Introduction
This chapter focuses on the diagnosis, treatment, and control of large animal diseases
primarily affecting the nervous system. In general, the principles of clinical neurology
and their application to large animal neurology has not kept pace with the study of
neurology in humans and small animals, although remarkable progress has been made
in equine neurology over the last 30 years. To a large extent this shortfall is caused
by the failure of large-animal clinicians to relate observed clinical signs to a neuroanatomical
location of the lesion. In many cases this failure has been because of adverse environmental
circumstances, or the large size or nature of the animal, all of which adversely impact
the quality of the neurologic examination. It may be very difficult to do an adequate
neurologic examination on an ataxic belligerent beef cow that is still able to walk
and attack the examiner. An aggressive, paretic bull in broad sunlight can be a daunting
subject if one wants to examine the pupillary light reflex; ophthalmoscopic examination
of the fundus of the eye in a convulsing steer in a feedlot pen can be an exasperating
task. Thus at one end of the spectrum is the clinical examination of pigs affected
with nervous system disease, which is limited to an elementary clinical examination
and necropsy examination. At the other end, neurologic examination of the horse with
nervous system disease is very advanced. The global occurrence of bovine spongiform
encephalopathy (BSE) has highlighted the importance of accurate clinical diagnosis
in adult cattle with neurologic abnormalities.
Discrete lesions of the central nervous system (CNS) resulting in well-defined neurologic
signs are not common in agricultural animals. Many diseases are characterized by diffuse
neurologic lesions associated with bacteria, viruses, toxins, nutritional disorders,
and embryologic defects, and the clinical findings of each disease are similar. Rather
than attempting to localize lesions in the nervous system, large-animal practitioners
more commonly devote much of their time to attempting to identify whether an animal
has diffuse brain edema or increased intracranial pressure, as in polioencephalomalacia
(PEM); whether it has clinical signs of asymmetric brainstem dysfunction and depression
of the reticular activating system, as in listeriosis; or whether the dysfunction
is at the neuromuscular level, as in hypomagnesemic tetany.
Radiographic examination, including myelography, is not used routinely as a diagnostic
aid in large-animal practice. The collection of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) from the
different species and ages of large animal without causing damage to the animal or
contaminating the sample with blood is a technique that few large-animal veterinarians
have mastered. However, the collection of CSF from the lumbosacral cistern is not
difficult if the animals are adequately restrained, and the information obtained from
analysis of CSF can be very useful in the differential diagnosis of diseases of the
brain and spinal cord. Referral veterinary centers are now providing detailed neurologic
examinations of horses with nervous system disease, and the clinical and pathologic
experience has expanded the knowledge base of large-animal clinical neurology.
In spite of the difficulties, the large-animal practitioner has an obligation to make
the best diagnosis possible using the diagnostic aids available. The principles of
large-animal neurology are presented in this chapter, and the major objective is to
recognize the common diseases of the nervous system by correlating the clinical findings
with the location and nature of the lesion. Accurate neuroanatomical localization
of the lesion(s) remains the fundamental requirement for creating a differential diagnosis
list and diagnostic and treatment plan.
A disease such as rabies has major public health implications, and it is important
for the veterinarian to be able to recognize the disease as early as possible and
to minimize human contact. It is also important to be able to recognize treatable
diseases of the nervous system, such as polioencephalomalacia (PEM), listeriosis,
and nervous ketosis, and to differentiate these diseases from untreatable and globally
important diseases such as Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE).
The nontreatable diseases must also be recognized as such, and slaughter for salvage
or euthanasia recommended if necessary. There must be a major emphasis on prognosis
because it is inhumane and uneconomic to hospitalize or continue to treat an adult
cow or horse with incurable neurologic disease for an indefinite period. If they are
recumbent, the animals commonly develop secondary complications such as decubitus
ulcers and other self-inflicted injuries because of repeated attempts to rise. Very
few diseases of the nervous system of farm animals are treatable successfully over
an extended period of time. This has become particularly important in recent years
with the introduction of legislation prohibiting the slaughter of animals that have
been treated with antibiotics until after a certain withdrawal period, which may vary
from 5 to 30 days. This creates even greater pressure on the clinician to make a rapid,
inexpensive, and accurate diagnosis and prognosis.
Because of limitations in the neurologic examination of large animals, there must
be much more emphasis on the history and epidemiologic findings. Many of the diseases
have epidemiologic characteristics that give the clinician a clue to the possible
causes, thus helping to narrow the number of possibilities. For example, viral encephalomyelitis
of horses occurs with a peak incidence during the insect season, lead poisoning is
most common in calves after they have been turned out on to pasture, and PEM occurs
in grain-fed feedlot cattle and sheep.
The functions of the nervous system are directed at the maintenance of the body's
spatial relationship with its environment. These functions are performed by the several
divisions of the nervous system including the following:
•
Sensorimotor system, responsible for the maintenance of normal posture and gait
•
Autonomic nervous system, controlling the activity of smooth muscle and endocrine
glands, and thus the internal environment of the body
•
Largely sensory system of special senses
•
Psychic system, which controls the animal's mental state
The nervous system is essentially a reactive one geared to the reception of internal
and external stimuli and their translation into activity and consciousness; it is
dependent on the integrity of both the afferent and efferent pathways. This integrative
function makes it often difficult to determine in a sick animal whether abnormalities
are present in the nervous system; the musculoskeletal system; or acid-base, electrolyte,
and energy status. Accordingly, the first step when examining an animal with apparent
abnormalities in the nervous system is to determine whether other relevant systems
are functioning normally. A decision to implicate the nervous system is often made
on the exclusion of other systems.
The nervous system itself is not independent of other organs, and its functional capacity
is regulated to a large extent by the function of other systems, particularly the
cardiovascular system. Inadequate oxygen delivery caused by cardiovascular disease
commonly leads to altered cerebral function because of the dependence of the brain
on an adequate oxygen supply.
It is important to distinguish between primary and secondary diseases of the nervous
system because both the prognosis and the treatment will differ with the cause.
In primary disease of the nervous system, the lesion is usually an anatomic one with
serious, long-range consequences. In secondary disease, the lesion, at least in its
early stages, is more likely to be functional and therefore more responsive to treatment,
provided the defect in the primary organ can be corrected. The clinical findings that
should arouse suspicion of neurologic disturbance include abnormalities in the three
main functions of the system.
Posture and Gait
An animal's ability to maintain a normal posture and to proceed with a normal gait
depends largely on the tone of the skeletal muscle but also on the efficiency of the
postural reflexes. Abnormalities of posture and gait are among the best indications
of nervous system disease because these functions are governed largely by the coordination
of nervous activity. Along with contributing to posture and gait, skeletal muscle
tone is characteristic in its own right. However, its assessment in animals is subject
to great inaccuracy because of our inability to request complete voluntary relaxation
by the patient. In humans it is a very valuable index of nervous system efficiency,
but in animals it has serious limitations. The most difficult step whenever there
is a defect of gait or posture is to decide whether the defect originates in the skeleton,
the muscles, or the nervous system.
Sensory Perceptivity
Tests of sensory perception in animals can only be objective and never subjective,
as they can be in humans, and any test used in animals is based heavily on the integrity
of the motor system.
Mental State
Depression or enhancement of the psychic state is not difficult to judge, particularly
if the animal's owner is observant and accurate. A helpful method for evaluating mental
state is to answer the question: Is the animal responding appropriately for its environment?
The difficulty usually lies in deciding whether the abnormality is caused by primary
or secondary changes in the brain.
Principles of Nervous Dysfunction
Nervous tissue is limited in the ways in which it can respond to noxious influences.
Because of its essentially coordinating function, the transmission of impulses along
nerve fibers can be enhanced or depressed in varying degrees, with the extreme degree
being complete failure of transmission. Because of the structure of the system, in
which nerve impulses are passed from neuron to neuron by relays at the nerve cells,
there may also be excessive or decreased intrinsic activity of individual cells giving
rise to an increase or decrease in nerve impulses discharged by the cells. The end
result is the same whether the disturbance is one of conduction or discharge, and
these are the only two ways in which disease of the nervous system is manifested.
Nervous dysfunction can thus be broadly divided into two forms, depressed activity
and exaggerated activity. These can be further subdivided into four common modes of
nervous dysfunction; excitation (irritation) signs, release of inhibition signs, paresis
or paralysis caused by tissue damage, and nervous shock.
Modes of Nervous Dysfunction
Excitation (Irritation) Signs
Increased activity of the reactor organ occurs when there is an increase in the number
of nerve impulses received either because of excitation of neurons or because of facilitation
of passage of stimuli.
The excitability of nerve cells can be increased by many factors, including stimulant
drugs, inflammation, and mild degrees of those influences that in a more severe form
may cause depression of excitability. Thus early or mild hypoxia may result in increased
excitability, whereas sustained or severe hypoxia will cause depression of function
or even death of the nerve cell.
Irritation phenomena may result from many causes, including inflammation of nervous
tissue associated with bacteria or viruses, certain nerve poisons, hypoxia, and edema.
In those diseases that cause an increase in intracranial pressure, irritation phenomena
result from interference with circulation and the development of local anemic hypoxia.
The major manifestations of irritation of nervous tissue are tetany, local muscle
tremor, and whole-body convulsions in the motor system and hyperesthesia and paresthesia
in the sensory system. For the most part the signs produced fluctuate in intensity
and may occur periodically as nervous energy is discharged and reaccumulated in the
nerve cells.
The area of increased excitability may be local or sufficiently generalized to affect
the entire body. Thus a local lesion in the brain may cause signs of excitatory nervous
dysfunction in one limb, and a more extensive lesion may cause a complete convulsion.
Release of Inhibition Signs
Exaggeration of normal nervous system activity occurs when lower nervous centers are
released from the inhibitory effects of higher centers. The classic example of a release
mechanism is experimental decerebrate rigidity caused by transection of the brainstem
between the colliculi of the midbrain. This results in an uninhibited extensor tonus
of all the antigravity muscles. The head and neck are extended markedly in a posture
of opisthotonus, and all four limbs in the quadruped are extended rigidly. The tonic
mechanism or myotactic reflex involving the lower motor neuron has been released from
the effects of the descending inhibitory upper motor neuron pathways.
Cerebellar ataxia is another example of inhibitory release. In the absence of cerebellar
control, combined limb movements are exaggerated in all modes of action including
rate, range, force, and direction. In general, release phenomena are present constantly
while the causative lesion operates, whereas excitatory phenomena fluctuate with the
building up and exhaustion of energy in the nerve cells.
Paresis or Paralysis Caused by Tissue Damage
Depression of activity can result from depression of metabolic activity of nerve cells,
and the terminal stage is complete paralysis when nervous tissue is destroyed. Such
depression of activity may result from failure of supply of oxygen and other essential
nutrients, either directly from their general absence or indirectly because of failure
of the local circulation. Infection of the nerve cell itself may cause initial excitation,
then depression of function, and finally complete paralysis when the nerve cell dies.
Signs of paralysis are constant and are manifested by muscular paresis or paralysis
when the motor system is affected and by hypoesthesia or anesthesia when the sensory
system is involved. Deprivation of metabolites and impairment of function by actual
invasion of nerve cells or by toxic depression of their activity produce temporary,
partial depression of function that is completely lost when the neurons are destroyed.
Nervous Shock
An acute lesion of the nervous system causes damage to nerve cells in the immediate
vicinity of the lesion but there may be, in addition, a temporary cessation of function
in parts of the nervous system not directly affected. The loss of function in these
areas is temporary and usually persists for only a few hours. Stunning is an obvious
example. Recovery from the flaccid unconsciousness of nervous shock may reveal the
presence of permanent residual signs caused by the destruction of nervous tissue.
Determining the type of lesion is difficult because of the limited range of modes
of reaction to injury in the nervous system. Irritation signs may be caused by bacterial
or virus infection, by pressure, by vascular disturbance or general hypoxia, by poisons,
and by hypoglycemia. It is often impossible to determine whether the disturbance is
structural or functional. Degenerative lesions produce mainly signs of paresis or
paralysis but unless there are signs of local nervous tissue injury, such as facial
nerve paralysis, paraplegia, or local tremor, the disturbance may only be definable
as a general disturbance of a part of the nervous system. Encephalopathy is an all-embracing
diagnosis, but it is often impossible to go beyond it unless other clinical data,
including signalment of the animal, epidemiology, and systemic signs, are assessed
or special tests, including radiographic examination and examination of the CSF, are
undertaken.
Some information can be derived from a study of the sign-time relationship in the
development of nervous disease. A lesion that develops suddenly tends to produce maximum
disturbance of function, sometimes accompanied by nervous shock. Slowly developing
lesions permit a form of compensation in that undamaged pathways and centers may assume
some of the functions of the damaged areas. Even in rapidly developing lesions partial
recovery may occur in time, but the emphasis is on maximum depression of function
at the beginning of the disease. Thus a slowly developing tumor of the spinal cord
will have a different pattern of clinical development from that resulting from an
acute traumatic lesion of the vertebrae. Another aspect of the rapidity of onset of
the lesion is that irritation phenomena are more likely to occur when the onset is
rapid and less common when the onset is slow.
Clinical Manifestations of Diseases of the Nervous System
The major clinical signs of nervous system dysfunction include the following:
•
Altered mentation
•
Involuntary movements
•
Abnormal posture and gait
•
Paresis or paralysis
•
Altered sensation
•
Blindness
•
Abnormalities of the autonomic nervous system
Altered Mentation
Excitation States
Excitation states include mania, frenzy, and aggressive behavior, which are manifestations
of general excitation of the cerebral cortex. The areas of the cortex that govern
behavior, intellect, and personality traits in humans are the frontal lobes and temporal
cortex. The clinical importance of these areas, which are poorly developed in animals,
is not great. The frontal lobes, temporal cortex, and limbic system are highly susceptible
to influences such as hypoxia and increased intracranial pressure.
Mania
In mania the animal acts in a bizarre way and appears to be unaware of its surroundings.
Maniacal actions include licking, chewing of foreign material and sometimes themselves,
abnormal voice, constant bellowing, apparent blindness, walking into strange surroundings,
drunken gait, and aggressiveness in normally docile animals. A state of delirium cannot
be diagnosed in animals, but mental disorientation is an obvious component of mania.
Diseases characterized by mania include the following:
•
Encephalitis, e.g., the furious form of rabies, Aujeszky's disease in cattle (pseudorabies,
mad itch)
•
Degenerative diseases of the brain, e.g., mannosidosis, early PEM, poisoning by Astragalus
sp.
•
Toxic and metabolic diseases of brain, e.g., nervous ketosis, pregnancy toxemia, acute
lead poisoning, poisoning with carbon tetrachloride, and severe hepatic insufficiency,
especially in horses
Frenzy
Frenzy is characterized by violent activity and with little regard for surroundings.
The animal's movements are uncontrolled and dangerous to other animals in the group
and to human attendants, and are often accompanied by aggressive physical attacks.
Examples of frenzy in diseases of the nervous system include the following:
•
Encephalomyelitides, e.g., Aujeszky's disease.
•
Toxic and metabolic brain disease, e.g., hypomagnesemic tetany of cattle and sheep,
poisoning with ammoniated roughage in cattle.
Examples of frenzy in diseases of other body systems include the following:
•
Acute pain of colic in horses.
•
Extreme cutaneous irritation, e.g., photosensitization in cattle. Apparently reasonless
panic, especially in individual horses or groups of cattle, is difficult to differentiate
from real mania. A horse taking fright at a botfly or a swarm of bees and a herd of
cattle stampeding at night are examples.
Aggressive Behavior
Aggression and a willingness to attack other animals, humans, and inert objects is
characteristic of the early stages of rabies and Aujeszky's disease in cattle, in
sows during postparturient hysteria, in the later stages of chronic hypoxia in any
species, and in some mares and cows with granulosa-cell tumors of the ovary. The latter
are accompanied by signs of masculinization and erratic or continuous estrus. It is
often difficult to differentiate between an animal with a genuine change in personality
and one that is in pain or is physically handicapped, e.g., pigs and cattle with atlantoaxial
arthroses.
Depressive States
Depressive mental states include somnolence, lassitude, narcolepsy/catalepsy, syncope,
and coma. They are all manifestations of depression of cerebral cortical function
in various degrees and occur as a result of those influences that depress nervous
system function generally, as well as those that specifically affect behavior, probably
via the limbic system. It is not possible to classify accurately the types of depressive
abnormality and relate them to specific causes, but the common occurrences in farm
animals are listed next.
Depression Leading to Coma
In all species this may result from the following:
•
Encephalomyelitis and encephalomalacia
•
Toxic and metabolic diseases of the brain such as uremia, hypoglycemia, hepatic insufficiency,
toxemia, septicemia, and most toxins that damage tissues generally
•
Hypoxia of the brain, as in peripheral circulatory failure of periparturient hypocalcemia
in dairy cows
•
Heat stroke
•
Specific poisons that cause somnolence, including bromides, amitraz in horses, methyl
alcohol, Filix mas (male fern), and kikuyu grass
Syncope
The sudden onset of fainting (syncope) may occur as a result of the following:
•
Acute circulatory and heart failure leading to acute cerebral hypoxia
•
Spontaneous cerebral hemorrhage, a most unlikely event in adult animals
•
Traumatic concussion and contusion
•
Lightning strike, electrocution
Narcolepsy (Catalepsy)
Affected animals experience episodes of uncontrollable sleep and literally “fall”
asleep. The disease is recorded in Shetland ponies and is thought to be inherited
in them, in other horses, and in cattle.
Compulsive Walking or Head Pressing
Head-pressing is a syndrome characterized by the animal pushing its head against fixed
objects and into a corner of a pen as well as leaning into a stanchion or between
fence posts. Head-pressing should be differentiated from compulsive walking, in which
affected animals put their heads down and walk slowly while appearing blind. If they
walk into an object, they lean forward and indulge in head-pressing; if confined to
a stall they will often walk around the pen continuously or head-press into a corner.
The syndrome represents a change in behavior pattern caused by an unsatisfied compulsive
drive characteristic of a disorder of the limbic system. Causes include the following:
•
Toxic and metabolic brain disease, especially PEM and hepatic encephalopathy
•
Diseases manifested by increased intracranial pressure
•
Encephalomyelitides
Aimless Wandering
A similar but less severe syndrome to compulsive walking is aimless walking, severe
mental depression, and apparent blindness with tongue protrusion and continuous chewing
movements, although the animal is unable to ingest feed or drink water. Causes include
the following:
•
Toxic and metabolic diseases of brain, including poisoning by Helichrysum sp. and
tansy mustard
•
Degenerative brain diseases, e.g., nigropallidal encephalomalacia in horses, ceroid
lipofuscinosis in sheep, hydrocephalus in the newborn
Involuntary Movements
Involuntary movements are caused by involuntary muscle contractions, which include
gradations from fasciculations, shivering and tremor, to tetany, seizures, or convulsions.
Opisthotonus or “backward tone” is a sustained spasm of the neck and limb muscles
resulting in dorsal and caudal extension of the head and neck with rigid extension
of the limbs.
Tremor
This is a continuous, repetitive twitching of skeletal muscles that is usually visible
and palpable. The muscle units involved may be small and cause only local skin movement,
in which case the tremor is described as fasciculations; or the muscle units may be
extensive and the movement much coarser and sufficient to move the extremities, eyes,
or parts of the trunk. The tremor may become intensified when the animal undertakes
some positive action. This is usually indicative of cerebellar involvement and is
the counterpart of intention tremor in humans. True tremor is often sufficiently severe
to cause incoordination and severe disability in gait. Examples of causes of tremor
include the following:
•
Diffuse diseases of the cerebrum, cerebellum, and spinal cord
•
Degenerative nervous system disease, e.g., hypomyelinogenesis of the newborn as in
congenital tremor of pigs and calves, poisoning by Swainsona sp.
•
Toxic nervous system disease caused by a large number of poisons, especially poisonous
plants and fungi, Clostridium botulinum toxin in shaker foal syndrome; metabolic disease
such as hyperkalemic periodic paralysis in the horse; early stages of hypocalcemia
in the cow (fasciculations of the eyelids and ears).
Tics
Tics are spasmodic twitching movements made at much longer intervals than in tremor.
The intervals are usually at least several seconds in duration and often much longer.
The movements are sufficiently widespread to be easily visible and are caused by muscles
that are ordinarily under voluntary control. They are rare in large animals but may
occur after traumatic injury to a spinal nerve.
Tetany
Tetanus is a sustained contraction of muscles without tremor. The most common cause
is C. tetani intoxication following localized infection with the organism. The degree
of muscular contraction can be exaggerated by stimulation of the affected animal,
and the limbs are rigid and cannot be passively flexed easily (“lead pipe” rigidity).
Myoclonus is a brief, intermittent tetanic contraction of the skeletal muscles that
results in the entire body being rigid for several seconds, followed by relaxation.
Inherited congenital myoclonus (hereditary neuraxial edema) of polled, horned, and
crossbred Hereford calves is a typical example. Affected calves are bright and alert
and can suck normally, but if they undertake a voluntary movement or are handled their
entire body becomes rigid for 10 to 15 seconds.
Convulsions
Convulsions, seizures, fits, or ictus are violent muscular contractions affecting
part or all of the body and occurring for relatively short periods as a rule, although
in the late stages of encephalitis they may recur with such rapidity they give the
impression of being continuous.
Convulsions are the result of abnormal electrical discharges in forebrain neurons
that reach the somatic and visceral motor areas and initiate spontaneous, paroxysmal,
involuntary movements. These cerebral dysrhythmias tend to begin and end abruptly,
and they have a finite duration. A typical convulsion may have a prodromal phase or
aura that lasts for minutes to hours, during which the animal is oblivious to its
environment and seems restless. The beginning of the convulsion may be manifested
as a localized partial convulsion of one part of the body that soon spreads to involve
the whole body, when the animal usually falls to the ground thrashing rhythmically.
Following the convulsion there may be depression and temporary blindness, which may
last for several minutes up to a few hours.
The convulsion may be clonic with typical “paddling” (involuntary movement in which
repeated muscle spasms alternate with periods of relaxation). Tetanic or tonic convulsions
are less common and are manifested by prolonged muscular spasm without intervening
periods of relaxation. True tetanic convulsions occur only rarely, chiefly in strychnine
poisoning and in tetanus, and in most cases they are a brief introduction to a clonic
convulsion.
Convulsions can originate from disturbances anywhere in the prosencephalon, including
cerebrum, thalamus, or even the hypothalamus alone. However, the initiating cause
may be in the nervous system outside the cranium or in some other system altogether;
convulsions are therefore often subdivided into intracranial and extracranial types.
Causes are many and include the following.
Intracranial convulsions are caused by
•
Encephalomyelitis, meningitis
•
Encephalomalacia
•
Acute brain edema
•
Brain ischemia, including increased intracranial pressure
•
Local lesions caused by trauma (concussion, contusion), abscess, tumor, parasitic
injury, hemorrhage
•
Inherited idiopathic epilepsy
Extracranial convulsions are caused by brain hypoxia, as in acute circulatory or cardiac
failure, and toxic and metabolic diseases of the nervous system, including the following:
•
Hepatic encephalopathy
•
Hypoglycemia (as in newborn piglets and in hyperinsulinism caused by islet cell adenoma
of the pancreas as described in a pony)
•
Hypomagnesemia (as in lactation tetany in cows and mares)
•
Inorganic poisons, poisonous plants, and fungi; there are too many to give a complete
list, but well-known examples are the chlorinated hydrocarbons, pluronics used in
bloat control in cattle, Clostridium spp.; intoxications, e.g., C. perfringens type
D and C. sordellii, and subacute fluoroacetate poisoning
•
Congenital and inherited defects without lesions, e.g., familial convulsions and ataxia
in Angus cattle
Involuntary Spastic Paresis
Involuntary, intermittent contractions of large muscle masses may result in spasmodic
movements of individual limbs or parts of the body. In most, contractions occur when
voluntary movement is attempted. Diseases in this category include the following:
•
Stringhalt and Australian stringhalt of horses
•
Inherited spastic paresis (Elso heel) of cattle
•
Inherited periodic spasticity (stall cramp) of cattle
•
Inherited congenital myotonia of cattle
•
Inherited myotonia of goats
Abnormal Posture and Gait
Posture
Posture is evaluated with the animal at rest. Abnormal postures may be adopted intermittently
by animals in pain, but in diseases of the nervous system the abnormality is usually
continuous and repeatable. Deviation of the head and neck from the axial plane or
rotation of the head and neck from the horizontal plane (head tilt); drooping of the
lips, eyelids, cheeks, and ears; and opisthotonus and orthotonos are examples, although
the latter two are often intermittent because they occur as part of a convulsive seizure.
Head pressing and assumption of a dog-sitting posture are further examples. Abnormalities
of posture and gait are the result of lesions of the brainstem, cerebellum, all levels
of the spinal cord, spinal nerve roots, peripheral nerves, neuromuscular junctions,
and muscles. The clinical emphasis is on vestibular disease, cerebellar disease, and
spinal cord disease. It is important to emphasize that cerebral lesions do not cause
abnormalities in posture and gait.
Vestibular Disease
The vestibular system is a special proprioceptive system that assists the animal in
maintaining orientation in its environment with respect to gravity. It helps to maintain
the position of the eyes, trunk, and limbs in relationship to movements and positioning
of the head.
From the vestibular nuclei, the vestibulospinal tracts descend ipsilaterally through
the length of the spinal cord. These neurons are facilitatory to ipsilateral motor
neurons going to extensor muscles of the limbs, are inhibitory to ipsilateral motor
flexor muscles, and are inhibitory to contralateral extensor muscles. The principal
effect of unilateral stimulation of this system on the limbs is a relative ipsilateral
extensor tonus and contralateral flexor tonus, which promote ipsilateral support of
the trunk against gravity. Conversely, a unilateral vestibular lesion usually results
in ipsilateral flexor and contralateral extensor tonus, forcing the animal toward
the side of the lesion.
The nuclei of cranial nerves (CNs) III, IV, and VI, which control eye movement, are
connected with the vestibular system by way of a brainstem tract called the medial
longitudinal fasciculus. Through this tract, coordinated eye movements occur with
changes in positioning of the head. Through these various pathways, the vestibular
system coordinates movements of the eye, trunk, and limbs with head movements and
maintains equilibrium of the entire body during motion and rest.
Signs of vestibular disease vary depending on whether there is unilateral or bilateral
involvement and whether the disease involves peripheral or central components of the
system.
The vestibular influence on balance can be affected
•
At the inner ear
•
Along the vestibular nerve or
•
At the vestibular nucleus in the medulla.
Unilateral excitation or loss of function can be caused by lesions at any of these
points.
General signs of vestibular system dysfunction are staggering, leaning, rolling, circling,
drifting sideways when walking and a head tilt, and various changes in eye position
such as strabismus and nystagmus. The walking in a circle toward the affected side
is accompanied by increased tone in the contralateral limbs, which is most easily
observed in the contralateral forelimb. Rotation or tilt of the head occurs, and severely
affected animals fall to the affected side.
When the lesion affects the inner ear, as in some cases of otitis media, the affected
side is turned down, the animal falls to that side, and there may be facial paralysis
on the same side if the lesion is extensive and affects CN VII. In the recumbent position,
the affected side is held to the ground, and if these animals are rolled over to the
opposite side they quickly roll back to the affected side. When the vestibular nuclei
are affected, as in listeriosis, the animal falls to the affected side.
Nystagmus and forced circling are common when there is irritation of the vestibular
nucleus or the medial longitudinal fasciculus.
Causes of vestibular disease include the following:
•
Otitis media interna with involvement of the inner ear
•
Focal lesion at the vestibular nucleus, e.g., listeriosis
•
Traumatic injury to the vestibular apparatus in the horse caused by fracture of the
basisphenoid, basioccipital, and temporal bones; the clinical signs include lack of
control of balance, rotation of the head, circling to the affected side, nystagmus,
and facial paralysis
In paradoxical vestibular syndrome there is also head tilting, but circling in a direction
away from the side of the lesion. Deviation of the head and neck must be distinguished
from a head tilt. Asymmetric lesions of the forebrain such as a brain abscess, some
cases of PEM, verminous larval migration, or head trauma may cause an animal to hold
its head and neck turned to one side, but there is no head tilt and the circle is
large in diameter. In fact, the presence of a head tilt (deviation of eyes away from
a horizontal plane) accompanied by a tight circle provide clinically useful methods
of differentiating a cerebral lesion from a vestibular lesion.
Gait
Gait is assessed when the animal is moving. Neurologic gait abnormalities have two
components, weakness and ataxia. Weakness (paresis) is evident when an animal drags
its limbs, has worn hooves, or has a low arc to the swing phase of the stride. When
an animal bears weight on a weak limb, the limb often trembles and the animal may
even collapse on that limb because of lack of support. While circling, walking on
a slope, and walking with the head elevated, an animal frequently will stumble on
a weak limb and knuckle over at the fetlock. During manipulation of the limb, the
clinician will usually make the subjective observation that the muscle tone is reduced.
Ataxia
Ataxia is an unconscious, general proprioceptive deficit causing incoordination when
the animal moves. It is manifested as a swaying from side to side of the pelvis, trunk,
and sometimes the whole body (truncal sway). Ataxia may also appear as a weaving of
the affected limb during the swing phase of the stride. This often results in abducted
or adducted foot placement, crossing of the limbs, or stepping on the opposite foot.
Hypermetria is an increased range of movement and is seen as an overreaching of the
limbs with excessive joint movement. Hypermetria without paresis is characteristic
of spinocerebellar and cerebellar disease. It is a decreased range of movement that
is characterized by a stiff or spastic movement of the limbs with little flexion of
the joints, particularly the carpal and tarsal joints.
Dysmetria is a term that includes both hypermetria and hypometria, with goose-stepping
being the most common sign. It usually is caused by a lesion in the cerebellum or
cerebellar pathway.
In equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy (EDM), there is dysmetria of the hindlimbs
and tetraparesis caused by neuraxonal dystrophy originating in the accessory cuneate
nuclei. Severely affected horses lift their feet excessively high and stamp them to
the ground.
Cerebellar Disease
When cerebellar function is abnormal there is ataxia, which is an incoordination when
the animal moves. In general terms, there are defects in the rate, range, and direction
of movement. In typical cerebellar diseases, ataxia of the limbs is common and no
weakness is evident. In true cerebellar ataxia (e.g., cerebellar hypoplasia), the
affected animal stands with the legs wide apart, sways, and has a tendency to fall.
Ataxia of the head and neck are characterized by wide, swinging, head excursions;
jerky head bobbing; and an intention tremor (nodding) of the head.
The head tremor may be the most obvious sign in mild cases of cerebellar hypoplasia
in young foals. The limbs do not move in unison, the movements are grossly exaggerated,
muscular strength is usually preserved, and there is a lack of proper placement of
the feet (hypermetria and hypometria); falling is common. The fault in placement is
the result of poor motor coordination and not related in any way to muscle weakness
or proprioceptive deficit. Attempts to proceed to a particular point are usually unsuccessful,
and the animal cannot accurately reach its feed or drinking bowl. Examples of cerebellar
disease include the following:
•
Inherited defects of cerebellar structure or abiotrophy in most breeds of cattle and
in Arabian horses
1
•
Congenital cerebellar defects resulting from maternal viral infections such as bovine
virus diarrhea (BVD) infection in cattle
•
Dysplastic disease of the cerebellum of the horse
•
Traumatic injury, e.g., by parasite larvae such as Hypoderma bovis, which have caused
unilateral cerebellar ataxia in adult cattle
•
Tremorgenic mycotoxicoses and ryegrasses
•
Cerebellar degeneration in cattle in Uruguay caused by grazing the perennial shrub
Solanum bonariense (“Naranjillo”)
2
•
Encephalomyelitis in which other localizing signs also occur
Spinal Cord Disease
Ataxia caused by cerebellar dysfunction can be difficult to differentiate from the
proprioceptive defects and partial motor paralysis (weakness) that occur in animals
with spinal cord lesions, and it is most important that this differentiation is made.
Spinal cord disease, causing varying degrees of weakness, and ataxia are common in
large animals. The weakness is caused by damage to the upper or lower motor neurons
and the proprioceptive deficit by damage to the ascending sensory neurons. With a
mild or even moderate cervical spinal cord lesion in an adult cow or horse, signs
of ataxia and weakness may be evident in the pelvic limbs only, and it can be difficult
to determine whether the thoracic limbs are involved.
Close examination of the gait, posture, and postural reactions in the limbs, together
with a search for localizing abnormalities, will often be productive in localizing
the lesion. Signs of weakness or ataxia may be elicited by gently pushing the hindquarters
to one side or pulling the tail to one side as the animal is walked (the sway response).
The normal animal resists these movements or steps briskly to the side as it is pushed
or pulled. The weak animal can be easily pulled to one side and may stumble or fall
and may also tend to buckle or collapse when strong pressure is applied with the hand
over the withers and loin regions. The ataxic animal may sway to one side, be slow
to protract a limb, cross its hindlegs, or step on its opposite limb.
It is often difficult to distinguish paresis from ataxia, but in most instances it
is unimportant because of the close anatomic relationship of the ascending general
proprioceptive and descending upper motor neuron tracts in the white matter of the
spinal cord. These same abnormal sway responses can be elicited in the standing animal.
The ataxic animal may abduct the outside pelvic limb too far as it is pushed to one
side or moved in a small circle. This may appear as a hypermetric movement similar
to a stringhalt action and is assumed to be a sign of a general proprioceptive tract
lesion. The pushed or circled animal may keep a clinically affected pelvic limb planted
in one position on the ground and pivot around it without moving it. The same failure
to protract the limb may be seen on backing. It may even force the animal into a “dog-sitting”
posture.
Examples of ataxia caused by spinal cord disease include the following:
•
Limited trauma to the spinal cord
•
The early stages of a developing compression lesion in the vertebral canal
•
Degenerative and inflammatory diseases of the nervous system, especially those causing
enzootic incoordination in horses and staggers in sheep (both of them dealt with under
their respective headings)
•
Functional diseases in toxic and metabolic diseases of the nervous system in which
lesions have not yet been identified and that are caused mainly by poisons, especially
plant materials; typical examples are poisoning by the fungi Claviceps paspali, Diplodia
spp., Acremonium lolii, the grass Phalaris aquatic, the ferns Zamia and Xanthorrhea
spp., and herbaceous plants such as Kallstroemia, Vicia, Baccharis, Solanum, Aesculus,
and Ficus spp.
•
Heat stress in lambs
3
•
Nutritional deficiency especially of thiamine, occurring naturally in horses poisoned
by bracken and horsetail, and experimentally in pigs
•
Developmental defects including congenital abnormalities and abiotrophic abnormalities
that develop sometime after birth; examples are Brown Swiss weavers and Pietrain creeper
pigs.
In many of these diseases, incoordination and paresis are a stage in the development
of tetraplegia or paraplegia.
Paresis and Paralysis
The motor system comprises the following:
•
Pyramidal tracts, which originate in the motor cortex
•
Extrapyramidal system, which originates in the corpus striatum, red nucleus, vestibular
nucleus, and roof of the midbrain
•
Peripheral nerves, which originate in the ventral horn cells
The pyramidal tracts are of minor importance in hoofed animals (ungulates), reaching
only to the fourth cervical segment. Accordingly, lesions of the motor cortex in farm
animals do not produce any deficit of gait. There is also no paresis, although in
an acute lesion weakness may be evident for the first day or two. If the lesion is
unilateral, the paresis will be on the contralateral side. This is in marked contradistinction
to the severe abnormalities of posture and gait that occur with lesions of the pons,
medulla, and spinal cord.
The main motor nuclei in these animals are subcortical and comprise the extrapyramidal
system, and most combined movements are controlled by nerve stimuli originating in
the tectal nuclei, reticular nuclei, vestibular nuclei, and possibly red nuclei. The
pyramidal and extrapyramidal tracts comprise the upper motor neurons, which reach
to the ventral horn cells of the spinal cord, whose cells, together with their peripheral
axons, form the lower motor neurons. Paralysis is a physiologic result in all cases
of motor nerve injury, which if severe enough is expressed clinically. The type of
paralysis is often indicative of the site of the lesion.
A lesion of the upper motor neuron causes the following:
•
Spasticity with loss of voluntary movement
•
Increased tone of limb muscles
•
Increased spinal reflexes
The spasticity of an upper motor neuron lesion usually occurs with the affected limb
in extension. These are all release phenomena resulting from liberation of spinal
reflex arcs from higher control.
A lesion of the lower motor neuron causes:
•
Paresis or paralysis with loss of voluntary movement
•
Decreased tone of the limb muscles
•
Absence of spinal reflexes
•
Wasting of the affected muscle (neurogenic atrophy)
Because injuries to specific peripheral nerves are treated surgically, these are dealt
with in surgical textbooks and are not repeated here.
A special form of paralysis is the Schiff–Sherrington syndrome, which is common in
dogs but recorded rarely in large animals. It is caused by acute, severe compressive
injury of the thoracolumbar spinal cord and manifested by extensor rigidity or hypertonia
of the forelimbs and hypotonic paralysis of the hindlimbs. Neurons located in the
lumbar spinal cord are responsible for the tonic inhibition of extensor muscle alpha
motor neurons in the cervical intumescence. The cell bodies of these neurons are located
in the ventral gray column from L1-L7, with a maximum population from L2-L4. Their
axons ascend to the cervical intumescence. Acute severe lesions cranial to these neurons
and caudal to the cervical intumescence will suddenly deprive the cervical intumescence
neurons of this source of tonic inhibition, resulting in a release of these latter
neurons. This results in extensor hypertonia observed in the thoracic limbs, which
can function normally in the gait and postural reactions, except for the hypertonia.
The degree of paresis or paralysis needs to be defined. Paralysis is identified as
an inability to make purposeful movements. Thus convulsive, uncontrolled movements
as they occur in PEM may still fit a description of paralysis. Paresis, or weakness
short of paralysis, can be classified into four categories:
•
Animals that cannot rise or support themselves if helped up but can make purposeful
movements in attempting to rise
•
Animals that cannot rise but can support themselves if helped up
•
Animals that can rise but are paretic and can move the limbs well and stumble only
slightly on walking
•
Animals that move with difficulty and have severe incoordination and stumbling.
Probably the most difficult decision in farm animal neurology is whether a patient's
inability to move is because of a nervous or muscular deficit. For example, the horse
recumbent because of exertional rhabdomyolysis often resembles a horse with an injured
spinal cord. Examples of paresis and paralysis include the following:
•
Focal inflammatory, neoplastic, traumatic lesions in the motor pathway. These lesions
usually produce an asymmetric nervous deficit.
•
Toxic and metabolic diseases of the nervous system in their most severe form, e.g.,
flaccid paralysis associated with tick bite (Ixodes holocyclus, Ornithodoros sp.),
poisoning, botulism, and snakebite. Comparable tetanic paralyses include tetanus,
lactation tetany of mares, and hypomagnesemic tetany of cows and calves. In contrast
to inflammatory, neoplastic, and traumatic lesions in the motor pathway, toxic and
metabolic lesions usually produce a symmetric nervous deficit.
Neurogenic Muscular Atrophy
Destruction of the lower motor neurons either within the vertebral canal or peripheral
to it causes neurogenic atrophy. Whether or not the atrophy is visible depends on
how many neurons and therefore how many muscle fibers are affected.
Altered Sensation
Lesions of the sensory system are rarely diagnosed in animals, except for those affecting
sight and the vestibular apparatus, because of the impossibility of measuring subjective
responses.
