Keynote Speaker Abstracts
Placebos, Words, and Drugs: Sharing Common Mechanisms of Action
Fabrizio Benedetti, MD1, 2
1Plateau Rosà Laboratories, Center for Hypoxia, Plateau Rosà,
Italy/Switzerland
2Department of Neuroscience, University of Turin Medical School, Turin,
Italy
Abstract
Although placebos have long been considered a nuisance in clinical research,
today they represent an excellent model to understand how words and therapeutic
rituals may affect the patient’s brain. Placebo effects, and their evil twins,
nocebo effects, are today an active and productive field of research, and
because of the involvement of many mechanisms, the study of the placebo effect
can actually be viewed as a melting pot of concepts and ideas for neuroscience.
Indeed, there exists not a single but many placebo effects, with different
mechanisms and in different systems, medical conditions, and therapeutic
interventions. For example, brain mechanisms of expectation, anxiety, and reward
are all involved, as well as a variety of learning phenomena, such as Pavlovian
conditioning, cognitive, and social learning. There is also some experimental
evidence of different genetic variants in placebo responsiveness. The most
productive models to better understand the neurobiology of the placebo effect
are pain and Parkinson’s disease. In these medical conditions, the neural
networks that are involved have been identified, that is, opioid, cannabinoid,
cholecystokinin, cyclooxygenase, and dopamine modulatory networks in pain and
part of the basal ganglia circuitry in Parkinson’s disease. Important clinical
implications emerge from these recent advances in placebo research. First, as
the placebo effect is basically a psychosocial context effect, these data
indicate that different social stimuli, such as words and therapeutic rituals,
may change the chemistry and circuitry of the patient’s brain. Second, the
mechanisms that are activated by placebos are the same as those activated by
drugs, which suggest a cognitive/affective interference with drug action.
Therefore, by taking all these data together, today we can talk of a true
pharmacology and toxicology of words, whereby the unique and special interaction
between the therapist and his/her patient can activate the same mechanisms that
are the target of drugs.
How Nutrition Can Impact Gut Microbiome Composition, Intestinal Permeability, and
Antigen Trafficking Leading to Chronic Inflammatory Diseases
Alessio Fasano, MD1,2,3
1Mucosal Immunology and Biology Research Center, Massachusetts General
Hospital for Children, Boston, Massachusetts
2Harvard Medical School, Bosten, Massachusetts
3European Biomedical Research Institute Salerno, Salerno, Italy
Abstract
Improved hygiene leading to a reduced exposure to microorganisms have been
implicated as 1 possible cause for the “epidemic” of immune-mediated diseases,
particularly noninfective chronic inflammatory diseases (CIDs), in
industrialized countries during the past 3–4 decades now affecting millions of
individuals. The social and financial burdens imposed by these chronic,
debilitating diseases include poor quality of life, high health-care costs, and
substantial loss of productivity. That is the essence of the hygiene hypothesis
that argues that rising incidence of these pathologies may be, at least in part,
the result of lifestyle and environmental changes that have made us too “clean”
for our own good. Interestingly, increased hygiene in some developing countries
did not lead to an increase in CID as seen in industrializing countries, casting
some doubts on the validity of the hygiene hypothesis. Apart from genetic makeup
and exposure to environmental triggers, 3 more elements have been recently
identified being key players in the pathogenesis of CID. A third element is the
inappropriate increase in intestinal permeability, which may be influenced by
the composition of the gut microbiota, has been proposed in the pathogenesis of
these diseases. Intestinal permeability, together with antigen (Ag) sampling by
enterocytes and luminal dendritic cells, regulates molecular trafficking between
the intestinal lumen and the submucosa, leading to either tolerance or immunity
to nonself Ag. This tolerance-immune response balance is influenced by the
function of the immune system (both innate and adaptive immune response) as a
forth element involved in the pathogenesis of CID. Finally, the composition of
gut microbiome and its epigenetic influence on the host genomic expression has
been identified as a fifth element in causing CID. The gut microbiome consists
of more than 100 trillion microorganisms, most of which are bacteria. It has
been just recently recognized that there is a close bidirectional interaction
between gut microbiome and our immune system, and this cross talk, particularly
during infancy, is highly influential in shaping the host gut immune system
function and, ultimately, the tolerance/immune response balance. This
observation led to a revisitation of the possible causes of CID epidemics. With
the appreciation that the gut microbiome plays a decisive role in either
generating (mucosal) tolerance or leading the way to the development of
inflammatory conditions, alternative hypothesis has been formulated. There is
growing evidence that many CID are characterized by a change in microbiome
composition. While factors such as modality of deliver, neonatal feeding
regimens, use of antibiotics, and infections can influence microbiota
composition, diet is by far the most important variable affecting gut ecosystem.
Therefore, reshaping gut microbiota through dietary manipulation is becoming an
extremely active area of research for the prevention or treatment of a multitude
of CID. Celiac disease and autism spectrum disorders will be discussed as
clinical examples of this new paradigm.
The Radical Redesign of Health Care: The Why, What, and How
Tracy Gaudet, MD1
1Department of Veteran Affairs, National Office of Patient-Centered Care
and Cultural Transformation
Abstract
The mission of the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) is “To honor America’s
Veterans by providing exceptional health care that improves their health and
well-being.” In keeping with this, VHA has made a commitment to innovate the way
health care is delivered by leading the expansion of the current medical
paradigm—which is historically predominantly disease based and reactive—to one
that is personalized, proactive, and patient driven. It is not difficult to
reflect on a time, either in the course of one’s practice or one’s own
experience of health care, when the typical medical model fell short—when a
diagnostic and procedural approach failed to identify an issue, resolve the root
of the problem, or move the person closer to their own goals for well-being. In
response, health-care professionals in America have begun to examine a more
comprehensive, holistic approach to health care would serve us—as both
practitioners and patients—better. How, then, do we get from the current state
to this patient-driven model? The core elements of this approach as well as the
demonstrations underway and the plan for national implementation across the The
Radical Redesign of Health Care: The Why, What, and How VA will be presented.
Specifically, this presentation will delineate the core drivers for the
transformation of health care, define the critical elements of a health-care
system that is designed to empower and equip people to optimize their health and
well-being, and describe examples of current demonstrations of this approach and
lessons learned.
Connective Tissue: Putting the Body Back Together Again
Helene Langevin, MD1
1Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Brigham
and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Connective tissue forms a whole-body network that “connects” the body’s cells,
tissues, and organs with one another. The same connective tissue that transmits
mechanical forces within the musculoskeletal system also constitutes the
“terrain” where immune responses take place. Dr Langevin’s research shows that
connective tissue can function as a bridge between the musculoskeletal system
and the immune system. This connection helps us understand how mechanical forces
produced during acupuncture-, manual-, and movement-based therapies can
influence immune processes such as inflammation. Dr Langevin’s presentation will
highlight the development of methods for controlling the “dose” of forces
applied to tissue in animal models has been key to advancing this field. She
will also discuss how understanding connective tissue can help us overcome the
artificial fragmentation of the body that handicaps modern physiology and
medicine.
Bringing the Body Back Into Mind–Body Research
Peter Wayne, PhD1
1Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Brigham
and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Mind–body practices have evolved to target and take advantage of the
interconnectivity between the body and mind, with the goal of enhancing
system-wide health. Significant progress has been made in exploring the impact
of mind–body therapies on brain structure and function, clinical measures of
cognition, and patient-reported outcomes related to affect and quality of life.
However, surprisingly little research has explored the use of practical,
body-based functional outcomes to inform more holistic concepts of mind–body
health. Research supports that body-based outcomes (eg, gait speed, gait rhythm,
and postural control) are effective biomarkers and predictors for multiple
domains of health including cognition, affective disorders, fall risk, heart
disease, and all-cause mortality. This talk will draw on key principles from the
field of embodied cognition to make a case for including measures of physical
performance and shape to characterize overall health and to better understand
the contributions and relevance of top-down processes such as executive
function, attention and affect to physical function and whole person health.
Research related to the impacts of multimodal mind–body exercises (eg, Tai Chi
and Qigong [TCQ]) on functional outcomes will then be summarized within an
embodied cognition framework. This research includes studies employing dual
tasking (cognitive challenges during gait and balance tasks) which support that
TCQ enhances cognitive-motor integration during activities of daily living, and
studies demonstrate that TCQ’s impact on anxiety and affective disorders can be
observed through quantitative and qualitative changes in gait and posture.
Opportunities afforded by new technology to assess gait and other embodied
outcomes in both laboratory and ecological settings, including wearable sensors
and gait monitoring systems are highlighted. Challenges inherent in using
multimodal interventions for studying cross-systems outcomes are also
discussed.
The Need for an Integrated Approach to Understanding the Determinants of
Health
Steven H. Woolf, MD, MPH1
1VCU Center on Society and Health, Virginia Commonwealth University
Center, Richmond, Virginia
Abstract
Integration is important not only to how we define health and wellness (eg,
integrative health) or deliver care (eg, integrated team care) but also to how
we understand the complex web of factors that shape health. Society tends to
equate health with health care, but our health is determined greatly by health
behaviors (eg, smoking, sedentary activity), lifestyle, and stress. These in
turn are shaped by upstream factors including socioeconomic conditions (eg,
education, poverty, income inequality) and the physical and social environment
in which we live. The physical environment includes not only clean air and water
but also a built environment that enables active living and heathy food choices,
healthy and secure housing, and affordable transportation. The social
environment also affects health, as when people experience trauma or toxic
stress from racism, residential segregation, exclusion, social isolation, or
loneliness. Macrostructural factors—such as public policies, social values, and
spending policies—function at the national, state, and local level to influence
all of these downstream domains from socioeconomic and environmental conditions
to the ability of people to obtain health care or maintain healthy behaviors.
These multilevel relationships are notoriously interdependent, which means that
meaningful efforts to improve population health require an integrated approach
to policy and practice. For example, efforts to improve access to health care or
employment cannot succeed if the people in need of these services lack stable
housing, child care, or affordable transportation to reach the health-care
facility or jobsite. Too often, clinicians, health systems, and communities
attempt to improve health by targeting a single domain. These efforts are less
likely to “move the needle” than cross-sector partnerships in which stakeholders
work across sectors to achieve collective impact through collaboration.
Integration is hard work; it requires commitment, resources, and infrastructure.
But it is essential to achieve transformational change.
Pre-Congress Workshop Abstracts
(1106) Words That Harm and Words That Heal: How to Transform Language to Improve
Clinical Encounters
Dawn M Bellanti, MSN, FNP1
1MedStar Institute for Innovation, Kensington, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this presentation is to illustrate the key
lessons learned from placebo, nocebo, and hypnosis research; bring awareness to
how our use of language in the field of health care has the power to both harm
and heal; and provide practical ways to reframe our choice of words from the
negative to the positive to improve encounters in our professional and personal
encounters. This presentation seeks to translate key findings from integrative
medicine research into clinically relevant actions, in alignment with the
conference’s goals to improve interprofessional collaboration.
Objectives: Following this presentation, attendees will be able to
paraphrase the lessons learned from placebo, nocebo, and hypnosis research in
order to interpret the key message: that our choice of words deeply influences
others in both positive and negative ways; appraise whether they have been
unknowingly using negative languaging in personal and professional conversations
in order to judge the relevance of this information to them as individuals and
health-care providers; and interpret the personal meaning and value of the
information learned in order to implement more positive languaging in the
future.
Outline: Presentation Overview:
1. Introduction and learning objectives
2. How “medical-eze” unintentionally harms (high-tech terminology, fear-inducing
metaphors, outdated insensitive language, gallows humor)
3. Why our words matter: the nocebo response
4. Leveraging lessons from placebo research
5. Top 8 “words to lose” and “words to use”
6. Therapeutic languaging during patient encounters
7. Putting it into practice: Two role-playing scenarios demonstrating “words that
harm” and “words that heal”
(1165) Nonrandomized Pragmatic Controlled Trials Supplement Randomized Controlled
Trails in Comparative Effectiveness Research
Franz Porzsolt, MD, PhD1 and Christel Weiss PhD1, 2
1Institute of Clinical Economics e.V., Ulm, Germany
2Medical Statistics, Campus Mannheim, Univ Heidelberg,
Mannheim/Heidelberg, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Archie Cochrane asked 3 essential questions: “Can it work?”
“Does it work?” and “Is it worth it?” The purpose of my presentation is to show
that the first question requires a efficacy trial (research under ideal study
conditions), while the second and third questions require an effectiveness trial
(research under real-world conditions).
Objectives: The objective will be to elucidate the difference
between efficacy and effectiveness trial.
Outline: There are significant differences between randomized
controlled trials (RCTs) and pragmatic controlled trials (PCTs). The following
are unique to PCTs (compared to RCTs), and I would discuss them further in my
presentation:
• PCTs do not differentiate between primary and secondary outcomes as PCTs are
descriptive but not explanatory trials.
• PCTs do not have exclusion criteria as any patient who meets the inclusion
criteria will be served under RWC.
• The definition of all important risk factors that influence the outcomes of any
investigated end point is essential for generation of the risk-stratified
subgroups.
• Any used treatment option will be accepted as any of the selected treatments is
considered ideal for the individual patient and condition.
• An informed consent is necessary for systematic and anonymous collection and
publication of data but not for the selection of approved treatments based on
doctor/patient preferences.
• Comparative effectiveness analyses are confined to large-size patient
groups.
• Recorded data of all groups that are too small for single-group evaluations are
combined to a “any other treatment group” that serves as “nonspecific control
group” for comparison with the specific interventions.
• No intent-to-treat evaluation is necessary as the patients were stratified to
risk-specific baseline subgroups.
This dichotomous evaluation strategy will change the theory, the ethical
assessment, the practice, the edition of clinical guidelines, and legal aspects
of health-care research.
(1170) Making the Business Case for Integrative Health: Practical Application of
Economic Evaluation
Patricia M. Herman, ND, PhD1 and Claudia M Witt2
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
2University Hospital Zurich, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this workshop to give attendees a strong
conceptual foundation on the use of economic evaluation (eg, cost-effectiveness,
return on investment, and other types of cost analyses) to make the business
case for complementary and integrative health approaches.
Objectives: The objective of this study is to know the basic
principles of economic evaluation, including the perspective of analysis, and
the different types of economic evaluations and their strengths and limitations
for use in establishing a business case; know how to identify and prepare
effectiveness data appropriate for a business case and for inclusion in the
different types of economic evaluations; and know how to determine types of cost
data available to their study, including administrative and chart data, how to
estimate implementation costs, and how all pieces come together in support of a
business case.
Outline:
1. Basic principles: presentation and whole group exercise looking at examples of
published studies and critiquing them from the perspective of their support for
a business case
2. Measures of effectiveness: presentation and individual exercise considering
the likely measures of effectiveness that would be of interest to different
business case audiences
3. Measures of cost and bringing it together: presentation and small-group work
on final exercise where participants will calculate cost-effectiveness and
return on investment from different perspectives (ie, of interest to different
types of decision makers) and interpret their results as to their impact on a
business case
(3286) Applications of Narrative Medicine for Patient Identity and Quality of
Life
John L Villano, MD, PhD1 and Robert B Slocum, PhD1
1Lexington, Kentucky
Abstract
Purpose: The purposes of this workshop are to provide a basic
introduction to narrative medicine and its applications for patient care, to
apply and illustrate these understandings in case-based presentations on the
clinical use of narrative medicine visits to assist brain cancer patients to
recover or discover identity and sense of self as they receive treatment, and to
provide an interactive and reflective narrative medicine-based experience for
participants through a journal writing exercise with expressive writing
prompts.
Objectives: The aim is to describe and discuss basic principles and
methods of narrative medicine, apply basic principles and methods of narrative
medicine in clinical practice and interactions with patients through discussion
of case histories, identify appropriate cases for application of narrative
medicine principles and methods, and demonstrate understanding of narrative
medicine methods by participation in a journal writing exercise with expressive
writing prompts.
Outline:
I. Introduction to narrative medicine
II. Application of narrative medicine principles and methods relative to
case-based studies
III. Journal writing exercise with expressive writing prompts
(3339) Developing Your Research Career: National Center for Complementary and
Integrative Health Training and Career Development Opportunities
Lanay M Mudd, PhD1, Gloria Yeh, MD, MPH2, Jeffery A Dusek,
PhD2, Wen Chen, PhD1, Ashlee Tipton, PhD1,
Emmeline Edwards, PhD1, John Denninger, MD/PhD, MS3, Peter
Wayne, PhD3 and Wendy Weber, ND, PhD, MPH1
1National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland
2Stockbridge, Georgia
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The purposes of this workshop are to provide attendees with
an overview of National Institutes of Health (NIH) training and career
development funding opportunities, tips for successful grant submissions and
review, and advice on key aspects of planning a successful research career with
NIH funding.
Objectives: The workshop will provide an overview of National Center
for Complementary and Integrative Health’s (NCCIH) strategic interests in
relation to training and career development opportunities by the Director of
Extramural Research (Dr Emmeline Edwards). The NCCIH Training Officer (Dr Lanay
Mudd) will provide an overview of training and career development funding
opportunities, and a Scientific Review Officer (Dr Ashlee Tipton) will describe
the review process. A mock study section consisting of some previous NCCIH
reviewers (Dr Gloria Yeh, Dr Jeffrey Dusek, Dr John Denninger, and Dr Peter
Wayne) will be used to illustrate key strengths and weaknesses commonly
discussed when reviewing F and K applications. Breakout sessions specific to
basic and mechanistic research or clinical research will discuss how to interact
with NCCIH staff to develop your proposal, planning a research career and
overcoming roadblocks, and how to find good mentors and collaborators. By the
end of the workshop, participants will know NCCIH strategic priorities for
clinical research and basic and mechanistic research; be able to develop a
research career plan that links NCCIH funding opportunities to different stages
of their career development; understand and be able to navigate the scientific
review process at NIH; know when and how to interact with NIH staff to develop
grant proposals; and be able to identify key characteristics of strong training
and career development grant proposals.
Outline: Didactic lectures with question and answer session for the
first 80 min (includes a hands-on career timeline activity).
Interactive mock study section for 30 min.
Didactic lecture for 15 min.
Interactive small groups with hands-on activities for last 55 min.
(3418) Putting Different Perspectives Into a Holistic Picture—How to Design an
Integrative Real Patient Conference
Friedrich Edelhäuser, MD, PhD1, Christian Scheffer, MD, MME1,
Diethard Tauschel, MD1, Peter Hinderberger, MD2 and Benjamin
Kligler, MD, MPH3
1Faculty for Health, Witten Herrdecke University, Witten, Germany
2Ruscombe Mansion Community Health Center, Baltimore, Maryland
3New York, New York
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to introduce participants to
an integrative patient conference with a real patient present; demonstrate a
systematic and collaborative approach to developing a diagnosis and a
therapeutic plan on 4 different levels: body, life processes, soul, and spirit;
and stimulate discussion on this approach as a conceptual integration of
conventional medicine with different CAM methods.
Objectives: Participants will be able to understand the potential
power of an integrative real patient conference, describe the principles of a
systematic 4-level approach to integrate different dimensions of diagnosis and
therapy, and describe the key elements for success in using real patient
conferences as an educational tool.
Outline: A major and challenging goal of integrative medicine and
health is to integrate different perspectives into a holistic framework.
Frequently, different CAM methods are simply added to conventional medicine, but
integration is lacking. Therefore, we suggest using a 4-level approach that
integrates conventional medicine—which is typically focused on the physical
dimension—with complementary/integrative-perspectives focusing on the 3 other
levels (life processes, soul, and spirit). This will be the conceptual framework
for the patient conference. In contrast to “paper cases” or simulations, real
patient conferences offer specific opportunities to focus on the patient and
his/her request for integrative health care; to perceive the different
dimensions of health, illness and healing; to exercise essential perception
skills; and to enhance experiential learning. The integrative real patient
conference has been developed over the last 14 years at the Integrated
Curriculum for Anthroposophic Medicine at Witten/Herdecke University and is
practiced regularly at the Clinical Education Ward for Integrative Medicine.
(3527) Using Health Coaching Skills to Enhance Patient Engagement and
Autonomy
Blaire Morriss, ANP1, Mark Dreusicke, MD1, Linda Manning,
PhD1 and Ann King, MA2
1Nashville, Tennessee
2National Board of Medical Examiners, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Informed, activated patients are essential to prevention
and treatment of chronic disease. Emerging health-care delivery practices
implicitly and explicitly demand that patients possess the skills to participate
constructively in their care, achieve coordinated care, increase treatment
adherence, and improve patient health outcomes. Yet clinicians are often either
not trained to support patient behavior change or believe it would be much more
time intensive than it needs to be. This experiential workshop will teach health
coaching skills to practitioners of all types to deepen their ability to enhance
patients’ autonomy, motivation, and ability to participate in their care. This
workshop will provide clinicians with instruction and multiple practice
opportunities to use health coaching skills to address patient desires and needs
in the moment in a way that empowers behavioral change. Participants will learn
to optimize intake forms to build patient autonomy and learn 7 key health
coaching skills to enhance growth-promoting relationships that support
behavioral change. These skills include mindful listening,
agenda setting in clinical encounters, provision of
accurate and meaningful reflections and summaries,
affirmation of patient strengths and values, utilization of
open-ended questions to empower patients, patient-centered
education using Elicit-Provide-Elicit, and Brief Action
Planning. Practitioners will also learn to identify patients in the
precontemplation and contemplation stages of change and practice coaching skills
to assist these patients to move forward in behavior change. The workshop will
be highly experiential, with brief overviews provided to explain the rationale
and use of each health coaching skill and demonstrations of how the skills fit
together. Each skill will be demonstrated and practiced in clinically relevant
scenarios using various configurations including dyads, triads, group practice,
and use of a new digital communication tool.
Objectives: After completing this workshop, participants will
1) understand the scientific and theoretical rationale for utilizing key health
coaching skills to enhance patient autonomy and motivation to change
behavior;
2) optimize intake forms to empower patients;
3) recognize the contribution of foundational health coaching skills (ie, mindful
listening) to growth-fostering relationships that support behavioral change;
4) practice addressing patient desires and needs in the moment utilizing mindful
listening and the other 6 additional health coaching and motivational
interviewing skills. In these practices, participants will learn to
• facilitate agenda setting in clinical encounters,
• provide accurate and meaningful reflections and summaries,
• clarify and support patient strengths and values through affirmations,
• utilize open-ended questions to empower patients,
• use Elicit-Provide-Elicit to educate patients in a highly patient-centric
manner, and
• support behavior change through Brief Action Planning.
5) “stack” or assemble the skills into usable formats in case-based
practices;
6) formulate appropriate steps forward in patient behavior change by identifying
patients in the precontemplation and contemplation stage of change and utilize
appropriate skills from the workshop to target this stage of change; and
7) demonstrate the integration of their new skills using a digital communication
tool.
(3578) Medicinal Plant Walk at Jim Duke’s Green Farmacy Garden
Andrea Miller, MS(c)1, Betsy Miller Costilo, MS1, Michael Tims,
PhD1, Termeh Feinberg, PhD, MPH2 and Bevin Clare,
MS1
1Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
2Center for Integrative Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this workshop is to develop or strengthen
skills in medicinal plant recognition, research, and use in clinical care. Dr
Jim Duke’s work in cataloguing both ethnobotanical and scientific evidence
surrounding the use of medicinal plants in the United States is unprecedented,
and his medicinal plant garden is a unique bounty of the plants he has
catalogued.
Objectives: The audience will be guided in a medicinal plant walk
and sensory tour around Jim Duke’s unique garden and will be encouraged to
participate in herb-related inquiry through interactions with tour leaders and
plants. The main educational outcome for this workshop is to increase
participant knowledge of medicinal plants, including when in the life cycle a
plant has the most medicinal properties, which has obvious implications for the
efficacy of herbal preparations used among patients in clinical practice.
Outline: Due to the wide variety of plants in the garden, as well as
perceived variability of the future growing season, it is not possible to list
specific plants which will be discussed. We will, however, prioritize discussion
on plants that are commonly seen in clinical practice and will be open to
answering questions on ethnobotanical background, current health applications,
and potential interactions regarding other specific plants the audience may be
curious about.
(3621) A Little Evidence Goes a Long Way … How to Write a High-quality Case
Report
Melissa S Barber, MSc1 and David S Riley, MD2
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
2Scientific Writing in Health and Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this workshop is to orient clinicians and
researchers on the case report writing and publishing process.
Objectives: From this workshop, attendees will become familiar with
the historical relevance and application of case reports, case report writing
tools (ie, CARE Guidelines and Explanation and Elaboration document), published
case report examples, critical evaluation skills for reading case reports, and
steps to writing and publishing a case report. The overall objectives are to
increase reporting from the point of care; support clinicians in writing a
high-quality, publishable case report; and create greater interface between
clinical and research communities.
Outline: This workshop will include a presentation, group breakout
sessions, and convening in a large group discussion.
(3622) Smartphone, Dumb BioMechanics. Fascia-based Pain Relief for Modern
Times
David Lesondak, BCSI, AS1
1Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this workshop is to provide the clinician or
physician with the skills to effectively indentify and treat common
musculoskeletal/myofascial pains associated with habitual cell phone usage. We
will include both pathoanatomical (postural) identifiers as well as
palpation-based assessments. Practical portion will teach how to target very
specific structures directly, comfortably, and effectively.
Objectives: The aim is to understand the fascia’s role as a tissue
and as a sensory nervous system; learn the biomechanical principle of tensegrity
in relation to the fascia and chronic postural deviations; identify the postural
patterns of habitual cell phone use, including analyzing the myofascial
relationships between the superficial front line and superficial back line;
recognize the contribution of the deeper arm and chest to the symptomatic neck,
shoulder, and arm pain; and learn 5 fascia-based approaches that provide
immediate relief.
Outline:
00:00–00:30—Introduction to fascia both as a tissue and a system.
00:30–01:00—Identifying common postural deviations and an overview of the
underlying myofascial pathology.
01:00–02:30—Practical portion includes palpation and treatment for sternochondral
fascia, scalenes, pectoralis minor, medial intermuscular septum, and
suboccipitals. Diaphragm will be covered in demo and with participants if time
allows.
02:30–03:30—Conclusions, questions, theoretical applications, and so on.
(3810) Weaving Together Patient-centered Care, Integrative Health, and Self-care:
The Whole Health Approach in Your Practice and Your Life
Adam Rindfleisch, MD1, Bisty Recupero, MD, Michael Hollifield, MD, Aysha
Saeed, MD, Theresa Liao, MD2, Carol Bowan, MD3 and Henri Roca,
MD
1University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin
2Portland, Oregon
3Baltimore, Maryland
4Little Rock, Arkansas
Abstract
Purpose: We all agree that patient-centered, integrative, and
self-care matter, but what does it look like to draw all of these elements of
care into your day-to-day practice? How do you create a personalized health plan
for each of your patients in a way that is both efficient and professionally
fulfilling? For several years, the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) National
Office of Patient-Centered Care and Cultural Transformation has been exploring
practical implementation of a new way of offering care, using what they call the
Whole Health approach. Over 5000 VA clinicians have received training in Whole
Health, and as of October 2017, 18 different VA facilities will be implementing
a Whole Health Systems model. The purpose of this preconference workshop is to
familiarize participants with the model, but even more importantly, to teach
them how to tailor the Whole Health approach to their own specific practices.
Skill building and experiential learning are emphasized, and multiple supportive
resources will be offered. The material from the VA’s national course, “Whole
Health in Your Practice,” will be adapted for use by non-VA clinicians. This
experience will enlist expertise from Whole Health educators nationwide and
builds on information that will be featured in Dr Tracy Gaudet's plenary
address.
Objectives: After completing this workshop, participants will be
able to describe the elements of Whole Health care, including the exploring
meaning/aspirations/purpose with patients, the Circle of Health, and the key
elements of Personal Health Planning; cocreate a personal health plan for
themselves and for a partner, emphasizing core values, self-care, and
complementary and integrative health approaches; describe how their own
self-care practices are relevant in this approach to care; complete a Whole
Health Assessment; discuss research findings relating to the efficacy of Whole
Health care and its various components; list at least 5 online resources where
they can get additional in-depth information about Whole Health; and describe 3
ways they will incorporate Whole Health more fully into practice after returning
home.
Outline: This 6-h session includes the following 9 modules, with
short breaks in the middle of the morning and afternoon sessions and a longer
break over lunchtime. Because faculty have taught these topics multiple times,
it is possible for us to gauge timing fairly accurately for each of the 9
modules.
1. Introductions (30 min): Participant introductions, introduction Whole Heath at
an individual, team, and system-wide level, with a focus on the Circle of Health
and elements of Personal Health Planning.
2. Mindful awareness (30 min): Summary of latest research on mindfulness, with
5-min mindfulness experience and discussion of how to integrate it into daily
clinical care. Each participant will assess their own clinical practice and
self-care in terms of what is going well and where they would like to make
improvements using 2 self-assessment instruments. Each person will complete a
Personal Health Inventory.
3. Cultivating therapeutic presence (30 min): Experiential exercise related to
reconnecting with reasons to enter a healing profession. Summary of research
related to how clinicians can be most effective for their patients/clients based
on nonspecific variables they bring into practice.
4. Self-care, part I (1 h): Participants will focus on 2 areas—healthy
surroundings (optimal healing environments; 30 min) and resilience/personal
development (30 min). They will complete an exercise related to key elements of
a healing space with a small group discussion with a partner. They will have
small group discussion on what contributes to resilience. Participants will each
be assigned “health planning partners” and they will begin to do Whole Health
assessments with each other, asking questions related to surroundings and
personal development.
5. Self-care, part II (40 min), healthy lifestyle: Self-care tips and resources
related to eating, activity, and sleep will be discussed. A guided movement
meditation will be offered in the middle of the time. Participants will discuss
these 3 aspects of self-care with their health planning partners.
6. Self-care, part III (40 min), healthy connections: Spirituality,
relationships, and power of mind will be discussed, with an emphasis on research
related to their roles in promoting health and well-being. Participants will
share their perspectives on spirituality and clinical care with their small
groups. They will practice taking a partner through a basic breathing exercise.
They will discuss these 3 elements of self-care with their planning partners as
well.
7. Professional care (40 min): The role of complementary and integrative health
in practice will be discussed, with a focus on several of the most popular
approaches used nationally. The VA now requires that several complementary
approaches be provided by all VA sites, and this unique perspective will be
discussed in a large group format. National resources to support professionals
in Whole Health Practice will be shared. Faculty will demonstrate the overall
model with a participant volunteer.
8. Implementation I (45 min): Working with their same partners, participants will
finish creating, with step-by-step guidance, their Personal Health Plan.
9. Implementation II (45 min): Working in small groups, participants will discuss
how to apply the Whole Health model in their own practices and share their ideas
with the larger group.
(3941) Honing Your Clinical Research Proposal for National Institutes of Health
and National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health Funding
Opportunities
Martina Schmidt, PhD1, Dave Clark, DrPH, MPH1, Emmeline
Edwards, PhD1, Wendy Weber, ND, PhD, MPH1 and Wen G Chen,
MMSc, PhD1
1National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: This workshop will provide attendees with an overview of
how to develop an application to National Institutes of Health (NIH) or National
Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) that includes human
subjects. The session will focus on how to distinguish between developing a
mechanistic study to determine how a complementary or integrative health
intervention exerts its effect versus developing an intervention that will be
tested to evaluate whether the intervention is beneficial for a given clinical
condition or symptom. Attendees will learn about important changes to NIH
funding opportunities and application forms, tips for successful grant
submissions and review, and specific NCCIH funding opportunities that will
support research with human subjects.
Objectives: The workshop will provide an overview of NCCIH’s
strategic interests in clinical research by the Director of Extramural Research
(Dr Emmeline Edwards). The NCCIH Clinical Research Branch Chief (Dr Wendy Weber)
will provide an overview of NIH policy changes related to clinical trials, and
Clinical Research Branch Program Director (Dr Dave Clark) will present NCCIH
funding opportunities for clinical trials focused on clinical outcomes. The
NCCIH Basic and Mechanistic Research Branch Chief (Dr Wen Chen) will summarize
how NCCIH encourages applicants to study the mechanisms of complementary and
integrative health approaches and the funding opportunities available to support
this type of research. A Scientific Review Officer (Dr Martina Schmidt) will
describe key changes to the application forms and how they will impact the
review process. Breakout sessions specific to human subjects basic and
mechanistic research or clinical outcomes focused research will allow attendees
to interact with NCCIH staff to discuss questions related to submitting an
application to NCCIH and NIH generally. By the end of the workshop, participants
will know NCCIH strategic priorities for human subjects research for both
clinical outcome focused research and basic and mechanistic focused research; be
able to identify which funding opportunity to use to submit a human subjects
research application to NCCIH; understand how the NIH review process will
evaluate the information submitted in the new NIH application forms; and
understand recent important changes to NIH policy for clinical trials.
Outline: Didactic lectures with question and answer (Q&A)
session for the first 120 min (2:1 lecture to Q&A). Interactive small groups
with hands-on activities for last 45 min.
Oral Session Abstracts
(64) Medicaton Cost Savings in an Inpatient Oncology Unit Using an Integrative
Model
Irene M Estores, MD1, Robert R Leverence, MD1, Lazarus Mramba,
PhD1, Carrie Warring, MHS, MBA1, Lauren Arce,
MSN2 and Andrew Hix, BS2
1University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida
2UF Shands Hospital, Gainesville, Florida
Abstract
Purpose/Background: Patients with a cancer diagnosis experience symptoms that
reduce their quality of life and ability to complete treatment. Pharmacologic
approaches alone are inadequate in fully controlling symptoms such as pain,
anxiety, emesis, and insomnia. They also contribute to adverse events and do not
promote self-empowerment. Nonpharmacologic approaches have been shown to improve
symptom control and sense of well-being. However, more data are needed on
related costs and outcomes.
Objective: To determine the effect of hospital-based integrative
medicine services on medication costs for opioids, benzodiazepines, and
antiemetics in an adult hematology oncology unit.
Results: Cost data were available for 111 hospital encounters for
patients who received integrative services and 273 encounters for those who did
not. Controlling for level of pain and length of stay, we found a decrease in
average medication cost per day of 41% (P = .003) for the
intervention group compared to a comparison group.
Conclusions: An integrative medicine model delivered on an inpatient
oncology unit that incorporates patient preference in care planning results in a
relative drug cost reduction for opioids, benzodiazepines, and antiemetics.
(1090) The Radical Redesign of Health Care: The Whole Health System
Amanda Hull, PhD1, Alison M Whitehead, MPH1, Kavitha Reddy,
MD1, Lauri Phillips, RDN, LD1, Jennifer Patterson,
PhD1 and Maureen Khung, MPH1
1Bedford, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: With the opioid epidemic, veteran suicides, rising rates
of chronic illness despite high expenditures, and provider burnout, it is time
to radically reenvision and redesign health care to create a health-based,
rather than disease-based, care system. We must expand our understanding of what
defines health care and develop a Whole Health System (WHS) that empowers and
equips individuals to discover a path to health and well-being. The Department
of Veterans Affairs (VA) is uniquely positioned to make this a reality for
veterans and our nation. The WHS has 3 components: (1) The pathway where peers
partner with the individual and their family, exploring their
mission/aspiration/purpose, and introduce personal health planning; (2)
well-being programs focusing on skill building in support of self-care goals and
including health coaching as well as proactive, complementary and integrative
health (CIH) approaches; and (3) Whole Health Clinical Care that focuses on
treatment with clinicians trained in whole health and includes changing the
conversation, aligning health goals with life goals, delivering care through
healing environments and relationships, CIH approaches, coaching, and personal
health planning. The implementation of the WHS requires a large-scale education
and deployment strategy for providers and staff, utilizing field implementation
teams around the country to assist with local implementation and community
partnerships. Eighteen design sites have been funded since Fiscal Year 16 (FY16)
to pilot components of this system. Supported by the Comprehensive Recovery and
Addiction Act legislation, VA has launched the implementation of the full system
in 18 Flagship Facilities in FY18, which is the first wave in national
deployment. Veteran engagement, activation, and satisfaction, utilization of
resources and biometrics will be tracked, as well as the interface with opioid
safety and suicide prevention. This session will review the WHS model of care
and its implementation at sites across VA.
Rationale: With the national opioid epidemic, veteran suicides,
rising rates of chronic illness despite high expenditures, and health-care
provider burnout, it is time to radically reenvision and redesign health care to
create a health-, rather than disease, care system. The VA is unique in that it
covers all aspects outlined in this year’s conference: research, education,
clinical practice, and policy.
Objectives: The aim is to describe 3 components of WHS, understand
how to implement large-system transformation, and list key outcomes of success
in whole health implementation.
(1094) Developing Concepts for Information, Communication, Counseling, and
Training of Health Professionals Who Are Involved in the Care of Cancer
Patients
Alfred Laengler1, Claudia M Witt2, Jan Schildmann3,
Corina Guethlin, PhD4, Stefanie Joos5 and Markus
Horneber6
1University Witten/Heredecke, Herdecke, Germany
2University Hospital Zurich, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
3Wilhelm Löhe University of Applied Science, Fuerth, Germany
4Johann Wolfgang Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, Germany
5University of Tübingen, Tuebingen, Germany
6Paracelsus Medical University Klinikum Nuernberg, Nuernberg, Germany
Abstract
Overview: Communication of health professionals about “Complementary
and Alternative Medicine” (CAM) in oncology, pediatric oncology, and primary
care is important. The German Cancer Aid is funding the “Competence Network
Complementary Medicine in Oncology” (KOKON) that consists of 20 academic
institutions and works on 9 research projects. The overall goal is developing
concepts for information, communication, counseling, and training of health
professionals who are involved in the care of cancer patients. Prospectively,
these concepts and offers should improve care for patients and their relatives
and support physicians in their daily work. For this purpose, one focus is the
systematic development and evaluation of training concepts for physicians. This
symposium will present and discuss structure and content of the different
training programs and share first results and lessons learned.
Rationale: More than half of the cancer patients use complementary
and integrative medicine. Many of them would like to get information about this
topic from their treating physicians. However, oncologists and primary care
physicians don’t feel particularly confident when discussing CAM-related topics.
There is a demand for feasible, high-quality trainings for health professionals
to develop knowledge and skills to inform their patients about CAM. KOKON
develops and evaluates 3 blended-learning (e-learning and on-site workshop)
training programs for physicians.
Objectives: The symposium will provide an overview about the content
and structure of the 3 newly developed training programs for physicians (medical
oncologist and gynecological surgeons, general practitioners, and pediatric
oncologist) and the rationale for the methodological steps taken during the
development. First results and leasons learned will be shared. Furthermore, the
overall aims and impact of the competence network complementary medicine in
oncology will be presented and discussed.
Outline:
Introduction/Aims of the Workshop
A. Längler; C.M. Witt (5 min)
Overview KOKON network
M. Horneber (10 min)
The multidisciplinary Competence Network “Complementary Medicine in
Oncology—KOKON” aims to improve standards for evidence-based information,
communication, and training through systematic research and collaborative
partnership of 20 universities and academic institutions of all areas of cancer
care.
CAM training for general practitioners
C. Guethlin, S. Joos (10 min)
Based on a questionnaire addressing training needs, we set up a blended-learning
training to enable GPs to talk about CAM with their cancer patients.
The training consists of (1) e-learning modules addressing definitions, concepts
of a variety of CAM options, and research results of the most prominent CAM
therapies in general practice and (2) a very practical workshop helping GPs to
talk about CAM options will be another part of the blended-learning training.
The training will be evaluated by means of a randomized pilot study.
CAM training for medical oncologist and gynaecological surgeons
C.M. Witt (10 min)
A blended-learning training (9 × 45 min e-learning plus 2 days onsite workshop)
for medical oncologist and gynaecological surgeons to inform their patients
about CAM has been developed and is under evaluation in a cluster-randomized
trial. A total of 40 physicians will inform 400 patients (10 each),
effectiveness evaluation will take place in 3 settings (after the e-learning,
during the workshop, and after physicians interacted with their patients). We
will share first results and lessons learned.
CAM training for pediatric oncologists
A. Längler (10 min)
In close cooperation with the projects “general practitioners “and “medical
oncologist and gynaecological surgeons,” this module develops specific
e-learning materials for the target group of “pediatric oncologists.” Results of
an expert survey as well as literature search are the basis for the e-learning
materials. The contents of the e-learning are based upon individual frequently
used or demanded treatment methods as well as on symptom-oriented treatment
strategies of integrative medicine in pediatric oncology. In addition, a
practice workshop with actor patients will be developed in which pediatric
oncologists deal with special decision-making and counseling situations.
Decision-making about complementary and integrative medicine. An
empirical-ethical analysis and guidance for consultation with cancer
patients
J. Schildmann (10 min)
Requests about complementary and integrative medicine (CAM) form a frequent and
at the same time challenging part of consultations with patients with cancer. In
this paper, we provide a findings from an interdisciplinary analysis of experts
in clinical medicine, medical ethics, and psychology on challenges regarding CAM
in oncology, general practice, and pediatric oncology. Based on content analysis
of qualitative research (ie, documentation and interviews with physicians and
patients) in combination with normative analysis, we present perceived needs
regarding CAM knowledge and skills and provide guidance and underlying
rationales for professional strategies to deal with CAM associated challenges
within the patient–physician encounter.
(1119) Genomic, Neural, and Allostatic Assessments Reveal Similarities and
Differences Among Mind–Body Interventions
Manoj Bhasin, PhD1, John Denninger, MD2, Elizabeth Hoge,
MD3 and Sara Lazar, PhD3
1Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
3Charlestown, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Little is known about how mind–body approaches differ in
terms of mechanisms of action. Combining experimental methodologies can reveal
commonalities and differences that have implications both for understanding the
approaches themselves and for designing studies to test them. The 4 speakers are
collaborating on a randomized clinical trial (RCT) (n = 211 healthy but stressed
adults) that compares the mechanistic basis of a yoga-based, a meditation-based,
and an attention control education-based program. Using the results of this
study as a use case, presenters will discuss the mechanistic and study-design
implications for mind–body interventions.
Rationale: Growing evidence suggests that mind–body programs may
utilize different mechanisms of action. These differences may have profound
implications for choosing the right methodologies to test treatments and,
ultimately, selecting the right treatments for our patients.
Objectives: Participants will be able to (1) explain how combining
methodologies can reveal commonalities and differences among mind–body programs,
(2) compare the underlying mechanisms of yoga and meditation, and (3) describe
the broader mechanistic and study-design implications for mind–body
programs.
Outline: The first speaker will frame the general problem of
choosing the best outcome measures for mind–body medicine studies and discuss
the rationale, design, and psychological findings of the RCT. The second speaker
will discuss findings from the allostatic load data, a composite measure used to
assess the effects of stress on multiple systems. The third speaker will present
findings on genomic and epigenomic changes in response to the 3 programs and,
combining these with findings from studies of massage and exercise, will discuss
pathways that change exclusively in mind–body programs. The fourth speaker will
discuss changes in neural structure and function associated with each program,
as well as changes associated with 2 other mind–body programs. The speakers will
also discuss the relationship between the measures and the power of integrating
them for investigating mind–body interventions.
(1144) Avoid the Struggle: Empowering Your Most Complex Patients to Make
Sustainable Health Behavior Change
Caryn Seebach, PsyD1 and Alyssa Adams, PsyD2
1Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA
2Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: Integrative medicine (IM) providers encounter some of the
most complex patients. These patients often present with multiple comorbid
conditions and may feel psychologically overwhelmed and disempowered. There can
be a high burden of responsibility placed on the IM health-care provider to
transition the patient from disillusioned to an active participant in his/her
own health care. This workshop will provide practical, applied approaches to
effectively support the biopsychosocial needs of even the most complex patients.
The theory and research supporting sustainable health behavior change will be
reviewed and clinicians will learn techniques grounded in health coaching,
positive neuroplasticity, and motivational enhancement that can be directly
applied in the next patient encounter. Providers will also explore their own
subjective reactions to complicated patients and how they impact the clinical
encounter.
Rationale: The cornerstone of IM is treating the whole person, which
necessitates a grounded understanding of behavioral medicine principles that
foster sustainable health behavior change. A growing proportion of patients with
complicated emotional and physical concerns are seeking IM providers. This
workshop is designed to support the IM clinician in facilitating the patient’s
transition from disempowered and frustrated to empowered and hopeful using a
health psychology framework. IM and functional medicine training programs
typically teach basic patient–provider communication skills, but this workshop
is designed to delve deeper into the nuances and common barriers that many
clinicians face during real-world implementation with complex patients. The
instructors have an extensive and varied background in clinical health
psychology, nutrition, and health behavior change and have worked with many
complex and challenging patients with chronic health issues.
Purpose: To provide evidence-based support, guidance, and skill
building to IM providers working with their most challenging cases (eg, multiple
comorbidities, externalizing patients, passive/disempowered patients).
Objectives: The aim is to identify various models of health behavior
change, assess patient stage of change and identify the appropriate intervention
to match, explore personal reactions to difficult patients and resultant impact
on the clinical encounter, and hone communication and health behavior change
skills.
Results: Providers will have an understanding of the extant research
regarding patient–provider communication with complex patients, communication
tools for facilitating health behavior change, and countertransference.
Conclusions: Patients with complex presentations are likely to seek
the care of IM providers, which requires IM providers to communicate in a way
that facilitates health behavior change, empowers the patient, and maintains
awareness of their own personal reactions to difficult patients. At the end of
this workshop, providers will have identified various models of health behavior
change, assessed patient stages of change and how to identify the appropriate
intervention to match, explored their personal reactions to difficult patients
and the resultant impact on the clinical encounter, and honed their
communication and health behavior change skills.
Outline: Background and evidence base
1. The empirical study of nonadherence, what the research says
2. What is health psychology and how it applies?
3. The empirical tenets of health behavioral change
Models of care in health behavior change
1. A new understanding of why change is possible
• Positive neuroplasticity
• Foundational principles of health coaching
• The role of motivational enhancement
Applied skills
1. The “holding” environment
2. Assessment and alignment with patient’s stage of change
3. Tools for externalization and the “yes, but” patient
4. Assessment and strategies for illness and identity
5. Techniques for empowerment and shifting responsibility to the patient
6. Awareness and management of subjective clinician experience and
countertransference
Group experiential exercise/discussion
(1153) Assessment of the Analgesic Properties of Auriculotherapy in Patients
Undergoing Carpal Tunnel Surgery
Carine Chaix-Couturier, MD, PhD1, Christian couturier, MD2 and
Henri Weckmans, MD2
13C-Santé, Meudon, France
2Clinique Arago Paris, Paris, France
Abstract
Purpose: Effective perioperative pain management of patients
undergoing hand surgery is critical because of the risk of postoperative of
algodystrophy. In the present context of increase concerns of opioid addiction
associated with surgery, increase considerations have been given to the use of
complementary approaches including auriculotherapy (AT) for perioperative pain
management. This study was designed to assess the analgesic properties of AT in
patients undergoing carpal tunnel surgery.
Results: The use of AT was associated with a significant decrease in
postoperative pain. Graph is attached below. POD# 1, 2, and 3 was 1, 0.7, and
0.8, respectively, in group 1 versus 3, 2, and 0.6 in group 2
(P < .005). Postoperative analgesic consumption was
similar in both groups. At 21 days, no patient required any analgesic
medication.
Conclusions: This preliminary study suggests that AT represents an
effective complementary approach to control postoperative pain following carpal
tunnel. Further investigations are required to confirm these findings.
(1160) Is Mindfulness Immeasurable? Discovery and Dialogue of Conceptual,
Practical, Scientific, and Experiential Solutions
David Victorson, PhD1, Eric Garland, PhD2, Adam Hanley,
PhD2 and Carol Greco, PhD3
1Chicago, Illinios
2Center on Mindfulness and Integrative Health Intervention Development,
Salt Lake City, Utah
3Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) have a prominent
place in public health and clinical research, yet a significant gap still
remains in mindfulness research: the lack of a comprehensive and standardized
self-report measurement system. Due to the sheer number of available mindfulness
measurement tools, each measuring different concepts in different ways, it is
difficult to establish whether MBI participants actually develop mindfulness
skills and attitudes, whether health outcomes can be attributed to intervention
gains, and whether mindfulness itself is the active ingredient in MBIs. Due to
this veritable “mindfulness alphabet soup,” it is not possible to compare
findings from one trial with another. Further, “response shift” can add to
confusion when one experiences a recalibration in understanding of what
mindfulness is after being exposed. In other words, there is a paradox inherent
in mindfulness measurement—if one is not mindful, how can one be aware enough to
assess their degree of mindfulness? And, it is only when one becomes more
mindful through training that they can begin to recognize when they are not
exhibiting mindfulness. This symposium session will address this topic through 3
presentations focusing on (1) challenges and possible solutions to measuring
mindfulness and related constructs drawing from the Patient-Reported Outcomes
Measurement Information System (PROMIS); (2) psychophysiological alternatives to
assessing mindfulness via self-report; and (3) a brief overview of the
methodology and focus group findings of a new National Center for Complementary
and Integrative Health (NCCIH)-funded R01 entitled Creating and
Optimizing Mindfulness Measures to Enhance and Normalize Clinical
Evaluation-R01AT009539, including experiential practice and
dialogue on some of the big questions surrounding mindfulness measurement.
Rationale: The scientific premise behind this symposium is that it
will generate important knowledge and discussion surrounding mindfulness
measurement and how PROMIS and other methodologies can help enhance and
standardize future efforts and ultimately reshape the mindfulness measurement
landscape.
Objectives: After attending this session, participants will be able
to describe common measurement challenges for mindfulness and related
constructs; identify ways in which PROMIS-based methodologies (eg, item
development, item response theory, item banking, computer-adaptive testing,
score linking) can help enhance and standardize mindfulness measurement;
recognize common real-world lessons learned from clinical trials research
experiences; increase understanding of a new NCCIH-funded effort to improve
mindfulness measurement; and engage in critical reflection and dialogue around
these issues.
Outline:
A. Introduction
B. Presentation I: Mindfulness and meditation-induced states of consciousness as
outcomes in integrative clinical trials research: lessons learned from the
trenches. This talk will provide real-world examples from several clinical
mindfulness studies, as well as new data from novel measures of deeper
meditative states, including nondual awareness.
C. Presentation II: Challenges and possible solutions to measuring mindfulness
and related constructs. This talk will provide an overview of some of biggest
challenges to measuring mindfulness and transition to some possibly solutions
based on item response theory methods and score linking/equating.
D. Presentation III: Highlights from the NCCIH-funded COMMENCE R01.
E. Question and answer, dialogues and experiential practice on some of the big
questions surrounding mindfulness measurement.
F. Summary and conclusion
(2169) Tools to Encourage Resiliency in Health-care Providers and
Educators
Audrey J Brooks, PhD1, Hilary McClafferty, MD1, Patricia
Lebensohn, MD1 and Mari Ricker, MD1
1Tucson, Arizona
Abstract
Overview: The University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine
developed an interactive, online Healthcare Professional Wellbeing curriculum.
The Wellbeing curriculum focuses on building resiliency skills, teaching
mindfulness techniques, and reflection activities that help reduce stress and
decrease burnout. We will describe how we piloted the curriculum in multiple
primary care educational training programs and community health centers. We will
describe our experience piloting the curriculum with residency programs within
our institution, collaborating with leaders across the organization, and
implementing a large scale, multispecialty Resident Wellbeing Training Program.
We will explore the lessons learned from these endeavors and review our outcome
data from this pilot program in the areas of hardiness, resiliency, gratitude,
and burnout. Participants will explore their own self-care challenges and learn
skills from the curriculum to improve their resiliency. Participants will
discuss feasibility to implement the changes in their lives and how to adapt the
program to their own institutions and how they can most effectively act as
agents of change within organizations. Emphasis will be placed on the need to
address burnout prevention and wellness promotion among all heath care
professionals, and at all levels of a health-care organization, for meaningful
change in the culture of burnout to occur.
Rationale: Burnout is highly prevalent and exceeds 46% among all
specialties. Residency programs have been mandated to address these unacceptably
high burnout levels, and are in need of effective tools to help address burnout
and promote well-being and resilience, and to teach residents the lifelong
skills to prevent future burnout. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical
Education has also identified physician well-being and the need to create
transformative changes in the culture of medicine as a top priority to be
addressed by Graduate Medical Education. However, focusing efforts on the
individual resident is insufficient, change in attitudes must occur at all
levels, in every type of health-care professional, and across the organizational
structure for meaningful change in burnout prevention to occur. Therefore,
programs are urgently needed to address underlying culture of burnout and
unrealistic endurance in organizations, in conjunction with individual education
and skill building in residents, faculty, and other health-care professionals.
The Healthcare Professional Wellbeing Course is designed to accomplish these
objectives and was piloted with primary care educational training programs, with
residents at a large academic institution, and with clinicians and staff at
community health centers for this purpose.
Objectives: The aim is to identify 4 elements of an evidence-based
approach to health-care professional well-being, list 3 interactive activities
that can be implemented in the academic and/or clinical settings to build
resiliency skills, and formulate the first steps of an action plan to begin to
implement well-being activities personally and within your education or work
setting.
Outline: Drs Ricker and Lebensohn will provide an overview of the
Healthcare Professional Wellbeing Course, detailing the components of the course
that guide participants to building resiliency skills, learn mindfulness
techniques, and practice reflection activities that help reduce stress and
decrease burnout. Dr Brooks will provide an overview of the evaluation results,
reviewing our outcome data in the areas of hardiness, resiliency, gratitude, and
burnout. Dr McClafferty will discuss the distinction between resiliency versus
burnout and moderate participant completion of wellness and self-care
assessments. Drs Lebensohn, McClafferty, and Ricker will lead 3 breakout groups
teaching resiliency practices from the course. Dr Lebensohn will moderate a
discussion on feasibility of implementing resiliency practices and self-care
strategies personally and within organizations, and how to act effectively as
agents of change within organizations.
(2201) Listen to Your Body: A Multidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive
Awareness for Mind–Body Research
Adam Hanley, PhD1, Eric Garland, PhD1, Emily Stern,
PhD2, Wolf E Mehling, MD2 and Cynthia J Price,
PhD3
1Center on Mindfulness and Integrative Health Intervention Development,
Salt Lake City, Utah
2San Francisco, California
3University of Washington, Seattle, Washington
Abstract
Overview: Interoception has been defined as the sensing of the
physiological condition of the body. Interoceptive bodily awareness is emerging
as a critical element for the understanding of mechanisms in mind–body research
and psychological health. Mindfulness approaches include training in attention
regulation toward breathing and other subtle body sensations. Alterations of
interoception play a key role in psychological health, and integrative medicine
approaches appear to be able to improve medical conditions through interoceptive
training. Interoceptive awareness is ambiguous and can be clinically beneficial
or maladaptive depending on the mode of attention, being either anxiety-driven
or mindful. Scientific research in the field of interoception is still hindered
by unresolved differences in the terminology of its multiple dimensions and the
lack of strong measurements for research that are also meaningful to clinicians.
Following a brief overview of the current terminology, the controversies around
it, and available objective/behavioral and self-report measures, the presenters
will focus on the MAIA and their research with this self-report measure, its
usefulness and limitations.
Rationale: Researchers in this field are just beginning to cooperate
across the world. This symposium addresses the need for stronger collaboration
among interoception and mind–body researchers to advance integrative health
using mind–body approaches. The MAIA’s 20 translations may assist in
international cooperation.
Objectives: As a result of this session, participants will have
learned about the concept of interoception, the complexity of its multiple
dimensions, the current state of measurement development for rigorous research
in the field of interoceptive body awareness, and will be able to make informed
measurement decisions for research and clinic.
Outline:
Introduction: Wolf Mehling will introduce the speakers. He will
clarify terms: bodily awareness, interoceptive awareness, interoceptive
accuracy, interoceptive sensibility, mindfulness, and their place in mind–body
therapies and contemplative practices. He will give a brief overview of
measurements: objective and self-report. Emily Stern
investigated neural mechanisms of interoception when 19 healthy individuals
attended to their heartbeat and skin temperature and examined the relationship
between neural activity during interoception and individual differences in
self-reported interoceptive sensibility (IS) using the MAIA together with
functional MRI brain imaging. IS represents the construct underlying the MAIA,
here synonymous with interoceptive awareness, a multidimensional construct
including not only the tendency to be aware of sensation but also how sensations
are interpreted, regulated, and used to inform behavior, with different
dimensions relating to different aspects of health and disease. Her data suggest
that self-rated IS is related to altered activation in regions involved in
monitoring body state, which has implications for disorders associated with
abnormality of interoception. Cynthia Price will present data
from an NIDA-funded clinical trial of mindful awareness in body-oriented therapy
(MABT) for women in substance use disorder treatment. MABT is designed to teach
interoceptive awareness and related skills for emotion regulation. The
presentation will focus on the associations between baseline measures and the
MAIA (N = 217), as well as the performance of the MAIA (ie, sensitivity to
change) in response to the intervention. These results support prior
neurobiological models and imaging research indicating the importance of
interoceptive awareness for emotion regulation and the potential relevance to
improved substance use disorder treatment outcomes. Eric
Garland and Adam Hanley will present results from
clinical studies using the MAIA with mindfulness-oriented recovery enhancement
(MORE) from 2 separate RCTs: MORE in obese cancer survivors (N = 51) and MORE
for opioid misusing chronic pain patients (N = 62). In both studies, MORE was
associated with significant increases in multiple MAIA subscales and increases
in self-regulation mediated the effect of MORE on reducing psychological
distress. They will also present cross-sectional network associations between
MAIA scales, dispositional mindfulness (Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire
[FFMQ]) and Scales of Psychological Well-Being in healthy adults
(N = 478). Wolf Mehling will present data
from (1) a study of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for comorbid
depression and chronic pain (N = 31). Increases in the MBCT group were
significantly greater than in the TAU group on the Self-Regulation and Not
Distracting scales of the MAIA. Furthermore, the positive effect of MBCT on
depression severity was mediated by “Not Distracting.” (2) In another study of
integrative exercise (IE) using aerobic and resistance exercise with
mindfulness-based principles and yoga provided improvements in PTSD intensity,
quality of life improvements in mindfulness, interoceptive bodily awareness
(MAIA), and positive states of mind in 47 war veterans with PTSD randomized to
12-week IE versus waitlist. Large effect sizes for the intervention were
observed on FFMQ nonreactivity (d = 0.85), MAIA body listening
(d = 0.80) and self-regulation (d = 1.05).
Finally, he will provide an overview over shortcomings of the original MAIA,
efforts to improve it and the use of the MAIA in its 20 translations in other
countries.
(2215) Role of Acupuncture in Integrative Medicine
Helene M Langevin, MD1, Sanjay Reddy, MD1, Melinda Ring,
MD1 and Chongbin Zhu, MD, PhD1
1Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee
Abstract
Overview:
Background: Acupuncture, as a specialty in Traditional Chinese
Medicine, has been increasingly available within conventional health-care
settings. There is growing evidence supporting the efficacy of acupuncture in
conditions ranging from chronic pain to mood disorders. While more high-quality
studies are warranted, the value of acupuncture as a component of health care is
increasingly recognized by integrative medicine (IM) practitioners and patients.
IM treatment plans often include recommendations for acupuncture. The role of
acupuncture as part of the system of IM, however, has not been clearly defined.
Program description: This proposal is to address and
explore acupuncture-based model(s) of collaborative intervention for IM
practitioners. Acupuncture is classically described as treating the whole person
and will be explored on multiple levels. From our practices, we observe that
acupuncture can improve symptoms, enhance quality of life, promote well-being,
reduce unwanted side effects of conventional treatments, and shorten recovery
time. We propose to explore several models of acupuncture-based integrative
intervention and models for inclusion within inpatient and outpatient settings.
We also propose to discuss the challenge of acupuncture-based models in
research, education, and policy/regulation. Conclusion:
Acupuncture-based integrative practice in our current health-care setting will
benefit from guidelines. The challenges of acupuncture in the context of
practice, research, and policy will be addressed, with recommendations to define
its role in IM.
Rationale: Although acupuncture has been proven effective in several
pain conditions and is receiving increased attention due to the opioid crisis,
the role of this unique modality in IM has yet to be defined. Acupuncture is
most often used in collaboration with other interventions; however, there are no
guidelines for IM or conventional health-care practitioners to refer patients to
acupuncture-based integrative interventions. Additionally, there are significant
challenges for acupuncture in research, education, and regulation/policy. In
research, appropriate acupuncture controls and blinding can be problematic. In
education, acupuncture, or IM as a whole, has not been endorsed by a majority of
medical schools, although it is being increasingly discussed. In
regulation/policy, the majority of insurance providers do not cover effective
acupuncture treatment in most states in the United States, hindering the public
access to acupuncture-based integrative intervention. The resolution to the
aforementioned issues requires a collaborative effort from different fields. Our
proposal is to address the above aspects to create recommendations that can
influence policy and is relevant to the conference theme: collaboration in
action.
Objectives: Participants will know the role of acupuncture-based
intervention in IM, commonly used models of acupuncture-based therapy, and
possible mechanisms. They will also have increased clarity about the current
challenges acupuncture practice faces in clinical care, research, and education.
Through a panel discussion with audience engagement, speakers and participants
will help work out some resolution via this program or provide direction for
future resolution.
Outline:
1. To define the role of acupuncture in IM and general health care.
2. To elaborate models of acupuncture-based integrative intervention.
3. To address challenges of acupuncture practice in clinic, education, and
research.
(2226) Neural Mechanisms of Manual Therapies for Chronic Pain
Mark D Bishop, PT, PhD1, William R Reed, DC, PhD2, Laura Case,
PhD3, Merav Sabri, PhD3, Partap S Khalsa, DC, PhD,
DABCO3 and Helene M Langevin, MD4
1University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida
2University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama
3National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, Bethesda,
Maryland
4Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Manual therapies (MTs) are a class of nonpharmacological
approaches that can be used for treatment and management of chronic pain. MT
(eg, massage, mobilization, spinal manipulation) could be an alternative to, or
used to reduce need for, prescription opioids. This is especially important
given the current, national prescription opioid epidemic. However, the
mechanisms by which MTs reduce pain are insufficiently understood, and this lack
of understanding impedes their optimal utilization. Further, there is little
consensus on the extent to which MTs modulate and/or modify neurophysiological
responses in the peripheral and/or central nervous system (ie, brain and spinal
cord), nor how neurophysiological responses might reciprocally affect peripheral
tissues and/or immunological processes. This proposed National Center for
Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)-sponsored symposium will explore
theoretically based research directions that focus on elucidating the peripheral
and central neural mechanisms of MT, with the goal to achieve individualized
mechanism-based pain management. The symposium will begin with a brief overview
by the cochair, Dr Merav Sabri, on the NCCIH priorities for manual therapies.
The first speaker, Dr Mark Bishop, will introduce a theoretical and testable
framework of the mechanisms of MT. The second speaker, Dr Helene Langevin, will
discuss the evidence and importance of peripheral mechanisms of MT. The third
speaker, Dr William Reed, will present evidence and the importance of central
mechanisms of MT. The fourth speaker, Dr Laura Case, will present research
related to the sensory-affective neural mechanisms of massage. The symposium
will conclude with a discussion moderated by the cochair, Dr Partap Khalsa.
Rationale: MTs (eg, massage, mobilization, spinal manipulation) are
a class of nonpharmacological approaches that can be used for treatment and
management of chronic pain. Based on data from Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention /National Center for Health Statistics National Health Interview
Surveys (2002 and 2012), there is a significant increase in adult use of MT for
pain management. MT could be an alternative to, or used to reduce need for,
prescription opioids. This is especially important given the current, national
prescription opioid epidemic. The mechanisms by which MT reduces pain are not
well established. Consequently, clinicians are often challenged in selecting the
most efficacious therapeutic approach for individuals with chronic pain.
Mechanistic understanding of MT effects could facilitate the development and
implementation of mechanism-based, individualized pain management, and
identification of responders from nonresponders. Historically, local and
segmental responses (eg, in tissue, structure) to MT were considered responsible
for clinical benefit. This biomechanical approach could not explain the presence
of nonsegmental hypoalgesia and autonomic function changes (eg, heart rate),
bringing attention to neurophysiological responses to MT. However, there is
little consensus on the extent to which MTs modulate and/or modify
neurophysiological responses in the peripheral and/or central nervous system
(ie, brain and spinal cord), nor how such responses might reciprocally affect
peripheral tissues and/or immunological processes. There is evidence that MTs
affect the interaction between inflammatory mediators and peripheral nociceptors
in response to injury. In addition, changes in spinal excitability following MT,
as indicated by decreased nociceptive flexion reflexes and reduced temporal
summation, represent evidence for reduced facilitation and increased inhibition
of nociceptive input as mediated by central descending pain modulatory systems.
Still, direct evidence for spinal or cortical changes are weak and whether
central nervous system plays a dominant or secondary role is unknown. The
proposed NCCIH-sponsored symposium will explore theoretically based neuroscience
research that focus on elucidating the potential peripheral and central
mechanisms of MT, to facilitate the development of individualized
mechanism-based pain management. The goals of this symposium are to (1)
stimulate discussion among clinicians, physiologists, and neuroscientists; (2)
facilitate collaborations on research of the neural pathways by which MT exert
beneficial effects; and (3) promote optimization of MT.
Objectives: The aim is to discuss the theoretical framework of MT
mechanisms, assess the peripheral and central mechanisms underlying MT, and
identify research gaps and discuss future research directions of the mechanisms
by which MT work to alleviate pain.
Outline: The proposed NCCIH-sponsored symposium will explore
theoretically based research directions that focus on elucidating the peripheral
and central neural mechanisms of MT, with the goal to achieve individualized
mechanism-based pain management. The goals of this symposium are to (1)
stimulate discussion among clinicians, physiologists, and neuroscientists; (2)
facilitate collaborations on research of the neural pathways by which MT exerts
beneficial effects; and (3) promote optimization of MT.
(2227) Comparing the Effectiveness and Cost-effectiveness of Pharmacologic and
Nonpharmacologic Options for Chronic Low Back Pain
Patricia M Herman, ND, PhD
Tara A Lavelle, PhD2 and John L Irwin, MPH1
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
2Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic low back pain (CLBP) is one of the most prevalent
types of chronic pain and the subject of many randomized trials, each comparing
2 or 3 complementary and/or conventional medicine interventions. Economic
simulation models offer one method by which the effectiveness of all (studied)
interventions can be directly compared, and their cost-effectiveness determined
even if costs were not included in the original study.
Results: The intervention arms included in the models were limited
to those with sufficient evidence: spinal manipulation, mobilization,
acupuncture, massage, exercise, yoga, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT),
interdisciplinary rehabilitation, opioids, NSAIDs, injections, prolotherapy, and
usual MD care. Based on available data for a typical CLBP cohort, the most
effective interventions were yoga, flexion distraction (a type of mobilization),
active trunk exercise, individualized acupuncture, and relaxation massage.
However, the most cost-effective therapies were yoga, CBT, exercise, flexion
distraction, and multidisciplinary rehabilitation. For a cohort with severe
CLBP, yoga was still highly effective and cost-effective, but injections of
different types (including prolotherapy) and spinal manipulation join the mix.
Two studies of tramadol and one of prescription NSAIDs were included for the
severe CLBP cohort (the only population in which we found usable studies of
these) and compared poorly to the nonpharmacologic interventions.
Conclusions: CLBP demands good strategies that are both clinically
effective and financially responsible. These models provide useful flexible
tools by which to examine what we know about the relative effectiveness and
cost-effectiveness of the large number of interventions commonly used for CLBP
under different assumptions and scenarios.
(2253) Massage Perceptions and Experiences for Individuals With
Amputations
Nick Rattay, PhD1, Sarah Shue, MS2 and Niki Munk, PhD,
LMT2
1School of Liberal Arts, Indiana University, Indianapolis, Indiana
2School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, Indiana University,
Indianapolis, Indiana
Abstract
Purpose: Massage therapy (MT) is self-reported by those with
amputation as effective, but little MT research related to amputation exists. We
sought to understand how people with amputations perceive MT in terms of
expected outcomes and utilization.
Results: N = 131 (n = 74 MT experienced) adults with amputation
completed the study’s quantitative portion. N = 26 (n = 14 MT experienced)
interviews were conducted. Qualitative analysis of transcribed interviews
resulted in several primary themes. First, how clients perceive individual
therapists impacts their perspectives on treatment. Second, clients have
concerns with how MT is delivered, reflected in perceptions of value and
potential utilization. Third, participants identified both general- and
amputation-specific barriers and reported a range of positive and negative
outcomes. MT experienced participants expressed desire to give back to the limb
loss community specifically in relation to massage. Although massage perception
and experience for those with amputation likely overlaps other populations,
several amputation-specific findings are notable. Apprehension existed regarding
the extent to which MT practitioners can address amputation-related complexity
and presentation uniqueness. Confident and appropriate communication was
identified as necessary traits for effective MT practitioners for clients with
amputation.
Conclusions: Study results combined with earlier MT practitioner
population work and critical consideration of current MT education and practice
may provide informative guidance to the field on how to best meet the limb loss
community’s needs.
(2255) Integrative East-West Medicine in the Academic Health Center Setting: The
University of California, Los Angeles Experience
Edward Hui, MD1, Lariza Johnson, MPA1, Sandi Chiu, MSOM,
LAc1, Ka-Kit Hui, MD1, Andrew Shubov, MD1 and
Justin G Laube, MD1
1Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview: When a group of University of California, Los Angeles
(UCLA) resident physicians were given an introductory talk about integrative
medicine (IM), their response was “ … isn’t that East-West medicine?” The Center
for East-West Medicine (CEWM) is an academic clinical program within the UCLA
Department of Medicine that is ingrained into the fabric of UCLA Health, an
integrated health system in Southern California. CEWM was founded in 1993 by
Ka-Kit Hui, MD, FACP, the current medical director, to blend the healing
traditions of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) with Western medicine. CEWM
includes 4 clinics in Los Angeles county, providing ∼25 000 patient visits per
year by a clinical team comprised 8.75 FTE faculty, 3 fellows, and 12 clinical
specialists (LAc, CMTs). Patients are primarily referred from >500 primary
care providers and specialists from within UCLA Health for a variety of
refractory conditions (eg, fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome, chronic
headaches). CEWM utilizes a consultative clinical model based on a
biopsychosocial framework that incorporates aspects of person-centered medicine,
TCM, IM, generalist problem-solving, and interprofessional teamwork. Patients
are seen by physicians with fellowship training in East-West Medicine and our
clinical specialist team. Revenue is generated primarily through insurance
reimbursement. The clinical program added a primary care arm in 2013 and will
launch an inpatient consult service this year. There is a variety of educational
programs including a visiting scholar exchange program with China, medical
student electives, resident rotations, and an advanced-physician American Board
of Integrative Medicine -recognized fellowship. This session will provide an
in-depth view of the CEWM clinical model. We will use patient cases to guide
participants through a typical patient experience at CEWM. Our management team
will discuss the financial model, including experiences with expanding the
program and suggestions for other clinics. We will present curricular examples
from our international, fellowship, and medical student educational
programs.
Rationale: This topic is important given the current challenging
insurance environment and recent closure of many IM ambulatory clinics
nationally. CEWM has survived 24 years, and other IM center leaders may benefit
from learning from our experiences, challenges, and triumphs during this time.
CEWM is also an unconventional IM clinic with emphasis on integrating a single
alternative health system as its core mission, and this model may be useful for
other programs looking to start IM programs. CEWM is a strong example of
“collaboration in action” through its consultative care clinical model, growing
East-West primary care program, new inpatient program, and international
exchange program with China. CEWM clinic visits include a customized treatment
plan that involves collaboration between patient, physician, and clinical
specialist (comprised TCM practitioners and integrative manual therapists). For
example, patients see the clinical specialist and then their physician
consultant at each follow-up visits to coprogress their care plan. Physicians
and clinical specialists are “bilingually” trained in discussing patient care
conditions in TCM and Western medicine nomenclatures and care philosophies. Each
practice according to their own expertise and work together to comanage the
patients care as a team. Treatment plans often include a variety of simultaneous
therapies that may include acupuncture, cupping, tui na, myofascial release, and
trigger point injections. Patients are actively engaged to create a self-care
plan that might include integrative East-West nutritional guidance (based on
modern nutritional and TCM diagnostic recommendations), flexibility and postural
exercises, acupressure and self-massage, medication risk reduction guidance, and
pertinent referral to various therapies (aquatic and land physical and
occupational therapy, sleep medicine, weight loss management, mindfulness
training) both at UCLA and in the local community. CEWM is expanding further to
encourage collaboration and integration in the UCLA Health system. The East-West
Primary Care program was created in 2013 for patients seeking care from more
open-minded integrative generalists (who are also CEWM consultants part time)
and to have access to the consultative clinic and care philosophy. This creates
a fluid collaborative environment between our primary care and consultative
treating clinical specialists. The East-West Inpatient Consult service will
formally launch in 2018 and allow full-time East-West hospitalists to
collaborate with inpatient medical providers to help patients with challenging
symptoms and potentially reduce hospital length of stay. Finally, CEWM is
leading the way to foster an exchange of expertise between IM in the United
States and China. CEWM hosts visiting scholars and cohorts of health
professionals from China to be immersed in our educational and clinical programs
and to share their expertise and research with our Center’s staff and faculty.
This cultural and knowledge exchange is the heart of our clinical fellowship and
health trainee educational programs. For example, a fellow will be taught by a
TCM expert, with a PhD and LAc degrees, as well as an integrative East-West
faculty at the same session.
Objectives: The aim is to learn about an integrative medicine
clinical delivery model that is ∼25 years old and deeply ingrained into the
culture of an academic health system; consider the integration of a specific
alternative medicine system with Western medicine as an alternative to other
integrative medicine “quarterback” models; identify the potential of
incorporating trigger point injections and myofascial release with TCM therapies
such as acupuncture, cupping, and tui na; experience examples of TCM inspired
self-care techniques, including self-acupressure, that are taught to patients in
our clinic; recognize how the model is financially sustainable and incorporates
insurance payments to achieve this state; and identify the challenges and
triumphs in growing an integrative medicine program within an academic health
system.
Outline:
• Introduction to CEWM and the care delivery model (25 min).
○ Clinic history with emphasis on the development from idea to creation of the
clinic.
• Key allies who supported the clinic and pivotal lessons learned during its
growth.
○ Ambulatory case-based learning examples.
○ Visual presentation of a patient’s experience at clinic including the health
history questionnaire, clinic environment, treatment experience, and self-care
homework examples.
○ Examples of EMR integration (including eg, Epic health system acupoint quick
tabs).
○ Self-care example with the audience: self-acupressure for common conditions
and presentation of other patient handouts.
○ Examples from our clinic to emphasize the role of a supportive workplace
culture that values interprofessional teamwork.
• Business and financial operation (15 min).
○ Experiences with insurance and billing in the ambulatory setting for IM
care.
○ Experiences with coverage for different IM treatments and visit types.
○ Tools to optimize length of visits.
• Experiences with creating an integrative East-West primary care home within an
established consultative care clinic (10 min).
• Experiences developing collaborative local and international educational
programs and curriculum (10 min).
• Take away points and open question and answer session (10–15 min).
(2259) Mindfulness-oriented Approaches to Pain and Opioid Misuse: Mechanistic
Considerations and Clinical Applications
Eric L Garland, PhD, LCSW1, Fadel Zeidan, PhD2 and David Vago,
PhD3
1Center on Mindfulness and Integrative Health Intervention Development,
Salt Lake City, Utah
2Center for Integrative Medicine, Winston-Salem, North Carolina
3Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee
Abstract
Overview: The development, testing, and validation of
nonpharmacological approaches to treat pain are critically important today, as
the national epidemic of opioid use and misuse has led to adverse clinical
outcomes and failure in symptom management. Mindfulness meditation and other
integrative health modalities have been found to significantly reduce pain in
both experimental and clinical settings, with additional possible therapeutic
benefit for opioid-related outcomes. Yet neither the mechanisms nor the
appropriate prescriptive protocols remain clear in scaling treatment of
heterogeneous populations of patients with acute and chronic pain seeking a
narcotic-free, self-facilitated form of pain therapy. Here, we discuss the
extant literature identifying the mechanisms of action that provide preliminary
evidence for the utility of mindfulness-based modalities in attenuating pain and
opioid misuse practices. We will delineate the prospects of its use in
integrative health-care settings in an audience-integrated discussion.
Rationale: There has been a need to develop and identify low-cost,
noninvasive, and nonaddictive alternatives to opiates for the treatment of
chronic pain. Mindfulness and other mind–body interventions have shown great
promise in subserving this clinical population. In fact, in early 2017, the
American College of Physicians developed a guideline providing evidence and
clinical recommendations to use such integrative mind–body methods for
first-line treatment of low back pain. Yet it remains unclear what aspects of
pain are affected, which populations (eg, low back pain) are best served, which
interventions are most effective, and the biological and physiological
mechanisms by which such mind–body interventions may predict clinical outcomes.
This proposed symposium is in alignment with the theme of the 2018 International
Congress on Integrative Medicine and health—specifically to advance integrative
health through the discussion of extant research in this field with experts
studying and implementing such modalities in both controlled research and in
clinical contexts that focus on pragmatic clinical trials and implementation
science.
Objectives: As a result of this session, participants will be able
to understand the current literature on the effects of mindfulness on acute and
chronic pain, examine in detail the underlying physiological and neurobiological
mechanisms by which mindfulness and other mind–body health practices support
clinical outcomes for experience of pain, and investigate best research and
clinical practices as well as a prescriptive agenda for future research
Outline:
• Pain is a multidimensional experience that involves sensory, cognitive, and
affective factors. The constellation of interactions between these factors
renders the treatment of chronic pain challenging and often a financial
burden.
• Recent studies that demonstrate that mindfulness meditation significantly
attenuates pain- and opioid-related problems through multiple, unique
mechanisms.
• Implementation of mindfulness in an integrative medical model can have various
forms, and research has yet to demonstrate which treatment modalities are most
effective for specific forms of chronic pain.
• Best practices for research and pragmatic applications in integrative health
care will be discussed.
(3233) Integrative Oncology: International Perspectives
Suzaane Grant, PhD, MPS, BAppSc, BA1, Elio G Rossi, MD2,
Jennifer Hunter, PhD, MScPH, BMed3, Dugald Seely, ND. MSc4 and
Jun J Mao, MD, MSCE5
1University of Western Sydney, Sydney, Australia
2Local Health Unit Tuscany North West, Region of Tuscany, Lucca, Italy
3Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
4Ottawa Integrative Cancer Centre, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
5Memorial Sloan Kettering, New York, New York
Abstract
Overview: Integrative oncology (IO) is a new evidence-based
specialty that integrates traditional and complementary medicine with
conventional cancer care. IO acknowledges the increasing role that cancer
survivors have in managing their own care, and the importance of a therapeutic
alliance that respects the preferences and values of cancer survivors.
Increasingly, IO services are being provided by public and private health
sectors across the globe. Often however, service development is ad hoc and
fragmented, reflecting local factors rather than coordinated regional or
national planning and policy.
In this symposium, leading health-care professionals and researchers from 3
continents (North America, Western Europe and Australia) will present an
overview of the extent of IO service provision and its implications for clinical
practice, health service delivery, education and research. Financial,
informational, cultural and logistical barriers and solutions will be discussed
from the perspectives cancer survivors, health-care professionals, organizations
and policy makers.
Rationale: This symposium will bring together leading health-care
professionals and researchers from across the globe to discuss the development
of integrative oncology services and its implications for clinical practice,
health service delivery, education, research and policy.
Objectives: The aim is to disseminate experience and knowledge from
the different countries and continents to identify mutual trends and future
directions for IO service provision; gain insight into unmet needs and
facilitators and barriers for IO and obtain knowledge about organizational and
educational aspects, strategies and policies to support the appropriate
development of IO services.
Outline:
1. IO in North America, Western Europe and Australia.
2. Current practices, models and policies for IO services in the respective
continents and countries.
3. Important unmet needs and barriers/facilitators for implementation of IO.
(3264) Effectiveness of a Self-care Tool Kit for Surgical Breast Cancer Patients
in a Military Treatment Facility
Dawn M Bellanti, MSN, FNP1, Erika Stoerkel, MPH, TLIF2,
Kimberly Peacock, EdD3, Alice Inman, PhD4 and Robert Setlik,
MD4
1MedStar Institute for Innovation, Kensington, Maryland
2McLean, Virginia
3University of Texas Health Sciences Center San Antonio, San Antonio,
Texas
4San Antonio Military Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: To assess whether a self-care tool kit (SCT) provided to
newly diagnosed breast cancer patients undergoing surgery could mitigate
distress and lessen symptoms associated with surgery and anesthesia.
Results: There were significant between group differences from
baseline to follow-up in PROMIS-57 scores of Pain interference, Fatigue, and
Satisfaction with social roles, favoring the SCT group compared to TAU
(P = .005, P = .023, and
P = .021, respectively). There was a significant mean
change in DVPRS scores from T2 to T3, with the SCT group having significantly
smaller increases in postoperative pain (P = .008) and in
postoperative ESR (P = .0197) compared with the TAU group.
Clinically, significant reductions in anxiety occurred in the SCT group during
the main intervention period.
Conclusions: These results suggest that using the SCT in the
perioperative period decreased pain perceptions, fatigue, and inflammatory
cytokine secretion.
(3285) Spirituality and Health: The Science of Connection and Meaning and Why
This Matters
Tobi Fishel, PhD1
1Residency Wellness
Abstract
Overview: Spirituality has been a controversial and significant
aspect of health and healing. Within the arena of integrative medicine, holistic
health as described as addressing mind, body, and spirit, but much less
attention has been paid to the latter, even though there is a robust literature
outlining the benefits of exploring spirituality and its connection to one’s
illness, and that having spiritual practices can provide protective mechanisms
for health and well-being. In addition, with clinician (particularly physician)
burnout and depression being recognized as an epidemic in the United States,
many solutions are focused on returning the clinician’s focus to meaning in
medicine, very much connected to the spirituality of health and healing. This
workshop will examine the latest research on spirituality and health,
spirituality and compassion, and spiritualty and meaning making for patients and
clinicians alike. Experiential practices that can be used for clinician
self-care as well as for patients’ well-being will be offered.
Rationale: Much research has demonstrated significant benefits in
health outcomes by engaging in spiritual practices. However, this area in often
minimized and even neglected in the clinical encounter. In this workshop,
participants will be introduced to the research showing health benefits for
patients as well as learn practical ways to introduce this concept and ways to
incorporate practices into the encounter (eg, compassion meditation, rituals,
ceremony, meaning making).
Objectives: Participants will be able to identify current research
in the area of spirituality and health. Participants will explore the connection
between spirituality, connection, depression, illness, and compassion.
Participants will learn and practice 3 exercises that can be used for patients
and clinicians for health benefits (ie, gratitude, compassion, ritual).
Outline:
Definitions—spirituality versus religion
Research on spirituality and health—less anxiety, more ease, and better coping
with chronic illness, experience more meaning in illness, longer life, less
depression, and less burnout for clinicians
Exploration of connection between spirituality and compassion
Experiential practices—gratitude, compassion meditation, ritual/ceremony
Review of a case
(3305) Yoga in the Occupational Setting: Efficacy Research Studies
Sat Bir S Khalsa, PhD1, Maryanna D Klatt, PhD2 and Crystal L
Park, PhD3
1Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2College of Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
3Storrs, Connecticut
Abstract
Overview: Chronic occupational stress is highly prevalent in the
workplace and negatively impacts many aspects of psychological and physical
health, including decreased immune function and increased risk of disease and
mortality. Stress is also a main contributing factor to workplace absenteeism,
employee turnover, job satisfaction and performance, and loss of productivity.
It is important to identify and evaluate interventions that can provide
practical skills and techniques to regulate stress, foster resilience, improve
positive affect, reduce negative affect, increase empowerment and self-efficacy,
increase and/or maintain healthy behaviors such as physical exercise and a
healthy diet, and improve quality of life, wellness, and well-being. Preliminary
studies of resilience-training programs, some of which include aspects of
mindfulness, compassion, self-regulation of stress, and cognitive behavioral
techniques, have been shown to improve psychological and physical well-being and
job performance. Mind–body interventions such as yoga are accessible, highly
adaptable, practical approaches that can build resilience to stress. Yoga is a
comprehensive multicomponent practice including postures and physical exercises,
breath regulation techniques, deep relaxation, and meditation and mindfulness
practices. The scientific evidence for the psychological and physical health
benefits of yoga continues to accumulate and the use of yoga in the United
States is on the rise, with approximately 10% of U.S. adults having practiced
yoga in 2012, and it is therefore a potentially useful and attractive workplace
intervention. This symposium will present findings from 3 investigators who have
conducted research on the implementation of yoga programs in occupational
settings.
Rationale: Stress in the occupational/workplace setting is a growing
concern, with over 70% of working people reporting that their occupation is a
main source of stress. Chronic occupational stress negatively impacts many
aspects of psychological and physical health, including decreased immune
function and increased risk of disease and mortality. Stress is also a main
contributing factor to workplace absenteeism and loss of productivity, with 60%
of workers reporting loss of productivity due to stress over the previous month
and an estimated 1 million workers in the United States are absent each day due
to stress. Workplace interventions that can provide practical skills and
techniques to regulate stress to prevent psychological and physical health
problems are therefore important. Resilience is a positive adaptation to
otherwise stressful situations whereby mental health is maintained or recovered
despite experiencing adversity. Fostering resilience can help reduce stress,
improve positive affect, reduce negative affect, increase a sense of empowerment
or self-efficacy, and increase or maintain healthy behaviors such as physical
exercise and a healthy diet. In occupational populations, higher resilience is
associated with higher job satisfaction and workplace happiness. Indeed,
resilience-training programs, some of which include aspects of mindfulness,
compassion, self-regulation of stress, and cognitive behavioral techniques, have
been shown to improve psychological and physical well-being and job performance.
Practical and cost-effective techniques that increase resilience may benefit
organizations by saving costs related to loss of productivity and absenteeism.
Mind–body interventions such as mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and
yoga are accessible, highly adaptable, practical approaches that can build
resilience to stress. The scientific evidence for the psychological and physical
health benefits of mindfulness and yoga continues to accumulate and the use of
yoga in the United States is on the rise, with approximately 10% of U.S. adults
having practiced yoga in 2012. Recent reviews and meta-analyses of mind–body
interventions in professional populations have shown improvements in stress,
resilience, mindfulness, and affect. A meta-analysis of 19 studies indicated
that brief (eg, 4 weeks) mindfulness interventions were as effective as longer
(eg, 8 weeks) interventions for improving psychological health, including
stress, affect, mood, anxiety, depression, job satisfaction, and sleep quality.
Therefore, programs that teach mindfulness practices over a shorter period of
time may be more practical and cost-effective approach to organizational
programs. Importantly, recent evidence suggests that the yoga component of MBSR
may be the critical element necessary for improving psychological wellbeing—even
more than the mindfulness meditation or body scan components. Yoga is a
multicomponent system of mind–body practices including physical postures and
exercises, breathing exercises, deep relaxation techniques, and
meditation/mindfulness practices. Systematic research reviews support the use of
yoga for promoting psychological health. There is burgeoning evidence that yoga
is effective for promoting psychological health in occupational settings.
Objectives: Participants will understand the need for behavioral
interventions in occupational settings and the rationale for yoga as a practical
efficacious intervention in the workplace. Participants will understand the yoga
intervention characteristics that have been used in research evaluating the
benefits of yoga interventions in the workplace setting. Participants will
understand the efficacy of yoga on physical and mental health and performance on
a variety of outcome measures in multiple research studies.
Outline:
• Introduction to the symposium topic and the speakers
• The psychological and health challenges in the occupational setting and the
rationale for yoga as a workplace intervention
• Introduction to yoga practice and a logic model for the efficacy of yoga in
health and wellness in the workplace
• Brief review of prior research on mind–body interventions in workplace
settings
• Presentation of research on yoga in mental health-care providers by Crystal
Park
• Presentation of research on yoga in workers in high-stress health-care
environments by Maryanna Klatt
• Presentation of research on yoga in clerical, enforcement, education, and
health-care workers by Sat Bir Khalsa
• Question and answer panel with symposium attendees and all 3 faculty.
(3307) Anti-inflammatory Diet in Pediatrics: From Evidence to Practice
Maria Mascarenhas, MBBS, Hiliary McClaferty, MD1 and Diane L Barsky,
MD2
1Tucson, Arizona
2Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: The role of nutrition in health promotion, disease
prevention and treatment is being increasingly recognized. Persistent
inflammation is linked to the development of chronic disease. Data from several
large international studies have illustrated the many health benefits of the
Mediterranean and Asian diets. The anti-inflammatory diet (AI) which combines
these 2 diets is an evidence-based diet that can be used to decrease
inflammation, improve health and prevent chronic disease. It encompasses not
just nutrition but a lifestyle approach which includes physical activity, whole
foods approach, food preparation, community and farm-to-table concept.
Rationale: Inflammation is a natural way the body reacts to protect
and assist in the healing process. At times, the inflammatory response can
persist, contributing to or leading to the development of chronic diseases. The
AI diet when followed regularly may decrease the inflammatory response and
decrease the risk of obesity, type 2 diabetes, heart disease and
other-associated chronic diseases. The emphasis of the diet is to maintain
and/or improve health through nutrition and lifestyle changes. The AI diet can
be a part of a broad approach to treat chronic disease linked to inflammation.
The focus is not on nutrition instead of medicine, but “Nutrition as Part of
Medicine”! This symposium will present a brief history of the diet and summary
of research in adults and pediatrics. The pediatric AI pyramid will be discussed
in detail including its development and implementation in clinical practice. As
the conference focuses on advancing integrative health through research,
education, clinical practice and policy, we plan to educate participants on the
research, education and clinical practice can be used to improve the health of
children through nutrition.
Objectives: The aim is to be knowledgeable about the history,
benefits and components of the AI diet; be aware of the research demonstrating
the benefits of the AI diet and be able to implement the AI diet in care of
pediatric patients.
Outline: AI Diet in Pediatrics
Background
History of the development of the AI diet, components, how it blends the
Mediterranean and Asian diets, whole foods approach and lifestyle changes
including physical activity and mindful eating
Review of the health benefits
Research
Review of the adult and pediatric literature supporting the use of the AI diet
with respect to cardiovascular risk, obesity, diabetes, non-alcoholic fatty
liver disease, asthma/allergies and microbiome
Implementation
Presentation of the pediatric AI diet pyramid
Discussion of practical aspects of the AI diet in pediatric practice and
available resources
(3313) Reduced Interference in Working Memory Following Mindfulness Training Is
Associated With Increases in Hippocampal Volume
Sara W Lazar, PhD1, Jonathan Greenberg, PhD1, Victoria L
Romero, PhD2, Seth Elkin-Frankston, PhD2, Matthew A Bezdek,
PhD3 and Eric H Schumacher, PhD3
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2Charles River Analytics, Cambridge, Massachusetts
3Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia
Abstract
Purpose: Proactive interference occurs when previously relevant
information interferes with retaining newer material. Overcoming proactive
interference has been linked to the hippocampus and deemed critical for
cognitive functioning. However, little is known about how this ability can be
improved or about the neural correlates of such improvement. Mindfulness
training emphasizes focusing on the present moment and minimizing distraction
from competing thoughts and memories. It improves working memory and increases
hippocampal density. The current study examined whether mindfulness training
reduces proactive interference in working memory and whether such improvements
are associated with changes in hippocampal volume.
Results: The mindfulness group exhibited significantly greater
accuracy in proactive interference resolution compared to the active control
group following training, and these memory improvements were significantly
associated with volume increases in the left hippocampus.
Conclusions: Results provide the first evidence suggesting that
mindfulness training can protect against proactive interference and that these
benefits are related to volumetric increases in the left hippocampus. In light
of these results, it is suggested that mindfulness may be particularly
beneficial for individuals with conditions typically characterized by
impairments to working memory and reduced hippocampal volume such as depression,
childhood adversity, post-traumatic stress disorder, and aging.
(3320) Can Acupuncture Be an Opioid-sparing Treatment for Chronic Pain
Management?
Lucy Chen, MD, MGH1 and Jianren Mao, MD, PhD1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Opioids are often used to treat moderate to severe
cancer-related pain. In recent years, there has been a dramatic increase in
opioid use for the treatment of chronic, noncancer-related pain conditions
despite riskes and lack of clear evidence of its effectiveness. Based on the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report, nearly 2 million Americans
were dependent on prescription opioids for pain relief in 2014 alone. Deaths
from opioid overdose have more than quadrupled since 1999. Accordingly,
nonpharmacologic therapies and nonopioid pharmacological therapies are perferred
for chronic pain management. Various modalities of complementary and alternative
medicine, particularly acupunture, have been used in acute and chronic pain
management. Indeed, acupuncture could become a useful adjunctive therapy for
chronic pain management to reduce the opioid use. However, the pressing issue is
to understand the role of acupuncture in chronic pain control and to explore
innovative assessment tools for the effectiveness. The objective of this
symposium is to provide (1) information about current opioid-related issues in
pain management, (2) data from current clinical trials on the role of
acupuncture therapy in pain management, and (3) current research on innovative
assessment tools for evaluation of acupuncture effectiveness.
Rationale: Chronic pain affects more Americans than diabetes, heart
disease, and cancer combined and is one of the most common causes for many
patients to seek medical assistance. There has been a dramatic increase in
opioid use in the treatment of chronic, noncancer-related pain conditions and
deaths from opioid overdose have more than quadrupled over the last 2 decades.
Despite new pain medications and advancement in interventional and surgical
procedures for chronic pain management, nonopioid treatments are urgently needed
in clinical practice. However, it remains unclear as to how effectively
acupuncture can be used as an opioid-sparing tool for the management of chronic
pain conditions with regard to clinical outcomes and assessment tools that
should be used to analyze clinical outcomes. This symposium will address both of
these issues and provide the up-to-date information from the literature as well
as our own clinical studies. Dr Chen will serve as the moderator and a speaker.
She will discuss current data on the effectiveness of acupunture therapy in pain
management. Dr Mao will discuss the issues related to opioid use as well as
innovative tools to assess acupuncture trials.
Objectives: The aim is to understand the role of acupuncture thepray
in pain management, provide research data on the efficacy of acupuncture
therapy, and discuss innovative assessment tools for evaluation of acupuncture
effectiveness.
Outline:
1) Clinical efficacy of acupunture treatment;
2) Challenges in acupuncture trials for pain management;
3) Role of translational research in developing innovative assessment tools for
evaluation of acupuncture effectiveness.
(3333) Results From RAND/NCCIH Center of Excellence for Research on CAM:
Patient-centered Methods for Determining the Appropriateness of Manipulation and
Mobilization for Chronic Neck and Low Back Pain
Ron D Hays, PhD1, Lara G Hilton, MPH2, Gery Ryan,
PhD2, Ian D Coulter, PhD2 and Patricia M Herman, ND,
PhD2
1UCLA, Los Angeles, California
2RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Overview: This symposium provides the results of the 4-year
RAND/NCCIH Center of Excellence for Research on CAM (1U19AT007912-01). The
Center includes 4 projects and an ancillary R21 study examining the
appropriateness of 1 form of complementary and integrative health (CIH) care.
The studies focus on chiropractic manipulation/mobilization for chronic low back
and cervical pain, but the methods are applicable to other therapies and
conditions. We used the traditional method of determining treatment
appropriateness with the RAND/UCLA expert panel process using evidence and
clinical experience of effectiveness and safety, but extended
it by incorporating patient preferences, resource
utilization, and patient-reported outcomes into
the determination of the appropriateness with data collected from 2024 patients
sampled from 125 chiropractic clinics from throughout the United States. The
panels were asked to rerate appropriateness after considering these new data
inputs to determine whether their appropriateness ratings changed. The
definition of appropriateness was expanded to match the needs of CIH where
patient preferences are expressed in self-referral and out-of-pocket payments
are common, and, thus, patient preferences and costs can also be important in
the determination of appropriate care. An ancillary study examined whether
crowdsourced data could be used as an efficient and effective patient data
collection method in future studies. This symposium will provide a brief
overview of the organization of the Center, followed by results from each of the
projects and culminating in the key findings from the expert panels after they
had been asked to consider patient-reported preferences and costs in their new
appropriateness ratings. Project-specific results include national data on
outcomes including patient experiences with care, health-related quality of
life, and patient preferences, and economic simulation models of the relative
cost-effectiveness of nonsurgical interventions for chronic low back and neck
pain.
Rationale: The appropriateness methodology provides what is known
from research to experienced clinicians who translate the evidence into practice
considering the range of patient presentations in real-world clinical practice.
Understanding the appropriateness of care is essential to improve clinical
outcomes, determine the need for guidelines, and inform policy. If most of the
care provided is judged to be appropriate, then no changes to clinical
guidelines are needed. If a substantial amount of care is judged to be
inappropriate or indeterminate, then policies to improve practice or more
research are needed, respectively. The addition of patient preferences, resource
utilization, and patient-centered outcomes to the traditional appropriateness
methods is essential for complementary and integrative health policy and health
care in general.
Objectives: The aim is to articulate the traditional procedure for
assessing the appropriateness of care and the use of these ratings in health
policy; report on the appropriateness of manipulation and mobilization in a
large representative sample of U.S. chronic low back and neck pain patients when
only effectiveness and safety are considered; identify elements of patient
preferences, outcomes, and resource utilization that should be included, along
with effectiveness and safety, in the determination of care appropriateness; and
report on the appropriateness of manipulation and mobilization in our sample
when patient preferences, resource utilization, and patient-reported outcomes
are considered.
Outline:
• Overview of the center, introduction to appropriateness method, and findings
from the appropriateness panels when only effectiveness and safety are
considered (Ian D Coulter, PhD)
• Results of psychometric testing of PROMIS and CAHPS on this population and the
relationship of these outcomes to the appropriateness of care (Ron Hays,
PhD)
• Findings from surveys on patient preferences, satisfaction, expectations,
coping behaviors, and pain profiles which may affect the ratings of
appropriateness (Gery Ryan, PhD).
• Results of the economic simulation models on the relative cost-effectiveness of
alternative interventions which may affect the ratings of appropriateness
(Patricia Herman, ND, PhD).
• Results from using crowdsourcing as an alternative data collection method for
clinical research (Lara Hilton, MPH).
• Changes seen in the ratings of the appropriateness of manipulation and
mobilization after patient-centered data are introduced (Ian D Coulter,
PhD).
• Discussion (Lead by Ian Coulter).
(3367) Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer’s Disease: Integrative Approaches to
Prevention and Treatment
George C Wang, MD, PhD1 and Mikhail Kogan, MD1
1Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: Dementia is one of the greatest health care and social
challenges in the 21st century. Alzheimer’s disease, accounting for 60%–80% of
dementia cases, affects more than 4 people in the United States and nearly 44
million globally. Current pharmacologic treatments do not halt or reverse the
progression of dementia. In this session, we will first discuss the state of the
science in understanding the pathogenetic mechanisms of cognitive impairment and
Alzheimer’s disease and risk factors for developing dementia. We will present a
whole-person framework for understanding the complex mix of etiologies and
perpetuating factors that underlie the temporal spectrum encompassing cognitive
impairment and dementia. Through this framework, we will discuss integrative
approaches to prevention and treatment. Case examples will illustrate the use of
a systematic approach to successfully halt or reverse the progression of
dementia. The session will conclude with an expert panel and interactive
questions and answers with the audience. Three faculty presenters, comprising
geriatricians and integrative medicine physicians from Johns Hopkins University
and George Washington University with research and clinical expertise in the
field, will foster an appreciation of the important roles that integrative
health practitioners can play in addressing the global dementia challenge
through prevention and whole-person therapeutic plans.
Rationale: Dementia is one of the greatest health care and social
challenges in the 21st century. Alzheimer’s disease is responsible for 60%–80%
of cases of dementia. The estimated number of people with Alzheimer’s disease is
more than 4 million in the United States and nearly 44 million worldwide. These
numbers are projected to triple by 2050. The annual cost of dementia care is
estimated to be $150–$215 billion in the United States and $600 billion
globally. The annual direct cost of dementia care has already exceeded those for
heart disease and cancer. Currently available pharmaceutical treatments do not
address the underlying pathology and do not halt or reverse the progression of
cognitive impairment in Alzheimer’s disease. Understanding Alzheimer’s disease
through the pathophysiologic lens of amyloid beta protein and tau protein has
not led to a successful therapeutic agent in humans. In fact, cognitive
impairment and Alzheimer’s disease comprise a complex mix of etiologies and
perpetuating factors and represent a temporal spectrum of pathological
progression with opportunities for intervention and varying potential for
reversal across time points. A whole-person approach is required for optimal
treatment.
Objectives: The aim is to recall mechanisms of pathogenesis in
cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease; recognize risk factors for
developing cognitive impairment and dementia; discuss integrative approaches to
prevention of cognitive impairment and dementia; and outline a whole-person
functional approach to the care, treatment, and reversal of cognitive impairment
and Alzheimer’s disease
Outline: The session will be organized into 2 presentations and an
interactive panel:
1) Cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease: pathogenesis and integrative
approaches to prevention
We will present the state of the science in the current understanding of the
pathogenesis of cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease. We will provide a
brief history of the development of amyloid beta and tau protein hypothesis and
biologic/pharmacologic interventions that have been developed.
We will discuss the epidemiology of cognitive impairment and dementia. Data from
population studies that have identified risk factors for dementia will be
summarized. We will present a whole-person framework for conceptualizing the
pathogenesis of cognitive impairment and dementia and discuss integrative
approaches to prevention. This framework serves as a crucial foundation for
understanding the critical roles that primary care and integrative health
practitioners can play in addressing the global challenge of dementia in the
decades to come.
2) Whole-person approach to the care and treatment of persons with cognitive
impairment and Alzheimer’s disease: rationale and case examples
Cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease comprise a complex mix of etiologies
and perpetuating factors and represent a temporal spectrum of pathological
progression with opportunities for intervention and varying potential for
reversal across time points. A systematic, whole-person, functional approach is
important in making the proper diagnosis and formulating an effective treatment
plan. We will outline the rationale for such a whole-person approach and will
outline a systematic approach to uncovering the etiologies and perpetuating
factors in these persons.
We will review Dr Dale Bredesen’s work, including his 2014 and 2016 case series
of 10 patients who had reversal of Alzheimer’s disease. Dr Kogan will present a
number of case examples from the GW memory clinic documenting reversal or arrest
of Alzheimer’s disease progression.
Additionally, we will present a framework for engaging the public, funding
agencies, and academia in advancing the understanding and clinical practice of
this treatment approach.
(3369) Medical Fasting—State of the Art
John S Finnell, ND, MPH, Lac1, Rainer- Stange, PhD2, Sebastian
Brandhorst, PhD3 and Valter Longo, PhD4
1Bastyr University Research Institute, Austin, Texas
2Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin and Immanuel Hospital, Berlin,
Germany
3Los Angeles, California
4FIRC Institute of Molecular Oncology, Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview: There exists a historical precedence for the use of
various fasting modalities for both medical and religious purposes, which are
held in common across many cultures. Well-characterized protocols for medically
supervised fasting for specific indications emerged in the United States and in
Europe within the 19th and 20th centuries, respectively. To date, however, there
has been limited evidence supporting the efficacy and safety of these
modalities. It is estimated that clinics in Europe and the United States
specializing in medically supervised fasting protocols treat approximately
100 000 patients with fasting each year. The predominant indications for fasting
reported in the literature include metabolic disorders, hypertension,
rheumatism, and other pain conditions and have recently expanded to include
indications, such as cancer, neurodegenerative diseases, as well as the
evaluation of novel protocols of time-restricted feeding and intermittent
fasting. The interest in research on fasting protocols has increased, as the
need for novel approaches to treat chronic degenerative diseases has grown.
Fasting in different modalities has been common to many cultures and religions
for centuries. Medically indicated, supervised, and evaluated fasting, however,
has emerged within the 19th century in the United States and the 20th in several
European countries and been given a limited amount of evidence as toward
efficacy and safety so far. Some clinics in Europe and the United States are
specialized treating approximately 100 000 patients with fasting each year.
Predominant indications are metabolic disorders, hypertension, rheumatism, and
other pain conditions. Within recent decades, there has been further support by
preclinical research, pointing to further indications like cancer and
neurodegenerative diseases, and evaluating new patterns of time-restricted
feeding or intermittent fasting.
Rationale:
Medically supervised fasting is a growing integrative medicine modality that is
being studied internationally. It is therefore necessary to characterize the
evidence presented to date, describe best practices, and establish the further
research needs in this emerging field of study. Medically supervised fasting is
already, resp. will be a growing part of integrative medicine everywhere. It
therefore seems necessary to outline the scientific results given so far and
directions of further research as well as good practice.
Objectives: The aim is to outline the standard practices of
medically supervised fasting protocols, including the patient assessment and
examination, contraindications and safety, and relevant outcome parameters.
Develop standard guidelines for counseling about self-practice of
time-restricted feeding and intermittent fasting and to outline of practice of
medical fasting including contraindications, safety exams, and outcome
parameters. Counselling about self-practice of time-restricted feeding, resp.
intermittent fasting.
Outline: Valter Longo, Sebastian Brandhorst: Most important results
of preclinical research including neurodegenerative and oncological diseases as
well as first trials of time-restricted feeding with healthy humans.
John Finnell: Practice of fasting and results of research on safety
Rainer Stange: Acceptance, clinical evidence by uncontrolled and controlled
clinical trials with long-term (>5 days) fasting, projects of present and
future research. Outline of certified qualifications for MDs in Austria and
Germany. Clinical evidence of fasting and oncological chemotherapy by so far 3
randomized controlled trials.
(3381) Mindful Resilience: An Innovative Honors Course Addressing
Individual/Organizational Resilience via the Embodiment of Integrative Health
Practices
Maryanna D Klatt, PhD1
1College of Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
Abstract
Overview: Emerging contemplative education courses and academic
programs that focus on embodying integrative health (IH) have a unique
opportunity to help students gain both self-awareness and an awareness of the
pragmatic benefits of IH in their life and career. Research utilizing meditation
in higher education shows promise in building resilience, interpersonal skills,
and the cognitive capabilities of attentional control. Pragmatic, reflective
pedagogy that successfully cultivates personal and social awareness is an avenue
to give our future health-care professionals the tools and capacity to create
institutions that are built to facilitate both individual and organizational
resilience. Course content and structure of Mindful Resilience: From the
Individual to the Organization will be shared so that others can
utilize this curricular innovation to teach resiliency skills to
preprofessionals. The course was informed by the recognition of the necessary
quadruple aim, “care of the provider” as pivotal to delivering quality
patient-centered care, and was designed to equip preprofessionals with the IH
skills/practices to preempt burnout and compassion fatigue, requiring a
self-care program by course completion. The course utilizes guided mindfulness
meditation and reflective writing to help students reflect upon their
‘‘performance of self’’ to increase awareness and help sculpt their personal and
professional lives. Interprofessional guest speakers share resiliency narratives
and are intentionally timed with specific scholarly readings. This pedagogy
demonstrates an innovative and creative application of the theory of
contemplative practice in action with the goal of creating a more nurturing
culture in which we live and work. Students recognize by semester end the
absolute necessity of being proactive about one’s self-care in order to
adequately care for ones patients. The earlier a student is made aware of the
existing challenges encountered by health-care practitioners, the sooner they
may be open to developing wellness practices, strategies, and organizational
structures to sustain them.
Rationale: This topic is critically important, as we need share
curriculum to teach emerging professionals the huge contribution that IH can
make in their life and careers. Curricula that are designed to give students a
first-person experience of meditation, reflection, and mindful movement while
they are preprofessionals is invaluable so that they can enjoy the lifelong
benefits that IH affords. This curricular innovation has been featured in 2
journals, Medical Teacher and the Journal of
Transformative Education, and embodies a curricular advance in
teaching the usefulness, and value, of IH.
Objectives: Participants attending this session will learn about the
curricular elements that have successfully been employed in teaching emerging
health-care professionals, the benefit of IH practices for their own life and
work, discern which curricular pieces and parts may be most vital in teaching
future health-care professionals about the value of IH, and be able to design
similar curricular innovations at their home universities based upon this
successful model.
(3384) Evidence-based Nonpharmacologic Pain Medicine as Culture Change in
Practice, Education, and Policy: How Do We Get There From Here?
Samantha Simmons, MPH1, Rosanne Sheinberg, MD1, Arya Nielsen,
PhD1, Rebecca Schultz, MS1 and Heather Tick,
MD1
1Seattle, Washington
Abstract
Overview: Medical pain management is in crisis. The United States
leads in the epidemic of opioid overuse, abuse, addiction, and death, but the
failure to adequately treat pain and the adverse effects of conventional pain
treatments are a worldwide challenge. The National Academy of Medicine (formerly
IOM), National Institutes of Health National Pain Strategy, Veterans Health
Administration, Department of Defense, the Federal Food and Drug Administration,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Drug Abuse,
and the Joint Commission (TJC) have all called for increased use of
evidence-based nonpharmacologic care. Moreover, these effective and low-risk
strategies should be engaged early in the course of care instead of as a last
resort when all else has failed. The ACIMH is well positioned to present the
evidence base for nonpharmacologic options, outline best practices, facilitate
the development of teaching curricula, and inform policy decisions to create a
culture change in pain medicine and ultimately health care.
Rationale: Why the topic is important and its relevance to the
conference themes? It is widely acknowledged that medical pain management is in
crisis: from the pervasiveness of pain to inadequate pain treatment, from the
escalation of prescription opioids to an epidemic in addiction, diversion, and
overdose deaths, the rising costs of pain care and managing adverse effects of
that care have prompted action from state and federal agencies. The Consortium
Pain Initiative was developed to address (inform) these issues with our unique
combination of foundations in research, academic rigor, educational access,
history of work with policy, and our mission to shift health care to be more
person centered, effective, evidence based, and safe.
Objectives: The aim is to discuss evidence-based nonpharmacologic
strategies that are opioid sparing have been shown to reduce opioid need;
describe which nonpharm therapies have been shown to be effective for acute
postsurgical or trauma pain; describe which nonpharmacologic therapies have been
shown to be effective for chronic pain not only reducing the risk of opioid use,
but the illness behavior opioids produce; and understand current state and
federal policies facilitating and inhibiting implementation and integration of
nonpharm therapies for pain
Outline: The Pain Project White Paper: introduction and the meaning
of culture change in pain medicine. Thomas Kuhn outlined the steps that lead to
culture change or paradigm shifts in science. Early adopters are significant
catalysts in this process. This section will explore how work over nearly 2
decades has positioned the consortium to help effect these changes. How do we
build the road map for lasting culture change in medicine using the current
crisis in pain medicine, the unsustainable costs of health care, and the growing
burden of disease as catalysts for change? (Heather Tick)
Evidence: the White Paper (Arya Nielsen)
1. The Consortium Pain Task Force White Paper: Evidence-based
Nonpharmacologic Strategies for Comprehensive Pain Care
2. Creating facile access to updates in evidence-based pain medicine
3. Dissemination strategies: learn to “recruit and represent” for a culture
change in medicine by relying on evidence-informed best practice
4. Prepare for discourse and interview strategies when interacting with friendly,
unfriendly, uinformed, or hostile questions
Clinical Best Practice: The development of best practices in
nonpharmacologic pain care (Rebecca Schultz)
1. Create evidence-informed clinical practice recommendations for pain
conditions
2. Incorporate whole person assessments to determine recommendations
3. Encourage shared decisions making and partnering with patients to create a
comprehensive pain plan that includes nonpharm options
4. Collaborate interprofessionally to enhance clinical knowledge and patient
outcomes
5. Identify resources to support nonpharmacologic pain options
Education: The development of educational curricula for
nonpharmacologic pain care (Rosanne Sheinberg)
1. Audience we seek to educate
2. Creation of level playing field
3. Paradigm shift
4. Widening the tool box
5. Dissemination in educating target groups
6. Content to be covered
Policy: How to effect policy shift: (Samantha Simmons)
1. This part of the session will focus on what attendees can do to help drive
policy changes in their states, highlight resources available to them to assist
their efforts, and describe how some states have been successful in implementing
policies that aim to help patients with pain and reduce opioid dependence and
misuse.
(3388) Using Interactive Medicine Apps and Technologies for the Treatment of
Health Conditions: A Hands-on Usability Workshop
Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1 and Robert Bonakdar, MD1
1San Diego, California
Abstract
Overview: There are thousands of different technologies available
for patients to treat and manage their health conditions. Integrative medicine
techniques (mindfulness, nutrition, and coaching) have become popular subjects
for apps and technologies. This hands-on workshop gives the attendee a firsthand
experience of technology (apps, devices, and Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act compliant telehealth services) for the treatment and
monitoring for health conditions including chronic pain and diabetes. There are
many apps/devices available to patients, and our workshop will give an overview
of how the evaluate the evidence, benefits, and risks of these technologies.
Rationale: It is important for clinicians and researchers to be able
to advise their patients on evidenced-based integrative medicine apps, devices,
and telehealth services.
Objectives: By the end of these sessions, participants will be able
to list 3 components of what makes an evidence-based technology, explain the
pros and cons of usability testing, and list 2 resources on where to find
evidence reviews on technology.
Outline:
1. Introduction to what types of technologies are available on the market and
which have been tested.
2. Components of excellent patient technology and how to interpret the
research.
3. Guidelines: How to perform usability testing on your technology.
4. Experiential stations:
○ Station 1: Mindfulness apps
○ Station 2: Nutrition/fitness apps
○ Station 3: Coaching apps
(3391) Research Recruitment Strategies for Undeserved Patients: Lessons
Learned
Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1, Iniya Rajendran, MD1, Myles Spar,
MD1, Robert B Saper, MD, MPH1 and Benjamin Kligler, MD,
MPH1
1Bronx, New York
Abstract
Overview: Low-income racially diverse patients are a historically
challenging population for research recruitment. Yet integrative medicine
research is taking place in community health centers and safety net hospitals
around the country. This panel will present several viewpoints about their
recruitment strategies. Speakers include viewpoints from both a practice-based
research network (PBRN) and representatives from 2 randomized controlled trials
funded from Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI). This panel
will share methods and strategies in overcoming barriers related to recruitment
of this patient population. Methods will include provider referral, warm
handoffs (face-to-face encounters with a research assistant during a clinical
session), targeted letters, and self-referral after seeing flyers, or using
patient incentives such as gift cards. Our 3 sites with discuss our challenges
and successes with recruitment methods and using patient incentives.
Rationale: Low-income racially diverse patients are a challenging
population for research recruitment. Yet integrative medicine research is taking
place in community health centers and safety net hospitals around the country.
We will represent 3 different institutions and different types of recruitment
methods.
Objectives: The aim is to list 3 strategies to recruit low-income
racially diverse patients, describe to an IRB agent why these strategies are
necessary and unique human subject’s protections, and identify existing low
literacy resources available for recruitment on the Internet.
Outline:
1. Introduction to the challenges working with low-income racially diverse
patients
2. Discussion of recruitment strategies used in the PCORI-funded acupuncture
approaches to decrease disparities in outcomes of pain treatment—A 2-arm
comparative effectiveness trial
3. Discussion of recruitment strategies for BraveNet—PBRN
4. Discussion of recruitment strategies used in the PCORI-funded integrative
medical group visit randomized controlled trial
5. Large group discussion and questions from audience
(3395) Traditional, Complementary, Integrative, and “Articulated Medicine” at the
Pan American Health Organization: Research Priorities and Partnerships
John Weeks1, Daniel Gallego-Perez, MD2, Daniel Miele Amado,
MD3, Ricardo Fabrega, MD, MPM4 and Tabatha Parker,
ND5
1The Integrator Blog News & Reports, Seattle, Washington
2Pan American Health Organization/WHO, Medellin, Colombia
3Brazil Health Ministry, Sao Paulo, Brazil
4Pan American Health Organization/WHO, Washington, DC
5Natural Doctors International, Ometepe, Nicaragua
Abstract
Overview: Participants will explore the most significant integrative
undertaking in the Western hemisphere: to create the skills, knowledge,
collaborations, and partnerships that will optimize the role of traditional,
complementary, and integrative health products, practices, and practitioners in
meeting the goal of primary care for all. The goal is urged by the World Health
Organization (WHO) 2014–2023 Traditional Medicine Strategic Plan and the Pan
American Health Organization’s (PAHO) Strategy for Universal Access to Health
and Universal Health Coverage (2014). National efforts throughout the Western
hemisphere are presently being supported by PAHO’s technical cooperation and
networked through a PAHO-facilitated effort, with the support of academic
collaborations. This panel will provide perspectives from professionals who have
been engaged in providing advice and leadership in developing PAHO and WHO
strategies, as well as those others working inside various national health-care
systems in the region, and supporting academic institutions, to achieve the
goals in what the majority of PAHO participants prefer to call “articulated
medicine.”
Rationale: Increasingly, many active in advancing integrative
medicine and health have begun to view the movement as global and intertwined
and supportive of the WHO’s effort to optimize the role of traditional and
complementary health products, practices, and practitioners in meeting the goal
of primary care for all. Yet knowledge is limited among the integrative health
community in the better resourced nations of North America, Europe, and Asia of
the directions urged by the WHO in its 2014–2023 Traditional Medicine Strategy.
For instance, the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health and
the Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health each endorsed the 2017 “Berlin
Agreement: Self Responsibility and Social Action in Practicing and Fostering
Integrative Medicine and Health Globally” (https://www.ecim-iccmr.org/fileadmin/ecim-iccmr/editors/documents/Berlin_Agreement_on_Self-Responsibility_160417.pdf).
That global vision is of an integrative model that draws not only on biomedicine
but also on “traditional medicine practices” and “respects multiple
philosophies” recognizing that “traditional medical products, practices and
practitioners are the main access to healthcare in most regions of the world.”
The PAHO, which serves as the WHO regional office for the Americas Region, is
fostering cooperation for traditional and complementary medicine integration
into health-care systems among its member states. This panel helps bridge this
knowledge and opportunity gap through presentations from professionals who
provided advice and leadership in developing PAHO and WHO strategies, and others
working inside South American and Central American nations to achieve the goals.
Among the topics will be that of emerging partnerships and opportunities.
Participants will be introduced to the concept of “articulated medicine” that
was favored in a voice vote by representatives of traditional medicine systems,
from nearly 2 dozen nations at a mid-2017 WHO-PAHO meeting in Managua, Nicaragua
in which efforts to create a regional collaborative network were formally
endorsed.
Objectives: The aim is to describe how WHO and PAHO and some
individual nations are engaging T&CM and promoting research, explain why
many in Central and South American nations favor depicting the integrative
effort via a concent of “articulated medicine” rather than “integrative
medicine,” identify priority T&CM research needs of PAHO member states,
evaluate the challenges and opportunities of existing and potential
collaborations with academic health institutions and delivery organizations, and
discuss possible partnership strategies for researcher and institutions.
Outline: The panel will be opened by the moderator–organizer (Weeks)
who served on workshops that led to the WHO strategy and participated in the
PAHO meeting. He will help set the context of the WHO strategy and open some of
the issues that emerged in the PAHO meeting (5–10 min). This will be followed by
presentation from the other panelists:
• Fabrega will share more on the WHO-PAHO link and the context of PAHO interest
in traditional, complementary integrative medicine, as well as its articulation
to PAHO’s Strategy for Universal Access to Health and Universal Health Coverage
(10 min).
• Gallego-Perez will offer details of PAHO’s current activities and emerging
partnerships and provide examples of the diversity of T&CM activity in a
selected set of nations (10 min).
• Parker will share information from a long-standing clinical offering in
Nicaragua that serves an underserved population and offers global service
learning opportunities to health professional students (10 min).
• Miele-Amado will offer insight into TC&M integration in the health system
and research initiatives in Brazil (10 min).
This will leave time for limited discussion in a 60 min panel. We would prefer
90 min or at least 75, for more dialogue with the audience, and the potential to
expand one or more of the talks to 12–15 min.
(3422) Probiotics and Gastrointestinal Conditions: An Overview of Evidence From
the Cochrane Collaboration
Elizabeth A Parker, PhD, RD1, Christopher R D'Adamo, PhD1, Tina
Roy, BS2 and L Susan Wieland, PhD3
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine, Scranton, Pennsylvania
3Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Alterations in the gut microbiota are associated with
numerous gastrointestinal (GI) conditions. Probiotics, live microorganisms that
may confer a health benefit to the host when consumed, are increasingly used to
treat GI conditions. Our objective was to summarize the evidence on probiotics
and GI conditions available from Cochrane, a nonprofit organization that
produces rigorous systematic reviews of health interventions.
Results: Fourteen Cochrane reviews published between 2006 and 2015
focused on probiotics and GI conditions (diarrhea, N = 5; colitis, N = 4;
Crohn’s disease, N = 3; liver conditions, N = 2). One review on liver conditions
identified no trials; the remaining 13 reviews included 1–63 trials with 11–8014
participants. The exclusive N of probiotic combinations included in each review
ranged from 1 to 21; Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG was the most
commonly studied. In total, 63% of included trials specified probiotic strain,
94% reported dosage, 79% specified intervention length, 29% indicated follow-up
duration, and 73% reported AEs. Four reviews on diarrheal conditions reported
that probiotics were beneficial; all other reviews were inconclusive.
Conclusions: There is good evidence for the efficacy of probiotics
for diarrheal conditions; however, reviews on probiotics for other conditions
require further updating to establish efficacy. Future clinical trials and
systematic reviews of probiotics should specify important and often unreported
information about the species, strain, manufacturing processes and storage
conditions of the tested probiotics, and the duration of follow-up. Findings
from this review will help improve future probiotics research and the
development of clinical guidance on their use.
(3424) Practical Tools for Building Clinician Resilience and Reducing
Burnout
Michelle L Dossett, MD, PhD1 and Darshan Mehta, MD, MPH1
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Over the past decade, a growing number of studies have
demonstrated that programs incorporating mind–body practices, cognitive
behavioral tools, appreciative inquiry, narrative medicine, and
community-building exercises can reduce burnout in health-care professionals.
This workshop will briefly review published data on burnout and resilience and
introduce participants to the Stress Management and Resiliency Training (SMART)
program developed at the Benson-Henry Institute (BHI) for mind–body medicine.
Participants will gain familiarity with the comprehensive resiliency tool kit
that comprises the SMART program and engage in several experiential exercises
taught in the program to develop awareness of tools used to build resiliency in
different domains. The workshop will introduce practical tools that busy
clinicians can incorporate into their lives and include time for question and
answer (Q&A). The SMART program is typically conducted for 2 h weekly over 8
weeks. It has been tested in, and shown to be efficacious among, a number of
different patient populations and in health-care providers.
Rationale: This workshop addresses both burnout and resiliency and
introduces clinicians to a range of practical, evidence-based tools that they
can incorporate into their personal and professional lives at any stage of their
career. This workshop also introduces clinicians to a multimodal, evidence-based
framework for thinking about resilience and provides a model (the BHI’s SMART
program) for future exploration of resiliency tools.
The SMART program is the outgrowth of years of clinical experience and research
and one of few such programs currently in existence. This multimodal resiliency
program targets stress with 3 main components: mind–body skills building
(participants are taught a variety of different meditation techniques,
minirelaxations, walking meditation, and yoga), traditional stress
awareness/management techniques to decrease stress reactivity, and practicing
adaptive strategies through healthy lifestyle behaviors (sleep, exercise,
nutrition, and social support) and cognitive reappraisal and adaptive coping
skills (borrowed from cognitive behavior therapy, acceptance commitment therapy,
and positive psychology). The program is offered in a group format which
includes interactive and narrative exercises and helps to build a sense of
community.
Objectives: The aim is to describe the physiologic mechanisms by
which mind–body practices reduce the stress response, explain how mindful
practice can enhance patient care and communication skills, list 5 techniques
for increasing resilience to stress and demonstrate 3 such approaches, and
describe a comprehensive framework for increasing resilience to stress.
Outline:
• Background on burnout—definition, frequency, and consequences
• Resilience as a construct to counteract burnout, meta-analyses, and potential
solutions
• The science of mind–body medicine, mindful practice, and benefits for patients
and providers
• Guided meditation practice and debriefing and introduction to
minirelaxations
• Overview of the SMART program resiliency model and its main components
• Energy battery exercise
• Introduction to cognitive skills
• Appreciation exercise
• Building empathy—loving kindness meditation and mini
• Summary
• Q&A
(3472) Let’s Stop the Opioids! An Experiential Workshop on Nonpharmacologic
Therapies for Pediatric Pain Management
Erica Sibinga, MD1, Shiu-Lin Tsai, MD2, Kathi Kemper,
MD3, Sanghamitra M Misra, MD4 and Danielle Graff,
MD5
1Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2Columbia University, New York, New York
3The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
4Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
5University of Louisville, Louisville, Kentucky
Abstract
Overview: In response to the opioid epidemic in our country,
numerous government agencies including the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) and Food and Drug Administration (FDA) have made official
recommendations for nonpharmaceutical approaches for the treatment of pain.
Participants will be introduced to 4 evidence-based therapies for pediatric pain
management: autogenic training, mindfulness, meditation/breathing techniques,
and acupuncture. All 4 modalities have shown benefits for pain. Attendees will
experience each therapy firsthand and learn at least 1 practical application to
take back for immediate clinical use.
Rationale: In response to the opioid epidemic in our country,
numerous government agencies including the CDC and FDA have made official
recommendations for nonpharmaceutical approaches for the treatment of pain. More
recently, the National Institutes of Health, the U.S. Department of Defense, and
the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs are partnering to expand research of
nonpharmacologic approaches to pain management. Not uncommonly, opioid addiction
begins with legitimately prescribed narcotic usage. Furthermore, increased
morbidity and mortality has been reported in pediatrics, including
multigenerational effects as seen in the rise of neonatal abstinence syndrome
and opioid associated brain changes in newborn babies affecting later
development. Given these alarming opioid-associated sequelae, effective
nonopioid treatment options for pain are urgently needed.
Objectives: Participants will be introduced to 4 evidence-based
therapies for pediatric pain management: autogenic training, mindfulness,
meditation/breathing techniques, and acupuncture. All attendees will experience
each therapy firsthand and learn at least 1 practical application to take back
for immediate clinical use.
Outline:
Autogenic Training—Autogenic training is a simple, effective
self-hypnosis tool to help manage pain and stress in patients of all ages.
Repeating 6 simple phrases quickly leads to deep relaxation within minutes.
Participants will experience this for themselves and then have the opportunity
to lead others in the exercise, practicing in a safe space prior to taking this
tool home to use with patients.
Mindfulness—Mindfulness has been described as nonjudgmental,
present-focused awareness and has been shown to be beneficial for mental health,
coping, and pain management. The evidence for mindfulness benefits will be
reviewed, and mindfulness concepts and formal and informal techniques will be
experienced and discussed. Session participants will learn simple mindfulness
concepts and techniques which can be used for both practitioners and patients
alike.
Meditation/Guided Imagery/Breathing Techniques—Meditation,
guided imagery, and breathing techniques can help manage stress and pain in
children of all ages. These techniques are simple to teach patients, even in a
busy office practice. Children feel empowered once they learn to manage their
own symptoms. Participants will learn to utilize simple tools that can be used
with patients.
Acupuncture—Attendees will experience and learn 2 auricular
acupuncture protocols:
1. Battlefield acupuncture to treat pain in general, currently used in the United
States military
2. Another standardized protocol to abort migraine headaches
(3475) Transformational Learning in Educating Health-care Professionals for
Integrative Medicine and Health
Christian Scheffer, MD, MME1, Diethard Tauschel, MD1, Mary J
Kreitzer, PhD, RN2 and Sian Cotton, PhD2
1Faculty for Health, Witten Herdecke University, Witten, Germany
2Cincinnati, Ohio
Abstract
Overview: Transformational learning is the process of deep,
constructive, and meaningful learning that goes beyond simple knowledge
acquisition and supports critical ways in which learners consciously make
meaning of their lives. Meaning making is central for patients to cope with
diseases in a productive way as well as in students to become engaged and
self-reflected heath-care professionals. This session will discuss different
educational interventions to foster transformational learning in different
stages of education in different educational settings including the beginning of
undergraduate medical education: learning workshop to become a self-directed
learner at medical school; during undergraduate education of health-care
professional students: an interprofessional student wellness retreat; at the end
of undergraduate medical education: supported active participation at
integrative clinical education wards; and creating a learner-centered
environment.
Rationale: For patients, suffering with an illness is strongly
connected with transformational experiences questioning the way of living in a
fundamental way. In order to prepare future health-care professionals to support
patients in such challenging situations, learning is needed promote the
transformation from the student role to a responsible health-care professional.
We will present and discuss different student-centered educational activities to
promote transformational learning based on exposing to and guiding students in
life-changing experiences in different settings. A focus will be on
collaborative learning with peers as well as in interprofessional settings.
Objectives: Participants will be able to understand the value of
transformational learning for health-care students, distinguish different
educational methods to promote transformational learning, and describe the value
of collaborative learning to support self-reflection and
self-transformation.
Outline:
• Learning workshops to promote self-directed learning at medical school
(D Tauschel)
• Interprofessional student wellness retreat (S Cotton)
• Becoming a doctor: Guiding transformational learning during participation at
integrative clinical education wards (C Scheffer)
• Integrating well-being practices into learning environments (MJ
Kreitzer)
(3484) Neuroscience of Compassion: Multidimensional Construct and Integrative
Health Skill
Yi-Yuan Tang, PhD1, Poppy Schoenberg, PhD2, David Vago,
PhD2 and Jonathan Greenberg, PhD3
1Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas
2Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee
3Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: The construct of compassion is multifaceted. It is broadly
defined as the feeling that arises in witnessing another’s suffering, alongside
the subsequent intention/motivation to help. Extant emotion research often
conflates the construct with emotional processes such as empathy, sympathy,
distress, sadness, self-compassion, and even love. Within social psychology,
compassion is often framed as a virtuous characteristic and determinant to
prosocial altruistic behavior that transcends self-referential processes. As
such, moral psychology proposes compassion as foundational to ethical judgment
and behavior. Here, we examine the concept of compassion as an empirical,
multifaceted construct through the lens of neuroscience. Specifically, what are
the distinct neurobiological substrates of compassion and its analogues, and can
it thus be considered as a “skill”, or group of skills, that may be developed?
Can the multifaceted construct of compassion involve multiple neurobiological
markers and be intentionally modulated? What implications would this have for
clinical, research, and educational settings toward the advancement and
optimization of integrative medicine and health? From an integrative health
perspective, clarifying the conceptual and neurobiological processes subserving
compassion will facilitate consistent empirically informed clinical care, in
addition to being good medicine.
Rationale: Compassion presents a central tenet of integrative health
and healing. Albeit, as a multifaceted construct, understanding and advancing
awareness of this operationalization and set of associated practices has
important implications for the integrative health field. This topic is relevant
for the following reasons: (1) from a clinical practice perspective, ensuring
interventions appropriately emphasize compassion-based care is pertinent for the
successful delivery of integrative health, ensuring patients are served in the
most optimal method for their complex clinical needs. Essentially, incorporating
a framework wherein compassion is described and embodied as a set of “skills”
that can be harnessed within integrative medical training; (2) disseminating the
extant research base regarding compassion as a multifaceted construct with
associated set of practices that cultivate it, may contribute to advanced
clinician awareness and development of compassion research, particularly as a
tool for working with “difficult” clinical cases, and personal experiences of
“burnout”; (3) specific to the 2018 Integrative Medicine congress theme,
ensuring the field remains collaborative, consistent, and that high-level
decisions regarding clinical practice, education, and research emphasize
compassion-based care, and a more comprehensive understanding of the mechanisms
of compassion at the individual biological and collective sociopsychological
levels.
Objectives: The aim is to examine compassion as a multifaceted
construct, alongside understanding the extant proposed clinical neurobiological
models; review the current neuroscientific research on neurobiological
substrates and mechanisms of compassion and its analogs (eg, empathy, prosocial
behavior, self-compassion); and synthesize the presented models and empirical
data, in terms of how it may be applied specifically to advancing integrative
health research, education, and clinical practice.
Outline:
1. Compassion is a multifaceted construct, encompassing biological, social,
psychological, and moral/ethical components.
2. Empirical data suggest compassion can be disambiguated from distinct emotional
processes (eg, distress, sadness, self-compassion, and love), with quantifiable
neurobiological substrates.
3. Based on neuroplasticity, compassion could be regarded as a set of skills,
which can be intentionally modulated and enhanced.
4. The implications for the integrative medicine field will be explored. That is,
compassion is not only good care; it may also represent an advanced platform for
clinical practice, education, and research.
(3513) Conducting and Translating Research for Policy-makers: A Case Study of
Acupuncture Coverage by Vermont Medicaid and Blue Cross Blue Shield
Robert Davis, MS1 and Remy Coeyteux, MD, PhD1
1Winston-Salem, North Carolina
Abstract
Overview: Results from the “acupuncture for chronic pain in the
Vermont Medicaid population” trial will be presented in a symposium format in
order to expand the discussion to include strategies that may enhance the
likelihood that research will have policy impacts. The story begins with the
opioid crisis and brings together a diverse set of Vermont stakeholders,
including state legislators, health care and insurance officials, the medical
community, the licensed acupuncturist workforce, and a population of underserved
Medicaid patients who suffer from chronic pain. The format will provide
attendees with a deeper context and insight into the unique challenges,
constraints, and rewards of working in a pragmatic, policy-oriented, and
politicized research environment.
Rationale: This symposium aims to stimulate thinking and provoke
action by integrative medical providers and researchers in the health
services/public policy arena. It is important because it will provide a rare
example of a U.S.-based pragmatic, prospective intervention trial with patient
centered and qualitative outcomes. The population studied is an underserved
group. The design was optimized for generalizability to the Vermont health-care
environment in order to inform health-care policy decisions. Our discussion will
extend beyond the trial design and results to include the unique challenges and
opportunities encountered during this project. Attendees will also benefit from
a description of our successful effort to challenge and educate Vermont Blue
Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) officials regarding their incomplete and erroneous
assessment of the state of the evidence regarding acupuncture for the treatment
of chronic pain.
Objectives: We aim to remind attendees about the continuum between
explanatory and pragmatic trials and the importance of matching each element of
the design with the research question being asked; inform attendees about the
effectiveness of acupuncture in a Medicaid population of chronic pain patients
in the domains of pain intensity, pain interference, sleep disturbance, fatigue,
anxiety, depression, physical function, and social isolation; provide attendees
with potential strategies for translating and contextualizing existing data and
research evidence into formats of use for both expert and nonexpert health-care
policy decision makers; and provide attendees with insight into the
opportunities that were created when a crisis disrupted the usual health-care
status quo.
Outline: (90 min total)
Background: Opioid crisis and Vermont Act 173—mandated BCBS report
and Medicaid pilot study described as follows (10 min):
BCBS VT report to legislature about acupuncture for chronic pain. Rebuttal of
report and discussions, relationships, and policy changes that ensued
(10 min).
Acupuncture for chronic pain in the Vermont Medicaid population—study
(40 min)
○ design and rationale—challenges and constraints
○ results
○ ensuing policy changes
Discussion (30 min)
○ challenges working with the state bureaucracy to get the study started
○ evolution of relationships with Medicaid and BCBS officials
○ loss/turnover of key Medicaid officials during the study due to election of new
governor
○ importance of contextualizing evidence, risks, and benefits of acupuncture with
opioids and other analgesic medications when considering policy decisions
○ self-care and biopsychosocial benefits of acupuncture as demonstrated by our
data and other literature fit well with National Pain Strategy
recommendations
(3520) Pediatric Massage: A Nonpharmacologic Intervention for Children With Pain,
Stress, and Chronic Conditions
Tina Allen, LMT, CPMMT, CPMT, CIMT1, Maria Mascarenhas, MBBS and Winona
Chua, MD2
1Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Vancouver, Washington
2Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Massage therapy has been found to be beneficial in many
clinical conditions. This is particularly true in children who have an essential
need for tactile stimulation to further their growth and development. Touch
stimulates the brain, including the limbic cortex, which is the area of the
brain where emotions are generated. Massage therapy has been shown to reduce
cortisol (stress hormone) levels. Receiving professional touch therapy can aid
in healthy development and can be a vital source of healing. Those who receive
massage therapy may experience benefits including decrease in anxiety,
improvement in pulmonary function, reduction of pain, and fostering an overall
sense of well-being. Given the concern for opioid overuse, pediatric massage
therapy may be an important complementary approach for the nonpharmacologic
management of chronic pain. During this session, participants will learn about
the benefits of pediatric massage through a review of available research as well
as the indications for pediatric massage therapy. There will be a demonstration
and hands-on practice of simple pediatric massage protocols, including those
which aid in decreasing anxiety, stress, and pain, and those that can be used to
manage some common pediatric conditions like constipation. Participants will
learn developmentally appropriate adaptations of common pediatric massage
techniques and will take away applications that will add to a health-care
provider’s professional practice and integrative tool kit.
Rationale: Pediatric massage therapy is a simple, noninvasive,
low-tech, and highly effective clinical intervention. Available evidence for its
effectiveness is increasing. Since it is portable and can be easily taught to
health-care providers and parents, it is an important and useful skill for
integrative health-care providers to have.
Objectives: The aim is to know the indications and importance of
pediatric massage therapy; be aware of the evidence that supports the use of
massage therapy in pain and chronic conditions, including developmentally
appropriate adaptations; and demonstrate a series of massage strokes that may be
especially beneficial to pediatric patients.
Outline:
• Background and literature review to support the use of pediatric massage
• Hospital- and ambulatory-based strategies for pediatric massage, including
examples of current usage in pediatric health care
• Simple hands-on protocols that are demonstrated and practiced during the
workshop
(3535) Mechanisms Underlying the Antidepressant Response of Acupuncture via JNK
Signaling Pathway
Qiuyun Yu1, Tuya Bao1, Huili Jiang1, Bingcong
Zhao1 and Xinjing Yang1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To observe the effect of acupuncture on JNK signaling
pathway in rats with chronic unpredicted mind stress (CUMS), so as to reveal the
underlying mechanism of acupuncture for depression.
Results: CUMS could induce depressive-like behaviors. The expression
of JNK, c-jun, and p-c-jun were upregulated by CUMS in model group, model+SP
group, and model+DMSO group compared with the control group
(P < .01). Compared with model group, the expression level
of each protein in model + DMSO group showed no significant difference
(P > .05). The expression level of JNK in model + SP
group, FLX group, and FLX + SP group showed no significant difference compared
with model group (P > .05), while in acupuncture group and
acupuncture + SP group, JNK expression level showed significant difference
(P < .01). The expression level of c-jun was reduced
significantly in model + SP group, FLX group, FLX + SP group, acupuncture group,
and acupuncture + SP group (P < .05). The expression level
of p-c-jun was reduced significantly in FLX group, FLX + SP group, acupuncture
group, and acupuncture + SP group (P < .01). Compared with
FLX group, the expression of the 3 proteins in FLX + SP group showed no
significant difference (P > .05). Compared with acupuncture
group, the expression of the 3 proteins in acupuncture + SP group also showed no
significant difference (P > .05).
Conclusions: Acupuncture could ameliorate depressive-like behaviors
by regulating-related proteins on the JNK signaling pathway in the prefrontal
cortex.
(3557) Differential Mechanisms of Stress Reduction Following the
Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction and Relaxation Response Programs
Adrienne McCallister, PhD1, Micheal Treadway, PhD2, Jeffery A
Dusek, PhD, James Carmody, PhD, Gunes Sevinc, PhD3, Javeria Hashmi,
PhD4, Marissa L Schneider, BA3, Britta Holzel,
PhD5, Sara W Lazar, PhD1 and Jonathan Greenberg,
PhD1
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia
3Boston, Massachusetts
4Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
5Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: The mechanisms through which stress reduction programs
promote wellness are important for understanding the treatment of stress and
stress-related disorders. In this study, we compared 2 different
meditation-based programs, in order to explore any potential
differential impact on stress-reduction and neural activity.
Results: Both programs reduced perceived stress and increased
mindfulness. The relaxation response (RR) program was exclusively associated
with stronger functional connectivity of the right inferior frontal gyrus—an
important hub of intentional inhibition and control—with supplementary motor
areas during the bodyscan. The mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) program
was exclusively associated with improvements in self-compassion and rumination
and with significant functional connectivity of the right anterior insula—an
important hub of sensory awareness and salience—with pregenual anterior
cingulate during bodyscan meditation compared to rest.
Conclusions: These findings indicate that the different types of
bodyscan exercises were associated with different mechanisms: inhibitory
control-related mechanisms in RR and emotion regulation and sensory
awareness-related mechanisms in MBSR. These results may have
potential implications for the differential effects of mind–body interventions
as well as their utilization for the treatment of diverse conditions.
(3564) Receipt of an Opioid Prescription Among Veterans of Recent Wars Using
Chiropractic Care
Anthony J Lisi, DC1, Christine M Goertz, DC, PhD2, Lori A
Bastian, MD, MPH3, Kelsey L Corcoran, DC3, Eric C DeRycke,
MPH3 and Cynthia A Brandt, MD, MPH3
1VA Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, Connecticut
2Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
3New Haven, Connecticut
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to examine patient factors associated with
opioid use among Veterans of Operations Enduring Freedom/Iraqi Freedom/New Dawn
(OEF/OIF/OND) who receive chiropractic care.
Results: We identified 14 025 OEF/OIF/OND Veterans with a
chiropractic care visit: mean age was 38 years; 15.8% were women; 56% reported
moderate/severe pain intensity; 54.2% had a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress
disorder (PTSD) and 47.6% had a diagnosis of depression. Overall, 4440 (31.6%)
Veterans received one or more opioid prescription. Moderate/severe pain (odds
ratio [OR] = 1.88, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.73–2.04), PTSD (OR = 1.57,
95% CI = 1.43–1.71), depression (OR = 1.42, 95% CI = 1.30–1.55), and current
smoking (OR 1.38, 95% CI = 1.26–1.51) were associated with a higher likelihood
of receiving an opioid prescription.
Conclusions: Opioid use among Veterans receiving chiropractic care
was common and was associated with several clinical factors. This highlights the
need to assess the characteristics and treatment outcomes of those Veterans
receiving opioids before and/or after initiating chiropractic care.
(3567) Human Subjects Research, National Institutes of Health Clinical Trials
Policy, and Implications for Your Research
Wendy Weber, ND, PhD, MPH1, Wen Chen, PhD1, Martina Schmidt,
PhD1 and Christine Wishnoff, MPH1
1National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Scientific disciplines can differ on what elements of a
study are necessary to meet the definition of a clinical trial.
National Institutes of Health (NIH) defines the term broadly, “A research study
in which one or more human subjects are prospectively assigned to one or more
interventions (which may include placebo or other control) to evaluate the
effects of those interventions on health-related biomedical or behavioral
outcomes.” As NIH finalizes the implementation of this definition, many changes
will impact investigators submitting applications with human subjects including
newly formatted funding opportunity announcements, new grant application forms
and elements, good clinical practice training certification requirements, and
registering and reporting requirements for funded projects. These elements have
been implanted as part of NIH’s ongoing efforts to enhance rigor and
reproducibility of clinical research. For example, NIH defines
intervention as a manipulation of a person or a person’s
environment to modify one or more health-related biomedical or
behavioral processes and/or end points. Researchers in complementary and
integrative health studying the basic science or mechanisms of these approaches
may find that their projects now fall within the rubric of NIH clinical trials.
This session will include a brief overview of the NIH clinical trial definition
and several new policies related to the implementation of this definition.
Presenters will orient participants to the newly implemented categories of NIH
funding opportunity announcements to help investigators submit applications for
peer review. Speakers will also provide an overview of how National Center of
Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) is implementing these policy
changes with attention to the new NCCIH clinical trial-specific funding
opportunity announcements. Panelists also will provide links to online resources
they can access to aid them in understanding these major policy changes at
NIH.
Rationale: Much of the research presented at the International
congress on Integrative Medicine and Health is fully or partially funded by the
NCCIH. Nearly 60% of the research supported by NCCIH include human participants.
Thus, the majority of the applications submitted to NCCIH by investigators
attending the International Congress on Integrative Medicine and Health meeting
will be impacted by these policy changes at NIH. This session will inform
attendees about the policy changes, why they were made, and how it will directly
impact them as they apply for funding from NIH and NCCIH specifically. The
session relates to both the policy and clinical research themes of the
Congress.
