliferative capacity
of T cells.
Nebulization of antibiotics is becoming a valuable therapeutic option in the treatment
of pneumonia in critically ill patients. Many of the technical aspects of drug delivery
to the lung by nebulization have been tested and optimized in animals, showing much
higher airway concentrations compared to an IV route [56]. Ferrari et al. [57] compared
treatment of ceftazidime delivered either by nebulization or IVs in pigs inoculated
into the lungs by a strain of P.aeruginosa with a decreased sensitivity to this antibiotic.
They demonstrated that the IV route was much less efficient than the nebulization
route in controlling bacterial proliferation in all lung segments cultured. These
results suggest that nebulization is capable of depositing higher bactericidal concentrations
of antibiotics into the lung than the IV route, an effect that is particularly valuable
in patients infected with bacteria with reduced sensitivity to antibiotics.
Mechanical ventilation and acute lung injury
Several studies compared different approaches to the lung recruitment maneuver in
animal models of acute lung injury and provided our readers with interesting findings.
It is important to identify the most reliable readouts to set adequate individual
levels of open lung PEEP during recruitment. In a sheep model of acute lung injury
induced by bilateral lung lavage, Caramez et al. [58] compared parameters measured
during a decremental PEEP trial with those obtained from P-V curves following recruitment
maneuvers. The authors observed a similar PEEP identified by the dynamic tidal respiratory
compliance, maximum PaO2, maximum PaO2 and PaCO2, minimum shunt, the inflation limb
of lower Pflex or deflation limb upper Pflex from quasi-static P-V curves in their
study set following a recruitment maneuver. However, it is unknown whether the parameters
of readouts reported in Garamez’s study are sensitive enough to detect the differences
of lung recruitment. Interestingly, Dellaca et al. [59] assessed lung recruitment
by monitoring the amount of derecruited lung using the forced oscillation technique
in piglets. The investigators simultaneously measured the oscillatory compliance by
using the forced oscillation technique and the percentage of non-aerated lung tissue
by CT scan. Measurements were conducted before and after several interventions including
mono- and bilateral atelectasis, and lung recruitment maneuvers. They reported a linear
correlation between the two methods in measuring lung volume and suggested that the
forced oscillation technique may be a useful tool for the non-invasive measurement
of lung recruitment or derecruitment in addition to the existing methods.
To achieve optimal open lung results, Steimback et al. [60] evaluated the effects
of frequency and inspiratory plateau pressure during recruitment maneuvers in paraquat-induced
lung injury in rats. Two sigh frequencies at 10 or 180 sighs/h were applied in combination
with a plateau pressure of either 20 or 40 cmH2O, respectively. The authors demonstrated
that a higher sigh frequency led to lung and kidney epithelial cell apoptosis associated
with increased gene expression of the extracellular matrix protein type III procollagen.
They further showed that a combined strategy of high sigh frequency with a lower plateau
pressure may even worsen lung injury. A different picture was seen by Pellicano et
al. using high-frequency oscillatory ventilation in combination with different stepwise
escalating pressures [61]. The researchers compared four methods of lung volume recruitment
during high frequency oscillatory ventilation in an acute lung injury model of neonatal
piglets after repeated saline lavage. The four methods included a stepwise increase
in pressure over 6 min to a peak mean airway pressure 12 cmH2O above basal pressure;
a sustained dynamic inflation for 20 s to the same peak pressure; a sustained dynamic
inflation repeated six times for 1 s each; and mean airway pressure set directly at
basal pressure. The investigators reported that all methods resulted in a reduction
in non-aerated lung, with the greatest redistribution to normally aerated lung being
with stepwise recruitment. The studies are of interest with respect to searching for
optimal approaches to lung recruitment. It would be good for our readers to know about
the gas volume distribution within an injured lung after lung recruitment maneuvers,
as overinflation in previously well-aerated lung is designated to be minimal.