Although animals must experience paresthesia, as in Aujeszky's disease (pseudorabies)
in cattle and sheep, the animal's response of licking or scratching does not make
it possible to decide whether the diagnosis should be paresthesia or pruritus. Lesions
of the peripheral sensory neurons cause hypersensitivity or decreased sensitivity
of the area supplied by the nerve. Lesions of the spinal cord may affect only motor
or only sensory fiber tracts or both, or may be unilateral.
Although it is often difficult to decide whether failure to respond to a normally
painful stimulus is caused by failure to perceive or inability to respond, certain
tests may give valuable information. The test usually used is pricking the skin with
a needle, or pinching the skin with a pair of forceps, and observing the reaction.
In exceptional circumstances, light stroking may elicit an exaggerated response. The
“nibbling” reaction stimulated by stroking the lumbar back of sheep affected with
scrapie is a striking example of hypersensitivity.
In every test of sensitivity, it must be remembered that there is considerable variation
between animals and in an individual animal from time to time, and much discretion
must be exercised when assessing the response. In any animal, there are also cutaneous
areas that are more sensitive than others. The face and the cranial cervical region
are highly sensitive, the caudal cervical and shoulder regions less so, with sensitivity
increasing over the caudal thorax and lumbar region and to a high degree on the perineum.
The proximal parts of the limbs are much less sensitive than the distal parts and
sensitivity is highest over the digits, particularly on the medial aspect.
Absence of a response to the application of a painful stimulus to the limbs (absence
of the withdrawal reflex) indicates interruption of the reflex arc; absence of the
reflex with persistence of central perception, as demonstrated by groaning or body
movement such as looking at the site of stimulus application, indicates interruption
of motor pathways and that central perception of pain persists. In the horse, the
response can be much more subtle than in other species, and movements of the ears
and eyelids are the best indicators of pain perception. Increased sensitivity is described
as hyperesthesia, decreased as hypoesthesia, and complete absence of sensitivity is
described as anesthesia. Special cutaneous reflexes include the anal reflex, in which
spasmodic contraction of the anus occurs when it is touched, and the corneal reflex,
in which there is closure of the eyelids on touching the cornea. The (cutaneous trunci)
panniculus reflex is valuable in that the sensory pathways, detected by the prick
of a pin, enter the cord at spinal cord segments T1-L3, but the motor pathways leave
the cord only at spinal cord segments C8, T1, and T2. The quick twitch of the superficial
cutaneous muscle along the whole back, which is the positive response (panniculus
reflex), is quite unmistakable. Examination of the eye reflexes and hearing are discussed
under the section Cranial Nerves (see later).
Blindness
Blindness is manifested as a clinical abnormality by the animal walking into objects
that it should avoid. Vision is a cerebral cortical function and is evaluated using
the pupillary light reflex, the menace response, and the ability to navigate around
a novel obstacle course.
The pupillary light reflex is present at birth in large animals but does not need
an intact cerebral cortex. This is the reason why ruminants with thiamine-responsive
polioencephalomalacia appear blind but have an intact pupillary light reflex; in contrast,
ruminants with lead poisoning and a greater extent of cerebral dysfunction appear
blind but have a depressed or absent pupillary light reflex. The pupillary light reflex
measures the integrity of the retina, optic nerves and chiasm, and oculomotor and
pretectal nuclei in the midbrain, and then to a descending motor pathway that includes
the oculomotor nerve, ciliary ganglion, and constrictor pupillae muscle.
The menace or blink response is used to test the integrity of the entire visual pathway
(retina, optic nerves, optic chiasm, optic tract, lateral geniculate nucleus, and
internal capsule to the visual area in the cerebrum [occipital lobe]). The visual
cortex processes the information and relays signals to the motor cortex. The descending
motor pathway receives some input from the cerebellum and proceeds from the ipsilateral
pons to the contralateral facial nerve nucleus in the medulla oblongata, and then
to the facial nerve, and finally the orbicularis oculi muscle. A threatening gesture
of the hand (or even better by the index finger in a pointing manner) toward the eye
elicits immediate closure of the eyelids. The finger must come close enough to the
eye without touching the tactile hairs of the eyelids or creating a wind that can
be felt by the animal. Some stoic, depressed, or even excited animals may not respond
to a menace reflex with closure of the eyelids; others may keep the eyelids partially
or almost closed. It may be necessary to alert the patient to the risk of injury by
touching the eyelids first. The menace response is a learned response that is absent
in neonates. Most foals have a menace response by 9 days after birth and most calves
by 5 to 7 days after birth. Group housing of neonatal calves appeared to facilitate
faster learning of the menace response as a result of more visual threats.
4
The most definitive test is to make the animal walk an obstacle course and place objects
in front of it so that it must step over the objects easily. A similar procedure is
the only way to test for night blindness (nyctalopia). The area should be dimly lit,
but the observer should be able to see the obstructions clearly. A decision that the
animal is blind creates a need for examination of the visual pathways.
Central or Peripheral Blindness
Blindness may be central or peripheral. Animals with forebrain lesions are centrally
blind, with depressed menace response in one or both eyes, whereas the pupillary light
reflexes are usually intact. In peripheral blindness, such as hypovitaminosis A, the
menace reflex is absent, and the pupillary light reflexes are also absent.
Blindness can be caused by lesions along the visual pathway, from the eye to the cerebral
cortex:
•
Diseases of the orbit include keratoconjunctivitis, hypopyon, cataract, panophthalmia,
mixed ocular defects inherited in white Shorthorn and Jersey cattle, night blindness
in Appaloosa horses, and sporadic cases of blindness caused by idiopathic retinal
degenerative disease in cattle.
•
Diseases of the retina include retinal dysplasia of goats, lenticular cataracts caused
by poisoning with hygromycin in pigs, and congenital ocular malformations in calves
after intrauterine infection with BVD virus (usually accompanied by cerebellar defects).
•
Diseases of the optic nerve and chiasma, e.g., abscess of pituitary rete mirabile,
constriction of optic nerve by diet deficient in vitamin A, tumor of pituitary gland,
and injury to the optic nerve, especially in horses after rearing and falling backward.
There is a sudden onset of unilateral or bilateral blindness with no ophthalmologic
change until 3 to 4 weeks after the injury, when the optic disc becomes paler and
less vascular.
•
Metabolic or ischemic lesions of the cerebral cortex as in PEM, cerebral edema, and
hydrocephalus.
•
Localized infectious or parasitic lesions caused by abscesses or migrating larvae.
•
Functional blindness in which there is complete, often temporary, apparent blindness
in the absence of any physical lesions is seen. Causes are acetonemia, pregnancy toxemia,
and acute carbohydrate indigestion (hyper d-lactatemia) of ruminants.
•
Specific poisonings causing blindness include F. mas (male fern), Cheilanthes spp.
(rock fern), and rape. Stypandra spp. cause a specific degeneration of the optic nerves.
Lead poisoning in cattle can also cause blindness.
Abnormalities of the Autonomic Nervous System
Lesions affecting the cranial parasympathetic outflow do so by involvement of the
oculomotor, facial, vagus, and glossopharyngeal nerves or their nuclei. The effects
produced are discussed in the Cranial Nerves section of Special examination of the
Nervous System.
In general, the lesions cause abnormality of pupillary constriction, salivation, and
involuntary muscular activity in the upper part of the alimentary and respiratory
tracts. Lesions of the spinal sympathetic system interfere with normal function of
the heart and alimentary tract. For the most part, affections of the autonomic nervous
system are of minor importance in farm animals. Central lesions of the hypothalamus
can cause abnormalities of heat exchange, manifested as neurogenic hyperthermia or
hypothermia and obesity, but they are also of minor importance.
Some manifestations of autonomic disease are important. Autonomic imbalance is usually
described as the physiologic basis for spasmodic colic of horses; grass sickness of
horses is characterized by degenerative lesions in the sympathetic ganglia; and involvement
of the vagus nerve in traumatic reticuloperitonitis of cattle can lead to impaired
forestomach and abomasal motility as well as the development of vagus indigestion.
Defects of sphincter control and motility of the bladder and rectum may also be of
importance in the diagnosis of defects of sacral parasympathetic outflow and the spinal
sympathetic system. The sacral segments of the spinal cord are the critical ones,
and loss of their function will cause incontinence of urine and loss of rectal tone.
The parasympathetic nerve supply to the bladder stimulates the detrusor muscle and
relaxes the sphincter; the sympathetic nerve supply has the reverse function. A spinal
cord lesion may cause loss of the parasympathetic control and result in urinary retention.
Incontinence, if it occurs, does so from overflow. When the sympathetic control is
removed, incontinence occurs but the bladder should empty. Similar disturbances of
defecation occur. Both micturition and defecation are controlled by medullary and
spinal centers, but some measure of control is regained even when the extrinsic nerve
supply to the bladder and rectum is completely removed.
Special Examination of the Nervous System
Veterinarians commonly include several components of a neurologic examination in a
complete clinical examination. Most often a diagnosis and differential diagnosis can
be made from consideration of the history and the clinical findings. However, if the
diagnosis is uncertain it may be necessary to conduct a complete neurologic examination,
which may uncover additional clinical findings necessary to make a diagnosis and give
a prognosis.
The accuracy of a clinical diagnosis of neurologic diseases in the horse is high.
In a study of 210 horses in which a definitive pathologic diagnosis was confirmed,
the overall accuracy of clinical diagnosis for all diseases was 0.95; the accuracy
ranged from 0.79 to 1.00, the sensitivity varied from 0.73 to 0.95, and the specificity
varied from 0.88 to 1.00 for individual disease categories. Some neurologic diseases
are therefore underdiagnosed, whereas others are overdiagnosed. The use of careful
and thorough clinical examinations and diagnostic techniques, combined with confirmed
pathologic diagnoses, will result in more accurate diagnosis and therapy. Retrospective
studies of series of ataxic horses, for example, will add to the body of knowledge
and improve diagnosis.
Neurologic Examination
The primary aim of the neurologic examination is to confirm whether or not a neurologic
abnormality exists and to determine the neuroanatomical location of the lesion. A
clinicoanatomic diagnosis is necessary before one can develop a list of differential
diagnoses and decide whether or not treatment is possible. The format for a precise
practical examination procedure that is logical in sequence, easy to remember with
practice, and emphasizes the need for an anatomic diagnosis is outlined later. The
rationale for the sequence is that the examination starts from a distance to assess
posture and mentation and then proceeds to a closer examination that may require placing
the animal in stocks or a chute. The examination sequence is therefore suitable for
minimally handled beef cattle, dairy cattle, horses, sheep, goats, and New World camelids.
The results of the neurologic examination should be documented and not left to memory.
There are many standard examination forms available that outline each step in the
examination and provide for documentation of the results.
Signalment and Epidemiology
The age, breed, sex, use, and value of the animal are all important considerations
in the diagnosis and prognosis of neurologic disease. Some diseases occur more frequently
under certain conditions, for example, lead poisoning in nursing beef calves turned
out to pasture in the spring of the year. Histophilus somni meningoencephalitis is
most common in feedlot cattle from 6 to 10 months of age, and hypovitaminosis A is
most common in beef calves 6 to 8 months of age after grazing dry summer pastures.
In the horse, there are several clearly defined diseases that affect the spinal cord
including cervical stenotic myelopathy, degenerative myeloencephalopathy, protozoal
myelitis, equine rhinopneumonitis myelopathy, rabies polioencephalomyelitis, and equine
motor neuron disease. Some of these diseases have distinguishing epidemiologic characteristics
that are useful in diagnosis and differential diagnosis. The neurologic examination
of the newborn foal is fraught with hazards because of the different responses elicited
from those in adults. The differences relate mostly to the temporary dysmetria of
gait and exaggerated responses of reflexes.
History
Special attention should be given to the recording of an accurate history. The questioning
of the owner should focus on the primary complaint and when it occurred and how it
has changed over time (the sign-time relationship). The duration of signs; the mode
of onset, particularly whether acute with later subsidence, or chronic with gradual
onset; the progression of involvement; and the description of signs that occur only
intermittently should be ascertained. When the disease is a herd problem, the morbidity
and mortality rates and the method of spread may indicate an intoxication when all
affected animals show signs within a very short period. Diseases associated with infectious
agents may have an acute or chronic onset. Neoplastic diseases of the nervous system
may begin abruptly but are often slowly progressive. For some diseases, such as epilepsy,
consideration of the history may be the only way to make a diagnosis. Traumatic injuries
have a sudden onset and then often stabilize or improve.
When obtaining a history of convulsive episodes, an estimate should be made of their
duration and frequency. The pattern is also important and may be diagnostic, e.g.,
in salt poisoning in swine. The occurrence of pallor or cyanosis during the convulsion
is particularly important in the differentiation of cardiac syncope and a convulsion
originating in the nervous system.
Head
Behavior
The owner should be questioned about the animal's abnormal behavior, which can include
bellowing, yawning, licking, mania, convulsions, aggressiveness, head-pressing, wandering,
compulsive walking, and head-shaking. Head-shaking may be photic in origin and can
be tested by the application of blindfolds, covering the eyes with a face mask, and
observing the horse in total darkness outdoors. In one horse, head-shaking ceased
with blindfolding or night darkness outdoors, and became less with the use of gray
lenses. Outdoor behavior suggested efforts to avoid light.
Mental Status
Assessment of mental status is based on the animal's level of awareness or consciousness.
Coma is a state of complete unresponsiveness to noxious stimuli. Other abnormal mental
states include stupor, somnolence, deliriousness, lethargy, and depression. Animals
may exhibit opisthotonus, either spontaneously or in response to stimulation (Fig.
14-1
). Large animals that are recumbent because of spinal cord disease are usually bright
and alert unless affected with complications, which may cause fever and anorexia.
Mature beef cattle that are recumbent with a spinal cord lesion and not used to being
handled may be quite aggressive and apprehensive.
Fig. 14-1
Abnormal mentation in Simmental calf with bacterial meningitis. The calf is exhibiting
opisthotonus and is acting inappropriately for its surroundings.
Fig. 14-1
Head Position and Coordination
Lesions of the vestibular system often result in a head tilt. Lesions of the cerebrum
often result in deviation of the head and neck. In cerebellar disease, there may be
jerky movements of the head, which are exaggerated by increasing voluntary effort.
These fine jerky movements of the head are called intention tremors. Animals with
severe neck pain will hold their neck in a fixed position and be reluctant to move
the head and neck. Head-shaking in horses has been associated with ear mite infestation,
otitis externa, CN dysfunction, cervical injury, ocular disease, guttural pouch mycosis,
dental periapical osteitis, and vasomotor rhinitis. However, idiopathic head-shaking
in the horse is often associated with evidence of nasal irritation, sneezing and snorting,
nasal discharge, coughing, and excessive lacrimation.
Cranial Nerves
Abnormalities of CN function assist in localizing a lesion near or within the brainstem.
Some of the information on CN dysfunction is presented in tabular form (Table 14-1,
Table 14-2, Table 14-3, Table 14-4, Table 14-5, Table 14-6
) in addition to the more detailed examination described here.
Table 14-1
Correlation between clinical findings and location of lesions in the nervous system
of farm animals: abnormalities of mental state (behavior)
Table 14-1
Principal sign
Secondary signs
Location of lesion
Example
Mania hysteria/hyperexcitability
Continuous, leading to paralysis; aggression, convulsions
Cerebrum-limbic system
Peracute lead poisoning, rabies, encephalitis
Intermittent, acetonuria, signs of hepatic insufficiency
Cerebrum-limbic system
Hypoglycemia, hypoxia
Coma (recumbency with no response to stimuli; dilated pupils)
Gradual developmentHypothermia, peripheral vascular collapse.Clinicopathologic testsSudden
onsetNormal temperature, pulse/heart rate slow to normal, nosebleed, skin laceration,
bruising middle of forehead or poll
Cerebral-brainstem reticular formation (ascending reticular activating system)Cerebral-brainstem
reticular formation (ascending reticular activating system)
Hepatic insufficiency, uremia, toxemia, septicemiaAccidental, severe blunt trauma
with edema, concussion, contusion of brain
Narcolepsy/catalepsyUncontrollable sleep
With or without sudden loss of consciousness, intermittent falling caused by loss
of voluntary motor function
Brainstem control of cerebral cortex
Inherited in Shetland ponies, American Miniature horses, and Suffolk horses
Compulsive walking and head-pressing, aggressive behavior, grinding of teeth.
Apparent blindness, nystagmus
Cerebral-visual cortex and limbic system
Increased intracranial pressure in polioencephalomalacia
No ataxia
Apparent blindness, no nystagmus, hepatic insufficiency shown on clinical pathology
tests
Cerebral-visual cortex and limbic system
Hepatic insufficiency (i.e., ammonia intoxication; in pyrrolizidine poisoning)
Imbecility in neonate; lack of response to normal stimuli; can walk, stand
Blindness
Cerebral cortex absent; hydranencephaly
Intrauterine infection with Akabane or bovine virus diarrhea virus in calves
Table 14-2
Correlation between clinical findings and location of lesion in the nervous system
of farm animals: involuntary movements
Table 14-2
Principal sign
Secondary signs
Location of lesion
Example
Tremor (continuous repetitive movements of skeletal muscles)
Moderate tetany
No specific focal lesionGeneralized disease, e.g., hypomyelinogenesis
Congenital tremor of HerefordsHypomyelinogenesis, shaker pigs, lambs with border disease
Intention tremor, sensory ataxia
Cerebellum
Cerebellar hypoplasia
With head rotation
Vestibular apparatus
Otitis media and internaFracture of petrous temporal bone
Nystagmus
Usually with tetraparesis, impaired consciousness, abnormal pupils, opisthotonus,
facial palsy, dysphagia
Cerebellopontine and midbrain areas
Injury, increased intracranial pressure, polioencephalomalacia, listeriosis
Pendular nystagmus
No lesion
Benign sporadic occurrence in dairy cattle, inherited in Finnish Ayrshire bulls
Independent episodes
Focus of irritation in cerebral cortex or thalamus, with spread of excitation
Idiopathic or traumatic epilepsy
Convulsions
Continuous, leading to paralysis
Cerebral cortex
Increased intracranial pressure, encephalitis
Intermittent, related to periods of metabolic stress
Cerebral cortex
Hypomagnesemia (lactation tetany); hypoglycemia (e.g., of baby pigs)
Tenesmus (straining)
Later paralysis of anus, sometimes tail headSexual precocity in male
Caudal cord segments and cauda equina, stimulation of nerve cells, later paralysis
Rabies, subacute local meningitis
Compulsive rolling
Disturbance of balance, cannot stand, must lie on one sideNystagmus
Vestibular apparatus
Brain abscess, otitis media
Table 14-3
Correlation between clinical findings and location of lesion in the nervous system
of farm animals: abnormalities of posture
Table 14-3
Principal sign
Secondary signs
Location of lesion
Example
Paresis (difficulty in rising, staggering gait, easily falling)
Persistent recumbency, muscle tone and reflexes variable depending on site of lesionGeneral
loss of muscle tone including vascular, alimentary systems
Loss of function in nervous tissue, e.g., spinal cord, may be upper or motor neuron
lesionDepression of synaptic or neuromuscular transmission for metabolic reasons or
toxic reasons
Lymphosarcoma affecting spinal cordPeriparturient hypocalcemia, botulism, peracute
coliform mastitis, tick paralysis
Flaccid paralysis
(1)
Pelvic limbs only
Thoracic normalPelvic limbs flaccid, no tone, or reflexes, no anal reflex, urinary
incontinence straining initiallyThoracic limbs normalPelvic limbs normal tone and
reflexes, anal reflex normalNo withdrawal reflex caudally
Tissue destruction, myelomalacia at lumbosacral cord segments L4 to end osteomyelitis,
fractureCord damage at thoracolumbarcord segments T3-L3
Paralytic rabiesSpinal cord local meningitis, vertebral bodySpinal cord local meningitis
as previously mentioned, damage by vertebral fracture, lymphosarcoma
(2)
Thoracic and pelvic limbs
Flaccid paralysis, normal tone and reflexes hindlimbsAbsent tone and reflexes in front
limbsAtrophy only in frontNo withdrawal reflex caudallyIntact perineal reflexFlaccid
paralysis all four legs and neckUnable to lift head off groundNormal tone and reflexes
all legsPain perception persistsNo withdrawal reflex caudally
Cord damage at cervicothoracic segments C6-T2Cord damage at upper cervical segments
C1-C5
Fracture of vertebra lymphosarcoma, abscessInjury while running or falling, abscess
or lymphosarcoma
Spastic paralysis (permanent, no variation, all four limbs in extension, increased
tone, exaggerated reflexes, opisthotonus)
Cranial nerve deficits trigeminal to hypoglossalLoss of central perception of painDepression
Medulla, pons and midbrain
Abscess, listeriosis
Tremor
Tremor (fine or coarse; no convulsions)
Red nucleus and reticular apparatus and midbrain/basal ganglia area tracts
Congenital disease of calves, e.g., hypomyelinogenesis, neuraxial edema
Tetany (all four limbs extended, opisthotonus)
Intense hyperesthesia, prolapse third eyelid
Decreased synaptic resistance generally
Tetanus
Tetanu (variable intensity modifiable by treatment)
Exaggerated response to all external stimuli, i.e., hyperesthesia
Increased neuromuscular transmission
Hypomagnesemia
Paralysis of anus
No anal or perineal reflexMay be straining
Damage to spinal cord at segments S1-S3
Injury or local meningitis, early rabies
Paralysis of tail
Flaccid tail with anesthesia
Injury to caudal segments
Injury or local meningitis, early rabies
Opisthotonus
With spastic paralysis, tremor, nystagmus, blindnessPart of generalized tetanic state
or convulsion
Cerebrum, cerebellum and midbrainNeuromuscular transmission defect, tetanus, hypomagnesemia
Polioencephalomalacia, traumaTetanus
Falling to one side
Mostly with circling
No detectable lesion in spinal cord
Xanthorrhea hastile poisoning
Also with deviation of tail
Table 14-4
Correlation between clinical findings and location of lesion in the nervous system
of farm animals: abnormalities of gait
Table 14-4
Principal sign
Secondary signs
Location of lesion
Example
Circling
(1)
Rotation of the head
Nystagmus, circles, muscle weakness, falls easily, may roll, other cranial nerves
affected
Vestibular nucleus
Brain abscess, listeriosis
Nystagmus, walks in circles, falls occasionally, animal strongFalls easily if blindfolded,
sometimes facial paralysis
Inner ear (vestibular canals), cranial nerve VII, facial nerve
Otitis media, otitis interna, fracture petrous temporal bone (horse)
(2)
Deviation of the head
Deviation of head and gaze, compulsive walking, depressionCan walk straightBalance
may be normal
Cerebrum
Brain abscess in calf (infection from dehorning or umbilicus)
Unable to walk straightFacial paralysis, other cranial nerve deficits, head may be
rotated
Medulla
Listeriosis
Cerebellar ataxia
Exaggerated strength and distance of movement, direction wrongHypermetriaIncoordination
because of exaggerated movementNo paresis
Cerebellum
Inherited cerebellar hypoplasia in all species, especially Arabian horses; Claviceps
paspali poisoning; Gomen disease a probable plant poisoning; destruction by a virus,
especially BVD in cattle; hematoma in the fourth ventricle causes cerebellar displacementIdiopathic
cerebellar degeneration in adult cattle
Sensory ataxia
No loss of movement or strength but timing movement wrong, legs get crossed, feet
badly placed when pivoting
Damage to sensory tracts in spinal cord
Cervical cord lesion, thoracolumbar if just pelvic limb
Sensorimotor ataxia
Weakness of movement, e.g., scuffing toes, knuckling, incomplete flexion, extension
causes wobbly, wandering gait, falls down easily, difficulty in rising
Moderate lesion to spinal cord tracts
Plant poisonings, e.g., sorghumCervical vertebral compression of spinal cordDegenerative
myelopathy
BVD, bovine viral diarrhea.
Table 14-5
Correlation between clinical findings and location of lesion in the nervous system
of farm animals: abnormalities of the visual system
Table 14-5
Principal sign
Secondary signs
Location of lesion
Example
Blindness (bumps into objects)
Pupillary dilatationNo pupillary light reflexNo menace reflex
Optic nerve (examine fundus of eye)
Vitamin A deficiencyPituitary rete mirabile abscessCongenital retinal dysplasia of
goats
Peripheral blindness or night blindness
Retina
Nutritional deficiency of vitamin AInherited defect of Appaloosa foals
Central blindness
Pupil normal sizePupillary light reflexes normal
Cerebral cortex
Polioencephalomalacia, lead poisoning
Abnormal dilatation of pupils (mydriasis)
Absence of pupillary light reflexCan see and does not bump into objects
Motor path of oculomotor nerve
Snakebite, atropine poisoning, milk fever
Absent pupillary light reflexNo visionRetinal damage on ophthalmoscopic examination
Retinal lesion
Toxoplasmosis, trauma, ophthalmitis
Absent pupillary light reflexNo vision
Optic nerve atrophy and fibrosis
Avitaminosis A in cattle
Retina normal
Abnormal constriction of pupil (miosis)
Diarrhea, dyspnea
Failure to activate acetylcholine
Organophosphate poisoning
Blindness, coma, semicoma, spastic paralysis
Diffuse lesion
Polioencephalomalacia, acute lead poisoning
Horner's syndromeDrooping upper eyelid, miosis, enophthalmos
Hemilateral sweating and temperature rise side of face and upper neckUnilateral exophthalmus;
nasal obstruction
Damage to cranial thoracic and cervical sympathetic trunk
Mediastinal tumorGuttural pouch mycosisNeoplastic space-occupying lesions of the cranium
involving the periorbit; perivascular injection around jugular vein or normal intravenous
injection of xylazine hydrochloride in normal horses, melanoma at the thoracic inlet
in a horse
Nystagmus
See Table 14-2
Abnormal position of eyeball and eyelids
Dorsomedial deviation of eyeball and eyelid
Trochlear (cranial nerve IV)Facial (cranial nerve VII)
PolioencephalomalaciaListeriosis
Ventrolateral fixation
Oculomotor (cranial nerve III)
Protrusion and medial deviation
Abducent (cranial nerve VI)
Abscess/tumor, e.g., bovine viral leukosis
No palpebral reflex
Deficit sensory branch of cranial nerve V
Trauma
Absence of menace response
Facial nerve (provided vision is present)
Listeriosis
Absence of pupillary light reflex
Oculomotor (provided vision is present)
Table 14-6
Correlation between clinical findings and location of lesion in the nervous system
of farm animals: disturbances of prehension, chewing, or swallowing
Table 14-6
Principal sign
Secondary signs
Location of lesion
Example
Inability to prehend or inability to chew
Facial (nasal septal) hypalgesia
Sensory branch of trigeminal (cranial nerve V) dysfunction
Poisoning by Phalaris aquatica in cattleLocal medullary lesion
Inappropriate movements of tongue
Hypoglossal (cranial nerve XII) nerve dysfunction
Poisoning by P. aquatica in cattleListeriosis, local medullary lesion
Inappropriate movements of lips
Facial (cranial nerve VII) nerve dysfunction
Traumatic injury to petrous temporal bone, otitis media and interna, listeriosis,
guttural pouch mycosis
Inadequate chewing movements of jaw
Motor branch of the trigeminal (cranial nerve V) nerve dysfunction
Poisoning by P. aquatica in cattle, listeriosis
Inability to swallow (in absence of physical foreign body; in pharyngeal paresis or
paralysis)
Regurgitation through nose and mouth, inhalation into lungs causing aspiration pneumoniaInappropriate
swallowing movements
Glossopharyngeal (cranial nerve IX) nerve dysfunction. Also vagus (cranial nerve X)Nuclei
in medulla globus pallidus and substantia nigra
Abscess or tumor adjacent to nerveListeriosis, abscess in medullaPoisoning by Centaurea
sp.
Olfactory Nerve (Cranial Nerve I)
Tests of smell are unsatisfactory in large animals because of their response to food
by sight and sound.
Optic Nerve (Cranial Nerve II)
The only tests of visual acuity applicable in animals are testing the eye preservation
(menace) reflex (provoking closure of the eyelids and withdrawal of the head by stabbing
the finger at the eye) and by making the animal run a contrived obstacle course. Both
tests are often difficult to interpret and must be performed in such a way that other
senses are not used to determine the presence of the obstacles or threatened injury.
In more intelligent species, a good test is to drop some light object, such as a handkerchief
or feather, in front of the animal. It should gaze at the object while it is falling
and continue to watch it on the ground. The same method can be applied to young ruminants,
which demonstrate normal vision by following the examiner's moving hand at an age
so early that they have not yet developed a menace reflex. Ophthalmoscopic examination
is an integral part of an examination of the optic nerve.
Oculomotor Nerve (Cranial Nerve III)
This nerve supplies the pupilloconstrictor muscles of the iris and all the extrinsic
muscles of the eyeball except the dorsal oblique, the lateral rectus, and the retractor
muscles. Loss of function of the nerve results in pupillary dilatation and defective
pupillary constriction when the light intensity is increased, abnormal position (ventrolateral
deviation) or defective movement of the eyeballs, and palpebral ptosis.
The pupillary light reflex is best tested by shining a bright point source of light
into the eye, which causes constriction of the iris of that eye (direct pupillary
reflex). Constriction of the opposite eye (consensual pupillary light reflex) will
also occur. The consensual light reflex may be used to localize lesions of the optic
pathways.
Examination of the menace reflex (eye preservation reflex to a menace) and the results
of the pupillary light reflex can be used to distinguish between blindness caused
by a lesion in the cerebral cortex (central blindness) and that caused by lesions
in the optic nerve or other peripheral parts of the optic pathways (peripheral blindness).
As examples, in PEM (central blindness) the menace reflex is absent, but the pupillary
light reflex is present. In the ocular form of hypovitaminosis A (peripheral blindness)
in cattle, the menace reflex is also absent, the pupils are widely dilated, and the
pupillary light reflex is absent. In PEM, the optic nerve, oculomotor nucleus, and
oculomotor nerve are usually intact but the visual cortex is not; in hypovitaminosis
A, the optic nerve is usually degenerate, which interferes with both the menace and
pupillary light reflexes.
Testing of ocular movements can be performed by moving the hand about in front of
the face. In paralysis of the oculomotor nerve, there may also be deviation from the
normal ocular axes and rotation of the eyeball. There will be an absence of the normal
horizontal nystagmus reaction with a medial jerk of the eyeball in response to quick
passive movement of the head. Failure to jerk laterally indicates a defect of the
abducens nerve.
Trochlear Nerve (Cranial Nerve IV)
This nerve supplies only the dorsal oblique muscle of the eye so that external movements
and position of the eyeball are abnormal (dorsolateral fixation) when the nerve is
injured. This is common in PEM in cattle, resulting in a dorsomedial fixation of the
eyeball. In other words, the medial angle of the pupil is displaced dorsally when
the head is held in normal extension.
Trigeminal Nerve (Cranial Nerve V)
The sensory part of the trigeminal nerve supplies sensory fibers to the face and can
be examined by testing the palpebral reflex and the sensitivity of the face. The motor
part of the nerve supplies the muscles of mastication and observation of the act of
chewing may reveal abnormal jaw movements and asymmetry of muscle contractions. There
may also be atrophy of the muscles, which is best observed when the lesion is unilateral.
Abducent Nerve (Cranial Nerve VI)
Because the abducent nerve supplies motor fibers to the retractor and lateral rectus
muscles of the eyeball, injury to the nerve may result in protrusion and medial deviation
of the globe. This is not readily observable clinically. An inherited exophthalmos
and strabismus occurs in Jersey cattle.
Facial Nerve (Cranial Nerve VII)
The facial nerve supplies motor fibers for movement of the ears, eyelids, lips, and
nostrils, in addition to the motor pathways of the menace, palpebral, and corneal
reflexes. The symmetry and posture of the ears, eyelids, and lips are the best criteria
for assessing the function of this nerve. Ability to move the muscles in question
can be determined by creating a noise or stabbing a finger at the eye. Absence of
the eye preservation reflex may be caused by facial nerve paralysis or blindness.
Facial paralysis is evidenced by ipsilateral drooping of the ear, ptosis of the upper
eyelid, drooping of the lips, and pulling of the philtrum to the unaffected side.
There may also be drooling of saliva from the commissures of the lips, and in some
cases a small amount of feed may remain in the cheeks of the affected side.
The common causes of damage to the nerve are fracture of the petrous temporal bone,
guttural pouch mycosis, and damage to the peripheral nerve at the mandible. A common
accompaniment is injury to the vestibular nerve or center. A diagnosis of central,
compared with peripheral, nerve involvement can be made by identifying involvement
of adjacent structures in the medulla oblongata. Signs such as depression, weakness,
and a head tilt would result, and are frequently present in ruminants and New World
camelids with listeriosis.
Vestibulocochlear Nerve (Cranial Nerve VIII)
The cochlear part of the vestibulocochlear nerve is not easily tested by simple clinical
examination, but failure to respond to sudden sharp sounds, created out of sight and
without creating air currents, suggests deafness. The cochlear portion can be tested
electronically (the brainstem auditory evoked response, or BAER, test) to diagnose
a lesion of the auditory nerve, eliminating the possibility of a central brain lesion.
Abnormalities of balance and carriage of the head (rotation around the long axis and
not deviation laterally) accompany lesions of the vestibular part of the vestibulocochlear
nerve, and nystagmus is usually present.
In severe cases, rotation of the head is extreme, the animal is unable to stand and
lies in lateral recumbency; moving to achieve this posture is compulsive and forceful.
There is no loss of strength. In some species there is a relatively common occurrence
of paralysis of the facial and the vestibular nerves as a result of otitis interna
and otitis media. This does occur in the horse but is less common than traumatic injury
to the skull as a result of falling.
Pendular nystagmus should not be mistaken as a sign of serious neurologic disease.
It is characterized by oscillations of the eyeball that are always the same speed
and amplitude and appear in response to a visual stimulus, e.g., a flashing light.
Pendular nystagmus is observed most frequently in Holstein Friesian cattle (prevalence
of 0.51% in 2932 Holstein Friesian and Jersey cows), is not accompanied by other signs,
and there is no detectable histologic lesion. A familial relationship was observed
in Ayrshire bulls in Finland.
Glossopharyngeal Nerve (Cranial Nerve IX) and Vagus Nerve (Cranial Nerve X)
The glossopharyngeal nerve is sensory from the pharynx and larynx, and the vagus nerve
is motor to these structures. Dysfunction of these nerves is usually accompanied by
paralysis of these organs with signs of dysphagia or inability to swallow, regurgitation
through the nostrils, abnormality of the voice, and interference with respiration.
Because of the additional role of the vagus nerve in supplying nerve fibers to the
upper alimentary tract, loss of vagal nerve function will lead to paralysis of the
pharynx and esophagus. Parasympathetic nerve fibers to the stomach are also carried
in the vagus, and damage to them could cause hypomotility of that organ. The principal
clinical finding in vagus nerve injury is laryngeal and pharyngeal paralysis.
Spinal Accessory Nerve (Cranial Nerve Xi)
Damage to this nerve is extremely rare and the effects are not documented. Based on
its anatomic distribution, loss of function of this nerve could be expected to lead
to paralysis of the trapezius, brachiocephalic, and sternocephalic muscles and lack
of resistance to lifting the head.
Hypoglossal Nerve (Cranial Nerve XII)
As the motor supply to the tongue, the function of this nerve can be best examined
by observing the motor activity of the tongue. There may be protrusion and deviation
or fibrillation of the organ, which all result in difficulty in prehending food and
drinking water. The most obvious abnormality is the ease with which the tongue can
be pulled out. The animal also has difficulty in getting it back into its normal position
in the mouth, although diffuse cerebral disease can also produce this clinical sign.
In lesions of some duration, there may be obvious unilateral atrophy.
Posture and Gait
The examiner evaluates posture and gait to give a general assessment of brainstem,
spinal cord, and peripheral nerve and muscle function. Evaluation of posture and gait
consists of determining which limbs are abnormal and looking for evidence of lameness
suggesting a musculoskeletal gait abnormality. Weakness and ataxia are the essential
components of gait abnormality. Each limb is examined for evidence of these abnormalities.
This is done while the animal is standing still, walking, trotting, turning tightly
(pivoting), and backing up. To detect subtle asymmetry in the length of the stride,
the observer should walk parallel to or behind the animal, step for step. If possible,
the gait should also be evaluated while the animal is walking up and down a slope
or walking with the head and neck held extended, while blindfolded and while running
free in an enclosure.
The best observations are made when the animal is running free, preferably at a fast
gait, to avoid abnormalities resulting from being led. Also, slight abnormalities
such as a high-stepping gait, slight incoordination of movement, errors of placement
of feet, stumbling, and failure to flex joints properly are all better observed in
a free animal.
Weakness or paresis is evident when an animal drags its limbs, has worn hooves, or
has a low arc to the swing phase of the stride. When an animal bears weight on a weak
limb, the limb often trembles and the animal may even collapse on that limb because
of lack of support. While circling, walking on a slope, and walking with the head
held elevated, an animal frequently will stumble on a weak limb and knuckle over on
the fetlock.
The presence of weakness in the limbs of horses or cattle can be determined by pulling
the tail while the animal is walking forward. A weak animal is easily pulled to the
side and put off stride. While the animal is circling, the examiner can pull on the
lead rope and tail simultaneously to assess strength. Ease in pulling the animal to
the side occurs because of weakness caused by lesions of the descending upper motor
neuron pathway, the ventral horn gray matter level with the limb, or peripheral nerves
or muscle. With lower motor neuron lesions, the weakness is often so marked that it
is easy to pull an animal to the side while it is standing or walking. In contrast,
a weak animal with a lesion of the upper motor neuron pathways will often fix the
limb in extension, reflexly, when pulled to one side. It resists the pull and appears
strong.
Severe weakness in all four limbs, but with no ataxia and spasticity, suggests neuromuscular
disease. Obvious weakness in only one limb is suggestive of a peripheral nerve or
muscle lesion in that limb.
Ataxia is an unconscious, general proprioceptive deficit causing poor coordination
when moving the limbs and the body. It results in swaying from side to side of the
pelvis, trunk, and sometimes the entire body. It may also appear as a weaving of the
affected limb during the swing phase. This often results in abducted or abducted foot
placement, crossing of the limbs, or stepping on the opposite foot, especially when
the animal is circling or turning tightly. Circumduction of the outside limbs when
turning and circling is also considered a proprioceptive deficiency. Walking an animal
on a slope, with the head held elevated, often exaggerates ataxia, particularly in
the pelvic limbs. When a weak and ataxic animal is turned sharply in circles, it leaves
the affected limb in one place while pivoting around it. An ataxic gait may be most
pronounced when an animal is moving freely, at a trot or canter, especially when attempting
to stop. This is when the limbs may be wildly abducted or adducted. Proprioceptive
deficits are caused by lesions affecting the general proprioceptive sensory pathways,
which relay information on limb and body position to the cerebellum (unconscious proprioception)
and to the thalamus and cerebral cortex (conscious proprioception).
Knuckling the flexed foot while the animal stands on the dorsum to determine how long
the animal leaves the foot in this state before returning it to a normal position
is a test for conscious proprioception in dogs and cats. The test has not been useful
in horses and adult cattle but is useful in sheep, goats, New World camelids, and
calves. Depressed animals will often allow the foot to rest on the dorsum for prolonged
periods. Crossing the limbs and observing how long the animal maintains a cross-legged
stance has been used to test conscious proprioception.
Hypermetria is used to describe a lack of direction and increased range of movement,
and is seen as an overreaching of the limbs with excessive joint movement. Hypermetria
without paresis is characteristic of spinocerebellar and cerebellar disease.