Objectives: The aim is to understand how NIH policy changes for
human subjects research may impact investigators’ ongoing research studies and
future applications for NIH funding, identify which funding opportunity
announcements can be utilized by investigators who want their applications
assigned to NCCIH for funding consideration, assist investigators in deciding
which available funding opportunity is the best fit for the types of research
that NCCIH supports, understand new review criteria for NIH-defined clinical
trial applications, learn about NCCIH methods for oversight of human subjects
research to enhance rigor and reproducibility goals at NIH, and learn about
resources available to investigators to assist them in the application
process.
Outline:
• Overview of NIH policy changes for human subjects research
• Summary of the impact these policy changes will have on investigators’ ongoing
research as well as new applications
• Overview of NCCIH-specific funding opportunities for clinical research and
basic and mechanistic research with human participants
• Summary of the new elements of clinical trial applications to NIH, new form
components, special attachments, and updated review criteria
• Description of the oversight activities NCCIH uses to assure rigor and
reproducibility
(3575) Do One, Teach One, See One: Flipping the Medical Learning Paradigm From
Passive to Active
Elaine Cheung, PhD1, Rupa Mahadevan, MD1, Melinda Ring, MD,
FACP1 and Sreela Namboodiri, MD1
1Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Overview: This session is intended for faculty or trainees involved
in any form of education in the field of integrative health. Active learning
strategies can increase students’ motivation; improve their participation,
confidence, and interpersonal skills; and encourage them to be involved in
higher order thinking. Engaging students through active learning techniques such
as changing lectures to prework videos, in-class role playing, case discussion,
coaching, and project-oriented hands-on learning can help engage all students by
making them an integral part of the learning process. During this workshop,
participants will learn strategies for incorporating active learning to support
their learning objectives, practice several forms of active learning with
colleagues, and formulate a plan for incoproration of at least one new active
learning strategy into their own work. By the conclusion of this workshop,
participants will be able to remember and
understand key concepts and terms related to active
learning, be comfortable enough to implement at least 1 active
learning strategy in his or her teaching, evaluate the suitability of an active
learning exercise for a given course situation, be able to
relate active learning to other teaching methods,
understand some of the personal and social implications of
using active learning in his or her classroom, care about
learning more about active learning, and have a list of resources for
learning more about active learning.
Rationale: This workshop addresses integrative medicine education
teaching methods and curriculum development, as well as the process of
collaboration with colleagues both within and outside of the medical field to
enrich curriculum development. Medical schools struggle with finding time for
required coursework within student’s schedules, and integrative medicine and
lifestyle focused topics are often given inadequate time in the core curriculum,
or relegated to electives or clubs. When presented as a required curriculum, a
subset of the learners may come with preconceived biases against integrative and
complementary medicine, or feel the content is not valuable and worth attention
compared to more conventional training such as anatomy and pharmacology.
Engaging students through active learning techniques such as role playing, case
discussion, coaching, and hands-on learning can help engage all students by
making them an integral part of the learning process. Active learning can also
be used in smaller groups when offered outside of usual class time, when
students may need a more engrossing experience to maintain their interest
levels. While shifting from traditional lectures to active learning can require
additional work by faculty during the preparation phase, it can lead to a
greater enjoyment of teaching by fostering greater interactions with students.
Ultimately, inviting students to participate in the learning environment gives
them greater responsibility and allows students to see a course as more valuable
and directly related to their goals, thereby creating a more fulfilling
experience for faculty and students alike.
Objectives: This session is intended for faculty or trainees
involved in any form of education in the field of integrative health. Active
learning strategies can increase students’ motivation; improve their
participation, confidence, and interpersonal skills; and encourage them to be
involved in higher order thinking. During this workshop, participants will learn
strategies for incorporating active learning to support their learning
objectives and practice several forms of active learning with colleagues. By the
conclusion of this workshop, participants will be able to remember and
understand key concepts and terms related to active learning, be comfortable
enough to implement at least 1 active learning strategy in his or her teaching,
evaluate the suitability of an active learning exercise for a given course
situation, be able to relate active learning to other teaching methods,
understand some of the personal and social implications of using active learning
in his or her classroom, care about learning more about active learning, and
have a list of resources for learning more about active learning.
Outline: Active learning is a process whereby students engage in
activities that promote analysis, synthesis, and evaluation of class content.
Active learning stands in contrast to standard modes of instruction in which
teachers do most of the talking and students are passive. Cooperative learning,
problem-based learning, and the use of case methods and simulations are some
approaches that promote active learning. In this session, we will review several
approaches to active learning, using as a case example their incorporation
within a Culinary Medicine elective at Northwestern Feinberg School of Medicine,
developed by faculty from the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine in
partnership with the nonprofit organization Common Threads.
1. Flipped classroom—creating short video segments for prehomework rather than
classroom passive lectures
2. Case-based improvisational patient coaching exercises
3. Student-led discussion of an assigned article
4. Active hands-on learning (culinary session) and mindful meal together
5. Learning through teaching (medical students volunteer in a Chicago Public
School to teach children about nutrition)
6. Social media—the use of Facebook or Google Classroom as a forum for active
exchange of ideas between classes
(3595) Impact of Mind–Body Programs on Dietary Behaviors and Attitudes
Carl Fulwiler, MD PhD1, Ruth Q Wolever, PhD1 and Sara Lazar,
PhD1
1Charlestown, MA
Abstract
Overview: Many studies have investigated mindfulness-based weight
loss programs. Relatively little is known about the utility of using mindfulness
to maintain significant weight loss. This symposia focuses on 3
National Center of Complementary and Integrative Health-funded studies to
explore the impact of mindfulness on dietary attitudes and behaviors as well as
psychosocial and neural measures that might support changes in eating and
exercise habits. Two presenters studied mindfulness programs explicitly designed
for weight loss maintenance, the third presenter studied changes in dietary
behaviors following a yoga-based stress reduction program that did not include
any explicit dietary content.
Rationale: Many individuals who successfully lose significant
amounts of weight will regain the weight within 1 year. New approaches are
needed to help these individuals change their dietary habits and maintain their
weight loss.
Objectives: Participants will (1) gain an understanding of how
mind-body practices impact dietary habits and attitudes and (2) how psychosocial
factors such as self-efficacy, body awareness, and self-compassion mediate these
changes.
Outline: The first speaker will present findings from a pilot
randomized controlled trial of overweight individuals who are trying to maintain
weight loss randomized to either mindfulness-based stress reduction or an active
control. Measures to be reported include pre–post resting state functional
connectivity, and pre–post and 6-month body weight, dietary behavior, emotional
eating, exercise, and psychological predictors. The second speaker will present
results of a qualitative interview conducted with 14 participants 12–18 months
following a mindfulness-based weight maintenance intervention to understand how
they had or had not incorporated mindfulness into their daily lives relative to
eating. Results include changes in awareness of bodily sensations, differences
in behavior and emotions, shifts in attention, thinking and decision-making, and
increased awareness of long-term, higher order values. The third speaker will
present findings from a pilot study that assessed changes in dietary attitudes
and behaviors in stressed individuals who were not explicitly trying to change
their weight or eating habits, and in the absence of any programmatic
dietary/weight loss content. Results include changes in caloric intake and
dietary quality, emotional eating, self-efficacy, self-compassion, and body
awareness.
(3600) Looking Back, Looking Forward: National Center for Complementary and
Integrative Health at 20
Margaret A Chesney, PhD1, Christine M Goertz, DC, PhD2,
Emmeline Edwards, PhD3, David Shurtleff, PhD3 and Anita
McRae-Williams, MA3
1San Francisco, California
2Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
3National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: The National Center for Complementary and Integrative
Health (NCCIH) is the lead federal agency for scientific research on the
usefulness and safety of complementary and integrative health practices. The
Center was established, by Congressional mandate, under provisions of the
Omnibus Appropriations Bill (P.L. 105-277). This bill amended Title IV of the
Public Health Service Act and elevated the Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM)
to a National Institutes of Health (NIH) Center. In 1998, Congress expanded the
status, mandate, and authority of OAM by enacting legislation to create the
National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). The Center
was later renamed NCCIH by a second congressional mandate as part of the omnibus
budget measure signed by President Obama. The Center’s charge is to “conduct
basic and applied research (intramural and extramural), research training, and
disseminate health information and will identify, investigating, and validating
CAM treatments, diagnostic and prevention modalities, disciplines and systems.”
This International Congress on Integrative Medicine and Health (ICIMH) symposium
will highlight NCCIH history, philosophy, current directions, and research
portfolios. Dr Christine Goertz, vice-chancellor for Research and Health Policy,
Palmer College of Chiropractic, member of NCCIH/NIH Advisory Council, and former
program officer at NCCIH, will give the historical perspective for NCCIH
scientific program developments in the early years. Dr Margaret Chesney,
professor of medicine at the UCSF Osher Center for Integrative Medicine and
former deputy director and director, DER, and training at NIH/NCCIH, will
comment on the middle years and the challenges encountered in integrating the
Center’s programs to the NIH biomedical research enterprise. Dr Emmeline
Edwards, director, DER, will highlight NCCIH current vision and will update the
ICIMH community on highlights of her 2012 closing session of the ICIMH meeting.
Finally, Dr David Shurtleff, NCCIH acting director, will discuss the Center’s
2016 strategic plan and future vision and high-priority research topics.
Rationale: NCCIH is the world’s largest funder of research on
complementary and integrative health. To address the need for objective evidence
as to the safety and efficacy of complementary and integrative health
approaches, NCCIH supports rigorous scientific investigation to better
understand how these interventions work, for whom, and the optimal methods of
practice and delivery. The Center’s strategic priorities have been shaped by
real-time developments in science, medicine, and health care. The Center
stresses the importance of basic/mechanistic and clinical research as the core
of building the evidence base for complementary and integrative health
approaches. NCCIH has developed and implemented a research framework that also
brings the methods of effectiveness and outcomes research to the real world
where public use is extensive. This ICIMH symposium will be an excellent forum
to discuss NCCIH’s history and continued commitment to advance the science of
complementary and integrative health, to build state-of-the-art research
capacity through targeted training and career development programs, to foster
multidisciplinary collaborations, and to provide objective and authoritative
evidence-based information to the public and health-care professionals.
Objectives: Participants at the ICIMH symposium will gain in-depth
knowledge of the Center’s vision and mission. The 4 presentations will offer the
historical perspective, a sense of the philosophy that guides our research
framework and a detailed view of the current and future research priorities for
the Center.
Outline:
• Historical perspective—NCCIH creation and development of research programs
• Integration of NCCIH programs at NIH
• Program priorities and blue-sky vision for integrative health
• 2016 strategic plan and future directions
(3601) Traditional Medicine Perspectives and Treatment of Patients With
Pain
Emily Telfair, ND1, Betsy Miller, MS, CNS, LDN1, Marlysa
Sullivan, PT, C-IAYT, MS1 and Tyme Gigliotti, DAc, LAc1
1Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Traditional modalities have unique explanatory frameworks
from which they approach and work with clients. This panel discussion will
involve practitioners of yoga therapy, naturopathy, acupuncture, and herbalism
presenting their discipline’s explanatory framework and approach to chronic
pain. Specific applications of each discipline for working with chronic pain,
including special considerations for the pain population, challenges, obstacles,
and relevant research will be addressed. Challenges in integrating traditional
perspectives and wisdom with a biomedical framework, along with recommendations,
will be presented.
Rationale: Understanding each distinct traditional perspective is
essential for interprofessional dialogue in working with the chronic pain
client.
Objectives: At the end of the panel session, participants will
differentiate various traditional approaches to chronic pain including
explanatory frameworks; compare and contrast-specific applications of our
various practices or treatments for pain, including challenges, obstacles, and
relevant research pertaining to the traditional perspectives presented; and
identify challenges of integrating evidence-informed practice into traditional
perspectives and modalities. Additionally, the aim is to recommend for
interprofessional communication and collaboration and discuss the approaches to
research that honor traditional frameworks.
Outline: Various practitioners of traditional modalities will
discuss their unique approaches to relating to and treating their patients in
the context of pain.
(3603) Pain and Functional Trajectories in Symptomatic Knee Osteoarthritis Over a
12-week Period of Nonpharmacological Exercise Interventions
Lori L Price, MAS, MLA1, Xingyi Han, MPH2, William F Harvey,
MD, MSc2, Augustine C Lee, MD2, Jeffrey B Driban, PhD, ATC,
CSCS2, Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc2 and Raveendhara R Bannuru,
MD, PhD2
1Tufts University, Boston, Massachusetts
2Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: While exercise is the recommended treatment for knee
osteoarthritis (OA), heterogeneous patterns in treatment response are poorly
understood. We aim to identify pain and functional trajectories from exercise
interventions among adults with symptomatic knee OA and explore their
association with baseline participant factors.
Results: We examined 171 participants (mean age 61 years, body mass
index 32 kg/m2, 71% female, 57% white) and identified 4 pain
trajectories: Lower early improvement (43%), moderate early improvement (32%),
higher delayed improvement (15%), and higher no improvement (10%; Figure 1). We
found similar trajectories for function, except the lower function trajectories
diverged into gradual (12%) or delayed improvement (15%). Compared with the
lower early improvement pain trajectory, moderate and higher pain trajectories
were significantly associated with younger age, obesity, black race, and poorer
physical and psychological health (Table 1). A similar pattern of significant
associations were found among the functional trajectories (data not shown).
Conclusions: We found 4 distinct trajectories for pain and function
over 12-week exercise interventions among adults with symptomatic knee OA. While
most participants experienced early improvements, subgroups with greater
baseline pain/physical disability had either gradual, delayed, or no
improvements. These findings help disentangle the heterogeneity of treatment
response and may advance patient-centered care for these patients.
(3607) Music, the Brain, and Chronic Pain
Emmeline Edwards, PhD1, Wen Chen, PhD1, Sunil Iyengar,
BS2, Catherine Bushnell, PhD1, Mathieu Roy,
PhD3 and Joke Bradt, PhD4
1National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland
2National Endowment for the Arts, Washington, DC
3McGill College, Montreal, Québec, Canada
4College of Nursing and Health Professions, Drexel University,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Music can get us moving, lift our mood, and even help us
recall a special moment or event, but can it be used to relieve pain and improve
well-being? This symposium will bring together some key players in the federal
government and the research arena to present the latest scientific discoveries
and governmental initiatives related to the possible interactions among music,
the brain, and management of chronic pain. Sunil Iyengar,
director of the Office of Research and Analysis at the National Endowment for
the Arts, will provide a brief overview of the Federal Interagency Task Force on
art-based therapies and introduce the concept of music as a game changer for
brain health and its capacity to manage difficult symptoms like chronic pain.
Dr Catherine Bushnell, scientific director of the National
Center for Complementary and Integrative Health/National Institutes of Health
(NCCIH/NIH) intramural research program, will present state of the science
research on neural circuits and brain mechanisms engaged in pain perception and
treatment. Dr Mathieu Roy, behavioral and cognitive
neuroscientist at McGill University, will discuss our current understanding of
brain mechanisms involved in music perception and production, with an emphasis
on music reward processing and overlap with neural mechanisms of pain
perception. Dr Joke Bradt, associate professor in the
Department of Creative Arts Therapies at Drexel University, will describe some
recent clinical research related to various forms of music therapy and their
potential mechanisms of action for chronic pain management. Finally, Dr
Emmeline Edwards, director for the Division of Extramural Research
at NCCIH/NIH, and Dr Wen Chen, cochair of the “Music and
Health” trans-NIH working group, will describe the Sound Health Initiative,
discuss ongoing NIH research initiatives, and highlight gaps and opportunities
in basic/mechanistic and clinical research on music and health.
Rationale: Music is universally enjoyed regardless of culture,
language, gender, ethnicity, and race. While the importance of music on our
daily lives and its positive impact on our health are widely recognized,
systematic and rigorous scientific studies are still lacking. The utilization of
music-based therapies as a complementary and integrative approach for chronic
pain management and opioid misuse remains largely unexplored. In early 2017, the
NIH and the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts established the Sound
Health initiative, a partnership initiated by Dr Francis Collins and the
renowned opera singer Renée Fleming. The goal of this initiative is to increase
our understanding of how music affects health, with emphasis on the basic
neuroscience of music and potential clinical applications. One of the first
activities of the Sound Health initiative was the January 26–27, 2017 workshop
“Music and the Brain: Research across the Lifespan,” held at the main NIH campus
in Bethesda, MD. Neuroscientists, music therapists, and supporters of biomedical
research and the arts discussed basic and mechanistic ways that music affects
the brain as well as the healing potential of music (or how music therapy can
change, restore, or improve nonmusic behaviors). On June 2–3, 2017, the Kennedy
Center and the NIH, in association with the National Endowment for the Arts,
hosted Sound Health: Music and the Mind, a series of performances, lectures, and
hands-on workshops that brought leading researchers in the field and performers
to explore the intersection of music and science. This proposed State-of-Science
International Congress on Integrative Medicine and Health (ICIMH) symposium will
expand on these previous efforts with a focus on the potential impact of music
on chronic pain and pain management.
Objectives: Music has always been a topic of wide appeal and broad
interest to the participants of the ICIMH meetings. In the 2016 ICIMH meeting,
an experiential workshop on music attracted a room full of attendees, many of
whom raised scientific questions about music and its impact on brain and health.
This proposed symposium will provide the ICIMH attendees and participants
in-depth insight into the science of music and health and include the following
objectives: (1) present the current and cutting-edge scientific research on
pain, music, and music therapies; (2) discuss the gaps and research
opportunities in the field of music and health; and (3) encourage dialogues and
discussions about the potential impact of music on pain management.
Outline:
1. What is the current scientific evidence on how the human brain processes pain
and manages the experience of chronic pain?
2. What is the current scientific evidence on how the human brain processes and
creates music?
3. Are there any common brain regions involved in pain experience and music
experience?
4. Can music therapy be used for chronic pain management?
5. What are the research gaps and opportunities in the study of music, its health
impact, and connections to pain and pain management?
(3611) Building the Infrastructure for Complementary and Integrative Health in
VA: Lessons Learned From the VA Integrative Health Coordinating Center
Kavitha Reddy, MD1, Alison M Whitehead, MPH1, Sara Grimsgaard,
MHMS1, Juli Olson, DC, LAc1, Benjamin Kligler, MD,
MPH1 and Belinda Collingbourne, MBA1
1Albany, NY
Abstract
Overview: Implementation of complementary and integrative health
(CIH) across the Veterans Health Administration (VA) had been inconsistent and
limited before Fiscal Year (FY) 2000. Given evidence of benefit, commitment to
innovation, and desire to help patients with chronic pain and mental health
conditions, as well as improve well-being, VA is embarking on a major
health-care transformation. The Integrative Health Coordinating Center (IHCC) in
VA’s Office of Patient-Centered Care and Cultural Transformation was established
in 2014 to identify and address barriers to implementing CIH across VA and to
serve as a resource for clinical best practices and education for veterans,
staff, and leadership. An FY15 internal survey showed 93% of VA facilities
offered at least 1 CIH approach. The most widely offered approaches were
acupuncture, meditation, yoga and tai chi which are known to help with complex
issues veterans face such as pain management and mental health conditions, as
well as optimization of well-being. IHCC is building the infrastructure to
support streamlined implementation of CIH across VA to include policy,
tracking/billing mechanisms, new professions, clinical guidelines, access to CIH
approaches through telehealth, and strategic partnerships. Guiding
implementation are evidence maps, which provide a visual overview of the
distribution of evidence for each approach, systematic reviews, and further
research on outcomes. Supported by the Comprehensive Recovery and Addiction Act
(CARA) legislation, VA has launched the Whole Health System (WHS) in 18 Flagship
Facilities in FY18, the first wave in national deployment of more comprehensive
CIH services. The WHS model will serve as a delivery system for bringing
effective, evidence-based CIH approaches, and self-care strategies into the care
plan of every veteran. This session will discuss steps IHCC has taken to build
the infrastructure for comprehensive implementation of CIH across VA, describe
barriers encountered, and share best practices and lessons learned.
Rationale: The VA is unique in that it covers all aspects outlined
in this year’s conference: research, education, clinical practice, and policy.
The VA is the largest integrated health-care system in the United States. Policy
that is implemented in VA often impacts other organizations. Lessons learned
from the work VA has done in the area of CIH could help inform other hospitals
and academic institutions.
Objectives: The aim is to list 3 of the barriers to CIH
implementation, and steps VA is taking to address them, understand how the WHS
model is the delivery system for CIH at VA, and describe 2 best practices for
implementation of CIH services from IHCC.
(3612) Power of a Community-based Organizations and Academic Health Programs
Working Together to Deliver Integrative Medicine: A Case Study
Neile Edens, PhD1, Stephanie Folkens, BA2, Elaine Cheung,
PhD2, Rupa Mahadevan, MD2 and Melinda Ring, MD,
FACP2
1Common Threads, Chicago, Illinois
2Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Overview:
Background: Academic health programs and community-based
organizations play complementary roles in delivering health care in underserved
neighborhoods. Physicians/clinicians are authorities on treating illness and
have the benefit of focused time with individual patients, while community-based
organizations can deliver accessible, intensive wellness programs in a
supportive group setting. Collaboration between academic health programs and
community-based organizations is beneficial to both physicians shape and enhance
program material and are a resource for faculty/student volunteers, while
community-based organizations can amplify and reinforce wellness messages and
offer unique learning environments for trainees. Program
Description: One model of this type of collaboration is the
Cooking Up Health: Docs and Kids in the Kitchen program,
developed and implemented jointly by the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine
at the Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, and Common Threads,
a nonprofit organization that provides cooking and nutrition education to
children and adults in underserved neighborhoods. The Cooking Up
Health program provides culinary medicine education to first-year
medical students, who then teach Common Threads classes to elementary school
students. In this model, medical students practice health coaching skills and
explore cultural and socioeconomic factors in behavior change, while elementary
students benefit from receiving nutrition instruction from medical student role
models. Evaluation of the pilot implementation of the program found benefits to
medical students, the effect of the program on elementary students is under
investigation. Key factors that supported success of this model were Common
Threads established infrastructure for delivering programs in public schools and
the commitment and support of Osher Center leadership.
Conclusion: Residents in underserved neighborhoods and
academic programs both benefit from collaborative programs linking integrative
medicine and community-based organizations (supported by the Alliance for
Research in the Chicagoland Communities).
Rationale: Building community-based partnerships is integral for
integrative medicine to flourish; it is one way to create sustainable change in
the local community and partner with already established organizations to
promote health and wellness. Partnering with community organizations can advance
the education sector of integrative medicine and lifestyle medicine in
meaningful ways for students from elementary school age to graduate level
education. With the help of community-based organizations, our advocacy effort
to build awareness for nutrition, healthy eating, and fighting childhood obesity
has impacted Chicago Public School education as well as medical school students.
Community partnerships can enhance community engagement in projects and bring
attention to health topics in underserved areas.
Objectives: By the end of this session, participants will be able to
see how community partnerships can enhance education and how integrative
medicine clinicians and trainees can impact on community health. Participants
will learn how engagement with the community can positively impact health-care
education, know how community partnerships can build greater awareness to fight
current health epidemics, understand how health-care delivery can be enhanced
through community partnerships, demonstrate how the medical establishment and
community sector can create lasting change through advocacy efforts, and develop
increased interest in finding a local community organization with whom to
partner.
(3618) Ketamine, Psychedelics, and MDMA: A New Path for Integrative
Psychiatry
Will Van Derveer, MD1 and Scott Shannon1
1▪▪
Abstract
Overview: Psychiatry is currently at a cross roads. The chemical
imbalance theory that has driven much of our conventional care over the last 30
years has been undercut by research that tells us that this model is overly
simplistic and not consistent with emerging brain research. In the last 10
years, research on ketamine, MDMA, and psychedelics has exploded in the
literature. All of these agents can highlight a model that employs intermittent
medication use that catalyzes deeper change. Clinicians and researchers are now
exploring medication-assisted psychotherapy that posits an inner healer and
moves away from the chemical imbalance theory and the model of daily suppressive
therapy to keep symptoms at bay. This session will highlight an interactive
discussion with the audience to consider the current research base, the concept
of an inner healer, and the role these agents may play in integrative medicine
and psychiatry.
Rationale: This session will explore how research in innovative
areas can alter both conventional and integrative care. It also opens up all of
conventional psychiatry to a sea change in which the internal ability to heal is
highlighted over the current model of pathology and daily medication and
management. The research with MDMA, psychedelics, and ketamine is often based on
a model in which the medications act as catalysts for deeper change and shift in
awareness. This is a collaborative model built on relationship and trust in the
inner healer. In late August, MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for severe PTSD was
awarded break through status by the Food and Drug Administration based on phase
II research. Currently, phase III of this trial is about to begin and
compassionate use of this medication in this model will likely begin next fall.
Both Dr Shannon and Dr Van Derveer are involved in the MDMA study as principal
investigator/study therapist and study physician/study therapist,
respectively.
Objectives: The aim is to evaluate the current trends and evolving
research model in medication-assisted psychotherapy and brief discussion about
the historical links to shamanism in this model; assess the current research
base in MDMA and the upcoming phase III trial; analyze the current research base
concerning psychedelic medications and the future directions for treatment;
recall the overall status of ketamine research and the appreciate the movement
toward ketamine-assisted psychotherapy; and as a large group openly assess the
concerns, limitations, and potentials for this work.
Outline:
1. Medication-assisted psychotherapy history, philosophical foundations, and
current status
2. MDMA background, history, and current research. Upcoming phase III trial
design and implications
3. Psychedelics medications brief history, review of work in neuroimaging, and
implications of findings in the default mode network and clinical research
4. Ketamine review of current research, discuss mechanism, and explore the
different existing styles of treatment
5. Large group discussion on the these topics, cued as needed by provocative
questions
(3638) So You Want to Start a Clinical Fellowship in Integrative Medicine?
Lessons Learned From 2 Osher Centers for Integrative Medicine in Developing
Programs
Shelley Adler, PhD1, Nancy Heap, MSW, LCSW1, Anand Dhruva,
MD1 and Melinda Ring, MD, FACP1
1Chicago, IL
Abstract
Overview: Integrative health (IH) is proposed as a possible solution
for addressing America’s health-care crisis, including the spiraling cost,
opioid addiction, and obesity epidemic. One important barrier to providing
access to evidence-informed integrative care is a lack of physicians who have
received quality training in integrative medicine and can become leaders within
academic centers, government agencies, and community settings. The Accreditation
Council for Graduate Medical Education currently accredits residencies and
fellowships in the United States but not those offering IH training. Efforts to
increase accountability and standardization of IH fellowships in recent years
include the publication of proposed IH fellowship competencies as well as the
establishment of a board exam by the American Board of Physician Specialties.
The number of clinical IH fellowships approved by the American Board of
Integrative Medicine as meeting criteria for training to be eligible to sit for
the board exam is increasing each year. Despite growing opportunities, the
demand from trainees and the need in our health-care system remains unmet. The
majority of traditional on-site clinical fellowships accept only 1–2 applicants
per year, and the primarily distance-based fellowships reach higher numbers of
trainees but lack on-site clinical oversight of patient care. In order to foster
the development of highly qualified IH clinicians, 2 Osher Centers for
Integrative Medicine (Northwestern University and University of California, San
Francisco) launched on-site fellowships within the past 3 years. This symposium
will share a stepwise process and offer some practical suggestions for those
interested in developing an IH fellowship or refining a currently existing
program. Presenters share from their own recent experiences, discussing lessons
learned and challenges ranging from funding to candidate selection, in order to
help attendees determine the feasibility for beginning the process at their own
institution. Faculty from existing fellowships is encouraged to attend to share
additional perspectives.
Rationale: The Congress and the Academic Consortium for Integrative
Medicine and Health are driven by the mission of sharing information on
education, research, and clinical fronts in order to foster the growth of
integrative medicine within our academic institutions. Providing a road map for
institutions interested in pursuing the development of a fellowship program is
aligned with the goal of nurturing our future leaders.
Objectives: This symposium is intended to serve as a blueprint for
some essential components of a successful fellowship program, as well as a road
map for effectively navigating the challenges faced in creating and sustaining
one. After this symposium a participant will be able to describe the process of
strategic planning for a fellowship; differentiate options for a curriculum that
can be customized to meet the educational goals of an individual fellow;
identify key components including core faculty, funding, space, and patient
access needed to ensure program success; and assess the options for trainee
recruitment in terms of numbers, specialties, and duration of training.
Outline: Session speakers will discuss the following topics from the
perspective of individual institutional experience that may serve as examples of
lessons learned for attendees.
1. Strategic planning
• Curriculum development
• Self-study
• Teaching sessions
• Experiential sessions
3. Clinical training
• Fellow specialties and faculty expertise
• Patient flow and referrals
• Clinical teaching models
4. Selecting fellows
• Number of fellows
• Fellow qualifications
• Recruitment of fellows
(3663) FOODCARE: Developing Evidence-based Clean Foods for Health and Disease
Prevention in Pediatric Patients
Maria Hanna, MS, RD, LDN1, Amy Dean, MPH, RD1, Alexandra Zeitz,
BS2, Ben Fulton, BS2, Jessi Erlichman, MPH3,
Jonathan Deutsch, PhD2 and Maria Mascarenhas, MBBS3
1The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
2Drexel University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
3Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Nutrition plays an important role in health and disease
with increasing evidence linking eating patterns to chronic disease. Pediatrics
provides a unique opportunity for disease prevention through nutrition education
and provision of “clean” or whole foods (natural, organic, non-GMO, locally
grown, nutrient rich, preservative, and pesticide free) from an early age. Food
product development is typically based on market opportunities related to taste,
convenience, cost, preparation time, shelf life, cultural preferences, and
nutrition. There is a growing demand from the public for whole foods with low
environmental impact. At the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP), we take
a “food as medicine” approach in an effort to prevent and manage chronic
conditions. We have requests from families for affordable whole foods that
involve simple meal preparation and have partnered with the Food Lab at Drexel
University’s Center for Food and Hospitality Management for recipe development.
After discussion, based on patient, parent, and clinician requests, food ideas
are ranked. The Drexel team then develops the recipe and tests it in their Food
Lab. Taste testing occurs at Drexel and by registered dietitians at CHOP. Based
on feedback, the finalized recipe is developed for dissemination. Initial
recipes include a clean rehydration solution that can be made at home as well as
a series of recipes that can be used for patients with constipation. The recipes
are platform agnostic in that they can be provided as education to parents,
produced by health-care food service providers on patient trays or in
cafeterias, used in clinical research, or manufactured by start-ups or
established food companies. Innovative partnership between clinicians and food
science experts results in the production of evidence-based, healthy, easy to
use food recipes for clinical use. FOODCARE creates clinically needed
evidence-based food recipes by working backward through the typical food product
development cycle.
(3692) Stakeholder-informed Addition of Spices and Herbs Increased Vegetable
Intake in the National School Lunch Program at an Underserved and Predominantly
African-American High School
Patrick F McArdle, PhD1, Mary K Bahr-Robertson, BA1, Brian M
Berman, MD1, Christopher R D'Adamo1, Brandin Bowden,
MS2, Elizabeth A Parker, PhD, RD1 and Ariel Trilling,
BS1
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2The Institute for Integrative Health, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: The National School Lunch Program (NSLP) serves over 5
billion school meals per year and helps surmount many barriers to healthy eating
among underserved children and adolescents. However, vegetable intake in the
NSLP remains strikingly low among underserved African-American high school
students. The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether addition of
stakeholder-informed vegetable recipes flavored with spices and herbs to the
NSLP at an underserved and predominantly African-American high school in
Baltimore, MD, would increase vegetable intake as compared to typical NSLP
vegetable recipes.
Results: A total of 4285 plates (typical: n = 2160, spiced:
n = 2125) were collected from students over 8 weeks for assessment of vegetable
intake. There was a 21% increase in total vegetable intake when spiced compared
to typical (0.33-ounce increase, P < .0001). Vegetables with
the largest increases when spiced compared to typical recipes were carrots,
broccoli, and vegetable medley (broccoli, carrots, cauliflower).
Conclusions: Adding student-tested vegetable recipes flavored with
spices and herbs to the NSLP and evaluating vegetable intake was feasible at an
underserved and predominantly African-American high school in Baltimore.
Extensive stakeholder engagement facilitated one of the largest school-based
vegetable intake studies conducted to date. While additional interventions are
needed to further engage students in dietary improvements, addition of spices
and herbs provides a resource-efficient means of achieving modest increases in
vegetable intake among this challenging demographic.
(3696) Culinary Medicine: Lessons Learned From Implementing Curricula Across the
Country
Rupa Mahadevan, MD
Amy Locke, MD1, Melinda Ring, MD2, Misha Kogan, MD, Sonia
Oyola, MD, Geeta Maker-Clark, MD and Seema Kakar MD3
1Salt Lake City, Utah
2Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, Chicago, Illinois
3Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: Medical school nutrition curricula have struggled to
provide the needed skills for assisting patients with health behavior change,
despite a strong societal need for guidance in this area. Culinary Medicine is a
unique approach to helping physicians improve the lives of their patients while
also impacting their own wellness. Challenges include access to a teaching
kitchen, suitable faculty knowledge, implementing interprofessional education,
and funding. University of Utah Health (UUH) developed a Culinary Medicine
program with the School of Medicine (SOM) and the College of Health (COH) using
the Goldring Center for Culinary Medicine at Tulane University curriculum in
2016. In 2017, this elective was expanded to students from the COH and School of
Pharmacy using curriculum designed and taught by UUH faculty. The Culinary
Medicine program at Pritzker School of Medicine is offered as part of the
curriculum for all students rotating through Family Medicine and as an 8 week
optional elective for M1 students taught by physicians and a chef/dietitian. The
program has recently expanded to include community outreach in the South Side of
Chicago, at Blackstone Bikes and the Montessori School of Englewood. Osher
Center for Integrative Medicine at Northwestern University received a grant to
cocreate a Culinary Medicine curriculum in partnership with Common Treads, an
organization which is experienced in delivering cooking and nutrition education
in schools and other youth program sites in Chicago and across the country. The
first student cohort participated in 2017. Georgetown School of Medicine
launched its Culinary Medicine elective in the fall of 2017 in collaboration
with Capital Food Bank who supplied the space. These evidence-based, nutrition
curricula are examples of innovative strategies to foster appreciation for
nutrition in prevention and management of disease. This panel discussion will
highlight the different curricula along with the challenges and successes in
implementation.
Rationale: Nutrition knowledge, food choices, and healthy cooking
habits have been shown to play a significant role in the prevention and
management of obesity and its related diseases. Yet primary care residents and
practicing physicians feel unprepared to counsel their patients about important
elements of lifestyle such as nutrition and exercise. A third of Americans are
obese and nearly two thirds are overweight; the negative sequelae of obesity and
its comorbidities cost the U.S. roughly $190 billion annually. Culinary Medicine
is a new approach to teach health-care professionals the necessary skills to
affect behavior change with patients. Implementation of curricula has been slow
to reach students despite interest due to difficulties operationalizing this
program on a large scale. The purpose of our presentation is to highlight the
importance of this type of interactive, interdisciplinary education while
exploring the steps, barriers, successes of starting this type of nutrition
curriculum at different schools of medicine.
Objectives: The aim is to define culinary medicine and describe the
role it can play in training students and residents to assess patients’ habits
and provide assistance in lifestyle modification, identify strategies for
implementation and solutions to common challenges of culinary medicine
curriculum into health sciences education, and articulate the role of culinary
medicine in the personal wellness of health-care providers.
Outline: Participants will be involved in an interactive discussion
with the faculty/panelists representing the University of Utah, Chicago Pritzker
School of Medicine, Osher Center for Integrative Medicine at Northwestern
University and Georgetown University after short presentations where each
faculty describes a short history of the program, current impact of the work on
either medical students, community member or both, challenges regarding
sustainability and future outlook. Throughout the postpresentation question and
answer session, participants will have the opportunity to discuss related
educational examples of innovative medical student education in their own
settings. Participants will also be encouraged to consider the benefits of and
barriers to incorporating educational programs for training medical students to
address nutrition with patients.
(3704) Exploring Interprofessional Integrative Clinical Care
Sonia Sosa, MD1
1▪▪
Abstract
Overview: Oregon Health and Science University (OHSU) Richmond
clinic opened in 1995 and became a Federally Qualified Look Alike in 2004. In
2012, it became a full Federally Qualified Health Center (FQHC). We serve a
primarily Medicaid, Medicare, and uninsured population with a service area which
compromises a population of greater than 50 000 people which is both ethnically
and socially diverse. In 2015, OHSU and the Naturopathic University of Natural
Medicine (NUNM) decided to join forces and create an Interprofessional
Integrative Medicine Consult Clinic within Richmond clinic. Richmond clinic has
a model for offering specialty consult clinic sessions to provide patients who
are having difficulty being seen in outside specialty clinics a specialist visit
within their primary care medical home. We offer these consult clinics for
cardiology, ENT, pain, sport’s medicine, podiatry, and orthopedics. We sought to
develop an integrative medicine consult clinic in this model. The goal of the
Interprofessional Integrative Medicine consult clinic was to bring together
allopathic medical students, Family medicine residents and attendings,
naturopathic residents and attendings, behavioral health, clinical pharmacists,
and RNs in the care of our often complex and challenging patients. We aim to
offer an Integrative Approach to Richmond’s patient population who otherwise
often find it challenging to acquire nonallopathic approaches to care. We also
intend to increase interprofessional collaboration between our students,
residents, and staff and hope to create a care model that improves both the
patient and provider experience. This presentation will discuss our process for
developing this clinic, what we have learned since the clinic was started,
patient and provider reactions, interprofessional collaboration strategies, our
evaluative process, and future goals for the clinic and for interprofessional
integrative medicine at our institutions.
Rationale: This consultative clinic provides a novel example of an
interprofessional and integrative clinical care model. In an era in which the
importance of interprofessional collaboration is gaining recognition, it is
imperative that we explore models of care in which there is true collaborative
care. This session explains the logistics of an integrative interprofessional
clinic, its benefits, and challenges. It provides a replicable model of care
which can be used in other academic and FQHC settings. In addition, we will
begin to explore further areas of research.
Objectives: The aim is to explore the development process of an
interprofessional integrative medicine consult clinic within an FQHC and
academic medical center including how to involve naturopathic providers in an
allopathic setting, examine best strategies for promoting interprofessional
collaboration in clinical care, describe our experience with an
Interprofessional Integrative Medicine consult clinic, review evaluative
strategies for an innovative clinic model, and discuss future goals and further
collaborative efforts.
(3707) Brain Mechanisms Underlying Symptom Improvement in Chronic Visceral Pain
After Mindfulness Training
Cody Ashe-McNalley, MS1, Jean Stains, RN, Suzanne Smith, NP2,
Greg Serpa, PhD3, Bruce Naliboff, PhD, Lisa Kilpatrick, PhD2,
Ravi Bhatt, PhD1, Jennifer Labus, PhD, Annie Gupta, PhD2 and
Kirsten Tillisch, MD1
1University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California
2Los Angeles, California
3Greater Los Angeles VA, Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Purpose:
Background: Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is a brain-gut
disorder characterized by abdominal pain associated with altered bowel habits
which responds well to mind–body interventions, such as hypnosis, cognitive
behavioral therapy, and mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR).
Aims: To determine symptom-related changes in resting state
network connectivity (RS-FC) in patients with IBS after an MBSR
intervention.
Results: A total of 63 participants (47 women; mean age, 33 ± 9.8
years; age range, 19–54 years) completed the MBSR training and scans.
Treatment-related improvement in IBS severity scoring system (IBS-SSS) was
observed (mean improvement, 74.8 points, P < .001), which
was significantly correlated with treatment-related improvement in MAAS
(r = .27, P = .039). IBS-SSS improvement
was significantly correlated with treatment-related decreases in the
connectivity strength of the left amygdala (r = .39,
P = .002, q = .039), right subcentral gyrus
(r = .30, P = .016, q = .15), and left
suborbital gyrus/sulcus (medial prefrontal cortex; r = .37,
P = .003, q = .039), and with treatment-related decreases
in the eigenvector centrality of the left suborbital gyrus/sulcus
(r = .38, P = .002, q = .039).
Treatment-related decrease in the connectivity strength of the left suborbital
gyrus/sulcus was also correlated with improvements in MAAS
(r = .036, P = .004).
Conclusions: IBS patients undergoing an MBSR intervention have
improvements in mindfulness and overall IBS symptoms, which are associated with
decreases in the strength and centrality of emotional processing, somatosensory,
and salience brain regions.
(3765) Electroacupuncture-induced Analgesia in an Animal Model of Complex
Regional Pain Syndrome Type 1: Evaluation of Peripheral Endothelinergic
Receptors
Francisco Cidral-Filho, PhD1, Afonso Salgado, PhD1, Daniel F
Martins, PhD1, Leidiane Mazzardo-Martins, PhD2, Júlia
Koerich3, Kamilla Pamplona1, Luiz A Belmonte,
PhD1, Ari Moré, PhD3, Verônica V Horewicz,
PhD1, Anna Paula Piovezan, PhD1, Daniela D Lüdtke,
PhD1, Elisa C Winkelmann Duarte, PhD2 and Daiana C
Salm2
1University of Southern Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
2University of Federal of Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Brazil
3Universitary Hospital, Florianópolis, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the possible antihyperalgesic effect of
electroacupuncture (EA) in a model of complex regional pain syndrome type 1
(CRPS-I) as well as the involvement of endothelinic ETB receptors in this
effect.
Results: I/R induced marked and long-lasting mechanical
hyperalgesia. EA reduced mechanical hyperalgesia on all treatment days (days 3
to 21 post I/R), with effects lasting for up to 1-h post treatment
(P < .05–.001). Sarafotoxin (i.pl., 10 μL) decrease
mechanical nociception induced by I/C with effect prevented by 15 min prior
administration with Bq-788 (i.pl., 10 μL). Pretreatment with Bq-788 (i.pl.,
10 μL, 15 min prior) prevented the antihyperalgesic effect of EA. EA and
sarafotoxin (i.pl., 10 μL) treatment combination induced 2-h analgesia, which is
twice longer than each separate treatment (1-h analgesia).
Conclusions: EA induced analgesia is dependent upon peripheral
endothelinergic receptors activation in an animal model of CRPS-I.
(3778) Clinical Nutrition for Doctors-in-Training: Reflections and Challenges of
Incorporating Nutrition Education Into Medical School Curricula
Mary P Smith, BA1, Catherine Crawford, BA1 and Raymond Teets,
MD1
1New York, New York
Abstract
Overview/Background: Effective lifestyle management, including nutrition
education, is an invaluable component of integrative health-care management. In
practice, however, few physicians feel comfortable addressing the nutritional
aspects of diseases. What’s more, nutrition education is underrepresented at
many medical schools, with most recent surveys showing that only 25% of programs
in the United States require nutrition education.
Program Description: We created and implemented the clinical
nutrition for doctors in training course to fill this gap by supplementing the
standard medical curriculum at the Icahn School of Medicine with instruction
about clinical nutrition. Our goal is to improve medical students’ competence
regarding their own health behaviors and to provide training for incorporating
nutritional management into patient care. The course was designed in Fall 2016
in collaboration with the Students for Integrative Medicine Group and the Mount
Sinai Hospital Clinical Nutrition Department as a 7-week extracurricular
learning experience. To receive credit, students are required to attend 4 of the
7 sessions. By completion, students will be able to differentiate the role of
inpatient and outpatient dietary specialists, better understand typical diets
consumed by patients, and counsel patients about dietary modification within the
context of their health and social needs.
Conclusion: Since Fall 2016, 5 participants completed the program.
In postcurriculum surveys, all participants reported improved confidence in
their ability to counsel patients on proper dietary habits in the context of
diabetes, heart disease, and chronic kidney disease. As a result of feedback,
the Office of Medical Education is incorporating themes from the sessions into
the standard medical curriculum. This will improve student understanding of how
disease progression can be slowed, stopped, or reversed by diet. In this way,
the rising generation of medical professionals will be better trained to improve
patient outcomes through diet, an increasingly meaningful component of
integrative health-care management.
Rationale: Providers who understand the impact of diet on disease
states and who can effectively counsel patients with regard to dietary needs can
offer a more integrative approach to addressing their patient’s health.
Nevertheless, nutrition education is conspicuously absent from most
undergraduate medical curricula across the United States, with most recent
studies showing that only 25% of U.S. medical programs require nutrition
education.1 We believe that this is a gross oversight given the
current health-care landscape within the United States: per the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention’s latest reports, 30.3 million individuals (9.4%
of the population) currently live with diabetes in the United States; more that
610 000 individuals die of heart disease each year; approximately 75 million (1
in 3) adults in the United States live with high blood pressure. These
statistics are staggering, and not enough is being done to educate physicians
about how to treat their patients with dietary and lifestyle modification.
What's more, a 2008 study that surveyed a random sample of internal medicine
residents across the country showed that while 77% agreed that nutrition
assessment should be included in routine primary care visits, and 94% agreed
that it was their obligation to discuss nutrition with patients, only 14% felt
physicians were adequately trained to provide nutrition counseling. With our
clinical nutrition for doctors in training curriculum, we strive to meet this
need by providing the next generation of medical professionals with the tools to
better advise and motivate patients with regard to nutrition.
Objectives: By the completion of this course, participants will
understand the differences in the role of an inpatient and an outpatient
dietitian/nutrition specialist; be able to make better decisions about their own
nutrition within the context of our current lifestyle (medical students) and
community (East Harlem/Upper East Side); have a better understanding of the
typical diets consumed by our patients, and how that is influenced by the
availability and cost of food in this community; give advice regarding how to
modify traditional meals so as to improve health but not sacrifice taste and
tradition; have a better understanding of the practice of “mindful eating,” and
how that can translate into a healthier body and environment; learn about
various “lifestyle diets” defined as dietary restrictions resulting from a
patient’s taste preferences, ethical convictions, environmental stances, or
religious observations; gain an understanding of how the progression of certain
diseases can be slowed, stopped, or in some scenarios, reversed by diet; have
gained experience interviewing and engaging patients about maintaining healthy
diets, especially in the context of dietary restrictions or clinical conditions;
and learn more about how to incorporate integrative medicine practices and
education into their medical school curriculum.
(3779) Comparative Effectiveness of Tai Chi Versus Aerobic Exercise for
Fibromyalgia: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1, Jeffrey B Driban, PhD, ATC, CSCS1,
William F Harvey, MD, MSc1, Lori L Price, MAS, MLA2, Timothy E
McAlindon, MD, MPH1, Christopher H Schmid, PhD3, Roger A
Fielding, PhD4, Kieran F Reid, PhD, MPH4, Ramel
Rones5 and Robert A Kalish, MD1
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Tufts University, Boston, Massachusetts
3Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island
4Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging, Boston,
Massachusetts
5Center for Mind-Body Therapies, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Fibromyalgia is a complex disorder with psychological and
pain components. Tai Chi (TC), an integrated mind–body approach, has potential
in treating fibromyalgia. It is unknown whether TC is more effective than
aerobic exercise, a common treatment for fibromyalgia, and if its effectiveness
depends on dosage and duration.
Results: We included 226 subjects (mean age = 52 ± 12, duration of
pain = 9 ± 8 years, body mass index = 30.0 ± 6.7 kg/m2, 92% women,
61% white). The average of 4 TC groups, compared to aerobic exercise, showed
significant improvements in Revised Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire (FIQR;
P = .03), patient global (P = .005),
anxiety (P = .006), and self-efficacy
(P = .0004). All other secondary outcomes favored TC over
aerobic exercise at 12, 24, and 52 weeks. Twenty-four-week TC groups achieved
significant improvements in FIQR, depression, and mental-component scores
compared to 12-week groups (Table 1). TC with the same dosage and duration as
aerobic exercise demonstrated an even larger effect for FIQR (16.2 points, 95%
confidence interval: 8.7, 23.6; P < .0001). TC effects were
consistent across instructors.
Conclusions: TC results in similar or greater symptom improvement
than aerobic exercise, and longer duration demonstrated greater improvement.
(3782) Effects of Meditation and Music-listening on Blood Biomarkers of Cellular
Aging and Alzheimer’s Disease in Adults With Preclinical Memory Loss: An exploratory
Randomized Controlled Trial
Dharma S Khalsa, MD1, Hannah Bowles, MS2, Zenzi Huysmans,
MS3, Sahiti Kandati, MPH, DDS4, Caitlin Montgomery,
MPH4, Terry K Selfe, DC, PhD5 and Kim Innes, PhD,
MSPH4
1Albuquerque, New Mexico
2School of Medicine, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West
Virginia
3College of Physical Activity and Sport Sciences, West Virginia
University, Morgantown, West Virginia
4School of Public Health, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West
Virginia
5University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Abstract
Purpose: Telomere length (TL), telomerase activity (TA), and plasma
beta-amyloid (Aβ) levels have emerged as possible predictors of cognitive
decline and dementia, and as potential targets for intervention. In this pilot
randomized controlled trial, we assess (1) the effects of two 12-week relaxation
programs on TL, TA, and plasma Aβ in older adults with subjective cognitive
decline and (2) the relationship of changes in these biomarkers to improvements
in cognitive function, psychosocial status, and quality of life (QOL).
Results: Baseline blood samples were available for 53 participants
(25 KK, 28 ML). Both KK and ML groups showed increases in TA, although changes
were significant only among those above the 30th centile in practice adherence.
Changes in TL and TA varied by baseline values of these markers, with greater
increases among participants with respective values ≤50th centile (P’s for
interaction <.006). The ML group showed significantly greater declines in
Aβ40 than did the KK group and greater increases in Aβ42/40 ratio. Both groups
improved significantly in memory, cognitive function, and psychosocial status
(P’s ≤.05), with improvements in stress, mood, and QOL
greater in the KK group (P’s ≤ .08). Increases in plasma Aβ
levels were significantly correlated with improvements in cognitive function,
mood, stress, sleep, and QOL at both 3 and 6 months; these relationships were
particularly pronounced in the KK group. Increases in TL and TA were also
significantly associated with improvements in certain measures of psychosocial
status and cognitive function.
Conclusions: Practice of simple mind–body therapies may alter plasma
Aβ levels, TL, and TA. Increases in these biomarkers were associated with
improvements in cognitive function, sleep, mood, and QOL, suggesting a possible
functional relationship.
(3788) Interoception, Meditation, and Pain
Sahib Khalsa, MD, PhD1, Wen G. Chen, MMSc, PhD2, Cynthia J
Price3, Stephen Liberles, PhD4 and Jennifer S. Labus,
PhD5
1University of Tulsa, Tulsa, Oklahoma
2National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, Bethesda,
Maryland
3University of Washington, Seattle, Washington
4Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
5David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles,
Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview: The ability of the brain to consciously sense the
physiological state of the body, including the cardiorespiratory system,
gastrointestinal system, nociceptive system, and endocrine and immune system,
has commonly defined the sensory process called interoception. Meditative
practices often employ techniques to heighten and enhance the interoceptive
experience. In addition, mindfulness meditation has been shown to benefit pain
relief in patients with chronic pain. A recent body of research has begun to
examine the mechanisms underlying the interoceptive experience of meditative
practices as well as the impact of meditative practices on nociceptive
processing. This symposium will bring some of the leaders in the fields of
interoception, meditation, and pain together to discuss cutting-edge findings
and explore the potential connections among interoception, meditation, and
possibly pain. Dr Cynthia Price from University of Washington, a National Center
for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) advisory council member, will
first present recent advances on the relationships among interoception,
meditation, and emotional regulation in clinical care. Dr Sahib S. Khalsa,
director of clinical studies at the Laureate Institute for Brain Research, will
then present current research on the neural mechanisms of interoception from
human studies. Next, Dr Stephen Liberles at Harvard Medical School, who has
pioneered some of the most influential work on the molecular and neural
circuitry mechanisms underlying interoception in animal models, will present his
current theory and research on the mechanisms of interoception. Lastly, Dr
Jennifer Labus from the University of California at Los Angeles will present and
discuss recent findings from the Pain and Interoception Imaging Network. The
session will conclude with a question/answer and discussion period moderated by
Dr Wen Chen from NCCIH.
Rationale: The ability of the brain to consciously sense the
physiological state of the body, including the cardiorespiratory system,
gastrointestinal system, nociceptive system, and endocrine and immune system,
has commonly defined the sensory process called interoception. Meditative
practices commonly employ techniques to heighten and enhance the interoceptive
experience. In addition, mindfulness meditation has been shown to benefit pain
relief in patients with chronic pain. Recent scientific research advances began
to examine the mechanisms underlying the interoceptive experience of meditative
practices as well as the impact of meditative practices on pain. This symposium
will bring some of the leaders in the fields of interoception, meditation, and
pain together to discuss cutting-edge findings and to explore the potential
connections among interoception, meditation, and possibly pain. A better
understanding of these interconnections may facilitate the development of more
effective complementary therapies to address some of the most challenging
medical conditions of the current time.
Objectives: As a result of attending this session, participants will
be able to (1) describe current and cutting-edge scientific research on
interoception, meditation, and chronic pain; (2) discuss the importance of
interoception research for improving our understanding of mind and body
interventions and their potential clinical benefits; and (3) promote a dialogue
about promising future research directions on interoception and its impact on
health.
Outline:
• What is the current scientific evidence on how brain detects and processes
interoceptive sensation?
• What is the current scientific evidence on how meditative practices utilize and
modulate interoceptive experience?
• Are there any common brain regions or neural networks involved in pain
experience, interoceptive sensation, and mindfulness meditation?
• How can understanding interoception at the molecular and neural circuitry
levels help optimize the beneficial effects of mindfulness meditation?
• Is the experience of pain a form of interoceptive awareness, and if so, how can
meditation help to manage conditions marked by chronic pain or interoceptive
dysregulation?
(3792) Utilization of Neuroimaging and Neurofeedback to Treat
Chemotherapy-induced Peripheral Neuropathy—Results of a Randomized Controlled
Trial
Gabriel Lopez, MD1, Lorenzo Cohen, PhD1, Sarah Prinsloo,
PhD1, Randall Lyle, PhD1, Larry Driver, MD1,
Diane Novy, PhD1, Lois Ramondetta, MD1 and Cathy Eng,
MD1
1Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: We examined neurophysiological correlates and
patient-reported outcomes of chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy (CIPN)
to understand CIPN as it relates directly to brain activity. We used a brain
training paradigm, neurofeedback (NF), to teach patients to modify brain
activity to alleviate symptoms of CIPN.
Results: Eighty-three percent of participants demonstrated similar
EEG patterns, which was significantly related to improvement in symptoms after
NF. 100% of participants who started NF completed treatment. NF lead to
significant reduction in neuropathic symptoms such as pain and numbness
(previously reported), and in cancer-related symptom interference (NF = −5.3 vs
WL = −0.5, P = .000); symptom severity (NF = −5.1 vs WL = −0.8,
P = .000), fatigue (NF = −3.7 vs WL = −0.8,
P = .001), and sleep disturbances (NF = −2.3 vs WL = 0.8,
P = .030); and improved physical functioning (NF = 3.3 vs
WL = 1.4, P = .003). At 4 months, the outcomes remained for
targeted symptoms.
Conclusions: CIPN may have distinct electrophysiological correlates.
NF clinically and significantly improved primary outcomes at 4 months
posttreatment and reduced secondary symptoms associated with CIPN.
Figure 1. Typical map of database comparisons of
electrophysiological activity in CIPN patients. CIPN, chemotherapy-induced
peripheral neuropathy.
(3799) Controlled Trial Evaluating the Addition of Chiropractic Care to Medical
Care for Patients With Low Back Pain
Joan Walter, JD, PA1, Katherine A Pohlman, DC, MS2, Robert D
Vining, DC3, Christine M Goertz, DC, PhD
Cynthia R Long, PhD and Ian D Coulter, PhD4
1Samueli Institute for Information Biology, Silver Spring, Maryland
2Parker University, Dallas, Texas
3Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
4RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: There is a critical need to evaluate the impact of
nonpharmacological treatments for low back pain (LBP) and associated disability.
This trial determined whether the addition of chiropractic care to usual medical
care (UMC) in patients with LBP resulted in better pain relief, pain-related
function, patient satisfaction, and perceived benefit after 6 weeks when
compared to UMC alone.
Results: Mean participant age was 31 years, 23% were female and 32%
were nonwhite. Thirty-eight percent of participants reported acute LBP, 11%
subacute, and 51% chronic. Statistically significant site-by-time-by-group
interactions were found in all models, so results are reported by site. Adjusted
mean differences in outcomes at week 6 were statistically significant in favor
of UMC plus chiropractic care at each site for LBP intensity (site 1: 0.7, site
2: 1.2, and site 3: 1.3), disability (1.7, 2.1, and 2.7), perceived improvement,
and satisfaction. There were no significant differences in pain medication use.
No serious adverse events related to treatment were reported.
Conclusions: Chiropractic care, when added to UMC, resulted in
short-term improvements in LBP intensity and disability, demonstrated a low risk
of harms, high patient satisfaction, and perceived improvement. This trial
supports the inclusion of chiropractic care as an effective component of a
multidisciplinary approach for LBP, consistent with newly released guideline
recommendations.
(3800) Customizing Integrative Oncology for Adolescent and Young Adults With
Cancer
Douglas McDaniel, MTOM, Dipl Ac (NCCAOM), LAc1, Leigh Leibel2
and Lynda Beaupin, MD1
1Roswell Park Cancer Institute, Buffalo, New York
2New York, New York
Abstract
Overview: This interactive workshop will focus on personalizing
integrative therapies for unique adolescent and young adult cancer scenarios.
Integrative techniques for neuropathy, psychologic distress, and sexual
health challenges will be highlighted. We will discuss implementing
these practices in different clinical structures, and how adaptive these
therapies are across the cancer care continuum, from diagnosis and through
survivorship.
Rationale: Adolescent and young adults (AYAs) are a unique subset of
oncology patients whom the National Cancer Institute identifies as those between
15 and 39 years of age. Cancer types across this age spectrum vary widely and
include Hodgkin Lymphoma, thyroid cancers, sarcomas, and breast cancer. AYAs may
experience treatment side effects that differ from the pediatric and older adult
populations and are at higher risk of infertility from their cancer treatment.
AYAs also face a myriad of psychosocial challenges ranging from
emotional to financial that occur during a critical period in human development,
when young people are becoming more independent, establishing relationships and
careers, exploring their sexuality, and forming their own worldview.
Though we have learned more about the AYA population over the past
decade, very little progress has been made to effectively address their
issues.
Integrative medicine has a role in cancer care for all patients. For AYAs,
integrative modalities may be particularly attractive due to their accessibility
and affordability. Meditation, yoga, and acupuncture are common
practices that have been shown to alleviate treatment side effects; reduce
symptoms of stress, anxiety, and depression; and improve quality of life
scores. These interventions are adaptable across a range of age groups,
treatment stages, demographics, and diagnoses seen among AYAs.
Through a panel discussion, we will highlight where the research in this area is
headed, what opportunities exist for clinician education, and how this relates
to clinical practice. Integrative medicine practice in AYA oncology is a true
collaboration in action!
Objectives: After attending this session, it is expected that the
attendee will be able to provide an overview of the challenges AYA cancer
patients face during and after a cancer diagnosis; describe the application of
various integrative medicine techniques for side effects, psychosocial issues,
infertility, and sexual health concerns; understand how to integrate
complementary therapies into AYA cancer care; and develop strategies to
personalize integrative therapies for AYAs.
Outline:
Format of workshop
The workshop will consist:
- Brief background lecture
- Interactive case discussions and demonstration
- Panel discussion where participants will be welcomed to share challenging
scenarios in their practice
(3801) Efficacy of Systolic Extinction Training in Reducing Pain and Interference
in Female Fibromyalgia Patients Who Respond to Stress With Elevated Blood
Pressure
Kati Thieme, PhD1
1University of Marburg, Marburg, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: An intrinsic pain regulatory system is both modulated by
cardiovascular dynamics that influence baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) and
diminished in fibromyalgia (FM). Baroreceptors relay cardiovascular output to
the dorsal medial nucleus tractus solitarius reflex arcs that regulate pain,
sleep, anxiety, and blood pressure. This study evaluated the effects of systolic
extinction training (SET) that combines operant treatment (OT) with baroreflex
training (BRT). BRT delivers peripheral electrical stimulation immediately after
systolic or diastolic peak of the cardiac cycle. This treatment is compared to
(1) OT-TENS, transcutaneous electrical stimulation independent
of cardiac cycle, and (2) aerobic training (AT)-BRT in FM patients with elevated
blood pressure stress responses.
Results: In contrast to OT-TENS and AT-BRT, patients receiving SET
reported a significant greater reduction in pain and interference (all
Ps <.01) that were maintained at 6- to 12-month
follow-up. Significant clinically pain reduction at T3 was reached in 82% of
SET, 39% of OT-TENS, and 14% of AT-BRT-treated patients. After SET, compared to
OT-TENS and AT-BRT, BRS increased 57% (Ps < .01).
Conclusions: SET resulted in significant and long-lasting pain
remission and interference compared to the OT-TENS and AT-BRT groups, suggesting
that BRS modification was the treatment outcome mechanism. Additional research
with larger samples and other chronic pain conditions appears to be warranted to
confirm and extend the results.
(3848) Aromatherapy, Acupressure, and Breathing to Balance for Kids
Kathleen S Farah, MD1, Maura Fitzgerald, APRN2 and Melanie
Brown, MD2
1Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Children’s Hospitals and Clinics of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Overview: This is an experiential workshop designed for the
participants to leave with tools they can use upon return to their practice and
with their own families. The copresenters have extensive experience in using
these skills at Children’s Minnesota and in populations of various backgrounds
in the community. Evidence-based use of aromatherapy will be introduced, with
opportunity to try out those we find most useful for common symptoms such as
nausea, pain, anxiety, and sleep issues. Acupressure is a child and teen
friendly alternative to acupuncture, and the participant will gain an
understanding of easy to use acupressure points. How to teach breathing to kids
and teens of various ages will be introduced, using fun props. The importance of
these skills to balancing the nervous system will be reviewed. We look forward
to sharing our knowledge and experience with the participants.
Rationale: Interest in integrative medicine is increasing in
popularity and significance across the United States and globe. Practitioners
and families are looking for practical alternatives to pharmaceuticals for their
children. This experiential workshop will focus on 3 key skills that have been
widely and successfully used by the presenters at Children’s Minnesota, in both
the inpatient and outpatient settings. This workshop will provide evidence-based
background combined with practical skills. We have chosen to focus on these 3
areas to allow ample time for the experience. Aromatherapy is easy to use and a
great tool for common symptoms such as pain, anxiety, nausea, and insomnia.
Acupressure is a wonderful self-help tool and easily learned by practitioners
and parents. Breathing to relax is the basis of many relaxation skills and is
easily taught to children of many ages and cultures. The participants will find
these skills helpful personally and professionally.
Objectives: The aim is to understand the use of aromatherapy in the
pediatric population for common symptoms, to understand the use of acupressure
for common pediatric symptoms; understand how breathing is of use in balancing
the nervous system (stress response) and learn how to teach to children of all
ages; and review the literature supporting the safe use of aromatherapy,
acupressure, and diaphragmatic breathing.
Outline: Introduction—Why is integrative medicine important for
children, their care givers, and their practitioner?
1. Aromatherapy
a. Brief history of aromatherapy
b. Sources of essential oils and methods of application
c. Selected research and research challenges.
c. Essential oils and pediatrics—common essential oils, safety, and management
of symptoms such as anxiety, nausea, pain, and poor sleep.
2. Acupressure/acupuncture
a. Brief background on how acupuncture/acupressure works
b. Teach acupressure points that are useful for common symptoms such as
headache, pain, and nausea
c. Selected research and research challenges
3. Breathing
a. Review of the autonomic nervous system, stress responses, and the importance
of breath in the body.
b. Teach several breathing techniques in child friendly ways using props such as
bubbles and pinwheel
c. Selected research using breath and breath-based skills
(3851) State of Complementary and Integrative Health Policy, Use, and Delivery in
the VA
Ben Kligler, MD1, A Rani Elwy, PhD1, Steve Zeliadt,
PhD1, Princess Osei-Bonsu, PhD1, Katherine Hoggatt,
PhD1, Karleen Giannitrapani, PhD1, Stephanie L Taylor,
PhD, MPH2, Alison M Whitehead, MPH3, Melissa M Farmer, PhD,
MS2, Uyi Igodan, MPA4, Barbara G Bokhour, PhD5
and Michael G. McGowan, MA5
1Palo Alto, California
2VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Los Angeles, California
3Washington, DC
4VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, North Hills, California
5Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview: The Veterans Health Administration (VHA), the nation’s
largest integrated health-care system, is at the forefront of providing
complementary and integrative health (CIH) approaches, with 93% of VHA medical
centers providing 2+ CIH approaches in 2015. The Integrative Health Coordinating
Center (IHCC) within the VA’s Office of Patient-Centered Care and Cultural
Transformation formed 2014 to identify and address barriers to providing CIH and
to serve as a resource across the VA. Partially in response to the 2016
Comprehensive Recovery and Addiction Act (CARA) legislation, the IHCC is leading
a major expansion of CIH provision. Through the VA Quality Enhancement Research
Initiative Complementary and Integrative Health Evaluation Center (CIHEC), the
IHCC and VA health services researchers are collaborating to evaluate the
effectiveness and implementation of CIH.
We will review 6 activities and results of this VA IHCC/health service research
collaboration.
1. Overview of IHCC’s efforts—Late 2017, the VA launched the first wave of a
national deployment of expanded CIH approaches in a “Whole Health System” effort
in 18 VA medical care centers.
2. “18 in 18” Whole Health Evaluation—We are evaluating the implementation and
effectiveness of the Whole Health components, one of which is CIH, at 18 VA
medical centers.
3. CIHEC Environmental Scan of CIH Provision at the VA—In August–September 2017,
we conducted a survey of CIH program leaders at all VA medical centers to assess
what CIH approaches were available.
4. CIHEC Veterans CIH Survey—We conducted a survey among a national sample of
veterans in July 2017 to learn their use of, satisfaction with, and interest in
24 CIH approaches.
5. CIHEC PRIMIER—We replicated BraveNet’s longitudinal study of patient-reported
outcomes (PROs) in 2 VA sites to examine how CIH approaches are associated with
changes in PROs over time.
6. CIHEC Battlefield Acupuncture (BFA)—We examined BFA implementation challenges
and strategies.
Rationale: The VA has been at the forefront of providing CIH
approaches to patients. Other health-care systems and individual providers can
learn from our experiences in implementing and evaluating CIH approaches.
Objectives: The aim is to learn what CIH policies the VA has
developed and activities they are conducting; list the top 3 CIH approaches that
veterans are requesting; list the top CIH approaches being provided and the
implementation barriers and strategies used to overcome those barriers;
summarize the Whole Health System model that the VA is adopting; learn about the
policies and resources the VA’s IHCC is providing to individual providers, staff
and facilities, as they attempt to implement CIH; learn about the effectiveness
of CIH for a variety of patient health outcomes; and learn about CIH
implementation issues.
Outline:
1. We will present what the VA’s IHCC is doing to facilitate the implementation
of CIH across the VA system.
2. We will discuss how we are evaluating the implementation and effectiveness of
the CIH portion of the Whole Health program at 18 VA medical centers, using
semistructured interviews, implementation checklists, and surveys of
patient-reported outcomes.
3. We will present the findings of the CIHEC Environmental Scan online survey of
CIH Provision at all VA medical centers.
4. We will present the findings of the CIHEC Veterans CIH Survey.
5. Tai chi, yoga, acupuncture, and guided imagery all resulted in significant
improvements in Veterans’ PROs, especially pain, perceived stress, and
functioning.
6. We will review the implementation barrier and strategies used to overcome
those barriers.
(3859) Cost-effectiveness of Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction Versus Cognitive
Behavioral Therapy Versus Usual Care for Chronic Low Back Pain
Melissa L Anderson, MS1, Benjamin H Balderson, PhD1, Karen
Sherman, PhD, MPH1, Judith A Turner, PhD2, Daniel C Cherkin,
PhD1 and Patricia M. Herman, ND, PhD3
1Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute, Seattle,
Washington
2University of Washington, Seattle, Washington
3RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic low-back pain (CLBP) is expensive in terms of
health-care costs and lost productivity. Mind–body interventions have been found
effective for back pain, but their cost-effectiveness is unexplored. The purpose
of this study was to determine the cost-effectiveness of 2 mind–body
interventions, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), and mindfulness-based stress
reduction (MBSR) for CLBP.
Results: This economic evaluation was limited to the 301 health plan
members enrolled for at least 180 days in the years pre- and postrandomization.
The mean incremental cost per participant to society of CBT over usual care (UC)
was $125 (95% confidence interval [CI]: −4103, 4307) and of MBSR was −$724 (CI:
−4386, 2778)—that is, a net saving of $724 compared to UC. Incremental costs per
participant to the health plan were $495 for CBT over UC and −$982 for MBSR, and
incremental back-related costs per participant were $984 for CBT over UC and
−$127 for MBSR. These costs (and cost savings) were associated with significant
gains in quality-adjusted life years over UC: 0.041 (0.015, 0.067) for CBT and
0.034 (0.008, 0.060) for MBSR.
Conclusions: In this setting, CBT and MBSR have high probabilities
of being cost-effective, and MBSR may be cost saving, as compared to UC for
adults with CLBP. These findings suggest that MBSR, and to a lesser extent CBT,
may provide cost-effective treatment for CLBP for payers and society.
(3873) Back to the Future: Probiotics and Microbial-host Keystone Organisms and
Their Essential Functions
Craig D Hopp, PhD1 and Linda C Duffy, PhD, MPH1
1National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Probiotics are “live microorganisms which, when
administered in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host.”
Probiotics are derived from human gut microorganisms that have coevolved with
us. Probiotic formulations include vaccines, drugs, functional foods, dietary
supplements, and topical applications. Over 80% of our immune system is found in
the intestines and microbial communities play an intimate role in immune
regulation imbalances throughout life. Our mental health could also be a sign of
intestinal imbalance. Much attention in human microbiome research has recently
shifted to the ecological concept of keystone microbes that, by definition, are
of low abundance, the removal of which has destabilizing impacts on energy
metabolism and host health. The search has intensified for identifying keystone
microbial groups and their genes that may provide novel molecular footprints
(immunogenic; metabolic; neurologic; physiologic) and a rationale basis for
designer probiotics for the future. This symposium will convene researchers from
federal government and broader research community. The symposium will open with
an invited talk from Justin Sonnenburg, PhD, Stanford University, who will give
a probiogenomics view in the search for keystone (probiotic) groups and
functions in the Ancestral Microbiome, of Hunter-Gatherers. Grace
Douglas, PhD, lead scientist in Genomics and Probiotic Functional Foods at
National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) will talk on What
NASA is learning about probiotics, microbiomes, and space flight.
Melanie Gareau, PhD at University of California, Davis, will share links between
probiogenomics, early life programming in the microbiota-gut-brain axis. Sean
Brady, PhD at Rockefeller University, will give an exciting glimpse of probiotic
biosensors in live cell signaling pathways. Linda Duffy, PhD program director
for the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)
Probiotics and Microbiome portfolios will Chair the Session concluding with
directions being addressed by the Trans-National Institutes of Health (NIH)
Probiotics Microbiome Workgroups and Omics Consortium and NIH/NCCIH research
initiatives. Craig Hopp, PhD, DER deputy director, will moderate the symposium
and panel discussion.
Rationale: Rationale: Why the topic is important and its
relevance to the conference themes? The probiotic concept that the
gut flora can be modified and harmful microbes replaced with beneficial ones was
introduced in 1907. Probiotics are naturally derived, orally ingested foods and
drug products commonly used by the consumer public that have yielded many
marketed products with somewhat equivocal evidence of health benefits. We gain
our natural exposure to these beneficial microorganisms that comprise the Human
Microbiome in 2 essential ways: (1) through our mothers and childbirth and (2)
from our environment and we are dependent on the microbes that inhabit our guts
for essential physiologic, immunologic, and metabolic functions. With innovation
technologies and emerging 3-D computational platforms available, exciting new
evidence is accumulating from ancestral microbiomes identifying beneficial
properties of keystone species and groups that may be evolving in low abundance
but when they or selected genes are missing can lead to health consequences,
chronic disease, and inflammatory conditions typically observed in Western
lifestyles. The ongoing efforts of the Trans-NIH Probiotic/Prebiotic Omics
Consortium coupled with the long-standing NIH Human Microbiome Project to
rigorously substantiate a probiotic rationale for use and guide new research
directions have significantly contributed to rapid advances in our understanding
and development of molecular footprints that deserve much more investigation.
The convergence of new strategies including the targeting of keystone species
and groups in probiogenomics and microbiome collections are at a critical
juncture requiring that rigorously validated mechanistic discoveries are further
translatable to more accelerated clinical research. Essential for this
transition is a diversity of thinking (systems biology, metabolism,
microbiology, physiology, and immunology) and standards for multiomic and
innovation technologies and models. The Symposium session seeks to broaden the
base of what defines the current search for keystone group membership in
probiotics and microbiome studies by inviting investigators to share their
vision, approach, and results to enhance understanding of signaling pathways and
underlying mechanisms of probiotic action.
Objectives: Objectives: What participants will know or be
able to do as a result of this session? The symposium aims to (1)
introduce the intriguing search for keystone ancestral groups of probiotics, and
their genes, challenges in the search, and how findings will benefit designer
probiotics and their genes in the future; (2) stimulate interest among junior
and senior investigators relevant to advancing next-generation probiotics and
microbiome studies; and (3) foster new collaborative, multidisciplinary
probiotic, genomic, and microbiome research that advances basic, translational,
and clinical research programs.
Outline: Topic outline: Main points of the session
Submission topic(s):
• Research
○ State of the science/evidence base for integrative modalities
○ Natural products/botanicals/supplements
(3874) Nurturing the Next Generation of Healers
Julian Jimenez, BA1, Victor Sierpina, MD1 and Julie McKee,
MD1
1Galveston, Texas
Abstract
Overview: The Physician Healer Track (PHT) is a 4-year longitudinal
curriculum designed to help students maintain the altruistic spirit that brought
them to medical school. The 4 pillars of PHT are wellness, mindfulness,
communication, and being with suffering. Enthusiasm for this work has resulted
in about 25% of incoming students enrolling in PHT. It is our hope that PHT
helps students weather medical training with an increased sense of efficacy and
resilience. Preliminary data suggest that we are succeeding.
Rationale: Students come to medical school in order to help people.
They matriculate as bright, energetic, and altruistic individuals. The standard
medical school curriculum focuses heavily on basic and clinical sciences which
teach how to fix patients. This curriculum has long been associated with
decreased well-being, diminished empathy, and increased burnout. The PHT helps
students gain skills in personal reflection, communication, wellness,
mindfulness, and being a healing presence for those who are suffering. It is our
hope that PHT helps students weather medical training with an increased sense of
efficacy and resilience. Preliminary data suggest that we are succeeding.
Objectives: Participants will be able to describe a 4-year
longitudinal curriculum focused on creating our next generation of healers,
describe the impact of this curriculum from a student’s perspective, describe
the results of data collected over the past 5 years, and experience an activity
designed to shift personal perception.
Outline:
1. Overview of curriculum
A. Topics and format of monthly evening small group meetings
B. Topics and experiential activities for the 2-month summer preceptorship
C. Topics and experiential activities for the senior elective
D. Required and optional readings
2. Student perspective
A. Why did you sign up for this in the first place?
B. What have you learned that has been helpful?
C. What has been most difficult for you on this journey?
D. How do you see this affecting you in the future both personally and
professionally?
3. Data
A. Results of data collected from students about the curricular content
B. Results of data collected about impact on personal life
C. Results of data collected about professional development
4. Experiential activity
A. Perception and your “to do list”
(3881) Patients Receiving Integrative Medicine Intervention Efficacy Registry: A
BraveNet Practice-based Research Evaluation Focusing on a Chronic Pain
Cohort
Ben E Kligler, MD, MPH1, Jeffery A Dusek, PhD1, Donald I
Abrams, MD1, M Diane McKee, MD1 and Rowena Dolor,
MD1
1Durham, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: BraveNet is the first national integrative medicine (IM)
practice-based research network. Patients Receiving Integrative Medicine
Intervention Efficacy Registry (PRIMIER) is a prospective, nonrandomized,
observational evaluation conducted at 17 BraveNet sites. A main purpose of
PRIMIER is to collect patient-reported outcomes at specified time periods across
the entire BraveNet. A secondary purpose examines whether specific clinical
populations (eg, chronic pain) or IM interventions are associated with improved
outcomes over time.
Results: Repeated-measures analyses were performed on interim data
to assess change from baseline through 12 months. Through April 2017, 3809
patients enrolled in PRIMER and 1392 met the criteria for chronic pain. Pain
participants were white (87%), female (77%) with a mean age of 49.6 (standard
deviation [SD] 14.6). On the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information
System (PROMIS) Anxiety, Fatigue and Pain Interference scales, our
population-reported elevated levels (0.5 SD) relative to national norms.
Significant reductions were observed at the 12-month assessment on the
all 7 PROMIS-29 subscales and across all 4 timeperiods (2,
4, 6, and 12 months) on Fatigue, Pain Interference, and Pain Intensity
constructs. Perceived Stress Scale 4 scores significantly improved across 3 of
the 4 assessments (2, 4, and 12 month), whereas the Patient Activation Measure
scores (which were already high at baseline) significantly increased at the
12-month assessment only.
Conclusions: To date, PRIMIER results indicate a profound
improvement across all of the tested PROMs. Further analyses will provide
insights as to whether specific IM interventions or combinations are associated
with larger improved outcomes in the chronic pain cohort and other
populations.
(3886) Changing the Pain Care Paradigm: Essential Actions for Moving Beyond
Medications
Leonard Wisneski, MD1, Robert Twillman, PhD, AIPM2, David
O’Bryon, JD3, Alison M Whitehead, MPH4 and Margaret A Chesney,
PhD4
1Denver, Colorado
2Lawrence, Kansas
3Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health, Bethesda, Maryland
4San Francisco, California
Abstract
Overview: New guidelines, regulations, and legislation are nearly
universal in recommending that first-line treatment for pain should focus on
nonpharmacological treatments. Very few recognize the existing challenges
inherent in following those recommendations. Many of these recommendations lack
details about which treatments should be pursued for which patients. Other
access challenges include, but are not limited to: inadequately educated
providers, regarding how to optimally assess and refer people with pain; lack of
central resources where professionals with nonpharmacological expertise can be
identified as referral providers; a paucity of providers available in some,
particularly rural, areas; and inadequate insurance coverage leaving people with
pain paying out of pocket for care, something many find challenging. This panel
discussion, chaired by Margaret Chesney, past chair of the Consortium, will
introduce these barriers and challenges to implementing the recommendations for
nonpharmacological pain treatments and the pressing need to address them. Bob
Twillman, executive director of the Academy of Integrative Pain Management, will
discuss efforts aimed at helping providers assess patients with pain with an eye
toward developing patient-centered care plans that include appropriate
nonpharmacological treatments. David O’Bryon, chair of the Academic
Collaborative for Integrative Health, will follow with examples of professions,
including acupuncture and chiropractic, which engage in educational and outreach
efforts to clinical providers to convey the benefits of nonpharmacological
treatments, a first step in developing referral resources. Alison Whitehead, the
Consortium’s Policy Working Group’s Chairperson, will discuss the VA’s
Patient-Centered Care and Cultural Transformation Program and highlight lessons
learned regarding incorporation of nonpharmacological treatments into that
program. Finally, Len Wisneski, chair of the Integrative Health Policy
Consortium, will review the outcomes of the recent Pain Care Policy Forum, a
meeting that involved professional organizations, pain patient advocacy
organizations, and third-party payers, with a focus on improving insurance
coverage for nonpharmacological treatments.
Rationale: While the new guidelines calling for nonpharmacological
approaches to pain are a major advance for integrative medicine and health,
there are many challenges that need to be met in order for these strategies to
be adopted widely into health care. It is important that these challenges be met
before the current attention to this issue fades and new pharmacological
approaches for pain management are introduced. The Consortium and other
integrative health organizations are taking steps to communicate what is known
about the evidence base for integrative approaches. This panel discussion will
focus on the critical next steps needed to translate that evidence in to action
with a focus on education, access, and coverage. Educational
efforts need to be directed to both health-care providers and the
public about nonpharmacological treatment options, including the evidence base
as well such details as expectations regarding frequency, dosing, and shared
responsibility. Access in the context of this panel discussion
will involve not only patients’ access to nonpharmacological care, but
clinicians’ access to a resource or system to facilitate referring patients to
experienced practitioners who can provide nonpharmacological pain care.
Coverage for nonpharmacological care is lacking despite the
recommendations coming from the National Academy of Medicine, Food and Drug
Administration, Joint Commission, and many other organizations. This panel
discussion will present steps that are being taken to advance efforts to improve
insurance coverage in today’s volatile heath care environment.
Objectives: As a result of this panel discussion, attendees will
understand the challenges that must be overcome in order for nonpharmacological
treatment to be widely utilized as the first-line treatment for pain, recognize
the importance of assessing patients with the goal of developing
patient-centered care plans that include appropriate nonpharmacological
treatments for pain, and appreciate the need to create systems to facilitate
referrals by clinical providers to professionals experienced in nonpharmacologic
treatments for pain.
Outline:
1. There are barriers and challenges to implementing the recommendations for
nonpharmacological pain treatments and a pressing need to address them.
2. Specific challenges to implementation include inadequate education for
providers and the public about nonpharmacological approaches, a lack of
resources where experienced professionals with nonpharmacological expertise can
be identified for referrals, availability of providers on some rural areas, and
inadequate insurance coverage.
3. Efforts are underway to help providers assess pain patients and develop
patient-centered care plans that include nonpharmacological treatments.
4. There are examples from several professions, including acupuncture and
chiropractic, which are reaching out to clinicians, conveying the benefit of
nonpharmacological treatments—a first step toward developing referral
resources.
5. The VA’s Patient-Centered Care and Cultural Transformation Program provides
lessons learned regarding incorporation of nonpharmacological treatments into
pain management.
6. Professional organizations, advocacy organizations, and third-party payers are
making efforts to improve insurance coverage for nonpharmacological treatments
for pain.
(3889) Nutritional Pain Management: Design, Implementation, and Evaluation of a
Certification Course for Diverse Pain Providers
Meg Sweeney, BS1, 2, Nancy A Cotter, MD, FACN3 and Robert A
Bonakdar, MD, FAAFP, FACN4
1Western University of Health Sciences
2The College of Osteopathic Medicine, Pomona, California
3Veterans Health Administration, Montclair, New Jersey
4La Jolla, California
Abstract
Overview/Background and Hypothesis: Several recently guidelines have
endorsed the use of nonpharmacologic interventions for first-line management of
pain. As pain can coexist with and result from metabolic dysregulation including
obesity, metabolic syndrome, and nutrient deficiency, nutritional interventions
hold promise for impacting pain in selected populations. Unfortunately,
clinicians often have suboptimal education and comfort in introducing and
implementing nutritional interventions in the setting of pain. We hypothesize
that a certification course will have a positive impact on clinician confidence
and implementation of nutritional strategies in the setting of pain.
Intervention: A 6-h continuing educational course was created to
address key learning areas related to pain. These areas included the role of
diet in promoting pain (ie, inflammatory, nutrient deplete, and obesogenic
diets); the role of diet in reducing pain (ie, reduction of inflammation, weight
management, and nutrient deficiency); as well as how to introduce a health
promoting diet and evidence-based nutrients in population associate by systemic
inflammation and deficiency (ie, rheumatoid arthritis, migraine, and metabolic
neuropathy).
Plan: The initial course will be provided to 100 clinicians of
diverse backgrounds as part of a larger pain-related continuing education
conference in the fall of 2017. In addition to a postintervention knowledge
assessment, attendees will have a pre- to postevaluation of their level of
education, knowledge base, and comfort level in discussing and implementing
nutritional intervention for those in pain. They will also be asked about
scenarios they find particularly challenging (ie, pain associated with obesity)
with discussion incorporated into the course. Postintervention, attendees will
have long-term monitoring to evaluate the impact of the certification on
practice changes related to the course. Postcourse data will be analyzed to
gauge the impact of the course as well as plan future interventions in the
content area.
Rationale: Chronic pain and obesity are both significant public
health concerns which appear to be increasing. Nutritional factors including
deficiency and proinflammatory diets appear to be important contributing factors
to both epidemics with nutritional counseling and support appearing as
potentially helpful interventions in helping to mitigate this scenario.
Unfortunately, recent studies demonstrate that less than one third of the time
do patients receive adequate nutritional counseling. A continuing education
program geared toward diverse pain management clinicians was created with the
goal of improving the knowledge base, confidence, and degree of counseling
regarding nutrition in the setting of pain.
Objectives: Diet is associated with pain in both curative and
causative relationships. The great majority of pain syndromes are associated
with chronic inflammation. Anti-inflammatory foods and dietary patterns have
been used successfully to treat chronic pain syndromes. Food sensitivities and
nutrient deficiencies are associated with common pain syndromes. Clinicians
should have a high degree of awareness of the role of diet in the amelioration
and exacerbation of pain. Stepwise counseling by clinicians of all backgrounds
can help to incorporate diet as an important and accessible treatment for pain
syndromes.
(3901) Utilization of Integrative Medicine in an Interdisciplinary Intensive
Outpatient Program for Service Members With Combat-related Traumatic Brain Injury
and Psychological Health Conditions
Melissa Walker, MA1, Manoj Bhasin, PhD2 and Thomas J DeGraba,
MD1
1Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Maryland
2Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Combat operations and training injuries have resulted in
traumatic brain injury (TBI) in over 370 000 service members (SM) since 2001.
The occurrence of behavioral health comorbidities in up to 40% of these SM
presents the need for novel treatment paradigms to address persistent symptoms.
The National Intrepid Center of Excellence (NICoE) developed a 4-week
interdisciplinary, holistic patient-centric, and family-centric intensive
outpatient program (IOP) utilizing conventional and integrative medicine
treatments to place SM on a trajectory of recovery. In an attempt to
characterize the injury and response to the implementation of the arts and other
mind–body techniques in the care of these service members, a multimodal
assessment approach including genomics is used. This symposium will address the
interdisciplinary integrative care model in the Military Health System and will
include the description of the IOP used at NICoE as well as mind–body techniques
used in the TBI Pathway of Care Network (10 min); the use of creative arts
therapies (art, music, dance/movement, and drama) as integrated components of
behavioral health assessment of SM and as treatment strategies for ongoing
recovery (30 min); the effects of the integrative care model on physiological
parameters including brain wave patterns measured by magnetoencephalography
(MEG) and autonomic patterns measured by transcranial Doppler (TCD) derive
cerebral vasomotor reactivity metrics (20 min); studying effect NICoE
intervention on genomics landscape of SM to identify key molecular pathways
associated with healing and further their association with the neurological and
behavioral response to treatment (20 min).
Rationale: Combat operations and training injuries have resulted in
traumatic brain injury in over 370 000 SMs since 2001. The occurrence of
behavioral health comorbidities in up to 40% of these SM presents the need for
novel treatment paradigms to address persistent symptoms. The NICoE developed a
4-week interdisciplinary, holistic patient-centric, and family-centric IOP
utilizing conventional and integrative medicine treatments to place SM on a
trajectory of recovery.
Objectives: In an attempt to characterize the injury and response to
the implementation of the arts and other mind–body techniques in the care of
these service members, a multimodal assessment approach including genomics is
used. This symposium will address the interdisciplinary integrative care model
in the Military Health System and will include the description of the IOP used
at NICoE as well as mind–body techniques used in the TBI Pathway of Care Network
(10 min); the use of creative arts therapies (art, music, dance/movement, and
drama) as integrated components of behavioral health assessment of SM and as
treatment strategies for ongoing recovery (30 min); the effects of the
integrative care model on physiological parameters including brain wave patterns
measured by MEG and autonomic patterns measured by TCD derive cerebral vasomotor
reactivity metrics (20 min); and studying effect NICoE intervention on genomics
landscape of SM to identify key molecular pathways associated with healing and
further their association with the neurological and behavioral response to
treatment (20 min).
Outline:
1) The interdisciplinary integrative care model in the Military Health System and
will include the description of the IOP used at NICoE as well as mind–body
techniques used in the TBI Pathway of Care Network.
2) The use of creative arts therapies (art, music, dance/movement, and drama) as
integrated components of behavioral health assessment of SM.
3) The effects of the integrative care model on physiological parameters
including brain wave patterns measured by MEG and autonomic patterns measured by
TCD derive cerebral vasomotor reactivity metrics.
4) Studying effect NICoE intervention on genomics landscape of SM to identify key
molecular pathways associated with healing.
(3903) Expansion and Spread of Student-lead Integrative Medicine Curricula
Change
Marni Hillinger, MD1, Christian Adams, MS-32, Agata Harabasz,
MS-23, Lauray MacElhern, CNS3 and Henri Roca,
MD3
1Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee
2Joan C. Edwards School of Medicine at Marshall University, Huntington,
West Virginia
3Little Rock, Arkansas
Abstract
Overview: The Leadership and Education Program for Students in
Integrative Medicine (LEAPs) has continuously operated for 10 years. During that
time, over 300 students have completed the Program. LEAPs brings a
transprofessional group of health professional students to a residential week in
an optimal learning environment to learn about common integrative medicine
modalities, to experience those modalities, and to develop leadership skills
directed toward incorporating integrative medicine curricula in their home
institutions. Each student implements a home project that increases the
visibility of integrative medicine, increases access to integrative medicine
teaching or experientials, or increases the access to underserved stakeholders
using student providers. These programs have been very successful. This workshop
will review the structure and intent of the LEAPS program, share the experience
of the student leaders of recent LEAPs, demonstrate the breadth and depth of
home-based programs, and allow participants to experience some of the leadership
development techniques.
Rationale: Integrative medicine curricula programming is often
lacking in institutions that exist in underserved communities, are located in
more rural or isolated portions of the country, or exist a freestanding training
institutions. In order to grow sustainable curricula change, student leaders are
required. LEAPs grows student leaders and supports their development over the
course of their training. This is submitted for a workshop.
Objectives: Participants will be able to list the components of an
optimal learning environment; sculpta miniversion of LEAPs for their home
institutions; experience a portion of the leadership development program; and
describe the impact at home institutions of student-lead integrative medicine
programming.
Outline:
1. History of LEAPS
2. Components of an optimal learning environment
3. Structure of LEAPs
4. Experience of leadership training technique
5. Discussion of home institution student-lead projects
6. Creation of mini LEAPs for participants’ home institution
(3908) Dietary Sugar Induces Breast Tumorigenesis in Murine Models Partially
Through 12-Lipoxygenase and Immune Modulation
Lorenzo Cohen, PhD1, Peiying Yang, PhD1, Yan Jiang,
PhD1, Patrea Rhea, BS1 and Mihai Gagea, DVM,
PhD1
1Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: High added sugar consumption might be associated with
increased breast cancer (BCa) risk, but the data are not consistent and the
molecular mechanisms remain unclear. We examined the effect of sucrose-enriched
diet in the development of primary and metastatic BCa and relevant
mechanisms.
Results: A diet with 125 g/kg sucrose (equivalent to the average
U.S. sugar consumption) shortened breast tumorigenesis in MMTV-ErbB2/neu mice
and promoted the development of BCa in mice bearing 4T1 cells and MDA-MB-231
cells. Further, sucrose diet significantly increased the numbers of lung nodules
2-fold in 4T1 animal models (P < .05). There was
upregulation of expression of 12-LOX protein and its metabolite, 12-HETE, within
the tumor tissues across the 3 BCa models. When mice were fed with
sucrose-enriched diets, the average mammary tumor weight in ALOX12 deficient
MDA-MB-231 cell-derived tumors were smaller than that of tumors derived from
scramble MDA-MB-231 cells. Furthermore, sucrose-enriched diet led to 2-fold
increases in protein and mRNA of monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP-1) in
serum and tumor tissues of MMTV-ErbB2/neu mice and mice bearing 4T1 mammary
tumors. Intriguingly, 12-HETE treatment concentration dependently increased
MCP-1 in MDA-MB-231 cells, whereas a selective 12-LOX inhibitor, ML355,
inhibited the MCP-1 gene expression in MDA-MB-231 cells. Finally, 4T1 mammary
tumors from sucrose diet had 2-fold higher inflammation score and infiltration
of CD68+ cells (tumor-associated macrophage) compared to that of starch control
diet.
Conclusions: Our data provide evidence that added sugar accelerates
the development of BCa through upregulating expression of 12-LOX and immune
modulation, especially MCP-1 pathway.
(3915) Building Integrative Medicine and Wellness Into Curriculum
Anne E Weisman, PhD, MPH, LMT1
1University of Nevada Las Vegas School of Medicine, Las Vegas, Nevada
Abstract
Overview: University of Nevada Las Vegas (UNLV) School of Medicine’s
innovative curriculum is relationship-based, designed to foster strong ties
between faculty and students, between students and patients, and between the
students and the community. Early in the design and creation of this curriculum,
the importance of the inclusion of integrative medicine was recognized. As the
integrative medicine curriculum was taking shape, the topics were intentionally
placed throughout the longitudinal curriculum throughout each learning block to
support the material being covered in each. UNLV School of Medicine created the
integrative medicine thread for patient care and extensive wellness programming
for practitioners to work in tandem and support each other. This design will
help medical students, faculty, and residents with the balance of caring for
others as well as caring for themselves. UNLV School of Medicine provides
medical students with didactic and experiential learning for specific skills to
decrease stress and enhance wellness while in school and throughout their
careers. The intent is to create the awareness and practice of integrative
medicine during the undergraduate medical education. The curriculum promotes
students’ well-being and exposes students to additional perspectives and
modalities that they can apply with their patients in conjunction with
conventional medicine. It is a comprehensive curriculum that includes the topics
of preventive health care, physical activity, stress management, flexibility,
addressing addictive behaviors, successful sleep, the importance of social
supports, meditation, gratitude, nutrition, art, theater, and nature. UNLV
medical students have the opportunity to experience and participate in a variety
of regularly scheduled modalities including tai chi, meditation, yoga,
mindfulness, narrative medicine, and graphic medicine. As the medical students
take up the rigors of the study of medicine, the integrative medicine and
wellness curriculum will provide practical strategies to enhance their own
self-care as well as training the future physicians to care for the whole
person.
Rationale: This topic is important and relevant to the conference
theme Collaboration in Action: Advancing Integrative Health through Research,
Education, Clinical Practice and Policy because UNLV School of Medicine created
their curriculum with integrative health topics throughout all 4 years of
training. This opportunity presented through the creation of a brand new medical
school in a medically underserved area that saw the future of medicine heading
this direction. Integrative medicine and health connects patients to themselves,
their practitioners, and to their communities. It reminds us of our innate
ability to heal while honoring all of the available and appropriate treatments.
It is also an issue of understanding and communication. Current research
suggests that many patients are using some forms of integrative medicine and
very few communicate this to their doctors. This gap in communication creates
more gaps in care. Many physicians who trained before were not taught about this
and express their discomfort discussion this with patients because of their lack
of knowledge. Through creating a new school of medicine that honors all forms of
healing, the lines of communication and dialogue are open to train medical
students, residents, faculty, and physicians.
Objectives: Participants will be able to look at their own
curriculum and identify places that this curriculum fits and assess the impact
of the curricular changes.
(4073) Effects of Aloe on the Regulation of Thyroxine Release in FRTL-5 Thyroid
Cells
Byoung-Seob Ko, PhD1, Hiroe Go, PhD1 and Jin A Ryuk,
PhD1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: We investigated the effects of aloe on thyroxine production
in FRTL-5 cells.
Results: In the 6H group (with thyroid-stimulating hormone [TSH]),
thyroxine release was decreased compared with the control group. Moreover, mRNA
and protein expression of thyroid peroxidase (TPO) which is one of the important
factors of thyroxine synthesis were decreased significantly. Conversely, in the
5H group (without TSH), thyroxine release and protein expression of TPO were
increased compared with the control group. To know the mechanism of regulatory
effects of aloe on thyroxine release, we investigated protein expression of
upstream key factors of thyroid hormone synthesis such as phospho-ERK,
phospho-CREB, phospho-AKT, and PKA. Although protein expression of phospho-ERK,
phospho-CREB, and PKA was decreased in 6H group, those of 5H group was
increased. Protein expression of phosphor-AKT was not changed in both 6H and 5H
groups.
Conclusions: These results suggest that aloe could be candidate for
TSH-like substances and play a regulatory role in thyroxin release via PKA-CREB
or PKA-ERK pathway.
Poster-experiential, Symposium, Panel Discussion Abstracts
(61) Kampo Medicine (Traditional Japanese Medicine) for Gastrointestinal Disease
Under Integrated Universal Health-care Coverage in Japan
Keiko Ogawa, PhD1, Junsuke Arimitsu, PhD2 and Kengo Nakata,
MPH3
1Kanazawa University, Kanazawa, Japan
2Kanazawa University Hospital, Kanazawa, Japan
3Japanese Society of Traditional Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Tokyo,
Japan
Abstract
Overview: The effectiveness of traditional Japanese (Kampo) medicine
in gastrointestinal disease is attracting more and more attention in the
Japanese medical system. Kampo, comprising both Kampo herbal medicine and manual
therapies such as acupuncture, moxibustion, and acupressure, is the most
frequently used alternative and complementary medicine in Japan. The aim of
Kampo therapy is to improve patients’ condition whatever their diseases are. The
illness concept of Kampo, body and mind as one, has similarity with gut-brain
axis (GBA) which consists of bidirectional communication between the central and
the enteric nervous system, linking emotional and cognitive centers of the brain
with peripheral intestinal functions. It can also be used easily for patients
because it is operated under integrated universal health care by the Japanese
government. Patients are diagnosed from both viewpoints of modern and Kampo
medicine, and they are treated with the appropriate combination of both
therapies. This characteristic suggests an ideal form of integrated medicine,
where scientific and analytical approaches of Western medicine are integrated
with holistic approach of Kampo Medicine. Though its origin was in ancient
China, Kampo medicine has been developed under the influence of Japanese nature
and culture, and nowadays is working as an independent medical system
significantly different from Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). We would like
to discuss on the advantage and disadvantage of Kampo medicine for patients
through some clinical researches and reports. According to the 4 key objectives
of World Health Organization (WHO) strategy: policy to integrate traditional
medicine (TM) within national health-care systems; establishment of the safety,
efficacy, and quality of TM; preservation of the right of patients to access TM;
and rational use to promote therapeutically sound use of appropriate TM by
practitioners and consumers, Japanese medical system might be a good example for
countries where TMs are used.
Rationale: The illness concept of Kampo, body and mind as one, has
similarity with GBA which consists of bidirectional communication between the
central and the enteric nervous system, linking emotional and cognitive centers
of the brain with peripheral intestinal functions. Therefore, Kampo medicine is
effective and has played more and more important roles in closing the gap
between modern medicine and demand of patients. According to the 4 key
objectives of WHO strategy: policy to integrate TM within national health-care
systems; establishment of the safety, efficacy and quality of TM; preservation
of the right of patients to access TM; and rational use to promote
therapeutically sound use of appropriate TM by practitioners and consumers,
Japanese medical system might be a good example for countries where TMs are
used. We would like to discuss on the advantage and disadvantage of Kampo
medicine for patients with gastrointestinal disease through some clinical
researches and reports. It will establish understandable concept in Kampo
medicine and patients can access to Kampo medicine more easily.
Objectives: They would like to learn the advantage and disadvantage
of Kampo medicine for patients through some clinical researches and reports.
They can adopt this knowledge to their clinical or research activity, and we
might cooperate to make better role of TMs.
Outline: We would like to discuss on the advantage and disadvantage
of Kampo medicine for patients with gastrointestinal disease through some
clinical researches and reports. It will establish understandable concept in
Kampo medicine and patients can access to Kampo medicine more easily.
(1102) Dietary Ingredients as an Alternative Approach for Mitigating
Musculoskeletal Pain: Evidence-based Recommendations for Practice in the
Military
Cindy C Crawford, BA1, Courtney Boyd, MA1, Patricia Deuster,
PhD2 and Scott Cota, CAPT3
1Thought Leadership and Innovation Foundation, McLean, Virginia
2Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, Maryland
3US Special Operations Command MacDill AFB, Tampa, Florida
Abstract
Overview: Alternative approaches to managing chronic pain resulting
from musculoskeletal injuries (MSK-I) are needed. MSK-I are one of the most
burdensome conditions in the U.S. Military, as they are a leading cause of pain,
medical encounters, lost duty time, and disability across the U.S. Military.
Already about 55%–76% of Service members use dietary supplements for various
reasons, and using such products for a wide-range of pain conditions has become
increasingly popular. Decisions to use dietary supplements are often driven by
information that is not evidence based, such as from peers, family members, and
other sources. If such products are going to be used for mitigating MSK pain,
evidence-based research is required to inform appropriate and safe decisions
about ingredients. In this symposium, we will introduce the methodological
approach we used to provide a clear, comprehensive, and unbiased synopsis of the
state of the science regarding dietary ingredient evidence for MSK-I pain in
order to provide evidence-based recommendations to Special Operations Force
(SOF) personnel. We then will demonstrate how this process allowed key
stakeholders and subject matter experts to develop transparent, evidence-based
information to direct policy decisions regarding the appropriate selection and
use of dietary ingredients for improving pain and pain-related outcomes.
Finally, we will describe the results and recommendations, which may be used to
inform policy decisions on this important topic.
Rationale: As noted, MSK pain is ubiquitous throughout the military
due to the extreme physical demands of training and combat. Across the military,
options for MSK pain are limited primarily to medications (eg, nonsteroidal
anti-inflammatories/NSAIDs), injections, dry needling, physical therapy,
acupuncture, and other modalities. One alternative that has not been considered
as carefully is natural ingredients found in food and used in dietary
supplements. In addition to the military, MSK pain is also common in the
civilian sector and may, in fact, be a surrogate for health quality. We will
present the state of the science recommendations about using specific dietary
ingredients as an alternative or adjunctive approach to minimizing chronic
musculoskeletal pain. Our recommendations take into account risk-to-benefit,
impact on various pain-related outcomes, patient preferences/values, and
cost/resources. The methodological process used can be applied to any
integrative approach in need of trusted evidence-based recommendations.
Objectives:
Upon completion of this Symposium, participants will (1)
describe a transparent, streamlined approach for developing evidence-based
recommendations for providers to consider using various dietary ingredients as
an alternative approach for mitigating chronic musculoskeletal pain; (2)
demonstrate how evidence can be integrated with clinical acumen in a
transparent, structured fashion to develop trusted evidence-based
recommendations regarding the appropriate use of dietary ingredients for pain;
and (3) translate the evidence-based recommendations for future research
initiatives and for use in various health-care venues.
Outline:
• The presenters will detail the purpose of the project and the intended impacts
specifically for SOF.
• The presenters will describe the methodological approach taken to determine
whether current research on dietary ingredients for chronic musculoskeletal pain
could provide sufficient evidence to inform decisions for both practice and
self-care.
• The presenters will summarize the state-of-the-science across dietary
ingredients for chronic musculoskeletal pain.
• The attendees will learn how to achieve evidence-based recommendations, using
decision factors applied within the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment,
Development and Evaluation Framework, and a multivoting, modified-Delphi
process.
• The presenters will discuss how evidence-based information can be used to
direct policy decisions regarding the appropriate selection and use of dietary
ingredients for improving pain and pain-related outcomes.
(1166) Psycho-neuro-endocrine-immunology Emotions and Reflection on
Disease
Gianpaolo Giacomini1
1Pianoro, Italy
Abstract
Overview: Emotions are the cornerstone of human experience, both in
health and in the illness. They change the way in which we observe life and
arise from the deepest interpretation patterns that lie in our minds. Social,
parental, scholastic, cultural, and religious education are all factors that
intervene when we have to judge our health. Often, an incorrect belief can lead
us to evaluate a fact in a distorted way, thus showing us a disease where there
is actually an opportunity. Healing is change, overcoming, inner conscious
transformation, especially with regard to mental patterns that force us to judge
reality. The chain that links mental beliefs, emotions, and activation of the
psycho-neuro-endocrine-immunology (PNEI) axes of the body can affect our health
or our illness. If we want to heal and help our patients, we must first and
foremost know and deal with ourselves, our mind, and our mental patterns that
inevitably and unconsciously make us often experience the same problems.
Rationale: Every well-being and medical practitioner faces not only
the disease but also the sick person. It is therefore indispensable to
understand how much the emotional side of a healthy or sick person is affecting
his physical and mental health. Medicine and care must be more and more about
the person and not the disease.
Objectives: The aim is to understand the complex reality of
interaction between education, mental patterns, beliefs, emotions, and axes of
the PNEI body; understand the crucial difference between acting and reacting to
the choices of life; know how to treat breathing techniques, postural,
integrative (eg, flower therapy) the emotional side of the patient; and
understand the environment in which the person lives, particularly familiar, as
a mental conditioning.
Outline:
-The mental reality of the human being: the mind as an instrument of the soul to
manifest to the body.
- PNEI communication paths between mind and body, endocrine and neurochemical
axes, and neuronal plasticity.
-The life-giving emotions and the way of transmutation, not the suppression.
-Illness as a manifestation in the body of the emotional and mental state of the
human being.
-Effect of controlled respiration on sympathetic and parasympathetic system.
-Use of postural rehabilitation and body consciousness.
-Revealing your own self and recognizing interactive family dynamics.
(2168) Integrative Health Education: Results of a National Interprofessional,
Primary Care Educational Program
Maryanna D Klatt, PhD1, Audrey J Brooks, PhD2, Benjamin
Kligler, MD, MPH2, Victoria Maizes, MD2, Mary Koithan, PhD,
CNS-BC, FAAN2 and Patricia Lebensohn, MD2
1College of Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
2Tucson, Arizona
Abstract
Overview: The University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine
in collaboration with the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and
Health established the Health Resources and Services Administration-funded
National Center for Integrative Primary Healthcare (NCIPH) in 2014. The NCIPH
goal is to transform primary care health professional education to include an
emphasis on providing an Integrative Health (IH) approach to patient care
utilizing an interprofessional collaborative team. A collaborative process
involving an interprofessional team developed a set of IH competencies for
primary care. Team members represent nursing, primary care medicine professions,
pharmacy, public health, acupuncture, naturopathy, chiropractic, nutrition, and
behavioral medicine. Based on the IH competencies and needs assessment, a 35-h
online interprofessional IH course, Foundations in Integrative Health (FIH), was
developed. FIH is an online, self-paced, interactive experience. Experiential
sessions were conducted at some sites. Trainees learn to conduct an IH
assessment, learn from the other perspectives presented in the course and other
trainees, and how patients are assessed and treated from each of the diverse
professions as part of integrative primary care. Course material is presented
with a focus on an interprofessional collaborative team approach and includes
diverse case examples. Units include IH Introduction; Prevention and Lifestyle;
Healthcare Professional Wellbeing; Addressing Patients through an Integrative
Lens; Integrative Interventions; and Community Settings and Systems. The course
was successfully pilot tested in primary care training programs, for example,
residencies, nursing, pharmacy, oriental medicine, chiropractic, and community
health centers. Six hundred seventy-nine trainees completed the course.
Evaluation ratings were very positive. Two thirds reported incorporating new
self-care practices. Positive changes were found on multiple well-being
measures. Challenges and opportunities implementing FIH in primary care training
programs targeting nursing, family medicine residents, and medical students will
be presented. Experiences implementing the curriculum in community clinics will
presented. Present and future initiatives utilizing the NCIPH course, and other
resources will be discussed.
Rationale: Evidence is accruing for the clinical and
cost-effectiveness of IH care; however, there is a knowledge gap for primary
care professionals, which has hindered widespread adoption of IH into
health-care systems. IH advocates for person-centered health care that is
informed by evidence and makes use of appropriate health-care professionals,
disciplines, healing traditions, and therapeutic approaches. IH envisions a care
process that is a team activity, with the patient as a central team member. This
differs from prevailing patterns of care that are often compartmentalized,
fragmented, and delayed. An IH team would employ professionals with a wide
spectrum of expertise and skills and diverse, interdisciplinary education, and
training in a set of core competencies. Health-care education efforts are often
hampered by constraints of time, scheduling, and budget. Additional barriers,
such as scheduling across disciplines, imbalances in professional group
composition, lack of colocation, and larger than optimal group size, are also
encountered in interprofessional education. An online course addresses the
challenges of time, cost, location, and curriculum consistency and can be widely
disseminated to the entire spectrum of primary care training programs and in
clinical settings. Developing course materials using an online learning format
acknowledges the global nature of primary care education and health-care
systems.
Objectives: The aim is to describe the FIH course and highlight
evaluation findings, identify successful ways to incorporate all or part of the
course into primary care educational programs and clinical settings, describe
ways to use the course in community health centers to provide IH
interprofessional development, and strategize ways to implement the FIH course
in educational programs and/or clinical settings-based upon lessons learned in
the FIH implementation.
Outline: Dr Lebensohn will discuss the development and content of
the FIH course, detailing the integrative interprofessional content and
structure of the online course. Dr Brooks will provide an overview of the pilot
study evaluation results. Drs. Klatt and Koithan will describe the lessons
learned at their sites implementing the pilot, including necessary features for
success, and encourage participants of the symposium to explore how this might
be best utilized at their home institution. Drs. Kligler and Brooks will discuss
applications of course in community health centers. The panel will discuss next
steps for dissemination. Drs. Lebensohn and Maizes will moderate a discussion of
challenges and opportunities implementing an interprofessional, integrative
health curriculum.
(2172) Inducing Therapeutic Lifestyle Changes for the Prevention and Treatment of
(Mental) Disease
Rogier Hoenders, MD, PhD1
1Center for Integrative Psychiatry, Lentis, Groningen, the Netherlands
Abstract
Overview: It has been estimated that if we pay more attention to
specific aspects of diet, overweight, inactivity and smoking, we might prevent
>90% of diabetes mellitus type 2, >80% of coronary heart disease, and
>70% of colon cancer and stroke. There is also growing evidence for the
efficacy of lifestyle changes for treating (mental) disease, but besides running
therapy and mindfulness, therapeutic lifestyle changes in (mental) health care
are seldom applied in clinical practice and seldom taught in medical curricula.
A lifestyle program consisting of diet/nutrition, exercise, and relaxation has
been proven effective for reversal of coronary heart disease and early stage
prostate cancer. Promoting lifestyle changes is also an effective intervention
for mental health. Besides improving heart disease, the Ornish program also
diminishes depression symptoms by 50%. A recent randomized controlled trial
showed a positive effect of a nutrition intervention when added to the treatment
of depression. Running therapy seems effective for depression. In this
interactive lecture, we will look at our modern nutrition, relaxation, and
exercise habits, learn about the scientific evidence for therapeutic lifestyle
changes, increase our awareness about our own lifestyle, and learn which
bio-psycho-socio-ecological factors hinder long-lasting behavioral change, and
we will practice how to overcome them using registration, motivational
interviewing, a step by step approach, the stages of change model, and a
lifestyle medicine attitude.
Rationale: Despite important progress in psychiatry not all patients
respond well to available treatments. Studies using data of both published and
unpublished clinical trials show that the effects of the most common treatments
in psychiatry have been overestimated. This seems to be true for psychotherapy
as well as for the pharmacologic treatments of many major psychiatric disorders.
In addition to growing concerns about efficacy, psychotropic drugs can cause
adverse effects and may potentially increase suicide risk. Many patients are
looking for other ways, specifically approaches they can apply themselves,
leading to less stigma and empowerment. Besides, the costs of health care are
getting out of control. One possible strategy to cut costs and to improve
treatment outcomes is inviting patients to take a more active role in their
recovery by learning them therapeutic lifestyle changes, such as nutrition,
exercise, and relaxation. This appears to be cost effective, even cost
saving.
Objectives: The aim is to learn about the scientific evidence for
improving (mental) health by inducing therapeutic lifestyle changes, increase
awareness about one’s own lifestyle, learn about which
bio-psycho-social-spiritual factors prevent us to achieve long-lasting
behavioral change and how to overcome them, and be able to do a lifestyle
anamnesis and coach patients in changing their lifestyle for better (mental)
health.
Outline: By changing our lifestyle, we can prevent and even treat
(mental) disease
Achieving long-lasting behavioral change is difficult
By applying specific techniques, we can increase our success rate
(2203) Engaging Nature for Health and Well-being: From Therapeutic to
Therapy
David Victorson, PhD1, Barbara Kreski, MHS, OTR, HTR2, Stacy A
Bare, MCP3, Teresa H Horton, PhD4 and Frederick O Foote,
MD5
1Chicago, Illinois
2Chicago Botanic Garden, Glencoe, Illinois
3Salt Lake City, Utah
4Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois
5Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: A continuum of therapeutic nature-based activities exists
including adventure wilderness trips, equine therapy, forest bathing, and
horticultural therapy. Practitioners and participants have compelling
qualitative and quantitative findings regarding changes in function, affect,
behavior, and biophysiological markers of stress that occur during and
postintervention. However, acceptance of these activities as adjunct or
complementary therapies within integrative medicine is limited due to a paucity
of standardization of programs, research designs, methodologies, conceptual
frameworks and definitions, and controlled research studies. Recent work strives
to overcome these limitations. This panel discussion will introduce 4 program
models that have been the subject of research that investigates the efficacy of
and/or mechanism by which engaging with nature improves health and well-being.
The panel will address the evidence that supports the use of these models as
primary or complimentary interventions and for what conditions these
interventions appear to be most effective. The discussion period will be used to
identify ways to overcome barriers to the acceptance of nature-based therapies
in integrative and complementary medicine.
Rationale: Developing the evidence base needed to transition from
the reported therapeutic effects of nature-based activities to the acceptance of
these activities as adjunct or complementary therapies requires collaboration
among multidisciplinary practitioners and researchers. Discussion of how
practitioners and researchers can collaborate to support research to document
the effects of nature-based therapies on specific patient populations, evaluate
the efficacy and effectiveness of an intervention, provide comparisons to
current practices, and identify specific health outcomes will facilitate this
transition.
Objectives: After attending this session, participants will be able
to describe the spectrum of nature-based activities, identify the modalities by
which nature influences physical and mental health, identify the patient
populations that appear to be best suited for nature based therapies, recognize
barriers that have impeded the widespread acceptance and incorporation of these
therapies in health care, recommended assessment tools that could enable and
facilitate research, and develop a research agenda for systematically
approaching the need for evidence.
Outline:
1 Introduction by moderator
• Introduce panelists
• Define key terms
• Introduce presentations by panelists
2 Panelists each (4) provide a video and explanation of their nature-based
program
3 The moderator will set the stage for the panel discussion by briefly
describing:
• The nature of illness, disorder, or malaise that appears to be most suitable
to complimenting existing standard practice with nature-based therapeutics,
• the current state of evidence basis for nature-based therapeutics which is
fledgling, and
• why this is a barrier to their more widespread use.
4 Selected panelists will address the points raised by the moderator
• Viewpoint from practitioners
• Viewpoint from practitioner/researchers
• Culminating in suggested research agenda
5 Moderator will open discussion to attendees and moderate discussion likely to
include the following questions:
• People have different definitions of nature. Is a formal garden “natural”? Do
images of nature count?
• Is not nature therapy simply a form of leisure therapy? How do you distinguish
the 2?
• Can you define the scope of practice for “nature therapists”?
6 Moderator will summarize and conclude
(3243) Development and Evaluation of Integrative Nutrition Education Programs for
Schools, Underserved Neighborhoods, and the Military
Diane Hannemann, PhD1, Patricia Deuster, PhD, MPH2, Elizabeth
Moylan, MPH, RD, CSSD2, Christopher R D'Adamo, PhD3 and
Brandin Bowden, MS1
1The Institute for Integrative Health, Baltimore, Maryland
2United States Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, Maryland
3University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Stress coupled with limited exposure and access to
affordable healthy foods influence food choices. Successful nutrition
programming that inspires lasting behavior changes should be experiential and
address social and economic barriers to healthy eating. This session will
feature integrative nutrition and culinary programs designed to address specific
communities, including underserved, schools, and the military. Integrative,
well-being platforms need to incorporate life skills, such as stress management,
nutrition, budget shopping, physical activity, and relationship building to
maximize success. Evaluation methods include anthropometrics, perceived stress,
food diaries, and sensory testing of foods, cooking habits, physical activity,
sleep, and well-being. Discussions will include how these measures inform
program dissemination and improvements and actionable federal and local policies
that support access to affordable healthy foods.
Rationale: Access to and knowing how to prepare healthy foods can
benefit multiple communities—military, underserved, and many others populations.
However, improving access and confidence in creating healthy meals requires
cooking skills, nutrition knowledge, and contact with the soil. These are the
key to improving community well-being and the food environment. This session
will present several experiential, integrated nutrition and culinary programs
that consider social and economic factors for each target community. Presenters
will also discuss how program results can inform program improvements as well as
policies to support access to affordable healthy food.
Objectives:
Upon completion, participants will be able to describe
experiential nutrition education programs that promote healthy eating and
life-skills development, demonstrate how important program evaluation is for
improving future programs and policies supporting access to affordable healthy
food, and translate how evidence from program evaluation can be used to develop
actionable policies.
Outline:
• Nutrition and culinary programs need to address socioeconomic factors in target
populations that present barriers to healthy food decisions. Experiential
learning is motivating and allows development of practical nutrition and
culinary skills.
• Incorporating life skills into nutrition programs creates an integrative
platform for well-being.
• Program evaluation informs policies that support access to affordable and
appealing healthy food.
(3248) Integrative Medicine and Cancer Patient Self-care: A Simple
Yoga/Progressive Muscle Relaxation Intervention for Patients to Practice at Home to
Help Manage Treatment Side Effects, Enhance Quality of Life, and Improve Clinical
Outcome
Leigh Leibel, MSc1 and Kathleen Sanders, APRN, MSN, MPH2
1Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center, NYP-Columbia University
Medical Center, New York City, New York
2Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, University of Washington,
Seattle, Washington
Abstract
Overview: The objective of this interactive workshop is to share a
simple and effective 15-min yoga/progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) technique
that cancer patients may practice on a regular basis to help manage various
physical and psychological side effects of the disease and its treatment. Common
adverse sequelae include anxiety, fatigue, sleep dysfunction, neuropathy/balance
issues, constipation/nausea, arthralgia, pain, and menopausal hot flashes. This
is a nonpharmacological intervention that is easy for clinicians to learn and
teach their patients, and it empowers patients by giving them an effective
stress management tool that is enjoyable to practice at home on their own or
with other family members, thereby increasing the incidence of daily compliance.
This yoga/PMR technique is appropriate for the immunosuppressed, those at risk
for lymphedema, those with decreased bone strength due to disease or treatment,
and for patients with general deconditioning. The physical exercises described
may be modified as necessary for functional limitations and may be performed in
a bed or chair. This simple practice introduces cancer patients to a healthy
lifestyle protocol that will help them thrive during active chemotherapy and
radiation treatment, as well as successfully transition from patient to
survivor. In this 75-min interactive workshop, we will introduce the technique
(15 min), cite relevant research (15 min), practice the protocol as a group
(15 min), discuss patient feedback and compliance (15 min), and propose
techniques for implementation in clinic (15 mins). Handouts and links to video
demonstrations will be provided.
Rationale:
Collaboration in action: Health-care providers empowering patients by
teaching them a simple, drug-free alternative to manage side effects of
cancer treatment! Yoga and PMR are mind–body techniques that cancer
patients may practice on a regular basis to help manage various physical and
psychological side effects of the disease and its treatment. Common adverse
sequelae include anxiety, fatigue, sleep dysfunction, neuropathy/balance issues,
constipation/nausea, arthralgia, pain, and menopausal hot flashes. The technique
is a nonpharmacological intervention that is easy for clinicians to learn and
teach their patients, and it empowers patients by giving them an effective
stress management tool that is enjoyable to practice at home on their own or
with other family members. It is appropriate for the immunosuppressed, those at
risk for lymphedema, those with decreased bone strength due to disease or
treatment, and for patients with general deconditioning. The physical exercises
described may be modified as necessary for functional limitations and may be
performed in a bed or chair. This simple yoga/PMR practice introduces cancer
patients to a healthy lifestyle protocol that will help them thrive during
active chemotherapy and radiation treatment, as well as successfully transition
from patient to survivor.
Objectives: This is a simple, nonpharmacological intervention that
is easy for clinicians to learn and teach their patients during an office visit.
Significantly, the clinician is able to offer the patient a drug-free
alternative to ameliorate cancer treatment side effects. As well, it empowers
patients by giving them an effective stress management tool that is enjoyable to
practice at home on their own or with other family members, thereby increasing
the incidence of daily compliance.
Outline: In this 75-min interactive workshop, we will introduce the
technique (15 min), cite relevant research (15 min), practice the protocol as a
group (15 min), discuss patient feedback and compliance (15 min), and propose
techniques for implementation in clinic (15 mins). Handouts and links to video
demonstrations will be provided.
(3348) Developing and Implementing a Successful “Medical Yoga” Program as a Part
of Integrative Care for Multiple Chronic Illnesses—Approach, Capabilities Required,
Integration Into Clinical Practice, and Benefit Summary From VA New Jersey Health
Care System 2-Year Experience
Ann C Cotter, MD, FABPMR, CNS1, Jayashree S Pathak, MBBS(MD), C-IAYT,
PGDYTD, DYEd1
1East Orange, New Jersey
Abstract
Overview: The VA Whole Health System includes clinical care that
supports veteran self-care in both veterans who seek prevention and those who
suffer from multiple chronic illnesses. Yoga therapy uses the science of yoga to
help patients harness their inherent homeostatic forces. Many integrative care
facilities across the United States and world have begun to incorporate yoga
therapy for a variety of medical conditions. Oftentimes, the yoga therapy being
implemented is labeled by a discipline “Hatha,” “Vinyasa,” “Iyengar,” and so on.
Published research has reported a range of results from such implementations. It
is important to develop a patient-centered and therapy-focused yoga program
which first and foremost answers the questions of Why is yoga useful? What
practices should be done? How do these benefit the patients? In-depth knowledge
of the field of medicine coupled with the knowledge and experience of yoga are
critical enablers for developing and implementing a successful yoga program
within integrative care. This workshop session is aimed at practitioners and
administrators who are looking to implement or increase the efficacy of yoga
within their integrative health care. The workshop would also be of interest to
the academic institutions that are looking to incorporate yoga-related education
as a part of their curriculum in undergraduate medical school, residency
training, and grand rounds lectures.
Rationale: Chronic diseases are common, costly, and debilitating.
According to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1 in 4 Americans has
multiple chronic conditions. As the number of conditions increase so does the
cost of care. About 71% of total health care spending in the United States is
associated with chronic care for more than 1 condition. A chronic disease
process signifies a state of prolonged maladjustment and is brought about by a
range of factors such as clinical, social, psychological, economic, and
familial. Increasingly, integrative care is being adopted as a way of addressing
a number of chronic conditions. Yoga is a scientific and practical discipline
that helps in regaining and maintaining the state of homeostasis in the face of
disturbances. Yogic practices bring about integration of psychophysiological
processes. Effectively incorporating yoga therapy in integrative care has the
potential to significantly improve patient’s quality of life, reverse some of
the underlying causes for the chronic conditions while reducing the overall cost
of care for patients as well as the society.
Objectives: The participants will discuss key principles of yoga
from a medical/scientific point of view, get help for developing a program that
could potentially be used for triaging and inducting chronic care patients in
medical yoga, learn strategies to integrate yoga therapy into multidisciplinary
care, identify an overall outline of a medical yoga therapy program for general
chronic conditions and some specific medical conditions, recognize the
importance and contents of the introductory first 2 sessions which are critical
for successful outcome, participate in medical yoga practices along with
explanation for these, get to know the outcome from a 2-year 200 patient
implementation of the program at VA New Jersey Health Care System (VANJHCS), and
assess best practices that can be deployed, challenges in implementation and
ways to mitigate these.
Outline: Following key topics would be covered in the experiential
workshop:
• Integrative care program—an implementation approach from VANJHCS
• Medical yoga—a medical/scientific perspective
• Medical yoga therapy program for multiple chronic conditions—implementation
approach
• The first 2 sessions—critical success enablers
• Experiencing medical yoga Practices along with why, how, and what not to do
• Qualitative patient-centered feedback
• Additional use cases: inpatient psychiatry and substance use
• 200-patient feedback from the implementation at VANJHCS
• Where can we further improve—preventive and acute conditions
• Question and answer
(3387) A Process for Facilitating Lasting Transformational Change Through Phoenix
Rising Yoga Therapy Using the Lens of the Memory Reconsolidation Process
Rickie T Simpson, PHD APRN-CNS, C-IAYT1, Michael Lee, MA, Dip.Soc.Sci,
Dip.T., C-IAYT, E-RYT 5002
1Stratford University, Manassas, Virginia
2Phoenix Rising Yoga Therapy, Great Barrington, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Clients often come to session with behaviors that are
baffling. In the context of past suffering, these behaviors often makes a lot of
sense to the brain’s implicit memory that is predicting and acting globally to
current experiences as if in the past. If formed in the presence of strong
emotion, these responses can be extremely durable. For 30 years, Phoenix Rising
Yoga Therapy has employed a refined embodied present-centered focus through
which the past is experienced differently than the original event. This “lens”
change is highly effective in alleviating the suffering caused by past trauma
with lasting results.
Rationale: Although yoga is not in its infancy, yoga therapy as an
integrative mind–body therapy is. Understanding how effective lasting change can
be experienced through an embodied present-centered focus will be helpful to
therapist of many modalities. This workshop will endeavor to explain and
demonstrate this by referencing the memory reconsolidation process, yogic
philosophy, and the essence of mindfulness.
Objectives: The aim is to identify the steps of the memory
reconsolidation process in supporting the use of an embodied present-centered
focus to support the brain’s natural transformational process and participate in
a Phoenix Rising guided process to experience working directly with embodied
present-centered awareness.
Outline:
1. What is the memory reconsolidation process and the necessary steps for
consistent transformational change.
2. Creating an effective embodied and present-centered experience referencing
yoga philosophy, mindfulness, and recent neuroscience.
3. Guided experience.
4. Discussion.
(3414) Fascia: The Missing Link in Mind/Body Interventions
David Lesondak, BCSI, AS1
1Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: What if one of the keys to mind/body medicine was under
our fingertips all along? Given the recent revelation that the fascial network
has over 100 million sensory nerve endings, it seems quite likely. Fascia is
both a tissue and a system. As such, fascia interacts uniquely with all the
other systems of body, influencing not just pain perception, but also
proprioception, interoception, and perhaps even neuroplasticity. Learn the
latest facts from one of the chief documentarians of fascia science over the
last decade.
Rationale: The tremendous leap forward in fascia science have been
occurring through collaboration among clinicians and researchers. Incorporating
fascial modalities is still an outlier in most integrative medicine centers
while public awareness of fascia is moving toward a tipping point. It is
important that the integrative professional have a clear understanding of what
fascia is and why it matters so that they can be able to intelligently guide
their patients and improve outcomes.
Objectives: The aim is to understand the role of fascia as both a
tissue and a system in the body, recognize fascia as the body’s largest sensory
organ, learn the clinical significance of fascia in chronic pain, gain insight
to the role of fascia in mind/body interventions, and identify what skills are
needed in a good fascial practitioner.
Outline:
1) Fascia as a tissue and its influence on biomechanics.
2) Fascia at the cellular level as an initiator of mechanotransduction (via
integrins and stretch).
3) Fascia as a bodywide cellular communication network (via telocytes).
4) Fascia as the body's largest sensory network.
5) Identifying fascial pathologies.
6) Key qualities for fascial practitioners.
(3454) Homeopathy in Public Health, Safety, and Plausibility Bias
Peter A Fisher, MD1 and Michelle L Dossett, MD, PhD, MPH2
1Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine, London, UK
2Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: The conclusions of systematic reviews of randomized
controlled trials (RCTs) of homeopathy vary from “comparable to conventional
medicine” to “no evidence of effects beyond placebo.” Analysis of 4
“authoritative” reports reveals major methodological and/or procedural flaws
that negatively bias their conclusions on homeopathy. Examination of the prior
beliefs underlying this standoff can advance the debate. Moreover, data from
rigorous RCTs, meta-analyses, and clinical effectiveness studies of the use of
homeopathy for respiratory tract infections, mental health, and pain conditions
showing evidence of clinical and public health benefit will be examined. Use of
homeopathy to reduce the growing problem of antimicrobial resistance will be
discussed, and data on the safety of homeopathy will be presented.
Rationale: Homeopathy is a highly contested but widely used whole
medical system. Some authorities have made sweeping statements about the
scientific impossibility of homeopathy without appropriate examination of the
evidence, an approach which is in itself unscientific. Careful examination of
the methodology used and underlying assumptions leads to greater understanding
in this debate. Focusing on well-conducted, peer-reviewed studies of homeopathy
in upper respiratory tract infections, mental health, and pain conditions, the
potential for homeopathy to advance public health will be discussed. Recent
concerns regarding safety will also be addressed.
Objectives: The aim is to identify and describe major methodological
and procedural flaws in 4 recent authoritative reports on homeopathy; understand
the global problem of antimicrobial resistance, interpret results of RCTs,
meta-analyses, and clinical effectiveness studies of homeopathy for respiratory
tract infections, and describe the role of homeopathy in combating antimicrobial
resistance; interpret RCT data, meta-analyses, and clinical effectiveness
studies on the use of homeopathy for mental health and pain conditions; and
understand data on the safety of homeopathy.
Outline:
1. Introduction—What is homeopathy and what is the controversy?
2. Examination of recent reports reviewing clinical effectiveness of
homeopathy
3. Review of the problem of antimicrobial resistance and data on homeopathy for
upper respiratory tract infections
4. Review of studies using homeopathy for mental health and pain conditions
5. Review of safety data on homeopathy, including recent Food and Drug
Administration action
6. Questions and answers
(3455) The Impact of Objective Mindfulness Practice Adherence on
Mindfulness-based Intervention Outcomes Among High-stress Populations
Michael Christopher, PhD1, Helané Wahbeh, ND, MCR2, Letícia
Ribeiro, MS1, Candice Hoke, MS1, Mathew Hunsigner,
PhD1, Richard Geoerling, MBA2, Barry Oken, MD,
PhD2, Cindy Gross, PhD2 and Dana D Colgan,
PhD2
1Pacific University, Hillsboro, Oregon
2Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Overview: Repetitive exposure to high levels of critical incidents,
the need to respond promptly with precision and accuracy, and high expectations
of optimal performance all contribute to high levels of stress among police
officers, physicians, and military personnel. Chronic stress has been shown to
adversely affect physical and mental health and has been linked to diminished
performance. Mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) have demonstrated
effectiveness in minimizing the damaging consequences of chronic stress among
high-stress populations. An important factor influencing MBI outcomes is
treatment adherence. Adherence data are important because they elucidate the
extent to which adhering to an intervention influences the outcomes of interest.
Several studies have documented that participants who endorse more (duration and
frequency) mindfulness practice are more likely to have better outcomes. This
symposium will present data on the relationship between objective adherence to
formal mindfulness practice and health-related outcomes in separate randomized
controlled trial MBIs among samples of law enforcement officers, physicians,
military veterans, and stressed older adults. All of the studies used iMINDr, a
custom software application developed for iPod Touch, that objectively tracks
home formal mindfulness practice adherence. Additionally, the relationship
between self-reported informal mindfulness practice and health-related outcomes
will be presented. Participants in the studies exhibited improvement across
several health-related outcomes following the MBI when compared to waitlist
controls. Participants generally reported that iMINDr was acceptable and easy to
use. Among high-stress populations, different relationships among objective
formal mindfulness practice, informal mindfulness practice, and MBI outcomes,
including increased resilience and reduced anger and aggression, emerged. The
impact of mindfulness practice adherence on MBI outcomes will be discussed as
well as preferred practices among these highly stressed populations. Developing
culturally sensitive delivery models that increase practice adherence within
these populations will also be explored.
Rationale: An important and especially salient factor influencing
MBI outcomes is adherence to treatment. Adherence data are important because
they elucidate the extent to which adhering to an intervention influences the
outcomes of interest. Adherence to mindfulness practice is usually assessed
through self-report, which limits the accuracy of these findings. Exploring new
methods of objectively measuring adherence is critical to our understanding of
these practices. In addition to objective assessment of adherence, future
research should investigate culturally sensitive delivery models that foster
greater mindfulness practice adherence among diverse populations.
Objectives: The aim is to discuss the benefits and obstacles
of objectively tracking home mindfulness practice adherence; examine the
relationships between objective adherence to formal mindfulness practice,
informal mindfulness practice, and health-related outcomes following MBI among
law enforcement officers, physicians, military veterans, and stressed older
adults; learn about the preferred mindfulness practices as well as perceived
supports and barriers to practice among highly stressed populations; and explore
culturally sensitive delivery models that foster out of session adherence to
mindfulness practice.
Outline:
Presentation I
Title: Objective adherence to meditation interventions in multiple
stressed populations
Authors: Helané Wahbeh, ND, MCR and Barry Oken, MD, PhD
Adherence data are important because they elucidate the extent to which adhering
to an intervention influences the outcomes of interest. Drug trials regularly
use Medication Event Monitoring System and pill counts as objective adherence
measures. No such standards exist in mind–body medicine research. In mind–body
medicine, there are 2 intervention aspects that can be measured for adherence:
class/instruction and home practice. Instruction adherence can be easily
collected through attendance records; however, these are rarely reported.
Adherence to home practice is usually assessed through self-report. Although
this is an improvement from not measuring home practice adherence at all, it has
limitations. First, self-report adherence data are rarely reported. Second,
self-report diaries are subject to errors and poor accuracy. Results based on
self-report home practice logs must be interpreted with caution because there
are no objective measures validating their accuracy. Not assessing objective
adherence is an important problem because any results from an intervention that
includes home practice will have an element of uncertainty due to the unknown
parameter of how much the subjects practiced at home. We developed iMINDr, a
custom software application for use with an iPod Touch, to accurately and
objectively track home practice adherence. iMINDr collects all actions performed
(date, time, action [start, stop, pause, volume change]). We have now collected
iMINDr data in multiple meditation studies in stressed older adults, older
adults with depression, and combat veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD). Unexpectedly, subjective and objective reports of adherence were highly
correlated. Average adherence levels ranged from 0 to 30 min per day. Adherence
was a significant covariate in multiple outcomes of the PTSD study. Challenges
in supporting meditation intervention adherence in stressed populations and the
benefits of having an objective adherence measure will be discussed.
Presentation II
Title: Adherence to informal, but not formal, mindfulness practice
correlates with resilience and team cohesion among interdisciplinary primary
care teams
Authors: Dana D Colgan, PhD and Michael Christopher, PhD
Increasing rates of burnout among primary care providers pose a serious threat to
the health-care system. MBIs have been shown to reduce burnout and enhance
quality of life among primary care physicians and nurses; however, a commonly
reported limitation of MBIs among health-care providers is high attrition rates
due to the intensive time requirement typically associated with MBIs. To address
this concern, mindfulness-based wellness and eesilience (MBWR) was developed and
designed to increase resilience and decrease burnout. MBWR is provided to intact
primary care teams (IPCT) and delivered onsite, during paid, protected time.
Mindfulness practice adherence was collected from participants in a controlled
trial evaluating the preliminary efficacy of MBWR (n = 38). Participants
assigned to the MBWR condition (n = 21) were given an iPod Touch device with the
software application iMINDr, developed to accurately track formal mindfulness
practice. Informal practice data were collected weekly with a brief self-report
questionnaire. Posttraining surveys gathered practice preferences and perceived
supports and barriers to practice. A multilevel modeling approach yielded
significant improvements in the MBWR group at post- and 3-month follow-up in
several outcomes, including mindfulness, resilience, and team cohesion.
Frequency of informal mindfulness practice was significantly correlated with
multiple outcomes, including post-MBWR (r = .55;
P = .03), nonjudgmental awareness
(r = .54; P = .04), and team cohesion
(r = .52; P = .05), and 3-month follow-up
scores in resilience (r = .57; P = .03).
Attendance and adherence to formal practices were not significantly correlated
with post-MBWR or 3-month follow-up outcomes. Preferred mindfulness practices
will be reported as well as perceived supports and barriers to practice
adherence. Providing opportunities for IPCTs to train together and create
tailored, authentic workflows that incorporate informal mindfulness practices
may bolster individual mental immunity as well as develop and sustain a culture
of mindfulness-based resilience within the primary care work environment.
Presentation III
Title: Adherence to formal and informal mindfulness practice
correlated to reduced aggression and improved resilience among law enforcement
officers
Authors: Leticia Ribeiro, MS, Dana D Colgan, PhD, Candice Hoke, MS,
Lt. Richard Geoerling, MBA, Matthew Hunsinger, PhD, Barry Oken, MD, PhD, and
Michael Christopher, PhD
Law enforcement officers (LEOs) are regularly exposed to critical incidents,
leading to high levels of stress and burnout. Stress and burnout among LEOs have
been linked to a number of negative outcomes, including aggressive behavior and
excessive use of force. Mindfulness practice has shown to effectively reduce
both stress and negative affect among highly stressed populations. Several
studies have shown higher frequency and duration of practices are related to
better outcomes, suggesting that the effectiveness of MBIs is at least partially
accounted for by mindfulness practice. In the current study, LEOs (n = 61) were
randomly assigned to an 8-week MBRT, or a waitlist control, and assessed at
baseline, post, and 3-month follow-up. Participants in the MBRT condition had
their adherence to formal mindfulness practice (FMP) tracked by a software
application (iMINDr) installed on an iPod Touch lent to participants during the
MBRT intervention. Informal mindfulness practice (IMP) was collected through
weekly self-reports. A multilevel modeling approach yielded significant
improvements in the MBRT group in several outcomes at posttraining, including
aggression (P = .05, d = .53), burnout
(P < .01, d = .73), and alcohol use
(P = .02, d = .37). MBRT participants
engaged in an average of 322 min of out-of-class FMP, and practiced an average
of 10 min of per day. Participants also endorsed practicing a number of IMPs
throughout the study. Baseline to 3-month follow-up residualized change scores
in aggression were negatively correlated with both frequency
(r = −48; P = .013) and duration
(r = −.45, P = .021) of FMP. IMP was
negatively correlated with baseline to post-MBRT residualized change scores in
aggression (r = −.60, P = .031), anger
(r = −.78, P = .013), and positively
correlated with resilience (r = .67,
P < .001). Implications regarding specific practices
predicting outcomes following mindfulness interventions in this population will
be discussed.
(3479) Designing Mind–Body Intervention Trials: Information Sources That Can Be
Useful
Terry K Selfe, DC, PhD1 and Terry K Selfe, DC, PhD1
1University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Abstract
Overview: This session, aimed at those new to Complementary and
Alternative Medicine research, will present randomized, controlled trial (RCT)
design basics, with an emphasis on mind–body studies, and some information
sources that can be used to facilitate study design. You will learn to locate
reporting standards that exist for various study designs and use them to enhance
your study; formulate answerable research questions; find outcome measures and
supportive resources to improve instrument selection and interpretation; and
recognize and address issues specific to studies of integrative therapies.
Combining lecture and small group workshops, the goal of this session is to
present information that will make designing a controlled trial less
intimidating and more manageable; thus, empowering novice researchers to begin
designing and conducting clinical trials, and strengthening the skills and
knowledge base of those already engaged in human subjects research. While this
content will be presented with a focus on its application to research design, it
will also be useful to clinicians and educators who want to improve their
ability to search the literature, retrieve pertinent articles, and assess the
quality of the studies.
Rationale: Developing a strong evidence base is critical to
advancing the field of integrative medicine and health. This requires
high-quality research studies. Like many other professional fields, many
clinicians receive little research training during their formal education. In
this session, I will present content that has been drawn not just from my
research training, but also from my library science background, and aimed
primarily at enhancing research design knowledge. My background as a clinician,
researcher, and librarian has given me a unique, cross-disciplinary perspective
and enabled me to see how knowledge from one domain can be used to advantage in
another. The goal of this session is to present content from both research and
information fields that will make designing an RCT less intimidating and more
manageable, thereby empowering novice researchers to begin designing and
conducting research, strengthening the skills of those already engaged in
research, and ultimately advancing the field.
Objectives: As a result of this session, attendees will be able to
locate and utilize reporting standards for their research design; form a
searchable research question using the population, intervention, comparator,
outcomes (PICO) framework; discuss studies in the context of the PICO framework;
locate and utilize outcomes instruments and related materials; and recognize and
address some design issues specific to mind–body research.
Outline: Introduce reporting standards, where they can be found, and
their usefulness in the study design phase
Briefly present PICO framework: population, intervention, comparator, and
outcomes
Discuss challenges specific to mind–body intervention studies (eg, blinding,
selecting an appropriate comparator)
Present information on outcomes instruments, information sources to check to find
the instruments, and the importance of locating the actual instrument and
reviewing the questions, scoring instructions, normative values, and any
clinically important differences
Break into small groups:
• Participants will work on developing a PICO question
• Using prompts provided by instructor, the groups will discuss issues and
brainstorm ideas related to each PICO component
Reconvene and briefly discuss common and divergent ideas generated by small
groups
(3490) Earthing (Grounding)—Rediscovery of Nature’s Oldest Healing Modality:
Introduction to the Science, Clinical Evidence, and Practice of “Earthing”
James Oschman, PhD1, Richard M Kotz, MA2, Gaetan Chevalier,
PhD3, Tracy Latz, MD3 and Stephen Sinatra,
MD3
1Nature’s Own Research Association, Dover, New Hemisphere
2North American Science Associates, Potomac, Maryland
3Manchester, Connecticut
Abstract
Overview: Throughout virtually all of history, humans have lived
grounded—connected to the Earth, that is, until man started sleeping on raised
beds and walking on wooden and carpeted floors. Then, beginning in the 1960s
with the advent of rubber or synthetic soled shoes which are insulators, we
became less grounded. Now most of us are rarely in direct contact with the Earth
except on those rare excursions to the beach. Why is this important? Because we
are separated from what may be the world’s original healing resource: the planet
itself and the unlimited supply of free electrons it provides. These electrons
may be critical to our ability to reduce the inflammation that is afflicting our
bodies. Inflammation caused by electron-scavenging free radicals is recognized
as a major contributor to virtually every chronic disease as well as the
diseases of aging. This leads us to the question of whether chronic inflammation
in humans is exacerbated by their lack of connection to the Earth. We now have
clinical evidence that grounding (reconnecting to the Earth) can reduce
inflammation and pain, thin the blood and improve blood flow, promote healthier
cortisol and blood sugar levels, and balance the autonomic nervous system. These
and additional effects are documented in well over 20 peer reviewed journal
articles (http://www.earthinginstitute.net/research/). In addition, many
observational reports describe benefits for multiple sclerosis (MS), lupus,
epilepsy, arthritis, peripheral artery disease, arrhythmia, premenstrual
syndrome, insomnia, and other medical conditions. In this session, we will
discuss the importance of reconnecting to the Earth, explain the theory and
science behind grounding, present clinical evidence supporting its benefits, and
demonstrate how it can easily and conveniently be incorporated into our lives.
There will also be an opportunity for individuals at this session to experience
“Earthing” firsthand.
Rationale: Through the collaboration of scientists in the fields of
engineering physics, biophysics, cell biology, cardiology, rheumatology,
psychiatry, and clinical trials, the role of grounding or “Earthing” on human
health has been developed and elucidated. The results of these collaborations
have been presented in over 20 peer-reviewed articles (http://www.earthinginstitute.net/research/).
Man’s lack of
connection to the Earth and this breakthrough discovery of the Earth’s ability
to heal could have profound impact on the prevention and treatment of many of
the inflammatory diseases which are epidemic in our society and on the way we
conduct animal studies (currently in ungrounded cages). We currently have
observational evidence that it may lead to successful amelioration of currently
poorly treated medical conditions such as arthritis, MS, lupus, Parkinson’s
disease, some hormonal imbalances, peripheral artery disease and cardiac
arrhythmias, among others. This session will also point out the importance of
continued research on the clinical benefits of Earthing and potential models for
conducting such research.
