Differences in post-operative complications after reconstruction for congenital biliary dilatation in a single institution-Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy versus hepaticoduodenostomy -

Until now, there have been no practical clinical guidelines for congenital biliary dilatation (CBD). In this review article, the Japanese Study Group on Congenital Biliary Dilatation (JSCBD) propose to establish clinical practice guidelines for CBD. Because the evidence-based literature is relatively small, we decided to create guidelines based on the consensus of experts, using the medical literature for reference. A total of 20 clinical questions (CQs) were considered by the members of the editorial committee responsible for the guidelines. The CQs included the distinct aspects of CBD: (1) Concepts and Pathology (three CQs); (2) Diagnosis (six CQs); (3) Pancreaticobiliary Complications (three CQs); Treatments and Prognosis (eight CQs). Each statements and comments for CQs were made by the guidelines committee members. CQs were finally approved after review by members of the editorial committee and the guidelines evaluation board of CBD. These guidelines were created to provide assistance in the clinical practice of CBD management; their contents focus on clinical utility, and they include general information on CBD to make this disease more widely recognized.

Excision has been established as a standard management practice for choledochal cysts in the last few decades. The two most commonly performed methods of reconstruction after excision are hepaticoduodenostomy (HD) and Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy (HJ), of which the HJ is favored by most surgeons. Evidence concerning the optimal method of reconstruction is, however, sparse.

Choledochal cysts are dilations of the biliary tree. Although commonly reported in Asian populations, the incidence outside of Asia is as low as 1:150 000. The largest series of patients with choledochal cyst disease outside of Asia is this one, studying 70 patients treated in Vancouver between 1971 and 2003. This was a retrospective chart review. In all, 19 paediatric and 51 adult patients were evaluated; 21% of paediatric and 25% of adult patients were Asian. All paediatric patients had type I or IV cysts, whereas adult patients represented the different subtypes. Abdominal pain was the presenting symptom in 79% of children and 88% of adults, vomiting was present in 42% of children and 63% of adults and jaundice was seen in 31.5% of children and 39% of adults. Ultrasound was used in 94.7% of children, and ERCP in 80% of adults. In all, 84% of paediatric patients, 100% of adult patients with type I cysts and 85.7% of adult patients with type IV cysts received complete cyst excision and Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy. Complications in both groups were low. Although Vancouver does have a large Asian population, this does not explain how common choledochal cysts are in this city. Although some authors argue that paediatric and adult disease are caused by different aetiologies, presentation patterns in our study between the two groups were very similar. We recommend complete cyst excision and Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy as the surgery of choice, and advocate early surgery after diagnosis to promote ease of surgery and prevention of future complications.