Hypometria is seen as stiff or spastic movement of the limbs with little flexion of
the joints, particularly the carpal and tarsal joints. This generally is indicative
of increased extensor tone and of a lesion affecting the descending motor or ascending
spinocerebellar pathways to that limb. A hypometric gait, particularly in the thoracic
limbs, is best seen when the animal is backed up or when it is maneuvered on a slope
with the head held elevated. The thoracic limbs may move almost without flexing.
Dysmetria is a term that incorporates both hypermetria and hypometria. Animals with
severe cerebellar lesions may have a high-stepping gait but have limited movement
of the distal limb joints, especially in thoracic limbs.
The degree of weakness, ataxia, hypometria, and hypermetria should be graded for each
limb. The types of gait abnormalities and the degree of weakness reflect various nervous
and musculoskeletal lesions. Generally, with focal, particularly compressive, lesions
in the cervical spinal cord or brainstem, neurologic signs are one grade more severe
in the pelvic limbs than in the thoracic limbs. Thus with a mild, focal, cervical
spinal cord lesion, there may be more abnormality in the pelvic limbs with no signs
in the thoracic limbs. The anatomic diagnosis in such cases may be a thoracolumbar,
cervical, or diffuse spinal cord lesion.
A moderate or severe abnormality in the pelvic limbs, and none in the thoracic limbs,
is consistent with a thoracolumbar spinal cord lesion. With a mild and a severe change
in the thoracic and the pelvic limb gaits, respectively, one must consider a severe
thoracolumbar lesion plus a mild cervical lesion, or a diffuse spinal cord disease.
Lesions involving the brachial intumescence (spinal cord segments C6-T2) with involvement
of the gray matter supplying the thoracic limbs, and diffuse spinal cord lesions may
both result in severe gait abnormality in the thoracic limbs and the pelvic limbs.
A severely abnormal gait in the thoracic limbs, with normal pelvic limbs, indicates
lower motor neuron involvement of the thoracic limbs; a lesion is most likely to be
present in the ventral gray columns at spinal cord segments C6-T2 or thoracic limb
peripheral nerves of muscle.
Gait abnormalities can occur in all four limbs, with lesions affecting the white matter
in the caudal brainstem, when head signs, such as CN deficits, are used to define
the site of the lesion. Lesions affecting the cerebrum cause no change in gait or
posture.
It is important for clinicians to recognize that a poor level of agreement exists
between skilled and experienced observers of gait abnormalities in horses.
5
There is also poor agreement between pathology and clinical signs. The level of agreement
is particularly poor when gait abnormalities are subtle. Consequently, there is an
important need to develop a set of objective parameters that quantify the severity
of ataxia in horses, with appropriate repeatability.
Neck and Forelimbs
If a gait abnormality was evident in the thoracic limbs and there was no evidence
of brain involvement, then examination of the neck and forelimbs can confirm involvement
of the spinal cord, peripheral nerves (spinal cord segments C1-T2), or thoracic limb
muscles. The neck and forelimbs are examined for evidence of gross skeletal defects,
asymmetry of the neck, and muscle atrophy. The neck should be manipulated from side
to side and up and down to detect any evidence of resistance or pain. Localized unilateral
sweating of the neck and cranial shoulder is evidence of Horner's syndrome, in which
there are varying degrees of ptosis; prolapse of the third eyelid; miosis; enophthalmos;
and increased temperature of the face, neck, and shoulder. The syndrome is associated
with lesions affecting the descending sympathetic fibers in the white matter of the
spinal cord or gray matter in the cranial thoracic segments, thoracocervical sympathetic
trunk, cervical vagosympathetic trunk, or cranial cervical ganglion and its preganglionic
and postganglionic fibers.
Sensory perception from the neck and forelimbs is assessed using a painful stimulus
such as a blunt needle or forceps. The local responses as well as the cerebral responses
are noted when the skin over the shoulders and down the limbs is pricked.
Gait deficits are evaluated by making the horse or halter-broken ruminant perform
a series of movements. Such exercises should include walking and trotting in a straight
line, in large circles, in tight circles, backing on a level ground and on a slight
slope, walking and trotting over curbs or low obstacles, walking in straight lines
and circles, and walking on a slope with the head held elevated. The sway reaction
for the thoracic limb is assessed by pushing against the shoulders and forcing the
animal first to resist and then to take a step laterally. This can be done while the
animal is standing still and walking forward. Pulling the tail and lead rope laterally
at the same time will assess the strength on each side of the body. Making the animal
turn in a tight circle by pulling the lead rope and tail at the same time will indicate
strength; an adult horse should be able to pull the examiner around and should not
pivot on a limb or be pulled to the side. Pressing down with the fingers on the withers
of a normal animal causes some arching, followed by resistance to the downward pressure.
An animal with weakness in the thoracic limbs may not be able to resist this pressure
by fixing its vertebral column but will arch its back more than normal and often buckle
in the thoracic limbs.
In smaller farm animal species, other postural reactions can be performed. These include
wheelbarrowing and the hopping response test. The spinal reflexes are assumed to be
intact in animals that are ambulating normally.
If a large mature horse, cow, or pig has a gait abnormality, it is very rare to cast
the animal to assess the spinal reflexes. However, spinal reflexes are usually examined
in calves, sheep, and goats.
A recumbent animal that can use its thoracic limbs to sit up in the dog-sitting position
may have a lesion caudal to spinal cord segment T2. If a recumbent animal cannot attain
a dog-sitting position, the lesion may be in the cervical spinal cord. In lambs aged
between 4 and 10 weeks with thoracic vertebral body abscesses extending into the epidural
space causing spinal cord compression, the thoracic limbs are normal and the lambs
frequently adopt a dog-sitting position and move themselves around using the thoracic
limbs only. Lambs with a cervical spinal cord lesion are unable to maintain sternal
recumbency and have paresis of all four limbs.
However, mature cattle with the downer cow syndrome secondary to hypocalcemia may
be unable to use both the thoracic and pelvic limbs. If only the head, but not the
neck, can be raised off the ground, there may be a severe cranial cervical lesion.
With a severe caudal cervical lesion, the head and neck can usually be raised off
the ground but thoracic limb function is decreased and the animal is unable to maintain
sternal recumbency.
Assessment of limb function is done by manipulating each limb separately, in its free
state, for muscle tone and sensory and motor activity. A limb that has been lain on
for some time cannot be properly evaluated because there will be poor tone from the
compression. A flaccid limb, with no motor activity, indicates a lower motor lesion
to that limb. A severe upper motor neuron lesion to the thoracic limbs causes decreased,
or absent, voluntary effort, but there is commonly normal or increased muscle tone
in the limbs. This is caused by release of the lower motor neuron, which reflexly
maintains normal muscle tone from the calming influence of the descending upper motor
neuron pathways.
The tone of skeletal muscle may be examined by passively flexing and extending the
limbs and moving the neck from side to side and up and down. Increased muscle tone,
spasticity, or tetany may be so great that the limb cannot be flexed without considerable
effort. If the spastic-extended limb does begin to flex but the resistance remains,
this is known as lead-pipe rigidity, which is seen in tetanus. If after beginning
to flex an extended spastic limb the resistance suddenly disappears (“clasp-knife
release”), then this suggests an upper motor neuron lesion, which occurs in spastic
paresis in cattle.
Flaccidity, or decreased muscle tone, indicates the presence of a lower motor neuron
lesion with interruption of the spinal reflex arc.
Localized atrophy of muscles may be myogenic or neurogenic and the difference can
be determined only by electromyography (EMG), a technique not well suited to large-animal
practice. If the atrophic muscle corresponds to the distribution of a peripheral nerve,
then it is usually assumed that the atrophy is neurogenic. In addition, neurogenic
atrophy is usually rapid (will be clinically obvious in a few days) and much more
marked than either disuse or myogenic atrophy.
Spinal Reflexes of the Thoracic Limbs
Spinal reflexes of the thoracic limbs include the flexor reflex, the biceps reflex,
and the triceps reflex. The flexor reflex is tested by stimulation of the skin of
the distal limb and observing for flexion of the fetlock, knee, elbow, and shoulder.
The reflex arc involves sensory fibers in the median and ulnar nerves, spinal cord
segments C6-T2, and motor fibers in the axillary, musculocutaneous, median, and ulnar
nerves. Lesions cranial to spinal cord segment C6 may release this reflex from the
calming effect of the upper motor neuron pathways and cause an exaggerated reflex
with rapid flexion of the limb, and the limb may remain flexed for some time. A spinal
reflex may be intact without cerebral perception. Cerebral responses to the flexor
reflex include changes in the facial expression, head movement toward the examiner,
and vocalization. Conscious perception of the stimulus will be intact only as long
as the afferent fibers in the median and ulnar nerves, the dorsal gray columns at
spinal cord segments C6-T2, and the ascending sensory pathways in the cervical spinal
cord and brainstem are intact.
The laryngeal adductory reflex is of special interest in the examination of ataxic
horses. In normal horses, a slap on the saddle region just caudal to the withers causes
a flickering adductory movement of the contralateral arytenoid cartilage that is visible
by an endoscope. Reflex muscle contraction can be palpated on the dorsolateral surfaces
of the larynx. The reflex is absent when there is damage to afferent tracts up the
spinal cord, when there is damage to the recurrent laryngeal nerves, and in tense
or frightened horses. Elicitation of the reflex is called the slap test.
Trunk and Hindlimbs
If examination of the posture, gait, head, neck, or thoracic limbs reveals evidence
of a lesion, then an attempt should be made to explain any further signs found during
examination of the trunk and hindlimbs that could have been caused by the lesion.
If there are only signs in the trunk and hindlimbs, then the lesion(s) must be either
between spinal cord segments T2 and S2 or in the trunk and pelvic limb nerves or muscles.
It must be remembered that a subtle neurologic gait in the pelvic limbs may be anywhere
between the midsacral spinal cord and the rostral brainstem.
The trunk and hindlimbs are observed and palpated for malformations and asymmetry.
Diffuse or localized sweating, the result of epinephrine release and sympathetic denervation,
is often present in horses affected with a severe spinal cord injury.
Gentle pricking of the skin over the trunk and over the lateral aspects of the body
wall on both sides, including on either side of the thoracolumbar vertebral column,
will test-stimulate the cutaneous trunci reflex. The sensory stimulus travels to the
spinal cord in thoracolumbar spinal nerves at the level of the site of stimulation.
These impulses are transmitted up the spinal cord to spinal cord segments C8-T1, where
the lateral thoracic nerve is stimulated, causing contraction of the cutaneous trunci
muscle, which is seen as a flicking of the skin over the trunk. Lesions anywhere along
this pathway will result in suppression or absence of this reflex caudal to the site
of the lesion. Degrees of hypalgesia and analgesia have been detected caudal to the
sites of thoracolumbar spinal cord lesions, especially if they are severe. In mature
cattle with fractured thoracolumbar vertebrae associated with traumatic injury or
vertebral body abscesses in calves, the site of the lesion may be able to be localized
with this reflex. Sensory perception of pinpricking the trunk and hindlimbs may also
be absent caudal to the lesion.
The sway reaction for the pelvic limbs involves pushing against the pelvis and pulling
on the tail with the animal standing still and walking forward. An animal that is
weak in the pelvic limbs will be easily pulled and pushed laterally, especially while
walking. Proprioceptive deficits can be observed as overabduction and crossing of
the limbs when a step is taken to the side.
Pinching and pressing down on the thoracolumbar or sacral paravertebral muscles with
the fingers causes a normal animal to extend slightly, then fix, the thoracolumbar
vertebral column. It also resists the ventral motion and usually does not flex the
thoracic or pelvic limbs. A weak animal usually is not able to resist the pressure
by fixing the vertebral column; thus it overextends the back and begins to buckle
in the pelvic limbs.
In the recumbent animal, examination of the pelvic limbs includes the pelvic limb
spinal reflexes, the degree of voluntary effort, and the muscle tone present. Observing
the animal attempting to rise on its own or following some coaxing will help to assess
the pelvic limbs. The flexor spinal reflex is performed by pricking the skin and observing
the flexion of the limb; central perception of the painful stimulus is also noted.
The afferent and efferent pathways for this reflex are in the sciatic nerve and involve
spinal cord segments L5-S3.
The patellar reflex is evaluated by placing the animal in lateral recumbency and supporting
the limb in a partly flexed position. The intermediate patellar ligament (horses)
or patellar ligament (ruminants, pigs, and New World camelids) is then tapped with
a heavy metal plexor. This results in extension of the stifle joint. The sensory and
motor fibers for this reflex are in the femoral nerve, and the spinal cord segments
are L4 and L5. The patellar reflex is hyperactive in newborn farm animals. The gastrocnemius
reflex and the cranial tibial reflex are not evaluated because they cannot be reliably
induced.
The spinal cord of the calf has more control of basic physical functions than in humans,
dogs, and horses. For example, calves are able to retain control of the pelvic limb
in spite of experimentally induced lesions that cause hemiplegia in dogs and humans.
Also, transection of the spinothalamic tract in the calf cord does not produce an
area of hypalgesia or analgesia on the contralateral side as such a lesion would do
in a human.
Skin sensation of the pelvic limbs should be assessed independently from reflex activity.
The femoral nerve is sensory to the skin of the medial thigh region, the peroneal
nerve to the dorsal tarsus and metatarsus, and the tibial nerve to the plantar surface
of the metatarsus.
Tail and Anus
Tail tone is evaluated by lifting the tail and noting the resistance to movement.
A flaccid tail, with no voluntary movement, is indicative of a lesion of the sacrococcygeal
spinal cord segments, nerves, or muscles. Decreased tone in the tail can be detected
with severe spinal cord lesions cranial to the coccygeal segment.
The perineal reflex is elicited by lightly pricking the skin of the perineum and observing
reflex contraction of the anal sphincter and clamping down of the tail. The sensory
fibers are contained within the perineal branches of the pudendal nerve (spinal cord
segments S1-S3). Contraction of the anal sphincter is mediated by the caudal rectal
branch of the pudendal nerve, and tail flexion is mediated by the sacral and coccygeal
segments and nerves (spinal cord segments S1-coccyx). An animal with a flaccid tail
and anus, caused by a lower motor neuron lesion, will not have an anal or tail reflex.
However, it may still have normal sensation from the anus and tail provided that the
sensory nerves and spinal cord and brainstem white matter nociceptive pathways are
intact.
Observation of defecation and urination movements and postures contributes to knowledge
of the state of the cauda equina. Thus neuritis of the cauda equina is characterized
by flaccid paralysis and analgesia of the tail, anus and perineum, rectum, and bladder.
There is no paresis or paralysis of the hindlimbs unless lumbosacral segments of the
cord are damaged.
Palpation of the Bony Encasement of the Central Nervous System
Palpable or visible abnormalities of the cranium or spinal column are not commonly
encountered in diseases of the nervous system, but this examination should not be
neglected. There may be displacement, abnormal configuration, or pain on deep palpation.
These abnormalities are much more readily palpable in the vertebral column and if
vertebrae are fractured. Abnormal rigidity or flexibility of the vertebral column,
such as occurs in atlantooccipital malformations in Arabian horses and cattle, may
also be detectable by manipulation.
Collection and Examination of Cerebrospinal Fluid
The collection and laboratory analysis of CSF from farm animals with clinical evidence
of nervous system disease can provide useful diagnostic and prognostic information.
A case series involving 102 cattle highlighted the clinical utility of CSF analysis
in the antemortem diagnoses of nervous diseases.
6
CSF is formed mostly from the choroid plexuses of the lateral, third, and fourth ventricles
by the ultrafiltration of plasma and the active transport of selected substances across
the blood-brain barrier; as such CSF should be regarded as a modified ultrafiltrate
of plasma. A small amount of CSF is formed from the ependymal lining of the ventricular
system, the pia arachnoid and meningeal blood vessels, and the central canal of the
spinal cord. The rate of CSF turnover is approximately 1% per minute; accordingly,
it takes many minutes for systemic electrolyte or acid-base changes (such as an increase
in plasma magnesium concentration in hypomagnesemic beef cattle) to result in detectable
and clinically relevant changes in CSF concentrations. CSF in the ventricular system
flows caudally and diffuses out of the lateral recess in the fourth ventricle to circulate
around the brain and spinal cord. The presence of CSF in the subarachnoid space separates
the brain and spinal cord from the bony cranium and vertebral column, which reduces
trauma to the underlying delicate nervous tissue. CSF flows within the subarachnoid
space of leptomeninges, and it is primarily in this location that CSF equilibrates
with the extracellular fluid (ECF) compartment of CNS parenchyma.
6
It also helps regulate intracranial pressure, maintains electrolyte and acid-base
homeostasis, serves as an intracerebral transport system for neurotransmitters and
hormones, and has excretory functions with the removal of products of cerebral metabolism.
CSF analysis therefore provides a clinically valuable insight into diseases of the
CNS.
Collection of Cerebrospinal Fluid
CSF can be collected from the lumbosacral cistern with sedation (horses) or restraint
(ruminants) and the atlantooccipital cistern (cisterna magna) using injectable general
anesthesia. For collection it is necessary to puncture the subarachnoid space in either
the lumbosacral space or cisterna magna. Although there is no substantial difference
between the composition of lumbosacral or cisternal CSF samples unless there is a
compressive lesion of the spinal cord, the general policy is to sample as close to
the lesion as possible, with the exception that atlantooccipital sampling should not
be attempted in animals suspected to have increased intracranial pressure. CSF should
be collected into a sterile tube and there is no need to add an anticoagulant, even
in samples visibly contaminated with blood. Cytology should be performed as soon as
possible after collection (ideally within 15 minutes) because the cells rapidly degenerate
after collection. The reason for this rapid degeneration appears to be associated
with the low oncotic pressure in CSF; the addition of autologous serum to make a 11%
serum solution permitted storage of bovine CSF samples for 24 hours at 4°C before
cytologic examination was performed with no loss in cell integrity.
7
The addition of serum to CSF in a ratio that provides an approximate final serum solution
of approximately 11% should therefore be considered if there is an unavoidable delay
before cytologic examination can be performed.
8
Collection From the Lumbosacral Cistern
The lumbosacral site is preferred because general anesthesia is not required. CSF
can be collected from the lumbosacral cistern with relative ease provided that adequate
restraint can be achieved and the anatomic landmarks can be identified. It can be
collected from the standing or recumbent animal. If recumbent, the animal should be
placed in sternal recumbency with hips flexed and the pelvic limbs extended alongside
the abdomen. This widens the lumbosacral space to permit correct placement of the
spinal needle. Ultrasonographic guidance has been described but is rarely needed.
9
The site for collection is the midpoint of the lumbosacral space, which can be identified
as the midline depression between the last palpable dorsal lumbar spine (L6 in cattle,
goats, and horses; L6 or L7 in sheep and pigs; L7 in New World camelids) and the first
palpable sacral dorsal spine (usually S2). In well-conditioned animals, these landmarks
cannot always be identified; in which case the site is identified as the midpoint
of a line connecting the caudal aspect of the tuber coxae. The site is clipped, surgically
prepared, and 1 to 2 mL of local anesthetic is administered subcutaneously. Sterile
surgical gloves should be worn. Hypodermic spinal needles with stylettes are recommended
because ordinary needles commonly plug with tissue. The length and gauge of needle
depends on the size of the animal, but at least 15-cm (6-inch) 18-gauge needles are
needed for adult horses and cattle. These needles can bend considerably with animal
movement, requiring the use of at least an 18-gauge needle; very tall horses may need
a 20-cm needle because the depth needed maybe 16 to 18 cm. The following guide is
recommended (Table 14-7
).
Table 14-7
Needle length gauge for lumbosacral cerebrospinal fluid collection
Table 14-7
Species and body weight
Length (cm) and gauge of needle
Lambs < 30 kg
2.5 and 20
Ewes 40–80 kg
4.0 and 20
Rams > 80 kg
5.0 and 20
Calves < 100 kg
4.0 and 20
Calves 100–200 kg
5.0 and 18
Cattle > 200 kg
10.0–15.0 and 18
Provided the animal is well restrained and care is exercised in introducing the needle,
little difficulty should be encountered. For collection from the lumbosacral space
the needle is slowly advanced perpendicular or up to 15 degrees caudal to perpendicular
to the plane of the vertebral column. The needle must be introduced in a perfectly
vertical position relative to the plane of the animal's vertebral column because of
the danger of entering one of the lateral blood vessels in the vertebral canal. Changes
in tissue resistance can be felt as the needle point passes sequentially through the
subcutaneous tissue and interarcuate ligament; then there is a sudden “‘pop” caused
by the loss of resistance as the needle point penetrates the ligamentum flavum into
the epidural space. Once the needle point has penetrated the dorsal subarachnoid space,
CSF will well up in the needle hub within 2 to 3 seconds. Failure to appreciate the
changes in resistance as the needle moves down may result in puncture of the conus
medullaris, which may elicit an immediate pain response and some discomfort. Movement
of the pelvic limbs may dislodge the needle point, with the risk of causing local
trauma and hemorrhage in the leptomeninges, which results in blood in the sample.
Repeated CSF taps of the lumbosacral space may make it more difficult to obtain an
adequate sample volume because of fibrosis of epidural tissue.
Careful aspiration with a syringe attached to the needle held between the thumb and
index finger is usually required to obtain a sample of 2 to 3 mL, which is sufficient
for laboratory analysis. This can be facilitated by firmly resting the forearms and
wrists on the animal's back. Failure to obtain fluid is usually caused by incorrect
direction of the needle, in which the case the bony landmarks of the lumbosacral space
(depression) must be rechecked and, with the needle correctly realigned, the procedure
repeated. Occasional small rotations of the needle to change the direction of the
bevel can be successful in obtaining CSF, particularly in smaller animals.
In animals with a vertebral body abscess and neurologic disease confined to the hindlimbs,
CSF may be difficult to obtain from the lumbosacral space because flow is occluded.
In these circumstances, if a sample is obtained, the CSF protein may be increased
as a result of stagnation of CSF distal to the lesion with exudation or transudation
of protein from the lesion (Froin's syndrome).
Collection From the Atlantooccipital Cistern (Cisterna Magna)
This site is preferred for intracranial lesions because the fluid is produced in the
subarachnoid space and flows caudally down the spinal cord. However, this site is
rarely used because of the inherent risk of needle penetration of the brainstem. Xylazine
at 0.20 mg/kg body weight (BW) intramuscularly is effective in providing adequate
sedation and analgesia for this procedure in cattle. A general anesthetic (such as
combined intravenous administration of xylazine and ketamine) is recommended for horses.
Ultrasonographic guidance has been described but is rarely needed.
The site is prepared as with the lumbosacral cistern. Ventriflexion of the head and
neck of cattle enlarges the space of the cisterna magna and allows easy entry using
a styletted spinal needle inserted at a point created by the transection of the transverse
line of the cranial rim of the wing of the atlas and the dorsal midline. The needle
is advanced carefully and steadily, and the tip is directed rostrally toward the symphysis
of the lower jaw. The needle point goes through the skin, ligamentum nuchae, and leptomeninges.
In most mature cattle with a BW over 500 kg, a 20-gauge, 10-cm (4-inch) spinal needle
will enter the cisterna magna at 5 to 7 cm after going through the ligamentum nuchae,
which provides some increased resistance. A 20-gauge 3.8-cm (1.5-inch) needle can
be used in sheep, goats, foals, and neonatal calves. The entrance to the cisterna
magna is at a depth of approximately 4 to 6 cm in adult horses and 1.5 to 2.5 cm in
neonatal foals. Once at the lower range of the anticipated depth to enter the cisterna
magna, the spinal needle is advanced 1 to 2 mm at a time. When the needle point punctures
the leptomeninges, the animal may move its head slightly. At that point the needle
is advanced only 1 to 2 mm and the stylette is then removed. If the end of the needle
is in the cisterna magna, CSF will flow out of the needle freely and the manometer
can be attached and the pressure measured.
Cerebrospinal Fluid Pressure
CSF pressure can be determined by the use of a manometer attached to the spinal needle.
Normal CSF pressures of the cisterna magna in cattle and xylazine/ketamine-anesthetized
horses range from 5 to 15 cm H2O (unknown reference point) and 28 ± 4 cm H2O (referenced
to the right atrium), respectively. When the fluid system is properly connected, occlusion
of both jugular veins causes a marked rise in CSF pressure; this is called Queckenstedt's
test. This test involves bilateral jugular vein compression, which results in a sudden
increase in intracranial subarachnoid pressure that is transmitted to the cranial
subarachnoid space. The resultant CSF pressure wave is transmitted to the lumbar area
(when obtaining CSF from the lumbosacral space) in the absence of an obstruction in
the spinal subarachnoid space, resulting in an increased flow of CSF.
Variations in CSF pressure are not of much use in clinical diagnosis except in hypovitaminosis
A, and measurement of CSF pressure is only indicated in animals with signs of cerebral
disease (abnormal mentation) that may have cerebral edema. Care is needed in interpreting
results because the pressure is greatly affected by voluntary movement such as tenesmus.
CSF pressure is increased in a number of diseases, including PEM, bacterial meningitis,
and hypovitaminosis A, reflecting the presence of increased intracranial pressure.
Xylazine given intravenously causes a decrease in intracranial pressure in healthy
conscious horses. Intracranial pressure is increased in anesthetized horses when their
head is placed lower than their heart because of an increase in the hydrostatic pressure
gradient.
10
Epidural pressure of cattle changes with change in position from standing to lateral
recumbency to dorsal recumbency, and epidural pressure is positive in laterally recumbent
animals.
Analysis of Cerebrospinal Fluid
Analysis of CSF has greater diagnostic value than hematology in animals with nervous
system disease. CSF can be examined for the presence of protein, cells, and bacteria.
The white blood cell count in normal animals is usually less than 5 cells/µL.
11
An increase in the CSF leukocyte count above 5 cells/µL is termed a pleocytosis and
is categorized as mild (6 to 49 cells/µL), moderate (50 to 200 cells/µL), or marked
(>200 cells/µL). The differential white cell count comprises mostly lymphocytes and
monocytes (mononuclear cells predominate); there are no erythrocytes in the CSF of
healthy animals with an atraumatic CSF tap. Cytologic examination of CSF is usually
done after a Cytospin preparation that carefully concentrates the cells without destroying
their architecture. This is needed because the cell count in CSF is usually very low.
With bacterial infections of the nervous system, the CSF concentration of protein
will be increased and the white blood cell count increased up to 2000 cells/µL with
more than 70% neutrophils. A neutrophilic pleocytosis is considered 95% to 100% indicative
of an inflammatory process within the CNS. Samples that show visible turbidity usually
contain large numbers of cells (>500 cells/µL) and a great deal of protein.
The CSF glucose concentration is usually 60% to 80% of serum glucose concentration;
this steady-state value reflects facilitated transport across the blood-brain barrier,
absence of binding proteins for glucose in CSF, and nervous tissue metabolism of glucose.
However, sudden changes in plasma glucose concentrations are not immediately reflected
in CSF glucose concentrations, because CSF turns over at around 1% per minute. Typically,
a lag time of up to 3 hours is needed for CSF glucose concentration to be in equilibrium
with plasma glucose concentrations. Therefore hyperglycemia from the stress of handling
and restraint may not be reflected by an increased CSF glucose concentration.
In cattle, protein concentrations range from 23 to 60 mg/dL, sodium concentrations
from 132 to 144 mmol/L, potassium 2.7 to 3.2 mmol/L, magnesium 1.8 to 2.1 mEq/L, and
glucose concentrations 37 to 51 mg/dL. In the horse, the reference values for CSF
are similar. Neonatal foals under 3 weeks of age have higher CSF protein concentrations
than do adult horses. Glucose concentrations peak in the first 48 hours after birth
and then decrease to adult values by the second week of life. Concentrations of sodium
and potassium are not affected by age and are similar to values reported for adult
horses and ponies. In sheep, protein concentrations range from 12 to 60 mg/dL and
glucose concentrations from 38 to 63 mg/dL.
Cytokine concentrations in CSF may have prognostic value,
11
and the cytokine gene expression in nucleated cells in CSF may have clinical utility
in the diagnosis of specific nervous diseases.
13
The presence of one or more eosinophils in CSF is extremely unusual and should be
assumed to indicate the presence of aberrant parasite migration or fungal encephalitis.
Theoretically, the CSF glucose concentration will be decreased and CSF lactate concentration
will be increased in animals with bacterial meningitis because of bacterial metabolism,
but these are unreliable signs and usually do not provide additional information to
that provided by determination of CSF leukocyte and protein concentrations. Bacteria
may also be cultured from the CSF.
The creatine kinase and lactate dehydrogenase activities in CSF have been examined
as an aid in the differentiation of some neurologic diseases. However, creatine kinase
activity is considered to be unreliable in the horse; contamination of the sample
with epidural fat and dura may increase CSF creatine kinase activity. In contrast,
CSF creatine kinase activity >19.5 U/L provided an excellent prognostic test of nonrecovery
in sheep with Listeriosis.
12
Insufficient information is available to evaluate the clinical utility of CSF lactate
dehydrogenase activity in large animals.
Blood contamination of CSF can make interpretation difficult. A formula has been developed
that “corrects” the CSF values for the degree of blood contamination, based on the
red blood cell count (RBC) in CSF (RBC
CSF) and blood (RBC
blood), in which the corrected value for substance X in CSF (X
corrected, where X is a concentration or activity) is derived from the measured value
of X in CSF (X
CSF) and blood (X
blood) and applying the following formula:
X
corrected
=
X
C
S
F
−
(
X
blood
×
R
B
C
C
S
F
/
R
B
C
blood
)
.
Calculation of a “corrected” value rarely provides additional insight into the CSF
analysis and is not commonly practiced in large animals. Xanthochromia is a slight
yellow tinge to CSF that indicates previous erythrocyte lysis or more commonly increased
protein concentration. A foamy appearance to the CSF is also suggestive of increased
protein concentration.
Protein fractionation of CSF is not routinely performed because it requires sensitive
electrophoresis methodology or species-specific radial immunodiffusion assays. Albumin
(ALB) concentration in CSF can also be measured using an immunologic technique based
on the detection of albumin–antialbumin immune complexes by nephelometry.
7
Calculation of the albumin quotient and IgG index may be informative in specific neurologic
diseases. Theoretically, these calculations can differentiate four blood-brain permeability
patterns, normal blood-brain barrier permeability (normal albumin quotient and IgG
index), intrathecal IgG production with normal blood-brain barrier permeability (normal
albumin quotient and increased IgG index), increased blood-brain barrier permeability
without intrathecal IgG production (increased albumin quotient and normal IgG index),
and increased blood-brain barrier permeability with intrathecal production of IgG
(increased albumin quotient and increased IgG index). The albumin quotient is calculated
from the albumin concentration in CSF (ALB
CSF) and serum (ALB
serum), in which:
Albumin
Quotient
=
(
A
L
B
C
S
F
)
×
100
/
(
A
L
B
serum
)
.
The normal range for albumin quotient in the adult horse is 0.6 to 2.2 for atlantooccipital
CSF samples and 0.7 to 2.3 for lumbosacral CSF samples, but the mean is 0.4 to 0.5
in cattle and adult llamas. Because CSF protein is most often derived by disturbance
of the blood-brain barrier and inflammation (resulting in an increased CSF albumin
concentration), an increased CSF protein concentration is usually accompanied by an
increased albumin quotient.
In animals suspected to have increased immunoglobulin production in the CNS (a rare
occurrence, and almost always accompanied by disturbance of the blood-brain barrier),
the IgG index can be calculated from the IgG concentration in CSF (IgG
CSF) and serum (IgG
serum), and the albumin concentration in CSF (ALB
CSF) and serum (ALB
serum), in which:
I
g
G
Index
=
(
I
g
G
C
S
F
/
(
I
g
G
serum
)
×
(
A
L
B
serum
/
A
L
B
C
S
F
/
)
.
An IgG index of more than 0.3 is suspected to indicate intrathecal IgG production
in the adult horse. This formula corrects the CSF IgG concentration for an increased
permeability of the blood-brain barrier; therefore, theoretically it provides a more
sensitive method for detecting local production of IgG within the CNS. Calculating
the albumin quotient and IgG index is expensive and rarely provides additional information
to that provided by CSF protein concentration alone, and for this reason is not commonly
performed in large animals.
When antigen-specific titers are measured, two modified CSF indices, the Goldmann–Witmer
coefficient (
C-value) and the antibody index (AI), can be calculated to distinguish intrathecal
versus passively acquired antibodies in the CSF.14, 15 The C-value is calculated as
C
-
value
=
(
I
g
G
serum
×
reciprocal
C
S
F
titer
)
/
(
I
g
G
C
S
F
×
reciprocal
serum
titer
)
.
The AI is calculated as the ratio of the specific antibody quotient to the albumin
quotient, in which
A
I
=
(
{
reciprocal
C
S
F
titer
}
/
{
reciprocal
serum
titer
}
)
/
(
{
C
S
F
albumin
concentration
}
/
{
serum
albumin
concentration
}
)
.
The urine dipstick protein test provides a useful on-farm assessment of CSF protein
concentration and is underutilized in clinical practice. Most dipsticks use the following
gradations of trace (<25 mg/dL), 1+ (28–75 mg/dL), 2+ (115–240 mg/dL), and 3+ (470–590 mg/dL),
and a study of dog CSF samples indicated that all dogs with a urine dipstick protein
of 2+ or greater had increased CSF protein concentration.
16
Similar studies do not appear to have been conducted in large animals.
The Pandy test also provides a useful on-farm assessment of CSF protein concentration.
The basis for the test is that proteins (globulin and albumin) are precipitated by
a saturated solution of phenol in water. The Pandy test uses a 10% solution of carbolic
acid crystals dissolved in water (providing a saturated aqueous solution of phenol);
the solution is termed Pandy's solution. One milliliter of Pandy's solution is placed
in a glass tube and one drop (approximately 0.05 mL) of CSF is carefully layered on
top. A turbid appearance at the interface signifies the presence of elevated concentrations
of globulin or albumin in the CSF and is regarded as a positive Pandy's reaction (usually
a total protein concentration greater than approximately 50 mg/dL). A variant of the
test has the sample thoroughly mixed and the degree of turbidity ranked from 1+ (faint
turbidity) to 4+ (dense milk-colored precipitate). A negative Pandy's reaction shows
no turbidity or precipitate, and this is the expected result in normal CSF samples.
A positive control (4+) can be run at the same time by adding a drop of serum or plasma
to 1 mL of Pandy's solution. Because Pandy's solution contains phenol, clinicians
should wear gloves and protective eyewear when handling the solution, and dispose
of used reagents appropriately.
In summary, collection and analysis of CSF from the lumbosacral region provides a
practical, safe, and informative diagnostic tool in conscious large animals with neurologic
disease. Analysis of CSF in animals with CNS disease has greater diagnostic value
than analysis of the leukon or serum biochemical analysis. Routine assessment of CSF
should include total protein concentration (including the semiquantitative Pandy test
and urine dipstick measurement), erythrocyte count, leukocyte count, and leukocyte
differential count. Other analytical procedures on CSF can be performed in specific
diseases related to the nervous system.
Examination of the Nervous System With Serum Biochemical Analysis
Arterial Plasma Ammonia Concentration
In animals suspected of having hepatic encephalopathy, measurement of the arterial
plasma ammonia concentration provides a clinically useful diagnostic test and a means
of monitoring the response to treatment. In monogastrics, ammonia is produced by bacterial
degradation of amines, amino acids, and purines in the gastrointestinal tract, by
the action of bacterial and intestinal urease on urea in the gastrointestinal tract,
and by the catabolism of glutamine by enterocytes. In ruminants, ammonia is derived
predominantly from bacterial metabolism in the rumen and catabolism of amino acids
in tissue. Absorbed ammonia is normally converted to urea by the liver and to glutamine
by the liver, skeletal muscle, and brain. In the presence of hepatic dysfunction,
ammonia is inadequately metabolized, resulting in high plasma ammonia concentrations.
Ammonia is a direct neurotoxin that alters inhibitory and excitatory neurotransmission
in the brain.
Hyperammonemia can be used as a specific indicator of hepatic dysfunction. Normal
values for arterial plasma ammonia concentration are less than 29 µmol/L in adult
cattle but may reach higher values in the immediate periparturient period. Arterial
values are higher than venous values and are preferred for analysis.
Blood gas analysis and serum electrolyte determination should be routinely undertaken
in animals with clinical signs of encephalopathy to rule out metabolic causes of cerebral
dysfunction.
Further Reading
Aleman
M
Miscellaneous neurologic or neuromuscular disorders of horses
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
481
506
22100041
Constable
PD
Clinical examination of the ruminant nervous system
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
215
230
15203223
Levine
JM
Levine
GJ
Hoffman
AG
Mez
J
Bratton
GR
Comparative anatomy of the horse, ox, and dog: the vertebral column and peripheral
nerves
Equine Comp Cont Educ Pract Vet
2
2007
279
292
Schwarz
B
Piercy
RJ
Cerebrospinal fluid collection and its analysis in equine neurologic disease
Equine Vet Educ
18
2006
243
248
Scott
PR
Cerebrospinal fluid collection and analysis in suspected sheep neurological disease
Small Rumin Res
92
2010
96
103
References
1
Cavalleri
JMV
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
105
23702154
2
Verdes
JM
J Vet Diagn Invest
18
2006
299
16789723
3
Sprake
PM
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
1242
23952523
4
Raoofi
A
Vet J
181
2009
296
18396429
5
Olsen
E
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
630
24612411
6
Stokol
T
Vet Clin Pathol
38
2009
103
19228366
7
Goehring
LS
J Vet Diagn Invest
18
2006
251
16789712
8
D'Angelo
A
Vet Rec
164
2009
491
19377088
9
Aleman
M
J Am Vet Med Assoc
230
2007
378
17269870
10
Brosnan
RJ
Am J Vet Res
69
2008
737
18518653
11
Ameri
M
Mousavian
R
Vet Res Commun
31
2007
77
17180453
12
El-Boshy
ME
Small Rumin Res
104
2012
179
13
Pusterla
N
Am J Vet Res
67
2006
1433
16881858
14
Furr
M
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
138
21155894
15
Reed
SM
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
1193
24033423
16
Jacobs
RM
Can Vet J
31
1990
587
17423648
Examination of the Nervous System With Imaging Techniques
Radiography
Examination of the bony skeleton of the head and vertebral column to detect abnormalities
that are affecting the nervous system of large animals is commonly used in referral
centers. Conventional diagnostic radiography remains the best method for the initial
evaluation of trauma to the brain and spinal cord, but usually the trauma needs to
have displaced bone for the lesion to be readily visible on a radiograph. Lesions
that can be identified on plain radiographs include fractured, luxated, or subluxated
vertebra; intervertebral disk prolapse; discospondylitis; osteomyelitis; and neoplasia.
1
The injection of contrast media into the CSF system (myelography) is used for the
detection of spinal cord compression but is not often performed in large animals because
spinal cord depression surgery is rarely undertaken and because sensitivity and specificity
estimates are low depending on criteria used for interpretation.
2
In cases of peripheral nerve injury the radiograph of the appropriate limb may reveal
the presence of a fracture or space-occupying lesion that has caused dysfunction of
the peripheral nerve.
Radiography has been used to diagnose lesions of the tympanic bullae in cattle (otitis
interna) characterized by thickening of the bulla wall, increased soft tissue opacity
within the bulla, and osteolysis of the bulla wall and trabeculations.