Objectives: The participants of this sessions will understand the
physics and electrophysiology of Earthing, be introduced to the current state of
clinical evidence supporting Earthing, learn how to use Earthing as an
integrative modality in their clinical practices, be exposed to the wide variety
of clinical research that still needs to be done and potential models for
conducting studies/trials, and experience Earthing firsthand.
Outline:
I. Physics and electrophysiology:
1) Why the Earth is a huge reservoir of electrons.
2) How humans have lost their connection to the Earth
3) Why this lack of connection is detrimental to electrophysiological and
biochemical functioning
II. Clinical evidence: studies showing
1) Cardiovascular effects
2) Rheumatological effects
3) Neurological effects
4) Other systemic effects
III. Practice of this modality
1) How individuals can easily practice Earthing naturally and/or utilizing
alternative technologies
2) How practitioners can guide their patients depending on medical
condition/diseases
IV Future clinical research:
1) Lupus, MS, Parkinson’s, atrial fibrillation, and so on.
2) Clinical research models: research paradigms and study designs
IV. Audience will be able to experience grounding during the symposia if
desired
(3493) Experiences of an Interdisciplinary Online Fellowship
Marni Hillinger, MD1, Darshan Mehta, MD, MPH2, Erika
Cappelluti, MD, PhD3 and Tabatha Parker, ND4
1Vanderbilt University, Nasvhille, Tennessee
2Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
3Hartford Healthcare Cancer Institute, Hartford, Connecticut
4Academy of Integrative Health and Medicine, La Jolla, California
Abstract
Overview: Integrated medicine is now a board-certified specialty
under the American Board of Physician Specialties. With the recently created
American Board of Integrative Medicine (ABOIM), there is now a requirement for
individuals to pursue a fellowship training program to sit for the board
examination to qualify for board certification. As such, there are very few
training options for health-care providers. In this panel discussion, we discuss
the recently created Academy of Integrative Health and Medicine (AIHM)
fellowship, as an interprofessional option for providers to learn through a
community-based online learning program.
Rationale: As the theme of this year’s conference is collaboration
in action, this fellowship model presents a cross-disciplinary and
interdisciplinary approach to community learning. We present a learning model
that incorporates fellows from conventional and allopathic health-care
professions, as well as naturopathic, chiropractic, and other licensed
health-care professions from nonallopathic traditions.
Objectives: The aim is to understand advantages and challenges to
distance learning programs using adult learning theory, hear from panelists the
challenges to participating in this type of interdisciplinary learning model,
and understand the process of board certification in the field of integrative
medicine.
Outline: The panel will be opened by the fellowship director, who
will describe the current structure of the AIHM fellowhip and its historical
origins. She will help set the context of the ABOIM certification process and
describe some of the challenges that have emerged in the creation of the
fellowship (10 min). This will be followed by presentation from the other
panelists of
• Dr Parker will share more on the technology platform used in the AIHM
fellowship, and the challenges of creating and maintaining curriculum for an
interprofessional set of learns (10 min).
• Dr Capelluti will discuss the benefits and challenges of having a clinical
immersion experience that serves the interprofessional audience (10 min).
• Dr Mehta will discuss some of the burnout issues that fellows face in
completing a robust curriculum over a 2-year period (10 min).
• Dr Hillinger will provide her firsthand experience as a current fellow as well
as unexpected challenges in completing this curriculum (10 min).
This will leave time for limited discussion in a 60 min panel. We would prefer
90 min or at least 75, for more dialogue with the audience, and the potential to
expand one or more of the talks to 12–15 min.
(3498) Bridging the Gaps of Integrative Medicine Between the United States and
China to Enhance Collaboration in Achieving Better Health Care
JianPing Liu, PhD1, Lixing Lao, PhD2, Ka-Kit Hui,
MD4 and Weijun Zhang, DrPH4
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
3Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview: There is growing interest worldwide in the development of
integrative medicine (IM) to improve patient care and the health of population.
In 2008, Health Ministers in China and the United States signed a memorandum of
understanding (MOU) to foster collaboration among scientists and clinicians in
both countries for IM research, which many believe would “improve the health of
the American and Chinese people.” However, our previous interviews with IM
experts in both countries indicated there is still a gap in understanding of IM
among both experts at the individual level and academic institutions at the
organizational/system level. These leading factors are currently hindering
effective collaboration. In this symposium, speakers from both countries who are
experienced in IM systems will share their knowledge and experience about
differences in IM modalities, poractice, and research in order to strengthen
future collaboration.
Rationale: The current conference theme is to improve health care
through better collaboration among IM experts and institutions in research,
education, and clinical practice. Chinese integrative medicine and Western
integrative medicine are 2 leading IM systems. However, clinical practice and
research focus in these 2 systems have shown many differences in areas such as
workforce, characteristics considered in research design, the range of commonly
seen diseases/conditions, modalities utilized in clinical practice, guideline
development in clinical practice, and so forth. A better appreciation of IM
development in China will broaden the knowledge base for IM experts outside of
China as well and facilitate collaboration worldwide.
Objectives: Upon completion of the session, participants are
expected to be able to understand essential features/approaches of integrative
medicine in China and the United States, understand evidence-based practice and
unique characteristics of research design in Chinese integrative medicine,
describe the clinical practice of integrative medicine in hospitals and
community facilities in China, and apply potential approaches for better
advancing integrative health care through collaboration among experts and
organizations of integrative medicine in both China and the United States.
Outline:
Introduction: the approaches of integrative medicine in China and
differences from integrative medicine in the West
Topic 1: How can research design represent both scientific rigor and
characteristics of Chinese integrative medicine?
Topic 2: Integrative medicine practice in hospitals and community facilities in
China
Topic 3: How can experts and organizations of integrative medicine in both China
and the United States collaborate effectively?
(3523) Pain Freeing Qigong and Meditative Techniques
CJ Rhoads, DEd1 and Elaine Mendelsohn, RN, BSN, LMT2
1Kutztown University, Kutztown, Pennsylvania
2HealthSouth Rehabilitation Hospital, Reading, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: It is often difficult for integrative health practitioners
and professionals to understand the physical and mental pain of their patients.
Providing effective solutions is even harder. This workshop will discuss the
challenges of pain management, while at the same time providing practical and
timely treatment options for chronic pain. The participants will come away with
a greater understanding of the evidence-based research as well as practical
hands-on menus of options to implement with their patients. One of the
presenters has lived with chronic pain since November 5, 2002, when injured in a
devastating car accident. In order to get out of severe, unrelenting pain, the
presenter cracked the code of how pain works, and learned to short circuit the
pain mechanism so that the pain can be ignored. The presenter now lives a full,
productive, successful life. The experience has resulted in a dedicated focus on
sharing the lessons of pain freeing activities with others who are suffering
from unrelenting pain. This experiential workshop will go into depth about the
pain mechanisms and the different aspects necessary in order to free the person
from pain. While the lesson is scientific and biology-based, the presenter will
utilize the ages-old methodology of qigong as a model of delivering the lesson.
The qigong serves as a mnemonic to the activities necessary to stay out of pain
and live a healthier, fuller, life. In an iterative cycle, the qigong becomes
both the reminder and the method, as it forms one piece of the puzzle for
solving the sticky wicket of unrelenting ideopathic pain. The other important
aspect of pain relief is meditation activities. One of the presenters has
trained extensively in pain relief utilizing meditation and has successfully
treated patients using this pain freeing activity.
Rationale: Pain management is one of the most difficult issues for
modern medicine. Modern models of pain mechanisms are built upon earlier models
such as Melzack and Wall’s Gate Control Theory which became popular in 1965.
Earlier in the century, the medical community recognized only direct modality
pain signals. In other words, physicians did not consider sensory perception of
pain. They also did not recognize the adjustment of the nervous system to
stimuli that previously did not cause pain but then would begin to cause pain
inexplicably. Doctors would simply ignore pain for which they could not find a
cause, as if it did not exist. Rather than recognize only pain with a specific
ideology, Melzack explained how and why pain can cause itself and become the
modality. Melzack recognized the important relationship between pain and stress.
He was among the first to realize the powerful therapies available to decrease
tension (relaxation) and the variety of ways to decrease pain intensity and
break the pain-stress feedback loop which underlies so much chronic pain. He
used the term neuromatrix to describe any particular individual’s experience of
pain. More and more, the medical community is recognizing that neuroplasticity,
with its ability to change the structure and function of the nervous system
itself, may be essential to decrease intractable chronic pain. The brain
chemistry requires changes to alter an individual’s sensitization and modulation
of pain, particularly pain that no longer has an objective pain stimuli. Another
useful paradigm in conceptualizing and understanding pain issues is the
biopsychosocial model. This model uses a multidimensional framework to describe
the relationship between physical, psychological, and social factors that
influence the type, severity, and presentation of pain. Many factors must be
considered when assessing and treating pain; history, emotions, family status,
and numerous other variables. Unfortunately, these models and theories of pain
are relatively new and are sometimes unknown by currently practicing physicians.
There is sometimes a tendency among primary care physicians to dismiss
complaints of pain, especially when no physical pathology can be identified.
This has begun to change. One influence that has spurred more research and
development into this area is returning veterans who have a very high incidence
of chronic idiopathic pain. Even more importantly, however, it is often
difficult for people in pain to trust in someone who has never been in severe
unrelenting pain. The spector of “not being believed” is always hanging over the
patient’s shoulder, seeking out more costly and more dangerous solutions. This
behavior actually becomes part of the modality itself. One way to break this
cycle is to listen and learn from someone who has been there; someone who has
spent many months addicted to opiates to deal with the pain, and then found a
way to manufacture their own opiates within their own body chemistry in order to
decrease the amount of pain felt. This workshop will introduce the practitioner
to such a person and enable them to learn from those experiences.
Objectives: This experiential workshop will present both the medical
mechanism of pain as well as a case-study type solution to severe unrelenting
pain. The format of the lesson is presented as a mnemonic qigong which both
serves as one aspect of the pain relief mechanism and reminds the patient of all
the aspects of the pain freeing activities. The participants will be able to
understand the physiological pain mechanisms within the body, recognize the
pain-relieving mechanisms of mind–body practices such as qigong and meditation
and explain how they work, explain to others about the pain freeing mechanisms
of several different lifestyle activities, demonstrate a simple-to-reproduce
qigong and meditative activity that provides both an aspect and a reminder of
those pain-relieving mechanisms, utilize an educationally proven methodology to
teach patients and clients methods for their own pain relief, and know how to
follow the pathway to sharing the educationally proven methodology with
others.
Outline:
1. The physiological pain mechanisms within the body.
○ About the pain network and how the different parts contribute to pain,
including how acute pain can become chronic pain.
○ An appreciation for the development of chronic pain as a lifestyle disease and
an understanding of the causes and reinforcement of pain.
○ About biopsychosocial models of pain, reinforcement and extinction of pain,
partner influences, stress influences at work, in the family, at home, and
during free time.
2. The pain-relieving mechanisms of mind–body practices such as qigong and tai
chi and how they work.
○ The connection between the parasympathetic nervous system and the
pain-influencing nerve cells.
○ The connection between brain waves and the parasympathetic nervous system.
○ The connection between stress-reducing activities and brain waves.
○ Overarching information on utilizing new technologies to help patients in
pain.
3. The pain freeing mechanisms of several different lifestyle activities.
○ About biopsychosocial models of pain, reinforcement and extinction of pain,
partner influences, stress influences at work, in the family, at home, and
during free time.
○ The difference between health and unhealthy behaviors, cognitions, and
feeling.
○ Pioneering ways to help patients feel less tired and depressed despite acute
or chronic pain.
○ About the role of cannabis; Is it a novel and much needed solution, or a
wayward path?
○ Original research on cost effectiveness of various treatments for pain.
4. A simple-to-reproduce qigong that provides both an aspect and a reminder of
those pain-relieving mechanisms.
○ Pain mechanism forms
○ Pain freeing forms
○ Dosage in frequency and intensity
5. An educationally proven methodology to teach patients and clients methods for
their own pain relief.
○ Social aspect of group practice
○ Importance of frequency
○ Importance of imagery
○ Backed by research
○ Importance of support
○ Supporting the journey
6. The pathway to sharing the educationally proven methodology with others.
○ Innovative ways to communicate to patients the pain mechanisms so that they
can understand how pain management works—and which ones will work best for
them.
○ Novel ways of helping patients understand the important connection between
strength, energy, flexibility, nutrition, emotional states, hormones, and their
pain levels.
○ How to distinguish physiological subgroups and the necessity to vary treatment
based upon subgroups of pain patients.
○ Special concerns when it comes to helping seniors in pain.
○ Special concerns when it comes to helping cancer patients in pain.
○ Review of the groundbreaking research on methods to enable patients to live a
longer, healthier, happier life (methods that can help the practitioner as
well!).
○ Discussion of the most common comorbidities of chronic pain including,
fatigue, depression, isolation, and others.
(3565) Psychology and Integrative Medicine Collaborating to Treat Pediatric
Chronic Pain
Melanie Brown, MD1, Ashley N Junghans-Rutelonis, PhD1
1Children’s Hospitals and Clinics of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Overview: Integrated behavioral health care offers exciting
opportunities for medical and mental health professionals to work in
collaboration to provide problem-focused treatment. The purpose of this workshop
is to help integrative medicine providers (1) determine when to assess for
chronic pain and concurrent psychological difficulties that would warrant
referral to a mental health provider, (2) use brief assessment measures for
chronic pain, and (3) practice interventions to target central nervous system
centralization. Participants will increase their knowledge of and skills in
focused treatments for chronic pain and will engage in hands-on activities for
treating pediatric chronic pain within a medical setting.
Rationale: Pediatric pain can be acute, disease related, chronic
(eg, headaches or abdominal that has been present for more than 3–6 months),
pain that is the disorder itself (eg, complex regional pain syndrome) or a
combination of complex diagnoses. Estimated rates of pediatric chronic pain vary
widely, with 5% of youth reporting moderate to severe pain and a much wider
range depending on the pain severity, location, and frequency (4% to 88%
[intermittent headache]; see review article by King et al.). Pediatric chronic
pain has a significant negative impact on patient and family life and can lead
to additional health, academic, sleep, social, physical, and functional
difficulties lasting into adulthood. Recent research has shown the significant
impact of integrative medicine and psychological therapies on the course,
intensity, and duration of chronic pain. Given there are few providers who
specialize in treating pain, it is important for integrative medicine providers
to be able to identify risk factors for developing chronic pain and know how to
intervene early and effectively. It is also critical for psychologists and
integrative medicine specialists to work in collaboration to treat the mental
and physical needs of youth with chronic pain. Patients and families strongly
benefit from these 2 disciplines coordinating care to better understand
diagnoses and treatment options, including appropriateness of inclusion of a
psychologist for treating chronic pain.
Objectives: This workshop will introduce participants to the
concepts of integrated behavioral health care, chronic pain-focused treatment,
and collaboration of pediatric psychologists in your medical practice. It will
include 3 didactic modules: (1) determine when to assess for chronic pain and
concurrent psychological difficulties that would warrant referral to a mental
health provider, (2) use brief assessment measures for chronic pain, and (3)
practice interventions to target central nervous system centralization.
Outline: Integrated behavioral health care offers exciting
opportunities for medical and mental health professionals to work in
collaboration to provide problem-focused treatment. The purpose of this workshop
is to help integrative medicine providers (1) determine when to assess for
chronic pain and concurrent psychological difficulties that would warrant
referral to a mental health provider, (2) use brief assessment measures for
chronic pain, and (3) practice interventions to target central nervous system
centralization. Participants will increase their knowledge of and skills in
focused treatments for chronic pain and will engage in hands-on activities for
treating pediatric chronic pain within a medical setting.
(3579) A Hands-on Approach to Qualitative Methodology Using NVivo
Eden Robles, PhD1, Juliana Cardoso Smith, MA1 and Rubi
Gonzales, BA1
1University of Texas at El Paso, El Paso, Texas
Abstract
Overview: In this workshop, we will be providing a brief
introduction of qualitative methodology and its major contributions to medicine
and health research. The workshop will consist primarily of building analytic
skills in qualitative research using the NVivo software. Helpful suggestions
about the use of NVivo and resources will be provided. Attendees will be
strongly encouraged to conduct a qualitative analysis with the assistance of
panel members.
Rationale: Given the contemporary focus on the need for culturally
adaptive interventions and treatment in the health field, it is important for
medical professionals to understand qualitative methodology. This workshop will
be given as an introduction to health professionals who are interested in
understanding qualitative research. Professionals who are interested in building
their statistical skills can benefit from this workshop. Furthermore, being
proficient in quantitative and qualitative methodologies will be be beneficial
for professionals interested in conducting mixed methods research. More
importantly, this workshop aims to merge the fields of social sciences and
medicine. The panelists will demonstrate that other fields can utilize a
qualitative approach to better understand their respective patients,
participants, barriers for treatment access and utilization.
Objectives: Attendees will also learn the basic and fundamental
essentials of qualitative research and be able to successfully conduct a
qualitative analysis using NVivo. In addition, attendees will also know about
the resources available for NVivo users.
Outline:
Rubi: Intro to qualitative
• What is qualitative?
• How it differs from quantitative?
○ Philosophical assumption
○ Theoretical lens
• Benefits of qualitative
○ Previous clinical/ medicine
○ Opening doors to mixed methods designs
• Qual in health research—major publications?
Juliana: NVivo analysis
• What is NVivo?
• Basics 101
• Helpful strategies
○ Familiarize with data
○ Develop themes
○ code
• Dr Robles (Juliana and Rubi assisting) hands-on approach
• Trial download—attendees downloads software
• Dyad approach—2 people working together
• 3 small transcripts
• Analysis
• Interpreting data
All panel members
• Answering questions
• Providing resources available
○ NVivo website—community forum and support forum
(3588) A Collaborative Model for Delivering Acupuncture Services as Part of
Oncology Supportive Care in a Community Cancer Center—A Clinical and Educational
Partnership
Alexandra York, MS, CHWC1, Patsy L Astarita, LCSW, OSW-C2
1Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
2Upper Chesapeake Health, Bel Air, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: In 2015, the Maryland University of Integrative Health
(MUIH) and the University of Maryland, Upper Chesapeake Medical Center, Kaufman
Cancer Center (KCC) entered into a partnership to deliver an integrative
medicine model in a community cancer center. Through the vision of a shared
board member, who recognized alignment in mission and values, an opportunity to
meet mutual needs was identified. The KCC was looking to grow their integrative
medicine program and MUIH was seeking integrative clinical experiences for their
doctoral acupuncture students. This proposed symposia will tell the story of
this partnership utilizing a marriage metaphor (courting, engagement, marriage,
marriage counseling, recommitment, flourishing and growth) in which we share the
processes for establishing a partnership, program development, teaching clinic
development, implementation, challenges and opportunities, lessons learned, and
future work. More specifically, this symposia will highlight how KCC and MUIH’s
mutual engagement has transformed each organization at many levels.
Additionally, this symposia will engage attendees in creative thinking about the
available resources in their settings and community which could be utilized to
deliver integrative care in such partnership. The presenters will provide a
scenario and invite the attendees to breakout into groups to think through all
the aspects of implementing an integrative medicine model.
Rationale: This innovative model is taking place in a
community-based setting where the majority of patients receive cancer care. A
large academic teaching institution or major cancer center is not required to
enhance cancer treatment and deliver an integrative medicine model. This model
spotlights true collaboration and integrative care. In doing so, the following
needs are met for the institutions involved. For KCC, an opportunity to provide
enhanced, supportive care service to cancer patients and their caregivers; to
provide additional tools for symptom management readily available to cancer
patients; and to provide acupuncture safely with the approval of a treating
physician being mindful of the special needs of this at-risk population. For
MUIH, to provide a rich learning environment where doctoral students are
learning about oncology treatments, how to modify their treatment plans, and
developing an understanding of the operations of a traditional medical setting;
preparing students for communicating and collaborating with conventional,
medical providers; through the experiences and lessons learned at the KCC
Clinic, MUIH is enhancing the delivery of care at their Natural Care Center
(student-based clinic at the University) through continuous improvement and
additonal rigor. This symposia will demonstrate the exact theme of this
conference—collaboration in action. Both MUIH and KCC have advanced their
clinical practices, and MUIH has enhanced its educational programming through
this collaboration.
Objectives: Participants will gain knowledge and tools for how to
implement a similar model or strategy to delivery care in their own community
through collaborative partnership, understand important factors which should be
considered in collaborative partnership while trying to create a customized
model of integrative care in their personal settings and communities, learn
about barriers and challenges which may be encountered through this process, and
receive a call to action to consider developing a model that may work for them
and begin to think about how to apply all of the above.
Outline: Using marriage as a metaphor, each phase of the development
and implementation process of the integrative model will be presented along with
an overview of the structure and function of the student-based acupuncture
clinic. The following the questions and topics will be address:
• Why this was brought to our institutions?
• How was it started?
• Who were the stakeholders with this project?
• What were the challenges/stumbling blocks you encountered?
• Were there any financial issues/stumbling blocks?
• What did we learn?
• How was time managed?
• Allocation of time between institutions—did one do more work?
• Sharing of resources and tools that have come out of the process
• Communication considerations
• Program evaluation
• Future considerations
(3624) Pranayama: An Experiential Workshop on the Clinical Application of Yoga
Therapy Breathing Practices at a Veteran’s Administration Mental Health Residential
Treatment Program
Anita Claney, MS1
1Tucson, Arizona
Abstract
Overview: Participants will learn basic yoga therapy breathing
techniques, the objectives and goals of yoga therapy’s clinical application of
breathing practices with regard to mental health care, specifically
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and substance use disorder (SUD), and be
taught and learn to teach an introductory breathing practice to clients.
Rationale: From VA Solicitation: VA258-17-Q-0385: “There is
continued evidence of how complementary and alternative treatments for
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and substance use disorder (SUD) aid in
the treatment for veterans in the Mental Health Rehabilitation Residential
Treatment Program (MHRRTP). Specifically, in the PTSD track, data suggest
significant difference from cohorts that received little to no yoga therapy
compared to those that received yoga therapy twice or more per week. The cohorts
that received yoga therapy twice per week reported significantly less anxiety
and significantly less depressive symptoms. Over 6 years of clinical development
and refinement by a yoga therapist, breathing practices were implemented as the
primary yoga therapy treatment protocol in a residential mental health VA
program. These practices aided in the regulation of affect and mood over the
short and long term and were validated clinically as an efficacious component of
an integrative approach to mental health care.
Objectives: General understanding of yoga therapy breathing
techniques; objectives and goals of yoga therapy’s clinical application of
breathing practices with regard to mental health care, specifically PTSD and
SUD; the complement between neurophysiology and yogic breathing practices with
regard to autonomic nervous system function and regulation; and being taught and
learning to teach an introductory breathing practice.
Outline:
1. Introduction to Pranayama: Breathing techniques
2. Autonomic nervous system function and regulation and relationship to yogic
breathing techniques
3. Clinical objectives and goals with regard to PTSD and SUD
4. Participants learning-basic techniques of breathing, sequencing, and how to
teach a simple breathing practice
(3647) Yoga Therapy: Special Implications for Working With the Neurological
Population
Anneke Bender, PT, MSCS, RYT200, Lauren Tudor, RT, RYT 2001, Marlysa
Sullivan, PT, C-IAYT2 and Kelli Bethel, PT, C-IAYT, E-RYT
5003
1Sheppard Center, Atlanta, Georgia
2Maryland Univeristy of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
3Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Yoga therapy, a growing complementary and integrative
health profession, has gained rising attention as a method of treatment with
special relevance for the neurologically impaired population. Demonstrated
benefits highlight improved physical function, including increased strength,
balance and peak expiratory flow, decreased fatigue, decreased pain, and
decreased incontinence. Additionally, yoga has been demonstrated to positively
impact mood, psychosocial function, and executive functioning for this group.
Yoga is not merely a physical activity, nor is it wholly a meditative/mental
practice, and it is the intersection of these aspects which is the intended
point of focus. As such, yoga has unique significance and applicability for
those with neurological illness or injury in that it precisely targets a
neuroplastic response. In a systematic review of studies exploring Hatha Yoga
and executive function, researchers theorized, “ … increases in mindfulness may
improve focus on presented tasks while minimizing internal distractibility.
Furthermore, the absolute concentration required to balance and coordinate
movement through challenging, unfamiliar postures while synchronizing breath
patterns may also facilitate attentional enhancement.” This quality is of
distinct importance in a system whose sensory and motor responses are diminished
and more difficult to perceive. This presentation will discuss the evidence
behind the use of yoga for individuals with neurological conditions and will
consider the integration of yogic concepts and techniques into neurological
rehabilitation using an evidence-based approach. Rehabilitation professionals
will describe the development of yoga programs across the continuum of care:
during inpatient rehabilitation for TBI; as a community-based class outside of a
hospital/medical setting for individuals with ABI; as part of a comprehensive MS
Wellness Program; and working with the dementia population in both research and
clinical contexts. Special considerations for each populations will be
highlighted including adaptations in yoga therapy practice both relevant and
directed to the needs of that population.
Rationale: This presentation will discuss the unique role of yoga
therapy in neurologic rehabilitation.
Objectives: The aim is to describe aspects of a yoga therapy that
have relevance to neurological rehabilitation and to the facilitation of a
neuroplastic response, discuss current available evidence for the use of yoga in
neurological rehabilitation and identify clinical questions yet to be addressed
in the literature, describe the explanatory framework of yoga therapy including
potential mechanisms for the neurological population, discuss modifications and
variations of yoga therapy practices relevant to the needs of each population,
and identify a process for evidence-based integration of yogic techniques into
existing medical models across the continuum of care.
Outline:
• Overview of yoga and yoga therapy (Marlysa Sullivan)
• Yoga for dementia (Marlysa Sullivan)
• Yoga as a community-based wellness program (Anneke Bender)
• Yoga for stroke survivors (Kelli Bethel)
• Yoga for traumatic brain injury across the continuum of care (Lauren Tudor)
(3667) Integrating Ayurveda for Management of Chronic Diseases: Guidance for
Clinical Practice
Ram Manohar, BAMS, MD1, Anupama Kizhakkeveettil, BAMS, MAOM,
PhD2 and Sivarama P Vinjamury, MD, MAOM, MPH2
1Amritha Ayurvedic College, Amritapuri, Kerala, India
2Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
Abstract
Overview: In 2015, 70% of global deaths were attributed to
noncommunicable diseases (NCDs). Cardiovascular disease, cancer, diabetes, and
chronic lung disease account for more than half of deaths caused by NCDs
worldwide. These disorders are of long duration and generally progress slowly,
leading to reduced quality of life in the affected population, adverse effects
of treatments, and huge expenditures. However, through utilization of preventive
measures, the prevalence of NCD can be significantly reduced. Ayurveda
(literally The Knowledge of Life) is an approach to health care
that offers personalised life style and nutritional counseling for prevention as
well as management of chronic illness. Ayurveda offers a multimodal approach to
the treatment of these diseases with herbal supplements and therapies (including
biocleansing and rejuvenation) coupled with yoga to restore the harmony of the
body, mind, and self. Ayurveda can complement, supplement, and even provide
alternatives in certain conditions to conventional management of NCD, thereby
enhancing the quality of life, achieving progression free survival, or reversal
of disease. In this educational workshop, the theoretical approaches and
practical applications utilized in the management of selected NCDs will be
discussed. Attendees will learn about Ayurvedic diet, lifestyle modification,
yoga, herbs, spices, biocleansing practices, and therapies for the management of
NCDs.
Rationale: During our discussions, we will highlight the specific
clinical contexts for integrating Ayurvedic treatments in the management of
selected NCDs. The benefits, risks, and expected outcomes will be highlighted.
Since the potential of Ayurveda in contributing to integrative medicine is not
yet widely recognized, our session will provide new insights for the development
of integrative medicine, which is the major focus of International Congress on
Integrative Medicine and Health 2018.
Objectives: Participants will learn the principles of Ayurvedic
medicine; role of Ayurvedic medicine in preventative care of chronic diseases;
role of Ayurvedic medicine in management of chronic NCDs; and theoretical
approaches and practical applications for management of selected chronic
NCDs.
Outline:
• Introduction to Ayurveda
• Basic Principles of Ayurveda
• Preventative Care in Ayurveda
• Ayurvedic Approach for diagnosis and management of chronic diseases
• Explain Ayurvedic assessment of selected chronic diseases
• Treatment principles for the selected chronic diseases
• Diet and lifestyle for the selected chronic diseases
• Herbal supplements for the selected chronic diseases
• Therapies for the selected chronic diseases
• Yoga for the selected chronic diseases
• How the multimodal Ayurvedic interventions can be integrated effectively for
management of the selected noncommunicable chronic diseases.
(3670) Evaluation of an Integrative Teacher Wellness Program in a Baltimore
Public School: A Mixed Methods Study
Patrick McArdle, PhD1, Nate Costa, MS2, Chris D'Adamo,
PhD1, Deborah Gioia, PhD1, Ariel Trilling, BS3
and Brian M Berman, MD3
1Baltimore, Maryland
2FX Studios and FX Well, Baltimore, Maryland
3University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Two-year study of teacher wellness at an urban
elementary/middle school, a partnership between Under Armour/FX Wellness and
University of Maryland. Teachers received state of the art gym with trainers.
Data collected: (1) validated measures from Patient-Reported Outcomes
Measurement Information System; (2) qualitative semistructured interviews; (3)
wearable fitness data; and (4) school-level administrative data. Self-reported
improvements in health and health behaviors were reported.
Rationale: Study fills a gap in understanding a health intervention
designed to influence health and health-related outcomes and matches the
conference theme on collaboration in action because of
stakeholders: teachers, university researchers, and a fitness enterprise.
Objectives: Participants will learn about project design, engaging
external partners, measurement strategies, results, and future direction.
Outline:
1) Description of a health and wellness intervention
2) Interprofessional project considerations
3) Measures used
4) Onsite data collection
5) Results of the study
6) Next steps
(3671) Implementation of Hospital-based Infant Massage Program for
Parents
Elizabeth A Cross, PT, DPT, MSW, CLT1 and Lydia D Rawlins, MEd,
OTR/L1
1Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Massage is a therapeutic technique that benefits both
infants and parents in the home and medical settings. It relaxes and minimizes
stress and relieves stomach discomfort from constipation, gas, and colic. It
normalizes muscle tone, helps circulation, and promotes infant sleep. A more
restful sleep stimulates brain development and enhances sensory awareness.
Additionally, the caregiver/infant bond is strengthened through this nurturing
connection. When parents are able to interpret the messages that their infant
conveys through behavioral cues and body language they become more aware of
their infant’s needs and are better able to respond in a more timely manner.
Through a hands-on experience, presentation, and written didactic, attendees
will learn how to implement a hospital-based parent and infant massage program
for clients inpatient and outpatient setting.
Rationale: The Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) is a very complex
and highly specialized hospital environment designed to care for infant who are
born prematurely or critically ill. Current research suggests it is this same
environment that may have adverse impact on infant development particularly in 3
areas. These areas are premature exposure to light, prolonged exposure to loud
noise, and adverse touch experiences. The NICU environment has made successful
efforts to reduce light and noise exposure to infants in their milieu however
adverse touch experiences continues to be a challenge. Existing literature
indicates premature infants are most likely to be exposed to the greatest number
of painful stimuli in the hospital setting. Overall, 77% of the pediatric
population experience moderate to severe pain during their hospitalization.
Research also indicates that parents are often excluded from the infants care
due to their medically instability. This influences the infant’s exposure to
positive touch experiences, their ability to bond with their caregiver, and
subsequently impacts the development of infants. This influence transcends the
hospital experience to home. Current research indicates that massage relaxes
infants, minimizes stress, relieves stomach discomfort from constipation and
gas, reduces pain, encourages normalization of muscle tone, and helps
circulation. This supports infants’ sleep. A more restful sleep stimulates brain
development and enhances sensory awareness. Additionally, the caregiver/infant
bond is strengthened through this nurturing connection. While massage is a
therapeutic technique that benefits both infants and parents in the medical and
home settings, the challenge to integrate it as a standard of care in the
hospital setting remains difficult.
Objectives: At the end of the course, attendees will learn the
benefits and contraindication of massage, name materials required and
environmental considerations before initiating massage program in a hospital
setting, participate in massage experience, and receive suggestions for
implementation of infant massage program for inpatients and outpatients.
Outline:
Introduction to hospital-based massage program
a. Review power point
b. Provide guideline for implementation
c. Provide background skills for required implementation of program
Review curriculum design and developmental progress
a. Review of how to obtaining client participation
b. Suggested frequency of program
c. Designing sessions: Massage technique and review of developmental skill
Massage group experience
a. Simulation of massage training (2 techniques reviewed and 1 developmental
skill such as “Tummy Time”
Discussion and questions on infant massage in hospital setting
a. Review challenges to implementation of program
b. Suggestions for improving program obtained by participants from hosptial and
community settings (offer resources)
c. Entertain questions
(3847) Analysis of State Insurance Coverage for Nonpharmacologic Treatment of Low
Back Pain as Recommended by the American College of Physicians Guidelines
Robert A Bonakdar, MD, FAAFP, FACN1, Meg Sweeney, BS2, 3 and
Dania Palanker, JD, MPP4
1La Jolla, California
2Western University of Health Sciences
3The College of Osteopathic Medicine, Pomona, California
4Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: This session will report findings of a recent analysis of
state insurance coverage for nonpharmacologic treatment of low back pain (LBP)
as recommended by the American College of Physicians (ACP) Guidelines. The
results will be used for a broader discussion of how nonpharmacologic approaches
are viewed from an evidence-based and coverage standpoint as well as what
clinicians and policy stakeholders can do to optimize coverage.
Rationale: In February 2017, The ACP released guidelines for
non-pharmacologic treatment of chronic LBP. These guidelines recommended
utilization of treatments including multidisciplinary rehabilitation,
acupuncture, mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), tai chi, yoga,
progressive relaxation, biofeedback, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), and
spinal manipulation. These recommendations are one of the several recent
recommendations calling for increased use of nonpharmacological approaches to
pain. It is unclear how closely insurance parallels coverage for these
evidence-based therapies. Thus, it is important to understand the level of
coverage, rationale for noncoverage, as well as approaches for optimizing
coverage when clinicians are faced with these recommendations.
Objectives: The aim is to learn about Essential Health Benefits
(EHB) Benchmark Plans for each state which represent the minimum benefits
required in all new plans in the individual and small group health insurance
markets; learn their state’s coverage for nonpharmacological treatments
recommended by ACP guidelines; review how insurances statements view chronic
pain, physical, and mental health benefits and decide on the evidence for
various nonphamacological treatments; and understand current barriers to
insurance coverage as well as clinician-, policy-, and system-level options for
expanding coverage.
Outline:
• Other than spinal manipulation, evidence-based therapies recommended by the
2017 ACP guidelines were routinely excluded from state benchmark plans.
• Insurance coverage statements routinely viewed pain in terms of acute or
palliative care with little mention of chronic pain treatment in a comprehensive
manner.
• Current insurance coverage is outdated and seems largely arbitrary in terms of
coverage for evidence-based nonpharmacologic treatments.
• Coverage statements would benefit from clarity and expansion in the areas of
behavioral care beyond mental health disorders as well as multidisciplinary,
integrative care options for chronic pain care.
• Clinicians, students, administrators, and policy experts should be increasingly
aware of the disparity between recommendation and coverage in order to promote
evidence-based coverage and understand models for provide recommended care.
Note: the full abstract of the research that will be utilized as a
point of discussion is listed below.
Analysis of State Insurance Coverage for Nonpharmacologic Treatment of Low Back
Pain as Recommended by the American College of Physicians Guidelines
Background: In February 2017, The American College of Physicians
(ACP) released guidelines for nonpharmacologic treatment of chronic low back
pain (LBP). These guidelines recommended utilization of treatments including
multidisciplinary rehabilitation, acupuncture, mindfulness-based stress
reduction (MBSR), tai chi, yoga, progressive relaxation, biofeedback, cognitive
behavioral therapy (CBT), and spinal manipulation. We aimed to determine state
insurance coverage for these treatments.
Methods: The 2017 state Essential Health Benefits (EHB) Benchmark
Plans, which represent the minimum benefits required in all new plans in the
individual and small group health insurance markets, were reviewed for coverage
related to practitioner-based treatments recommended by ACP guidelines.
Additionally, modality and insurance specific publications related to EHB were
reviewed for comparison.
Results: Nearly all coverage statements did not specifically address
chronic pain. Modality coverage was highest for spinal manipulation with
coverage in 46 states. Multidisciplinary rehabilitation as an entity beyond
physical therapy could not be evaluated in nearly all state coverage statements.
Similarly, CBT coverage for LBP could not be determined in most cases as
although behavioral health coverage was noted, it was restricted in many cases
to mental health diagnoses. Acupuncture, massage, and biofeedback were covered
by 5 states or less with MBSR, tai chi, yoga, and relaxation therapy not
officially covered by any states.
Conclusion: Other than spinal manipulation, evidence-based therapies
recommended by the 2017 ACP guidelines were routinely excluded from state
benchmark plans. Insurance coverage statements routinely viewed pain in terms of
acute or palliative care with little mention of chronic pain treatment in a
comprehensive manner. Current insurance coverage is outdated and seems largely
arbitrary in terms of coverage for evidence-based nonpharmacologic treatments.
Coverage statements would benefit from clarity and expansion in the areas of
behavioral care beyond mental health disorders as well as multidisciplinary,
integrative care options for chronic pain care.
(3855) Heart of Caring Yoga Nursing
Damaris m Grossmann, RN DNPc1
1Rutherford, New Jersey
Abstract
Overview: The purpose of this activity is to enable nurses to
utilize yoga nursing to reduce stress, burnout and musculoskeletal problems for
themselves and patients through the utilization of diaphragmatic breathing,
gentle stretching, and relaxation techniques. Yoga nursing program content is
holistically orientated. addressing mind, body, spirit, and emotion. Yoga
nursing includes centering as well as spiritual learning sutras. Multiple
aspects of learner perception: multiple senses during educational experience
including deep breathing, movement, and deep relaxation.
Rationale: Health-care professionals are stressed, burned-out, have
many musculoskeletal problems. The desired outcome acquires knowledge and skills
to help reduce stress, burnout, and musculoskeletal problems; improves
well-being for self and patients; teaches individual stress management; improves
the immune system and overall health, resulting in decreased absenteeism and
sickness levels, decreases headaches; increases productivity, motivation, and
work performance; improves decision-making and creativity; increases energy,
mental alertness, and clarity; improves morale, job satisfaction, and positive
thinking patterns; reduces muscle tension and pain due to sedentary working
positions; improves flexibility and physical strength; creates team building
through relaxation; and yoga nursing remedies can be shared with patients—will
increase patient satisfaction outcomes.
Objectives: The aim is to describe yoga nursing; explain the
beneficial components of yoga nursing; explore the technique and benefits of
sacred breath; demonstrate the 7 essential therapeutic yoga postures of sacred
movement and describe ideas for incorporating postures into self-care and
individual clinical practice; describe beneficial components of sacred rest; and
summarize the therapeutic benefits of yoga as an adjunct therapy in nursing
practice and in a variety of clinical settings. Question and answer.
Outline:
1. Yoga nursing
a. Definition: The union of ancient yoga with modern nursing, new accredited
therapy, treatment for stress, anxiety, pain, suffering (SAPS).
b. Mission: To build an army of modern Nightingales, enlighten health care,
relieve SAPS in nurses and all they serve.
c. Yoga nursing sutras
d. SAPS
2. Sacred remedy
a. Sacred breath
b. Sacred movement
c. Sacred rest
3. ABC’s of yoga nursing
a. Awareness
b. Breathing
c. Circulation
4. Benefits of yoga nursing
a. Nursing self-care
b. Patients, hospitals, other organizations
1. Sacred breath
a. Science of breath
b. Components of 3 part breath
c. Examples of evidence-based practice utilizing breathing techniques
d. Physiological and psychosocial changes as a result of yoga breathing
techniques
e. Practice sequence of 3 part breath
1. Sacred movement
a. Seven postures: Mountain, Half Moon, Cobra, Forward Bend, Wind Relieving
Series, Knee Down Twist, Relaxation Posture
b. Adaptations and modifications required for self and clients with different
disabilities and conditions
c. Ideas for incorporating postures:
i. Self-care during breaks at work
ii. Patients who are bedridden
iii. Other patient populations
1. Sacred rest
a. Basic concepts and components of yoga nidra and meditation techniques.
b. Evidence of efficacy of yoga nidra and meditation in clinical practice.
c. Benefits for different patient populations
i. Post traumatic stress
ii. Heart, stroke, and cancer patients
iii. General population suffering from psychological, emotional, and physical
painiv. Care giver burnout
d. Practice one guided relaxation technique: the practice of Yoga Nidra
1. Evidence-based benefits list
2. Clinical settings
i. Hospitals
ii. Corporations
iii. Oncology clinics
3. Use as a component of practice for nursing excellence
(3876) Tibetan Yoga: Simple Breath and Movement Meditative Techniques for
Everyday Life
Alejandro Chaoul, PhD1
1Houston, Texas
Abstract
Overview: The Tibetan Yoga program that will be taught during this
workshop is based on ancient texts and teachings from the Tibetan Bon Buddhist
tradition as taught by Tenzin Wangyal Rinpoche. Parts of this practice have been
used at MD Anderson dating back to 1999. Since then, we have utilized these
particular Tibetan Yoga techniques that include breath and movement in
randomized clinical trials for people with lymphoma, and women with breast
cancer, as well as a single-arm trial for people with lung cancer and their
caregiver. Findings from these studies have been published in Cancer and
PsychoOncology journals. These are also part of our free group class offerings
for people touched with cancer (patients and caregivers) in our Integrative
Medicine Center. These practices have been adapted to remove any religious
aspects. People from any religious or nonreligious background can use them to
help reduce distress and improve mental function and overall well-being. We have
also used them in our meditation group for Faculty Health and Wellbeing at MD
Anderson and The University of Texas McGovern Medical School in Houston.
Rationale: Tibetan Yoga is not as well-known as Indian yogas but not
only they are an ancient mind–body practice which has been continuously
practiced for centuries without interrumption in Asia, but since 1999 we have
included them in reseach and clinic at MD Anderson Cancer Center’s Integrative
Medicine Program, with good outcomes for patients and caregivers. To create this
program, there was collaboration of Tibetan Lamas (teachers) together with
Western researchers, to bring an authentic mind–body practice adapted for the
contemporary western mind, and in particular people with cancer. In that way, we
are advancing integrative health through research, education, and into the
clinic.
Objectives: The goal of this workshop is to provide the participants
with meditative techniques that can help them release tensions and cultivate a
more relaxed, peaceful yet aware state of mind even in the midst of life
obstacles (eg, stress from work or other, fatigue, lack of sleep). In this way,
one can also cope with negative emotions such as anxiety, or anger, and learn
the ability to objectively and nonjudgmentally acknowledge those unwanted
circumstances or feelings and release them, returning to a meditative state of
mind that provides more choices than the flight-fight response. This also
supports cultivating the positive qualities (ie, love, joy, compassion, and
equanimity) inherent in all human beings.
Outline:
• Historical introduction to the concepts and techniques
• Importance of intention
• Applications in cancer care settings
• Breathing, awareness, and concentration
• Tibetan Yoga Movements
• Conclusion with sharing the benefits with others
(3879) Inspiring the Next Generation of Integrative Medicine
Rebekah Wilks1 and Marisa Soski2
1University of Western States, Portland, Oregon
2National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Overview: This interactive workshop will provide the tools necessary
to assist faculty and students in constructing Integrative Medicine
organizations at their respective institutions.
Rationale: The 2007 National Health Interview Survey conducted by
the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released that 38% of
Americans (114 million) used alternative forms of health care. It is postulated
that $7.7 billion are wasted by patients who utilize both forms of health care
but do not inform either their complementary or conventional provider. This
simultaneously increases healing time, the probability of interactions, and
cost; this is not reflective of patient-centered care. It has become
increasingly paramount to educate health-care professionals on the importance of
interprofessional communication and collaboration, especially when these
practitioners are students. The Student Alliance for Integrative Medicine (SAIM)
in Portland, Oregon, is working to teach budding professionals the importance
and value of Integrative Medicine. SAIM is a unique organization comprised
students from various health-care disciplines, including Chinese Medicine,
Chiropractic Medicine, Naturopathic Medicine, Occupational Therapy, Pharmacy,
Psychology, and Traditional Medicine. We were developed to address the necessity
for engaging medically focused students in integrative medicine before they
enter the workforce, so that they will be equipped with interprofessional
networking skills, knowledge of treatment modality effectiveness, and a general
respect for colleagues and other professions. SAIM has been assembling a tool
kit to be placed on our website that will help other students and institutions
begin to implement their own organizations and integrative medicine networks.
Ultimately, this workshop will help promote Integrative Medicine by facilitating
and motivating students and professionals to build interprofessional
relationships for purposes of attaining the goal of high-quality
patient-centered care.
Objectives: The aim is to outline the importance of involving
students in Integrative Medicine; present the SAIM tool kit; and help
participants develop concrete steps for creating their own organization.
Outline:
Importance of engaging students in Integrative Medicine
Tool kit components: with fill-in-the-blank handout and hands-on
components throughout, illustrating from website and engaging the audience
with a Moodleroom cafe
1. Identify key players at their institutions
• Find a faculty/staff mentor
2. Identify protocols for establishing a new organization at their
institution
3. Identify institutions in the area to collaborate with
4. Form an organizational structure
• Develop and implement a charter
• Fill officer positions
• Ensure continuity
5. Build a following/promotion/marketing on campus and in their communities
• Website/social media
○ Timing
○ Which platforms work best
○ Website structure
• Fund-raising
6. Event ideas
• Students/faculty/staff
○ Social/networking events
○ Educational events
• Interactive
• Speaking engagements
• Community
○ Integrative Medicine Day
○ Integrative Medicine Grand Rounds
Small presentations within breakout groups followed by constructive feedback
session
1. Brainstorm components in small groups
• Optional, time permitting: present small group discussion to the larger
group
Question and answer
(3895) Is Agni-the Ayurvedic Gut Microbiome? Principles and Practical
Implications for Integrative Health-care Practitioners
Anupama Kizhakkeveettil, BAMS, MAOM, PhD1, Sivarama Prasad Vinjamury, MD,
MAOM, MPH1, Jayagopal Parla, MD, MAOM1, Manjusha Vinjamury,
MD, MAOM1 and Bharathi Venkat, BAMS1
1Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
Abstract
Overview:
Agni is defined as the “digestive/metabolic fire” in Ayurveda.
Its central role in the disease pathogenesis parallels to the recent
understanding of the function of the gut microbiome. Optimal function of agni is
important for nutrition, immunity, and effects on the brain and behavior,
similar to the gut microbiota. In this educational session, the theory and
practical implications of agni will be discussed along with the
pathogenesis and evidence-based ayurvedic treatments for irritable bowel
syndrome, metabolic disorders, and depression. Additionally, ayurvedic herbs and
formulas used as prebiotics and probiotics for maintaining and restoring the
function of agni will be discussed. In the hands-on
experiential component of this workshop, attendees will learn how to prepare
simple ayurvedic herbal teas, organic ghee, juicing, yoga, and oil massages that
can be easily adopted in integrative practices as supportive care as well as use
these remedies for self-care.
Rationale: The presentation will focus on describing, translating,
explaining, and discussing ayurvedic concept of “agni” and communicate
effectively with other health-care professionals to demonstrate its similarity
with current knowledge of gut microbiome. The session’s focus will be to
articulate its relevance and use from a biomedical perspective. The individual
presentations will provide the relevance of agni and its evaluation in specific
diseases such as irritable bowel syndrome, mental health, and so on, along with
simple remedies that can be easily incorporated in integrative health-care
practices. The experiential component will offer the conference attendees
necessary skills to prepare certain recipes and teach DIY techniques to build
agni, which they can pass it on to their patients. The significance of this
session is its overall emphasis in 2 important areas: Integrative Health Care to
improve patient outcomes as well as patient empowerment using evidence based
information. Therefore, we believe that it matches the conference theme of
advancing integrative medicine through education and clinical perspective.
Objectives: Participants will be able to learn about ayurvedic
concept of agni and its relevance, assess status of agni, if relevant in their
practices, describe its usefulness in clinical practice, integrate some simple
DIY home remedies in their practice, experience the taste of herbal teas and
products, and describe the yoga postures and experience them as well.
Outline: The session will start with 5 brief presentations:
1. Overview of agni—theory and practical application
2. Ayurvedic prebiotics and probiotics
3. Agni dysfunction in the etiopathogenesis of irritable bowel syndrome and
metabolic disorders
4. Can agni imbalance in the gut cause an imbalance in psychological state
(depression) of a person?
5. Quick overview of agni and gut microbiome—similarities and differences. How
can you integrate it from tomorrow in clinical practice?
These presentations will be followed with an experiential session where in the
participants will touch, feel, smell the ayurvedic prebiotics and probiotics.
This session will also include the demonstration of preparation of herbal teas,
ghee, and oil applications. Finally, the attendees will experience yoga postures
and breathing techniques that focus on agni nourishment.
(3918) Approaches to Integrative Health and Mind–Body Strategies for Persons With
Hypermobility-related Disorders, such as Ehlers–Danlos Syndromes, Hypermobility
Spectrum Disorders, and Comorbid Conditions: A Movement and Mindfulness-based Health
Education Program
Kendra Neilsen Myles, BS1
1EDS Wellness, Inc., Bethesda, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Kendra Neilsen Myles, Certified Health Education
Specialist (CHES), RYT 200, founder of EDS Wellness, Inc. a Maryland-based
501(c)(3) nonprofit, joined forces with Dr Clair Francomano, director of The
Harvey Institute for Human Genetics at Greater Baltimore Medical Center (GMBC),
to establish evidence-based patient and health education resources on
integrative health therapies and to develop and implement a mindfulness and
movement-focused program for Individuals with hypermobility-related disorders
such as Ehlers–Danlos syndromes (EDSs), hypermobility spectrum disorders (HSDs),
and comorbid conditions. Combined with educational materials on integrative
health strategies, the ability to attend weekly gentle yoga classes with a
knowledgeable instructor and the support of a monthly mind–body-centered group
meeting, EDS/HSD patients are provided the opportunity to learn about and engage
in diverse self-care and mind–body-focused activities to help manage chronic
pain and other common symptoms associated with hypermobility-related disorders.
These activities include learning how to practice yoga safely with
hypermobility, engaging in several types of yoga practices, exploring various
breathing and mindfulness exercises, cultivating the principles of natural
movement and restorative exercise into daily life, and experiencing various
types of meditation.
Rationale: Through a collaborative agreement with Deborah Norris,
PhD, founder of The Mindfulness Center in Bethesda, MD (also a Maryland-based
501(c)(3) nonprofit), and led by a CHES, who is also a 200-h certified yoga
instructor, patients living with chronic pain and multisystemic conditions such
as EDS and HSD explore their fears discover their strengths and face their
weaknesses—all with a collective goal of increasing physical strength and
stamina, regaining function, finding self-empowerment over the medical
condition(s) they live with, and improving their general health status. This
program culminates in a mind–body-focused exploration in discovering
evidence-based integrative strategies for living well. Clinical
significance: EDSs are the collection of disorders that affect the
structure or function of collagen, the most abundant protein in the body. Since
collagen is in nearly every type of connective tissue in our bodies, including
our bones and blood, EDS often impacts each system in the body in some way. EDS
is believed by some researchers and specialists to be the “most neglected
disorder(s) in modern medicine.” Previously believed to be “rare,”
geneticists and providers who specialize in the diagnosis
and management of patients with hypermobility-related disorders, such as EDS,
believe that in reality, EDS is “rarely diagnosed.” In the persistent quest to
validate and understand the numerous chronic and multisystemic issues EDS
patients face, EDS researchers and specialists collaborated on a major
classification update to all types of EDSs and introduced the newly described
HSDs—both groups of conditions fall under the broader hypermobility-related
disorders umbrella. The newly updated EDS and HSD classification was published
in The American Journal of Medical Genetics on March 15, 2017,
and includes management and care guidelines that providers of all specialties
can follow. However, despite the recent classification update or the increased
awareness in some groups, most of the mainstream medical community still lacks
understanding and knowledge on EDS, HSD, or other hypermobility-related
disorders. Additionally, other multisystemic conditions that often found
comorbidly with hypermobility syndromes, such as mast cell activation syndrome
and dysautonomia/postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, are also poorly
understood and overlooked. Patients are left lonely, often feeling hopeless, and
scared of either mistreatment or injury in the hands of uneducated providers.
They scramble, often alone, trying to pieces of their medical puzzle together
and search for ways to stop their bodies from becoming unglued—literally.
The result? All of us, patients, health-care providers, and
caregivers are left with the reality that we are facing a true public health
crisis—an epidemic of misdiagnosis after misdiagnosis, preventable medical
mistakes, and life-threatening disability—even death. Patients need treatment
options and hope. Most will never live to see a cure, and waiting for
researchers to discover the gene responsible for hypermobile EDS, will not help
us find ways to live well now. Hence, the rationale behind EDS Wellness’ mission
and vision to help patients learn ways to regain function and live as well as
possible now through research and the development of programs focused on
integrative health. The same rationale applies to the development of this
program and the submission of this abstract. We are facing a public health
crisis and the “EDS Spiral” can be haulted through proper professional and
medical education, the development and implementation of health education
programs and research initiatives focusing on integrative health strategies—we
need to help patients help themselves.
Objectives: Based on Jon Kabat-Zinn’s Mindfulness-Based
Stress Reduction Program, patients employ the use of gentle
movement and meditation as self-directed strategies for managing chronic pain
and other symptoms often associated EDS, HSD, and other multisystemic
conditions. Movement and mindfulness-based activities are used to help guide
patients to uncover long-standing insecurities surrounding their health and
explore their physical, mental, and emotional weaknesses in safe, supportive
environment. Patients are challenged to hone lifelong lifestyle and behavior
changes needed to regain confidence, a sense of personal control over their
health care, and stability in their overall well-being.
Outline: Over the past year, approximately 20 individuals have
developed lifestyle and mind–body strategies for living well with EDS, HSD and
related chronic conditions, evolved through slow and deliberate behavior
changes, and learned through participation our program. Postimplementation
program evaluation includes interactive group participation, weekly or monthly
program, and attendance and completion of the postprogram evaluation and
feedback survey. Individual gains are evident through increased physical
strength and endurance, improved mental and emotional health, regular
journaling, and a commitment to a consistent, self-directed movement and
mindfulness-based at-home program.
(3939) An Innovative Approach to Health Education: Blending “Informal and Formal”
Curricula to Expand Ancestral, Integrative, and Functional Medicine
Education
Robert D Abbott, MD1, 2, Adam Sadowski, BS, ND(c)3, Guillermo
Ruiz, ND4 and Zach Pope, BS, MD(c)5
1University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia
2Virginia Commonwealth University, Shenandoah Valley, Front Royal,
Virginia
3National University of Naturopathic Medicine, Portland, Oregon
4Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, Tempe, Arizona
5University of Tennessee College of Medicine, Memphis, Tennessee
Abstract
Overview: According to the World Health
Organization, a health-care system involves “all the activities
whose primary purpose is to promote, restore or maintain health” (The
World Health Report 2000—Health systems: improving performance).
This broad definition encompasses health-care practitioners, health-care
students, and patients. In recent years, the ancestral, integrative, and
functional medicine (FM) movements have helped empower all 3 of these groups.
The Institute for Functional Medicine defines FM as a system that addresses the
underlying causes of disease, using a systems-oriented approach, engaging both
patient and practitioner in a therapeutic partnership. The University of Arizona
defines Integrative Medicine (IM) as healing-oriented medicine that takes
account of the whole person, including all aspects of lifestyle. It emphasizes
the therapeutic relationship between practitioner and patient is informed by
evidence and makes use of all appropriate therapies. Ancestral Health can
broadly be described as an approach to health focused on optimizing lifestyle
habits involving diet, sleep, social interaction, movement, and spiritual
engagement based on the evolutionary history of our ancestors as well as our
more recent cultural relatives. An obstacle for all of these movements, however,
is that the delivery of information and educational resources is limited as part
of most formal medical education programs. Books, websites, videos, podcasts,
and even online-based trainings can be easily found on the Internet but not
easily organized or vetted for relevance and validity. As part of this panel
discussion, we highlight the need to expand one’s ancestral, integrative, and
functional medicine education beyond what is currently being offered through
formal trainings or beyond what may be entirely absent from many medical schools
and residency programs. The discussion will feature a family medicine resident,
a medical student, a naturopathic medical doctor, and a naturopathic medical
student each describing various ways to expand the “informal” integrative
medicine curricula.
Rationale: Health education and its delivery are changing. Medical
school costs are exceeding $200 000 and the demand for integrative and
functional clinicians well versed in lifestyle and root-cause resolution
approaches to health is outpacing the current supply. Many medical schools and
residency programs still provide very little nutrition, lifestyle, or
integrative medicine education as part of their formal curricula. The majority
of students are often unaware of ancestral, integrative, and functional
approaches to wellness outside of their formal school training and are often
easily overwhelmed by the breadth of knowledge required as part of their formal
education. Collectively, practitioners need educated and empowered patients and
patients need educated and open-minded clinicians. We are a worldwide community
needing change in order to promote health and need each other to thrive. This
panel discussion highlights the need to synthesize and broadcast some of the
most relevant health education resources currently available including both
freely available, informal educational resources, and formal integrative
medicine training programs so students and clinicians can expand/complement
their formal traditional medical training with a robust and comprehensive
exposure to ancestral, integrative, and functional medicine.
Objectives: Participants will be able to discuss the availability,
utility, and accessibility of educational resources with regard to an ancestral,
functional, and integrative approach to health; to provide a methodical and
practical approach for exploring educational resources with regard to identified
goals, intentions, and cognitive/learning styles; to allow one to appreciate the
need for broadening one’s approach and understanding of currently available
educational resources including both those that are freely accessible and those
available through formal trainings/certification programs; to expand their
“informal” integrative medicine education, utilizing a combination of resources
available outside of their formal training or institution; to engage in a
thoughtful discussion about the benefits and potential pitfalls of utilizing
freely available resources; and to brainstorm creative ways to increase the
number of “informed” students and clinicians with regard to ancestral,
integrative, and functional medicine. The additional aims are as follows: For
clinicians, to empower them to expand their education into integrative,
ancestral, and functional medicine as well as to provide them with a framework
to offer concise and individualized educational health resources/plans tailored
to the individual interests, concerns, and preferred learning style of their
patients; for students, to provide them with a practical, complementary
education plan to support their current academic endeavors, tailoring the
experience to their available financial resources and preferred cognitive
learning style; for patients, to provide them and their families with reliable
and relevant educational resources, to empower them to utilize a variety of
resources to aid in lifestyle and habit change, and to allow them to appreciate
the need for collaboration with an experienced holistic clinician when
necessary.
Outline:
Definitions and introductions
Define ancestral, integrative medicine, functional medicine
Define health education
Personal experiences
Each presenter will describe their personal experience and exposure to ancestral,
integrative, and functional medicine during their formal training and/or as part
of their current training
Main questions to address
Are current certification and training programs focused on integrative health
educating enough clinicians?
What are the gaps in formal and informal education?
How can students and clinicians discover and access resources outside of
formalized curricula and remain evidenced based?
How do we increase exposure to ancestral, integrative, and functional medicine to
more students, residents, and clinicians in training?
What are the current barriers to schools offering formal trainings and how can
students access reliable resources if their institution has no such integrative
medicine program?
What are the potential downsides of pitfalls of relying entirely on freely
accessible resources to provide the bulk of one’s integrative medicine
education?
What are the best short-term solutions to the long-term problem of creating more
engaged integrative medicine practitioners?
Discussion: Open audience discussion and question and answer for
panel.
Poster Research, Nonresearch Abstracts
(1069) Philosophical Principles of Healing in Reference to the Yoga Sutras of
Patanjali
Ji Yashoda, PhD1
1Indian Board of Alternative Medicines, Berlin, Germany
Abstract
Purpose/Objective: The purpose of this qualitative study is to examine the role
of Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras in supporting experiences of healing, holistic
health, and wholeness in advanced Western yoga practitioners. Multiple studies
have shown the potential positive health effects of yoga, yet little is known
about the holistic health experiences of those individuals to whom the entirety
of the practice and philosophy as laid out by Patanjali is accessible and who
properly study and practice according to the Yoga Sutras.
Results: Data analysis suggests that yoga practice in the form of
studying Patanjali’s yoga philosophy and following its prescribed practice,
results in subjective holistic health experiences, and furthers the experience
of the transpersonal self.
Conclusions: Expansion of consciousness promotes healing, health,
and wholeness. Patanjali’s cosmic yoga philosophy aids in expanding
participant’s consciousness into wholeness, thereby affirming classical yoga’s
claim that in an ultimate sense healing is liberation (Kaivalya) from suffering
and wrong identification (Avidya).
(1073) Management of Primary Ovarian Insufficiency With Herbal Medicine and
Acupuncture: 3 Case Reports
Eun-Ji Choi, BD and Jae-An Shin, BD1
1Jayoon Oriental Medical Clinic, Gyeonggi-do, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Primary ovarian insufficiency (POI) is the dysfunction of
ovaries before age 40. There are conventional management options such as hormone
therapy, psychosocial support, and routine health assessment. Recently, herbal
medicine and acupuncture have also been used to support women’s health. The aim
of this study was to describe the outcome of the herbal medicine and acupuncture
treatments in 3 women with POI.
Results: After the treatment, the follicle stimulating hormone (FSH)
and estradiol levels of all patients were normalized, and they had periods of
menstruation. The FSH levels dropped from 100.4 to 8.0 mIU/mL (case 1), 96.3 to
5.6 mIU/mL (case 2), and 73.9 to 5.2 mIU/mL (case 3). Estradiol levels increased
from <10 to 230 pg/mL (case 1), 10 to 552 pg/mL (case 2), and <10 to
191 pg/mL (case 3). Case 1 and 2 had 2 periods, and case 3 had 4 periods during
treatment.
Conclusions: This study suggests that herbal medicine and
acupuncture may be potential therapeutic options for women with POI. Further
studies are needed to support the results.
(1076) Preclinical Evaluation of a Mistletoe Extract (Viscum
album) in Pediatric Tumor Cells
Melanie Schwermer, PhD1, Katrin Menke2, Jürgen Eisenbraun,
MD3, Alexander Schramm, PhD4, Alfred Längler,
MD5 and Tycho Zuzak, MD6
1Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
2University Children’s Hospital Essen, Essen, Germany
3ABNOBA GmbH, Pforzheim, Germany
4University Hospital Essen, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen,
Germany
5Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
6Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: In Europe, mistletoe preparations are one of the most
frequently used complementary and alternative therapies in adults and children.
Despite numerous preclinical and clinical studies, the efficiency and safety of
mistletoe therapies remain controversial. In particular, studies validating the
effectiveness in pediatric tumor entities are missing. Therefore, in this study,
the anticancer effects of a mistletoe extract (abnobaVISCUM Fraxini) were
investigated in pediatric tumor cell lines.
Results: All tested pediatric cell lines were shown to be more
sensitive to the dandelion extract treatment than normal human fibroblast cells.
Our results revealed an induction of apoptosis upon mistletoe treatment.
Elevated caspase-9 levels as well as a loss of mitochondrial integrity indicated
a contribution of the intrinsic signaling pathway. In addition, inhibition of
migration and invasion capacities was demonstrated after treatment. In in vivo
experiments, the intraperitoneal injections of allotransplanted mice caused a
reduction of tumor growth and prolonged overall survival rates.
Conclusions: In conclusion, our study provides first preclinical
data for the effectiveness of abnobaVISCUM Fraxini in pediatric tumor cells and
stresses the need for qualitative clinical studies to validate our
observations.
(1077) Taraxacum Officinale Extract Induces Antitumorigenic Effects in Ovarian
Carcinoma Cell Lines
Tycho Zuzak, MD1, Katharina Falke, BSc2, Jennifer
Felenda3, Christiane Beckmann, MD3, Florian
Stintzing3, Anette Voigt, MD4, Katrin Menke2,
Alexander Schramm, PhD5, Alfred Längler, MD6 and Melanie
Schwermer, PhD4
1Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
2University Children’s Hospital Essen, Essen, Germany
3WALA Heilmittel GmbH, Bad Boll/Eckwälden, Germany
4Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
5University Hospital Essen, University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen,
Germany
6Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Ovarian carcinoma is the most lethal of all gynecological
cancers and the fifth most common deadly cancer disease among women worldwide.
Despite intensive multimodal treatment options including surgery,
chemotherapies, radiation, hormone therapy, and targeted therapies, the 5-year
survival rate (46%) unfortunately stagnates in the last decades. This fact and
also other reasons may be responsible for the increasing use of complementary
and alternative medicine. In Europe, mistletoe therapy accounts to one of the
most popular herbal preparation. For the treatment of ovarian cancer, it is
often combined with dandelion (Taraxacum officinale) extracts.
Thus, our study aims to shed light on the anticancer properties of a dandelion
extract as single agent or in combination with mistletoe preparations in ovarian
carcinoma cells.
Results: It was shown that both ovarian carcinoma cell lines were
susceptible to dandelion extract treatment within a panel of adult tumor cell
lines. In addition, the dandelion preparation induced apoptosis and reduced
mitochondrial integrity, indicating an involvement of the intrinsic apoptosis
pathway. Our data also elicited an inhibition of migration upon dandelion
treatment. Moreover, combinational treatment with mistletoe extracts revealed a
synergistic antiproliferative effect on ovarian carcinoma cells.
Conclusions: In conclusion, our results support the efficiency of
combination therapy including mistletoe and dandelion extracts for the treatment
of ovarian cancer patients in vitro. Nevertheless, efficiency and safety have to
be elucidated in further in vivo studies and in clinical trials.
(1078) Systematic Literature Search of Complementary Therapies for the Treatment
of Acute Gastroenteritis in Children With a Focus on Anthroposophic Medicine
Melanie Schwermer, PhD1, Alfred Längler, MD2, Tycho Zuzak,
MD3, Katharina Fetz, MSc4 and Thomas Ostermann,
PhD4
1Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
2Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
3Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
4University Witten/Herdecke, Witten, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Acute gastroenteritis in childhood accounts for about 10%
of hospital admissions and is still one of the major causes of death worldwide.
In hospitals and pediatric practices with an integrative orientation children
suffering from acute gastroenteritis are often treated with complementary and
alternative medicine (CAM) associated therapies. Therefore, a systematic
literature search was conducted to present an overview of applied CAM therapies,
especially anthroposophic therapies, indicated for acute gastroenteritis in
children.
Results: Here, articles for diverse CAM-associated therapies (eg,
anthroposophic medicine, herbal preparation, dietary management) were
identified. The majority of hits were reached for dietary therapy approaches
(124). Articles considering anthroposophic approaches constitute only 3.11% (7)
of all articles. Among these articles, 2 observational studies (WALA Gentiana
comp., WALA Bolus alba comp.), 3 experience reports, and 2 reviews were
identified. For the anthroposophic remedies used in these articles, a second
systematic search was performed. This search revealed surveys for Chamomilla,
Ipecacuanha, Podophyllum, and Tormentilla preparations (mostly homeopathic)
indicated for the treatment of gastroenteritis or its symptoms in children. All
surveys reported about successful treatment or even reduction of disease
course.
Conclusions: All in all studies concerning anthroposophic approaches
and medications, respectively, are deficient. The results of this study
underline that effort is needed to validate anthroposophic therapies in a
clinical setting.
(1079) A Systematic Literature Search: Anthroposophic Therapies in the Treatment
of Pseudocroup in Childhood
Thomas Ostermann, PhD1, Katharina Fetz, MSc1, Tycho Zuzak,
MD2, Alfred Längler, MD3 and Melanie Schwermer,
PhD4
1University Witten/Herdecke, Witten, Germany
2Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
3Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
4Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: In Europe, only few integrative pediatric wards exist—and
in Germany, 2 of them have a focus on anthroposophic medicine as part of
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). Whilst the most common pediatric
diseases are treated here, pseudocroup patients make up a large group in these
hospitals, receiving conventional as well as anthroposophic therapies. However,
effectiveness of these therapy concepts mostly based on physician’s experiences,
but clinical studies are hitherto missing.
Results: One retrospective study and 5 experience reports describing
anthroposophic treatments were found. Here, a broad spectrum of anthroposophic
medications (eg, Aconitum, Apis, Bryonia, Hepar sulfuris, Lavender, Pyrit,
Sambucus and Spongia) for the treatment of pseudocroup were described.
Conclusions: Our study demonstrates that clinical trials
investigating the scientific evidence for their effectiveness are sparse.
Therefore, development and validation of therapy strategies are required.
(1080) Rational and Effective Therapies for Children: Scientific Reappraisal of
Integrative Therapy Concepts in Anthroposophic Pediatrics
Melanie Schwermer, PhD
Alfred Längler, MD2, Tycho Zuzak, MD3, Katharina Fetz,
MSc4, Thomas Ostermann, PhD4, Jan Vagedes, MD5,
Markus Krüger, MD6 and David Martin, MD4
1Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
2Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
3Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
4University Witten/Herdecke, Witten, Germany
5ARCIM Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine,
Filderstadt, Germany
6Filderklinik, Filderstadt, Germany
Abstract
Overview: In hospitals with integrative paediatric departments and
also in outpatient situations, children often receive a supportive
anthroposophic treatment. These therapies are based on long-term experiences of
anthroposophic physicians, but clinical trials validating these experiences are
often missing. Therefore, we start a project to investigate anthroposophic
multimodal therapy concepts in children. The aim of this study is to present
validated therapy recommendations for frequent diseases in children (eg, acute
gastroenteritis, pseudocroup). For this issue, we develop a 3-step process: (1)
systematic literature search, (2) expert inquiry (Delphi-process) and (3)
prospective documentation. In the first step available literature for
complementary and alternative medicine-related therapies, with a focus on
anthroposophic treatments, for the relevant disease are searched to provide an
overview of applied therapy options. In the second step, a therapy
recommendation is developed based on expert opinions collected in a Delphi
process. Subsequently, our therapy recommendation regarding to effectiveness,
safety and economic parameters will be verified in a prospective study in the
departments of paediatrics at the Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke and the
Filderklinik (Germany). We concluded that these data will gain prestige to the
anthroposophic medicine to a broader public and facilitate remedy selection for
physicians in their fast-moving working routine.
Rationale: As anthroposophic medicine is an important part of
integrative medicine in Europe, especially in German-speaking countries, a
scientific basis for these therapies is essential. Therefore, our project will
contribute to scientifically underpin the use of anthroposophic treatments in
childhood and make it more accessible for physicians as well as health insurance
companies.
Objectives: We present a scientific process with 3-steps for the
reappraisal of anthroposophic treatment options for most frequent diseases in
childhood.
(1084) Descriptive Study of Medical Cannabis Patients in the Illinois
Compassionate Use of Medical Cannabis Pilot Program: Opportunities for Improving
Patient Care
Leslie Mendoza Temple, MD1 and Sara L Lampert, BA2
1Northshore University Health System, Glenview, Illinois
2Lehigh University, Glencoe, Illinois
Abstract
Overview: This study examines 166 medical cannabis-certified
participants in a North Chicago suburban Integrative Medicine practice. Patients
were as young as 6 and as old as 96 years old. Mean age was 58 years; median age
was 60 years. Race was predominantly Caucasian at 93.37%; 3.6% African-American;
1.8% Asian; 1.2% Hispanic. One hundred seventeen patients (70.5%) were female;
49 patients (29.5%) were male. Of the total cohort of 166 cases with medical
cannabis cards, 117 patients (70.5%) were subjectively judged and coded through
independent analysis of the physician’s progress notes to have successfully
completed an adequate, self-directed trial of medical cannabis. Cancer,
fibromyalgia, and seizures were the top 3 certified conditions in this medical
practice. 88.0% of patients who completed an adequate trial of medical cannabis
reported relief of 1 or more of their symptoms based on subjective review of the
electronic medical record. Insomnia, chronic pain, and anxiety were the top 3
relieved symptoms. 29.1% patients reported encountering barriers to obtaining
relief with cannabis. Barriers to use included undesired psychoactive effects,
uncertainty regarding cannabis dose, frequency, route, and strain, and
insufficient funds to obtain an adequate supply of medical cannabis.
Opportunities exist to reduce these barriers and improve patient outcomes,
safety, and satisfaction.
Rationale: Illinois is the 20th state to approve a medical cannabis
law in the United States of the 29 states plus the District of Columbia. With
more than half of the United States having a medical cannabis law (and some with
recreational use allowed), a growing number of patients are demanding medical
cannabis for symptom relief for various conditions. This project highlights an
Integrative Medicine practice in the north suburbs of Chicago, IL. The clinic
has certified 166 patients with eligible debilitating conditions like
fibromyalgia, cancer, epilepsy, multiple sclerosis, rheumatoid arthritis,
Crohn’s disease, and others. Patients with these conditions are likely to engage
in Integrative Medicine therapies which establish relevance of this project to
the conference. This project highlights opportunities to study medical cannabis
use to promote better outcomes, safety, and patient satisfaction through
industry improvements in staff education; enhance dispensary-patient-physician
communication; and streamline medical cannabis product offerings. The Illinois
Compassionate Use of Medical Cannabis Pilot Program (MCPP) Act commenced on
January 1, 2014, but experienced a prolonged hard start. The first dispensary
opened on November 9, 2015. As of August 2017, approximately 23 300 patients
were registered medical cannabis cardholders in Illinois, which is much less
than estimated projections. Physician certification has also seen a slow start
with only a handful of physicians writing a majority of the certifications.
Patient demand may likely exceed supply of medical cannabis-certifying
physicians in Illinois due to various factors including lack of education on
cannabis efficacy, safety, dosage, strain, route, and potential drug
interactions. Other factors contributing to low physician adoption of medical
cannabis may include paucity of quality clinical evidence, cultural stigma,
and/or lack of time during short office visits to name a few possibilities.
Additional challenges to the success of the Illinois MCPP may include
dispensary-related factors such as communication barriers due to logistic and
legal obstacles, dispensary worker training variables, and inconsistent and
varied cannabis products.
Objectives: The aim is to learn about how physicians certify
patients for medical cannabis eligibility; identify factors that can interfere
with optimal patient outcomes and safety with medical cannabis usage, that is,
dose confusion, financial limitations, side effects; learn about clinical
outcomes seen in an early phase of a state’s medical cannabis program, with
improvement in insomnia, pain, seizure, and nausea symptoms; and plan for
quality improvement projects that can improve patients’ experiences with medical
cannabis certification and dosing regimens. Examples include standardizing
dispensary staff training; enhancing Health Insurance Portability and
Accountability Act compliant communication between dispensary, physician, and
patient; and streamlining medical cannabis product offerings from
cultivators.
(1088) Acupuncture as Adjuvant Therapy for the Management of Cervical
Dystonia
Danny Bega, MD1, Kelley Park, BA1, Ania Grimone, LAc,
CH1, Fang Lin, LAc1 and Melinda Ring, MD2
1Chicago, Illinois
2Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: There are no curative treatments for cervical dystonia
(CD), therefore conventional management is aimed at pain relief and muscle
relaxation. Many patients with CD use complementary and integrative/alternative
interventions to manage symptoms, yet there is limited data on the use of
acupuncture for CD.
Results: Five subjects completed the study with only 1 acupuncture
session missed by 1 subject, thereby meeting our predetermined adherence goal.
All participants reported improvement from acupuncture. Only minor adverse
events were reported, with self-resolved discomfort in 1 subject, and
self-resolved minor bruising in 2 subjects. Data from exploratory efficacy end
points including visual analog scale for pain, a clinician global impression of
change, the Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale, and the Short
Form (36) Health Survey are presented.
Conclusions: Acupuncture is feasible and safe as an adjunct
treatment for chronic CD, and it is associated with subjective symptomatic
benefits.
(1091) Comprehensive Lifestyle Change Program in Elderly Patients With Heart
Failure
Marta Alhama-Belotto, MD1, James Gray, MD1 and Christopher
Suhar, MD1
1La Jolla, California
Abstract
Purpose: Cardiac rehabilitation has proven to be beneficial in
patients with chronic heart failure (CHF). In this study, we studied the impact
of adding a comprehensive lifestyle and psychosocial program to traditional
cardiac rehabilitation in patients with CHF.
Results: Eighteen patients were included, of which 11 were
randomized to the intervention group. Mean age was 67.9 ± 15.7 and 74.6 ± 11.9
years in the intervention and placebo group, respectively. Mean ejection
fraction (EF) was 31.3 ± 15.4 and 41.9 ± 10%. There were no statistical
differences in terms of EF, New York Heart Association (NYHA) class, and
guideline-directed medical therapy between groups. There was a trend toward more
significant improvement in the 6 MWD in patients in the intervention group
compared to placebo (63 vs −6 m change, P = .19, respectively),
as well as in physical function (521 vs 393 score, P = .06,
higher scores meaning better physical status) and depression (31.7 vs 54.4
score, P = .33, lower scores meaning less depression). There
was a statistically significant improvement in left-hand grip (32.7 vs 22.1 kg,
P = .003) and quality of life (QoL; 43% vs −6% improvement,
P = .02) in patients who completed the program. No
differences were seen in cognitive function or NYHA class between groups.
Conclusions: A comprehensive program focused on lifestyle and
spiritual well-being adds incremental benefit to CHF patients participating in
cardiac rehab. Our program shows improvement in QoL and hand grip strength, and
a trend toward better 6 MWD, physical function, and less depression in this
population.
(1093) Triggers of Psychological Trauma: A Tool to Empower Patients to Cope More
Effectively
Lesley M Teitelbaum, PhD1 and Ronald C. Fish, PhD1
1Psychological HealthCare PLLC, Syracuse, New York
Abstract
Overview: Trauma by its very nature overwhelms an individual’s
physical, mental, and/or emotional resources, thereby rendering that person
vulnerable to the memories related to that trauma. These memories can be
precipitated by environmental stimuli and may be associated with negative
behavioral coping responses. The consequences of trauma can shatter one’s
concept of self and may be associated with diminished self-efficacy, intensified
psychological symptoms, and threaten one’s ability to fulfill role
responsibilities. Trauma survivors may encounter environmental cues that trigger
memories of their traumatic experience that can intensify their psychological
symptoms, diminish their self-efficacy and emotional well-being, and threaten
their ability to fulfill their role responsibilities. To date, there are no
instruments in the extant empirical literature to assist patients who have
experienced trauma with coping with these environmental cues. We have developed
a psychoeducational, clinical tool that includes a 6-step process (ie,
reorienting, self-care, observing, refocusing, reframing, and revising) to help
individuals who have been exposed to traumatic experiences cope more effectively
with environmental cues that may trigger memories of those experiences. Each
step offers a psychoeducational overview of a particular behavioral health
technique with an associated exercise that offers patients an opportunity to
apply that particular technique to their life circumstances. This tool is
designed to be used in integrative health-care settings to (a) encourage patient
engagement and inform behavioral health treatment decisions; (b) promote greater
levels of self-awareness and increase ability to cope with environmental
triggers more effectively; and finally, (c) encourage active engagement in the
therapeutic process and promote post-traumatic growth. In summary, this clinical
tool is designed to empower patients to overcome their instinctive, emotional
reactions to environmental cues associated with their traumatic experience(s)
and promote greater levels of self-awareness, self-efficacy, and emotional
well-being in their day-to-day lives.
Rationale: Trauma can impair emotional well-being as well as quality
of life and is associated with increased risk of mental illness, substance
abuse, physical health concerns, and early mortality. Implementing
psychoeducational behavioral health tools within clinical settings can improve
the assessment and treatment aspects of the therapeutic process. We have
developed a psychoeducational, clinical tool to be used in integrative medicine
and health settings to assist patients with coping with triggers of their
traumatic experience and reengage with their world. This tool can be
administered by nurses, or primary care providers, as well as behavioral health
clinicians, to help patients develop new skills to cope with environmental
triggers of traumatic experiences. This tool is desgined to facilitate patient
engagement and help to guide and inform behavioral health treatment. Increasing
one’s ability to cope with reminders of traumatic experiences can be an
empowering experience that can improve the individual’s sense of self-efficacy
and emotional well-being.
Objectives: The objectives are 3-fold: (1) to develop and implement
a clinical tool within behavioral health settings to help persons more
effectively cope with triggers of traumatic events, reengage in the world, and
reintegrate their traumatic experience into their identity; (2) to use this
clinicial tool to promote engagement in behavioral health treatment, increase
interdisciplinary communication, and inform treatment intervention strategies;
and (3) to increase patient sense of empowerment, self-efficacy, and emotional
well-being.
(1100) Exploring the Role of Complementary and Integrative Health-care Providers
in the Diagnosis and Treatment of Obesity
Sara Diaz, David Victorson, PhD, Ashley Hite1, Beth Plunkett, MD,
MPH2 and Rita Elue, MPH2
1Chicago, Illinois
2NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the role of integrative heath-care providers in
the diagnosis and treatment of obesity.
Results: A total of 67 people responded, 60 of whom met the
inclusion criteria. Respondents represented 14 different professions including
physicians (MD—47%), licensed acupuncturists (Lac—13%), registered dieticians
(RD—8%), and nurses (RN/APN—8%). The accuracy of visual assessment of body mass
index (BMI) was 45%, and providers underestimated weight category 44% of the
time. This varied by the percentage of overweight/obese patients that providers
reported seeing in their practice. Those who reported greater obesity management
practices had higher accuracy than those who did not. Accuracy did not vary by
provider’s BMI, experience, or profession. The majority of respondents correctly
answered BMI knowledge questions (82%); however, only half said they regularly
calculated BMI (55%) or used it to determine weight status (48%). The most
commonly discussed interventions were physical activity, meditation/stress
reduction, and dietary changes. Few providers reported feeling comfortable
prescribing weight loss medications (15%) or discussing surgical interventions
(18%). The most common barrier to weight management counseling was because the
patient already knows that he/she is overweight or obese (52%).
All (100%) MDs, RDs, Lac’s, and nurses agreed that it is their profession’s role
to address obesity.
Conclusions: Providers feel it is their role to address
overweight/obesity and are frequent counselors; however, accuracy of visual
inspection is low, providers use BMI infrequently and do not feel comfortable
discussing medications or surgical interventions.
(1101) Correlation Between Constipation and Coughing in a Patient With
Interstitial Pneumonia Reflects the Traditional Chinese Medicine Theory of “Lung-gut
Connection”
Kosuke Mizoguchi, MD, PhD1, Masahiro Senju, MD, PhD2, Yusuke
Goto, MD, PhD1, Ryo Yoshinaga, MD, PhD1, Hiroki Inoue, MD,
PhD1, Hiromi Yano, MD1, Nobuyuki Yanagihara,
PhD1, Eichi tahara, MD, PhD1 and Yoichi Nakamura, MD,
PhD3
1Iizuka Hospital, Iizuka, Fukuoka, Japan
2Senju Hospital, Sasebo, Nagasaki, Japan
3Tochigi Cancer Center, Utsunomiya, Tochigi, Japan
Abstract
Overview:
Background: According to traditional Chinese medicine, the lung
and the intestine are a pair of related organ systems, although the lung has no
direct anatomical connection with the intestine. This idea is still not a
general medical concept in Western medicine, but recently, some studies have
reported the correlation of constipation and bronchospasm, high prevalence of
pulmonary involvement, and high cough sensitivity among patients with
inflammatory bowel disease. Here, we had 1 rare case that suggested the
correlation between constipation and coughing in a patient with interstitial
pneumonia. Case report: A 61-year-old woman in the terminal
stage of idiopathic interstitial pneumonia was suffering from severe cough. She
also had chronic paralytic ileus and chronic constipation, therefore it was
difficult to use codeine for cough suppression. When we tried using codeine on
her, it was slightly effective, but we had to cease it soon after starting due
to her abdominal distention and worsening of constipation. As a precondition to
use codeine again, we tried to improve her chronic constipation with herbal
medicine “Juncho-to” because usual laxatives were insufficient. It controlled
her constipation successfully, and unexpectedly, her coughing was decreased to
less than half of before and she did not need reuse of codeine. Improving her
constipation may have contributed to suppression of her cough. Although the
detailed mechanisms are still unknown, increased abdominal pressure associated
with constipation might press the lung upward and stimulate cough reflex, or
low-level systemic inflammatory process induced by chronic constipation might
possibly increase cough sensitivity. Conclusion: In the case of
the uncontrollable chronic cough associated with severe constipation
concurrently, improving constipation might lead to control coughing from the
standpoint of “lung-gut connection.” In addition, traditional herbal medicine is
a good option of an alternative treatment.
Rationale: It illustrated the necessity to see patients from both
standpoints of Western and Eastern medicine rather than from either 1.
Objectives: Knowledge that a new standpoint based on the traditional
Chinese medicine theory of “lung-gut connection” may help in clinical settings
and traditional Chinese herbal medicine is a good option of an alternative
treatment.
(1103) Exploring Mechanisms of Qigong Sensory Training Massage for Autism
Kristin Jerger, MD, LMBT1 and Aysenil Belger, PhD1
1Chapel Hill, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Despite the enormous worldwide prevalence of autism
spectrum disorder (ASD), its full impact has yet to be realized. Millions of
families worldwide need effective treatments to help them get through everyday
challenges like eating, sleeping, digestion, and social interaction now and
going forward. Qigong sensory training (QST) is a nonverbal, parent-delivered
intervention recently shown to be effective at reducing these everyday
challenges in children with ASD. This exploratory study aimed to (1) assess the
feasibility of a protocol for studying biological mechanisms underlying QST’s
clinical efficacy and (2) collect preliminary data of autonomic nervous system
(ANS) and prefrontal cortex (PFC) activity for mechanism hypothesis
generation.
Results: Protocol feasibility was confirmed with 95% completion
rate. Missing data (7.6%) were acceptable (<10%) but provided information to
make technical changes for future studies. Although exploratory and not
statistically significant, average high-frequency power midintervention was
greater during the massage (2.9, standard deviation [SD] = 0.3) compared to
video (2.5, SD = 0.5). PFC oxygenation decreased over time for both groups,
except during emotional faces, when it tended to increase in the massage group
with a concomitant drop in parasympathetic tone (P = .036). If
replicated in a larger group, these preliminary results suggest a possible
increase in PFC processing as a result of QST massage in autistic children.
Conclusions: This study demonstrates solid protocol feasibility.
Exploratory data suggest repeating this protocol with a larger sample could help
clarify the relationship between ANS and PFC activity induced by QST.
(1108) Social Interaction and Support Attenuate Pain-related Social Behavioral
Disorder in Inflammatory Pain Rat Model
Ruixin Zhang, PhD1, Fan Wu, PhD2, Ming Li2, Xinyun
Yuan1, Xueyong Shen, MD2, Ke Ren, PhD1 and
Brian M Berman, MD3
1Baltimore, Maryland
2Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
3University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: People with chronic pain show less social and recreational
activities. It is not known, however, whether social interaction/support
modulates pain-associated behavioral disorder. We hypothesize that social
interaction/support attenuates pain-associated behavioral disorder by inhibiting
the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) neuronal activities.
Results: (1) Rats with persistent pain showed a significant loss of
novelty preference to an unfamiliar rat; (2) social interaction/support from a
same-sex cage mate restored the novelty preference in male rats; (3) yellow
light stimulation inhibited neuronal spikes that were more frequent during pain;
and (4) the yellow light stimulation of mPFC restored the novelty
preference.
Conclusions: Our data indicate that the mPFC neuronal activities may
be correlated with social behavior disorder and inhibition of such activities
attenuates these abnormal behaviors. Inhibition of cortex neuronal activities
may be targeted for control of pain-associated behavioral disorder. Positive
social interaction/support may provide an alternative strategy to help patients
to cope with their condition. Supported by NIH R21 AT008467.
(1109) A Food-based Dietary Supplement Containing a Low Dose of Iron Improved
Markers of Iron Status and Quality of Life Among Nonanemic Iron Deficient Women
Without Any Adverse Events
Christopher R D’Adamo, PhD1, James Novick, MD2, Valerie Dawson,
BS, MS-IV3, Larry Miller, PhD4 and Termeh Feinberg, PhD,
MPH5
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2Charm City Research Group, University of Maryland St. Joseph Medical
Center, Towson, Maryland
3Baltimore, Maryland
4Miller Scientific Consulting, Asheville, North Carolina
5Center for Integrative Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Iron deficiency is the most common nutrient deficiency in
the world. While iron deficiency can often be resolved through dietary
supplementation with iron, adverse events are common and frequently preclude
compliance. The purpose of this study was to determine whether a food-based
dietary supplement containing a very low dose of iron along with nutrients that
increase iron absorption could resolve iron deficiency with fewer adverse events
than typically reported at higher doses.
Results: Twenty-three women participated in the clinical trial. Iron
deficiency was resolved among the study sample (mean serum ferritin:
baseline = 13.9 mg/L, 8 week = 21.1 mg/L, P < .001) and all
other markers of iron status demonstrated clinically and statistically
significant improvements (P < .04). Study participants also
reported reductions in the frequency and severity of fatigue and increases in
energy (P < .001). No adverse events were reported.
Conclusions: While larger studies are needed, a low dose of iron
with accompanying nutrients in this food-based dietary supplement resolved iron
deficiency and improved all other markers of iron status without any adverse
events. These findings suggest that lower doses of iron may be required if
nutrients that increase the absorption of iron are included in the dietary
supplement.
(1111) An Ongoing Randomized Controlled Trial in an Urban Methadone Clinic:
Lessons Learned and the Road Ahead
Zofia Kozak1, Annabelle Belcher, PhD1, Luana Colloca, MD,
PhD1 and Christopher Welsh, MD1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Methadone (MTD), a full mu-receptor opioid agonist, is a
commonly prescribed medication for opioid use disorder. A physician works
closely with patients to prescribe a dose that manages withdrawal symptoms and
craving, which are self-reported by the patient. The placebo effect reduces
symptom severity in a variety of diseases and may extend the therapeutic index
of pain analgesics via a placebo dose extension (PDE) paradigm. This RCT,
conducted in a West Baltimore city MTD clinic, examines the potential role of
open-label placebo administered within a PDE paradigm. Conducting this study in
a high-volume, inner-city MTD clinic presented several unique challenges. One
notable difficulty was integrating the study protocol into an already-congested
clinic workflow. Patients were approached to participate in the study on their
first day of treatment, when they typically have 4–6 h of intake procedures with
a variety of clinic personnel, from therapists to payment counselors. Fitting
the RCT study measurements into an already nonlinear intake process proved to be
a primary challenge. Other challenges included completing intake
procedures/study questionnaires while participants were experiencing acute
opioid withdrawal (ie, prior to dosing), and maintaining participant contact and
follow-up, most of whom were housing unstable. These challenges are redeemed by
the invaluable insights this study provides into the pulse of Baltimore’s opioid
epidemic. In this community-based setting, all participants were enrolled in a
local MTD treatment program and recruited directly from this ground source. In
contrast, an RCT conducted in a traditional research setting recruits outside
patients to participate in the specific research trial and often has
infrastructure setup to facilitate the clinical protocol. The demographics of
such participants and this specific infrastructure makes the study less
susceptible to the challenges described above; however, this may be at the
expense of obtaining a representative cross-section of the target population
being studied.
Rationale: Drug use is endemic throughout the United States and
increasing amounts of research dollars are spent investigating interventions to
stem this public health emergency. Addiction is a complex phenomenon to study,
as there are a wide range of factors thought to contribute to its onset and
progression. Research settings that closely resemble the natural environment of
those affected by the disease may be able to provide the most accurate and
representative insights. However, conducting such RCTs comes with unique
challenges. Having studied addiction both in a clinical setting (such as this)
and research setting with the National Institute on Drug Abuse, the presenting
author (Zofia Kozak, MSII at University of Maryland, School of Medicine), will
discuss the challenges and benefits of conducting addiction research in a
community clinical setting.
Objectives: The aim is to learn about unique challenges faced by an
RCT studying addiction within an urban, community MTD clinic; discuss the
benefits of conducting clinical research, particularly studying addiction, in a
setting that is interwoven with participants’ typical daily routine (ie, within
the walls of a community MTD clinic vs a research setting); and learn about how
the placebo response, which involves mind/body interactions, may be ethically
harnessed in clinical practice and about its potential in improving outcomes in
MTD-maintained patients.
(1112) Reliability of Ayurvedic Diagnosis for Knee Osteoarthritis Patients—A
Nested Diagnostic Study Within a Randomized Controlled Trial
Christian S Kessler, MD, MA1, Andreas Michalsen1, Claudia M
Witt2, Antonio Morandi, MD3, Abhimanyu Kumar4,
Kartar S Dhiman5, Shivenarain Gupta6, Katja Icke7,
Carina Bühner, MD1, Elmar Stapelfeldt, MA1, Manfred B
Wischnewsky8, Ludwig Kronpaß, MD9 and Vijayendra Murthy,
MD10
1Immanuel Hospital Berlin and Charité Medical University, Berlin,
Germany
2University Hospital Zurich, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
3Ayurvedic Point, Milan, Italy
4All India Institute of Ayurveda, New Delhi, India
5Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences, New Delhi, India
6J.S. Ayurveda College & P.D. Patel Ayurveda Hospital, Nadiad,
India
7Datamanager, Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
8University of Bremen, Bremen, Germany
9AyurSan-Zentrum Sankt Salvator, Sankt Salvator, Germany
10University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
Abstract
Purpose: Ayurveda is a traditional Indian system of medicine. The
customized Ayurvedic approach consists of a combination of several diagnostic
procedures and subsequent individualized therapeutic interventions. Evaluation
of interrater reliability of Ayurvedic diagnoses has rarely been performed. Aim
of this study was to evaluate interrater reliability of Ayurvedic diagnosis for
patients with knee osteoarthritis.
Results: One hundred twenty different ratings and 30 consensus
ratings were performed and analyzed. While high percentages of agreement for
main diagnostic entities and the final Ayurveda diagnosis (95% consensus
agreement on main diagnosis) could be observed, this was not reflected by the
corresponding kappa values, which largely yielded fair to poor interrater
agreement kappas for central diagnostic aspects such as
prakriti and agni (κ values between 0 and
0.4). Notably, agreement on disease related entities was better than those of
constitutional entities.
Conclusions: This is the first diagnostic study embedded in a
clinical trial on patients with knee osteoarthritis utilizing a multimodality
whole systems approach. Results showed a contrast between the high agreement of
the consented final diagnosis and disagreement on certain diagnostic details.
Future diagnostic studies should have larger samples sizes and a methodology
more tailored to the specificities of traditional whole systems of medicine.
Equal emphasis will need to be placed on all core diagnostic components of
Ayurveda, both constitutional and disease-specific, using detailed structured
history taking forms.
(1114) Development and Psychometric Properties of the Mindfulness Self-efficacy
Scale
Gurjeet S Birdee, MD, MPH1, Kenneth A Wallston, PhD1, Sujata G
Ayala, MPH1, Edward H Ip, PhD1 and Stephanie J Sohl,
PhD1
1Winston-Salem, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Mindfulness meditation is a popular Eastern-based technique
that improves quality of life. Participants in mindfulness meditation
interventions report a wide range of adherence to home practice. Understanding
self-efficacy for mindfulness meditation may improve understanding of adherence
variability. Self-efficacy also affects health behavior and is associated with
health outcomes. The purpose of this study was to develop and examine the
psychometric properties of a self-efficacy measure for mindfulness meditation
practice (Mindfulness Self-Efficacy Scale [MSES]).
Results: A majority of participants were White (95%) and female
(74%). The 9-item MSES was unidimensional with 3 subconstructs of attention,
compassion, and emotion. The omega hierarchical coefficient for the total scale
was 0.78, and test–retest reliability was intraclass correlation
coefficient = 0.85 (95% confidence interval: 0.80, 0.89). MSES scores were
positively correlated with the Perceived Health Competence Scale
(rho = 0.41), the 5 Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire
(observing, rho = 0.42; describing,
rho = 0.47; Nonreactivity, rho = 0.72; Acting
with awareness, rho = 0.48; nonjudging,
rho = 0.54), the Global Health Scale from the Patient-Reported
Outcomes Measurement Information System (physical health,
rho = 0.27; mental health, rho = 0.58), and a
Social Desirability Scale (rho = 0.42).
Conclusions: This study provides preliminary evidence that MSES is a
reliable and valid measure of self-efficacy for mindfulness meditation practice
that may provide insight into barriers to adopting and maintaining mindfulness
meditation as a health behavior that improves quality of life.
(1124) An Integrative Medicine Elective Rotation: Pre–Post Changes on Well-being
and Wellness Behaviors
Audrey J Brooks, PhD1, Ann Marie Chiasson, MD, MPH1, Racquel
Bustamante, BA1, Victoria Maizes, MD1 and Mei-Kuang Chen,
PhD1
1Tucson, Arizona
Abstract
Purpose: To examine changes in well-being and wellness behaviors in
medical students and residents participating in a 4-week Integrative Medicine
elective rotation.
Results: Four cohorts of participants have enrolled in this 1-month
rotation (N = 115), with most completing both pre- and posttest assessments
(N = 83). Statistically significant (P < .05) pre–post
changes were observed for all well-being measures with the exception of
emotional intelligence. Decreases in perceived stress, negative affect,
depression, emotional exhaustion, and depersonalization and increases in
positive affect, mindfulness, physician empathy, life satisfaction, and personal
accomplishment were observed. Changes in wellness behaviors including frequency
of days staying hydrated, servings of fiber, mind–body/spiritual practices,
socializing, quality sleep, and enjoying work increased; days eating animal
protein, red meat, drinking caffeinated beverages, and work stress decreased.
Greater increases in frequency of mind–body practices were associated with
greater improvements on burnout, mindfulness, emotional intelligence, stress,
affect, and depression (P < .05).
Conclusions: A 4-week elective teaching core aspects of Integrative
Medicine for both patient and practitioner health and well-being has a
significant positive impact on student and resident burnout, well-being, and
self-care behaviors. Integrative Medicine curriculum taught in medical school or
residency must be considered when designing medical curriculum that incorporates
physician well-being.
(1136) Association of Diet Quality With Overall Fibromyalgia impact, and
Psychosocial and Quality of Life Outcomes in Women With Fibromyalgia
Mei Chung, PhD, MPH1, Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc2, Andrew
Beauchesne, MS1, Zhuxuan Fu, MPH1 and Lori Lyn Price,
MAS2
1Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts
2Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Lifestyle modifications, including of diet and exercise,
have been widely disseminated for the prevention and treatment of chronic pain.
However, the relationships between dietary habits and fibromyalgia (FM) impact,
and psychosocial or quality of life (QoL) outcomes have not been well
studied.
Results: A total of 26 female participants (mean age = 56 years;
mean pre-intervention body mass index = 29.6) were included in the analyses. Of
which, 6 (3 in each intervention arm) participants reported that their diet has
changed since the end of the original trial. Diet quality of these participants
was better than general U.S. adult population (Table 1). Higher pre-intervention
self-efficacy and physical health QoL were associated with higher diet quality
(r = .62 and .32, respectively). Higher pre-intervention
levels of anxiety and depression were associated with lower diet quality
(r = −.43 and − .47, respectively). There were no
significant associations between diet quality and pre-intervention severity of
depressive symptoms, mental health QoL, sleep quality, or FM impact scores
(Table 2).
Conclusions: Better diet quality as recommended by the 2010 Dietary
Guidelines for Americans may be associated with more favorable psychosocial and
physical health QoL outcomes in women with FM. Our results are consistent with a
large cross-sectional study in women with FM from Spain (J Acad Nutr
Diet. 2017 Mar;117(3):422–432). Future studies evaluating the
effects of healthy dietary patterns on psychosocial and physical outcomes in
individuals with FM are warranted.
(1139) Effect of a 6-Week Yoga and Meditation Program on Medical Students’ Stress
Levels and Sense of Well-being Prior to Taking Exams
Lona Prasad, MD1, Aneesha Varrey, MD2 and Giovanni Sisti,
MD3
1New York, New York
2Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan
3Bronx Lebanon Hospital, New York, New York
Abstract
Purpose: Medical students’ stress is essential for academic
achievement. However, persistent stress may compromise performance and personal
health. Our study’s purpose was to determine the effect of 6-weeks of yoga and
meditation on medical students’ perceived stress and sense of well-being prior
to exams.
Results: A total of 13 women and 14 men participated. Median age was
28 (24 years–32 years); 48.1% Caucasian, 7.4% Black, 11.1% Hispanic, 11.1%
Asian, and 22.2% other. Paired t tests showed a significant
reduction in perceived stress (18.44 vs 14.52; P = .004) after
6 weeks. The Wilcoxon signed-rank test showed a significant improvement in
feelings of peace, focus, endurance, and fatigue. No significant changes in
happiness, positivity, personal satisfaction, self confidence, or patience were
seen.
Conclusions: Results show 6 weeks of yoga and meditation
significantly reduced stress and improved aspects of personal well-being. A
future larger study including a control group may help to validate these
results.
(1141) Integrating Psychology Into Integrative Medicine: A Pilot Clinical Service
and Training Program in Supportive Cancer Care
Elizabeth L Kacel, MS, Irene M Estores, MD1 and Deidre B Pereira,
PhD1
1University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Abstract
Overview: Integrative Medicine approaches to symptom management are
gaining popularity among cancer patients with unmet supportive care needs. While
chronic problems faced by cancer survivors are often physical in nature, many
patients also experience persistent psychological distress and impairment. This
presentation will describe a pilot collaboration between Psychology and
Integrative Medicine at a large academic medical center in the Southeastern
United States that is designed to evaluate and treat medical and psychological
symptom burden among cancer patients and survivors. We will explore ways in
which this innovative dyadic consultation model may positively affect clinical
practice, training programs, and research initiatives.
Rationale: Integrative Medicine services are often provided by
physicians and specialized practitioners (eg, massage therapist, acupuncturist).
Only select programs around the United States include psychologists who are
expertly trained in addressing the behavioral aspects of disease and symptom
management and the emotional concerns of cancer patients. This presentation will
demonstrate how collaboration between Integrative Medicine and Psychology may
(1) identify patients with psychological problems that may influence adjustment
to cancer and/or adherence to medical intervention and (2) increase efficiency
by triaging patients to determine the level of psychological intervention, if
any, they require. We will present preliminary data on patients seen in the
first 6 months of this program.
Objectives: The goals of this session are (1) to present a pilot
collaboration of service provision and training between Psychology and
Integrative Medicine within supportive oncology care, (2) to discuss the ways in
which collaboration between these specialties may optimize behavioral health
(eg, sleep, pain, mood, adherence) and maximize emotional well-being among
cancer patients and survivors, (3) to describe the ways in which this type of
collaboration may improve continuity of care and efficiency from an operations
perspective, and (4) to explore potential avenues for additional collaboration
via training and research initiatives.
(1142) Nonpharmacological Treatment on Fatigue, Depression, Disease Activity, and
Quality of Life of Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: A Systematic Review
Monthida Fangtham, MD, Jacob Louis Nash, MSLIS, Stephanie Hyon, MS1,
Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD, PhD2 and Chenchen Wang, MD,
MSc2
1Boston, Massachusetts
2Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: In recent years, nonpharmacological therapies have been
deemed as potentially beneficial for patients with systemic lupus erythematosus
(SLE). These include complementary and integrative approaches, physical and
psychological interventions. We conducted the systematic review to determine the
effects of these therapies to inform practice in SLE patients.
Results: Nine randomized controlled trial (RCT) studies totaling 651
participants met the inclusion criteria and were included in this review. SLE
disease duration ranged between 2.5 and 12 years, mean age ranged from 13 to 48
years, and 96% were female. The quality of trials was generally moderate to
good. Table 1 summarizes the RCTs evaluating the effects of nonpharmacological
treatment in patients with SLE. Of the 9 trials, 4 used exercise interventions,
4 used psychological interventions (1 group psychotherapy, 2 cognitive
behavioral therapies, 1 psychoeducation intervention), and 1 used
electroacupuncture. Three of the 9 studies utilized control groups consisting of
usual medical care. Other studies included control interventions of relaxation,
attention placebo, symptom monitoring support, minimal needling, and isotonic
and resistance exercise. Compared with the control conditions,
nonpharmacological interventions were associated with a significant improvement
in fatigue in 3 of the 4 studies (1 exercise, 1 psychological, and 1 acupuncture
intervention). Four studies reported improvement in overall quality of life as
measured by Short Form-36, compared to control. Two of the 6 studies also
reported improved anxiety and depression, and 3 studies improved pain after
interventions. However, 1 psychotherapy study did not find any clinically
important improvement in psychological distress, disease activity, and quality
of life compared to usual care. Also, no studies demonstrated a greater
improvement in disease activity with 6–20 weeks of nonpharmacological
interventions.
Conclusions: The review showed promising results for physical
exercise and psychological interventions as an adjunct to traditional medical
therapy for improvement in fatigue and quality of life. However, many studies
had small sample sizes and short intervention durations. Further high-quality
RCTs with longer follow-up periods are warranted.
References
1. Tench 2003.
2. Bogdanovic, 2015.
3. Abrahão, 2016.
4. Prado, 2013.
5. Karlson, 2004.
6. Dobkin, 2002.
7. Greco, 2004.
8. Navarrete, 2010.
9. Greco, 2008.
(1149) Improving Boston’s Health Network: Identifying Neighborhood-level Stress
Sources, Stress-related Behaviors, and Health Problems
Frank Conyers, BS1, Darshan Mehta, MD2, Helene Langevin,
MD2 and Gary Badger, MS2
1Osher Center, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Norwood, Massachusetts
2Burlington, Vermont
Abstract
Purpose: The role chronic stress plays in the development of health
disparities was demonstrated in recent studies that established the relationship
between neighborhood characteristics and idealized health measures. However, the
relationship between neighborhood stressors and their effect on stress-related
health problems and behaviors is unknown. In Boston, MA, the neighborhoods of
Roxbury, Jamaica Plains, and Back Bay, while within a 3 mile radius, have widely
divergent life expectancies (59, 78, and 89, respectively). This work aims to
map the distribution of perceived neighborhood-level stressors, stress-related
negative behaviors, and stress-related health problems in these 3
neighborhoods.
Results: Mean age was 58.1 years, with 52% women. There were
statistically significant differences in stressors across neighborhoods for 19
of the 27 questions (Analysis of variance P values <.02).
The largest neighborhood stressors were (1) Roxbury—cost of living, addiction,
and discrimination were the largest stressors (mean score: 4.1, 3.8, and 3.0,
respectively); (2) Jamaica Plain—housing costs, addiction, and unsafe
pedestrian/bike access (mean: 3.1, 2.8, and 2.0, respectively); and (3) Back
Bay—unsafe pedestrian/bike access, lack of affordable fitness facilities, and
noise pollution (mean: 3.2, 2.9, and 2.4, respectively). The highest reported
stress-related health problems were—(1) Roxbury—addiction, obesity, and lack of
exercise; (2) Jamaica Plain—addiction, insomnia, and chronic pain; and (3) Back
Bay—anxiety, chronic pain, and insomnia. The largest stress-related behaviors
were—(1) Roxbury—addiction, physical violence, and child abuse; 2) Jamaica
Plain—poor diet, addiction, and lack of exercise; and 3) Back Bay—aggressive
driving, lack of exercise, and intolerance.
Conclusions: The marked contrasts between the 3 neighborhoods could
guide strategies for improving the health of neighborhoods and individuals.
Further research is needed to investigate how stressors are embedded into
specific neighborhood environments and which interventions would best target
these barriers.
(1151) A Cost-effectiveness Analysis of Yoga for Chornic Low Back Pain
Lin Liu, PhD1, Laura Schmalzl, PhD2 and Erik J Groessl,
PhD1
1La Jolla, California
2Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
Abstract
Purpose: Yoga interventions can improve function and reduce pain in
persons with chronic low back pain (CLBP). Using data from a recent trial of
yoga for military veterans with CLBP, we analyzed the incremental
cost-effectiveness of yoga versus the study comparator.
Results: At 6 months, 43 (57%) yoga participants had a chronic
multisymptom illness compared with 18 (24%) of the DT group
(P = .003). The yoga group had significantly greater increases
in EQ5D scores than the DT group (mean change difference = 0.063;
P = .047). Adjusting for lead-in effects and diminishing
effects from 6 to 12 months, quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) gained over 1
year were estimated as 0.041. Total intervention costs including estimated
overhead were $550 per yoga participant and $85 per DT participant. Health-care
costs were assumed to be equal based on very similar utilization and AE data.
The incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were $1,395 per clinically
improved patient at 6 months and $11,341/QALY over 1 year. To adjust for
inflated intervention costs resulting from conducting a randomized controlled
trial in a limited time frame, a sensitivity scenario estimated that costs for
an ongoing yoga intervention could be delivered at about half the cost or
$287/participant. In this scenario, ICERs are lowered to $606 per clinical
improvement at 6 months and $4,927/QALY.
Conclusions: The results suggest that yoga, which is typically
delivered in a group format, is a relatively low-cost intervention and has a
favorable cost-effectiveness ratio. Using intent-to-treat data, yoga was
delivered for about $23 per session/participant and has been shown to produce
equivalent benefits to physical therapy which is often reimbursed at $100 per
60-min session.
(1155) Mindfulness for Chronic Pain: A Systematic Review and
Meta-analysis
Lara G Hilton, MPH1, Susanne Hempel, PhD1, Alicia Maher,
MD1, Eric Apaydin, PhD1, Lea Xenakis, MPA1,
Newberry Sydne, PhD1, Melony Sorbero, PhD1 and Maglione
Margaret, MPP1
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic pain, often defined as pain lasting longer than 3
months, can lead to significant medical, social, and economic consequences; lost
productivity; and larger health-care costs. Chronic pain patients increasingly
seek treatment through mindfulness meditation. Our aim was to synthesize
evidence on efficacy and safety of mindfulness meditation interventions for the
treatment of chronic pain.
Results: Thirty-eight randomized controlled trials (RCTs) met
inclusion criteria; only 2 reported on safety. Interventions included
mindfulness-based stress reduction, mindfulness-based
cognitive therapy, and other mindfulness interventions. Medical conditions
reported included fibromyalgia, back pain, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis,
headache/migraine, irritable bowel syndrome, and others. We found low-quality
evidence that mindfulness meditation is associated with a decrease in pain
compared to all controls in 30 RCTs. Statistically significant effects were also
found for depression and health-related quality of life. The efficacy of
mindfulness meditation on pain did not differ systematically by type of
intervention, medical condition, length, or frequency of intervention or whether
offered as mono- or adjunctive therapy.
Conclusions: Mindfulness meditation improves pain symptoms,
depression, and quality of life; however, quality of evidence for outcomes is
low to moderate due to substantial heterogeneity and mixed quality of included
RCTs. Additional trials with adequate power, greater efforts to prevent
attrition, monitoring of adherence to meditation practice, active collection of
adverse events, and better reporting of methods are suggested to decisively
provide estimates of the efficacy of mindfulness meditation for chronic
pain.
(1157) Meditation or Exercise for Preventing Acute Respiratory Infection: A
Randomized Controlled Trial
Bruce Barrett, MD, PhD1, Mary S Hayney, PharmD1, Daniel Muller,
MD, PhD2, David Rakel, MD1, Roger Brown, PhD1,
Aleksandra E Zgierska, MD, PhD1, Mary M Checovich, MS1, Shari
Barlow, BA1, Supriya Hayer, MD1, Jodi H Barnet,
MS1, Elisa R Torres, PhD1 and Christopher L Coe,
PhD1
1Madison, Wisconsin
2University of Colorado, Fort Collins, Colorado
Abstract
Purpose: The Meditation or Exercise to Prevent Respiratory Infection
(MEPARI-2) trial was designed to replicate and extend MEPARI-1 findings of
reduced acute respiratory infection (ARI) in people who received meditation or
exercise training.
Results: Of 413 participants randomized (76% female, 85% white, mean
age 49·6 ± standard deviation 11·6 years), 390 completed the trial. In the
mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) group, 74 experienced 112 ARI episodes
with 1045 days of ARI illness. Among exercisers, 84 had 120 episodes totaling
1010 illness days. Eighty-two of the controls had 134 episodes with 1210 days of
ARI illness. Mean global severity was 315 for MBSR (95% confidence interval
244–386), 256 (193–318) for exerciser (EX), and 336 (268–403) for controls. A
prespecified multivariate zero-inflated regression model suggested reduced
incidence for MBSR (P = .036) and lower global severity for EX
(P = .042), compared to control, but not attaining the
P < .025 prespecified for null hypothesis rejection.
There were 73 ARI-related missed-work days and 22 ARI-related health-care visits
in the MBSR group, 82 days and 21 visits for EXs, and 105 days and 24 visits for
controls. On average, meditators used 28 (23–32) medications per ARI episode,
similar to controls 29 (26–32). Exercisers used fewer medications than controls
22 (18–26), P = .001.
Conclusions: Observed incidence, duration, severity, and impact of
ARI illness were modestly lower among people trained in meditation or exercise
than in observational controls. Further research is needed to confirm these
effects and to inform clinical practice and health policy.
(1162) Acupuncture for Pediatric Chronic Pain Relief: A Review
Yujuan Zhang, MD, Stephanie Hyon1 and Chenchen Wang, MD,
MSc2
1Boston, Massachusetts
2Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Evidence of the effect of acupuncture for pediatric
chronic pain is scarce. We have performed a review evaluate the effect of
acupuncture on chronic pain in pediatric subjects.
Rationale: Our review suggests that current evidence supports
acupuncture as a safe and helpful alternative treatment of chronic pain in the
pediatric population but is insufficient for a definitive conclusion. Rigorous
and well-controlled randomized trials are warranted.
Objectives/Background: Acupuncture, a type of complementary and integrative
therapy, has been widely used for pain relief in adults. However, evidence of
the effect of acupuncture for pediatric chronic pain is scarce. We evaluate the
effect of acupuncture on chronic pain in pediatric subjects.
Methods: We performed a comprehensive search of Eastern and Western
databases in MEDLINE and Chinese databases: China Hospital Knowledge Database,
China National Knowledge infrastructure, WanFang Data, and Traditional Chinese
Medical Database System until January 2017. Selection criteria included clinical
trials and observational studies of acupuncture in pediatric chronic pain
patients, sample size ≥8, and outcome measures included pain evaluation.
Results: We identified 142 potentially relevant studies. Eight
studies (total 493 participants) met eligibility criteria. Of the 8 studies, 1
was randomized controlled trial, 5 were nonrandomized controlled trials, and 2
were retrospective chart reviews. Four used traditional Chinese acupuncture, 1
used Korean hand acupuncture and 1 used Japanese style needle, the other 2 were
unclear. Table 1 summarizes the studies evaluating the effect of acupuncture on
pain measured with a pain scale on exam. More than 90% of subjects were able to
complete all treatments acupuncture was associated with a significant pain
reduction in 7/8 studies. All 8 studies reported improvement in pain-related
function after treatments. Four of the 8 studies showed a reduction in pain by 3
to 5 points on pain scale; 3/8 studies reported either a high percentage of
improvement in pain (70% ∼ 96%) or a statistically significant reduction on pain
scale (1.5 point, P < .001). One study reported subjects
with chronic fatigue had improved function (P < .01). None
of the studies reported any adverse effects related to the acupuncture
treatment, with 7 studies clearly stating that there were no adverse effects
from the acupuncture treatment. Discordant trial designs, varying outcome
measures, and methodological limitations precluded a pooled meta-analysis.
Conclusion: The current evidence suggests that acupuncture appears
to be safe and helpful in the treatment of chronic pain in the pediatric
population but is insufficient for a definitive conclusion. Rigorous and
well-controlled randomized trials are warranted.
References
1. Pintov S, Lahat E, et al. Pediatr Neurol.
1997;17:129–133.
2. Jodorkovsky R. Med Acupunct. 1999;Spring/Summer(11):1.
3. Kemper KJ, Sarah R, et al. Pediatrics. 2000;105(4 Pt
2):941–947.
4. Lin Y-C, Bioteau A, Lee AC. Med Acupunct.
2002;14(1):45–46.
5. Zeltzer LK, Tsao JC, et al. J Pain Symptom Manage.
2002;24(4):437–446.
6. Lin Y, Ly H, Bioteau AB. Acupunct Med. 2004;(16):21–23.
7. Lin YC. ASA Annual Meeting Abstract; October 13–17, 2007; San Francisco,
CA.
8. McDonald MJ. Med Acupunct. 2015;27(6):481–486.
(1163) Research on a Traditional Chinese Medicine-related Generation Tea With the
Efficacy of Antihypertension and Lipid Lowering
Hui H Zhao1, Li Xue Li1, Ming Gong1, Pei P
Wang1, Xi Tan1, Juan Wang1 and Wei
Wang1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose:
Wuweijiangyasan was stem from the empirical formula of veteran
doctors of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), which consists of Cortex lycii,
Gegen, Danshen, Hawthorn, and Burdock root. Meanwhile, it has the function of
purging liver fire, nourishing the Yin fluid of liver and kidney, and the effect
is either heat clearing and detoxicating or promoting blood circulation to
remove blood stasis. It is also acknowledged for tonification and purgation in
combination, Qi and Blood used simultaneously, to cure the hypertension with the
syndrome of TCM in liver and kidney’s Yin deficiency. Therefore,
Wuweijiangyasan has been known for its reliable effective
on antihypertension in clinical, which is valid for more than 85% hypertension
patients. Even more noteworthy is that Wuweijiangyasan not only
safe but also without side effects. The characteristics of the formula resulted
from its simple composition, less ingredients, small dosage, and the 5 Chinese
medicines are very common to see in clinical. At the same time,
Wuweijiangyasan is easy to obtain at a low price with
significant quality and efficiency. The directions for hypertension patients to
use are as follows: cortex lycii, Gegen, Danshen, Hawthorn, and Burdock root are
each 3 g, then put them together in a cup and pour boiling water to stewing for
about half an hour to make tea substituted. It just need to take 3 times a day,
respectively, after breakfast, a nap, and supper walk. The more crucial is to
have the antihypertension tea persistently. According to the antihypertensive
effect of the Wuweijiangyasan in clinical, then do animal basic
research to verify the antihypertensive effect of traditional Chinese medicine
for tea substituted. In the meantime, to study the effect of
Wuweijiangyasan on the systolic blood pressure and blood
lipid in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR).
Results:
Wuweijiangyasan showed significant antihypertensive effect on
the fourth weeks medication (P <. 05); at the same time, the
detection results of the SHR serum biochemical indexes even showed that
cholesterol (CHOL), triglycerides (TG), and low-density lipoprotein C (LDL-C) in
blood lipid were reduced to a certain extent.
Conclusions:
Wuweijiangyasan showed significant antihypertensive effect on
the fourth weeks medication (P < .05); at the same time, the
detection results of the SHR serum biochemical indexes even showed that CHOL,
TG, LDL-C in blood lipid were reduced to a certain extent.
(1164) An International Exploration of “Purpose-built” Art in Hospitals
Judy A Rollins, PhD1
1Washington, DC
Abstract
Purpose: The effects of viewing hospital artwork on stress reduction
and other medical outcomes is a growing area of investigation with implications
for integrative, holistic health. Disagreement exists about whether hospital art
is intended to challenge and provoke in addition to soothing and comforting. A
movement has emerged for unique “purpose-built” artwork designed to promote
other positive outcomes for patients, family, and staff. Research to date is
slim and primarily anecdotal. This international study, conducted as a scholar
at The Institute of Integrative Health, sought to identify examples of this type
of art and to explore the perceptions of the individuals who create, select, or
use this art; the principles that guide creation and selection; and evidence
regarding outcomes for individuals exposed to the art.
Results: Bespoke artwork was identified throughout the world.
Analysis revealed 8 major categories of purpose: (1) meditative, (2)
inspirational, (3) interactive, (4) remembrance, (5) messaging, (6) cultural,
(7) empathetic, and (8) community. Styles ranged from ambiguous and abstract to
realistic. Themes included patient experience, infection control,
artist-initiated “extras,” and the need for outcomes research. Some hospitals
are conducting or planning research, yet most cite lack of resources to do
so.
Conclusions: Findings indicate that hospital art is used for
purposes other than soothing and comforting and suggest that such art can have a
positive impact on individuals. Although most evidence remains anecdotal,
momentum is building for rigorous research in this area.
(1167) Competencies Developed for Hospital-based Massage Therapy
Dale Healey, DC, PhD1, MK Brennan, RN, MS, LMBT2, Carolyn
Tague, MA, CMT3 and Beth Rosenthal, MPH, MBA, PhD4
1Northwestern Health Sciences University, Bloomington, Minnesota
2Carolinas HealthCare System University Hospital, Charlotte, North
Carolina
3Laguna Honda Hospital, San Francisco, California
4Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health, Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Overview: As massage therapy experiences a resurgence of use for
hospitalized patients, it is appropriate to consider competencies needed to
practice in these settings. The hospital environment differs vastly from other
massage practice locations such as private offices, spas, and sports clubs. The
variety of conditions presented by the patients requires the ability to adapt
massage protocols appropriately. With this in mind, the Hospital-based Massage
Therapy Task Force was formed to determine whether there is a need for standard
competencies for hospital-based massage therapy (HBMT)_. If indicated, the group
would develop a peer reviewed set of competencies, which could be useful to
hospitals, massage therapy schools, and massage therapists. The members of the
task force identified massage therapists who worked in hospitals and hospitals
known to them that had massage therapy programs. A survey was created and
distributed to those who agreed to participate. The purpose of the survey was to
assess various elements of their massage therapy programs such as
educational/experience requirements, employment status, orientation, and
supervision. Thirty-two of the 37 hospitals completed the survey, resulting in
an 87% response rate. The Task Force considered the high response rate and the
extent to which respondents provided in-depth information to the open-ended
questions as support for a standard set of HMBT competencies for safe and
effective massage therapy for hospitalized patients. In addition to the survey,
the task force used a Delphi technique to engage survey participants and other
experts in the field to shape the initial draft of the competencies. The
resultant competencies specific to HMBT build on the Academic Collaborative for
Integrative Health (ACIH) Competencies for Optimal Practice in Integrated
Environments. As these competencies are shared with hospitals, massage
therapists, and massage schools, the Task Force members expect that additional
development of the competencies will take place as various groups implement
them.
Rationale: The set of HBMT-specific competencies created include
some of the ACIH Competencies most relevant to HBMT and additional competencies
that specifically address practical issues relevant to HBMT practice. As such,
we determined the following 3 areas for the HBMT competencies: hospital
environments, massage practice, and therapeutic presence. Hospital environments
includes values and ethics, charting, medical terminology, communication with
hospital staff, evidence-informed decision-making, roles and responsibilities,
credentialing, and informed consent. Massage practice competencies are focused
on understanding medical conditions and appropriately adjusting massage
protocols as well as understanding indications, contraindications, and
precautions. The ability to work around medical equipment, demonstrating correct
body mechanics, and recognizing one’s limitations in this environment are also
included in this competency category. Therapeutic presence focuses on working
relationships in the hospital environment with patients including appropriate
boundaries, communication, and self-care.
Objectives: As a result of this session, participants will be able
to discuss the process used by the HBMT Competencies Task Force to investigate
the need for HBMT competencies; discuss the process used by the HBMT
Competencies Task Force to develop HBMT competencies, including their
relationship to the ACIH Competencies for Optimal Practice in Integrated
Environments; Discuss the need for HBMT competencies; and consider ways in which
the HBMT competencies could be disseminated for use by hospitals, schools, and
practitioners.
(2167) Impact of Lactulose Breath Testing Thresholds on the Diagnosis of Small
Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth
Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH1, Doug Hanes, PhD1 and Laurie Menk Otto,
ND, MPH1
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the impact of lactulose breath testing (LBT)
interpretation thresholds on the diagnosis of small intestinal bacterial
overgrowth (SIBO).
Results: In the 20 symptomatic participants, the
frequency ratio of symptomatic LBT+:LBT− was 18:2, 15:5, and 19:1 based on
community, published, and lab criteria, respectively, with “positive” results in
90%, 75%, and 95% of the sample, respectively. In the 96
asymptomatic participants, the frequency ratio of LBT+:LBT−
was: 64:32, 63:33, and 71:25 based on community, published, and lab criteria,
respectively, with “positive” results in 67%, 66%, and 71% of the sample,
respectively. Self-reported frequency of poor concentration, sleep, and memory;
past or current gastroesophageal reflux disease or irritable bowel syndrome
diagnosis; and history of food-induced headaches were all more common in the
symptomatic LBT+ group (chi square test, P < .05 for each).
There were no differences in symptom frequency between asymptomatic LBT+ and
LBT− samples, by any criteria, including constipation in “methane
producers.”
Conclusions: The frequency of SIBO positivity is highly variable
depending on the interpretation criteria applied to the results. Positive LBT
results are common in asymptomatic individuals, and this finding should deter
routine use of LBT except for highly symptomatic patients.
(2170) Effectiveness of Integrative Health-care Support on Hypertensive Patients
in Japan
Kiyoshi Suzuki, MD, PhD1 and Hiroshi Katamura, MD, PhD2
1MOA Health Science Institute, Tokyo, Japan
2MOA Health Science Foundation, Tokyo, Japan
Abstract
Purpose: To examine whether adhering to an integrative medicine
approach toward normalizing blood pressure (BP) and reducing/stopping drug use
is more effective than conventional medicine.
Results: Of the351 subjects, 131 (37.3%) patients received medical
treatment at Tokyo Ryo-in Clinic (group A), 106 (30.2%) patients received
treatment at other clinics (group B), and the remaining 114 (32.5%) underwent
medical examination once a year and did not receive any treatment (group C).
During initial visit, group A were affected with higher severity of hypertension
than did group B (P = .015). However, at the last visit, group
A included less individuals with higher BP than did group B
(P = .015). In group A, hypertension improved in 78.7% of the
patients, and 29.8% either reduced/stopped antihypertensive drug use, and 10.7%
increased/started taking medication. In group B, hypertension improved in 61.3%
of the patients; however, only 1.9% were able to reduce/stop drug use, and 28.3%
either increased/started taking medication (P < .001). Group
C had higher number of patients with mild hypertension than any other groups
during initial visit, but hypertension improved in only 19.3%, and 3 patients
died before their mid-70s.
Conclusions: In hypertensive patients who received integrative
health-care support, approximately 30% could either reduce/stop taking
medication without the risk of adverse events. However, about 30% of patients
receiving treatment at other clinics increased/started drug use. Hypertension
did not improve for most patients who have only undergone medical
examination.
(2171) Effects of Different Types of Yoga on Hypertension: A 3-Armed Randomized
Controlled Trial
Charlotte Sellin1, Dania Schumann, MSc1, Holger Cramer,
PhD1 and Gustav Dobos, MD PhD1
1University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Clinical research suggests that yoga can induce short-term
reductions of blood pressure in hypertensive patients. Breathing and meditation
rather than physical postures seem to be the active part of yoga interventions
for hypertension. This study aimed to compare the efficacy of yoga with and
without physical postures for improving blood pressure in patients with
hypertension.
Results: A total of 75 patients (72.0% women; 58.7 ± 9.5 years) were
randomized to yoga including postures (n = 25), yoga without postures (n = 25),
or control (n = 25). After 12 weeks, the yoga group without postures had
significantly lower 24-h systolic blood pressure compared to control (difference
[Δ] = −3.8 mm; 95% confidence interval [CI] −0.3 to −7.4 mm;
P = .035) as well as compared to yoga including yoga postures
(Δ = −3.2 mm; 95% CI −6.3 to −0.8 mm; P = .045). After 24
weeks, the findings reversed: the yoga group including postures now had
significantly lower 24-h systolic blood pressure compared to control
(Δ = −5.3 mm; 95% CI −9.8 to −0.8 mm; P = .022) and to yoga
without yoga postures (Δ = −4.6 mm; 95% CI −9.3 to −0.3 mm;
P = .037). Comparable findings were revealed for day-time
systolic blood pressure. No serious adverse events occurred in any group.
Conclusions: In line with prior research, short-term effects on
ambulatory blood pressure were induced by yoga based on breathing and meditation
but not by yoga including physical postures. However, in order to induce longer
term effects, the inclusion of yoga postures seems to be required. Yoga can be
recommended as a complementary intervention for pharmacologically treated
patients with hypertension.
(2176) Changes in Coping and Quality of Life Among Children With Chronic Pain at
an Interdisciplinary, Integrative Medicine Pediatric Pain Clinic
Caitlin Neri, MD, MPH, Laura Goldstein, PsyD, Kristen Bodner, MPH, Salvatore D'Amico,
BS, Kelsey Macapagal, MPH and Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic pain in children and adolescents often result in
missed school, poor coping skills, and a decreased quality of life.
Results: From 2015 to 2017, 70 participants were seen at the
Pediatric Pain Clinic. Age groups include school age (30%), adolescence (54%),
and young adult (16%). Seventy-nine percent of participants were female, 42%
identified as White, and 27% African-American. Upon intake, 23 participants
missed more than 10 days of school in the previous month due to pain (34%). For
overall Integrative Medicine, 69% reported ever using; 23% reported current use
at baseline; 33% reported use at 3-months. For mind–body strategies, 56%
reported ever using; 16% reported current use at baseline; 30% reported used at
3-months. From baseline to follow-up, participants showed an increase in
positive coping mechanisms (8%) (eg, distractions, meditation) There was no
change in negative coping mechanisms. Results from the PedsQL showed an increase
in emotional quality of life. Additionally, PCS showed decreases in
magnification (P = .0035) and helplessness
(P = .0034). Among all 24 participants who completed the
3-month follow-up, school/academics was the most frequent self-reported stressor
(71% overall). In participants in the school-age and adolescence groups,
social/peer issues were the second highest (53% and 36%, respectively). However,
among the young adult group, parental stress was the second most reported
stressor (36%).
Conclusions: Overall, positive coping and emotional quality of life
increased among participants and negative coping decreased.
(2178) Mindfulness Meditation for Workplace Wellness: An Evidence Map
Aneesa Motala, BA1, Stephanie L. Taylor, PhD, MPH2, Nell J.
Marshall, PhD3, Isomi M. Miake-Lye, PhD4, Michele R Solloway,
PhD1, Susann Hempel, PhD1 and Lara G. Hilton,
MPH1
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
2VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Los Angeles, California
3Palo Alto, California
4West Los Angeles VA Medical Center, Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Purpose: Mindfulness interventions aim to foster greater attention
and awareness of present moment experiences. Uptake of mindfulness programs in
the workplace has grown as organizations look to support employee health,
well-being, and performance. In support of evidence-based decision-making in
workplace contexts, we created an evidence map summarizing physical and mental
health, cognitive, affective, and interpersonal outcomes from systematic reviews
of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of mindfulness interventions.
Results: In total, 168 systematic reviews met inclusion criteria.
Reviews included a variety of mindfulness-based interventions including
mindfulness-based stress reduction and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. The
largest reviews addressed general health effects, psychological outcomes,
chronic illness, pain, and substance use. Twenty-six systematic reviews assessed
studies conducted in workplace settings, health-care professionals, educators,
and caregivers. The evidence map shows the research volume and highlights
promising applications of mindfulness interventions.
Conclusions: The evidence map provides an overview of existing
mindfulness research. It shows the body of evidence to inform policy and
organizational decision-making supporting employee well-being in work
contexts.
(2180) Appropriateness of Spinal Manipulation/Mobilization for Chronic Low Back
Pain: Systematic Review
Ian D Coulter, PhD1, Eric L. Hurwitz, DC, PhD2, Howard T
Vernon, DC, PhD3, Cindy Crawford, BA4, Margaret D Whitley,
MPH1 and Marika Booth, MS1
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
2Honolulu, Hawaii
3Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
4RAND Health, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Systematic review of the scientific literature of
manipulation and mobilization for the treatment of chronic low back pain.
Results: A small-medium effect in favor of manipulation for chronic
low back pain patients with pain duration of at least 3 months or more. The
effect increased over time for reducing pain intensity. Manipulation was also
shown to reduce disability. In the case of studies that defined chronic pain as
12 months or more, there is insufficient evidence to draw any conclusions.
Evidence to support mobilization interventions is not as strong as the
manipulation intervention studies.
Conclusions: The multimodal studies programs, where the effect of
either manipulation or mobilization could be “teased out,” may be the most
promising style of interventions for patients’ overall benefit.
(2181) Appropriateness of Spinal Manipulation/Mobilization for Chronic Cervical
Pain Patients: A Systematic Review
Margaret D Whitley, MPH1, Eric L Hurwitz, DC, PhD2, Marika
Booth, MS1, Howard T Vernon, DC, PhD3, Cindy Crawford,
BA4 and Ian D Coulter, PhD1
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
2Honolulu, Hawaii
3Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
4RAND Health, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Findings from the systematic review of the scientific
literature regarding the efficacy, effectiveness, and safety of manipulation and
mobilization for the treatment of chronic neck pain.
Results: Patients suffering the consequences of chronic neck pain
for at least 12 weeks or more are likely to experience a reduction in pain
intensity with manipulation compared to sham or no treatment. There were not
enough data to assess the strength of the evidence for mobilization compared to
sham or no treatment for reducing pain intensity or disability. Manipulation
produces a much larger effect over mobilization interventions for reducing pain
intensity.
Conclusions: Other critical outcomes such as disability and health
related quality of life need to be included in future studies in order to draw
more definitive conclusions for addressing patient-reported outcomes.
(2182) Clinical Observation on Treatment of Adult-attention Deficit Hyperactivity
Disorder by Acupuncture Refreshing Brain Method
Ta-Ya Lee, PhD, DAOM, DNP, MPH, MBA1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Systematically evaluated previous 5 years of Chinese
Medicine to treat attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) research
literatures to explore the possibility and effectivity of utilizing the Xing Nao
Kai Qiao (XNKQ) acupuncture technique. Based on clinical observational studies
to evaluate the effectiveness of XNKQ techniques to treat adult ADHD patients,
and utilized literature reviewed of functional MRI acupuncture point researches
to explore the mechanism of using XNKQ technique for treating adult ADHD
patients.
Results:
1. Literature review
(1) There were 1803 articles in total listed with these key words, and only 691
articles left within the last 5-year limitation. A totally of 76 research
articles met the criteria for this literature review. There were 4 articles
(5.2%) rated high quality and 59 articles (77.6%) rated good quality for
research evidence, but most of articles did not fulfill the high quality of
research evidence. There were 9 articles (11.8%) rated level I, 5 articles
(6.5%) rated level II, 5 articles (6.5%) rated level III, 3 articles (3.9%)
rated level IV, and 37 articles (48.6%) rated level strength of evidence.
(2) The acupuncture treatment with ADHD prescription medication was better than
ADHD prescription alone, for improved ADHD symptoms, reduced medication side
effect, and showed statistical significance (P < .05).
2. Clinical research
(1) The baseline data
The adult ADHD self-report scale symptom checklist, Connors’ adult ADHD rating
scale screening tool compared patients’ differences in gender, none ADHD
medication, ADHD medication showed no statistical significance
(P > .05).
(2) The total effective rate
Totally 34 patients completed clinical observation study with 8 XNKQ treatments.
Overall, the scores of repeat measure scales indicated the decrease of ADHD
symptoms.
(3) The adult ADHD self-report scale symptom checklist
This scale showed a statistically significant difference
(P < .001) after 8 treatments, and there was a statistically
significant difference between the male and female gender
(P < .001). Based on the simple contrasts repeated measure
analysis, adult ADHD self-report scale symptom checklist had a statistically
significant difference (P < .001) after the first treatment.
The third, fourth, and fifth treatment survey scores stayed in plateau, with no
statistically significant significance (P = .056,
P = .065, P = .004). By the sixth,
seventh, and eighth treatment, the survey scores had reached the statistically
significant significance (P < .001).
(4) The Connors’ adult ADHD rating scale screening tool
This tools results showed a statistically significant difference
(P < .001) after 8 treatments. Based on the simple
contrasts repeated measure analysis, Connors’ adult ADHD rating scale screening
tools results had a statistically significant difference
(P < .001) after the first treatment. The third and fourth
treatment survey scores stayed in a quiescent period (plateau), with no
statistically significant significance (P = .426,
P = .030). The survey scores had reached the statistically
significant significance of (P < .001) by the fifth
treatment. The sixth and seventh treatment survey scores stayed in plateau, with
no statistically significant significance (P = .014,
P = .007). By the eighth treatment, the survey scores had
reached the statistically significant significance
(P < .001).
Conclusions:
1. The literature study
(1) Most of articles did not reach the high quality of research evidence
standards. This systematic review reached level III and V strength of evidence.
Most of quality of the evidence were rated good (B level). Thus, the acupuncture
research needs to improve in strength and quality by improving the research
methodology.
(2) Acupuncture treatment may improve ADHD patient’s symptoms and compared to
Western medicine prescription treatment with less side effect.
2. The clinical trials
(1) This clinical observation study indicated the effective, feasibility, and
safety of XNKQ techniques to treat adult ADHD patients.
(2) This study will lay the foundation for the further clinical research for
utilizing XNKQ technique and functional MRI, proof the advantage of XNKQ
technique, and hopefully to contribute the promotion of XNKQ technique for
treating adult ADHD patients.
(2184) Complementary Therapies for Depression: A Systematic Review of
Reviews
Heidemarie Haller, MSc1, Dennis Anheyer, MA1, Gusatv Dobos,
MD1 and Holger Cramer, PhD1
1University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Standard antidepressants were shown to be superior to
placebo only for very severe symptoms of depression. Clinical depression
guidelines, however, still do not systematically search for alternatives and
vary widely in their recommendations of complementary (CAM) therapies. This
systematic review therefore aimed at summarizing the recent level-1 evidence of
CAM in patients with primary depression.
Results: Literature search revealed 24 meta-analyses conducted
between 2003 and 2017 on 2 to 29 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in patients
with major, minor, and seasonal depression. The quality of RCTs and
meta-analyses ranged between low to high. Based on consistent high-quality
evidence, grade A recommendations can be given for St. John’s wort as it was
superior to placebo and a safer equivalent to standard antidepressants for mild
to moderate major depression. Moderate-quality evidence resulted in grade B
recommendations for saffron and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy as well as
bright light, dance and music therapy as adjunctive treatments, and acupuncture
for treating drug side effects. Grade D recommendations were given for
mindfulness-based stress reduction, spiritual-adapted cognitive therapy,
selected supplements, and yoga showing several promising effects, however,
across low-quality studies.
Conclusions: CAM treatments can be recommended with different grades
for treating depression. Quality of further research needs improvement.
(2190) Effects of a Delphi Consensus Acupuncture Treatment Protocol on the Levels
of Stress and Vascular Tone in Women Undergoing In Vitro Fertilization: A Randomized
Clinical Pilot Study Preliminary Findings
Yan Zhang, PhD1, Jennifer Phy, DO1, Jennie Orlando,
MD1, Sheila Garos, PhD2, Lindsay Penrose, PhD1,
Samuel Prien, PhD1 and Jaou Chen Huang, MD1
1Lubbock, Texas
2Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: In 2012, a Delphi consensus protocol is published to
describe the parameters of best acupuncture practice for assisted reproductive
technology and future research. However, there has been no clinical trial
utilizing this protocol to assess its effects. Our pilot study aimed to assess
the feasibility of the Delphi consensus acupuncture protocol and examine the
impact of acupuncture on stress and tissue perfusion.
Results: By the time of the preliminary analysis, 37 who completed
the study and had all 6 time points of urine collection were included in the
analytic sample (20 and 17 in the acupuncture group and the control group
respectively). A paired t test comparing changes of visit 1 to
visit 3 showed that stress score reduction in both acupuncture (0.21 ± 0.43,
P = .039) and control (0.04 ± 0.34,
P = .678) groups. No significant changes of ratios of 6-k-PGF1α
to TxB2 were found. Power analysis indicated that the current results are
underpowered.
Conclusions: A Delphi consensus acupuncture treatment protocol is
feasible and safe to be carried out in a reproductive clinical setting.
Acupuncture may affect the self-perceived stress levels in women undergoing
in vitro fertilization (IVF). Bigger sample size is warranted in future study to
further assess the impact of acupuncture on individuals receiving IVF
treatment.
(2192) A Cross-sectional Review of the Prevalence of Integrative Medicine in
Pediatric Pain Clinics Across the United States
Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1, Kelsey Macapagal, MPH1, Salvatore
D'Amico, BS1, Laura Goldstein, PsyD1, Caitlin Neri, MD,
MPH1 and Kristen Bodner, MPH1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: This project assesses the prevalence of integrative
medicine (IM) in pediatric pain clinics (PPCs) across the United States.
Results: Of the 53 PPCs identified, 43 (81%) were part of a
nonprofit health-care organization, and 10 (19%) were within a private hospital;
85% were located in urban settings, 15% in rural settings; 83% were located in
free-standing children’s hospitals. Thirty-two (60%) PPCs utilized IM, including
acupuncture (38%), mind–body (21%), massage (21%), aromatherapy (19%), nutrition
counseling (17%), and/or art/music therapy (11%). The most prevalent providers
within PPCs offering IM were yoga instructors (84%), nutritionists (56%), and
mind–body specialists (44%). IM was offered in 63% of programs in nonprofit
organizations and 50% in private hospitals; 58% of urban sites and 75% of rural
sites. Thirty-one percent of PPCs with IM were located in the Midwest, 29% in
the West, 25% in the Northeast, and 15% in the South.
Conclusions: Of 53 current PPCs, over half offer IM services.
However, children in southern regions or by private hospitals have less access
to IM than children in other regions of the United States.
(2194) Showcase of Collaboration Between Integrative Medicine and
Interprofessional Education
Yan Zhang, PhD
Renée J Bogschutz, PhD1 and Betsy Jones, EdD2
1Lubbock, Texas
2Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, Lubbock, Texas
Abstract
Overview:
Background: A biennial Integrative Medicine Symposium (IMS) was
developed at an academic health sciences center to increase awareness of
integrative medicine via interprofessional education (IPE) learning activities.
The purpose of this poster presentation is to describe this integrative medicine
IPE activity, provide lessons learned from the most recent symposium, and share
participant outcomes data. Program Description: The 2017 theme
of the IMS was Mind–Body Wellness: the Science, Art and
Practice. This symposium included 2 keynote speakers, an
interprofessional panel discussion, a therapeutic tea brewing station, an aroma
essence mixing station, a wellness art exhibit, and 10 interprofessional
hands-on complementary medicine workshops. These included acupuncture, dry
needling, reflexology, taping, reiki, mindfulness, therapy dogs, music therapy,
performing arts, and yoga. Each workshop was designed to give participants
across multiple health professions a better understanding of the professional
roles and responsibilities related to each presented modality.
Results: According to the assessment data, the majority of
the participants agreed or strongly agreed that the content of the symposium was
relevant, informative, and/or educational (97%) and that it emphasized the
importance of collaborative care and teamwork (92%). As for the workshops,
nearly all of participants indicated that the workshops provided a hands-on,
collaborative, and active-learning environment (100%) and allowed them to learn
with, about, and from each other (95%). Lessons learned regarding planning,
logistics, interprofessional education integration strategies, assessment
methods, and marketing approaches will be shared in the presentation.
Conclusion: To improve patient-centered care and overall
patient health, it is critical for health-care practitioners to be informed
about integrative medicine modalities and have opportunities to learn, from,
with, and about other health-care professionals. An engaging, interprofessional
IMS is an efficacious approach to providing interprofessional participants with
evidence-based treatment options within a collaborative team-based
environment.
Rationale: Overall, integrative medicine reaffirms the importance of
the relationship between practitioner and patient and makes use of all
appropriate health-care professionals and disciplines to achieve optimal health
and healing. Therefore, it is important to train and involve health-care
practitioners from multiple professions/disciplines to provide patient-centered
integrative care. This poster highlights the experience of developing an IMS as
an IPE learning activity across different health-care professions, which fits
perfectly with the theme of the congress “Collaboration in Action: Advancing
Integrative Health through Research, Education, Clinical Practice and
Policy.”