Acute lung injury is characterized by excessive inflammatory responses. To further
explore the mechanisms by which inadequate mechanical ventilation induces lung injury,
Martínez-Caro et al. [62] demonstrated that increased formation of reactive oxygen
and nitrogen species is involved in ventilator-induced vascular dysfunction in rats.
The authors reported that the use of TV at 35 ml/kg and zero PEEP resulted in hypotension,
systemic acidosis, hypoxemia and hyperlactatemia in vivo, and impaired vasoconstriction
in response to acetylcholine and norepinephrine challenge in aortic rings. Immunostaining
for both superoxide and nitrotyrosine was increased in aortic rings; thus, pre-treatment
of the vascular rings with tempol (an intracellular superoxide scavenger) or MnTMPyP
(a superoxide and peroxynitrite scavenger) improved acetylcholine- or norepinephrine-induced
vasoconstriction. These data suggest a role of intracellular reactive oxygen and nitrogen
species in ventilation-induced vascular dysfunction. In another study, Bueltmann et
al. [63] examined the effects of inhaled milrinone, a phosphodiesterase 3 inhibitor,
in models of acute lung injury following infusion of oleic acid in rats or intratracheal
instillation of hydrochloric acid in mice. They demonstrated that a single inhalation
of milrinone decreased myeloperoxidase activity and neutrophil counts, reduced protein
concentration and TNF-α production in bronchoalveolar lavage, and attenuated lung
injury. The lung protective effects of aerosolized milrinone administration were further
enhanced when milrinone was repeatedly inhaled. They two further support that there
may be a place for pharmacological intervention by targeting inflammatory responses
in reducing ventilator-induced lung injury.
Ischemia/reperfusion and sepsis associated distal organ failure
Several studies investigated regional blood flow and oxygenation during ischemia and
reperfusion injury, which may help enhance our understanding of the pathophysiology
of distal organ injury.
Dubin et al. [33] measured systemic hemodynamics as well as microcirculatory changes
at different vascular beds during progressive hemorrhage in anesthetized and MV sheep.
The investigator reported that over a broad range of CO and superior mesenteric artery
blood flow, the changes in intestinal serosal and mucosal capillary microvascular
blood flow, and red blood cell velocities are more susceptible than the changes of
mean arterial blood pressure, arterial pH and base excess, and intramucosal-arterial
PCO2 in response to progressive bleeding. They suggested that the microcirculatory
changes measured by the semi-quantitative flow index may help detect microcirculatory
alternations at an early stage prior to global hemodynamic deterioration. The concept
of measuring microcirculation at the organ system is of importance. The regional blood
flow device is yet to be tested in other experimental conditions, and the feasibility
of using the invasive technique is yet to be investigated at bedside monitoring. This
study by Dubin et al. is in agreement with previous studies showing that global hemodynamics
may fail to reflect changes in regional blood flow at distal organs. In another interesting
study, Dyson et al. [64] compared the changes of global oxygenation with that measured
in liver, kidney, muscle and bladder in response to a variety of inspired oxygen concentrations
during progressive hemorrhage in spontaneously breathing, anesthetized rats. The authors
observed that survival times following progressive hemorrhage were similar in animals
breathing room air, 60 or 100% O2, but significantly worse in rats breathing 15% O2.
However, a decreased blood pressure and aortic blood flow and an increased lactatemia
were observed in the hypoxemic and hyperoxemic groups compared to normoxemic animals.
It appears that high FiO2 or hyperoxemia cannot compensate for the low CO and thus
tissue perfusion. This study indicates that hypoxemia and hyperoxemia both altered
organ perfusion during severe and progressive hemorrhage. In an editorial, Dr. Douzinas
[65] stated that we should keep in mind that CO and mixed venous oxygen tension are
higher in isovolemic anemia than hypovolemia or hypoxemia. Therefore, it would be
interesting to resuscitate the animals at different levels of blood volume loss and,
by varying FiO2 and measuring oxidative parameters, to determine if the management
should mainly lie with O2 therapy or with resuscitation efforts.