3
Radiography is not as sensitive as computed tomography (CT) for the diagnosis of otitis
media, however, because CT provides more detailed information regarding the bony structures
of the middle ear
4
and is more sensitive and specific than radiography in the diagnosis of otitis media
in calves.
3
Computed Tomography
CT of the skull has several advantages over radiography because structures are viewed
in cross section without superimposition. The use of contrast agents and development
of computer software and technology that permit rapid acquisition times and three-dimensional
reconstruction allows a large amount of information to be obtained from a CT examination.
Numerous diseases of the head of the horse, including those of the brain and cervical
spine, can be diagnosed using this technique, but the limiting factors are the weight
of the patient (a custom-designed table is required for adult horses and cattle),
accessibility for large animals, and the need for general anesthesia.
CT provides an excellent image of skeletal cranial defects and soft tissue defects
that differ considerably from surrounding tissue. CT has been used for the antemortem
diagnosis of many conditions in foals, horses, and cattle, including cerebral abscess,
porencephaly, meningoencephalocele, pituitary adenoma, cervical stenotic myelopathy,
spinal cord rupture, and otitis interna/media, and has been used to guide brain biopsy
for in vivo diagnosis of an intracranial mass.4, 5, 6, 7 CT provides less contrast
resolution than magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), but CT provides better spatial resolution
(i.e., is more able to differentiate fine anatomic features such as bone trabeculae),
is more widely available, and has a shorter scan acquisition time. In a case series
of 57 cases, CT was a useful diagnostic test in horses with abnormal mentation or
a history of trauma followed by a period of unconsciousness. In contrast, CT did not
provide clinically helpful information in horses with seizures.
8
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
MRI scanning uses nuclear magnetic resonance to create cross-sectional images based
on the magnetic properties of tissues. In general, MRI provides an excellent image
of soft tissue defects and is considered superior to CT for intracranial and intraspinal
lesions because MRI provides a high contrast between soft tissues and better anatomic
detail. MRI can be performed in standing sedated horses; however, these MRI units
(typically 0.25 T) produce low-resolution images that may not have sufficient detail
to be diagnostic for many nervous diseases. Higher resolution images are produced
by more expensive magnets (typically 1.0–3.0 T) that require the patient be immobile.
The limiting factors for MRI use are therefore cost (MRI is more expensive than CT),
the weight of the patient, accessibility for large animals, and the need for general
anesthesia for higher resolution images (usually MRI has a longer imaging time than
CT). Other challenges specific to MRI are that the environment provides considerable
challenges for the monitoring of anesthesia and the placement of limbs to minimize
postanesthetic myopathy/neuropathy syndrome, particularly in horses.
9
MRI has been used for the antemortem diagnosis of a number of neurologic conditions
in foals and horses, including brain abscess, hydrocephalus, nigropallidal encephalomalacia,
10
cerebellar abiotrophy in Arabian horses,
11
cervical stenotic myelopathy,
2
and peripheral nerve sheath tumor (PNST) in the tongue.
12
MRI has also been used to diagnose PEM and cerebellar hypoplasia in calves
13
and PEM, leukoencephalomalacia, and porencephaly and demyelination in sheep and goats.
14
More studies are required documenting the clinical superiority of MRI versus other
diagnostic modalities. For instance, MRI can differentiate horses with cervical stenotic
myelopathy (CSM) and cervical vertebral stenosis from healthy horses and horses with
other causes for ataxia; however, MRI cannot accurately localize the site of cord
compression.
2
MRI will be more widely used in the diagnosis of nervous diseases, particularly intracranial
and cervical spinal cord disease, as equipment and acquisition costs decrease.
Further Reading
Aleman
M
Miscellaneous neurologic or neuromuscular disorders of horses
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
481
506
22100041
Scrivani
PV
Advanced imaging of the nervous system in the horse
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
439
453
22100039
References
1
Hughes
KJ
Equine Vet Educ
19
2007
460
2
Mitchell
CW
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
53
2012
613
22533785
3
Finnen
A
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
143
21182544
4
Lee
K
Vet Rec
165
2009
559
19897870
5
Ohba
Y
J Vet Med Sci
70
2008
829
18772559
6
Pease
AP
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
1144
21985144
7
Vanschandevijl
K
J Am Vet Med Assoc
233
2008
950
18795858
8
Sogaro-Robinson
C
J Am Vet Med Assoc
235
2009
176
19601739
9
Franci
P
Equine Vet J
38
2006
497
17124838
10
Jose-Cunilleras
E
Piercy
RJ
Equine Vet Educ
19
2007
179
11
Cavalleri
JMV
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
105
23702154
12
Schneider
A
Equine Vet Educ
22
2010
346
13
Tsuka
T
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
49
2008
149
18418995
14
Schenk
HC
J Vet Intern Med
21
2007
865
17708412
Ultrasonography
Ultrasonography of the cricoarytenoideus lateralis muscle has been used as part of
the examination of horses with suspected laryngeal hemiplegia and compared with endoscopic
findings obtained at rest and during exercise. An 8.4-MHz curvilinear transducer was
applied over the larynx and four acoustic windows evaluated. Subjectively assessed
increased echogenicity of this muscle had a sensitivity of 94.6% and a specificity
of 94.5% for detecting laryngeal hemiplegia.
1
The reported advantages of ultrasonography are that it is widely available, noninvasive,
and depicts a real-time view of the tissues.
The supraspinous ligament has been evaluated in horses with and without back pathology
using ultrasonography. Linear and sector array transducers (5–10 MHz) were used to
obtain longitudinal and cross-sectional views of the supraspinous ligament, and lesions
were identified and categorized. All 39 horses studied had at least one site of supraspinous
ligament desmitis, and there was no association between desmitis lesions and clinical
signs of pain that could be localized to this region.
2
Ultrasonography has been used to diagnose syringohydromyelia and segmental hypoplasia
of the lumbar spinal cord in a 4-day-old Holstein Friesian calf that had been unable
to stand since birth. The calf was placed in right lateral recumbency, and lumbosacral
flexion was induced to enable widening of ultrasound windows. Diagnostic images of
the lumbar spinal cord were obtained in sagittal and transverse orientations at the
lumbosacral junction (L6-S1), as well as the proximal lumbar intervertebral junctions
up to L2-L3, using a 6- to 10-MHz linear transducer.
3
An ultrasound imaging technique of the tympanic bullae has been developed for the
diagnosis of otitis media in calves.
4
A 7.5-MHz linear probe is applied to the base of the ear without the use of coupling
gel and with the calf in a standing position. The probe is applied ventral to the
base of the ear and caudal to the mandible. Abnormalities detected included anechoic
to hyperechoic content; trabeculae lysis; and thinning, deformation, and rupture of
the bulla wall. In calves, ultrasonography has also been used to identify the femoral
nerve in calves to assist in the diagnosis of spastic paresis cases that involve the
quadriceps muscle (such as in Belgian Blue cattle with a cranially directed hyperextension
of the limb) instead of the more common form of spastic paresis that involves the
gastrocnemius muscle and a caudally directed hyperextension of the hindlimb.5, 6 Placement
of a 5-MHz curved linear array transducer over the dorsal paravertebral space between
the fifth and sixth lumbar transverse processes provided the best view of the femoral
nerve and permitted selective blocking of the femoral nerve using 4% procaine solution.
Endoscopy (Rhinolaryngoscopy)
Endoscopy (rhinolaryngoscopy) is now a routine technique for the examination of horses
with suspected laryngeal hemiplegia, which is a distal axonopathy of the left recurrent
laryngeal nerve.
Endoscopic examination of the epidural and subarachnoid space from the atlantooccipital
space to the eighth cervical nerve has been performed safely in healthy adult horses.
7
The procedure was performed under general anesthesia. The technique may have clinical
utility in the diagnosis of cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy because physical
constraints do not currently permit imaging of the caudal cervical vertebral column
by MRI or CT.
Endoscopy has also been used to examine the anatomic structures in the sacrococcygeal
area of adult cattle. Cows were restrained and sedated with xylazine (0.03 mg/kg,
intravenously). A lidocaine epidural was administered and a flexible endoscope (outside
diameter, 2.3 mm) introduced through an introducer set and a small amount of air introduced.
The procedure permitted visualization of blood vessels, connective tissue, fat, nerves,
and the spinal dura mater.
8
Ophthalmoscopy
Ophthalmoscopy for the examination of the structures of the eye is important in the
diagnosis of diseases affecting the optic nerve such as in vitamin A deficiency and
the optic disc edema (papilledema) associated with diffuse cerebral edema.
Electromyography
Electromyographic needle examination is a technique that records the electrical activity
generated by single muscle fibers and the summated electrical activity of muscle fibers
in individual motor units. The technique involves inserting a recording needle into
the muscle of interest and recording the resultant EMG. Typically, animals are unsedated
and restrained in stocks or a chute. An abnormal EMG signals include short-duration
and low-amplitude motor unit action potentials, which indicate diseased muscle fibers
of early or incomplete reinnervation after denervation. Other abnormalities include
the presence of fibrillation potentials, positive sharp waves, and complex repetitive
discharges that occur when the skeletal cell membrane becomes unstable because of
denervation or myopathy.
EMG provides a more practical diagnostic test than electroencephalography (EEG) and
provides a sensitive indicator of neurologic dysfunction and assists in the neuroanatomic
localization of the lesion.
8
It is especially useful for evaluating peripheral nerve injury and diagnosing hyperkalemic
periodic paresis in horses and should be helpful in additional studies on calving-associated
paralysis and other peripheral nerve injuries in cattle. EMG can discriminate between
lower motor neuron and myogenic disorders, and nerve conduction studies can differentiate
axonal loss from demyelination. In addition, repetitive stimulation can provide information
regarding neuromuscular transmission. Reference values for motor nerve conduction
velocity have been developed for calves and, as expected, conduction velocities are
related to the nerve fiber diameter.
10
Somatosensory evoked potentials of the trigeminal complex using the infraorbital nerve
have been used in horses to assist in the diagnosis of idiopathic head-shaking. An
electrical surface stimulus is applied at a set stimulus rate but variable stimulus
currents to a focal area of the buccal mucosa. Recording electrodes placed along the
sensory pathway of the trigeminal complex detect the presence or absence of sensory
nerve action potentials (SNAPs) and nerve conduction velocity.
11
The threshold current required to trigger a SNAP provides clinically useful information
about the sensitivity of the anatomic location to stimuli.
EMG has been coupled with transcranial magnetic stimulation to induce magnetic motor
evoked potentials in the horse. This provides a useful noninvasive evaluation of cervical
spinal cord dysfunction in horses with radiologic abnormalities of the cervical vertebrae
by detecting the presence of a neuropathy involving the descending motor tracts. However,
EMG does not provide information on upper motor neurons; therefore it is not useful
in the clinical evaluation of horses suspected to have hindlimb neurologic deficits
caused by cervical spinal cord disease.
9
Electroencephalography
EEG has not been used to any significant degree in large animals. It requires sophisticated
equipment, a quiet dim environment free from electrical interference, and a quiet
patient that has minimal muscular activity. Because of the difficulty in obtaining
quality recordings in a conscious large animal, it is preferred that the animal is
sedated or anesthetized for the recording, which confounds interpretation of the EEG
pattern depending on the anesthetic protocol. Thorough and repeated observations of
simultaneously recorded EEG and video may facilitate interpretation of the EEG,12,
13 but the clinical utility of EEG remains uncertain in large animals exhibiting nervous
signs consistent with an intracranial lesion. Therefore EEG has been primarily used
in large animals as an antemortem or research tool, and its use will probably remain
as a complementary test to other neurologic examinations and diagnostic tests at referral
institutions.
Recommendations have been made to standardize EEG techniques for animals; these typically
involve meticulous preparation of the recording sites on the scalp, and placement
of electrodes over the left and right frontal areas, the left and right occipital
areas, and the vertex area, and a reference electrode is placed behind the tip of
the nose. The addition of other recording sites increases the ability to localize
a focal lesion.
12
Neurologic disease is associated with changes in EEG frequency or amplitude, or both,
and frequency changes are a more reliable indicator of disease. In general, focal
EEG abnormalities indicate a focal lesion in the cortex, whereas diffuse EEG abnormalities
indicate diffuse cortical or subcortical lesions or focal subcortical lesions.
EEG has been used to study epilepsy in goats and cattle, congenital hydranencephaly
and hydrocephalus in cattle, scrapie in sheep, thiamine-responsive PEM in cattle,
and BSE in cattle. When performed under controlled conditions, EEG has been shown
to be a useful diagnostic tool for the early diagnosis of equine intracranial diseases,
with adequate sensitivity and specificity.
Electroretinography
Flash electroretinography (ERG) is a recording of rod and cone function of the eyes.
The animal is sedated (usually with xylazine) and topical 0.5% proparacaine is applied
to both eyes to permit the placement of a contact lens electrode on both eyes. Subcutaneous
electrodes are then placed at the lateral canthus and midline at the nostrils to provide
reference and ground electrodes, respectively. A period of dark adaptation is then
implemented, and a standardized flash sequence applied.
10
Decreased B-wave amplitudes during flash ERG have been identified in horses with equine
motor neuron disease and attributed to lipofuscin deposits on the retina.
Brainstem Auditory Evoked Potentials
The brainstem auditory evoked potential (BAEP) is a recording of the electrical activity
of the brainstem following an acoustic stimulation; as such, BAEP can be used to evaluate
the integrity of the auditory pathway. The use of the BAEP permits differentiation
of cochlear pathology (including otitis media/interna) from retrocochlear pathology
(auditory nerve or brainstem).
BAEP is obtained on a sedated patient (xylazine is frequently used) by recording neuroelectrical
activity from generators in the auditory pathway immediately following an acoustic
click stimulus, and BAEP waveforms for horses,
14
ponies, foals,15, 16 and calves have been recorded. Such recordings can be useful
in evaluating horses suspected to have deafness, vestibular disease, brainstem disease,
or temporohyoid osteoarthropathy,
17
as well as calves with otitis media and facial paralysis,
18
and to monitor the response to treatment.
17
Intracranial Pressure Measurement
Intracranial pressure has been measured in neonatal foals, although the clinical utility
of such measurements in foals has not been demonstrated. Increases in intracranial
pressure can cause decreases in cerebral perfusion pressure and irreversible injury
to the CNS.
The head-down position in the horse increases the hydrostatic pressure gradient between
the heart and brain, increasing mean intracranial pressure in isoflurane-anesthetized
horses from 31 to 55 mm Hg when placed in the Trendelenburg position to facilitate
abdominal surgery.
19
Similar directional changes in intraocular pressure were measured in adult horses
sedated with detomidine.
20
Hydrostatic pressure effects on intracranial pressure have also been observed in isoflurane-anesthetized
adult cattle.
21
In other words, large animals suspected to have increased intracranial pressure should
be encouraged to keep their heads elevated to prevent cerebral edema formation. In
addition, head position must be standardized when intracranial pressure is measured.
Kinetic Gait Analysis
Lameness is common in large animals and usually results in asymmetric gait abnormalities;
lameness caused by selected musculoskeletal abnormalities is discussed in Chapter
15. Ataxia caused by spinal cord disease also causes gait abnormalities that are usually
symmetric and particularly evident in the hindlimbs. Diagnostic differentiation of
lameness and neurologic causes of gait abnormalities can be challenging, even to experienced
practitioners. Consequently, kinetic gait analysis offers an objective quantitative
test that may assist in the differentiation of neurologic from musculoskeletal causes
for a gait abnormality. Two indices appear to have the greatest clinical utility in
identifying the presence of a neurologic gait abnormality: higher lateral force peak
and increased variation in vertical force peak in both hindlimbs.
22
Further Reading
Aleman
M
Miscellaneous neurologic or neuromuscular disorders of horses
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
481
506
22100041
Constable
PD
Clinical examination of the ruminant nervous system
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
215
230
15203223
MacKay
RJ
Brain injury after head trauma: pathophysiology, diagnosis, and treatment
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
20
2004
199
216
15062465
Scott
PR
Diagnostic techniques and clinicopathologic findings in ruminant neurologic disease
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
215
230
15203223
References
1
Chalmers
HJ
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
53
2012
660
22985286
2
Henson
FMD
BMC Vet Res
3
2007
3
17331234
3
Testoni
S
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1485
23039936
4
Gosselin
VB
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
1594
24986376
5
De Vlamynck
C
Vet Rec
196
2013
451
6
De Vlamynck
CA
Am J Vet Res
74
2013
750
23627388
7
Prange
T
Equine Vet J
43
2011
404
21496080
8
Franz
S
Am J Vet Res
69
2008
894
18593242
9
Mitchell
CW
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
53
2012
613
22533785
10
Schenk
HC
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
646
24417498
11
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
250
24428325
12
Williams
DC
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
630
18466241
13
Finno
CJ
Vet Ophthalm
15
suppl 2
2012
3
14
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
1310
24902479
15
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
1318
24903742
16
Lecoq
L
J Vet Intern Med
29
2015
362
25619523
17
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
1196
18681921
18
Kawasaki
Y
Vet Rec
165
2009
212
19684349
19
Brosnan
RJ
Am J Vet Res
69
2008
737
18518653
20
Komaromy
AM
Am J Vet Res
67
2006
1232
16817748
21
Arai
S
J Vet Med Sci
68
2006
337
16679724
22
Ishihara
A
J Am Vet Med Assoc
234
2009
644
19250044
Diffuse or Multifocal Diseases of the Brain and Spinal Cord
There are many different causes of diffuse or multifocal nervous system disease in
large domestic animals.
•
Infectious causes include bacteria, viruses, fungi, and helminth, arthropod, and protozoan
parasites.
•
Exogenous substances such as lead, salt, selenium, organophosphate insecticides, feed
additives such as urea, poisonous plants, and many other chemicals are common causes.
•
Endogenous substances such as products of disease in other body systems or of abnormal
metabolism such as bacterial toxins, ammonia, and carbon dioxide can cause abnormalities
of the nervous system.
•
Metabolic and nutritional causes include ischemia secondary to cardiopulmonary disease;
hypoglycemia; hypomagnesemia; copper deficiency in pregnant animals; and hyper d-lactatemia
in calves, lambs, and kids with neonatal diarrhea and adult ruminants with grain overload.
•
Chronic acidemia associated with diarrhea can cause mental depression and ataxia (whereas
experimentally induced acute acidemia does not cause mental depression in neonatal
calves).
•
Idiopathic diseases account for several diseases of the spinal cord of horses.
•
Malformation occurs primarily in the developing fetus and results in congenital nervous
system disease, which is usually present at birth. Many different teratogens can cause
congenital defects. In some cases of inherited disease, the clinical signs do not
manifest until sometime after birth.
Responses of Central Nervous System to Injury
The CNS may respond to injury by morphologic changes that include cerebral edema and
brain swelling, inflammation, and demyelination. Malformations occur when the CNS
is affected during fetal life.
The remainder of this chapter will present the general clinical aspects of the diseases
of the nervous system according to anatomic sites and causative agent. The salient
features of the etiology, pathogenesis, clinical findings, diagnosis, and treatment
of these clinicoanatomic diseases are described. Cerebral hypoxia, hydrocephalus,
cerebral edema, meningitis, encephalitis, myelitis, encephalomalacia, and myelomalacia
are common to many diffuse or multifocal diseases of the nervous system and are described
here.
Cerebral Hypoxia
Cerebral hypoxia occurs when the supply of oxygen to the brain is reduced for any
reason. An acute or chronic syndrome develops depending on the acuteness of the deprivation.
Initially there are irritation signs followed terminally by signs of loss of function.
Etiology
All forms of hypoxia, including anemic, anoxic, histotoxic, and stagnant forms cause
some degree of cerebral hypoxia, but signs referable to cerebral dysfunction occur
only when the hypoxia is severe. Hypoxia of the brain may be secondary to a general
systemic hypoxia or be caused by lesions restricted to the cranial cavity.
Cerebral Hypoxia Secondary to General Hypoxia
•
Poisoning by hydrocyanic acid or nitrite
•
Acute heart failure in severe copper deficiency in cattle
•
Anesthetic accidents
•
Terminally in pneumonia, congestive heart failure
•
During or at birth in foals, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy in foals (also known
as neonatal encephalopathy, perinatal asphyxia, dummy foal syndrome, or neonatal maladjustment
syndrome),
1
or intrapartum hypoxia in calves and lambs caused by prolonged parturition
Cerebral Hypoxia Secondary to Intracranial Lesion
•
In increased intracranial pressure
•
In brain edema
Pathogenesis
The CNS is extremely sensitive to hypoxia, and degeneration occurs if the deprivation
is extreme and prolonged for more than a few minutes. The effects of the hypoxia vary
with the speed of onset and with the severity. When the onset is sudden, there is
usually a transitory period during which excitation phenomena occur, and this is followed
by a period of loss of function. If recovery occurs, a second period of excitation
usually develops as function returns. In more chronic cases the excitation phase is
not observed, and the signs are mainly those of loss of function. These signs include
dullness and lethargy when deprivation is moderate and unconsciousness when it is
severe. All forms of nervous activity are depressed, but the higher centers are more
susceptible than medullary centers and the pattern of development of signs may suggest
this.
Clinical Findings
Acute and chronic syndromes occur depending on the severity of the hypoxia. Acute
cerebral hypoxia is manifested by a sudden onset of signs referable to paralysis of
all brain functions, including tetraparesis and unconsciousness. Muscle tremor, beginning
about the head and spreading to the trunk and limbs, followed by recumbency, clonic
convulsions, and death or recovery after further clonic convulsions is the most common
pattern, although affected animals may fall to the ground without premonitory signs.
In chronic hypoxia, there is lethargy, dullness, ataxia, weakness, and blindness and
in some cases muscle tremor or convulsions. In both acute and chronic hypoxia, the
signs of the primary disease will also be evident. Cerebral hypoxia of fetal calves
is thought to be a cause of weakness and failure to suck after birth, leading to the
eventual death of the calf from starvation. Such hypoxia can occur during the birth
process, especially if it is difficult or delayed, or during late pregnancy.
Clinical Pathology and Necropsy Findings
There is no distinctive clinical pathology or characteristic necropsy lesion other
than those of the primary disease.
Differential Diagnosis
Clinically there is little to differentiate cerebral hypoxia from hypoglycemia or
polioencephalomalacia in which similar signs occur. Irritation and paralytic signs
follow one another in many poisonings including lead and arsenic and in most diffuse
diseases of the brain including encephalitis and encephalomalacia. The differential
diagnosis of cerebral hypoxia depends on the detection of the cause of the hypoxia.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
An increase in oxygen delivery is essential and can usually only be provided by removing
the causative agent. A respiratory stimulant (the most effective is doxapram, 2 mg/kg
BW, intravenously)
2
may be advantageous in acute cases, and artificial respiration may be necessary and
effective.
Increased Intracranial Pressure, Cerebral Edema, and Brain Swelling
Diffuse cerebral edema and brain swelling usually occur acutely and cause a general
increase in intracranial pressure. Cerebral edema is rarely a primary disease, but
is commonly an accompaniment of other diseases. Cerebral edema is often a transient
phenomenon and may be fatal, but complete recovery or recovery with residual nervous
signs also occurs. It is manifested clinically by blindness, opisthotonus, muscle
tremor, paralysis, and clonic convulsions.
Etiology
Diffuse cerebral edema and brain swelling may be vasogenic, when there is increased
permeability of capillary endothelium, and cytotoxic when all the elements of brain
tissue, glia, neurons, and endothelial cells undergo swelling. Causes include the
following.
Vasogenic Edema
•
Brain abscess, neoplasm, hemorrhage, lead encephalopathy, purulent meningitis
•
Minor edema after most traumatic injuries, in many encephalitides and many poisonings,
including propylene glycol in the horse; probably contributes to the pathogenesis
•
Accidental intracarotid injection of promazine in horses
•
Leukoencephalomalacia in horses caused by fumonisin consumption
•
Septicemia in neonatal foals
Cytotoxic Edema
•
Hypoxia
•
PEM of ruminants (thiamine deficiency or sulfur toxicosis)
•
Salt poisoning of swine
Interstitial Edema
•
Hydrocephalus
Pathogenesis
Cerebral Edema and Brain Swelling
This disease is potentially life-threatening because of the limited ability for accommodation
of increased volume within the confines of the dura and the cranium. CNS parenchyma
does not possess a lymphatic system, and the interstitial space between cells, especially
in the gray matter, is much narrower than in other tissues. When CNS edema develops,
of necessity it largely accumulates within cells, although interstitial fluid will
form if cells lyse or if the edema is severe.
Cerebral edema usually occurs to some degree in all pathologic states, whether degenerative
or inflammatory or traumatic or neoplastic. Edema around chronic, focal lesions such
as abscesses, parasitic cysts, and primary or metastatic tumors in white matter often
produce marked swelling. Cerebral hemispheric swelling compresses the underlying brainstem,
flattening the rostral colliculi and distorting the aqueduct. As the swollen brain
expands and fills the confines of the calvaria, some regions are prone to herniation.
If this occurs, the accompanying blood vessels are likely to become occluded, which
may result in hemorrhage or infarction. Commonly with brain swelling the caudal lobe
of the cerebellar vermis protrudes as a flattened lip over the medulla oblongata toward
the foramen magnum.
In vasogenic edema the primary insult is to the wall of cerebral capillaries, allowing
the escape of plasma fluid and proteins under the hydrostatic pressure of the circulation.
The inciting vascular injury may be brain or spinal cord trauma, vasculitis, a neoplasm,
or a cerebrovascular accident. Vasogenic edema affects predominantly the white matter,
in which fluid accumulates within the cytoplasm of astrocytes and spreads in the interstitial
spaces. Vasogenic edema moves over very long distances and from one hemisphere to
the other via the corpus callosum. A chronic epidural abscess involving the frontal
lobe can produce sufficient brain swelling from vasogenic edema to induce herniation
of the occipital cortex beneath the tentorium cerebelli.
Cytotoxic edema results from an injury to a glial cell that disturbs osmoregulation
of that cell by depletion of energy stores and failure of energy-dependent ionic pumps.
This leads to cell swelling with fluid and differs from edema in other tissues in
which fluid accumulation is interstitial. Cytotoxic edema reflects a specific cellular
insult and may result from ischemia or hypoxia, nutritional deficiency, an intoxication,
or an inherited metabolic abnormality. Brain swelling from cytotoxic edema is less
dramatic than that seen in vasogenic edema. It may affect just the gray matter, just
the white matter, or both.
The ECF volume in vasogenic edema is increased by the edema fluid, which is a plasma
filtrate containing plasma protein. In cytotoxic edema it is the cellular elements
themselves that increase in size. In hypoxia this is because of failure of the adenosine
triphosphate (ATP)-dependent sodium pump within the cells. As a result sodium accumulates
within the cells and water follows to maintain osmotic equilibrium. In PEM and salt
poisoning, the edema of the brain is primary. In salt poisoning in pigs there is an
increase in concentration of cations in brain tissue with a sudden passage of water
into the brain to maintain osmotic equilibrium. The cause of the edema in PEM of ruminants,
associated with a thiamine inadequacy, is unknown. When promazine is injected accidentally
into the carotid artery of the horse, it produces a vasogenic edema and infarction
generally, but especially in the thalamus and corpora quadrigemina on the injected
side. The vasogenic edema surrounding an abscess is localized and is not evident in
the white matter.
Cerebral edema and cerebellar herniation have been described in neonatal foals admitted
to an intensive care unit for treatment. All foals had septicemia. It was suggested
that hypoglycemia, hypoxia, or the alterations in cerebral blood flow associated with
septicemia might have initiated injury to cell membranes, resulting in vascular damage
and subsequent edema. It is hypothesized that cerebellar herniation occurs in neonatal
foals with sepsis because of the inelastic nature of the dural folds and the anatomic
rigidity of the neonatal equine skull. This is in contrast to the human infant, in
whom cerebral edema occurs in bacterial meningitis but cerebral or cerebellar herniation
is not normally a feature. The relatively small brain of the newborn foal is only
1% of total body mass compared with the human infant, which is 12% and in which the
brain is enclosed within a large but relatively thin calvarium with sutures that,
in the preterm infant at least, can be separated by excess internal pressure.
An increase in intracranial pressure occurs suddenly and, as in hydrocephalus, there
is a resulting ischemic anoxia of the brain caused by compression of blood vessels
and impairment of blood supply. This may not be the only factor that interferes with
cerebral activity in PEM and salt poisoning. The clinical syndrome produced by the
rapid rise in intracranial pressure is manifested by involuntary movements such as
tremor and convulsions followed by signs of weakness. If the compression of the brain
is severe enough and of sufficient duration, ischemic necrosis of the superficial
layers of the cortical gray matter may occur, resulting in permanent nervous defects
in those animals that recover. Opisthotonus and nystagmus are commonly observed and
are probably caused by the partial herniation of the cerebellum into the foramen magnum.
Clinical Findings
Although the rise of intracranial pressure in diffuse edema of the brain is usually
more acute than in hydrocephalus, the development of clinical signs takes place over
a period of 12 to 24 hours and nervous shock does not occur. There is central blindness,
and periodic attacks of abnormality occur in which opisthotonus, nystagmus, muscle
tremor, and convulsions are prominent.
In the intervening periods, the animal is dull, depressed, and blind, and optic disc
edema may be present. The involuntary signs of tremor, convulsions, and opisthotonus
are usually not extreme, but this varies with the rapidity of onset of the edema.
Because of the involvement of the brainstem, in severe cases muscle weakness appears,
the animal becomes ataxic, goes down and is unable to rise, and the early signs persist.
Clonic convulsions occur terminally, and animals that survive may have residual defects
of mentality and vision.
Clinical Pathology
Clinicopathologic observations will depend on the specific disease causing the edema.
Necropsy Findings
Microscopically the gyri are flattened and the cerebellum is partially herniated into
the foramen magnum with consequent distortion of its caudal aspect. The brain has
a soft, swollen appearance and tends to sag over the edges of the cranium when the
top has been removed. Caudal portions of the occipital lobes herniate ventral to the
tentorium cerebelli.
Differential Diagnosis
Diffuse brain edema causes a syndrome not unlike that of encephalitis, although there
are fewer irritation phenomena. Differentiation from encephalomalacia and vitamin
A deficiency may be difficult if the history does not give a clue to the cause of
the disease. Metabolic diseases, particularly pregnancy toxemia, hypomagnesemic tetany
of calves, and lactation tetany, resemble it closely, as do some cases of acute ruminal
impaction. In the history of each of these diseases, there are distinguishing features
that aid in making a tentative diagnosis. Some of the poisonings, particularly lead,
organic mercurial and arsenicals, and enterotoxemia associated with Clostridium perfringens
type D produce similar nervous signs, and gut edema of swine may be mistaken for diffuse
cerebral edema.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Decompression of the brain is desirable in acute edema. The treatment will depend
in part on the cause; the edema associated with PEM will respond to early treatment
with thiamine. In general terms, edema of the brain responds to parenteral treatment
with hypertonic solutions (mannitol and hypertonic sodium chloride are most often
used) and corticosteroids (specifically dexamethasone). Hypertonic solutions are most
applicable to cytotoxic edema and corticosteroids to vasogenic edema. This is in addition
to treatment for the primary cause of the disease.
Hypertonic solutions open the blood-brain barrier by shrinking endothelial cells and
widening the tight junctions.
3
The magnitude of the opening is dependent on the type of hypertonic solution (mannitol
and hypertonic saline are used most frequently with mannitol as the first choice treatment)
and the achieved plasma concentration. The magnitude of the opening is also dependent
on age, with neonates having a “leakier” blood-brain barrier than adults.3, 4 This
supports clinical observations that mannitol treatment appears to be more successful
in treating neonates suspected to have cerebral edema than adults. The preferred treatment
is mannitol given as a 20% solution in a series of bolus intravenous infusions of
0.25 to 1 g/kg BW every 4 to 6 hours. The suggested dose rate has been derived from
those recommended for humans and dogs but is very expensive. There are dangers with
mannitol: it should not be repeated often, it must not be given to an animal in shock,
and it should be given intravenously slowly. A recent meta-analysis suggested that
hypertonic saline (1.5–23.5% NaCl at 10–30 mL/kg BW total dose) may be as effective
as 20% mannitol in the treatment of cerebral edema, with 7.5% NaCl as the most commonly
used osmalality.
5
Dexamethasone administration (1 mg/kg BW intravenously every 24 hours) is no longer
recommended for the treatment of cerebral edema in human infants,
6
and its efficacy in large animals with cerebral edema is uncertain. Dexamethasone
is thought to decrease cerebral edema and CSF production and inhibit tumor-induced
angiogenesis in patients with intracranial tumors. Hypertonic glucose given intravenously
is not recommended because an initial temporary decompression is followed after a
4- to 6-hour interval by a return to pretreatment CSF pressure when the glucose is
metabolized.
Diuretics usually produce tissue dehydration too slowly to be of much value in acute
cases, but they may be of value as an adjunct to hypertonic solutions or in early
or chronic cases. The removal of CSF from the cisterna magna in an attempt to provide
relief may cause complications. In some cases the removal of 25 to 75 mL of CSF provides
some temporary relief, but the condition becomes worse later because portions of the
swollen brain herniate into the foramen magnum. There is no published information
available on how much CSF can be safely removed; therefore recommendations cannot
be made.
References
1
Ringger
NC
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
132
21143301
2
Bleul
U
Theriogenology
73
2010
612
20022095
3
Stonestreet
BS
Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol
291
2006
R1031
16690764
4
Bengtsson
J
Br J Pharmacol
157
2009
1085
19438510
5
Mortazarvi
MM
J Neurosurg
116
2012
210
21942722
6
Anon
Pediatr Crit Care Med
13
2012
S61
Hydrocephalus
Obstructive hydrocephalus may be congenital or acquired and is manifested in both
cases by a syndrome referable to a general increase in intracranial pressure. Irritation
signs of mania, head-pressing, muscle tremor, and convulsions occur when the onset
is rapid, and signs of paralysis including dullness, blindness, and muscular weakness
are present when the increased pressure develops slowly.
Etiology
Obstructive hydrocephalus may be congenital or acquired, but in both instances it
is caused by defective drainage or absorption of CSF. In the congenital disease, there
is an embryologic defect in the drainage canals and foramina between the individual
ventricles or between the ventricles and the subarachnoid space, or in the absorptive
mechanism, the arachnoid villi.
Congenital Hydrocephalus
Causes include the following:
•
Alone, with lateral narrowing of the mesencephalon
•
Inherited defects of Hereford, Holstein, Ayrshire, and Jersey cattle
•
Inherited combined defects with chondrodysplasia, or in white Shorthorn cattle combined
with hydrocephalus, microphthalmia, and retinal dysplasia
•
Virus infections of the fetus suggest themselves as possible causes of embryologic
defects in the drainage system, but there are no verified examples of this; the cavitation
of brain tissue and subsequent accumulation of fluid, hydranencephaly, which occurs
after infection with bluetongue virus in lambs, and Akabane virus in calves, is compensatory,
not obstructive
•
Vitamin A deficiency may contribute
•
Other occurrences, sometimes at high levels of prevalence, but without known cause
Acquired Hydrocephalus
Causes include the following:
•
Hypovitaminosis A in young growing calves causing impaired absorption of fluid by
the arachnoid villi
•
Cholesteatoma in choroid plexuses of the lateral ventricles in the horse; these may
produce an acute, transient hydrocephalus on a number of occasions before the tumor
reaches sufficient size to cause permanent obstruction
•
Other tumor or chronic inflammatory lesion obstructing drainage from the lateral ventricles
Pathogenesis
Increased intracranial pressure in the fetus and before the syndesmoses of the skull
have fused causes hydrocephalus with enlargement of the cranium. After fusion of the
suture lines the skull acts as a rigid container, and an increase in the volume of
its contents increases intracranial pressure. Although the increase in volume of the
contents may be caused by the development of a local lesion such as an abscess, tumor,
hematoma or cestode cyst, which interferes with drainage of the CSF, the more common
lesion is a congenital defect of CSF drainage.
Clinical and pathologic hydrocephalus has been produced experimentally in animals
by creating granulomatous meningitis. The clinical signs included depression, stiffness
of gait, recumbency, and opisthotonus with paddling convulsions. The general effects
in all cases are the same, the only difference is that local lesions may produce localizing
signs as well as signs of increased intracranial pressure. These latter signs are
caused by compression atrophy of nervous tissue and ischemic anoxia caused by compression
of blood vessels and impairment of blood supply to the brain.
In congenital hydrocephalus the signs observed are usually those of paralysis of function,
whereas acquired hydrocephalus, being more acute, is usually manifested first by irritation
phenomena followed by signs of paralysis. Edema of the optic papilla is a sign of
increased intracranial pressure and may be detected using an ophthalmoscope. Bradycardia
occurs inconstantly and cannot be considered to be diagnostic.
Clinical Findings
In acquired hydrocephalus there is, in most cases, a gradual onset of general paresis.
Initially there is depression, disinclination to move, central blindness, an expressionless
stare, and a lack of precision in acquired movements. A stage of somnolence follows
and is most marked in horses. The animal stands with half-closed eyes, lowered head,
and a vacant expression and often leans against or supports itself on some solid object.
Chewing is slow, intermittent, and incomplete, and animals are often observed standing
with food hanging from their mouths. The reaction to cutaneous stimulation is reduced,
and abnormal postures are frequently adopted. Frequent stumbling, faulty placement
of the feet, and incoordination are evidenced when the animal moves, and circling
may occur in some cases. Bradycardia and cardiac arrhythmia have been observed.
Although the emphasis is on depression and paresis, signs of brain irritation may
occur, particularly in the early stages. These signs often occur in isolated episodes
during which a wild expression, charging, head-pressing, circling, tremor, and convulsions
appear. These episodes may be separated by quite long intervals, sometimes of several
weeks' duration. In vitamin A deficiency in calves, blindness and papilledema are
the early signs and an acute convulsive stage occurs terminally.
Congenitally affected animals are usually alive at birth but are unable to stand and
most die within 48 hours. The cranium is sometimes domed, the eyes protrude, and nystagmus
is often evident (Fig. 14-2
). Meningocele is an infrequent accompaniment.
Fig. 14-2
A, Holstein Friesian calf with hydrocephalus caused by in utero infection with bovine
viral diarrhea virus. The calf was able to suckle but appeared to have diminished
responsiveness to its environment. B, Piglet with meningocele secondary to in utero
hydrocephalus.
Fig. 14-2
Clinical Pathology
Examination of the composition and pressure of the CSF will be of value. The fluid
is usually normal biochemically and cytologically but the pressure is increased. A
marked increase in serum muscle enzyme activity has been observed in calves with congenital
hydrocephalus, caused probably to an accompanying muscular dystrophy. Convulsions,
if they occur, may contribute to this increase.
Necropsy Findings
On necropsy the cranium may be enlarged and soft in congenital hydrocephalus. The
ventricles are distended with CSF under pressure and the overlying cerebral tissue
is thinned if the pressure has been present for some time.
Differential Diagnosis
Congenital hydrocephalus resembles vitamin A deficiency in newborn pigs, toxoplasmosis,
and hydranencephaly if there is no distortion of the cranium.
Acquired hydrocephalus needs to be differentiated from other diffuse diseases of the
brain, including encephalitis and encephalomalacia, and from hepatic dystrophies,
which resemble it very closely. In these latter diseases, there may be other signs
of diagnostic value, including fever in encephalitis and jaundice in hepatic dystrophy.