Objectives: As result of this poster presentation, the participants
will be able to describe the importance of integrating IPE and collaborative
care concepts into integrative medicine information for health-care
practitioners; list 3 ways to provide hands-on IPE learning experiences related
to integrative medicine treatment modalities to foster a collaborative and
active-learning environment; and relate 3 lessons learning when developing an
engaging, interprofessional IMS.
(2197) Differing Definitions of Chronic Pain: Comparison of Patients, Providers,
and Researchers
Ian D Coulter, PhD1, Gery Ryan, PhD1, Margaret D Whitley,
MPH1 and Lara G Hilton, MPH1
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Patient perspectives on what constitutes chronic pain are
less understood than clinician and research definitions. We explored the
relationships between these 3 perspectives on chronic low back and neck pain in
order to inform health policy. This study is nested within a National Center for
Complementary and Integrative Health Center of Excellence for Research on
Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
Results: Findings indicate that patient definitions are misaligned
with research and clinician definitions; however, research and clinical
definitions overlap somewhat. Clinical and research definitions emphasize
duration, while patient definitions emphasize permanency of the condition,
quality of life, and function.
Conclusions: Patient attitudes about pain are important, as they
impact care seeking behaviors and expectations for outcomes. Findings are key
for future research on chronic pain within the context of patient-centered care
that emphasizes the provision of care that is respectful of and responsive to
individual patient preferences, needs, and values.
(2198) The Role of Personality in Patients With Fibromyalgia
Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1, Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD, PhD1,
Andrew Seto, BA1, William F Harvey, MD, MSc1, Teresa Wu,
BA1, Xingyi Han, MPH1 and Lori L Price, MAS,
MLA2
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Tufts University, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Previous studies investigating potential associations
between personality and clinical symptoms in fibromyalgia patients have found
mixed results. We examined the associations between personality dimensions and
overall fibromyalgia impact, psychosocial factors, and health-related outcomes
in fibromyalgia patients.
Results: The sample consisted of 92 participants (95% female, mean
age = 52, body mass index 30 kg/m2, 52% white, 94% with high school
degree, mean duration of body pain of 14 years). Multivariable linear regression
showed neuroticism was significantly associated with Revised Fibromyalgia Impact
Questionnaire and symptom severity (Table 1). Higher neuroticism was also
associated with higher anxiety, depression, and stress, worse mental quality of
life, and lower self-efficacy, mindfulness, and social support. Higher
conscientiousness and extraversion were associated with better mental quality of
life and mindfulness, and lower symptom severity, anxiety, depression, and
stress. Higher conscientiousness was associated with better self-efficacy and
outcome expectations. Higher extraversion was associated with better social
support. More openness was associated with better outcome expectations,
mindfulness, and less depression. Agreeableness was not associated with any
outcome.
Conclusions: Personality was associated with fibromyalgia impact and
a variety of health outcomes. Higher neuroticism was associated with worse
psychosocial factors, suggesting this subset of patients may benefit from
treatment that takes personality into consideration. Results further elucidate
characteristics of fibromyalgia patients.
(2199) Expansion of Integrative Medicine Services Within an Interdisciplinary
Pediatric Pain Clinic in an Urban Safety Hospital
Salvatore D'Amico, BS1, Pei-Chi Kao, MPH1, Kristen Bodner,
MPH1, Caitlin Neri, MD, MPH1, Laura Goldstein,
PsyD1, Kelsey Macapagal, MPH1 and Paula Gardiner, MD,
MPH1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose/Background: Chronic pain is a growing problem among children and
adolescents and is more prevalent in children from low income families. In 2015,
the Boston Medical Center Interdisciplinary Pain Clinic launched an Integrative
Medicine (IM) team model to address chronic pain in children. Types of IM
services include acupuncture, massage, aromatherapy, nutrition, and therapeutic
karate. Children are referred to pain clinic from primary care and specialty
providers. During initial consultation, the clinical team discusses which IM
therapies are appropriate for the patient. The patient is scheduled for
follow-up visits with the IM adjunctive services.
Results: Seventy-five participants were enrolled from June 2016 to
September 2017. Demographics include average age of 14.75 years; 27% identified
as Black, and 27% identified as Latino. For primary pain regions, 40 (53%)
participants reported chronic abdominal pain, 17 (23%) reported chronic
migraines/headaches, and 13 (17%) reported musculoskeletal pain. Fifty (67%)
participants had problems falling or staying asleep, and 46 (61%) reported
missing 5 or more days of school in the past year due to pain. At baseline, 28
patients (37%) reported having previous experiences using IM, including dietary
supplements (56%), massage (16%), and acupuncture (12%). Among patients who
attended the pain clinic, 73 (97%) were recommended acupuncture, 71 (95%) were
recommended aromatherapy, and 66 (88%) were recommended massage.
Conclusions/Discussion: IM services including acupuncture,
aromatherapy, and massage are acceptable to children who attend a pediatric
specialty pain clinic in an urban safety-net hospital. For the majority of
patients, this is their first experience with IM.
(2202) Involvement of Salience Network in the Expectations of Sensory Experience
for Acupuncture Stimulation
Younbyoung Chae, PhD1
1Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: The brain is known to actively interpret sensory inputs
from the integration of top-down and bottom-up information. Humans can make
inferences on somatosenation based on prior experiences and expectations even
without the actual stimulation. We used functional MRI and investigated the
neural substrates to the expectations of sensory experience about acupuncture
stimulation without invasive cutaneous stimuli.
Results: Expectations of acupuncture stimuli without actual
stimulation on 3 acupoints resulted in greater deqi sensation
compared to the control condition. Cognitive components of acupuncture
stimulation exhibited greater brain activation in the anterior insula, dorsal
midcingulate cortex and presupplementary motor area, and secondary somatosensory
area.
Conclusions: We demonstrated that expectations of acupuncture
stimulation exhibited a distinct experience of somatosenation as well as
activations in salience networks in the brain. Our findings imply the
involvement of salience network in cognitively induced somatosensation from
acupuncture stimulation, which is likely due to the predictive role of salience
network in monitoring internal and external bodily state.
(2207) Efficacy of Clinic-based Treadmill Walking in Creating Behavioral Change
in Overweight and Obese Adults With Bipolar I Disorder
Jacob Poynter, BS1, Allesandro Cuomo, MD2, Suzanne Havstad,
MS3, Anne Germain, PhD4, Andrea Fagiolini, MD5,
Ellen Frank, PhD4, David J Kupfer, MD4 and Carol Janney,
PhD6
1Michigan State College of Human Medicine, Livonia, Michigan
2University of Siena School of Medicine, Siena, Italy
3Henry Ford Health System, Livonia, Michigan
4University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
5University of Siena School of Medicine, Siena, Italy
6Michigan State College of Human Medicine, Midland, Michigan
Abstract
Purpose: To determine the efficacy of in-clinic treadmill walking as
part of a weekly behavioral intervention program among overweight and obese
adults with bipolar I disorder (BD).
Results: Optional clinic treadmill walking was offered to 37 of 50
(74%) IRRI participants and 54%(n = 20) expressed interest. At baseline,
participants averaged 5075 ± 2128 total steps/day. On average, participants
walked on the treadmill for 29 ± 9 min, 1.4 ± 0.5 miles, 3 mph, 8 ± 6 (62%) of
sessions. Treadmill walkers (n = 16) increased PA by an average of 857 steps/day
(P = .11) and 5690 aerobic steps/week
(P = .04) from baseline to 4-month follow-up (end of weekly
in-clinic treadmill walking sessions). At 6-month follow-up, in-clinic treadmill
walkers averaged 293 more steps/week (P = .62) and nontreadmill
walkers averaged 137 less steps/week (n = 17, P = .83) when
compared to baseline.
Conclusions: Weekly in-clinic treadmill walking with a lifestyle
coach facilitates PA in adults with BD. It remains to be established whether
lack of sustained behavioral change at 6 months was due to inadequate program
length or lack of access to exercise facility/equipment.
(2208) Integration of Transcendental Meditation® Into Alcohol Use Disorder
Treatment
Jan Gryczynski, PhD1, Robert P Schwartz, MD1, Marc J Fishman,
MD2, Courtney D Nordeck, BA1, James Grant,
EdD3, Sandi Nidich, EdD4, Stuart Rothenberg, MD4
and Kevin E O'Grady, PhD5
1Friends Research Institute, Baltimore, Maryland
2Maryland Treatment Centers, Baltimore, Maryland
3Maharishi Foundation USA, Fairfield, Iowa
4Maharishi University of Management, Fairfield, Iowa
5College Park, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Maladaptive responses to stress are thought to play a role
in addiction and relapse. Transcendental Meditation (TM) is a popular meditation
technique with promising clinical applications. This study sought to (a) examine
the feasibility of providing TM during alcohol use disorder (AUD) treatment, (b)
compare outcomes for TM versus treatment as usual (TAU), and (c) investigate the
relationship between TM practice and outcomes.
Results: Integrating TM into inpatient AUD treatment was feasible.
Uptake of TM was high (85% meditating on most of the past 30 days at follow-up;
61% closely adherent to recommended practice of twice-daily TM). Participants
reported high satisfaction with TM. The sample as a whole improved on multiple
measures after AUD treatment, but there were no significant differences between
TM and TAU cohorts. However, those practicing TM twice daily as recommended were
less likely than the rest of the sample to return to any drinking (25% vs 59%;
P = .02) or heavy drinking postdischarge (0% vs 47%,
P < .001). Greater regularity of TM practice was
inversely correlated with stress, psychological distress, craving, and alcohol
use at follow-up.
Conclusions: This study established the feasibility and
acceptability of using TM during AUD treatment. Consistently practicing TM (but
not just learning it) was associated with better outcomes. These promising
findings warrant further investigation in larger, controlled studies.
(2212) Interprofessional Collaboration Among Integrative Health and Medicine
Providers in Private Practice and Community Health Settings Providing Care to the
Underserved
Beth Rosenthal, MPH, MBA, PhD1, Anthony Lisi, DC2 and Hannah
Gravrand, DC, MS3
1Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health, Chicago, Illinois
2University of Bridgeport, Bridgeport, Connecticut
3VA Sierra Nevada Health Care System, Reno, Nevada
Abstract
Purpose: To investigate the extent and features of interprofessional
collaboration (IPC) among integrative health and medicine (IHM) providers from
the 5 licensed disciplines and to explore IPC and other characteristics of IHM
providers who are providing care to medically underserved patients either in
private practice settings or at community health centers (CHCs).
Results: We conducted interviews with 12 providers in private
practice and 14 providers in CHCs. The outcomes our presentation focuses on are
the perceived impacts of IPC and recommendations to improve IPC.
Conclusions: We found that most subjects had little to no exposure
to IPE during their training, yet emphasized the importance of IPE for
current/future students in their profession. Most subjects reported
having/finding time to communicate and meet other providers is of importance to
IPC. Most subjects reported that IPC has a strong positive impact on patient
care and professional satisfaction.
(2214) A Bibliometric Analysis of Clinical Study Literatures of Traditional
Chinese Medicine Therapies for Smoking Cessation
Jian-Hua Wang, PhD1, Mei Wang, PhD1, Shu-Chun Liu,
PhD1, Xiao-Feng Du1, Mei Han, PhD2, Jun-Feng
Liu, PhD1, Wei Qin, PhD1, Bin Chen, PhD1, Robbert
van Haselen, PhD3 and JianPing Liu, PhD4
1Liaoning University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shenyang, China
2Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
3International Forum on Integrative Medicine, France
4Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to systematically retrieve and analyze the
literatures related to smoking cessation using Traditional Chinese Medicine
(TCM) therapies in order to understand the current situation and provide
reference for further evaluation of TCM therapies for smoking cessation.
Results: In total, 260 literatures were identified from 1980 to
2016, including 17 systematic reviews, 52 randomized clinical trials, 7
controlled clinical studies, 110 case series, 18 case reports, 1 cohort study,
50 traditional reviews, and 5 descriptive epidemiological studies. The majority
(178; 68.5%) were published in Chinese. The annual number of publications
increased slightly in wavy linear, with a peak of 14 in 2006. China (129; 49.6%)
was the leading country in conducting studies in this field, followed by the
United States (27; 10.4%) and UK (25; 9.6%). From 40 countries, 36,645
participants with age ranging from 12 to 86 years were involved in 188 clinical
studies (excluding reviews and epidemiological studies). The most commonly
reported therapy was auricular acupressure (25; 13.3%), followed by body
acupuncture (14; 7.4%), and body acupuncture plus auricular acupressure (14;
7.4%). Composite outcomes (combination of withdrawal rate, withdrawal symptoms,
smoking craving, and other indicators referring to smoking cessation) was the
most frequently reported outcomes (110; 58.5%).
Conclusions: A substantial number of clinical studies have been
conducted on TCM therapies during the past 3 decades. Further systematic reviews
should take place to comprehensively assess the evidence on TCM therapies for
smoking cessation in order to formulate effective and feasible smoking cessation
measures in combination with the actual situation of smokers.
(2216) Nutraceutical Approach to Treating Subclinical Hypothyroidism
Amy Locke, MD1 and Briana M Rueda, DO1
1Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Overview: Subclinical hypothyroidism is a common disorder with
controversial treatments. Several studies have shown that patients with
subclinical hypothyroidism suffer from many of the same cardiometabolic and
psychophysiologic effects as overt hypothyroidism. These include dyslipidemia,
insulin resistance, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, increased carotid artery
intima thickness, cerebral small vessel disease, and decreased quality of life.
However, due to the suppressive effects of replacement and the potential need
for lifelong treatment, many health-care providers are hesitant to initiate
hormone replacement. Here, the latest in scientific research is applied to
highlight an integrative medicine approach to treating subclinical
hypothyroidism using nutraceutical therapies, including supplementation with
selenium, vitamin D, Ashwagandha, myo-inositol, and optimization of iodine
levels. This approach can result in the normalization of thyroid function
without the suppressive effects of hormone replacement.
Rationale: Relevant to this year’s conference theme, subclinical
hypothyroidism is a condition that is treated by a wide variety of integrative
medicine providers. Within the integrative medicine community, collaboration and
agreement as to an optimal treatment of subclinical hypothyroidism is much
needed. It is also relevant from a scientific standpoint, as the number of
studies regarding nonpharmacologic treatment of subclinical hypothyroidism is
rapidly expanding. With an ever-increasing amount of knowledge available, it is
imperative to determine which therapies have been clinically proven successful
and should be implemented as valid treatment options for integrative medicine
providers.
Objectives: Following this presentation, participants will be able
to identify which patients would most benefit from a trial of nutraceutical
therapies prior to hormone replacement, identify the risks and benefits of a
nutraceutical approach to subclinical hypothyroidism, and have a solid
understanding of the latest scientific evidence demonstrating statistically
significant improvements in thyroid-related biomarkers in patients with
subclinical hypothyroidism using a nutraceutical-based integrative medicine
treatment approach.
(2217) Guided Imagery for Anxiety Reduction for Nursing Students
Damaris m Grossmann, RN, DNPc1 and Molly Bradshaw, DNP, APRN, FNP-BC,
WHN-BC1
1Newark, New Jersey
Abstract
Purpose: In this section, the aim is presented with corresponding
objectives. The overarching aim of this project is to investigate guided imagery
as a tool to for anxiety reduction in graduate nursing students. Ultimately,
guided imagery intervention will be incorporated for future use self-care and
many health settings for utilization in patient care.
Results: This study still in process. Results to be determined by
January 2018
Conclusions:
Tentative conclusion: Guided imagery is a reliable tool to
reduce anxiety in graduate nursing students, which has the potential for
sustainability and replication in the future. One-way guided imagery can be
utilized to reduce anxiety would be to purchase and hand out the guided imagery
information cards with guided imagery resources to students to use when needed.
Guided imagery could also be replicated for use in future semesters within the
university. The prerecorded media of guided imagery may be utilized prior to
examinations and with additional student cohorts, including the undergraduate
students. The university could purchase the guided imagery for the students to
use prior to their examination or for any time needed. Overall, this project of
guided imagery intervention as an effective solution for reducing anxiety in
nursing students and further projects would be beneficial to implement with use
of control subjects and evaluation of physiological changes within the body with
use of application of guided imagery. Additionally, the use of guided imagery
intervention would be affordable, safe and sustainable for use by any nurse or
health-care professional in any health-care setting for improvement of
patient-centered care.
(2220) An Event-related Potential Study on Cognitive Regulation Mechanism in
Subthreshold Depression: The Happier, the Better?
Yichunzi Zhang1, Xue Li1, Junhui Kong1, Jinpeng
Zhang1, Xi Tan1 and Lesley Zhang1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: In the perspective of preventive treatment of disease, the
theory of mutual restraints of emotions of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM)
can help to improve the emotional state of subthreshold depressive people. The
paper aims to find out the mechanism of delight regulating cognition of
subthreshold depressive people.
Results: After delight induction, delight score of visual analogue
scales of group 2 (delight-induction group of the subthreshold depressive) was
increased (M = 40.29 vs M = 69.32), and anxieties score of visual analogue
scales of group 2 was decreased (M = 34.68 vs M = 20.03). The amplitudes of N2
of group 2 were higher than group 4 (control group of the subthreshold
depressive; positive stimulation: t = −2.10, P < .05;
neutral stimulation: t = −3.65, P < .001; negative
stimulation: t = −1.98, P < .05), and under positive
stimulation, the amplitude of P3 of group 2 was higher than group 4 (t = −3.51,
P < .001), and under neutral stimulation, the latency of
P3 of group 2 was shorter than group4 (t = −4.42, P < .000)
and the normal (subjects in group 1 and group 3; t = −3.41,
P < .001).
Conclusions: Delight can improve the emotional state of the
subthreshold depressive. For the subthreshold depressive, delight induction
enhanced their cognitive control ability and their attention processing ability
of positive stimulation and greatly improved their cognitive processing ability
of neutral stimulation.
(2224) Changing Workforce Dynamics: The Experience of Integrative Professionals
Working Within Patient-centered Medical Homes
Jennifer Olejownik, PhD1
1
Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health, Columbus, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: Given the context of the changing health-care landscape,
integrative professions can help reduce health care costs and improve the
patient experience. The Patient-centered Medical Home (PCMH) movement is a
comprehensive, team-based approach to care that focuses on quality,
accessibility, and coordinated services. While physicians are typically the
first point of contact in this model, other integrative professionals are
exploring leadership roles in PCMHs. This research will explore some of the
challenges and obstacles integrative professionals encounter delivering care in
PCMHs.
Results: Preliminary findings point to common themes related to
educational preparedness, the management of chronic care, the role of patient
education in regard to becoming actively engaged in the healing process, the
challenge of promoting a new culture centered on wellness in a system that
traditionally has focused on disease, and how to best manage and treat an of
influx of patients who have not had access to care for many years.
Conclusions: Integrative professionals can be successful leaders
within the PCMH model. Institutes of higher education could improve program
offerings to better train and prepare integrative professionals, such as
naturopathic physicians and chiropractors, to serve in primary care roles.
Through the creation of mentoring relationships, residencies, and internship
programs, other pathways could then be forged and developed for integrative
professionals to acquire the skills needed to work in these settings.
(2228) Integrative Oncology in Australia: Findings From a National Survey of
Cancer Services and the Experiences of Cancer Survivors
Jennifer Hunter, PhD, MScPH, BMed1, Caroline Smith, PhD1, Jane
Ussher, PhD, BA1, Geoff Delaney, MD, PhD, MBBS2, Eleanor
Oyston, BT3, Kate Templeman, PhD1, Suzanne Grant, PhD, MPS,
BAppSc, BA1, Andrew Kellet, BA1 and Chloe Parton, PhD,
BA1
1Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
2South Western Sydney Local Health District, Sydney, Australia
3Oncology Massage Limited, Canberra, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this project was to examine integrative oncology
(IO) service provision and unmet needs in Australia and explore cancer
survivors’ views on integrating traditional and complementary medicine
(T&CM) into cancer services.
Results: Of the 295 eligible organisations, 275 (93%) responded;
from which 71 (26%) provided IO services for a median duration of 6 years and in
a variety of settings— inpatient (52%), outpatient (53%), dedicated centre (35%)
and home visits (4%). Compared to non-IO providers, organisations were more
likely to be owned by a not-for-profit company (46%) or were government owned
(38%) (P < .001). Provision was restricted at most sites to
a limited range of services, most commonly massage (73%), well-being (71%) and
movement modalities (39%). Institutional policies and information regarding CM
products and practitioner services were generally underdeveloped and
inconsistent for IO and non-IO providers alike. Thematic and content analysis of
the cancer survivor data (n = 154) identified the need for greater service
provision and more equitable access to IO services. There was a substantial
mismatch between cancer services’ provision of and cancer survivors’ use and
demand for biologically based T&CM therapies and advice.
Conclusions: Australian health-care organisations are increasingly
providing IO services, signalling the need for clearer national guidance and
polices. Fragmented service development has led to inconsistent service
provision and unmet needs across many areas of Australia. Discrepancies exist
between what cancer survivors are doing or seeking, and the IO services they can
access through their local cancer services.
(2229) Supportive Care and Integrative Oncology: Barriers and Unmet Needs
Chloe Parton, PhD, BA1, Andrew Kellet, BA1, Suzanne Grant, PhD,
MPS, BAppSc, BA1, Kate Templeman, PhD1, Geoff Delaney, MD,
PhD, MBBS2, Eleanor Oyston, BT3, Caroline Smith,
PhD1, Jennifer Hunter, PhD, MScPH, BMed1 and Jane Ussher,
PhD, BA1
1Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
2South Western Sydney Local Health District, Sydney, Australia
3Oncology Massage Limited, Canberra, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this study was to identify unmet cancer service
needs and explore barriers and solutions to integrative oncology (IO) service
provision in Australia.
Results: Of the 275 organisations that answered the survey, 209
(76%) provided some type of supportive cancer services and 71 (26%) provided IO.
Four interrelated themes (finance, logistics, evidence and culture) were
identified as barriers to providing or accessing IO. The strongest convergence
across all the data was financial barriers. Out-of-pocket costs were an
important barrier for 82% of cancer survivors and the only obstacle for 40%.
Funding IO was the greatest barrier identified by 60% of non-IO providers. IO
providers relied heavily upon patient payments, followed by philanthropy, and
volunteer practitioners. Views on solutions were more contentious. Some
considered it was the patient’s responsibility. Others thought the public health
sector should reduce socio-economic inequalities or that higher rebates from
private health insurers were required. Cancer survivors emphasised that IO was
not a ‘luxury item’, rather it was important for managing side effects,
comorbidity and rehabilitation. Other important barriers were general lack of IO
services across much of Australia, difficulties in referral pathways,
health-care professional attitudes, insufficient evidence and provider
uncertainty around which IO services to provide, clinical governance and
business models.
Conclusions: We propose a patient-centred model with broad
applicability that illustrates the complex interrelationship between patients,
health-care practitioners, services and policy and the thematic barriers and
solutions identified by this study.
(2243) Development and Validation of an Instrument to Evaluate Inpatient Beliefs,
Expectations, and Attitudes Toward Reflexology-16: A Pilot Study
Samuel Attias, MPH1, Elad Schiff, MD1, Zahi Arnon,
PhD2, Yael Keshet3, 4, Ibrahim Matter1, Lital
Keinan Boker5, 6 and Eran Ben-Arye7
1Bnai Zion Medical Center, Haifa, Israel
2Bnai Zion Medical Center, Yezreel Valley Academic College, Haifa,
Israel
3Western Galilee Academic College, Acre, Israel
4Tivon, Israel
5University of Haifa, Israel
6ICDC, Ministry of Health Israel, Tel Aviv, Israel
7Lin Medical Center, Clalit Health Services, Haifa, Israel
Abstract
Purpose: Despite the extensive use of manual therapies, reflexology
in particular, no validated tools have been developed to evaluate patients’
beliefs, attitudes and expectations regarding reflexology. Such tools, however,
are essential to improve the results of the reflexology treatment by better
adjusting it to the patients’ attitudes and expectations. The tool also enables
assessing correlations with clinical results of interventional studies using
reflexology.
Results: After its construction, the Inpatient Beliefs,
Expectations, and Attitudes Toward Reflexology (IBEAR) questionnaire passed the
expert group’s preliminary consensus, evaluation of the questions’ clarity (from
5.1 to 7.0), inner validation (from 5.5 to 7), and structural validation (from
5.5 to 6.75). Factor analysis pointed to 2 content worlds in a division into 4
questions discussing attitudes and expectations versus 5 questions on belief and
attitudes. Of the 221 questionnaires collected, a Cronbach’s alpha coefficient
was calculated on 9 questions relating to beliefs, expectations, and attitudes
regarding reflexology. This measure stood at 0.716 (satisfactory reliability).
At the test–retest stage, 199 research participants filled in the questionnaire
a second time. The Pearson coefficient for all questions ranged between 0.73 and
0.94 (good to excellent reliability). As for dichotomic answers, Kappa scores
ranged between 0.66 and 1.0 (mediocre to high). One of the questions was removed
from the IBEAR following questionnaire validation.
Conclusions: The present study provides evidence that the proposed
IBEAR-16 questionnaire is a valid and reliable tool for the characterization of
potential reflexology patients and may be effectively used in settings which
include the evaluation of inpatients’ beliefs, expectations, and attitudes
toward reflexology.
(2244) Citation and Relevant Factors of Randomized Controlled Trials on
Acupuncture Published in English Literature
Liqiong Wang, PhD1, Ning Liang, MD1, Lianhan Shang,
MD1, Xuehan Liu, MD1, Jianping Liu, PRO1,
Chunxiang Su, PRO1 and Yu-tong Fei, MD, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Increasing number of randomized clinical trials (RCTs) have
been published internationally to assess the effect and safety of acupuncture.
There is insufficient information about the citation of the published RCTs to
reflect their uptaking. We aim to explore the citation of acupuncture RCTs
published in English and relevant factors to promote their value.
Results: Eight hundred twenty-three acupuncture RCTs were identified
(including 244 highly and 579 lowly cited trials of which 32 [5%] was not
cited). The median of citation per year of 823 RCTs was 1.71 (interquartile
range: 0.86-3.18; range: 0–27.20). Ten of the 24 variables were analyzed:
diseases, center numbers was not associated with citation, but the country from
the West (vs Eastern odds ratio [OR]:1.78), general and professional medical
journals (vs complementary related journals OR: 2.11; 2.55), trials with
multiple arms (vs 2 arms OR: 2.04), outcome specified (vs unspecified OR: 2.02),
funding (vs no funding OR: 1.74), and positive results (vs negative OR: 1.73)
were independently associated with more citations, while no blinding of
participants were less likely to be cited (vs blinding OR: 0.60).
Conclusions: Trials from the West, published in high-impact
journals, with funding and positive results were more likely to be cited, and
participants unblinded were less likely cited. Future acupuncture trials might
be taking care of participants blinding, specified outcomes to increase their
use.
(2248) The Effect of Reflexology on Anxiety and Duration of the Active Phase in
Primigravida Women: Preliminary Results
Tamar S Lavee1, Ofri Avneri1, Dan Steinberger1, Gil
Cohen, MD1, Shlomi Shosh Belachsan, BA, RN1, Samuel Sagi,
MD1, Elad Attias, MPH1 and Schiff, MD1
1Bnai Zion Medical Center, Haifa, Israel
Abstract
Purpose: Intrapartum anxiety is a common condition associated with a
negative experience, increased morbidity, and prolonged labor. The aim of this
study was to assess the hypothesis that reflexology treatment can reduce anxiety
of primiparous women during labor and furthermore reduce the duration of
labor.
Results: In the reflexology + ST group, reduction in anxiety from
baseline was statistically significant (from 6.79 to 4.34, n = 32,
P < .0001). Patients with baseline moderate–severe
anxiety also had statistically significant reduction in anxiety (from 7.55 to
4.92, n = 28, P < .0001). In the ST group, anxiety was
reduced nonsignificantly (from 5.30 to 4.90, n = 53, P = .25),
however, for patients with baseline moderate–severe anxiety, there was a
significant reduction (from 8 to 7.03, n = 33, P = .03). The
duration of active labor from 4 to 5 cm to complete dilation of the cervix was
nonsignificantly reduced in the reflexology group compared to the standard care
alone group (5:31 h in the ST group [n = 28] and 5:17 h in the reflexology group
[n = 58, P = .68]). The duration of labor until delivery
(first + second stages) does not indicate any difference between the reflexology
and the ST group, 6:27 h in the ST group (n = 28) and 6:32 h in the reflexology
group (n = 58, P = .96).
Conclusions: The integration of reflexology treatment with standard
care is better than standard care alone in reducing intrapartum anxiety. The
effect of reflexology was prominent in patients experiencing moderate to severe
baseline anxiety. Duration of labor was not affected by reflexology. Future
studies should utilize explanatory methodologies in order to assess the specific
effects of reflexology as compared to nonspecific touch and attention. The
association between expectations and outcomes should further be explored.
(2251) Effects of Protein Supplementation on Energy and Protein Intake:
Preliminary Findings From a Randomized, Controlled Trial in the Intensive Care
Unit
Monica C Serra, PhD1, Avelino C Verceles, MD1, Elizabeth A
Parker, PhD, RD2 and Termeh Feinberg, PhD, MPH3
1Baltimore, Maryland
2University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
3Center for Integrative Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Delivering nutrition support early in intensive care unit
(ICU) stay favorably impacts patient outcomes; yet, few patients meet the
American Society for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition guidelines of ≥80% goal
energy and protein (Pro) while in the ICU. Difficulty feeding is further
compounded by the effects of aging including the individual’s nutritional status
and number of comorbidities.
Results: At baseline, there were no differences in mean energy
(Health Protection and Research Organisation [HPRO]:
22 ± 4 kcal/kg actual body weight [ABW]; CON: 21 ± 4 kcal/kg ABW) or Pro (HPRO:
1.4 ± 0.2 g/kg ABW; CON: 1.3 ± 0.2 g/kg ABW) prescribed by the RD. In the first
5 days, HPRO received higher mean daily energy (1516 vs 1092 kcals,
P < .01) and Pro (103 vs 57 g,
P < .001) compared to CON. This effect remained significant
after accounting for ABW (energy: 18.4 ± 6.0 vs 13.3 ± 6.2 kcal/kg,
P = .01; Pro: 1.3 ± 0.4 vs 0.8 ± 0.4 g/kg,
P < .001). The HPRO group had significantly higher
adherence to RD recommendations for energy (83 ± 0.2 vs 63 ± 0.3%,
P < .05) and Pro (92 ± 0.3 vs 54 ± 0.03%,
P < .001). Common conditions that limited intake
included holding enteral feeds in preparation for extubation, need for
noninvasive ventilation, and diagnostic procedures requiring fasting and/or
transport from the ICU.
Conclusions: Increasing goal Pro recommendations and using whey Pro
supplementation significantly increased overall energy and Pro intake in MV
critically ill patients in the ICU over the first 5 days. Studies have
demonstrated improved clinical outcomes following higher nutrition delivery
early in ICU stay; thus, strategies to optimally reach nutrition goals to
overcome feeding barriers in the ICU are needed.
(2262) Ketogenic Diet for Dog With Pituitary Tumor
Jacquelyne Motta, DVM1
1Vila Velha University UVV-ES Brazil, Plantation, Florida
Abstract
Overview:
Zahn, an 8-year-old male French Bulldog with severe symptoms of vertigo,
nerve paralysis and corneal ulcers caused due to a pituitary tumor was
submitted on a ketogenic diet. After 6 months of therapy, the
tumor-associated inflammation was completely reduced, and no more
neurological deficits were found during clinical tests. On summer
of 2016, after complete clinical examinations which suggested neurological
deficits, the dog was submitted to image exams and blood work. Ultrasound images
showed abnormalities on spleen (hypoechoic spot sizing 0.83 × 0.72 cm), liver
(discreet increase in size and volume), and adrenal glands size (left: 2.22 cm
L × 0.80 cm W; right: 2.18 cm L × 0.88 cm W). Computed tomography scan of the
brain showed a skull base tumor suggesting pituitary tumor (hypophysis), which
confirmed the findings on the previous clinical examination. The tumor was
compressing adjacent structures on the left side and causing the neurological
deficits. The persistent intracranial pressure led to arterial occlusion and
pressure on cranial nerves causing the paralysis of the brain. The blood test
revealed an increase of serum alkaline phosphatase (5,838 UI/L), an increase of
serum alanine aminotransferase—ALT (961 UI/L) and an increase of aspartate
aminotransferase—AST (118 UI/L). Leukocytes and bilirubin were also slightly
increased. The ketogenic diet was prescribed. The keto diet consists in the
replacement of carbohydrates by healthy fats, which are converted to ketones,
and in the intake of moderate amounts of high-quality protein to metabolize
ketone bodies as an alternative fuel, when glucose availability is low. After 6
months on a keto diet, blood work results came with no more alterations. Zahn
didn’t present neurological dysfunctions anymore and the following clinic
check-ups were all in accordance with normal healthy parameters.
Rationale: There are alternatives other than conventional medicine.
Diet must be included on therapy plans either as an adjuvant or whenever
possible as the main treatment. Nutrition plays an important role in the future
of medicine. The ketogenic diet is an effective nontoxic metabolic therapy that
can provide antiangiogenic and proapoptotic mechanisms. In Zahn’s case, it
suggests that tumor cells have reduced the ability to metabolize these ketone
bodies for energy. The ketogenic diet can offer hope against cancer, both for
prevention and treatment, and those interested in cancer prevention should know
about this.
Objectives: This study is here to demonstrate the effectiveness of
ketogenic diet as adjunctive therapy in the treatment of brain tumor. Although
the study was done in a dog, it is known that ketogenic diet is also effective
in preventing and reducing cancer risks in humans. Integrative Medicine
conducted with criteria and responsibility leads to health and vitality for
patients. Participants will know about this nontoxic alternative to help their
patients and themselves.
(3234) Integrative Psychiatry Curriculum for Psychiatry Residents
Stefana Morgan, MD1, Ning Zhou, MD1, Selena Chan,
DO1 and Sudha Prathikanti, MD1
1San Francisco, California
Abstract
Overview/Background: Based on National Health Interview Survey data, one third of
U.S. adults use a complementary modality annually and adults with
neuropsychiatric symptoms have a significantly greater prevalence of
complementary modality use. As growing evidence supports the efficacy of many
complementary therapies in treating mental health issues, integrating such
therapies into conventional psychiatric care will likely enhance therapeutic
outcomes. The Integrative Psychiatry Elective at University of California San
Francisco (UCSF) addresses the need for psychiatry residents to be educated in
integrative approaches to mental health care.
Program Description: Participants in the course were able to learn
about key elements of an integrative psychiatry approach to mental health care.
Based on clinical factors, residents also learned to identify patients likely to
benefit from an integrative psychiatry approach and evaluate efficacy data,
risks, benefits, and contraindications of complementary therapies for
psychiatric conditions. Via the experiential component of this course,
participants had the opportunity to practice applying selected complementary
therapies amenable to an office setting (eg, yoga breathing exercises for
anxiety reduction). Additionally, residents learned to identify licensing and
professional safety boards for complementary care providers in the community,
and independent labs that test safety and quality of nutraceuticals and herbal
products. Finally, participants learned to apply practice guidelines for
communicating with and monitoring patients who have complementary care providers
in the community. Mixed methods data were collected in order to assess the
impact of the course. Survey data collected over 2 iterations of the elective
demonstrate increased clinical competency of residents in understanding and
using complementary modalities as well as in collaborating with complementary
medicine experts in comanaging patients.
Conclusion: This innovative curriculum was successfully implemented
in the UCSF psychiatric residency training program and may offer a model to
other clinical training programs for advancing knowledge of integrative mental
health care.
Rationale: Some complementary therapies require expert
nonconventional practitioners to administer them, while others may be applied by
practitioners having traditional medical backgrounds with only minimal training
in complementary therapies. Psychiatry residents should be educated in
integrative approaches to mental health care in order to better understand them,
utilize them, and work collaboratively with other practitioners to enhance
therapeutic outcomes.
Objectives: The aim is to identify the learning needs of psychiatry
residents with respect to understanding and implementing integrative mental
health care; describe the components of the UCSF Integrative Psychiatry
Curriculum designed to address these needs; and describe the effectiveness of
the UCSF Integrative Psychiatry Curriculum in meeting the educational needs of
residents, as measured by both qualitative and quantitative outcomes.
(3235) Yoga Referrals—More to It Than Meets the Eye
Rosanne Sheinberg, MD1 and Amy G Kozak1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: More data exist for practitioners to recommend the use of
yoga to patients for various medical diagnoses. There is some confusion,
however, exactly how to thoughtfully refer a patient to an appropriate setting
of yoga, as all styles, practitioners and classes are not created equal and not
suitable for all types of medical conditions.
Rationale/Background: Yoga is rooted in a rich and long Indian tradition dating
back over 5000 years. Since taking root in the United States, many styles of
yoga have developed, including the highly popularized and medically tied, Hatha
Yoga. More data exist for practitioners to recommend its use to patients for
various medical diagnoses. There is some confusion, however, exactly how to
thoughtfully refer a patient to an appropriate setting of yoga, as all styles,
practitioners, and classes are not created equal and not suitable for all types
of medical conditions.
Teaching Point: There is currently a divide in the yoga certification community
that causes confusion. Yoga Alliance currently tracks the individual training
hours, ongoing education, and the credibility of yoga schools and training
courses for yoga teachers starting with RYT200 (Registered Yoga Teacher). The
International Association of Yoga Therapists is specifically interested in
bridging yoga and health care. They require about 1000 h of instruction. To
complicate matters, there are also master’s level programs. Many yoga teachers
find themselves working in various settings—crossing the thresholds of both gyms
and clinics. The bottom line for the medical community is that there exist
options for matching a medical condition with the appropriate “yoga.” While some
patients, for example with depression, may thrive at a general yoga class, this
may not be the case for every patient, for example, a diagnosis of traumatic
brain injury or sexual trauma. Therefore, it is important to note that medical
providers have a bigger responsibility when it comes to patient-centered care;
the difference between yoga and yoga therapy must be understood when making any
referral. It is no longer appropriate to simply tell a patient, “you should try
yoga.”
Conclusion: A larger evidence base exists to begin recommending yoga
to certain patient populations and medical conditions. Clinicians need education
and guidance to appropriately refer a patient to an appropriate yoga provider
and setting.
Objectives: The aim is to understand different levels of yoga
training and affiliated training requirements and understand the responsibility
of providers to refer patients to an appropriate yoga setting.
(3238) Mindfulness for Health-Care Professionals: A Long-term Follow-up and
Mixed-methods Investigation of an Interdisciplinary Course
Patricia Kinser, PhD, WHNP, RN1, Andrew Harris, BSN1, Caroline
Carrico, PhD1, George Deeb, MD, DDS1, Alan Dow, MD,
MSHA1 and Sarah E Braun, MS1
1Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia
Abstract
Purpose: Mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) may help reduce
health-care professional (HCP) burnout and stress-related outcomes. However, few
studies have investigated the long-term effects of MBIs in interdisciplinary
HCPs. Furthermore, more research is needed to better understand HCP perceptions
of mindfulness’ effects and practice in the context of HCP work. Therefore, the
purpose of the present study was to evaluate the effect of an MBI for
interdisciplinary HCPs over time and at a long-term follow-up and to explore
perceived benefits, facilitators, and barriers to the practice of mindfulness
following an MBI for HCPs (MBSR-HP).
Results: Eighteen HCPs (88% female) participated in the study.
Significant reductions were found for 2 subscales of burnout: depersonalization;
F(2, 17) = 5.98, P = .01, emotional exhaustion F(2, 17) = 2.64,
P = .10. Nonsignificant reductions were found for perceived
stress, depressive symptoms, rumination, and anxiety. Three facets of
dispositional mindfulness showed significant increases at the long-term
follow-up, act aware: F(2,15) = 4.47, P = .03,
nonjudge: F(2, 15) = 4.7, P = .03, and
nonreactivity: F(2, 15) = 3.58, P = .05.
Benefits and facilitators of the continued practice of mindfulness skills
included using informal practices and perceived improvements in emotion
regulation. Participants reported that integration of mindfulness into their
lives was the greatest barrier and the greatest facilitator.
Conclusions: MBSR-HP showed long-term benefit in burnout and
dispositional mindfulness. A larger, controlled study should confirm these
findings and explore potential moderators for which this study was underpowered.
Themes revealed the importance of developing a mindfulness practice that can be
integrated into the context of HCP work.
(3239) Prevalence and Correlates of Black Cohosh Consumption in the United
States
Kim Innes, PhD, MSPH1, Chris D’Adamo, PhD2, Elizabeth A Parker,
PhD, RD3 and Termeh Feinberg, PhD, MPH4
1West Virginia University School of Public Health, Morgantown, West
Virginia
2University of Maryland Baltimore School of Medicine, Baltimore,
Maryland
3University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
4Center for Integrative Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Although the herbal supplement Black Cohosh is anecdotally
used to treat menopausal symptoms, rheumatic disorders, and other conditions,
the prevalence and correlates of use in the United States remain unknown. In
this study, we estimated Black Cohosh consumption in a weighted national sample
and assessed variation in use by demographics, lifestyle factors, and health
conditions.
Results: Black Cohosh was used by an estimated 402 003 adults (0.41%
of the U.S. population); users were less likely to be minority (adjusted odds
ratio [AOR] for black vs white adults = 0.2, confidence interval [CI] 0.1, 0.6)
and male (AOR = 0.1, CI 0.0, 0.2). Black Cohosh use was 6–8 times more likely to
be reported by participants: aged 45–64 years than by younger adults (AOR = 8.1,
CI 3.6, 18.0); with out-of-pocket medical costs over $2000 (AOR = 7.1, CI 1.6,
31.1); using other CHAs (AOR = 6.2, CI 2.1, 18.0); and reporting herbalist
visits in the past year (AOR = 7.6, CI 2.8,20.4). Users were more likely than
nonusers to delay medical care due to cost (AOR = 3.1, CI 1.8,5.4). Users were
11 times as likely to report menopausal symptoms (AOR = 11.1, CI 6.7, 18.5), and
over twice as likely to report chronic rheumatic pain (AOR = 2.3, CI 1.3, 4.2),
migraine (AOR = 2.3, CI 1.3,4.1), and mental health conditions (AOR = 1.8, CI
1.13.1).
Conclusions: Although reported use of Black Cohosh was low in this
national cross-sectional study, consumption was strongly and positively
associated with menopausal symptoms, rheumatic pain, and mental health
conditions.
(3241) Ginkgo Use in the United States: Characteristics of Users and 5-Year
Trends
Termeh Feinberg, PhD, MPH1, Chris D’Adamo, PhD2, Kim Innes,
PhD, MSPH3 and Ryan C Costantino, PharmD, BCPS4
1Center for Integrative Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2University of Maryland Baltimore School of Medicine, Baltimore,
Maryland
3West Virginia University School of Public Health, Morgantown, West
Virginia
4University of Maryland Baltimore School of Pharmacy, Baltimore,
Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Although the herbal supplement, Ginkgo biloba, has been
used to treat memory disorders and other conditions and is widely sold in the
United States, prevalence and patterns of Ginkgo consumption remain little
explored. In this study, we estimated Ginkgo herbal supplement consumption in 2
weighted national samples and assessed variation in use by sociodemographic
factors, lifestyle characteristics, and health conditions.
Results: Ginkgo use significantly decreased between 2007 and 2012,
and was used by an estimated 1 382 659 adults (1.4% the U.S. adult population;
weighted confidence interval [CI] 1.2%–1.6%) in 2007 and 828 340 adults (0.8% of
the U.S. adult population; CI 0.7%–0.9%) in 2012; Ginkgo use was nearly twice as
likely to be reported by participants: aged 45–64 years than by younger adults
(2007 and 2012 odds ratios [ORs]: 1.6–1.9, respectively); former smokers
(adjusted odds ratios [AORs] = 1.6); those delaying medical care due to cost
(AORs 2.1–2.3); and who reported migraine in 2012 (AOR = 1.9, CI 1.3, 2.6),
mental health condition in both years (AORs = 1.4–1.9), and memory loss in 2007
(AOR = 1.7, CI 1.1, 2.6). Ginkgo use did not vary among those with headache.
Those using other complementary approaches were also 18–36 times as likely to
report Ginkgo use (AORs = 18.4–35.8).
Conclusions: In this national cross-sectional study, Ginkgo
supplement use significantly decreased between 2007 and 2012. Ginkgo consumption
was significantly higher in those experiencing migraine, memory loss, and mental
health conditions.
(3242) Ginseng Consumption in the United States: 5-Year Prevalence Trends and
Correlates of Use
Chris D’Adamo, PhD1, Kim Innes, PhD, MSPH2 and Termeh Feinberg,
PhD, MPH3
1University of Maryland Baltimore School of Medicine, Baltimore,
Maryland
2West Virginia University School of Public Health, Morgantown, West
Virginia
3Center for Integrative Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Although the herbal dietary supplement Ginseng is
anecdotally used for increasing resistance to a wide variety of stressors within
the body and is widely sold in the United States, prevalence and patterns of
Ginseng consumption remain unclear. In this study, we estimated Ginseng herbal
supplement consumption in 2 weighted national samples and assessed variation in
use by sociodemographic factors, lifestyle characteristics, and health
conditions.
Results: Ginseng use significantly decreased between 2007 and 2012
from an estimated 1.6% (confidence interval [CI] 1.4%–1.8%) of the U.S. adult
population (N = 1 559 834 adults) in 2007 to 0.8% (CI 0.7%–1.0%) of U.S. adults
(N = 857 482) in 2012. Males were significantly more likely to use Ginseng (2007
and 2012 adjusted odds ratios [AORs]: 1.4–1.6, respectively), as were adults who
delayed medical care due to cost (AORs 2.1–2.2); were former smokers (AORs
1.6–1.9); or had chronic rheumatic pain/conditions (AORs 1.7), migraine (AORs
1.5–1.6), GI conditions (AORs 1.3-2.0), insomnia (AORs 1.8–2.0), or memory loss
in 2012 (AOR = 1.9, CI 1.1, 3.1). Participants indicating use of other CHAs were
also 10-11 times as likely to report using Ginseng (AORs 9.6–11.1).
Conclusions: Ginseng supplement use decreased between 2007 and 2012
in this national cross-sectional study. Ginseng consumption was significantly
higher in those experiencing rheumatic pain, gastrointestinal conditions,
migraine, or memory loss.
(3244) The Multidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive Awareness Questionnaire:
Benefits, Shortcomings, Controversies
Wolf E Mehling, MD1
1San Francisco, California
Abstract
Purpose: Since its 2012 publication, the Multidimensional Assessment
of Interoceptive Awareness (MAIA) questionnaire has been translated into 20
other languages for application in mind–body research. Interoceptive bodily
awareness has emerged as a key topic in understanding mind–body approaches. This
presentation will summarize research with the MAIA, its potential benefits for
mind–body research, shortcomings, controversies, and ongoing improvement
efforts.
Results: The 8-scale 32-item MAIA differentially modifies aspects of
the complex construct of interoceptive awareness with mind–body approaches,
highlighting key domains of regulatory aspects of interoceptive awareness.
Not-distracting mediates the effect of a mind–body approach to comorbid
depression and chronic pain. Self-regulation and attention regulation enhance
the ability to decenter mediating the effect of mindfulness training on
depressive symptoms. Fitness training integrated with mindfulness and yoga
improves interoceptive awareness in parallel with post-traumatic stress disorder
symptoms. Translations into foreign languages confirmed the factor structure
with exceptions potentially due to cross-cultural differences, which are
currently explored by focus groups. Two of the 8 scales consistently showed low
Cronbach’s alphas prompting a revision of their items in preparation for an MAIA
version 2. MAIA scores for interoceptive awareness are independent of
interoceptive accuracy but related to altered activation in brain regions
involved in monitoring body state.
Conclusions: The MAIA fills an important gap in mind–body research.
A revision of 2 of its eight scales is underway. Controversies regarding the
underlying construct and cross-cultural differences in bodily awareness require
further research.
(3245) Mind–Body Practices Delivered in a Cancer Infusion Suite to Reduce
Symptoms and Improve Well-being: A Practice-based Study
Sian Cotton, PhD1, Ellen N Drosdick, MS1, Tina Walter,
BA1 and Harini Pallerla, MS1
1Cincinnati, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: Anxiety, pain, nausea, and fatigue are common side effects
of patients undergoing chemotherapy. Mind–body practices (eg, yoga therapy,
relaxation/breathwork, mindful awareness, auricular acupuncture) have been shown
to be effective in reducing symptoms in outpatient settings. The purpose of this
practice-based study was to assess the use of mind–body practices delivered at
the point of care during cancer infusion and to examine changes in symptoms
before and after the intervention.
Results: One hundred ninety-one patients, with various cancers and
blood disorders, participated in this study from April 2016 to July 2017, with
86% (n = 165) of participants completing both pre- and postsurveys. Levels of
anxiety (Mpre = 3.61/Mpost = 1.73, P < .01), pain
(Mpre = 1.82/Mpost = 1.02, P < .01), nausea
(Mpre = .72/Mpost = .326, P < .05), and overall distress
(Mpre = 3.48/Mpost = 1.83, P < .01) all significantly
decreased post intervention. Furthermore, 32% of participants (n = 22)
spontaneously reported that the treatment was relaxing and/or soothing.
Conclusions: In this practice-based study, clinical symptoms
significantly decreased following a mind–body intervention in a cancer infusion
suite delivered at the point of care. Future studies should use objective raters
to assess symptom reduction. Mind–body practices delivered during infusion
services may provide symptom reduction for patients and should be rigorously
assessed for dose, individualized preference, and long-term symptom
improvement.
(3246) Paper-based Colorimetric Analysis of Mushroom Extracts: Effects of
Mushroom Variety, Brew Time, Reinfusion, and Extraction Method on Antioxidant
Activity
Erica M Sharpe, PhD1, Tom Huber, MS2, Sylvia
Ludlam3, Margaret Walker3, Silvana Andreescu, PhD4
and Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH1
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
2Paul Smith’s College, Paul Smiths, New York
3SUNY Canton, Canton, New York
4Clarkson University, Potsdam, New York
Abstract
Purpose: This study investigates the effects of infusion time and
reinfusion on the antioxidant (AOX) activity of Inonotus
obliquus (ie, chaga) as well as the differences in AOX activity
between 12 double-extraction mushroom tinctures (Fomes fomentarius,
Fomitopsis pinicola, Ganoderma applanatum and tsugae, Hericium americanum,
Inonotus obliquus, Lentinula edodes, Phellinus igniarius, Piptopous
betulinus, Pleurotus ostreatus, Trametes versicolor, and 1 mixture
of all samples).
Results: Antioxidant activity values ranged from 1.81 ± 0.16 to
24.77 ± 6.51 mM GAE, with the highest activity coming from P.
igniarius (ie, fire sponge), and the lowest detectable activity
coming from L. edodes (ie, shiitake). H.
americanum (ie, lion’s mane), P. betulinus (ie,
birch bracket), and P. ostreatus (ie, oyster) showed no
activity using this method. Several samples were notable including the tincture
of all 11 mushrooms combined (21.08 mM GAE); F. fomentarius
(ie, tinder fungus), 10.51 mM GAE; and G. applanatum (ie,
artist conk), 10.33 mM GAE. Decoctions of chaga showed a direct relationship
between brew time and AOX activity, with the AOX activity of a 4-h brew reaching
nearly 90 mM GAE (more than 10 times stronger than a cup of tea). When decocted
a second time, the AOX activity of chaga was less than half that of the first
extraction.
Conclusions: Our results highlight the notable AOX activity of
P. igniarius, and further support the mixing of varietal
mushroom for an AOX-rich solution. Our work confirms the high AOX activity of
chaga and displays its usefulness throughout repetitive infusions and varied
infusion lengths.
(3247) Integrating Mindfulness Classes into Primary Care Clinics: Clinical and
Financial Considerations
Abigail Zeveloff, MSW, MPH1, Amy Locke, MD1, Bernadette Kiraly,
MD1, Ruben Tinajero, MS1 and Katherine Fortenberry,
PhD1
1Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Overview: Group therapy is an effective way to manage high patient
case loads while providing skill-based, behavioral treatment options.
Mindfulness skills, in particular, are effective treatment options for a variety
of mental health and medical conditions frequently seen in primary care. The use
of Health Behavior Assessment and Intervention (HBAI) codes provide innovative
ways to medically bill for behavioral group therapy visits. Mindfulness group
sessions, billed under these HBAI codes, offer patients timely, supportive, and
skill-based behavioral health therapy with a medical visit copay.
Rationale: Recent developments in primary care models support the
integration of behavioral health within patients’ primary medical homes. Despite
benefits of improved access and reduced stigma, barriers of long appointment
wait times and poor behavioral health insurance coverage remain. In 2 busy,
primary care clinics, we are addressing these barriers by developing 4-week
mindfulness classes which are billed through patients’ medical insurance using
HBAI codes. Group treatment is an ideal model of delivering behavioral health
interventions within medical clinics due to: management of high-volume caseloads
within a single, behavioral health appointment slot; providing patients with
concrete, behavioral skills; and the effectiveness of group therapy in treating
depression and anxiety with the added benefit of social learning. Mindfulness
skills have been shown to be effective in the treatment of conditions frequently
seen in primary care. The mental/behavioral health carve out of medical
insurance often do not adequately cover psychotherapy services, thus leaving
patients with session limits, high deductibles, and/or high copays. HBAI codes
provide a financially innovative way to medically bill for group treatment,
typically having the same out-of-pocket expenses as a primary medical care
appointments. HBAI appointments offer greater flexibility for working with
patients on targeted, health-related interventions in individual, 15-min
increments as well as up to 90-min group therapy. Through offering time-limited,
mindfulness group classes, primary care clinics are able to provide patients
with timely, affordable, skill-based behavioral health treatment. Furthermore,
clinics are able to diversify billing structures for behavioral health visits
while providing clients with in-house, integrative treatment options.
Objectives: The aim is to identify appropriate presenting issues for
mindfulness groups; identify ways in which to develop and recruit for behavioral
health groups; and generate a broad understanding of uses for HBAI billing
codes.
(3252) Promoting Research in Complementary and Integrative Health: A Framework
for Undergraduate Engagement
Deanne Tibbitts, PhD1, Heather Zwickey, PhD1, Morgan Schafer,
MA1 and Megan Golani, ND1
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Overview/Background: Many colleges and universities provide
opportunities for undergraduate students to engage in biomedical research.
However, opportunities for undergraduates to engage in complementary and
integrative health (CIH) research are limited.
Program Description: Here, we describe a framework for promoting CIH
research among undergraduates through an immersive, 8-week internship program at
a research institute within a CIH-centered university. Students engage in (1) an
introductory course on CIH, (2) small group discussions with CIH research
faculty, and (3) development and execution of an evidence-based personal
intervention project. Self-reported assessment of learning outcomes showed that
students improved their CIH research skills by the end of the program. Exit
interviews indicated that mentoring was a key component of the educational
experience.
Conclusion: Adoption of this framework may improve research skills
and foster interest in CIH research among undergraduate students.
Rationale: The goal of the program we have created is to advance
integrative health by inspiring the next generation of CIH clinicians and
scientists. Our program does this by engaging undergraduate students in CIH
research through a combination of research, education, and exposure to clinical
practice.
Objectives: Participants will learn about successful elements to
include when creating a CIH-focused research internship program for
undergraduate students.
(3256) Crowdsourcing Clinical Research: Feasibility of Amazon Mechanical Turk for
Obtaining National Data About Adults With Chronic Pain
Ron D Hays, PhD1, Ian D Coulter, PhD2 and Lara G. Hilton,
MPH2
1University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California
2RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: This study compares estimates of demographic
characteristics, health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and pain outcomes of
adults with chronic low back pain in the United States using crowdsourced data
(Amazon Mechanical Turk [AMT]), and data collected from 1129 patients in 125
chiropractic clinics from throughout the United States.
Results: The AMT sample was significantly younger, less educated,
with lower average annual income than chiropractic patients in the national
sample; after adjusting for the confounder chiropractic utilization, there were
no significant mean differences in pain and HRQOL between the AMT and national
chiropractic samples. The AMT data cost approximately $15 per respondent in
incentives, while the national sample cost was $200 per respondent.
Conclusions: The AMT sample differed on some demographic
characteristics but was similar in pain and HRQOL to a national sample of
chiropractic patients after controlling for utilization. The results of this
study suggest that estimates of patient-reported pain outcomes might be obtained
using relatively inexpensive crowdsourcing data collection platform.
(3257) Evaluation of Extended Practice and Workplace Integration Following a
Yoga-based Program for Workplace Professionals
Natalie L Trent, PhD1, Mindy Miraglia, MS2, Sat Bir S Khalsa,
PhD1, Jeffrey A Dusek, PhD3 and Edi Pasalis,
MBA2
1Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health, Stockbridge, Massachusetts
3Aurora Health Care, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Abstract
Purpose: This study examined the level of integration of practices
learned in a yoga-based program into the workplace and daily life, which has
been a challenge for previous mind–body programs.
Results: At post-resilience, integration, self-awareness, engagement
(RISE) assessment, participants generally reported a plan to practice the
skills/approaches learned in RISE (M = 73.1, standard deviation [SD] = ±25.6),
were likely to share the skills/approaches they learned with others
(M = 91.0 ± 10.6), and that it was feasible to accommodate RISE practices into
their schedule (M = 80.8 ± 18.9). At follow-up, participants reported that they
continued to practice RISE approaches (M = 61.0 ± 26.2). Most participants
reported they observed a positive shift in their workplace (M = 64.2 ± 16.4) and
that they shared skills/approaches with others (M = 71.0 ± 15.6). Qualitatively,
as in the post-RISE assessment, participants indicated continued practice of
yoga, mindfulness, breathing techniques, meditation, and experienced greater
self-care, compassion, and health due to RISE. Participants incorporated and
shared mindfulness, breathing techniques, mindful communication, and self-care
practices in their workplace. They described that their organization had
benefited from RISE by increasing the self-care and mindfulness of
colleagues.
Conclusions: The 5-day RISE program resulted in participants
reporting a wide range of psychosocial and organizational benefits. Participants
reported continued long-term use of the RISE practices in their workplace and
home.
(3259) Partially Randomized Controlled Trial Considering Patient Preference in
Comparative Evaluation of Nonpharmaceutical Therapy of Traditional Chinese
Medicine
Hui Hu, PhD1, Xin-lin Li1, Huijuan Cao, PhD2,
Jian-ping Liu, PhD1, Tian-jiao Li, PhD1, Zhan-guo
Xie3 and Ya-jing Zhang1
1Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
3The First Hospital in the Eastern District, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To investigate the feasibility of applying partially
randomized patients’ preference (PRPP) trial in clinical evaluation of cupping
therapy versus acupuncture.
Results: There were 4 parallel groups: randomized cupping (30
cases), nonrandomized cupping (27 cases), randomized acupuncture (30 cases), and
nonrandomized acupuncture (39 cases; Figure 1). The primary outcomes showed
nonrandomized participants completed the recruitment 8 months earlier. Though
totally 21 (16.67%) participants dropped out with no statistical difference
between randomized and nonrandomized participants (P = .62),
almost all cases of dropped out of nonrandomized patients were happened before
we decided to return the cost if the treatment completed. After adjusting the
impact of the strategy change, the drop-out rate of nonrandomized participants
might be 7.6% lower than of those who were randomized allocated. Neither the
patients’ expectation before treatment (P = .89, over 30% of
the participants expect to be cured) nor the patients’ satisfactory after
treatment (P = .43, probably 40% of the participants reported
very satisfied to the treatment) showed statistical difference related to the
grouping method. When assessing the effect of acupuncture and cupping on pain
relief, both of them made clinical meaningful reduction of pain intensity (mean
difference of visual analogue scale was—37.47 mm, 95% confidence interval from
−42.08 mm to −32.87 mm, P < .0001). However, no difference
was found between these 2 therapies (P = .77) as well as other
pain intensity assessment scores.
Conclusions: PRPP model may shorten the study duration and decrease
the drop-out rate. Since it may control the impact of patients’ preference on
outcome measurement (when lack of blinding methods), PRPP model may be suitable
to be applied in clinical evaluation of nonpharmaceutical therapy of traditional
Chinese medicine.
(3261) The Integrative Medicine Bubble
Tyler Phan, PhD1
1Goldman Institute for Social Research, Pittsburgh, PA
Abstract
Purpose: The pupose of the paper is to provide insight on the
possible risks and legitimacy of integrative medicine modalities in the United
States. The research focuses around the curriculum and standards of integrative
medicine throughout the country. Through a 3-year long survey of integrative
medicine practices across the nation, the evidence indicates a looming financial
catasrophe.
Results: There is evidence to support the vast majority of
curriculum of integrative medicine does not reflect a focus on patient safety.
Instead, much of the curriculum is based on the dominance of a homogenous
abstract medical theory. This theory supersedes other tradtions’ medical
theories in the attempt for standardization. This results in an inadequate
standard for a patient-centered care, the threat of a homogenous medical
tradition while marginalizing of other traditions, and the accruement of debt
for students from their education.
Conclusions: The data demonstates an inevitable crisis in the
pedagogical approaches to integrative medicine. If policy does not change to
take in consideration all of the issues provided in this paper, many professions
will fail and leave a whole generation in debt all while failing the safety of
patients.
(3290) Exploring Perceptions Pertaining to Spiritual Care
Religiousness/Spirituality and Traditional Medicine Among Different Countries Using
a Text Mining Approach
Hideaki Tanaka, PhD1, Kiyoshi Suzuki, MD, PhD1 and Tomoaki
Kimura, PhD1
1MOA Health Science Foundation, Atami-shi, Japan
Abstract
Purpose: To examine common understanding about spiritual care and
opinion toward incorporating spiritual care and traditional medicine into
medical care.
Methods: The international committee of the Japan Society of
Integrative Medicine conducted an electronic survey toward medical
professionals, government, and administrative staff from 14 different countries
(Japan, United States, Central & South America, Southern Europe, Asia,
Democratic Republic of Congo), which was translated into 7 different languages
prior to distribution. Survey questions regarding the participants’ opinion
about (1) spiritual care and (2) challenges in incorporating traditional
medicine and religiousness/spirituality into conventional medicine were analyzed
qualitatively through a text mining approach using SPSS Text Analysis for
Surveys 3.0.
Results: Data from 505 participants were analyzed, more than half
(54.2%) were either medical doctors or other medical staff. Responses from the
first question on spiritual care were classified into 16 categories. “Important”
and “needed” were the 2 most common categories extracted, others included
“medical treatment,” “mind,” “spiritual,” “human,” “religion,” and “purpose of
life.” Categories maybe related to terminal care such as “terminal” “pain” and
“alleviation” were also extracted. More than 20 categories were extracted from
responses to the second question. Most common were “religion,” “medical care,”
and “person.” Next, “inclination,” “health,” and “disease” were common.
“Religion” has both a positive and negative aspect, descriptions on challenges
toward incorporating religiousness/spirituality into modern medicine were
observed. Participants described “inclination” toward science or a specific
religion to be problematic. “Disease” was derived from opinions which discussed
the benefits of incorporating traditional medicine and
religiousness/spirituality into medicine in the process of recovery from
disease. The present survey did not include questions regarding religious
affiliation and religious views, therefore the relationship with the study
results is unknown.
Conclusion: Many participants believed spiritual care to be
important, however, many believed there to be challenges in incorporating
reigiousness/spirituality into medicine.
(3293) Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction and Yoga for Treating Chronic Headache:
Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses
Petra Klose, PhD1, Matthew J Leach, PhD2, Dennis Anheyer,
MA1, Holger Cramer, PhD1 and Gustav Dobos, MD,
PhD1
1University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
2University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and yoga are 2
mind–body techniques frequently used to treat pain-related conditions, but their
effects on headache symptoms remain uncertain. The aim of this presentation is
to report the findings of 2 systematic reviews examining the efficacy and safety
of MBSR and yoga in patients with chronic headache (ie, migraine and/or
tension-type headache).
Results: After full-text screening, 4 randomized controlled trials
(RCTs) with a total of 177 patients treated with MBSR and 5 RCTs with a total of
251 patients treated with yoga were eligible for quantitative analysis. While
yoga significantly reduced headache frequency (5 RCTs; standardized mean
difference [SMD]: −1.97 [95% CI: −2.75 to −1.19]), duration (4 RCTs; SMD: −1.46
[95% CI: −2.54 to −0.37]) and intensity (5 RCTs; SMD: −3.44 [95% CI: −6.08 to
−0.79]) in comparison to usual care, no evidence was found for MBSR in reducing
any of these outcomes when compared to usual care. Only 1 study on MBSR reported
safety-related data, while none of the studies on yoga reported such data.
Conclusions: Evidence supports the recommendation of yoga (but not
MBSR) as an adjunctive therapy for patients suffering from chronic headaches.
However, since study quality was mainly low, more rigorous RCTs are necessary to
underpin this recommendation.
(3301) Metaphor: The Language of Healers and Healing
Paul A Dieppe, MD1, Sara Warber, MD2, Sarah Godlingay,
PhD1 and Emmylou Rahtz, PhD1
1University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
2Ann Arbor University, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Abstract
Purpose: To explore how healing practitioners conceptualise
healing.
Methods: Self-identifying, practicing healers underwent in-depth
interviews of 60–90 min, during which their views on healing were explored, and
they were asked to tell stories about healing events. At the end of the
interview, they draw a picture in response to the question – ‘what does healing
mean to you?’ and what they said about the pictures as they drew was recorded.
The interviews were transcribed, and qualitative analysis of both interviews and
pictures undertaken.
Results: A total of 26 subjects have been interviewed. Six subjects
were qualified doctors, as well as self-identifying healers, the remainder were
practicing Reiki, energy healing or spiritual healing outside the conventional
medical system. Most subjects found it hard to talk about healing, many noting
that they did not have the language to explain the experiences that surrounded
their practice, or for the responses of their clients. Most resorted to the use
of metaphor to try to explain the subject. This was most apparent when they drew
pictures. The process of trying to draw what healing meant seemed to allow many
to access new ideas, concepts and metaphors that had not arisen when they were
talking rationally about the subject in the preceding interview. The most common
metaphors used included: growth (eg, nurturing a seed into growth), restoration
of wholeness (eg, pictures of order emerging from chaos, or of something being
mended), energy channelling (the idea of energy transfer within the body, or
into the body from outside), the value of nature (stories of the restorative
power of nature), making connections between people (eg, pictures of individuals
connecting together) and love (eg, pictures of hearts).
Conclusions: Healing is an experiential issue, best described
through the use of metaphor.
(3303) The Experience of People Being Treated by Healers
Sue Knight, BSc1, Sue Child, BSc2, Emmylou Rahtz,
PhD2, Sara Warber, MD3 and Paul A Dieppe,
MD2
1Confederation of Healing Organisations, London, UK
2University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
3Ann Arbor University, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Abstract
Purpose: To gain further understanding of the experience of clients
being treated by spiritual or energy healers.
Methods: The UK Confederation of Healing Organisations (CHO) sent
survey forms to their constitent healing groups as well as individual healers,
asking for information about individual healing encounters. The data sought
included information on the age and gender of client, the main reasons for their
seeking healing, the experiences of the client and their perceptions of the
‘outcome’.
Results: A total of 281 completed forms, each relating to a single
client–practitioner interaction, were obtained and have been analysed both
quantitatively and qualitatively. The healers identified themselves as
predominantly spiritual, Reiki or energy, healers and used a variety of
different techniques to activate healing. Clients were predominantly female
(76%) with an age range of 19 to 90 (median 55). The main reasons for seeking
healing were mental health problems, musculoskeletal disorders, pain and
fatigue. Ninety-three percent of clients reported some immediate benefit. The
most commonly reported outcomes were relaxation (57%) and improved general
well-being (29%). In addition, many reported physical effects, including
feelings of warmth and heat (16%), relief of pain (14%), being energised (13%),
seeing colours (5%) and sensations of pressure or tingling (5%). Many clients
reported being amazed by the effect, for example, one said, ‘I think it’s
brilliant. I don’t understand it, but it bloody works’.
Conclusions: Treatments by healers can induce significant relief of
symptoms and improvements in well-being and can also result in unusual
physiological responses.
(3304) Creating a Healing Space Within a General Hospital Corridor
Paul A Dieppe, MD1, Emmylou Sara Warber, MD2, Lisa Rahtz,
PhD1, Deborah Harty, BSc3, Sarah Weinreb, BSc4
and Godlingay PhD1
1University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
2Ann Arbor University, Ann Arbor, Michigan
3Musgrove Park Hospital, Taunton, UK
4Bristol, UK
Abstract
Background: Healing is difficult to talk about or describe, as it is
essentially an individual experiential phenomenon or process, rather than a
definable ‘thing’. Therefore, it may be easier to open conversations about
healing through exhibitions and experiences, rather than written material.
Methods: We have been undertaking interviews with doctors, healers,
their clients and members of the general public in a variety of different
places. In most instances, we posed the question ‘what does the word healing
mean to you?’ We have obtained drawings as well as spoken or written answers to
this question. Some of these responses were used to develop an artistic
exhibition to be shown in a large General Hospital in South West England.
Quotations about healing and responses for interviewees were put together around
4 emergent themes: (1) the many ways of being broken, (2) connections with
others and with the natural world, (3) healing at the end of life’s journey and
(4) wholeness and oneness. In addition, a ‘cabinet of healing curiosities from
around the world’ was displayed. The exhibition was displayed in a busy corridor
of the hospital for 5 months. Responses were obtained from people viewing the
exhibition through written feedback, brief interviews and via a focus group with
hospital staff. Some people found it difficult to relate to the exhibition, or
thought it confusing, but the vast majority, particularly patients and nursing
staff k, were enthusiastic. Many described it as a ‘healing space’ and patients
as well as staff said they came to look at it again and again to help them in
their own healing journeys. A few people described it as transformational for
them.
Conclusions: Healing exhibitions can be of great value within
general hospitals.
(3310) Comparisons of Integrative Medicine Group Visit and Clinical Visits in
Improving the Application of Adaptive Stress Management Techniques Among Patients
With Chronic Pain and Depression
Man Luo, MPH1, Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1 and Salvatore D'Amico,
BS1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose/Background: For low-income racially diverse patients with chronic pain
and depression, high stress levels are very common. Integrative Medicine Group
Visits (IMGV) teach the principles of Mindfulness and Evidence-Based Integrative
Medicine Techniques such as stress management techniques. This analysis aims to
compare the effectiveness of IMGV group to a clinical visit in improving
applications of adaptive stress management techniques.
Results: This study included 155 participants, among which 86% were
female, 58% were self-reported Black, and the average age was 50. At baseline,
participants who did exercise had significantly lower pain medication use
(P = .04) and opioid use (P < .01) than
those did not exercise. For summary scores, intervention group had more adaptive
techniques than control group at week 9 (P = .09) and week 21
(P = .14). The use of nonadaptive stress management
techniques was similar between intervention and control groups. For individual
adaptive techniques, there was a significant increase in doing exercise among
intervention participants at both week 9 (risk ratio [RR]: 3.25, confidence
interval [CI]: 1.14, 10.47) and week 21 (RR: 4.05, CI: 1.18, 15.75) compared to
control group. Intervention group also had a significant increase in doing
meditation compared to control at week 9 (RR: 7.98, CI: 2.37, 33.00) adjusted
for baseline meditation.
Conclusions: The study suggested that IMGV is a good method to
increase participants’ positive stress management techniques such as doing
exercise and meditation.
(3315) Mindfulness-based Cognitive Therapy for Depressed Individuals Improves
Suppression of Irrelevant Mental-sets
Jonathan Greenberg, PhD1, Sara W Lazar, PhD1, Benjamin G
Shapero, PhD and David Mischoulon, MD, PhD
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Depression is a leading cause of disability and one of the
most common mental disorders. It is characterized by impaired ability to
suppress competing or currently irrelevant mental sets such as distracting
ruminative thoughts. Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) was specifically
designed to help depressed individuals avoid getting caught in such irrelevant
mental sets. However, is currently unknown whether MBCT can improve this
ability, and how such benefits relate to improvements in depressive
symptoms.
Results: The MBCT group exhibited significantly lower depression
scores and greater improvements in irrelevant mental-set suppression compared to
a wait-list plus treatment-as-usual group. Moreover, improvements in
mental-set-suppression were associated with improvements in depression
scores.
Conclusions: Results provide the first evidence that MBCT can
improve suppression of irrelevant mental sets, a key cognitive deficit in
depression, and that such improvements are associated with depressive
alleviation. The potential role of improvement in cognitive functioning is
discussed in the context of the efficacy of MBCT in treating depression and
preventing relapse is discussed.
(3317) Mindfulness-based Resilience Training to Reduce Health Risk, Stress
Reactivity, and Aggression Among Law Enforcement Officers: A Feasibility and
Preliminary Efficacy Trial
Matthew Hunsinger, PhD1, Sarah Richard Goerling, MBA2, Cindy
Bowen, PhD1, Jens Gross, PhD3, Michael Pruessner,
PhD4 and Christopher, PhD1
1Pacific University, Hillsboro, Oregon
2Hillsboro Police Department, Hillsboro, Oregon
3Minneapolis, Minnesota
4McGill University, Quebec City, Quebec, Canada
Abstract
Purpose: As first responders who are frequently exposed to
job-related trauma, law enforcement officers are at an elevated risk of adverse
health outcomes. The stressful nature of policing and the substantial
limitations of both tertiary and secondary prevention suggest a real need for
primary prevention research on ways to increase resilience and reduce
aggression. The primary objective of this study was to assess feasibility and
gather preliminary outcome data on mindfulness-based resilience training (MBRT)
for law enforcement officers.
Results: Attendance, adherence, posttraining participant feedback,
and interventionist fidelity to protocol all demonstrate feasibility of MBRT for
law enforcement officers. Compared to waitlist controls, MBRT participants
experienced greater reductions in salivary cortisol (AUCi), self-reported
aggression, burnout, alcohol use, sleep disturbance, and increases in
psychological flexibility and nonreactivity at posttraining; however, group
differences were not maintained at 3-month follow-up.
Conclusions: This initial randomized trial suggests MBRT is a
feasible intervention, and a larger fully powered randomized Controlled trial is
warranted. Outcome data suggest that MBRT targets key physiological,
psychological, and health risk factors in law enforcement officers, consistent
with the potential to improve officer health and public safety. However,
follow-up training or “booster” sessions may be needed to maintain training
gains.
(3318) Effects of Mindfulness and Acceptance Interventions on Affect Tolerance
and Sensitivity: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials
Kristen Kraemer, PhD1, Christina M Luberto, PhD2 and Gloria
Yeh, MD, MPH2
1Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Affect tolerance/sensitivity, broadly defined as the
ability to withstand negative emotional states, has been implicated in the
development and maintenance of numerous forms of psychopathology, negative
health behaviors, and chronic illnesses. Though considered a trait-like
predisposition, affect tolerance/sensitivity factors are malleable and have been
posited to improve with mindfulness and acceptance interventions. The aim of the
current review was to synthesize the available literature evaluating mindfulness
and acceptance interventions on affect tolerance/sensitivity.
Results: Seventeen randomized controlled trials with 16 unique
samples (pooled N = 1001) were included. Interventions ranged from 15 min to 12
weeks. Studies included outcomes of anxiety sensitivity (fear of arousal-related
sensations; n = 8), distress tolerance (ability to withstand emotional distress;
n = 6), and intolerance of uncertainty (inability to withstand uncertain states;
n = 3). Most studies included healthy adults (25%), those with an anxiety
disorder (25%), or substance use problems (19%). Mindfulness and acceptance
interventions were associated with greater longitudinal improvements in affect
tolerance/sensitivity compared to inactive controls (n = 7), similar
improvements compared to active interventions (eg, cognitive behavioral therapy;
n = 7), and greater short-term improvements compared to acute experimental
conditions (eg, avoidance, rumination; n = 3). Studies were generally of
moderate quality. Further formal meta-analysis is forthcoming.
Conclusions: Mindfulness and acceptance interventions appear
promising for improving affect tolerance/sensitivity across multiple
populations. Future work is needed to determine whether specific mindfulness or
acceptance interventions differentially improve affect tolerance/sensitivity and
whether these improvements mediate treatment outcomes.
(3319) Health-related Links Between Chronic Symptoms and Yoga Program
Attendance
Louise Mahoney, MS1, Linda Collery, MA1, Peter J. Bayley,
PhD2, Melinda Wong, BS1 and Jennifer Hanft,
MS1
1U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, Palo Alto, California
2Palo Alto, California
Abstract
Purpose: Yoga is becoming increasingly popular as an adjunct therapy
in health-care settings for a range of mental and physical health conditions.
Despite a broad consensus that yoga may benefit health, many people do not
attend classes, even when recommended by their health-care provider. We explored
the health-related links between reasons for referral to a clinical yoga program
and attendance.
Results: The 3 most common reasons for referral were musculoskeletal
pain (n = 67), stress/anxiety (n = 61), and health/wellness (n = 59). Only 45
(39.5%) of the sample attended at least 1 yoga class. Attendance varied
according to the referral reason. Conditions with the best attendance rates
included those referred for stress/anxiety (49%), meditation/mindfulness (46%),
and symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (41%). Conditions having
the poorest attendance rates included those referred for chronic fatigue (23%),
nonmusculoskeletal chronic pain (24%), and musculoskeletal pain (27%). Veterans
were also given a questionnaire (Mymop-2) over the phone to identify their main
subjective health complaints prior to their first yoga class. These data showed
a similar pattern such that the best attendance rates were those reporting mood
disorders including depression, anxiety, and PTSD (59%). Likewise, the poorest
attendance rates were those reporting musculoskeletal problems (33%) and chronic
musculoskeletal pain (34%).
Conclusions: The data indicate a systematic pattern. Those referred
to the yoga program for stress or wellness were more likely to attend, perhaps
due to the perceived mental health benefits of yoga. Those referred for chronic
pain or other musculoskeletal problems were less likely to attend, perhaps due
to the physical difficulty of attending. Further research is warranted to
identify more precisely the reasons for attendance and nonattendance in clinical
yoga programs.
(3326) Group Yoga Effects on Cancer Patient and Caregiver Symptom Distress:
Assessment of Self-reported Symptoms at a Comprehensive Cancer Center
Alejandro Chaoul, PhD1, Catherine Powers-James, PhD1, Carol A
Eddy, MPT1, Smitha G Mallaiah, MS1, Amie D Koronczok,
MS1, Gabriel Lopez, MD1, Telma Gomez, MS1,
Janet Williams, MPH1, Qi Wei, MS1, Eduardo Bruera,
MD1 and Lorenzo Cohen, PhD1
1Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Complementary and integrative health approaches such as
yoga provide benefits for psychosocial health. We explored the effects of group
yoga classes available to patients and caregivers in the outpatient center of an
integrative medicine program at a comprehensive cancer center.
Results: Two hundred eighty-three unique participants (205 patients,
78 caregivers; 81% female, 74% Caucasian; ages 23–90) attended 1 or more yoga
groups from July 18, 2016, to August 8, 2017. Eighty-nine percent of
participants completed at least a preassessment; 65% completed both pre- and
postassessments. Similarities in baseline symptom burden for patients versus
caregivers included anxiety, pain, sleep and Edmonton Symptom Assessment System
(ESAS) subscale of psychological distress (PSS; all P’s
>.05). For all participants, we observed clinically significant
reduction/improvement in physical distress, global distress, and PSS scores and
in individual symptoms (ESAS decrease ≥1; means) of anxiety (−2.0), fatigue
(−1.83), well-being (−1.68), depression (−1.2), appetite (−1.1), drowsiness
(−1.0), and sleep (−1.0). Clinically significant improvement for both patients
and caregivers was observed for symptoms of anxiety, depression, fatigue, and
well-being and for all ESAS subscales. Clinically significant improvement was
observed in the patient group only for appetite and drowsiness.
Conclusions: A single yoga group class resulted in relief of
multiple self-reported symptoms for both cancer patients and caregivers. Further
research is needed to better track symptoms over time, to understand the
symptoms that yoga can help control, and how differences in yoga class content
and intensity can affect outcomes.
(3329) Building Research Across Interdisciplinary Gaps Clinical Research Training
Program in Complementary and Integrative Health
Craig Scott, MD1, Cathryn Booth-LaForce, PhD1, Heather Zwickey,
PhD2 and Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH2
1University of Washington, Seattle, Washington
2National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: To present key design and evaluation features of a National
Institutes of Health-funded multidisciplinary clinical research training program
in complementary and integrative health (CIH) geared toward doctoral degree
holders in both CIH clinical and conventional bioscience disciplines.
Results: Clinical backgrounds of T90 fellows include doctors of
acupuncture and oriental medicine (DAOM; n = 2) and naturopathic medicine (ND;
n = 1). R90 research backgrounds include doctors of philosophy in toxicology
(n = 1), nutrition and food science (n = 1), chemistry (n = 1), nursing research
(n = 1), and genetics (n = 1). Mean results of Clinical Research Appraisal
Inventory assessments upon entry to the program (n = 8) suggest moderate
confidence in choosing a research topic (7.3), refining a study question (7.3),
providing a scientific rationale (7.4), and expressing the idea in writing
(7.6). Mean results suggest less confidence in providing direction to a
statistician (2.1), performing specific statistical tests (3), preparing a
project budget (3.25), connecting scientific designs to analytical methods
(3.25), and ensuring data reliability (4.6). Mean scores increased in all areas
of appraisal with increased years in training.
Conclusions: By combining clinical research methodologies with
immersive mentorship in the context of CIH, the UW-NUNM BRIDG program
exemplifies a new standard for the multidisciplinary training of clinical
researchers.
(3330) A Collaborative Clinical Approach—Lessons Learned During a Pilot Sickle
Cell Wellness Clinic
Melanie Brown, MD1, Kristin Moquist, APRN, CNP1, Rae Blaylark,
CHW1 and Ashley N Junghans-Rutelonis, PhD1
1Children’s Hospitals and Clinics of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Overview: The Sickle Cell Wellness Clinic pilot period in 2017–2018
will include 12 - to 21-year-old youth with sickle cell disease (SCD) and their
caregivers. Structured around feedback from an intensive family focus group,
this monthly 1/2 day clinic, housed within Pain, Palliative Care, and
Integrative Medicine (PPCIM) Department and including collaboration with the
Department of Hematology/Oncology, will provide services in both individual and
group settings with goals of increasing use of proactive coping skills and
integrative medicine strategies. While pilot data will be mentioned, the major
goal of the presentation will be a discussion of program development, model
feasibility, and lessons learned during pilot stages of a 12-discipline,
collaborative clinic.
Rationale: SCD is the most common genetic disorder among
African-Americans in the United States, impacting 73.1 per 1000 African-American
births. Importantly, youth with SCD often have comorbid chronic pain and poor
access to quality health-care and insurance coverage, which can impact their
health-care utilization and functional outcomes. Within this Midwestern
Children’s hospital, there has been no predictable process for referring youth
with SCD to the PPCIM Department or to teach pain management strategies outside
of crisis inpatient consultation. The new Sickle Cell Wellness Clinic, a
collaboration of 12 disciplines, provides programming to help youth with SCD
normalize daily life by teaching skills to cope with SCD pain, minimize chronic
pain development, and improve quality of life through proactive symptom
management and wellness. It is critical to examine how disciplines can
collaborate to advance service provision for often underserved and at-risk youth
with SCD and to discuss how 1 Children’s Hospital has made strides in this
area.
Objectives: Attendees will be able to list facilitators and barriers
that go into planning a collaborative clinic and identify how to increase family
buy-in and feedback.
(3334) A Novel Nutritional Formulation Containing the Prebiotic Human Milk
Oligosaccharide 2′-Fucosyllactose Reduces Gastrointestinal Symptoms and Beneficially
Alters the Gut Microbiome in Adults With Gastrointestinal Dysfunction
Kirti Salunkhe, MD1, Jennifer J Nikhat Contractor, PhD1 and
Ryan, ND, MS2
1Metagenics, Inc., Gig Harbor, Washington
2National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Gut dysbiosis, disruption in the homeostasis of the
intestinal microbiota, contributes to the pathogenesis of many gastrointestinal
disorders. Human milk oligosaccharides, which are naturally occurring in human
breast milk, are considered “bifidogenic” and “butyrogenic.” In breast-fed
infants, they serve as primary substrates for select
Bifidobacterium spp. and are metabolized into butyrate by
butyrate-producing gut microbiota. Upper Gastrointestinal Research (UGIR) is a
formulation that provides nutritional support for adults with gastrointestinal
dysfunction; it contains a combination of essential macro- and micronutrients
and prebiotics, including 2′-fucosyllactose (2′FL). This study reports novel
data on the effect of 2′FL, in the context of a comprehensive nutritional
formulation, in adults with gastrointestinal dysfunction.
Results: Twelve participants completed the study. Gastrointestinal
Quality of Life Index total score, gastrointestinal symptoms domain, and social
function domain scores improved (P < .05). Butyrate,
acetate, and total short chain fatty acids (SCFAs) increased
(P < .05). Several commensal bacteria increased including
Bifidobacterium spp., Bifidobacterium
longum, Faecalibacterium prausnitzii,
Aneurotruncus colihominis, and
Pseudoflavonifractor spp.
(P < .05).
Conclusions: UGIR consumption was associated with reduced
gastrointestinal symptoms, increased fecal SCFAs, increases in several
beneficial gut microbes (including species that have been shown to consume 2′FL
as a substrate in vitro), increases in butyrate-producing species, and increases
in species that have been previously shown to be low in patients with
inflammatory bowel syndrome, inflammatory bowel disease, and celiac disease. It
is plausible that the improvements in butyrate levels and commensal gut
microbiota contributed to the clinical benefits demonstrated on the
questionnaire. These results suggest that UGIR is a promising novel nutritional
formulation that could be used in the management of gastrointestinal dysfunction
associated with gut dysbiosis.
(3335) Predicting Osteoporotic Fractures by Bone Mineral Density, Conventional
Risk Factors, and Clinical Symptoms for Chinese Community Middle-aged Women
Yili Zhang1, Hao Shen2, Junjie Jiang, PhD2, Yan
Chai, PhD3, Yanming Xie2 and Xu Wei, PhD3
1Institute of Basic Research in Clinical Medicine, China Academy of
Chinese, Beijing, China
2China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China
3Wangjing Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing,
China
Abstract
Purpose: The aim was to construct an early risk prediction tool for
community women aged 40–65 years with osteoporotic fracture in Beijing and
Shanghai.
Results: Eventually, the Cox univariate analysis showed that major
pathogenic factors for osteoporotic fractures were age, whether menopause or
not, years of menopause, delivery times, dizziness, lower limb spasm, and bone
mineral density (BMD) classification. The Cox’s model was constructed
respectively including model 1 (BMD classification plus conventional risk
factors and clinical symptoms), model 2 (BMD classification plus conventional
risk factors), and model 3 (conventional risk factors plus clinical symptoms).
The receiver operating characteristic curve indicated that model 1 had the best
prediction accuracy.
Conclusions: Based on the relative risk coefficients of various
factors at different level of model 1, the early risk prediction tool for
osteoporotic fractures of community middle-aged women was initially
established.
(3337) Wellness in Teaching: A Dynamic Educational Intervention to Improve
Faculty Performance
Bryan A Lamoreau, MD1, Vicki Sue Rose, MPH1, Amy Hayes,
MD1, Christine Segdwick, MD, FACEP, E-RYT1 and Hein,
MD1
1Maine Medical Center, Portland, Maine
Abstract
Overview/Background: Health-care providers’ wellness has been identified as a key
quality indicator linked with efficiency and safety. Interaction between
providers and patients involves unique interpersonal and emotional demands with
potential for emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and burnout. For
providers in an academic setting, there are additional expectations for teaching
and research that can add additional stress. Significant attention has been paid
to resident physician work hours and burnout, driving very recent Accreditation
Council for Graduate Medical Education changes to address well-being. However,
there is scarce data for the role of curricula aimed at prevention of burnout in
faculty physicians and other teaching clinicians that are often working in
direct supervisory roles of learners including residents. This study aims to
improve several measures of wellness in this heavily influential group.
Program Description: This is a pilot program consisting of 3
modules, each 2 weeks in duration, that will teach and reinforce wellness
concepts of flow, mindfulness, and resilience with practical applications to
improve teaching effectiveness. Additionally, the program will include regular
yoga practice at local yoga studios to reinforce the practical application of
these concepts. Pre- and postqualitative surveys and validated scales of these
concepts will be used to assess the effects of the program.
Conclusion: At this time, curriculum and data collection are
ongoing. We postulate that the effects of the Wellness in Teaching program will
result in less self-reported stress and burnout and improve wellness as measured
on the scales. This may translate to increasing educators’ sense of well-being
and teaching self-efficacy as well as their ability to manage the learning
environment and establish and maintain supportive relationships with learners.
We are hopeful that as a result of our pilot that institutional changes such as
the inclusion of regular yoga or other wellness opportunities at our academic
center could result.
Rationale: Burnout in health-care providers has been a topic of
growing interest, especially as evidence of its wide spanning ill effects within
a health-care system continues to accumulate. This has driven a growing number
of academic centers and health-care organizations to implement strategies to
combat burnout and promote wellbeing among providers. This study is unique and
important in that it targets attending providers that play a supervisory and
teaching role, and thus exert a heavy influence on learners, most notably
residents, and medical students. Whether willingly or not these are the role
models of our next generation of providers. We foresee the benefit of improving
provider wellness as a way to also create an improved experience for both our
learners and the patients that interact with our participants. We see our
stakeholders as any provider or faculty member within the institution, and we
see this pilot program as gathering much needed data to show the wide-reaching
benefits of wellness programs such as the Wellness in Teaching program. Wellness
programs are associated with lowering health-care costs, reducing absenteeism,
achieving higher employee productivity, reducing workers’ compensation and
disability-related costs, reducing injuries, and improving employee morale and
loyalty.
Objectives: Participants will understand the current state of
evidence regarding the impact of provider burnout, and conversely well-being, at
both the interpersonal and organizational levels; participants will become
familiar with validated tools of assessment used in flow, mindfulness, and
resilience; and Participants will be able to analyze the results of this study
and consider potential applications within his/her own organization.
(3343) Cooking Up Health: Assessing the Efficacy of a Culinary Medicine Elective
in Medical Students
Stephanie Folkens, BA1, Neilé Edens, PhD1, Elaine Cheung,
PhD1, Rupa Mahadevan, MD1 and Melinda Ring,
MD2
1Chicago, Illinois
2Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: Physicians are the frontline of advising patients on
nutrition; however, physicians report feeling ill-prepared to counsel patients
on nutrition, and patients often lack the basic skills to make changes to their
diet. Only 27% of medical school teach the recommended 25 h of nutrition, and
fewer than 14% of practicing physicians feel adequately trained. These findings
highlight a need for attention to nutrition in the medical school
curriculum.
Results: Over the course of the elective, students showed increased
confidence in nutrition and obesity counseling (Ps < .002)
and improved attitudes about the importance of nutrition counseling in patient
care (P = .003). Moreover, students showed increases in their
own cooking and nutrition confidence (Ps < .004). We did not
find parallel changes in students’ actual cooking or eating behavior
(Ps > .47).
Conclusions: This study provided preliminary evidence demonstrating
the efficacy of a culinary medicine elective for increasing medical students’
confidence in counseling patients in nutrition care and for increasing students’
own cooking and nutrition confidence. Ultimately, this program of research may
provide evidence to support widespread integration of the current elective into
medical education.
(3345) Conducting a Scoping Review on Mind–Body Medicine in Pediatric
Oncology
Angelica L D'Aiello, BA1 and Jennifer A Lyon, MS, MLIS,
AHIP2
1SUNY Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York
2Children’s Mercy Kansas City, Kansas City, Missouri
Abstract
Purpose: Scoping reviews represent a valuable technique for
assessing the conceptual underpinnings of emerging topic areas, particularly
when the topical literature encompasses varying interventions, research
techniques, and outcomes. Here, we describe our experience conducting a scoping
review of mind–body interventions in pediatric oncology.
Results: Both authors individually evaluated every abstract,
resulting in 274 conflicts out of 2165 examined. Conflicts were resolved by
mutual agreement, resulting in the elimination of 1867 abstracts. Both authors
individually screened the remaining 298 full-text articles, mutually resolved 26
conflicts, ending with 74 selected articles. Citation tracking identified 4
additional studies for a final total of 78 included studies. These were
iteratively examined, leading to more stringent definitions of exclusion
criteria. The final major categories of interventions included
“meditation/mindfulness,” “yoga/tai chi,” “massage,” “healing touch/reiki,”
“acupuncture,” “art/music therapy,” “virtual reality/advanced technology,” and
“complex programs.”
Conclusions: The success of a scoping review on emerging fields such
as integrative medicine depends on the initial precision of inclusion/exclusion
criteria and a willingness to fine-tune those criteria based on the nature of
the literature itself. Within the field of pediatric oncology, there is a wide
range of mind–body interventions being studied that are imprecisely defined. The
scoping review illuminates the need for significantly improved clarity of
interventions and outcomes.
(3346) Starting a National Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health: The
Dutch Experience
Ines von Rosenstiel, MD1, Miek C Jong, PhD2, Rogier Hoenders,
MD, PhD3 and Martine Busch, Msc4
1Hagaziekenhuis, Den Haag, the Netherlands
2Mid Sweden University, Sundsvall, Sweden
3Centre for Integrative Psychiatry, Lentis, Groningen, the Netherlands
4Van Praag Institute, Utrecht, the Netherlands
Abstract
Purpose: Assessing interest in and need for a Dutch consortium for
Integrative Medicine and Health to support the worldwide growth of Complementary
and Integrative Medicine (CIM) and to guide and improve patient care, research,
education, policy and advocacy regarding CIM in the Netherlands.
Methods: The Dutch Organisation for Health Research and Development
(ZonMw) installed a steering committee to guide 6 pioneering hospitals/research
institutes in developing a Dutch consortium. Board members of these
organisations and stakeholders from CIM organisations were interviewed about
their perceptions, needs and concerns regarding the foundation of a Dutch
consortium. Relevant topics were discussed during an invitational conference.
American CIM centres were visited and international experts interviewed. The
board of the American consortium was consulted.
Results: Most Dutch hospitals offer services regarding CIM, however,
often without clear procedures or quality standards. There is an urgent need for
high-quality research on CIM in the Netherlands, specifically in terms of
safety, efficacy and patient outcome. There is also a need for better education
and policy making. Facilitators for starting a Dutch consortium are patient
demand, new health concepts like positive health, worldwide interest and growth
in CIM and support from Dutch medical doctors, researchers and hospital boards
with experience in CIM. Barriers are insufficient funding, lack of consensus
regarding terminology and framing and influential organisations and doctors that
oppose to CIM. All those interviewed stress the need for a Dutch consortium. A
founding meeting took place on the first of May 2017 in the presence of board
members of the American Consortium. Mission and 5-year strategic plan are now
being formulated. Future collaboration with the America consortium was discussed
and formalised.
Conclusions: A Dutch consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health
is feasible and needed.
Rationale: The use of CIM is widespread in the Netherlands and the
Western world at large. A national survey in the Netherlands demonstrated that
almost all Dutch hospitals offer some CIM. However, there is no national
research agenda, a lack of national policy regarding the integration of
conventional medicine and CIM and a need for better education on CIM. The
American consortium has been an essential factor in the growth of CIM, but to
further support and facilitate the growth of CIM worldwide, more national
consortia are needed.
Objectives: Participants will learn about (lessons learned in the
Netherlands) the process of starting a national consortium. What are
facilitators, pittfalls and barriers?
(3355) Is Tai Chi Effective for Treating Osteopenia and Primary Osteoporosis?
Grading the Evidence Through Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Yanming Xie1, Xu Wei, PhD2, Junjie Jiang, PhD1, Yili
Zhang3, Hao Shen1 and Yan Chai PhD4, 5
1China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China
2Wangjing Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing,
China
3Institute of Basic Research in Clinical Medicine, China Academy of
Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China
4University of California, Los Angeles, USA
5Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: The necessity of lifelong treatment and the potential side
effects like upper gastrointestinal symptoms hinder pharmacologic treatments for
osteoporosis. Tai Chi (TC), one of traditional Chinese exercises without side
effects, has proven to be effective in the treatment of many orthopedic
diseases. This systematic review was performed to determine the clinical
efficacy and safety of TC for osteopenia and primary osteoporosis and provide
clear evidence to inform clinical practice.
Results: Meta-analysis showed that there was no statistically
difference between TC plus conventional treatments (CTs) and CTs on any
outcomes. Both in the subgroup that TC versus no intervention and TC versus CTs,
there was significant difference on spinal bone mineral density (BMD; 95%
confidence interval [CI]: 0.60 to 1.02; 95% CI: 0.09 to 0.23) values, femoral
BMD value (95% CI: 0.01 to 0.06; 95% CI: 0.04 to 0.29). Two trials compared TC
versus no treatment through the index of quantitative ultrasound but result
indicated that TC maybe have a little bit effect only on reducing the SOS (95%
CI: 1.28 to 25.76). In addition, 2 trials compared TC plus CTs versus CTs on BGP
(95% CI: −1.66 to −0.70), which found a remarkable difference between the 2
groups.
Conclusions: There were positive results for TC to benefit for
osteopenia and primary osteoporosis. However, the relevant evidence should be
interpreted with caution due to the low methodological quality. International
methodological and reporting standards could help researchers conduct
well-designed trials and improve the level of evidence for Chinese herbal
medicine.
(3361) Complementary Medicine in Cancer Care: An Observational Retrospective
Study on Patients With Cancer at the Hospital of Lucca (Italy)
Cristina Noberasco, MD1, Editta Baldini, MD2, Marco Picchi,
PsycD1, Mariella Di Stefano, BA1 and Elio G Rossi,
MD3
1Tuscan Regional Center for Complementary Medicine, Lucca, Italy
2ASL Toscana North West, Lucca, Italy
3Local Health Unit Tuscany North West of the Region of Tuscany, Lucca,
Italy
Abstract
Purpose: This retrospective observational study describes the
results of complementary medicine (CM) treatment to reduce the adverse effects
of anticancer treatment and cancer symptoms and improve the quality of life of
cancer patients seen at the Clinic for Complementary Medicine and diet in
oncology of the hospital of Lucca (Italy). Near all the patients are referred by
their medical oncologists.
Results: Main type of cancer or localization were breast (56.2%),
colon (7.2%), lung (5.4%), ovary (4.2%), stomach (2.7%), prostate (2.5%), uterus
(2.7%), brain (1.5%), kidney (1.2%), liver (0.6%), and pancreas (1,1%). Symptoms
most frequently treated were adverse effects of anticancer therapies (61.9%),
namely, the effects of chemotherapy (37.9%), hormonal therapy (16.3%), surgery
(3.2%), and radiotherapy (4.5%). Cancer symptoms were 23.1% and the concomitant
symptoms 11.8%. The most frequent symptoms were asthenia/fatigue, hot flashes,
depression, neuropathy, nausea/vomiting after chemotherapy, irritable intestine,
diarrhea, leucopenia, dermatitis, anxiety, and radiodermitis. Comparing the
clinical conditions before and after the treatment, we observed a significant
amelioration of nausea (P < .05), insomnia
(P < 05), depression (P < .001),
anxiety (P < .05), asthenia (P < .001),
mucositis (P < .05), hot flashes
(P < .001), articular pain (P < .05),
dysgeusia (P < .05), and also prevention of radiodermitis
(P ≤ .01).
Conclusions: A clinic of integrative oncology seems to give the
possibility to reduce adverse effects of anticancer therapy and ameliorate the
quality of life of cancer patients.
(3366) Complementary and Alternative Medicine Visits by Persons With Mental
Disorders Across Disorders and Treatment Settings in 29 Countries: Results From the
World Mental Health Surveys
Peter de Jonge, PhD1, Klaas J Wardenaar, PhD1, Ronald Kessler,
PhD2, Viviane K Masfety, PhD3, Sara Evans-Lacko,
PhD4, Graham Thornicroft, PhD4 and Rogier Hoenders, MD,
PhD5
1Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, Groningen, the Netherlands
2Boston, Massachusetts
3Université Paris Descartes, Paris, France
4King’s College London, London, UK
5Center for Integrative Psychiatry, Lentis, Groningen, the Netherlands
Abstract
Purpose: A substantial proportion of persons with mental disorders
visits complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) professionals, often in
conjunction with conventional psychiatric or general medical treatment. However,
a data-driven overview of how CAM use varies across countries, mental disorders
and their severity, and health-care settings is currently lacking.
Results: An estimated 3.6% (standard error [SE] 0.2%) reported
visiting a CAM provider, which was 2 times higher in high-income countries
(4.6%; SE 0.3%) than in low- to middle-income countries (2.3%; SE 0.2%). CAM
visits were largely comparable for different disorder types but particularly
high in persons receiving conventional care (8.6%–17.8%). CAM visits increased
with increasing mental disorder severity, particularly in those receiving
conventional care. Among persons receiving specialist mental health care, CAM
visits were reported by 14.0% for severe mood disorders, 16.2% for severe
anxiety disorders, and 22.5% for severe behavioral disorders.
Conclusions: CAM visits are particularly common in persons with
severe mental disorders, in high-income countries, and in persons receiving
conventional care. Our findings underscore the need for a coordination of
conventional and CAM treatments.
(3368) The Pharmacological and Nonpharmacological Treatment of Functional
Constipation in Adults: Protocol for an Umbrella Systematic Review and
Network-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Ying Li1, Xiaohang Yang1, Li Liu1 and Hui
Zheng2
1Shaanxi University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Xianyang, China
2Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Chengdu, China
Abstract
Purpose: Functional constipation (FC) is one of the most common
functional bowel disease associated with substantial socioeconomic loss. Despite
several interventions have been tested for their effectiveness in managing FC
with randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews, the comparative
effectiveness of these interventions remains unclear. Pharmacological and
nonpharmacological interventions have not been simultaneously evaluated for
comparative effectiveness in treating FC in a systematic review. This limits
attempts to make comprehensive inferences to patients, clinician and policy
makers. This study will compare the direct and indirect effectiveness and safety
of interventions for FC. The findings will offer the opportunity to generate a
ranking and assist patient, clinicians, and policy maker to make evidence-based
decisions regarding treatment selection.
(3372) Reconceptualizing Pain Through Patient-centered Care in the Complementary
and Alternative Medicine Therapeutic Relationship
Vinita Agarwal, PhD1
1Salisbury University, Salisbury, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: To identify pathways for recontextualizing the subjective
experience of pain in the integrative provider–patient relationship through an
examination of patient discourses of therapeutic management of chronic pain with
their complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) providers.
Results: The therapeutic relationship utilizes 3 alternative
pathways for patient pain self-management of chronic pain through provider
assisting alternative patient knowledge positions. First, by listening to the
patient’s body, with the provider utilizing intuition to sense what the patient
was feeling and to understand what they needed as a person. Second, by
connecting the patient’s mind to the body, whereby the provider integrated CAM
to connect the patient’s mind to the body by reframing their pain response in
alignment with lived experiences. Finally, third by cultivating a self-reflexive
therapeutic relationship, whereby the provider encouraged patient
self-reflexivity through integrative practices guiding awareness of
physiological and cognitive triggers to recontextualize the experience of
pain.
Conclusions: For integrative providers to assist patients in making
evidence-based decisions, there is a need to explicate patient perceptions of
the therapeutic relationship to (re)conceptualize models of patient-centered
care. The assessment of pain depends on patient perception of and response to
pain and pain-related disability. The study suggests integrative
provider–patient relationships should emphasize patient–provider
interdependence, whereby provider expertise promotes patient mechanisms of
listening to their body in collaboration with their patients to connect mind and
body for aligning nonpharmacological and biomedical alternatives to support
patient long-term self-management of pain.
(3373) Punica granatum L. (Pomegranate) Leaves Extract With
Potential for Hair Growth Promoting Activity
Dheeraj S Randive, MPharm1, Somnath D. Bhinge, PhD1 and Mangesh
A. Bhutkar, PhD1
1Rajarambapu College of Pharmacy, Kasegaon, Maharashtra, India
Abstract
Purpose: In the Indian traditional system of medicine,
Punica granatum L. has been used in the treatment of
various diseases and found to exhibit high antioxidant, anti-inflammatory,
anticarcinogenic, antimicrobial potential, and a wide array of other
pharmacological activities. The aim of the present investigation was to explore
the effect of alcoholic and aqueous extract of P. granatum L.
as hair growth promoter.
Results: The hair growth promoting activity of the extracts of
P. granatum was observed by studying hair length, hair
weight and microscopic study of follicles in vehicle control, and 1%
minoxidil-treated and extract-treated animals. The activity was assessed by
studying follicle count in the subcutis and skin thickness in vehicle-treated
control and extract-treated animals.
Conclusions: The findings suggest the hair growth promoting
potential of the extract of P. granatum.
(3374) Powdered Red Yeast Rice and Plant Stanols and Sterols to Lower
Cholesterol—A 5-Year Retrospective Chart Review
Joseph S Feuerstein, MD1, Krista M Palmer, BA1, Wendy Bjerke,
PhD2, Daniella Lazarus1 and Ella K
Feuerstein1
1Stamford, Connecticut
2Sacred Heart University, Fairfield, Connecticut
Abstract
Purpose: Elevated low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol is a
significant risk factor for cardiovascular disease. It is estimated that 42% of
females and 34% of males in the United States have elevated total cholesterol.
The current mainstay of lipid-lowering therapy utilizes
3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-coezyme A reductase inhibitor (ie, statin)
medications that lower total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol by an average of
20% and 28%, respectively. However, due to the significant side effects of
statin medications, many patients seek alternative therapies to help manage
their hypercholesterolemia. Red yeast rice (Monascus purpueus)
has been used as a food and as an herbal medication in China for centuries.
Phytosterols are foods that are similar in structure and function to animal
cholesterol. Both of these compounds have been shown in clinical studies to
significantly lower LDL cholesterol. An 18 person case series undertaken by the
principal investigator (PI; JSF) in April 2012 and published in the
Journal of Dietary Supplements using a proprietary blend of
1200 mg of citrinin free red yeast rice (M. purpueus) and
1250 mg of phytosterol complex (sitosterol, campesterol, and stigmasterol)
(Natur-lo cholesterol) showed a statistically significant reduction
(P < .05) total cholesterol 19% (46 mg/dL) and LDL 33%
(53 mg/dL) after 6 weeks of use, without any reports of muscle pain, abnormal
liver tests, or any other side effects.
Results: One hundred forty patients at the center were prescribed
Natur-lo cholesterol during the 5-year period. Seventy-two percent of them were
female, and the average age was 62. The average baseline total cholesterol and
LDL cholesterol were 248.2 mg/dL (SD 39.3 mg/dL) and 165 mg/dL (SD 33.8 mg/dL),
respectively. Of the 140 patients, 86 met inclusion criteria and had followed up
with the PI (JSF) in addition to obtaining repeat laboratory testing after 6–8
weeks on the supplement. The average total cholesterol after 6–8 weeks on
Natur-lo cholesterol was 196.4 md/dL (SD 34.6 mg/dL), a drop of 20% from the
baseline reading. The average LDL cholesterol was 116.2 mg/dL (SD 29.6 mg/dL), a
reduction of 29% from the baseline reading over the same period. Paired
t tests of mean changes in total cholesterol and LDL were
significant (P < .001). No abnormal liver function tests,
muscle pains, or other side effects were reported to the PI while using the
natural product.
Conclusions: In conclusion, this 5-year retrospective chart review
reinforces the clinical effectiveness of Natur-lo cholesterol in significantly
reducing both total and LDL cholesterol in patients with hyperlipidemia.
(3375) “We all have the drug that keeps us moderately functional, but I don’t
want to just exist. I want to be better than that”: Interest in and Use of
Integrative Health Approaches to Migraine Management in Primary Care Among a
Socioeconomically Diverse Patient Group
Sharon Hull, MD, MPH1, Justine S de Oliveira, DrPH, PA-C2,
Gillian S Schmidler, PhD3, Morris Weinberger, PhD3, Remy
Coeytaux, MD, PhD3 and Deanna Befus, PhD4
1Durham, North Carolina
2Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry, London, UK
3Winston Salem, North Carolina
4Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston Salem, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Migraine is a highly disabling neurological disorder
affecting over 45 million people in the United States. The World Health
Organization has declared migraine a major public health problem due to a
paucity of knowledge about cause and effective treatment options. Both in
incidence and severity, migraine disproportionately affects people occupying low
social locations (LSLs). Daily preventive and as-needed abortive medications
come with high literal and figurative costs: intolerable side effects,
medication interactions, and prohibitive prices. Currently, the available
preventive medications are effective in only 50% of patients and 50% of the
time. Costly, ineffective, and unsustainable pharmacological treatments have
contributed to high levels of interest and use of complementary approaches by
people with migraine, but little is known about their usage motivations or
patterns.
Results: We identified 4 themes: a more holistic, collaborative,
long-term treatment approach; medication only as a short-term solution; high
personal and economic costs of medication; and desire for more information and
access to “alternative” and “natural” approaches. Across social locations,
participants expressed keen interest in integrative approaches and wanted better
access to complimentary modalities. LSL participants, especially people of
color, described heavier reliance on traditional/folk remedies, including family
and community healers (eg, “root doctors”), who they described as more
affordable and culturally accessible.
Conclusions: Integrative approaches were preferred over medication
for long-term migraine management. However, people in LSL did not feel as
comfortable accessing available integrative approaches. Engaging with LSL
communities and using a critical lens to explore barriers to access can develop
options to make complimentary modalities more approachable, while attending to
systemic blind spots in integrative approaches that may unintentionally alienate
socially marginalized groups.
(3377) A Systems Thinking Exploration of Women’s Migraine Experiences and
Self-management Strategies
Deanna Befus, PhD1, Kristen H Lich, PhD2, Shawn Kneipp, PhD,
MSN2, Janet Bettger, ScD2, Remy Coeytaux, MD,
PhD2 and Janice Humphreys, PhD, MSN2
1Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston Salem, North Carolina
2Durham, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Migraine affects over 20% of women and is the sixth most
disabling condition worldwide. In incidence and severity, migraine
disproportionately disables women occupying low social locations (LSLs).
Self-management (SM) behaviors are inextricably linked to social determinants of
health and have direct correlations to health outcomes. Yet women in LSLs are
often ignored in highly medicalized migraine research, making their SM behaviors
and outcomes largely unknown.
Results: “Life stressors” was the top trigger across groups, though
specific stressors varied by SL. LSL women engaged in more isolating and
avoidant SM behaviors. High social locations (HSLs) women used more proactive
and integrative approaches and consistently demonstrated more self-efficacy and
internal loci of control. LSL women identified concrete SM needs, such as
specific objects or environmental requirements (eg, darkness, quiet), while
women in HSLs identified personal qualities and behaviors (eg, discipline,
memory). LSL women identified reduced pain severity as their most valued
outcome, while HSL women valued more opportunities for self-improvement. LSL
women had lower expectations for SM, displayed less self-efficacy, used fewer
integrative approaches, and were more focused on difficulties of the migraine
experience than SM.
Conclusions: Traditional migraine treatment metrics (frequency,
severity, duration) do not reflect our participants’ most meaningful outcomes.
SL proved a useful lens through which to explore women’s experiences, and
revealed heterogeneity in SM strategies, priorities, and outcomes. Systems
thinking approaches present ways to understand complex health behaviors within
the context of multiple overlapping systems influencing choices and
experiences.
(3378) Indirect Effects of Mindfulness on Empathic Concern and Perspective Taking
Through Emotional Awareness
Jordan T Quaglia, PhD1, Alison C McLeish, PhD2, Emily M
O'Bryan, MA2 and Christina M Luberto, PhD3
1Naropa University, Boulder, Colarado
2University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Empathy (ie, awareness and understanding of others’
emotions) is important for individual and societal well-being, and strategies to
enhance empathy are increasingly under investigation. Mindfulness, as a trait
and as a practice, is related to greater empathy, but exactly how this
intrapersonal practice may give rise to interpersonal empathy remains unclear.
Theoretically, improved intrapersonal emotion regulation may support empathy for
others, particularly emotional awareness (ie, the ability to notice one’s own
emotions) and emotional clarity (ie, the ability to label one’s own emotions).
Indeed, mindfulness has been shown to improve emotion regulation, and emotion
regulation is related to greater empathy. Thus, emotion regulation may serve as
a mechanism underlying the association between mindfulness and empathy. We
explored the indirect effect of mindfulness on empathic concern (ie, positive
feelings for another) and perspective taking (ie, understanding another’s point
of view) through emotional awareness and emotional clarity.
Results: There was a significant indirect effect of mindfulness on
empathic concern through emotional awareness (b = .11, 95% confidence interval
[CI] = .05 to .18; 69% variance) but not emotional clarity (b = .00, 95%
CI = −.08 to .06). Similarly, there was a significant indirect effect of
mindfulness on perspective taking through emotional awareness (b = .13, 95%
CI = .07 to .21; 100% variance) but not emotional clarity (b = −.06, 95%
CI = −.13 to .02).
Conclusions: An individual’s ability to regulate their own emotions,
particularly to notice rather than necessarily understand or label the specific
emotion, accounts for most of the relationship between mindfulness and empathy.
Research using longitudinal designs is warranted.
(3379) Symptoms and Treatment Preferences for Managing Distress Among Acute
Coronary Syndrome Patients: Interests in Mindfulness and Electronic Health
Approaches
Christina M Luberto, PhD1, Gloria Yeh, MD, MPH1, Christopher
Celano, MD2, Jeff C Huffman, MD2 and Elyse R. Park, PhD,
MPH2
1Boston, Massachusetts
2Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Many acute coronary syndrome (ACS) patients experience
elevated emotional distress, which increases the risk of cardiac morbidity and
mortality. Easily accessible treatments that reduce distress and improve cardiac
outcomes are needed. Mindfulness interventions delivered via electronic health
(e-health) technologies (eg, texting, videoconferencing) could improve emotional
and cardiac outcomes and be easily accessible, but no research has explored ACS
patients’ interests in mindfulness and e-health interventions. We therefore
explored (1) the specific symptoms which cause distress for ACS patients
(physical, cognitive, and emotional) and (2) preferences for treatment
(treatment delivery and timing), with a focus on mindfulness and e-health
interventions.
Results: The most common forms of distress were worry (33%), anger
(25%), and sadness (15%). Participants most commonly reported distress due to
pain (35%), lack of energy (34%), feeling weak (33%), activity/role limitations
(33%), fatigue/sleep problems (32%), and exercise recommendations (29%). Most
(67%) were interested in a treatment program for distress. Among those, 73% were
interested in a mindfulness intervention specifically, 40% were interested in a
group intervention, 86% currently used at least one e-health technology, 68%
would use e-health technologies for a treatment program, and 64% felt the best
time for treatment was within 6 months post-ACS. Sixty-five percent reported
interest in both a mindfulness intervention and e-health approach.
Conclusions: ACS patients report a range of distressing symptoms and
most would participate in an e-health mindfulness treatment. Mindfulness
interventions should be adapted to target ACS patients’ identified needs and
preferences and be explored for feasibility and acceptability in controlled
trials.
(3383) Modified Dialectical Behavior Therapy Skills Training for Emotion
Dysregulation: A Naturalistic Practice-based Research Study in a Hospital
Setting
Julianne G Wilner, BA1, Jessica F Magidson, PhD2, Ellen
Prairie, PhD2, Jenn DeSouza, LICSW, CGP2, Michelle Jacobo,
PhD2, Harley Rebecca, PhD2 and Christina M Luberto,
PhD3
1Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts
2Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Dialectical behavior therapy skills training (DBT-ST) is an
efficacious mindfulness-based treatment for emotion dysregulation (ie, the
inability to effectively regulate emotional distress). Originally developed for
individuals with borderline personality disorder, DBT is being increasingly used
to treat emotion dysregulation across a range of patient populations and
clinical settings. Research on the utilization and effectiveness of DBT-ST for
diagnostically heterogeneous patient populations in real-world settings is
therefore needed. The aims of this naturalistic practice-based research study
are to explore (1) the clinical characteristics of patients who initiate DBT-ST
and (2) DBT-ST effectiveness (ie, changes in emotion dysregulation and
psychological symptoms).
Results: Patients had elevated baseline symptoms of emotion
dysregulation (M = 106.41, standard deviation [SD] = 28.18; 56%
above the clinical cutoff of 96) and a range of psychiatric diagnoses (61% major
depressive disorder; 32% bipolar disorder; 25% generalized anxiety disorder;
M = 2.4, SD = 1.0 disorders each). DBT-ST was associated
with large and statistically significant improvements in global emotion
regulation (ΔM = −16.29; d = .62;
P = .01), emotional awareness (ΔM = −1.94;
d = .52; P = .02), emotional acceptance
(ΔM = −2.89; d = .49;
P = .03), access to emotion regulation strategies
(ΔM = −5.82; d = .73;
P < .001), and symptoms of anxiety
(ΔM = −5.59; d = .51;
P = .01), depression (ΔM = −6.59;
d = .44; P = .03), and borderline
personality disorder (ΔM = −4.71; d = .49;
P < .001).
Conclusions: This exploratory naturalistic study suggests that
hospital patients with elevated emotion dysregulation are willing to initiate
DBT-ST as part of their clinical care, and DBT-ST can improve emotional outcomes
in heterogeneous patients in a real-world setting. Naturalistic studies with
larger sample sizes are warranted.
(3393) Effects of Joyful Emotion on Pulse-graph Parameters in Healthy Female
College Students Based on Emotion-induced Experiments
Rong Yuan, MD1, Tianfang Wang, PhD1, Jiayuan Zhang,
MD1, Yan Zhao, PhD1 and Yu Wei, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the effects of joyful emotion on the pulse
diagram parameters of healthy female college students.
Results: (1) Compared with NT0, all of the pulse diagram parameters
in the NT1 had no signficant difference. (2) Compared with JT0, the t1, t2, and
t3 in the JT1 were statistically significant and showed a rising trend. (3)
Compared each parameter in the NT0 with that of the JT0, there was no
statistical difference. Compared each parameter in the NT1 with that of the JT1,
the t1 and t2 in the NT0 were significantly higher than that of the NT1, and the
other parameters were not statistically different.
Conclusions: The pulse diagram parameters t1 and t2 in the JT1 are
significantly higher than that of JT0 and NT1, which indicates that the joyful
emotion may influence the pulse manifestation by extending the rapid ejection
time of left ventricular.
(3397) Utilizing Mindfulness With Health-care Professionals to Improve Burnout,
Self-compassion, and Patient Quality and Safety Measures: A Comparison of Cardiac
Units
Anne-Marie Duchemin, MD1, Beth Steinberg, RN, MSN2, Susan
Moffatt-Bruce, MD, PhD2 and Maryanna D Klatt, PhD3
1Columbus, Ohio
2Wexner Medical Center, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
3College of Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: Patient quality and safety outcomes are affected by the
ability of the health-care professionals (HCPs) to provide optimal care; stress
and burnout can hinder this ability. For instance, nurses’ burnout has been
associated with higher rate of patients’ infections. Critical care nurses report
high rates of stress and burnout due to organizational factors such as workload
demands, limited resources, in addition to individual experiences with direct
and secondary traumatic stress, and values conflicts; these concerns are
mirrored in interprofessional HCP team members.
Results: By intervention end, subscale depersonalization scores
(Maslach Burnout Inventory) decreased by 57% (P = .0188) for
MIM participants, while controls increased 106% compared to baseline. Stress
(measured by Perceived Stress Scale) also significantly decreased in the
intervention group to 80% of baseline (P = .0438) while
control’s stress increased to 107% compared to baseline. Self-compassion (Self
Compassion Scale) demonstrated significant increases postintervention in the
intervention group (P < .01) with no changes in the control
group. Based on literature reports of average safety event cost estimates/per
event, intervention unit baseline (previous year) safety events cost was
$506,786, which decreased to $394,019, while control unit estimate went from
baseline of $155,019 to $86,768.
Conclusions: Research, tying patient safety events with HCP
mindfulness training (intended to decrease interprofessional HCP burnout and
perceived stress), is possible. This feasibility study indicates that
mindfulness programming for HCPs may reduce patient safety events within
hospital units. Future studies need to examine the year prior, during, and after
the mindfulness training on the unit to accurately assess mindfulness training
effect on unit safety events.
(3398) Study on Group Psychological Intervention of Subthreshold Depression in
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Junhui Kong1, Yichunzi Zhang1, Lesley Zhang1 and Xi
Tan1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: From yin-yang perspective, as a whole system, Traditional
Chinese Medicine (TCM) believes that the subthreshold depression is caused by
excessive yin and deficient yang and treated it by the principle of tonifying
yang and restricting yin. Many studies have verified that group psychological
intervention has great curative effect in the nonpharmacotherapy of depression,
but few studies combined with TCM and its characteristic methods of regimen.
This paper is to design a group psychological intervention program for people
with subthreshold depression from the perspective of tonifying yang and
restricting yin in TCM and to evaluate the curative effect of the program.
Results: After 8 weeks of intervention, the Center for
Epidemiological Studies-Depression (CES-D) score of intervention group
(M = 13.17) was lower than before (M = 20.33), t(70) = 14.11,
P < .000, and the CES-D score of control group (M = 18.19)
was lower than before (M = 21.39), t(70) = 3.30, P < .002,
and comparing the CES-D score of preintervention with postintervention, the
difference of intervention group (M = 7.17) was more significant than control
group (M = 3.19), t(70) = 3.64, P < 0.001.
Conclusions: Group psychological intervention program guiding by
tonifying yang and restricting yin in TCM can improve the negative emotion of
people with subthreshold depression. This study is of important reference value
for the intervention of subthreshold depression and preventive treatment of
depression.
(3400) A New Idea to Cultivate Traditional Chinese Medicine Postgraduates:
Combining the Experience Inheritance and Modern Scientific Research Training
Liping Zhang1, Xi Tan1, Lesley Zhang1 and Yichunzi
Zhang1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Overview: Compared with modern medicine, the theoretical basis of
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is totally different, thus the education of
TCM postgraduates should not only comply with TCM theoretical system and
teaching methods but also take current scientific research into consideration.
Based on this, we built a mode of “inheriting experience from TCM
teachers-clinical practice training-scientific research training by teachers of
life sciences” for TCM postgraduates, in Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,
which has been well verified in the education of TCM postgraduates.
Rationale: After 5000 years of development in China, TCM has been
proved to have good curative effect, while modern scientific researches are more
acknowledged. To combine TCM with modern research, we divided education system
of TCM postgraduates into 3 parts: cultivating TCM thinking, training clinical
practice, and conducting modern life science research. In the part of
cultivating TCM thinking, the mode focuses on learning of TCM theories and
teacher’s clinical practice experience. In the part of training clinical
practice, experienced teachers are necessary in clinical practice bases and TCM
hospitals to help students apply their clinical skills to diagnose and treat
diseases. In the part of conducting modern life science research, the students
should study the theory of modern life science and master the methods of modern
research and demonstrate the clinical experience of TCM by the language of
modern medicine. This mode could improve the clinical practice ability of
postgraduates and promote the development of alternative medicine.
Objectives: Influenced by modern concept of science, TCM should
develop combined with modern science. In clinical practice, this combination
could not only help postgraduates solve problems under guidance of TCM but also
explain solutions by means of modern science, and in that way can we develop TCM
in modern times. This mode is of important reference value to other alternative
medicines.
(3401) Information Needs of Pediatric Oncologists in Complementary and
Integrative Medicine (CIM)—A Cross-sectional Study Establishing a Blended Learning
Program Focusing on CIM
Alfred Längler, MD1, Clara C Hilje, BSc2, Tycho Zuzak,
MD3, Daniela Reis, MSc2 and Corina Güthlin,
PhD4
1Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
2Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
3Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
4Johann Wolfgang Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: About one third of all German pediatric patients with
cancer use complementary and integrative medicine (CIM); however, pediatric
oncologists do not feel particularly confident when discussing CIM-related
topics. Only few scientific studies of pediatric oncologists’ information needs
in CIM have been conducted. The survey carried out in this study aims to
continue to fill this gap.
Results: The questionnaire was completed by 101 participants. The
age of the participants ranged from 29 to 67. The proportion of women and men
was almost equal. Additionally, most participants were senior or chief
physicians. More than 70% feel insufficiently informed about CIM, 40% have
difficulties obtaining relevant information. Most of them need information about
CIM often or occasionally. They stated that they potentially would invest 1 day
on average for training. The study revealed that age, professional position, and
experience affect the response. Questioned physicians consider an overview of
CIM therapies for cancer patients and information about relaxation methods as
most important. They were mainly interested in CIM therapies indicated for
nausea and vomiting, tumor-related pain, lack of appetite, and fatigue.
Conclusions: The study revealed that pediatric oncologists need
information on CIM, are very interested in CIM training but have only a limited
time frame for advanced training. As a part of the competency network of CIM in
oncology (KOKON), we are developing and evaluating a training (e-learning and
on-site learning) for pediatric oncologists based on these results.
(3404) Characteristics of Registered Acupuncturists, Osteopaths, and Naturopaths
in Switzerland
Julie Dubois, MA1, Pierre-Yves Rodondi, MD1, Anne-Sylvie Bill,
BSc1, Jérôme Pasquier, PhD1 and Silva Keberle,
MD2
1Lausanne University Hospital, Lausanne, Switzerland
2Eskamed, Basel, Switzerland
Abstract
Purpose: More than 20 000 complementary and alternative medicine
(CAM) nonphysician therapists are registered in Switzerland. Despite this
substantial number, very little is known about the characteristics of these
therapists and their practice. The aim of this study was to gain a better
understanding of nonphysician licensed therapists in the French speaking part of
Switzerland.
Results: A total of 426 therapists returned the questionnaire
(response rate: 27.5%). Most respondents were women (67.8%) of Swiss nationality
(85.1%). The mean age of the respondents was 46.0 (standard deviation
[SD] ± 11.6). More than half of participants (56.7%) had a previous training
outside the CAM field, especially naturopaths (85.7%). Among those with previous
training, more than a half of osteopaths (67.1%) and acupuncturists (57.4%) were
trained in a field related to health care while only a fifth (21.7%) of
naturopaths were trained. CAM represented the main source of income for a
majority of therapists (82.8%), most of them were independent (86.3%) and worked
in a single location (77.5%). Naturopaths and acupuncturists mostly worked alone
(60.2% and 44.3%, respectively), whereas osteopaths often worked in group
practices (56.7%). Length and number of consultations per month varied across
therapists: osteopaths performed 117.5 consults/month (SD ± 51.3), lasting
45.5 min each (SD ± 6.5); acupuncturists performed 83.2 consults/month
(SD ± 72.9), lasting 61.6 min each (SD ± 12.5); and naturopaths performed 54.3
consults/month (SD ± 57.1), lasting 72.0 min each (SD ± 16.7). Acupuncturists
(71.6%) and naturopaths (64.3%) were significantly more favorable than
osteopaths (27.7%) to have consultation costs covered by basic health insurances
(P < .001).
Conclusions: This first study about nonphysician CAM therapists in
Switzerland will provide useful information on them and about their role within
the health-care system.
(3406) Tuina (Therapeutic Massage) for Treatment of Acute Diarrheain Children
Under 5 Years Old: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Liyan Jia1, Huijuan Cao, PhD2, Ning Liang, PhD2,
Rui-xue Hu2, Chun-li Lu2, Sai-nan Fang2, Yajing
Zhang2, Jianping Liu, PhD2 and Baoyong Lai2
1Center for Evidence-Based Chiese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the effectiveness and safety of tuina
(therapeutic massage) as a nonpharmaceutical treatment for acute diarrhea in
children under 5 years old.
Results: Twenty-nine randomized controlled trials (RCTs) were
included involving 3106 children with acute diarrhea. Due to its manipulative
nature of tuina, we did not evaluate the participants and operators blinding.
All trials did not report allocation concealment and blinding of outcome
assessors, the methodological quality of the included RCTs was poor in terms of
random method, blinding, and drop out. Compared with the control, the pooled
result showed a statistical significantly higher cure rate in the tuina group
(risk ratio [RR] 1.61, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.41 to 1.84, n = 21 at
3-day treatment; RR 1.68, 95% CI: 1.37 to 2.06, n = 7 at 6-day treatment). Tuina
significantly decreased the duration of acute diarrhea (hours; mean difference
[MD] −13.82, 95% CI: −16.84 to −10.79, n = 8) and the stool output
(frequency/24h; MD −2.02, 95% CI: −2.22 to −1.82, n = 3) compared with control.
No adverse events were reported from the included trials in tuina therapy.
Conclusions: Tuina seems to be an effective nonpharmaceutical
therapy for treatment of acute childhood diarrhea. However, a firm conclusion
could not be drawn due to general low methodological quality. Further
high-quality trials are needed in the future.
(3408) Investigation Into Complementary Medicine Practitioners’ Clinical
Experience of Intestinal Permeability: A Cross-sectional Survey
Bradley Leech, BHSc1, Janet Schloss, PhD1 and Amie Steel, PhD,
ND1, 2
1Endeavour College of Natural Health, Brisbane, Australia
2University of Technology Sydney, Brisbane, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Increased intestinal permeability (IP) may play an
important role in disease exacerbation and pathogenesis. Through deductive
reasoning, complementary medicine (CM) practitioners may have acquired new
understanding of IP not yet published within the literature. This study aims to
explore the conditions CM practitioners associated with IP and the methods
employed to manage IP.
Results: CM practitioners (n = 36, response rate 15.9%) associate IP
with gastrointestinal (100.0%), autoimmune (91.7%), skin (91.7%), neurological
(80.6%), respiratory (55.6%) and liver conditions (44.4%). Observed-associated
conditions include food sensitivities (97.2%), intestinal dysbiosis (91.7%),
noncoeliac gluten sensitivity (91.7%), bloating (83.3%), rheumatoid arthritis
(75.0%), brain fog (65.7%) and inflammation (62.9%). Furthermore, the degree of
included conditions was often/always observed to be associated with IP (93.4%).
CM practitioners frequently treat IP (72.7%); however, almost never test for IP
(58.8%). Patient’s clinical signs and symptoms were the main reasons CM
practitioners suspect their patients have IP (94.1%). CM practitioners observe a
good (60.6%), major (32.8%) and slight (6.6%) clinical improvement after
treating IP in associated conditions. Moreover, conditions with a higher
observed association to IP resulted in a major degree of observed clinical
improvement after treating IP. Frequently used methods to manage IP include
dietary, nutraceutical, and herbal medicine. CM practitioners observe a minimum
3 months of treatment is required to resolve IP with retesting not considered
until 6 months of treatment.
Conclusions: CM practitioners observe an association between IP and
conditions not yet recognised within the published literature. The experience
that CM practitioners have obtained through deductive reasoning holds
substantial value to the advancement of research and the clinical management of
IP.
(3411) Yoga for Headache in Adolescents: A Multicenter Randomized Controlled
Trial
Catharina Amarell, MD1, Melanie Anheyer, MD2, Dania Schumann,
MSc3, Gustav Dobos, MD, PhD3, Holger Cramer,
PhD3 and Dennis Anheyer, MA3
1Childrens-Hospital St. Marien, Landshut, Germany
2Elisabeth-Hospital, Essen, Germany
3University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Previous studies have shown that yoga can be used
effectively to prevent and alleviate symptoms in patients with chronic
headaches. However, none of these studies examined the effects of yoga on
children and adolescents. For this reason, our study aimed to investigate the
safety and effectiveness of a yoga program in the treatment of adolescents with
chronic headaches.
Results: A total of 45 adolescents (81.8% female; 14.6 ± 1.3 years)
were randomized to yoga (n = 22) or wait-list control group (n = 23). No
significant group difference in headache frequency between yoga and control
group was found after 12 weeks of intervention (difference [Δ] = −1.0 days; 95%
confidence interval [CI]: −4.4 to 2.4 days; P = .545), whereas
the group difference after the 3-month follow-up period was statistically
significant (Δ = −4.1 days; 95% CI: −7.7 to −0.5 days;
P = .027). None of the secondary outcomes were statistically
significant, neither in the short term nor in the long term. Surprisingly, it
turned out that parent’s participation in the yoga program even reduced the
therapeutic effect. However, this effect showed to be statistically
nonsignificant.
Conclusions: In line with prior research on adults, it was shown
that yoga can also reduce the frequency of headache in adolescents. However,
this effect did not become apparent immediately after the intervention but only
after a 3-month follow-up period. Moreover, neither headache duration nor pain
intensity was significantly influenced by yoga in comparison to the control
group. Due to the small number of participants, further studies are needed to
verify these results.
(3415) How Colored Light Affects the Autonomic Nervous System Activity During a
Cognitive Task—Differences Between Blue and Red Light
Ursula Wolf, MD
Ursula Wolf, MD1, Felix Scholkmann, PhD1, Nassim Nasseri,
PhD1 and Hamoon Zohdi1
1University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
Abstract
Purpose: In previous studies, we demonstrated that colored light
exposure (CLE) evoked specific changes in human brain and body physiology. The
aim of this study was to investigate whether CLE has an effect on the autonomic
nervous system (ANS) activity during the performance of a cognitive task.
Results: We found that the factors “color” and “trial order” were
the most significant factors explaining the variance of the data. The type of
CLE (red vs blue) determined significantly (F = 511.41,
P < .001) the magnitude of the integrated skin conductance
response (ISCR). In addition, the order of trials had a significant effect on
ISCR as well (F = 122.21, P < .001). The magnitude of the
ISCR under the blue light was higher than under the red light exposure
(ISCR_blue = 7.95 ± 6.40 log (µS*s), ISCR_red = 5.28 ± 4.44 log (µS*s),
t = 4.101, df = 286.0, P < .01).
Conclusions: CLE evoked a color dependent effect on ANS activity
during performing a cognitive task (verbal fluency task). Blue light was
associated with a stronger activity of the sympathetic part of the ANS (increase
in ISCR). Our findings are important for future basic research and clinical
applications as well as being relevant for everyday life.
(3420) Impact of Postoperative Acupuncture on Pain, Nausea, Mood, and Medical
Outcomes in Patients Undergoing Valve Surgery: Design and Lessons Learned From the
ACU-Heart Pilot Trial
Melinda Ring, MD1, Ania Grimone, LAc, CH2, Kim Feingold,
PhD2, Judith T Moskowitz, PhD2, Fang Lin, LAc2,
Tatyana Shafiro, LAc2, Patrick McCarthy, MD2, Ruchi Patel,
BME2 and Charles Davidson, MD2
1Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, Chicago, Illinois
2Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: In addition to pain, nausea, depression, and anxiety,
postoperative atrial fibrillation is a common complication after cardiac
surgery. ACU-Heart is a randomized controlled pilot trial evaluating daily
postoperative acupuncture among patients undergoing valve surgery.
Results: ACU-Heart enrollment and intervention are ongoing (N = 70
of 100). The acupuncturists have been successfully trained in delivering
treatment within the restrictions of the intensive care environment as well as
the need to adhere to the research protocol. Factors that facilitate delivery of
daily acupuncture include advanced scheduling and coordination with nursing
staff. Retention has been high, with minimal refusals for daily acupuncture
sessions. Days of floor transfer and discharge can be more difficult to provide
acupuncture given increased demands on the patient. Patients are eager to be
randomized to acupuncture and have welcomed the sessions to date. Several
patients noted that the acupuncture was the highlight of the hospitalization and
surgeons have received positive feedback from patients.
Conclusions: This ongoing randomized trial is the first to assess
the feasibility and acceptability of delivering daily acupuncture in the
hospital setting after open heart surgery. To date, postoperative acupuncture is
proving to be both feasible and accepted in the hospital setting, including in
cardiac intensive care as early as POD1.
(3423) Integrative Clinical Hypnosis and Massage Therapy in Treatment-refractory
Chronic Regional Pain Syndrome-I
Lindsey McKernan, PhD1 and Taylor Koval, NMT, DT1
1Connecticut
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic regional pain syndrome (CRPS) is a chronic
neurological condition involving the limbs characterized by severe pain along
with sensory, autonomic, motor, and trophic impairment. The gold standard of
diagnostic criteria varies as do the treatments for the 200 000 cases reported.
Multimodal intervention is recommended for CRPS; however, literature supporting
integrative interventions is extremely limited. We present a 2-year case study
of the integration of weekly massage therapy (MT) and clinical hypnosis in a
case of 2-year treatment refractory CRPS of right upper extremity (CRPS-I)
diagnosed 5 years after injury.
Results: Over the course of 5 months of collaborative hypnosis and
MT sessions during his 24-month treatment Patient M showed significant and
clinically meaningful decrease in neuropathic pain levels. Goniometric findings
(see Figure 1) indicate significant improvements in flexion/distance with the
incorporation of self-hypnosis. These results were maintained over a course of
approximately 6 months in spite of significant situational stress. Results
became less effective as appointments decreased in months 18–24.
Conclusions: In a case of treatment-refractory CRPS-I, the
integration of fascial MT with clinical hypnosis led to significant and
meaningful reductions in neuropathic pain, improved cervical flexion, and TMJ-AP
distance. Long-term follow-up indicates that the continued practice and
intervention may be required to maintain treatment gains.
(3425) Stress Management and Resiliency Training for Health-care
Professionals
Darshan Mehta, MD, MPH1 and Michelle L Dossett, MD, PhD,
MPH1
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Burnout is epidemic among health-care professionals. Prior
studies have suggested that resiliency training programs incorporating mind–body
skills may reduce provider burnout. We examined the effects of a stress
management and resiliency training (SMART) program developed for clinical
populations and adapted it to health-care providers.
Results: Participants attended an average of 6 of 8 sessions. There
was a significant reduction in perceived stress (P = .001,
Cohen’s d = 0.71) and significant improvement in global mental health
(P = .018, Cohen’s d = 0.48) as well as nonsignificant
trends toward improvement in physical health (Cohen’s d = 0.36) and job
satisfaction (Cohen’s d = 0.30). All participants except for one agreed that the
program was relevant to their life and that the skills taught were helpful.
Qualitative analysis of free text responses revealed that participants developed
greater presence with patients, ability to live in the moment, and empowerment
to make positive life changes.
Conclusions: Delivering the SMART program to health-care
professionals is feasible and may serve as a useful tool for increasing
resilience to stress. Many participants found the program transformative and the
majority felt they benefited from the skills learned. Additional groups are
ongoing.
(3426) Which Chronic Low Back Pain Patients Respond Favorably to Yoga? Responder
Analyses From a Large Randomized Controlled Trial
Eric Roseen, DC1, Robert B Saper, MD, MPH1, Anthony Delitto,
PT, PhD1, Hanna Karen Sherman, PhD, MPH2 and Gerlovin,
MA3
1Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
2Kaiser Permanente, Seattle, Washington
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic low back pain (cLBP) is the leading cause of
disability worldwide. While yoga has demonstrated effectiveness for cLBP, little
guidance exists to help identify patients most likely to benefit from yoga.
Results: Sixty participants (48%) were classified as treatment
responders. At baseline, treatment responders were more likely to be nonsmokers
(P = .004), nonhypertensive (P = .007),
and employed (P = .013); have less than daily back pain
(P = .002); and believe yoga to be effective for cLBP
(P = .013). These 5 characteristics formed the clinical
prediction rule which had a sensitivity, specificity, and positive likelihood
ratio of 25%, 92%, and 3.1, respectively.
Conclusions: Participants who did not smoke, had normal blood
pressure, were employed, perceived yoga as effective, and had less than daily
back pain were more likely to respond favorably to yoga. However, our findings
need to be replicated in a prospective clinical trial with a comparison group.
Future analyses of Back to Health should compare the predictive
factors of yoga to those of physical therapy and education.
(3428) Treating Chronic Pain; the Kairos Model
Renee Meyer, MD1
1Primula Internal Medicine, Yonges Island, South Carolina
Abstract
Overview: In April 2017, the British Medical Journal (BMJ) awarded
the Kairos Rehabilitation Centre for its innovative approach to chronic pain.
Kairos, a specialty service of the Vanbrugh Community Pain Management Centre in
Greenwich, SE London, works with patients with persistent, intractable pain.
Most patients have failed to improve at other chronic pain programs. The Kairos
center was established in 2009 by Dr David McGavin, a family practitioner who
had witnessed benefits to patients with chronic diseases through a
multidisciplinary anthropsophic medical approach. In 1991, he helped form the
Blackthorn Medical Centre in Maidstone, Kent. At Blackthorn, chronic illnesses
as well as general family care are addressed by physicians and other therapists.
The Blackthorn Centre was joint winner of the 2001 Prince of Wales’s Foundation
for Integrated Medicine Healthcare Award. Together with a therapeutic eurythmy
movement specialist and rhythmic massage therapist, the Kairos Rehabilitation
team helps patients find and reawaken their own life forces through natural
remedies as well as conventional medications, gentle movement exercises, and
movement experiences in massage. The therapies aim to restore sleep patterns and
lift anxiety in preparation for restoring inner balance. Activities, such as
on-site gardening, cooking and singing in a choir, and guiding patients to
vocational retraining, support the important area of social reintegration.
Patients must agree to be active team members in this process. Kairos
rehabilitation has documented significantly decreased depression, improved
health status, and decreased analgesic prescription requirements in 29 patients
followed at the center.
Rationale: Innovative approaches to chronic pain is a central theme
of this conference. Chronic pain is a national concern.
Objectives: This is a proposed poster presentation. Interested
participants will be able to recognize what symptoms commonly accompany chronic
pain; appreciate that improving these symptoms may be key to successfully
launching further therapy; understand that a multidisciplinary, long-range plan
in which the patient must actively participate has been beneficial for chronic
pain and other chronic diseases; and acknowledge that adding natural remedies
may help decrease use of conventional analgesics.
(3429) Integrative Approach Incorporating Acupuncture and Trigger Point Therapy
for Occipital Neuralgia
Lawrence Taw, MD1 and Rachael M Maciasz, MD1
1Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview/Background: Occipital neuralgia (ON) is a difficult to treat
debilitating condition. There is limited data on treatment options, and there is
no clear consensus on management. Utilizing trigger point injections and
acupuncture may be a safe, efficient, and low-cost approach to treating ON.
Program Description: Thiry-eight-year-old man presents with chronic
neck and occipital pain for 6 months. Associated symptoms include insomnia,
anxiety, and depression. History and physical reveal poor sleep hygiene, family
stress, intense weight lifting exercises, hypertension, and tenderness at the
left skull base with radiation to the occipital dermatome and left trapezius.
Treatment included one session of trigger point injections, acupuncture, and
counseling on sleep hygiene and self-care including self-acupressure points,
nightly foot massage, and magnesium supplementation. Symptoms resolved after 1
session.
Teaching Point: ON is a difficult condition to treat. Current treatments include
conservative management, medications with adverse side effect profiles, or
invasive procedures including nerve blocks, or neurosurgical intervention. Safe,
effective, and low-risk treatment options are needed and may include an
integrative approach utilizing acupuncture and trigger point injections.
Conclusion: Trigger point injections and acupuncture are low risk,
inexpensive, and may be effective treatment of ON.
Rationale: ON is a difficult to treat debilitating condition. There
is limited data on treatment options, and there is no clear consensus on
management. Utilizing and integrative medicine approach incorporating trigger
point injections and acupuncture may be a safe, efficient, and low-cost approach
to treating ON.
Objectives: Participants will have knowledge of an integrative
approach to treat occipital neuralgia; participants will know where to locate
trigger points associated with occipital neuralgia; and participants will
understand acupuncture points that can treat occipital neuralgia.
(3431) Evaluating the Effect of Qigong on Cancer-related Fatigue and Quality of
Life
Cassidy Doucette, DNP1 and Shelley White, MSW1
1Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Purpose: Examine the effectiveness of Qigong as an intervention to
improve and prevent common side effects associated with cancer and cancer
care.
Results: Twenty-three individuals completed at least 2
Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System-29 (PROMIS-29)
questionnaires and 20 individuals submitted their Journal of
Experience for review. Results from the PROMIS-29 questionnaires
were analyzed using linear-mixed-effect models. Significant improvement was
found in 6 of the 8 domains measured. The most dramatic improvements were seen
for fatigue (P = .0009) and sleep disruption
(P < .0001). Other findings showed significant changes
in social functioning (P = .0069), decreased pain interference
(P = .0194), decreased pain intensity
(P = .0150), and decreased depression
(P = .0342). No significant change was seen in physical
function (P = .0596) or anxiety (P = .0871).