To further explore the relationship between systemic perfusion and tissue oxygenation,
Hare et al. [66] investigated the effects of oxygen affinity for optimal tissue oxygen
delivery in extreme hemodilution status by administration of a hemoglobin-hydroxyethyl
starch conjugate (HRC 101) in rats. They reported that hippocampal tissue oxygen tension
was best maintained after hemodilution with low but not high affinity HRC 101 at Hb
100 and 70 g/l after near complete blood volume exchange in rats. This is an interesting
study that tests oxygen delivery with a hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier that can be
constructed to have high and low oxygen affinity. The rationale for this model was
that it would be easier to compare otherwise identical Hb in the absence of red blood
cells in which the Hb would be the primary contributor to oxygen delivery.
In a rat intestinal ischemia-reperfusion model, Liu and colleagues [67] demonstrated
that immediate but not delayed postconditioning carries protective effects. The underlying
mechanisms may involve inhibiting oxidant generation and reducing the release of proinflammatory
mediators, etc. There are two major findings, namely that post-conditioning and pre-conditioning
exert an apparently synergystic effect in this model, and if post-conditioning is
deferred until several minutes of reperfusion have elapsed, the apparent protective
effect is lost. Both of these observations may have important clinical implications.
The observations regarding timing may explain the apparent failure of post-conditioning
in some series and has important implications for future trial design.
It has been known for many years that cooling alters or reduces the coagulation system,
and clinical data show that “NovoSeven” will not work in hypothermic patients. Hypothermia
also results in changes in the cell surface lipid membrane, reduced platelet function
and altered platelet morphology observed during hypothermic bypass surgery. Krouzecky
et al. [68] elegantly demonstrated that cooling of blood in the extracorporeal circuit
of continuous veno-venous hemofiltration enables preventing in-circuit clotting without
the need to use any other anticoagulant. Dr. Davenport made comments that, as any
young transplant surgeon knows, clotting and bleeding during any major transplant
operation in heart, lung and liver differ when operating on pigs, dogs and humans.
So it must be stressed that these results are from pig experiments. Secondly, in humans
extracorporeal clotting during dialysis for example can occur independently of activation
of factor XII, which was measured in the study by Krouzecky and colleagues. Also,
as pointed out by Bagshaw and Davenport [69], the study only applied regional blood
cooling of the extracorporeal circuit in their experimental model for a short duration.
Additional investigations using a longer duration of CRRT with regional blood cooling
in their model are needed to evaluate both efficacy and effectiveness, but also importantly
safety, specifically in terms of temperature-induced hemolysis with repeated blood
cooling and re-warming.
Pharmacology and sedation
Drug-drug interactions are a difficult field of intensive care medicine because of
the application of multiple different classes of drugs and the large heterogeneity
of the patients. One aspect in this context is the involvement of CYP450-mediated
interactions, which is reason enough to give priority to this issue for a Mini Series
on Basic Research-Related Topics in Intensive Care Medicine: Mouly et al. [70] concentrated
on the basic science in Part 1 of the Mini Series. The authors present the clinical
rationale for this important field of research to introduce the reader to the basics
of the CYP450 system. Subfamilies of this enzyme group are mentioned, as well as inducers
and inhibitors of the major CYP enzymes. In vitro systems to assess drug metabolism
and interactions are shown to act as potentially useful tools during the preclinical
step of drug development. Finally, “computer-assisted” prediction systems are presented
as an interesting view into the future. Spriet et al. [71] focus on the clinical aspects
including relevant CYP450-mediated drug interactions in the ICU. Multiple drug therapies
are common for ICU patients, and the practicing intensivist must remain aware of the
major mechanisms for drug-drug interactions. This manuscript covers a practical overview
of clinically relevant interactions. Frequently used medications, such as benzodiazepines,
immunosuppressive agents, opioids, certain anticonvulsants, the azoles and macrolides,
have the potential to interact with the CYP450-mediated metabolism and may lead to
toxicity or therapeutic failure. Especially this second part is an extremely important
tool for every intensivist!