In most cases it is necessary to depend largely on the history and recognition of
individual disease entities.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Meningitis
Inflammation of the meninges occurs most commonly as a complication of a preexisting
disease. Meningitis is usually associated with a bacterial infection and is manifested
clinically by fever, cutaneous hyperesthesia, and rigidity of muscles. Although meningitis
may affect the spinal cord or brain specifically, it commonly affects both and is
dealt with here as a single entity. Meningoencephalitis is common in neonatal farm
animals. Primary bacterial meningitis is extremely rare in adult farm animals, with
the exception of listeriosis and H. somni (formerly Haemophilus somnus) infection,
although the latter is more a vasculitis than a primary meningitis. The possibility
of immunodeficiency should be considered in adult horses with bacterial meningitis.
Compared with adults, bacterial meningitis is more common in neonates because their
immune system is immature, the blood-brain barrier is incomplete, and umbilical infections
are common, providing a nidus of infection.
Etiology
Most significant meningitides are bacterial, although most viral encephalitides have
some meningitic component.
Cattle
•
Viral diseases including bovine malignant catarrh, sporadic bovine encephalomyelitis
•
Bacterial diseases including listeriosis, H. somni, chronic lesions elsewhere in the
body possibly associated with meningitis in adult animals; rarely tuberculosis
•
Facial paralysis syndrome of calves in the Franklin district of New Zealand
1
Sheep
•
Melioidosis, S. aureus (tick pyemia) in newborn lambs
•
Pasteurella multocida in lambs
•
Mannheimia (Pasteurella) haemolytica in lambs
Horses
•
Strangles, Pasteurella haemolytica (also donkeys and mules), Streptococcus suis, S.
equi, Actinomyces spp., Klebsiella pneumonia, Staphylococcus aureus,
2
coagulase-negative staphylococci, Anaplasma phagocytophilum (equine granulocytic ehrlichiosis,
formerly named Ehrlichia equi), Borrelia burgdorferi,
3
Sphingobacterium multivorum, and Cryptococcus neoformans.
Pigs
•
Glasser's disease, erysipelas, salmonellosis; S. suis type 2 in weaned and feeder
pigs
Coliform and streptococcal septicemias are probably the most common causes of meningitis
in neonatal farm animals. The infection may originate from omphalophlebitis, bacteremia,
or bacterial translocation across the gastrointestinal tract in neonates less than
24 hours of age or with enteritis. Septicemia occurs in all species, especially calves,
and may be accompanied by polysynovitis, endocarditis, and hypopyon. The causative
bacteria are usually a mixed flora.
Hematogenous infection occurs from other sites also. In neonatal animals, some of
the common infections include the following:
•
Calf:
Escherichia coli; the disease is most common in calves under several days of age and
can occur in less than 24 hours after birth; failure of transfer of colostral immunoglobulins
is a common contributing factor
•
Piglet:
S. zooepidemicus, S. suis type 1
•
Lamb:
S. zooepidemicus
Pathogenesis
Inflammation of the meninges causes local swelling and interference with blood supply
to the brain and spinal cord but as a rule penetration of the inflammation along blood
vessels and into nervous tissue is of minor importance and causes only superficial
encephalitis. Failure to treat meningitis associated with pyogenic bacteria often
permits the development of a fatal choroiditis, with exudation into CSF, and ependymitis.
There is also inflammation around the nerve trunks as they pass across the subarachnoid
space. The signs produced by meningitis are thus a combination of those resulting
from irritation of both central and peripheral nervous systems. In spinal meningitis,
there is muscular spasm with rigidity of the limbs and neck, arching of the back,
and hyperesthesia with pain on light touching of the skin. When the cerebral meninges
are affected, irritation signs, including muscle tremor and convulsions, are the common
manifestations. Because meningitis is usually bacterial in origin, fever and toxemia
can be expected if the lesion is sufficiently extensive.
Defects of drainage of CSF occur in both acute and chronic inflammation of the meninges
and produce signs of increased intracranial pressure. The signs are general although
the accumulation of fluid may be localized to particular sites such as the lateral
ventricles.
A newly described mild nonsuppurative meningitis is associated with facial paralysis
in calves in a specific geographic location in New Zealand.
1
Affected animals have a fever with unilateral or bilateral dysfunction of the facial
nerve (CN VII; buccal and auriculopalpebral branches). The case–fatality rate ranges
from 38% to 52%, and affected calves do not have listeriosis or M. bovis infection.
Clinical Findings
Acute meningitis usually develops suddenly and is accompanied by fever and toxemia
in addition to nervous signs. Vomiting is common in the early stages in pigs. There
is trismus, opisthotonus, and rigidity of the neck and back. Motor irritation signs
include tonic spasms of the muscles of the neck causing retraction of the head, muscle
tremor, and paddling movements. Cutaneous hyperesthesia is present in varying degrees,
with even light touching of the skin causing severe pain in some cases. There may
be disturbance of consciousness manifested by excitement or mania in the early stages,
followed by drowsiness and eventual coma.
Blindness is common in cerebral meningitis but not a constant clinical finding. In
young animals, ophthalmitis with hypopyon may occur, which supports the diagnosis
of meningitis. The pupillary light reflex is usually much slower than normal. Examination
of the fundus of the eyes may reveal evidence of optic disc edema, congestion of the
retinal vessels, and exudation.
In uncomplicated meningitis the respiration is usually slow and deep, and often phasic
in the form of Cheyne–Stokes breathing (a breathing pattern characterized by a period
of apnea followed by a gradual increase in the depth and rate of respiration) or Biot's
breathing (an irregular breathing pattern characterized by groups of quick, shallow
inspirations followed by periods of apnea). Terminally there is quadriplegia and clonic
convulsions.
The major clinical finding of meningoencephalitis in calves under 2 weeks of age was
depression, which progressed rapidly to stupor, but the mental state changed to hyperesthesia,
opisthotonus, and seizures in unresponsive terminal cases. Meningoencephalitis should
be considered in calves that have been treated for the effects of diarrhea with fluid
therapy but fail to respond and remain depressed.
In a series of 32 cases of meningitis in neonatal calves, the mean age at admission
was 6 days (range, 11 hours to 30 days). The major clinical findings were lethargy
(32/32), recumbency (32/32), anorexia and loss of the suck reflex (26/32), and stupor
and coma (21/32). The frequencies of other clinical findings were as follows: opisthotonus
(9/32), convulsions (7/32), tremors (6/32), and hyperesthesia (6/32). The case–fatality
rate was 100%; this case series was accumulated before the widespread availability
of third-generation cephalosporins labeled for use in food animals.
Although meningitis in farm animals is usually diffuse, affecting particularly the
brainstem and upper cervical cord, it may be quite localized and produce localizing
signs, including involvement of the cranial or spinal nerves. Localized muscle tremor,
hyperesthesia, and rigidity may result. Muscles in the affected area are firm and
board-like on palpation. Anesthesia and paralysis usually develop caudal to the meningitic
area. Spread of the inflammation along the cord is usual. Reference should be made
to the specific diseases cited under Etiology in this section for a more complete
description of their clinical manifestations.
In newborn calves, undifferentiated diarrhea, septic arthritis, omphalophlebitis,
and uveitis are frequent concurrent clinical findings. Bacterial meningitis has been
reproduced experimentally in calves, resulting in typical clinical signs consisting
of convulsions, depression, circling and falling to one side, ataxia, propulsive walking,
loss of saliva, tremors, recumbency, lethargy, and nystagmus.
Clinical Pathology
Cerebrospinal Fluid
CSF collected from the lumbosacral space or cisterna magna in meningitis contains
elevated protein concentrations, has a high cell count, and usually contains bacteria.
The collection of CSF from the lumbosacral space of calves has been described under
the section Special Examination of the Nervous System. Culture and determination of
antimicrobial susceptibility is strongly recommended because of the low antimicrobial
concentrations achieved in the CSF. In a series of meningitis in neonatal calves,
the CSF revealed marked pleocytosis (mean 4,000 leukocytes/µL; range, 130–23,270 leukocytes/µL),
xanthochromia, turbidity, and a high total protein concentration.
Hematology
Hemogram usually reveals a marked leukocytosis, reflecting the severity of the systemic
illness secondary to septicemia.
Necropsy Findings
Hyperemia, the presence of hemorrhages, and thickening and opacity of the meninges,
especially over the base of the brain, are the usual macroscopic findings. The CSF
is often turbid and may contain fibrin. A local superficial encephalitis is often
present. Additional morbid changes are described under the specific diseases and are
often of importance in differential diagnosis. In neonatal calves with meningitis,
lesions of septicemia are commonly present at necropsy and E. coli is the most common
isolated organism.
Differential Diagnosis
Hyperesthesia, severe depression, muscle rigidity, and blindness are the common clinical
findings in cerebral meningitis, but it is often difficult to differentiate meningitis
from encephalitis and acute cerebral edema. Examination of the CSF is the only means
of confirming the diagnosis before death. Analysis of CSF is very useful in the differential
diagnosis of diseases of the nervous system of ruminants. Details are presented in
the section Collection and Examination of Cerebral Spinal Fluid. Subacute or chronic
meningitis is difficult to recognize clinically. The clinical findings may be restricted
to recumbency, apathy, anorexia, slight incoordination if forced to walk, and some
impairment of the eyesight. Spinal cord compression is usually more insidious in onset
and is seldom accompanied by fever; hyperesthesia is less marked or absent, and there
is flaccidity rather than spasticity.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Most of the viral infections of the nervous system are not susceptible to chemotherapeutics.
Some of the larger organisms such as Chlamydia spp. are susceptible to broad-spectrum
antimicrobial agents such as the tetracyclines and chloramphenicol.
Bacterial infections of the CNS are usually manifestations of a general systemic infection
as either bacteremia or septicemia. Treatment of such infections is limited by the
existence of the blood-brain and blood-CSF barriers, which prevent penetration of
some substances into nervous tissue and into the CSF. Very little useful data exist
on the penetration of parenterally administered antibiotics into the CNS of either
normal farm animals or those in which there is inflammation of the nervous system.
In humans it is considered that most antimicrobials do not enter the subarachnoid
space in therapeutic concentrations unless inflammation is present, and the degree
of penetration varies among drugs. Chloramphenicol is an exception; levels of one-third
to one-half of the plasma concentration are commonly achieved in healthy individuals;
chloramphenicol administration is now much reduced in developed countries because
of the idiosyncratic occurrence of aplastic anemia in humans. The relative diffusion
of gram-negative antimicrobial agents from blood into CSF in humans is shown in Table
14-8
.
Table 14-8
Relative diffusion of gram-negative antimicrobials
Table 14-8
Excellent with or without inflammation
Good only with inflammation
Sulfonamides
Ampicillin
Third-generation
Carbenicillin
Cephalosporins
Cephalothin
Cefoperazone, cefotaxime
Cephaloridine
Minimal or not good with inflammation
No passage with inflammation
Tetracycline
Polymyxin B
Streptomycin
Colistin
Kanamycin
Gentamicin
The most promising antimicrobial agents for the treatment of bacterial meningitis
in farm animals are trimethoprim-sulfonamide combinations, the third-generation cephalosporins,
and fluoroquinolones. When treating bacterial meningitis, pharmacodynamic principles
suggest that CSF antimicrobial concentrations should have a peak concentration that
is at least five times the minimum bactericidal concentration (MBC) of the pathogen,
and concentrations above the MBC are required during the entire dosing interval for
optimal bactericidal activity.
In most instances of bacterial encephalitis or meningitis in farm animals, it is likely
that the blood-brain barrier is not intact and that parenterally administered drugs
will diffuse into the nervous tissue and CSF to a greater extent than in healthy animals.
Certainly, the dramatic beneficial response achieved by the early parenteral treatment
of H. somni meningoencephalitis in cattle using intravenous oxytetracycline or intramuscular
penicillin suggests that the blood-brain barrier may not be a major limiting factor
when inflammation is present. Another example of an antibiotic that does not normally
pass the blood-brain barrier well but is able to do so when the barrier is damaged
is penicillin in the treatment of listeriosis. When cases of bacterial meningoencephalitis
fail to respond to antimicrobial agents to which in vitro testing indicates that the
organisms are susceptible, other reasons should also be considered. Often the lesion
is irreversibly advanced or there is a chronic suppurative process that is unlikely
to respond.
Intrathecal injections of antimicrobial agents have been suggested as viable alternatives
when parenteral therapy appears to be unsuccessful. However, there is no evidence
that such treatment is superior to appropriate parenteral therapy. In addition, intrathecal
injections can cause rapid death and therefore are not recommended.
Glucocorticoids may be administered in an attempt to decrease nerve damage resulting
from inflammation. Appropriate randomized clinical trials have not been performed
in large animals, but steroid administration in adult humans with meningitis was associated
with decreased mortality.
4
Further Reading
Fecteau
G
George
LW
Bacterial meningitis and encephalitis in ruminants
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
363
378
15203230
Johnson
AL
Update on infectious diseases affecting the equine nervous system
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
573
587
22100045
Kessell
AE
Finnie
JW
Windsor
PA
Neurological diseases of ruminant livestock in Australia. III: bacterial and protozoal
infections
Aust Vet J
89
2011
289
296
24635630
Scott
PR
Diagnostic techniques and clinicopathologic findings in ruminant neurologic disease
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
215
230
15203223
Whitehead
CE
Bedenice
D
Neurologic diseases in llamas and alpacas
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
25
2009
385
405
19460647
References
1
McFadden
AMJ
New Zeal Vet J
57
2009
63
2
Mitchell
E
Equine Vet Educ
18
2006
249
3
Imai
DM
Vet Pathol
48
2011
1151
21285382
4
van de Beek
D
Lancet Infect Dis
4
2004
139
14998499
Encephalitis
Encephalitis is, by definition, inflammation of the brain, but in general usage it
includes those diseases in which inflammatory lesions occur in the brain, whether
there is inflammation of the nervous tissue or primarily of the vessel walls. Clinically,
encephalitis is characterized initially by signs of involuntary movements, followed
by signs caused by loss of nervous function. The meninges and spinal cord may be involved
in an encephalitis, causing varying degrees of meningoencephalomyelitis.
Etiology
Many encephalitides of large animals are associated with viruses but other infectious
agents are also common. Some causes are as follows.
All Species
•
Viral infections including rabies, pseudorabies, Japanese B encephalitis, West Nile
virus encephalomyelitis
•
Bacterial infections of neonatal farm animals
•
Toxoplasmosis, which is not a common cause in any species
•
Sarcocystosis
•
Verminous encephalomyelitis, which is migration of larvae of parasitic species that
normally have a somatic migration route, e.g., Halicephalobus gingivalis (previously
H. deletrix or Micronema deletrix) and Setaria spp.
Cattle
•
BSE
•
Viral infections including malignant catarrhal fever, BVD virus, sporadic bovine encephalomyelitis,
Akabane virus, and bovine herpesvirus-5 (BHV-5), rarely louping-ill virus,
1
and astrovirus (BoAstV-NeuroS1)
2
•
Bacterial infections including Listeria monocytogenes, H. somni (formerly Haemophilus
somnus), heartwater, and clostridial infections following dehorning of calves
•
Migration of Hypoderma bovis occasionally to brain and spinal cord
•
Newborn calves with in utero protozoal infection of Neospora caninum
3
Sheep
•
Scrapie
•
Viral infections including louping-ill, visna (associated with maedi-visna virus [MVV]),
BVD virus (border disease), and Akabane virus
•
Thrombotic meningoencephalitis associated with H. somni (formerly H. ovis) in lambs
•
Bacterial meningoencephalitis in lambs 2 to 4 weeks of age
•
Migration of Oestrus ovis
Goats
•
Scrapie
•
Caprine arthritis encephalitis (CAE) virus, Akabane virus
New World Camelids
•
Viral infection caused by Eastern equine encephalitis virus
4
•
Bacterial infection caused by L. monocytogenes
•
Verminous encephalomyelitis caused by Parelaphostrongylus tenuis (“meningeal worm”
of white-tailed deer)
Horses
•
Viral infections including infectious equine encephalomyelitis; Borna disease; equine
herpesvirus-1 (EHV-1) myeloencephalopathy; equine infectious anemia; eastern, western,
Venezuelan, and West Nile equine encephalomyelitis; Murray Valley encephalitis virus5,
6; Shuni virus
7
; and rarely louping-ill virus
•
Bacterial meningoencephalitis caused by Anaplasma phagocytophilum (equine granulocytic
ehrlichiosis) and Borrelia burgdorferi
8
•
Protozoal myeloencephalitis caused by Sarcocystis neurona infection
•
Verminous encephalomyelitis caused by Strongylus vulgaris, P. tenuis (meningeal worm
of white-tailed deer), and Draschia megastoma; Angiostrongylus cantonensis, which
normally migrates through the CNS of the rat, has been found as a cause of verminous
encephalomyelitis in foals
Pigs
•
Bacterial infections as part of the systemic infections with Salmonella and Erysipelas
spp., rarely L. monocytogenes
•
Viral infections including hog cholera, African swine fever, encephalomyocarditis,
swine vesicular disease, hemagglutinating encephalomyelitis virus, and porcine encephalomyelitis
virus
Pathogenesis
Compared with other extraneural tissues, the inflammatory response mounted by the
nervous system is unique. The CNS is in a sequestered and immunologically dormant
state within the body. The capillary endothelial blood-brain barrier restricts free
access by blood constituents. The CNS lacks specialized dendritic antigen-presenting
cells, and the intrinsic expression by CNS cells of major histocompatibility complex
molecules, especially class II, is low. There is no lymphatic system within nervous
tissue, but cells and antigens within the CNS drain into the circulation and into
the cervical lymph nodes.
The CNS has unique populations of cells consisting of parenchymal cells, which are
neurons and neuroglia. The neuroglia are supporting cells and are subdivided into
macroglia and microglia. The macroglia are astrocytes and oligodendrocytes; the third
glial cell type is a microglial cell. The brain and spinal cord are enclosed by meninges
(dura, arachnoid, and pia), which provide protection, a compartment for CSF circulation
(the subarachnoid space), support for blood vessels, and a sheath for the cranial
and spinal nerves. Within the brain and spinal cord are the ventricular system and
central canal, which are lined by ependymal cells, and the choroid plexuses, which
produce the CSF. Circulation of the CSF moves from the lateral, third, and fourth
ventricles into the central canal or through lateral apertures at the cerebellomedullary
angle into the subarachnoid space of the brain. CSF in the subarachnoid space drains
via specialized arachnoid granulations into intracranial venous sinuses, with some
draining into venous plexuses associated with cranial and spinal nerves. CSF may also
cross the ventricular surface into the adjacent parenchyma.
The histologic characteristics of CNS inflammation include the following:
•
Perivascular cuffing
•
Gliosis
•
Neuronal satellitosis and neuronophagia
A perivascular compartment, actual or potential, exists around all CNS arteries, arterioles,
venules, and veins. A characteristic feature of CNS inflammation is perivascular cuffing,
which is the accumulation of leukocytes of one or multiple types in the perivascular
space. All perivascular cuffing results in vasculitis of some degree. In bacterial
diseases, polymorphonuclear cells predominate with a minor component of mononuclear
cells. In general, viral diseases are characterized by lymphocyte-rich cells with
some plasma cells and monocytes; some arbovirus infections cause a polymorphonuclear
cell response. In immune-mediated diseases, there are mixtures of polymorphonuclear
and mononuclear cells. In thrombogenic diseases, such as thrombotic meningoencephalitis,
vascular occlusion precludes the development of cuffing around injured vessels.
Gliosis is the increased prominence of glial cells, resulting from cytoplasmic swelling
and the acquisition of more cell processes, from cell proliferation, or both. Either
of the macroglia (oligodendrocytes or astrocytes) or microglia may participate in
gliosis.
Neuronal satellitosis occurs when oligodendrocytes react and proliferate in response
to degenerating neurons, which may be infected by a virus.
Neuronophagia is the progressive degeneration of the neuron characterized by its piecemeal
division and phagocytosis, eventually leaving a dense nodule of glial cells and fragments
of the former neuron. Details of the form, functions, and roles of astrocytes in neurologic
disease have been reviewed.
Primary demyelination is characteristic of only a small number of inflammatory neurologic
diseases and is associated with only a few viruses. The inflammatory neuraxial diseases
of large animals include visna in sheep and caprine arthritis encephalitis. The demyelinating
process may be initiated directly by the infectious agent alone or by an immunologic
response initiated by the agent.
With the exception of the viruses of bovine malignant catarrh and EHV-1, which exert
their effects principally on the vasculature, those viruses that cause encephalitis
do so by invasion of cellular elements, usually the neurons, and cause initial stimulation
and then death of the cells. Those bacteria that cause diffuse encephalitis also exert
their effects primarily on vascular endothelium. L. monocytogenes does so by the formation
of microabscesses. In some diseases, such as meningoencephalitis in cattle associated
with H. somni, the lesions may be present in the brain and throughout the spinal cord.
Entrance of the viruses into the nervous tissue occurs in several ways. Normally the
blood-brain barrier is an effective filtering agent, but when there is damage to the
endothelium infection readily occurs. The synergistic relationship between the rickettsias
of tick-borne fever and the virus of louping-ill probably has this basis. Entry may
also occur by progression of the agent up a peripheral nerve trunk, as occurs with
the viruses of rabies and pseudorabies and with L. monocytogenes. Entry via the olfactory
nerves is also possible.
The clinical signs of encephalitis are usually referable to a general stimulatory
or lethal effect on neurons in the brain. This may be in part due to the general effect
of inflammatory edema and in part to the direct effects of the agent on nerve cells.
In any particular case, one or the other of these factors may predominate, but the
tissue damage and therefore the signs are generalized. Clinical signs are often diverse
and can be acute or chronic, localized or diffuse, and progressive or reversible.
Because of diffuse inflammation in encephalitis, the clinical signs are commonly multifocal
and asymmetric. This is not the case in listeriosis, in which damage is usually localized
in the pons-medulla. Localizing signs may appear in the early stages of generalized
encephalitis and remain as residual defects during the stage of convalescence. In
calves with thromboembolic meningoencephalitis caused by H. somni, prolonged recumbency
may be associated with widespread lesions of the spinal cord. Visna is a demyelinating
encephalitis, and caprine leukoencephalomyelitis is both demyelinating and inflammatory
and also invades other tissues including joints and lung.
In verminous encephalomyelitis, destruction of nervous tissue may occur in many parts
of the brain and in general the severity of the signs depends on the size and mobility
of the parasites and the route of entry. One exception to this generalization is the
experimental “visceral larva migrans” produced by Toxocara canis in pigs when the
nervous signs occur at a time when lesions in most other organs are healing. The signs
are apparently provoked by a reaction of the host to static larvae rather than trauma
caused by migration. Nematodes not resident in nervous tissues may cause nervous signs
caused possibly by allergy or by the formation of toxins.
Clinical Findings
Because the encephalitides are associated with infectious agents, they are often accompanied
by fever, anorexia, depression, and increased heart rate. This is not the case in
the very chronic diseases such as scrapie and BSE. In those diseases associated with
agents that are not truly neurotropic, there are characteristic signs, which are not
described here.
The clinical findings that can occur in encephalitis are combinations of the following:
•
Subtle to marked changes in behavior
•
Depression
•
Seizures
•
Blindness
•
Compulsive walking
•
Leaning on walls or fences
•
Circling
•
Ataxia
Bacterial meningoencephalitis in lambs 2 to 4 weeks of age is characterized by lack
of suck reflex, weakness, altered gait, and depression extending to stupor, but hyperesthesia
to auditory and tactile stimuli. Opisthotonus is common during the terminal stages.
There may be an initial period of excitement or mania. The animal is easily startled
and responds excessively to normal stimuli. It may exhibit viciousness and uncontrolled
activity including blind charging, bellowing, kicking, and pawing. Self-mutilation
may occur in diseases such as pseudorabies. Mental depression, including head-pressing,
may occur between episodes.
Involuntary movements are variable in their occurrence or may not appear at all. When
they do occur, they include convulsions, usually clonic, and may be accompanied by
nystagmus, champing of the jaws, excessive frothy salivation, and muscle tremor, especially
of the face and limbs. In cattle with malignant catarrhal fever, there is severe depression
for a few days followed by the onset of tremors associated with the terminal encephalitis.
Unusual irritation phenomena are the paresthesia and hyperesthesia of pseudorabies
and scrapie.
Signs caused by loss of nervous function follow and may be the only signs in some
instances. Excessive drooling and pharyngeal paralysis are common in rabies. In horses
with equine encephalomyelitis, feed may be left hanging from the mouth, although swallowing
may not be impaired. The loss of function varies in degree from paresis with knuckling
at the lower limb joints, to spasticity of the limbs with resultant ataxia, to weakness
and recumbency. Recumbency and inability to rise may be the first clinical finding
encountered as in many cases of meningoencephalitis associated with H. somni. Hypermetria,
a staggering gait and apprehensiveness progressing to belligerency, may occur in a
disease such as BSE.
Clinical signs referable to certain anatomic sites and pathways of the brain and spinal
cord are manifested by deviation of the head, walking in circles, abnormalities of
posture, ataxia, and incoordination but these are more often residual signs after
recovery from the acute stages. Progressive ascending spinal cord paralysis, in which
the loss of sensation and weakness occur initially in the hindlimbs followed by weakness
in the forelimbs, is common in rabies. Residual lesions affecting the CNs do not commonly
occur in the encephalitides, except in listeriosis and protozoal encephalitis of horses,
both infections predominating in the caudal brainstem.
In the horse with cerebral nematodiasis caused by S. vulgaris, the clinical signs
are referable to migration of the parasite in the thalamus, brainstem, and cerebellum.
There is incoordination, leaning and head-pressing, dysmetria, intermittent clonic
convulsions, unilateral or bilateral blindness, and paralysis of some CNs. The onset
may be gradual or sudden. The clinical diagnosis is extremely difficult because examination
of CSF and hematology are of limited value. A pathologic diagnosis is necessary. In
foals with neural angiostrongylosis, tetraparesis was the result of progressive and
multifocal neurologic disease.
Clinical Pathology
Clinical pathology may be of considerable assistance in the diagnosis of encephalitis,
but the techniques used are for the most part specific to the individual diseases.
Hemogram
In the horse, complete and differential blood counts and serum chemistry profiles
are recommended for most neurologic cases.
Serology
Acute and convalescent sera can be submitted when a specific infectious disease is
suspected for which a serologic diagnosis is possible.
Cerebrospinal Fluid
Laboratory examination of CSF for cellular content and pathogens may also be indicated.
In bacterial meningoencephalitis, analysis of CSF obtained from the lumbosacral space
reveals a highly significant increase in protein concentration with marked neutrophilic
pleocytosis.
Necropsy Findings
In some of the common encephalitides there are no gross lesions of the brain apart
from those that occur in other body systems and that are typical of the specific disease.
In other cases, on transverse section of the brain, extensive areas of hemorrhagic
necrosis may be visible, as in meningoencephalitis in cattle caused by H. somni. Histologic
lesions vary with the type and mode of action of the causative agent. Material for
laboratory diagnosis should include the fixed brain and portions of fresh brain material
for culture and for transmission experiments.
Differential Diagnosis
The diagnosis of encephalitis cannot depend entirely on the recognition of the typical
syndrome because similar syndromes may be caused by many other brain diseases. Acute
cerebral edema and focal space-occupying lesions of the cranial cavity, and a number
of poisonings, including salt, lead, arsenic, mercury, rotenone, and chlorinated hydrocarbons,
all cause similar syndromes, as do hypovitaminosis A, hypoglycemia, encephalomalacia,
and meningitis.
Fever is common in encephalitis but is not usually present in rabies, scrapie, or
bovine spongiform encephalopathy; but it may occur in the noninflammatory diseases
if convulsions are severe.
In general, the clinical diagnosis rests on the recognition of the specific encephalitides
and the elimination of the other possible causes on the basis of the history and clinical
pathology, especially in poisonings, and on clinical findings characteristic of the
particular disease. In many cases a definite diagnosis can only be made on necropsy.
For differentiation of the specific encephalitides, reference should be made to the
diseases listed under the previous section Etiology.
Infestation with nematode larvae causes a great variety of signs depending on the
number of invading larvae and the amount and location of the damage.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Specific treatments are dealt with under each disease. Antimicrobials are indicated
for bacterial meningoencephalomyelitis. In general, the aim should be to provide supportive
treatment by intravenous fluid and electrolyte therapy or stomach tube feeding during
the acute phase. Sedation during the excitement stage may prevent the animal from
injuring itself, and nervous system stimulants during the period of depression may
maintain life through the critical phase. Although there is an increase in intracranial
pressure, the removal of CSF is contraindicated because of the deleterious effects
of the procedure on other parts of the brain.
Further Reading
Johnson
AL
Update on infectious diseases affecting the equine nervous system
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
573
587
22100045
Kessell
AE
Finnie
JW
Windsor
PA
Neurological diseases of ruminant livestock in Australia. III. Bacterial and protozoal
infections
Aust Vet J
89
2011
289
296
24635630
Kessell
AE
Finnie
JW
Windsor
PA
Neurological diseases of ruminant livestock in Australia. IV. Viral infections
Aust Vet J
89
2011
331
337
21864304
Whitehead
CE
Bedenice
D
Neurologic diseases in llamas and alpacas
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
25
2009
385
405
19460647
References
1
Benavides
J
Vet Pathol
48
2011
E1
2
Li
L
Emerg Infect Dis
19
2013
1385
23965613
3
Malaguti
JMA
Rev Bras Parasitol Vet Jaboticabal
2
2012
48
4
Nolen-Watson
R
J Vet Intern Med
21
2007
846
17708408
5
Gordon
AN
J Vet Diagn Invest
24
2012
431
22379060
6
Holmes
JM
Aust Vet J
90
2012
252
22731944
7
van Eeden
C
Emerg Infect Dis
18
2012
318
22305525
8
Imai
DM
Vet Pathol
48
2011
1151
21285382
Epilepsy
Seizures occur most frequently in conjunction with other signs of brain disease. The
syndrome of inherited, recurrent seizures, which continues through life with no underlying
morphologic disease process, is true epilepsy, which is extremely rare in farm animals.
Familial epilepsy has been recorded in Brown Swiss cattle and Arabian foals.
1
Residual lesions after encephalitis may cause symptomatic epileptiform seizures, but
there are usually other localizing signs. A generalized seizure is manifested by an
initial period of alertness, the counterpart of the aura in human seizures, followed
by falling in a state of tetany, which gives way after a few seconds to a clonic convulsion
with paddling, opisthotonus, and champing of the jaws. The clonic convulsions may
last for some minutes and are followed by a period of relaxation. The animal is unconscious
throughout the seizure, but appears normal shortly afterward.
Some seizures may be preceded by a local motor phenomenon such as tetany or tremor
of one limb or of the face. The convulsion may spread from this initial area to the
rest of the body. This form is referred to as jacksonian epilepsy and the local signs
may indicate the whereabouts of the local lesion or point of excitation. Such signs
are recorded very rarely in dogs and not at all in farm animals. The seizures are
recurrent, and the animal is normal in the intervening periods.
EEG has been performed but there are significant challenges in obtaining and interpreting
the EEG from a conscious foal. It is not clear whether the EEG recording changed the
initial treatment protocol for affected foals, and it should be noted that a diagnosis
of epilepsy in humans is made primarily on clinical grounds.
1
Treatment
Treatment is empirical. Seizures in foals can be initially controlled with intravenous
diazepam (0.1–0.4 mg/kg; the large dose range suggests that some seizures are of short
duration). Long-term seizure control emphasizes oral phenobarbital because of its
cost and proven efficacy in humans and dogs. A loading intravenous phenobarbital dose
that has been used in foals is 12 to 20 mg/kg diluted in 1 L of 0.9% NaCl and administered
over 30 minutes, followed by oral phenobarbital at 6 to 12 mg/kg every 12 hours. The
oral dose is adjusted based on clinical response and measured peak and trough serum
phenobarbital concentrations. Therapeutic phenobarbital concentrations for horses
are unknown, but the therapeutic range in humans is 15 to 40 µg/mL. Once seizure control
is established with oral phenobarbital and the foal is seizure free for 6 months,
the phenobarbital dose can be decreased by 20% every 2 weeks and the horse closely
monitored. If phenobarbital does not provide adequate seizure control, potassium bromide
can be tried at a tentative initial oral dose of 25 mg/kg every 24 hours. Clients
should wear gloves during administration of potassium bromide.
Further Reading
McBride
S
Hemmings
A
A neurologic perspective of equine stereotypy
J Equine Vet Sci
29
2009
10
16
Reference
1
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
20
2006
1443
17186863
Myelitis
Inflammation of the spinal cord (myelitis) is usually associated with viral encephalitis.
Clinical signs of myelitis are referable to the loss of function, although there may
be signs of irritation. For example, hyperesthesia or paresthesia may result if the
dorsal root ganglia are involved. This is particularly noticeable in pseudorabies
and to a lesser extent in rabies. However, paresis or paralysis is the more usual
result of myelitis. There are no specific myelitides in farm animals, with most viral
infections producing an encephalomyelitis with variations on the predominance of clinical
signs being intracranial or extracranial. Viral myelitis associated with EHV-1 (the
equine rhinopneumonitis virus) is now commonplace, and equine infectious anemia and
dourine include incoordination and paresis in their syndromes. In goats, CAE is principally
a myelitis, involving mostly the white matter.
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis (EPM) causes multifocal lesions of the CNS mostly
on the spinal cord. The most accurate diagnosis is based on histologic findings:
•
Necrosis and mild to severe, nonsuppurative myeloencephalitis
•
Infiltration of neural tissue by mononuclear cells
•
Sometimes giant cells, neutrophils, and eosinophils
•
Infiltration of perivascular tissue by mononuclear cells including lymphocytes and
plasma cells.
EPM is caused primarily by S. neurona, which has the opossum (Didelphis virginiana)
as the definitive host, raccoons as the most likely intermediate host, and the horse
acting as a dead end host. Occasional cases of protozoal myeloencephalitis in horses
are associated with Neospora hughesi.
Myelitis associated with N. caninum infection in newborn calves has been described.
Affected calves were recumbent and unable to rise but were bright and alert. Histologically,
there was evidence of protozoal myelitis.
Encephalomalacia
The degenerative diseases of the brain are grouped together under the name encephalomalacia.
By definition encephalomalacia means softening of the brain. It is used here to include
all degenerative changes. Leukoencephalomalacia and PEM refer to softening of the
white and gray matter, respectively. Abiotrophy is the premature degeneration of neurons
caused by an inborn metabolic error of development and excludes exogenous insults
of neurons. The underlying cellular defect in most abiotrophies is inherited. The
syndrome produced in most degenerative diseases of the nervous system is essentially
one of loss of function.
Etiology
Some indication of the diversity of causes of encephalomalacia and degenerative diseases
of the nervous system can be appreciated from the examples that follow, but many sporadic
cases occur in which the cause cannot be defined.
All Species
•
Hepatic encephalopathy is thought to be caused by high blood levels of ammonia associated
with advanced liver disease. This is recorded in experimental pyrrolizidine alkaloid
poisoning in sheep, in hepatic arteriovenous anomaly, and thrombosis of the portal
vein in the horse. Congenital portacaval shunts are also a cause of hepatic encephalopathy.
•
Abiotrophy involves multisystem degenerations in the nervous system as focal or diffuse
lesions involving the axons and myelin of neuronal processes. These include a multifocal
encephalopathy in the Simmental breed of cattle in New Zealand and Australia and progressive
myeloencephalopathy in Brown Swiss cattle, known as “weavers” because of their ataxic
gait.
•
Poisoning by organic mercurials and, in some instances, lead; possibly also selenium
poisoning; a bilateral multifocal cerebrospinal poliomalacia of sheep in Ghana.
•
Cerebrovascular disorders corresponding to the main categories in humans are observed
in animals, but their occurrence is chiefly in pigs, and their clinical importance
is minor.
•
Congenital hypomyelinogenesis and dysmyelinogenesis are recorded in lambs (hairy shakers),
piglets (myoclonia congenita), and calves (hypomyelinogenesis congenita). All are
associated with viral infections in utero. EHV-1 infections in horses cause ischemic
infarcts.
•
Cerebellar cortical abiotrophy occurs in calves and lambs.
Ruminants
•
BSE
•
Plant poisons, e.g., Astragalus spp., Oxytropis spp., Swainsona spp., Vicia spp.,
Kochia scoparia
•
Focal symmetric encephalomalacia of sheep, thought to be a residual lesion after intoxication
with C. perfringens type D toxin
•
PEM caused by thiamine inadequacy in cattle and sheep and sulfur toxicosis in cattle;
poliomalacia of sheep caused possibly by an antimetabolite of nicotinic acid
•
Progressive spinal myelopathy of Murray Grey cattle in Australia
•
Spongiform encephalopathy in newborn polled Hereford calves similar to maple syrup
urine disease
•
Neuronal dystrophy in Suffolk sheep
•
Shakers in horned Hereford calves associated with neuronal cell body chromatolysis
•
The abiotrophic lysosomal storage diseases including progressive ataxia of Charolais
cattle, mannosidosis, gangliosidosis, and globoid cell leukodystrophy of sheep
•
The inherited defect of Brown Swiss cattle known as weavers, and presented elsewhere,
is a degenerative myeloencephalopathy
•
Swayback and enzootic ataxia caused by nutritional deficiency of copper in lambs
•
Prolonged parturition of calves causing cerebral hypoxia and the weak calf syndrome
•
Idiopathic brainstem neuronal chromatolysis in cattle
•
Bovine bonkers caused by the consumption of ammoniated forages
•
Inherited neuronal degeneration in Angora goats
Horses
•
Leukoencephalomalacia caused by feeding moldy corn infested with Fusarium moniliforme,
which produces primarily fumonisin B1 and, to a lesser extent, fumonisin B2
1, 2
•
Nigropallidal encephalomalacia caused by feeding on yellow star thistle (Centaurea
solstitialis)
3
•
Poisoning by bracken and horsetail causing a conditioned deficiency of thiamine
•
Ischemic encephalopathy of neonatal maladjustment syndrome of foals
•
EDM,4, 5 which is associated with vitamin E deficiency
Ruminants and Horses
Neurotoxic Mycotoxins
Swainsonine and slaframine produced by Rhizoctonia leguminicola cause mannose accumulation
and parasympathomimetic effects. Lolitrems from A. lolii and paspalitrems from C.
paspali are tremorgens found in grasses.
Pigs
•
Leukoencephalomalacia in mulberry heart disease
•
Subclinical attacks of enterotoxemia similar to edema disease
•
Poisoning by organic arsenicals, and salt.
Pathogenesis
The pathogenesis of the degenerative diseases can be subdivided into the following:
•
Metabolic and circulatory disorders
•
Intoxications and toxic-infectious diseases
•
Nutritional diseases
•
Hereditary, familial, and idiopathic degenerative diseases
Metabolic and Circulatory
Hepatic encephalopathy is associated with acquired liver disease, and the resultant
hyperammonemia and other toxic factors are considered to be neurotoxic. Disorders
of intermediary metabolism result in the accumulation of neurotoxic substances such
as in maple syrup urine disease of calves. Lysosomal storage diseases are caused by
a lack of lysosomal enzymes, which results in an accumulation of cellular substrates
and affecting cell function.
CNS hypoxia and ischemia impair the most sensitive elements in brain tissue, especially
neurons. Severe ischemia results in necrosis of neurons and glial elements and areas
of infarcts. Gas anesthesia–related neurologic disease occurs in animals that have
been deprived of oxygen for more than 5 minutes. The hypoxia is lethal to neurons,
and on recovery from anesthesia affected animals are blind and seizures may occur.