Review of participant experience journals demonstrated that practicing Qigong
reduced anxiety and increased a feeling of calm (n = 18), reduced tension
(n = 14), reduced pain (n = 10), improved balance (n = 7), improved strength
(n = 10), increased mind and body awareness (n = 17), increased breath expansion
(n = 17), improved stress management (n = 18), and created a more positive
outlook on life and self (n = 15).
Conclusions: Incorporating mind–body practices such as Qigong into
standard treatment and survivorship plans has the potential to improve quality
of life and reduce the physical, emotional, and economic burden of symptom
management on individuals with cancer as well as their caregivers.
(3432) Compassion Circles and Colored Pencils: Using Expressive Arts as a Tool
for Medical Student Self-reflection
Lolly Forsythe-Chisolm, BA1 and Delia Chiaramonte, MD1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: The University of Maryland School of Medicine Center for
Integrative Medicine offers a biannual elective in Integrative Medicine to
senior medical students. Within this elective students engage in diverse
self-care and self-awareness activities, including the use of expressive arts.
Led by an expert in both mind–body skills and visual art, students explore their
values, strengths, weaknesses, and perspectives through the use of art-based
activities. The session culminates in an art-based exploration of compassion.
After participating in a mindfulness-based imagery experience, students employ
the use of visual art as a means of personal exploration. Guided art-based
activities are used to allow students to clarify their values, identify their
strengths, and explore their weaknesses. Their final activity is the creation of
a “compassion circle.” They are instructed to write 3 words or sentences
defining their perspective on compassion and then draw a “compassion circle”
that expresses this perspective. Over 50 students have created compassion
circles and recurrent themes are clear in both the written and artistic
expressions of compassion. Written themes include doing for others, forgiveness,
lack of judgment, and healing presence. Artistic themes include nature,
especially trees, people, hands, eyes, and hearts. This poster will include
multiple examples of compassion circles, and the presenters will have others
available for participants to review. The poster will include specific
instructions for implementing the artistic activities so that viewers can
replicate expressive arts activities at their home institution.
Rationale: Medical students are at high risk of psychological stress
and burnout. Encouraging self-awareness and exploring creativity can be helpful
in managing stress and preventing burnout. Therapeutic art can be used to help
medical students identify their values and strengths and realistically evaluate
their weaknesses. Compassion circles are a tool used to encourage medical
students to creatively explore their views on compassion. This poster will
provide specific instruction to allow others to replicate this teaching
technique.
Objectives: The aim is to implement a therapeutic art exercise for
medical learners to identify values and strengths, assist medical learners in
positively reframing their weaknesses using an art-based activity, and employ
the use of compassion circles to enhance self-reflection in medical
learners.
(3434) Successful Strategies for Overcoming Financial Barriers in Establishing
Integrative Oncology Programs
Danielle Gentile, PhD1, Chasse Bailey-Dorton, MD, MSPH1, Tara
Eaton, PhD1, Beth York, MA, LPC1 and Susan Yaguda, RN,
MSN1
1Levine Cancer Institute, Charlotte, North Carolina
Abstract
Overview: Oncology is a critical field for the development of
Integrative Medicine. Integrative oncology (IO) supports cancer patients from
diagnosis through survivorship by reducing symptoms, facilitating recovery, and
enhancing well-being. However, IO programs remain a rarity in oncology due to
financial obstacles in creating them. The purpose of this presentation
is to demonstrate practice-proven strategies to reduce financial obstacles
associated with IO program establishment through evidence-based and
value-driven approaches adaptable across cancer centers. The IO
program at Levine Cancer Institute is a success made possible by implementing
the following strategies: cost sharing service providers across departments;
targeting patients with clinical indications most in need of IO services;
purchasing services from independent contractors; training providers in IO
approaches throughout care; utilizing trainee healing touch apprentices and
kinesiology externs; utilizing community volunteers for therapeutic arts
services; cultivating and nurturing philanthropy from individual donors and
community fundraising. A 24-h cycling and walking fundraiser has provided nearly
$500 000 over 5 years; seeking grant funding for research activities to advance
clinical practice; billing insurance for consult visits with an IO
fellowship-trained, family medicine physician; and implementing group
acupuncture of 5–6 patients rather than costly individual appointments. By
implementing these strategies, the IO program provides treatment services
(acupuncture, healing touch, massage), integrative classes (nutrition,
meditation, yoga, tai chi), a healing arts program (writing, art, music),
kinesiology, an IO physician consult clinic, and IO pharmacy consult clinics.
These comprehensive services provide value to patients, providers, and the
health-care system. It is possible to develop a robust IO program without full
insurance reimbursement when dedicated leaders cater to the evidence-based needs
of patients, providers, and the system while adopting financial strategies. New
and expanded IO programs will advance the IO field by expanding patient access
and providing opportunities for scientific inquiry.
Rationale: Integrative oncology clinics are a rarity in cancer
centers and may be difficult to establish due to financial obstacles. By
implementing evidence-based, value-driven strategies appropriate for each cancer
center’s unique patients, providers, and goals, it is possible to implement
integrative oncology services and expand the reach of integrative services. This
abstract relates to the theme of advancing integrative health through
clinical practice by demonstrating strategies to make
integrative clinical care services practices available to cancer
populations.
Objectives: Participants will be able to recount strategies for
reducing financial obstacles to establishing integrative oncology programs which
can be adapted at their home institutions and participants will be able to
describe the core components and features of a comprehensive integrative
oncology program.
(3436) Facilitating Provider–Patient Interdependence in Integrative Medicine for
Patient-centered Care: Examining Complementary and Alternative Medicine Therapeutic
Relationships
Vinita Agarwal, PhD1
1Salisbury University, Salisbury, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to inform how integrative
providers can set up a patient-centered relationship through facilitating
provider–patient interdependence by examining complementary and alternative
medicine (CAM) providers’ therapeutic relationship.
Results: CAM providers’goal was to encourage openness and relating
in an interdependent therapeutic relationship. They presented themselves not as
experts within an objective epidemiological encounter but as a partner and guide
seen through their own illnesses and spirituality with a goal to increase their
patients’ self-management support and positive health outcomes.
Conclusions: The body is central to health outcomes. However,
biomedical encounters are premised on a disassociation of the provider’s body,
its life context, and spirituality to establish an expert provider–patient
relationship. Integrative providers seeking to enhance the patient–provider
relationship and self-management support can gain insight from CAM providers to
cultivate interdependence, openness, and relating by serving as a partner and
guide in the patient encounters.
(3438) Inpatient Integrative Medicine in the Acute Care Hospital: Impact on
Clinical Outcomes and Metrics of Interest to Hospital Administrators
Delia Chiaramonte, MD1, Anil Bajnath, MD1, Blaine Guelde,
CRNP1 and Donna Audia, RN1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: A collaboration between a medical school-based Center for
Integrative Medicine and an acute-care hospital has created a formal inpatient
integrative medicine consultation service. Based upon a palliative medicine
model, the interprofessional team includes a physician, nurse practitioner,
acupuncturist, mind–body specialist/expressive artist, live therapeutic
musicians, and several integrative nurses. Services include therapeutic
dialogue, guided imagery, acupuncture, acupressure, Reiki, M technique,
journaling, therapeutic art, Emotional Freedom Technique, pain management
education, live therapeutic music/sound, relaxation breathing, and aromatherapy.
We had over 2000 patient contacts last year. Patient feedback is highly
positive. Inpatient Integrative Medicine (IM) consultation is provided
throughout the hospital and requires a formal physician consultation request.
Patients receiving at least 3 IM team visits are offered an anonymous
Likert-type scale survey, which is returned to the Center for Integrative
Medicine in a sealed envelope. The survey assesses modalities used,
effectiveness of the IM team at improving pain, anxiety/stress, and insomnia,
satisfaction with overall hospital care, perceived value of the IM service and
whether the presence of an IM service would affect hospital choice. Survey
collection is ongoing. We hope to assess the overall benefit of the IM service,
most effective modalities, and impact of the IM service on patient satisfaction
and hospital choice. Preliminary review reveals highly positive results in both
clinical and patient satisfaction domains. By May 2018, we will collect at least
100 surveys. Our formal IM consultation service requires a financial commitment
from the hospital for uncovered services. Preliminary data will assess not only
the effectiveness of the service at relieving patients’ suffering but also
assess if providing the service offers benefits of interest to the hospital such
as improving patient satisfaction, facilitating JCAHO requirements to provide
nonpharmacologic pain management, and potentially increasing market share.
Rationale: Formal inpatient integrative medicine consultation may
provide physical and psychological benefits to patients coping with serious
illness. Convincing hospitals to fund such initiatives will require assessment
of the effectiveness of such a service at providing nonpharmacologic pain
management, increasing patient satisfaction, and providing unique marketing
opportunities. In this session, we will present the mechanics of a
well-established inpatient integrative medicine consultation service as well as
an initial assessment of clinical benefit and metrics of interest to hospital
administrators.
Objectives: The aim is to describe a formal inpatient integrative
medicine consultation service; discuss the value of an inpatient integrative
medicine consultation service to hospital administrators; and replicate an
inpatient integrative medicine consultation service at one’s own
institution.
(3441) Effects of Didgeridoo Sound Meditation on Acute Stress and Mood in
Undergraduate Students
Kamaira H Philips, BM1, John D Mann, MD1, Susan Gaylord,
PhD1 and Carrie Brintz, PhD1
1Chapel Hill, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Research has shown that meditation is effective for stress
reduction in students. Additionally, listening to repetitive sounds often
elicits a calming effect. Thus, sound meditation may be effective for reducing
stress. Evidence indicates playing didgeridoo (Aboriginal Australian instrument)
is therapeutic for sleep apnea. However, psychological effects of experiencing
didgeridoo as a form of sound meditation are unknown. We compared the acute
effects of didgeridoo sound meditation versus silent meditation on stress and
mood in undergraduate students without prior meditation experience.
Results: Two-way mixed analyses of variance (ANOVAs) showed that
participants in both groups reported significantly decreased acute perceived
stress (P < .001, η2 = 0.57), negative arousal
(P < .001, η2 = 0.24), decreased energy
(P < .001, η2 = 0.22), and tiredness
(P < .001, η2 = 0.40). Relaxation
significantly increased in both groups (P < 0.001,
η2 = 0.46); although the didgeridoo group reported a greater
increase in relaxation, the interaction was not significant
(P = .06, η2 = 0.05). Fifty-three percent of silent
participants and 80% of didgeridoo participants agreed that they would attend
that type of meditation again.
Conclusions: These data suggest that brief didgeridoo sound
meditation is as effective at reducing acute stress and negative affect as
silent meditation. The results warrant investigation into didgeridoo as a stress
management therapy in students. Future studies should investigate (1) the
effects and mechanisms of action of didgeridoo sound in comparison to other
types of sounds used in meditation and (2) efficacy of live sounds compared to
recorded sounds for sound meditation interventions.
(3442) Developing, Integrating, and Implementing Evidence Informed Practice
Curricula Throughout a Chinese Medicine Degree Program
Roni Evans, DC, MS, PhD1, Paul R Marantz, MD, MPH2, Belinda J
Anderson, PhD, MA(Ed)3 and Ben E Kligler, MD, MPH4
1University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, New York
3Pacific College of Oriental Medicine, New York, New York
4Mount Sinai Hospital, New York, New York
Abstract
Purpose: Pacific College of Oriental Medicine (New York) (PCOM-NY)
received funding (2013–2018) from the National Institutes of Health/National
Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) to train faculty and
develop curricula in evidence-informed practice (EIP). The project is being
undertaken in collaboration with Albert Einstein College of Medicine,
Northwestern Health Sciences University, and the University of Minnesota. This
presentation describes the process of developing, integrating, and implementing
EIP curricula.
Results: Only 5% of PCOM-NY faculty had prior research training. To
date, 83% of the PCOM-NY faculty have received EIP training, 42% have undertaken
the first section of the online EIP modules (1.3 h), 31% have completed the FEIP
course, and 5% have completed all sections of the online EIP modules (10 h). EIP
curriculum mapping was completed, and EIP is being integrated into 74% of the
master’s degree curricula. EIP course learning outcomes for all courses and
clinic activities have been developed, and the department chairs are working
with faculty to develop EIP assignments. Issues related to how EIP is defined in
conjunction with the nature of available scientific research in Chinese medicine
have presented challenges to developing learning outcomes.
Conclusions: Training faculty and developing curricula in EIP within
Chinese medicine colleges have unique challenges that must be factored into the
strategies and process. Having faculty take a leadership role in driving the
process greatly facilitates the success of these endeavors.
(3443) Dispositional Mindfulness Moderates the Effects of Daily Fluctuation in
Negative Affect on Well-being Among Stressed Older Adults
Jeff Proulx, PhD1, Dan Klee, BS1, Tab Memmott, BS1,
Dana D Colgan, PhD1 and Barry Oken, MD, PhD1
1Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: In older adults, dispositional mindfulness has been
associated with increased emotional well-being and decreased negative affect.
The variability of daily negative affect contains unique information relevant to
well-being, beyond that provided by mean negative affect, and has been shown to
be salient marker for reduced physical and mental health. To further examine the
effects of mindfulness in stressed older adults, this study investigated whether
dispositional mindfulness would moderate the relationship between daily
fluctuation in negative affect and emotional well-being among older adults.
Results: Bivariate correlation analysis revealed a statistically
significant inverse relationship between daily fluctuation in negative affect
and well-being (r = −.46; P < .001). When
controlling for age and gender, the effect of daily fluctuation in negative
affect on well-being was moderated by dispositional mindfulness, β = .74,
t(108) = 3.60, P < .001. Similar
results were found when investigating the interaction effect of dispositional
mindfulness and maximum daily negative affect on emotional well-being, β = .52,
t(110) = 4.30, P < .001.
Conclusions: Research has only recently begun to examine mindfulness
in older adults. Results suggest that dispositional mindfulness may decouple the
effects of daily fluctuation in negative affect on emotional well-being in a
real-time, ambulatory measurement.
(3445) Translational Evaluation of a Novel Sulforaphane and Beta-glucans Dietary
Supplement on Biomarkers of Detoxification and Inflammation
Christopher R D'Adamo, PhD1, Sharis A Erwin, MS2, Grace A
Cornblatt, PhD2, Stacy L Ownby, MS2 and Brian S Cornblatt,
PhD2
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2Nutramax Laboratories, Edgewood, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Studies suggest increased fruit and vegetable consumption
mitigates oxidative stress and chronic inflammation, which have been linked to a
variety of health issues. This may be due in part to the presence of
phytochemicals like sulforaphane (SFN), derived from broccoli, that modulates
oxidative and inflammatory pathways, and the glucans in maitake mushrooms, which
support the immune system. While SFN and glucans are potent individually, this
study translationally evaluates the cytoprotective and anti-inflammatory
properties of the combination of both in vitro and through an ongoing human
clinical trial. We assessed the effects of the combination on the expression of
biomarkers including the detoxifying enzyme NAD(P)H quinone oxidoreductase 1
(NQO-1), the anti-oxidative enzyme/heat shock protein heme-oxygenase 1
(HMOX-1/HSP32), and the pro-inflammatory markers interleukin-6 (IL-6) and
cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2).
Results: The SFN and glucan combination induced the expression of
NQO-1 by 2.3-fold (18 h, P < .001), HMOX-1 by 3.5-fold (6 h,
P < .001), and decreased IL-6 by 34% (24 h,
P < .001), and COX-2 by 28% (24 h,
P < .05).
Conclusions: While validation in the human clinical trial is pending
results expected in early 2018, the preclinical results reveal that the
combination offers cytoprotective properties and helps to diminish expression of
pro-inflammatory mediators.
(3446) The Lower Extremity Contribution of the Vertical Support During Tai
Chi
Amos Smith, MS1 and Wei Liu, PhD2
1Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama
2Edward Via College of Osteopathic Medicine, Auburn, Alabama
Abstract
Purpose: Tai Chi (TC) exercise is becoming an increasingly popular
complementary and alternative approach for both healthy people and patients with
a variety of medical conditions in the United States. TC is a continuous, slow
rhythmic, and bipedal movement, and this requires TC to control joints at ankle,
knee, and hip in a coordinate manner. The ground reaction force (GRF) is an
important indicator of lower extremity synergy of vertical support during
walking and running. Few studies have investigated the lower extremity
contribution of GRF during TC. To better understand the biomechanics of TC, the
purpose of study was to determine the lower extremity contribution of GRF during
TC and compared to normal gait.
Results: TC was significantly predominated by the contribution of
the contralateral ankle (ankle: 32.44%) than normal waking (0.11%), whereas the
knee was the primary contributor to support in normal walking (knee: 41.39%)
than in TC (17.11%).
Conclusions: This study demonstrates that TC places a high
mechanical demand on the contralateral ankle joint during vertical support. The
lower stress the knee experiences during TC supports benefits of TC on
decreasing knee joint load, which suggests TC as a potential therapy for people
with joint disease.
(3447) The Economic Impact: Optimum Timeline from Behavioral Therapies to
Surgical Therapies in Response to Pain
CJ Rhoads and DEd1
1Kutztown University, Kutztown, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this article is to investigate the financial
influences and costs associated with pain management therapies designed for
treating patients in chronic pain. Twenty-nine approaches to pain management
(including folk, integrative, standard, and surgical) were identified. Each was
rank ordered on 5 characteristics: level of invasiveness, duration of expected
relief, potential life impact, risk of side effects, and cost. A pain management
approach index was calculated based upon the rank orders, and a prioritized list
of approaches was developed. The economics of pain management is not a small
issue. The Institute of Medicine estimates that pain causes a burden to
approximately 100 million U.S. adults, at a cost of at least $560–635 billion
annually (not counting people who are institutionalized, or the indirect cost of
pain such as loss of productivity). Typically, single pain treatments are less
than 50% effective. Pain relief, especially chronic pain relief, is often a
matter of multiple treatments rather than a single treatment. Pain management
specialists are adept at figuring out what combination of treatments each
patient requires based upon the type of pain, duration of pain, as well as both
the psychosocial impact and attenuation to pain. This combination is known as
the neuromatrix of pain. It is precisely because pain management requires a
combination of a multitude of treatments to be fully effective that economic
factors are so important. When there are dozens of choices, and multiple
treatments necessary to solve the problem, the decision is not simple. Having
list of prioritized approaches that takes multiple factors into account should
help physicians and patients make better, more informed decisions regarding pain
management approaches for acute or chronic pain, regardless of the cause of the
pain.
Results: The first rank ordering of the methods will be amount of
invasiveness. Obviously surgical methods will be more invasive than nonsurgical
methods. The results are in the first table (Table 1).
The pain management approaches can also be rank ordered by impact on lifestyle
and amount of typical pain relief. This can be found in Table 2.
The final rank order will be by cost of procedure (Table 3). Given the discussion
previously on the difficulties of analyzing economics, and the myriad of choices
regarding the items, it was decided to look up the codes for each procedure in a
consumer-lookup site (http://fairhealthconsumer.org/). When the procedure was not
available, a fair sample (3–5) of instances of the costs were searched on the
World Wide Web and utilized. When possible, the cost to the patient, the cost to
the insurance company, and the cost to Medicare were recorded. Based upon these
myriad of costs, an assessment was made that enabled the procedures to be rank
ordered based upon their 5-year cost. Because some of the costs are ongoing
(such as massage therapy, mind–body therapies, etc.) and dose-specific, the
typical number of times the therapy would be paid for was utilized to rank
order. For example, a Pilates, Yoga, or Tai Chi class would typically be held 2
times per week, whereas a massage was more typically done 1 time per week.
Surgery would typically be counted only once, except in the cases where a
battery would need to be replaced; the cost would include 1 additional surgery
for that purpose.
In addition to the rank order of the cost, whether or not there is potential for
negative side effects must be taken into account. For each approach listed, in
addition to the rank order of the cost, the assessment for potential negative
side effects has been listed (Table 3). Small, medium, and high are relative
assessments for negative, unwanted side effects. When the possibility of
negative side effects was nonexistent, and there was no potential for positive
side effects either, the table indicates none. If there was potential for
positive side effects, such as the case of physical/behavioral therapy or
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) or mind/body practices improving one's
overall health, relationships, or quality of life, then the assessment was
positive.
Conclusions: Due to the limitations of this study, it might be
considered simply a starting point for further study. One of the difficulties in
treatment, however, is the fact that practitioners generally come from only 1 of
the categories. In other words, those who tend to prescribe analgesics are more
likely to be primary care physicians and those who perform surgery are likely to
be orthopedic or neurological surgeons. Those who work in the integrative
medicine world are likely not part of the official health networks at all, and
folk medicine or home remedies often have no specific advisor for the patient
except for articles in the popular press and websites such as The People’s
Pharmacy (www.peoplespharmacy.com). Nonetheless, the results, which
include both economic and noneconomic factors, provide some practical clinical
guidelines for treatment. The pain management approach to which patients are
directed, therefore, is generally a foregone conclusion based upon who they see.
If they go to a healer, they will get folk medicine. If they go to a
chiropractor, they will get an adjustment. If they go to a primary care
physician, they will get analgesics, and if they go to a surgeon, they will get
surgery. In a perfect world, the primary care physician would take the
responsibility to direct the pain management options and would include low-cost
folk medicine and integrative medicine in the continuum of care. Because many
primary care physicians are not prepared or trained to do that, pain management
specialists have cropped up, at a higher specialty cost, in order to direct the
care with multidisciplinary approach. Though they generally include more options
such as CBT or physical therapy, even they don’t include the whole gamut of
options for pain management. Except for those on the cutting edge of pain
relief, you will not generally see doctors recommend Tai Chi, yoga, pilates,
meditation, or nutrition therapy for pain management despite the fact that past
anecdotal evidence is strong and now there is growing scientific evidence as
well. Furthermore, for some of the treatment options (especially integrative
medical therapies), there is still, however, difficulty in control. Patients
could chew willow bark instead of going to the store aspirin, but the dosage
would be wildly variable, perhaps causing more problems than it solves. There
are few controls, or even guidance, as to mind/body or meditative practices. How
often is enough? How long must sessions be? Who is qualified to teach the
patient how to do it? These are all valid questions that currently have no
standard answer. From a society perspective, and from the patients perspective,
it is beneficial to try folk and integrative medicine before jumping to standard
care. Standards of care generally rely upon the patient to try home remedies,
exercise, and nutrition before coming to the doctor with a complain of pain, but
often patients have not done so, don’t understand how powerful simple remedies
might be, and are not willing to try something on their own without the blessing
of the physician. Finally, patients themselves must be relied upon to carry out
the treatments. Exercise, for example, is generally accepted as being highly
effective in a pain management program (as well as many other metabolic
maladies). Dosage is even relatively well established scientifically; it is
known that 20–60 min a day of medium-intensive repetitive exercise such as
walking is generally required to make a difference. But other than telling that
to the patient, the standard medical practice does not have a system of coaching
to help, support, and encourage patients to exercise daily. As a result, it goes
unused as part of the pain management program despite its effectiveness. While
this study is only a start, and has many limitations, it does do 1 thing that
most studies do not; it brings together different pain management approaches
from many different areas (folk, integrative, standard, and surgical) in order
to provide a more complete view of the options. Therefore, despite its
limitations, and with the recognition that not all pain management approaches
would be appropriate for all sorts of pain, a list was compiled that provides
guidelines for the order in which each of the approaches should be utilized
(before giving up on it as not effective). These approaches are not mutually
exclusive, and it is not a waterfall list. In other words, many approaches
(perhaps even dozens) should be tried simultaneously, and those that don’t
appear effective after a sincere effort and several months of trial should be
dropped. Some of the remedies should only be utilized for a short time (such as
analgesics of any sort) due to the fact that side effects increase dramatically
as the approach extends in duration. Other remedies, especially the integrative
medicine approaches, CBT/acceptance and commitment therapy and
physical/behavioral therapies should be used for at least 6 months before giving
up, especially if the pain is not so severe as to require stronger approaches.
It should also be kept in mind that some approaches such as opioids or surgery
often result in increased pain in the long run. While the patients themselves
should be the ultimate deciders on the order and duration of the different
approaches, it behooves either the primary care physician or the pain management
specialist to present all the approaches, their advantages and their
disadvantages, rather than just the standard approaches. The patients should be
more fully informed regarding costs and side effects of all the different
approaches. This list takes into account all of the different rank orders; side
effects, life impact, typical pain relief, level of invasiveness, and, finally,
cost. The impact of side effects was given a number value between 1 and 5
equivalent to the potential impact: positive 1, none 2, small 3, medium 4, and
high 5. The index was calculated by taking the rank orders of each of the
factors and adding them together, times the potential impact of side effects,
which provided the final rank order by priority of pain management approach seen
in Table 4.
Though subjective in nature, and only a beginning, the information provided in
this study can help physicians and patients impact the economics and
effectiveness of pain management. Both practitioners and patients benefit from
knowledge of all the various approaches to pain management (folk, integrative,
standard, and surgical) and from an understanding of the advantages and
disadvantages of each on 5 characteristics: level of invasiveness, duration of
expected relief, potential life impact, risk of side effects, and cost.
Reviewing this information will help physicians and patients make better
decisions with more positive outcomes at lower cost. The analysis shows that
more focus and higher priority should be placed on approaches with low incidence
of side effects (or positive side effects) such as mind/body practices,
biofeedback/meditation, massage therapy, physical/behavioral therapy, and CBT.
Scientific evidence of the effectiveness of these approaches in pain management
is strong and growing. Physicians are urged to become familiar with the whole
gamut of pain management therapies and to direct their patients to try multiple
therapies in optimized order before resorting to therapies with more side
effects such as opioids and surgery.
(3448) Yoga: Theory and Practice: A Course Illustrating Yoga Belongs in the
Academy
Maryanna D Klatt, PhD1
1College of Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
Abstract
Overview: The course “Yoga: Theory and Practice” (YTP) evolved from
the realization that graduate and undergraduate academic offerings of yoga
courses were filled beyond capacity with long waitlists, while students were
missing the depth and breadth of what yoga has to offer as an integrative health
practice. Students experientially understood the contribution yoga practice
(asanas, breathing, and meditation) made in their lives, and sensed the health
benefits it afforded. Yet, they were hungry for the scientific evidence behind
yoga for various clinical conditions. Students wanted scientific evidence for
what they experientially knew to be true—yoga helped them feel more grounded in
their bodies, more like themselves. In 2004, college yoga courses were typically
in Departments of Physical Education, there was no educational literature on how
to design a course that would give students the knowledge they desired, and the
theory behind why yoga was practiced was slim to nonexistent in
yoga courses offered. This is no longer the case. YTP is a course within an
academic minor of study, “Integrative Approaches to Health and Wellness” at one
of the largest universities in America. Salient features of the course include
(1) philosophical exploration of the difference between reductionism and wholism
as applied to health, (2) theoretical/historical background of yoga and
Ayurveda, (3) scientific and experiential benefits of mindfulness/meditation,
and (4) scientific evidence that has emerged on the health benefits of yoga for
specific conditions. YTP provides students with the historical, philosophical,
and integrative health benefits that yoga has to offer. Utilizing the text,
The Principles and Practice of Yoga in Health Care (Khalsa,
Cohen, McCall, & Telles, 2016) provides the evidence detailing the
scientific study of yoga. All 4 of the salient features of the course inform the
practice of yoga within YTP. Yoga belongs in the academy!
Rationale: Course design is not an easy task, but course design
bridging paradigms is nearly (but not quite!) impossible. The course design of
YTP was implemented in 2004 and is a thriving course in
today’s academy—one of the largest universities in America. This educational
abstract definitely advances integrative health through research and education,
giving these students (our leaders of tomorrow) the means to implement yoga into
their lives and careers. Many of the students over the years who have taken this
course were pre health-care professionals. Today, those students are practicing
health-care professionals, hopefully utilizing yoga in their practice. Enrolled
in this course, they were enriched with the history, philosophy, and scientific
background necessary to utilize these concepts in their medical practice.
Curriculum design is vitally important in advancing cultural change, and
YTP has been an important, innovative part of that
movement.
Objectives: As a result of this session, participants will be able
to detail how the course design of a yoga college course is integral to the
content one is trying to convey; explicate the 4 essential components of YTP as
they relate to advancing integrative health through research and education; and
design their own college course back at their home university utilizing the 4
essential elements described in this session.
(3450) Where East Meets West: Integrative Medicine and Health at Mayo Clinic in
Florida
Dawn M Mussallem, DO1, Michelle A Leak, DEd, MBA1, Melissa B
Smith1, Carol Ann O Schwartz, RN, BSN1, Ingram
Caswell1, Tony E Hanneken1, Mark A Mihaly1 and
Troy R Delaney, MBA1
1Jacksonville, Florida
Abstract
Overview: Noting the limited availability of Integrative Medicine
and Health (IMH) programs at academic medical centers in the Southeast United
States, Mayo Clinic in Florida (MCF) conducted a 4-month (March 1–June 30, 2017)
pilot among outpatients with breast cancer offering acupuncture, massage,
functional nutrition, mindfulness and resiliency, integrative medicine MD
consults, and botanicals and supplements consults in an effort to help patients
manage unresolved symptoms and/or the potentially debilitating adverse effects
of conventional cancer treatment. The pilot was extended to include massage
therapy for neurology and neurosurgery inpatients. The pilot was designed to (1)
identify and/or confirm any benefits of integrative medicine therapies to
patients, (2) assess patient demand or interest in integrative medicine
therapies, (3) assess the financial implications of integrative medicine
therapies for patients and providers, and (4) assess clinical practice models
specific to integrative medicine therapies. Patients completed the Breast Cancer
Prevention Trial Quality of Life Survey. In addition, patients were asked to
complete a survey specific to their interactions with IMH providers. Patient
satisfaction results totaled 100%—“very good” (93% minimum) plus “good.” IMH
therapies were utilized by over 90% of newly diagnosed breast cancer patients
and a wait list currently exits for IMH consults. With respect to neurology and
neurosurgery inpatients, the massage therapist documented patients’
self-reported pain scores before and after providing massage therapy. On
average, patients reported a 60% improvement in their level of pain after
massage therapy. The IMH pilot achieved a 36.9% operating margin reflecting
allowances for customary expense reductions. Recognition of revenue reductions
resulted in a 8.2% operating margin. Pilot results revealed opportunities
specific to availability of consult slots and exam rooms, use of supplemental
staff, billing and reimbursement, “no-show” policy development, ordering
processes, and post discharge follow-up and tracking. Efforts are currently
underway to offer IMH therapies to all MCF patients.
Rationale: The IMH pilot at MCF highlights collaborative
opportunities for health-care consumers, IMH practitioners and administrators,
policy makers, and insurers. Consumer out-of-pocket expenditures for integrative
medicine therapies now total over $34 billion annually. While an increasing
number of hospitals now offer integrative medicine therapies, reimbursement for
integrative medicine lags behind reimbursement for more traditional and invasive
therapies and treatment modalities. Consumers and IMH practitioners and
administrators have the opportunity to influence policy makers and insurers
based on their individual and collective experiences utilizing and designing IMH
services. More specifically, consumers can speak to the benefits of integrative
medicine, as IMH reaffirms the importance of the relationships between
practitioner and patient, focuses on the whole person, and makes use of all
appropriate therapeutic approaches for health and healing. IMH practitioners and
administrators have the opportunity to ensure that IMH services and therapies
offered are informed by evidence, driven by inquiry, and open to new paradigms.
Policy makers and insurers have the opportunity to act upon the evidence and in
so doing expand health-care reform to include reimbursement for less costly and
invasive treatment modalities and therapies while adding value—a measure of cost
and quality—to an increasingly overburdened and inefficient health-care
system.
Objectives: As a result of this session, participants will gain
insights into how to design, implement, and manage a financially viable IMH
program; engage providers and practitioners across clinical disciplines; and
anticipate and proactively address patient expectations specific to billing and
reimbursement for integrative medicine therapies.
To fully present this topic, submitting author requests consideration of
powerepoint presentation (not poster presentation). Thank you.
(3451) Maoto, Traditional Kampo Formula, for Influenza: A Systematic Review and
Meta-analysis
Ryutaro Arita, MD1, Yuko Horiba, MD1, Kenji Watanabe, MD,
PhD1 and Tetsuhiro Yoshino, MD, PhD1
1Keio University School of Medicine, Shinjuku, Tokyo, Japan
Abstract
Purpose: Influenza is common viral infection all over the world, and
it causes general symptoms, including fever, headache, malaise, and cough.
Traditional Kampo formula, maoto, has been used traditionally for the treatment
of acute febrile disease. In the Japanese national health insurance system, the
influenza is one of the indications of maoto. However, there has been no
meta-analysis of maoto for the treatment of influenza. Here, we performed a
systematic review and meta-analysis to clarify the efficacy and tolerability of
maoto (ma-huang-tang) for the treatment of influenza.
Results: Twelve relevant studies (total n = 1248) were identified
including 3 randomized clinical trials (RCT) and 9 non-RCTs. The duration of
fever did not differ between maoto and neuraminidase inhibitor (NI). Maoto plus
NI was superior to NI alone in terms of the duration of fever
(P = .002, weighted mean difference = −5.41 h,
I2 = 0%). There was no severe side effect reported from maoto nor
NI.
Conclusions: Our result suggests that maoto has a beneficial effect
on the duration of fever when it is used solely or additionally to NI, and maoto
seems to be a well-tolerated treatment. The quality of evidence for this
finding, however, was low because of a high risk of bias. More RCTs are needed
to determine the efficacy and safety of maoto.
(3452) Entry-level Massage Education’s Preparation for U.S. Health-care Settings:
Perspectives From Experienced Massage Therapists
Ann Blair Kennedy, DrPH, LMT, BCTMB1, Arash Zakeresfahani2,
Angela Weaver Barker, BCTMB, LMT, AMTA3, Troy Lavigne, LMT, CKTI, CPMT,
AMTA4, William Dunn, BA, LMBT5 and Niki Munk, PhD,
LMT2
1University of South Carolina School of Medicine Greenville, Greenville,
South Carolina
2Indiana University School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences,
Indianapolis, Indiana
3Milton, West Virginia
4Healthcare Operational Committee, Boulder, Colorado
5Greenville Technical College, Greenville, South Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Massage therapists work in a variety of settings including
health-care centers (organization, business, or institute providing preventative
and/or medical care services). Little research focuses on massage therapists’
experience working in U.S. health-care centers, and reliable data are needed to
understand existing educational preparation and to better inform educators and
practitioners for increasing health-care integration opportunities.
Results: N = 386 surveys were completed and analyzed for all and by
medical setting experience (defined as in/out patient medical clinic, hospital,
doctor’s office, or nursing home). A majority of respondents were White (85%),
female (88%), and state licensed/equivalent (94%). Forty-seven percent reported
medical setting massage experience. Smaller proportions of therapists under 40
worked in medical care settings (34%; P < .01) compared to
those aged 40–59 years (51%) and 60+ (57%). A majority of respondents (80%)
indicated education beyond entry-level training was needed for massage
therapists working in health-care centers, but proportions were smaller among
those not working in a medical care environment (74% vs 87%;
P = .0014). Those whose health-care center work as a
massage therapist were in medical care environments reported reliance on
experience from other related fields in greater proportions (73% vs 59%;
P = .003) and did not feel as strongly that their
entry-level massage training prepared them for work in health-care centers.
Conclusions: Different experiences and medical team involvement
based on health-care center setting type may influence massage therapists’
education needs and perceptions.
(3453) A Multidisciplinary Approach to the Development of a Rational
Phytotherapeutic From Centella Asiatica
Maya Caruso, BS1, Kirsten Wright, ND, MS1, Nora Gray,
PhD1, Donald G Matthews, PhD1, Armando Alcazar Magana,
PhD2, Charles Murchison, MS1, Amala Soumyanath,
PhD1, Jan F Stevens, PhD2, Claudia S Maier,
PhD2, Joseph Quinn, MD3, Jonathan Zweig, BS1,
Jennifer Zhu, BA1, Christopher Harris, BS1, Parnian Lak,
PhD2, Doris Kretzschmar, PhD1 and Margeux Hunter,
BA1
1Portland, Oregon
2Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon
3Portland VA Medical Center, Oregon Health and Science University,
Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is a debilitating form of dementia
with a high global burden and need for effective treatments. Centella
asiatica (CA) is a botanical from Eastern medicine reputed to
enhance cognition. Previous studies on CA and its bioactive components in
preclinical models strongly support its potential as a phytotherapeutic for
cognitive decline and AD. The development of effective and reproducible
phytotherapeutics warrants a plethora of specialized skills due to the
complexity and variability of botanical extracts. We will present our approach
to the development of a rational phytotherapeutic from CA for future examination
in clinical trials of AD.
Results: Aqueous CA extracts improve cognitive function in mouse and
Drosophila models of aging and AD. This may be due to
influences on the antioxidant response, mitochondrial activity, tau
phosphorylation, and synaptic density. Sensitive liquid chromatography coupled
to mass spectrometry methods have been developed to fingerprint CA extracts and
measure biologically active compounds (triterpenes and caffeoylquinic acids) in
biological matrices. These bioactives have been found to be bioavailable in
rodents allowing for the use of interspecies scaling in determining doses for
future translational studies in humans.
Conclusions: A multidisciplinary approach is essential to the
development of rational phytotherapeutics. Our methodology is an example of a
robust scientific approach to developing a phytotherapeutic for examination in
AD.
(3462) Treatment Plan as a Significant Predictor of Appointment Scheduling in
Acupuncture Patients
Chun Nok Lam, MPH1, David S Black, PhD1, Sang Hyun Lee,
Lac2 and Chris Ruth, LAc, DAOM2
1Los Angeles, California
2Emperor’s College of Traditional Oriental Medicine, Santa Monica,
California
Abstract
Purpose: Clinical factors that influence a patient’s decision to
continue acupuncture treatment after initial consultation are not known. This
study tests the effect of having a clinical treatment plan on patients to
schedule a follow-up appointment after their initial consultation.
Results: The study analysis included 120 participants (age:
M = 42.6 ± 13.0 years, 27.5% male). About two thirds (62.5%) received a
treatment plan recommending follow-up visits, and 55.8% reported scheduling an
appointment prior to leaving the clinic. Treatment plan and appointment
scheduling were correlated (rho = 0.32, P < .001); 68.0% of
participants with a treatment plan scheduled an appointment while only 35.6%
without treatment plan scheduled (P < .001). Adjusted
regression analysis showed that having a treatment plan (odds ratio [OR] = 3.06,
95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.26, 7.41, P = .013) and
intention to follow-up (OR = 2.09, 95% CI: 1.15, 3.77,
P = .015) increased the likelihood of appointment scheduling.
Other covariates including age, sex, illness perception, level of disability,
chronic illness, immediate symptom improvement, attitude toward integrative
therapies, acupuncture expectancy, and patient–provider relationship did not
predict appointment scheduling.
Conclusions: Appointment scheduling reflects a patient’s decision to
continue care with acupuncture. Treatment plans serve a key role in offering
patients guidance for future actions and can potentially lead to improved
adherence to treatment recommendation. Acupuncturists can help patients benefit
from ongoing treatment by establishing a treatment plan as part of their routine
clinical procedure.
(3463) Insight From the Experts: A Qualitative Study to Assess Definitions,
Outcomes, and the Process and Practice of Mindfulness
Michael Christopher, PhD1, Josh Kaplan, MS1, Cindy Marino,
PsyD1, Varinthorn Christopher, MFA1, Sukjai Charoensuk,
PhD2, Penphan Pitaksongkram, PhD2 and Dana Dharmakaya
Colgan, PhD3
1Pacific University, Forest Grove, Oregon
2Boromarajonani College, Chon Buri, Thailand
3Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Eastern and Western perspectives on mindfulness share an
overarching intention to alleviate suffering, and there is significant overlap
in their methodologies. However, there are also differences in the
conceptualization of mindfulness in Buddhism and Western science, which may have
important implications for treatment delivery, assessment procedures, and
optimal clinical outcomes of secular mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs).
This qualitative study was designed to ascertain culturally grounded, expert
information on mindfulness from Buddhist monks, nuns, and lay practitioners
recruited from Zen, Tibetan, and Theravada Buddhist temples in the United States
and Thailand.
Results: The data revealed prominent distinctions between the
process/practice and outcomes of mindfulness. Key processes included clear
comprehension, 4 foundations of mindfulness, receptive awareness, deliberate
focus of attention, and returning to present moment. Key outcomes included
wisdom, joy, interpersonal positivity, spaciousness, calm mind, and equanimity.
Participants also identified Buddhist concepts deemed essential to the
cultivation of well-being that have received little attention in MBIs (eg,
ethical living, impermanence of all phenomena).
Conclusions: Understanding mechanisms and outcomes of mindfulness
from a Buddhist perspective has the potential to inform MBI development, enhance
mindfulness assessment, and optimize clinical outcomes.
(3464) Recovery of Centella Asiatica Bioactives From Plasma: Method Development
and Application to a Pharmacokinetic Study
Maya Caruso, BS1, Kirsten Wright, ND, MS1, Margeux Hunter,
BA1, Joseph Quinn, MD2, Amala Soumyanath, PhD1,
Charles Murchison, MS1, Donald G Matthews, PhD1 and Nora Gray,
PhD1
1Portland, Oregon
2Portland VA Medical Center, Oregon Health and Science University,
Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose:
Centella asiatica (CA) is an Eastern medicine botanical
believed to enhance memory. Aqueous extracts (200–300 mg/kg/day) containing
triterpenes (0.94%–2.41%) and caffeoylquinic acids (CQAs; 0.01%–0.46%) improve
cognition in several rodent models. Mouse models for translational studies
present a challenge due to low plasma yields. This study evaluated different
plasma work up methods to recover CA’s chemically divergent compounds and detect
them with sensitive liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. This
methodology was applied to a pharmacokinetic (PK) study in mice.
Results: Phree columns were effective for the CQAs and C8 columns
were effective for the triterpenes. Protein precipitation with
methanol:acetonitrile 1:3 gave good linearity
(r
2 = .907 to .999) and precision (3% to 16%
relative standard deviation) for both the triterpenes and CQAs. In the PK study,
maximum plasma concentrations (Cmax) of CQAs and metabolites (10–125
ng/mL) occurred within 60 min, whereas triterpenes did not peak within 4 h.
Conclusions: Protein precipitation with methanol:acetonitrile 1:3 is
the preferred method for recovery of CA analytes from small volumes of mouse
plasma. CQAs from CA water extract are orally bioavailable and metabolized.
These methods will be translated to future human studies.
(3465) First Timers Versus Repeat Users of Acupuncture: Differences in Perceived
Illness Severity, Treatment Appraisal and Intention for Follow-up Treatment
Adam Burke, PhD, MPH, LAc1, Eileen Jia, LAc2, David S Black,
PhD3 and Chun Nok Lam, MPH3
1San Francisco State University, San Francisco, California
2Emperor’s College of Traditional Oriental Medicine, Santa Monica,
California
3Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to test for potential differences between
first timers and repeat users of acupuncture on key factors related to
acupuncture utilization.
Results: The study analysis included 120 participants (age:
M = 42.6 ± 13.0 years, 27.5% male). Participants were predominantly white
(72.5%), well-educated (70.8% 4-year graduate), and had health insurance
(90.8%). Thirty-three participants (27.5%) were first timers. First timers were
more likely to be male (48.5% vs 19.5%, P = .002) with less
education (48.5% vs 79.3% 4-year graduate) compared to repeat users. First
timers reported higher illness perception (M = 46.1 vs 41.1,
P = .001), appraised acupuncture as less effective (M = 2.1 vs
3.2, P < .001) and had a less positive attitude toward
integrative therapies in general (M = 17.5 vs 20.8,
P < .001). Both groups reported a similar level of intention
to return for follow-up treatment visits (M = 3.5 vs 3.5) and complete the
recommended treatment course (M = 3.5 vs 3.7).
Conclusions: First-time acupuncture users reported higher illness
severity and lower positive appraisals than repeat users. Notably, these
disparities did not affect first timers’ intention to continue care with
acupuncture for the same health condition. Our findings inform acupuncturists to
specifically address concerns over first timers’ heightened illness perception
and provide additional information on existing evidence for integrative
therapies.
(3466) Anti-inflammatory Bowel Disease Effects of Dietary Chitin in Both
Sexes
Patricia Louis, MS1, Janet Menzie, PhD1, Zhongwei Li,
PhD1, Minoru Koi, PhD2, C Kathleen Dorey, PhD3,
Changlong Nan, PhD1 and Yoshimi Shibata, PhD1
1Charles E. Schmidt College of Medicine, Florida Atlantic University, Boca
Raton, Florida
2Ann Arbor, Michigan
3Virginia Tech Carilion School of Medicine and Research Institute,
Roanoke, Virginia
Abstract
Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) is a chronic relapsing colitis, associated with
risk for obstruction, fistula and colorectal cancer. IBD is probably caused by
immunologically dysregulated host and microbial interactions. The prevalence of
IBD has been increased significantly over the last decades in the US. Women with
IBD were found to suffer from adverse effects of anti-inflammatory agents more
often than men; therefore, new treatment strategies for both sexes are
needed.
Chitin is natural N-acetyl glucosamine polymer, existing in fungi and crustaceans
but not in mammals or bacteria. Chitin is purified from wastes of seafood
industry. Various forms of chitin and its derivatives including drug delivery
nanoparticles are muco-adhesive. Although use of chitin products for IBD
treatment has be reported by many groups, there are no comparative studies among
chitin products or between males and females. Previously, we found that chitin
microparticles (1 -- 10 μm diameters, CMPs) induce phagocytosis-dependent and
CD14-mediated macrophage activation. Using mouse models of human IBD, we
initially found anti-IBD effects of CMPs in both sexes. However, recent studies
showed that large chitin beads (LCBs, 40 -- 70 μm) produced better anti-IBD
effect than CMPs in males, whereas, in females, CMPs and LCBs were equally
effective. Poor anti-IBD effects were found in both sexes treated with dietary
de-acetylated chitin (chitosan) mircoparticles or soluble chitin. Our additional
results suggest several key host factors regulating anti-IBD effects of chitin,
including CD14-mediated macrophage activation, stomach acidic mammalian
chitinase activity, and gut colonization by Candida albicans
and other fungi recently strongly implicated in IBD pathogenesis. Interestingly
enough, the contribution of these host factors to anti-IBD effect appears to be
distinct between sexes and/or dependent on estrogen sex hormone.
These results and future clinical studies will ultimately reduce excess risk for
IBD and for other chronic inflammatory diseases in women, and increase women's
health.
(3473) Rationale for Routine Collection of Patient Reported Outcomes During
Integrative Medicine Consultation Visits
Stephanie W Skarolid, MA1, Sue Fairchild, PMP1, Rachael Rivard,
MA1, Anne Betzner, PhD1, Jeffery A Dusek, PhD1,
Meghan JaKa, PhD1 and David Victorson, PhD1
1Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: Integrative medicine (IM) is whole-person care utilizing
complementary health approaches to address numerous physical or emotional
influences that can impact an individual’s health. Patient-reported outcomes
(PRO) are subjective measures that quantify patients’ perception of their
quality of life. Our primary purpose was to assess the ability and utility of
routine collection of PRO measures in an IM clinic. A secondary purpose was to
examine any possible changes on longitudinal administration of the PRO
measure.
Results: From November 2013 through October 2016, the
Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System-10 (PROMIS-10) was
administered during 59% of IM provider consultation visits (7172/12 207),
representing 3473 unique patients. Most patients were female (81%), White (93%),
middle-aged (49.2; SD 15.4), and had commercial health insurance (66%). Baseline
mental (44.9; standard deviation [SD] 9.1) and physical health (44.2; SD 8.6)
scores were roughly 0.5 SD below the national mean values (50; SD 10). Factors
such as age, race, and noncommercial insurance were associated with lower
PROMIS-10 scores. Patients completing at least 2 questionnaires (n = 1541)
exhibited increases of 2.3% and 2.8% from first to last PROMIS-10 assessment in
mental and physical heath scores, respectively.
Conclusions: It is possible to routinely collect PRO measures in
large IM clinic and longitudinal improvements in mental and physical health
scores were observed. Future research should focus on understanding how
providers can utilize PRO results in real time to improve patients’ clinical
outcomes and potentially decrease health-care utilization.
(3474) Association Between Utilization of Chiropractic Services for Treatment of
Low Back Pain and Use of Prescription Opioids
James Whedon, DC, MS1, Andrew WJ Toler, MS2, Justin M Goehl,
DC, MS3 and Louis A Kazal, MD3
1Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
2Toler Training Institute, LLC, The Woodlands, Texas
3Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Hanover, New Hampshire
Abstract
Purpose: 15-min oral presentation.
Purpose: The overuse of prescription opioids for treatment of low
back pain is associated with addiction, adverse drug events, and escalating
costs. Chiropractors offer nonpharmacological treatments for low back pain, and
use of chiropractic services may be associated with reduced use of opioids. This
study was intended to quantify the association between utilization of
chiropractic services for low back pain and use of prescription opioids.
Results: The adjusted likelihood of filling a prescription for an
opioid analgesic in 2014 was 55% lower among recipients as compared to
nonrecipients of chiropractic services (odds ration [OR] 0.45; 95% CI 0.40–0.47;
P < .0001). In 2014, annual per-person charges were 78% lower for opioid
prescriptions and 71% lower for clinical services among recipients as compared
to nonrecipients.
Conclusions: Utilization of chiropractic services is correlated with
reduced use of prescription opioids. It is unknown whether this association
results from use of chiropractic care or unmeasured differences between cohorts.
Future research on this correlation will focus on further reducing the risk of
bias and accounting for confounding factors.
(3476) ADME and Anti-inflammatory Activity of the Antimalarial Drug Artemisinin
Delivered Orally as Dried Leaves of Artemisia annua
Matthew Desrosiers, BS1 and Pamela Weathers, PhD1
1Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose:
Artemisia annua offers a new treatment for malaria. The plant
produces the antimalarial drug artemisinin (AN) whose derivatives make up the
major component of artemisinin combination therapies, the frontline global
treatment for malaria. Previously, we showed that AN delivered as powdered,
dried leaves of A. annua (DLA) is >40-fold more bioavailable
in mice, about 4 times more soluble in intestinal fluid, and 37% more permeable
to the intestinal membrane than pure AN. Furthermore, AN and several
phytochemicals native to A. annua have known anti-inflammatory
activity making DLA a potential anti-inflammatory therapeutic.
Results: DLA-delivered AN was distributed in significantly higher
quantities, up to 6-fold greater than from pure AN throughout all tested
tissues. Serum tumor necrosis factor-α was significantly reduced at 1-h
postgavage in DLA-treated rats. Similarly, serum interleukin-6 was significantly
reduced at 2 - and 4-h postgavage in DLA-treated rats.
Conclusions: In agreement with in vitro solubility and intestinal
permeability data, AN delivered as DLA is more bioavailable and more readily
distributed than pure AN in vivo. The effects of DLA phytochemicals on the liver
need investigating to determine their role in these bioavailability differences.
DLA, but not AN, given orally decreases inflammatory cytokine secretion and
requires further investigation in specific inflammatory disease models.
(3477) How to Build an Integrated Care Model for Chronic Conditions
Danielle Greenman, MD1 and Katherine Takayasu, MD1
1Stamford Hospital, Stamford, Connecticut
Abstract
Overview: Navigating health care is frustrating for patients. It is
equally frustrating for providers attempting to coordinate care, particularly
for patients with chronic disease. At Stamford Hospital, we piloted an
interdisciplinary team approach to the management of chronic pelvic pain. To
date, we have treated over 150 patients with early qualitative data analysis
suggesting improvements in patient-reported quality of life and provider
satisfaction. Our goal is to share our approach and which can be applied to any
chronic disease in a variety of health-care systems.
Rationale: Chronic medical conditions are multifactorial and benefit
from an interdisciplinary team approach. Outside of systems like the Veterans
Administration, most providers caring for the same patient rarely communicate
with each other and are not working collaboratively. Lack of collaboration often
results in worsened clinical outcomes and comes at a great financial cost to the
health-care system since patients with chronic conditions are the most frequent
users of health care. Treatment of chronic conditions accounts for 81% of all
hospital admissions, 91% of all prescriptions filled, and 76% of all provider
visits, which is close to $6000 spent per patient per year. A multidisciplinary
team approach addresses many of the current challenges of high-needs
populations. At Stamford Health, we created a patient-centered model to help
patients with chronic pelvic pain in which provider-to-provider communication
was streamlined. This model is reproducible in other health-care institutions to
help high-need patient populations.
Objectives: The aim is to understand why a multidisciplinary team
approach is needed to address chronic medical issues; gain insight into how this
team approach worked at Stamford Health to address chronic pelvic pain; and
extrapolate information and apply it to the learner’s home institution to
address a high-need chronic patient population.
(3478) Accelerometry for the Mobility Impaired: A Scoping Review in Preparation
for a Randomized Study of a Mindfulness Intervention for Physical Activity
Megan N Conlon, MS1 and Roni Evans, DC, MS, PhD2
1Minneapolis, Minnesota
2University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: Adults with mobility limitations are more likely to fall
short of physical activity recommendations. In preparation for a randomized
trial to test the effectiveness of a mindfulness intervention versus an
educational control to increase physical activity in older adults (NCCIH 21
AT009110-01A1), we performed a scoping review. The objective was to assess
whether the Actigraph GT3X+ triaxial accelerometer, the trial’s primary outcome
measure, could be used in individuals with mobility impairments, which is common
in older adults. While the Actigraph GT3X+ has been studied in healthy
ambulatory individuals, less is known regarding its usefulness for those that
are mobility impaired.
Results: The search yielded 1763 articles. When duplicates were
removed, there were 1445 references, of which 1361 were excluded based on title
and abstract. After reviewing the 1445 abstracts, 84 studies were identified for
full-text screening, and 16 studies ended up met all the criteria for inclusion.
A total of 10 were validation studies, 3 addressed reliability, and 4 addressed
cutpoints for determining physical activity levels.
Conclusions: Using validated disability-group specific cut points
and appropriate device placement protocols, we found physical activity can be
accurately measured using Actigraph GT3X+ triaxial accelerometers in individuals
with mobility impairments who ambulate with or without assistive devices. This
is important for ensuring that older adults with mobility impairments can
participate in a study of mindfulness, and potentially other complementary
therapies, aimed at enhancing physical activity.
(3480) Role of Ayurveda in Primary Health-care System: An Approach for Prevention
and Health Promotion
Jayagopal Parla, BAMS, MD, MAOM1 and Anupama Kizhakkeveettil, BAMS, MAOM,
PhD1
1Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
Abstract
Overview:
Purpose: Ayurveda is a traditional healing system with over
5000-year history. The goal of Ayurvedic medicine is to protect the health in a
healthy person and management of the disease. Ayurveda explains how lifestyle
and diet recommendations, in accordance to seasons and individual body types,
can be used to maintain health. A branch of Ayurveda called Rasayana
(rejuvenation) deals with maintaining health and healthy aging. Herbs,
supplements, dietary ingredients, and therapies described under Rasayana are
studied and found to help promote tissue longevity. Their actions are attributed
to their ability to remove metabolic toxins and provide an antioxidant effect.
Modern literature supports this action by explaining the suppression of free
radical formation, breaking free radical chain propagation and damage repair.
Panchakarma incorporates detoxification therapies to remove toxins and keep the
body healthy. Even though the practices of Ayurvedic health modalities have been
observed for several thousands of years, there is a need for research to
evaluate the effectiveness of Ayurveda. Methods: A literature
search was conducted among the classical textbooks of Ayurveda and published
research studies to identify the preventative and health promotive aspects of
Ayurveda. Results: Detailed explanations about the health
promotion and preventative aspects of Ayurveda can be seen in classical
textbooks of Ayurveda. Evidence from the current scientific literature also
indicates the effectiveness of these modalities for health promotion. Concepts
of Ayurvedic traditional holistic health-care system can be easily integrated
into one’s day-to-day life to promote a better quality of life and can play a
role in the prevention of many chronic diseases. Conclusion:
Drawing upon evidence from classical textbooks and the scientific literature,
this presentation explains how a comprehensive natural health-care system can be
used in primary care for health promotion as well as prevention of disease.
Rationale: Ayurveda is a comprehensive natural holistic health-care
system that can be integrated with the various practice of the system of
healing. Ayurveda has unique concepts and methodologies to address health care
throughout the course of life. An integrated approach that combining Ayurveda
and Western medicine would benefit prevention and health promotion. This
presentation explains various modalities explained in this system of medicine
which can be practiced by an integrative medicine practitioner for over
well-being of the patients.
Objectives: The aim is to describe principles of health promotion
and preventive methods in Ayurvedic system of medicine; to describe various
modalities in Ayurveda for prevention and health promotion for healthy aging;
and to describe the evidence from the classical textbooks and scientific
literature regarding how this health care system can be used in primary care for
health promotion as well as prevention of disease.
(3481) Treating Major Depression With Yoga: Research Overview and Results of
University of California, San Francisco Randomized Controlled Pilot Trial
Sudha Prathikanti, MD1
1San Francisco, California
Abstract
Purpose: Conventional pharmacotherapies and psychotherapies for
major depression are associated with limited adherence to care and relatively
low remission rates. Yoga may offer an alternative treatment option, but
rigorous studies are few. This randomized controlled trial with blinded outcome
assessors examined an 8-week hatha yoga intervention as monotherapy for
mild-to-moderate major depression.
Results: In intent-to-treat analysis, yoga participants exhibited
significantly greater 8-week decline in Beck's Depression Inventory (BDI) scores
than controls (P value = .034). In subanalyses of participants
completing final 8-week measures, yoga participants were more likely to achieve
remission, defined per final BDI score ≤9 (P value = .018).
Effect size of yoga in reducing BDI scores was large, per Cohen’s d = −0.96 (95%
confidence interval, −1.81 to −0.12). Intervention groups did not differ
significantly in 8-week change scores for either the, the Generalized
Self-efficacy Scale or Rosenberg’s Self-esteem Scale.
Conclusions: In adults with mild-to-moderate major depression, an
8-week hatha yoga intervention resulted in statistically and clinically
significant reductions in depression severity.
(3482) Learning From N of 1 Patient With Stage 4 Colon Cancer Has Dramatic
Response to Integrative Medicine Approach
Mikhail Kogan, MD1 and Bianca Palushaj1
1Washington, DC
Abstract
Purpose: We present a 60-year-old male with medical history of
hypercholesterolemia and nephrolithiasis, diagnosed with stage IV adenocarcinoma
of the colon. The patient underwent routine surgical pathology exam and was
found to have a primary tumor of 6.5 cm in the cecum (histologic grade: low,
moderately differentiated) with extension into the serosal surface, greater than
6 positive regional nodes, and distant metastasis to the omentum. He initially
presented to our clinic 9 days status post partial right colon resection to
discuss adjuvant chemotherapy versus radiation versus intravenous (IV) vitamin C
versus IV mistletoe. We started him on a sugar-free, therapeutic diet. In
addition, he quit tobacco use and initiated high-dose cannabis oil, methylated
multivitamin, Designs for Health OmegaAvail, Hepatatone Plus, Klaire Labs
Therbiotic Complete, and low-dose Naltrexone HCl (4 mg). He received standard
chemotherapy to shrink the tumor and 7 weeks of once weekly IV vitamin C.
Results: Subsequently, the patient underwent exploratory laparotomy,
during which no cancer was detected, and biocept liquid biopsy tests were
negative for circulating tumor cells (defined as CD45−, DAPI+, CK+ or CK−
cell).
Conclusions: This case represents an unusual response to a
combination of chemotherapy and integrative approaches. Such “miracle cancer
cures” are occasionally seen in integrative medicine practices and often
generate lots of hype among cancer patient communities. Unfortunately, a clear
understanding of how this result was achieved in this patient is not possible;
however, we strongly believe that continuing to document and study each such N
of 1 is important in order to formulate specific research questions and future
directions. Our team will continue to follow this patient and will report in 2–3
years on his condition.
(3489) Yoga for Quality of Life in Chronic Disease Patients—A Systematic
Review
Anupama Kizhakkeveettil, BAMS, MAOM, PhD1, Eric Hurwitz, DC,
PhD2, Laura Schmalzl, PhD1 and James Whedon, DC,
MS1
1Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
2University of Hawaii, Honolulu, Hawaii
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic disease is the leading cause of death and
disability worldwide, and people living with chronic disease also experience
reduced quality of life (QOL). Yoga is a traditional health practice that
includes physical movement, breath regulation, and meditative components. Yoga
confers certain health benefits, but the effectiveness of yoga for improving QOL
among chronic disease patients is uncertain. The objective of this study was to
conduct a systematic review on the effect of yoga versus usual care for
improving quality of life in patients with chronic disease.
Results: A total of 1488 studies were identified from our initial
search based on the above criteria. Among these, only 7 studies met inclusion
criteria as determined by full text review. The yoga practices used in these
studies include both posture and breathing practices. All 7 studies showed that
interventions incorporating yoga were more effective than usual care alone for
the improvement of QOL in patients with chronic disease. However, statistically
significant between-group differences were detected for at least one QOL outcome
in only 5 of the 7 trials.
Conclusions: The current literature suggests that yoga may be an
effective therapeutic approach for improvement of QOL in patients with chronic
disease. However, the quality of studies included in this review was generally
low. Further research using rigorous methods is needed to establish more
conclusive evidence.
(3491) Clinical Hypnosis With Graded Exposure to Feared Foods in the Treatment of
Dysphagia: A Case Study
Danielle M Dorn, MA and Lindsey McKernan PhD1
1Nashville, Tennessee
Abstract
Purpose: Treatment of dysphagia is complex, involving significant
psychological burden. In addition to pain and difficulty swallowing, symptoms
can include food avoidance, mealtime panic, and weight loss. Visceral
hypersensitivity is theorized to drive esophageal symptoms.1 Clinical
hypnosis is an established treatment for patients with anxiety disorders as well
as a variety of medical conditions such as irritable bowel syndrome.2
Although the literature is very limited, hypnosis is considered an appropriate
treatment for dysphagia to promote relaxation, decrease sensitivity, and
modulate reactions to physical discomfort.1 We present a case of
hypnosis with graded exposure in a patient suffering from severe dysphagia, food
avoidance, and neck pain postcervical anterior laminectomy. Efficacy is measured
by reference to posttreatment changes in pain, anxiety, depression, and other
correlates with 6 - and 9-month follow-up.
Results: We observed significant reductions across all measures
following treatment, and these reductions were maintained over a 6 - and 9-month
posttreatment period (Table 1). Immediately posttreatment, the patient reported
a 64% reduction in overall pain, 74% reduction in anxiety sensitivity, 79%
improvement in quality of life, and 85% reduction in trauma symptoms. As
impressive, scores at 6 and 9 months remained lower than posttreatment levels
across all instruments. Modest posttreatment declines over time lend further
evidence of treatment effects.
Conclusions: This patient maintained treatment gains and a
significant increased ability to eat foods without hesitation at the end of the
9-month period. This case study provides additional support for hypnosis and
graded exposure as effective treatments of dysphagia.
(3496) Research on Substances and Energy Metabolism Mechanisms of Yinlai
Decoction Treating Pediatric Pneumonia Based on Methods of Network
Pharmacology
Jingnan Xu, MD1, Ling Huang, MD1, Chen Bai, MD1,
Xiaohong Gu, MD1, Tiegang Liu, PhD1, He Yu, PhD1
and Yuxiang Wan, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Based on the methods of network pharmacology, the authors
aim to explore the potential targets and mechanisms of substances and energy
metabolism with Yinlai Decoction treating pediatric pneumonia and provide a
targeted guidance for subsequent experimental study.
Results: We obtained 15 molecular compounds, 68 key targets
proteins, and 61 related genes of substances and energy metabolism with Yinlai
Decoction treating pediatric pneumonia, involving 27 signaling pathways
(false-discovery rate <0.01), which are mainly relevant to substances and
energy metabolisms, such as amino acids metabolism, fatty acid metabolism,
glycolysis, and drug metabolism, including Arginine and proline metabolism,
glycine, serine, and threonine metabolism, tyrosine metabolism, biosynthesis of
amino acids, alanine, aspartate, and glutamate metabolism, Drug
metabolism-cytochrome P450, carbon metabolism, and so forth.
Conclusions: Yinlai Decoction can participate in the regulation of
complex substances and energy metabolism pathways, such as amino acid metabolism
and fatty acid metabolism, which may be the underlying mechanism for treating
pediatric pneumonia, yet the specific regulatory mechanisms still need further
studies to explore and verify.
(3499) An Evidence-based Review on Integrative Medicine in Weight Control
Monirsadat Sahebkarkhorasani, MD1, Hoda Azizi, MD, PhD1, Mahdi
Yousefi, MD, PhD1, Roshanak Salari, PharmD, PhD1, Hamidreza
Bahrami-taghanaki, MD, MPH, PhD1 and Pardis Behravanrad2
1Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Islamic Republic of
Iran
2Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Islamic
Republic of Iran
Abstract
Purpose: Considering the high prevalence of obesity in the world and
Iran, its serious complications, failure of standard treatments in many
patients, and recent trends towards complementary medicine, awareness of the
effectiveness and side effects of such therapies seems necessary. This research
aimed to review the effectiveness, safety and side effects of complementary
medicine in obesity.
Results: In total 86 articles were found related to the subject
among which 79 fulfilled the inclusion criteria, entered the study and were
reviewed. Among the herbs and supplements used for weight control agar,
psyllium, alpha lipoic acid, conjugated linoleic acid, diacylglycerol, aloe,
caffeine, calcium, bean pod and vitamin D have acceptable scientific evidence
for efficacy and safety. Among non-herbal complementary therapies, yoga and
meditation have shown promising scientific evidence.
Conclusions: Agar, psyllium, alpha lipoic acid, conjugated linoleic
acid, diacylglycerol, aloe, caffeine, calcium, bean pod, vitamin D, yoga and
meditation could be suggested as complementary and integrative treatments
besides the standard treatment of obesity, with acceptable effectiveness and
safety.
(3501) Chinese Herbal Medicine for People Living With HIV in Guangxi, China:
Analysis of Registered Data
Nuala McGrath, PhD1, Nicola Robinson, PhD2, Jin Sun,
PhD3, Jianping Liu, PhD3, Feng Jiang, PhD4, Mei
Han, PhD5 and Ying Zhang, PhD3
1University of Southampton, London, UK
2London South Bank University, London, UK
3Beijing University of Chinese Medicine , Beijing, China
4Reikang Hospital, Nanning, China
5Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) has been used for treating
people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) in China for over 20 years. The National
Free Traditional Chinese Medicine HIV/AIDS Treatment Program provided CHM for
PLWHA from 2004.We analyzed registered data from Guangxi region as to inform
practice and policy-making.
Results: Two thousand five hundred seventy-two records of PLWHA in
registered data from 2004 to 2016 were analyzed. Mean age was 47.87 ± 13.97
years, and 64.8% were male. Mean follow-up duration was 18 months. Most
participants (85.4%) considered their possible HIV-infected route as sexual
behavior, and followed by drug abuse (11.6%). One thousand three hundred
seventy-four PLWHA (18.2% at AIDS stage) used CHM alone, and 1198 PLWHA (44.3%
at AIDS stage) used CHM combined with antiretroviral therapy (ART). Participants
from CHM alone group showed better baseline on CD4 cell levels (n = 1111,
380.11 ± 240.59 cell/μL) than those from CHM plus ART group (n = 1053,
271.45 ± 181.54 cell/μL). CD4 cell levels of PLWHA in both groups improved
significantly after 3 months treatment. CD4 cell levels from CHM and CHM plus
ART groups reached peak at 499.49 ± 199.25 (n = 87) and 442.83 ± 232.22 (n = 66)
cell/μL by 48 months, respectively. CHM treatment showed no significant
improvement for quality of life (QOL). However CHM plus ART showed significantly
improved QOL for the first-year treatment. For PLWHA at AIDS stage, both groups
demonstrated significant improvement for QOL at the first-year treatment. There
was no report on serious adverse events by monitoring liver and kidney
function.
Conclusions: It appears that CHM used alone or combined with ART
have potential improving in CD4 cell levels and may benefit PLWHA at AIDS stage
on QOL. However, herb and drug interaction is not clear based on the registered
data.
(3502) Research on Immunoregulatory Mechanisms of Yinlai Decoction Treating
Pediatric Pneumonia Based on Methods of Network Pharmacology
Yuxiang Wan, MD1, Xiaohong Gu, MD1, Ling Huang, MD1,
He Yu, PhD1, Chen Bai, MD1, Tiegang Liu, PhD1 and
Jingnan Xu, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Based on the methods of network pharmacology, the authors
aim to explore the potential targets and immunoregulatory effect mechanisms of
Yinlai Decoction and provide a scientific basis for the further explanation of
the mechanism for treating pediatric pneumonia.
Results: We obtained 90 molecular compounds and 433 key targets
proteins of Yinlai Decoction treating pediatric pneumonia, involving 84
signaling pathways and relevant biological processes (false-discovery rate
<0.05). In the network comprised with those functioning targets, there were
18 molecular compounds, 40 key targets proteins and 5 signaling pathways
associated with immunoregulatory, namely, IL-17 signaling pathway, T cell
receptor signaling pathway, Th1 and Th2 cell differentiation, Th17 cell
differentiation, and Toll-like receptor signaling pathway.
Conclusions: The immunoregulatory mechanism of Yinlai Decoction
treating pediatric pneumonia is probably concerned with imbalance of Th1/Th2 and
Th17/Treg, yet specific regulatory mechanisms still need further studies to
explore and verify.
(3507) The Clinical Study on Association Between Gastrointestinal Heat Retention
Syndrome and Intestinal Microbiome Disorder in Children
Yuxiang Wan, MD1, Xiaofei Li, MD2, Zian Zheng, PhD1,
Jianhua Zhen, PhD3, Tiegang Liu, PhD1, He Yu, PhD1,
Xiaohong Gu, MD1, Yunhui Wang, MD1, Xueyan Ma, MD and Fei Dong
PhD4
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2People’s Hospital of Leling City, Dezhou, China
3China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, China
4Dongfang Hospital Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing,
China
Abstract
Purpose: Gastrointestinal heat retention syndrome (GHRS) is a
syndrome that is associated with increased gastrointestinal heat caused by a
metabolic block in energy. Symptoms are intolerance to heat, dry mouth, a
preference for cold drinks desire, swift digestion with increased apatite, dry
and smelly stool, a reddened tongue with yellow fur, and so on. We aim to
explore the relationship between GHRS and intestinal microbiome disorder in
children by detecting the feces samples using high-throughput sequencing
method.
Results: Fifty feces samples were collected from volunteers which
comprises of 12 healthy boys (H-B), 12 healthy girls (H-G), 14 GHRS boys
(GHRS-B), and 12 GHRS girls (GHRS-G). The intestinal microbiome which has been
annotated in children covered 20 phylum, 30 classes, 65 orders, 105 families,
156 genus, and 66 species. The genus, bacteroides, and faecalibacterium were the
predominant bacteria. However, there was neither significant difference in gut
microflora between GHRS and healthy children nor was there any findings in the
characteristic index related to GHRS.
Conclusions: The intestinal microbiome in children showed diverse
structural characteristics, but there was no observable difference between the
GHRS and healthy children, this might due to the small sample size in this
study. Therefore, large sample size is needed to explore the association between
GHRS and intestinal microbiome disorder in the future.
(3508) Proteomic Analysis of Effects of Yinlai Decoction on Dyspepsia-pneumonia
in Mice
Yunhui Wang, MD1, Xueyan Ma, MD1, Liyi Yan, MD1,
Xiaohong Gu, MD1, He Yu, PhD1, Tiegang Liu, PhD1,
Chen Bai, MD1, Jingnan Xu, MD1, Zian Zheng, MD1 and
Yuxiang Wan, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the mechanism of Yinlai decoction in the
treatment of dyspepsia–pneumonia (DP) mice.
Results: In DP group, the alveolar structure was destroyed, and the
pulmonary septum was significantly widened. There was vascular dilatation and
congestion, accompanied by a large number of inflammatory cell infiltration.
After Yinlai decoction treatment, the pathological changes were alleviated. A
total of 2626 proteins were reliably identified in the lung tissue. Compared
with normal group, the DP mice had 521 differential proteins identified from
lung tissues, which are involved in the following biological processes:
biological adhesion, cell adhesion, organonitrogen compound metabolic process,
peptide metabolic process, response to organic substance, response to chemical,
small molecule metabolic process, oxidation–reduction process, immune system
process, defense response, and response to cytokine. They are also involved in
the following Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathways:
extracellular matrix-receptor interaction, focal adhesion, leukocyte
transendothelial migration, tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle, and phagosome.
Compared with DP group, 87 differential proteins were identified from lung
tissues of Yinlai decoction treatment mice, which involved in the following
biological processes: TCA cycle and lymphocyte costimulation, and so on. The
related KEGG pathways included TCA cycle, oxidative phosphorylation, fatty acid
metabolism, and so on.
Conclusions: Differential proteins expressed in lung tissues of DP
mice are mainly related to immunity, inflammation, and metabolism. Yinlai
decoction may play a therapeutic role through regulating metabolism and immunity
of the body.
(3509) Anthroposophic Therapeutic Speech for Asthma Patients—A Randomized,
Controlled Cross-over, Multi-center Trial in a Real-life Outpatient Setting
Dietrich von Bonin, MME1, Eva Streit, MD2, Oliver Avianus,
MS3, Christian Grah, MD3, Jörg Salomon, MD4,
Sabine D Klein, PhD5, Jana Würker, MS6 and Ursula Wolf,
MD5
1KSKV/CASAT, Bern, Switzerland
2Kinik Arlesheim, Arlesheim, Switzerland
3Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Havelhöhe, Berlin, Germany
4Salem-Spital, Bern, Switzerland
5University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
6Private Practice, Dresden, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Breathing retraining techniques receive increased attention
in the management of asthma, because there is growing evidence for the
usefulness of such methods to improve quality of life, to reduce symptoms and
bronchodilator use. Anthroposophic therapeutic speech (ATS) applies, for
example, sounds, syllabic rhythms, and quality of sound, is one of the classic
anthroposophical medicine artistic therapies. In this study, we investigated the
effect of ATS in patients with asthma in a real-life outpatient setting.
Results: Sixty-three patients were randomized, 56 were enrolled, and
49 completed the study. Statistically significant differences between ATS and
waiting control were found for the Asthma Quality of Life Questionnaire overall
score (d = 0.86, P = .001) and its domains symptoms, activity
limitation, and emotional function as well as the American College Testing score
(d = 0.53, P = .048). No significant differences were observed
in spirometry parameters, inhaled glucocorticoids, peak flow, and days without
asthma exacerbation per week. No serious adverse events occurred during ATS
sessions.
Conclusions: ATS significantly improves asthma control and quality
of life in patients with asthma. It remains to be shown whether ATS may also
improve lung function.
(3514) Tinospora Cordifolia Controls Arthritis by Modulating the Mediators of
Autoimmune Inflammation and Bone Remodeling
Kamal D Moudgil, MD, PhD1, Shivaprasad H Venkatesha, PhD1 and
Kumar Sannegowda, PhD1
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Herbal products offer a versatile resource for identifying
and characterizing new therapeutic agents that have the potential for the
control of various inflammatory and autoimmune diseases, including rheumatoid
arthritis (RA). The need for such agents in RA is evident from the reports that
about 40% of patients fail to respond to biologics (anticytokine therapeutics)
and other mainstream drugs. Furthermore, the long-term use of such drugs
frequently results in severe adverse reactions. Therefore, RA patients are
gradually resorting to the use of herbal products for their unmet medical needs.
However, limited information about the mechanisms of action of many natural
products is a major hurdle in the widespread acceptance of herbal therapy by
professionals and patients alike.
Results:
Tinospora treatment suppressed arthritic inflammation and bone
and cartilage damage. These effects of Tinospora were mediated
via reduction of the pro-inflammatory cytokines (interleukin-1 [IL-1], IL-6,
tumor necrosis factor -a, and IL-17), the frequency of T helper 17 (Th17) cells
that produce IL-17, and the production of chemokines such as regulated and
activated normal T-cell expressed and secreted. Furthermore,
Tinospora treatment afforded protection against bone damage
by skewing the balance of mediators of bone remodeling (eg, receptor activator
of nuclear factor kappa-Β ligand and matrix metalloproteinase -9) in favor of
anti-osteoclastic activity.
Conclusions:
Tinospora effectively controlled arthritis via modulation of
various mediators of inflammation and tissue damage in arthritic rats. On the
basis of our results, we propose that Tinospora should be
evaluated for its utility as a therapeutic adjunct to the mainstream drugs for
RA therapy.
(3515) Comparison of Randomized Controlled Trials and Guideline Recommendations
of Oral Chinese Patent Medicine for Acute Lower Respiratory Tract Infections in
Adults
Yu-tong Fei, MD, PhD1, Michael Moore, MD, PhD2, Xiao-yang Hu,
MD, PhD2, Di Wang1, Ying Wang1, Andrew Flower, MD,
PhD2, Xun Li, PhD1, Merlin Willcox, DPhil,
MRCGP2, Lily Lai, MD, PhD2, Jian-ping Liu, MD,
PhD1, Rui-xue Hu1 and Ru-yu Xia, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
Abstract
Purpose: Chinese patent medicines (CPMs) are widely used for acute
lower respiratory tract infections (ALRTIs) in China (60% market share). We
aimed to compare recommendations on the use of oral CPM for ALRTIs from clinical
practice guidelines (CPGs) with existing evidence of randomized controlled
trials (RCTs) to inform practice.
Results: We identified 29 RCTs (5093 patients) on 42 CPMs for
ALRTIs. Thirty-seven CPMs has only 1 trial each. Five CPMs have 2 trials each
but no similar comparisons. Each meta-analysis was only with small sample size
and very low certainty. For the 6 guidelines identified, 29 CPMs were
recommended. Four of them were identified both in the RCTs and in CPGs.
Ninety-three percent (27/29) of the recommendations of CPMs in CPGs were not
based on RCT evidence. Ninety-five percent (40/42) of the CPMs identified from
this systematic review of RCTs were not mentioned in the CPGs. Both RCTs and
CPGs were generally low quality.
Conclusions: Evidence base of CPMs for ALRTIs was very weak. CPGs
were not evidence-based. Massive use of CPM for ALRTIs was neither based on
scientific evidence nor guidelines. There is an urgent call for good quality
research to inform massive clinical use.
(3516) Comparison of Randomized Clinical Trials on Sham/Placebo Acupuncture by
Western and Eastern Country Origins
JianPing Liu, PhD1, Liqiong Wang, PhD1, Chunxiang Su,
PRO1, Yu-tong Fei, MD, PhD1, Guoyan Yang, PhD2
and Ning Liang, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: To describe and compare the randomized clinical trials
(RCTs) on sham/placebo acupuncture by their country origins (Western and
Eastern).
Results: A total of 532 sham/placebo acupuncture RCTs (384 from
Western countries and 148 from Eastern countries) were identified. The top 3
Western countries which published most acupuncture RCTs were United States
(17.3%), Germany (13.1%), and UK (9.8%), while Eastern countries were mainland
China (12.6%), South Korea (4.7%), and Taiwan Region (3.9%). There was a
statistic difference in acupuncture RCTs by published journals
(P < .001). RCTs from the West were published more
frequently in professional medical journals (47.9%), while RCTs from Eastern
countries were more published in complementary and alternative medicine journals
(55.4%). The most commonly treated conditions by acupuncture RCTs were
musculoskeletal and connective tissue diseases (22.1% vs 14.2% by Western and
Eastern countries). Manual acupuncture was used more in the West than the East
(65.6% vs 50.7%, P < .001). There was no statistical
difference for the reported outcomes including clinical, surrogate, and safety
between Western and Eastern countries. RCTs from Eastern countries reported more
positive results compared with Western countries (79.7% vs 56.0%,
P < .001). However, there was no significant difference
between country origins in low risk of bias including generation of allocation
sequence (49.7% vs 54.7%), concealment (44.3% vs 39.9%), incomplete outcome
(69.3% vs 79.7%), and selective reporting (79.2% vs 84.5%).
Conclusions: Sham/placebo acupuncture RCTs show significantly
difference on journal type, acupuncture type, and reporting positive results
between Western and Eastern countries. Future acupuncture RCTs should have a
very clear clinical research question, hypothesis, and rigorous design with
registered protocol and transparent reporting.
(3522) Light Therapy for Treating Sleep and Mood Disruption in Brain-injured
Patients
George Brainard, PhD1, Stevi Anderson, MS2, Melanie McKendry,
RMA1, Samar Colette Glatts, MS2, Sreeramya Jasser,
MD1, Leanna Kanumilli, MD1, Benjamin Panepinto,
BS1, Maria Warfield, BFA1, John Pineda, MD1,
Talia Hanifin, PhD1, Kimberly Glodjo, BS1, Mijail Atkinson,
DO1, Lisa Serruya, PhD, MD1, Fadee Bowman,
CRNP1 and Disoke, BA1
1Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
2Rothman Institute, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Purpose: Light is a potent stimulus for regulating circadian,
neuroendocrine, and neurobehavioral responses in healthy humans. Further, light
therapy is effective for treating selected affective, circadian, and sleep
disorders. The purpose of this research is to characterize sleep and mood
disruption in brain-injured patients and determine whether light therapy can
improve such symptoms.
Results: Actigraphy provides an objective measure of circadian and
sleep stability in all 3 studies. For example, in the completed studies,
actigraphy demonstrated that mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) patients had
statistically and clinically meaningful longer sleep latencies compared to
control subjects (P < .02). Similar significant results were
observed in the study with stroke patients (P < .005).
Validated measures of mood disturbance showed that mTBI patients had
significantly increased mood disturbance (P < .001) compared
to control subjects. Stroke patients also showed significantly increased mood
disturbances (P < .0001) compared to their matched control
subjects.
Conclusions: The results are potentially important to the
integrative medical care of patients with brain injury. It is valuable to
provide patients with a nonpharmacological, built-in stimulus that can
ameliorate their symptoms. These studies will contribute to the design of future
built-in smart lighting interventions for hospitals and home care environments
to foster patient health and well-being. Support: The Institute
for Integrative Health; NSF #EEC-0812056; and the Philadelphia Section of
Illuminating Engineering Society NA.
(3524) Exploring the Impacts of Yinlai Decoction on Mechanical Barrier Function
of Intestinal Mucosa of Mice With High-fat and Calorie-diet Combined With FM1
Influenza Virus Infection
Yu Hao, PhD1, Yunhui Wang, MD1, Teck C Kong, MD2,
Zeji Qiu, MD1, Jun Wu, MD1, Jianhua Zhen, PhD3,
Xiaofei Li, MD4, Jingnan Xu, MD1, Tiegang Liu,
PhD1, He Yu, PhD1 and Xiaohong Gu, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore
3China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, China
4People’s Hospital of Leling City, Dezhou, China
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the influence Yinlai decoction has on the
mechanical barrier function of the intestinal mucosa of mice with high-fat and
calorie-diet induced with FM1 influenza virus infection and to identify the
efficacy of Yinlai decoction and its potential mechanism.
Results: Compared with the normal group, the levels of zonula
occludens-1 (ZO-1) mRNA in colon tissue decreased significantly
(P < .05) and the levels of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in
serum increased significantly (P < .05) in infection group
as well as the high-fat and calorie-diet infected compound group. Compared with
the high-fat and calorie-diet infected compound group, the levels of ZO-1 in
colon tissue and LPS in serum decreased significantly
(P < .05) in positive treatment groups, it increased
significantly (P < .05) in the Xiaoerhuashiwan group.
Compared with the normal group, the levels of ZO-1 mRNA decreased significantly
(P < .05) in each treatment group, the levels of ZO-1 in
colon tissue decreased significantly (P < .05) in positive
treatment group, the levels of LPS in serum increased significantly
(P < .05) in each dose of Yinlai decoction group,
Shuanghuanglian group, and Xiaoerhuashiwan group.
Conclusions: Yinlai decoction can influence the levels of ZO-1 in
colon tissue and reduce the content of LPS in serum, which may be a mechanism to
protect the intestinal mucosa that functions as a mechanical barrier.
(3526) Integrative Pediatric Inpatient Wards in Germany: Analysis of Clinical and
Demographic Characteristics
Jan Vagedes, MD1, Markus Krüger, MD2, David Martin,
MD3, Tycho Zuzak, MD4, Katharina Fetz, MSc3,
Thomas Ostermann, PhD3, Alfred Längler, MD5 and Melanie
Schwermer, PhD6
1Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine, Filderstadt,
Germany
2Filderklinik, Filderstadt, Germany
3University Witten/Herdecke, Witten, Germany
4Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
5Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
6Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Integrative medicine is frequently used in adults as well
as in children in Europe. In Germany, there are 2 anthroposophical pediatric
wards: The Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus in Herdecke and the Filderklinik in
Filderstadt near Stuttgart. Until today, there are no systematic analyses of
patient characteristics in integrative pediatric hospitals in Germany.
Results: Patients in the integrative pediatric sample were 47.6%
female (n = 15 697) and 52.4% male (n = 14 259). The gender distribution did not
differ significantly from representative data (female: n = 4 046 229 [46.80%];
male: n = 4 598 256 [53.19%]). Median age was 3 years (range −1 to 45). In the
representative sample, median age was 3.5 years (range 0–101). Most frequent
diseases in the integrative pediatric sample were diseases of the respiratory
system (n = 5019; 17.1%), infectious and parasitic diseases (n = 3859; 12.9%),
and diseases of origin in perinatal period (n = 3547; 11.8%). In the
representative sample, most frequent diseases were diseases of the respiratory
system (n = 1 714 182; 19.83%) and infectious and parasitic diseases
(n = 1 281 000; 14.82%) and sequelae of injuries, of poisoning and of other
consequences of external causes (n = 999 233; 11.56%). Frequencies of the focus
diagnoses in the integrative pediatric sample were pneumonia (n = 1702; 5.68%),
bronchitis (n = 1782; 5.95%), bronchial asthma (n = 451, 1.5%), and
gastroenteritis (n = 2364; 7.89%).
Conclusions: The characteristics of patients in integrative
pediatric hospitals in Germany are comparable to those of standard pediatric
German wards.
(3528) Integrative Hospitals in Germany: Analysis of Pediatric Patients With a
Focus on Health Economic Parameters
Melanie Schwermer, PhD1, Alfred Längler, MD2, Tycho Zuzak,
MD3, Katharina Fetz, MSc4, Thomas Ostermann,
PhD4, David Martin, MD4, Markus Krüger, MD5 and
Jan Vagedes, MD6
1Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
2Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke,
Witten, Germany
3Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus Herdecke, University Hospital Essen, Herdecke,
Essen, Germany
4University Witten/Herdecke, Witten, Germany
5Filderklinik, Filderstadt, Germany
6Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine, Filderstadt,
Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Integrative medicine is frequently used in adults as well
as in children in Europe. In Germany, there are 2 anthroposophical pediatric
wards: The Gemeinschaftskrankenhaus in Herdecke and the Filderklinik in
Filderstadt near Stuttgart. Until today, there are no systematic analyses of
health economic parameters of integrative pediatric hospitals in Germany.
Results: Most frequent diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) in
integrative pediatric hospitals were B80Z (head injuries; n = 1933, 6.5%), G67B
(oesophagitis, gastroenteritis, gastrointestinal bleeding, ulcer, complex
genesis; n = 1286, 4.3%), P67C (newborn >2499 g, without complex diagnosis;
n = 1254, 4.2%), G67C (oesophagitis, gastroenteritis, gastrointestinal bleeding,
ulcer, uncomplex genesis; n = 1158, 3.9%), and P67B (n = 975, 3.3%, newborn
>2499 g, with complex diagnosis). Mean duration of stay was significantly
lower in the integrative pediatric sample (M = 4.74 days (standard deviation
[SD] = 6.23) than the mean duration of stay proposed by DRG (M = 5.80),
t(28,235) = −37.74; P < .001. In the representative sample,
the mean duration of stay was 4.48 days (SD = 7.83). The mean effective cost
weight in the integrative pediatric sample was 0.76 (SD = 1.22).
Conclusions: Here, we present first systematic analyses of health
economic parameters of integrative pediatric hospitals in Germany. The duration
of stay in integrative pediatric hospitals was shortened compared to
DRG-expected mean duration of stay. Duration of stay seems to be comparable in
integrative and conventional pediatric hospitals. An important implication for
future research is to compare these data further with representative data of
conventional pediatric wards in Germany.
(3529) Improvements in Psychological Well-being Following a Residential
Yoga-based Program for Professionals: A Pragmatic Clinical Trial
Edi Pasalis, MBA1, Jeffrey A Dusek, PhD2, Natalie L Trent,
PhD3, Mindy Miraglia, MS1 and Sat Bir S Khalsa,
PhD3
1Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health, Stockbridge, Massachusetts
2Aurora Health Care, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
3Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this pragmatic, real-world controlled trial
was to examine changes in psychological well-being and health-related behaviors
in professionals that attended a residential yoga-based program.
Results: Relative to the control group, participants in the
experimental group reported significant improvements in perceived stress
(P = .002), positive affect (P = .01),
negative affect (P = .004), and vegetable consumption
(P = .03) from baseline to postprogram. From baseline to
follow-up, participants in the experimental group exhibited statistically
significant improvements in mindfulness (P = .03), perceived
stress (P = .004), positive affect (P = .03),
negative affect (P = .03), self-compassion
(P = .04), and vegetable consumption (P = .01)
compared to controls.
Conclusions: To date, these findings suggest that the resilience,
integration, self-awareness, engagement program improves psychological
well-being and health-related behaviors immediately following the program which
were sustained at the 2-month follow-up.
(3530) The Effects of a Yoga-based Stress Reduction Program on Fatigue and
Quality of Life in Women With Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Breast Cancer: A
Multicenter, Pragmatic, Randomized Clinical Study
Herman A van Wietmarschen, PhD1, Ellen van der Pol, MSc1, Miek
Jong, PhD1 and Inge Boers, MSc1
1Louis Bolk Institute, Bunnik, the Netherlands
Abstract
Purpose: Breast cancer survivors report high levels of distress and
persistent fatigue, negatively impacting quality of life. They are often unable
or unwilling to participate in standard exercise interventions because of the
experienced fatigue. There is some evidence for beneficial effects of yoga on
cancer-related fatigue. A pragmatic, randomized controlled study was conducted
in the Netherlands, to compare the effects of a yoga-based stress reduction
(YBSR) program with usual care in stage I–III breast cancer patients after
primary surgery and scheduled for chemotherapy.
Results: Eighty-three breast cancer patients participated in the
study: YBSR group (N = 43) and control group (N = 40). Demographic
characteristics were similar at baseline. Preliminary within-group
intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis showed a significant increase in general
fatigue after 3 months in the control group (P = .002), but not
in the YBSR group (P = .175). After 6 months, general fatigue
remained significantly higher in the control group (P = . 020)
but not in the YBSR group. However, no significant differences were found in
general fatigue in the between-group ITT analysis after both 3
(P = .859) and 6 months (P = .065). After
3 months, there was significantly more confidence in fatigue reduction
(P = .021), amount of expected fatigue reduction
(P = . 001), and satisfaction with fatigue reduction
(P = . 001) in the YBSR group. Significant differences in
favor of the YSBR group were also found on secondary outcomes nausea and
vomiting (P = .013, η2 = 0.08) and impact of event
(P = . 049, η2 = 0.05) after 6 months. These
effects were not due to treatment expectations since expectations of usual care
were higher than that of the YBSR program (P = .002).
Conclusions: Although there was no overall significant treatment
effect of the yoga program on general fatigue in breast cancer patients
undergoing chemotherapy, these patients do seem to benefit from such a program.
Final results will be presented at the conference.
(3531) Strengthening Observation Skills in Integrative Medical Practice
Adam Blanning, MD1, Peter Hinderberger, MD2 and Renee Meyer,
MD3
1Physicians’ Association of Anthroposophic Medicine, Denver, Colorado
2Ruscombe Mansion Community Health Center, Baltimore, Maryland
3Primula Internal Medicine, Yonges Island, South Carolina
Abstract
Overview: Integrative medical teaching involves not only sharing new
content but also new perspectives. Practitioners seek new ways to think about
health and illness. Enlivening our thinking is a central tenet in anthroposophic
medical trainings and is incorporated into all elements of teaching. For
example, a 4-fold methodology is incorporated into teaching herbal medicine.
Over a series of days, students learn diverse but complementary observation
exercises, which simultaneously facilitate learning about a specific medicinal
plant in small group study. Instead of initially learning about traditional
medicinal plant uses, participants are guided through a series of steps: First
day: What do you see, factually? (avoiding botanical terms, without trying to be
clever or interpretive); second: How do you imagine the plant changes and grows
in time? (what might it look like a month from now? A month ago?); Third: What
is the plant’s character? Does it show a one-sidedness?; and Finally: What is
the plant's archetypal process? These steps mirror anthroposophic considerations
of the physical, functional, emotional, and spiritual aspects of human
physiology. Then, the group’s impressions are compared with known, traditional,
and modern botanical uses. While this methodology is used for plant study, it
applies equally well for phenomenological consideration of other therapeutic
substances and processes. Our experience shows that this process encourages
diverse, collaborative thinking. Participants gain confidence and renewed
interest in their own observation and problem-solving skills. Typical comments
included “plenty of time in exploring, taking in, and coming up with our thought
process of the plant “being,” “different throught processes were heard and then
channeled in a proper way,” “really looked at the plant in an interactive way.”
The poster will demonstrate how these methods can be applied to
Primula and Hyocyamus, 2 healing plants
used commonly in anthroposophic medicine.
Rationale: Enlivened thinking and guided group problem-solving can
enrich present health ideas and therapies and encourages innovation. The present
theme of chronic pain calls for creative approaches and a social dimension to
healing.
Objectives: This abstract is intended as a poster presentation.
Interested participants will experience the lively, mobile quality of this
learning methodology, as the example of the 2 medicinal plants will be presented
in this way; receive lasting impressions of the dynamics of the 2 sample plants;
and employ the observational, group—process character of this methodology to
teaching about other findings in the natural world.
(3534) Blood-letting and Herbal-cupping Therapy for Lumbar Spinal Stenosis:
Prospective Case Series Study
Changxin Liu1, Xingzhi Wang2, Xiyou Wang1 and
Changhe Yu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine Affiliated Dongzhimen Hospital,
Beijing, China
2Guobaotang Clinic, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Lumbar spinal stenosis (LSS) is a degenerative condition in
which changes in the discs, ligamentum flavum, and facet joints with aging cause
narrowing of the spaces around the neurovascular structures of the spine. These
changes lead to pain in the legs and back, as well as impaired ambulation and
other disabilities. LSS affects more than 200 000 people in the United States,
and it is the most common reason for spinal surgery in patients over 65 years,
and the cost of surgeries on LSS was nearly $1.65 billion in 2007. But only
60%–70% of patients are satisfied with their symptoms after surgery, and there
was insufficient evidence and controversy to recommend any specific types of
nonsurgical treatment for LSS. A new nonsurgical technique, namely,
blood-letting and herbal-cupping therapy, has been explored for LSS. It has been
used for the spinal pain and pain-related function disorders including LSS in
folks and the palace since Qing dynasty (more than 350 years ago). And it has
been regarded as the China intangible cultural heritage, and many LSS patients
has benefited from it. However, the effect of such therapy has never been
proved. Thus, the purpose of study was to evaluate the safety and effectiveness
of the blood-letting and herbal-cupping therapy for lumbar spinal stenosis.
Results: Fifty-three patients were included, with 64.15% (34/53) of
LSS showing neurogenic claudication (walking distance less than 200 m). The
average age was 64.22 ± 11.68 years, 21 (39.6%) female, and the average body
mass index was 25.79 ± 3.31 kg/m2. The scores of symptom severity
scale of SSM were 2.79 ± 0.76, 2.63 ± 0.68, 2.27 ± 0.62, and 1.88 ± 0.21 at
baseline, first, second, and third course, respectively, and the scores of
physical function scale were 2.54 ± 0.79, 2.42 ± 0.68, 2.11 ± 0.51, 1.79 ± 0.29,
and all the changes between baseline and each course showed significant
improvement. The patient satisfaction of SSM, ODI, and SF-12 showed significant
improvements after the first, second, and third course
(P < .05). The SF-12 subgroup physical composite scores
after third course and mental composite score after first showed no significant
improvement. The minimal clinically important difference for the “Symptom
Severity Scale” in the SSM was achieved with improvement of 19%, 41%, and 83% in
the LSS patient population after first, second, and third course; and the
“physical function scale” in SSM was achieved with improvement of 23%, 31%, and
50%. A total of 15 patients felt pain when they were micropunctured with little
blood at first time, but the symptom were immediately relieved without any
treatment.
Conclusions: The blood-letting and herbal-cupping therapy could
benefit patients with lumbar spinal stenosis after third course of treatment in
the fields of symptom relief and quality of life with no severe adverse event.
However, this was a phrase analysis, so more evidence of this study and large
comparative researches should be warranted in the future.
(3536) Cerebral Response of Healthy Subjects to a Somatosensory Stimulaton With
Xingnao Kaiqiao Acupuncture Compared to Control Interventions Measured With
Resting-state Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Claudia M Witt1, Bin Liu, MD2, Xuemin Shi2, Yinghui
Chang, MD2, Daniel Pach, MD3 and Till Nierhaus, Dr rer.
medic., Dipl-Ing(FH)4
1University Hospital Zurich, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
2Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Tianjin, China
3Charité—Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
4Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Neuroimaging studies have shown that stimulation at single
acupuncture points can specifically modulate brain activity in comparison to
stimulation of nonacupuncture points. However, the effects of acupuncture using
more than 1 point are less clear. Xingnao Kaiqiao (XNKQ) acupuncture is an
acupuncture technique used for the rehabiliation of stroke patients. We
evaluated functional connectivity changes with functional magnetic resonance
imaging (fMRI) in healthy subjects after applying XNKQ acupuncture.
Results: For stimulation, we found decreased eigenvector centrality
in precuneus (stimulation < nonstimulation), whereas for the factor location,
no statistically significant differences in centrality were found. However, when
comparing XNKQ acupuncture with manual needle-stimulation on nonacupuncture
points, we found decreased centrality in midbrain structures (thalamus, caudate,
and lentiform nucleus), claustrum, and cingulate cortex. The comparison of XNKQ
acupuncture with the other 2 (nonstimulation) interventions showed no
significant differences.
Conclusions: When evaluating acupuncture on multiple points,
stimulation and location of acupuncture seem to affect brain activity
changes.
(3538) Lessons Learned During the Integrative Medical Group Visits Randomized
Controlled Trial for Recruiting Low-income Racial/Ethnic Minority Research Study
Participants
Anna S. Lestoquoy, MPH1 and Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Integrative Medical Group Visits (IMGV) are an innovative
program for delivering chronic pain and depression care. This randomized control
trial compares the IMGV model to primary care appointments across 3 inner city
clinics in Boston. Our participants largely identify as racial/ ethnic
minorities, a historically challenging population for research recruitment. This
poster will share our methods and strategies in overcoming barriers related to
recruitment of this patient population.
Results: A total of 331 patients were consented and screened for
inclusion in the study, and 154 enrolled. Seventeen percent of those screened
were male; 59% identified as Black; with the site specific demographics similar
to each site’s patient population. Over the course of the study, in order to
ensure a representative sample, we changed our recruitment methods to enroll a
greater number of male participants. Different patients responded to different
recruitment methods, with older patients responding largely to targeted letters
and younger patients responding to self-referral and provider referral
(P = .0003, α = 0.05). The most common reasons for
declining participation was not being interested in groups or having scheduling
conflicts with the group schedule.
Conclusions: Different populations of patients respond to different
forms of recruitment. Our varied approaches resulted in successfully recruiting
our target number of participants.
(3539) Exploring the Impacts of Yinlai Decoction on DLA and DAO in Serum in Mice
With High-fat and Calorie-diet Combined With Pneumonia
Jun Wu, MD1, Teck Chuan Kong, MD2, Zeji Qiu, MD1, Yu
Hao, PhD1, Yunhui Wang, MD1, Yuxiang Wan, MD1, Zian
Zheng, PhD1, Xiaohong Gu, MD1, He Yu, PhD1, Jingnan
Xu, MD1, Tiegang Liu, PhD1 and Yingqiu Mao, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the protective effect of Yinlai decoction on DLA
and DAO in serum in mice with high-fat and calorie-diet combined with pneumonia
and to ascertain the potential mechanism of Yinlai decoction.
Results: The DLA level in serum of pneumonia group, high-fat and
calorie-diet group, and high-fat and calorie-diet combined with pneumonia group
were increased significantly (P < .05) compared with the
normal group. The DLA level in serum of Yinlai decoction group was decreased
significantly (P < .05) compared with high-fat and
calorie-diet combined with pneumonia group. The DLA level in serum of
dexamethasone group was increased significantly (P < .01)
compared with the normal group and Yinlai decoction group. The DAO level in
serum of pneumonia group, high-fat and calorie-diet group, and high-fat and
calorie-diet combined with pneumonia group were increased compared with normal
group. The DAO level in serum of Yinlai decoction group and dexamethasone group
were decreased compared with high-fat and calorie-diet combined with pneumonia
group, but there was no statistical significance in the DAO level of serum
between each group (P > .05).
Conclusions: Pneumonia could lead to higher levels of DLA and DAO in
serum. Yinlai decoction can reduce the pathological permeability of intestinal
mucosa and the levels of DLA and DAO in serum to protect the intestinal mucosal.
Dexamethasone could significantly relieve pulmonary inflammation, but
concurrently causes intestinal mucosal tissue damages, which results in an
increase in intestinal mucosal permeability and the level of DLA in serum as
well.
(3540) Improved Health Outcomes in Integrative Medicine Visits May Reflect Shifts
in Physician and Patient Behaviors Compared to Standard Medical Visits
Judith A Hall, PhD1, Ted J Kaptchuk2, Michelle L Dossett, MD,
PhD, MPH3 and Gloria Yeh, MD, MPH2
1Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts
2Boston, Massachusetts
3Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: We previously demonstrated in patients with
gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) that individuals receiving an integrative
medicine visit had greater improvements in symptom severity than individuals
receiving a standard empathic primary care visit regardless of treatment
provided. To better understand these results, we analyzed study visit videos to
assess differences in physician and patient behaviors in these 2 visit
types.
Results: Both visit types began similarly and most positive
patient-centered impressions and nonverbal behaviors increased over the course
of both visit types. In the integrative visits, the physician was rated as
significantly more engaged (P = .009), friendly
(P = .005), and relaxed (P = .002), smiled
more (P = .006), gazed longer (P = .021),
gestured more (P = .007), and spent more time talking
(P = .024) compared to standard visits. There were
significant time by visit type effects such that as visits progressed, patients
in the integrative group were more friendly (P = .002),
confident (P = .042), and pleased (P = .044)
than patients in the standard visit group. Improvement in GERD symptoms was most
highly correlated with patients being pleased (r = .71,
P < .01) and friendly (r = .67,
P < .01) at the end of the visit.
Conclusions: The structure of integrative medicine visits may
enhance relationship building not only improving patient-centered behaviors by
physicians but also modifying patients’ responses, potentially facilitating
symptom improvement.
(3546) Feasibility, Acceptability, and Effectiveness of a Mindfulness-based
Smoking Cessation Program for Cancer Patients
Man Luo, MPH1, Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1, Salvatore D'Amico,
BS1, Marjory Charlot, MD, MPH, MSc1, Karen E Lasser, MD,
MPH1 and Hasmeena Kathuria, MD1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Cigarette smoking is a major cause of cancer death and
contributes to health disparities. Stress is an important trigger for cigarette
smoking. Low socioeconomic and minority populations who smoke have high cancer
mortality rates and are less likely to use evidence-based smoking cessation
treatments. The use of mindfulness training to assist with cessation of smoking
has been postulated to manage craving/withdrawal symptoms and emotional
distress. This pilot project aims to test the feasibility and acceptability of
mindfulness training program to engage low-income and minority current smokers
with cancer to smoking cessation therapy.
Results: Eighteen participants were enrolled from October 2016 to
May 2017. Participant demographics were as follows: 56% identified as Black, 56%
reported a yearly income of $20,000 or less, and the average age was 64 years.
At baseline, 8 (44%) participants were actively undergoing cancer treatment. The
average cigarette intake was 75.1 per week, and the median perceived stress
score was 6.0. At follow-up, participants significantly decreased their weekly
cigarette intake to 44.3 cigarettes (P = .07), and the median
PSS reduced to 3.0. The number of participants who did home practice (including
meditation, body scan, yoga, and mindful eating) increased from 30.8% after week
1 to 100% at week 8. Twelve (66.7%) participants attended at least half of the
MBSC sessions.
Conclusions: Mindfulness training is feasible and acceptable among
low-income and racially diverse cancer patients who smoke.
(3549) Patient Safety and Quality of Care in Chiropractic Academic Clinics: A
Qualitative Evaluation of Respondent Feedback to an International Survey
Maeve O'Beirne, MD, PhD1, Sunita Vohra, MD MSc1, Katherine A
Pohlman, DC, MS2, Michelle M Holmes, MS3, Stacie A Salsbury,
RN, PhD4 and Martha Funabashi, PhD5
1Edmonton, Alberta
2Parker University, Dallas, Texas
3Anglo-European University College, Bournemouth, UK
4Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
5Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Abstract
Purpose: Patient safety and quality of care are growing concerns for
all health-care settings, including clinics within educational institutions. The
purpose of this study was to evaluate written feedback offered by chiropractic
academic settings’ clinic personnel on the topics of patient safety and
quality.
Results: Of 800 academic respondents, 80 individuals provided
written feedback. While quantitative survey results noted good-to-excellent
scores on most items, qualitative comments identified 5 domains of concern
potentially impacting patient safety and quality of care in the chiropractic
academic setting. Patient safety culture described themes of
patient-centeredness, safety knowledge, adverse events, medical errors, incident
reports, and safety protocols. Clinic environment highlighted equipment, clinic
setting, documentation systems, and personnel. Clinic processes revealed issues
of appointment scheduling, visit duration, marketing/recruitment, paperwork,
workload, and outcome assessments. The education domain discussed teaching
style, faculty staffing, training, and comanagement. Finally, the leadership
domain emphasized professional identity, quality standards, intern
opportunities, and community involvement. While many issues were identified,
respondents offered few solutions to improving patient safety and quality of
care in this setting.
Conclusions: Chiropractic personnel in academic settings are aware
of patient safety and quality of care issues in their workplaces but offered few
solutions. Targeted interventions to foster patient safety culture and implement
sustainable quality improvement initiatives may be warranted.
(3552) Crowdsourcing for Patient Engagement in Research: Results of a Qualitative
Analysis Methods Study
Tarek Azzam, PhD1, Gery Ryan, PhD2, Ian D Coulter,
PhD2 and Lara G. Hilton, MPH2
1Claremont Graduate University, Claremont, California
2RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Patient-centered care increases credibility and legitimacy
of programs, participant uptake, and most importantly improves outcomes;
however, the high costs and amount of time required to recruit and engage
patients makes it difficult to routinely involve them in health-care research
and evaluation. The purpose of this methods study is to test the feasibility of
patient engagement in health research using an innovative web-based tool called
crowdsourcing. Crowdsourcing is the process of obtaining services, ideas, or
content by soliciting contributions from a large group of people, and especially
from an online community.
Results: Analyzing textual responses using a crowdsourcing platform
was feasible, fast, and inexpensive. Data quality were good as compared to a
clinical sample from a practice-based network. The domains of “intensity” and
“function” were straightforward for Mechanical Turk (MTurk) participants to
apply to text, but they found “duration” and “frequency” to be overlapping
constructs. They ranked domains in this order of importance: intensity,
frequency, function, and duration. Additional themes that emerged consistently
across MTurk participants were no cure, pain management/treatments,
cause/diagnosis, and psychological effects.
Conclusions: Findings illustrate that patients value different
dimensions of chronic pain than we typically use for defining it in the research
context where duration of greater than 3 months of pain is the norm. In order to
advance patient-centered research, we require innovative, efficient tools such
as crowdsourcing to increase patient inclusion and participation; this new
experimental system has the potential to enhance patient engagement in clinical
research, evaluation, and policy.
(3553) Exploring the Impacts of Yinlai Decoction on Colonic Ultrastructure in
Mice With High-fat and Calorie-diet Combined With Pneumonia
Zeji Qiu, MD1, Jun Wu, MD1, Teck C Kong, MD2, Yu
Yunhui Wang, MD1, Tiegang Hao, PhD1, Jingnan Liu,
PhD1, He Xu, MD1, Xiaohong Yu, PhD1, Zian Gu,
MD1, Yuxiang Zheng, PhD1, Yingqiu Wan, MD1 and
Mao, MD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the protective effect of Yinlai decoction on
colonic ultrastructure and intestinal mucosa in mice with high-fat and
calorie-diet combined with pneumonia and to ascertain the potential mechanism of
Yinlai decoction.
Results: The mice colon mucosa of pneumonia group reflected an
inconsistent size of microvilli. In the high-fat and calorie-diet group and
high-fat and calorie-diet combined with pneumonia group, the intercellular
junction of colon mucosa epithelial cells was loose, the cells’ gap was widened,
the colon mucosa epithelial cells exhibit a low-density bright band, while the
microvilli were shortened and sparse in disorderly and unsystematic directions,
the surface of microvilli had no cell membrane. The ultrastructure pathological
changes of colon tissue in Yinlai decoction group were improved; the
intercellular junction was loose, the cells gap and low-density bright band were
significantly narrowed compared to the pneumonia group. In the dexamethasone
group, the intercellular junction of colon mucosa epithelial was loose, the
cells gap was widened, and the colon mucosa epithelial cells illustrated a
low-density bright band, and the microvilli were shortened.
Conclusions: Yinlai decoction can reduce the pathological
permeability of intestinal mucosa. It may be associated with improving the
intestinal mucosal histomorphology and maintaining the integrity of cell
connection and microvilli structure. Dexamethasone could significantly relieve
pulmonary inflammation but concurrently causes intestinal mucosal tissue
damages.
(3555) Impact of a Brief Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction Program for First
Semester Nursing Students
Catherine Kelleher, ScD, MPH, MS, RN1 and Lynn Chen, PhD1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: There is increasing evidence that brief mindfulness-based
stress reduction (MBSR) programs reduce stress, but few studies have tested
their impact on nursing students and none on their grades. A randomized
intervention pilot evaluated impact of a brief MBSR program for Fall 2012 first
semester baccalaureate students in nursing (BSNs) and was repeated for Spring
2013 first semester BSNs. The intervention group received an MBSR program of 4
weekly 1-h classes and 10 min of daily practice; the controls received a 4-h
MBSR workshop at the beginning of their second semester. All completed
electronic surveys at baseline, 4, and 8 weeks.
Results: In Fall 2012, the intervention group had significantly
lower stress and higher resilience and mindfulness scores than controls at 4 and
8 weeks, and a significantly higher mean grade in the practice fundamentals
course; there were no differences in grade point average. In Spring 2013, there
were no differences between groups.
Conclusions: Results suggest that a brief MBSR program builds stress
management skills and has potential to improve academic performance of first
semester BSNs.
(3559) Integrating Chiropractic Care Into a Neurorehabilitation Hospital: A
Descriptive Study
W Carl Cooley, MD1, Lance Donna Gosselin, PT2, Christine M
Corber, MSITM3, Robert D Goertz, DC, PhD3, Stacie A Vining,
DC3 and Salsbury, RN, PhD3
1Dartmouth College, Concord, New Hampshire
2Crotched Mountain Specialty Hospital, Greenfield, New Hampshire
3Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
Abstract
Purpose: Inpatient rehabilitation for individuals suffering complex
neurological injury commonly includes a multidisciplinary approach. However, the
role of chiropractic care in such settings is unknown. This study describes
chiropractic care integrated into a specialty hospital focused on inpatient
rehabilitation for patients with brain injury, spinal cord injury, stroke, and
other neurological conditions.
Results: The mean (standard deviation) age of 27 participants was
42.8 (13) years (range 20–64 years). Male patients (n = 18; 67%) and persons of
white race/ethnicity (n = 23; 85%) comprised the majority. Most participants
(n = 20) suffered brain injury from trauma (n = 9), nontraumatic hemorrhage
(n = 7), infarction (n = 2), and general anoxia (n = 2). Three participants
suffered complete or incomplete cervical spinal cord injury. Common secondary
diagnoses included myospasm (n = 13), depression (n = 11), anxiety (n = 10),
dysphagia (n = 8), substance abuse (n = 8), and candidiasis (n = 7). The most
common chiropractic procedures employed, by percentage of visits, were manual
myofascial therapies (93%), mechanical percussion (83%), manual muscle
stretching (75%), and thrust manipulation (65%) to address spinal-related pain
(n = 15; 54%), joint or regional stiffness (n = 14; 50%), and extremity pain
(n = 13; 46%). Care often required adapting to participant limitations or
conditions, such as the need for lift assistance, wheelchair dependence,
contractures, impaired speech, quadriplegia/paraplegia, and the presence of
feeding tubes and urinary catheters.
Conclusions: Chiropractic services were successfully integrated into
an inpatient setting caring for patients with significant functional limitations
and comorbidity. This study also identified care challenges not commonly
encountered in outpatient settings where chiropractic services are typically
available.
(3560) Traditional, Complementary, and Alternative Medicine for Treatment of
Atopic Eczema in Children Under 13 Years: A Systematic Review of Randomized Clinical
Trials
Chun-li Lu, Xue-han Master1, Agnete E Liu1, ArneJohan
Kristoffersen2, Frauke Norheim2, Terje Musial2,
Vinjar Araek2, Jian-ping Fonnebo2, Trine Liu3, 4
and Stub, PhD2
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2The National Research Center in Complementary and Alternative Medicine,
Tromso, Norway
3Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
4The Arctic University of Norway, Tromsø, Norway
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the beneficial effect and safety of
traditional, complementary, and alternative medicines (TCAM) for children under
13 years with atopic eczema (AE).
Results: One hundred eleven randomized clinical trials (RCTs;
involving 8797 children with AE) were included (Figure 1). The methodological
quality was of unclear risk of bias in general (Figure 2). The trials tested 53
different types of TCAM for children with AE. For clinical effectiveness
(defined as 50% global symptom improvement like itch, skin lesions, swelling,
and papula), 36 trials showed better effect from TCAM (risk ratio [RR] 1.37, 95%
confidence interval [CI] 1.24–1.52) in addition to usual care, and 59 trials
showed better effect from TCAM alone (RR 1.33, 1.28–1.37) compared with usual
care, and 2 trials showed beneficial effect from TCAM (RR 0.92, 0.70–1.20)
compared with placebo. For 6-month follow-up, 9 trials reported lower relapse
rate from TCAM + usual care (RR 0.31, 0.23–0.42) comparing with usual care, and
another 9 trials reported lower relapse rate from TCAM alone (RR 0.41,
0.21–0.82) compared with usual care. Nine trials reported nonserious adverse
events in relation to TCAM.
Conclusions: TCAM may reduce symptoms and the relapse rate in
children with AE. The safety of TCAM remains unclear due to insufficient
reporting. Well-designed, adequately powered, and further rigorous RCTs are
warranted.
(3561) How Stakeholder Input Shaped a Patient-Centered Outcomes Research
Institute-funded Study of Acupressure to Decrease Symptoms During Treatment for a
Childhood Cancer
Anne Lown, DrPH1, Melissa Martin, RN, MSN, CPNP, CPON2, L Lee
Dupuis, RPh, PhD1, Diane Sabin, DC1, Christina Mangurian,
MD1, Alison Olig, JD3 and Frederick M Hecht,
MD1
1San Francisco, California
2Patient Advocacy Committee, Children’s Oncology Group, Atlanta,
Georgia
3Patient Adovocacy Committee, Children’s Oncology Group, Tulsa,
Oklahoma
Abstract
Purpose: To describe the process of stakeholder engagement in the
development of a Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute-funded study
testing an acupressure intervention to decrease treatment-related symptoms in
children in treatment for a childhood cancer.
Results: Stakeholder input significantly influenced the final study
design including changing the primary outcome from pain to nausea/vomiting,
including a wider age range (5–21 years), adding inclusion of children with
brain tumors (malignant and nonmalignant), incorporating parents as providers of
acupressure (in addition to professionally provided acupressure), use of
acupressure rather than acupuncture, and the use of a pragmatic comparative
effectiveness study design that emphasized an intervention comparision
representing a “real life” context (not using sham treatment). Stakeholder
feedback often dovetailed with systematic reviews related to the importance of
addressing patient symptoms and best advice for acupuncture research.
Conclusions: Inclusion of a widely representative group of
stakeholders led to significant changes in the study design and measures.
Stakeholder feedback will be continually incorporated throughout the study to
ensure that study implementation and results addresses stakeholder need, that
analysis approaches are meaningful, and that the likelihood of disseminating the
study findings to additional pediatric cancer treatment centers will be
maximized.
(3562) Comparative Impact of Brief Mindfulness-based Compassion and
Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction Programs on Stress Management and Grades of First
Semester Nursing Students
Lynn Chen, PhD1 and Catherine Kelleher, ScD, MPH, MS, RN1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: A 2-year randomized intervention pilot study during
2014–2016 evaluated if brief mindfulness-based compassion (MSC) and
mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) programs would have comparable
outcomes in reducing stress and boosting resilience, mindfulness,
self-compassion, and academic performance of fall and spring first-semester
baccalaureate students in nursing (BSNs). The MSC program was expected to do
better because it emphasized self-kindness. During year 1, participants were
randomized to MBSR and MSC programs as originally planned but enrollment was
low. During year 2, the randomized design was modified to drop the MBSR arm,
focus only on the MSC program, and use a control group in which participants
would get the MSC program in a consolidated half-day program at the beginning of
the following semester. The simplified design permitted testing student interest
in signing up for an MSC study and the impact on enrollment if there was no
uncertainty about being randomized to 1 of 2 programs which met at different
times. Enrollment continued to be low.
Results: In year 1, total recruitment = 19, total withdrawal = 8,
and 11 of the 11 participants completed all surveys (baseline, 4 and 8 weeks),
yielding an analytic sample = 11. In year 2, total recruitment = 22, total
withdrawal = 9, and 9 of the 13 participants completed all surveys, yielding an
analytic sample = 9. Due to small sample size, analysis for both pilot years was
limited to descriptive statistics, and hypotheses could not be tested; however,
descriptive analysis indicated that MSC program participants had greater
reductions in stress and greater increases in resilience, mindfulness, and
self-compassion than did participants in the MBSR and control groups.
Conclusions: Despite the brevity of the MBSR and MSC programs, both
delivered via 4 weekly face-to-face 1-h sessions, and 10 min of daily at home
practice, the format was not feasible due to competing demands for student time,
including scheduled classes, labs, and clinical assignments, and support
services students were urged or required to use. An online format may not be the
answer to the face-to-face scheduling conflicts and other competing demands, but
it is an option worth exploring via future pilot studies.
(3563) Exploring Mechanisms of Tai Chi for Improving Quality of Life and
Depression Symptoms in Heart Failure Patients
Roger B Davis, ScD1 M Peter, Gloria Wayne, PhD2, Christina M
Yeh, MD, MPH1 and Luberto, PhD1
1Boston, Massachusetts
2Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Many heart failure patients report elevated depression
symptoms and poor quality of life (QoL). Our randomized controlled trial
previously showed that Tai Chi exercise improves these outcomes in heart failure
patients, but the mechanisms are unclear. As a group-based exercise, Tai Chi may
improve social support and behavioral activation (eg, general activity levels,
independent of intensity or caloric expenditure), 2 key factors that reduce
depression symptoms. We explored whether Tai Chi is associated with greater
improvements in social support and behavioral activation (amount of activity,
frequency of activity) as compared to an active control, and whether changes in
these variables are correlated with improved depression symptoms.
Results: Amount of activity (ie, number of activities completed in
the past month) decreased in the control group (ΔM = −1.26) but
remained stable in the Tai Chi group (ΔM = 0.36; group by time
interaction P = .02). There was a trend for greater
improvements in activity frequency (ie, number of times various activities were
preformed in the past month) in the Tai Chi group (ΔM = 17.89)
compared to the control group (ΔM = 13.11; group by time
interaction P = .06). Activity changes were not correlated with
changes in depression or QoL (P’s > .05). For social
support, there was no significant group by time interaction
(P > .05), but individual-level increases in social support
were correlated with decreased depression symptoms for Tai Chi participants
(r = −.32, P = .03).
Conclusions: Tai Chi may protect against declines in activity
levels, and increases in social support may play a role in Tai Chi-related
improvements in depression symptoms.
(3570) Use of Heart Rate Variability to Measure the Treatment Effects of an
Integrative East-West Encounter: A Pilot Study
Devon J Carter1, Andrew Shubov1 and Annie Zhang1
1Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: The effects of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM)
therapies are difficult to measure because they are often used to treat
subjective experiences such as pain. Autonomic tone reflects the intensity of
chronic pain conditions, and so heart rate variability (HRV) analytical tools
offer potential objective measures of the effects of CAM therapies on pain. We
aimed (1) to investigate whether HRV markers can be used to quantitatively
measure the effects of CAM modalities at the University of California, Los
Angeles Center for East-West Medicine (CEWM) by comparing the HRV before and
after therapeutic interventions during a routine patient visit. We also
attempted (2) to use this method to identify differences in effect among the
interventions (provider encounter, trigger point injections, acupuncture, and
massage).
Results: Root mean square of successive differences (RMSSD)
decreased from 15.81 ms to 22.00 ms (P = .0015), and low
frequency/high frequency (LF/HF) decreased from 6.98 to 3.43 (confidence
interval [CI] 95%, P = .0096) when comparing the pre- and
posttreatment recordings across all patients (n = 20). Patients reporting severe
pain (n = 9) demonstrated more robust reductions in LF/HF from a higher baseline
of 8.82 to 4.58, while the LF/HF ratio of relatively healthier patients (n = 10)
dropped from 2.41 to 1.59. All CAM modalities tested produced similar changes in
RMSSD and LF/HF.
Conclusions: HRV measurements of RMSSD and LF/HF may be a valid tool
for measuring the treatment effect of CAM modalities. Patients in severe pain
seemed to have a more pronounced effect.
(3571) Study on the Mechanism of Wumei Pill in Treating Pancreatic Neoplasms With
the Method of Network Pharmacology
Jinchang Huang, PhD1, Zeyu Liu1, Ming Yang1 and
Yuxiang Wan1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Because of its high lethality rate, low 5-year survival
rate, and poor clinical efficacy, pancreatic neoplasms pose a great threat to
human health. Wumei Pill, a Chinese herbal formula, plays a positive role in
treating pancreatic neoplasms by effectively alleviating pain, improving
appetite, promoting quality of life, and extending the median survival of
patients. To explore the potential antineoplasm targets and mechanism of the
treatment of Wumei Pill on pancreatic neoplasms, through analyzing the
prescription of Wumei Pill with the method of network pharmacology, in order to
provide targeted guidance for the following study.
Results: A total of 42 significant target points of Wumei Pill
treating on pancreatic neoplasms were found, 114 cellular biological processes
were processed through GO biological process (GO_BP) enrichment analysis
(P value < .01), and 27-related pathways were carried on
by Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (P value < .05),
which mainly including hypoxia-inducible factor 1 signaling pathway, tumor
necrosis factor signaling pathway, PI3K-Akt signaling pathway, mitogen-activated
protein kinase signaling pathway, NF-kappa B signaling pathway, vascular
endothelial growth factor signaling pathway, Ras signaling pathway, and so
on.
Conclusions: The intervening of a complex multiple-target points
pathway may account for the effect of Wumei Pill in treating pancreatic
neoplasms. This study not only makes a contribution to a better understanding of
the anti-pancreatic neoplasms mechanism of Wumei Pill but also proposes a
strategy to develop new Traditional Chinese Medicine candidates at a network
pharmacology level.
(3572) The Clinical Research on the Association Between Gastrointestinal Heat
Retention Syndrome and Pharyngeal Microbiome Disturbance in Children
Yuxiang Wan1, Yunhui Wang, MD1, Xueyan Ma, MD1, Fei
Dong, PhD2, Xiaofei Li, MD3, Zian Zheng, PhD1,
Jianhua Zhen, PhD4, Xiaohong Gu, MD1, He Yu, PhD1
and Tiegang Liu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Dongfang Hospital Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing,
China
3People’s Hospital of Leling City, Dezhou, China
4China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Gastrointestinal heat retention syndrome (GHRS) is a
syndrome that is associated with increased gastrointestinal heat caused by a
metabolic block in energy, especially in children. Symptoms are intolerance to
heat, dry mouth, a preference for cold drinks desire, swift digestion with
increased apatite, dry and smelly stool, a reddened tongue with yellow fur, and
so on. Our teamwork has showed that GHRS plays an important role in the
development of respiratory and digestive diseases. This is a pilot study to
explore the association between GHRS and pharyngeal microbiome disturbance in
children by detecting the throat swab specimens with high-throughput sequencing
testing method.
Results: Ten GHRS children and 10 healthy children were enrolled,
then 20 throat swab specimens were collected from the participants. The
pharyngeal microbiome which was annotated included 15 phyla, 24 classes, 56
orders, 90 families, 124 genus, and 58 species. There was no significant
difference between 2 groups in microbial diversity. However, the relative
abundance of Lactobacillaceae and Lactobacillus was significantly increased in
GHRS children. The specific pharyngeal microbiome indicators of children with
GHRS was OTU_353 which was annotated as p__Firmicutes, c__Clostridia, and
o__Clostridiales statistically.
Conclusions: GHRS may have an association with pharyngeal microbiome
disturbance in children. And large sample size is needed in the future.
(3576) Self-administered Acupressure Improves Co-occurring Symptoms in Fatigued
Cancer Survivors
Suzanna Zick, ND, MPH1, Richard E Harris, PhD1, Afton Hassett,
PhD1, Gwen Wyatt, PhD, RN, FAAN2, Ananda Sen,
PhD1, Susan Murrphy, ScD OTR1, J Todd Arnedt,
PhD1 and Andrew Schrepf, PhD1
1Ann Arbor, Michigan
2Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan
Abstract
Purpose: Cancer-related fatigue is a prevalent and troublesome
symptom in breast cancer survivors (BCS). In a clinical trial, we demonstrated
that self-administered acupressure improved fatigue and sleep quality; however,
how self-administered acupressure impacted other common symptoms that co-occur
with fatigue including pain, anxiety, and depression has not been
investigated.
Results: RA and SA both significantly improved anxiety (RA vs UC,
mean difference: −1.87, 95% confidence interval [CI]: −3.66 to −0.09,
P = .34/SA vs UC, mean difference: −1.83, 95% CI: −3.56 to
−0.10, P = .037), pain interference (RA vs UC, mean difference:
−1.10, 95% CI: −1.93 to −0.27, P = .010/SA vs UC, mean
difference: −1.36, 95% CI: −2.23 to −0.48, P = .003) and pain
severity versus UC (RA vs UC, mean difference: −1.56, 95% CI: −2.49 to −0.63,
P = .001/SA vs UC, mean difference: −1.41, 95% CI: −2.38 to
−0.43, P = .005). Only for depression, there was a significant
difference between RA and SA (mean difference: −1.99, 95% CI: −3.78 to −0.20,
P = .024) and for RA versus UC (mean difference: −2.99, 95%
CI: −4.79 to −1.18, P < .001). There was no difference
between SA and UC (P = .502).
Conclusions: Six weeks of both acupressure protocols were equally
helpful in relieving anxiety and chronic pain compared to UC. RA seemed to
perform better than SA and UC in this population in reducing depressive
symptoms. These results could help clinicians personalize care depending on
which symptoms are reported by cancer survivors.
(3577) Is Less More? A randomized Comparison of Home Practice Time in a Mind–Body
Program
Tosca Braun, MA1, Marissa L Schneide, BA2, Lucy
Finkelstein-Fox, BA1, Lisa A Conboy, ScD3, Elizabeth D
Schifano, PhD1 and Jonathan Greenberg, PhD2
1University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut
2Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Home practice is a major component of mind–body programs.
However, previous studies assessing the effects of home practice have relied
solely on observational/correlational methods, making it extremely difficult to
draw causal conclusions about its role in clinical outcome. Moreover, little is
known about how to optimize the amount of prescribed home practice in order to
achieve an effective “dose” of practice while minimizing participant burden. The
primary aim of the current study was to determine how systematically varying the
amount of home practice impacts compliance and stress reduction among
individuals undergoing a 12-week yoga program. Secondary aims of the study were
to examine whether increasing partipants’ amount of flexibility in home practice
would increase compliance and to identify predictors of compliance.
Results: The low practice group exhibited the highest compliance
(91%) compared to the medium and low practice groups (∼60%), but also exhibited
the lowest total practice time, and did not significantly reduce stress. The
high practice group was the only group to achieve significant reductions in
stress, which were maintained 12 weeks after program completion. Allowing
flexibility did not increase compliance. Baseline levels of self-efficacy and
self-control predicted home practice compliance regardless of prescribed
dose.
Conclusions: Assigning less home practice boosts compliance but does
not yield significant stress reduction. Additionally, compliance can be
predicted by levels of self-efficacy and self-control, but compliance is not
impacted by assigning a flexible home practice regimen.
(3584) Integrative Medical Group Visits: A Randomized Controlled Trial in
Patients With Chronic Pain and Depression in a Diverse Urban Setting
Man Luo, MPH1, Salvatore D'Amico, BS1, Paula Gardiner, MD,
MPH1, Katherine A Gergen-Barnett, MD1, Laura F White,
PhD1, Suzanne E Mitchell, MD1, Robert B Saper, MD,
MPH1 and Anna S Lestoquoy, MPH1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Medical group visits and mindfulness techniques provide a
promising adjunct to chronic pain treatment, especially for underserved patients
who have limited access to nonpharmacological care.
Results: One hundred fifty-nine patients were enrolled and
randomized (intervention n = 76; control n = 79). The average age was 51 years,
86% female, 58% identify as black, and 23% as other race. The average income was
$5,000–$29,999 with 42% on work leave or disability. The study demonstrates that
Integrative Medicine Group Visits (IMGVs) are (1) in demand (nearly 400 patients
asked to participate); (2) feasible (94% intervention participants attended the
IMGV, 72% attended half or more sessions); (3) valuable to patients (88% of
patients attended the IMGV had high satisfaction). In the intention-to-treat
analysis, at 21 weeks, there was a reduction in depressive symptoms (risk ratio
[RR]: 0.89, 95% confidence intervals [CIs]: 0.75–1.06) and average pain (RR:
0.98, CI: 0.88–1.08) compared to control group. At 21 weeks, for participants
who attended 5 or more sessions, there was a 30% reduction in depression (RR:
0.70, CI: 0.53–0.92) and a 20% reduction in average pain (RR: 0.80, CI:
0.67–0.95). At 21 weeks, there was a significant reduction in pain medication
use (odds ratio: 0.42, CI: 0.18–0.98); and at 9 weeks, there was a significant
reduction in total emergency department visits (RR 0.32 95% CI: 0.12–0.83)
between intervention and controls.
Conclusions: Our results suggest that IMGV is an option to increase
nonpharmacological strategies for low-income racially diverse patients with
chronic pain and depression.
(3585) Evaluation of the Potential of Tai Chi/Qigong Exercises for Treatment of
Low Back Pain by Electromyography, Laser Doppler Flowmetry, and Machine
Learning
Jacqueline Nguyen, BS1, Sam L Herring, BS1, Jackson K Tran,
BS1, Shin Lin, PhD1, Yu Tsao, PhD2 and Payton
Lin, PhD2
1Irvine, California
2Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan, ROC
Abstract
Purpose: Animal studies have shown that stretching reduces
inflammation/pain of the lower back, a problem prevalent in humans. This pilot
study tests a combination of technologies for evaluation Tai Chi/Qigong
stretching exercises for potential treatment of this condition.
Results: The 9 Tai Chi/Qigong movements tested showed different
levels of muscle activation recorded at the lower and upper back. Most
illustrative are electromyographic data showing moderate activity at the upper
back and strong activity at the lower back for “Deer Sprinting,” while the
opposite was obtained for “Tiger Pouncing” (both from 5 Animals Frolic Qigong).
Activities were moderate at both places for “9 Ghosts Drawing Saber” (from
Tendon Changing Classic Qigong). Blood perfusion data were consistent with these
patterns: 34.7 ± 3.0 (mean increase ± standard error mean, arbitrary units) for
upper back, 66.1 ± 11.6 for lower back for deer, 50.9 ± 3.8 and 39.2 ± 4.9 for
tiger, and 37.5 ± 2.9 and 48.8 ± 11.2 for ghosts.
Conclusions: This study shows that the methodology used is promising
for evaluating the extent Tai Chi/Qigong movements might be effective for
stretching the lower back for relieving inflammation/pain.
(3586) Development of an Inpatient Integrative East-West Medicine Consultative
Service
Annie Zhang1 and Andrew Shubov1
1Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Overview:
Background: Integrative Medicine (IM) provides a range of
therapeutic treatment options for patients who are refractory to the medical
care available in the hospital. Unfortunately, the challenges of building a
sustainable inpatient IM program limits the availability of these services for
patients and keeps many physicians unaware of the potential value of IM.
Bringing IM services into the hospital setting would be a major step forward in
the integration of IM into mainstream medical culture. The University of
California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Center for East-West Medicine (EWM) offers
Traditional Chinese Medicine inspired lifestyle counseling and treatment options
to outpatients in the UCLA health system. Our clinical experience has shown that
EWM can also be used in the inpatient setting to successfully break the
recurrent readmission cycles of chronic abdominal pain and other refractory pain
syndromes. Program Description: We are launching a full-time
inpatient integrative EWM consult service to test the concept that IM
consultants can work alongside other medical subspecialties as part of an
inpatient treatment plan as well as to develop a sustainable inpatient financial
model to provide EWM services while minimizes costs to patients. Our first aim
is to develop a consultative service that integrates into the inpatient
treatment team for complicated hospitalized patients. Following the initial
physician consultation, IM-informed recommendations will be offered and
evidence-based EWM services such as acupuncture will be provided as part of the
medical treatment plan. Our second aim is to evaluate the physician consultative
service as a financial model for a sustainable inpatient IM program with minimal
cost to the patient. Revenue will be generated primarily from evaluation and
management coding, as well as occasional procedures such as trigger point
injections, without billing for noncovered acupuncture services.
Conclusion: This program will test the feasibility and
preliminary clinical effects of an inpatient Integrative East-West consultative
service.
Rationale: Bringing IM services into the hospital setting would be a
major step forward in the integration of IM into mainstream medical culture. The
Mission of the Consortium is to advance IM and health through academic
institutions and health systems, and the conference more specifically discusses
advancing IM through collaboration. This clinical initiative represents a direct
advance of IM into the inpatient academic health-care setting through direct
collaboration with the inpatient treatment teams.
Objectives: Participants are intended to gain an understanding of
the upcoming UCLA East-West Medicine inpatient consult service and of the
financial model we plan to employ. More broadly, participants are encouraged to
consider inpatient IM services in the treatment of complex hospitalized
patients.
(3590) Resiliency in Medical Students: Contributing Factors
Laura Malosh, PhD1, Emily Moss, BS1, Sian Cotton,
PhD1 and Harini Pallerla, MS1
1Cincinnati, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: Increasing resiliency in medical students is a key factor
in promoting wellness during the rigors of medical school. The purpose of this
study was to examine mental and emotional factors related to resiliency as a
target for future resiliency programming.
Results: Six hundred eighty-three students (F = 49.3%; White = 65%;
mean age = 24) completed the survey (response rate >95%). HR students across
all years (80.1%) scored better on most measures as compared to their LR peers
(P < .05). Higher mindfulness (B = .093), more positive
affect (B = .063), less stress (B = −.222), and less anxiety (B = −.066) were
associated with higher resilience (R2 = .409). In qualitative
responses, students identified creating a plan and gaining perspective as key to
improved resiliency. Students reported that their resiliency could be increased
with more free time, mentorship, and better access to wellness resources at
school.
Conclusions: Resilience in these medical students was related to
increased mindfulness and better mental health. Most students reported high
levels of personal resiliency and identified feasible targets for school
enhancement of resiliency. Developing resiliency programs that emphasize
mindfulness while reducing stress of medical students should be prioritized.
(3596) Sibley Memorial Hospital’s “Poets-in-Residence” Program
NP Harpreet Gujral1 and Frankie Abralind, BS, MBA2
1Sibley Memorial Hospital, Washington, DC
2Sibley Memorial Hospital Innovation Hub, Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: At Sibley Memorial Hospital, a community hospital in
Washington, DC, “Poets in Residence” (PiRs) write custom poems for patients,
staff, and visitors. They make themselves available at designated locations and
engage one-on-one with any curious person who comes up to talk. Trained by
experienced street poet and experience designer Frankie Abralind, they solicit a
topic, ask a few probing questions, then compose an original poem which they
hand off to the recipient a few moments later. Themes range from hope and
gratitude to romantic discord and the anguish of grief. Poets have long provided
a service of helping people understand emotions, experiences, and defining
moments in life. A poem can shed unexpected light on a situation and make
connections that are not otherwise obvious. It can reassure the reader. It can
help someone get through a difficult time, giving comfort in suffering. Finding
one’s voice via poetic means can be a healing process because it opens up the
opportunity for self-expression not otherwise felt through everyday words.
To ensure sustainability of the program, our train-the-trainer program allows
current PiRs and alumni of the program to train future poets.
Rationale: The arts and humanities have an established benefit for
healing. Art therapy can reduce reliance on painkillers, lower average duration
of hospitalization, and improve recovery times. Our PiR program helps the
hospital address people as humans first, and recognizes their medical experience
as more than just corporeal. This supports Sibley Memorial Hospital’s mission,
“To deliver excellence and compassionate care– every person, every time.”
Initial studies indicate that a poetry therapy intervention may improve
emotional resilience and anxiety levels in cancer patients. Because the goal of
integrative medicine is to bring together various healing modalities into
contemporary medicine, we offer this program as great opportunity for low-cost,
nonpharma benefit in this era of human disconnection and medical crises like
America’s opioid epidemic. Findings from numerous experiments have suggested
that writing exercises can give a whole array of health benefits including
reductions in emotional and physical health complaints, and enhanced social
relationships and role functioning.
Objectives: The aim is to showcase Sibley’s innovative program,
provide an example other hospitals and health systems can emulate, and elevate
the perception of the arts in healing.
(3597) Dose–Response Effects of Tai Chi and Physical Therapy Exercise
Interventions in Symptomatic Knee Osteoarthritis
Xingyi Han, MPH1, Jeffrey B Driban, PhD, ATC, CSCS1, Maura D
Iversen, SD, DPT, MPH2, William F Harvey, MD, MSc1, Augustine
C Lee, MD1, Lori L Price, MAS, MLA1, Chenchen Wang, MD,
MSc1 and Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD, PhD1
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: While exercise is the recommended nonpharmacological
treatment for knee osteoarthritis (OA), optimal treatment dose, and clinically
meaningful treatment durations remain unclear. We examined dose–response
relationships, minimum effective dose, and baseline factors associated with
timing of response from 2 exercise interventions among adults with knee OA.
Results: We examined 182 participants (mean age 61 years, BMI
32 kg/m2, 70% female, 55% white). Both interventions had linear
dose–response effects resulting in a 9- to 11-point reduction in pain and 32- to
41-point improvement in function per week. There was no difference in overall
time-to-response for pain and function between treatment groups (Figure 1).
Median time-to-response for ≥20% improvement in pain and function was 2
attendance-weeks and 4 to 5 attendance-weeks for ≥50% improvement. In unadjusted
models, we found a general pattern wherein physical health, self-efficacy, and
outcome expectations tended to be associated with treatment response rather than
psychosocial or biomechanical factors (Table 1). In multivariable models,
outcome expectations were independently associated with incident function
response (Hazard Ratio: 1.47; 95% CI: 1.004 to 2.14).
Conclusions: Both interventions had linear dose-dependent effects on
pain and function, and minimum effective doses ranged from 2 (≥20% improvement)
to 5 weeks (≥50% improvement). Patient-perceived benefits of exercise
independently influenced timing of response among adults with knee OA. These
results may help clinicians optimize patient-centered exercise treatments and
better manage patient expectations.
(3606) Seven Years of Patient Data at an Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
Teaching Clinic—A Retrospective Analysis
Ben Marx, MAcOM1
1Oregon College of Oriental Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Analyze data for patients treated at the Oregon College of
Oriental Medicine between 2009 and 2016.
Results: A cohort comprising 6820 patients was analyzed. The
majority were white (64%) and female (68%). Average age was 45.5 (SD 16.95). At
visit 1, 56% reported prior acupuncture treatments and confidence (71%) that
treatment would be effective. Fifty-five percent self-report chief complaint as
pain and 75% report pain as a comorbidity. Fifty-one percent report chronicity
of chief complaint as “1 year or more;” 26% report “5 years or more;” and 38%
report taking prescription medication for their chief complaint. For those
taking medication, 60% report cutting down medication is “very important” or “a
bit important.” For those not taking medication, 55% report avoiding medication
is “very important” or “a bit important.” From visit 1 to visit 5, patients
report 1.38 point average improvement in severity of chief complaint, 1.08 point
improvement in pain level, and a 1.25 point improvement in activity
interference. Small, nonsignificant improvements were reported in well-being and
QOL.
Conclusions: Pain conditions constitute the overwhelming majority of
visits to the OCOM clinic. Patients utilize services primarily for chronic
conditions, and majorities do so with the goal of reducing or avoiding
medication. After 5 treatments, regardless of chief complaint, patients report
modest but clinically meaningful improvements in symptom severity, pain level,
and activity interference, suggesting that intern-delivered AOM is an effective
short-term intervention for a spectrum of health concerns, particularly chronic
pain. Future studies should examine long-term patient outcomes in similar
settings.
(3615) Safety of Custom Traditional Chinese Herbal Medicine Practice at Cleveland
Clinic
Galina V Roofener, LAc1
1Cleveland, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: The goal of this study is to evaluate the safety of
Traditional Chinese Herbal Medicine (TCHM) practice at CC CILM.
Results: Over 24 months, 206 patients received 1245 prescriptions,
totaling 68 379 doses and199 640 grams. Patients were reevaluated in person on
an as-needed basis. Detailed treatment progress, adverse event, and
hospitalizations were documented in the patient’s EMR. In the event of any
unusual symptom or allergic reaction, patients were instructed to contact a
provider. A complete metabolic panel (CMP) collected at a baseline, 4 to 8 weeks
and 6 months of herbal intake was used to evaluate safety. CMP results did not
detect changes that could be attributed to herbs. Patients reported 3 cases
(1.5%) of mild adverse effects which includes anxiety, nausea, and pruritus. All
events were reported to The State of Ohio Medical Board according to Ohio law
but none required FDA reporting.
Conclusions: This study illustrates THCM as practiced at CC CILM is
likely to be safe. This includes TCHM formulas compounded from concentrated 5:1
water-decocted extract granules manufactured according to ISO/IEC 17025:2005
testing lab international standards, compounded according to FDA regulation
Title 21 CFR 111, and prescribed according to TCM principles by a licensed
Chinese Herbalist. A prospective, well-controlled trial which includes a larger
cohort monitored over a longer period of time is warranted.
(3616) Higher Mindfulness Is Associated With Less Pain and Greater Psychological
Well-being in Fibromyalgia
Emily Wolcott, BA1, Brandon Pleman, BS1, Lori L Price, MAS,
MLA1, Jeffrey B Driban, PhD, ATC, CSCS1, Xingyi Han,
MPH1, William F Harvey, MD, MSc1, Raveendhara R Bannuru,
MD, PhD1 and Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Previous studies show that mindfulness is associated with
health outcomes in people with chronic pain, but its impact in individuals with
fibromyalgia remains unclear. We examined the associations between mindfulness
and pain and psychological outcomes in fibromyalgia patients.