Adverse drug reactions (ADR) are a noxious, unintended and undesired effect of a drug
that occurs at doses used in humans for prophylaxis, diagnosis or therapy. The incidence
of serious and fatal ADR is high. Schwake et al. [72] aimed (1) to determine the prevalence
of ICU admissions resulting from an ADR and (2) to compare affected patients with
patients admitted to the ICU for the treatment of deliberate self-poisoning using
medical drugs. A total of 1,554 patients admitted on 1 January 2003 to 31 December
2003 in a 14-bed medical ICU were prospectively studied. Ninety-nine patients were
admitted to the ICU with a diagnosis of ADR (6.4% of all admissions); 269 admissions
(17.3%) were caused by deliberate self-poisoning. Patients admitted for treatment
of ADR had a significantly higher age, a longer treatment duration in the ICU, a higher
SAPS II score and a higher 6-month mortality than those with deliberate self-poisoning.
Most patients (71.7%) suffering from ADR required advanced supportive care in the
ICU, whereas the majority of patients (90.7%) with deliberate self-poisoning could
be sufficiently treated in the integrated intermediate care area. All diagnostic and
therapeutic procedures in the ICU except mechanical ventilation were performed significantly
more often in patients with ADR. It was concluded that ADR is a frequent cause of
admission to medical ICUs resulting in a considerable use of ICU capacities and that
patients with ADR required longer and more intense medical treatment in the ICU than
those with deliberate self-poisoning.
In an observational case series from Western Australia, Brown et al. [73] reported
that early clotting factor replacement to treat snake venom-induced comsumption coagulopathy
resulted in earlier recovery.
It is especially appreciated when investigators have the courage to present research
on very rare, but sometimes important topics in intensive care medicine. One example
is the paper by Struck et al. [74], who reviewed the current literature on severe
cutaneous adverse reactions that are not associated with burn injuries. They presented
life-threatening examples, such as cases of Steven-Johnson syndrome and toxic epidermal
necrolysis, and concluded that these patients will substantially benefit from early
interdisciplinary care and thorough consideration of complications during transport
and intensive care treatment. The attending medical team should be aware of possible
underlying diseases and instigating substances, and these patients should be treated
in a manner similar to severe burn patients.
Short-term analgosedation with intravenously administered short-acting drugs is associated
with significant cost. Analgosedation by inhalative agents appears to be an intriguing
alternative, which was investigated in 17 ICU patients requiring mechanical ventilation
[75]. The feasibility of sedation with sevoflurane using the anesthetic conservative
device (AnaConDa) for short-term sedation was tested. The application was found to
be safe, and hemodynamic tolerance was good, but the induction and termination waking
times were longer than when using remifentanil and propofol.
The hepatic metabolism of another commonly used drug, midazolam, is altered during
critical illness. Kirwan et al. [76] used this property to explore the reliability
of a single measurement of midazolam concentration as an indicator of hepatic drug
metabolism. The findings of this study indeed confirmed a satisfactory correlation
between the single midazolam concentration and the area under the curve of the plasma
concentrations. The presence of acute kidney injury was associated with increased
midazolam concentration.
In a pilot, phase III, double-blind multicenter study of 85 randomized medical and
surgical patients, Ruokonen et al. [77] compared dexmedetomidine (1.4 μg/kg/h) with
propofol/midazolam for long-term sedation. Target RASS was reached in 64% of patients
receiving dexmedetomidine and in 63% of control patients. Similarly, the length of
ICU stay was similar. Dexmedetomidine was comparable to propofol/midazolam in maintaining
sedation targets of RASS of 0 to −3. However, patients with a RASS target of −4 or
less reached the target in 42% of the cases with dexmedetomidine and in 62% with propofol/midazolam
(P = 0.006).