The typical lesion consists of widespread neuronal damage. Postanesthetic hemorrhagic
myelopathy and postanesthetic cerebral necrosis in horses are typical examples.
Hypoglycemia occurs in neonates deprived of milk and in acetonemia and pregnancy toxemia
and clinical signs of lethargy, dullness progressing to weakness, seizures, and coma
have been attributed to hypoglycemia. However, there are no studies of the CNS in
farm animals with hypoglycemia and the effects, if any, on the nervous tissue are
unknown.
Intoxications and Toxic-Infectious Diseases
A large number of poisonous substances including poisonous plants, heavy metals (lead,
arsenic, and mercury), salt poisoning, farm chemicals, antifreeze, herbicides, and
insecticides can directly affect the nervous system when ingested by animals. They
result in varying degrees of edema of the brain, degeneration of white and gray matter,
and hemorrhage of both the central and peripheral nervous system. Toxic-infectious
diseases such as edema disease of swine and focal symmetric encephalomalacia of sheep
are examples of endotoxins and exotoxins produced by bacterial infections, which have
a direct effect on the nervous system resulting in encephalomalacia.
Nutritional Diseases
Several nutritional deficiencies of farm animals can result in neurologic disease:
•
Vitamin A deficiency affects bone growth, particularly remodeling of the optic nerve
tracts, and CSF absorption. The elevated CSF pressure and constriction of the optic
nerve tracts results in edema of the optic disc and wallerian-type degeneration of
the optic nerve resulting in blindness.
•
Copper deficiency in pregnant ewes can result in swayback and enzootic ataxia of the
lambs. Copper is an integral element in several enzyme systems such as ceruloplasmin
and lysyl oxidase, and copper deficiency affects several organ systems. The principal
defect in swayback appears to be one of defective myelination probably caused by interference
with phospholipid formation. However, some lesions in the newborn are more extensive
and show cavitation with loss of axons and neurons rather than simply demyelination.
In the brain, there is a progressive gelatinous transformation of the white matter,
ending in cavitation that resembles porencephaly or hydranencephaly. In the spinal
cord the lesions are bilateral, and it is suggested that the copper deficiency has
a primary axonopathic effect
•
Thiamine deficiency in ruminants can result in PEM or cerebrocortical necrosis. Thiamine,
mainly as thiamine diphosphate ([TDP]; pyrophosphate), has an important role as a
coenzyme in carbohydrate metabolism, especially the pentose pathway. Diffuse encephalopathy
may occur characterized by brain edema and swelling, resulting in flattening of the
gyri, tentorial herniation, and coning of the cerebellar vermis. Bilateral areas of
cerebral cortical laminar necrosis are widespread.
Hereditary, Familial, and Idiopathic Degenerative Diseases
A large number of neurologic diseases of farm animals are characterized by abnormalities
of central myelinogenesis. In most instances, the underlying abnormality directly
or indirectly affects the oligodendrocyte and is reflected in the production of CNS
myelin of diminished quantity or quality or both. Many of these are inherited and
manifest from or shortly after birth. They include leukodystrophies, hypomyelinogenesis,
spongy degeneration, and related disorders. Neuronal abiotrophy, motor neuron diseases,
neuronal dystrophy, and degenerative encephalomyelopathy of horses and cattle are
included in this group.
Polioencephalomalacia and Leukoencephalomalacia
PEM appears to be, in some cases at least, a consequence of acute edematous swelling
of the brain and cortical ischemia. The pathogenesis of leukoencephalomalacia appears
to be related to vasogenic edema as a result of cardiovascular dysfunction and an
inability to regulate cerebral blood flow. Whether the lesion is in the gray matter
(PEM) or in the white matter (leukoencephalomalacia) the syndrome is largely one of
loss of function, although as might be expected irritation signs are more likely to
occur when the gray matter is damaged.
Clinical Findings
Weakness of all four limbs is accompanied by the following:
•
Dullness or somnolence
•
Blindness
•
Ataxia
•
Head-pressing
•
Circling
•
Terminal coma
In the early stages, particularly in ruminant PEM, there are involuntary signs including
muscle tremor, opisthotonus, nystagmus, and convulsions.
In equine leukoencephalomalacia, which may occur in outbreaks, initial signs include
anorexia and depression. In the neurotoxic form, which is the most common, the anorexia
and depression progresses to ataxia, circling, apparent blindness, head-pressing,
hyperesthesia, agitation, delirium, recumbency, seizures, and death. An early and
consistent sign in affected horses is reduced proprioception of the tongue, which
manifests as delayed retraction of the tongue to the buccal cavity after the tongue
has been extended. In the hepatotoxicosis form, clinical findings include icterus,
swelling of the lips and nose, petechiation, abdominal breathing, and cyanosis. Horses
with either syndrome may be found dead without any premonitory signs.
In many of the leukoencephalomalacias, the course may be one of gradual progression
of signs, or more commonly a level of abnormality is reached and maintained for a
long period, often necessitating euthanasia of the animal. For example, EDM is a diffuse
degenerative disease of the equine spinal cords and caudal portion of the brainstem
and primarily affects young horses. There is an insidious onset of symmetric spasticity,
ataxia, and paresis. Clinical signs may progress slowly to stabilize for long periods.
All four limbs are affected, but the pelvic limbs are usually more severely affected
than the thoracic limbs. There is no treatment for the disease, no spontaneous recovery
and, once affected, horses remain atactic and useless for any athletic function.
Clinical Pathology
There are no clinicopathologic tests specific for encephalomalacia, but various tests
may aid in the diagnosis of some of the specific diseases mentioned in this section
under Etiology.
Necropsy Findings
Gross lesions including areas of softening, cavitation, and laminar necrosis of the
cortex may be visible. The important lesions are described under each of the specific
diseases.
Treatment
The prognosis depends on the nature of the lesion. Early cases of thiamine deficiency–induced
PEM can recover completely if treated with adequate levels of thiamine. Encephalomalacia
caused by sulfur-induced PEM and lead poisoning is more difficult to treat. Young
calves with acquired in utero hypomyelinogenesis and horses with myelitis associated
with EHV-1 infection can make complete recoveries.
Differential Diagnosis
The syndromes produced by encephalomalacia resemble very closely those caused by most
lesions that elevate intracranial pressure. The onset is quite sudden, and there is
depression of consciousness and loss of motor function. One major difference is that
the lesions tend to be nonprogressive, and affected animals may continue to survive
in an impaired state for long periods.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Further Reading
Cebra
CK
Cebra
ML
Altered mentation caused by polioencephalomalacia, hypernatremia, and lead poisoning
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
287
302
15203227
De Lahunta
A
Abiotrophy in domestic animals: a review
Can J Vet Res
54
1990
65
76
2407332
References
1
Smith
GW
Am J Vet Res
63
2002
538
11939316
2
Foreman
JH
J Vet Intern Med
18
2004
223
15058775
3
Chang
HT
Vet Pathol
49
2012
398
21527781
4
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
1439
22092640
5
Wong
DM
Vet Pathol
49
2012
1049
22390882
Myelomalacia
Degeneration of the spinal cord (myelomalacia) occurs rarely as an entity separate
from encephalomalacia. One recorded occurrence is focal spinal poliomalacia of sheep,
and in enzootic ataxia the lesions of degeneration are often restricted to the spinal
cord. In both instances there is a gradual development of paralysis without signs
of irritation and with no indication of brain involvement. Progressive paresis in
young goats may be associated with the virus of CAE and other unidentified, possibly
inherited causes of myelomalacia.
Degeneration of spinal cord tracts has also been recorded in poisoning by Phalaris
aquatica in cattle and sheep, by Tribulus terrestris in sheep,
1
by sorghum in horses, by 3-nitro-4-hydroxyphenylarsonic acid in pigs, and by selenium
in ruminants; the lesion is a symmetric spinal poliomalacia. Poisoning of cattle by
plants of Zamia spp. produces a syndrome suggestive of injury to the spinal cord but
no lesions have been reported. Pantothenic acid (PA) or pyridoxine deficiencies also
cause degeneration of the spinal cord tract in swine.
A spinal myelinopathy, possibly of genetic origin, is recorded in Murray Grey calves.
Affected animals develop ataxia of the hindlegs, swaying of the hindquarters, and
collapse of one hindleg with falling to one side. Clinical signs become worse over
an extended period.
Sporadic cases of degeneration of spinal tracts have been observed in pigs. One outbreak
is recorded in the litters of sows on lush clover pasture. The piglets were unable
to stand, struggled violently on their sides with rigid extension of the limbs and,
although able to drink, usually died of starvation. Several other outbreaks in pigs
have been attributed to selenium poisoning.
Neuraxonal dystrophy is a progressive degenerative process of CNS axons characterized
initially by discontinuous swellings (called spheroids) along the distal section of
axons. The spheroids reflect an inability of the neuron to maintain a normal structure
and function. Neuraxonal dystrophy has been diagnosed in a number of sheep breeds,
including Suffolks in the United States, Coopworth and Romney lambs in New Zealand,
and Merino sheep in New Zealand and Australia, where it was previously been called
Murrurrundi disease or ovine segmental axonopathy. The disease is consistent with
an autosomal recessive disorder.
2
EDM (neuraxonal dystrophy) affects young horses and has been recorded in the United
States, Canada, the UK, and Australia. EDM appears to be inherited with vitamin E
intake during growth modifying the clinical expression and is pathologically more
advanced form of neuraxonal dystrophy.3, 4 The major clinical signs are referable
to bilateral leukomyelopathy involving the cervical spinal cord. There is abnormal
positioning and decreased strength and spasticity of the limbs as a result of upper
motor neuron and general proprioceptive tract lesions. Hypalgesia, hypotonia, hyporeflexia,
muscle atrophy, or vestibular signs are not present, and there is no evidence of CN,
cerebral, or cerebellar involvement clinically. Abnormal gait and posture are evident,
usually initially in the pelvic limbs but eventually also in the thoracic limbs. There
are no gross lesions, but histologically there is degeneration of neuronal processes
in the white matter of all spinal cord funiculi, especially the dorsal spinocerebellar
and sulcomarginal tracts. The lesion is most severe in the thoracic segments and is
progressive.
5
Motor neuron diseases are a group of nervous disorders characterized by selective
degeneration of upper motor neurons and/or lower motor neurons. Common characteristics
of motor neuron diseases are muscle weakness or spastic paralysis. Motor neuron diseases
have been identified in a number of species and are currently considered incurable.
6
An inherited motor neuron disease has been identified in an extended family of Romney
lambs. Lower motor neuron signs predominated and affected lambs were euthanized at
4 weeks of age. The disorder was inherited in a simple autosomal recessive manner.
6
Bovine spinal muscular atrophy is an inherited motor neuron disease of Brown Swiss
cattle characterized by progressive weakness and severe neurogenic muscle atrophy
with early postnatal onset and death within the first few months of life.
2
An inherited lower motor neuron disease has been recorded in pigs. Clinical findings
of muscular tremors, paresis, or ataxia developed at 12 to 59 days of age. There is
widespread degeneration of myelinated axons in peripheral nerves and in the lateral
and ventral columns of lumbar and cervical segments of the spinal cord. Axonal degeneration
is present in ventral spinal nerve roots and absent in dorsal spinal nerve roots when
sampled at the same lumbar levels.
Equine motor neuron disease is a neurodegenerative condition that affects horses from
15 months to 25 years of age of many different breeds and has been associated with
oxidative stress and vitamin E deficiency.7, 8 Progressive weakness, short-striding
gait, trembling, long periods of recumbency, and trembling and sweating following
exercise are characteristic clinical findings. The weakness is progressive and recumbency
is permanent. Appetites remain normal or become excessive. At necropsy, degeneration
or loss of somatic motor neurons in the spinal ventral horns, angular atrophy of skeletal
muscle fibers, and the presence of lipofuscin deposits in the ventral horns of the
spinal cord and retina are characteristic.
Sporadic cases of spinal cord damage in horses include hemorrhagic myelomalacia following
general anesthesia and acute spinal cord degeneration following general anesthesia
and surgery. Following recovery from the anesthesia, the horse is able to assume sternal
recumbency but not able to stand. A hemorrhagic infarct assumed to be caused by cartilage
emboli, and a venous malformation causing spinal cord destruction, have also occurred
in the horse. The disease must be differentiated from myelitis and spinal cord compression
caused by space-occupying lesions of the vertebral canal and cervical, vertebral malformation/malarticulation.
References
1
Bourke
CA
Aust Vet J
84
2006
53
16498837
2
Krebs
S
Mamm Genome
17
2006
67
16416092
3
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
1439
22092640
4
Finno
CJ
Valberg
SJ
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1251
22925200
5
Wong
DM
Vet Pathol
49
2012
1049
22390882
6
Zhao
X
Heredity
109
2012
156
22588130
7
Wijnberg
ID
Equine Vet Educ
18
2006
126
8
Mohammed
HO
Am J Vet Res
73
2012
1957
23176423
Focal Diseases of the Brain and Spinal Cord
Traumatic Injury to the Brain
The effects of trauma to the brain vary with the site and extent of the injury, but
initially nervous shock is likely to occur followed by death, recovery, or the persistence
of residual nervous signs. Traumatic lesions of the skull or vertebral column were
the most commonly diagnosed nervous diseases of horses at necropsy in a large case
series of 4,319 horses with clinical signs of nervous disease, accounting for 34%
of all diagnoses.
1
Etiology
Traumatic injury to the brain may result from direct trauma applied externally, by
violent stretching or flexing of the head and neck, or by migration of parasitic larvae
internally. Recorded causes include the following:
•
Direct trauma is an uncommon cause because of the force required to damage the cranium.
Accidental collisions, rearing forward, falling over backward after rearing are the
usual reasons.
•
Periorbital skull fractures in horses are caused by direct traumatic injury commonly
from colliding with gate posts.
•
Cerebral injury and CN injury accounted for a large percentage of neurologic diseases
in horses. Young horses under 2 years of age seem most susceptible to injuries of
the head.
•
Injury by heat in goat kids is achieved with prolonged application of a hot iron used
for disbudding
•
Pulling back violently when tethered can cause problems at the atlantooccipital junction.
•
Animals trapped in bogs, sumps, cellars, and waterholes and dragged out by the head,
and recumbent animals pulled onto trailers can suffer dire consequences to the medulla
and cervical cord, although the great majority of them come to surprisingly little
harm.
•
The violent reaction of animals to lightning stroke and electrocution causing damage
to central nervous tissue; the traumatic effect of the electrical current itself also
causes neuronal destruction.
•
Spontaneous hemorrhage into the brain is rare but sometimes occurs in cows at parturition,
causing multiple small hemorrhages in the medulla and brainstem.
•
Brain injury at parturition, recorded in lambs, calves, and foals, is possibly a significant
cause of mortality in the former.
Pathogenesis
The initial reaction in severe trauma or hemorrhage is nervous shock. Slowly developing
subdural hematoma, a common development in humans, is accompanied by the gradual onset
of signs of a space-occupying lesion of the cranial cavity, but this seems to be a
rare occurrence in animals. In some cases of trauma to the head, clinical evidence
of injury to the brain may be delayed for a few days until sufficient swelling, callus
formation, or displacement of the fracture fragments has occurred. Trauma to the cranial
vault may be classified, from least to most severe, as concussion, contusion, laceration,
and hemorrhage.
Concussion
Concussion is usually a brief loss of consciousness that results from an abrupt head
injury, which produces an episode of rapid acceleration/deceleration of the brain.
Contusion
With a more violent force, the brain is contused. There is maintenance of structure
but loss of vascular integrity, resulting in hemorrhage into the parenchyma and meninges
relative to the point of impact. Bony deformation or fracture of the calvaria results
in two different kinds of focal lesions:
•
Direct (coup) contusions immediately below the impact site
•
Indirect (contrecoup) contusions to the brain at the opposite point of the skull;
these hemorrhages result from tearing of leptomeningeal and parenchymal blood vessels.
Laceration
The most severe contusion is laceration in which the CNS tissue is physically torn
or disrupted by bony structures lining the cranium or by penetrating objects such
as bone fragments. Focal meningeal hemorrhage is a common sequel to severe head injury.
Subdural hematomas usually follow disruption of bridging cerebral veins that drain
into the dural venous sinuses, but subarachnoid hemorrhages are more common. The importance
of these hemorrhages is that they develop into space-occupying masses that indent
and compress the underlying brain. Progressive enlargement of the hematoma can result
in secondary effects such as severe, widespread brain edema, areas of ischemia, herniations,
midline shift, and lethal brainstem compression.
In birth injuries the lesion is principally one of hemorrhage subdurally and under
the arachnoid.
Experimental Traumatic Craniocerebral Missile Injury
Traumatic insult of the brains of sheep with a .22 caliber firearm results in a primary
hemorrhagic wound track with indriven bone fragments and portions of muscle and skin.
There is crushing and laceration of tissues during missile penetration; secondary
tracks caused by bone and bullet fragments; widely distributed stretch injuries to
blood vessels, nerve fibers, and neurons as a consequence of the radial forces of
the temporary cavity that develops as a bullet penetrates tissue; marked subarachnoid
and intraventricular hemorrhage; and distortion and displacement of the brain. The
lesions are consistently severe and rapidly fatal.
Clinical Findings
Clinical signs of neurologic disease usually follows the pattern of greatest severity
initially with recovery occurring quickly but incompletely to a point where a residual
defect is evident, with this defect persisting unchanged for a long period and often
permanently. This failure to improve or worsen after the initial phase is a characteristic
of traumatic injury.
With severe injury there is cerebral shock in which the animal falls unconscious with
or without a transient clonic convulsion. Consciousness may never be regained, but
in animals that recover it returns in from a few minutes up to several hours. During
the period of unconsciousness, clinical examination reveals dilatation of the pupils;
absence of the eye preservation and pupillary light reflexes; and a slow, irregular
respiration, with the irregularity phasic in many cases. There may be evidence of
bleeding from the nose and ears, and palpation of the cranium may reveal a site of
injury. Residual signs vary a great deal. Blindness is present if the optic cortex
is damaged, hemiplegia may be associated with lesions in the midbrain, and traumatic
epilepsy may occur with lesions in the motor cortex.
Fracture of the petrous temporal bone is a classic injury in horses caused by rearing
and falling over backward. Both the facial and the vestibular nerves are likely to
be damaged so that at first the animal may be unable to stand and there may be blood
from the ear and nostril of the affected side. When the animal does stand, the head
is rotated with the damaged side down. There may be nystagmus, especially early in
the course of the disease. The ear, eyelid, and lip on the affected side are also
paralyzed and sag. Ataxia with a tendency to fall is common. Some improvement occurs
in the subsequent 2 or 3 weeks as the horse compensates for the deficit, but there
is rarely permanent recovery. An identical syndrome is recorded in horses in which
there has been a stress fracture of the petrous temporal bone resulting from a preexisting
inflammation of the bone. The onset of signs is acute but unassociated with trauma.
Fracture of the basisphenoid and/or basioccipital bones is also common. These fractures
can seriously damage the jugular vein; carotid artery; and glossopharyngeal, hypoglossal,
and vagus nerves. The cavernous sinus and the basilar artery may also be damaged and
lead to massive hemorrhage within the cranium. Large vessels in the area are easily
damaged by fragments of the fractured bones, causing fatal hemorrhage. A midline fracture
of the frontal bones can also have this effect.
Other signs of severe trauma to the brain include opisthotonus with blindness and
nystagmus and, if the brainstem has been damaged, quadriplegia. There may also be
localizing signs, including head rotation, circling, and falling backward. Less common
manifestations of resulting hemorrhage include bleeding into the retropharyngeal area,
which may cause pressure on guttural pouches and the airways and lead to asphyxia.
Bleeding may take place into the guttural pouches themselves.
Newborn lambs affected by birth injury to the brain are mostly dead at birth, or die
soon afterward. Surviving lambs drink poorly and are very susceptible to cold stress.
In some flocks it may be the principal mechanism causing perinatal mortality.
Diagnosis
Radiography of the skull is important to detect the presence and severity of fractures,
which may have lacerated nervous tissue; however, CT is a much more sensitive method
for detecting fractures of the calvarium and basilar bone than radiography.
1
Clinical Pathology
CSF should be sampled from the cerebellomedullary cistern and examined for evidence
of RBCs. Extreme care must be taken to ensure that blood vessels are not punctured
during the sampling procedure because this would confound the interpretation of the
presence of RBCs. The presence of heme pigments in the CSF (xanthochromia) suggests
the presence of preexisting hemorrhage; the presence of eosinophils or hypersegmented
neutrophils suggests parasitic invasion.
Necropsy Findings
In most cases a gross hemorrhagic lesion will be evident, but in concussion and nematodiasis
the lesions may be detectable only on histologic examination.
Differential Diagnosis
Unless a history of trauma is available diagnosis may be difficult.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
The principles of treatment of animals exhibiting neurologic abnormalities after a
traumatic event are derived from the results of large, controlled, multicenter clinical
trials in humans. Similar studies have not been performed in large animals. The general
principles are (1) stabilize the patient by ensuring a patent airway, obtaining vascular
access and attending to wounds; (2) specific treatment for hyperthermia, because brain
defects may result in an inability to regulate core temperature; (3) prevent or treat
systemic arterial hypotension; (4) optimize oxygen delivery; (5) ensure adequate ventilation
by placing in sternal recumbency whenever possible; (6) decrease pain; (7) monitor
plasma glucose concentration and maintain euglycemia; and (8) prevent or treat cerebral
edema by having the head elevated or by the intravenous administration of a hyperosmolar
agent (20% mannitol as a series of bolus infusions of 0.25–1.0 g/kg BW every 4–6 hours,
the latter is an expensive treatment; hypertonic saline, 7.2% NaCl, 2 mL/kg BW every
4 hours for five infusions). Intravenous catheterization should be confined to one
jugular vein, and the neck should not be bandaged in an attempt to minimize promotion
of cerebral edema by jugular venous hypertension.
Seizures should be treated when they occur by initially administering diazepam at
0.1 mg/kg intravenously. If no improvement is noticed within 10 minutes, then one
or two additional doses of diazepam (0.1 mg/kg, intravenously; total dose 0.3 mg/kg,
intravenously) should be administered at 10-minute intervals. Midazolam could be substituted
for diazepam, but dose rates are not well defined. If this dosage protocol of diazepam
does not provide adequate seizure control, then phenobarbitone (20 mg/kg intravenously
over 20 minutes) should be administered to effect; the phenobarbitone can be diluted
in 0.9% NaCl solution. This should provide seizure control for a number of hours.
If seizures return, then oral phenobarbitone (6 mg/kg every 8 hours) can be administered
to foals and horses, with a reduction in the oral dose to 3 mg/kg every 8 hours if
seizures are controlled. An alternative protocol in horses is a mixture of 12% chloral
hydrate and 6% magnesium sulfate to effect at an intravenous administration rate not
exceeding 30 mL/min. Euthanasia should be considered to adult ruminants with seizures
that are only responsive to intravenous phenobarbitone.
Many anecdotal treatments have been used in large animals, but evidence attesting
to their efficacy is lacking. Among the more popular empiric antioxidant treatments
are dimethyl sulfoxide (1 g/kg BW IV as a 10% solution in 0.9% NaCl) administered
intravenously or by nasogastric tube every 12 hours, vitamin E (α-tocopherol, 50 IU/kg
BW administered orally every day), vitamin C (ascorbic acid, 20 mg/kg BW administered
orally every day), and allopurinol (5 mg/kg BW administered orally every 12 hours).
Corticosteroids have also been advocated; promoted treatments include an antiinflammatory
dose of dexamethasone (0.05 mg/kg BW IV every day) or a high dose of methylprednisolone
sodium succinate (30 mg/kg BW initial IV bolus, followed by continuous infusion of
5.4 mg/kg BW per hour for 24–48 hours); the latter treatment is prohibitively expensive
in large animals and must be given within a few hours of the traumatic event to be
effective. Intravenous magnesium sulfate (50 mg/kg BW) in the first 5 to 10 L of intravenous
fluids has also been advocated on the basis that it inhibits several aspects of the
secondary injury cascade.
The overall short-term survival rate in one case series of 34 cases was 62%.
2
In those animals that recover consciousness within a few hours or earlier, the prognosis
is favorable and little or no specific treatment may be necessary other than nursing
care. When coma lasts for more than 3 to 6 hours, the prognosis is unfavorable, and
slaughter for salvage or euthanasia is recommended. Horses with basilar bone fractures
are 7.5 times more likely not to survive as horses without this type of fracture.
2
Treatment for cerebral edema of the brain as previously outlined may be indicated
when treatment for valuable animals is requested by the owner. Animals that are still
in a coma 6 to 12 hours following treatment are unlikely to improve, and continued
treatment is probably not warranted.
Further Reading
MacKay
RJ
Brain injury after head trauma: pathophysiology, diagnosis, and treatment
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
20
2004
199
216
15062465
References
1
Laugier
C
J Equine Vet Sci
29
2009
561
2
Feary
DJ
J Am Vet Med Assoc
231
2007
259
17630894
Brain Abscess
Abscesses of the brain are rare, but occur most commonly in young farm animals under
1 year of age and rarely in older animals. They appear to be more common in ruminants
than in horses. Brain abscesses were not observed at necropsy in a large case series
of 4,319 horses with clinical signs of nervous disease in France.
1
They produce a variety of clinical signs depending on their location and size. Basically
the syndrome produced is one of a space-occupying lesion of the cranial cavity with
some motor irritation signs. Localized or diffuse meningitis is also common, along
with the effects of the abscess.
Etiology
Abscesses in the brain originate in a number of ways. Hematogenous infections are
common, but direct spread from injury to the cranium or via the nasopharynx may also
occur.
Hematogenous Spread
The lesions may be single, but are often multiple, and are usually accompanied by
meningitis. The infection usually originates elsewhere.
•
Actinobacillus mallei from glanders lesions in lung
•
Streptococcus zooepidemicus var. equi as a complication of strangles in horses
•
Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis in a goat causing an encapsulated abscess in the
left cerebellar peduncles
•
Actinomyces bovis and Mycobacterium bovis from visceral lesions in cattle
•
Fusobacterium necrophorum from lesions in the oropharynx of calves
•
Pseudomonas pseudomallei in melioidosis in sheep
•
Staphylococcus aureus in tick pyemia of lambs
•
Systemic fungal infections such as cryptococcosis may include granulomatous lesions
in brain.
Local Spread
•
Via peripheral nerves from the oropharynx, the one specific disease is listeriosis
in ruminants and New World camelids.
•
Multifocal meningoencephalitis associated with lingual arteritis induced by barley
spikelet clusters.
•
Space-occupying lesions of facial and vestibulocochlear nerves and geniculate ganglion
secondary to otitis media in calves.
•
Abscesses of the rete mirabile of the pituitary gland are seen secondary to nasal
septal infection after nose-ringing in cattle. Trueperella (Arcanobacterium or Actinomyces
or Corynebacterium) pyogenes is the most common isolate, and several other species
of bacteria that cause chronic suppurative lesions have been recovered. Similar abscesses,
usually containing T. pyogenes, occur in the pituitary gland itself.
•
Extensions from local suppurative processes in cranial signs are seen after dehorning
from otitis media. The lesions are single and most commonly contain T. pyogenes and
are accompanied by meningitis.
Pathogenesis
Infectious agents can invade the CNS by four routes:
•
Retrograde infection via peripheral nerves
•
Direct penetrating injuries
•
Extension of adjacent suppurative lesions
•
By way of the systemic circulation
Single abscesses cause local pressure effects on nervous tissue and may produce some
signs of irritation, including head-pressing and mania, but the predominant effect
is one of loss of function caused by destruction of nerve cells. Multiple abscesses
have much the same effect. In single abscesses the signs usually make it possible
to define the location of the lesion, whereas multiple lesions present a confusing
multiplicity of signs and variation in their severity from day to day, suggesting
that damage has occurred at a number of widely distributed points and at different
times.
The pituitary abscess syndrome has an uncertain pathogenesis. The pituitary gland
is surrounded by a complex mesh of intertwined arteries and capillary beds known as
the rete mirabile, which has been identified in cattle, sheep, goats, and pigs but
not horses. This extensive capillary network surrounding the pituitary gland makes
it susceptible to localization by bacteria that originate from other sources of infection.
Nose-ringing of cattle may result in septic rhinitis, which could result in infection
of the dural venous sinus system, which communicates with the subcutaneous veins of
the head. Bacteria may also reach the rete mirabile by way of lymphatics of the nasal
mucosa and cribriform plate. CN deficits occur as a result of the extension of the
abscess into the adjacent brainstem.
Clinical Findings
General signs include mental depression, clumsiness, head-pressing, and blindness,
often preceded or interrupted by transient attacks of motor irritation including excitement,
uncontrolled activity, and convulsions. A mild fever is usually present, but the temperature
may be normal in some cases.
The degree of blindness varies depending on the location of the abscess and the extent
of adjacent edema and meningoencephalitis. The animal may be blind in one eye and
have normal eyesight in the other eye or have normal eyesight in both eyes. Unequal
pupils and abnormalities in the pupillary light reflex, both direct and consensual,
are common. Uveitis, iris bombé, and a collection of fibrin in the anterior chamber
of an eye may be present in some cases of multiple meningoencephalitis in cattle.
Nystagmus is common when the lesion is near the vestibular nucleus; strabismus may
also occur.
Localizing signs depend on the location of lesions and may include cerebellar ataxia,
deviation of the head with circling and falling, and hemiplegia or paralysis of individual
or groups of CNs often in a unilateral pattern. In the later stages, there may be
papilledema. In calves with lesions of the facial and vestibulocochlear nerves and
geniculate ganglion, clinical signs may include drooping of the ears and lips, lifting
of the nose, slight unilateral tilting of the head, and uncontrolled saliva flow.
Inability to swallow may follow and affected calves become dehydrated.
These localizing signs may be intermittent, especially in the early stages, and may
develop slowly or acutely.
Pituitary gland abscesses are most common in ruminants, primarily cattle 2 to 5 years
of age, but are relatively rare. The most common history includes anorexia, ataxia,
depression, and drooling from the mouth with inability to chew and swallow. The most
common clinical findings are depression, dysphagia, dropped jaw, blindness, and absence
of pupillary light reflexes. Terminally, opisthotonus, nystagmus, ataxia, and recumbency
are common. Characteristically, the animal stands with a base-wide stance with its
head and neck extended and its mouth not quite closed; there is difficulty in chewing
and swallowing, and drooling of saliva. Affected animals are usually nonresponsive
to external stimuli. CN deficits are common, and usually asymmetric, multifocal, and
progressive. These include reduced tone of the jaw, facial paralysis, strabismus,
and a head tilt. There may also be ptosis and prolapse of the tongue. Bradycardia
has been recorded in about 50% of cases. Terminally there is opisthotonus, nystagmus,
and loss of balance, followed by recumbency.
Clinical Pathology
Cerebrospinal Fluid
Leukocytes, protein, and bacteria may be present in the CSF, but only when the abscess
is not contained.
Hematology
In pituitary gland abscessation there may be hematologic evidence of chronic infection
including neutrophilia, hyperproteinemia, and increased fibrinogen, although it is
unlikely that a pituitary abscess itself is sufficiently large enough to induce these
changes.
Imaging
Radiographic examination will not detect brain abscesses unless they are calcified
or cause erosion of bone. CT has been used to diagnose a brain abscess in the horse.
MRI is the preferred imaging modality to diagnose a cerebral abscess, with mature
abscesses having an isointense to hypointense core on T1-weighted images and an isotense
to hyperintense core with a hypointense capsule on T2-weighted images.
2
Electroencephalography
Electroencephalographic assessment of central blindness caused by brain abscess in
cattle has been reported.
Necropsy Findings
The abscess or abscesses may be visible on gross examination and if superficial are
usually accompanied by local meningitis. Large abscesses may penetrate to the ventricles
and result in a diffuse ependymitis. Microabscesses may be visible only on histologic
examination. A general necropsy examination may reveal the primary lesion.
Differential Diagnosis
Brain abscess is manifested by signs of involuntary movements and loss of function,
which can occur in many other diseases of the brain, especially when local lesions
develop slowly. This occurs more frequently with tumors and parasitic cysts but it
may occur in encephalitis. The characteristic clinical findings are those of a focal
or multifocal lesion of the brain, which include the following:
•
Localizing signs of hemiparesis and ataxia
•
Postural reaction deficit
•
Vestibular signs, including head tilt and positional nystagmus
•
Cranial nerve deficits
There may be evidence of the existence of a suppurative lesion in another organ, and
a high cell count and detectable infection in the CSF to support the diagnosis of
abscess. Fever may or may not be present. The only specific disease in which abscess
occurs is listeriosis, in which the lesions are largely confined to the medulla oblongata
and the characteristic signs include circling and unilateral facial paralysis. Occasional
cases may be associated with fungal infections, including cryptococcosis. Toxoplasmosis
is an uncommon cause of granulomatous lesions in the brain of most species.
Many cases of brain abscess are similar to otitis media but there is, in the latter,
rotation of the head, a commonly associated facial paralysis and an absence of signs
of cerebral depression.
The pituitary gland syndrome in cattle must be differentiated from listeriosis, polioencephalomalacia,
lead poisoning, other brain abscesses, and thrombomeningoencephalitis. In sheep and
goats, Parelaphostrongylus tenuis infection and caprine arthritis encephalomyelitis
syndrome may resemble the pituitary gland abscess syndrome.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Parenteral treatment with antimicrobials is indicated but the results are often unsatisfactory
because of the inaccessibility of the lesion, with the clear exception being listeriosis.
Treatment of pituitary gland abscess is not recommended, and an antemortem diagnosis
is rarely obtained. There is one successful report of recovery after surgical excision
of the complete abscess in a 1-month-old alpaca.
2
Further Reading
Kessell
AE
Finnie
JW
Windsor
PA
Neurological diseases of ruminant livestock in Australia. III. Bacterial and protozoal
infections
Aust Vet J
89
2011
289
296
24635630
Morin
DE
Brainstem and cranial nerve abnormalities: listeriosis, otitis media/interna, and
pituitary abscess syndrome
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
243
274
15203225
References
1
Laugier
C
J Equine Vet Sci
29
2009
561
2
Talbot
CE
J Am Vet Med Assoc
231
2007
1558
18021001
Tumors of the Central Nervous System
Primary tumors of the CNS are extremely rare in farm animals. They produce a syndrome
indicative of a general increase in intracranial pressure and local destruction of
nervous tissue. Tumors of the peripheral nervous system are more common.
Etiology
The reader is referred to the review literature for a summary of available references
on the tumors of the CNS of farm animals, which include the following:
•
Meningeal tumors in cattle
•
Oligodendroglioma in a cow
1
•
Ependymoblastoma in a heifer
2
•
Primitive neuroectodermal tumor with ependymal differentiation in a cow
3
•
Cerebellar medulloblastoma in a calf
4
•
Choroid plexus carcinoma in a goat
5
•
Equine papillary ependymoma
•
Lymphoma confined to the CNS in a horse.
6
Pathogenesis
The development of the disease parallels that of any space-occupying lesion, with
the concurrent appearance of signs of increased intracranial pressure and local tissue
destruction. Many lesions found incidentally at necropsy may not have had any related
clinical findings.
Clinical Findings
The clinical findings are similar to those caused by a slowly developing abscess and
localizing signs depending on the location, size, and speed of development of the
tumor. Clinical signs are usually representative of increased intracranial pressure,
including opisthotonus, convulsions, nystagmus, dullness, head-pressing, and hyperexcitability.
Common localizing signs include circling, deviation of the head, and disturbance of
balance.
Clinical Pathology
There are no positive findings in the clinicopathologic examination, which aids in
diagnosis.
Necropsy Findings
The brain should be carefully sectioned after fixation if the tumor is deep-seated.
Treatment
There is no treatment.
Differential Diagnosis
Differentiation is required from the other diseases in which space-occupying lesions
of the cranial cavity occur. The rate of development is usually much slower in tumors
than with the other lesions.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
References
1
Kleinschmidt
S
J Comp Pathol
140
2009
72
19064271
2
Miyoshi
N
J Vet Med Sci
71
2009
1393
19887749
3
Patton
KM
J Am Vet Med Assoc
244
2014
287
24432960
4
Bianchi
E
J Vet Intern Med
29
2015
1117
26110579
5
Klopfleisch
R
J Comp Pathol
135
2006
42
16820166
6
Morrison
LR
J Comp Pathol
139
2008
256
18823902
Central Nervous System–Associated Tumors
The pituitary gland (hypophysis) consists of the adenohypophysis (pars distalis, intermedia,
tuberalis) and the neurohypophysis (pars nervosa). Tumors of the pituitary gland are
common in older horses. Cushing's syndrome in horses almost invariably originates
from an adenoma of the pars intermedia of the pituitary gland. Initially, these animals
exhibit only one remarkable sign, namely, hirsutism. Horses with Cushing's disease
only do not manifest polyuria and polydipsia. Major sequelae of an adenoma of the
pars intermedia of the pituitary gland are type 2 diabetes mellitus and laminitis.
Diagnosis of an adenoma of the pars intermedia of the pituitary gland in the horse
mainly depends on dynamic endocrinologic function tests. The sensitivity of the adrenocorticotropin
test is about 80%.
Pituitary adenomas can arise from other parts of the pituitary gland; there is a report
of a nonfunctional chromophobe adenoma located in the pars distalis of an alpaca with
depression and compulsive walking.
1
Further Reading
McFarlane
D
Equine pituitary pars intermedia dysfunction
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
93
113
21392656
Reference
1
Gilsenan
WF
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1073
22646293
Metastatic Tumors of the Central Nervous System
Many primary tumors of nonnervous tissue have the potential for metastasis or localized
growth into the CNS.
•
Ocular squamous cell carcinoma of cattle may invade the cranium through the cribriform
plate
•
Lymphomas of cattle may metastasize to the CNS with either a multicentric distribution
or occasionally as the only lesion. Most commonly bovine lymphoma occurs as an epidural
mass in the vertebral canal. Intracranial lymphoma usually involves the leptomeninges
or the choroid plexus. Clinical signs are related to the progressive compression of
the nervous tissue at the site of the mass. Lymphoma in the horse has occurred in
the epidural space with spinal cord compression.
•
Thymic lymphosarcoma rarely metastasizes to the cerebellum and intracranial extradural
sites in yearling cattle.
1
•
Rhabdomyosarcoma invaded the thoracic spinal cord of a heifer, resulting in posterior
paresis.
2
•
Schwannomas (also called neuromas) originate from the Schwann cells of cranial or
spinal nerve roots except CNs I and II, which are myelinated by oligodendroglia. Local
growth of a schwannoma into the thoracic or sacral spinal cord produced clinical signs
of spinal cord dysfunction in two adult cattle.
3
Schwannomas occur in adult horses with no apparent breed or sex predisposition. There
is one report of successful treatment of a dermal schwannoma using localized radiation
therapy.
4
In domestic animals, schwannomas can be difficult to differentiate from neurofibromas,
and consequently, schwannomas and neurofibromas are categorized as PNSTs by the WHO.
•
Malignant melanoma has been diagnosed in a cow with hindlimb ataxia
3
and in gray horses where they are usually metastases from skin tumors.
Central Nervous System–Associated Masses
Cholesterinic granulomas, also known as cholesteatomas, may occur in up to 20% of
older horses without any clinical effects. However, they can be associated with significant
neurologic disease. Affected horses are usually obese. Cholesterinic granulomas occur
in the choroid plexus of the fourth ventricle or in the lateral ventricles and mimic
cerebrocortical disease. It has been suggested that cholesterol granulomas result
from chronic hemorrhage into the plexus stroma, but the underlying pathogenesis is
unknown.