Results: We included 177 participants (52.0 ± 12.2 years; 93.3%
women; 60.0% white; body mass index: 30.0 ± 6.7 kg/m2; FFMQ: 131.0;
FIQR: 57.0). Higher mindfulness was associated with lower fibromyalgia impact
(P = .003), pain interference
(P < .0001), stress (P < .0001), anxiety
(P < .0001), depression (P < .0001),
and higher mental health-related quality of life
(P < .0001). Of the 5 facets, Describing,
Acting-with-awareness, and Non-judging were most significantly associated with
pain and psychological outcomes. Furthermore, we did not find that mindfulness
significantly moderated the effect of pain interference on psychological
outcomes.
Conclusions: Higher levels of mindfulness are associated with lower
fibromyalgia impact, pain, and better psychological health and quality of life
in people with fibromyalgia. Future studies should assess how mind-body
therapies increasing mindfulness may improve the well-being of patients with
fibromyalgia.
(3617) A Few More Chiropractic Doctors: A Qualitative Study of Stakeholder
Perceptions of Access to Chiropractic Care in Veterans Affairs Health-care
Facilities
Christine M Goertz, DC, PhD1, Anthony J Lisi, DC2, Robert B
Wallace, MD, MSc3, Stacie A Salsbury, RN, PhD1 and Robert D
Vining, DC1
1Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
2Connecticut VAHCS, West Haven, Connecticut
3The University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa
Abstract
Purpose: Veterans experience high rates of musculoskeletal
disability, with low back pain (LBP) among the most common reasons for seeking
care within Veterans Affairs (VA) health-care facilities. This study explored VA
stakeholder perceptions of patient access to chiropractic care.
Results: All stakeholder groups reported a perceived need for
chiropractic care within VA based on veterans’ high LBP symptom burden and
susceptibility paired with the efficacy of chiropractic for many LBP complaints.
Actual and/or perceived access to chiropractic services were limited by
geographical distances to clinics,
temporal issues around appointment wait times, and
financial barriers of service-related eligibility. Some
stakeholders noted cultural concerns from biases toward the
chiropractic profession and issues of gender/ethnicity/language concordance
between patients and providers. Telehealth technology which has
increasing application in VA primary care and mental health settings, was
questioned for hands-on, manual therapies. Patients perceived access issues
related to chiropractic dose, including the lack of ongoing care for chronic LBP
and beliefs that shorter durations of episodic care could worsen LBP severity.
Additional chiropractors, increased service availability at more VA locations,
removal of gatekeeping structures, and improvements in interprofessional
collaboration were suggested solutions to access restrictions.
Conclusions: Stakeholder perceptions of chiropractic care suggested
expanded access to these services for veterans with LBP. Future research should
test the validity of this model of chiropractic access in representative
samples.
(3619) Management of Allergic Disorders in Child and Adolescent Age-group Through
Ayurvedic Dietetic Principles
Aparna W Panikkasseril, BAMS, MD1 and Naveen Chandran Venkallil, BAMS, MD
(Ay)2
1Indian Systems of Medicine, Kollam, Kerala, India
2Atreya Ayurveda, Moscow, Russian Federation
Abstract
Overview: The history of dietetics can be traced back to the era of
ancient civilizations. During the era of enlightenment when scientific and
medical development increased exponentially, the theory of nutrition was
redefined based on equations of Chemistry. But in modern era, earlier dietary
principles are being peer reviewed based on concepts like endoecology. Child and
adolescent age-group allergies are on the rise and considered a modern epidemic.
Allergic reactions to common substances represent new risks. Factors associated
with westernization, rather than urbanization, probably account for the increase
in dietary changes which lead to alteration in internal environment. Ayurveda is
a system of medicine which defines normal nutrition and metabolism as a prime
indicator of health. It explains in detail the role of impaired metabolism in
the etiopathogenesis of diseases. The functional balance of the body is
maintained by 3 factors (Dosha) called Vata,
Pitta, and Kapha. Dosha
represents a group of functions in the body. Kapha when normal
provides normal growth and immunity and has prime role in respiratory sytem.
Childhood and adolescence being the age of growth and development,
Kapha is naturally predominant in this age-group. Ayurveda
explains how improper diet and metabolism in children vitiates
Kapha, leading to abnormal immune reactions and respiratory
disorders. It classifies food products based on their specific properties and
what role they have in the etiopathogenesis of diseases. Rule of dietetics
prohibits the use of specific food products with respect to 5 factors—Dosha,
age, stage of digestion, season, and disease. Thus, the concept of diet in
Ayurveda is highly individual and sophisticated which follows dynamic changes in
the internal body and external environment. This concept is unique based on
specific dietary principles. These principles help to modify the intrinsic
factors of allergy with respect to the changes in external environment
Rationale: Allergies are on the rise and considered a modern
epidemic. Allergic reactions to common substances represent new risks. Factors
associated with westernization, rather than urbanization, probably account for
the increase in dietary changes with more use of processed foods which lead to
alteration in internal environment. The ancient cultures like India, Egypt, and
China had highly developed medical systems in practice. These systems in place
even before 2000 BC, had defined day-to-day dietary practices of the people in
detail. Currently body of evidence is mounting that diet may play an important
role in respiratory diseases such as asthma. There have been very few randomized
controlled trials, so it is difficult to estimate the effect that these
suggestions might have. The concept of diet in Ayurveda is highly individual and
sophisticated which follows dynamic changes in the internal body and external
environment. These principles can help to modify the intrinsic factors of
allergy with respect to the changes in external environment and can provide
better outcome.
Objectives: The concept of dosha in Ayurveda and its physiology in
respiratory system will be explained. The discussion will provide an outlook
into the dietary principles of Ayurveda and rules of dietetics in Ayurveda. The
etipathogenesis of allergic disorders will be explained based on Ayurvedic
parameters. Practical application of Ayurvedic dietetics in the clinical
practice of allergic disorders will be explored.
(3623) How Effective Is Music Therapy for Chronic Noncancer Pain? A Systematic
Review and Meta-analysis
Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1, Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD, PhD1,
Ting-An Tsai1, Michelle Park, BA1 and Jan Vagedes,
MD2
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2ARCIM Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine,
Filderstadt, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic pain affects 33% of the U.S. population.
Pharmacological treatment risks adverse events, ineffectiveness, and addiction.
Complementary and integrative options are needed. Evidence suggests that music
therapy alleviates acute and cancer-related pain. However, its benefits for
chronic pain are unknown. We systematically review the preliminary effect of
music therapy for chronic pain.
Results: Our systematic search yielded 26 relevant studies. Eight
studies (published 2002–2016, total n=503, 77% women) met inclusion criteria
(Table 1). Mean age was 48 years. Treatment durations ranged from 1 to 16 weeks.
Sample sizes varied between 37 and 87. Two studies included patients with
fibromyalgia, 1 with osteoarthritis, 1 with low back pain, 1 with primary
headache disorders, and 3 with unspecified chronic pain. Six trials compared
music listening with usual care, 1 compared vocal music therapy with usual care,
and 1 compared vocal music therapy with music listening. Compared with control
interventions, music therapy was associated with significant improvement in pain
in all 8 studies. Three studies reported improved anxiety and 5 reported
improved depression. We found a pooled effect size of −0.58 (95% confidence
interval (CI): −1.03, −0.12) for pain favoring music therapy over control
(Figure 1(A)). We found significant effects favoring music therapy for
depression −0.67(95% CI: −1.15, −0.19) (Figure 1(B)) and anxiety −0.90 (95% CI:
−1.66, −0.13) (Figure 1(C)).
Conclusions: Music therapy may be effective in alleviating chronic
pain. Future studies should be performed to deepen our understanding of this
therapeutic modality.
(3629) Efficacy of Curcumin and Boswellia for Knee Osteoarthritis: Systematic
Review and Meta-analysis
Mikala C Osani, BS1, Timothy E McAlindon, MD, MPH1, Raveendhara
R Bannuru, MD, PhD1 and Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The unfavorable safety profiles of many of the treatments
commonly prescribed for knee osteoarthritis (OA) have led clinicians to seek
safer alternatives for symptom management. Research has suggested that
curcuminoid and boswellia formulations could impede the action of key
inflammatory mediators in early knee OA and block inflammatory pathways
associated with disease progression. We conducted a systematic review and
meta-analysis to assess the efficacy and safety of these treatments versus
placebo or NSAIDs for knee OA.
Results: Ten RCTs (N = 875) were eligible for analysis. Study
quality was low overall, and most included RCTs were conducted on fewer than 100
participants. Both curcuminoid and boswellia formulations were statistically
significantly more effective than placebo for pain relief and functional
improvement (Figure 1). There were no significant differences between
curcuminoids or boswellia and placebo in safety outcomes. Curcuminoids showed no
statistically significant differences in efficacy outcomes compared to NSAIDs;
patients receiving curcuminoids were significantly less likely to experience
gastrointestinal adverse events. No RCTs compared boswellia against approved
NSAIDs.
Conclusions: The results of our study indicate that both curcuminoid
and boswellia formulations are significantly more effective than placebo in
relieving the symptoms of knee OA and do not pose significant safety risks.
Generalizability of our results may be limited by the quality and duration of
the available RCT evidence. With more robust research, it may be possible to
investigate a synergistic effect between curcuminoid or boswellia formulations
and other OA treatments.
(3630) Outcome Expectations and Fibromyalgia: Perceived Benefits of Exercise Are
Associated With Self-Efficacy and Physical Performance
Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1, Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD, PhD1,
Jolanta Marszalek, MD1, Gerald Chi, MD2 and Lori L Price, MAS,
MLA1
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Outcome expectancy is recognized as a determinant of
exercise engagement and adherence. Higher outcome expectations for exercise
(OEE) have been shown to correlate with greater motivation to exercise in
patients with osteoarthritis. However, little is known about which factors may
influence OEE in fibromyalgia. This is the first study to examine the
associations between baseline OEE and demographic, physical and psychosocial
variables in patients with fibromyalgia.
Results: Participants had a mean age of 51.8 years and body mass
index of 30.0 kg/m2, 92.5% were female, 61.1% were white, and 36.0%
possessed at least college-level education. Compared to the lower OEE group,
individuals with a higher OEE were more likely to have a greater self-efficacy
(5.7 ± 2.2 vs 4.8 ± 2.0; P = .001) and physical performance as
assessed by 6-min walk distance (meters) (423.8 ± 85.8 vs 382.2 ± 77.6;
P < .001) or SF-36 physical component (31.8 ± 7.0 vs
29.6 ± 8.0; P = .029). There were no other significant
associations.
Conclusions: Our study found that higher OEE was significantly
associated with greater self-efficacy and physical performance. Future
longitudinal research should explore how these relationships affect long-term
exercise engagement for patients with fibromyalgia.
(3632) Protocol of a Comparative Effectiveness Feasibility Trial of a
Mindfulness-based Intervention for Insomnia Among Breast Cancer Survivors
Daniel Lewin, PhD1, Elizabeth Goldberg, LMT2, Gabriella Cifu,
MPH2, Mikhail Kogan, MD2 and Hannah Arem,
PhD2
1Children’s National Health System/GW School of Medicine, Washington,
DC
2Washington, DC
Abstract
Purpose: Breast cancer survivors suffer from late and long-term
effects of cancer diagnosis and treatment, including insomnia. While Cognitive
Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I) is considered to be the gold standard to
address insomnia, it is not widely accessible to cancer survivors due to limited
numbers of practitioners and complicated insurance requirements. This study
aimed to compare effectiveness of CBT-I with a mindfulness-based intervention,
which included complementary and alternative medicine techniques. We
hypothesized that this mindfulness intervention would prove acceptable, be
feasible, and improve insomnia symptoms among women who had completed breast
cancer treatment.
Results: Preliminary results suggest high acceptability of the
mindfulness intervention to address insomnia among breast cancer survivors.
Among the women enrolled in the first group, participants overall attended 85.7%
of the sessions. Early feedback on content indicates more favorable responses to
sleep hygiene, breathing techniques, nutrition, yoga, and guided meditation. The
study will be completed by March 2018.
Conclusions: The results of this study will be used to inform the
design of future insomnia intervention efficacy studies among breast cancer
survivors to optimize mindfulness-based interventions.
(3637) Modeling Spinal Manipulative Therapy for Studies of Analgesia in Chronic
Experimental Pain
Bradley K Taylor, PhD1, Renee R. Donahue, MS1, Qian Li,
MS2, Randall S Sozio, BS2, Danielle M DiCarlo,
BS2, Cynthia R Long, PhD2 and Stephen M Onifer,
PhD2
1University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky
2Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
Abstract
Purpose: Treatments of low velocity variable amplitude spinal
manipulation (LVVA-SM) improve pain in chronic low back pain patients,
especially those with neuropathic radiating leg pain following peripheral
nervous system insult. Despite the analgesic effectiveness of this nonthrust
spinal manipulative therapy, no one has reverse-translated these findings to
animal models. The present study addresses this gap using a reductionist
approach.
Results: SNI produced behavioral signs of mechanical and cold
allodynia. LVVA-SM reduced mechanical hypersensitivity as compared to Control
LVVA-SM (0.15 Hertz: P = .04 at 10 min; 0.16 Hertz:
P < .001 at 10 min, P = .04 at 25 min).
LVVA-SM did not change cold hypersensitivity.
Conclusions: We reverse-translated the analgesic effect of LVVA-SM
in chronic low back pain patients with neuropathic radiating leg pain to an
animal model. We will use this model to investigate underlying mechanisms of
LVVA-SM analgesia, such as the technique’s components and activity-dependent
neurotransmitter systems modulating spinal cord activity.
(3640) Meditation and Health, Prospective Case Analysis Study
Petere Hudoba, MD1, 2
1Sha Research Foundation, San Francisco, California
2Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada
Abstract
Purpose: Over last years, researchers are increasingly turning their
attention to alternative healing methods like prayer, meditation, Qi Gong, Yoga,
reiki, and similar. From our point of view, these techniques have much wider
effects on human beings than simply the alleviation of symptoms of illness. We
feel that in order to advance the field, it is necessary to use standard medical
research instruments that can capture not only the changes in symptoms, but
changes documented by medical professionals also.
Results: Fifty-five subjects have been observed for past 3 years, 42
of them continued up to the end of the study, 4 has died before end of the
study. They have been suffering from various types of illness raging from
addiction, psychiatric illnesses, neurologic illnesses up to cancer in various
stage. Retrospective analysis of data shows that most of the patients exhibited
improvement in general well-being, an increase in optimism and energy level, as
well as improvement of their symptoms. Twenty-one (45.6%) reported marked
improvement or complete recovery, 16 (34.8%) moderate improvement, 3 (6.8%)
minimal improvement, 2 (4.3%) unchanged or continued to deteriorate, and 4
(8.7%) died (terminal cancers and a stroke). Detailed analysis of the data will
be discussed during the presentation.
Conclusions: The study treatment was well tolerated and no
complications arose. The results of this study confirmed efficacy of combining
Meditation and Qi Gong healing with conventional medical treatment.
(3641) Can Psychological Resilience Decrease Symptoms of Pain and
Fatigue?
Tej Khalsa, MD, MSc, FRCP1, Cindy Kermott, MD1 and Amit Sood,
MD, MSc, FACP1
1Rochester, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: To examine the association of resilience with pain and
fatigue in a cross-sectional survey.
Results: A total of 3188 survey responses were recorded. The final
cohort for this study (n = 1954) comprised participants who were currently
employed executives or other business professionals and answered all 10 CD-RISC
items. Executives with the highest resiliency scores had the fewest experiences
of pain: mean of 2.7 (SD 2.5) for resilience scores less than 30, mean 2.6 (SD
2.6) for resilience scores 30–34, and mean 2.3 (SD 2.5) for resilience scores of
35 or greater (P = .0262). Severity of pain also decreased with
increasing resilience scores (mean 2.1 (SD 1.9) for resilience scores less than
30, mean 2.0 (SD 2.0) for resilience scores 30–34, and mean 1.7 (SD 1.8) for
resilience scores of 35 or greater; P = .0005). Those with
higher resilience scores also experienced less fatigue (mean 4.1 (SD 2.2) for
resilience scores less than 30, mean 3.2 (SD 2.1) for resilience scores 30–34,
and mean 2.7 (SD 2.3) for resilience scores of 35 or greater;
P < .00011).
Conclusions: Observational data suggests higher resilience is
associated with lower pain frequency, lower pain severity, and lower fatigue.
Although this study cannot infer causality, testing the efficacy of resilience
training on symptoms of pain and fatigue will be a worthwhile next step, given
the prevalence and societal impact of chronic pain.
(3642) Incorporate Oriental Medicine Treatment to Conventional Psychiatric Clinic
for Secondary Insomnia
Yumin Cho, PhD1 and Sanghyun Lee, MS2
1Los Angeles, California
2Insight Choices, West Hollywood, California
Abstract
Purpose: Insomnia is one of the common side effects of
antidepressant. Incorporate oriental medicine to conventional psychiatry
practice to reduce secondary insomnia.
Results: According to ISI, among 10 patients who have improvement in
1 to 10 visits from 13.5 (subthreshold insomnia) to 6.8 (no clinically
significant insomnia) changed from 4 patients to 2 patients with clinical
insomnia, 4 to 2 with subthreshold, and 2 to 6 patients without clinical
insomnia. 7 patients with medication changed from 15 (clinical insomnia) to 8.1
(subthreshold) while nonpsychiatric medication patients changed from 10 to 3.6.
Result from another 4 patients is shown average from 5.6 to 9.8 include 2 with
jet lag of international trips, 1 with increased dosage of risperidone from 1 mg
to 2 mg, and 1 patient with change career.
Conclusions: Oriental medicine include acupuncture, cupping, and
recommendation of lifestyle is helpful to decrease insomnia level for patients
with medication and without medication. In the future study, outside source that
might influence include change medication and dosage, include control group of
insomnia without treatment, cortisol level measurement as biomarker, specify
types of antidepressant and increase population needs to be included.
(3644) Centella Asiatica Extract Improves Cognition in 2 Mouse Models of
Alzheimer’s Disease
Maya Caruso, BS1, Kirsten Wright, ND, MS1, Joe Quinn,
MD1, Don Don Matthews, PhD1, Nora Gray, PhD1,
Amala Soumyanath, PhD1 and Christopher Harris, BS1
1Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose:
Centella asiatica (CA) is a traditional botanical medicine
believed to enhance memory. We have reported that CA water extract (CAW)
protects neuroblastoma cells and primary neurons from beta amyloid (Aβ) toxicity
in vitro. The presence of Aβ plaques in the brain are a hallmark pathological
feature of Alzheimer’s disease (AD). We therefore examined the effects of CAW on
memory in the Tg2576 and 5xFAD transgenic mouse models of AD which develop brain
Aβ plaques and show learning and memory deficits. Tg2576 mice develop plaques by
18 to 20 months of age, whereas 5xFAD animals develop them earlier, by 5 to 7
months of age.
Results: Untreated Tg2576 animals showed memory deficits compared to
WT littermates in both the NORT (P < .01) and CFR tests
(P < .05) confirming a genotype effect. CAW (2 mg/ mL)
improved memory of Tg2576, but not WT littermates, in both the NORT
(P < .05) and CFR (P < .05)
paradigms. Untreated 5xFAD mice differed from WT mice in the CFR test
(P < .05) but not in the NORT. CAW dose dependently
improved behavior of 5xFAD animals in the CFR test at 2 mg /mL
(P < .01) and 5 mg/mL (P < .001),
but only the higher dose improved memory in WT littermates
(P < .05). A nonsignificant trend to improved memory was
seen in the NORT for the 5xFAD mice at 5 mg/mL CAW.
Conclusions: CAW improved cognition in 5xFAD and Tg2576 mice,
supporting its traditional use as a memory enhancer and its potential utility in
treating Alzheimer’s Disease.
(3645) Combination-guided Meditation and Yoga and Medical Student Stress
Reduction
Brenna Beck, BA, Sheena MEd1, Delia Patel, BS1, Zofia
Chiaramonte, MD1 and Kozak, BS1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Background: Medical students regularly experience high levels of
stress related to high-stakes testing, sleep deprivation, and demanding
schedules. This places students at particularly high risk for the ill-effects of
elevated stress, including depression, substance abuse, and overall
deterioration of mental health. The benefits of mindfulness or guided meditation
and physical exercise on stress levels are well documented. We hypothesize that
self-reported stress in medical students at a U.S. medical school would decrease
after participation in combination guided meditation and yoga sessions.
Program Description/Teaching Point: An 8-week program of weekly 1-h
sessions has been made available to first and second year medical students at a
U.S. medical school for the past 2 years, including guided mindfulness
meditation combined with yoga practice, led by a physician trained in these
techniques. The program, sponsored by the medical student-led Complimentary and
Integrative Medicine Interest Group (CIMIG) occurs twice yearly. To date, the
efficacy of these sessions in reducing stress among students has not been
studied. A simple web-based self-reporting tool has been designed for use in the
upcoming program. Participants will be prompted to report relative stress on a
10-point Likert-type scale prior to beginning the program as a baseline, before
and after each session, and following the completion of the 8-session program.
We hypothesize that self-reported stress among students will decrease following
session participation.
Conclusion: A combination program of weekly mindfulness meditation
and yoga practice for medical students has been implemented; however, the
effects of these sessions have not been studied. The student leadership of CIMIG
has designed and implemented this project to measure self-reported stress among
medical student participants in these stress-reduction activities.
(3646) From Cookie Cutter to Compassionate Care: The Story of Innovation and
Design to Integrate Care Delivery Across the Hospital
Joanne Miller, DNP, RN, NEA-BC1, Caroline Shafa, MHA2 and
Harpreet Gujral, NP3
1Sibley Memorial Hospital, Johns Hopkins University, Washington, DC
2Washington, DC
3Sibley Memorial Hospital, Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: Through use of cutting edge, design thinking; this
hospital is unique with a dedicated physical space for Innovation. Even the
mission statement is the byproduct of codesigning, cocreating within various
stakeholders including engaging patients, physicians, hospital staff, and
leadership. The mission is to deliver excellence and compassionate care—every
person, every time. The vision is to be the role model for innovation in health
care and wellness for all. By using human-centered design to solve clinical
problems/issues while engaging all stakeholders including the patients/family
members, several solutions have been achieved by simple process of inspiration,
ideation, and implementation in clinical practices. Hospital-wide initiatives to
care for patients, families, and staff include “About Me boards” in patient
rooms, a Tranquility room for staff, and a meditation garden for patients,
families, and employees. Beginning various team meetings and huddles with a
3-min meditation, purposeful optimal healing environment, healthy food options,
and employee gymnasium for well-being are ways to enhance compassionate care
while using Relationship-based Care model as framework. By implementing these
innovative practices to cultivate well-being and resilience among employees;
collaboration is constantly stimulated. Interprofessionalism is being promoted
via various interprofessional committees to solve clinical problems including
managing patient’s symptoms using guided imagery, acupuncture, essential oils,
yoga, meditation classes, and so forth. This organically has created a fertile
ground for delivering compassionate care as we aim to reduce the opioids use to
manage our patients’ symptoms. The human-centered design process along with
incorporating various integrative modalities has been the basis for creating and
incorporating various ideas to improve the compassionate care delivery model
while caring for the team members. We continue to aspire to be the workplace
where innovation is the foundation to target wellness for all.
Rationale: Clinical innovative initiatives are vital to not only
meet the needs of the patients and their loved ones but allow
caregivers/health-care providers to stay inspired, passionate, and resilient.
Quadruple Aim is no longer a novel concept. It is important to ensure that the
clinicians and other health-care workers have resources to learn creative ways
for solving routine or complex problems/issues using human-centered design
approach and to learn ways for caring themselves while at work.
Objectives: The aim is to learn use of human-centered design
approach in any setting for solving problems (clinical and systems issues) and
be the change agents; experience a quick design sprint to learn this method can
be replicated. (time permiting); gain various strategies to solve clinical
problems by learning various examples of current practice at this unique
hospital with Innovation hub; and learn ways to take care of self and others
while at work.
(3648) Evaluating Stress Among Medical Students After Combined Physical Activity
and Teaching Sessions With School Children
Brenna Beck, BA, MEd1 and Jacqueline A Krevitz, BA1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Background: Medical students regularly experience high levels of
stress related to high-stakes testing, sleep deprivation, and demanding
schedules. This places students at particularly high risk for the ill-effects of
elevated stress, including depression, substance abuse, and overall
deterioration of mental health. The benefits of physical exercise on stress
levels are well documented. We hypothesize that participation in physically
active games combined with positive interactions with young students will reduce
self-reported stress in medical students.
Program Description/Teaching Point: An ongoing program at a U.S.
medical school is described, consisting of weekly 2-h sessions led by medical
students at a local elementary school. Sessions include 1 h of physical activity
including outdoor games. Following exercise, a second hour consists of
preplanned lessons covering general wellness topics taught by medical students.
This student-led program has been ongoing for 5 years throughout the spring and
fall semesters. To date, the efficacy of these sessions in reducing stress among
students has not been studied. A simple web-based self-reporting tool has been
designed for use during the upcoming program. Participants will report relative
stress on a 10-point Likert-type scale prior to beginning the program as a
baseline, before and after each session, and following the completion of the
year-long program. Stress levels will then be reassessed among participants
during the following school year. We hypothesize that self-reported stress among
students will decrease following session participation, and that relative stress
levels will remain lower relative to baseline over time.
Conclusion: A program of weekly sessions led by medical students at
a local elementary school combining physical activity and wellness lessons has
been implemented. The second year medical student leaders of this program have
designed this study and aim to measure self-reported stress among medical
students before and after participation in these sessions.
(3653) Disclosure Patterns of Concomitant Use of Conventional and Complementary
Medicine to Health-care Providers Within the General Population and Among
Individuals With Chronic Health Conditions
Amie Steel, PhD, ND1, Hope M Foley, BHSc (Nat) (Hons)2 and Jon
Adams, PhD3
1Endeavour College of Natural Health, University of Technology Sydney,
Brisbane, Australia
2Endeavour College of Natural Health, University of Technology Sydney,
Sydney, Australia
3University of Technology Sydney, Sydney, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Concomitant use of conventional and complementary medicine
(CM) is common. There are risks associated with unmanaged concomitant use and
potential benefits when such use is appropriately managed. This is particularly
true for individuals with chronic conditions who more commonly engage in
concomitant use. However, individuals utilising both conventional and CM do not
always disclose concomitant use to health-care practitioners, increasing
potential for adverse outcomes and hindering access to potential benefits. This
study assesses rates of disclosure of CM to conventional practitioners, and of
conventional medicine to CM practitioners within the Australian general
population, alongside comparison of disclosure rates between individuals with
and without diagnosed chronic conditions.
Results: Full sample comprised 2019 respondents. Rates of full
disclosure of CM use to conventional practitioners were reported as 71.5% to
specialist doctors, 68.6% to GPs, 61.2% to hospital doctors, and 50.5% to
pharmacists. Individuals with chronic conditions were significantly more likely
to disclose CM use to conventional practitioners (P = .004 GPs,
P = .004 hospital doctors, P = .005
pharmacists, P = .024 specialist doctors). Rates of full
disclosure of conventional medicine to CM practitioners were substantially lower
(41.9% to chiropractors, 38.5% to massage therapists and naturopaths, 35.6% to
acupuncturists, 32.2% to traditional Chinese medicine practitioners, 28.9% to
homeopaths).
Conclusions: Disclosure rates of CM use to conventional providers in
Australia have substantially improved over the last decade. However, CM
practitioners are encouraged to initiate discussion with patients about
conventional medicine use to reduce risks and optimise benefits of concomitant
use.
(3659) Medicinal Cannabis and Cancer: A Narrative Systematic Literature
Review
Danielle Brown1, Janet Schloss, PhD1 and Amie Steel, PhD,
ND2
1Endeavour College of Natural Health, Brisbane, Australia
2Endeavour College of Natural Healthm, University of Technology Sydney,
Brisbane, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Medicinal cannabis (Cannabis sativa) and its use by cancer
patients has been brought to the forefront in many countries due to new
legislation. The potential benefits of medicinal cannabis for cancer symptom
relief have been subject to a number of government reviews in addition to public
debate in recent years. Currently, there is evidence for medicinal cannabis use
for individuals with cancer in the managment of nausea and vomiting, as
adjunctive analgesic for severe pain, and as an appetite stimulant. However, to
date there is no systematic literature reveiw which comprehensively examines the
current research regarding medicinal cannabis in all cancers and cancer-related
symptoms.
Results: The results found that medicinal cannabis shows promise in
assisting patients with cancer for various symtomology, in addition to having
potential anticancer activity. Trials have confirmed benefits for nausea and
vomiting, pain and appetite stimulation, potential anticancer actions (in vitro
and in vivo), reduction of seizure activity, and sleep assistance.
Conclusions: This review indicates that further clinical trials are
required to ascertain the benefits of medicinal cannabis as well as the dosage,
ratio of cannabinoids for different symptoms or cancers, timing, potential
interactions and targeted populations most appropriate for this herbal
medicine.
(3664) Initial Experience With Tai Chi and Meditation With Long-term Inpatients
in a Psychiatric Facility
Maya Armstrong, oh
Abstract
Overview: This presentation will summarize the experience and
highlight successes from a 12-session pilot program using meditation and a
short-form of tai chi in stable, long-term inpatients on a forensics unit in a
psychiatric facility.
Patients: History of arrest (alleged crimes typically violent in
nature) committed to the facility as part of a competency restoration program,
which may last months to years. Diagnoses include schizophrenia, bipolar
disorder, and various personality disorders. Patients are relatively stable on
medical therapy.
Program: The program, which is voluntary and in addition to their
regular daily activities and therapies, consists of weekly 1-h sessions,
consisting of approximately 30 to 35 min of tai chi, 10 to 20 min of guided
meditation, and 10 to 15 min of written reflection and/or discussion, all of
which are grounded with words and movements that reinforce healing intentions,
mindfulness, and self-care.
Rationale: This project embodies the theme of “Collaboration in
Action.” First, the setting—inpatient care and rehabilitation of individuals
with chronic mental health issues—requires a collaborative, team-based approach,
involving physicians, nurses, and a variety of mental health professionals, as
well as the patients and their families. Second, this project combines clinical
experience, potential for research, and implications for policy. Third, it
highlights the collaborative nature of integrative therapies and their role in
the recovery process for individuals with mental health problems.
Objectives: The aim is to summarize the key components of tai chi
and meditation and explain their utility in the inpatient management of complex
mental health conditions; identify other settings in which similar approaches
may provide benefit for physical and mental health; and access resources to aid
in the development of clinical programs utilizing meditation and/or tai chi.
(3666) Effectiveness and Safety of the New Percutaneous Release Technique Cutting
Knife for the Stenosal Tendosynovitis: A Randomized, Participants-Blinded, Active
Controlled Parallel Trial
Changxin Liu1, Xiyou Wang1, Tao Luo1 and Changhe Yu,
PhD1
1Dongzhimen Hospital, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing,
China
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness and
safety of the new percutaneous release technique cutting knife for the stenosal
tendosynovitis.
Results: A total of 120 participants were included and divided into
each group with 60 patients, where there was not across the groups. All 119
participants completed the trial and analyzed for intentional analysis (ITT).
The trigger Week 27 cure rate for patients in the intervention group was 91.70%
(55/60), while the control group was 65.00% (39/59). There was significant
difference between 2 groups (P < .001). After the treatment,
the indices NRS, ROM, and sign of trigger digits of both groups were
significantly improving with the time. The intervention group showed proved
superior to the control group in the indices of NRS, ROM, and signs. No adverse
events or complication happened in both groups.
Conclusions: The cure rate of cutting knife treating stenosal
tendosynovitis was high. Besides, cutting knife could also relieve the pain,
release the joints’ range of motion, reduce the sign of trigger digits, and the
effectiveness could last as least 27 weeks after only one treatment, without any
safety problems. The trial offered evidence of the cutting knife for stenosal
tendosynovitis.
(3668) Factors Affecting Patients Participation in and Completion of Acupuncture
Clinical Trials: A Cross-sectional Survey
JianPing Liu, PhD1, Yajing Zhang1, Huijuan Cao, PhD1
and Xinlin Li1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To explore factors influence on patients participating in
and completing acupuncture trials.
Results: All participants with the age of 15–85 years completed the
survey. When investigating patients’ attitude towards enrolling in a trial, the
therapeutic effect and the safety of the intervention were thought (by 92% and
96% respondents, respectively) as important deciding factors. For surveyed
participants, only 40 of them (8.0%) had involved in clinical trials before, the
LRA showed they paid more attention to treatment regimen (frequency and session
of treatment) when deciding whether joining in trials (OR 1.54, 95% CI 1.02 to
2.34). Multivariate LRA showed that elder people took cost (OR 1.36, 95% CI 1.09
to 1.70) as a more important factor; the participants used medical insurance (OR
1.45, 95% CI −0.20 to 0.93) preferred to think informal consent was important;
meanwhile, participants with higher education level preferred to regular
follow-up (OR 1.16, 95% CI 0.02 to 0.28).
Conclusions: The effect, safety of the intervention and treatment
regimen of a trial would be important factors for patients on deciding whether
to join in or complete acupuncture studies. Other factors, such as cost or
consent, should be given special consideration according to specific demographic
characteristics.
(3669) A Pilot Trial Examining the Absorption of Oral Forms of Folic Acid
Supplementation in a Healthy Population
Janet Schloss, PhD1, Jessica Bayes1 and Nitish Agrawal,
PhD1
1Endeavour College of Natural Health, Brisbane, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this trial is to investigate the absorption
of three different oral folate supplments in healthy individuals. The aim is to
see if there is any difference between the different forms in absorption and
utilisation. Considering folate supplements are frequently prescribed by health
professionals, the oral asbsorption of the three main forms of folate is
unknown, which is an important factor for clinical relevance.
Results: A total of 31 participants were randomised with 1
participant excluded due to being found deficient in folate (5.3 ug/L). Of
these, 4 participants were found to have both MTHFR mutations, 7 had A1298C
mutation, 9 had C6777T, and 4 had no MTHFR mutations. The control group serum
levels were consistent with little variation over the 4 weeks. Within the
intervention groups, all saw an increase in absorption with variations noted
both in form and in those participants with MTHFR mutations.
Conclusions: Oral supplements of folate, folinic acid and 5-MTHF all
show absorption over 4 weeks. For healthy individuals who have a MTHFR genetic
mutation, absorption can vary depending on the folate form and their genetic
mutation. Further studies are required, but this study showed that absportion
varied depending on the folate form and if the person had a MTHFR mutation.
Trial number: ACTRN12617001033336
Protocol number: 20170761
(3674) A Pilot Study of a Mindfulness Website for Teachers and Classrooms:
DeStress Mondays
Tamar Mendelson, PhD1, Lindsey Webb, MS, MHS1 and Erica
Sibinga, MD1
1Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Research has begun to highlight the positive effect of
mindfulness instruction for teachers in need of resources to reduce stress.
However, issues arise in the logistics of implementing mindfulness programming
to primary school teachers, as they face the barriers of limited time and
competing priorities. The aim of this study was to examine the feasibility and
acceptability of a website designed to provide teachers with mindfulness
practices that could be used for self-care, as well as in the classroom with
students. Additionally, the study aimed to explore the potential impact of
website practices on teachers' mental and physical well-being.
Results: Across the three schools, 50 teachers participated in the
baseline survey (82% female, 52% African American). A majority of the teachers
who participated in the postprogram survey (n = 41), reported
using the website practices at least 1–3 times during the study period for
self-care (85.3%) or in the classroom (65.9%). Significant pre–post differences
were seen in several variables, including a decrease in work-related stress
(P = .001), perceived stress (P = .01),
depression (P = .001), and anxiety (P = .02),
as well as an increase in overall sleep quality (P = .001).
Conclusions: Results from this pilot pre-post study provide
preliminary evidence that the practices delivered by a mindfulness website may
help improve the mental health and well-being of primary school teachers. Future
research should focus on further evaluating web-based delivery methods for
mindfulness interventions and practices to teachers using control groups, larger
sample sizes, and longitudinal study designs.
(3677) Prospective Safety Evaluation of a Dietary Supplement Commonly Recommended
by Integrative Health-care Providers to Support Blood Pressure Levels
Jennifer J Ryan, ND, MS1, Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH1, Janae Taylor,
BA1 and Douglas A Hanes, PhD1
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to prospectively evaluate the
safety of a popular herbal-mineral supplement that is commonly recommended by
many integrative health-care providers to support healthy blood pressure levels.
Although the study product has been on the market since 1993, no formal safety
studies had previously been conducted on the finished product.
Results: There were no serious adverse events. Of 30 participants
who began the study, 19 completed the 6-month study visit, 9 dropped out citing
potential side effects (most frequently nasal congestion or fatigue), 1 was
withdrawn, and 1 was lost to follow up. Outcomes with at least a medium effect
size (d > 0.5) included serum potassium, PHQ-9 score, systolic blood
pressure, and diastolic blood pressure. A slight increase in potassium (within
normal reference ranges) was significant (P < .05) and
decreases in systolic and diastolic blood pressure were highly significant
(P < .0001).
Conclusions: These results suggest that the investigated blood
pressure support supplement is safe in adults with blood pressure readings
consistent with pre-hypertension and stage I hypertension. Aspects of this study
may serve as a model for the long-term, rigorous monitoring of the clinical
safety of dietary supplements used by integrative health-care practitioners.
(3678) Complementary Medicine and Use of Contraception
Amie Steel, PhD, ND1
1Endeavour College of Natural Health, University of Technology Sydney,
Brisbane, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: The choice of naturopathy as a career is rarely a linear
path for most members of the profession. Social norms do not lend individuals
who are interested in a career in health to move beyond the common professions
such as nursing, medicine, and pharmacy to consider complementary medicine (CM)
professions. The biography of those who decide on CM for their chosen field is
commonly more circuitous. The purpose of this study is to describe the
experiences and perceptions of individuals who have chosen naturopathy as a
career with regards to their journey to this decision.
Results: Two dominant typologies were identified: The
Accidental Tourist and the Wounded Healer.
The Accidental Tourist individual was not aware of naturopathy
as a career option until an unexpected encounter brought it to their attention.
The Wounded Healer described choosing naturopathy as a career
based on seeing the benefits of naturopathy in the management of illness,
primarily their own. Philosophical and ideological drivers found to underpin the
choice of naturopathy as a career included the alignment of naturopathic
principles with the individual’s personal philosophy and dissatisfaction with
conventional health care.
Conclusions: In line with the ever-increasing professionalization of
naturopathy in the international landscape, this study presents novel findings
about the characteristics of naturopathy as a career as perceived by individuals
within the profession. These findings may help in for policy and education
practices in an underresearched health profession.
(3680) Cohort Study of Evaluating the Outcomes of Insomnia Treated by TCM
Patterns Differentiation Among Different TCM Physicians
Changhe Yu, PhD1, Ya’nan Sun, PhD2, Liyun He, PhD3
and Baoyan Liu3
1Dongzhimen Hospital, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing,
China
2Xuanwu Hospital Capital Medical University, Beijing, China
3China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Take insomnia as an example, to evaluate the effect of
physicians’ treatment for insomnia by TCM patterns differentiation and to
analyze the difference and the characteristics of TCM physicians’ treatment.
Based on the results of former 2, the methodology was explored and established
to evaluate the effect of treatment by the TCM patterns differentiation with the
application of physicians’ cohort study.
Results: The outcome effective rates of TST and PSQI from high to
low ranks were TCM Physician C, D, B, and A. That meant the insomnia-related
symptoms were the main factors influencing the effective rates. Results of data
mining took TCM Physician A as an example that 3 core prescriptions were
analyzed based on those that the TCM physician offered. TCM patterns,
individualized treatment and changes of outcomes were obtained. Besides, the
qualitative comparisons were conduct between the results of data mining and
those the TCM physician offered. The correlation of TCM patterns, individualized
treatment and changes of outcomes from TCM Physician A was stronger than those
from either 2 TCM physicians, which proved that the TCM Physician A showed high
self-consistence in the relationship of TCM patterns, individualized treatment
and changes of outcomes, but there were large differences between either two TCM
physicians. The results proved the research hypothesis that TCM patterns
differentiation took TCM physicians as the core part, and was an individualized
diagnosis and treatment process of high correlation of TCM patterns,
individualized treatment and changes of outcomes. All above results could prove
that the methodology of cohort study design, complement, data mining, and
analyses was scientific and feasible.
Conclusions: TCM physicians as the core of the cohort study method
can evaluate the effect of different physicians’ treatment based on their TCM
patterns differentiation. Based on the effectiveness of the TCM physicians’
treatment, the regularity and characteristics of their treatment by TCM patterns
differentiation were analyzed. This method was scientific and feasible to the
research hypothesis that TCM patterns differentiation took TCM physicians as the
core part and was an individualized diagnosis and treatment process of high
correlation of TCM patterns, individualized treatment and changes of
outcomes.
(3681) Expert Consensus on the Comprehensive Individualized Protocol of Tuina
Therapy for Knee Osteoarthritis
Lunxue Qing1, Changxin Liu2, Xiyou Wang2 and Changhe
Yu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Dongzhimen Hospital, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing,
China
Abstract
Purpose: The expert consensus was researched on the comprehensive
individualized protocol of Tuina therapy for Knee osteoarthritis for future RCT
study.
Results: Based on the literature review and the interviews, the
preliminary Tuina protocol contained 3 specific Tuina treatment, whose process
showed 8, 5, and 9 manual practice, respectively. After discussions in the
expert consensus, 3 sets of specific protocols were researched on the Chinese
Tuina therapy for KOA, which indicated the individual classification based on
the KOA main symptoms. In the protocol, 75%–80% of the entries were considered
as strong recommendation and the others were weakly recommended.
Conclusions: According to the expert consensus, the comprehensive
individualized protocols of Tuina therapy for KOA are feasible and reproducible.
Thus, it is suitable for RCT as an intervention after standardization.
(3686) A Prospective, Observational Study of Complementary and Integrative Health
Approaches to Improve Pain and Functioning in Veterans: The VA PRIMIER Study
Stephanie L Taylor, PhD, MPH1, A Rani Elwy, PhD2, Dorothy N
Plumb, MA2, Shibei Zhao, MPH2, Michael G McGowan,
MA2, Nui G Brown, MA3, Wendy Westleigh, BA4,
Grace W Yan, PhD5 and Barbara G Bokhour, PhD5
1VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Los Angeles, California
2Los Angeles, California
3Greater Los Angeles VA Medical Center, Los Angeles, California
4VA New Jersey Healthcare System, East Orange, New Jersey
5Bedford, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Our objective was to replicate the BraveNet practice-based
research network’s Patients Receiving Integrative Medicine Interventions
Effectiveness Registry (PRIMIER) patient reported outcomes (PROs) study among
Veterans receiving complementary and integrative health (CIH) approaches at
Veterans Affairs (VA) medical centers.
Results: Veterans (n = 288) participated in 23 forms of CIH
approaches and completed surveys at two VA sites between 2015 and 2017. Those
who participated in tai chi (estimate = 1.62, P < .01) and
guided imagery (estimate = 4.33, P < .01) reported less
average pain and those who participated in tai chi reported less current pain
(estimate = 1.69, P < .001) than Veterans who participated
in other CIH approaches over the 12-month period. Yoga participants reported
less stress at 12 months compared to their baseline reports (estimate = 2.12,
P < .01), while those who used acupuncture reported
reductions in stress at 2 months versus baseline scores (estimate = 11.08,
P = .02). Tai chi participants reported greatest
improvements in functioning (estimate = 8.34, P < .01).
There were no significant results of CIH approaches on patients’ activation for
self-management of their health.
Conclusions: In this first longitudinal examination of CIH
approaches on Veterans’ current and average pain, perceived stress and physical
and mental health functioning, tai chi, guided imagery, yoga, and acupuncture
appear to have the greatest impact on Veterans’ patient reported outcomes over
time.
(3688) Analyzing on Mechanisms and Medication Rules of Herbal Prescriptions for
Children With Indigestion Due to Accumulated Heat in Stomach Based on Methods of
Bioinformatics
Yuxiang Wan, MD1, Li Yi Nyiam, MD1, Xia Zhang, MD1,
Chen Bai, MD1, Yunhui Wang, MD1, Tiegang Liu, PhD1,
He Yu, PhD1, Xiaohong Gu, MD1 and Zian Zheng,
PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To explore the medication rules and mechanisms in herbal
prescriptions for indigestion due to accumulated heat by the methods of data
mining and network pharmacology.
Results: Among the 150 screening prescriptions, we obtained 6 core
drug combinations and 3 new prescriptions, 9 high-frequency herbs groups of
similar properties, flavor and meridian tropism and 330 related targets. In the
network comprised with those action targets, there were 2961 actions and 137
signaling pathways (FDR < 0.01). Among those signaling pathways, there were 7
pathways had the most closely relationship with the digestive system.
Conclusions: For children with indigestion due to accumulated heat
in stomach, the commonly used therapy of TCM was ridding of retained food,
regulating qi and tonifying the spleen, and clearing heat and dampness. And its
action was achieved by the regulation of digestive juice secretion, regulation
of intestinal digestion and immunity, the body’s immune function of
microorganisms and other multitarget complex pathway.
(3690) Changes in Prescription Rates of Antimicrobials in Respiratory Departments
Between Western Medicine Hospitals and Integrative/Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hospitals Under the Stewardship
Ruixue Hu1, Xiaoying Yang1, Lingzi Wen1, Sainan
Fang1, Nanqi Zhao1, Na Huang1, Xinlin
Li1, Yu-tong Fei, MD, PhD1, Di Wang1, Yajing
Zhang1 and Baoyong Lai2
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Center for Evidence-based Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Our study aims to explore the changes of prescription rates
of antimicrobials in respiratory departments between western medicine (WM)
hospitals and integrative/traditional Chinese medicine (IM-TCM) hospitals.
Results: Two hundred fifty-eight reports were included: 238 reports
were from WM hospitals and 20 from IM-TCM hospitals. Data covered 24 provinces
and 3 municipalities in China. In east China, antimicrobial prescription rates
of IM-TCM hospitals dropped greatly during and after the stewardship, from 90%
(2 studies, 238 patients, I2 = 73%), 63% (3 studies, 1208 patients,
I2 = 94%, random) to 39% (2 studies, 1160 patients,
I2 = 95%) comparing to those of the WM hospitals, from 89% (51
studies, 15 296 patients, I2 = 98%), 77% (22 studies, 8723 patients,
I2 = 98%) to 76% (8 studies, 5751 patients, I2 = 97%).
In tertiary hospitals, the antimicrobial prescription rates in IM-TCM hospitals
responded to the stewardship better, from 93% (5 studies, 631 patients,
I2 = 82%), 81% (5 studies, 1578 patients, I2 = 97%) to
31% (1 studies,1100 patients, I2 = 94%), comparing to WM hospitals,
from 90% (91 studies, 28 407 patients, I2 = 95%), 89% (26 studies, 14
775 patients, I2 = 98%) to 79% (10 studies, 7559 patients,
I2 = 95%). Data of IM-TCM hospitals from other parts of China and
other level of hospitals were insufficient to analyze.
Conclusions: Respiratory departments in east China and in tertiary
hospitals (both IM-TCM hospitals and WM hospitals) responded to the policy
effectively. Use of TCM might reduce the noncompulsory use of antimicrobials for
patients. More data for use of antimicrobials for outpatients from secondary,
primary, and private practices and from IM-TCM health-care organizations are
needed.
(3693) Adverse Events and Adverse Drug Reactions of a Patent Chinese Herbal
Medicine: Inconsistency of Data From Literatures and Real-World State
Monitoring
Jianping Liu, PhD1, Di Wang1, Xun Li, PhD1, Ruyu
Xia1, Yutong Fei, PhD1, Ruixue Hu1 and Liqiong
Wang, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To investigate the consistency of Adverse Events/Adverse
Drug Reactions (AEs/ADRs) from the real-world state monitoring data, the whole
literature base, RCTs and non-RCTs in a patent Chinese herbal medicine (PCHM).
To explore the PCHM’s risk of biased scope of using the RCTs data rather than
monitoring data or the whole literature base in Systematic Reviews (SR) of
interventions to draw safety conclusions.
Results: Proportions of the most prevalent AE in CFDA monitoring
data, whole literature, RCT reports, and case series/case reports were
consistent. Proportions of the most prevalent ADRs were different in RCT reports
comparing with other information sources. Distributions of both symptoms and
affected system-organ disorder classes of AEs and ADRs were different between
CFDA monitoring data and literatures, with those from RCT reports varied most
from others. Data from CFDA were with better quality and relatively
comprehensive. Case series and case reports contributed important data. ADRs
looked insufficiently inference and reported in RCTs.
Conclusions: This PCHM distribution of AEs and ADRs from RCTs is the
least likely similar with the data from the monitoring system, which is largely
consistent in the most prevalent AEs/ADRs with the data from the whole
literature base or non-RCTs. For intervention systematic reviews that included
only RCTs, conclusions for safety should be drawn with special cautious.
(3698) Investigation on the Effects of Acupuncture on Cognitive Improvement Using
f-NIRS
Ho-Ryong Yoo1, Hyuntae Kim2, Eunsun Jung2, Jeongeun
Yoo, KMD, PhD2 and Jeonghyo Cho, KMD, PhD2
1Daejeon, South Korea
2Daejeon University, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Neuroimaging studies have been actively conducted to find
out neural mechanism of acupuncture therapy to influence the cognitive function.
Nonetheless, the effects or mechanism of acupuncture therapy have not been
proven on cognitive function. Therefore, this study aimed to seek the
feasibility and therapeutic mechanism of acupuncture therapy on the improvement
of cognitive function in normal subjects upon checking the changes of
hemodynamic response in prefrontal cortex in the process of working memory (WM)
task before and after the acupuncture treatment using functional near-infrared
spectroscopy. This is a preliminary study to confirm whether acupuncture
treatment is effective for patient with mild cognitive impairment.
Results: It was observed that for almost subjects, the frontal
region seems to get more active after acupuncture. A reason may be that the
subject’s feel more comfortable/relaxed after stimulation and they have to pay
more attention to the working memory task after acupuncture. An increased focus
cause an increase in ΔHbO in the frontal regions, this increase is significant
in comparison to ΔHbO changes before acupuncture. The results showed significant
changes before and after acupuncture in ΔHbO. And type-A group’s ΔHbO changes
were significantly better than those of B and control group’s measure. Also, the
working memory tasks scores for both Group A and B after acupuncture were better
in comparison to the scores achieved by the control group.
Conclusions: As the subject’s scores were better after acupuncture,
this indicates that acupuncture is effective in improving brain activity and
cognitive function.
(3705) Evaluating the Impact of Telephone and Text Message Reminders on Patient
Return to Acupuncture Follow-up Treatment: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Chih-Ping Chou, PhD1, Chun Nok Lam, MPH1, David S Black,
PhD1 and Chris Ruth, LAc, DAOM2
1Los Angeles, California
2Emperor’s College of Traditional Oriental Medicine, Santa Monica,
California
Abstract
Purpose: This study tested the relative impact of two reminder
delivery methods using telephone call and text messages to increase patient
return rates to acupuncture follow-up treatment.
Results: One hundred twenty participants (age:
M = 42 ± 13 years, 28% male) were enrolled in the study. Two
thirds (63%) received a treatment plan recommending follow-up visits. Chart
review showed that 68 participants (57%) returned for at least 1 follow-up
visits. Return rates were 58% for the call group, 58% for the text group, and
55% for the control group. Proportional differences between trial conditions did
not reach statistical significance (χ2 = 0.07,
P = .97). Logistic regression analysis showed that having a
treatment plan (OR = 2.9, 95% CI = 1.2, 7.2, P = .02) and
intention to follow-up (OR = 2.6, 95% CI = 1.3, 5.2,
P < .01) predicted patient return. Odds of patient return
was lower among participants who experienced immediate symptom improvement
(OR = 0.4, 95% CI = 0.2, 1.0, P = .04). Greater expectancy of
acupuncture was associated with intention to follow-up (beta = 0.1, 95%
CI = 0.0, 0.2, P < .01).
Conclusions: A 1-time telephone call or text message reminder did
not increase patient return rates to acupuncture follow-up treatment. Future
intervention can focus on improving intention to follow-up and expectancy of
acupuncture.
(3709) Real-time Relief of Video-induced Stress by Acupressure Stimulation of
Relaxation Points Used for Symptom Cluster
Xiaoshi Zhang, BS1, Jacqueline Nguyen, BS1, Shin Lin,
PhD1 and Jackson K Tran, BS1
1Irvine, California
Abstract
Purpose: Acupressure on 5 “relaxation points” has previously been
shown to relieve a cluster of symptoms: sleep disorder, pain, depression, and
fatigue. This study tests whether such a treatment can relieve stress induced by
horror movies in real time.
Results: Viewing of horror movies induced stress measured as
increases in heart rate from a baseline of 64.4 ± 3.6 beats/minute (mean ± SEM)
to 103.7 ± 13.4 and LF/HF from 0.8 ± 0.3 to 2.2 ± 0.7. Acupressure on Anmian
reversed these changes substantially to 83.6 ± 12.0 and 1.2 ± 0.3. Changing to
acupressure on sham point (subject blinded) partially reduced these changes to
99.3 ± 16.2 and 1.9 ± 0.2. When acupressure was on sham point followed by
Anmien, the results were essentially reversed: heart rate 60.1 ± 1.7 to
108.5 ± 1.7 to 112.5 ± 1.6 to 93.3 ± 4.1, and LF/HF 0.9 ± 0.3 to 1.4 ± 0.1 to
1.8 ± 0.4 to 0.9 ± 0.0. All of the above trends in heart rate and HRV changes
were observed in experiments on the other relaxation points SP6, LV3, HT7, and
Yin Tang.
Conclusions: The results of this study show that acupressure on all
5 “relaxation points” substantially reversed increases in heart rate and
sympathetic tone induced by watching horror movies in real time. Such stress
relief is likely an important basis of the reported efficacy for acupressure
treatment of the symptom cluster.
(3710) Addressing Concussion Symptoms With Massage and Manual Therapy
Principles
Sylvia Burns, MEd1
1Newberg, Oregon
Abstract
Overview: Concussion, its recognition, diagnosis, and treatment, is
a growing public health issue in the United States. Practitioners were
specialized in rehabilitation deal with a variety of injury cases that involve
concussions. This includes those incurred by falls, motor vehicle incidents, and
sports injuries. This session presents a unique approach using biomechanical
principles as used by massage and manual therapy to diminish concussion symptoms
and regain ease of range of motion in the cervical area.
Rationale: The treatment of concussion is important for the recovery
of function and health of the brain following a brain injury. The triage of
physical and mental conditions of the injury, evaluations of balance and
cognition, and assessment of fracture or hemorrhage is appropriate for the
medically trained physician. Following the initial event imaging and medical
work, the patient has the challenge of rehabilitation. By implementing the
massage and manual therapy principles to the case, the course of treatment may
be abbreviated and the use of pharmaceuticals minimized. This pattern of
treatment encourages the interface of all types of recovery treatment of the
patient.
Objectives: Objectives of the presentation is to understand the
anatomy/kinetics of the atlanto-occipital joint, to recognize the resulting
movement of the joint from trauma, to create an analysis of the trauma and how
the biomechanics of it affected this site, and to apply the principles of
balancing the body/posture for the rehabilitation.
(3711) Wellness Curriculum for Psychiatric Residents
A Ning Zhou, MD1, Wendy Feng, MD1, Andrea Rosati,
MD1, Erick Hung, MD1 and Stefana Morgan,
MD1
1San Francisco, California
Abstract
Background: Psychiatry residents experience many stressors including
high-pressure environments, busy schedules, financial difficulties, and
vicarious trauma. There is growing evidence for the efficacy of integrative
approaches for improving well-being as well as for prevention and treatment of
mental health issues. Over the past 3 years, the University of California, San
Francisco (UCSF) Department of Psychiatry has designed, piloted, and refined a
resident-led Wellness Curriculum that introduces residents to evidence-based
integrative approaches they can apply to patient care and allows residents to
incorporate integrative practices in their busy lives.
Program Description: The curriculum aims to familiarize residents
with integrative healing approaches and resources; engage residents through
interactive, hands-on experiential exercises which allow residents to practice
integrative approaches which promote well-being; and educate residents regarding
guidelines for communication and collaboration with non-traditional
practitioners. The curriculum included 3–8 sessions annually and was designed
and led by UCSF psychiatry residents with support from the training program.
Needs assessment was accomplished at the start of every year to guide the scope
of the curriculum and respond to naturally shifting resident interests. The
curriculum began as an elective course and due to resident feedback was
eventually incorporated into the formal residency training curriculum. Each
session focused on 1 type of integrative approach which included massage,
mindfulness, yoga, tai chi, dance, music, contemplative hikes, and so forth.
Session length was about 1.5 h and started at 8 am. The sessions
included a 60-min experiential component and 30-min didactic component which
presented the evidence base for the integrative approach. In order to ensure
attendance, breakfast was provided and residents were given time off from
clinical duties.
Conclusion: The course was well received by residents. This
curriculum could be utilized as a model by other residency training programs to
support resident well-being and advance knowledge about integrative psychiatry
approaches.
Rationale: The topic of wellness and integrative approaches to
health is an emerging area of interest in psychiatry training programs.
Psychiatry residents who are educated in integrative approaches to wellness may
be able to better understand and utilize for themselves and for patients. Their
familiarity with these topics may help them work collaboratively with
practitioners of integrative, complementary, and alternative modalities.
Objectives: The participants in this presentation should be able to
identify the needs of psychiatry residents with respect to bolstering their
well-being and resilience through integrative approaches; describe the didactic
and hands-on components of the integrative approaches used in the Wellness
Curriculum at UCSF; and describe the effectiveness of the UCSF Wellness
Curriculum for psychiatry residents.
(3713) Analysis of Randomized Trials of Traditional Chinese Medicine for Cancer
From the Registry of Cochrane Complementary and Alternative Medicine Field
Chunli Lu1, Xuehan Liu1, Yuqian Yan1 and Jianping
Liu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To provide evidence-based references for scientific
research and clinical applications in treating cancer by traditional Chinese
medicine (TCM).
Results: The proportion of randomized trials in ProCite database was
43.88% (8742/19 921), cancer and cancer-related conditions accounting for 7.09%
(620/8742) of the ratio, which ranked second of all the diseases by frequency.
The proportion of randomized trials with better efficiency in the combined
treatment of TCM therapies than Western medicine therapies was 99.57% (466/468).
The proportion of randomized trials with better efficiency in TCM therapies than
Western medicine therapies was 99.19% (122/123). The proportion of randomized
trials with better efficiency in TCM therapies than blank or placebo was 100%
(15/15). The remaining 14 trials were about comparison of different TCM
therapies.
Conclusions: This study confirmed that TCM therapies have promising
effect on reducing the toxicity, prevention of tumor metastasis and recurrence,
prolong survival, and improvement of quality of life, etc. However, giving
reflection on the results, there might have a risk of publication bias. It is
very necessary to pay more attention on the transparency of future clinical
trial from protocol registration to complete reporting of all available data,
thus to avoid incomplete data reporting and selective outcome reporting. We also
suggest to provide the most promising treatment as intervention for target types
of malignant tumor or related conditions.
(3714) Effects of Milk Thistle Extract (Silibinin) on Circulating Unconjugated
Bilirubin Levels and Markers for Oxidative
Michael J Watson, PhD1, Andrew Bulmer, PhD2 and Josif Vidimce,
BSc2
1Endeavour College Natural Medicine, Gold Coast, Australia
2Griffith University, Gold Coast, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Extracts from Milk Thistle (Sylibum
marianum) have been used as medical remedies for around 2000 years.
They continue to be used as therapeutic agents in herbal medicine for the
treatment of acute and chronic liver diseases. Its effects have been shown to
due to an antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effect and have been directly
attributed to the silibinin molecule. In addition to this and consistent with an
effect on the hepatic biliary system is evidence from a number of in vitro
studies which demonstrate that an active constituent within Milk Thistle extract
called Silibinin acts as a partial UDP-glucuronosyltransferase 1A1 (UGT1A1)
inhibitor. UGT1A1 is involved in the conjugation of endogenous compounds such as
bilirubin, steroids and bile acids. Specifically, the conjugation of glucuronic
acid to these substrates increases their polarity and hence solubility so as to
facilitate their excretion from the body. Preventing bilirubin glucuronidation
through the inhibition of UGT1A1 would lead to a mild increase in the
circulating unconjugated bilirubin termed ‘mild hyperbilirubinemia’ and is of no
clinical concern. The effect of partial inhibition of UGT1A1 function is
observed in individuals with Gilbert’s syndrome, which is a harmless condition
and affects 5–10% of the general population. Individuals with Gilbert’s syndrome
present with mild hyperbilirubinemia caused by a genotypic variation in UGT1A
gene, reducing UGT1A1 activity by approximately 65%. Many clinical studies and
clearly demonstrate a dramatic reduction in the incidence of cardiovascular
disease and atherosclerosis in patients with Gilberts syndrome and attribute
this protection to elevated bilirubin concentrations. Indeed, cardiovascular
(CVD) risk reduction increases with increasing bilirubin concentrations, in
otherwise healthy individuals. A number of clinical studies also associate
mildly elevated bilirubin with a reduction in key inflammatory markers for CVD,
improvements in endothelial function, blood lipid profile and reductions in
platelet reactivity. Additional approaches to increasing bilirubin include
prescription of the anti-viral medication, Atazanivir, which is also an
inhibitor of UGT1A1. Patients treated with Atazanivir for HIV infection show an
increase in circulating bilirubin levels, which are strongly correlated with a
reduction in markers for oxidative stress. Furthermore, administration of
Atazanivir to diabetic patients without HIV improves antioxidant capacity and
vascular function. These studies provide additional evidence that increased
bilirubin, induced by UGT1A1 inhibition (identical to the mechanism of
silibinin), increases antioxidant capacity and reduces CVD risk. Atazanivir has
a number of serious side effects related to its anti-viral properties and would
be inappropriate to use in the current study. Therefore, alternative natural
UGT1A1 inhibitors with a documented safety profile, including silibinin,
represent excellent candidates for further investigation.
The aim of this pilot study will be to examine the effect of a short-term (21
days) administration of the Milk Thistle extract, Legalon® on markers for
inflammation, endothelial function, blood lipid profile and platelet reactivity
in healthy volunteers.
(3715) Chuna (or Tuina) Manual Therapy for Musculoskeletal Disorders: A
Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Nam-Woo Lee1, Eui-Hyoung Hwang, KMD, PhD1, In-Hwa
Park1, Gee-Heon Kim1, In Heo1, Koh-Woon Kim,
KMD, PhD2, In-Hyuk Ha, KMD, PhD3, Jun-Hwan Lee, KMD,
PhD4 and Byung-Cheul Shin, MD (DKM), PhD1
1Pusan National University, Yangsan, Republic of Korea
2Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
3Jaseng Medical Foundation, Seoul, Republic of Korea
4Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: To review the literature and systematically evaluate the
effectiveness of Chuna (or Tuina) manual therapy (C[T]MT) on pain and function
for musculoskeletal disorders.
Results: Sixty-six randomized controlled trials
(RCTs) with 6170 participants were included. One sham-controlled RCT showed that
C(T)MT relieved pain more effectively than a sham control (SMD: −3.09 [−3.59,
−2.59]). For active-controlled RCTs, pooled meta-analysis showed that C(T)MT had
statistically significant effects on pain reduction, especially compared to
traction (P < .00001), drugs (P = .04) and
physical therapies (P < .0001). For functional improvement,
combined effects of C(T)MT with drugs (P = .04) and traction
(P = .05) also showed similar positive effects.
Conclusions: This systematic review suggests that C(T)MT is safe and
effective for pain reduction and functional improvement for musculoskeletal
diseases; however, the evidence for functional improvement was not as strong as
for pain reduction. For future studies, high-quality RCTs such as
sham-controlled studies with standardized interventions are needed to provide
sufficient evidence on the effects of C(T)MT for musculoskeletal diseases.
(3716) Patient’s Perception for Developing Research Questions of a Clinical
Practice Guideline of Korean Medicine for Degenerative Lumbar Spinal Stenosis: A
Descriptive Cross-sectional Survey
Ji M Bae, KMD1, Kun H Kim, KMD1, Gi Y Yang, KMD1,
Byung R Lee, KMD1 and Ji W Choi, KMD1
1Pusan National University Korean Medicine Hospital, Yangsan-si, Republic
of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to explore patient’s view of
developing research questions of a clinical practice guideline of Korean
medicine for degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis.
Results: Twenty of 40 invited participants responded to the
questionnaire. Acupuncture, herbal medicine and cupping were the most frequently
used Korean medicine interventions. Fourteen patients (70%) had experienced drug
therapy (Table 1). Eighteen respondents reported that Korean medicine treatments
were helpful for their improvement, while 6 of 19 stated that Western medicine
treatments were beneficial. Among 16 patients who mentioned that research on
Korean medicine is needed, the prioritized research topics were on acupuncture
(88%), herbal medicine (45%) and bee venom acupuncture (38%) (Table 1).
Important outcomes in the view of 19 respondents included functional recovery
(65%), pain relief (50%), cost-effectiveness (20%), quality of life (15%),
safety (10%) and overall prognosis (5%). Thirteen respondents (65%) replied that
both short-term and long-term outcomes were important for them.
Conclusions: Patients’ perceptions with regard to the important
interventions and outcomes for the study of Korean medicine were explored.
Findings are not representative due to the potential selection and information
bias. Further study to reflect patients’ view on the development of the clinical
practice guidelines of Korean medicine is needed.
(3719) No One Is Ever Too Old or Weak to Set a New Exercise Goal
Jason S Chen, BS1 and Sarah Ingersoll, MS, MBA1
1Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Overview: Background: The 5K Training Team, primarily for
individuals with Parkinson disease, was inspired by the patients in a
traditional support group who knew about the benefits of exercise. But they had
excuses, the usual excuses, and did not exercise much.
Program description: When the team started 2010, it was modeled on community
teams for the able-bodied. A professional coach led off each training session
with tai-chi-based “looseners,” followed by a walk/jog and then a light lunch.
The goal for each season is participation in a community 5K. This routine has
been modified only slightly over the intervening years. The conceptual framework
has evolved to explicitly include social engineering concepts, particularly the
approach articulated by the Behavioral Insights Team, a UK social purpose
consulting company that applies behavioral science to policy. The assumption is
that decisions, such as the decision to exercise, are primarily influenced by
environment and habit. To encourage a behavior, make it Easy, Attractive,
Social, and Timely (EAST).
Teaching point: Older and frailer individuals will enthusiastically participate
in a relatively rigorous exercise program that features “nudges” and appropriate
incentives. The 5K Training Team, currently in its eighth season, is now
supported in part by the Parkinson’s Foundation and participates in MovingDay as
Team MovaDopa. “No one is ever too old or weak to set a new exercise goal.”
Conclusion: The EAST approach focuses on drivers of behavior that
health systems often neglect. This approach may serve as a model for diverse
programs that promote health and wellbeing.
Rationale: Healthy lifestyle is wonderful in theory but can be hard
to achieve in practice. Social engineering principles can inform the development
of successful efforts to encourage healthy behaviors. And healthy behaviors are
a natural fit for “Collaboration in Action.”
Objectives: The objective is to articulate the components and
conceptual framework of an exercise program that appeals to older adults with
neurologic and other challenges and that has sustained long-term participation.
A secondary objective is to encourage the application of similar techniques to
other wellness-related programs thereby championing the concept of wellness as
well as improving the health status of our patients.
Artwork citation: Roz Chast, The New Yorker, Conde
Nast.
(3723) Patent of Ophiocordyceps Sinensis (Jin Shui Bao) for Diabetic Kidney
Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Lingzi Wen1, Xia Tian1, Di Wang1, Ruyu
Xia1, Yutong Fei, PhD1, Na Huang1, Ruixue
Hu1 and JianPing Liu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Diabetic kidney disease (DKD) is one of the major chronic
complications of diabetes. Ophiocordyceps sinensis is a traditional Chinese
herbal medicine, with immune regulation, anti-bacterial, anti-tumor,
anti-oxidation, anti-aging, lower blood sugar and blood lipids, and other
extensive pharmacological effects. Jin Shui Bao (JSB) capsule (about 20 million
USD marketing per year) is a patent medicine for ophiocordyceps sinensis. We aim
to systematically evaluate the effectiveness and safety of JSB capsule in the
treatment of DKD.
Results: Literature search revealed 20 articles including 1344
participants. All included trials were with high risk of bias, specially
blinding. The inclusion of 20 articles did not directly report mortality,
progress in nephropathy, the quality of life, eGFR, and CrCl. JSB combined with
routine treatment compared to routine treatment, UAER (T: 659.7 ± 229.2; n = 30;
C: 1159.7 ± 534.7; n = 30; MD: −500.00; 95% CI: −708.17, −291.83) and (T:
56.88 ± 44.63; n = 28; C:117.25 ± 36.75; n = 28; MD: −60.37; 95% CI: −81.78,
−38.96), 24 h UP (MD: −329.30; 95% CI: −414.72, −243.88; I2 = 0%),
SCr (MD: −22.95; 95% CI: −29.28, −16.62; I2 = 18%), number of
ineffective treatment (RR: 0.35; 95% CI: 0.26, 0.48; I2 = 0%). JSB
combined with routine treatment compared to routine treatment combined with
placebo, 24 h UP (T: 610.0 ± 370.0; n = 36; C: 1210.0 ± 1090.0; n = 32; MD:
−600.00; 95% CI: −996.53, −203.47), SCr (MD: −15.72; 95% CI: −33.49, 2.04;
I2=56%), number of ineffective treatment (RR: 0.03; 95% CI: 0.00,
0.21). Adverse events were reported insufficiently. All evidence was assessed as
low certainty by GRADE approach.
Conclusions: JSB combined with routine treatment can lower UAER and
24 h UP and improve the efficiency of clinical treatment compared to routine
treatment or placebo. However, the quality of the existing evidence is low;
further development of a large sample of multi-center randomized
controlled trials is to be confirmed.
(3724) The Methodology and Methods for the Effective Treatment From the Folk to
Clinical Practice in China
Changhe Yu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Dongzhimen Hospital, Beijing,
China
Abstract
Purpose: A lot of effective therapies or treatments are been used in
the folk and showed great benefit for the patients, but they are ignored or even
denied by the modern medicine due to being less scientific or less evidence.
Even some disease that seems to be no choice for the doctor in the hospital
could be treated well by the “doctor” in the folk, due to such effective
therapies. Since 2011, it has been regarded as an important task that China
government has published the documentation to emphasize the collection and
selection of the effective treatments from the folk, and lastly to and for the
clinical practice in the hospital by the evidence-based medical methods. In
addition, not all the treatment in the folk was effective, where there was some
cheat. Thus, the methodology and methods for the selection are the key
techniques. We discussed the characteristics and the problems of the folk
treatment, offered the methods used in the selection process, and explained why
such methods were chosen.
Results: Inclusion of many categories such as herbal medicine,
acupuncture, massages, and qigong, which were totally different from the
treatment in the hospital, was the first characteristic of the folk therapies.
The second characteristic was that there was few mechanism studies for the folk
treatment, even something obeyed the knowledge we have already known. The third
was less evidence could be used to prove the safety and effectiveness. Less
evidence may resulted from that few or even no medical records were taken in the
clinic, that the records were only taken when patients showed the improvement,
that the safety of the treatment was little recorded, that little observation of
the long-term outcomes, that nearly no one compared his own treatment with the
active ones, and that the outcomes they chose for the therapeutic evaluation
were not generally accepted. The principle of the selection process was that
“qualitative and quantitative methods are combined, the observation and
experimental trials are integrated, that clarify the elements for evaluation,
and improve the levels of the evidence gradually." The reproducibility and the
authenticity are first evaluated, and then the safety, effectiveness, and
economy are evaluated. Thus, the interviews of the patients, possessors, and
practitioners, and the qualitative method clinical observation are used first to
identify the authenticity of their effectiveness. And such process also offers
the elements of the treatment, including standard of practice, the indication
and contraindication of patients, treatment courses, outcome index, and safety
problem. And then, case series were used as the observation trial to prove the
effect and safety, and to provide more indication and contraindication for the
further study. Finally, the rigorous RCT or PRCT was used to prove the efficacy
and effectiveness and the economic utility.
Conclusions: The methods in the paper could be an effective process
for the folk therapies selection, and the empirical studies should be taken to
prove that it works.
(3726) Development of a ResearchKit App Study for Menstrual Pain
Jiani Wang, MSc1, Mike Armour, PhD2, Alizé Rogge,
MSc1, Daniel Pach, MD1, Caroline Smith, PhD2
and Claudia M Witt3
1Charité—Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany
2Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
3University Hospital Zurich, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Abstract
Purpose: In recent years, the use of smartphone applications (apps)
for medical needs (mHealth) has increased rapidly. Apps are a promising tool for
people with different kinds of health conditions and may be particularly useful
to guide and support individuals in self-management strategies. In a recent
study on app-based self-acupressure for women with menstrual pain, we could show
a decrease in pain and pain medication intake in the app group compared to the
usual care group. For this study, 221 subjects were recruited on site by health
professionals in Germany from winter 2012 until summer 2014. Our aim was to
adapt the app so that it could be used internationally without recruiting on
site. It should be usable for new randomized controlled trials evaluating the
apps broader application.
Results: For a 3-armed randomized pragmatic trial, (1) self-care
recommendations plus self-acupressure, (2) self-care recommendations only, and
(3) self-acupressure only, we developed an app for Apple iOS and used new
technologies such as the programing language Swift, the Apple ResearchKit
framework, and HealthKit. In addition to questionnaires and intervention
content, the app also uses behavioral change techniques including feedback
graphs and notifications, as well as calendar features. The app supports German,
English, and Chinese. No tracking is used and the user remains anonymous. During
the whole process, app development and trial methodology simultaneously
influenced each other.
Conclusions: Designing mHealth interventional studies is a
multidisciplinary effort. Keeping study results relevant is difficult because of
the fast development of mobile technologies.
(3731) Ayurvedic Preventive Protocol for Neuro-degenerative Diseases With Special
Reference to Intranasal Administration of Medicated Oil (Nasya)
Aparna W Panikkasseril, BAMS, MD1 and Naveen C Venkallil, BAMS,
MD2
1Indian Systems of Medicine, Kollam, Kerala, India
2Atreya Ayurveda, Moscow, Russia
Abstract
Overview: Adult neurogenesis is a dynamic, finely tuned process and
subject to modulation by various physiological, pathological and pharmacological
stimuli. There have been major advances in understanding of adult mammalian
neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus and from the subventricular
zone of the lateral ventricle, the rostral migratory stream to the olfactory
bulb.
In Ayurvedic medicine, nose is considered as a major route of drug
administration. It is considered as a gate way to the head
(Shiras). Nasya karma is the special
procedure where the drug is administered through that gateway. Ayurvedic
treatment is based on the concept of Dosha – Vata, Pitta and
Kapha – functional elements of body. Neurogenesis is the
function of balanced vata and kapha. Abnormal
increase of vatha is explained as the basic factor in the
etiopathogenesis of most of the neurodegenerative diseases. Ayurvedic literature
and clinical evidences has already proved that nasya is an effective treatment
for many neurological, vascular, respiratory and musculoskeletal diseases
affecting the upper part of the body from shoulder to the head. Pratimarsa nasya
is one category of nasya where small dose of medicated oil is applied through
nose every day from 7 to 70 years of age. Medicine that is administered through
the nose reaches the vital point called sringataka where all channels related to
the eyes, ears and throat meet and then spread to the higher centers of brain.
The intranasal administration of medicines ie, Nasya helps to
control vatha and kapha. Thus
Pratimarsa Nasya can be applied as a preventive protocol in
the management of neurodegenerative disorders.
Rationale: We now witness an unprecedented situation in neurological
practice with increasing number of neurodegenerative diseases. They represent
more than a third of non-stroke neurological disorders today. Neurodegenerative
disorders manifest as diseases or syndromes with varied combinations of
cognitive, motor, sensory and autonomic dysfunctions. Currently, these are
managed with medicines and surgical methods based only on symptomatology.
Advances in stem cell biology of the adult brain and the discovery of adult
neurogenesis have raised the hope that neurodegenerative disorders such as
Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, Lewy body and Huntington's diseases etc. might
ultimately become amenable to causal therapy. Ayurvedic literature and clinical
evidences has already proved the effectiveness of Nasya in the
effective management of neurological disorders. A preventive treatment protocol
based on Nasya can be integrated into the management of
neurodegenerative disorders.
Objectives: Etiopathogenesis of neurodegenerative disorders as per
Ayurvedic principle will be explained. The benefits of Nasya
and its method of application will be explored in detail. Its possible outcome
in the management of neurodegenerative disorders will be discussed.
(3732) Feasibility of Data Collection in a Student Yoga Therapy Clinic
Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH1, Steffany Moonaz, PhD2 and Marlysa
Sullivan, MPT, C-IAYT3
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
2Maryland University of Integrative Health, Baltimore, Maryland
3Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Yoga Therapy is professionalizing through the development
of educational competencies, program accreditation, and practitioner
certification. Simultaneously, yoga research is growing in volume and rigor, yet
most yoga therapists are not exposed to research. University-based student yoga
therapy clinics provide an opportunity to gather data that will contribute to
the research literature and expose students to ongoing research. This study aims
to determine the feasibility of research data collection in a university-based
student yoga therapy clinic.
Results: Interest and engagement in research in the student yoga
therapy clinic is high, with most clients enrolling in the study. Due to the
nature of the student clinic schedule, return visits do not occur for many
participants, making outcomes data less robust. Challenges include ensuring that
data collection does not interfere with the flow of clinical encounters and
technical/logistical challenges. While students are supportive of the project,
the turn-over of students each term requires frequent orientation to study
procedures in addition to general clinic procedures. Regular meetings including
study investigators, clinic supervisors, student representatives, IT personnel,
and/or facilities staff are recommended.
Conclusions: Interest and participation in research is high for
clients utilizing a student yoga therapy clinic. Student cooperation is also
high, but some challenges exist unique to a student clinic that must be
considered during planning and data collection.
(3733) How Do Members of the Public Perceive Healing? A Qualitative Study
Paul A Dieppe, MD1, Sara Warber, MD2, Sarah Godlingay,
PhD1 and Emmylou Rahtz, PhD1
1University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
2Ann Arbor University, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Abstract
Purpose: Background: Although there is a growing body of research
about healing amongst healers and medical professionals, little is known about
how the general public conceives of healing. However, healing is an abstract
concept that can be difficult to articulate. We used creative qualitative
methods to address this gap in the literature.
Methods: We approached members of the public visiting either a
wellbeing fair or a museum. Participants used crayons to draw the first image
that came to mind when we asked, “What does the word healing mean to you?” They
explained their pictures to us and we recorded these short interviews. The
resulting pictures and interviews were analyzed by the team using a narrative
approach, with an emphasis on metaphors used.
Results: Fifty-eight people took part, across the 2 sites. The
pictures and accompanying explanations indicated that people have 3 principal
ways of understanding healing. Some saw healing as originating from a powerful
external source such as “energy,” often visually represented by the sun. Others
felt that healing came from another person, who might be a health-care
professional or an alternative healer. A third group believed that healing came
from within; that a person can heal themselves by cultivating their inner
states, although the nature of these states varied. Some in this group described
a cycle of healing and regeneration as part of healing from within. This third
group often drew hearts to represent healing. In addition to these 3 main models
of healing, some people used combinations of the models. A small number of
people described a healed state rather than a process of healing, exemplified by
wholeness, such as one’s woman’s description of “a oneness … a wholeness,
everything, holistic, looking at everything.”
Conclusions: Members of the public have nuanced and varied
understandings of the concept of healing. These different understandings build
an overall model of the many elements of healing.
(3734) Complementary and Alternative Medicine Integration into Georgian
Health-care System
Giorgi Pkhakadze, MD, PhD1, Karsten Lunze, MD, PhD2, Ilia
Nadareishvili, MD1 and Nino Tabagari, MD, PhD1
1David Tvildiani Medical University, Tbilisi, Georgia
2Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of the study was to analyze the needs to
include Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) introductory course into MD
curricula of Georgian medical schools and postgraduate education and contribute
to a framework proposal for interprofessional cooperation for step by step
integration of CAM into the health-care system.
Results: Use of CAM in Georgia was projected to be rising over the
next years, with high satisfaction, patient-to-patient spread of information,
insecurity and low trust to conventional medicine, and fear of drug side-effects
pushing the patients to seek CAM services. Patients tend to not disclose CAM
usage to their physicians and/or stop conventional treatment. Academia,
physicians' and CAM specialist are concerned about lack of cooperation and
knowledge among the stakeholders. CAM benefits are underutilized while research
and development is restricted by poor understanding on the activities of each
other. Patients' health is put at risk, while treatment lacks potential
effectiveness and cost-effectiveness it could have. Regulatory frameworks are
minimal and do not reflect the needs of the involved stakeholders.
Conclusions: CAM practice and integration into health-care system in
Georgia is seen as a field of opportunities by the stakeholders but lack of
dialog platforms, coordinating bodies and resources prevents the progress in the
problem solution. Introductory course on CAM as PCD educational component could
be considered as a first step of integration process.
(3736) On Field Intervention for Fear and Anxiety Secondary to Mexico City
Earthquake Disaster: An Observational Case Series
Leon Morales-Quezada, MD, MSc, PhD, MPH1, Diana Martinez, MD,
PhD2 and Gloria Yeh, MD, MPH3
1Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
2Trauma Center at JRI, Boston, Massachusetts
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Earthquake exposure has often been associated with
psychological distress characterized by acute fear and anxiety that may lead to
negative long-term effects on mental health. Behavioral/neuromodulation is a
novel intervention that includes (1) heart rate variability biofeedback
(HRV-BFB) which has been used in traditional settings to treat anxiety and
post-traumatic stress disorder and (2) low intensity/frequency median nerve
stimulation (MNS) based on electroacupuncture for enhancement of parasympathetic
activation. In this clinical case series, we describe preliminary effects of
HRV-BFB plus MNS to manage acute anxiety as first response treatment in an
earthquake disaster zone.
Results: From pre- to postintervention, overall Anxiety Symptoms
score decreased in all subjects (d = 2.5, SE = 0.342,
P = <.001), with improvements seen in each subscale. In
particular, sleep disturbances, one of the most severe problems detected at
baseline decreased after intervention (d = 2.3, SE = 0.298,
P = <.001). The LF/HF ratio also decreased over time
(d = 0.683, SE = 0.098, P = <.001).
Conclusions: Psychophysiological entrainment of HRV and
neuromodulation by MNS can be used in the acute setting of a natural disaster.
Behavioral/neuromodulation may be useful in mitigating symptoms associated with
anxiety and stress in subjects exposed to the acute emotional trauma of an
earthquake.
(3737) Spinal Manipulation and Exercise for Low Back Pain in Adolescents: A
Randomized Trial
Roni Evans, DC, MS, PhD1, Mitchell Haas, DC2, Brent Leininger,
DC2, Linda Hanson, DC, MS2, Craig Schulz, DC,
MS3 and Gert Bronfort, DC, PhD2
1University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Minneapolis, Minnesota
3Children’s Hospital, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: Low back pain (LBP)-related disability has increased an
alarming 42% over the past 2 decades, making it the leading cause of disability
globally. While there has been a long-standing belief that LBP is limited to
adults, there is now substantial evidence to the contrary and a paucity of
high-quality research to inform care. We conducted a multicenter randomized
trial comparing 12 weeks of spinal manipulative therapy (SMT) combined with
exercise therapy (ET) to ET alone.
Results: Of the 185 enrolled patients, 179 (97%) provided data at 12
weeks, and 174 (94%) at 26 and 52 weeks. Adding SMT to ET resulted in a larger
reduction in LBP severity over the course of 1 year (P = .007).
Differences in LBP severity were small at the end of treatment (5 percentage
points; P = .08) but were larger at weeks 26 (11 percentage
points; P = .001) and 52 (8 percentage points;
P = .009). At 26 weeks, SMT with ET performed better than
ET alone for disability (P = .04) and improvement
(P = .02). The SMT with ET group also reported
significantly greater satisfaction with care at weeks 12, 26, and 52
(P ≤ .02). There were no serious treatment-related adverse
events.
Conclusions: For adolescents with chronic LBP, SMT combined with ET
was more effective than ET alone over a 1-year period, with the largest
differences occurring in the long-term.
(3739) A Pilot Study on the Effects of Transcutaneous Auricular Vagus Nerve
Stimulation on Blood Glucose Level in Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
Jie Chen1, Zhaohui Liu2 and Peijing Rong2
1Beijing Zhongguancun Hospital, Beijing, China
2China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To study the effects of transcutaneous auricular vagus
nerve stimulation (taVNS) on blood glucose level in type 2 diabetes mellitus
(T2DM) patients.
Results: The FBG and 2hPBG values were not statistically significant
in the taVNS group, but the reduction was 1 week ahead of the sham-taVNS group.
Many HbA1c values of the taVNS group decreased after treatment, which have
statistical significance, P < .05, comparison of curative
effect: taVNS group total effectiveness 68.6%, sham-taVNS group 30%, the test of
P < .01, with significant differences between these 2
groups.
Conclusions: taVNS could reduce blood glucose in type 2 diabetic
patients with various indicators of specificity; its hypoglycemic effect with
the increase of treatment time and more significantly can reduce the effect of
stage blood glucose.
(3741) Efficacy of Ginger and Mustard Foot Baths on Psychophysiological
Parameters: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Bernhard Deckers, MN1, Frank Andrasik, PhD2, Szoeke Henrik,
PhD3, Müller Verena, MSc1, Helmert Eduard, MD1,
Jan Vagedes, MD4 and Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc5
1ARCIM Institute, Filderstadt, Germany
2University of Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee
3University of Pecs, Pecs, Hungary
4ARCIM Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine,
Filderstadt, Germany
5Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Footbaths are applied for enhancing body warmth of
patients. Although studies abound, only a few report data on direct comparisons
of ginger and mustard. The main aim of this study was to compare both substances
with one another and additionally to warm water alone under standardized
conditions.
Results: Eighteen participants were enrolled in the study (mean age:
22 years, SD: 2.3); 6 were male (33.3%). Warmth sensations were significantly
increased in both feet only after the mustard and ginger foot baths
(P < .05). The warmth sensation was maintained in the
group receiving the ginger bath, but the effects of the mustard bath decreased
after rest (P < .05). The skin surface temperature of the
legs significantly (P < .05) increased (t1 vs t0) and
significantly (P < .05) decreased (t2 vs t1) with no changes
between the different interventions. In the mustard and ginger groups, the
subjective impression of “vitality” increased significantly
(P < .05), whereas no significant changes were seen in the
control condition (water alone).
Conclusions: The present findings provide evidence that mustard and
ginger foot baths influence the subjective impression of warmth sensation on the
legs and the subjective impression of “vitality” differently than warm water
alone.
(3742) Resveratrol Reverses the Effect of TNF-α on Inflammatory Markers in a
Model of Human Uveitis
Rachel Paladino, MS1, Sierra N Miller, BS1, Karlee F Kleiber,
BS1 and Donna M Byers, PhD1
1West Texas A&M University, Canyon, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Uveitis is a potentially severe medical condition
characterized by inflammation of the uvea, which includes the iris, ciliary
body, and choroid. While there are multiple treatments for uveitis, the most
common includes the use of corticosteroids and immunosuppressive or cytotoxic
drugs, some of which are associated with serious side effects. Resveratrol
(trans-3,4',5,-trihydroxystilbene) is a naturally occurring polyphenolic
compound found in red grapes, peanuts, cranberries, Japanese giant knotweed, and
legumes. Human studies have shown that it is protective against oxidative
damage, supportive of vascular health, and down regulates inflammatory
cytokines. Â The purpose of this study was to investigate the potential of
resveratrol to attenuate the inflammatory response in a model of human
uveitis.
Results: In all 5 genes, tumor necrosis factor α (TNF-α) treatment
induced a change in expression expected with an inflammatory response. Post
TNF-α, resveratrol treatment had a significant reversal effect on expression of
inflammatory markers which was either time- or dose-dependent. In addition,
pre-treatment with resveratrol yielded an attenuation of the expression of
several genes after subsequent treatment with TNF-α. Finally, resveratrol
treatment alone had no negative effect on proliferation of ARPE-19 cells or
expression of the target genes.
Conclusions: These data suggest resveratrol may be a viable
intervention for the treatment and prevention of human recurrent uveitis, while
avoiding the negative side effects of current therapies.
(3743) Attitudes and Knowledge Regarding Interprofessionalism Among Naturopathic
Students Before and After a Year of Clinical Internship Education
Laura T Simmons, ND1 and Kieran Cooley, ND1
1Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Abstract
Purpose: Attitudes among health-care practitioners have been shown
to impact their effectiveness in collaborative practice. Naturopaths in Canada
have a scope and interest conducive to collaboration; however, there is a lack
of quantitative evidence evaluating their attitudes toward interprofessional
care. Understanding these attitudes, as well as knowledge of other health-care
providers, may assist in future integrative practice or education and training
for health-care professionals, including naturopaths. In order to begin to
understand the topic, a 2-phase mixed methods study was proposed to (1) assess
baseline attitudes amongst naturopathic students at the beginning of their
internship year and (2) follow-up with these students at the end of their
internship year to assess for change and conduct in-depth qualitative assessment
of themes/attitude development through additional questioning.
Results: Of the 88 surveys returned initially, 77 responded in the
second round of collection. Of these, 46 were completed adequately in both
rounds for analysis. Eighty-seven percent of these respondents identified as
female with an average age of 28.8 years. Naturopaths were labelled the most
“caring” profession by interns in both rounds of data collection
(P < .05). Massage therapists and nurse/nurse
practitioners were seen as the next most caring by naturopathic students overall
while medical doctors and pharmacists were seen as the least. Naturopaths,
massage therapists, dieticians and nurses were seen as the most “subservient”
professions (P > .05) while chiropractors and medical
doctors were seen as the least (P < .05). Very few attitudes
significantly changed within the 1 year of internship. Primarily, interns
indicated that they interacted with medical doctors (85%) in collaborative care,
and 91% indicated that letter was the primary form of communication. The
majority of interns (89%) indicated their personal experiences contributed to
their established attitudes.
Conclusions: There was very little change in the attitudes of
naturopathic interns over their clinical training. Further investigation and
development of IPE is warranted to improve collaboration of naturopathic
doctors.
(3744) Integrative Health and Medicine Treatment Programs for Inflammatory Bowel
Disease: Program Framework, Clinical Case Series and Health Coaching
Joel Edman, PhD1 and Joseph R Libonati, PhD2
1Edman Wellness Services, Media, Pennsylvania
2Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Background: Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) is a chronic
and complex disease whose causes are not well understood. Integrative health and
medicine (IHM) treatment program offers a comprehensive and potentially
effective approach to management that addresses underlying causes, and may
minimize medication needed, surgical interventions and may help to optimize
quality of life. It is important to acknowledge, however, that there has never
been a published study of an IHM treatment program for IBD.
Program Description: Our hypothesis is that IBD can become acute and
highly symptomatic if any of the core functional issues are imbalanced or
abnormal and contribute to a viscous negative cycle of inflammation and symptoms
– these include: (a) chronic/high stress and/or lack of effective and
comprehensive stress management; (b) food intolerance/allergy, or lack of
effective dietary guidelines; (c) gut flora/microbiome; (d) related
physiological factors such as intestinal permeability and gut immune activation;
and (e) other individualized influences. An IHM treatment program for IBD
includes individualized and effective: (a) dietary guidelines with
identification of foods/beverages and circumstances that contribute to symptoms;
(b) stress management techniques and approaches that also address any underlying
emotional/psychological issues; (c) targeted nutritional supplements; (d)
regular physical activity/exercise; and (e) a range of other potential
approaches such as massage, acupuncture/traditional oriental medicine, and
others as indicated. Four case studies are presented utilizing an IHM treatment
program outlined above and identifying individualized influences important in
each case. Group health coaching is also presented as a potential model for
conducting a study of an IHM treatment program.
Conclusion: IHM programs have produced consistent anecdotal benefits
for IBD patients and hold significant promise for those who may not respond
effectively to standard medical treatments. Considerable future research is
required to further develop our understanding of core functional area influences
and the effectiveness of comprehensive IHM treatment programs.
Rationale: IBD is a chronic and complex disease that is not well
understood, and integrative health and medicine assessment and treatment
programs may offer the best opportunity to address underlying causes and achieve
optimal health outcomes. Unfortunately, there are no research studies that have
examined the benefits of an integrative health and medicine treatment program
for IBD, and now is the time to conduct this research.
Objectives: To be familiar with the current status of integrative
health and medicine research for IBD; to understand a clinical model of IBD that
describes the primary core functional issues and how they interact; and to
discuss different research study models that can effectively evaluate an
integrative health and medicine treatment program for IBD.
(3746) Vasodilation and Symptom Relief From Topical Rosemary Essential Oil in
Systemic Sclerosis: A Case Report
Eduard Helmert, MD1, Jörg Henes, PhD2, Tido Schön-Angerer,
MD1, Bernhard Deckers, MN1 and Jan Vagedes,
MD3
1ARCIM Institute, Filderstadt, Germany
2University of Tuebingen, Tuebingen, Germany
3ARCIM Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine,
Filderstadt, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Systemic sclerosis, or scleroderma, is a fibrosing
microvascular disease that primarily manifests with skin sclerosis and Raynaud’s
phenomenon, but can affect almost every organ system. The only proven topical
therapy to alleviate the symptoms of Raynaud’s phenomenon is nitroglycerin gel.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate preliminary data of the vasodilation
and symptom relief effect of topical rosemary essential oil in a patient with
systemic sclerosis.
Results:
Right hand (operated carpal tunnel syndrome): mean dorsal
fingertip temperature change 30 min after rosemary oil was +2.1°C and −0.8°C
after olive oil. Left hand (non-operated carpal tunnel
syndrome): temperature decreased by −0.9°C after rosemary oil and −1.7°C after
olive oil. Room temperature was 0.8°C cooler during olive oil application
days.
Conclusions: Topical Rosamarinus officinalis L.
essential oil had a vasodilator and warming effect in a patient with advanced
systemic sclerosis and Raynaud's phenomenon.
(3748) The PAWS That Refresh Us: Can Animal-Assisted Therapy Have an Effect on
Exam Performance in Medical Students?
Susan Pressly Lephart, PhD1, Connie Jennings, MD2,
Ashlee-Nicole C Hamilton, MS1 and Andrew R Hoellein, MD,
FACP1
1University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky
2Lexington, Kentucky
Abstract
Overview: Pet Therapy, also referred to as animal-assisted
intervention (AAI) and animal-assisted therapy (AAT), is defined as any practice
that involves animals as a part of a therapeutic or ameliorative process with
the goal of positively affecting human health by utilizing animals as adjuncts
to therapy. Human–animal interaction has been shown to provide numerous
psychological benefits. Some of these include decreased levels of anxiety,
sadness, and increased social functioning, and the secretion of the neuropeptide
oxytocin during human–animal contact has been suggested to be a modulating
factor. Additionally, interaction with a friendly dog can increase short-term
tolerance of aversive acoustic stimulation. Based on this information, how then
do first and second year medical students respond to interactions with AAT at
various times around their scheduled exams? This innovative intervention is
being offered at different intervals for the first and second year medical
students at the University of Kentucky. These interactions include contact with
AAT before or after their exams, with an occasional option for interactions both
before and after, or for no interaction around the exam at all. Brief surveys
are administered electronically to the medical students after each interaction
for feedback specific to their reactions and perceptions of how this
intervention may or may not have effected their performance or state of mind
during and/or around the exam period.
Rationale: A 2016 study by Rotenstein et al., found that more than
27% of medical students suffer from depression or symptoms of it, and that 11%
reported suicidal thoughts. These future leaders of our medical world are at the
beginning of their careers when the chance is ripe for them to learn novel,
integrative management techniques for stress and anxiety. In doing so, they will
not only acquire the knowledge of how AAT can help modulate their own
psychological state, but also help them realize the value of implementing this
modality in the lives of their future patients.
Objectives: To gain an objective understanding of the value of AAT
as a modality in medical student training, to obtain innovative ideas for
further utilization of AAT and to acquire a model for replication and future
study.
(3749) Integrative Health Group Visits Nordic: A Pilot Interventional Feasibility
Study to Manage People With Chronic Pain in a Nordic Inner-city Medical
Clinic
Katrine Bangsgaard, MSc1, Rupa S Appa, PhD2 and Shelley R
Noble-Letort, PhD2
1University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark
2Nordic Integrative Medicine, Copenhagen, Denmark
Abstract
Overview: Driven by the lack of evidence in the Nordic region,
especially Denmark, and grounded in the North American clinical success, the
primary goal of this Nordic IHM 2017 study is to help determine the
effectiveness and feasibility of the integrative health group visit (IHGV)
Nordic care model to manage people with chronic pain in a Nordic inner-city
(Copenhagen, Denmark) outpatient medical clinic. Nordic Integrative Medicine
surveyed groups of people, pre and post, who underwent a series of 6
week/8-session IHGV programs (5 – 6 groups; median 12 people/group; range: 8–16
participants) to evaluate their qualitative changes in pain (0–10 point scale
and Autonomic Symptoms Questionnaire), sleep quality, and co-morbid symptoms as
well as perceived stress, anxiety, and depression (Patient Health Questionnaire
15 [PHQ-15] Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale [HADS]).
Rationale: The IHGV Nordic care model combines people-centered,
non-pharmacologic strategies that complement pharmacological treatments and
incorporate the principles of NIH NCCIH recommended therapies for the management
of chronic pain and associated symptoms. Chronic pain is a condition that 75% of
North American highly esteemed academic medical centers and affiliate
institutions practicing integrative medicine, report the most clinical success.
Based on the overall findings of the 2016 NIH NCCIH/Mayo Clinic Review of 150
Randomized Control Trials (RCT) investigating Complementary Approaches to Pain
and the 2014 study conducted by the Boston Medical Center (BMC) Integrative
Medicine Group Visit (IMGV), evidence suggests that Integrative Health and
Medicine (IHM) is effective for the treatment of chronic pain.
Objectives: Our presentation will be delivered in 3 parts: (1)
Participants will be introduced to the current status of “people centered
integrated healthcare” (PCIH) being delivered in Denmark. (2) The preliminary
results of the Nordic IHM 2017 study will include comparative analysis to
similar studies being conducted in the USA. (3) Our objective: The improvement,
development, and enhancement of future IHM mixed-methods research, including
qualitative comparative effectiveness research (CER) and patient-centered
outcomes research needed to aid the reformation of health-care policy in Denmark
and the Nordic countries.
(3750) Integrative Health Coaching for Employees With Chronic and/or Complex
Health Profiles: Results of a Pilot Study From a Health-care System Corporate
Wellness Program and Considerations for Best Practices
Joel Edman, PhD1 and Jeffrey M Greeson, PhD2
1Edman Wellness Services, Media, Pennsylvania
2Rowan University, Glassboro, New Jersey
Abstract
Overview: Background: Health coaching promotes healthy lifestyles
and may be particularly helpful for employees with chronic/complex health
profiles. This is important since 20% of employees/patients account for 80% of
health-care costs, and integrative health coaching is an innovative approach
that may produce optimal health outcomes. We present data from a health coaching
program that targeted health-system employees with at least 1 cardiovascular
(CVD) risk factor. Fifty-four employees volunteered for health coaching (at
least 1 cycle of a 6-session, 12-week program).
Program Description/Results: Health coaching focused on nutrition,
movement/exercise, stress management and resources/support, in a standard health
coaching framework (health-vision, 3-month and 2-week goals). 40/54 completed
the program. Average age was 53.3 years; 95% were female; 82.5% were Caucasian.
75% were obese/morbidly obese. 52.5% experienced hypertension, 47.5%
diabetes/borderline diabetes and 40% hyperlipidemia. 20% reported chronic
pain/rehabilitation needs and 17.5% reported seasonal depression/winter blues.
Aerobic/weight-training exercise increased (P <. 0001) and
85% lost weight—average loss, 8.5 pounds (P < .0001). There
was a significant reduction in perceived stress (P < .04)
and a trend for improved sleep (P = .06). Symptom improvements
included: 62.5% increased energy, 30% decreased gastrointestinal symptoms, and
20% decreased headaches/migraines.
Conclusions: Health coaching can significantly decrease CVD risk
(weight/exercise) and stress, and improve quality of life in employees with
chronic/complicated health profiles. This is especially important for
higher-risk employees who may have a vicious cycle of chronic disease and high
stress, and account for a high percentage of health-care costs. Future research
is required confirm these findings, develop best practices for chronic disease
employee engagement, lifestyle change, and optimal health outcomes, and evaluate
key markers/measures of physical/emotional well-being that can guide health
transformation.
Rationale: Today's model and cost of health care is unsustainable.
Health coaching in general and specifically integrative health coaching is an
important role that is not currently available in health care, and is essential
for changing and sustaining lifestyles that help to prevent and manage diseases.
This is especially important for the estimated 20% of employees/patients with
chronic and/or complex disease who may account for upward of 80% of health-care
costs.
Objectives: To describe the results of a pilot study of integrative
health coaching for employees of a health-care system with chronic and/or
complex disorders; to understand the range of diseases and co-morbidities that
are present in employees with chronic and/or complex disease; to identify
important factors that need to be addressed as best practices for integrative
health coaching are developed; and to understand the key areas of future
research that will help to determine the best health outcomes for health
coaching/corporate wellness programs, potential cost savings, and program
implementation requirements.
(3752) Implementing a Concept of Integrative Care at a Pediatric Oncology
Intensive Care Unit at a University Hospital in Germany
Britta Rutert, PhD1, Wiebke Stritter, MA1, Christine Holmberg,
PhD1 and Georg Seifert, PhD1
1Charité Berlin, Berlin, Germany
Abstract
Overview: Background: The pediatric oncology intensive care unit
(ICU) at the Charité University hospital in Berlin is known for excellent
biomedical treatment and care, yet offers limited space for alternative forms of
care. The presented project “Integrative Medicine in Care" aims at developing
and implementing a concept of integrative care into conventional care of the
ICU. The process asks for methodological and practice-oriented steps, which will
be depicted here.
Program Description: The aim of the project is to integrate
anthroposophic outer applications like oil-compresses and rhythmic embrocations
into the ICU of the pediatric oncology of the Charité. In anthroposophic
medicine, these applications are embedded in complex philosophical medical
knowledge and practices. However, for an ICU, they had to be adjusted to the
structural setting of the ward and the capacities of the nurses. To understand
these, qualitative research was conducted: (1) participant observation to
identify the status quo of care at the ICU and during training period of
applications; (2) interviews with nurses on job satisfaction; (3) interviews
with parents on integrative care; and (4) interviews with health personnel
(doctors, nurses, and therapists) of anthroposophic clinics. Subsequently, the
data were analyzed and a concept of integrative care was developed from the
data.
Conclusion: Implementing integrative care at an ICU of a German
hospital meets challenges and chances. High work-related stress, lack of staff
members and time as well as structural constraints impeded the development and
implementation process. These were compensated with the development of reduced
versions of the anthroposophic applications, which were easier to apply in a
stressful setting. These “reduced" versions were offered to patients on a
regular basis. Additionally, more complex applications were also offered
according to needs of patients.
Rationale: The presentation describes the attempt to integrate
anthroposophic care into conventional care and thus advances a biomedical
context by integrating alternative modes of care.
Objectives: They will know how a new system (integrative care) was
integrated into an existing system (conventional care) in a University clinic
setting, which is primarily biomedically oriented.
(3753) Modified Complete Decongestive Therapy for the Treatment of Pediatric
Klippel-Trenauny Syndrome
Elizabeth A Cross, PT, DPT, MSW, CLT1
1Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Case Description: Prior to evaluation by a Certified
Lymphedema Therapist (CLT), all 3 patients had been treated with surgical and
non-surgical interventions, which had not been effective in managing the edema
in one extremity. All patients were referred to the lymphedema team for
persistent edema in the affected limb. All 3 patients demonstrated decreased
functional mobility and sensory tolerance of the affected limb which limited age
appropriate activities. The patients with lower extremity edema had a history of
wounds which were not healed at initial evaluation. Modified complete
decongestive therapy (CDT) was used to decrease limb edema, provide consistent,
well-fitting compression, and educate families for long-term care of this
chronic condition. We choose to assess 3 cases of children of the same age and
diagnosis to compare a similar group to help us understand the effects of our
work on 1 diagnostic group then extrapolate the findings to work with other
lymphatic disorders.
Rationale: Outcomes: Edema reduction was achieved with use of
compression bandaging and bandaging-alternative garments. Patients were fitted
for custom garments for night and daytime wear that resulted in successful
maintenance of limb volume. Volumetric measurements and serial photographs were
taken to monitor differences in limb during course of therapy, in addition to,
changes in limb volumes and appearance following interventions. Volumetric
differences between the affected and unaffected limbs were as follows: Patient 1
reduced from 97% to 71%, Patient 2 reduced from 151% to 107%, and Patient 3
reduced from 29% to 17%. The draining wounds in the 2 males with lower extremity
edema were healed and all 3 patients had improved sensory tolerance in the
affected limb. Additionally, all 3 patients demonstrated improvements in
functional age appropriate activities, which will be further described in this
case review. This topic is of tremendous interest to many professionals as we
explore the importance of the lymphatic system on the physical and physiological
development of the child. It has required a collaborative effort of many
professionals to understand and design creative interventions to improve the
lives of the children and their families (GI, Oncology, Orthopedics, Pulmonary,
Cardiac, Hematology, Plastics, Interventional Radiology, PT, OT). It is exciting
to be on the cutting edge of understanding and intervening with the lymphatic
system and the effects a dysfunctional system have on the development of the
child and as we explore new ways to effect the developing systems and manage
these lymphatic diagnoses with cost effective and nonsurgical interventions. The
interventions we have determined that are effective for most of the lymphatic
disorders we encounter are simple and are easily taught to the families which
allows better involvement of the family in the treatment process and better
advocacy of the patient needs as they understand the particular issues related
to the particular lymphatic disorder.
Objectives: Discussion: Modified CDT led to effective outcomes in
achieving the goals of edema reduction, wound healing and improvement of
functional limb use. These case reviews present success with conservative
management using modified CDT as an intervention for pediatric patients with
Klippel-Trenauny syndrome. This intervention lays the groundwork for guidelines
for effective and appropriate treatment of edema in children with KT syndrome.
The issues we addressed with KTS have allowed us to explore the options with our
work with all lymphatic diagnoses. As we work with multiple professionals now
diagnosing the lymphatic disorders that we once knew nothing about and now are
diagnosing at very young ages and these interventions are easy to administer
with very little equipment therefore they are effective worldwide. Additionally,
we want to share our findings in an effort to encourage professionals worldwide
to assist in the exploration of the lymphatic system and the influence it has on
all organs and our physiological performance.
Keywords: pediatric lymphedema, primary lymphedema,
Klippel-Trenauny
(3755) Feasibility and Acceptability of Adapted Mindfulness Training to Treat
Chronic Pain in the Military
Nakisa Asefnia, BA1, Kristine Rae Olmsted, MSPH2, Shari Miller,
PhD2, Alex Buben, BA2, Michael Bartoszek, MD3,
Michael Butler, PhD4, Susan Gaylord, PhD4 and Carrie Brintz,
PhD4
1University of South Carolina, Barnwell College, Columbia, South
Carolina
2RTI International, Durham, North Carolina
3Womack Army Medical Center, Fort Bragg, North Carolina
4Chapel Hill, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Service members experiencing chronic pain have the highest
rates of medical discharge from military service. Disability costs are over $1.5
billion annually. Pharmacological approaches may be ineffective, produce side
effects, and lead to addiction. The purpose of the study is to test the
acceptability and feasibility of a live web-based mindfulness training with
active duty service members experiencing chronic pain.
Results: Four participants enrolled in the training. At least 3
participants attended each live video session, and there was 100% participation,
as participants viewed the recorded sessions on the tablet when unable to attend
live. Participants reported the platform and tablet were easy to use and that
they used the tablet to review sessions and practice the mindfulness skills. All
participants reported that didactic material was clear, informative, and
engaging, and that the mindfulness skills were beneficial for managing pain and
stress. Suggestions included making the app available on a personal phone or
computer, and shortening the sessions.
Conclusions: An interactive web-based mindfulness training was
feasible and acceptable to implement with active-duty military personnel with
chronic pain. This study addresses the critical need for increasing
accessibility of complementary, non-pharmacological approaches for managing
chronic pain and co-occurring conditions in U.S. military personnel. Future
research should examine effects of the training on pain, medication use and
co-occurring conditions.
(3756) A Mindfulness-Based Intervention for Low-income African-American Women
With Depressive Symptoms Delivered by an Experienced Instructor Versus a Novice
Instructor
Judith T Moskowitz, PhD1, Amy Yang, MS1, Elizabeth Waldron,
BA1, Carly Maletich, MA1, Inger
Burnett-Zeigler1 and Sunghyun Hong, BA1
1Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: In the present study, we evaluate the feasibility of a
mindfulness-based intervention for depression delivered to women in a Federally
Qualified Health Center (FQHC), pilot a streamlined mindfulness teacher training
protocol for FQHC staff, and examine the distribution and variability of
psychological outcomes for participants in groups led by an experienced
instructor as compared to FQHC staff instructor who received the streamlined
training.
Results: Depressive symptoms and stress significantly decreased, and
mindfulness significantly increased in the experienced and novice instructor
groups. In the novice instructor group, there was also a significant increase in
well-being and functioning. The change in depressive symptoms, stress,
functioning, and well-being was significantly greater in the novice instructor
group than the experienced instructor groups.
Conclusions: Providing streamlined training in mindfulness based
interventions to community based health-care staff provides an opportunity to
increase access to effective treatments for mental health symptoms in
underserved communities.
(3757) Usurping the Olympian Gods' Nectar: A Botanical and Biochemical Review of
Flower Nectar for Its Possible Therapeutic Uses
Tamima O Mourad1
1Universidade Anhembi Morumbi, Sâo Paulo, Brazil
Abstract
Overview: Flower nectar is not a “flat" substance. This paper
presents it from a botanical biochemical perspective; and as food supplement, as
it is one of the 3 main constituents of Flower Essences. The study of nectar
biochemical constitution gained momentum in the mid-1990s, in the field of
botany. Such studies were undertaken to investigate the relationship between
plants and their pollinators; as an award, not only attracting them but also
stimulating pollinator behavior. This research is an interdisciplinary study of
nectar, consisting of a bibliographical review of the biochemistry of nectar,
its possible effects in human consumption through the use of Flower
Essences.
Rationale: Integrative medicine has an inclusive tendency toward
therapeutic practices that had not been before accepted in health sciences. An
academic review of the biochemical constituents of flower nectar assists in the
objective understanding of what biochemical constituents are present in the
Flower Essences used for therapeutic purposes for almost a century.
Objectives: Among the objectives of this study: (i) constituents
that are only present in the nectar, and no other plant parts, (ii) biochemical
composition of nectar that serve as an active principle to stimulate pollinator
behavior, and (iii) biochemical composition in flower nectar that can be
considered useful for therapeutic use.
(3758) Clinical Pain Characteristics and Placebo Analgesia in Patients With
Temporomandibular Disorder
Luana Colloca, MD, PhD1, Nathaniel Haycock, BA1 and Titilola
Akintola, BSc1
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Considerable gaps exist in the understanding of how
endogenous pain modulation (EPM) influences clinical pain. Differences in EPM
may account for the high variability observed in the pain experience of chronic
pain patients. Here, we examine whether the nature of clinical pain can impact
placebo analgesia in chronic orofacial pain patients, specifically those with
temporomandibular disorder (TMD).
Results: Findings showed no statistically significant difference in
placebo-induced analgesia between TMDs and controls. There was a main effect of
condition in both TMDs, F(1, 29) = 24.72,
P < .001, and healthy controls, F(1,
30) = 27.31, P < .001. There were no significant
correlations between placebo analgesia and duration of pain
(rs
= .01, P = .374),
severity of pain (rs
= .01,
P = .357), overall pain (rs
= .13,
P = .236), and likelihood of neuropathic pain
(rs
= .06, P = .577).
Conclusions: This is the first evidence that TMD patients experience
substantial placebo analgesic effects that are linked to the reward system. Pain
type, severity, duration, and likelihood of a neuropathic component did not
impact placebo response, indicating that chronic orofacial pain does not affect
the magnitude of placebo analgesia. Through further research, we can learn to
optimize clinical outcomes by activating EPM to induce placebo analgesia.
(3759) Nighttime Use of Far-infrared Emitting Ceramic Shirts Increases Quality of
Sleep in Young Baseball Players
Alan Letton, PhD1, Shannon Vissman, PhD1, Francisco
Cidral-Filho, PhD2 and Daniel F Martins, PhD2
1Multiple Energy Technologies, Washington, Pennsylvania
2University of Southern Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: Far-infrared has been shown to reduce muscle pain and
improve physical functioning and health. The purpose of this study was to
evaluate the effect of nighttime use of far-infrared emitting ceramic shirts
upon quality of sleep of young baseball players.
Results: In comparison to placebo group results, the use of cFIR
shirts increased overall quality of sleep (P < .01), while
reduced sleep latency (P < .01) and sleep disturbance
(P < .01).
Conclusions: Nighttime use of far-infrared emitting ceramic shirts
increases quality of sleep, reduces the length of time to falling asleep (sleep
latency) as well as the influences of sleep disturbances upon sleep in young
baseball players. These results are aligned with literature data further support
the current growing use of cFIR garments to improve general well-being and
quality of sleep.
(3760) Placebo Analgesia and Neuropathic Pain: Insights From a Novel Rodent
Model
Luana Colloca, MD, PhD1, Titilola Akintola, BSc1, Radi Masri,
DDS, BS, PhD1, Asaf Keller, PhD1 and Paige Studlack, BA
1Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: The lack of effective therapies for chronic pain has been
cited as a major contributor to the opioid epidemic and necessitates the
advancement of research into alternative therapies. Placebo analgesia has
emerged as a potential approach to reduce opioid use by interspersing with
placebos. The development of an animal model of placebo analgesia in chronic
pain is essential to a full understanding of its neurobiological mechanisms and
a complete assessment of its therapeutic potentials.
Results: Fentanyl-conditioning produced a placebo analgesic effect
on test day when animals received only saline, resulting in significantly
reduced scores (P = <10−3) on the facial grimace scale, a
validated metric for assessing the affective component of pain. Saline also
significantly reduced mechanical sensitivity (P = .0035) in
Fentanyl-conditioned animals. Control animals who were conditioned with saline
(and never received Fentanyl) showed no significant reduction in pain ratings on
either metric.
Conclusions: This study provides evidence for the first time that
placebo analgesia can be induced in an animal model of chronic pain. We show
that placebos may have utility in alleviating the affective and reflexive
components of chronic pain in rats. Furthermore, this study highlights a robust
animal model of placebo analgesia that could be useful in the development of
more effective chronic pain therapies.
(3762) National Board Certification for Health and Wellness Coaching: Updates and
Outcomes in a Pioneering Field for Health-care Transformation
Cynthia Schultz, MA, LP1, Meg Jordan, PhD, RN, CWP, ACC2,
Margaret Moore, MBA3, Raja Subhiyah, PhD4, Karen Lawson,
MD5 and Ruth Q Wolever, PhD5
1Minneapolis, Minnesota
2California Institute of Integral Studies, San Francisco, California
3McLean Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts
4National Board of Medical Examiners, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
5Nashville, Tennessee
Abstract
Overview: The demand to manage burgeoning chronic disease has led to
the emergence of job roles such as health and wellness coaches (HWC). As use of
the titles “health coach” and “wellness coach” have increased dramatically, so
has the need to ensure consistency, quality and safety for HWC provided in both
practice and research. Clear and uniform role definitions and competencies are
required to ensure appropriate scope of practice, to allow best practices to
emerge, and to support the implementation of rigorous research. To
professionalize the field, a collaborative volunteer non-profit organization,
the National Consortium for Credentialing Health and Wellness Coaches (NCCHWC),
gathered input since 2010, and changed its name and structure to International
Consortium for Health and Wellness Coaching (ICHWC) in 2017. This presentation
will discuss how this group gathered the field to clarify core competencies in
HWC, applied best-practice processes to conduct and validate a Job Task
Analysis, and garnered the attention of the National Board of Medical Examiners
(NBME). In collaboration with NBME for the past 2 years, we jointly launched the
inaugural national certification exam with over 1300 applicants in September
2017. With a senior statistician from NBME, we will review the process of
building the national exam. We will also consider how the ICHWC-NBME partnership
has brought forth a uniform job definition, with clarification of core skill
competencies, and needed training standards with a process for educational
program approval. The momentum in building this field is supported by many
stakeholders. The potential of HWC to significantly transform health care toward
a truly relationship-centered and client-empowering system, and the next steps
to move the field forward, will be explored.
Rationale: The demand to manage burgeoning chronic disease has led
to the emergence of job roles such as health and wellness coaches (HWC). As use
of the titles “health coach” and “wellness coach” have increased dramatically,
so has the need to ensure consistency, quality and safety for HWC provided in
both practice and research. The successful launch of the first national board
certification for HWC helps to ensure quality and safety as well as better
define the field.
Objectives: Participants will recognize the need for consistency in
job definitions and professional practices for health and wellness coaching
(HWC) to advance education, clinical practice and research; become aware of the
brand new National Board Certification process and consider its role in
advancing practice both for current health providers, as well as new health and
wellness coaches; and define the core competencies of health and wellness
coaching (HWC) and identify how they complement and expand those in other health
and medical professions.
(3763) Warmth Distribution in Adolescent Anorexia Nervosa
Jan Vagedes, MD1 and Cara Simmance, PhD2
1ARCIM Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine,
Filderstadt, Germany
2University of Tuebingen, Tuebingen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Anorexia nervosa (AN) is associated with thermoregulatory
disturbances such as hypothermia. However, few studies have explored body warmth
in AN patients. In this study, we assessed the body surface temperature
distribution in adolescent AN patients using high-resolution infrared thermal
imaging, and through a patient questionnaire, and explored how this differed
between intervention and control group and length of treatment.
Results: The AN patients were significantly colder in all chosen
body domains at t1 compared to healthy controls, except the abdomen area: canthi
of both eyes (−0.76°C, P < .001), face (−1.36°C,
P < .001), forehead (−0.55°C,
P < .01), nose (−4.25 degrees,
P < .001), hands (−3.11°C, P < .001),
feet (−2.54°C, P < .001), and abdomen (+0.48°C,
P < .05). The questionnaire findings supported these
results. Differences between the intervention and control groups noted at t1
were significantly reduced by t2 and t3.
Conclusions: Our findings suggest that abnormities in the body
warmth distribution of AN patients are reversible after having received an AN
specific treatment. Reducing the loss of warmth could improve therapeutic
outcomes in AN patients and be a predictor of recovery, and should be
investigated in further studies.
(3764) Mindfulness is Associated With Sleep Quality Among Patients With
Fibromyalgia
Yuan Zhang, PhD1, Xingyi Han, MPH2, Lori L Price, MAS,
MLA3, Michelle Park, BA4, Chenchen Wang, MD,
MSc4 and Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD, PhD4
1University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, Massachusetts
2Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
3Tufts University, Boston, Massachusetts
4Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Patients with fibromyalgia commonly experience sleep
disturbance. Previous studies suggest higher mindfulness may be associated with
better sleep quality in people with chronic pain conditions. However, the role
of mindfulness in fibromyalgia remains understudied. We examine the
relationships between mindfulness and sleep disturbance, depression, and pain
interference in fibromyalgia.
Results: A total of 176 patents with fibromyalgia were included (93%
female, mean age: 52 ± 12 years, BMI: 30 ± 7 kg/m2, 60% white).
Higher mindfulness in patients was associated with better sleep quality
(r = .22, P = .003) as well as less sleep
disturbance (r = .23, P = .002), chronic pain
(r = .31, P < .0001), and depression
(r = .59, P < .0001) (Table 1). Chronic
pain mediated the associations between mindfulness and sleep quality (42.7% of
total effect, P = .05) and mindfulness and sleep disturbance
(33.8% of total effect, P = .03) (Figure 1).
Conclusions: Higher mindfulness is associated with better sleep
quality in people with fibromyalgia, with chronic pain mediating this
relationship. Longitudinal studies designed to increase mindfulness in patients
with fibromyalgia are warranted.
(3767) Addressing Pain With Integrative Medicine at a Large Freestanding
Children’s Hospital
Sanghamitra M Misra, MD1, Evelyn C Monico, MD1, Esther Kim,
BS1, Grace Kao, PhD1, Caroyl Gilbert, RN,
PNP-BC1, Monica Marcus, DO1, Meesha Khatker,
BS1 and Angelo Giardino, MD1
1Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: At our large pediatric hospital, we launched an IM
inpatient pilot consult service to investigate the feasibility; parent and
patient interest; and benefits of a coordinated IM consult service to address
pain in children.
Results: Thirty-four patients (14 male) were enrolled in the study.
Nineteen of the subjects, 21 of their mothers and 18 of their fathers used CAM
in the last 1 year. Ten of the patients were covered by Medicaid/CHIP, and 21
had private insurance. The patients were taking between 1 and 5 pain medications
at time of consult. Before our intervention, 33 parents were interested in their
child receiving IM services, 3 parents were nervous about the IM services, 29
felt that IM services would benefit their child’s pain, and 33 parents felt that
our hospital should have an IM consult service. One parent noted that her child
was more irritable after an IM therapy but there were no other adverse events.
All the 15 families interviewed felt that IM services helped their child’s pain,
helped their child’s mood, and that our hospital should have an IM consult
service.
Conclusions: During this national opioid crisis, integrative
techniques can be helpful to address pain without significant side effects.
(3768) Manual Therapy Reduces Nociception and Oxidative Stress in an Animal Model
of Complex Regional Pain Syndrome Type 1
Leidiane Mazzardo-Martins, PhD1, Juliana Stramosk2, Ana
Cristin, a C Kuci2, Fabricia Petronilho, PhD2, Lucineia G
Danielski2, Drielly Florentino2, Daniela D
Ludtke3, Afonso Salgado, PhD4, Francisco Cidral-Filho,
PhD4 and Daniel F Martins, PhD4
1University of Federal of Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Brazil
2University of Southern Santa Catarina, Tubarão, Brazil
3University of Federal of Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
4University of Southern Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: Evaluate the analgesic and anti-oxidative effect of manual
therapy in an animal model of complex regional pain syndrome type 1
(CRPS-I).
Results: I/R induced marked and long-lasting mechanical
hyperalgesia. Acute AJM reduced mechanical hyperalgesia (days 2, 7 and 11
post-I/R) with significant results 0.5 h (P < .05) and 1 h
(P < .5) after AJM. Repeated daily treatments (days 2–7
and 7–11) also decreased mechanical hyperalgesia 30 min after treatment
(P < .05). On day 2 post-I/R paw tissue concentrations
of TBARS and protein carbonyls were elevated; while levels of CAT and SOD
activity were decreased in relation to Sham I/R. AJM significantly prevented
TBARS and protein carbonyls increase, as well as prevented the decrease in CAT
but not SOD activity.
Conclusions: Manual therapy reduced nociception and oxidative stress
in an animal model of CRPS-I.
(3770) Evidence-based Medicine in Homeopathy: A Review of Study Designs in
Homeopathic Treatment of Anxiety and Recommendations for Future Research
Sonia Malani1 and Steven LaBrecque, MPH1
1Bastyr University, Seattle, Washington
Abstract
Purpose: In the last 20 years, the migration to evidence-based
medicine (EBM) has been rapid and pervasive. The main reasons for this are the
implementation of electronic medical records, the internet, an increasing number
of point-of-care tests, and the rising costs of health care. EBM was originally
defined in the 1990s as the conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of
current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients.
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have been considered the gold standard of
EBM. In well-designed trials of significant size, the randomization evenly
distributes known and unknown factors among both the control and intervention
groups, and reduces the potential for confounding variables. Since the 1990s,
the definition of EBM has been revised in the 21st century as the integration of
clinical aptitude, patient values, and the most promising evidence available to
aid the process of decision-making in patient-centered health care (see Figure
1). Thus, the clinical experience of the health-care professional is equally as
important as the research at hand in this this revised definition.
Opponents of homeopathy often claim that it is not based in scientific evidence
nor can it be studied based on principles of EBM, however, this is simply not
the case. This misinformation highlights the issue with dogmatic thinking in the
conventional medical community fueled by the historical stigma of homeopathy in
the American health-care system. Homeopathic pathogenic trials (HPTs) have long
been the pillars of scientific studies on homeopathy. In fact, the design method
was one of the first examples of systematic research on medicine, and it served
as the basis for which the first major experiment with a placebo control group
occurred in Nürnberg, Germany in 1835. HPTs, or “provings,” were initially
developed by Dr Samuel Hahnemann, a German medical doctor in the 19th century.
In homeopathic provings, a particular substance (ie, plant or animal material)
is diluted, shaken, and then tested in healthy human subject volunteers until
they begin to show symptoms. The symptoms are then recorded by each subject and
the complete list of symptoms eventually becomes the materia medica for the
remedy based from that particular substance. Homeopathy is embedded in the
philosophy of “like cures like,” meaning that a person who has certain symptoms
is treated homeopathically with an ultra-diluted remedy that would normally
produce those symptoms in an otherwise healthy individual. There have been a
number of research studies conducted in recent years on the treatment of anxiety
with homeopathic remedies in a variety of study designs, ranging from
observational animal studies to randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled
trials. According to the Anxiety and Depression Association of America, anxiety
is one of the most prevalent mental illnesses and affects 40 million adults in
the United States age 18 and older each year. Since homeopathy is known to take
into account the mental, emotional, and physical manifestations of a disease, it
has had particular success in patients with a diagnosis of generalized anxiety
disorder. This current presentation reviews the literature and highlights how
the published research on homeopathy can follow the principles of EBM and guide
clinical decision-making in the patient encounter.
Results: Included in Methods as one combined section.
Conclusions: Homeopathy is often falsely accused that it is not
based in scientific evidence; however, this review demonstrates how the
principles of EBM have been applied to homeopathy in the last 20 years. It is
this clinical research that serves to provide validation of HPTs that have been
conducted over the past 2 centuries by medical doctors like Dr Samuel Hanhemann.
EBM has strengthened clinical recommendations within population medicine,
however, some researchers claim that EBM often fails to provide evidence to
guide decisions in clinical care for individual patients. Despite their
strengths, RCTs often have substantial limitations. Although they can have
significant internal validity, RCTs sometimes lack external validity. For
example, generalizations of findings outside the study population may actually
be invalid. In addition, RCTs have increasingly high costs with a major time
commitment, which can lead to reliance on surrogate markers that may not
correlate well with the outcome of interest. This all reduces the ability of
RCTs to keep up with clinical advances, and so new products and standards of
care are often developed prior to completion of the research studies. These
pitfalls of the traditional EBM model underscore the shift toward an era of
personalized medical care that is more patient-centered and holistic-based.
There are several challenges with respect to EBM-oriented research on
homeopathy, much of which stems from the dilution factor of the homeopathic
substance. Homeopathic preparations typically start as 6C potencies and progress
to more dilute potencies (ie, 12C, 30C, 200C). By the time the dilution factor
reaches 12C, there is theoretically no active substance left in the preparation
because the dilution has surpassed Avogadro’s number of 6.022 × 1023.
Homeopathic treatment of anxiety was the topic of choice for this literature
review because of homeopathy’s ability to address the mental, emotional, and
physical complaints of a patient. Since a homeopathic intake is customized to
the symptomatology and experience of each patient, changes in anxiety symptoms
can be measured using clinical assessments like the GAD-7 questionnaire in
future research. Based on our understanding of homeopathic prescribing, we
recommend the following suggestions for future research on homeopathic protocols
for anxiety: (1) A comparison of a specific remedy at a particular potency (ie,
200C dilution factor) with a placebo control; (2) Blinding of participants, but
not the homeopath because he or she needs to be able to examine the patient as a
whole to determine the most accurate remedy for the particular patient; (3)
Selection of the top 4–5 strongest rubrics by the homeopath that best fits the
case; (4) Implementation of a GAD-7 assessment prior to treatment and at the
follow-up appointment 4–6 weeks after the start of treatment. An added strength
to the potential study would be to ask the participants to guess which
experimental group they thought they were in throughout the study. In this case,
the study would be less biased if there is no difference in the guesses between
the groups, indicating a strong blinding procedure.
(3772) Effects of Mantra Meditation Versus Music Listening on Knee Pain,
Function, and Related Outcomes in Older Adults With Knee Osteoarthritis: A Pilot
Randomized Controlled Trial
Kim Innes, PhD, MSPH1, Terry K Selfe, DC, PhD2, Sahiti Kandati,
MPH, DDS1, Caitlin Montgomery, MPH1, Hannah Bowles,
MS3 and Zenzi Huysmans, MS4
1West Virginia University School of Public Health, Morgantown, West
Virginia
2University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida
3West Virginia University School of Medicine, Morgantown, West
Virginia
4West Virginia University College of Physical Activity and Sport Sciences,
Morgantown, West Virginia
Abstract
Purpose: Although meditation and music listening (ML) have been
shown to reduce pain and improve other outcomes in certain chronic pain
populations, research in osteoarthritis (OA) is sparse. In this pilot RCT, we
compare the effects of these two simple practices on knee pain, function, and
related outcomes in older adults with knee OA.
Results: Participants were aged 51 to 74 (X = 58.5 ± 1.4) years, 82%
white, and 68% female. Twenty participants (91%) completed the study (9 MM, 11
ML). Compliance was excellent, with participants completing a mean of 12.1 ± 0.8
sessions/wk. Relative to baseline, participants in both groups demonstrated
improvement at 8 weeks in all core outcomes, including knee pain (KOOS,
P ≤ .03; NRS, P ≤ .03), function (MM,
P < .02, ML P < .1), and perceived
OA severity (P ≤ .04), as well as in mood
(P ≤ .05), perceived stress (P ≤ .04), and QOL
(Physical Health Component, P ≤ .01). The MM group showed
greater improvements than the ML group in mood and sleep
(P < .04), and a tendency toward greater improvements in
certain domains of knee-related function and QOL (P < .09),
QOL-Mental Health (MH) (P < .07), and kinesiophobia
(P = .09).
Conclusions: Findings of this pilot RCT suggest that a simple MM,
and possibly, ML program may be effective in reducing knee pain and dysfunction,
decreasing stress, and improving mood, sleep and QOL in older adults with knee
OA, with improvements in mood and sleep that were significantly more pronounced
in the MM group.
(3773) Effects of Qigong on Interoceptive Awareness in Breast Cancer Survivors
With Persistent Post-surgical Pain
Kamila Osypiuk, MS1, Gloria Vergara-Diaz, MD2, Roxanne Solis
Quinn, BS3, Winnie Ng, BS3, Paolo Bonato, PhD2,
Jennifer Ligibel, MD3 and Peter M Wayne, PhD1
1Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
3Dana Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Persistent post-surgical pain (PPSP) is a prevalent and
distressing side-effect of breast cancer treatment. A multifaceted mind-body
intervention, such as Qigong, which incorporates physical activity and
meditative and psychosocial components, may address underlying causes of the
pain. Interoceptive awareness has been purported to contribute to the benefits
of mind-body interventions. In this single-arm pilot study, in addition to
evaluating the feasibility of a 12-week Qigong program for breast cancer
survivors, the effects of this intervention on interoception are explored.
Results: Twenty-one women with mean age of 54 (SD: 10.18) and 4.54
(SD: 2.81) years since surgery were enrolled. Eighteen subjects completed
follow-up outcome assessments (2 withdrew for health reasons, 1 was lost to
follow-up). Subjects attended on average 6.52 (SD: 3.37) Qigong classes. Among
subjects who completed the study (n = 18), improvements were observed in 7 of 8
domains of interoception measured by the MAIA (“attention regulation,” “body
listening,” “emotional awareness,” “noticing,” “self-regulation,” “trusting,”
and “not worrying”). The greatest mean differences were observed in
“self-regulation” (+1.43 CI = 0.88, 1.98; P < .0001),
“trusting” (+1.46 CI = 0.88, 2.04; P < .0001), and “body
listening” (+1.43 CI = 0.74, 2.11; P = .0002).
Conclusions: Delivery of Qigong for women with PPSP is feasible and
shows promise in increasing interoceptive awareness, particularly impacting
one’s ability to listen to and trust the body, and use awareness of body
sensations to regulate emotion. Future studies evaluating the clinical and
psychophysiological benefits of Qigong and the relationship between
interoception and other key issues affecting breast cancer survivors, eg, pain,
self-esteem, and perceived stress, are warranted.
(3774) The Effects of Pranayama on the Autonomic Nervous System
Alison Lacombe, PhD1, Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH1, Doug Hanes,
PhD1, John Phipps, PhD1, Erica Sharpe, PhD1,
Jan Taylor, BA1 and Ryan Heer, BS1
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Pranayama deep breathing (PDB) component yoga involving
conscious regulation of breath. Sheetkari (SK) and
Sheetali (ST) are two forms of PDB purported to have
specific physiological effects. Recent research demonstrated PDB could modulate
autonomic nervous system (ANS) markers such as heart rate variability (HRV). The
purpose of this study is to measure the effects of modifiable SK and ST practice
parameters on ANS activity, as an intermediate step to investigating PDB in
clinical conditions associated with ANS dysregulation, such as hypertension.
Results: Currently, n = 10 participants have enrolled and n = 3 have
completed all 5 study conditions. We anticipate n = X participants will have
completed by the time of presentation. Our primary outcome is changes in HRV
statistics, which will be reported between practice conditions. Secondary
outcomes will determine the interrelations between measures of HRV and changes
in respiration rate variability to determine the impact of pacing on the
ANS.
Conclusions: Measuring the impact of modifiable components of
mind-body interventions on the reliability of their purported mechanisms of
action is a critical step toward developing clinical trials. The proposed
presentation will demonstrate the impact of key PDB practice conditions on the
purported mechanism of SK/ST.
(3775) A Study of Reiki Practitioners’ Ability to Detect Human Energy
Fields
Gabriel Moss1, Sean Hobson, BA2, Richard T Lee, MD1,
Bethanny Bristol, BA2, Ming Li, PhD1 and Katherine Daunov,
MSN, CNP2
1Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio
2University Hospitals, Cleveland, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: Reiki is a form of energy healing that is gaining
popularity. This practice commonly includes energy scanning to focus the
treatment. This study examines the capability of Reiki practitioners (RP) to
detect human energy fields (HEF).
Results: A total of 67 RP participated in this study with a mean age
of 58 (range 27–77) and most were female (61). The majority were Reiki Masters
(60) and practiced Reiki an average of 11.4 years (±6.2, 1.5–24). All RP were
able to complete 20 trials for a total of 1340 individual trials with each
taking an average of 18.7 s (±20.1, 3–190). RP had a mean success rate of
detecting HEF of 25.4%, (median 5 ± 1.9, 2–11). Two subjects met criteria for
repeat testing with results of 12/40 and 15/40. Reiki Masters were more likely
to detect HEF (>25% accuracy) than RP level 2 (P = .03).
Years of experience (>10), age (>58), sex, and hand dominance did not
correlate to an increase in detecting HEF. The control group of 25 non-energy
trained volunteers had a mean success rate of 24.2% (median 5 ± 1.7, 2–8).
Conclusions: In general, RPs’ ability to HEF in this study was
equivalent to chance and similar to a control group of non-energy trained
volunteers.
(3780) Unsupported in a Changing Landscape: Learning Technologies in Integrative
and Complementary Medicine Education Provision: Results of an International Survey
of Faculty
Alastair Gray, MSc1
1University of Technology Sydney, New York, New York
Abstract
Purpose: Closely related to the continuing popularity of
complementary medicine (CM) has been an increased number of enrolments at CM
education institutions across the public and private tertiary sectors. Despite
growth in CM education and a number of significant challenges and changes facing
higher education more generally there has been very little peer-reviewed
research examining CM education. In direct response to this important gap, this
paper reports on faculty perceptions of attitudes to technologies in general,
technologies in CM academic work and perceptions of support from colleges.
Results: Responses to the survey (n = 91). Striking results
highlight that CM academics are clearly disgruntled about technology in their
lives and have strong attitudes to it. They reported student’s skills and
behaviors as different than before as a consequence of technologies. They see
their jobs as changing, see technologies as an impediment to good teaching and
having a major impact on their jobs. Staff do not feel supported. Applying
Rogers Diffusion of Innovation theory there were more self-reported innovators
at NUNM, more early adopters at Endeavour, more early majority at Endeavour,
more late majority at NUNM. There were no self-reported laggards at either
institution.
Conclusions: The data points to supporting the clear trends in the
university sector worldwide, but also key differences, with some resistance to
the use of technologies, due to the unique values, demographics and
psychographics of those who involved in CM education. This has significance of
the CM and IM industries as a whole. Comparison with concurrent student surveys
highlights a deep digital divide between a new generation of health-care
providers and their teachers. It also shows an important difference across
countries. It highlights that the 2 dominant providers of CM are at different
places in their educational provision.
(3783) What Social Networks Teach Us About Patient–Provider Communication on
Pain
Yasmine Kloth, MS1 and Ken Deutsch2
1National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, Bethesda,
Maryland
2JPA Labs, JPA Health Communications, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: We aim to understand how patient conversations and
health-care provider (HCP) conversations on pain are structured on Twitter. By
identifying how information is spread by and between these audiences,
organizations will be better poised to develop and share materials that can help
facilitate communication between HCPs and patients, with an end goal of
improving a shared decision-making process around pain management.
Results: Preliminary data indicate that chronic pain patients mostly
follow each other, get information from like-minded sources, and are more likely
to cite consumer websites. In comparison, cancer patients are more likely to
follow specialists than their chronic pain counterparts and cite health-focused
sources such as jamanetwork.com and cancer.gov.
Conclusions: In the social media sphere of Twitter, patient and
provider discussions around pain are less interactive than those in oncology.
Pain patients do not follow medical professionals or share medical or
health-related information on Twitter to the same extent that oncology patients
do. This could be because pain can be a part of many different conditions and as
a result, pain patients are not organized online in the same way oncology
patients are; likewise, pain patients might not have a central hub of
evidence-based information to cite, such as cancer.gov. This indicates a
resource need that could be of benefit to the pain patient community.
(3784) Shifting Paradigms at the Bedside: How to Create, Implement, and Sustain a
Holistic Model of Care
Teri Verner, DNP, RN, AHN-BC1
1▪▪
Abstract
Overview: Integrative therapies are making their way into mainstream
hospitals across the country in a variety of ways—some are more successful and
sustainable than others. This presentation will illuminate HealthEast’s story of
success in creating a holistic standard of care in a health-care system. Using
Jean Watson’s Caring Science Theory as the framework for this model, every
caregiver is empowered to practice in a truly holistic way. The process begins
with self-care opportunities for staff and continues with education and
validation of one unit at a time. The foundation of this work is healing
presence and other holistic principles, and includes the use of a variety of
integrative therapies. Through education and empowering nursing division staff,
patients are receiving integrative therapies as a standard of care in all acute
care areas of 3 hospitals. This has resulted in shifting the paradigm on how
care is delivered at the bedside, as evidenced by chart audits, nurse
testimonials and nursing survey results.
Rationale: The Joint Commission’s statement on pain assessment and
management requires that accredited hospitals require that the hospital offers
both pharmacologic and nonpharmacologic approaches for pain control.
Additionally, with the opioid crisis, it is incumbent on health-care providers
to offer other option s for pain control. The acute care setting is the perfect
place to do this. Many hospitals are trying to comply with this with volunteer
programs and/or providers paid for with philanthropic dollars offering specific
services to patients. While these models do bring therapies to the patients, it
is not in a reliable and sustainable way. By teaching bedside staff basic
knowledge and skills about healing presence and mind body connection to help
facilitate whole person care, as well as offering and teaching integrative
therapies, holistic care has become the standard of care in the HealthEast
Healthcare System.
Objectives: To identify 3 strategies for gaining buy in from staff
and articulate 3 key strategies for creating and sustaining an integrative model
in a health-care-based setting.
(3785) Yoga Therapy: Explanatory and Theoretical Frameworks and Implications for
Research, Teaching, and Clinical Practice
Steffany Moonaz, PhD1, Marlysa Sullivan, PT, C-IAYT1, Matt Erb,
PT2 and Laura Schmazl, PhD3
1Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
2Center for Mind-Body Medicine, Tucson, Arizona
3Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
Abstract
Overview: Yoga therapy is a developing and growing complementary and
integrative health profession with a growing body of evidence supporting the
practice for diverse patient populations and conditions. Some of the limitations
to the research in yoga therapy include the heterogeneity of the practices and
absence of clear reporting guidelines for yoga protocols. This presentation will
present recent developments in the defining and understanding of yoga therapy
which may have important implications for both clinical practice and research.
The program will explore current work in developing an explanatory framework of
yoga therapy informed by philosophical and ethical perspectives including
phenomenology, eudaimonia and first person virtue ethics. In addition, the
convergence of yoga therapy philosophical principles with current theories in
neurophysiology, such as polyvagal theory, to promote self-regulation and
resilience will be introduced. The implications for yoga research will be
discussed including the difficulties with studying mind-body therapies and how
these frameworks may help to create a language and methodology for research. By
advocating a common explanatory and theoretical framework it is hoped that this
work will contribute to the cultivation of best practices in yoga therapy
education, clinical practice, and research. Both an explanatory model and
theoretical framework for yoga therapy and the application of these frameworks
in diverse patient populations will be presented.
Rationale: Mind-body therapies, such as yoga therapy, face obstacles
in research as they integrate many top-down and bottom-up processes. These
processes are sometimes reduced in the clinical use of therapeutic yoga, and
often reduced in yoga research, where the context of the whole of the practice
of yoga therapy is lost. Understanding an explanatory framework for yoga therapy
as well as the convergence with current neurophysiological principles may assist
in the development of research guidelines for yoga therapy and research designs
to capture the practice more fully. In addition a common theoretical and
explanatory framework may help create best practices in yoga therapy education
and clinical practice, all of which will be overviewed. The poster presentation
will be built off recent and pending publications in the field of yoga therapy,
integrative health and neuroscience. The novel content of this presentation
reflects an exciting and rapidly expanding area of integrative health of
interest across fields and disciplines.
Objectives: To define yoga therapy and the status of its evolution
into a distinct integrative health-care profession; to describe an explanatory
framework of yoga therapy including the current state of the science; to
describe the convergence of yoga therapy philosophical foundations with
neurophysiology to address the complex top-down and bottom-up practice of yoga
therapy for diverse patient populations including clinical considerations; and
to describe and discuss implications for yoga research.
(3789) Moving Toward Transprofessional Integration: Findings From an Ethnography
of Integrative Pain Management at a Large Urban Pediatric Hospital
Isabel Roth, MS, DrPH (c)1, Paula Cuccaro, PhD1, Linda
Highfield, PhD1, Joan Engebretson, DrPH1 and Sanghamitra M
Misra, MD2
1UTHealth School of Public Health, Houston, Texas
2Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: As we learn more about the detriments of opioids, there is
an urgent need to disseminate non-pharmacological pain management strategies.
Complementary and integrative medicine (CIM) shows positives clinical benefit
with minimal side effects, yet challenges to effective integration in hospital
settings remain. While previous qualitative studies have examined the process of
integration from the perspective of providers or administrators, there is less
understanding of the perspectives of pediatric patients and caregivers regarding
integrative pain management. The current study aimed to better understand the
process of integration at a large urban pediatric hospital from the perspectives
of providers, patients, caregivers, and administrators.
Results: Themes identified included logistical challenges navigating
between inpatient and outpatient settings, collaboration for complex patients,
and the need for a hospital-wide pain strategy.
Conclusions: The current study was the first to incorporate the
perspectives of pediatric patients, their caregivers, as well as providers and
administrators to create a holistic, in depth understanding of the process of
integration in a pediatric hospital setting. Despite limitations, these findings
further our understanding of the process of developing integrative medicine
programs to treat pediatric pain.