In a prospective study, Chanques et al. [78] validated an adaptation of the Behavioral
Pain Scale for use in non-intubated delirious patients (BPS-NI). One physician and
the bedside nurse rated the level of pain during catheter dressing change and turning
in 30 consecutive adult patients. Delirium was assessed by the CAM-ICU. Pain scores
were higher during painful procedures than at rest, whereas no changes in pain scores
were found during non-nociceptive procedures. The BPS-NI showed good internal consistency,
good inter-rater reliability and good responsiveness.
Tardy-Poncet et al. [79] reported danaparoid cross-reactivity with heparin-induced
thrombocytopenia antibodies in 12 patients treated with lepirudin. They concluded
that the absence of any increase in platelet count after 3–5 days of danaparoid therapy
and/or the occurrence of a new thrombotic event should lead to suspicion of danaparoid
cross-reactivity.
A case of acute respiratory failure after charcoal aspiration with recurrent release
of charcoal from an intrapulmonary cavern has been reported by Francis et al. [80].
Communication and teaching
Rego Lins Fumis and Deheinzelin reported on satisfaction and prevalence of symptoms
of anxiety and depression in family members of 300 critically ill cancer patients
[81]. Prevalence of anxiety and depression in family members was 71 and 50.3%, respectively.
Anxiety was independently associated with prolonged mechanical ventilation, relative’s
gender and religion. Factors associated with symptoms of depression were presence
of metastasis and relative’s gender.
Stricker et al. [82] assessed family satisfaction in the relatives of 996 Swiss ICU
patients. Overall, proxies were satisfied with care and with information/decision-making.
Higher severity of illness was associated with higher satisfaction, whereas a higher
patient:nurse ratio and written admission/discharge criteria were associated with
lower overall satisfaction. The need for improving emotional support, coordination
of care and communication was highlighted.
In a multicenter before/after observational study, Tremey et al. [83] assessed the
compliance and impact of a teaching program on guidelines for the management of severe
bleeding under oral anticoagulation therapy in EDs. Forty-five patients with severe
bleeding under oral anticoagulation therapy were included in 2003 and 54 patients
in 2005. The intervention consisted of a training program on management of severe
bleeding under oral anticoagulation therapy performed by an expert physician. The
primary end-point was the use of a prothrombin complex concentrate-vitamin K combination
between the two study periods. Nine patients (20%) in 2003 and only 29 patients (54%)
in 2005 received this combination (P < 0.01). Almost one-third of patients had only
withholding of oral anticoagulation therapy. Adverse events and mortality rate did
not differ between the two phases.
Chalumeau-Lemoine et al. [84] evaluated the impact of limited training of ICU physicians
without knowledge of ultrasound in performing basic general ultrasonography. After
8.5 h of training comprising a 2.5-h didactic course that included essential views
of normal and pathologic conditions and three hands-on sessions of 2 h each, an ICU
resident and a senior radiologist performed the same examination in a blind manner.
The questions addressed concerned the presence of pleural effusion, intra-abdominal
effusion, acute cholecystitis, intrahepatic biliary duct dilation, obstructive uropathy,
chronic renal disease and deep venous thrombosis. The answers to 129 questions were
analyzed. Residents answered 84.4% of the questions correctly. Most of the discrepancies
concerned small non-drainable pleural or abdominal effusions. For questions with a
potential therapeutic impact, residents answered 95% of the questions correctly. Residents
completed the examination in 37 ± 39 min compared with 296 ± 487 min for the radiologists.
Intensive care medicine has developed rapidly and to a considerable extent throughout
the past 10–15 years. Hence, it is most important to implement and adapt programs
for training the physicians. Years ago, the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine
(ESICM) was one of the first contributors to the CoBaTrICE program (Competency-Based
Training in Intensive Care MedicinE). Meanwhile, this program has been established,
and the CoBaTrICE Collaboration presented the results from a recent survey in 28 European
countries in a report [85]. It was demonstrated that, although more than half of the
countries have modified their training programs since CoBaTrICE was initiated, national
standards for approving hospitals as training centers vary widely, and there is considerable
diversity in pedagogic structures and processes. Nonetheless, the Collaboration will
continue to harmonize and develop international standards for quality assurance of
training programs.