Brownish nodular thickening of the plexuses with glistening white crystals is a common
incidental finding in mature and aged horses. Occasionally, deposits in the plexuses
of the lateral ventricles are massive and fill the ventricular space and cause secondary
hydrocephalus caused by the buildup of CSF behind the mass. CSF may be xanthochromic
with an elevated total protein.
Clinical findings include episodes of abnormal behavior such as depression and bolting
uncontrollably and running into fences and walls. Some horses exhibit profound depression,
somnolence, and reluctance to move. Seizures have also been reported. Other clinical
findings reported include decreased performance, aggression, head tilt, incoordination,
intermittent convulsions, hindlimb ataxia progressing to recumbency, intermittent
circling in one direction, and spontaneous twitching along the back and flank. There
are often serious changes in temperament, with previously placid animals becoming
violent and aggressive. In others there are outbursts of frenzied activity followed
by coma. The horse may be normal between attacks, and these may be precipitated by
moving the head rapidly.
These signs are referable to cerebrocortical disease and the differential diagnosis
of cholesterol granulomas must include diffuse cerebral encephalopathy caused by abscess,
tumor, toxicosis, metabolic disease, encephalomyelitis, trauma, and hydrocephalus.
At necropsy, large cholesterol granulomas are present in the choroid plexus.
References
1
Tawfeeq
MM
J Vet Med Sci
74
2012
1501
22785125
2
Kajiwara
A
J Vet Med Sci
71
2009
827
19578298
3
Braun
U
Ehrensperger
F
Vet Rec
158
2006
696
16714435
4
Saulez
MN
Tydskr S Afr Vet Assoc
80
2009
264
Plant Toxins Affecting the Nervous System
Cannabinoids
Cannabinoids are resinoids found in the plant Cannabis sativa (marijuana). The toxic
principle is the alkaloid tetrahydrocannabinol. Most reports of poisoning are in dogs
and humans, but cattle and horses have also been affected. Clinical signs of poisoning
in horses include restlessness, hypersensitivity, tremor, sweating, salivation, dyspnea,
staggering gait, and death or recovery after a few hours. No significant necropsy
lesions are recorded. The toxin is detectable in stomach or rumen contents.
Cynanchoside
Cynanchoside is found in Cynanchum spp. (monkey rope),
1
and a very similar toxin is found in Marsdenia rostrata (milk vine), M. megalantha,
1
Sarcostemma brevipedicellatum (= S. australe; caustic vine), and S. viminale (caustic
bush). It is associated with hypersensitivity; ataxia; muscle tremors; recumbency;
tetanic and clonic convulsions; opisthotonus; and death in horses, donkeys, pigs,
and ruminants.1, 2 Other less common signs include teeth grinding, dyspnea, salivation,
and vomiting.
Diterpenoid (Kaurene) Glycosides (Atractyloside, Carboxyatractyloside, Parquin, Carboxyparquin,
and Wedeloside)
Diterpenoid glycoside toxins have been found in the following species:
Atractylis
Atractylodes
Callilepsis
Cestrum
Iphiona
Wedelia
Xanthium
Xanthium strumarium (cockleburr, Noogoora burr) includes the taxa X. canadense, X.
italicum, X. orientale, X. pungens, and X. chinense, and is poisonous to pigs and
ruminants. X. spinosum (Bathurst burr) is also toxic and assumed to contain diterpenoid
glycosides. The two cotyledonary leaves, either within the spiny burrs or just after
sprouting, contain the largest amount of toxin and are the usual source of poisoning.
The cockleburs occur on most continents. Poisonings are reported from North America,
UK, Europe, and Australia. Most deaths occur on flood plains on which the weed is
allowed to grow in abundance. After heavy rain the seeds in the burrs sprout and are
palatable to all species, especially calves and pigs. Mortalities are also recorded
in adult cows and sheep. Burrs may contaminate feed grains and poison livestock fed
on the compounded ration.
Cestrum spp. (e.g., C. parqui, C. laevigatum), are garden plants originating from
South and Central America which, except for C. diurnum, also contain a carboxyatractyloside
toxin.
Wedelia asperrima (yellow daisy), W. biflora, and W. glauca contain wedeloside. Severe
hepatic necrosis is the principal necropsy finding, and the clinical syndrome and
clinical pathology are characteristic of hepatic encephalopathy.
Poisoning by diterpenoid glycoside toxins in pigs and calves is acute, manifested
by hyperexcitability, so that the entire herd appears restless, followed by severe
depression, rigidity of the limbs and ears, weakness and a stumbling gait, falling
easily and recumbency, and clonic convulsions with opisthotonus. Calves may be belligerent.
Acute cases die during the first convulsive episode. The course may be as long as
48 hours and terminate in recovery, but death is the usual outcome. The characteristic
lesion is hepatic necrosis.
Treatment is not undertaken. Control depends on keeping livestock away from pasture
dominated by these weeds, especially when there are large quantities of sprouted Xanthium
spp. seeds available.
Stypandrol
Stypandrol (syn. hemerocallin), a binaphthoquinone (binaphthalene tetrol) is found
in Dianella revoluta (flax lily), Stypandra glauca (= S. imbricata, S. grandiflora—nodding
blue lily), and Hemerocallis spp. (day lily). Field cases occur only with S. glauca
and are characterized by blindness, incoordination, posterior weakness and, eventually,
flaccid paralysis and recumbency in grazing ruminants. Dilatation and immobility of
the pupil, with retinal vascular congestion, hemorrhage, and papilledema visible ophthalmoscopically,
are characteristic. At necropsy there is diffuse status spongiosis in the brain, general
neuronal vacuolation, and axonal degeneration of optic nerve fibers and the photoreceptor
cells of the retina.
3
Only the young green shoots are poisonous, so that outbreaks occur only in the spring
when the plant is flowering.
Tropane Alkaloids
Tropane alkaloids include atropine, hyoscyamine, hyoscine, and scopolamine, found
in the following:4, 5
Atropa belladonna (deadly nightshade)
Datura stramonium (common thorn apple, jimsonweed, gewone stinkblaar)
4
D. ferox (large thornapple, groot stinkblaar)
4
Duboisia leichhardtii
D. myoporoides (corkwoods)
Hyoscyamus niger (henbane).
D. stramonium grows universally but cases of poisoning are few, possibly because of
its unpalatability, its high toxic dose, and because it produces ruminal atony in
cattle. All parts of Datura spp. contain belladonna alkaloids with the highest amount
in the flowers, followed by the stem, seeds, leaves, and roots.
5
The seeds of the plant are likely to contaminate grain supplies and may be associated
with poisoning.
4
Clinical signs are primarily caused by blockade of peripheral muscarinic receptors
innervating smooth muscle, cardiac muscle, and exocrine glands. Ingestion of these
plants in sufficient quantity is associated with a syndrome of mydriasis (pupil dilation
and blindness), dry mouth, restlessness, tremor, tachycardia, hyperthermia, and frenzied
actions.
5
Colic, in particular impaction colic, is reported in horses.
4
Convulsions, recumbency, and death may occur. Cholinesterase inhibitors such as physostigmine
may be used to reverse the anticholinergic effects.
4
There are no significant necropsy lesions.
Tutin
Tutin is a poisonous constituent of the Coriaria spp. (tutu trees) in New Zealand.
It is associated with a short course of hypersensitivity, restlessness, and convulsions
followed by death, with no visible lesions at necropsy.
Further Reading
Botha
CJ
Naude
TW
Plant poisonings and mycotoxicoses of importance in horses in southern Africa
J S Afr Vet Assoc
73
2002
91
97
12515293
Jain
MC
Arora
N
Ganja (Cannabis sativa) refuse as cattle feed
Indian J Anim Sci
58
1988
865
867
Naudé
TW
Gerber
R
Smith
R
Datura contamination of hay as the suspected cause of an extensive outbreak of impaction
colic in horses
J S Afr Vet Assoc
76
2005
107
112
16108531
References
1
Neto
SAG
Toxicon
63
2013
116
23266310
2
Pessoa
CRM
Toxicon
58
2011
610
21930141
3
Finnie
JW
J Aust Vet Assoc
89
2011
24
4
Gerber
R
J S Afr Vet Assoc
77
2006
86
17120625
5
Krenzelok
E
Clin Toxicol (Phila)
48
2010
104
20229618
Indole Alkaloids
A large number of indole alkaloids occur in fungi, especially the Claviceps and Acremonium
spp. In plants there are also some groups of toxins with similar toxic effects, and
similar to those of the fungi. The important two are the β-carbolines and the dimethyl
tryptamines; followed by the hydroxyl methyl tryptamines, and a miscellaneous group
of alstonine and related toxins. Plants included in the latter group that are associated
with an incoordination syndrome like phalaris staggers are Gelsemium sempervirens
(yellow jessamine), Alstonia constricta (bitter bark tree), and the mushroom Psilocybe
spp. (mad or magic mushroom). Poa hueca and Urtica spp. (stinging nettle) are associated
with a more acute syndrome of convulsions and sudden death. Phalaris spp. are unusual
in that they contain both β-carbolines and methylated tryptamines. Related indole
alkaloids of the pyrrolidinoindoline type have poisoned livestock in Australia (idiospermuline
in Idiospermum australiense) and North America (calycanthine in Calycanthus spp.),
producing tetanic convulsions.
β-Carboline Indoleamine Alkaloid Poisoning
β-Carboline indole alkaloids (harmala alkaloids) in plants include harmaline, tetrahydroharmine,
harman, norharman, tetrahydroharman, harmine, harmol, harmalol, peganine, and deoxypeganine.
1
The mechanism of action for these alkaloids is competitive inhibition of monoamine
oxidase (primarily MAO-A) resulting in increased serotonin activity.
2
Synthetic forms of these alkaloids are associated with clinical signs similar to those
occurring in natural plant poisonings with Peganum harmala (African or Turkish rue),
P. mexicana (Mexican rue), Phalaris spp., T. terrestris (caltrop, catshead burr),
T. micrococcus (yellow vine), Kallstroemia hirsutissima (hairy caltrop, carpet weed),
and K. parviflora.
1, 2, 3
The characteristic syndrome, similar to that of an upper motor neuron lesion, includes
hypermotility or hypomotility, sometimes sequentially in the same patient, muscle
tremor, partly flexed paresis of the thoracic and/or the pelvic limb, hypermetria,
a wide-based stance, crossing of the limbs, extension of the neck, swaying of the
head, walking backward, sudden jumping movements, sham eating, and terminal convulsions.
The net effect, seen in all farm animal species and camels, is one of easy stimulation,
by stimulating gait incoordination and stumbling, fetlock knuckling, falling, and
recumbency. The signs appear gradually; are similar to, but less severe than, those
associated with the methylated tryptamines; and are irreversible. There is axonal
degeneration in peripheral nerves. Long-term cases of T. terrestris poisoning pivot
on their front limbs while their hindlimbs trace a circle. The pivoting is related
to the unilateral muscle atrophy of limbs of one side or the other.
Further Reading
Allen
JRF
Holmstedt
BR
The simple β-carboline alkaloids
Phytochemistry
19
1980
1573
1582
Bourke
CA
A novel nigrostriatal dopaminergic disorder in sheep affected by Tribulus terrestris
staggers
Res Vet Sci
43
1987
347
350
3444981
Moran
EA
Couch
JF
Clawson
AB
Peganum harmala, a poisonous plant in the Southwest
Vet Med
35
1940
234
235
References
1
Burrows
GE
Tyrl
RJ
Nitrariaceae Lindl. Toxic Plants of North America
2nd ed
2013
Wiley-Blackwell
Hoboken, NJ
833
2
Herraiz
T
Food Chem Toxicol
48
2010
839
20036304
3
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
89
2011
247
Indolizidine Alkaloid Toxicosis (Locoism, Peastruck)
The two indolizidine alkaloids of plant origin are castanospermine and swainsonine
and both of them affect cellular enzyme activity.
Castanospermine Poisoning
Castanospermine, an indolizidine alkaloid found in the seeds of Castanospermum australe
(Moreton Bay chestnut tree), is structurally and functionally similar to swainsonine.
1
It inhibits α-glucosidase activity so that affected cattle have been misdiagnosed
as heterozygotes for generalized glycogenosis type II (Pompe's disease). The seeds
are also associated with hemorrhagic gastroenteritis with myocardial degeneration
and nephrosis in cattle and sheep if eaten in large quantities.
1
Swainsonine Poisoning
Synopsis
Etiology Poisoning by some plants in the genera of Astragalus, Oxytropis, and Swainsona.
It is associated with induced mannosidosis.
Epidemiology Grazing toxic plants for 2–6 weeks is associated with signs, reversible
if pasture is changed.
Clinical pathology Urine content of mannose-containing oligosaccharides is elevated.
Lesions Vacuolation of neurons.
Diagnostic confirmation Swainsonine can be detected in serum, urine, or animal tissues;
the endophyte may be detected in the plant.
Treatment No treatment is available.
Control Restrict both the amount of plant and time animals allowed to graze infected
pastures.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Swainsonine is an indolizidine alkaloid found in many Astragalus spp., Oxytropis spp.,
and Swainsona spp. legumes.2, 3 Some Ipomoea spp.
4
as well as Turbina cordata
5
and Sida carpinifolia
6, 7 contain swainsonine either alone or in combination with mixtures of other alkaloids.
Ingestion of the toxic plants over a long period is associated with an induced lysosomal
storage disease in all animal species. Not all plants in a particular species contain
swainsonine. In North America there are over 354 different species of Astragalus and
22 species of Oxytropis, yet only 20 of them are known to contain swainsonine or are
associated with locosim.
2
The common plants in which the alkaloid's presence has been identified include the
following:
•
Astragalus lentiginosus, A. mollisimus, A. wootonii, A. emoryanus.
2
Other plants of this genus that are associated with a similar disease, and in which
the presence of swainsonine is assumed, are A. northoxys, A. lentiginosus var. waheapensis,
A. lusitanicus, and A. thurberi.
•
Oxytropis sericea, O. ochrocephala.
2
Other plants of this genus that are associated with a similar disease, and in which
the presence of swainsonine is assumed, are O. besseyi, O. condensata, O. lambertii,
and O. puberula.
•
Swainsona canescens, S. galegifolia, S. brachycarpa, S. greyana, S. luteola, S. procumbens,
S. swainsonioides.
3
Undifilum oxytropis (formerly Embellisa spp.), a fungal endophyte present in the seeds,
has been identified in the genera of Astragalus spp. and Oxytropis spp. as well as
in S. canescens and is currently thought to be responsible for the production of swainsonine.6,
8, 9 Swainsonine is also synthesized by the fungus R. leguminicola, but the disease
associated with this fungus is caused by its slaframine content.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Poisoning is most common in North America (as locoism associated with Astragalus spp.
and Oxytropis spp.) and in Australia as Darling pea or peastruck (Swainsona spp.),
but it occurs worldwide.2, 3, 8 Toxicity from Oxytropis spp. has been reported in
China, Ipomea spp. in goats in Brazil,
4
T. cordata in goats in Brazil,
5
S. carpinifolia in horses in Brazil,
10
and unknown swainsonine source in a horse in Belgium.
7
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
All animal species are affected, and experimental administration of the alkaloid to
monogastric, farm, and laboratory animals is associated with the typical neuronal
A. lentiginosus lesions. Horses are highly sensitive to swainsonine and develop clinical
signs when fed 0.2 mg swainsonine/kg BW for 60 days followed by cattle and sheep at
0.25 mg/kg BW for 30 to 45 days.7, 11
Grazing animals must ingest the plants for at least 2 weeks, and more often 6 weeks,
before clinical signs appear.
7
The plants are not addicting, but animals appear to have a preference for them over
other plants. It may be that the plants are more palatable to them at certain times
of the year compared with what other forage is available.
2
Swainsonine is excreted in the milk and may intoxicate nursing animals.
2
Pathogenesis
Swainsonine is a specific inhibitor of lysosomal α-mannosidase causing accumulation
of mannose in lysosomes and thus widespread neurovisceral cytoplasmic vacuolation.2,
3, 7 The vacuoles are accumulations of mannose-rich oligosaccharides, including abnormal
glycoproteins. Vacuolation reaches its greatest intensity in the CNS, and this is
probably related to the predominance of nervous signs in the disease. Vacuolation
of the chorionic epithelium may be related to the occurrence of abortion, and a transient
infertility is suspected in rams to be the result of a similar lesion in the epithelium
of the male reproductive tract. The lesion appears quickly and is reversible if the
swainsonine intake ceases. In addition, swainsonine inhibits mannosidase II resulting
in an alteration of glycoprotein synthesis, processing, and transport. The net result
is a dysfunction of membrane receptors and circulating insulin, as well as impairment
of cellular adhesion.2, 7
Clinical Findings
After several weeks of grazing affected pasture adult animals begin to lose condition
and young animals cease to grow. The appetite is diminished, and the coat becomes
dull and harsh.2, 7, 10, 11 Several weeks later nervous signs of depression; gait
incoordination; muscle tremor; and difficulty in rising, eating, and drinking become
apparent. Sheep commonly adopt a “star-gazing” posture, and horses may show nervousness,
excitation, rearing over backward when handled, tremors, colic, recumbency, and death.7,
11 Cases may become overexcited if stressed or stimulated. Recovery is likely if the
animal is removed from the source of the toxin soon after signs appear. Recovery may
be complete or there may be a residual gait incoordination if the animal is excited.
Advanced cases may show no improvement, and others become recumbent and die. Calves
at high altitudes fed A. lentiginosus or O. sericea develop a higher incidence of
congestive heart failure than calves not fed on the plants.
Pregnant ewes ingesting Astragalus spp. plants may abort or produce abnormal offspring
with contractures. The defects take the form of small, edematous, or dead fetuses
or skeletal deformity.2, 12 There are no such abnormalities recorded with Swainsona
spp.
Clinical Pathology
Vacuolation in circulating lymphocytes occurs in poisoning caused by Swainsona spp.,
and may have diagnostic significance. Serum levels of α-mannosidase are significantly
reduced and swainsonine levels increased. Swainsonine levels reflect the amount being
ingested and not the duration of exposure, and quickly return to normal when ingestion
of the plants ceases.
7
The urine content of mannose-containing oligosaccharides is greatly increased during
the period of intake of swainsonine.
Necropsy Findings
The characteristic microscopic lesion is fine vacuolation of the cytoplasm in neurons
throughout the CNS. Similar vacuolation is present in cells of other organs, especially
the kidney, and the fetus in animals poisoned by Astragalus spp. High blood and tissue
levels of swainsonine are detectable, including in frozen material.
In aborted calves, lambs, and foals there is extensive vacuolation of the chorionic
epithelial cells. The skeletal deformities include arthrogryposis and rotation of
the limbs about their long axis.
Diagnosis is made by documenting exposure to a swainsonine-containing plant, identifying
the clinical signs, and swainsonine serum or tissue concentrations. Recently a quantitative
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method was identified that can measure fungal endophytes
in the Astragalus spp. and Oxytropis spp.
13
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list
•
Conium spp. piperidine alkaloids
•
Inherited mannosidosis
•
Lupinus spp. quinolizidine alkaloids
•
Nicotiana spp. alkaloids
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no effective treatment for Swainsonine poisoning. Removal of the affected
animals from access to source plants may result in partial or complete recovery, provided
the cases are not too advanced.
Control
Pregnant animals should not be exposed to sources of swainsonine, but other stock
may be grazed on the plant without ill effect for short, specified periods, namely
4 weeks for sheep and cattle and 2 weeks for horses. The most important factor is
the amount of plant material ingested and the amount of time the animal is exposed
to the toxin. Animals should not be allowed to graze when toxic plants are palatable
and other forage is in short supply. In the western part of the United States, cattle
should not be allowed to graze on locoweed-infected pastures until late May or early
June, when other grasses have begun to grow. Pastures should not be overstocked because
a lack of adequate forage will force animals to graze on locoweed. Animals grazing
on locoweed pastures should be monitored closely and moved to a different pasture
if they begin to show signs of poisoning. Herbicides may be used to control Astragalus
spp. and Oxytropis spp., but the endophyte is contained in the seeds and they are
drought resistant and able overwinter, allowing only for control and not elimination.
Attempts to reduce consumption of the toxic plants by creating conditioned reflex
aversion, to reduce absorption of ingested swainsonine or by supplementing the diet
with bentonite, have not been rewarding.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Indolizidine alkaloid poisoning
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1870
Stegelmeier
BL
James
LF
Panter
KE
The pathogenesis and toxicokinetics of locoweed (Astragalus and Oxytropis spp.) poisoning
in livestock
J Natural Toxins
8
1999
35
45
References
1
Stegelmeier
BL
Toxicol Pathol
36
2008
651
18497426
2
Cook
D
Rangelands
31
2009
16
3
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
88
2011
247
4
Barbosa
RC
Pesq Vet Res
27
2007
409
5
Dantas
AFM
Toxicon
49
2007
111
17030054
6
Cook
D
J Agric Food Chem
59
2011
1281
21214242
7
Nollet
H
Equine Vet Ed
20
2008
62
8
Grum
DS
J Nat Prod
76
2013
1984
24053110
9
Ralphs
MH
J Chem Ecol
34
2008
32
18060459
10
Lima
EF
Riet-Correa
B
Riet-Correa
F
Poisonous plants affecting the nervous system of horses in Brazil
Riet-Correa
F
Pfister
J
Schild
AL
Wierenga
TL
Poisoning by Plants, Mycotoxins, and Related Toxins
2011
CAB International
Oxfordshire, UK
290
11
Stegelmeier
BL
Lee
ST
James
LF
The comparative pathology of locoweed poisoning in livestock, wildlife, and rodents
Pater
KE
Ralphs
MH
Pfister
JA
Poisonous Plants: Global Research and Solutions
2007
CAB International
Oxfordshire, UK
59
12
Panter
KE
Welch
KD
Lee
ST
Plants teratogenic to livestock in the United States
Riet-Correa
F
Pfister
J
Schild
AL
Wierenga
TL
Poisoning by Plants, Mycotoxins, and Other Toxins
2011
CAB International
Oxfordshire, UK
236
13
Cook
D
J Agric Food Chem
57
2009
6050
19545150
Neurogenic Quinolizidine Alkaloids (Lupinus Spp.)
Etiology
Alkaloids causing the nervous syndrome include sparteine, lupinine, lupanine, hydroxylupanine,
spathulatine, and thermopsine. These vary widely in their toxicity and their concentration
in plant species, and within the same species between years, depending largely on
the climate. Species of lupin known to contain them are Lupinus angustifolius and
L. cosentinii (synonym L. digitatus). Species that are associated with the characteristic
nervous syndrome and in which the presence of the alkaloids in the plant is assumed
include the following:
L. argenteus
L. caudatus
L. cyaneus
L. greenei
L. laxiflorus
L. leucophyllus
L. leucopsis
L. onustus
L. pusillus
Epidemiology
The alkaloids are present in all parts of the plant but are in their greatest concentration
in the seeds and pods; most outbreaks of poisoning occur when livestock graze mature,
standing lupins, carrying many pods. Sheep eat the plant more readily and are more
commonly affected than cattle or horses. The mortality rate in sheep is high. In cattle,
it is usually low but may be as high as 50%.
Other plants in which the alkaloids occur and which are associated with the nervous
disease include the following:
Cytisus (synonym Laburnum, Sarothamnus spp.)
Baptisia spp.
Sophora spp.
Spartium junceum (Spanish broom)
Thermopsis spp.
Clinical Findings
In the nervous disease, affected animals may develop dyspnea and depression, followed
by coma and death without a struggle. More acute cases have convulsive episodes in
which they are dyspneic and staggery, and show frothing at the mouth, clonic convulsions,
and grinding of the teeth. A more prolonged disease is reported in cattle poisoned
experimentally with Thermopsis montana. There is anorexia, depression, edematous swelling
of the eyelids, tremor, a stilted gait, arching of the back and a tucked-up abdomen,
rough hair coat, and prolonged recumbency.
Pathology
Severe myopathy results in high aspartate aminotransferase (AST), creatine kinase
(CK) and lactic acid dehydrogenase (LDH) activities. The possibility of a myopathy
being associated with lupins has been raised because the prevalence of enzootic muscular
dystrophy appears to be much higher on lupin than on other pasture. Lupins are low
in selenium and vitamin E content, and classical white muscle disease may also occur.
Histologic and biochemical examination of affected calves discount myopathy as the
primary lesion. In poisoning by Cytisus spp., both C. laburnum (laburnum) and C. scoparius
(broom) are associated with fatalities.
Further Reading
Panter
KE
Maryland
HF
Gardner
DR
Beef cattle losses after grazing Lupinus argenteus (silvery lupine)
Vet Hum Toxicol
43
2001
279
282
11577932
Nitrocompound Plant Toxicosis (Milk Vetch)
Synopsis
Etiology Several different toxins; miserotoxin in certain Astragalus spp. is the most
important.
Epidemiology Limited to geographic distribution of the toxic plants; mostly North
America but other countries affected depending on specific plant.
Clinical pathology Nonspecific; methemoglobin values >20%.
Lesions Degenerative lesions in peripheral nerves and spinal cord.
Diagnosis confirmation Associated with isolation of nitrotoxins in tissues and fluids.
Treatment None.
Control Management of pasture to avoid grazing pasture when relevant plants are abundant.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Nitrocompounds (nitrotoxins) poisonous to animals occur in a number of plants, especially
in some species of Astragalus. They are all glycosides of 3-nitropropionic acid (NPA)
or of 3-nitro-ropanol (NPOH). Miserotoxin is the most common and well known toxin;
other toxins include cibarian, corollin, coronarian, coronillin, and karakin.
1
The best known occurrences of the nitrocompounds include the following:
•
A. canadensis (Canadian milk vetch), A. emoryanus (Emory's milk vetch), A. miser (forest
or woody milk vetch), A. pterocarpus (winged milk vetch), A. tetrapterus (four-wing
milk vetch), and others; contain miserotoxin.
1
•
Corynocarpus laevigatus (karaka tree); contains karakin.
2
•
Oxytropis spp., a plant genus very similar botanically to Astragalus spp., is associated
with the same diseases as the latter but its toxic agent has not been identified.
•
Securigera varia (Coronilla varia), contains cibarian and others.
1
•
Indigofera linnaei (Birdsville indigo), contains karakin and other nitrocompounds.
3
Epidemiology
Occurrence
The occurrence of these plant poisonings is determined by the presence and ingestion
of the specific plants. Astragalus and Oxytropis spp. are, for the most part, limited
in distribution to North America, but poisoning of sheep by A. lusitanicus is recorded
in Morocco, and of all species by O. puberula in Kazakhstan. Corynocarpus spp. occur
in New Zealand and Indigofera spp. are widespread, occurring in North America, Australia,
Africa, and Southeast Asia.
Astragalus and Oxytropis spp. are herbaceous legumes, most of them are perennial,
and they dominate the desert range over large areas of the United States. They provide
excellent forage. Only some species contain miserotoxin, but this makes them very
destructive and very heavy losses of sheep and cattle may occur.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Cattle are the more susceptible. Lactating animals are more susceptible than dry animals.
There are reports of the disease in horses in North America and a similar disease
in horses in China after grazing O. kansuensis
Human Risk Factors
Miserotoxin and its metabolic end products may be excreted in the milk of cows eating
these plants.
Pathogenesis
In ruminants the glycosides are hydrolyzed in the rumen to NPOH and NPA. Both are
absorbed from the rumen and once in the liver, NPOH is further biodegraded to NPA.
Nitrous dioxide (NO2) formed during biodegradation may account for methemoglobinemia.
1
Some nitrite may also be formed resulting in methemoglobinemia in horses and ruminants.
The onset of clinical signs is associated with the accumulation of NPA and a resulting
neurologic syndrome, characterized principally by nervous signs and the development
of degenerative lesions in the CNS. In experimental animals the dose rate and length
of exposure to the toxin determine whether the acute or chronic disease occurs. Typically,
animals must have consumed nitrotoxin plants for a week or more before showing signs.
Morbidity is 10% to 15%; case–fatality rate may be up to 30%.
1
Clinical Findings
Acute Poisoning
Death may occur as soon as 3 hours after the commencement of signs, but the course
is usually about 24 hours. Common signs include ataxia or a staggering walk, recumbency,
and death from respiratory or cardiac arrest.
Chronic Poisoning
The syndrome in cattle is often referred to as “cracker heels,” because of the noise
made when rear hooves strike each other.
1
Affected animals lose weight, and develop a poor hair coat, nasal discharge, and poor
exercise tolerance. Respiratory distress, with loud stertor (roaring), is more marked
in sheep than in cattle and knuckling of the fetlocks and incoordination, followed
in some by paraplegia, is more common in cattle. Temporary blindness and drooling
of saliva may also be evident. The mortality rate is very high, with the course lasting
over several months. Animals that recover have a long convalescence. Death may occur
suddenly if affected animals are stressed.
I. linnaei poisoning in horses (synonym Birdsville horse disease) is associated with
weight loss, gait incoordination, easy falling, toe dragging, dyspnea, and convulsions.
3
The plant is equally poisonous when dry or green, although most cases occur in the
spring when the plant is succulent. Horses need to graze the plant for about 10 days
before signs appear. Characteristic signs include segregation and somnolence, with
the animal often standing out in the open in the hot sun, apparently asleep when unaffected
horses have sought the shade. There is marked incoordination, with the front legs
being lifted and extended in an exaggerated manner. The hocks are not flexed, causing
the fronts of the hind hooves to be dragged on the ground. The head is held in an
unnaturally high position and the tail is held out stiffly. There is difficulty in
changing direction, and incoordination increases as the horse moves. The horse commences
to sway and at the canter there is complete disorientation of the hindlegs so that
the animal moves its limbs frantically but stays in the one spot with the legs becoming
gradually abducted until it sits down and rolls over. Terminally there is recumbency
with intermittent tetanic convulsions, which may last for up to 15 minutes and during
which death usually occurs.
A chronic syndrome may develop in some horses subsequent to an acute attack. Affected
animals can move about, but there is incoordination and dragging of the hindfeet with
wearing of the toe, and inspiratory dyspnea (roaring) may also occur. No lesions have
been described in the nervous system of affected animals. I. linnaei contains the
toxic amino acid, indospicine, an analog of arginine, and NPA.
3
Poisoned horses may not always develop the liver damage typical of intoxication by
indospicine
3
; however, supplementation of the diet with arginine-rich protein feeds prevents development
of the disease.
4
Peanut meal (0.5–1 kg/day) and gelatin provide readily available and cheap sources
of arginine.
Clinical Pathology
Methemoglobinemia concentrations greater than 20% may occur in cattle and horses.
Laboratory procedures for the determination of blood levels of miserotoxin, some other
nitrotoxins, and NPOH and NPA are available.
Necropsy Findings
Brown discoloration of the blood, and extensive petechiation in tissues, are common
findings in the acute form of the disease. In the chronic disease, there are degenerative
changes in the spinal cord and peripheral nerves, especially the sciatic nerve, as
well as areas of necrosis in the thalamus and Purkinje cells in some cerebellar folia,
white matter spongiosis in the globus pallidus, and distension of the lateral ventricles.
1
Nonspecific gross lesions include pulmonary emphysema and pneumonia, abomasal ulceration,
and pericardial/pleural fluid.
Diagnosis confirmation depends on the identification of the poisonous plants in the
environment and the toxins in the plants and animal tissues
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list (chronic form)
•
Chronic cyanide poisoning
•
Paspalum staggers
•
Phalaris staggers
•
Ryegrass staggers
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Treatment includes removing animals from the suspected pastures and providing an alternate
food source. The use of injectable thiamine has not shown to be of any value. There
is no specific treatment for the chronic form of the disease, and some animals may
ultimately recover.
Control
Control of the growth of the plants by stimulating growth of competitive grasses,
or the widespread use of selective herbicides, is recommended but unlikely to be a
practicable procedure in many of the situations in which the plants occur. Experimentally,
the use of some herbicides significantly reduces the content of miserotoxin in A.
miser var. oblongifolia in pasture. Variations between species of Astragalus spp.
in their capacity to produce miserotoxin and store selenocompounds (some of them,
e.g., A. toanus, do both) provides opportunities to manipulate the grazing of particular
fields to best advantage.
Further Reading
Anderson
RC
Majak
W
Rasmussen
MA
Toxicity and metabolism of the conjugates of 3-nitropropanol and 3-nitropropionic
acid in forages poisonous to livestock
J Agric Food Chem
53
2005
2344
2350
15769179
Benn
M
McEwan
D
Pass
MA
Three nitropropanoyl esters of glucose from Indigofera linnaei
Phytochemistry
7
1992
2393
2395
Majak
W
Benn
M
Additional esters of 3-nitropropanoic acid and glucose from fruit of the New Zealand
karaka tree, Corynocarpus laevigatus
Phytochemistry
35
1994
901
903
Majak
W
Stroesser
L
Lysyk
T
Toxicity and development of tolerance in cattle to timber milkvetch
J Range Manage
56
2003
266
272
References
1
Burrows
GE
Tyrl
RJ
Nitrotoxicosis (cracker heels)
Toxic Plants of North America
2nd ed
2013
Wiley-Blackwell
Hoboken, NJ
515
2
Noori
MA
Toxicol Environ Chem
89
2007
479
3
Ossedryver
SM
Aust Vet J
91
2013
143
23521099
4
Lima
EF
Toxicon
60
2012
324
22560887
Piperidine Alkaloid Plant Toxicosis
Etiology
The important, identified piperidine alkaloids include coniine, cynapine, nicotine,
and lobeline. These alkaloids are primarily neurotoxins; some alkaloids present in
Conium maculatum and Nicotiana spp. are also teratogens and are dealt with separately
in Chapter 18.
Conium
C. maculatum (poison hemlock) contains five major acetate-based piperidine alkaloids—coniine,
N-methylconiine, conhydrine, pseudoconhydrine, and γ-coniceine—and a number of other,
lesser, alkaloids. γ-Coniceine is likely a precursor of the others and is much more
toxic.
1
The concentration of each of the alkaloids in different parts of the plant, in different
climates, and at different times of the year is quite variable. For example, the concentration
of the γ-coniceine is high in the fruits when they are formed, but there is no significant
content in the roots. In the dormant stage, the toxicity of the roots is very high.
Epidemiology
Poison hemlock occurs in most parts of the world. All animal species are affected,
with cattle, sheep, goats, horses, and pigs showing the nervous form of the disease.
Poisoned cattle, pigs, and sheep also produce deformed offspring, with ewes being
much less susceptible than cows and sows. Grazing animals are poisoned by eating the
standing plant, the seeds, or roots at the appropriate time of their development.
The plant may also be fed in hay or green feed or the seeds may contaminate harvested
grain. Milking cows secrete the alkaloids in their milk.
Pathogenesis
The alkaloids are associated with two modes of poisoning, paralysis of skeletal muscle
by blocking transmission at neuromuscular junctions and by acting as teratogens. All
of the major alkaloids are associated with the acute disease. Only coniine and γ-coniceine
are known to be teratogenic.
Clinical Findings
Clinical signs in the acute, neurologic form of poisoning include tremor, staggering
gait, knuckling of fetlocks, belching, vomiting, frequent urination and defecation,
drooling of saliva, tachycardia, and pupillary dilation.2, 3 In cows and sows, prolapse
of the nictitating membrane occurs, and in affected cows, a characteristic mousy odor
of the milk and urine is described. The course in cattle, goats, and horses is only
a few hours and terminates in recumbency and death by respiratory paralysis, without
convulsions. Sheep are least affected and recovery is common.
Cynapine
Cynapine, a piperidine alkaloid found in Aethusa cynapium (fool's parsley, lesser
hemlock) is associated with dyspnea and gait incoordination in cattle, goats, and
pigs.
Nicotiana
The most common poisonous members of the tobacco family of plants include the following:
Nicotiana tabacum (commercial tobacco)
N. attenuata (wild tobacco)
N. exigua
N. glauca (tree tobacco)
N. megalosiphon
N. trigonophylla (wild tobacco)
N. velutina
The principal toxins include nicotine, anabasine, and anagyrine.
4
Other alkaloids occurring in Nicotiana spp., but which are not recorded as having
poisoned animals, are nornicotine and anatabine. Duboisia hopwoodii (pituri) is another
plant with these alkaloids. Several alkaloids may be present in the one plant, but
most plant species have a particular alkaloid that predominates. The concentration
of the alkaloid varies between parts of the plant and between different stages of
growth.
Acute poisoning of livestock ingesting Nicotiana spp. or D. hopwoodii is associated
with muscle tremor, weakness, incoordination, pupil dilation, and recumbency with
limb paddling progressing to paralysis. Diarrhea may be present. The alkaloid anabasine
is teratogenic.
Tobacco-specific nitrosamines, formed from Nicotiana spp. alkaloids, are known to
be carcinogenic to laboratory animals, but there is no record of this association
in agricultural animals.
Lobeline
The piperidine alkaloid lobeline is found in the plant Lobelia berlandieri. Ingestion
of the plant is associated with mouth erosions, salivation, and diarrhea. Necropsy
lesions are limited to the lesions of enteritis.
Further Reading
Galey
FD
Holstege
DM
Fisher
EG
Toxicosis in dairy cattle exposed to poison hemlock (Conium maculatum) in hay: isolation
of Conium alkaloids in plants, hay, and urine
J Vet Diagn Invest
4
1992
60
64
1554771
Panter
KE
Keeler
RF
Baker
DC
Toxicoses in livestock from the hemlocks (Conium and Cicuta spp
J Anim Sci
66
1988
2407
2413
3049497
References
1
Odriozola
E
Poisoning by plants, mycotoxins, and algae in Argentina livestock
Riet-Correa
F
Pfister
J
Schild
AL
Wierenga
TL
Poisoning by Plants, Mycotoxins, and Other Toxins
2011
CAB International
Oxford, UK
35
2
Binev
R
Trakia J Sci
5
2007
40
3
Nicholson
SS
Vet Clin North Am Food Animal Pract
27
2011
447
4
Schep
LJ
Clin Toxicol (Phila)
47
2009
771
19778187
Corynetoxins (Tunicaminyluracils) (Annual Ryegrass Staggers, Flood Plain Staggers,
Stewart Range Syndrome)
Synopsis
Etiology Corynetoxins (tunicaminyluracils) present in infected grass (Lolium rigidum,
Lachnagrostis filiformis, Polypogon monspeliensis) eaten by all species. A similar
tunicaminyluracil has been isolated from water-damaged wheat eaten by pigs.
Epidemiology Outbreaks in Australia (summer to early fall) and South Africa when grazing
animals ingest infected seedhead galls. Occurs anytime of the year in animals fed
infected hay.
Clinical pathology Increased activity of hepatic enzymes in serum; prolonged prothrombin
and activated partial thromboplastin time.
Lesions Perivascular edema in meninges and brain; hemorrhages in multiple tissues.
Diagnosis confirmation Tunicaminyluracil in pasture seed heads.
Treatment Magnesium sulfate in horses or small herds. Removal of animals from infected
fields or hay; reduce stress.
Control Keep animals off infected pastures; decrease prevalence of infection by various
methods (see text); test hay before purchasing.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Nematode larvae infest and are associated with galls in the seedheads of Lolium rigidum
(Wimmera or annual ryegrass), Polypogon monspieliensis (annual beard grass), and Lachnagrostis
filiformis (formerly Agrostis avenacea and commonly referred to as blown or blowaway
grass).1, 2 Nematodes in the genus Anguina (A. agrostis, A. funesta, A. paludicola)
transport the corynetoxin producing bacteria Rathayibacter toxicus into the cuticle
of grass seeds.1, 3, 4 Bacteriophages were originally felt to play an integral part,
but that may no longer be the case.