(3790) The Benefits of Yoga Classes for Veterans With Chronic Lower Back
Pain
Robert B Saper, MD, MPH1, Marty Boldin1, Ruth Paris,
PhD1 and Lisa Koppleman, MSW, MPH1
1Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic low back pain (cLBP) is the most frequently
diagnosed musculoskeletal pain condition among Veterans (Kerns, 2013). Long-term
cLBP is associated with non-physical sequelae, such as stress, depression and
family problems (IOM, 2011). Initial research on the use of yoga as a
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) approach for cLBP in Veteran
populations yields promising results (Groessl et al., 2013). Additionally,
findings have shown that yoga classes for cLBP among specialized populations
with limited access to CAM, encouraged participation and increased ability to
manage non-physical symptoms (Keosaian et al., 2015). Although cLBP is a major
problem for Veterans, there is a paucity of qualitative research that explores
the non-physical impact of yoga for Veterans with cLBP. Given that healthcare
professionals in VA settings often must address the impact of cLBP on their
clients, this study explores the ways that yoga classes impact Veterans who seek
treatment for cLBP.
Results: Findings demonstrate that participation in yoga yielded
perceptions of non-physical benefits for Veterans that extended beyond the
12-week classes. They described that breathing and meditative practices taught
in classes assisted them in managing stress in an array of real-world settings
(eg, driving). Some participants indicated improved focus and ability to manage
stressful interpersonal interactions at home and in the workplace. A number of
Veterans reported their spouses noticed differences in their ability to respond
to and manage stress. Participants identified the importance of being involved
in yoga classes designed expressly for Veterans. While most participants
indicated that yogic practice was overall beneficial, few continued to practice
yoga after the study. In part, this was the case because Veteran-specific yoga
classes were not available as a part of VA services.
Conclusions: Given the frequent occurrence of cLBP in the Veteran
population and the positive non-physical benefits gained through yoga practice
by participants in this study, healthcare workers practicing in VA settings may
consider Veteran-specific yoga as a means of addressing stress and/or family
problems. In addition, further research on the use of yoga for cLBP-related
concerns of Veterans is indicated.
(3791) Defining the Immune Mediators and Pathways Involved in the Anti-arthritic
Activity of Celastrol, a Chinese Herbal Product
Brian Astry, PhD1, Rakeshchandra R Meka, MS1, Chun-Tao Che,
PhD2, Steven Dudics, BS1, Shivaprasad Venkatesha,
PhD3, Kamal D Moudgil, MD, PhD1 and Brian M Berman,
MD1
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2College of Pharmacy, University of Illinois, Chicago, Illinois
3Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Celastrol, derived from medicinal plants of the
Celastraceae family, has anti-inflammatory and anti-oxidant activities. It is a
pentacyclic triterpene (C29H38O4) and belongs
to a small class of organic compounds called quinone methides. We examined the
anti-arthritic activity of celastrol using the rat adjuvant-induced arthritis
(AA) model. AA shares several features with human rheumatoid arthritis (RA), an
autoimmune disease characterized by chronic inflammation of the synovial lining
of the joints, leading to tissue damage and deformities.
Results: Celastrol modulated the T-cell proliferative and cytokine
(IL-17) responses; the production of chemokines (CCL2, CCL5) and immune cell
migration into the joints; the levels of anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide
antibodies (aCCP); the balance between pathogenic/protective T cells via STAT3
inhibition; the process of bone remodeling to inhibit osteoclastogenesis; and
the inhibition of pro-inflammatory products of fibroblast-like synoviocytes.
Furthermore, celastrol altered some of the major cell signaling pathways,
including NF-kB pathway, MAPK pathway, JAK/STAT pathway, and RANKL/OPG
pathway.
Conclusions: Celastrol executes its anti-arthritic activity via
altering both cellular and biochemical mediators of immune pathology. The
results of our preclinical studies suggest that celastrol is a promising
candidate for further testing in the clinic for RA. If successful, celastrol can
fill a vital gap in the treatment of RA, wherein despite the availability of
many potent mainstream drugs, there are many patients who either fail to respond
to these drugs or are seeking alternative treatments owing to significant
toxicity of these drugs following prolonged use.
(3793) Salutogenesis and the Greco-Arabic (Unani) Medicine Roots of Health
Promotion
Hakima Amri, PhD
Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: While the biomedical community in the West does not
necessarily identify with ancient medical concepts, it is important to note that
the teachings of Hippocrates (460–370 BC) and Avicenna or Ibn
Sina (980–1037 CE) have emphasized the creation of health and the
preservation of wellness in their respective Corpus of Medicine
and Cannon of Medicine. Those two aspects of medicine are
currently at the center of the 21st century modern medicine and are described as
salutogenesis. Salutogenesis or the creation/preservation
of health is the crux of Greco-Arabic (Unani) Medicine. It stems from the
ancient practice of Healthy Bodies Management that is presented in a 6-step
framework. Those are summarized as follows: (1) breathe fresh clean
air: modern science has shown not only the obvious importance of
oxygen but also the detrimental effects of ischemia; (2) eat nutritious
food and drink: this is witnessed in today’s debate about diets as
well as the importance of seasonal and whole foods; (3) alternate
between movement and rest: this is becoming the modern physician’s
recommendation to manage most chronic diseases; (4) respect sleep and
wakefulness cycles: it is only recently that the science of
chronobiology emerged; (5) ensure regular eating and bowel
movement: irritable bowel disorders are devastating and are still
with unknown etiology; and (6) maintain healthy mental state:
Mind-Body Medicine is now being incorporated in various aspects of medicine. In
this work, we explain the Science of Health Preservation
described by Avicenna more than a millennial ago within the current
Salutogenic theoretical framework. It is important to
revisit these ancient medical systems in light of modern science and
discovery.
Rationale: This topic is important as it shows how the alternative
medical systems are being revisited to inform our modern medicine on various
aspects of health preservation and wellness promotion.
Objectives: Participants will:
1. Learn about Unani Medicine as a complete alternative medical system of the
Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, and Persian regions;
2. Find how health preservation and wellness promotion have been the pillars of
Unani Medicine; and
3. Explain the 6 prerequisites of health from Unani Medicine in the salutogenesis
framework of modern medicine.
(3794) A Virtual Resiliency Treatment for Parents of Children With Learning and
Attentional Disabilities: A Randomized Pilot Trial
Jacqueline Proszynski, BS1, Giselle K Perez-Lougee, PhD1,
Rachel A Millstein, PhD1, Lara N Traeger, PhD1, Emma
Chad-Friedman, BA1, Karen A Kuhlthau, PhD1, Christina M
Luberto, PhD2 and Elyse R Park, PhD, MPH1
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: One in 5 children have a learning or attentional disability
(LAD). Parents of children with LAD are vulnerable to high levels of distress.
Despite their vulnerability, evidence-based resiliency treatments for parents of
children with LAD have not been developed.
Results: Fifty-six parents (mean age = 46.8; SD = 5.7; 89% female,
88% white, non-Hispanic; 75.9% married/partnered; 50% employed) participated.
70.4% of participants completed ≥6 sessions. Among 62% of intervention
participants who completed the T2 survey, 81% reported practicing relaxation
response exercises daily/weekly, and 76.2% rated ≥7 (1, not at all – 9, very) on
the treatment reducing stress-related symptoms. T1-T2 comparisons found that
intervention vs control participants showed significant improvements in distress
(ΔM = −1.48; CI = −2.95, –.002; P = .05), CES (ΔM = 6.52;
CI = 1.37, 11.68; P = .01), CAMS-R (ΔM = 3.24; CI = .77, 5.71;
P = .01), and MOCS-A (ΔM = 7.48; CI = 3.45, 11.50;
P = .001), but not in social support. Among intervention
participants, T1-T2 improvements were reported on distress, the CES, CAMS-R, and
MOCS-A (all Ps ≤ .05).
Conclusions: Pilot trial findings showed promising feasibility,
acceptability, and efficacy. Specifically, we demonstrated that a virtually
delivered resiliency treatment improved parents’ overall levels of distress,
stress coping, and resiliency. The virtual delivery modality facilitates its
implementation and dissemination.
Funding: Marino Foundation.
(3795) Diet and Psychosis: A Scoping Review
Monique Aucoin1 and Laura LaChance, MD
1Toronto, ON, Canada
Abstract
Purpose: Psychotic disorders, including schizophrenia, affect
approximately 1% of the population. Despite the use of the best available
pharmacologic and behavioral interventions, patients suffer from a dramatic
20-year reduction in life expectancy. Despite the new field of nutritional
psychiatry research, no comprehensive assessment and synthesis of the research
related to diet and psychosis has been completed. This review seeks to scope and
map the range of therapeutic strategies and mechanisms being pursued through the
completion of a systematically completed, scoping review.
Results: The search strategy yielded 50 000 results; 45 000 have
been screened to date with 1200 studies identified. Preliminary analysis reveals
studies that involve primarily human subjects, an equal portion of experimental
and observational studies, and common nutrients of interest including amino
acids, vitamins, fats, and whole diet approaches. Commonly cited mechanisms
include oxidative stress, inflammation, and allergy.
Conclusions: Although in preliminary stages, relative to other
medical conditions, there is research related to the impact of dietary factors
on psychotic disorders, next steps include synthesis and analysis of the
identified studies as well as framework creation, analysis of gaps, and
opportunities. Application of these results will include development of an
evidence-informed diet strategy for use in a pilot clinical trial and tool kits
to assist clinicians and patients with applying diet interventions for the
improvement of mental health.
(3796) Lessons Learned: Implementation of Longitudinal Studies Green
Exercise
Hollyn M Cetrone1, Arseniy Minasov1, William R Leonard,
PhD1, Mark A Pereira, PhD2, Junia Nogueira De Brito,
MPH2, Ingrid S Schneider, PhD2, Teresa H Horton,
PhD1, Annie J Lee1 and Elizabeth PD Koselka,
BA1
1Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois
2University of Minnesota, St. Paul, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: Exercising in natural landscapes, green exercise, is
hypothesized to reduce stress and lead to better health outcomes than exercising
in a built environment. However, for green exercise to be accepted as a
complementary therapy by the wider medical community, additional research is
needed to identify the biomedical mechanisms, duration, and frequency of
exposures required to improve health outcomes. To obtain these data,
longitudinal studies using rigorous controls are needed. We report the lessons
learned from implementing two longitudinal, randomized, cross-over study
designs.
Results: Sharing methods and problem solving between study teams
facilitated progress. Recruiting and retaining participants for a longitudinal
study requiring repeated laboratory visits required flexibility from the
investigators and ample compensation for the participants. Males were less
willing to participate than females, necessitating targeted recruitment
materials. Automated reminders facilitated compliance. Relational database
software facilitates the integration of multiple forms of data.
Conclusions: Collaborative studies using harmonized assessments can
facilitate the longitudinal studies needed to inform the evidence base for green
exercise.
(3802) Lost and Found: Musical Reminiscence Therapy for Dementia Care
Nils P de Mol van Otterloo, MSW1
1South Pasadena, California
Abstract
Overview: Dementia affects millions of patients and patients'
families. Finding clinical solutions that are both effective and economical for
clients is important. Musical reminiscence therapy (MRT) is the use of
customized music to improve the lifestyle of persons living with dementia and
their family members. It is possible with MRT for dementia patients to
experience emotional improvement by sharing music that was familiar to them in
their youth. The economic and educational barrier to MRT is very limited. It has
been demonstrated that persons in countries with very little health
infrastructure can benefit from this type of therapy. It is possible to teach
nurses, social workers, music therapists, and patients’ family members how to do
MRT in as little as one lesson. Making clinical tools available that are cost
effective and beneficial to the cohort of clients and families is a goal for the
future of dementia care. MRT is a fusion of practical technology and integrative
health innovation.
Rationale: MRT is based on neurological principles that are
universal, making this clinical tool effective globally. Use of music to help
dementia patients has been demonstrated to be effective. MRT provides a clinical
model for therapeutic care of dementia patients and their families. MRT provides
the link between music, neurologic principles, and technology in order to
provide a fast and effective method for disseminating care to dementia patients
of diverse backgrounds.
Objectives: This session will demonstrate the clinical use of MRT.
Attendees will learn how technology is making it possible to change the lives of
dementia patients and their families. By the end of this session, attendees will
be able to explore MRT and share its use with clinicians, students, and
clients.
(3806) Integrating a Mind-Body Medical Group Visit for Chronic Pain Patients Into
Routine Primary Care
Paula Gardiner, MD, MPH1, Salvatore D'Amico, BS1, Iniya
Rajendran, MD1 and Manasi Bhandarkar, MD1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The number of low income and racially diverse chronic pain
patients and the consequent use of opioids have risen significantly over the
past decade. As a result, medical group visits that offer mindfulness based
non-pharmacological and self-care approaches have received attention.
Results: Eleven patients, 9 females and 2 males, were scheduled for
the group visit. The average attendance was 6 participants each week with 7
participants attending sessions. Seventy-one percent of patients identified as
either Black or Hispanic. All patients had a diagnosis of musculoskeletal
chronic pain with an average PROMIS pain interference score that was 1.8 SD
higher than the U.S. population. On the 11-point pain scale, the average score
change from baseline to 6 weeks was 7.2 to 6.0. The drop in average blood
pressure drop was from 134/86 to 122/79. Patients reported trying new
supplements such as fish oil, turmeric, magnesium, vitamin D and attending
osteopathic, acupuncture, nutritionist referrals. Transportation issues, timing
of the group and receiving prior insurance authorization were challenges
observed. Participant feedback included (1) usefulness of learning Mind-Body
techniques for both pain control and overall health and (2) need for more group
visits.
Conclusions: Group medical visits that integrate Mind-Body
techniques have a role in the management of chronic pain. It is well accepted by
the urban and racially diverse population and has the potential to be fully
integrated into routine primary care.
(3812) Genetic Risk Testing and Integrative Health Coaching for CHD and T2D
Prevention: An RCT to Improve Health Behaviors in the Air Force
Vlayka Liotcheva, PhD1, Gladwell Mbochi, BS1, Allison A
Vorderstrasse, DNSc2, Michael Musty, BA1, Teji Rakhra-Burris,
MS3, Carlos J Maldonado, PhD4, Geoffrey S Ginsburg, MD,
PhD1, W Michael Scott, DNP, FAANP5, Nicole H Armitage,
Qing Colonel, USAF, PhD6, Jianhong Yang, PhD7, Ruth Q Chang,
PhD7 and Wolever, PhD7
1Durham, North Carolina
2NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing, New York, New York
3Duke University, Durham, North Carolina
4US Veterans Administration, Orlando, Florida
5Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, El Paso, Texas
6U.S. Air Force School of Aerospace Medicine, Wright-Patterson Air Force
Base, Ohio
7Nashville, Tennessee
Abstract
Purpose: Innovative approaches are needed to motivate and support
health behaviors to reduce risk of coronary heart disease (CHD) and type 2
diabetes (T2D). Combining integrative health coaching (IHC) with risk counseling
that provides novel genetic information may have additive or interactive
effects. We examined the effectiveness of providing participants in AF primary
care with 5 months of IHC following risk counseling (standard ± genetic risk) in
improving exercise and dietary intake at 12 months.
Results: A logistic regression model for exercise (categorized into
2 levels) at 12 months, adjusting for baseline, revealed that those who received
IHC were 2.85 times more likely to report moderate, hard, or very hard intensity
activity versus inactivity or light activity. No differences were seen in those
who received genetic risk testing versus those who did not. Linear mixed models
for dietary intake demonstrated no significant differences at 12 months for IHC
or genetic risk testing groups. Mediation analyses will also be discussed,
including the finding that IHC produced greater weight loss in those with higher
genetic risk for CHD.
Conclusions: While few significant differences emerged in outcomes
by genetic risk levels, the IHC groups reported significant improvements in
physical activity, relevant stages of change, and depression symptoms, providing
support for IHC as an intervention to lower risk for CHD and T2D, and
particularly for those in higher genetic risk groups.
(3814) Health and Wellness Coach Collaboration With Psychiatrist in Multimodal
Intervention for ADHD: Case Report
Elizabeth Ahmann, ScD, Rn, PCC1, Katherine Smith, MPH, CHWC1,
Laurie Ellington1 and Rebecca O Pille, PhD, CWP1
1Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Stimulant medications are the most common treatment for
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). However, a multimodal approach
including health and wellness coaching (HWC) yielded improved outcomes for a
young adult female struggling with graduate studies. The purpose of this case
report is to illustrate the value of combining HWC, a science-based,
client-centered behavioral intervention, with psychiatric care in realizing
improved ADHD management.
Results: Six weeks of HWC resulted in meaningful improvements for
the client, in areas including academic achievement, personal growth,
self-efficacy, daily functioning, organizational skills, interpersonal skills,
and self-care. At the end of 6 weeks, the psychiatrist submitted a letter
outlining these improvements to the client’s academic program, and the client
was allowed to resume her graduate studies. This was the most important outcome
from the client’s point of view. Follow-up conversations between the coach and
client indicated that she maintained her gains over time.
Conclusions: Collaboration between a psychiatrist, health and
wellness coach, and client resulted in a successful intervention for improved
management of the client’s ADHD and executive functioning challenges. These
changes contributed to the client meeting her goal of being permitted to resume
her graduate studies.
(3815) Evidence for the Effectiveness of ADHD Coaching
Elizabeth Ahmann, ScD, Rn, PCC1, Micah Saviet, BA, CNA and Lisa Joy
Tuttle, MA, BCC2
1Maryland University of Integrative Health, Laurel, Maryland
2Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Overview: Coaching for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
(ADHD) emerged as a treatment modality in the 1990s but receives less attention
than either psychopharmacological or psychotherapeutic interventions in the
management of ADHD. Over the past decade, a research base examining coaching for
ADHD has begun to develop. This poster, reviewing extant research on ADHD
coaching, summarizes outcomes of this emerging practice modality. Most studies
in this review were identified through PubMed/Medline, EBSCO Megafile, Google
Scholar, and ERIC databases using keywords “ADHD,” “executive functions,” and
“coaching.” Several studies were identified through cross-referencing citations
in articles and a generic Google search. Nineteen studies addressing ADHD
coaching outcomes were identified. Of these, 16 were published in peer-reviewed
journals. A study in a book, a dissertation, and a conference presentation were
also found. The 19 studies varied in design, from a case study to randomized
controlled trials, and included qualitative and quantitative approaches. Studies
were mostly small in size—10 studies had ns ≤ 10—and examined coaching for ages
from childhood through adulthood. Outcome measures varied: among the 19 studies,
participants demonstrated improvements in executive functioning and ADHD
symptoms (19), well-being/improved family life (8), and
self-efficacy/self-esteem (3). Three studies found maintenance of gains; 9
identified satisfaction with coaching. Heterogeneity in study design, varied
training of the coaches, and varied outcome measures complicate comparison of
results between studies; small sample sizes are a limitation in this body of
research. Despite limitations, extant research consistently demonstrates
beneficial client outcomes with ADHD coaching.
Rationale: An overview of extant research on outcomes of ADHD
coaching will assist integrative health practitioners in understanding the
evidence for, and value of, collaborating with coaches in effective
client-centered management of ADHD.
Objectives: Awareness and understanding of extant ADHD coaching
research, participants will appreciate that coaching appears effective both as a
stand-alone modality and as a useful aspect of multimodal integrative
client-centered treatment for ADHD.
(3816) Tai Chi and Wellness for Gulf War Illness: Protocol for a Randomized
Trial
Katharine Smidt, PhD1, DeAnna L Mori, PhD2, Anica Pless Kaiser,
PhD1, Elizabeth Weinstein, BA1, Barbara L Niles,
PhD1 and Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc3
1National Center for PTSD – Behavioral Science Division, Boston,
Massachusetts
2Department of Psychiatry, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston,
Massachusetts
3Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Over 40,000 Veterans who served in the 1991 Gulf War have a
form of chronic multisymptom illness that defines Gulf War Illness (GWI). With
no existing proven treatments, it is critical to find efficacious and acceptable
treatments for GWI. Tai Chi has been practiced for centuries and accumulating
evidence demonstrates that it promotes both physical and psychological
well-being. Our randomized trial is underway to establish the efficacy of a Tai
Chi as a treatment for GWI. The current paper presents lessons learned in
developing and implementing the protocol for this rigorous, large-scale
randomized clinical trial.
Results: We will present our study design and describe how we
addressed issues such as: development of manualized interventions, minimizing
participant disappointment regarding randomization to group, finding space for
group interventions, minimizing waiting for a full cohort of participants to
randomize, maximizing session attendance, ensuring availability of instructors,
maximizing participant recruitment, and keeping assessors blinded to treatment
condition.
Conclusions: There are many challenges inherent in conducting
randomized clinical trials for mind-body treatments. We offer the solutions we
found to address obstacles to scientific rigor in the design and implementation
of a large-scale trial.
(3817) Outcomes of an Online Interprofessional Integrative Health Course for
Primary Care Educational Programs and Clinics
Audrey J Brooks, PhD1, Benjamin Kligler, MD, MPH1, Victoria
Maizes, MD1 and Patricia Lebensohn, MD1
1Tucson, Arizona
Abstract
Purpose: Clinical and cost-effectiveness evidence for integrative
healthcare (IH) is accruing; however, a shortage of trained IH providers exists.
The National Center for Integrative Primary Healthcare developed a course to
address this need with the goal of transforming primary care education to
include an interprofessional IH approach to patient care.
Results: In sum, 679 completed the course. Medical knowledge and IH
self-assessment scores improved at posttest (P < .05). Units
were highly rated (5-point scale): met objectives (4.4), technology (4.2),
clinical utility (4.1), educational depth (3.7), and helpfulness of resources
(3.8), reflections (3.8), and sharing reflections (3.2). A majority (60–73%)
recommended incorporating the units into required training. Final survey ratings
were also positive: interest in applying IH (4.5), seek additional IH education
(4.3), course enhanced educational/clinical experience (4.3), and recommend to
others (4.2). Two thirds reported incorporating new self-care practices.
Improvements in interprofessional collaboration, empathy, self-care behaviors,
resiliency, and well-being (P < .004) were found.
Conclusions: The Foundation Integrative Healthcare (FIH) course
successfully provided IH training to health professionals across the primary
care spectrum. FIH provides a foundation for building an IH training program in
educational and clinical settings. Online courses address time, cost, and
curriculum consistency challenges and can be widely disseminated.
(3820) A Study on the Severity Classification in the Korean Diagnosis-related
Groups for Korean Medicine
Byungmook Lim, PhD1, Jiseon Ryu, KMD, PhD1, Dongsu Kim, KMD,
PhD2 and Byungwook Lee, KMD, PhD3
1Pusan National University, Yangsan/Gyeongnam, Republic of Korea
2Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
3Dongguk University, Gyeongju, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Patient Classification System for Korean Medicine
inpatients (KDRG-KM) was developed in 2013 and has been applied for monitoring
the quality and costs of Korean Medicine hospitals. Yet, severity of patients’
condition is not applied in the KDRG-KM. This study aimed to develop the
severity classification methods for KDRG-KM and assessed the explanation powers
of the severity adjusted KDRG-KM.
Results: Two options for severity classification were deduced based
on the severity classification principle in the domestic and foreign DRG
systems. The option 1 is to classify severity groups using Clinical Complexity
Level (CCL) and Patient CCL scores, and the option 2 is to form a severity group
with patients who belonged principal diagnosis-secondary diagnosis combinations
which prolonged length of stay. For third option, patients who received certain
treatments for severe conditions were grouped into severity group. The treatment
expense of the severity group was significantly higher than that of other
patients groups.
Conclusions: Applying the severity classifications using principal
diagnosis and secondary diagnoses can advance the KDRG-KM for Korean Medicine
hospitalization. More practically, including patients with procedures for severe
conditions in a severity group needs to be considered.
(3821) A Targeted Non-pharmacologic Intervention to Prevent Chronic Low Back Pain
in High-risk Patients—The TARGET Trial
Rebecca Mishuris, MD1, Charles Williams, MD1, Samia Jaffar,
MPH1, Dorothy N Plumb, MA1, Robert B Saper, MD,
MPH1 and Iniya Rajendran, MD1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Acute Low Back Pain (aLBP) may progress to persistent
chronic low back pain (cLBP) with poor clinical outcomes. Early risk factor
screening can potentially guide primary care clinicians to intervene with
high-risk aLBP patients to prevent progression to cLBP. Psychologically Informed
Physical Therapy (PIPT), utilizing biomedical and cognitive behavioral
approaches, is a potential intervention to prevent cLBP progression and warrants
further evaluation.
Results: To date, in Boston, 1081 patients have been screened. Six
hundred thirty-seven (59%) have cLBP and were ineligible for TARGET but were
provided nonpharmacologic pain management resources. Of the 444 (35%) with aLBP,
165 (37%) were high risk and have been referred to PIPT.
Conclusions: It is feasible to integrate aLBP risk stratification
within the EMR in underserved primary care settings using a patient navigator
model leading to non-pharmacological pain management referrals. Challenges in
risk stratification include cross-cultural differences and language nuances
among our diverse population.
(3823) Needs and Capacity Assessment for Research on Naturopathy in
Canada
Kieran Cooley, ND1, Christopher Knee, MSc, ND2, Diane Grondin,
PhD3, Teresa Tsui, ND, MSc3 and Monique
Aucoin3
1Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
2Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
3Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Abstract
Purpose/Background: Naturopathy has been depicted as both an emerging and
evolving profession in Canada. Despite recent shifts in regulation and
recognition of the role that naturopathy plays in health-care delivery in
Canada, comparatively little research has been conducted on this practitioner
group. In order to better understand the needs and capacity for research on
naturopathy, a survey of naturopaths, naturopathic associations, and
complementary/alternative medicine researchers was piloted, revised through
stakeholder engagement, and broadly disseminated.
Results: Pilot testing, stakeholder engagement, and analysis of a
facilitated workshop have informed the design and distribution of a web-based
needs and capacity assessment for research on naturopathy in Canada. Results of
the full survey will be available for presentation prior to the ICIMH
conference.
Conclusions: Findings from this investigation will be used to inform
an agenda for naturopathy research and activities of the N-SIG with respect to
enhancing research capacity, improving the use of evidence within and about the
naturopathic profession.
(3824) Is Fasting Safe? A Chart Review of Adverse Events During Medically
Supervised, Water-only Fasting
Alan C Goldhamer, DC1, Toshia R Myers, PhD1, Bradley C Saul,
DrPH2 and John S Finnell, ND, MPH, Lac3
1TrueNorth Health Foundation, Santa Rosa, California
2North Carolina State University, Chapel Hill, North Carolina
3Bastyr University Research Institute, Austin, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Evidence suggests that fasting, during which only water is
consumed, results in potentially health promoting physiological effects.
However, peer-reviewed research assessing the safety of water-only fasting is
lacking. To address this, we conducted a chart review to describe adverse events
(AEs) that occurred during medically supervised, water-only fasting.
Results: There was 80.5% agreement between the original and
secondary MedDRA codes, with a weighted kappa statistic (squared weights) of
0.92 measuring agreement of the AE grade. During the protocol period, the
highest grade AE (HGAE) in 555 visits was a grade 2 event or lower, in 212
visits it was a grade 3 event, in 1 visit it was a grade 4 event, and there were
no grade 5 events. There were 2 (0.002%) visits with a serious AE (SAE). The
majority of AEs identified were mild (n = 4490, 75%) in nature and known
reactions to fasting.
Conclusions: To our knowledge, this is the most comprehensive
analysis of AEs experienced during medically supervised, water-only fasting
conducted to date. Overall, our data indicate that the majority of AEs
experienced were mild to moderate and known reactions to fasting. This suggests
that the protocol used in this study can be safely implemented in a medical
setting with minimal risk of a SAE.
(3826) Far Infrared Decreases Thermal Hypersensitivity, Edema Formation, and
Nitrite/Nitrate Plantar Tissue Concentration in a Mouse Model of Paw
Inflammation
Ralph F Rosas, MsC1, Aline A Emer, MsC1, Ana P Batisti,
MsC1, Bruna T Lenfers, MsC1, Franciane Bobinski,
PhD1, Fabricia Petronilho, PhD1, Lucinéia G Danielski,
MsC1, Mariana P Goldim, MsC1 and Francisco Cidral-Filho,
PhD2
1University of Southern Santa Catarina, Florianopolis, Palhoça, Brazil
2University of Southern Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the possible effect of far infrared (FIR)
emitted by far-infrared emitting ceramic (cFIR) materials upon thermal
hypersensitivity, edema formation, and nitrite/nitrate plantar tissue
concentration in the mouse model of Freud’s complete adjuvant (CFA)-induced paw
inflammation.
Results: CFA-injection resulted in a significant decrease in the
response latency to heat stimulus (hot plate test), an increase in paw edema as
well as increase in nitrite/nitrate plantar tissue concentrations. cFIR
treatment induced a significant decrease in sensitivity to hot stimulus
(P < .05); significant antiedematogenic activity
(P < .05), as well as a significant decrease in the
nitrite/nitrate concentration (P < .05).
Conclusions: FIR emitted by cFIR decreased thermal hypersensitivity,
edema formation, and nitrite/nitrate plantar tissue concentration in a mouse
model of CFA-induced inflammation.
(3827) Randomized Placebo-controlled Trial of Acupuncture to Prevent
Radiation-induced Xerostomia
Lorenzo Cohen, PhD1, Qi Wei, MS1, Zhiqiang Meng,
MD2, Wenying Bei, BS eq2, Yehua Shen, MD2, Mark
Chambers, DMD1, Chaosu Hu, MD2, Caijun Wu, BS eq2,
David I Rosenthal, MD1 and M Kay Garcia, DrPH1
1Houston, Texas
2Fudan University Cancer Center, Shanghai, China
Abstract
Purpose: To determine if acupuncture can prevent radiation-induced
xerostomia among head/neck cancer patients undergoing radiotherapy (XRT) in
China and the United States.
Results: For combined institutions at the 1-year follow-up
(N = 358), there was a significant between-group difference between VA and WLC
(26.6 vs 34.8, P = .001; Cohen’s D = −0.44),
with marginal between-group difference between VA and SA (26.6 vs 31.3,
P = 0.06; D = −0.26) and no difference
between SA and WLC. There was a significant group by institution effect. For
patients in China (N = 221), there were significant group differences between VA
and WLC (20.8 vs 29.6, P = .005; D = −0.48)
and between VA and SA (20.8 vs 29.9, P = 0.0045;
D = −0.50), with no difference between SA and WLC. For
patients in the United States (N = 137), there were significant between-group
differences between SA and WLC (31.8 vs 42.2, P = .01;
D = −0.59) and marginal group difference between VA and WLC
(34.7 vs 42.2, P = 0.07; D = −0.42), with no
differences between VA and SA. Incidence of clinically significant xerostomia
followed a similar pattern. Center differences will be discussed as they relate
to culture and the neuroscience of placebo.
Conclusions: Patients in China who received VA concurrently with XRT
experienced significantly less xerostomia as compared to SA and standard oral
hygiene only. In the United States, both VA and SA reduced xerostomia symptoms
1-year after XRT.
(3830) Treating Urge Urinary Incontinence in Older Adult Women with Complementary
Therapies: A Feasibility and Randomized Controlled Trial Utilizing MBSR and
HEP
Katherine P Supiano, PhD, LCSW, FT1 and Katarina Friberg Felsted,
MS2
1University of Utah College of Nursing, Salt Lake City, Utah
2Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Purpose: Older adult women have the highest incidence of urge
urinary incontinence in the population. Current treatment practices for this
age-group remain insufficient and largely ineffective. This study sought to
determine the research and intervention feasibility of a randomized controlled
trial comparing mindfulness-based stress reduction compared with the Health
Enhancement program in older adult women presenting with urge urinary
incontinence. Preliminary efficacy data were also evaluated.
Results: Feasibility determinants were recorded and evaluated
throughout and at completion of the study. All 6 feasibility determinants
provided positive results in the enrolled population. Preliminary efficacy data
indicate that while both mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and HEP
groups improved in a statistically significant way, the MBSR group improvement
was statistically significant compared to the HEP group improvement. Additional
mixed method data analysis is underway.
Conclusions: These positive feasibility results warrant the design
of a larger scale, multisite trail to study the efficacy of MBSR in treating
urge urinary incontinence. The feasibility and preliminary efficacy data suggest
that MBSR may be a reasonable approach for older adult women with urge urinary
incontinence. There is also evidence that a combined MBSR and HEP approach may
be suitable.
(3836) The Role of the ECB System in the Effects Induced by High-intensity
Swimming Exercise in an Animal Model of Chronic Peripheral Inflammation
Francisco Cidral-Filho, PhD1, Afonso Salgado, PhD1, Daniel F
Martins, PhD1, Aline Siteneski2, Daniela D Ludtke2
and Adair RS Santos, PhD2
1University of Southern Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
2University of Federal of Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: The present study investigated the role of the ECB system
in the effects induced by high intensity swimming in an animal model of chronic
peripheral inflammation.
Results: High-intensity swimming induced hyponociception and reduced
paw edema. AM281 or AM630 pretreatment prevented swimming-induced
hyponociception. Preadministration of URB937 or JZL184 prolonged
swimming-induced hyponociception.
Conclusions: High-intensity swimming induces hyponociception and
reduces edema in animals with chronic peripheral inflammation. Activation of CB1
and CB2 receptors and prolongation of hyponociception by inhibition of ECB
degradation enzymes confirm the participation of the ECB system in
swimming-induced hyponociception.
(3837) PACT—A Transformative Self-management Program for Chronic Pain Utilizing
Online Education and Tele-health Coaching
Jeanette Ziegenfuss, PhD1, Gabriela Vazquez Benitez, PhD1,
Karen Lawson, MD2, Robin Whitebird, MSW, PhD2, Elizabeth
Grossman, MS3 and James R Fricton, DDS, MS3
1Health Partners Institute, Bloomington, Minnesota
2Bloomington, Minnesota
3Health Partners Institute, Edina, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: The Institute of Medicine has made research on pain
conditions among its highest priorities due to high prevalence and cost. Health
professionals’ primary role for chronic pain should be guiding, coaching, and
assisting patients with day-to-day self-management. However, they often lack the
time and training to perform this role, and there is limited research on
self-management approaches. This transformative care model integrates robust
self-management online training with health and wellness tele-coaching to
improve outcomes from self-management of chronic pain.
Results: Eighty-one subjects were randomized to PACT and TSC, 1
subject withdraw from the study. Mean age was 47 (SD = 16), 86% were female, and
82% had pain onset of 1 year or more. Participants showed significant
improvement in measures of pre–post change at 8 weeks for pain severity (PACT
−.94 vs TSC −0.5), but not for pain interference or jaw functioning (16 week
follow-up data are still in collection at the time of this submission but will
be completed and included at the time of the conference).
Conclusions: This research demonstrated that transformative care
model that includes tele-health coaching and online training is both feasible
and effective. It provides an accessible, scalable, and transferable method for
self-management that can be integrated into routine care without increasing the
burden of time demands upon the providers.
(3839) A Randomized Trial Comparing a Stretching/Exercise Program and Learning
About Self-care Practices From a Self-care Book for Chronic Low Back Pain
Marc Brodsky, MD1, Ann Hansen, DVM, MD, FACP1 and Wendy Bjerke,
PhD2
1Boise, Idaho
2Idaho
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the efficacy of a stretching exercise program
versus learning self-care practices from a self-care book for chronic low back
pain
Results:
This is a late breaking abstract as the final cohort began 10/4/17 and
will be completed 12/20/17.
Conclusions:
This is a late breaking abstract as the final cohort began 10/4/17 and
will be completed 12/20/17.
(3841) Challenges and Strategies for Implementing Battlefield Acupuncture in the
VA
Karleen Giannitrapani, PhD, MPH1, Stephanie Taylor, PhD, MPH2,
Princess Ackland, PhD3, Jesse Holliday, MSW1, Kavitha Reddy,
MD4 and Benjamin Kligler, MD, MPH4
1VA Palo Alto Healthcare System, Menlo Park, California
2VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Los Angeles, California
3Minneapolis VA Health Care System, Minneapolis, Minnesota
4Washington, DC
Abstract
Purpose: Battlefield acupuncture (BFA) is a rapid, 5-needle,
auriculotherapy protocol for pain. Although nearly 1000 VA clinicians have been
trained in BFA, little is known about how well BFA has been implemented at the
VA. We sought to understand the challenges BFA providers experienced in
implementing BFA and any successful strategies they used to overcome these
challenges.
Results: Sites reported multiple implementation challenges. Many
said their states’ licensure regulations prevent nonphysician providers from
having acupuncture privileges. Others reported having insufficient dedicated
time to meet high patient demand (e.g., having a BFA-specific clinic timeslot).
Perhaps unique to the VA were challenges in being able to purchase supplies and
often having an overly burdensome local credentialing process. Many said that
several months had passed between the time they were trained in BFA and could
finally overcome these barriers to provide BFA, resulting in their no longer
feeling confident they knew how to deliver BFA. Strategies used to overcome
implementation challenges included integrating BFA provision in an existing
clinic (e.g., pain or mental health clinic); using group visits and walk-in
clinics to meet high patient demand; increasing buy-in from peers,
administrators and leadership to overcome logistical and local credentialing
challenges; getting BFA training only after credentialing challenges were
addressed; and having a dedicated person for either scheduling or providing
BFA.
Conclusions: Systematic challenges can impede BFA implementation at
the VA and perhaps elsewhere. Some challenges can be addressed at local
facilities, while others are regulatory in nature and, as such, are more
impeding.
(3845) Human Touch: Perceptions of Self-efficacy From a Non-pharmacology
Treatment for Individuals Living With HIV/AIDS
Carolee Dodge-Francis, EdD1, Sheila Clark, PhD1, Karl Kingsley,
PhD, MPH1 and Anne E Weisman, PhD, MPH, LMT1
1University of Nevada Las Vegas, Las Vegas, Nevada
Abstract
Overview:
HIV/AIDS and a subsequent drug regimen can create many negative symptoms and side
effects that lead those infected to seek out alternative and complementary
therapies as treatments. Massage therapy is an ancient form of treatment that is
now gaining popularity as part of the integrative medicine movement. A
phenomenological, qualitative research study was conducted at Aid for AIDS of
Nevada. Participants received a massage, and rich descriptive narratives were
captured from the 12 participants: 6 females and 6 males, ranging in age from 30
to 67 years. The interviews were transcribed and coded for themes. For the
purpose of this qualitative study, the research design included field
observations and one on one interviews. Data were analyzed using a
phenomenological lens. The data were coded for themes that emerged from the data
and grouped. Four thematic themes resulted from this data analysis:
self-efficacy, human connectivity through touch, physical and mental responses,
and an emotional roller coaster. Bandura states “perceived self-efficacy is
concerned with people’s beliefs in their ability to influence events that
influence their lives.” Many of the participants expressed statements that the
nonpharmacology treatment of massage therapy assisted them in making a variety
of positive decisions, thus alluding to the question of self-efficacy.
Rationale: People living with HIV/AIDS face many challenges managing
the multiple symptoms that accompany infection. In a clinical trial study among
HIV-positive patients seeking relief from complementary and alternative
therapies, the most commonly reported symptoms were nausea, insomnia,
dermatological problems, depression, and weakness. To date, much of the research
about living with HIV/AIDS focused on prevention and treatment, symptom
management, and quality of life. There has been a surge in massage therapy
research recently. However, no research exists to examine how receiving massage
therapy could impact self-efficacy for people living with HIV/AIDS. Finch and
Becker, in preliminary work investigating changes in self-efficacy in MS
patients receiving massage therapy, found significant improvement after an 8
week series of treatments. Self-efficacy has been found to be a predictor of
health status, and the concept is implicitly linked to psychoemotional
morbidity. Notably, a negative perception of control (a key component of
self-efficacy) has been associated with both decreased optimism and increased
hopelessness. These findings suggest that massage therapy has the potential to
positively impact people with HIV/AIDS who receive massage therapy and will
explore how self-efficacy is impacted. This directly ties into the theme of the
conference of Collaboration in Action: Advancing Integrative Health through
Research, Education, Clinical Practice and Policy.
Objectives: Participants will know how massage therapy affects
self-efficacy for individuals living with HIV/AIDS.
(3846) The Effect of Mindfulness Practice on Graduate Occupational Therapy
Students Perceived Stress and Well-being
Mary Walsh Roche, MS1, Nicole Palse1, Alexander
Lopes1, Sarah Wolosin1, Ingrid Nichols1,
Christine Rigney1 and Jan Garbarini, PhD1
1Dominican College, Orangeburg, New York
Abstract
Overview: The purpose of this study is to identify the effects of
mindfulness practice on reducing perceived stress levels among occupational
therapy students enrolled in a nontraditional weekend graduate program who are
beginning the clinical phase of their education. The idea for a program in which
participants could practice on their own as part of a virtual community was
proposed as a way to increase opportunities for students to learn about and
experience mindfulness practice. As part of this initiative, mindfulness
education and practice sessions were incorporated into the Fieldwork Seminar
graduate course classroom activities. All students enrolled in the course
attended a 1-h “Introduction to Mindfulness” presentation and engaged in three
15-min mindfulness practice sessions over the course of the 6 weekends they were
on campus during the Fall trimester (16 weeks). In addition, students were
invited to volunteer to participate in an independent mindfulness practice
component as part of a virtual community. Eighteen of 43 students agreed to
participate in this virtual community and independent practice. These
participants were provided with a brief-guided mindful breathing and body scan
audio recording to practice daily on their own for 10 weeks. Participants
received weekly email practice reminders and resources, and they agreed to chart
the frequency of their practice. All students completed quantitative and
qualitative pre- and posttest self-report measures of perceived stress and
mindfulness. Students were also asked to respond to open-ended questions
exploring their perceptions and knowledge base at pre- and posttest. Results
were analyzed to assess the change that occurred over the course of the program.
Future occupational therapy practitioners benefit from learning about
mindfulness and such programs may assist students in developing practices early
in their careers that promote well-being and stress relief.
Rationale: The topic is relevant to the conference theme of
“Collaboration in Action: Advancing Integrative Health through Research,
Education, Clinical Practice and Policy” as this poster presentation addresses
education, research, and clinical practice. The purpose of the study is to
identify the effects of mindfulness practice on reducing perceived stress in
occupational therapy students enrolled in a graduate program who are beginning
the clinical phase of their education. It is important for future health-care
providers to learn the importance of self-care and to develop skills to care for
their own physical, emotional, social, and spiritual well-being. Health-care
providers do not seek to learn such skills frequently until burnout and
compassion fatigue are evident. Students in this graduate program follow a
nontraditional full-time format. Students are on campus 6 weekends a trimester
and there is a great deal of work outside of class time that must be
accomplished. In addition, many graduate students work full time while attending
school. This leaves students little time to engage in mindfulness workshops and
activities that are offered during the typical college weekly schedule.
Providing students with opportunities to learn about and practice mindfulness in
a way that fits into their full schedules will hopefully help them cultivate
positive habits and routines that they will carry into their clinical education
and into their work lives after graduation.
Objectives: At the end of this session, participants will be able to
explain the benefits of integrating opportunities for mindfulness education and
practice into the curriculum for graduate health professions students; describe
the ways mindfulness practice was introduced into course sessions during the
trimester during this study; reflect on ways in which they might incorporate
similar programs into their practice settings.
(3850) Adherence to Mind–Body Therapies: A Systematic Review and
Meta-analysis
Malik Shaw1, Michelle Park, BA1, Raveendhara R Bannuru, MD,
PhD1 and Chenchen Wang, MD, MSc1
1Tufts Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Non-pharmacological treatments such as exercise have
suffered from low adherence, the degree to which a patient correctly follows a
prescribed treatment. Recent evidence indicates mind–body therapies may be
effective in managing knee osteoarthritis. However, adherence to mind–body
treatments that incorporate both physical and psychological components remains
unknown. We systematically review evidence on adherence to mind–body
interventions for knee osteoarthritis.
Results: Ten RCTs, published between 2000 and 2016, with a total of
954 subjects (67.7% women) met our inclusion criteria. Sample sizes varied
between 33 and 250. Mean age was 66.5 years, and treatment durations ranged from
8 to 18 weeks. Duration of knee osteoarthritis ranged from 2 months to 1 year
(Table 1). Four studies were on yoga, 5 were on Tai Chi, and 1 was on qigong. Of
the 6 studies that reported on adherence, 4 studies defined adherence as
attending ≥75% of sessions and 2 studies defined adherence as attending ≥50% of
sessions. The overall adherence rate was 81% (95% Confidence Interval; 64%,
91%). For the 2 studies that defined their adherence as attending ≥50% of
sessions, the overall adherence rate was 65%.
Conclusions: The results of our study indicate that the adherence
rate to mind–body therapies appears to be high in patients with knee
osteoarthritis. Generalizability of our results may be limited by the quality of
reporting among the available RCT evidence. Future trials should define
adherence a priori and report it consistently to improve study quality.
(3854) Impact of an Integrative Health Clinical Education Effort on Changing
Clinician Attitudes and Behaviors
Stephen R Shamblen, PhD1, Aree Sangpukdee, EdD1, Ben Kligler,
MD2, Tracy Gaudet, MD2, Theresa Liao, MD2,
Katharine A Atwood, MSc, ScD1, April Schweinhart, PhD1 and
Adam Rindfleisch, MD3
1Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, Louisville, Kentucky
2Portland, Oregon
3University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to assess whether a 3-day
clinical education course focused on Integrative Health (IH) and
patient-centered care strategies, delivered to clinical staff at Veteran Health
Administration (VHA) facilities, resulted in changes in attitudes,
self-efficacy, preparedness to use non-pharmaceutical approaches to care, and
self-reported use of Integrative Medicine (IM) strategies after 3-month
follow-up.
Results: Self report survey findings suggest that the clinical
course was associated with attitudinal and behavioral changes at the 3-month
follow-up, including increases in attitudes toward IH, self-efficacy to engage
in IH strategies, perceived preparedness to discuss nonpharmaceutical approaches
to care, and greater use of IH strategies during clinical encounters.
Differential impacts were found for participant age, gender, occupational role,
and whether the participant volunteered or was required to attend.
Conclusions: Findings suggest that a brief, experiential course,
designed to be a foundational strategy in driving transformation, is effective
at achieving sustained shifts in attitudes and self-reported use of IM
strategies.
(3860) Introduction to Functional Nutrition Increases Provider Preparedness and
Self-efficacy
Theresea Liao, MD1, Nancy A Cotter, MD1, Gail Meissen,
RDN2, Sherry Brewer, MD3, Sherri Pollack, RDN3,
Anne Utech, PhD3, Marite Hagman, MPH4, William Scarbrough,
PhD5, Adam Rindfleisch, MD4 and April Schweinhart,
PhD5
1Veterans Health Administration, Montclair, New Jersey
2Veteran Health Administration, Madison, Wisconsin
3Veterans Health Administration, Washington, DC
4University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin
5Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, Louisville, Kentucky
Abstract
Purpose: As part of its clinical education initiative, the Veteran’s
Affairs Office of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation introduced a
new, 2-day course for clinicians entitled, Eating for Whole Health:
Functional Approaches to Food and Drink. Two pilot implementations
of the course were evaluated using both qualitative and quantitative methods to
determine the distribution of course participants, their reactions to the
course, and how they improved on measures designed around course outcomes.
Results: There were no significant improvements in self-care from
pretest to follow-up, although this was likely due to high baseline level
reports on this outcome (M = 3.1, range = 1–4). Similarly, 1
implementation showed no significant increase in Mindful Eating from pretest to
follow-up, again, likely due to high baseline levels (M = 3.1,
range = 1–4). However, both implementations showed significant improvements in
Nutritional Preparedness (P < .001) and Nutritional
Self-efficacy (P < .001) from pretest to posttest which were
sustained at follow-up. Moreover, findings from the focus group indicated
participants would be bringing strategies they had learned in the course, such
as Mindful Eating, back into their own lives and into their practice with
patients.
Conclusions: The results of these pilot course implementations show
that a short, provider-focused course designed to introduce a Whole Health
approach to nutrition can have sustained impacts on provider self-reports of
Preparedness and Self-efficacy for discussing functional nutrition with
patients.
(3862) Implementing an Inner-city Prenatal Yoga Program: A Case Study at Newark’s
University Hospital obstetrician-gynecologist Clinic
Kristen Harris1, Emily Babiss1, Lisa Gittens-Williams,
MD1, Alejandrina Canelo Villafana, MS1 and Katherine
Salamone, MA1
1New York, New York
Abstract
Overview: Prenatal yoga is a subgroup of yoga for pregnant women. It
includes breathing exercises, meditation, and poses tailored at easing the
physical and emotional changes women undergo during pregnancy and delivery.
Studies evaluating prenatal yoga suggest a range of benefits. A systematic
review evaluating 10 randomized control trials suggests prenatal yoga
intervention was associated with lower incidences of prenatal disorders and
small for gestational age births. Studies also showed yoga interventions were
associated with lower levels of pain and stress.
The prenatal yoga program at University Hospital Prenatal Clinic in Newark, NJ
was introduced in April, 2017. This inner-city clinic serves a predominantly
African American and Hispanic population, where the average household income is
$33 139. Women in Essex County have a higher rate of preterm birth than the
state average and are more likely to deliver low birth weight infants. The
existing Lifestyle Pregnancy Program (Centering Pregnancy for Diabetes and
Obesity) provides an integrative approach to care for high-risk pregnant women.
Patients attend group sessions with a physician, facilitators, and content
experts where lifestyle management and long-term health maintenance are
discussed. Our prenatal yoga program was introduced during the Lifestyle
Centering Program. A similar session was delivered in the clinic waiting area to
broaden patient exposure.
A certified yoga instructor developed a 20-min sequence of chair yoga postures
and trained 2 medical students who delivered the program to women of any
gestational age. Sessions began with alternate-nose breathing and stretching.
Six active postures followed to emphasize stretching and strengthening,
including Star, Tree, Chair, and Downward-Facing Dog. Following each session,
patients were asked if they had questions, given an illustrated representation
of the postures, and encouraged to repeat the sequence at home. There were 19
participants in the Lifestyle Pregnancy Program and 28 participants in the
waiting area sessions.
Rationale: Prenatal yoga has been shown to have positive health
effects for both mother and baby. Our aim was to introduce the practice of yoga
to women in our at-risk patient population to increased awareness and
accessibility. Yoga is most commonly practiced among non-Hispanic, white,
college-educated, female, and young- to middle-aged adults; and the prenatal
period is an important time to introduce and emphasize wellness practices;
successful program implementation required collaboration between patients,
obstetrician-gynecologist practitioners, clinic staff, and medical students.
Objectives: Our objectives in testing this prenatal yoga program
were to determine whether implementation of the program was feasible, report
barriers to initiation, and assess patient response; conference participants
will gain an appreciation for the potential benefits of prenatal yoga and will
learn about starting a prenatal yoga class in an underserved population. Tools
to initiate prenatal yoga classes in similar environments will be provided.
(3863) The Effects of Spinal Manipulation on Migraine Pain and Disability: A
Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Rhayun Song, RN, PhD1, Pamela Rist, ScD2, Audrey J Hernandez,
MS2, Carolyn Bernstein, MD2, Matthew Kowalski,
DC2, Kamila Osypiuk, MS2, Cynthia R Long, PhD3,
Peter M Wayne, PhD4, Christine M Goertz, DC, PhD3 and Robert D
Vining, DC3
1Chungnum National University, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
2Boston, Massachusetts
3Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
4Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Migraine is one of the leading causes of disability
worldwide. Manual therapies and spinal manipulation are among the most commonly
used nonpharmacologic approaches for treating migraines. We performed a
systematic review and meta-analysis of published randomized controlled trials
(RCTs) to evaluate the evidence regarding spinal manipulation as an alternative
or integrative therapy in reducing migraine pain and disability.
Results: Our search identified 6 RCTs (pooled n = 677; range of
n = 42–218) eligible for meta-analysis. Of the 6 studies, 5 compared treatment
groups to active controls (e.g., sham electro-stimulation, medications, and
spinal mobilization). Intervention duration ranged from 2 to 6 months; outcomes
were assessed between 0 and 52 weeks posttreatment. Outcomes indicated high
levels of heterogeneity among studies (I2 = 72.6% and
I2 = 82.7% for pain and disability, respectively). Methodological
quality scores indicated low bias in 2 trials, moderate bias in 3, and high bias
in 1. Random effects models indicated that spinal manipulation significantly
reduced pain with an overall moderate effect size (Hedges’ g = −0.69; 95% CI
−1.13, −0.26; P < .001). Spinal manipulation also
significantly decreased disability with an overall moderate effect size (Hedges’
g = −0.70; 95% CI −1.21,−0.19; P = .007).
Conclusions: Spinal manipulation may be an effective therapeutic
technique to reduce migraine pain and disability. Methodologically rigorous,
large-scale RCTs are warranted to better inform the evidence base for spinal
manipulation as a treatment for migraine.
(3865) What is the Appropriate Duration of Care for Chronic Low Back and Chronic
Neck Pain Patients?
Patricia M Herman, ND, PhD1 and Mallika Kommareddi, MPH
1RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, California
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic low back pain (CLBP) and chronic neck pain (CNP)
are two of the most prevalent types of chronic pain. Spinal manipulation is one
recommended treatment for this pain, commonly delivered by chiropractors.
However, little work has been done on the appropriate duration of this care for
this population.
Results: Essentially all these patients have been in pain for years
(M = 13.8, SD = 13.0), have been receiving chiropractic care for years
(M = 10.9, SD = 11.6), and perceive that their pain would be substantially
higher (M = 6.8 SD = 2.2 on a 0–10 scale) than current levels (M = 3.1 SD = 3.8
on a 0–10 scale) if they did not see their chiropractor. During the 3-month data
collection period, only 131 (8.0%) of patients ended their chiropractic care and
51 (38.9%) of these also restarted it again, so continuous chiropractic care is
fairly common for this population. The HLM models indicate that on average pain
and function improved slowly and significantly for patients over the 3-month
period. However, those with both CLBP and CNP have worse pain and function than
others with only CLBP or CNP and their pain and function improvement is even
slower. The longer someone has been in pain also slows pain and function
improvement. However, those who report higher estimates of what their pain would
have been without going to the chiropractor improve more over time.
Conclusions: What seems to be working for these patients is
continuous (aka maintenance) care. Unfortunately, not enough ended care (and
ended it because of no longer needing care) during this period to enable
prediction of a patient-satisfactory end of care. Instead, the higher pain
values reported by patients as what they would experience without chiropractic
care provide an argument for maintenance care.
(3866) The Unani Medicine Approach to Dietetics: Using Food Energetics to Balance
the Patient’s Temperament (Mizaj)
Samira S Ardalan, BA1 and Hakima Amri, PhD1
1Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: Unani Medicine originated in the Eastern-Mediterranean
region and was systematized and compiled by Ibn Sina (Avicenna) in his Canon of
Medicine. Unani Medicine is another alternative medical system that looks at the
body as a whole, instead of by its individual parts. Ibn Sina’s practices and
proven methods of natural healing are still being taught today throughout
various continents across the globe.
In this work, we focus on the importance of diet in Unani Medicine, or the
influence of foods and drinks on the maintenance and preservation of health
using modern scientific discoveries. Most illnesses arise solely from
long-continued errors of diet and regimen. The Unani approach to food and
dietetics is contingent on the individual eating the right foods and drinks, in
the right quantity, at the right time/season, to maintain balance, good health,
and prevent disease. In Unani medicine, the Mediterranean-inspired diet consists
of simple, all natural, dishes, snacks, and drinks that balance one’s unique
Mizaj (Temperament). One’s Mizaj characterizes their fundamental makeup and the
vital energies that flow within their body, mind, and spirit. We will discuss
the modern interpretation of the elemental qualities of one’s Mizaj (i.e., hot,
cold, wet, and dry), which help the practitioner understand what foods and
drinks are best for the patient. For instance, if the dominant Mizaj consists of
the Earth qualities (cold and dry); it is advised to consume warming foods to
balance the cold that the patient’s body naturally presents.
Although Avicenna’s explanation of each step is based on the theories and
principles of his time (humors, elements, and temperaments), his explanatory
model holds still true today in light of our modern interpretation of health and
disease.
Rationale: This topic in important as it discusses the relevance of
food and diet as presented in Unani Medicine.
Objectives: Participants will learn how Unani Medicine views food
and diet when treating patients and find about the importance of food
energetics.
(3867) Employing Evidence in Evaluating Complementary Therapies: Findings From an
Ethnography of Integrative Pain Management at a Large Urban Pediatric
Hospital
Isabel Roth, MS, DrPH (c)1, Joan Engebretson, DrPH1, Linda
Highfield, PhD1, Paula Cuccaro, PhD1, Rebecca Wells,
PhD1 and Sanghamitra M Misra, MD2
1UTHealth School of Public Health, Houston, Texas
2Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Ethnographies of integrative health-care models have
revealed intricate social, professional, and ideological challenges between
biomedical practitioners and complementary therapists. The need for in-depth
observation on the impact of integrative medical care on patients has been
implicated as a promising future direction by past researchers. This study aimed
to better understand the role evidence played in the process of integration of
complementary and integrative therapies into a large urban pediatric hospital
from the perspective of patients, caregivers, providers, and administrators
through applied medical ethnography.
Results: Analysis of the data revealed 5 themes regarding the role
of evidence in the process of integration: Anecdotal Evidence and
Personal Experience Effecting CIM Use, Open to Trying Whatever Works,
Resistance to the Unfamiliar, Patients and Parents Trusting Doctors as
Experts, and Importance of Scientific Evidence to
Biomedicine. All themes address the role of evidence in relation to
cultural acceptance of complementary therapies and correlate with 3 thought
processes: critical thinking, relying on others for evidence, and reactionary
thinking.
Conclusions: As biomedical environments seek to integrate IM into
pain regimens, education and training are needed for providers, administrators,
and families about the context and evidence for IM. In order to create a truly
patient-centered healing encounter, families must be empowered to participate in
the decision-making process and bring their own personal and cultural knowledge
into their health care.
(3868) Art therapy Program for Parents-caregivers Inside the Bone Marrow
Transplant Unit (UTMO) at Hospital de Niños Dr Luis Calvo Mackenna
Ilana D Solowiejczyk, MA1, Luis Calvo Mackenna2 and María Inés
Villanueva1
1Hospitalde Niños
2Santiago, Chile, Santiago, Chile
Abstract
Overview: This work presents an ongoing experience using art therapy
(AT) to promote health and provide support to parents-caregivers of hospitalized
and isolated children in the Bone Marrow transplant Unit UTMO children in an
isolation unit for bone marrow transplants at the Hospital de Niños Dr Luis
Calvo Mackenna in Santiago, Chile. This hospital is a national referral center
for complex pathologies. Many patients come from distant locations to be
transplanted. Both patients and caregivers stay in isolation for at least 41
days in order to complete the transplant protocol. Caregivers often face
disruption of their personal, family, and professional life in addition to the
responsibilities and emotional cost of caring for a sick child. Financial stress
is added to the difficulties of living in a restricted space with strict rules
and schedules. They assume this new role at the expense of losing their sense of
identity, independence, and decision-making abilities. Program objectives
include: improve socialization, promote health and well-being, and strengthen
caregivers coping skills. AT sessions are held weekly inside the 8 bed unit so
parents can tend to their children if required. The number of participants per
session ranges from 0 to 8 and the average number of sessions attended is 4. A
total of 32 caregivers have participated since November, 2016. Difficulties
establishing a consistent AT setting and schedule, frequent interruptions and
lack of privacy are addressed as well as adjusting to the restrictions on
quantity and type of materials allowed in the Unit. High patient turnover and
discharges and death of patients may affect attendance and objectives and
interfere with follow-up and evaluation efforts. Every session and art
production is registered. Overall, caregivers have informally reported
satisfaction and increased interest in attending and motivating the hospital and
a private foundation to support implementation of new AT programs.
Rationale: Taking care of the caretakers will ultimately reflect in
the quality of care they can provide for their children. The Hospital is a
national referral center for complex pathologies and many patients come from
distant locations in the country to be treated and hopefully transplanted. Both
patients and caregivers must live in an isolated unit for at least 41 days in
order to complete the rigorous transplant protocol. The center of attention is
certainly the child and parents or other caretakers are often left aside. They
might face severe disruption of their personal, family, and professional life.
High levels of fatigue, stress, and loneliness are common. Most of the families
have been dealing with diagnosis for a long time. The inability to care for
other children left at home and financial stress due to the high costs of
treatment, relocation, and so forth, is added to the difficulty of living in a
restricted space with strict schedules and rules, caring for a very sick child.
caretakers might assume this new role at the expense of their sense of identity,
loss of independence, and decision-making ability. This public hospital has been
unable to address the needs of the parents and caregivers. This is an innovative
AT experience in Chile. Parents-caretakers have not been served inside
transplant units, allowing them to continue being close to their kids while
sharing and creating with a group of adults going through the same hopeful and
painful treatment.
Objectives: Participants will learn an innovative way of supporting
caretakers’ health and well-being in a hospital environment; how art therapy can
offer a new delivery model, providing a safe space for adults in an isolated
unit in a children hospital; about the reality of a public hospital and
population in Santiago, Chile; participant will hear about the challenges of
doing art in an isolation unit, as well as the success of the experience; and
participants will share their views and ideas for improving the program and
hopefully help design a method for evaluating this program.
(3869) Use of Complementary and Integrated Health: A Retrospective Analysis by
U.S. Veterans With Chronic Musculoskeletal Pain Nationally
Anita Yuan, PhD1, Patricia Herman, PhD2, Karen Chu,
MS1, Karl Lorenz, MD3, Nell J Marshall, PhD4
and Stephanie L Taylor, PhD, MPH5
1Los Angeles, California
2RAND, Santa Monica, California
3Veterans Health Administration, Palo Alto, California
4Palo Alto, California
5VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic musculoskeletal pain is highly prevalent, but there
are concerns with the risks and benefits of common therapies. Complementary and
integrative health (CIH) therapies, including yoga, meditation, and acupuncture,
are important nonpharmacologic options. Health-care systems are increasingly
offering CIH therapies, and the Veterans Health Administration (VA), the
nation’s largest integrated health-care system, has been at the forefront of
this movement. Examining CIH therapy use for musculoskeletal pain could inform
opportunities to improve CIH therapy uptake.
Results: In our cohort, 15% used meditation, 7% yoga, 6%
acupuncture, 5% chiropractic, 4% guided imagery, 3% biofeedback, 2% tai chi, 2%
massage, and 0.2% used hypnosis, with 27% using any. Those who were more likely
to use any CIH therapy (at P<.0001 level) included female
(33% probability) versus male (23% probability), single (27% probability) versus
married (22% probability).
Conclusions: Use of CIH therapies is prevalent among veterans with
chronic musculoskeletal pain. Low rates of some specific CIH therapies and
associations of CIH with a growing population of single and female, veterans
suggest the potential to augment CIH use. Given CIH use by one quarter of
veterans, evaluating clinical impact appears feasible.
(3871) Wellness Interventions for Medical Residents—Do Animals Beat
Machines?
Peter J Bayley, PhD1, Mala C Mandyam, MD1, Rachael Cho,
MSEd1, Lisa Shieh, MD, PhD1 and Danielle C Mathersul,
PhD1
1Palo Alto, CA, United States
Abstract
Purpose: Physician burnout contributes to workplace stress and has
been shown to negatively impact patient care. One underutilized potential avenue
for improving physician wellness is break time. Anecdotal evidence suggests that
physicians often spend their brief periods of free time on their smartphones.
However, some studies suggest that excessively accessing social media, news, and
e-mails can be detrimental to mental health, increasing social isolation and
discontent. Animal-assisted therapy is known to benefit hospital patients with
various conditions, including mental illness, postoperative pain, and
cardiovascular disease. Recognizing the benefits of therapy animals, health-care
facilities now offer these services to staff. Pet Assisted Wellness at Stanford
(PAWS) is a group of volunteer owners and dogs that regularly visits inpatients
and may also be available to staff.
Results: Preliminary data from 34 Stanford internal medicine
residents (50% F, 29.18 years (SD = 3.27); 50% PAWS condition) were analyzed.
Interestingly, while residents in the PAWS condition had significantly greater
reductions in self-reported stress (P < .001) than the
smartphone condition, they also had significantly lower HF n.u.
(P = .045) and a trend toward a higher LF:HF
(P = .086).
Conclusions: Together, these preliminary findings suggest that while
the PAWS condition increased arousal (possibly due to the excitement of the dogs
and the dynamic change to the work environment), it had positive effects on
overall well-being.
(3872) Making Mindfulness Accessible for First Responders: A Novel Immersion
Approach
Joshua B Kaplan, MS1, Richard Goerling, MBA2, Candice H
Kennedy, MS1 and Michael Christopher, PhD1
1Pacific University, Hillsboro, Oregon
2Hillsboro Police Department, Hillsboro, Oregon
Abstract
Overview: Exposure to critical incidents place law enforcement
officers (LEOs) at an increased risk for adverse psychological and physiological
health outcomes when compared to the general U.S. population. Mindfulness-Based
Resilience Training (MBRT) is an 8-week intervention designed to enhance
psychological and physiological health among first responders. In a recent RCT,
MBRT participants experienced greater reductions in salivary cortisol,
self-reported aggression, burnout, alcohol use, and sleep disturbance, relative
to waitlist controls. However, some participants were unable to commit to an
8-week training model. To enhance program accessibility and adherence, we
developed a 2-day immersion model.
Rationale: The goal of this session is to present the clinical
outline of the MBRT immersion model. The immersion training includes topics such
as an orientation to the concept of mindfulness, psychoeducation on the
mind–body relationship, stress reactivity, and barriers to mindfulness practice.
Formal mindfulness practices such as body scan, awareness of breath, sitting
meditation, and mindful walking are described, practiced, and discussed.
Integrating mindfulness into on- and off-duty tasks is also emphasized. Brief
practices will be reviewed during the presentation.
Objectives: MBRT is an innovative mindfulness-based intervention
(MBI) tailored to first responder culture. The 2-day immersion model may enhance
accessibility for LEOs, allowing participation in a MBI that may be inconvenient
in an 8-week format. Research following outcomes associated with participation
in the immersion model is in its tentative stages and continues to develop in an
effort to better understand and promote mechanisms of LEO health. Session
attendees will gain introductory knowledge in conducting intensive MBIs with
first responders.
(3875) National Survey of Veteran Interest in and Use of Complementary and
Integrative Health Approaches
Stephanie L Taylor, PhD, MPH1, Benjamin Kligler, MD, MPH2,
Katherine Hoggatt, PhD2, Alison Whitehead, MPH2 and Amanda
Hull, MPH2
1VA Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, Los Angeles, California
2Washington, DC
Abstract
Purpose: A major expansion of the provision of complementary and
integrative health (CIH) approaches is underway at the Veterans Health
Administration (VA), the nation’s largest integrated health-care system.
However, we know little about veteran-reported interest in and use of CIH
approaches. As such, we conducted a national survey to examine this issue.
Results: At least half of veterans were interested in
trying/learning more about 6 CIH approaches (72% for massage therapy, 63% for
chiropractic, 56% for acupuncture, 54% for acupressure, 50% for reflexology, and
50% for progressive relaxation). In the past year, 23% used massage therapy, 20%
used chiropractic, 18% used meditation/mindfulness, 13% used yoga, 11% used
progressive relaxation, and 9% used acupuncture. Veterans reported using
meditation/mindfulness (8%) or animal-assisted therapy (7%) at least weekly; and
meditation/mindfulness (14%), massage (12%) or chiropractic (11%) a few times a
month/about once a month. Pain was the most frequent reason for using CIH
approaches (93% of acupuncture users, 92% of chiropractic users, and 75% of
massage users). Stress reduction was the second most frequent reason for use. On
average, less than half reported CIH was helpful for the conditions they used it
for. The strong majority were unaware of specific CIH therapies being available
at the VA.
Conclusions: Veterans use CIH approaches at rates similar to or
slightly higher than those of the general population. However, additional
patient encouragement or education might be needed to increase the frequency of
CIH use, which might be required for efficacy.
(3877) Predictors of Engagement in a Yoga Intervention for Spanish-speaking
Cancer Survivors
Elizabeth L Addington, PhD1, Bruriah Horowitz, MEd1, Judy
Guitelman2, Carly Maletich, MA1 and David Victorson,
PhD1
1Chicago, Illinois
2ALAS-WINGS, Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: To examine predictors of engagement in yoga classes and
home-based practice among cancer survivors participating in a community-based,
Spanish-language yoga pilot study.
Results: Participants (N = 36) were primarily (89%)
female breast cancer survivors. Age ranged from 30 to 78 years
(M = 56, SD = 10.42). On average,
participants attended 9 yoga classes and engaged in home practice 3 days/week
during the 12-week intervention. During the 12-week follow-up period, yoga use
averaged 3.6 days/week. Yoga use during the intervention and the follow-up
period did not significantly correlate. Cancer history and sociodemographic
characteristics were not significantly related to yoga use. Positive affect and
well-being was the only significant predictor of class attendance. In bivariate
analyses, home practice of yoga during the intervention period was significantly
higher among participants without a history of back pain or migraine headaches
and those with better physical function, less pain interference, and lower
levels of depression at baseline. Only migraine history remained significant in
the multivariate regression. Engagement in yoga during the follow-up period was
higher among participants with higher baseline BMI and those without a history
of back pain or migraine headaches, with only BMI remaining a significant
predictor in multivariate regression.
Conclusions: Among Spanish-speaking cancer survivors, psychological
well-being and overweight/obesity can facilitate engagement in yoga. Despite
benefits of yoga for pain, migraine headaches can be a barrier to home-based
yoga practice.
(3878) Estimating the Cost-effectiveness of Spinal Manipulation, Exercise, or
Self-management for Neck or Back Pain in the United States Using an Individual
Participant Data Meta-analysis Approach
Roni Evans, DC, MS, PhD1, Brent Leininger, DC2, Pamela Jo
Johnson, MPH, PhD2, John Nyman, PhD2, Gert Bronfort, DC,
PhD2, Jim Hodges, PhD2 and Karen Kuntz,
ScD2
1University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: Spinal pain is a common and disabling condition with
considerable socioeconomic burden. The management of spinal pain in the United
States has gathered increased scrutiny amidst concerns of overutilization of
costly and potentially harmful interventions and diagnostic tests. Complimentary
and integrative health-care interventions such as spinal manipulation may
provide value for the care of spinal pain, but little is known regarding the
cost-effectiveness of these interventions within the United States. Our primary
objective for this project is to estimate the incremental cost-effectiveness of
spinal manipulation, exercise therapy, and self-management for spinal pain using
an individual patient data meta-analysis approach.
Conclusions: This project represents a unique opportunity to combine
clinical and economic data collected alongside a number of clinical trials with
similar methodologies. The findings will provide important information on the
value of spinal manipulation, exercise therapy, and self-management for spinal
pain in the United States.
(3880) Restoring Balance: Lifestyle and Mind–Body Management of Chronic
Inflammatory Symptoms and Adrenal Fatigue
Kaylan Baban, MD, MPH1 and Zulianna Ibrahim, MSc1
1Washington, DC
Abstract
Overview: Lifestyle and mind–body management holistically assess
wellness with a focus on root causes and sustainable personalized behavior
change, to support patient goals while maximizing their health resilience and
minimizing potential pharmaceutical-related adverse effects.
Rationale: Thirty-one-year-old female health-care consultant and
graduate student with history of anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome (IBS),
attention deficit (Adderall as needed), hypothyroidism (Synthroid daily)
presented with fatigue, full-body myalgias and arthralgias described as moderate
to severe, that interfered with her studies, with worsening IBS symptoms for 8
months. Physical exam; basic laboratories; viral, rheumatologic, and thyroid
panels; and colonoscopy were unremarkable. She reported strong social support
and twice-weekly dedicated physical activity in the setting of poor quality and
limited quantity sleep, pro-inflammatory foods with regularly skipped meals, and
a mostly sedentary, high stress lifestyle for several years, recently
intensified. Initial assessment identified a pattern of symptoms consistent with
generalized chronic inflammation and adrenal fatigue, likely exacerbated by
Adderall. Recommended behavior changes targeted lifestyle imbalances based on
history and symptomatology. Shared decision-making and motivational interviewing
guided personalization of sustainable goals, tools, and timeline. Management
included circadian support (sleep hygiene, melatonin, and tryptophan), dietary
modification (anti-inflammatory foods—including probiotics and turmeric—and
regular meals), adrenal support (Ashwaghanda, B12, hydration, and
discontinuation of Adderall), and mindfulness-based stress management (anchoring
on breath and movement). Over a 7-month period without diminishing her
professional activities, our patient reported full resolution of myalgias,
arthralgias, fatigue, and IBS symptoms, and self-reported wellness improved from
baseline with sustained restful sleep, anti-inflammatory dietary habits, regular
physical activity and mindfulness practice, prioritization of hydration and
meals, and successful long-term discontinuation of Adderall, maintained at
4-month follow-up.
Objectives: A young adult with a high-intensity career sustainably
resolved inflammatory symptoms and improved health resilience through guided
lifestyle change without pharmaceuticals or sacrifice to her professional
goals.
(3882) A Qualitative and Systematic Review of Multimodal Weight Management
Interventions for the Treatment of Migraine
Meg Sweeney, BS1 and Robert A Bonakdar, MD, FAAFP, FACN2
1The College of Osteopathic Medicine, Western University of Health
Sciences, Pomona, California
2La Jolla, California
Abstract
Background: Headache and obesity are prevalent public health issues
that impose significant societal burdens. Both conditions are hampered by low
treatment efficacy and dissatisfaction with currently available treatments,
which highlight the unmet needs in this population. Researchers have identified
a 27% to.
Methods: We completed a qualitative and systematic review of PubMed,
Embase, databases for trials that evaluated weight loss interventions in the
setting of migraine in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis guidelines. Additionally, trials were
reviewed for potential mechanisms related to migraine reduction as well as
comparative efficacy of evaluated interventions.
Findings: A total of 14 trials were identified which evaluated
weight loss in the setting of pediatric and adult migraine. Interventions were
broadly categorized as surgical, nonsurgical-behavioral and
nonsurgical-multicomponent. A systematic review was not possible due the
heterogeneity of the interventions and populations evaluated. A qualitative
review noted that weight loss was associated with reduction in migraine severity
with multiple potential interventions. Surgical interventions were associated
with enhanced migraine reduction with similar levels of weight loss versus
nonsurgical interventions. Additionally, the level of obesity and insulin
resistance was inversely associated with migraine reduction. Multiple mechanisms
were postulated including modulation of inflammation, adipokines, and lifestyle
factors (sleep, stress, and physical activity) known to effect migraines.
Conclusions: Obesity and weight management appear to be promising
interventions in the setting of migraine. Several potential interventions may be
of benefit with additional trials required to elucidate ideal parameters. Based
on available evidence, recommendations are provided for optimizing staging,
compliance, and outcomes of weight loss interventions in the setting of
migraine.
Rationale: Obesity and migraine are conditions which create large
medical, financial, and societal burdens. Migraine affecting roughly 1 of every
7 Americans and causes more than 100 million days/year of missed work with an
annual cost of $13 billion related to missed work and medical care. Obesity
effects at least 36% of U.S. adults with an estimated cost at $147 billion/year.
Unfortunately, both conditions are associated with dissatisfaction with
currently approved medication treatments. Recently, weight management research
trials have demonstrated benefit in synergistically improving obesity and
migraine disability in certain populations. It is important for providers and
researchers to be aware of this emerging research in order to help provide
enhanced and integrative options for helping patients with comorbid migraine and
obesity to find patient-centered treatments.
Objectives: The aim of this study was to understand the association
between obesity and migraine headaches; review potential mechanisms of how
weight management can improve migraine status; analyze what type of weight loss
interventions may work best in certain populations with comorbid migraine and
obesity; and review factors that help predict compliance with weight management
interventions in the setting of headache
(3883) The Antihyperalgesic Effect of Continuous and Interval Running on
Mechanical Hyperalgesia and Cytokine Levels in an Animal Model of Complex Regional
Pain Syndrome Type 1
Francisco Cidral-Filho, PhD1, Afonso Salgado, PhD1, Daniel F
Martins, PhD1, Franciane Bobinski, PhD2, Daiana C
Salm3, Bruna H Oliveira1, Kamilla P Frech1,
Luana M Belmonte1 and Luiz OA Belmonte1
1University of Southern Santa Catarina, Palhoça, Brazil
2University of Souther Santa Catarina, Florianopolis, Brazil
3University of Federal of Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the antihyperalgesic effect of continuous and
interval running on mechanical hyperalgesia and cytokine levels in an animal
model of complex regional pain syndrome type 1 (CRPS-I)
Results: Both the continuous and interval running groups showed a
higher threshold in mechanical hyperalgesia from the 1st to the 5th day of
training (P < .05) as well as lower levels of TNF-α and IL-6
in the spinal cord, brain stem, and prefrontal cortex when compared to the
nonexercised group. Interestingly, the interval group experienced a more
prolonged antihyperalgesic effect for up to 5 h postrace, higher levels of IL-10
in the brainstem and prefrontal cortex, as well as lower levels of IL-6 in the
same structures when compared to the continuous running group.
Conclusions: Interval running produces greater analgesia than
continuous running and this effect seems to be related to higher release of
IL-10 and lower levels of IL-6 and TNF-α.
(3884) Knowledge, Attitudes and Perceptions: What Medical, Dental and Pharmacy
Students Report Regarding the Medical Use of Marijuana
Aimee McRae-Clark, PharmD, BCPP1 and Lynneice Bowen, MD,
MEd1
1Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: The medicinal use of marijuana has been legalized in 28
states with a wide range of specificity for approved conditions. It is also the
most commonly used illicit substance in the United States and the second most
common substance for which people seek treatment. Physicians, dentists, and
pharmacists should be at the forefront of shaping patient understanding of this
topic; however, limited data have been gathered on the knowledge and perceptions
of medical marijuana among health professions students and the learning gaps
these trainees experience.
Results: Three hundred eight full and partial responses were
collected. Ten percent responded that they had sufficient knowledge to answer
patient questions regarding efficacy of marijuana, 90% agreed that information
regarding medical marijuana should be included in their curriculum. Only a third
cited medical knowledge as the primary influence on their perception of the
medical use of marijuana. The majority agree that marijuana has fewer negative
health effects than prescription medications. Most reported that legalizing
medicinal use would increase recreational use.
Conclusions: 22.2 million people aged 12 or older use marijuana each
month according to the 2015 National Survey on Drug use and Health. Policy
changes have increased legal access to cannabis for medicinal purposes.
Professional school students demonstrate knowledge gaps related to the medicinal
use of cannabis and are using anecdotal level evidence to inform patient care.
This represents an opportunity for educators.
(3885) Beyond the Prescription Pad: Group Acupuncture for Chronic Pain
Elaine Chu, MD1, Dean Sasaki, MD1, David Seto, MD1
and Kirsten Tillisch, MD2
1Los Angeles, California
2University of California, Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Background: Chronic pain is one of the most compelling issues facing
the VA health care system. Our medical therapies often fall short. Acupuncture
benefits chronic pain; however, its availability to Veterans is limited. With an
enormous need for nonpharmacological pain treatments, group acupuncture visits
were implemented to assess feasibility and acceptability to Veterans.
Program Description: Our acupuncture program is embedded in the
Division of Integrative Medicine at Greater Los Angeles Veteran’s Administration
(GLAVA). Veterans with chronic pain are referred for acupuncture once a
diagnosis is established. The initial visit includes a 1 h session discussing
the pathophysiology of chronic pain, the biopsychosocial health model, a
description of acupuncture including its risks/benefits, and our philosophy
regarding the role of acupuncture as a bridge treatment best utilized in
conjunction with self-care interventions. The GLAVA yoga, taichi, mindfulness,
healthy eating, and holistic nursing programs are described. In the second hour,
the Veterans receive acupuncture from a physician acupuncturist in a group
setting. Healing touch and/or aromatherapy from holistic nurses is offered.
Auricular protocols are utilized in the majority of patients at the first visit
but any treatment achievable without disrobing can be used at the discretion of
the acupuncturist. Pre- and posttreatment pain and anxiety ratings are recorded.
In the first year, 265 Veterans participated, with a mean baseline pain of 6.4
(SD = 2.1) on a 0 to 10 scale. Pain decreased at the end of visit by 2.9
(SD = 2.0) and anxiety decreased by 2.6 (SD = 2.3). Visit satisfaction was 8.8
of 10 (SD = 1.75).
Conclusion: Group acupuncture is feasible in a VA setting and is
received with high satisfaction by Veterans. Further, the reduction in pain
achieved in the visit is comparable to those reported in the literature.
Rationale: New models for delivering integrative treatments for pain
are essential in the VA system. In this abstract, we describe the delivery of
acupuncture for pain in an enhanced group setting. Veterans receive acupuncture
but also are provided with education and opportunities related to other
evidence-based treatments of pain including yoga, tai chi, and mindfulness.
Through collaboration with other providers in our Integrative Health Center,
including holistic nurses, recreation therapists, and mental health providers,
we are able to help Veterans implement a multifaceted treatment plan that is
aimed at their overall well-being.
Objectives: Participants will know how to implement a group-based
integrative pain treatment program that results in pain reduction and high
satisfaction.
(3887) Does Dispositional Mindfulness Correlate With Blood Pressure Consistently
Across Demographics? Baseline Analyses From the Serenity Study
Rosa Heryak, BA1, Megan Strowger, MA1, Monica Fallon,
MA2, Joel Hughes, PhD1, David Fresco, PhD1,
Devin Barney, BA3, Mary Keenan, BA4, Jeffery Greeson,
PhD5, Vanessa Anyanso, BA6, Jonathan Reda, BS6
and Gabrielle Chin, BS5
1Kent State University, Kent, Ohio
2University of Mannheim, Stuttgart, Germany
3Manoa, Hawaii
4University of Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee
5Rowan University, Glassboro, New Jersey
6Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Purpose: Mindfulness is consistently associated with subjective
measures of mental health; however, few studies have addressed the relationship
between dispositional (aka “trait”) mindfulness and physical health. Utilizing
baseline data from the ongoing Serenity Study (NCT02371317), we aimed to examine
if trait mindfulness correlates with blood pressure (BP) levels consistently
across demographic subgroups, including race, gender, and socioeconomic status
(SES).
Results: In African-Americans (n = 59), BP was significantly and
negatively correlated with two facets of mindfulness, observing,
r(59) = −.401, P = .002, and
nonreactivity, r(59) = −.374, P = .004. In
contrast, Caucasians (n = 141) showed positive correlations across three
mindfulness scales, Nonjudgment, r(141) = .191,
P = .023), nonreactivity (P = .04), and
observing, r(141) = .174, P = .087. Gender
differences produced mixed results, such that some facets of trait mindfulness
correlated positively with BP, while others correlated negatively with BP, as a
function of gender. For SES, observing negatively correlated with BP for lower
income households, r(52) = −.372, P = .007,
but positively in higher income households, r(138) = .215,
P = .011.
Conclusions: Taken together, results show that trait mindfulness
correlates with BP differently across demographic subgroups, at baseline, prior
to mindfulness training. Therefore, future studies that attempt to relate
questionnaire measures of mindfulness and objective measures of health should
consider examining such associations separately, by demographics, to better
understand implicit variables within demographics and to avoid assuming that
associations remain the same across diverse groups.
(3891) Mindfulomics: Searching for the Molecular “Signature” of
Mindfulness
Mary Keenan, BA1, Devin Barney, BA2, Jonathan Schug,
PhD3, Jonathan Reda, BS3, Vanessa Anyanso, BA3,
Xiangdong Ren, MD, PhD4 and Jeffrey M Greeson, PhD5
1University of Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee
2University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, Hawaii
3University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
4The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
5Rowan University, Glassboro, New Jersey
Abstract
Purpose: New studies have recently emerged that investigate changes
in gene expression with mindfulness meditation, a field we term
Mindfulomics. Mindfulness, though, is a multifaceted
construct; it is at once a state (induced during meditation), a
trait (an enduring disposition), and a
skill (developed through practice). No published studies
have examined genomic or other biologic “signatures” of mindfulness in this
multifaceted way.
Results: Contrary to hypotheses, there were no differences in
resting-state blood biomarkers or gene expression post-mindfulness-based stress
reduction (MBSR), nor any difference in gene expression as a function of either
state mindfulness (meditation vs quiet rest) or
trait mindfulness (Cognitive and Affective Mindfulness
Scale – Revised score; median split). There was a significant decrease in
resting-state salivary α-amylase (P < .05) post-MBSR. A
trend toward decreased CTRA gene expression was found for MBSR responders who
showed a 50% increase in mindfulness (P = .12). Several changes
in stress responsivity were also observed, including decreased emotional
reactivity (P < .001), lower BP reactivity
(P = .059), and stronger innate immune system reactivity
(P = .049 for WBC count; P = .005 for
neutrophils).
Conclusions: These findings reveal some objective changes in stress
biomarkers after 8 weeks of mindfulness training. Moreover, genomic results
suggest that among relatively young, healthy adults, changes in stress-related
and proinflammatory gene expression appear to be most pronounced for individuals
who experience the greatest change in mindfulness after MBSR training.
(3893) The Development and Implementation of an Integrative Medicine Diploma—The
Portland Institute for Integrative Medicine, Bristol, UK
Elizabeth A Thompson, MD1, Duncan Still, MD1, Patricia Turton,
Ed1 and Alastair Gray, MSc2
1Portland Institute for Integrative Medicine, Bristol, UK
2University of Technology Sydney, New York, New York
Abstract
Overview: The swift adoption of integrative medicine (IM) by a
willing public has not necessarily been paralleled with excellent educational
provision about IM. While departments of integrative medicine are emerging
especially in the private equity American university sector, this trend is
currently not yet a feature of the United Kingdom, European, or Australian
medicine education landscape. Previous attempts at establishing integrative
medical programs have been met with resistance and opposition and ultimately not
thrived. The Portland Institute for Integrative Medicine (PCIM) diploma of IM is
an initiative to develop and run a 2-year accredited qualification in IM for
licensed health-care providers. The program is a 1200-h 120 credit course
accredited by Crossfield’s Institute based in the UK education space.
Rationale: There were a number of challenges in the establishment of
this world-class program, integrated medicine program. Enrolments should the
institute only accept licensed medical or health-care providers? Whether to
accept complementary medicine practitioners. If not, why not?
Compliance—resistance is from local universities to accredit and support the
program. Technology and curriculum design—the clear challenges presented by an
interested potential student body but who are overwhelmed, overworked, and have
little time in their busy professional lives for further educational
opportunities. It was for this reason that PCIM adopted a blended e-learning and
face-to-face model of learning that relied heavily on a learning management
system with asynchronous use of expert video lecture and synchronous use of
student engagement including tutorial, webinar, and forum support.
Objectives: This presentation will chart the challenges, hurdles,
uptake, and uptake of technologies, as well as the capacity building required in
the establishment of the world-class course of integrative medicine. In
describing this journey, it seeks to start a dialogue between IM education
leaders to discuss the mutual challenges provided by compliance, learning
technologies, enrolments, and resistance from within and with out.
(3896) Acupuncture as a Complementary Therapy for In Vitro Fertilization
Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Cybelle M Costa, MD1, Clariana C Souza1, Julia G
Lopes1, Victor H Melo, MD, PhD1 and Rubens LC Tavares, MD,
PhD1
1Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this randomized controlled trial is to evaluate
the use of acupuncture as a complementary therapy for in vitro fertilization
patients.
Results: There was a statistically significant difference in the
physical domain of the WHOQOL-Bref questionnaire after intervention
(P = .029) and in the social aspects of the Short-Form 36
questionnaire (P = .033). FERTIQOL and DASS 21 did not show
differences between the control and treatment groups.
Conclusions: Our preliminary results demonstrated an improvement in
the scores of the Physical domain of the WHOQOL-Bref and in the social aspects
domain of Short-form 36. A larger number of patients will be necessary to
confirm these preliminary results.
(3897) Acupuncture for Chronic Pain in an Underserved Population: A Responder
Analysis
Robert B Saper, MD MPH1, Aaron B Afran1 and Eric Roseen,
DC1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Challenges of long-term pharmacological management of
chronic pain include insufficient pain relief and risk of addiction and
overdose. To identify characteristics that predict favorable response to
acupuncture for chronic pain among racially diverse low-income participants.
Results: From August 2015 to March 2018, 218 patients were recruited
at Boston Medical Center. Of these, 160 had chronic pain, 142 had received
acupuncture, and 128 had completed baseline and 4 or 6 months of follow-up.
Sixty-five patients met all three criteria, who were 74% female, 19–86 years
old, and 59.7% non-white. Thirty-two percent of patients experienced a 30% or
greater reduction of pain. Although not statistically significant, responders
were more likely to be female (P = .13) and have private
insurance (P = .14).
Conclusions: Use of acupuncture for chronic pain achieved a
clinically meaningful improvement in a third of patients with chronic pain.
Following completion of PRIMIER data collection in December 2018, we will repeat
our responder analysis using information from all (20) PRIMIER sites.
(3900) Impact of Homeopathy and Acupuncture Treatment on the Quality of Life of
Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Julia G Lopes1, Clariana C Souza1, Paula C Costa1,
Barbara L Justo1, Dayane M Dutra1, Adrienne M Mendes,
MsC1, Claudia P Santos, MD1, Natalia S Champs, MD,
PhD1 and Rubens LC Tavares, MD, PhD1
1Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the Quality of life (QoL) of women treated with
homeopathy or acupuncture within the Public Health System of Belo Horizonte,
Brazil.
Results: Randomization afforded similar baseline results in all
domains of QoL analysis for both groups. After 6 months of homeopathic
treatment, there was a statistically significant difference between groups with
or without treatment in the physical, social, and environmental domains. The
biggest difference was within the physical domain, where the average score
improved from 54.32 to 63.36 (P < .001). Beyond that, while
comparing the subjective perception of their own health during the homeopathic
treatment, treated patients displayed an improvement, while values in the
control Group remained unchanged after 6 months (P = .002).
However, between the experimental and control groups of patients for the
acupuncture study, there was no statistical difference between them after the
6-month period.
Conclusions: Homeopathic treatment showed a positive impact on the
QoL of women with chronic diseases during the 6-month period. This positive
impact was not found with the use of acupuncture. Further studies should be
carried out to study the long-term effects of treatment with Complementary and
Integrative Medicine on the QoL and their determinant factors.
Financial Support: Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade Federal de
Minas Gerais, Programa de apoio à Pós-Graduaça∼o - PROAP - CAPES, Programa de
Pós-Graduaça∼o em Saúde da Mulher, Programa de Pós-Graduaça∼o em Promoça∼o da
Saúde e Prevença∼o da Violencia, Fundaça∼o de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de
Minas Gerais - FAPEMIG, Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e
Tecnológico - CNPq (401024/2013-0)
(3904) Meditation and Infertility: A Bibliometric Analysis of Randomized
Controlled Trials
Rubens LC Tavares, MD, PhD1, Jane Guirado, MsC1 and Mariza
Talim, MsC1
1Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: To perform a bibliometric analysis of randomized controlled
trials (RCTs) about meditation and infertility in Web of Science database.
Results: One hundred twenty-four articles were found. The 10
countries that most published this strategy were United States (32.2%),
Australia (13.7%), England (12.1%), Netherlands (8%), China (7.2%), Sweden
(6.4%), New Zealand (5.6%), Canada (4.8%), Germany (4.%), and France (4%). The
main journals that have published were Cochrane Database of Systematic
Reviews (11.2%), Fertility and Sterility (10.4%),
Human Reproduction (4.8%), European Journal of
Obstetrics Gynecology and Reproductive Biology (4%),
Seminars in Reproductive Medicine (1.6%),
Reproductive Biomedicine Online (1.6%), Obstetrical
Gynecological Survey (1.6%), Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology (1.6%), Journal of Assisted Reproduction and
Genetics (1.6%), and Human Reproduction Update
(1.6%). The National Institutes of Health (USA) funded the largest number of
projects.
Conclusions: Few RCTs had addressed Meditation and infertility.
United States, Australia, England, Netherlands, China, Sweden, New Zealand,
Canada, Germany, and France are the main countries that have been producing this
scientific knowledge and the National Institutes of Health (USA) has funded the
largest number of projects.
Financial Support: Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade Federal de
Minas Gerais, Programa de Apoio à Pós-Graduaça∼o - PROAP - CAPES, Programa de
Pós-Graduaça∼o em Saúde da Mulher, Programa de Pós-Graduaça∼o em Promoça∼o da
Saúde e Prevença∼o da Violencia, Fundaça∼o de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de
Minas Gerais - FAPEMIG, Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e
Tecnológico - CNPq.
(3905) Effects of Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction on Functional Mobility and
Quality of Life in a Patient Post Left Ventricular Assist Device Implantation: A
Case Report
Alexandra Flis, MD1 and Jennifer Chung Peck, DPT, ATC1
1Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Purpose: To examine the feasibility of implementing a
Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) program in a patient in the intensive
care unit after destination left ventricular assist device (LVAD)
implantation.
Results: MLHFQ improved 50% and FIM scores improved 75% at the end
of the 12 week trial.
Conclusions: Implementing a MBSR program post LVAD implantation may
improve quality of life and functional outcomes. Further randomized controlled
studies should be designed to explore this in more detail.
(3906) Mimicking Prerenal and Intrinsic Acute Kidney Injury by Different Doses
and Exposure Times of Cisplatin in Renal Proximal Tubular Cells and Both Recovery
by
Single Herbal Medicines via Activity of the Biomarkers HMGB1, NGAL, and
KIM-1
Kyung-Soo Kim, MD, PhD1, Seung Hoon Lee, PhD2, Sung Man Oh,
MS2, Dal-Seok Oh, OMd, PhD2, Chang-Seob Seo,
PhD2, Hyeun-Kyoo Shin and OMd, PhD2
1Seoul St. Mary’s Hospital, Catholic University Graduate School of
Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea
2Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Acute kidney injury (AKI) is an initial factor in kidney
disorder cascades. Pre- and intrinsic (renal) AKI are frequent and have
different therapeutic approaches. Recently, surrogate biomarkers on each AKI
were developed; little is known about herbal medicine. Thus, this study aimed to
investigate dose- and time-dependent effects of herbals to recover AKI in
cisplatin-induced human kidney 2 (HK-2) cell line via high-mobility group box
protein 1 (HMGB1), neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL) and kidney
injury molecule-1 (KIM-1).
Results: Cisplatin of 10 μM decreased cell viability. Treatment with
400 µM of cisplatin reduced HMBG1 activity and lactate dehydrogenase release was
observed. Longer exposure up to 48 h, NGAL and KIM-1 exhibited activity from
24 h onward. Additionally, NY showed over 50% change in all 3 biomarkers.
Time-dependent profiles of 3 biomarker activities up to 48 h were different;
HMGB1 exhibited a 7-fold change (6 h), and NGAL and KIM-1 exhibited 1.7-fold
changes (24 h), respectively. For in vivo study, NY and PS showed over 50%
reduction change of NGAL and KIM-1 activities.
Conclusions: Two single herbal medicines, NY and PS, have potential
on AKI due to inhibit activities of HMGB1, NGAL, and KIM-1 at AKI-mimicked
condition. Furthermore, in vivo proof-of-concept study is needed for chronic
kidney disorders.
(3907) Fire Needle Acupuncture for Herpes Zoster: A Systematic Review and
Meta-analysis of Randomized Clinical Trials
Jian-ping Liu, PhD1, Li-yan Jia1, Bao-yong Lai1,
Xiao-yi Yan1, Zhao-lan Liu, PhD1, Xiao Wang1 and
Nanqi Zhao1
1Center for Evidence-based Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: To evaluate the effect and safety of fire needle
acupuncture for treatment of herpes zoster from randomized clinical trials
(RCTs).
Results: We included 22 RCTs with a total of 1611 participants. Only
1 RCT had low risk of bias and the other trials were of high risk of bias. Total
effectiveness (the proportion of clinical recovery): fire needle acupuncture
versus Chinese herbal medicine (RR1.10, 95% CI 1.03 to 1.17; n = 5); fire needle
acupuncture versus antiviral agent (RR1.08, 95% CI 1.01–1.16; n = 3). Fire
needle acupuncture relieved pain (VAS 0–10 cm) compared with Chinese herbal
medicine (MD-1.20, 95% CI −2.02 to −0.39; n = 3), western medicine (MD-2.70, 95%
CI −3.47 to − 1.93; n = 2). Using fire needle acupuncture shorten the skin
lesion recovery time (day) compared with manual acupuncture: time of check
blister (MD-1.38, 95% CI −1.97 to −0.79; n = 2), time of scab (MD-2.25, 95% CI
−3.11 to −1.39; n = 2) time of herpes shed (MD-3.53, 95% CI −5.14 to −1.92;
n = 2). The post neuralgia occurrence rate was lower with fire needle than
western medicine or electro-acupuncture, but higher than manual acupuncture.
There was no serious adverse effect reported from the trials.
Conclusions: Fire needle acupuncture maybe effective in alleviating
pain and shorten the skin lesion recovery time in patients with herpes zoster.
However, due to general low methodological quality, further rigorous trials are
needed.
(3909) Qualitative Evaluation of a Whole-school Mindfulness Intervention at 2
Urban Public Schools
Tamar Mendelson, PhD1, Ciara McAfee, BA2 and Angela E Lee-Winn,
PhD1
1Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland
2University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Children from disadvantaged urban neighborhoods
disproportionately experience chronic stress and trauma, which negatively
affects academic performance. Mindfulness programs have shown promise in
improving youth social, emotional, and academic outcomes. Mindful
Moment is a whole-school intervention developed by the Holistic
Life Foundation that combines daily mindfulness practices, a cool-down room for
coaching students in self-regulation, and teacher mindfulness training. We
assessed perspectives of students, teachers, and principals on the
Mindful Moment intervention at 2 urban public schools: 1
elementary and 1 high school.
Results:
Mindful Moment was well received by both teachers (83%) and
students (90%). Across both schools, most students (86%) and teachers (96%)
noted that the program enhanced student emotion regulation. Many teachers (74%)
reported improvements in their own ability to manage stress. The program’s
provision of additional supports was seen as a key strength. Participants at the
larger school (high school), in which the program had not been implemented as
long, noted more implementation challenges; recommendations for addressing these
challenges included increased staff number and visibility, consistency of
programming across students, and greater program variety.
Conclusions: Positive program impacts were reported by principals,
teachers, and students across both schools, particularly in the area of stress
management. Findings also highlight aspects of program implementation critical
for program success, which appear to differ based on school characteristics.
(3910) Multidisciplinary Integrative Approach With Improved Clinical Outcomes in
Patients With Chronic Pain Syndrome
Ashima Shukla, MA, PhD1 and Ashutosh Shukla, MD, FACP1
1Artemis Hospitals, New Delhi, India
Abstract
Overview: Chronic pain is defined as pain present most of the time
for a period of 3 months or more during the prior year. A multidisciplinary
integrated approach was used in patients with chronic pain syndrome to integrate
conventional treatment, cognitive behaviour therapy, physiotherapy, mind–body
medicine and dietary advice. Patients were randomly allocated to 2 arms: in one
arm patients received conventional treatment for chronic pain syndrome and in
the other arm patients received integrated approach of management. McGill Pain
Questionnaire was filled by all patients when they enrolled as well on the
follow-ups to look for the result of intervention and for the comparison with
the conventional treatment. The sample size of this study was 100 consecutive
patients and the study design was comparative, qualitative and interventional
study. Inclusion criteria were patients between 18 years and 70 years suffering
from pain lasting for more than 3 months. Results from this study demonstrated
that patients enrolled in the integrative medicine arm showed higher efficacy of
pain relief compared to those in the conventional arm. Pain killer medications
were withdrawn much earlier in patients in the integrative arm compared to those
in the conventional arm.
Rationale: Chronic pain is common in primary and tertiary care
patients and is associated with distress, disability and increased health-care
use. Pain is a multifactorial process that has both objective and subjective
components. Chronic pain is complex and can manifest in multiple ways. This
study highlights the importance of using multimodality treatments in an
integrated system where in different specialists work in harmony for the welfare
of the patient. Unfortunately, our current system of medicine with specialists
working in silos is not effective for pain relief in patients with chronic pain
syndrome.
Objectives: To highlight the importance of using integrative
medicine as a cost-effective tool in managing complex situations of patients
with chronic pain syndrome.
(3911) Integrative Medicine Program for Pain (IMPACT): An Innovative
Transprofessional Non-pharmacologic System for Rehabilitating Chronic Non-cancer
Pain
Henri Roca, MD1
1Little Rock, Arkansas
Abstract
Overview: The Integrative Medicine Program for Pain (IMPACT) is an
innovative comprehensive program designed to help individuals reengage with
their mission, vision, and values within the existence of chronic pain. Impact
operates exclusively from a health coaching perspective utilizing functional
medicine, functional nutrition, acceptance and commitment therapy, movement and
physical therapy using yogic methods, and auricular acupuncture. This primary
program lead to a more intensive secondary program of enhanced offerings
including Yoga, Culinary Arts, CBTi, Styles of Nutrition, Living Well with Pain,
Relationships, Healing the Heart of the Warrior, and Home Evaluations. Services
are offered exclusively to Veterans at the Central Arkansas Veterans Healthcare
System. After discussion of the history and creation of this successful program,
we will briefly discuss a best case series.
Rationale: Nonpharmacologic approaches to addressing chronic pain
have become a focus of care planning for pain. Models providing such care
efficiently and effectively are lacking. The Central Arkansas Veterans
Healthcare System has created a reproducible program to provide these
services.
Objectives: Participants will understand the benefits and challenges
of changing the conversation surrounding care of chronic disease from one
focused on the suppression of symptoms or treatment of the diagnosis to one that
focuses on the enhancement of wellness and support of a fulfilling life; the
significance of a singular method of communication within the electronic medical
record surrounding patient’s valued actions directed toward wellness; and how a
transprofessional team can come together to produce an integrated program for
living well with chronic pain.
(3912) Culture-based Neurological Differences in Response to Verum and Placebo
Acupuncture to Prevent Radiation-induced Xerostomia
Sarah Prinsloo, PhD1, David I Rosenthal, MD1, Y Shen,
PhD2, MK Garcia, PhD1, Z Mung, MD2, Catherine
Wu, BS2, W Bei, BS2, C Hu, BA2, Qi Wei,
MA1, Mark Chambers, PhD1 and Lorenzo Cohen,
PhD1
1Houston, Texas
2Fudan University, Shanghai, China
Abstract
Purpose: Differentiating verum acupuncture from placebo via
neuroimaging has failed to produce a consistent pattern of activation of either
acupuncture or placebo acupuncture. Here, we determine cultural differences in
neural mechanisms for acupuncture to prevent xerostomia among head/neck cancer
patients undergoing radiotherapy (XRT).
Results: Brain activity profiles between verum and placebo
conditions in China and the United States resulted in consistencies with
published acupuncture research: (1) Alpha activity (8–12 HZ) decreased in the
cingulate in the verum condition and increased in the placebo condition; (2)
current source density decreased in the verum versus placebo condition in all
predetermined regions of the brain including Brodmann areas 3, 6, 13, and 33.
However, during the placebo condition in the United States, maximal activity was
seen in BA 17 and 18 associated with perception of phenomenon. During placebo,
the Chinese demonstrated maximal activity in areas associated with verum (BA 3,
4, 5 and 40, insula), and decreased activity in areas associated with
perception.
Conclusions: Chinese patients processed placebo in part as “verum
acupuncture” but showed activity in the opposite direction than expected in
verum—showing a different mechanism of placebo in the Chinese. Also, acupuncture
may not have a “true” effect in perception of salivary production unless areas
of perception reach a certain magnitude of activation.
(3913) The Translational Potential of Celastrol, a Natural Triterpenoid, for
Arthritis Therapy
Kamal D Moudgil, MD, PhD1, Shivaprasad H Venkatesha, PhD1,
Brian M Berman, MD1, Steven Dudics, BS2, Chun-Tao Che,
PhD3 and Rakeshchandra R Meka, MS1
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2Baltimore, Maryland
3College of Pharmacy, University of Illinois, Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a multifactorial disease that
involves both genetic and environmental components. Approximately 1% of the
world’s population is afflicted with RA. Current treatments, including biologics
such as anti-TNFα, are effective, but only in about 50% to 60% of RA patients.
In addition, the use of biologics may render some RA patients vulnerable to
infections. Therefore, there is an urgent need to identify and develop new
therapeutic agents for RA. We tested celastrol, a triterpenoid derived from the
traditional Chinese herb Celastrus aculeatus Merr, which
possesses anti-inflammatory properties.
Results: We observed a significant reduction in arthritic scores
compared to controls. Moreover, key pro-inflammatory cytokines such as
interleukin-1 (IL-1), IL-6, and IL-17 were decreased along with reduction in the
T-cell response and antibodies to antigens relevant for disease pathogenesis.
Also, assessed was the effect of celastrol on the relative frequency of T helper
17 and T regulatory cells in the draining lymphoid cells, and it was found to
favor immune regulation.
Conclusions: Our results demonstrate that celastrol administered via
the oral route had beneficial anti-arthritic effect, as was also observed with
intraperitoneal delivery. The added benefit to oral delivery is its
translational capabilities, which will allow this work to eventually move from
the bench to treating patients.
(3919) The Evolution in the CAM Research in Colombia
German D Benitez1, Eduardo H Beltran1 and Natalia S
Aldana1
1Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogota, Colombia
Abstract
Purpose: To analyze the evolution of CAM (Complementary and
Alternative Medicine and therapies related) research in Colombia, in the period
1980–2016, through a documentary review of the indexed literature, nonindexed
academic literature, and gray literature and the revision of existing
databases.
Results: During the period 2011–2016, 568 investigations were
carried out in the area of CAM compared to the period 1980–2010 in which the
number of documents collected was 561. In other words, in just 6 years, the same
amount of works that in the last 30 years. In total, 1146 documents were found,
of which only 15% correspond to indexed literature, while 80% of the research
work is academic. The object of study and the methods used are more in keeping
with the classical research models. The themes with more production are
Traditional Chinese Medicine with 32% and Homeopathy with 28% of the total. The
main topics are chronic diseases, pain treatment, allergies, osteoarticular,
respiratory and mental illness, and also CAM in public health. The most common
research methods used was literature reviews, prospective observational studies,
and retrospective case series.
Conclusions: CAM’s research output in Colombia has increased
exponentially over the past 20 years, but, in particular the last 10 years, the
increase in works has been most associated with the creation of graduate
programs in CAM. However, 85% of investigative efforts remain in institutional
libraries and repositories and are not visible at the international level. It is
recommended to strengthen research training in CAM, including teaching
alternative forms of research and to encourage the publication of works at the
indexed level and interinstitutional collaboration.
(3921) Integrative Medicine Program Outpatient Meditation Group Classes at a
Comprehensive Cancer Center: Analysis of Effects on Participant Self-reported
Outcomes
Alejandro Chaoul, PhD1, Gabriel Lopez, MD1, Lorenzo Cohen,
PhD1, Qi Wei, MS1, Amy Spelman, PhD1, Rosalinda
Engle, MS1 and Kathrin Milbury, PhD1
1Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Our integrative oncology program offers 3 different Tibetan
meditation classes at no cost to patients and caregivers. We explore the effects
of these classes on participant self-reported symptoms.
Results: One hundred forty-two unique participants (76 patients and
66 caregivers) attended 1 or more classes (mean 1.84) from May to December 2015
(265 total attendance across all classes: PB n = 92; SS n = 87; MB n = 86). Most
frequently reported symptoms at baseline for both patients and caregivers
included well-being, sleep, and fatigue. Significant differences in symptom
burden at baseline for patients versus caregivers included fatigue (2.72 vs
1.73), well-being (2.71 vs 1.75), pain (1.55 vs 0.8), and ESAS subscales of
Physical health (9.04 vs 5.25) and Global distress (18.03 vs 11.17) (all
P’s ≥ .05). There were no significant between meditation
group differences in participant symptom burden at baseline or in symptom score
reduction. Comparing class length (60 min vs 90 min), there were no
statistically significant differences in symptom score reduction. For all
meditation group classes, we observed a clinically significant improvement in
fatigue (PB −1.2; SS −1.6; MB −1.2) and well-being (PB −1.7; SS −1.0; MB
−1.2).
Conclusions: A single meditation group class resulted in relief of
multiple self-reported symptoms. Further research with a larger sample size is
needed to better understand the symptoms that meditation can help control and
how differences in meditation technique can affect outcomes.
(3925) Public Health Through Integrative Complementary Traditional Health
Practices
Sivarama P Vinjamury, MD, MAOM, MPH1, Deborah Ndao, MPH2 and
Beth Sommers, PhD, LAc3
1Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier,
California
2Columbia University, New York, New York
3Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Overview: Integrative Complementary Traditional Health Practices
(ICTHP) comprises all the health-care practices that are not part of
conventional medicine. In the last 3 decades, there is a growing interest in
these practices in the United States. During this period, a special interest
group on Alternative and Complementary Health Practices was started within the
American Public Health Association, which grew into a huge section with 400 plus
members and was renamed as Integrative Complementary and Traditional Health
Practices Section. “The purpose of the ICTHP Section is to convene health
professionals within the American Public Health Association (APHA) whose
interests include any aspect of clinical care, research, teaching, advocacy,
policy-making and health promotion related to integrative, complementary, and
Traditional health practices, where we can pursue common goals and interests.
The section envisions creating and participating in a global society where
integrative health care and practice including wellness is a right, not a
privilege. Our vision encompasses health promotion, disease prevention, and
enhancement of well-being for all people.” This presentation will include the
growth and development of this section. It will also discuss the methods and
opportunities for multidisciplinary interaction and collaboration with
organizations such as Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health
that aim at promoting community and global health and develop evidence-based
research.
Rationale: Integrative medicine’s role within Public Health is not
emphasized despite its main premise of prevention through natural methods is its
goal. It is very appropriate to discuss about it in this conference.
Objectives: To describe the growth and development of an Integrative
Health Section within American Public Health Association. To discuss
opportunities for collaboration between like-minded organization to establish
integrative medicine and health practices to promote public health.
(3929) The Experiences of Complementary and Alternative Medicine Practitioners in
Providing Treatments With Controversial and Conflicting Proposed Mechanisms of
Action
Anne Majumdar
Abstract
Purpose: Acupuncturists and homeopaths in the United Kingdom are
often statutory-regulated health professionals with biomedical training. The
proposed mechanism of action of the complementary and alternative medicine
therapy that they practice may considerably conflict with this conventional
biomedical view. This study aimed to explore opinions and experiences of
practitioners in rationalising and explaining their approach of working with
these diverse approaches using a mixed methods approach.
Results: Acupuncture participants with biomedical training reported
using ‘Medical’ acupuncture and were less likely to explain effects of
acupuncture on non-local effects and qi than non-biomedically trained
acupuncturists. Biomedically trained homeopaths, on the other hand, agreed with
non-biomedical colleagues that homeopathy was energy medicine to achieve
vitality. Key themes identified from analysis of homeopathy interviews included
triggering of self-healing mechanisms, importance of the consultation and
indifference to medical colleagues’ attitudes towards their practice.
Conclusions: Results of this study will inform the integration
debate and highlight areas that warrant further study.
(3930) North Cypriot Breast Cancer Patients’ Perspectives on Traditional Black
Olive Oil Consumption and Diet, a Qualitative Study
Anne Majumdar1
1▪▪
Abstract
Purpose: The incidence of breast cancer (BC) in Northern Cyprus is
higher than is seen internationally. There is little extant literature on the
influence of diet on breast cancer recovery in Cyprus. Cypriot Black Olive Oil
(BOO) is heavily consumed and differs from standard olive oil, which is a key
component of the Mediterranean diet. The aim of this study was to explore breast
cancer patients’ experiences and their perceptions of the dietary management of
their breast cancer.
Results: Fourteen participants (females aged 30–60 years) were
interviewed. Key themes included coping with side effects, impact on emotional
well-being, and self-consciousness. Others were physical impact on eating and
confusion due to conflicting dietary advice. Some participants’ nutritional
approaches were appropriate while others were not backed up by evidence or
guidelines. A common theme was a reduction in carbohydrate intake, particularly
sugar. Perceptions and habits regarding the consumption of BOO varied.
Conclusions: Deeply affected by BC, participants were very concerned
about diet and keen to try anything to recover. Some participants adopted very
strict dietary changes. Results suggest that the BC patients would benefit from
further dietary advice to prevent confusion. Further investigation into BOO
would be useful.
(3934) Stress Management and Resiliency Training for Health-care
Professionals
Michelle L Dossett, MD, PhD, MPH1 and Darshan Mehta, MD2
1Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
2Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Burnout is epidemic among health-care professionals. Prior
studies have suggested that resiliency training programs incorporating mind–body
skills may reduce provider burnout. We examined the effects of a stress
management and resiliency training (SMART) program developed for clinical
populations and adapted it to health-care providers.
Results: Participants attended an average of 6 of 8 sessions. There
was a significant reduction in perceived stress (P = .001,
Cohen’s d = 0.71) and significant improvement in global mental health
(P = .018, Cohen’s d = 0.48) as well as nonsignificant
trends toward improvement in physical health (Cohen’s d = 0.36) and job
satisfaction (Cohen’s d = 0.30). All participants except for one agreed that the
program was relevant to their life and that the skills taught were helpful.
Qualitative analysis of free text responses revealed that participants developed
greater presence with patients, ability to live in the moment, and empowerment
to make positive life changes.
Conclusions: Delivering the SMART Program to health-care
professionals is feasible and may serve as a useful tool for increasing
resilience to stress. Many participants found the program transformative and the
majority felt they benefited from the skills learned. Additional groups are
ongoing.
(3935) A Spin on Ageing: The Effects of International Poi on Health
Kate R van West1
1University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to measure the effects of
International Poi (a weight on the end of a cord which is swung in circular
patterns around the body), as compared to Tai Chi, on physical, cognitive, and
emotional health in healthy older adults with an assessor-blind randomized
controlled study.
Results: Both interventions benefited postural stability (Functional
Reach Test P = .008, 4-Stage Balance Test
P = .003), upper limb strength (hand grip
P = .0001), memory (composite memory P = .007,
visual memory P = .004), and simple attention
(P = .038). Tai Chi also benefited systolic blood pressure
(P = .026). Qualitative analysis revealed participants in
the International Poi group felt relaxed, challenged, and happy during the
intervention. For Tai Chi; relaxed, calm, and peaceful.
Conclusions: International Poi is as effective as Tai Chi for
improving physical, cognitive, and emotional health in healthy older adults.
(3936) The Feasibility and Efficacy of a Ketogenic Diet Intervention on
Overweight and Obese Men Undergoing Active Surveillance for Prostate Cancer
Mohummad M Siddiqui, MD1, Jason Bosley-Smith, MS, LDN, CNS1,
Joseph Aryankalayil, BA1, Adeel Kaiser, MD1 and Christopher R
D’Adamo, PhD2
1Baltimore, Maryland
2University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: Many men with indolent forms of prostate cancer are managed
expectantly using active surveillance (AS), with the goal of delaying treatment
and associated toxicities. Elevated body mass index has been identified as an
independent factor associated with increased risk of cancer progression during
AS. The ketogenic diet is a promising intervention that is increasingly employed
in integrative oncology. This clinical trial aims to gather preliminary data
evaluating the effects of the ketogenic diet to delay cancer progression in
overweight and obese prostate cancer patients undergoing AS.
Results: Two of 12 patients have enrolled with full enrollment
expected by early next year. The impact of the ketogenic diet on the prostate
tissue microenvironment will be compared to matched controlled samples from 24
AS subjects meeting our study enrollment criteria but not undergoing the diet
intervention.
Conclusions: This trial represents the first prospective study
examining the use of a ketogenic diet for prostate cancer patients on AS. We
anticipate that the ketogenic diet will be a feasible strategy to elicit weight
loss in our study population. The dietary impact on serum inflammatory and
hormonal biomarkers, as well as associated changes in the prostate
microenvironment, may help elucidate the mechanisms behind the benefit from
weight loss and identify targets for future intervention.
(3937) Integrative Proton Therapy: A Novel, Personalized Strategy Combining
Precision Proton Treatment With Integrative Medicine Modalities to Improve Quality
of Life and Outcomes for Cancer Patients
Brian M Berman, MD1, Delia Chiaramonte, MD2, Adeel Kaiser,
MD2, Charles B Simone II, MD, Griffin McMath, ND2 and
William F Regine, MD2
1University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland
2Baltimore, Maryland
Abstract
Overview: Approximately 60% of cancer patients receive radiation
therapy during their disease course. Conventional radiation techniques employ
high energy X-rays that deposit cytotoxic energy along the entire path of the
radiation beam, extending to the targeted tumor and beyond. Proton therapy (PT)
is a highly focused form of radiation using charged particles that deposit most
of their energy directly into a tumor volume and terminate at that location.
This limits unnecessary radiation exposure to critical organs that may abut
tumor tissues. PT requires a particle accelerator and is only available in a few
U.S. facilities. However, with even the most advanced forms of cancer therapy,
patients may still experience toxicities through direct tissue damage or the
psychological impact of their disease. Prior studies using complementary
modalities have demonstrated positive results concerning these domains with
improved quality of life (QOL).
Rationale: We will examine the impact of a novel treatment strategy
employing advanced, precision radiation technology with a personalized wellness
plan developed by a naturopathic doctor and implemented by an integrative health
team. The wellness plan is formed prior to the initiation of proton therapy to
identify baseline psychological, psychosocial, and/or nutritional deficiencies
that may negatively impact the patient’s cancer care experience and
post-treatment QOL. Targeted interventions based on this assessment include
combinations of guided imagery, yoga nidra, acupuncture, massage, therapeutic
art, yoga therapy, mind–body medicine, and educational sessions covering stress
management, nutrition optimization, and supplement use.
Objectives: To our knowledge, this newly launched cancer program is
the first of its kind to fully integrate precision cancer therapy using proton
technology with complementary modalities to maximize quality of life outcomes.
We anticipate that this targeted approach will help to greatly reduce the
negative impact of cancer therapies and will serve as a new model for the
treatment of cancer patients.
(3938) An Innovative Approach to Health Education: Utilizing an Ancestral,
Integrative and Functional Medicine Education Resource With Students, Clinicians and
Patients
Robert D Abbott, MD1
1University of Virginia, Virginia Commonwealth University, Shenandoah
Valley, Charlottesville, Virginia
Abstract
Overview: According to the World Health Organization, a health-care
system involves “all the activities whose primary purpose is to promote, restore
or maintain health” (The World Health Report 2000 – Health systems:
improving performance). This broad definition encompasses
health-care practitioners, health-care students and patients. In recent years,
the Ancestral, Integrative and Functional Medicine movements have helped empower
all 3 of these groups.
The Institute for Functional Medicine defines Functional Medicine (FM) as a
system that addresses the underlying causes of disease, using a system-oriented
approach, engaging both patient and practitioner in a therapeutic
partnership.
The University of Arizona defines Integrative Medicine (IM) as healing-oriented
medicine that takes account of the whole person, including all aspects of
lifestyle. It emphasizes the therapeutic relationship between practitioner and
patient, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all appropriate
therapies.
Ancestral Health can broadly be described as an approach to health focused on
optimizing lifestyle habits involving diet, sleep, social interaction, movement
and spiritual engagement based on the evolutionary history of our ancestors as
well as our more recent cultural relatives.
An obstacle for all of these movements, however, is that the delivery of
information and educational resources is dispersed over many different
organizations and is often difficult to access and consume. Books, websites,
videos, podcasts and even online-based trainings can be easily found on the
Internet but not easily organized or vetted for relevance and applicability.
This presentation highlights an electronic book resource that organizes
Ancestral Health, IM and FM resources by learning style (auditory, visual and
kinetic) and further categorizes the resources by level of expertise or intended
audience. The goal of this educational resource is to provide individuals with a
dynamically evolving, free repository of educational health resources that can
streamline ancestral, IM, and FM education for practitioners, health-care
students and patients.
Rationale: Health education and its delivery are changing. Medical
school costs are exceeding $200,000 and the demand for integrative and
functional clinicians well versed in lifestyle and root-cause resolution
approaches to health is outpacing the current supply. Many medical schools and
residency programs still provide very little nutrition, lifestyle or integrative
medicine education as part of their formal curricula. The majority of students
are often unaware of ancestral, integrative, and functional approaches to
wellness outside of their formal school training and are easily overwhelmed by
the breadth of information provided as part of their formal education. Patients
and laypersons too are not immune to the growing problem of information
overload, as the coming generations will not be faced with the problem of going
without, but rather, with the problem of having too much. Collectively,
practitioners need educated and empowered patients and patients need educated
and open-minded clinicians. We are a worldwide community needing change in order
to promote health and need each other to thrive. This presentation highlights a
dynamically evolving electronic book resource, a first attempt at synthesizing
and consolidating some of the most relevant health education resources, so
students, clinicians and patients do not have to search in vain for what can
bring them joy and health.
Objectives: The aim is to discuss the availability, utility and
accessibility of educational resources with regard to an ancestral, functional
and integrative approach to health; to provide a methodical and practical
approach for exploring educational resources with regard to identified goals,
intentions and cognitive/learning styles; to allow one to appreciate the need
for broadening one’s approach and understanding of currently available
educational resources including both those that are freely accessible and those
available through formal trainings/certification programs; for clinicians, to
empower them to expand their education into integrative, ancestral and
functional medicine as well as to provide them with a framework to offer concise
and individualized educational health resources/plans tailored to the individual
interests, concerns and preferred learning style of their patients; for
students, to provide them with a practical, complementary education plan to
support their current academic endeavors, tailoring the experience to their
available financial resources and preferred cognitive learning style; for
patients, to provide them and their families with reliable and relevant
educational resources, to empower them to utilize a variety of resources to aid
in lifestyle and habit change, and to allow them to appreciate the need for
collaboration with an experienced holistic clinician when necessary.
(3950) A Case Report of Subacute – Phase Hypersensitivity Pneumonitis Treated
With Korean Traditional Medicine
So H Shim1, Kwon J Nam1, Jun Y Choi1 and Hee J
Seo1
1Korean Medicine Hospital of Pusan National University, Yangsan, Republic
of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: As the environmental pollution increases, the importance of
allergic diseases has been emphasized. Among them, hypersensitivity pneumonitis
is an allergic disease clinically causing dyspnea, cough and fever. However,
diagnostic criteria and guidelines have not been clearly established and the
studies are not actively conducted. In this study, we report a case of subacute
– phase hypersensitivity pneumonitis patient, treated with Korean traditional
medicine.
Results: After about 2 weeks of treatment, the patient showed the
marked improvement. Fever completely disappeared after 2 days of treatment.
Dyspnea, the most uncomfortable symptoms, improved from third day of admission
and was significantly reduced to G/A 3/10 level at the sixth day of admission.
Cough also improved to similar levels by 2 days later. Besides, the accompanying
symptoms such as discomfort of the throat, general weakness and myalgia were
also improved.
Conclusions: These results suggest that the Korean traditional
medicine could be effective to regulate the hypersensitivity pneumonitis
symptoms.
(3952) Dialectical Pain Management Skills Group for Adults on Long-term Opioid
Therapy: Feasibility and Preliminary Outcomes
Deborah Barrett, PhD, LCSW1, Amanda Zaski, MSW1, Mark J Edlund,
MD, PhD2 and Carrie Brintz, PhD1
1Chapel Hill, North Carolina
2RTI International, Durham, North Carolina
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic pain is often treated with opioids, which have
limited effectiveness and significant side effects and risks. This study aimed
to test the feasibility and preliminary effects of a novel intervention
targeting emotional and physical distress associated with chronic pain. It was
hypothesized that teaching skills to reduce distress may also reduce reliance on
opioids.
Results: Seventeen adults aged 28–75 years (71% female, 82% White)
were enrolled. The majority identified multiple pain conditions (82%) and were
taking 2 opioids (59%); 71% attended 6 or more sessions, with 18% withdrawing
and 76% completing postassessments. From pre- to postintervention, significant
improvements were found on the Chronic Pain Acceptance Questionnaire (Mean
change = 15.77, P = .002) and PHQ-9 depression scores (Mean
change = −3.85, P = .03); 38.5% of completers decreased their
opioid dosage from baseline and 0% increased their dosage. In qualitative
interviews, participants described high levels of satisfaction with the
intervention and benefits from the skills.
Conclusions: In adults taking daily opioid medications for chronic
pain, a DPM group is feasible and may reduce depression, increase pain
acceptance, and help reduce opioid reliance. An appropriately powered randomized
controlled trial is needed to assess the intervention’s effectiveness and
determine mediators and moderators of improvement.
(3958) Shedding Light on the Relational Influences of Yoga On and Off the Mat
Through Qualitative and Quantitative Methods
Steriani Elavksy, PhD1, Scherezade K Mama, PhD2, Linda Larkey,
PhD3 and Moé Kishida, PhD3
1University of Ostrava, Ostrava, Czech Republic
2The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania
3Arizona State University, Phoenix, Arizona
Abstract
Purpose: The overarching aim of the present study was to utilize
both qualitative and quantitative methods to better understand the potential
influences of yoga on relational outcomes (i.e., connections with oneself and
social relationships), which are invaluable for one’s health and well-being.
Results: In the qualitative analyses, 4 emerging themes were
identified (i.e., yoga generates calm states, mindfulness, (self)-compassion,
and social connectedness) culminating in the development of a conceptual model
of how yoga may work to bring about relational benefits. Pathways in the
framework were then tested through a series of multilevel analyses which
indicated that on days when an individual practiced more yoga than their usual,
greater mindfulness (b = 2.93, SE = 0.39,
P < .05) and self-compassion (b = 1.45,
SE = 0.46, P < .05) were reported.
1-1-1 multilevel mediation models demonstrated yoga had an indirect effect on
both compassion and social connectedness through increases in mindfulness at the
within- and between-person levels. In models testing self-compassion as the
mediator, the indirect effect of daily yoga practice on compassion was
significant, although limited to the within-person level.
Conclusions: Findings suggest a routine yoga practice appears to
hold promise in having a positive impact (on and off the mat) on preserving and
strengthening the intra- and interpersonal connections which constitute the
building blocks of our day-to-day lives.
(3960) Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses on Effect of Ayurvedic Interventions
for Hypercholesterolemia, Hypertension and Coronary Heart Disease
Dinesh Gyawali, PhD1, Sridharan Ramaratnam, MD2, Robert
Schneider, MD, FACC1 and David W Orme-Johnson, PhD1
1Maharishi University of Management, Fairfield, Iowa
2Apollo Hospitals, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
Abstract
Purpose: Heart disease is the number one cause of death globally.
Due to increasing costs and numerous side effects of conventional medicine
complementary healing approaches like Ayurveda are trending now. However, in
lack of sufficient scientific evidence, safety and efficacy profile of these
interventions has not yet been established. Systematic reviews and meta-analysis
are the gold standard of evidence upon which clinicians and consumers rely. Till
date, there are no Cochrane or any other systematic reviews on Ayurvedic
interventions for cardiovascular risk factors. Hence, the current study was
conducted with an aim to explore the efficacy of Ayurvedic interventions in
hypercholesterolemia, hypertension and coronary heart diseases, identify the
strength of evidence and any possible side effects.
Results: Three meta-analyses of 64 studies on 2629 people studying
effects of 10 different Ayurvedic interventions for hypercholesterolemia, high
blood pressure and coronary heart disease, concluded that there is moderate to
high strength evidence that several Ayurvedic herbal preparations are safe and
effective. They pose no known side effects and thus can be used as dietary
supplements or as an adjuvant to conventional therapy for better results. It was
observed that Commiphora mukul (guggulu) reduced total
cholesterol and low-density lipoprotein levels by approximately 16 mg/dL and
18 mg/dL, respectively, with high certainty evidence. Similarly, garlic and
Terminalia arjuna (arjuna) based formulas also had high to
moderate strength evidence of their efficacy to reduce cholesterol levels. On
the other hand, Arjun Vachyadi compound and Rauwolfia
serpentina based formulas were found to have moderate certainty
evidence to reduce high blood pressure. It was also observed that Ayurvedic
formulas with arjuna as a chief ingredient are capable of improving left
ventricular ejection fraction by 12% with a moderate strength of evidence.
Findings of these systematic reviews and meta-analysis encourage future
researchers to conduct methodologically rigorous randomized clinical trials
studies with a larger sample size.
Conclusions: In conclusion, findings from 3 systematic reviews and
meta-analysis suggested that Ayurvedic herbal medicine for hypercholesterolemia,
hypertension and coronary heart disease do not pose any side effects and/or any
serious drug interaction and thus can be used safely as supplements or as
adjuvants to western medication. On an average, there is a moderate strength of
evidence that these herbal medicines may reduce the cardiovascular risk factors
within a range of 6% to 15%. However, more randomized controlled trials on
bigger population are of utmost need to develop better confidence in the
evidence found.
(3961) A Case Report of Antibiotic-associated Diarrhea Treated With Traditional
Korean Medicine
Yoon-Jeong Seo1
1Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this clinical study is to describe the case of a
patient with antibiotic-associated diarrhea, which was improved by treatment
with herbal medicine.
Results: During the treatment, the Bristol Stool Form Scale changed
from type 7 to type 5.
Conclusions: The results suggest that traditional Korean medicine
may be an effective treatment for antibiotic-associated diarrhea.
(3962) Utilization of Complementary and Integrative Medicine Among Lupus
Patients: A Patient-centered Analysis of Perceived Effectiveness and
Preference
Lindsey A Warner, BS, MS1 and Shazia Beg, MD1
1University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this study is to ascertain the use, preference,
motivation and perceived effectiveness of Complementary and Integrative Medicine
(CIM) in individuals with systemic lupus erythematous.
We hope that this data will be informative for physicians caring for individuals
with lupus to the prevalence of CIM use and perceived effectiveness in this
population so that they may better advise their patients on safety. We also hope
to encourage further research into the most prevalently used modalities to both
promote patient safety and to suggest novel therapies to help increase quality
of life for individuals with this poorly controlled condition.
Results: The 3 CIM therapies most commonly used among our lupus
sample were non-herbal natural products (44; 57%), aromatherapy/essential oils
(32; 41.5%) and meditation (31; 40.2%). Non-herbal natural products include
chondroitin, coenzyme Q 10, fish oil, omega 3 and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA),
glucosamine, lutein, melatonin, methylsulfonylmethane, and sesame oil. The most
commonly utilized were natural fats (40; 90.9%) which includes fish oil, omega 3
and DHA. This was followed by melatonin (13; 29.5%) and glucosamine (11; 25 %).
Despite their high rate of utilization, over a third of participants (17; 38.6%)
felt that they were not effective or only somewhat effective. Similarly (14;
43.8%) of the aroma therapy users found it not effective or only somewhat
effective. However, 67.7% (21) of the meditation users found their therapy to be
effective, very effective or extremely effective. The most commonly used
essential oil was lavender (11; 36.7%) followed by peppermint (3; 10.0%). The
majority of respondents in all 3 groups indicated that their motivation for
utilizing these therapies was because ‘they believed it worked’ and when asked
about their desired benefit indicated ‘general wellness’. This was a common
theme for and was reported as the motivation and benefit for 10 of the 19
therapies. The most striking deviation from this theme however was herbal
medicine, with (22; 84.6%) reporting motivation was relief of a lupus related
symptom; 91.7% of the 26 respondents that utilized herbs did so specifically to
alleviate lupus-related symptoms rather than general wellness, with 20 (76.9%)
reporting benefit. Of the 20 herbs listed, turmeric (7; 26.9%), marijuana (6;
23.0%) and green tea (2; 7.6%) were reported to be most beneficial for
lupus-related symptoms.
Discussion/Conclusions: The rate of CIM utilization reported by our
sample was 87.6%, which is approximately 3 times higher than the 2012 National
Health Statistic Reports estimated average of 33.2% for the general U.S.
population. The 3 most commonly used modalities among our participants,
non-herbal natural products (57%), aromatherapy (41.5%) and meditation (40.2%),
differed from the nationally reported top 3, which were non-herbal natural
products (17.7%), meditation (10.9%) and yoga (10.1%).
With a disorder as poorly controlled as lupus, any therapy that increases quality
of life warrants consideration regardless of how unconventional. Meditation,
herbal medicine and massage were particularly promising, as over one third of
the sample had utilized them with over 60% of participants reporting
benefit.
(3963) Effectiveness of a Mind–Body and Peer Support Program for Teens Living
With Chronic Illness and Their Parents: A Pilot Study
Brittany Blockman, MD1, Michael Acree, PhD1, David Becker, MD,
MPH1, Audrey Nichols, RN1, Arielle Schaffer-White,
MD1, Megan Winkelman, MA1, Judith T Moskowitz,
PhD1 and Frederick M Hecht, MD1
1San Francisco, California
Abstract
Purpose: To assess the feasibility of a novel group intervention
providing mind–body skills and peer support for teens living with chronic
illness and their parents and explore its impact on physical and mental health,
resiliency, and symptoms.
Results: Teens (N = 26) were 73% female, average age 15.5 years,
average attendance 7.8 sessions. Illnesses represented: cancer, chronic
abdominal pain, chronic migraine, cystic fibrosis, endometriosis, inflammatory
bowel disease, juvenile idiopathic arthritis, lung disease, neuromuscular
disorders, type 1 diabetes mellitus, Wegener’s granulomatosis. Comparing
baseline with immediate postintervention, multiple outcomes showed statistically
significant improvements: physical health (NIH Promis) mean change (MC) = +0.92,
Effect Size (ES) = 0.45, P = .036; Mental Health (NIH Promis),
MC = +2.46, ES = 0.83, P = .005; Total Mood Disturbance
(Profile of Mood States—POMS), MC = −1.37, ES = 0.51, P = .021;
Depression (POMS), MC = −0.39, ES = −0.52, P = .018; Fatigue
(POMS), MC = −0.028, ES = 0.52, P = .011; Vigor (POMS),
MC = +0.30, ES = 0.49, P = .003; Perceived Stress (Perceived
Stress Scale), MC = −3.72, ES = −0.79, P = .001; Resiliency
MC = +0.36, ES = 0.73, P = .002; Posttraumatic Growth
MC = +0.39, ES = 0.54, P = .015. All results retained
significance 3 months postintervention, except posttraumatic growth, and ES for
anxiety (POMS) became significant at this point (ES = −0.89,
P = .003). Teens also reported decreases in symptom frequency
(P = .001) and medication usage (.002), when comparing
baseline to immediately post-intervention. Parents reported a decrease from
baseline in unplanned doctor visits for their child at the 3-month follow-up
(P = .034). The majority of these results become stronger
in an analysis that retained only participants attending ≥50% of the sessions
(n = 22).
Conclusions: Our results suggest that the intervention resulted in
positive changes in physical health, mental health, mood, stress, resiliency,
and posttraumatic growth in teens living with chronic illness; these promising
results warrant further testing in a controlled trial design.
(3964) Barriers to Access and Perceptions of Massage Therapy at a Public Hospital
System in Northeast Ohio
Earl Pike, BA1, Diane Mastnardo, BS2, Jacqueline Dolata,
MBA1 and John D Thornton, MD1
1
MetroHealth Medical Center Case Center for Reducing Health Disparities,
Cleveland, Ohio
2
Massage of Northern Ohio Practice Based Research Network/MetroHealth Case W,
Cleveland, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: To identify perceptions and barriers to access of massage
therapy utilization among patients receiving care in a public hospital
system.
Results: Massage was seen as health care equal to luxury and not
viewed as dirty or inappropriate. Respondents from urban clinics were less
likely to have had a massage by a licensed massage therapist. Cost is
overwhelmingly the largest barrier in both urban and suburban settings. Patients
identified back pain, headaches, stress, and anxiety as reasons they would seek
massage.
Conclusions: Dispelling myths and increasing understanding about the
benefits of massage as a treatment option will be necessary for inclusion in
health centers. Providing licensed massage therapist as a billable provider
would help make massage therapy a more viable option for those of lower
socioeconomic status, as cost was overwhelmingly seen as the largest barrier to
access. With today’s opioid epidemic, massage therapy may be a viable
alternative to prescription opioids for pain.
(3965) Resilient Residency: Creating a Culture of Interdisciplinary,
Interprofessional Support Through a Multimodal Integrative Intervention
Terri Menser, PhD, MBA1, Nikol Marchenko, BS2, Scott Holliday,
MD3 and Maryanna D Klatt, PhD2
1Houston Methodist Research Institute, Houston, Texas
2The Ohio State University, College of Medicine, Columbus, Ohio
3Columbus, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: This novel and practice changing research shows that
Mindfulness in Motion, a multimodal intervention, delivered during the workday
significantly reduced burnout, increased resilience and vigor toward work for a
group of interdisciplinary residents. Our team expanded a Graduate Medical
Education pilot to target interprofessional, institutional resiliency within our
academic health center by bringing together residents, chaplaincy residents,
attending physicians, medical center faculty, and hospital
administrative/clinical staff.
Results: The first cohort (n = 23) demonstrated a significant 22%
reduction in burnout, while increasing in resilience, across programs. By
intervention end, there was a significant decrease in the depersonalization
score (P = .0442), and in the emotional exhaustion
(P = .388) Maslach Burnout Inventory subscale compared to
baseline. In addition, the pre/post score for resilience, (Children’s Depression
Rating Scale-Revised) significantly increased (P = .0204),
while there was a significant increase for the vigor subscale
(P = .0042) of the Utrecht Work Engagement Scale.
Conclusions: A hybrid (in-person and online) mindfulness
intervention administered can lead to significant improvements in burnout,
specifically depersonalization, emotional exhaustion, resilience, and work
engagement, more specifically, vigor. The Graduate Medical Education office used
Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education common program requirements
around well-being to extend beyond our 800+ resident physicians, recognizing
that health care as an interprofessional team endeavor, with each member of any
health-care team impacting the other. Future expansion will be
interprofessional, as well as interdisciplinary across residencies.
(3968) Preliminary Findings for a Wellness Program for Veterans With
Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
Barbara L Niles, PhD1, DeAnna L Mori, PhD2, Elizabeth
Weinstein, BA1, Anica P Kaiser, PhD1, Katharine Smidt,
PhD1 and Laurel Brown, PhD3
1Behavioral Science Division, National Center for PTSD, Boston,
Massachusetts
2Department of Psychiatry, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston,
Massachusetts
3Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The Veterans Administration Whole Health Initiative
promotes a model of care where Veterans play a central role in managing their
health and well-being in partnership with their health-care team. A key
component is learning mindfulness skills that help Veterans make choices about
their health with the goal of enhancing their overall well-being. This approach
may be particularly helpful for Veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD) who are at increased risk for health problems. Focusing on healthy
behaviors that promote improved wellness may interrupt the progression of
disease and disability associated with PTSD. In addition, mindfulness training
may reduce hyperarousal symptoms that have been identified as prominent in the
development and maintenance of PTSD.
Results: Both interview data and responses on the Client
Satisfaction Questionnaire indicated high satisfaction with the program
(M = 29.56 of possible 32). In addition, the mean
attendance rate was high (76.9%) with only one no-show and no dropouts. Themes
identified through the qualitative interview data suggested that the group
motivated participants to make healthy behavior changes and taught skills that
helped them cope with their symptoms of PTSD.
Conclusions: The preliminary results indicated that this Wellness
intervention was well attended with high rates of satisfaction. This Wellness
approach may offer an alternative or supplementary treatment for PTSD that is
highly acceptable and may improve health behaviors.
(3970) Stakeholder Expectations of Integrating a Doctor of Chiropractic Into a
Rehabilitation Specialty Hospital: A Qualitative Analysis
Zacariah K Shannon, DC, MS1, William C Cooley, MD2, Stacie A
Salsbury, RN, PhD1, Robert D Vining, DC1 and Christine M
Goertz, DC, PhD1
1Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
2Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, New Hampshire
Abstract
Purpose: Incorporating new disciplines into integrative settings can
introduce novel perspectives on care and additional challenges in terms of
establishing logistics and defining treatment roles. This qualitative research
project explored stakeholder expectations of adding a doctor of chiropractic
(DC) to the health-care team at a rehabilitation specialty hospital.
Results: The overall goal of the hospital was to progress patients
toward discharge, often through an extended, incremental process that involved
interdisciplinary collaboration to form personalized treatment strategies.
Stakeholders most commonly expected that chiropractic care would benefit
patients directly by affecting pain and physical function, which were thought to
improve upper/lower extremity function and advance self-care activities of daily
living, including wheelchair use and transfers. Stakeholders also expected
indirect effects of chiropractic care to impact the work of other providers and
the overall hospital mission. For example, a reduction in pain and resulting
behaviors was expected to increase patient cooperation and performance with
other providers’ treatments. Expectation themes were consistent across
stakeholder groups with emphasis of patients on ambulation, family on quality of
life, medical providers on medication use, therapists on muscle tone, and nurses
on pain-related behaviors.
Conclusions: Expectations for the DC emphasized pain management and
physical function placed within the context of incremental progress culminating
in eventual discharge. Understanding expectations can benefit both the new
practitioner and current stakeholders, serving to illuminate the reasonableness
of expectations and as an anchor point for future evaluation of success.
(3973) “Placebo Effect is Probably What We Refer to as Patient Healing Power”: A
Qualitative Pilot Study Examining How Norwegian Complementary Therapists Reflect on
Their Practice
Trine Stub, PhD1, Nina Foss, PhD2 and Ingrid Liodden,
PhD3
1The National Research Center in Complementary and Alternative Medicine,
Tromso, Norway
2UiT, The Artic University of Norway, NAFKAM, Tromso, Norway
3Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences, Oslo,
Norway
Abstract
Purpose/Background: Complementary therapists spend considerable time with their
patients, especially in the first consultation. The communication between
patients and their therapists is important for raising consciousness and
activation of the patient’s self-healing power. Thus, the aims in this study
were to delineate what complementary therapists regard as essential in patient
consultations, their view of the healing process, and how the therapists
understand the placebo effect and its position in the healing process.
Results: The pilot study showed that the implemented methods seems
feasible and fit well with the aims of this study. Complementary therapists
(chiropractor, naprapath [musculoskeletal therapist], acupuncturist, and
acupuncturist/homeopath) representing 4 different complementary modalities
participated. A combination of the conversation and examination during the first
consultation formed the basis for the therapist’s choice of treatment. A
successful consultation was characterized by a fruitful relationship between the
therapist and the patient. Moreover, the therapist needs to be humble and show
the patient respect. Patients’ positive beliefs and expectations about the
treatment play a significant role in the healing process. The more hope the
therapist can bring about, the more easily the patient can start believing that
it is possible to get well.
Conclusion: This was a pilot study. Therefore, the findings should
be appreciated as limited and preliminary. Therapists’ and patients’ mutual
understanding and treatment goals were essential for a successful consultation.
The therapists emphasized their professional skills and therapeutic competence
as important when building fruitful relationships with their patients. Exerting
authority and making the patient feel confident were essential factors for a
successful healing process. The complementary therapists understood the placebo
effect as the patient’s self-healing power, resulting from establishing trust
and belief in the treatment process.
(3976) Use of the MyStrength+MyHealth App to Identify Strengths, Challenges, and
Needs for a Whole-person Personalized Approach to Care for Women With
Circulation-related Problems
Robin Austin, DNP, DC, RN-BC1, Karen A Monsen, PhD, RN, FAAN2
and Ruth Lindquist, PhD, ACNS, RN, FAAN2
1University of Minnesota, School of Nursing, Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: Cardiovascular disease is a leading cause of death in
women. In cardiac care management, women’s voices are often underrepresented,
and women have experienced being seen “as the disease” rather than as a
whole-person with positive attributes as in addition to their physical
challenges. Current methods are lacking to better understand a whole-person
perspective to include strengths, challenges, and needs; and to provide
interventions using a strengths-based approach. Strengths are defined as assets,
skills, and talents in each family member, team member, family as a whole, and
the community. A strengths-based approach offers a person-centered approach to
address problems and to leverage each person’s unique strengths to support
physical, emotional, and psychosocial well-being. A consumer-facing application,
MyStrengths + MyHealth app, was developed to enable self-report of strengths,
challenges, and needs using a consumer-facing version of the Omaha System, a
multidisciplinary standardized health terminology.
Results: For the entire sample, there were significant correlations
between strengths, challenges, and needs (P < .01). Compared
to women without self-reported circulation-related problems, women with
circulation-related problems reported more strengths (M = 20.3; SD = 12.6 vs
M = 19; SD = 14.5; P = .5); challenges (M = 14.5; SD = 9.7 vs
M = 5.6; SD = 5.6; P < .0001); and health needs (M = 2.4;
SD = 5.6 vs M = 1.1; SD = 2.9; P = .07).
Conclusions: The MyStrengths + MyHealth app allows for standardized
person-generated data to include both problems and strengths. This may provide
insight into previously excluded or hidden data and potentially reveal new
findings important for patients, caregivers, and health-care teams. Our
long-term goal is to incorporate a strengths-based approach into health care
through embedding a standardized holistic assessment and care planning process
within electronic health record platforms, beginning with the patient voice.
(3978) Advances in Integrative Medicine Policies in Brazilian Public Health
System and the Parallel With the Actual National Medical Curriculum
Thais S Araujo, MD1, Aarão C Dias dos Santos, MD2 and Idê G
Dantas Gurgel, MD, PhD2
1Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil
2Fiocruz, Recife, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: Brazil has a publicly funded health-care system called the
Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS, Unified Health System), which 72% of the nation’s
physicians practice within. In 2006, SUS initiated a National Policy for
Integrative and Complimentary Practices (PNPIC) and since then is expanding
integrative medicine (IM) services offered to the population. Despite these
initiatives, it is unclear if there have been systemic changes in the public
medical schools’ curricula to include IM topics. The purpose of this project is
to review national IM initiatives through PNPIC, including their definitions,
actions, and regulation; and to review the national curriculum guidelines and
current curriculum at medical schools.
Results: The Brazilian ministry of health has included in the PNPIC
17 complementary and alternative practices (CAM) that can be offered by the SUS.
There are currently no national curricular medical school guidelines focused on
IM. None of the largest 10 medical school’s websites reviewed mentioned IM or
CAM in their core curriculum. Only 2 offered an elective in IM, both focused on
acupuncture and homeopathy.
Conclusions: This study supports that there is a disconnect between
the SUS’s PNPIC initiative and the national graduate medical curriculum on IM.
The results suggest that many graduating physicians will have limited teaching
in IM and may be unprepared to work within SUS. Further evaluation is warranted
to conduct a more comprehensive national curricular needs assessment to
determine baseline amount of graduate medical training in IM and CAM and to
update the national curricular medical school guidelines to address this
need.
(3980) Effects of Tai Chi on Stress and Cardiovascular Function in Patients With
Coronary Heart Disease and/or Hypertension: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Xufang Wu, MMed1, Nan Gu, MMed2, Wenyuan Li, MMed3,
Yuyi Wang, MMed4, Jianping Liu, PhD, MD3, Alan Bensoussan,
PhD5, Hosen Kiat, MBBS5,6,7, Paul Fahey, Nerida
MMedStat5, Dennis Klupp, PhD5, Guoyan Chang,
PhD5 and Yang, PhD5
1Changying Community Health Service Center, Beijing, China
2Dougezhuang Community Health Service Center, Beijing, China
3Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
4Chongqing Hospital of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
5Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
6University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia
7Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: To investigate the effects of Tai Chi on stress and
cardiovascular function in patients with coronary heart disease and/or
hypertension.
Results: Of 120 randomized participants (mean age, 64.3 years), 102
(85.0%) completed the trial. Using a linear mixed model, the Tai Chi group
demonstrated a significant reduction in PSS-10 scores at week 24 (Mean, 10.44;
95% confidence interval (CI), 8.86–12.03) compared with the waitlist group
(Mean, 11.71; 95% CI, 10.01–13.34) (P = .009). The mean walking
distance during 6-min walk increased from 494.77 meters at baseline to 552.81
meters at 24 weeks in the Tai Chi group, while from 518.83 to 519.63 meters in
the waitlist group. The difference between the 2 groups is statistically
significant (P < .001). Significant differences were also
detected between the 2 groups in depression, diastolic blood pressure, and
quality of life. No adverse events related to Tai Chi were reported.
Conclusions: A 24-week standardized Tai Chi intervention resulted in
modest but statistically significant improvements in stress, fitness,
depression, diastolic pressure, and quality of life, in patients with coronary
heart disease and/or hypertension compared with those in the waitlist control
group.
(3982) Synergistic Effect of Dietary Delta-tocotrienol and Geranylgeraniol on
Bone Properties in Obese C57BL/6 J Mice With Obesity-associated Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus
Chwan-Li Shen, PhD1, Michael D Tomison, BS2, Gurvinder Kaur,
PhD2, Latha Ramalingam, PhD3, Eunhee Chung,
PhD4, Naima Moustaid-Moussa, PhD3 and Jannette Dufour,
PhD2
1Lubbock, Texas
2Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, Lubbock, Texas
3Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas
4University of Texas at San Antonio, San Antonio, San Antonio, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) is a risk factor for
osteoporosis and current diabetic therapies have potential adverse effects on
bone metabolism. We previously reported that individual dietary bioactive
components, delta-tocotrienol (d-TT, extracted from annatto) and geranylgeraniol
(GG) benefit bone health by improving glucose homeostasis. In this study, we
further investigated d-TT and GG for their possible synergistic effects on bone
protection in a T2DM mouse model.
Results: Both d-TT and GG significantly increased glucose clearance
and improved insulin sensitivity, while no interaction (d-TT x GG) was observed.
Neither d-TT nor GG affected serum insulin or pancreas insulin levels. In terms
of serum bone markers, there was a significant interaction in procollagen I
intact N-terminal propeptide (P1NP-bone formation marker) and collagen type 1
cross-linked C-telopeptide (CTX-bone resorption marker), resulting in d-TT + GG
having the highest concentration of P1NP. The order of CTX levels was control
> d-TT = GG = d-TT + GG. MicroCT analysis revealed that only d-TT
supplementation, not GG, increased cortical thickness and decreased bone marrow
volume/tissue volume at mid-shaft femur (P < .05). On the
other hand, only GG supplementation was shown to (i) increase bone volume/tissue
volume, trabecular number, and connectivity density; and (ii) decrease
trabecular separation and structure model index at the cancellous bone of both
femur and lumbar vertebrae-4. There was a significant interaction in femoral
trabecular thickness with a result of d-TTxGG group having the highest value of
trabecular thickness.
Conclusions: Our results suggest that d-TT and GG have a synergistic
effect on bone protection in obese T2D mice independent of improving glucose
homeostasis.
(3985) A Randomized Trial of a Group-based Therapeutic Yoga Program for Urinary
Incontinence in Older Ambulatory Women
Alison Huang, MD1, Amy Hsu, MD2, Michael Schembri,
BS1, Leslee Subak, MD1, Nadra E Lisha, PhD1 and
Margaret A Chesney, PhD1
1San Francisco, California
2Palo Alto Medical Foundation, Palo Alto, California
Abstract
Purpose: Purpose: To evaluate the feasibility, tolerability, and
preliminary efficacy of a group-based therapeutic yoga program for urinary
incontinence (UI) in older ambulatory women.
Results: Results: Over 18 months, 56 women were randomized, 28 to
yoga, 28 to control. Mean age was 65 ± 8 (range 55−83) years; 35% were ethnic
minorities. Mean baseline UI frequency was 24 (±14) episodes/week. Fifty women
completed the trial (89%), with 27 in the yoga and 23 in the control group. Of
those, 75% attended >90% of group classes, and 88% completed >90% of home
practice hours. Over 3 months, total UI frequency decreased by a mean of
19.3 ± 10.2 episodes/week in the yoga versus 11.2 ± 17.9 episodes/week in the
control group (P = .02 for between-group difference in percent
UI reduction from baseline; P = .09 for between-group
difference in absolute UI reduction, after imputation for missing data). No
women reported any adverse events related to either intervention.
Conclusions: Conclusions: Findings demonstrate the feasibility of
recruiting and retaining ambulatory incontinent women across the aging spectrum
into a 3-month therapeutic yoga program and provide strong preliminary evidence
to support efficacy in reducing UI frequency. When taught in a standardized way
and with appropriate attention to safety, yoga may offer a promising
community-based self-management strategy for UI among older women.
(3987) Classroom-based Mindfulness for Stress Reduction in High School
Students
Jeanette Johnstone, PhD1, Joel Nigg, PhD2, Amanda Ribbers,
MS2, Rachel Atchley, PhD2, Hanna Gustafsson,
PhD2, Jessica Tipsord, PhD2 and Barry Oken, MD,
PhD2
1National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
2Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Given the high degree of stress experienced by many high
school students, this study sought to examine whether mindfulness was an
acceptable classroom-based stress reduction intervention and whether it offered
improvement in mood, anxiety and stress, as measured by self-reports and
physiological measures.
Results: Full data were available from 9 classes
(n = 202 students). Post-intervention satisfaction for
mindfulness withstood baseline expectancy effects
(P < .001), while wellness satisfaction was positively
correlated with pre-intervention expectations, r = .33,
n = 39, P = .03. Post-intervention anxiety
scores were significantly lower in students receiving mindfulness compared to
usual health class (β = −.07, SE = .03, P = .009); no
significant differences were found in other primary outcomes. Fifty-two percent
of students (n = 35) used the mindfulness app once to practice
outside of class; of those 10% used it 10 or more times.
Conclusions: Wellness satisfaction was influenced by
pre-intervention expectations. Offering mindfulness during the high school day
was acceptable to students, but less than 10% met the expectation to use the
mindfulness app to practice regularly outside of the classroom. Although anxiety
improved, 8 weeks of classroom-based mindfulness, without outside practice, did
not appear to be a sufficient “dose” to detect significant improvements in mood
and stress in self-reports and physiological measures of lab-induced stress.
These findings address some of the questions about the delivery of mindfulness
in a classroom-based situation and suggest lifestyle elements that contribute to
an active control for future comparative mindfulness research. CTN:
NCT02629016.
(3989) Herbal Medicines for Prevention of Anti-tuberculosis Drug-induced
Hepatotoxicity: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials
Jian-Hua Wang, PhD1, Yuan Chi1, Merlin Willcox, DPhil,
MRCGP2, Jian-ping Liu, MD, PhD3, Mei Wang, PhD1
and Xiu Dong, PhD1
1Liaoning University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shenyang, China
2University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
3Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Herbal medicines are widely used for liver protection along
with anti-tuberculosis treatment in China. This systematic review aims to
evaluate the effectiveness and safety of herbal medicine for prevention of
anti-tuberculosis drug-induced hepatotoxicity (ATDH) so to inform current policy
and practice.
Results: In total, 35 randomized trials involving 9552 participants
who received anti-tuberculosis treatment were included. The commonly used herbal
medicines were Silibinin (7/35), Hugan Pian (4/35), Dangfei Liganning (4/35),
Fufang Yiganling (4/35), and Compound glycyrrhizin (3/35). Meta-analysis of
low-grade evidence showed Silibinin reduced incidence of ATDH compared with no
intervention (RR 0.25, 95% CI 0.14 to 0.43; 5 trials), and with Inosine (RR:
0.29, 95% CI: 0.16 to 0.52; 2 trials). Compared with Gluconolactone, Hugan Pian
and Fufang Yiganling showed beneficial effect of ATDH rate (RR: 0.32, 95% CI:
0.17 to 0.62; 2 trials, and 0.46, 95% CI: 0.32 to 0.66; 3 trials, respectively).
Meta-analysis showed that there was no significant difference between Fufang
Yiganling and Gluconolactone for serum ALT levels (U/L) (MD −1.79, 95% CI: −3.99
to 7.56, I2 = 79%, 4 trials); however, positive effect was found for
decreasing serum AST levels (U/L) (MD −15.73, 95% CI: −30.78 to −0.67,
I2 = 98%, 4 trials). No serious adverse events were reported in
relation to herbal medicine.
Conclusions: Low-quality evidence shows prophylactic liver
protection effect from some herbal medicines for ATDH. Further rigorous studies
are needed to confirm the beneficial effect and safety of those potential herbal
medicines for ATDH.
(3993) Paediatrics and Gerontology Specialisations in the Complementary and
Integrative Medicine Workforce: Characteristics of Practitioners
Brenda Leung, PhD1, 2, Helene Diezel, MHSc3, Janet Schloss,
PhD3, David Sibbritt, PhD4, Jon Wardle, PhD,
ND4, Jon Adams, PhD4, Hope M Foley, BHSc3, 4,
Matthew J Leach, PhD5 and Amie Steel, PhD, ND3, 6
1University of Lethbridge, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada
2University of Technology Sydney, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
3Endeavour College of Natural Health, Brisbane, Australia
4University of Technology Sydney, Sydney, Australia
5University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia
6University of Technology Sydney, Brisbane, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Individuals frequently visit complementary and integrative
medicine (CIM) practitioners to access specialised care during specific
life-stages, including for support through paediatric and gerontology related
challenges. The nature of specialisation amongst CIM practitioners in the
Australian workforce has not previously been explored. This study examines rates
of specialisation in paediatrics and gerontology amongst CIM practitioners
within a representative sample of the Australian CIM workforce, and describes
characteristics of practitioners with special interests in these 2 fields.
Results: One thousand three hundred six practitioners completed the
survey. Paediatrics and gerontology were the least frequently reported special
interests in the sample. 30.1% of respondents indicated special interest in
paediatrics and 19.3% in gerontology. Practitioners specialising in paediatrics
were most likely to practice homeopathy (OR: 4.3,
P ≤ .001), Chinese herbal medicine (OR:
2.5, P ≤ .001) or naturopathy (OR: 2.1,
P ≤ .001). Practitioners specialising in
gerontology were most likely to practice homeopathy (OR: 2.6,
P ≤ .001), in non-urban localities (OR:
1.6, P = .002), and to have been practicing
15 + years (OR: 1.7, P = .021).
Conclusions: While perceptions of homeopathy being safe may be
influencing the specialisation of homeopaths in these vulnerable populations,
there is much debate about the modality’s efficacy, calling for greater research
in paediatric and gerontological homeopathy. Additionally, concerns surrounding
quality and contamination of Chinese herbal products require attention,
particularly in the paediatric population. The CIM practitioner workforce shows
less interest in gerontology than other specialisations. In light of the ageing
population in many countries, CIM practitioners should consider increasing
support for this demographic.
(3997) Non-specific Effects of Acupuncture and Sham Acupuncture in Clinical
Trials From the Patient’s Perspective: A Systematic Review of Qualitative
Evidence
Justin CY Wu, MD1, Samuel YS Wong, MD1, Vincent CH Chung,
PhD1, Robin ST Ho, MPH1 and Charlene HL Wong,
BSc1
1The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Sha Tin, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Abstract
Purpose: Previous clinical trials have demonstrated that both
acupuncture and sham acupuncture exert significant, non-specific effects on
treatment outcomes when compared to no-treatment controls. Recently developed
framework (mechanisms in orthodox and complementary and alternative medicine
[MOCAM]) suggests non-specific effects of acupuncture originate from multiple
domains (eg, patient characteristics, acupuncturist skill/technique,
patient-acupuncturist relationship, and acupuncture environment). However, it
remains to be determined precisely how these domains influence non-specific
effects of treatment among patients receiving acupuncture and sham acupuncture
in clinical trials. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review (SR) to
synthesize existing qualitative evidence on how trial participants randomized to
acupuncture and sham acupuncture groups experience non-specific effects,
regardless of types of medical conditions investigated.
Results: Twenty studies of high methodological quality were
included. Our proposed model indicated these effects may be increased by
maintaining a professional status, applying a holistic treatment approach,
practicing empathy, and providing patients with an appropriate explanation of
theory behind acupuncture and sham acupuncture. From patient’s perspective, the
efficacy of treatment can be increased by following lifestyle modification
advice provided by acupuncturists, maintaining a positive attitude toward
treatment efficacy, actively engaging with acupuncturists during consultation,
and making behavioral changes based on experience gained during trial.
Conclusions: Results of the present study may provide basis for
improving and standardizing key components of non-specific effects in
acupuncture treatment and for improving the isolation of specific effects in
future clinical trials involving acupuncture and sham acupuncture.
(3998) Mindfullness-based Stress Reduction: Does a Crash Course Work for Medical
Students?
Theresa Meotti1, Daniel Rappoport1 and Mary P Guerrera, MD,
FAAFP1
1Farmington, Connecticut
Abstract
Purpose: To determine if techniques taught by a trained and
certified mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) instructor over a one-week
pilot course will teach students the basics of a mindfulness practice and result
in a decrease in self-rated scores of perceived stress.
Results: The study results are currently pending as this MBSR course
and associated research will occur February to March 2018. Pre-course data will
be compared to post-course data to determine effect.
Conclusions: We hypothesize that the condensed MBSR training course
will result in decreased perceived stress ratings among participants. Formal
conclusions will be formulated after data analysis.
(3999) CHIMERAS Showed Better Inter-rater Reliability and Inter-consensus
Reliability Than GRADE in Grading Quality of Evidence From Cochrane Reviews: A
Randomized Controlled Trial
Charlene HL Wong, BSc1, Justin CY Wu, MD1, Vincent CH Chung,
PhD1, Irene XY Wu, PhD1, Benjamin HK Yip, PhD1
and William KW Cheung, BSc1
1The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Sha Tin, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Abstract
Purpose: To inform decision-making and guideline developing,
appraising quality of evidence (QoE) is an essential process for performing a
systematic review. The Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and
Evaluation (GRADE) is one of the tools for assessing QoE; however, concerns on
its reliability and comprehensiveness were raised. To address these
shortcomings, we developed the Clinical and Health Intervention Meta-analysis
Evidence RAting System (CHIMERAS). This randomized controlled trial aims to
assess and compare the reliability of CHIMERAS and GRADE.
Results: The 100 SRs covered 17 different categories of conditions,
including pharmacological (37.0%) and non-pharmacological interventions (63.0%).
CHIMERAS showed moderate agreement (ICC = 0.54, 95% confidence interval [CI]:
0.44–0.64), while GRADE had fair agreement (ICC = 0.38, 95% CI: 0.28–0.49) for
inter-rater reliability among individual raters. CHIMERAS showed substantial
agreement (ICC = 0.78, 95% CI: 0.69–0.84), while GRADE had moderate agreement
(ICC = 0.52, 95% CI: 0.36–0.65) for inter-consensus reliability across pairs of
raters. With GRADE, 77.0% and 11.0% SRs were judged as having low or very low
and high QoE, respectively. With CHIMERAS, 10.0% and 54.0% SRs were judged as
having low or very low and high or very high QoE, respectively.
Conclusions: CHIMERAS outperformed GRADE in terms of inter-rater
reliability and inter-consensus reliability. CHIMERAS and GRADE also showed
substantial disagreement in grading QoE, indicating the possible impact on
decision-making attributable to varying rating approaches.
(4000) Successful Management of Eosinophilic Esophagitis Using Traditional
Chinese Medicine: A Case Report
Xiu-Min Li, MD1, Song Park, BS1 and Gary Soffer,
MD1
1New York, New York
Abstract
Purpose:
• Eosinophilic Esophagitis (EoE) is a relatively recently described condition,
with rapidly increasing prevalence over the past several years.
• EoE is a chronic food protein induced allergic disease that involves both IgE
and non-IgE mediated processes.
• It typically presents with symptoms of esophageal dysmotility such as
gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)-like symptoms, emesis, abdominal pain,
dysphagia, and most severely, food impaction.
• It is characterized histologically as greater than 14 eosinophils on an
esophageal biopsy and diagnosis is made based on both symptomatology and
pathology.
• Current treatment involves food elimination and off label use of topical
steroids. There is currently no alternative treatment for EoE.
• Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is a medical system utilizing herbs,
acupuncture and acupressure.
• Laboratory research provides strong evidence that some of the herbal formulas
and compounds utilized in TCM reduce Th2 cytokines, IgE production and eotaxin;
all have which have been implicated in EoE pathophysiology.
• We describe a patient with EoE refractory to conventional treatment who was
successfully treated with TCM. An 11-year-old boy with a history of EoE and
subsequent failure to thrive presented to clinic after only moderate improvement
with conventional therapy (elimination diet and swallowed corticosteroids).
• He was diagnosed with EoE at age 10 following a long standing history of
emesis, and GERD-like symptoms. Esophageal biopsy was significant for >50
eosinophils/hpfHis history was also significant for reflux, (diagnosed at 6
months), multiple food allergy (initially diagnosed at 9 months), eczema and
allergic rhinitis.
• He was initiated on Digestion tea and Mei Huang tea III, as well as Huo Xiang
Zheng Qi Wan for weekends/reactions. He was also treated with TCM topicals, Bath
Additives and Cream III. Medications were adjusted throughout his course
Results:
• Following initiation of TCM patient remained event free for 6 months, which was
the longest duration in his lifetime.
• When rare events did occur they were reduced in intensity and duration. Prior
to treatment symptoms would last 48 to 72 h, now they only lasted 2 to 3 h.
• Previously eliminated foods were successfully reintroduced over 3 years
including, but not limited to, baked milk products (pizza), baked egg, tree nuts
and legumes.
• Other benefits during the TCM treatment period were resolution of eczema and a
weight gain of 35 lbs.
• Four years following initiation of treatment repeat endoscopy showed 0 to 7
eosinophils/hpf.
Conclusions:
• Eosinophilic esophagitis is one of the most rapidly emerging allergic and
gastrointestinal diseases.
• Treatment options are very limited and can come with significant adverse
reactions.
• Further research is needed, but TCM may provide a safe and effective modality
for the treatment of EoE.
(4001) Acupuncture and Related Interventions for Treating Carpal Tunnel Syndrome:
A Systematic Review
Robin ST Ho, MPH1, Vincent CH Chung, PhD1, William KW Cheung,
BSc1, Victor CK Lam, BSc1, Regina WS Sit, MBBS1
and Irene XY Wu, PhD1
1The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Abstract
Purpose: Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is one of the most common
upper extremity disorders. Acupuncture is a commonly used conservative treatment
for CTS. However, its effectiveness for CTS is uncertain and existing systematic
review (SR) is out of date. This SR was performed to provide up-to-date clinical
evidence on acupuncture and related interventions for treating CTS.
Results: Ten RCTs (728 participants) were included. When compared to
conventional medications, manual acupuncture showed significant superior effect
in improving CTS symptom than ibuprofen (mean difference [MD] = −5.80, 95%
confidence interval [CI]: −7.95 to −3.65) and prednisolone (MD = −6.50, 95% CI:
−10.14, −2.86). Electro-acupuncture plus splinting was more effective in
reducing symptom severity than splinting alone (MD = −0.20, 95% CI: −0.36 to
−0.03). Significant superior effects were shown in manual acupuncture versus
ibuprofen (MD = −1.84, 95% CI: −2.66 to −1.02), and electro-acupuncture plus
splinting versus splinting alone (MD = −6.22, 95% CI: −10.73 to −1.71) for
improving CTS patients’ functional status. Electro-acupuncture (MD = −0.70, 95%
CI: −1.34 to −0.06) and manual acupuncture with specified magnetic spectrum heat
lamp (MD = −1.70, 95% CI: −3.43 to 0.03) showed add-on effect in reducing pain
when compared to splinting alone.
Conclusions: Electro-acupuncture could be considered as an add-on to
splinting for CTS patients. Manual acupuncture, electro-acupuncture, TENS and
moxibustion also be considered as an alternative to splinting for CTS patients.
Future trials should use guidelines recommended interventions as control,
determine the optimal follow-up duration and report the trial according to the
STRICT guideline.
(4002) Evaluation on Impacts of Evidence-based Health-care Education for Chinese
Medicine Practitioners
William KW Cheung, BSc1, Irene XY Wu, PhD1, Vincent CH Chung,
PhD1, Robin ST Ho, MPH1, Justin CY Wu, MD1 and
Charlene HL Wong, BSc1
1The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Abstract
Purpose: The Hong Kong government has been adopting an approach to
facilitate the development of Chinese medicine based on the principles of
evidence-based healthcare (EBHC). In order to increase Chinese medicine
practitioners (CMPs)’ access to EBHC knowledge and information, an intensive
EBHC curriculum was tailored-made for them. A 3-day EBHC education workshop was
presented in mixed interactive and didactic formats. The aim of this study was
to evaluate the effectiveness of EBHC education among CMPs.
Results: Among the CMPs who completed the 3-day EBHC education
workshop (n = 59), there were significant improvements in attitude, perceived
behavioural control, decision-making, and intention and behaviour domains based
on evidence-based practice inventory questionnaire. Significant increase in
scores were also observed in attitude and knowledge domains of evidence-based
practice in evidence-based practice questionnaire.
Conclusions: Findings of this study suggested the importance of
tailored-made EBHC education in enhancing knowledge and attitudes towards
evidence-based practice among CMPs in Hong Kong. To improve their perceived
social influence and application of evidence-based practice, previous literature
proposed that patient-oriented interventions and monitoring of CMPs might be
further explored. This would help promote the advancement of local integrative
Chinese-western medicine practice in an evidence-based manner in the future.
(4005) A Double-blind, Randomized, 2-dose Trial of Chinese Medicine,
Tumor-Shrinking Decoction, in Patients With Symptomatic Uterine Fibroids
Lixing Lao, MD1, Wai L Lin, PhD1, Yan B Zhang, PhD1,
Zhang J Zhang, PhD1 and Wei Meng1
1The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong
Abstract
Purpose: Uterine fibroids (UFs) are the most common benign tumors in
females in the middle and later reproductive ages. On the basis of empirical
evidence and clinical practice, a formula called Tumor-shrinking Decoction (TSD)
was developed for the treatment of UFs. The present study was designed to assess
the clinical efficacy of TSD in the therapy for UFs through an extensively
controlled trial.
Results: Of the 78 randomized subjects, 73 patients completed the
study. The end point outcomes showed significant improvement in both groups in
UF symptom severity, pelvic pain, TCM syndrome, fibroid size and uterus
condition under MRI; but no significant between-group differences were found in
all measured clinical outcomes at any time point, except for TCM syndrome. The
changes (mean ± SD) in UF symptom severity measured by UFS-QOL in low-dose group
and high-dose group after 20 weeks were 14.30 ± 4.28 and 13.72 ± 4.26
respectively (P > .05). Low-dose TSD rather than high-dose
TSD significantly improved patient’s quality of life (TSD-L baseline vs end
point: 46.07 ± 17.08, 52.37 ± 16.95, P < .05). No serious
adverse events were reported in this study. On the safety front, all the tested
samples fulfilled the Hong Kong Chinese Materia Medical Standards.
Conclusions: The herb formula TSD was safe and stable in treating
UF. Both low-dose and high-dose TSD significantly ameliorated UF-related
symptoms and fibroid size, but not the quality of life. The dose–response
relationship seems to be absent in TSD for treating UF. Further studies with
larger sample size are warranted.
(4008) Comparative Effectiveness of Individual Versus Group Acupuncture Therapy
for Chronic Pain and Function in an Underserved Population
Belinda J Anderson, PhD1, Arya Nielsen, PhD2, M Diane McKee,
MD, MS2, Elizabeth Chuang, MD, MPH2, Florangel De León,
BA2, Mimi Kim, ScD2, Qi Gao, PhD2, Eric N Gil,
BA2, Claudia Lechuga, MS2 and Benjamin Kligler, MD,
MPH2
1Pacific College of Oriental Medicine, New York, New York
2Bronx, New York
Abstract
Purpose: Chronic pain is prevalent in the United States; minority
populations experience greater prevalence of chronic pain and worse outcomes.
While acupuncture therapy has been shown to be effective for chronic pain,
minority, ethnically diverse and lower socioeconomic populations are limited in
access. Group acupuncture is proposed as a lower cost option to facilitate
access in safety net settings but research that establishes effectiveness
compared to individual session acupuncture therapy is lacking. Our trial aimed
to assess non-inferiority of group acupuncture therapy to individual acupuncture
therapy for chronic pain, function and depression in a safety net setting.
Results: Study participants were mostly Medicaid insured (75%). More
than half (60%) reported poor or fair health; 51% were on SSI, and 37% were
unable to work due to disability. Of the 706 participants, 360 were randomized
to individual treatment and 346 to group. Retention rates were 87% at 6 weeks,
85% at 12 weeks and 84% at 24 weeks. Randomization to group setting did not
affect initiation or retention in treatment.
The mean number of treatments was 8.1 with no difference between arms. In the
intent-to-treat analysis, 34.8% of individual and 30.5% of group participants
achieved the primary end point of 30% or more reduction on pain, corresponding
to between group difference of d = 4.3% (95% CI: −3.3%, 11.9%). While clinical
improvement was shown in both arms, non-inferiority of group acupuncture could
not be demonstrated since the upper boundary of the 95% CI exceeded the
non-inferiority margin of 10%. For BPI pain interference, 30% or greater
improvement was reported by 37.5% of participants in individual and 30.3% in
group care, corresponding to a difference of d = 7.2% (95% CI: −0,6%,
15.1%).
In per-protocol analysis, limited to those participants who received an adequate
course of treatment (8 or more treatments), 39.2% of individual versus 36.3% of
group participants reported 30% or better improvement in pain severity
(d = 2.8%; 95% CI: −6.5%, 12.2%) and 39.7% of individual and 34.4% of group
participants reported 30% or greater improvement in pain interference (d = 5.3%;
95% CI: −4.2%, 14.9%). Few minor adverse events and no serious adverse events
were reported. Secondary outcome data and 24-week data are pending.
Conclusions: While non-inferiority of group to individual
acupuncture therapy was not shown at 12 weeks, levels of clinical improvement
were still impressive, with more than 30% of participants achieving the primary
end point. Randomization to a group setting did not impact initiation or
retention in treatment. Group acupuncture is feasible and may be considered an
option for patients with chronic pain in a safety net setting.
(4009) Yoga, Physical Therapy, and Education for Sleep Quality in Adults With
Chronic Low Back Pain: A Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Controlled Trial
Robert B Saper, MD, MPH1, Eric Roseen, DC1, Alexandra Femia,
MS1, Jae Cho, BA1, Suzanne Bertisch, MD, MPH1
and Susan Redline, MD, MPH1
1Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Poor sleep quality is common among adults with chronic low
back pain (cLBP). While yoga and physical therapy (PT) are effective cLBP
treatments, their impact on sleep quality in adults with cLBP is unknown.
Results: Participants (mean age = 46.0 [SD = 10.7]; mean PSQI
score = 10.2 [SD = 3.9]) were mostly female (64%), black (57%), and had poor
sleep quality (93%). Sleep quality improved at 12 and 52 weeks among yoga (PSQI
mean difference [MD] = −1.2 [95% CI: −1.9, −0.6] and −2.4 [95% CI: −3.2, −1.5],
respectively), PT (MD = −1.1 [95% CI: −1.8, −0.3] and MD = −1.7 [95% CI: −2.7,
−0.7], respectively), and education (MD = −0.5, [95% CI: −1.4, 0.5] and
MD = −1.0 [95%CI: −2.1, 0.1], respectively) participants. Small non-significant
(P > .05) between-group differences favored Yoga and PT
to education at 12 (MD = −0.7 and −0.5, respectively) and 52 (MD = −1.1 and
−0.5, respectively) weeks. More yoga (35%) and PT (35%) than education (25%)
participants were responders (P = .37).
Conclusions: In a sample of adults with cLBP, the vast majority had
poor sleep quality at baseline. Small within-group improvements in Yoga and PT
groups were similar in magnitude; the education improvement was less in
magnitude.
(4014) Psychosocial Interventions as Adjuncts to Orthopedic Surgery: A Systematic
Review and Meta-analysis
Csenge Szeverenyi, MD1, Zoltan Kekecs, PhD2, Gary Elkins,
PhD3, Zoltan Csernatony, MD, PhD, DSc1, Katalin Varga,
PhD, DSc4 and Alisa Johnson, MA3
1University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary
2Lund University, Lund, Sweden
3Baylor University, Waco, Texas
4Eotvos Lorand University, Budapest, Hungary
Abstract
Purpose: The present study aims to assess the effectiveness of
psychosocial techniques to decrease postoperative pain and improve perioperative
clinical care in orthopedic surgery. A systematic review and meta-analysis was
performed to evaluate the effects of psychosocial methods (eg, patient
education, relaxation techniques, therapeutic suggestions, cognitive or
behavioral interventions, and combinations of these) on pain, anxiety and
functional recovery in short and long-term follow-up among adults undergoing
orthopedic surgeries.
The study was designed to specifically answer the following questions: Can the
applied psychosocial techniques reduce (1) postoperative pain, (2) analgesic
use, (3) preoperative anxiety, (4) postoperative anxiety, and enhance (5)
quality of life and (6) recovery in adults undergoing orthopedic surgery; and
(7) what are the moderating factors of effectiveness? This information is needed
to aid healthcare providers and insurance companies in identifying best
practices in surgical procedures.
Results: The meta-analysis of 62 RCTs demonstrated that psychosocial
interventions significantly reduced postoperative pain (0.31 [0.14, 0.48]), and
pre- and postoperative anxiety (g = 0.26 [95% CI = 0.11, 0.42] and 0.4 [0.21,
0.59], respectively). Furthermore, psychosocial interventions improved recovery
(0.38 [0.22, 0.54]). However, no significant effects were found for
postoperative analgesic use (0.16 [−0.01, 0.32]) and quality of life (0.14
[−0.05, 0.33]).
Electiveness of surgery was a statistically significant moderator of
effectiveness (eg, pain, analgesic use, anxiety). Type of surgery (major vs
minor) and timing of interventions did not moderate effects.
Conclusions: Compared with a previous orthopedic surgery
meta-analysis,98 this meta-analysis expands the current knowledge
base by including preoperative measures, long-term recovery outcomes, and
several types of psychological interventions. Patient education and relaxation
techniques produced the most consistent positive effects, showing benefits on
pain, anxiety, and recovery. Cognitive or behavioral techniques improved
recovery. Furthermore, larger effects were found for studies that included acute
surgeries compared to elective surgeries.
The current analysis revealed encouraging findings regarding the effects of
psychosocial interventions on postoperative pain and related outcomes such as
anxiety and recovery, warranting future clinical investigations to improve
researcher’s confidence in the size of the effects. More well powered
high-quality studies are needed. The effects of psychosocial interventions are
most consistent on decreasing preoperative anxiety. Evidence supports the use of
patient education to decrease postoperative pain, pre- and postoperative
anxiety, relaxation techniques to ameliorate postsurgical pain and anxiety, and
improve recovery, and cognitive or behavioral interventions to improve
recovery.
In this meta-analysis of RCTs in orthopedic surgeries, significant benefits in
postoperative pain, perioperative anxiety and recovery were found, suggesting
that psychosocial interventions, especially patient education and relaxation
techniques, are useful in improving the clinical care.
(4015) Effect of a 5-Day Ketogenic Diet on Chemotherapy Side Effects: A Case
Series Report
Carla Kuon, MD1, Carla Kuon, MD1 and Anand Dhruva,
MD1
1San Francisco, California
Abstract
Purpose: Fasting may be effective in reducing side effects of
chemotherapy. Tumor cells typically demonstrate a high glycolytic rate, termed
the “Warburg effect.” As a result, glucose and glutamine become prime fuels for
the dysregulated growth of tumors. Fasting, as well as fast-mimicking diets such
as the ketogenic diet, have anti-tumor and anti-inflammatory properties,
purportedly by turning off the glycolytic pathway and switching energy
production to fatty acid metabolism and ketones. In addition, high-fat diets in
murine mouse models have been shown to reduce leukocyte recruitment and
activation by lowering inflammatory cytokines.
Results:
Case 1: 53-year-old male with BRAF mutant, colon cancer with
metastasis to liver, was receiving vemurafenib, cetuximab, and irinotecan every
4 weeks. He experienced side effects of diarrhea, skin rash, fatigue, and a
10-pound weight loss. He was hospitalized for dehydration after his first
infusion and required 3 days of anti-diarrheal medication after each infusion,
consistent with CTCAE category 3 side effects. After placement on a 5-day
ketogenic diet, he suffered minimal diarrhea, trace fatigue, and enjoyed
increased appetite. CTCAE level was reduced from category 3 to category 1.
Case 2: 68-year-old female with stage 2C clear cell ovarian
cancer, receiving paclitaxel every 28 days. She voluntarily started a ketogenic
diet to reduce side effects of therapy and to achieve weight loss. Prior to
starting this diet, she suffered severe fatigue, anorexia, nausea, neuropathy,
insomnia, and joint pain after chemotherapy. After starting the ketogenic diet,
she experienced minimal side effects, lowering her CTCAE category from 2 to
1.
Conclusions: Both patients achieved a reduction of
chemotherapy-related side effects based on CTCAE criteria upon switching to a
ketogenic diet, timed around chemotherapy. Both diets were well-tolerated. We
propose that a 5-day ketogenic diet may be a viable way to reduce side effects
of chemotherapy. Further studies are warranted.
(4016) Effects of a Modified Ramadan Fasting on Physical and Mental Health in
Healthy Adult Muslims – A Randomized Controlled Trial
Gustav Dobos, MD, PhD1, Holger Cramer, PhD1, Romy Lauche,
PhD2, Petra Klose, PhD1, Chalil Saddat, MD1,
Iman Fathi, MD1, Thomas Rampp, MD, PhD1, Jallal Al-Abtah,
BNurs3 and Arndt Büssing, MD, PhD4
1University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
2University of Technology Sydney, Sydney, Australia
3Kliniken Essen-Mitte, Essen, Germany
4University of Witten/Herdecke, Herdecke, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Fasting during the month of Ramadan is considered one of
the 5 pillars of the Islamic religion, and Muslims must abstain from eating and
drinking between dusk and dawn. Research has found that fasting during Ramadan
affects the health of Muslims, but study results were often contradictory about
the direction of those effects. Therefore, this study aimed to determine whether
a modified fasting regimen is beneficial for physical and mental health among
adult Muslims undergoing Ramadan fasting.
Results: A total of 112 participants (63 females and 49 males;
27.8 ± 9.4yrs) were randomised, and no drop-outs occurred. After Ramadan, the
experimental group reported significant higher well-being (WHO-5, MD: 5.93; 95%
CI: 0.02 to 11.84), with 57.8% and 42.2% of participants in experimental and
control groups being responders, respectively. Analyses revealed further group
differences regarding satisfaction with life, and mindfulness, weight, body mass
index, hip circumference, and blood pressure directly after the intervention;
however no group differences were found for serum markers. About 60% of
participants reported adverse events, including headaches, dizziness, and
gastrointestinal symptoms. Creatinine was elevated in 2 participants. Two
serious adverse events occurred, but they were not intervention-related.
Conclusions: A modified Ramadan fasting regimen appears to improve
mental and physical health of Muslims; though observed effects were rather small
and short-term only. Since the major limitation of this trial is the
overrepresentation of young and healthy Muslims, further research is warranted
to examine the effects of similar interventions in a sample of adults with
diagnosed CVD risk factors.
(4017) A Case Report of a Cerebral Infarction Patient With Shoulder Pain Using
Korean Medical Treatment
Hee J Seo1, Jung N Kwon1 and So H Shim1
1Korean Medicine Hospital of Pusan National University, Yangsan, Republic
of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Shoulder joint pain in stroke patients with hemiplegia is
one of the most common complications within 2 weeks after stroke and is a
complaint in about 70% of patients. In addition, shoulder joint pain causes not
only pain in stroke patients but also disabilities in rehabilitation treatment,
resulting in social and economic loss, and also negative effects on the quality
of life of patients and caregivers. The purpose of this clinical study is to
evaluate the effect of Korean Medical Treatment on a 79-year-old Korean female
with shoulder pain after stroke.
Results: After 24 days, total score of NRS was decreased from 7 to
2.1. Average sleep time was increased and waking up due to shoulder pain was
decreased during the night.
Conclusions: This study suggests that Korean medical treatment,
especially Moxibustion could be effective to reduce shoulder pain in stroke
patients with hemiplegia and alleviate sleep disturbance. Further studies are
needed.
(4018) High-velocity, Low-amplitude Spinal Manipulation Training of Prescribed
Forces and Thrust Duration: A Pilot Study
Zacariah K Shannon, DC, MS1, Maruti R Gudavalli, PhD2, Ron J
Boesch, DC1 and Robert D Vining, DC1
1Palmer College of Chiropractic, Davenport, Iowa
2Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, Illinois
Abstract
Purpose: High-velocity, low-amplitude spinal manipulation (HVLA-SM)
is a manual therapy that induces different physiological effects depending on
peak force and thrust duration. Inter-clinician variability in thrust force
delivery suggests training clinicians to target specific force levels may be
necessary to standardize treatments, which has implications for research and
practice. This pilot study developed and assessed an HVLA-SM training
program.
Results: No difference in peak force mean absolute error (AE) from
target was noted between the 8 student and 8 doctor of chiropractic
participants. Adjusted mean AE (SD), (adjusted 95% CI) were: baseline, 107N
(127), (40 to 175) at 350N and 63N (148), (−16 to 142) at 550N, immediately
post-training, 0.2N (41), (−22 to 22) at 350N and −6N (58), (−37 to 25) at 550N,
and 8 weeks post-training, 32N (53), (4 to 60) at 350N and 9N (87), (−38 to 55)
at 550N. Median thrust duration was 117 ms at baseline and 134 ms immediately
post-training.
Conclusions: This HVLA-SM training resulted in improved ability to
deliver prescribed forces, however accuracy lessened after 1 week. Further study
to understand how to maintain skill over the long-term is warranted.
(4020) Mindfulness Training Disrupts Classical Conditioning
Eric Garland, PhD1 and Adam W Hanley, PhD1
1Center on Mindfulness and Integrative Health Intervention Development,
Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Purpose: Mindfulness meditation is purported to de-automatize
conditioned behavior. Conditioned behavior is implicated in a host of clinical
concerns, including depression, addiction, and suicidality. However, the effects
of mindfulness on classically conditioned behavior has not been assessed in a
controlled experiment. This study is the first to demonstrate that mindfulness
meditation training can attenuate classically conditioned behavior.
Results: Repeated-measures analysis of variance revealed a
significant Condition × Time interaction for state mindfulness
(F5,35 = 3.52, P = .011,
η
2 = .34), indicating that mindfulness training
increased state mindfulness (Figure 1). A one-way analysis of covariance
(ANCOVA) revealed a significant mean difference in first conditioned response
(F1,46 = 6.12, P = .017,
η
2 = .12), indicating that mindfulness training
delayed the onset of conditioned responding (Figure 2). A repeated measures
ANCOVA revealed a significant main effect of condition on conditioned response
frequency, (F1,46 = 16.95, P < .001,
η
2 = .27), indicating that mindfulness training
attenuated conditioned responding (Figure 3). Finally, path analysis revealed
experimental condition had a significant indirect effect on conditioned response
frequency via change in state mindfulness (Figure 4).
Conclusions: Findings from this study indicate that mindfulness
training inhibits the acquisition of conditioned behaviors and the frequency
with which conditioned behaviors are expressed. Thus mindfulness training may
serve to inoculate against the development of maladaptive habits, allowing
individuals to behave non-reactively and with greater intentionality when
responding to present moment circumstances.
(4021) An Exploratory Study of Core Values and Depression in Adults With Type 2
Diabetes
Suzanne Danhauer1, Shannon L Mihalko, PhD1, Beverly Levine,
PhD2, Jaimie C Hunter, PhD2, Julienne Kirk,
PharmD2, Heather L Black, PhD3, Sally A Shumaker,
PhD2 and Deanna Befus, PhD2
1Wake Forest University, Winston Salem, North Carolina
2Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston Salem, North Carolina
3Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp., North Wales, Pennsylvania
Abstract
Purpose: Patients managing Type 2 Diabetes face many adherence
challenges. Depressive symptoms are common among adults with diabetes and can
substantially impact glycemic control and self-management. Values associated
with maintaining good health may conflict with other core values (needs), making
optimal adherence difficult. The primary aims of this analysis were to identify
values relevant to managing diabetes and examine the impact of depression on
these values.
Results: Of the original 108 in our sample, 106 had complete data on
the PHQ-8. Of these, 58% were female; mean age was 56.7 (SD = 10.4, range 29–79)
years. By design, there were nearly equal numbers of White (50.9%, n = 54) and
African American (49.1%, n = 52) participants. Mean PHQ-8 score was 5.5
(SD = 5.1, range 0–22), and 18% (n = 19) reported a significant level of
depressive symptoms (PHQ-8 ≥ 10). Across participants, the “top 10” values
reported were: love/belonging (14.6%, n = 85), self-care (13.8%, n = 80),
control (10.3%, n = 60), life/survival (10.1%, n = 59), accomplishment (9.1%,
n = 53), self-esteem (7.4%, n = 43), independence (6%, n = 35), peace (4.5%,
n = 26), security (3.8%, n = 22), and faith/spirituality (2.8%, n = 16). There
were no differences in the rank order of core values by depression status
(P = .5).
Conclusions: We assessed and ranked the core values of people with
diabetes and examined these values across depression status. We found no
evidence of an association between depression status and ranking of values.
Future research should consider whether other aspects of living with diabetes
vary according to depression status.
(4026) Manual Therapy Based on the Myofascial Meridians Theory for Scapulohumeral
Periarthritis: A Clinical Observation
Kang Liu, MD, MS1, Chun Li, MD, MS2 and Zhonglong Li, MD,
MS3
1Beijing Hospital, National Center of Gerontology, Beijing, China
2China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China
3UCLA, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Scapulohumeral periarthritis is chronic injury inflammation
of the muscle, tendons, bursa and joint capsule. Its morbidity accounts for 8%
of orthopedic diseases. Myofascial meridians theory has been widely used in
sports, rehabilitation, medicine and other fields. The purpose of our article is
to observe the efficacy of using new manual therapy based on the myofascial
meridians theory on scapulohumeral periarthritis.
Results: Pain relief and improvement of shoulder function
therapeutic effects had been achieved in the treatment of scapulohumeral
periarthritis in 2 groups (P < .05), and there is no obvious
difference (P > .05) between the treatment group and control
group.
Conclusions: Manual therapy based on the myofascial meridians theory
has obvious therapeutic effect on scapulohumeral periarthritis, it provides a
method of feasible, economical and easy to operate for the treatment of
scapulohumeral periarthritis.
(4028) BASIC-health: A 16-h Course, Produces Measurable Salutogenesis in Pain
Patients, by Linking Exteroception With Interoception Through Physical
Movement
Daniela H Jurisic, MD1 and Judith B Kosasih, MD2
1Active Integrative Medicine Associates, Pavia, Italy
2Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Abstract
Purpose: To explain the development, testing and clinical results in
75 patients, of BASIC-health (Body as a Source of Identification and Coherence
for Health): a medically guided somatic practice invented for salutogenesis
activation.
Results:
Clinical trial: 75 patients (5 min); 80 patients enrolled
within 2 years, ages 45–78, 58 women and 22 men. Diagnoses:
chronic fatigue syndrome, post-laminectomy pain, post-chemotherapy pain and
asthenia, and post-acute disabling pain. All patients: examined
by the same physician who invented and taught the course; 42 improved by 4
points; 27 improved >12 points; 6 improved 0–1 point; 0 worsened.
Enjoyment level: reported as uniformly positive;
6-month follow-up: 58 of 75 participants were continuing
with some form of specific salutogenic movement. No patients reported increased
pain or disability.
Conclusions: “BASIC” can be a clinically useful tool toward
activating salutogenesis by directly teaching and practicing increased somatic
perception. It is integrative medicine both in its scientific basis and its
emphasis on the therapeutically relating to the whole person. It is direct,
time-effective and has proven to be efficacious in 75 patients, with maintained
efficacy on 6-month follow-up.
(4030) How to Explore the Effectiveness of Traditional Chinese Herbal Medicine in
a Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial? Experiences From Treating Diabetic Kidney
Disease
Xinmiao Wang, MM1, Bing Pang, MD1, Linhua Zhao, MD1,
Zhao Xuemin, MM1 and Ying Zhang, PhD2
1Guang’anmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medicine Sciences,
Beijing, China
2Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: In clinical practice, double-dummy and actively controlled
design is necessary for examining the effectiveness and safety of Shenzhuo
Formula (SZF) in the treatment of DKD patients with macroalbuminuria. However,
we will still face many challenges to choose candidate western medicine (WM) as
a control group and administrate corresponding simulation agents in routine
treatments. The drug preparation of either simulation SZF or WM agents in both
groups is quite difficult, which may lead to the deficiency of the
implementation of blinding. To maintain patients’ compliance and relative
ethical issues also need to be considered carefully. In our ongoing trial, we
have made several efforts to make it practicable and ethical.
Results: Currently, more than 50 patients have been recruited, and
the overall dropout rate is less than 20% by monitoring. Adverse events (AEs),
such as signs and symptoms and other ailments, are documented at every visit.
Most of the adverse reactions are mild until now, including urticaria, edema,
diarrhea, and so forth.
Conclusions: In order to provide initial evidence regarding the
effectiveness and safety of SZF in the treatment of DKD, in addition to the real
treatment effect, good clinical management strategies also play an important
role in the double-dummy PRCT.
(4031) Stand-Alone Ayurvedic Treatment in Acute Ischaemic Stroke: A Pilot
Study
Archana Purushotham, MD, PhD1, Aarthi J Harini, BAMS2, Avineet
Luthra, BPT, MSc2, Shrey Madeka, MSc2, Prasan Shankar, BAMS,
MD(Ayu.)3, Pitchaiah Mandava, MD, PhD4, Ravishankar
Pervaje, BAMS, MD(Ayu.)5 and Sanjith Aaron, MD, DM6
1Stony Brook School of Medicine, The State University of New York, Stony
Brook, New York
2Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine, Bangalore,
Karnataka, India
3Institute for Ayurvedic and Integrative Medicine, Bangalore, Karnataka,
India
4Houston, Texas
5Sushruta Ayurveda Hospital, Puttur, Andhra Pradesh, India
6Christian Medical College and Hospital, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
Abstract
Purpose: The Allopathic arsenal for treating ischaemic stroke is
rather limited, and the only treatments shown to improve outcomes – thrombolysis
and angio-intervention – are not accessible to the majority of stroke patients
across the globe. Stroke patients in the Indian sub-continent commonly use
Ayurvedic therapies, but there is no evidence regarding the efficacy or safety
of these therapies, the latter being of particular concern in acute ischaemic
stroke (AIS). Ayurvedic therapy could prove especially valuable if found
efficacious, as it can be used well beyond the ‘golden hour’ for thrombolysis
and thrombectomy. We carried out a pilot observational study of the safety
profile of stand-alone Ayurvedic treatment in AIS.
Results: We enrolled 13 patients into the Ayurvedic and 20 patients
into the Allopathic arm. One patient in the Ayurvedic arm was lost to follow-up
but mortality data could be obtained. Significant baseline imbalances in
pre-stroke disability, initial National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale
(NIHSS) and time from stroke onset to initiation of treatment were improved
after the matching process which yielded 11 matched pairs of subjects. Pooled
analysis of outcomes did not show statistically significant differences in
mortality (15.38% vs 15%, P = 1.00), non-fatal adverse event
rates (15.38% vs. 30%, P = .4) or improvement in NIHSS: 3 (IQR
2-6) versus 4 (IQR 0–6), P = 1.00. The paired analysis of the
11 matched pairs continued to suggest that the safety profiles of classical
Ayurveda and conservative Allopathy in AIS are similar.
Conclusions: Stand-alone classical Ayurvedic treatment of AIS is
safe. This is the first ever report of stand-alone Ayurvedic therapy in AIS. Our
results support the conduct of a larger randomized controlled trial to study the
efficacy of Ayurvedic treatment of AIS.
(4032) Measuring What Matters in Primary Care
Rebecca Etz, PhD1 and Kurt C Stange, MD, PhD2
1Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia
2Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: Health-care systems based on primary care have healthier
populations, greater equity, and lower cost. However, current quality measures
do not reflect most of the integrative mechanisms hypothesized to provide this
value. Incorrectly focused measurement and incentives risk burning out the
workforce and diminishing the value of primary care for people and populations.
This article conveys findings from efforts to understand what matters in primary
care and how it can be measured.
Results: The apparent simplicity of primary care masks the
complexity of integrating, personalizing, and prioritizing care for people and
communities. This interrelated complexity does not fit well into usual
reductionist classification systems that assume that the whole is merely the sum
of its parts. We identified two complementary ways of understanding and
assessing primary care: First, building on principles from complexity science,
we uncovered three simple rules that, when actualized together by patients and
practices and supported by systems, describe the processes from which the
outcomes of primary care emerge as follows: recognize and prioritize
problems/opportunities (for person and population at all stages of life); make
sense of the problem/opportunity through a life course perspective and being
known (as an individual and as a member of family and community); generate some
kind of relief, comfort, connection, or health. The enactment of these
apparently simple rules, over time, in ongoing primary care relationships, leads
to the emergence of better health and equity at sustainable cost. Second, a
parsimonious set of individual items, used as a set, rather than assessed
individually, can focus attention and support on the mechanisms by which primary
care provides value are as follows: accessibility—includes the first contact
with the health-care system; comprehensiveness—focusing on the whole person;
integration—bringing together the biological and the biographical across acute
and chronic illness, prevention, mental health, and family;
coordination—managing care across different clinicians and settings;
relationship—being known, continuity of care, longitudinality (being together
over time), sustained partnership, being present for key events, and trust;
advocacy (looking out for the person in fragmented health-care or social
systems); family context, knowledge, and engagement that informs and supports
care; community context, knowledge, and engagement, including social and
environmental determinants; goal-oriented care; disease and illness management;
patient enablement. As a starting point for future work, we provide a table that
outlines these measures and suggests related contextual and outcome measures in
current use, and appendices that depict specific patient report measurement
items.
Conclusions: These two ways of knowing and assessing primary
care—simple rules from which complexity emerges, and a parsimonious set of items
representing key mechanisms—can be used as a starting point to reduce
measurement burden and to focus attention on improving the means by which
primary care provides value.
(4034) Exploring Integrative Modalities With Interprofessional Education
Lilian White, BS1, Lucas Harrison, BS1, Kim Gilliam,
EdD/PC1 and Patrick Jonas, MD1
1Boonshoft School of Medicine, Wright State University, Dayton, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this investigation is to
assess the attitudes of health professions students toward the value of selected
modalities in integrative medicine. A survey will be conducted for an
educational event including a keynote presentation by an integrative
practitioner and a period of workshops in integrative care modalities. Students
will choose two 1-h workshops to attend. A survey will be conducted following
the event. The findings of this survey will inform the founding of an
interprofessional interest group in integrative medicine at the Boonshoft School
of Medicine, Wright State University. The specific aims of this
study are to assess the attitudes of health professions students
toward massage, acupuncture, osteopathic manipulative therapy, nutrition,
meditation/mindfulness, and aromatherapy. Complementary care has become
increasingly utilized by U.S. patients. A study by Eisenberg et al. cited a rise
in the use of complementary therapies by patients in the United States from
33.3% in 1990 to 42.1% in 1997. A more recent study in 2007 demonstrated that 4
in 10 adults use complementary therapies; however, only one third of patients
surveyed reported talking about their use of complementary therapies with their
physician. The discrepancy between use and disclosure begs for more physician
education and comfort with complementary therapies to facilitate open
communication between patient and physician and to minimize the potential for
adverse effects. Currently 54 medical schools and 8 medical systems nationwide
have joined in the effort to advance education in integrative care through the
Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health. In the Dayton area,
there are multiple schools of health professions students that may benefit from
more education in complementary and integrative care. Students from schools
invited to participate in the event include University of Dayton (dietetics,
physical therapy, and physician’s assistant), Sinclair Community College
(dietetics and nursing), Clark State Community College (nursing), Cedarville
University School of Pharmacy, Kettering College of Medical Arts (nursing,
occupational therapy, and physician’s assistant), Ohio University—Grandview
location (D.O.), Dayton School of Medical Massage, and Wright State University
Schools of Medicine and Professional Psychology. We hypothesize
that students will be more willing to recommend attended workshop modalities.
Results from the survey will guide the agenda for the coming year of interest
group activities in integrative medicine and serve as a baseline for future
surveys.
Results: A total of 54 students from the invited institutions
attended. Students attending the event were primarily female, between the ages
of 18 and 27, Caucasian, and affiliated with the Wright State University
Boonshoft School of Medicine. The workshop with the highest attendance focused
on meditation and mindfulness. Of the workshops attended, nutrition was the
topic students were most likely to recommend. Using the CHBQ questionnaire, the
mode for statements with “7” or “absolutely agree" included: “The physician’s
role is primarily to promote the health and healing of the physical body; a
strong relationship between patient and physician is an extremely valuable
therapeutic intervention that leads to improved outcomes; mindfulness practices
are a useful tool for patients.” The mode for statements with “1” or “absolutely
disagree” included: “The spiritual beliefs and practices of physicians play no
important role in healing; the spiritual beliefs and practices of patients play
no important role in healing; meditation can benefit patient’s health
temporarily, but does not have long-term benefits.
Conclusions: Overall, each workshop attended showed an increase in
students’ willingness to recommend the integrative modality to future patients.
Attitudes toward the spiritual beliefs and practices of patients and physicians
alike were not viewed as integral to the healing process as addressing the
physical body and meditation/mindfulness practices. Recommendations by attendees
for next year include hosting the event on a Saturday and allowing participants
to attend more than 2 workshops. Following the event, a total of 33/54
participants expressed written interest in creating an interprofessional student
group to host workshops throughout the year on integrative modalities. The
student group—also named Project Wellness—is now an established organization at
the Boonshoft School of Medicine, Wright State University. A grant from the
leadership and education program for students program and additional funding
from the student affairs department at the Boonshoft School of Medicine
supported the project.
(4035) What IMPACT Contributes to Integrative Medicine
Matthew Carvey, BSc, EMT-P, FP-C1 and Robert Hage, MD, PhD1
1St. George’s University, St. George’s, Grenada
Abstract
Purpose: Integrative medicine’s intent is to restore and maintain
health and wellness during a person’s lifetime through aspects which influence
the body, mind, spirit, and community. Future integrative medicine practitioners
should embrace its principles and commit themselves to self-exploration and
self-development. Basic science medical students at St. George’s University,
Grenada who registered for the integrative medicine selective are offered
sessions on yoga, Reiki, acupuncture, hypnosis, naturopathic medicine, and many
other topics.
Results: Results will be tabulated based on the data gathered,
utilizing the methods discussed, in future integrative medicine courses at St.
George’s University.
Conclusions: IMPACT is a fun way for students to engage in this
selective and will have an influence on future health-care providers. Knowledge
of the different modalities adds to aptitude, and the components of IMPACT
directly govern the attitudes of health-care workers. Because IMPACT directly
influences the health-care workers attitude and aptitude in integrative
medicine, knowledge of the modalities gained through this presentation will
openly influence how the practitioner approaches patient care in the future.
(4036) Systematic Acupuncture for Cervical Pathology
Daun Jeong, BOM1
1Pureunsan Korean Medical Clinic, South Korea, Gwangju City, Republic of
Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Acupuncture is widely used for pain relief. Although
acupuncture has a long history, clinical practice manual for diagnosis, physical
exam, and treatment has not been established yet. To project evidence-based
manual, neurophysiological, anatomical, and biomechanical scheme was adopted.
Systematic acupuncture manual will be helpful for practitioners of primary
care.
Results:
http://prezi.com/bejlqofmfodj/?utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=copy
Conclusions: Acupuncture is an effective treatment option, as a
substitute for analgesics or an adjunct therapy. Well-established diagnosis and
treatment manual which is based on neurophysiology, anatomy, pathology, and
biomechanics can promote active interactions among other health-care providers.
Eventually, acupuncture can shed a light in integrative patient care.
(4037) A Research on the Development of the Abdomen diagnosis Devices Based on
Traditional Korean Medicine
Keun Ho Kim, PhD1 and Jun-Su Jang, PhD1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Abdomen diagnosis of traditional Korean medicine is based
on the synthetic analysis of the tension, the skin thickness, the structural
ratio, the color, and the relative temperature distribution of the abdomen for
understanding the pathology of internal organs and establishes criteria for
pattern identifications for correct treatment. The purpose of this study is to
develop diagnostic devices, which imitate the abdomen diagnosis and an algorithm
to classify functional dyspepsia (FD) by using the devices.
Results: In order to evaluate the measurement reliability of the
pain cognitive measuring device, the measurement repeatability of the pressure
and the depth according to the difference in the lower repulsive force of the
sponge structure over time was evaluated. The upper structure of the sponge
structure is a common sponge having a thickness of 1T. In the lower structure,
conditions 1, 2, and 3 are a sponge of 3T, a high elastic sponge of 3T, and 3T
thick plastic, respectively, where the forces of 5kgf were applied to 3
structures for 10 s in accordance with the pressure–time graph guide. It was
confirmed that the depth value changed when the same pressure guide was applied
according to the difference of the repulsive force of the substructure. The
temperatures of the four portions from IRT before and after the correction by
the tactile sensor were measured. In both subjects 1 and 2, the temperature
deviation after the correction was smaller than that before the correction. The
correlation coefficient was also found to be higher after calibration than
before calibration. For evaluating the repeatability of the 3-dimensional
geometric information measurement device, experiments were performed by using a
manikin with no change in geometric information. The scan data were acquired so
that the robustness of the device could be confirmed by slightly changing the
position and color of the manikin every time. As a result of the repeatability
evaluation of the geometric features and color information of CIE L* a* b*, the
standard deviations were 0.3–0.8 mm and 0.5–1.5, respectively.
Conclusions: We suggested the development of measurement devices for
abdomen diagnosis and presented their reliability. Since FD is also a chronic
disease, it needs to be developed as a system capable of collecting and managing
personal medical data of patients with chronic medical illnesses connected to
the Internet. If the diagnostic algorithm is developed through clinical
research, the marketability of traditional medical devices is expected to
increase greatly.
Funding: The research was supported by the Korea Evaluation
Institute of Industrial Technology (Project Number: 10060251).
(4039) Analysis of Facial Features Among Native Japanese and Native Korean
Populations According to Sasang Types
Lin Ang, Bachelor of Medicine (Chinese Medicine)1, Lee Jeongyun, MD, (
Korean Medicine), PhD1, Kim Jong Yeol, MD, and ( Korean Medicine),
PhD1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Facial diagnosis is a common practice and essential
diagnostic method used in the Sasang Constitution Medicine (SCM). SCM is a kind
of personalized medicine in Traditional Korean Medicine which categorizes people
into four types, namely, Tae-Yang type, Tae-Eum type (TE), So-Yang (SY) type,
and So-Eum (SE) type. This study is conducted to compare and analyze the
differences in facial feature across Sasang types among Native Japanese and
Native Koreans.
Results: Significant differences can be seen in the facial feature
variables related to lower face area and eye shape. TE type had wider lower face
area and narrower eyes as compared to other constitutions in both gender.
Besides that, SY type for male and SE type for female had rounder eyes. In
general, the average lower face area for Native Koreans was larger compared to
Native Japanese, whereas Native Japanese have rounder eyes than Native Koreans
in male and vice versa in female.
Conclusions: This study presented distinctive feature in lower face
area and eye shape among the Sasang types in both Native Japanese and Native
Koreans. This suggested that facial feature variables can be used as an
objective tool in the distinguishing the Sasang types in Native Japanese.
Further studies with a larger sample size will be needed to generalize these
results.
(4040) Use of Traditional Medicine for Maternal Well-being Among African Migrant
Women in Australia: Implications for Improving Culturally Responsive Integrated
Health Care
Tinashe Dune, PhD1, Zewdneh Shewamene1 and Caroline Smith,
PhD1
1Western Sydney University, Sydney, Australia
Abstract
Purpose: Existing evidence regarding the traditional health
practices and beliefs of African minorities in Western countries is limited. The
purpose of this study was to explore the use of traditional medicine for
maternal well-being among African migrant women in Australia.
Results: A total of 319 participants completed the survey. Overall,
232 (72.7%) women reported using some form of traditional medicine for maternal
well-being in Australia. The most frequently used therapies and services were
herbal medicine (163, 61.7%), prayer for health (146, 55.3%), vitamins (88,
33.3%), massage (87, 33%), faith healers’ services (81, 30.7%), and traditional
Chinese medicine (72, 27.3%). Common reasons for use of traditional medicine in
maternity were pregnancy-related symptoms, well-being during pregnancy,
postnatal health conditions, and maternal depression. Age ≥ 35 years (odds ratio
[OR], 16.5; 95%confidence interval [CI], 6.58–41.5;
P < .001), lower educational level (OR, 24; 95% CI,
8.18–71.1; P < .001), parity (OR, 7.3; 95% CI, 1.22–42.81;
P = .029), and lower income (OR, 2.7; 95% CI, 1.23–5.83;
P = .013) were associated with an increased use of
traditional medicine for maternal well-being.
Conclusions: Our survey indicates that traditional medicine is
retained as an important form of health care among African migrant women in
Australia. It is important that main stream health professionals be aware of the
widespread use of traditional therapies among African migrant women.
(4042) Acupuncture in the Treatment of Pain in Patients With Sickle Cell
Disease
Thais Salles Araujo, MD1, Stela Cezarino de Morais, MD2, Felipe
Caldas de Oliveira, MD2, Maria Stella Figueiredo, MD2 and
Marcia Lika Yamamura, MD, PhD2
1Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil
2Unifesp, Sao Paulo, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: Sickle cell disease (SCD) is the genetic hematologic
disease most prevalent in the world. Individuals with SCD can have acute pain
crises or chronic pain as aseptic necrosis. The medical literature about the use
of acupuncture in these patients is very scarce.
Results: 26 patients with SCD were assisted, with 28 complaints,
because a patient presented pain in three different places simultaneously. The
median intensity before acupuncture by ASP was 7 (2 to 10); 43% of the pains had
until 7 days long. All showed reduction in pain intensity, and 86% were
asymptomatic after the medical attendance.
Conclusions: Acupuncture was beneficial to all patients, by reducing
or eliminating pain. It is an analgesic tool more lasting than any conventional
medication. A study with a control group would be necessary to increase the
power of evidence of the effectiveness of acupuncture in patients.
(4043) What Do Academic Physicians and Trainees Know About Botanicals? A Pilot
Study to Explore Knowledge and Attitudes in a University Setting
Min Jung Kim, PhD1, Jordan Albano1 and Mary P Guerrera, MD,
FAAFP1
1Farmington, Connecticut
Abstract
Purpose: Over 80% of people living in developed countries use some
form of complementary medicine, including botanicals; however, studies have
demonstrated that a majority of physicians do not ask their patients about
supplement use, and if they do, are largely unaware of the botanical’s use or
potential risks or benefits. To bridge this gap, an educational module was
developed with the purpose of assessing and educating physicians and residents
about botanicals at our Academic Health Center. Five commonly used botanicals
were selected: garlic, gingko biloba, cranberry, St. John’s wort, and black
cohosh. Using this module, our study was conducted to determine the baseline
knowledge of botanical medicine among physicians and to assess the efficacy of
the module to improve upon participants’ understanding.
Results: Over 30 physicians completed the surveys. We had five
multiple choice questions with single best answers that assessed knowledge about
the five botanicals. The Binomial test was used to assess the difference between
pre- and postbotanical education exposure, and statistically significant
differences are observed across the five questions. Two questions regarding
attitudes about botanicals and knowledge of evidence-based resources were
analyzed using a Wilcox Rank Sum test which also demonstrated statistical
significance.
Conclusions: Our results show that a brief educational module was
successful in educating physicians about botanicals. Findings also emphasized
that although physicians tend to see botanicals as an important topic to
understand, they lack knowledge of this field. This module could potentially
serve as a catalyst for UConn’s evolving medical school curriculum.
(4044) Beyond Conventional Therapy in Child Neurology
Els Peeters, MD1, Rianne Boeters-van Kester, PA1 and Ines A von
Rosenstiel2
1Hagaziekenhuis/Juliana Children’s Hospital, The Hague, The
Netherlands
2Rijnstate Hospital, The Hague, The Netherlands
Abstract
Purpose: Investigations in America and Canada revealed that the use
of complementary therapies in children was approximately 1 in every 10 children.
In children who have chronic conditions, this percentage is even higher till
more than 50%. In paediatric neurology, there are a lot of children with chronic
diseases and more and more parents ventilate the wish of reducing frequency and
duration of taking medication. There are also more questions of how to prevent
specific conditions and reduce severity of the disease from a holistic
perspective.
Results: Thirty-five children in the age of 0 till 17 years were
seen. Main complaints were headaches, sleep disorders, epilepsy, chronic
fatigue, behavioural disorders, tics and autism. Every parent and child were
advised about healthy food and life style. Different interventions were
discussed resulting in a top 5 therapies: stress reducing therapies,
supplements, cognitive behavioural therapy, emotional freedom technique, and
hypnotherapy. Of those 35 children, 5 reported no benefit of the intervention
and 14 definitively improved.
Conclusions: Overall, we noticed that parents and children
appreciate the innovative integrative medicine approach in child neurology,
stressing the need to discuss different forms of CAM strategies in ameliorating
the well-being of the child. The clinical evidence is growing for many
complementary modalities and they warrant consideration for inclusion into
treatment plans.
(4047) Level of Stress in Medical Students
Renato Leca1, Alana D Araujo1, Adriana W Campos1,
Andreza R Andrade1, Carolina Guimaraes1, Julia F
Pellegrim1, Adelle B Abdulmassih1, Fernando A Fonseca,
PhD1 and Ana Paula M Watanabe1
1Faculdade de Medicina do ABC, Santo Andre, Brazil
Abstract
Purpose: The emotional burden and responsibilities resulting from
medical training make medical students more susceptible to presenting symptoms
related to chronic stress, psychiatric disorders, and even suicides. From this
situation, we evaluated the level of stress in medical students from the
Faculdade de Medicina do ABC, Brazil, from all grades, to measure the possible
impact of high hourly loads with intense study pace of medical graduation on the
mental health of these students.
Results: A total of 98 medical students from the Faculdade de
Medicina do ABC, Brazil, were evaluated, being 81% women and 19% men, aged
between 17 and 34 years, with a mean age of 21.92 years. Of these students, 90%
considered themselves having high or very high stress and 69% reported at least
one episode of stress in the month before the survey. Thirty-nine percent
considered themselves to be tired or very tired and 86% slept less than 8 h per
night on average, with 40% restful sleep. On the other hand, 75% considered
having a good memory and only 22.4% were sedentary. The salivary cortisol tests
corroborated the data of stress levels from the questionnaires.
Conclusions: The results of the salivary cortisol analysis and
questionnaires evidenced the high level of stress that medical students present
and adequate strategies should be developed to mitigate this problem.
(4048) Efficacy of Bee Venom Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain: A Randomized,
Double-Blinded, Sham-Controlled Trial
Byung-Kwan Seo, PhD1, Ojin Kwon, PhD2, Dae-Jean Jo, MD,
PhD3, Kyungsun Han, PhD2 and Jun-Hwan Lee, KMD,
PhD2
1Kyung Hee University Hospital at Gangdong, Seoul, Republic of Korea
2Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
3Kyung Hee University Hospital at Gangdong, Seoul, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Bee venom acupuncture (BVA) is an effective treatment for
chronic low back pain (CLBP) through the pharmacological effects of bee venom
and the simultaneous stimulation of acupoints. However, evidence of its efficacy
and safety in humans remains unclear.
Results: After 3 weeks of the treatment, significant improvements
were observed in the bothersomeness, pain intensity, and functional status in
the BVA group compared with the sham group. Although minimal adverse events were
observed in both groups, subsequent recovery was achieved without treatment.
Conclusions: Consequently, our results suggest that it can be used
along with conventional pharmacological therapies for the treatment of CLBP.
(4049) A Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Sijunzi Decoction on Chemotherapy-Induced
Nausea and Vomiting
Liqiong Wang, PhD1, Chunhui Wang, PhD1, Xiaohua Pei,
PhD2 and Xinyan Jin, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
2Third Affiliated Hospital of Beijing University of Chinese Medicine,
Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting (CINV) is a common
adverse event associated with anticancer treatment. Sijunzi decoction, one of
the most classic decoctions, is used to treat CINV, although we do not know how
effective it is in treating CINV.
Results: We included 15 trials including sijunzi decoction compared
with no treatment or adding an emetic in both groups in a total 1155
participants with CINV. For the incidence of WHO III-IV degrees, sijunzi
decoction plus an emetic group benefits more than the emetic group (N = 6,
n = 468, RR = 0.41, 95% CI 0.31–0.55, I2 = 0%, fixed effect model,
moderate-quality evidence). There is no clear evidence between sijunzi decoction
group and no-treatment group. For the incidence rate of CINV, there is no
difference between sijunzi decoction plus an emetic group and the emetic group.
There is a significant reduction in sijunzi decoction group comparing with
no-treatment group (N = 3, n = 317, RR = 0.52, 95% CI 0.35 to 0.77,
I2 = 0%, fixed effect model, very low-quality evidence).
Conclusions: Sijunzi decoction plus an emetic could decrease the
incidence rate of WHO degrees III-IV. Sijunzi decoction may offer some benefit
in terms of decreasing the incidence of CINV. There is insufficient evidence to
demonstrate whether sijunzi decoction or sijunzi decoction plus an emetic are
effective in the incidence rate of CTCAE degrees III-IV, and the evidence is too
limited to make any confident conclusion. The quality of most evidence is very
low for both comparisons. The main limitations are risk of bias, poor reporting,
and inconsistency. We need high-quality randomized controlled studies
investigating the effects of sijunzi decoction upon CINV.
(4051) Comparative Effectiveness of Cheonwangbosimdan (Tian Wang Bu Xin Dan)
Versus Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia of Cancer Patients: A Protocol for
Randomized Parallel-group Pilot Trial
O-Jin Kwon, PhD1, Sun-Young Moon1, Ui-Min Jerng, KMD,
PhD2, Seong Woo Yoon, KMD, PhD3, So-Young Jung,
BS1, Jee Young Lee, KMD, PhD3, Won-Chul Shin, MD,
PhD3, Jung-Ick Byun, MD, PhD3 and Jun-Hwan Lee, KMD,
PhD1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
2Sangji University, Wonju, Republic of Korea
3Kyung Hee University Hospital at Gangdong, Seoul, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Cancer patients have two times higher prevalence of
insomnia than that of healthy populations. Although cancer-related sleep
deprivation can aggravate the rehabilitation of cancer treatment and
quality-of-life, cancer-related insomnia has been cared with less attention.
Pharmacotherapy and cognitive behavioural therapy-insomnia (CBT-I) are jointly
undergone to insomnia patients. However, pharmacotherapy can be partially used
to short-term insomnia patients, and CBT-I needs skilled physicians.
Cheonwangbosimdan is a Korean herbal medicine generally used to relieve sleep
deprivation, anxiety and palpitation. There are few prior studies to examine the
effect of Cheonwangbosimdan on cancer sleep deprivation, whereas trials of other
primary insomnia and secondary insomnia with hyperthyroidism were performed.
Purpose of this study is to examine the effectiveness and safety of
Cheonwangbosimdan to cancer patients.
Conclusions: This study will be the first randomized controlled
pilot trial to observe the effectiveness and safety of Cheonwangbosimdan on
cancer patients’ insomnia by comparing with CBT-I. It can contribute to
attentive care to cancer patients’ insomnia.
(4053) Preclinical Safety Evaluation of Hwanglyeonhaedok-tang, a Traditional
Herbal Formula: Acute, Sub-chronic Toxicity and Genotoxicity Studies
Seong Eun Jin, MS1, Mee-Young Lee, PhD1, Chang-Seob Hyekyung
Ha, PhD1, Hyeun-Kyoo Seo, PhD1 and Shin, OMd,
PhD1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose:
Hwanglyeonhaedok-tang (Huang-Lian-Jie-Du-Tang,
Oren-gedoku-to) has been used for the treatment of
inflammatory, gastrointestinal, and cardiovascular diseases. In the present
study, it evaluated the toxicity of Hwanglyeonhaedok-tang water extract
(HHT).
Results: We found no mortality and no abnormality in clinical signs,
body weight, and necropsy findings for any of the animals in the acute toxicity
study, following oral administration of HHT. However, there were significant
changes in urinalysis after 2000 mg/kg/day HHT treatment for both sexes in the
sub-chronic toxicity study. In male and female rats, 750 and 2000 mg/kg/day HHT
treatment decreased the number of red blood cells and increased reticulocyte.
Histopathological examinations revealed stomach mucosal erosion in female rats
(2000 mg/kg/day). In the Ames test, the number of revertant colonies with the
Salmonella typhimurium TA1537 strain and S9 mix increased
in a dose-dependent manner. HHT significantly increased the number of structural
chromosome aberrations in 6 h or 22 h incubation without S9 mix. In the
micronucleus test, no significant increase was observed in micronucleated
polychromatic erythrocytes, and no significant decrease was observed in
polychromatic to total erythrocytes.
Conclusions: The 50% lethal dose of HHT is greater than 2000 mg/kg
body weight in rats. The no-observed adverse effects level were established for
750 mg/kg HHT in rats of either sex. The genotoxicity results indicate that HHT
might be genotoxic, based on both the Ames and chromosome aberration tests.
(4054) Yoga-Therapy for Rheumatoid Arthritis: Rapid Improvement in Proms
Tina Cartwright, PhD1, Kofi Annie, PhD2, Vidhi Sadana, BA
(Hon)2 and Bernard Colaço, MBChB FRCP2
1University of Westminster, London, UK
2Central Middlesex Hospital, LNWHT, London, UK
Abstract
Purpose: Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a long-term condition that
results in inflammation of joints resulting in comorbidities including mood
disorders leading to poor quality-of-life. Multidisciplinary interventions such
as cognitive behavioural therapy and physiotherapy are routinely used but with
limited evidence on functional outcomes and quality-of-life (QOL). Group yoga
classes showed little impact in mental and QOL measures. Our study investigated
RA patients’ experiences of individualised yoga therapy, a multi-modal,
multi-target intervention, in terms of its acceptability and perceived impact on
patient outcomes and behaviours.
Results: Ninety-eight of 100 sessions were attended by participants.
Qualitative findings indicated that considerable value was placed on therapeutic
function of the consultation, of being listened to and receiving advice on
concerns. Therapeutic mechanisms appeared to reflect tailored physical practices
alongside psychosocial techniques, which promoted psychological well-being and
increased perceptions of control and self-efficacy. Several reported reductions
in their medication and broader benefits such as improved sleep, mood and
energy. All but one participant reported positive changes to their RA symptoms,
including pain reduction, greater mobility and joint flexibility.
Conclusions: This novel pilot YT intervention was positively
received by patients with RA, with high levels of adherence to both the course
of treatments and the tailored home practice. The results suggest that yoga
therapy has potential as an adjunct therapy to improve RA symptoms, increase
self-care behaviours and address negative mood.
(4055) Self-Reported Effects of Energy Healing: A Prospective Cohort Pilot Study
in the Practitioner’s Office
Trine Stub, PhD1, Olav Knudsen-Baas, MD2, Anne H Udal, PhD,
MD2 and Agnete E Kristoffersen3
1UiT The Arctic University of Norway, Tromsø, Norway
2Hospital of Southern Norway, Arendal, Norway
3The National Research Center in Complementary and Alternative Medicine,
Tromso, Norway
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to map the symptoms the
participants reported when visiting a healer for the first time and to evaluate
the subjectively experienced benefits from the healing sessions.
Results: The participants who visited the healers in this study were
manly women (80%) with chronic disease (82%) with pain, fatigue, and/or
psychological problems as main complaints. They experienced an improvement in
symptoms, well-being, and activity level of approximately 50% regardless of the
nature of the complaints. Women reported more improvement than men, and the
change from baseline was found after an average of 4.1 treatment sessions. Forty
percent of the participants reported adverse effects, which occurred directly
after the healing sessions, generally lasting for less than 1 day.
Conclusions: The study participants reported substantial improvement
of, and major reduction of the burden of symptoms, improved well-being and
activity level after healing treatment. Due to the pilot nature of the study, no
interpretations about specificity of the descriptive results or mechanisms of
effect can be made.
(4057) Hatha Yoga for Chronic Pain in Patients Receiving Methadone Maintenance
Treatment: A Pilot Study
Lisa Uebelacker, PhD1, Donnell Van Noppen, BA2, Genie Bailey,
MD3, Ana M Abrantes, PhD1, 2 and Michael Stein,
MD4
1Brown University and Butler Hospital, Providence, Rhode Island
2Butler Hospital, Providence, Rhode Island
3Stanley Street Treatment and Resources, Fall River, Massachusetts
4Boston University School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Purpose: Chronic pain is a significant problem for many
people receiving opioid agonist treatment for opioid use disorder. We adapted
existing yoga programs for chronic pain and conducted a pilot RCT to assess
acceptability and feasibility in people enrolled in methadone maintenance.
Results: We recruited 20 participants in 6.5 months, meeting our
target recruitment rate. Ninety percent of participants completed an endpoint
assessment. There were no serious adverse events related to study participation.
Self-report measures of credibility, acceptability, and satisfaction exceeded
pre-set cut-offs for both arms. Participants who attended more than 1 yoga class
reported practicing yoga at home at least twice per week for at least 75% of the
weeks for which they provided data. The only benchmark we did not meet was class
attendance. Although rates improved over time as we made modifications, only 5
of 10 people assigned to yoga attended 7 classes or more (of 12 possible). We
examined reasons for poor attendance. One person went to jail right after
randomization, one experienced a severe pain exacerbation before attending
classes, and one had ongoing health problems including influenza and
gastrointestinal distress. Finally, two participants seemed fearful that yoga
might increase pain rather than help.
Conclusions: Yoga seems acceptable and is readily adopted by some
people with chronic pain who are taking methadone. However, health problems,
justice system involvement, and fear of pain may interfere with participation.
Next steps include a consideration of ways to address the problem of fear of
pain in this population.
(4059) Limitations to Assessment of Acupuncture in the Military Health
System
Avni Patel, MPH1, Megan Vaughan, BSN, RN, CCRP1, Tracey Perez
Koehlmoos, PhD, MHA2 and Cathaleen A Madsen, PhD1
1Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine,
Rockville, Maryland
2Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda,
Maryland
Abstract
Purpose: “Big Data” provides a means of investigating patterns of
usage and outcomes in health care. However, Big Data is rarely used to
investigate Integrative Medicine (IM), despite calls for this type of research.
This study examines a single IM modality, acupuncture, in a universally insured
population, and illustrates several challenges with this approach to
investigation of IM.
Results: A total of 15 761 recipients of acupuncture were identified
in the MHS. While demographic and diagnostic information was available,
significant obstacles to analysis included 13% missing race data, 9.5%
ill-defined diagnoses, insufficient procedural codes to differentiate between
different modalities of acupuncture or to separate acupuncture from
non-cupuncture modalities in a common therapeutic category (eg, “infrared”), and
inability to determine primary from adjunct therapy.
Conclusions: Missing data, inefficient coding, and insufficient
granularity represent system-wide obstacles to big data investigation of
acupuncture in the MHS, and likely to other systems using standard coding.
Additional electronic notation is recommended to enable full analysis.
Disclaimer: The contents of this publication are the sole
responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views,
assertions, opinions, or policies of the Uniformed Services University of the
Health Sciences; the Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military
Medicine, Inc.; the Defense and Veterans Center for Integrative Pain Management;
the Department of Defense; or the Departments of the Army, Navy, or Air Force.
Mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations does not imply
endorsement by the U.S. Government.
(4061) Does the Presence of Integrative Medicine Curriculum Enhance Residency
Recruitment?
Patricia Lebensohn, MD1, Victoria Maizes, MD1, Mei-Kuang Chen,
PhD1, Hilary McClafferty, MD1, Mari Ricker, MD1
and Audrey J Brooks, PhD1
1Tucson, Arizona
Abstract
Purpose: The University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine
Integrative Medicine in Residency (IMR) program began in 2008 as a feasibility
pilot in 8 Family Medicine residencies. Since the successful pilot, the IMR
program is now in use in 58 Family Medicine residencies, 4 internal medicine, 2
psychiatry, 2 preventive medicine, and 1 obstetrician–gynecologist residencies.
The Pediatric IMR began in 2013 in 5 pilot sites and is now in 11 sites. A
potential benefit of the IMR program in residencies is that it may enhance
recruitment at those sites. This study surveyed incoming residents at IMR sites
to examine the role of the IMR program as a recruiting tool.
Results: 253 residents completed the survey (29% response rate). The
majority were Family Medicine (n = 173; 68%) or pediatric (n = 66; 26%)
residents. Almost half (45%) had personal experience with IM, 36% had taken an
IM elective in medical school, and 31% had taken a required IM course. Two
thirds (65%) were aware of the IMR curriculum when applying to the residency and
57% discussed the IMR when interviewing. IMR was rated as one of the main
decision criteria in applying (25%), interviewing (22%), and ranking (31%).
Location was the most frequently cited criteria (81% applying, 90% interviewing,
79% ranking). Most residents were interested in learning (68%) and applying IM
(63%). Family Medicine residents were significantly more likely to be aware of
the IMR curriculum than pediatric residents (81% vs. 21%), discuss it when
interviewing (73% vs. 10%) and rated the importance of the IM curriculum in
applying and ranking higher (P < .001). However, there was
no difference between the groups of interest in learning or applying IM.
Conclusions: This study examined the potential impact of the IMR
curriculum as a recruitment tool. A majority of residents were aware of the
presence of the IMR program at the residency site and had strong interest in
learning and applying IM. However, in the Family Medicine programs where there
is a longer IMR history, awareness and importance of IMR in residency site
selection was much higher indicating the potential of an IMR program to enhance
recruitment.
(4062) Capturing the Ineffable: Development of the Nondaul Awareness Dimensional
Assessment
Eric Garland, PhD1, Adam W Hanley, PhD1 and Yoshio Nakamura,
PhD1
1Center on Mindfulness and Integrative Health Intervention Development,
Salt Lake City, Utah
Abstract
Purpose: Nondual awareness is an altered state of consciousness that
is well documented in religious and meditative traditions. Yet, no standardized
method of measuring nondual awareness currently exists. To address this gap, we
developed and validated two forms of the Nondual Awareness Dimensional
Assessment (NADA). The first form captured dispositions toward nondual awareness
(NADA-T) and the second form captured states of nondual awareness (NADA-S).
Results: PCA revealed 2 interpretable dimensions of the NADA-T:
self-transcendence and bliss. B-ESEM indicated that both NADA-T dimensions were
components of a second-order nondual awareness construct. Positive correlations
were observed between the NADA-T and theoretically aligned constructs, such as
interdependent self-construals and decentering. Mindfulness practitioners
reported higher NADA-T scores than nonpractitioners, and practice frequency was
positively correlated with NADA-T scores. Finally, a mindfulness induction was
observed to increase nondual awareness relative to an active listening task.
Conclusions: The NADA-T and -S were constructed as a means to
facilitate quantitative investigation of nondual awareness. Our findings
indicate that the NADA-T and -S are valid measures, and that continued use and
refinement of these instruments may provide useful insights into the prevalence,
correlates, mechanisms, and consequences of nondual states of awareness and
their relations to health and illness. Systematic, quantitative investigation of
nondual awareness has much to contribute to the emerging field of contemplative
science.
(4063) How Do Yoga and Meditation Influence the Relationship Between Negative
Life Events and Depression?
Romy Lauche, PhD1, Holger Cramer, PhD2, Dennis Anheyer,
MA2, Jon Adams, PhD1 and David Sibbritt,
PhD1
1University of Technology Sydney, Sydney, Australia
2University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: Yoga and meditation have been gaining popularity worldwide.
While benefits have been reported for physical and mental health, the mode of
action is vastly unknown. Previous research has suggested that yoga/meditation
may act via the reduction of stress, one of the major risk factors for
depression. Therefore, this study aims to determine whether yoga/meditation
moderates the relationship between negative life events and depression.
Results: Stepwise analyses revealed that perceived stress partially
mediated the association between negative life events and depression. Social
support moderated the paths life events—stress, and stress—depression, while no
such moderation was found for yoga/meditation. Instead yoga/meditation use was
found to moderate the direct path between negative life events and depression.
Contrary to yoga/meditation use, no such moderating effect was found for
physical activity.
Conclusions: This study found that yoga/mediation use did not
influence depression through the stress path, instead yoga/mediation was found
to dampen the influence of negative life events on depression directly. More
research on the mechanisms of yoga are warranted.
(4065) Development of an Attention Control Group for Tai Chi in Older Adults With
Chronic Low Back Pain
Karem J Sherman, PhD, MPH1, Manu Thakral, ARNP, PhD1, Emily
Bandy, MSn2, Judith Turner, PhD3 and Elizabeth Phelan,
MD3
1Kaiser Permanente Washington, Seattle, Washington
2Seattle University, Seattle, Washington
3Seattle, Washington
Abstract
Purpose: Attention control groups are designed to control for
“nonspecific” effects in nonpharmacological studies. In this presentation, we
describe the systematic development of an attention control group for a study of
tai chi in older adults with chronic back pain.
Results: We did develop a 24-session course, lead primarily by a
nursing student who was also a social worker, but with guest lectures from
several others. All classes had short power point presentations as well as
questions designed to engage patients in discussion. The course material was
quite comprehensive and included various physical and mental health difficulties
(depression, sleep, and bladder problems), prevention (fall prevention, brain
health flu, and pneumonia prevention), making medical care safer (using
medications safely and communication with the health care provider), changes as
a result of aging (nutrition and osteoporosis), and special issues as a result
of aging (safe driving, caregiving, and social support). As of this submission,
9 classes had been held. In the attention control group, 6 of 12 participants
attended 7 or more classes versus 9 of 13 in Tai Chi. Classes will be completed
at the end of March, and then formal comparisons will be made between attendance
for the two interventions.
Conclusions: We describe an attention control group that may meet
the needs of complex mind–body therapies, though until the classes are
completed, this cannot be known for sure.
(4067) Identification of Circulating MicroRNAs Associated With Sleep Disorder
Using Next-Generation Sequencing
Seongwon Cha, PhD1 and Boyoung Lee, BA1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Mibyeong (or subhealth) from traditional East-Asian
medicine is a nondisease physiological state that presents medically unexplained
symptoms. One of main cause of Mibyeong would be sleep disorder. It is important
to prevent severe form of sleep disorder such as chronic insomnia, leading to
lower performance at work, a higher accidental risk, depression, and so on.
Circulating microRNA (19–24 nucleotides) exists as a stable-form in body fluid
including serum (plasma), cerebrospinal fluid, and saliva and has potential as a
biomarker of cancer, cardiovascular disease, etc. Therefore, we focused on
circulating microRNA (miRNA) as a biomarker of sleep disorder, and aimed at
identifying dyssomnia-associated serum miRNAs using next-generation sequencing
(NGS).
Results: Totally 63 miRNAs from individuals with sleep disorder
compared to healthy individuals showed differential serum levels (over 2-fold,
P < .05). Interestingly, the number of identified miRNAs
was clearly distinguished between men and women: 8 miRNAs in men and 58 miRNAs
in women.
Conclusions: Gender difference in miRNA levels associated with sleep
disorder may reflect that women usually suffer from sleep disturbance more
frequently than men. Further study to confirm the dyssomnia association of NGS
miRNAs in other independent groups would be necessary.
(4071) Mindfulness-based Interventions for DSM-5 Anxiety Disorders—A Systematic
Review and Meta-analysis
Pascal Breilmann1, Heidemarie Haller, MSc1, Holger Cramer,
PhD1 and Gustav Dobos, MD PhD1
1University of Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany
Abstract
Purpose: This meta-analysis aimed to systematically review the
evidence on mindfulness-based interventions in patients with DSM-5 anxiety
disorders.
Results: The literature search revealed 14 RCTs including 1159
patients with generalized or social anxiety disorder, panic, phobias, or anxiety
disorder NOS. The overall risk of bias was unclear, except for mostly low
detection bias, attrition bias, and other bias. Compared to TAU,
mindfulness-based interventions showed significant short-term effects on
clinician-rated (3 RCTs; SMD = −2.51; 95% CI = [−4.24¦−0.77];
I2 = 94%) and patient-rated anxiety (9 RCTs; SMD = −0.86; 95%
CI = [−1.16¦−0.55]; I2 = 71%). While clinician ratings all based on
ACT studies, subgroup analyses of patients-rated effects revealed significant
SMDs for ACT, MBCT, and MBSR with considerable heterogeneity only between the
MBSR studies. Patient-rated depression (9 RCTs; SMD = −0.89; 95%
CI = [−1.46¦−0.50]; I2 = 87%) and quality-of-life (6 RCTs;
SMD = 0.67; 95% CI = [0.14¦1.21]; I2 = 86%) also significantly
improved in the short term. In comparison to psychotherapeutic interventions
such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, education and relaxation, effects of ACT,
MBCT, and MBSR were comparable for all outcomes in the short term, 6 and 12
months after randomization. Adverse events were reported insufficiently.
Conclusions: This meta-analysis suggested significant greater
anxiolytic effects of mindfulness-based interventions against TAU and comparable
effects in comparison to standard psychotherapeutic interventions up to 12
months. However, risk of bias was often unclear and heterogeneity was considered
particularly in MBCT and MBSR analyses, which limits the conclusions.
(4074) Herbal Medicine (Danggui Liuhuang Decoction) for Treating Menopausal
Symptoms: A Systematic Review of Randomized Clinical Trials
Hye Won Lee, PhD1, Ji Hee Jun, MSc1, Junhua Zhang, MD,
PhD2, Fengwen Yang, MD, PhD2 and Myeong Soo Lee,
PhD1
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
2Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Tianjin, China
Abstract
Purpose: Danggui Liuhuang (DLH) decoction is a traditional herbal
medicine that is widely used in East Asia to treat menopausal symptoms. Most of
the available clinical trials that investigated DLH decoction have been included
in this review. The purpose of this review was to evaluate the effectiveness and
safety of DLH decoction in the treatment of menopausal symptoms.
Results: Eight RCTs showed better effects of modified DLH decoction
than of Western medicine on treatment effects and the Kupperman index. Seven
RCTs tested the effects of modified DLH decoction in comparison with those of
Western medicine on treatment effects and favorable treatment effects of
modified DLH decoction. Moreover, our meta-analysis also showed significant
improvements in treatment effects (n = 482, RR:1.27, 95% CI: 1.07 to 1.52,
P = .007) with high heterogeneity (I2 = 84%).
Two RCTs compared the DLH decoction with Western medicine using the Kupperman
index. However, our meta-analysis failed to show significant improvement
(n = 270, MD: −4.67, 95% CI: −13.28 to 3.95, P = .29).
Conclusions: This systematic review and meta-analysis provide
preliminary evidence of the superiority of DLH decoction over other therapies
for treating menopausal symptoms. Unfortunately, the level of evidence is low
due to small sample sizes and low quality of reporting.
(4076) Aromatherapy for Managing Pain in Primary Dysmenorrhea: A Systematic
Review of Randomized Placebo Controlled Trials
Hye Won Lee, PhD1, Myeong Soo Lee, PhD1 and Mohamed Khalil, MD,
PhD2
1Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine, Daejeon, Republic of Korea
2National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, Ministry of
Health, Riyadh, Republic of Korea
Abstract
Purpose: Aromatherapy, the therapeutic use of essential oils, is
often used to reduce pain in primary dysmenorrhea. The aim of this study was to
summarize and critically assess the available evidence regarding the efficacy of
aromatherapy in managing pain in primary dysmenorrhea.
Results: We identified 382 potentially relevant studies, 19 of which
met our inclusion criteria All of the trials reported superior effects of
aromatherapy for pain reduction compared to placebo (n = 1787, standard mean
difference (SMD): −0.91, 95% CI: −1.17 to −0.64, P < .00001)
with high heterogeneity (I2 = 88%). A subanalysis for inhalational
aromatherapy for the alleviation of pain also showed superior effects compared
to placebo (n = 704, SMD: −1.02, 95% CI: −1.59 to −0.44,
P = .0001, I2 = 95%). With regard to aromatherapy
massage, the pooled results of 11 studies showed favourable effects of
aromatherapy massage on pain reduction compared to placebo aromatherapy massage
(n = 793, SMD: −0.87, 95% CI: −1.14 to −0.60, P < .00001,
I2 = 70%). Oral aromatherapy had superior effects compared to
placebo (n = 290, SMD: −0.61, 95% CI: −0.91 to −0.30,
P < .0001, I2 = 0%).
Conclusions: Our systemic review provides a moderate level of
evidence on the superiority of aromatherapy (inhalational, massage or oral use)
for pain reduction over placebo in primary dysmenorrhea.
(4079) What Should Massage Education Do More of, Different, Start, and Stop?
Massage Education Stakeholder Views From the 2017 Alliance for Massage Therapy
Educational Congress
Jasmine L Dyson-Drake, BS1, Diane Mastnardo, BS2 and Niki Munk,
PhD, LMT1
1Indiana University School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences,
Indianapolis, Indiana
2Massage of Northern Ohio Practice Based Research Network/MetroHealth Case
W, Cleveland, Ohio
Abstract
Purpose: An Education Futures Forum held during the 2017 Alliance
for Massage Therapy Education’s Educational Congress systematically gathered
massage education stakeholders’ opinions through a World Café modeled
exercise.
Results: Eighty-five to 91 attendees participated in the 3 breakout
sessions resulting in 674 comments with 3744 assigned value points. The top 5
scoring comments from each room per session (N = 45) determined stakeholder’s
most critical views. Stop comments made up the smallest total comments
proportion (19%) yet largest top scoring comment proportion (36%) potentially
highlighting unified frustration for various massage education practices.
Comparatively, start comments made up 26% of total comments but the smallest
highest scoring proportion (18%) perhaps suggesting stakeholders feel it more
important to improve what is already being done rather than beginning new
endeavors in these areas.
Conclusions: Stakeholder views were systematically gathered in a
large conference setting for organization, analysis, and dissemination to inform
field decision-making.
(4081) Development, Implementation, Assessment, and Refinement of an
Evidence-based, Multidisciplinary, Graduate Integrative Medicine Program
Leigh A Frame, PhD, MHS1, Whitney Milhouse, MS1, Andrew Heyman,
MD, MHSA1 and Leslie Davidson, PhD, OT/L, FAOTA1
1Washington, DC
Abstract
Purpose: Graduate level education in the area of Integrative
Medicine (IM) and health is emerging across a number of institutions in the
United States including the University of Arizona, Duke University, and the
University of California, San Francisco. The popularity of an IM approach can be
linked to the personalized medicine movement as well as sustainability issues
such as prevention of chronic disease and provider burnout. The goal of this
poster is to outline the process of development, implementation, assessment, and
refinement of evidence-based, multidisciplinary IM programs at the George
Washington University in the School of Medicine and Health Sciences.
Results: Success in these programs has been dependent on the
adoption of an interprofessional approach, emphasizing current training needs of
practitioners across the IM spectrum. Emerging and robust scientific evidence is
used throughout the curriculum to ensure clinical practice efficacy. Upon
completion of the program, students demonstrate competency in legal/ethical
issues surrounding these areas of practice. Admissions into the program have
grown by at least 30% over the past 2 years indicating a demand for this type of
academic work.
Conclusions: The adoption of comprehensive content, contributors,
and instructors, who are leaders in the field, has been the foundation for the
development and sustainability of this education program. This process can be
adopted by other institutions who are seeking to expand their footprint to IM
education.
(4084) Adverse Reactions of Blood-lipid Lowering Chinese Patent Medicine: Data
From ADR Monitoring Center in China
Xiatian Zhang1, Baoyi Shao1, Ying Zhang, PhD1, Di
Wang1 and Jianping Liu, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: The incidence and prevalence of hyperlipidemia in China
were still high, causing huge medical and economic burden. Chinese patent
medicine (CPM) was widely used as monotherapy or combination with western
medicine in clinical practice to control blood lipid. As the marketing approval
from China Food and Drug Administration was based on the results of randomized
controlled trials from phases I to III, the analysis of safety data of post
marketing for CPM was more important for learning about the adverse reactions
(ARs) in real world. This study aimed to explore the incidence of ARs for
commonly used CPMs which registered in database of ADR monitoring center.
Results: Totally, 122 212 cases were recorded as adverse reactions
in the database. There were 42 326 cases of ARs caused by 184 CPMs. The top 5
kinds of CPMs were Xuezhikang capsule (n = 135), Tongxinluo capsule (n = 16),
breviscapine injection (n = 7), tea pigment capsule (n = 7), and puerarin
injection (n = 6). The main types of ARs were nausea (n = 113), bloating
(n = 90), dizziness (n = 40), rash (n = 39), and diarrhea (n = 37). Compared
with the selection of CPMs and the types of ARs, the binary logistic regression
showed that compared with other lipid-lowering CPMs, Xuezhikang capsule had
relatively lower ORs to ARs.
Conclusions: Post-marketing ADR monitoring of lipid-lowering CPMs is
important not only to help physicians and patients optimize treatment
interventions but also to help policymakers allocate medical resources
efficiently. In addition, it can provide reference for the design and evaluation
of future studies.
(4085) Patients’ Participation on Their On-Site Review of Doctors’ Notes:
Physicians’ OpenNotes Experiences in a Pain Clinic
Victor Wang, MD, PhD1, Christopher Gilligan, MD, MBA1, Ashish
Bhandari, MBBS1 and Manasi Bhandarkar, MBBS1
1Brookline, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Inviting patients with chronic pain to read their doctors’
visit notes via secure electronic portals may empower them and improve their
understanding of their health condition. However, sharing the clinician’s
perspective on the psychosocial contributors to a patient’s pain via transparent
medical records could potentially lead to conflicts between patients and
providers. Mirroring the OpenNotes study, we investigate and
describe the effects of increased clinic visit note transparency on physician
experience in a large outpatient pain medicine clinic.
Results:
Pain Medicine Physician and Patient Participation: Of the 10
BIDMC pain medicine physicians who started using OpenNotes, 9 completed the
study. All the participants who completed the 6-month study submitted pre- and
postintervention surveys. The participants also attended pre- and
postintervention debriefing sessions to discuss issues not directly covered in
the survey. Since this study focused on experiences of pain medicine physicians,
no patients were contacted during the study period. Pain Physician
Experiences: Of the 9 physicians who responded to the
postintervention survey, 5 estimated that conversations about OpenNotes occurred
less than once per month, 3 felt that patients were calling 1–3 times per month,
and 1 believed their patients were calling 1–6 times per week about the notes.
This represents an insignificant change from call volume prior to the
intervention. Before the start of the study, the participating pain physicians
were generally worried about the increasing workload that OpenNotes could bring
to their practices. The postintervention surveys illustrate that the perceived
workload did modestly increase. However, the increases were not as significant
as these physicians originally believed they would be. Although patient
experiences were not directly captured, before the intervention, 89% of the
participating physicians “agreed” or “somewhat agreed” that their patients would
worry more after being able to read their clinic notes. Following the
intervention, 79% “agreed” or “somewhat agreed” that their patients did indeed
worry more after having access to their notes. Participants were also asked to
assess whether they believed that patients would request changes to their notes.
In the preintervention survey, 89% “agreed” or “somewhat agreed” that patients
would request changes. Following the intervention, 44.5% of the physicians
reported that they received 1 request for modification per month, 44.5% reported
receiving 2–4 requests per month, and 11% received more than 5 requests for
changes per month. Although 33% of participants were “moderately concerned” or
“very concerned” that OpenNotes would increase the average visit length, none of
them felt that visit time was increased following the intervention. In the
preintervention survey, 78% of providers were “moderately concerned” or “very
concerned” that they would spend more time outside of scheduled visits answering
questions, while 56% reported spending more time answering questions after the
intervention. Another subset topic on the pre- and postintervention surveys
addressed issues regarding offending patients, candid documentation, and
avoidance of subjects likely to produce offense such as mental health disorders
and substance abuse. Regarding offending patients, 56% of the participants were
“moderately concerned” before the intervention that their notes would offend
patients and 56% reported offending 1–3 patients per month after the
intervention. Regarding less candid documentation, 33% of the physicians
reported being “moderately concerned” or “very concerned” that their notes would
be less candid before the intervention, while only 11% reported being less
candid in their documentation after the intervention. Prior to the intervention,
22% of the participating pain physicians believed that they would have to change
the way they address topics like mental health and substance abuse and 22%
reported changing the way they address these subjects in the postintervention
survey. The postintervention survey also evaluated physician perceptions of
patient confusion and provider experiences using OpenNotes. Regarding patient
confusion, 56% of participating physicians either “agreed” or “somewhat agreed”
that their patients were confused by reading their notes, while 33% were not
able to tell. When asked “Is having patients read their notes a good idea?” 67%
either “agreed” or “somewhat agreed.” When given the prompt, “If OpenNotes were
turned off, our physicians would…,” 56% of participants stated they “would not
care,” 11% would be “somewhat pleased” and 33% claimed they would be “very
pleased.” Postintervention Comments from Debriefing Sessions:
The postintervention debriefing session allowed the study participants to
comment on their experiences using OpenNotes. Some of the challenges of
OpenNotes were as follows: changes in notes requested by patients often lacked
clinical significance, documentation was targeted to nonmedically trained people
which was not effective for professional communication, notes included fewer
details of clinical diagnoses such as mental health and substance abuse, and
notes sometimes created confusion and worry for patients over clinically
insignificant matters. Some providers felt that OpenNotes could potentially help
patients understand their care better but this was not formally assessed.
Providers were also given the opportunity to offer feedback on OpenNotes. As
this study was conducted at an academic institution, several physicians
expressed frustration with the inferior quality of their trainees’ notes,
feeling they were often inaccurate or poorly written. Limitations in the note
writing software program also prevented the participants from directly editing a
trainee’s note. Furthermore, the faculty also felt that they did not have enough
time to write addenda before the clinic notes became available to patients. One
asserted that “it would be better if the attending could edit a trainee’s
notes.”
Conclusions: This study represents the start of a journey that
explores how pain medicine physicians can communicate more transparently with
their patients. However, this study also raises questions about the complex
effects of OpenNotes on the patient–physician interaction and how shared
decision-making may be facilitated or hampered by this intervention. Thus, it
motivates future research into this area to define the patient perspective and
answer the question of whether changes in physician workload are quantitative or
qualitative. In the future, it will be fascinating to compare patient
perspectives with those of our pain medicine faculty and trainees. Despite the
challenges of introducing OpenNotes in an academic setting and modestly
increasing workloads, the potential benefits provided by increased transparency
between patients and pain physicians, such as increased medication adherence,
greater understanding of care plans, and empowering patients to improve their
pain, make it imperative to explore this fundamental change in practice
carefully and creatively.
(4086) Trigger Point Self-Care for Chronic Neck Pain: Pilot Study Results
Arash Zakeresfahani, BS1, Anthony Perkins, MS2 and Niki Munk,
PhD, LMT3
1Indiana University School of Physical Education and Tourism Management,
Indianapolis, Indiana
2Indiana University Richard M. Fairbanks School of Public Health,
Indianapolis, Indiana
3Indiana University School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences,
Indianapolis, Indiana
Abstract
Purpose: Massage is promising for chronic neck pain (CNP) but
accessibility is limited due to out-of-pocket costs. Trigger points contribute
to CNP and trigger point self-care (TrPtSc) may be an effective way for massage
benefit to reach broad populations. This proof-of-concept/feasibility study
sought to examine trigger point self-treatment effect for CNP.
Results: Forty-six (n = 36 females) adults, aged 19–67
(mean = 47.6 ± 12.9) years, were enrolled. Five enrollees (n = 1 female) were
excluded from the analysis due to missing data and early withdrawal resulting in
N = 41. Within-group analysis indicated improved current and worst pain Visual
Analogue Scale (VAS) scores for TrPtSc (P = .003; .007,
respectively) and massage (P = .02, .05, respectively) groups
and improved average VAS (P = .009), current 11-point pain
(P = .02), and best 11-point pain
(P = .018) for the TrPtSc group. TrPtSc improved current
11-point (P = .029) and VAS pain (P = .044),
worse VAS pain (P = .049), and best 11-point pain
(P = .004) compared to control at week 8.
Conclusions: TrPtSc and massage were both effective for CNP after 4
weeks but only TrPtSc retained benefit and continued to improve at week 8. Fully
powered, larger research is needed to confirm trends and determine the extent to
which TrPtSc alone or combined with massage contribute to CNP’s long-term
management.
(4087) Treating Contact Dermatitis With Cool-reducing Method and Blood-letting
Puncture – A Case Report
Yuhao Wu, PhD1 and Yumin Cho, PhD2
1Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Chengdu, China
2Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Purpose: Contact dermatitis, a common allergic skin disease, usually
occurs when the skin develops an allergic reaction after being exposed to a
foreign substance. In modern medicine, glucocorticoids are often used for
treating contact dermatitis. However, symptoms recur with medication
discontinuation in some patients. The purpose of the present study was to
address the effect of treating contact dermatitis by using acupuncture and
blood-letting, complemented with Chinese herbal medicine.
Results: After 3 months treatment, the color of the rash on cheeks
fades and the rash on forehead was eliminated. No itching and burning sensation
was present. There was no symptom recurrence observed during a follow-up
investigation of 2 months.
Conclusions: Acupuncture and bloodletting, supplemented with Chinese
herbal medicine, may be an effective option in treating contact dermatitis.
(4088) Randomized Controlled Trials Investigating the Association Between Dietary
Pattern and High-sensitivity C-reactive Protein: A Systematic Review
David Deichert, ND, ARNP1, Jamie Corroon, ND, MPH2, Courtney K
Pickworth, BA3 and Ryan Bradley, ND, MPH3
1Seattle Healing Arts Center, Seattle, Washington
2Center for Clinical Consulting, Del Mar, California
3National University of Natural Medicine, Portland, Oregon
Abstract
Purpose: Elevated serum concentration of high-sensitivity C-reactive
protein (hsCRP), a biomarker of systemic inflammation, is associated with
increased risk for coronary heart disease (CHD) and cardiovascular events.
Evaluation of nonpharmaceutical methods for lowering hsCRP has not been
emphasized in the literature due to the efficacy of pharmacological methods (ie,
statin drugs) in reducing hsCRP as well as the historically low adherence to
intensive lifestyle modification. Alternatives to statins to lower serum hsCRP,
including dietary modification, merit investigation.
Objective: To systematically review clinical trials focused on
dietary interventions and hsCRP.
Results: Fifty-six manuscripts met inclusion criteria for detailed
review. The value of modifications to dietary pattern for hsCRP reduction has
been investigated in many populations, including those at risk for CHD, type 2
diabetes, and other chronic disease. Collectively, results suggest that the
adoption of several dietary patterns may lead to clinically significant
reductions in hsCRP in both healthy and diseased populations. These patterns
include low fat, Mediterranean, Portfolio, Paleolithic, and the Dietary
Approaches to Stop Hypertension diets. Other interventions, eg, low carbohydrate
diets, have had mixed results.
Conclusions: Clinical trials of dietary interventions to lower hsCRP
are mixed in terms of quality, risk of bias, and findings. Despite the
variability of results, randomized clinical trials to assess dietary
interventions for lowering hsCRP are justified and valuable.
(4089) Associations Between a Contemplative Curricula and Self-compassion in
University Students
Dara James, MS1, Maria Napoli, PhD1, Robin Bonifas,
PhD1, Lisa Schmidt, MS1 and Jacob Szeszulski,
MS1
1Arizona State University, Phoenix, Arizona
Abstract
Purpose: University students experience a myriad of psychosocial
stressors. Studies have established that self-compassion can ameliorate negative
psychological outcomes (ie, stress, depression, anxiety) while increasing
positive psychological outcomes (ie, well-being, academic performance,
happiness). Self-compassion combines the concepts of self-kindness, common
humanity, and mindfulness; it is understood as treating oneself the way one
would treat a suffering friend. Few studies have addressed the influence of
academic courses on self-compassion; this study aimed to examine contemplative
curricular effects (1. acknowledgement, 2.
attention, 3. acceptance without judgment, and
4. choosing to respond) on self-compassion.
Results: At baseline, no differences in self-compassion by race
(P = .618) or age (P = .474) were noted,
but significant differences by gender (males 37.2 ± 6.1; females 32.9 ± 7.6;
P < .001) were present. Self-compassion increased
3.6 ± 7.9 points at posttest; changes were higher among females (5.5 ± 8.7 vs
1.6 ± 6.5; P = .001) and Caucasians (5.6 ± 8.0), followed by
Latino (5.3 ± 8.3), multi-racial (1.7 ± 9.7), and Asians (.4 ± 6.0), but were
not different by age (P = .716). Differences between Caucasians
and Asians were significant (P = .026).
Conclusions: Contemplative curricula may increase self-compassion
and potentially help reduce psychosocial impacts of burdens commonly experienced
among university students. Improved outcomes may have strong implications for
both immediate and long-term reduced stress, enhanced well-being, and student
success. Variables of culture and gender may moderate these associations and
should be explored further.
(4091) Does Pilot Study Always Provide Credible Parameters? Considerations on the
Sample Sizes of Vanguard Trials for CAM
Ying Zhang, PhD1, Jianping Liu, PhD1, Di Wang, Xun
Master1, Yutong Li, PhD1 and Fei, PhD1
1Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
Abstract
Purpose: Most of the complementary and alternative medicine (CAMs),
such as Traditional Chinese Medicine, has a long application history in clinical
practices but lacks empirical data to investigate the efficacy or effectiveness
as an intervention for a specific disease. In recent decades, more and more
randomized controlled trials of CAMs were carried out, and a pilot study is
necessary to explore the feasibility, acceptability, and time schedule for the
main trial. In addition, the pilot study could provide the key parameters which
will be used to calculate the sample size of the main trial. However, the pilot
study, in fact, often has been conducted with an arbitrary sample size. This
study aims to explore the principles to determine sample size for pilot
studies.
Results: The factor which should be considered firstly is
feasibility. Julious proposed the rule of thumb for 12 in each group, because 12
is a convenient number to be divided by 2, 3,4, 6, or even 12 and therefore
could be adaptive to various block size in randomization. From the perspective
of precision, iteration method was often used. Some advised from 10 to 75 for
different Cohen effect size. Monte Carlo simulations were applied to explore
power, and 30–60 per group were recommended in several researches.
Conclusions: The study implies that using parameters without any
adjustment in the pilot study will underestimate the sample size in the main
trial and therefore lose the statistical power. Iterations or simulations should
be done, if possible, to provide parameters with high precision and guarantee
the main trial achieve ideal power.
(4096) Indigo Naturalis Ointment for Plaque-type Psoriasis: A Systematic
Review
Hung-Jen Lin, MD, PhD1, Hung-Rong Yen, MD, PhD1 and Kuo-Feng
Hung, MD1
1China Medical University Hospital, Taichung, Taiwan, Province of
China
Abstract
Purpose: Plaque-type psoriasis is challenging to treat. Currently
available treatments are limited in efficacy and often produce unfavorable side
effects. A plant extract, indigo naturalis (IN), is widely used in topical
ointment form for plaque-type psoriasis. The aim of this study is to evaluate
the efficacy and safety of IN ointment (INO) for patients with plaque-type
psoriasis.
Results: In terms of efficacy, only three studies met the criteria
for study design and passed a Cochrane risk of bias analysis. Sixty-four
participants received INO therapy, and 55 were treated with vehicle ointment
(VO). Based on this limited dataset, 64% of patients achieve more than 75%
reduction in Psoriasis Area Severity Index after 8-week INO therapy, compared to
2.5% of patient in VO group. For safety outcomes, no serious or life-threatening
adverse effects were found.
Conclusions: There were some evidence of benefit of INO for
plaque-type psoriasis, and no reported serious adverse events related to INO.
However, the conclusion was limited by the small number of included trials.
Future randomized controlled trials are needed to clarify the effect of INO for
plaque-type psoriasis.
(4098) Effect of Homeopathy Treatment for Post-traumatic Stress Disorder in
Battered Women: Randomized Wait-list Controlled Trial
Neha Sharma, PhD1 and Sadhana Sharma, MD2
1Warwick Research Services, Leicester, UK
2NMP Medical Research Institute, Jaipur, India
Abstract
Purpose: Although numerous mental health issues are associated with
intimate partner violence, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is the most
prevalent disorder in battered women. Traditional PTSD treatments that
incorporate exposures are contradicted. Treatments exist for persons in the
acute aftermath of trauma treatment do not address battered women’s ongoing
threat of revictimization. To date, only cognitive behavioral therapy has been
tried for battered women. To determine if treating with homeopathy could
effectively diminishes symptoms of PTSD in battered women, randomized waitlist
controlled trial was designed.
Results: After the 3 months of treatment period, participants in
homeopathy group showed significant decrease in PTSD symptoms
(P < 0001). A between-group comparison at posttest
revealed greater PTSD symptom reduction (P < .001) and
depression (P < .001) in homeopathy group that WLC.
Participants in homeopathy group reported high satisfaction with treatment and
high rate of recovery.
Conclusions: This is first randomized controlled trial using
homeopathy for treating PTSD in battered women. Homeopathy is easily available,
self-administered, feasible option that might help women cope with traumatic
effect of their abuse and establish long-term well-being.
(4099) Quxie Capsule Inhibits the Colon Tumor Growth Through FOXO1-Mediated
Apoptosis and Immune Modulation
Yan Jiang, PhD1, Yufei Yang, PhD2, Dongmei Chen, Peiying
Master3 and Yang, PhD4
1Texas
2Xiyuan Hospital, Beijing, China
3Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing, China
4Houston, Texas
Abstract
Purpose: Traditional Chinese Medicine, such as Quxie Capsule (QXC),
has been routinely used in colorectal cancer treatment in Xiyuan Hospital in
China. However, the mechanism(s) underlying the effect of QXC in colon cancer
still remain unclear which hampers its optimal use for the treatment of colon
cancer. Forkhead box O1 (FOXO1), a transcription factor plays an important role
in cell cycle, apoptosis, and immune modulation in various cancers. In this
study, we aimed to examine the antitumor efficacy of QXC in mouse colon cancer
and further investigated the mechanism by which QXC upregulated FOXO1
protein-mediated pathways.
Results: QXC gavage to mice carrying CT26 mouse colon tumors for 2
weeks significantly reduced the average tumor weight (0.68 ± 0.41 g) compared to
that in the control treated mice (1.16 ± 0.22 g, P < .05).
Both Foxo1 mRNA and protein expression in tumor was increased in QXC group as
opposed to that of the control. Further, QXC treatment led to elevated apoptotic
regulating proteins such as Fas, Bim, and cleaved caspase-3 in tumor tissue
compared with that of the control group. Intriguingly, the ratio of Th1/Th2 and
its key regulator, T-bet protein, was increased while Treg/Th17 ratio and T-reg
regulator, Foxp3, were reduced in QXC treated mice compared to that of the
control, revealing that Foxo1 upregulated T-bet and downregulated Foxp3 and
induced the shrift of immune balance which is critical in enhancing antitumor
efficacy of QXC.
Conclusions: QXC may have a therapeutic potential for patients with
advanced colorectal cancer and deserved further investigation.
Funding: This study was funded by National Natural Science
Foundation of China (No. 81373824).
(4101) Impact of Back Pain on Mortality Differs by Gender: Results of a
Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Peter Stein, DC, PhD1, Lisa Fredman, PhD2, Howard Fink, MD,
MPH3, Michael LaValley, PhD2, Eric Roseen, DC4,
Robert B Saper, MD, MPH4 and Iniya Rajendran, MD4
1Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts
2Boston University School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts
3Minneapolis, Minnesota
4Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Back pain is the most common cause of disability worldwide.
While disability is associated with early mortality, the association between
back pain and mortality is unclear. Individual studies may be limited by small
sample sizes; therefore, we conducted a meta-analysis of published studies of
back pain and mortality.
Results: Fourteen studies were included in our primary
meta-analysis. Among 87,937 total participants, adults with back pain had an
increased risk of mortality in both random effect (RE) models (odds ratio [OR]:
1.12, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.02–1.24 [I2 = 84%]) and fixed
effect models (OR: 1.16, 95%CI: 1.13–1.20). Sex-stratified estimates show
elevated mortality risk in women (RE OR: 1.37, 95%CI: 1.07–1.76) but not men (RE
OR: 1.00, 95%CI: 0.76–1.15). The risk of mortality associated with back pain did
not appear to increase with age (slope per year of mean study age = .005,
P = .34).
Conclusions: Among women, but not men, back pain was associated with
a modest increase in risk of mortality. This study raises the question of
whether better management of back related pain and disability, over time, may
extend life. Future studies should evaluate the impact of longitudinal
integrative medicine use on survival in adults with chronic back pain,
especially for women.
(4102) Echinacea purpurea: Deciphering the Controversy Behind
Its Medicinal Properties
Johanne A Gerstel, ND Student1 and Jeffrey O Langland, PhD2
1Tempe, Arizona
2Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, Tempe, Arizona
Abstract
Purpose: Rhinovirus infections are associated with the common cold.
Symptomology and complications of rhinovirus infections are often linked to the
immune response and the expression of the cytokine, IL-8. Rhinovirus
complications may include chronic bronchitis, sinusitis, otitis media and
asthma. Echinacea purpurea has historically been asserted as a
therapy for rhinovirus infections, but results from clinical studies have been
controversial. Many studies conclude that Echinacea is an
effective therapeutic against the rhinovirus infections, whereas an equal number
of reports claim the opposite. The purpose of our study was to investigate the
biological activities of Echinacea based on different plant
parts and various extraction methods.
Results: Results demonstrated a dramatic difference between the root
and flower portions of the plant, where flower ethanol extracts enhanced immune
cytokine production, while ethanol extracts of the root repressed cytokine
production and inhibited viral growth. In addition, a water extract of the root
led to an enhancement in rhinovirus replication.
Conclusions: Based on our results, predictions can be made where
Echinacea flower extracted in ethanol or root extracted in
water may lead to increased symptoms if used to treat a rhinovirus infection,
while root extracted in ethanol would likely decrease and improve symptoms if
used to treat a rhinovirus infection. From this, we can begin to understand and
decipher the controversy surrounding the therapeutic efficacy of
Echinacea where different plant parts and extraction
methods will likely produce significantly different physiological responses.
(4103) Acupuncture Versus Usual Care in the Abbott Northwestern Emergency
Department: A Feasibility Randomized Trial
Whitney L Wunderlich, MA1, Adam Reinstein, MAOM LAc1, Kristen H
Griffin, MA, MPH1, Rachael L Rivard, MPH1, Michael Finch,
PhD2, Chris E Kapsner, MD3 and Jeffery A Dusek,
PhD3
1Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Children's Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
3Stckbridge, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: Our prior observational research demonstrated that
acupuncture was acceptable to patients and clinical providers in the Abbott
Northwestern Emergency Department (ANW ED). We now evaluate the feasibility of
conducting a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of acupuncture versus usual care
in the ANW ED prior to a future multi-site RCT across the BraveNet
Practice-Based Research Network (PBRN).
Results: During the 8-month study period, 418 patients were screened
for study eligibility: including but not limited to pain ≥4. Following
screening, 59 were determined eligible, and 46 consented and were randomized to
the study arms (23 to acupuncture, 23 to usual care). Those randomized to
acupuncture reported a pre-treatment score of 8.18 (SD 1.62), a 60-min
post-treatment decrease of 3.0 units (SD 2.51) and a decrease at ED discharge of
2.71 units (SD 1.86). Those randomized to usual care reported a pre-treatment
score of 7.91 (SD 1.41), a 60-min post-treatment decrease of 1.56 units (SD
2.37) and a decrease at ED discharge of 2.53 units (SD 2.27). Since the aim of
the RCT was feasibility of enrollment/retention and refinement of study
procedures, between-group analyses were not appropriate nor conducted.
Conclusions: Results from this feasibility RCT indicate successful
enrollment/retention and that conduct of the RCT was acceptable to patient flow
within the ANW ED. The success of this feasibility RCT indicates that a future
multi-site RCT across the BraveNet PBRN is both achievable and warranted.
(4105) Qualitative Evaluation of a Residential Yoga-Based Program for Frontline
Professionals
Tegan Reeves, MS1, Mindy Miraglia, MS2, Jeff A Dusek,
PhD2, Lisa A Conboy, ScD3, Edi Pasalis, MBA4,
Sat Bir S Khalsa, PhD4 and Natalie L Trent, PhD4
1University of Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee
2Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health, Stockbridge, Massachusetts
3Boston, Massachusetts
4Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts
Abstract
Purpose: The present study was a qualitative evaluation of Kripalu
Center for Yoga & Health’s 5-day residential yoga-based program, called RISE
(resilience, integration, self-awareness, engagement), for frontline
professionals. The quantitative evaluation of the RISE program for psychological
health and healthy behaviors has been published elsewhere.
Results: Qualitative analyses using grounded theory revealed 5 major
themes, related to improvements in psychological health and workplace dynamics:
(1) increased resilience, particularly related to decreased levels of stress,
(2) increased self-compassion and self-care, (3) experiential mindfulness, (4)
continued use of inner resources/tools, such as breathing exercises, and (5) the
advantages of a multiplier effect, which is defined as sharing the practices
with colleagues and clients.
Conclusions: The frontline professional participants of the RISE
program described continued use of yoga-based concepts, skills, and practices
that influenced their improvements in psychological health and well-being.
Furthermore, participants reported sharing the practices with others as a means
to multiply the impact and potentially reinforce their own practice. Future
research will explore factors that facilitated the RISE participants to use of
these practices beyond the RISE training.
(4106) The Pain Management Inventory: Patterns of Conventional and Complementary
Non-pharmacological Therapy Use in Minnesota National Guard Veterans
Melvin Donaldson, MS1, Elizabeth S Goldsmith, MD, MS2, Lynsey R
Miron, PhD, MA3, Erin E Krebs, MD, MPH4, Melissa A Polusny,
PhD3 and Rich F MacLehose, PhD5
1Minneapolis, Minnesota
2Epidemiology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
3Department of Psychiatry, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis,
Minnesota
4Department of Medicine, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis,
Minnesota
5Minneapolis, Minnesota
Abstract
Purpose: There is a growing body of research regarding complementary
and integrative health approaches (CIH) in pain management, but the
heterogeneity of techniques included in prior studies challenges the external
validity of findings. We therefore developed and piloted the Pain Management
Inventory (PMI)—a checklist of 20 common conventional and complementary
non-pharmacological health approaches. The long-term goal of the present study
is to facilitate standardized reporting of non-pharmacologic pain management in
research.
Results: Among all respondents, 74% endorsed use of any PMI
approach, 43% any practitioner-delivered CIH (P-CIH), 26% any active/self CIH
(A-CIH), and 15% both P-CIH and A-CIH (A&P-CIH). Forty-one percent reported
chronic pain. The best fit model had 6 classes: low PMI use (51% of respondents;
class mean different CIH modalities endorsed = 0.4), exercise users (23%; 1.1),
psychotherapy users (5%; 2.2), multi-modal P-CIH users (12%; 2.6), multi-modal
A-CIH users (6%; 3.2), and high-use mixed A&P-CIH (5%; 5.4).
Conclusions: These findings suggest the existence of 6 subgroups of
veterans characterized by their use of mixing multiple non-pharmacological
health approaches. Over one-fourth of respondents reported using multiple CIH
modalities over the previous year. We will discuss implications for patients
with chronic pain. Future studies will examine the generalizability of the
latent classes identified with the PMI in other patient populations.
(4107) Chronic Epistaxis Successfully Treated by an Alternative Health Approach –
A Case Report
Yumin Cho, PhD1 and Ming-Dong Li, MD, PhD, LAc1
1Los Angeles, California
Abstract
Purpose: To address the alternative treatment for chronic epistaxis
by using herbal medicine, acupuncture and a self-care plan.
Results: The symptom of epistaxis was improved after the herbal
treatment, with only one 5-min bleeding episode occurring the first month of
treatment. This recurrence of his epistaxis was during his vacation when he
forgot to take his herbal treatment for 3 days. The patient has had no nosebleed
and any issues after restarting the continuous use of the herbal capsules. No
bleeding episodes have been observed during a follow-up investigation over 8
months.
Conclusions: The alternative health approach including herbal
medicine and acupuncture combined with a self-care plan may be the effective
treatment in chronic epistaxis.
(4108) Patient Safety Surveillance on CAM Therapies: Challenges and
Priorities
Ram Vempati, PhD1
1Yoga Sangeeta, Sunnyvale, California
Abstract
Purpose: The patient safety of complementary and alternative
medicine (CAM) is a primary concern of the public because CAM-Drug interactions
often overlooked. However, patient safety surveillance activities largely have
been focused on conventional medicines, and the current models of
pharmacovigilance and its science and processes have developed in relation to
pharmaceutical synthetic drugs. Applying the existing pharmacovigilance models
and its tools from pharmaceutical industries to monitor the patient safety of
herbal medicines, Ayurvedic preparations, other CAM therapies practiced in
vulnerable patient population such as cancer patients, child and elderly
population presents unique challenges in addition to those described for
conventional medicines, and it is important that all stakeholders understand
these. There is an increasing awareness at several levels of the need to develop
pharmacovigilance practices for herbal medicines, including Ayurvedic medicines.
Awareness has arisen not only because of the extensive use of herbal medicines,
including Ayurveda, but also because in recent years there have been several
high-profile herbal safety concerns, which have had an impact on public health.
Research into the safety of CAM therapies presents challenges. Per WHO
Traditional Medicine Strategy 2014–2023, it is clear from the global review that
there are many opportunities and challenges in relation to national policies,
law and regulation, quality, safety, and effectiveness of CAM therapies. The
described risks associated with CAM products/therapies, practitioners, and
self-care are mainly, use of poor quality, adulterated or counterfeit products;
Unqualified practitioners; Misdiagnosis, delayed diagnosis, or failure to use
effective conventional treatments; Exposure to misleading or unreliable
information; Direct adverse events, side effects or unwanted treatment
interactions. It is highly pertinent to promote the safety and quality of CAM by
expanding the knowledge base, and providing guidance on regulatory and quality
assurance standards notably by assessment of products and services,
qualification of practitioners, methodology and criteria for evaluating
efficacy. Based on available literature and CAM policy decision makers, problems
in implementing CAM patient safety surveillance must be addressed which include:
the apparently low incidence of harmful incidents or CAM practitioners ignoring
the serious adverse events; the limited regulatory setting for CAM practice
including the omission of CAM interventions from most mainstream adverse event
reporting schemes; the widespread perception of CAM as natural and safe; the
complexity of CAM therapies; interactions between CAM and Pharmaceutical drugs;
professional self-satisfaction; and the special challenges unique to specific
CAM therapies such as the concept of a “healing crisis.”
Conclusions: The CAM researchers reached a consensus that the
priority for CAM safety research is active surveillance, or the measurement of
actual harm from CAM. The second priority is research into beliefs and attitudes
of practitioners, public and professional organizations, and what influences
those attitudes; the final research area covers the procedures used to ensure
safe practice, and their effectiveness.
(4109) Level of Evidence and Quality of Reports of Cranial and Visceral
Osteopathic Treatment Trials
Chantal Morin, PhD1 and Isabelle Gaboury, PhD1
1Universite de Sherbrooke, Longueuil, Quebec, Canada
Abstract
Purpose: Over the last 40 years, empirical osteopathy-related trial
publications have doubled almost every 5 years. Trials on cranial and visceral
osteopathic treatments represent more than one-third of this scientific output.
The objectives of this project were (1) to assess the quality of reports of
studies on cranial and visceral osteopathic treatment identified through a
systematic review of all osteopathy-related trial publications, (2) to determine
the level of evidence of these treatments by health problems, and (3) to
identify criteria for which the quality of reports remains to be improved.
Results: 106 and 51 studies were examined reporting respectively on
cranial and visceral osteopathic treatment. Level of evidence was judged high
(meta-analysis or randomized controlled trial) for 44 of the 72 health problems
for which an osteopathic treatment was used. 38% and 25% of the cranial and
visceral treatment trials, respectively, scored high in terms of quality of
reports. Areas for improvement included reporting on sociodemographic
characteristics of the participants, differences between groups prior to the
intervention (for the non-randomized controlled trial studies), blinding, and
adverse events.
Conclusions: Less than one third of the trials retrieved presented a
high quality of reporting. Although this is similar what was found for
conventional medicine and other complementary medicine therapies, this study
shows that efforts are needed to further increase the quality of reports in the
osteopathy field. It also identifies health problems for which more rigorous
studies are still required.
(4110) An Integrative Clinical Initiative to Treat Patients Diagnosed With
Microvascular Coronary Dysfunction
Grant Antoine, ND1, Arvin Jenab, ND1 and Shaista Malik, MD,
PhD, MPH1
1Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine, Costa Mesa, California
Abstract
Purpose: Microvascular coronary dysfunction (MCD) is a
multifactorial disorder that has become increasingly recognized as a cause of
ischemia and angina associated with non-obstructive coronary disease. To date,
there are no specific guidelines for the assessment or treatment of MCD,
underlining the need for development of MCD focused clinical programs. This
position paper aims to explore evidence-based strategies for the management of
MCD, and to propose clinical initiatives from which to base multi-center
collaboration for future study.
Results: Current understanding implicates endothelial dysfunction
(ED) as the primary mechanism by which blood flow is restricted. As a result of
ED, the microvasculature of the heart becomes damaged and less compliant,
resulting in inefficient exchange of gases and metabolites. Preliminary
literature review also draws strong correlations between autonomic
dysregulation, hormone deficiencies, and impaired cardiomyocyte metabolism in
the development and progression of MCD. Current treatment options for MCD rely
heavily on standard management of CAD ischemic disease and include
pharmacotherapy with anti-hypertensives, anti-anginals, and statins.
Conclusions: An integrative treatment approach that includes
lifestyle modification, phytotherapy, nutraceutical supplementation,
pharmacologic treatment, hormone replacement therapy, mind/body therapies, and
cardiac rehabilitation could potentially reduce risk, improve quality of life,
and decrease morbidity and mortality associated with MCD.
(4111) Military Health Literacy Leadership Theory
Angela McConnell, PhD1
1Woodbridge, Virginia
Abstract
Purpose: To educate on a new concept in successful intraprofessional
integration of military/veteran collaboration. I offer the Military Health
Literacy Leadership Theory (MHLLT) to promote productive effective
communication, collaboration, and coordination between health officials,
civilian healthcare providers, and military/Veterans leaders and Veteran
population. The MHLLT incorporates and synthesizes systems and social network
theory; collaborative leadership theory; value-based leadership theory; and the
Be, Know, Do Military leadership model. It advances knowledge, abilities, and
practical implementation methods for effective partnering and work with military
leadership and effective communication and outreach to support the continuum of
comprehensive health care for the Veteran/family civilian population.
Integrative health leadership from a systems perspective does a comprehensive
job of collaborating, coordinating, communicating, and partnering among actors
and stakeholders from the multiple levels of government and throughout the
community. This includes federal, state, and local government agencies,
healthcare providers, urgent and emergency responders, and the general
population. However, gaps are found around who, how, and when to work with
military leaders. Additionally, there is no information on how and when to
target the Veteran/family civilian population to provide public health care and
support. Health literacy is the ability to obtain, read, understand, and use
healthcare information to make appropriate healthcare decisions. Health
officials may not be aware of their local community Veteran and family health
needs, or if they are aware how best to target this population to provide
necessary effective outreach, support, and services. A fundamental part of
improving this gap in service and situation involves how public health leaders
work with local military/Veteran leadership and organizations. There may be
resistance on both sides of this leadership equation due to lack of
understanding each other’s culture, language, scope of work, missions, and rules
of engagement to include knowing the current supportive federal, state and local
policies and initiatives (Copeland & Sutherland, 2010; Kudler &
Straits-Troster, n.d.; Kuehner, 2012; Muerer, Bonner, Rowe, Morris, &
Zgabay, n.d.; Pew Research Social & Demographic Trends, 2011;
Straits-Troster & Goodale, 2011). In today’s environment of fewer resources
and funding, we need to develop and utilize community health partnerships that
include public health, nonprofit/profit healthcare providers, Department of
Defense (DoD) (eg, military installations and military treatment facilities),
Veteran Health Administration (VHA), and local, state, and federal government
agencies/programs as necessitated (Copeland & Sutherland, 2010; Kuehner,
2012; Muerer, Bonner, Rowe, Morris & Zgabay, n.d.; Straits-Troster &
Goodale, 2011). These partnerships allow the ability to be creative, innovative,
and resourceful through leveraging each other’s expertise and resources in order
to meet the joint specific mission of caring for our Veteran population.
Creating and leveraging partnerships and joint programs are necessary due to the
increasing number of Veterans reintegrating into the civilian population and
their associated challenges and health conditions that can negatively impact
themselves, their families, jobs, community, and overall quality of life
(Berglass & Harrell, 2012; Chretien & Chretien, 2013; Coalition of Human
Services Public Health District, 2014; Copeland & Sutherland, 2010; Deloitte
Consulting, 2014; Department of Veteran Services, n.d; Institute of Medicine.
2013; Institute for Policy & Governance & Dunkenberger, 2010; Kemp &
Bossarte, 2012; Muerer, Bonner, Rowe, Morris & Zgabay, n.d; Pew Research
Social & Demographic Trends, 2011; Sayer, Noorbaloochi, Frazier, Carlson,
Gravely & Murdoch, 2010; Straits-Troster & Goodale, 2011; White House,
2011). It is essential for healthcare leaders to know how, who, and when to work
with military/Veteran organization leaders and how and when to provide public
health and other healthcare/urgent care support to their Veteran/family
population as part of their comprehensive systems approach to public health. To
support these abilities and skills, they need to understand the culture,
language, and best practices of the military. I propose a Military Health
Literacy Model of Leadership that includes educating, exercising, and outreach
tools and programs for public health leaders that will achieve two main
objectives (Keian Weld, Padden, Ricciardi & Garmon Bibb, 2009). First, it
will give public health leaders the ability to learn and understand military
language, culture, and DoD/VHA best practices and resources in order to work
with military/Veteran leaders from a shared vantage point thus providing them
common ground. Second, it will give public health leaders the information and
tools necessary for effective outreach and communication with their
Veteran/family population in order to provide the necessary support and
services. I propose a new public health leadership theory that promotes the
ability to obtain, read, and understand military culture, language, and best
practices to better collaborate, communicate, and coordinate with military
leadership, and further the ability to effectively communicate and provide
outreach and services for the Veteran/family population.
Results: Outcomes include (1) greater understanding of the military
and veteran tenants that are required for effective, efficient communications
between military/veteran health/medicine/emergency response sectors and it's
civilian counterparts and collaborators, (2) to actively engage leadership to
include this education and practice within their areas of public health and
integrative health leadership, and (3) to initiate and inspire action steps to
incorporate Military Health Literacy into community/regional strategic planning
in collaboration with military and government facilities/counterparts.
Conclusions: The Military Health Literacy Leadership Theory and
Model will fill a gap in public health leaders’ ability to effectively outreach
to the Veteran population in order to meet specific and general needs, and
efficiently work with military leadership on any joint civilian/military
partnership and program. A fundamental part in closing this gap involves
creating a supportive environment and common ground from which public health and
the military/Veterans can operate. An environment that promotes mutual knowledge
and understanding of culture, language, scope of work, missions, and rules of
engagement to include knowing the current supportive federal, state, and local
policies and initiatives. With fewer resources and increased missions and
mandates, we need to have the flexibility and options to develop and utilize
community health partnerships between public health, nonprofit/profit healthcare
providers, Department of Defense, Veteran Health Administration and local,
state, and federal government agencies/programs. It is essential for public
health and integrative health leaders to know how, who, and when to work with
military/Veteran organization leaders and how and when to provide public health
support to their Veteran/family population as part of their comprehensive
systems approach to public health. To support these abilities and skills, they
should have the requisite knowledge of military culture, language, and best
practices of the military. The Military Health Literacy Model of Leadership
supports this through achieving two main objectives. First, it will give public
health leaders the ability to learn and understand military culture, language,
and DoD/VHA best practices and resources in order to work with military/Veteran
leaders from shared vantage point thus giving them common ground. Second, it
will give public health leaders the information and tools necessary for
effective outreach and communication with their Veteran/family population in
order to provide the necessary support and services.
Note: References are available on request.
(4112) Effect of Chamomile (Matricaria recutita) Syrup on Chemotherapy-Induced
Neutropenia: A Randomized Triple-Blind Placebo Controlled Clinical Trial
Majid Nimrouzi, MD, MPH, PhD1, Mehdi Shahriari, MD1 and Babak
Daneshfard, MD, PhDc
1Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Islamic Republic of
Iran
Abstract
Purpose: Acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) is the most common
malignancy of childhood. Chemotherapy-induced neutropenia as a serious
hematologic toxicity is one of the main treatment complications in these
patients. We hypothesized that an herbal formulation of chamomile could be
effective in management of neutropenia.
Results: A total number of 20 patients in each group (40 in total)
finished the study. Comparison of longitudinal changes between the groups
revealed higher level of WBC (P-value = .008) and absolute
neutrophil count (P-value = .038) in the test group. In
addition, patients in chamomile group had shorter course of hospitalization in
comparison to control group (2 days on average). No adverse effect was
reported.
Conclusions: Using chamomile syrup as a complementary treatment in
pediatric oncology patients can improve their immunity and minimize their
chemotherapy complications, specially neutropenia.
(4113) Medical Humanities in the Medical School Curriculum
Kimberly Pham, BA1 and Robert Hage, MD, PhD1
1St George's University, St George's, Grenada
Abstract
Purpose:
The care of the sick unfolds in stories. The effective practice of health
care requires the ability to recognize, absorb, interpret, and act on
the stories and plights of others.
—Columbia University Narrative Medicine, webpage
St George’s University (SGU) graduates undertake residencies in human and
veterinary medicine across the United States, Canada, Great Britain, and beyond.
Recognizing the potential for an integrative medicine approach to improve
patient and population health locally and globally, SGU incorporates integrative
medicine into aspects of its human and veterinary medical curricula, both
formally and informally. The successes of integrative medicine in improving
health are documented in, among others, stories that capture the lived
experiences of those involved in illness and its management. Medical humanities
is one means of understanding and sharing those stories. Medical humanities move
beyond objective scientific knowledge and expose students and clinicians to
emotional and other subjective responses to health, illness, and healthcare. In
doing so, medical humanities can improve patient care, patient satisfaction, and
physician job satisfaction by bringing reflection and meaning to challenging
experiences in the healthcare arena. We use the lens of integrative medicine to
examine how medical humanities offer SGU medical and veterinary students a space
to hone observational, reflective, and narrative skills as they move towards
their clinical training and practice. SGU’s School of Medicine (SOM) offers
medical humanities courses at some of its hospitals. Additionally, ad hoc
activities through an Integrative Medicine Selective offered to Basic Sciences
students exposes students to opportunities to reflect on the value of medical
humanities to their future practice. We outline some of these activities and
reflect on how these may enhance the future and practice of integrative
medicine.
(4114) Yoga Therapy and Integrative Medicine: Oncology Perspective
Chidananda Murthy, BT, ND, DY, DPPHC, PhD, YO1 and Ram Vempati,
PhD2
1Wellness Center, Monticello, Sullivan County, New York
2Yoga Sangeeta, Sunnyvale, California
Abstract
Purpose: Yoga is one of the fastest growing health and wellness
sooqs in the world. Within this field, a specialized therapeutic discipline
known as Yoga Therapy has emerged. In this complementary treatment approach, the
specialized practice of yoga is applied towards relieving and healing specific
disease conditions. With its remarkable results, this revolutionary approach to
an ancient practice is rapidly gaining tremendous respect among medical doctors
and health care professionals. Several clinical studies have shown that yoga can
be integrated with modern medicine for many disease conditions including some
oncological conditions. This integrated medical approach using yoga as an
adjuvant therapy, as applied in some oncology conditions, has been shown to help
patients at both early and advanced stages of the cancer experience to minimize
their pain and fatigue while increasing their psychological strength to fight
cancer, overcome denial, and for relaxation. Ethical dilemmas arising in setting
priorities among interventions and among individuals in need of care are most
acute when needs are great and resources few. Under ethical considerations, yoga
cannot be introduced as a stand-alone treatment for cancer conditions. Hence, it
can only be applied as an adjuvant treatment along with an established medical
regimen. However, some of earlier clinical studies lacked in proper clinical
study protocols as per ICH guidelines in terms of collecting quality of data and
efficacy and safety measures.
Conclusions: It is the need of the hour to discuss role of yoga in
the realm of integrative medicine especially from an oncology perspective.
Furthermore, while designing clinical trials as well as yoga treatment
protocols, it is highly recommended to follow ICH guidelines for collecting
efficacy and safety clinical data.