2
Corynetoxins (tunicaminyluracils) are glycolipid tunicaminyluracil antibiotics produced
in the seedhead gall and sheep, cattle, and horses grazing the pasture are poisoned
when they are ingested.1, 3, 5 Animals eating corynetoxin-infected hay are poisoned.1,
2
Other outbreaks have been recorded. In the 1960s, sheep and cattle in the northwestern
United States developed a similar neurologic condition when fed fescue infected with
A. agrostis and Rathayibacter-like organisms.
1
Tunicaminyluracil has been isolated from water-damaged wheat, which when fed to pigs
is associated with clinical signs and deaths similar to those associated with the
tunicaminyluracil on grasses.
1
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Poisoning that occurs in livestock pastured on L. rigidum (termed annual ryegrass
toxicity or ARGT) or in those grazing L. filiformis (flood plain staggers) has become
a very important cause of death losses on farms in western and southern Australia,
southern New South Wales, and also in South Africa.1, 3, 5 Toxicity associated with
ingestion of P. monspieliensis (termed Stewart range syndrome) is found in flood-prone
portions in southeastern South Australia.
1
Typically, in Australia, infected seed heads are toxic beginning with the dry summer
period and continuing until the onset of fall rains.1, 2 Clinical signs do not occur
until the stock has been on pasture for several days or up to 12 weeks.
1
Forced exercise and high ambient temperatures precipitate or exacerbate clinical signs.1,
5
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
The oral dose of tunicamycins in sheep associated with the onset of clinical signs
following investigational intraduodenal administration is 150 µg/kg.
6
The subcutaneous lethal dose is much smaller, 30 to 40 µg/kg as a single dose or a
set of small sequential doses. The toxins are cumulative if the interval between doses
are few days.
Plant Risk Factors
Pasture improvement based on annually alternating crop-pasture rotations seem to predispose
to the disease, with the worst outbreaks occurring after the end of a cropping year.
This can be avoided by burning the pasture in the autumn. The organism is introduced
onto farms by the introduction of infested grass seed or contaminated agricultural
implements.
2
L. rigidum has become a weed in southern Australia and herbicide-resistant strains
have evolved, complicating control measures. Hay made from infested grass remains
poisonous for 5 to 6 years. Poisoning associated with L. filiformis has occurred in
cattle on extensive pasture recently subjected to severe flooding, hence the name
flood plain staggers.
1
Pathogenesis
Corynetoxins are similar structurally to tunicamycin antibiotics originally isolated
from an actionmycete (Streptomyces lysosuperificus).
1
Collectively the group, including corynetoxins, is referred to as tunicaminyluracil
antibiotics. They are potent inhibitors of lipid linked N-glycosylation of glycoproteins
1
and capable of causing cerebral vascular lesions in experimental animals. Interference
with cardiovascular function and vascular integrity leads to interference with oxygenation
of tissues, particularly the brain.
Clinical Findings
Signs appear when the cattle or sheep are disturbed or stressed, especially by driving.
The animals fall in a convulsion with paddling of limbs, nystagmus, opisthotonus,
jaw champing and salivation, head nodding, tetanic extension of limbs and, in sheep,
posterior extension of the hindlimbs.1, 2, 3 Death may occur during a convulsion or,
if left alone, the animal may recover to the point of being able to stand, but there
may be gait incoordination caused by hypermetria, stiff gait, a broad-based stance,
head swaying, rocking backward and forward, and loss of balance. Intermittent convulsive
episodes recur and the animals soon go down again. Death occurs in up to 24 hours.
Further cases occur for up to 10 days after affected animals are removed from the
pasture.
2
Morbidity and mortality rates may reach as high as 100% in sheep flocks. In surviving
ewes, abortion may occur in up to 10% of pregnant sheep.
1
Poisoning occurs less frequently in horses and stress is often a precipitating factor.
5
Colic with tachycardia, borborygmi, and congested mucous membranes, is often the first
sign observed followed by hypermetria, ataxia, muscle tremors, recumbency, convulsions
with limb paddling, and death.
5
Clinical Pathology
Blood levels of liver enzymes, bilirubin, and bile acids are elevated. Prothrombin
time and activated partial thromboplastin time are prolonged.
1
Necropsy Findings
Necropsy findings are inconsistent and nonspecific. The liver may be enlarged and
pale or icteric. There may be hemorrhages in a range of tissues. Histologically, there
may be perivascular edema in the brain, particularly in cerebellar meninges. Other
lesions may include significant liver damage.
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list:
•
Lead poisoning
•
Perennial ryegrass staggers
•
Phalaris staggers
•
Poisoning by any one of a large number of plants in which the toxic agent has not
been identified.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Affected flocks or herds should be removed from a toxic pasture as slowly and as quietly
as possible to good-quality feed with shade and water in a place free of disturbance.1,
5 Stress should be kept to a minimum.
No specific antidote or antitoxin is available.1, 5 An antidote was developed by CSIRO
in Australia for use early in outbreaks of poisoning, but field trials were disappointing.
7
Pharmacologic measures are impractical in herd situations, although intravenous administration
of magnesium sulfate could be used for individual animals. Horses have been treated
successfully with an intravenous injection of magnesium sulfate (approximately 100 mg/kg
BW; range of 60–200 mg/kg) and supportive measures including flunixin meglumine, dimethyl
sulfoxide, and intravenous fluids.
5
Doses of 25 to 150 mg/kg intravenously have been used for hypomagnesemia in horses
and may be useful in managing equine cases.
8
It is recommended that magnesium not be administered concurrently with calcium-containing
intravenous fluids. Used in combination, calcium is used preferentially at the neuromuscular
junction, limiting the effectiveness of magnesium in preventing muscle contractions.
5
Control
Pasture management in endemic areas should aim to reduce exposure of livestock to
mature pastures with seedheads. This may be achieved by a variety of measures such
as heavy stocking during winter and spring, harvesting pasture for silage or hay before
seeding followed by heavy grazing to remove ryegrass seedlings, burning crop and pasture
residues, and herbicide application.
2
Methods exist for testing hay and are used for hay exported from Australia.2, 9 Recent
improvements in testing have shortened the turnaround time considerably.
10
Hay purchased for use within Australia should be tested and accompanied by a declaration
stating that testing occurred and the hay is safe for use.
2
Two cultivars of L. rigidum (Guard and Safeguard) resistant to A. funesta have been
developed that significantly reduce the number of galls per kilogram of hay and the
risk of developing ARGT.
2
Pasture application of Dilophospora alopecuri, a fungal pathogen of A funesta, has
been studied, but the results are mixed and may be uneconomical.
11
Immunization against the toxin is promising but difficult as glycolipids are poor
immunogens.
1
Further Reading
Bourke
CA
Carrigan
MJ
Love
SCJ
Flood plain staggers, a tunicaminyluracil toxicosis of cattle in north New South Wales
Aust Vet J
69
1992
228
229
1449461
Cockrum
PA
Culvenor
CCJ
Edgar
JA
Toxic tunicaminyluracil antibiotics identified in water-damaged wheat responsible
for the death of pigs
Aust J Agric Res
39
1988
245
253
Riley
IT
Gregory
AR
Allen
JG
Poisoning of livestock in Oregon in the 1940s to 1960s attributed to corynetoxins
produced by Rathayibacter in nematode galls in Chewings fescue
Vet Hum Toxicol
45
2003
160
162
12776797
References
1
Finney
JW
Aust Vet J
84
2006
271
16911226
2
Allen
JJ
Microbiology
8
2012
18
3
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
89
2011
247
4
Bertozzi
T
Zootaxa
2060
2009
33
5
Grewar
JD
J S Afr Vet Assoc
80
2009
220
20458861
6
Haply
SL
Dose response of tunicamycins in sheep following intra-duodenal administration
Panter
KE
Wierenga
TL
Pfister
JA
Poisonous Plants: Global Research and Solutions
2007
CABI
Oxford, UK
242
7
Allen
JG
8th International Symposium on Poisonous Plants (ISOPP8), Joâo Pessoa, Paraiba, Brazil,
May 2009
2011
CABI
Oxford UK
8
Plumb
DC
Magnesium
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
618
9
Masters
AM
Crop Pasture Sci
57
2006
731
10
Masters
AM
Crop Pasture Sci
62
2011
523
11
Barbetti
MJ
Plant Dis
90
2006
229
30786418
Miscellaneous Plant Toxins Affecting the Nervous System (Unidentified Toxins)
Plants with ingestions resulting in signs of gait incoordination, with or without
recumbency, convulsions, or lesions of nervous system include the following:
Ageratina altissima
Araujia hortorum (cruel vine)
Berula erecta
Brachychiton populneus (kurrajong tree)
Brachyglottis repanda (rangiora)
Catharanthus spp.
Centella uniflora
Combretum platypetalum
Craspedia chrysantha
Doronicum hungaricum (wild sunflower)
Echinopogon spp. (roughbearded grass)
1
Ervum spp.
Euphorbia mauritanica
Gomphrena celosioides (soft khaki weed)
Hoya spp. (wax flower)
1
Idiospermum australiense
Melanthrium hybridum
M. virginicum (bunchflower)
Melica decumbens (dronkgras)
Melochia pyramidata
Modiola caroliniana (creeping mallow)
Pennisetum clandestinum (kikuyu grass)2, 3
Rhodomyrtus macrocarpa (finger cherry; also is associated with blindness).
E. mauritanica is associated with hypersensitivity, stiffness, tremor, incoordination,
recumbency, and convulsions in sheep.
1
Echinopogon ovatus poisoning in calves and lambs is characterized by stress-induced
episodes of stiff-legged incoordination and easy falling and bellowing followed by
spontaneous recovery.
G. celosioides is associated with outbreaks of incoordination in horses in northern
Australia. Spontaneous recovery follows removal from the pasture.
P. clandestinum poisoning was originally attributed to rumen acidosis, but the current
suggestion is that it is a poisoning associated with the fungi Fusarium torulosum
growing on the grass, which is an unlikely association in some outbreaks.2, 3 Epidemiologically,
the disease occurs concurrently with circumstances conducive to fungal growth, including
warmth, moisture, and litter under the grass, often caused by the depredations of
heavy infestations of sod webworms (grass caterpillars), African black beetles, leaf
hoppers, and armyworm caterpillars (Pseudoletia separata, Pseudocalymma elegans, Spodoptera
exempta).
2
Cattle, sheep, and to a lesser extent, goats, show signs of poisoning in late summer
and autumn.
2
Clinical signs include depression, hypersalivation, abdominal pain, ruminal tympany
and stasis, paralysis of the tongue and pharynx, sham drinking, muscle tremors, incoordination,
recumbency, diarrhea, dehydration, and death.
2
In the forestomachs there is distension, mucosal reddening, and extensive microscopically
visible necrosis in the rumen and abomasum.
Plant ingestions associated with paralysis in ewes and horses, with lesions of a lysosomal
storage disease and prominent neuronal pigmentation in the brain and spinal cord include
the following:
Romulea spp. (onion weed)
1
Solidago chilensis
Stachys arvensis (stagger weed)
Stephania spp.
Trachyandra spp.
T. laxa
T. divaricata.
Romulea bulbocodium is associated with a high incidence of phytobezoars, a level of
fertility in ewes as low as 20%, and a severe gait incoordination when stimulated
to move.
1
Affected sheep walk with their heads held high, fall easily, struggle momentarily,
then relax and get up and walk normally. If they are left on the same pasture for
3 or 4 weeks, they become permanently recumbent.
Plant ingestions resulting in signs of mania (e.g., wild running, hyperexcitability,
incoordination, circling, aimless wandering, blindness) include the following:
Burttia prunoides
Pisum sativum
Further Reading
Peet
RL
Dickson
J
Kikuyu poisoning in sheep
Aust Vet J
67
1990
229
2222368
References
1
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
89
2011
247
2
Bourke
CA
Aust Vet J
85
2007
261
17615037
3
Ryley
MJ
Australas Plant Dis Notes
2
2007
133
Fungal Toxins Affecting the Nervous System
Diplodia maydis (synonym D. zeae, Stenocarpella maydis) is associated with a serious
disease of maize crops called corn cob rot. Infected cobs fed to cattle, sheep, goats,
and horses are associated with diplodiosis, a neuromycotoxicosis, reported in Australia,
Argentina, Brazil, and most often in South Africa.
1
The toxin has been identified as diplonine; a second toxin, diplodiatoxin, has been
identified but may not be related to poisoning.
1
The fungus develops its toxin only after a prolonged (more than 6 weeks) period of
growth. This may explain frequent reports that the fungus is not poisonous. The same
applies to cultured fungus used to produce the disease experimentally; it must be
a culture that is at least 8 weeks old.
Clinical signs in adults include lacrimation, salivation, tremor, ataxia, paresis,
and paralysis, but signs disappear when the corn is removed from the diet. If the
subjects are females in the second and third trimesters of pregnancy, there may be
a very high mortality rate (up to 87%) in stillborn or newborn lambs or calves; many
of the dead neonates have widespread degeneration of the CNS. Affected animals recover
if feeding of the infected grain is stopped.
At postmortem, a status spongiosus lesion may occur in the brain of affected animals,
but in most cases there are no necropsy lesions. Fetuses are much more susceptible,
and spongiform lesions in the brain are present in most. Their BWs are less than normal,
and the gestation period is also reduced.
Further Reading
Odriozola
E
Odeon
A
Canton
G
Diplodia maydis: a cause of death of cattle in Argentina
New Zeal Vet J
53
2005
160
161
Reference
1
Snyman
LD
J Agric Food Chem
59
2011
9039
21780820
Tremorgenic Mycotoxins
Tremorgenic mycotoxins are produced by fungi belonging to the Penicillium, Aspergillus,
Claviceps, and Neotyphodium genera.
1
Over 20 different mycotoxins, all containing a tryptophan indole moiety, affect many
different mammals including cattle, sheep, goats, and horses. The fungi grow on a
wide variety of foodstuffs including spoiled food, garbage, stored grains, forages
(grasses and legumes), malt (beverage) residues, and compost piles.2, 3 Despite the
different fungi and mycotoxins, the common neurologic signs of prolonged muscle tremors,
ataxia, and stress-exacerbated weakness are similar in most species.
2
Hyperexcitability or depression, tetanic seizures, recumbency, paralysis, and rarely
death may occur.2, 4
Tremorgenic mycotoxins are rapidly absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract, and signs
occur anywhere from a few hours to several days, depending on the species and particular
mycotoxin. Age is important with younger animals more susceptible than older.
5
They are lipid soluble and easily move across the blood-brain barrier and into the
CNS. Excretion is primarily biliary and fecal; little hepatic metabolism occurs.
6
The mechanism of action is unknown, but generally tremorgenic mycotoxins interfere
with inhibitory neurotransmitters (γ-amino butyric acid [GABA] and glycine) and stimulate
excitatory neurotransmitters. Treatment is supportive and symptomatic.
Aspergillus-Associated Mycotoxins
Aspergillus clavatus, other Aspergillus spp., and Penicillium spp. produce several
tremorgenic mycotoxins associated with outbreaks in cattle and sheep. Verruculogen
is the most widely recognized mycotoxin; less recognized mycotoxins produced by these
fungi include tryptoquivaline, territrems A and B, and aflatrem. A. clavatus–associated
mycotoxins have been incriminated in several neurologic outbreaks in sheep and cattle.2,
7, 8 Common clinical signs included tremors, posterior paresis, knuckling at the fetlocks,
recumbency, and death. The specific mycotoxin may be patulin, although that was not
present in all cases.
2
Bermudagrass Staggers
Cattle in California, Oklahoma, and Texas have developed tremors and neurologic signs
after grazing on mature bermudagrass (Cynodon dactylon) infected with C. cynodontis.
Analysis of infected seedheads showed high concentrations of the tremorgens paspalitrems
and paspaline-like indole-diterpenes and low concentrations of ergine and ergonovine.
1
Claviceps-Associated Mycotoxins (Paspalum or Dallis Grass Staggers)
Cattle, sheep, and horses may develop “grass staggers” after several days after grazing
on mature Bahia grass (Paspalum notatum) or Dallis grass (P. dilatatum) infected with
C. paspali.
2, 4, 8, 9 The tremorgenic mycotoxins paspaline and paspalitrems A, B, and C are present
in the sclerotia (ergots); paspalitrem B is most commonly associated with the onset
of signs in cattle and sheep. Affected animals develop exercise-induced nervousness,
odd facial expressions, tremors, ataxia, seizures, and death.
Neotyphodium-Associated Mycotoxins (Perennial Ryegrass Staggers)
Horses, deer, cattle, alpacas, and in particular, sheep grazing on perennial ryegrass
(L. perenne) in the northwestern United States, Australia, New Zealand, and some parts
of Europe have developed neurologic signs similar to other stagger-producing grasses.2,
5, 10 Lolitrems A, B, and D and other lolitrem precursors produced by the endophyte
Neotyphodium lolii are the tremorgenic mycotoxins most involved.9, 10 Lolitrem B (maximum
tolerable dose 2 mg/kg BW) is the predominant mycotoxin associated with the onset
of signs in sheep and cattle.
2
Signs most often occur in the late summer/early fall when animals are on overgrazed
pastures. Tremors begin in the head, progress to the neck and shoulder, and finally
include the extremities. Affected animals are uncoordinated and become recumbent or
develop seizures when stressed. If removed from infected grasses and not stressed,
affected animals recover in 7 days or so.
Penicillium-Associated Mycotoxins
Penitrem A and roquefortines, produced by Penicillium spp., are the most common mycotoxins
associated with tremors. In general, toxicosis with these mycotoxins are more common
in small animals ingesting spoiled food (meats, cheese, nuts, eggs, etc.) and garbage,
but cases have occurred in horses, cattle, and sheep. Janthitrem A, B, and C produced
by P. janthinellum have been associated with outbreaks of staggers in sheep grazing
on ryegrass.
Further Reading
Cole
RJ
Paspalum staggers: isolation and identification of tremorgenic metabolites from sclerotia
of Claviceps paspali
J Agric Food Chem
25
1977
1197
1201
893851
Scudamor
K
Occurrence and significance of mycotoxins in forage crops and silage: a review
J Sci Food Agric
77
1998
1
17
References
1
Uhlig
S
J Agric Food Chem
57
2009
1112
2
Mostrom
MM
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
27
2011
344
3
Riet-Correa
F
J Vet Diagn Invest
25
2013
692
24091682
4
Moyano
MR
Vet Med (Praha)
55
2010
336
5
Sampaio
N
Anim Prod Sci
48
2008
1099
6
Hooser
SB
Talcott
PA
Mycotoxins
Peterson
ME
Talcott
PA
Small Animal Toxicology
3rd ed
2013
Elsevier
London, UK
925
7
Fink-Gremmels
J
Food Add Contam
25
2008
172
8
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
89
2011
247
9
Cawdell-Smith
AJ
Aust Vet J
88
2010
393
20854295
10
Di Menna
ME
New Zeal Vet J
60
2012
315
328
Miscellaneous Fungal Toxins Affecting the Nervous System (Unidentified Toxins)
Black Soil Blindness
This is a mycotoxicosis of grazing cattle, associated with the fungus Corallocytostroma
ornicopreoides growing on Mitchell grass (Astrebla spp.) in pastures on heavy basalt
(black soil) soil in tropical northwest Australia. The disease has occurred only once,
in a year marked by heavy seasonal rainfall and a longer than usual growing season.
Morbidity and mortality were high at the peak of the outbreak. Clinical characteristics
include blindness and death within 24 hours. Necropsy lesions include renal tubular
nephrosis, rumenoreticulitis, and moderate liver cell damage.
Nervous Signs
Nervous signs of tremor, gait incoordination, recumbency, and convulsions are the
primary toxic effects present after ingestion of Trichothecium roseum and Penicillium
cyclopium.
Further Reading
Jubb
TF
Black soil blindness: a new mycotoxicosis of cattle grazing Corallocytostroma-infected
Mitchell grass (Astrebla spp)
Aust Vet J
73
1996
49
51
8660198
Other Toxins Affecting the Nervous System
Inorganic Toxins Affecting the Nervous System
Lead Toxicosis (Plumbism)
Synopsis
Etiology Accidental ingestion of lead metal or lead-containing substances, ingestion
of lead-contaminated feed, or grazing pastures containing excessive lead in the soil.
Epidemiology Occurs in all age groups. One of the most common poisonings of farm livestock,
especially in young calves after turn out in spring. In cattle, usually sporadic and
caused by ingestion of a single source of lead but outbreaks occur when feed is contaminated.
High case–fatality rate if untreated. Sources include discarded lead batteries, lead-based
paints, industrial sources of lead, ash residues, pastures near motor vehicle highways,
and smelters. Occurs in sheep and horses grazing contaminated pastures.
Clinical pathology Lead levels in blood, feces, liver, kidney; elevated porphyrins
in blood.
Lesions Encephalopathy, degeneration of liver and kidney; pale musculature, brain
laminar cortical necrosis, intranuclear renal inclusion bodies.
Diagnostic confirmation Toxic levels of lead in blood and tissues.
Treatment Supportive care, removal of large amounts of lead from the gastrointestinal
tract, chelation therapy.
Control Identify and prevent access of animals to sources of lead.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Lead poisoning is associated with the accidental ingestion of lead metal or lead-containing
compounds; ingestion of feed, usually forage, containing lead; or grazing lead-contaminated
pastures.1, 2 The latter two are often associated with environmental pollution. Both
organic and inorganic lead are toxic, with organic lead the most bioavailable followed
by inorganic lead and then metallic lead.1, 3
Epidemiology
Where groups of animals have access to the same source of lead, outbreaks occur and
the morbidity rate ranges from 10% to 30%. The case–fatality rate may reach 100% but
early intensive therapy can be successful and reduce the figure to less than 50%.
In one recorded outbreak, in which a discarded 24-V battery was accidentally mixed
and ground up into the feed of 80 heifers, 55 of the animals died or were euthanized.
Occurrence
Lead is one of the most common poisonings in farm animals, especially young cattle.
1
Sheep and horses are also affected but not as often.3, 4 Pigs, because of housing
conditions, are not often exposed to lead and appear to be more tolerant than other
species.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Cattle
Data from diagnostic toxicology laboratories illustrate that lead poisoning is one
of the most common toxicosis in cattle. In Alberta, Canada, over a period of 22 years,
lead poisoning was the most frequently diagnosed toxicoses of cattle, representing
0.68% of all bovine submissions to the provincial diagnostic laboratories. Most cases
of poisoning occur during the summer months from May to August, when the cattle have
ready access to lead-containing materials such as crankcase oil and batteries that
are being changed in agricultural machinery. In many countries the incidence of the
disease is highest in cattle in the spring of the year a few days after the animals
have been turned out onto pasture.
5
Poisoning is most common in younger cattle, with 52% of the cases reported in animals
6 months of age or less.
6
Younger animals are more susceptible to lead toxicosis presumably because of a higher
rate of gastrointestinal tract absorption. In addition, young cattle are especially
curious and seem to seek out and find sources of lead. Confined housing of calves
with or without overcrowding is often followed by the appearance of pica, which may
be associated with boredom and an increase ingestion of lead-containing objects.
Lead poisoning in cattle is usually acute and caused by accidental ingestion of a
toxic quantity of lead over a short period of time.
7
The natural curiosity, licking habits, and lack of oral discrimination of cattle makes
any available lead-containing material a potential source of poisoning. Cattle will
readily drink motor oil; lick older machinery grease, peeling paint, and paint ashes;
and chew lead-based batteries. Many countries currently ban leaded gasoline, and in
these areas used motor oil may not contain lead as well as motor oil from diesel engines
or present-day machinery grease.
8
In ruminants, there is a tendency for metallic lead particles to settle in the reticulum,
and poisoning results from the gradual conversion of lead particles to soluble lead
acetate. Several epidemics of lead poisoning in domestic animals have been recorded
throughout the world in which the source of the metal was contamination of pasture
or crops by nearby lead mining or industrial lead operations.9, 10 Animals eating
vegetation in these areas may accumulate amounts of lead sufficient to produce clinical
signs of lead poisoning.
Buffalo
Lead poisoning in buffalo has been reported and provides interesting comparative data;
they may have a higher tolerance to lead than cattle.
Sheep
Sheep are usually affected by eating soil or forage contaminated by environmental
sources of lead.
Horses
Horses are much more selective in their eating habits. They usually do not lick old
paint cans, lead storage batteries, and peeling paint, and they do seem to find the
taste of used motor oil attractive. Lead poisoning in horses is most common when they
graze lead-contaminated pastures rather than by the accidental ingestion of a toxic
amount of lead.2, 4, 10 Young horses are particularly more susceptible than older
horses and cattle grazing on the same pasture.
Environmental Risk Factors
Environmental pollution with lead is a common occurrence in cities and surrounding
suburbs. For farm animals, significant pollution is more likely to occur near smelters
or other industrial enterprises or near major highways where pasture is contaminated
by exhaust fumes of automobiles if leaded gasoline is still used in the region. Much
of the poisoning is subclinical because of the low level of absorption, but lead-intoxicated
animals have served as sentinels for human lead exposure.
11
Lead is still commonly found in pastures near highways. The lead levels in the whole
blood of sheep grazing near main highways in three areas of the Nile delta region
of Egypt were 0.062, 0.067, and 0.083 parts per million (ppm). Pasture adjacent to
heavily used roads may carry as much as 390 mg/kg of lead, in contrast to 10 mg/kg
on lightly used roads.9, 10 The concentration of lead on pasture varies markedly with
proximity to the traffic, falling rapidly the greater the distance and with the time
of the year. Pastures contaminated by smelters are recorded as carrying 325 mg/kg
of lead (equivalent to a daily intake for an animal of 6.4 mg/kg BW).
12
In some locations near lead smelters, lead poisoning is considered to be a predictable
occurrence in horses that are allowed to graze on local pastures.
4
As a result horses are either not raised in these areas or hay is imported from other
areas. Although ingestion is the principal method of poisoning of animals, inhalation
may also be a significant method of entry for cattle grazing close to smelters or
highways.
Lead as an environmental contaminant is often combined with cadmium, which has some
effects similar to those of lead, thus the effects may be somewhat additive. Experimental
poisoning with both elements is associated with reduced weight gain in calves at dose
levels up to 18 mg/kg BW of each contaminant, and clinical signs appear at levels
above 18 mg/kg BW of each. Lead is also combined with chromate for industrial purposes.
The combination is nontoxic when combined with lead at lead intake levels of less
than 100 mg/kg BW.
Environmental pollution in the vicinity of lead and zinc-ore processing factories
can result in varying degrees of poisoning with lead, zinc, and cadmium.
13
These can be monitored by the analysis of blood, hair, and tissues obtained at necropsy.
Farm or Premise Risk Factors
The relationship between lead concentrations in blood of cattle with lead poisoning
and those in the milk is exponential.
14
The lead level in milk is relatively constant up to a blood level of 0.2 to 0.3 mg/L,
and increases sharply at higher blood levels. The biological half-life of lead excretion
in cattle is between 6 and 14 weeks.
15
Studies in six affected dairy herds reported a variable half-life ranging from 48
to 2507 days.
2
One probable reason for this great variance is the ability of the ruminant to retain
variable amounts of metallic lead in the rumen, which acts as a continuing reservoir.
Half-life studies do not account for variable intake and retention of a persistent
reservoir of toxicant, so the concept of using half-life excretion in dealing with
lead-poisoned cattle is not likely accurate. Owners of such cattle should be advised
of the potentially long withdrawal period. It may be advisable to test periodically
and allow marketing based on actually measured levels or to estimate the costs of
such a plan and consider salvage. This recent work casts doubt on the economic utility
of holding recovered animals. In acutely sick cows that were emergency slaughtered,
the range of lead levels in edible muscle tissue was 0.23 to 0.50 mg/kg. The concentrations
in the kidneys ranged from 70 to 330 mg/kg and in the livers 10 to 55 mg/kg.
Human and Public Health Risk Factors
The source of lead intoxication in animals must be identified so humans are not inadvertently
poisoned. In one recent study, investigations involving cattle deaths from lead poisoning
led to elevated blood levels in a pregnant woman, dog, cat, and remaining cattle.
11
A major concern with the treatment of lead-poisoned animals, particularly food-producing
animals, is the assurance that the edible tissues of recovered animals do not contain
toxic levels of lead. The length of time required after successful treatment of cattle
with typical clinical lead poisoning before such animals can be sent to slaughter
or before the milk can be used safely is not known. It is suggested that treated animals
should be appropriately identified
6
and blood lead levels determined once or twice monthly for several months. When the
blood lead levels have dropped to background levels for three consecutive samplings
at least 2 weeks apart, the animals are assumed to be safe for slaughter. Undocumented
field observations suggest that at least 6 months are necessary for background levels
to be achieved. Decisions about reaching acceptable residue levels will depend on
national or local regulations as well as the economics of maintaining a herd for long
periods without sales of milk or meat, and appropriate food safety and public health
officials should be consulted in this decision. The lead concentrations in blood and
milk from periparturient heifers 7 months after an episode of acute lead poisoning
revealed no lead in the milk. Animals that had been severely affected by lead poisoning
experienced a transient increase in whole-blood lead concentration at parturition
that was not high enough to be considered toxic.
Transmission (Sources of Lead)
Lead poisoning is most common in cattle on pasture, particularly if the pasture is
poor and the animals are allowed to forage in unusual places, such as trash dumps.15,
16 Phosphorus deficiency may also be a predisposing factor, because affected animals
will chew solid objects as a manifestation of osteophagia. However, cattle on lush
pasture may also seek out foreign material to chew. Discarded lead batteries are one
of the most common sources of lead poisoning in cattle.
13
In Alberta, Canada, over a period of 22 years, discarded batteries or used crankcase
oil accounted for more than 80% of cases for which the source of lead was determined:
batteries, 39.5%; used crankcase oil, 31.6%. The batteries are commonly placed in
garbage dumps on the farm and, in temperate climate countries, the batteries freeze
during the winter months and break open, exposing the plates, which are attractive
and palatable for cattle to lick and chew.
The contamination of forage supplies with shotgun lead pellets used in hunting and
shooting exercises can serve as a source of lead for cattle grazing the pasture or
consuming haylage or silage made from the contaminated field.1, 6 Automobile batteries
have been accidentally added to feed mixers in which they are ground by powerful augers
and mixed into the feed supply of cattle. Discarded lead-based paint cans are particularly
dangerous but fences, boards, the walls of pens, painted canvas, and burlap are also
common sources in calves. Painted silos may cause significant contamination of the
ensilage. One outbreak of lead poisoning in cattle was associated with silage containing
1200 mg/kg dry matter lead, which had become contaminated by ash and debris left after
burning an old lead-containing electrical cable in the silo before it had been filled.
Metallic lead in the form of lead shot, solder, or leaded windows has been associated
with mortalities, although, experimentally, sheet lead is not toxic.1, 2, 4 Lead sheeting
that has been exposed to the weather or subjected to acid corrosion appears to be
more damaging, possibly because of the formation of a fine coating of a soluble lead
salt. Lead poisoning can be a major hazard in the vicinity of oil fields, and engine
sump oil may contain over 500 mg lead per 100 mL. Automotive and other mineral oils
are very palatable to young beef calves. As lead use becomes restricted in many countries,
grease and lead-contaminated engine oil have become less common sources of lead.
8
Less common but still potent sources of lead are linoleum, roofing felt, putty, automobile
oil filters, and aluminum paint. Some of the latter paints contain large quantities
of lead, and others none at all. Only lead-free aluminum paint should be used on fixtures
to which animals have access.
Lead parasiticide sprays, particularly those containing lead arsenate, were once associated
with heavy losses in cattle grazing in recently sprayed orchards or vegetable crops.
These are not commonly used now, except in some countries, but cattle may accidentally
ingest old stores of the compound.
Pathogenesis
The absorption, distribution, and elimination of lead vary depending on the chemical
form of lead, amount ingested, age and species of animal, and other physiologic factors.
Deficiencies in calcium, iron, and zinc are associated with increased lead absorption
and increased toxicity. Lead from salts such as lead sulfate are absorbed more than
metallic lead from battery plates.
13
Regardless of the chemical form of the ingested lead, only a small proportion (2%–10%)
is absorbed because of the formation in the alimentary tract of insoluble lead complexes,
which are excreted in the feces.1, 15 Once absorbed, 60% to 90% of lead is found in
erythrocytes and the rest bound to albumin and other proteins.
3
Very little lead is found unbound in the serum. Lead is distributed to first to the
soft tissues, especially kidneys and liver, and ultimately to bone, which serves as
a storage or “sink” for excess lead. Excretion is slow and primarily through bile
and the milk of lactating animals with little excreted in the urine.1, 3, 14
Blood lead concentrations are an excellent marker of exposure in animals. In cows,
blood-level concentrations greater than 0.35 ppm have been associated with poisoning
1
and blood lead levels less than 0.1 ppm with normal background exposure. In horses,
blood lead levels greater than 0.2 to 0.35 ppm have been associated with poisoning
4
and blood lead levels less than 0.2 ppm with background exposure. Correlation between
blood lead levels and milk levels is good; correlation between blood lead levels and
the presence or severity of clinical signs is often poor.14, 17
Lead is transferred across the placental barrier,
17
and high liver levels occur in the lambs of ewes fed more than normal amounts of lead.
Calves born from cows experimentally poisoned with lead have elevated levels of lead
in bone, kidney, and liver. In a naturally occurring case of lead poisoning in a pregnant
heifer, the blood and liver concentrations in the fetus were 0.425 and 4.84 ppm, respectively,
which was 72% and 84% of the same tissue lead concentrations of the dam. Hepatic lysosomes
of the fetus contained metallic electron densities, which may have been lead.
Several biochemical processes are affected by lead. Lead is a neurotoxicant and at
elevated doses it disrupts the blood-brain barrier allowing albumin, water, and electrolytes
to enter, resulting in edema. The complete mechanism of action associated with lead's
neuropathy is unknown, but its ability to substitute for calcium and/or zinc is involved.
3
Lead mimics or inhibits the action of calcium altering the release of neurotransmitters
and activating protein kinases.
3
It also binds to a sulfhydryl group on proteins resulting in inhibition of enzymes,
conformational changes in proteins, and alterations in calcium/vitamin D metabolisms.
16
Lead inhibits δ-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (D-ALAD) and ferrochelatase activity,
thus decreasing heme synthesis and hemoglobin production.2, 3, 18 This not only plays
a role in lead-associated anemia but results in decreased oxygen carrying capacity
with the nervous system susceptible to the resulting tissue ischemia.
Clinical Findings
Lead is toxic to a number of organ systems including the nervous, gastrointestinal,
hematologic, cardiovascular, renal, musculoskeletal, and reproductive systems.
3
The major effects of lead toxicity are often manifested in three main ways
7
:
•
Lead encephalopathy
•
Gastroenteritis
•
Degeneration of peripheral nerves
Clinical signs vary depending on the species, type and amount of lead involved, and
duration of exposure. Typically, acute nervous system involvement occurs following
the ingestion of large doses in susceptible animals such as calves, alimentary tract
irritation following moderate doses, and peripheral nerve lesions following long-term
ingestion of small amounts of lead. The nervous signs of encephalopathy and the lesions
of peripheral nerve degeneration are caused by the degenerative changes of nervous
system tissue. Gastroenteritis is associated with the caustic action of lead salts
on the alimentary mucosa.
Cattle
The signs of acute lead poisoning are more common in calves and younger cattle and
have a sudden onset and short duration, usually lasting only 12 to 24 hours. Many
animals, especially those on pasture, are found dead without any observable signs.
Staggering and muscle tremors particularly of the head and neck, with champing of
the jaws (chewing gum fits) and frothing at the mouth are obvious. Snapping of the
eyelids, rolling of the eyes, and bellowing are common. Blindness and cervical, facial,
and auricular twitching are consistent in acute lead poisoning of cattle.
15
The animal eventually falls and intermittent tonic-clonic convulsions occur and may
continue until death. Pupillary dilation, opisthotonus, and muscle tremors are marked
and persist between the convulsive episodes (Fig. 14-3
). There is hyperesthesia to touch and sound, and the heart and respiratory rates
are increased. In some cases, particularly in adults, the animal remains standing,
is blind, maniacal, charges into fences, attempts to climb or jump over walls, and
head-presses strongly against walls or fences. Frenzy is common and some animals appear
to attack humans, but the gait is stiff and jerky and progress is impeded. Death usually
occurs during a convulsion and is caused by respiratory failure.
Fig. 14-3
Holstein Friesian steer with acute lead toxicity. Notice the abnormal mentation, contraction
of facial muscles, and marked dilatation of the pupils. The bandage around the neck
protected an intravenous catheter that was used for daily intravenous Ca-EDTA treatment.
The steer recovered following treatment.
Fig. 14-3
The subacute form is more common in adult cattle, and in this form the animal remains
alive for 3 to 4 days. Gastrointestinal tract dysfunction is one of the most common
abnormalities. Ruminal atony is accompanied by constipation in the early stages. Later
a fetid diarrhea occurs in most cases. Grinding of the teeth is common, and hypersalivation
may occur. Neurologic signs include dullness, blindness, and some abnormality of gait
including incoordination and staggering, and sometimes circling. The circling is intermittent
and not always in the same direction and usually occurs when the animal is confined
in a small space like a box stall. Muscle tremor and hyperesthesia are common but
not as pronounced as in the acute form.
Sheep
Lead poisoning in sheep is usually manifested by a subacute syndrome similar to that
seen in adult cattle. There is anorexia and scant feces followed by the passage of
dark, foul-smelling feces. Weakness and ataxia follow, often with abdominal pain,
but there is no excitement, tetany, or convulsions. Polyuria occurs when the intake
of lead is small but with large amounts there is oliguria.
Chronic toxicity is rare, but two syndromes of posterior paresis have been described
in young lambs in old lead-mining areas, and tissue levels of lead are abnormally
high in both instances. In both syndromes there is gait impairment. Osteoporosis is
present in one but in the other there is no suggestion of skeletal changes. In the
osteoporotic disease the signs occur only in lambs 3 to 12 weeks of age and never
in adults. There is stiffness of gait, lameness, and posterior paralysis. Affected
lambs are unthrifty and the bones, including the frontal bones, are very fragile.
The paralysis is caused by lesions of the vertebrae, usually affecting one or more
of the lumbar bones, resulting in compression of the spinal cord. In the other form,
gait abnormalities occur in the same lamb age group and are manifested initially by
incomplete flexion of the limb joints so that the feet drag while walking. In a later
stage the fetlocks are flexed, the extensor muscles paretic, and the lamb soon becomes
recumbent. Recovery is common, although many lambs die of concurrent disease.
Horses
Acute and chronic lead poisoning occurs in horses and ponies, although more rarely
than other species. Signs occur most often in horses ingesting contaminated forage
or soil found near old lead mines, smelters, and battery recycling depots.3, 4 The
clinical findings are extremely variable, but include ataxia, weakness, hypotonia,
muscle tremors, rough hair coat, dysphagia, weight loss, dyspnea, roaring or stridor,
seizure like movements, colic, and maniacal behavior.
3
A roughened hair coat, pharyngeal dysfunction, and weight loss were the most common
clinical findings in 10 case reports involving a total of 68 animals. Some horses
died without any previous clinical illness but where clinical signs are apparent they
were usually distinct and dramatic rather than subtle. Inspiratory dyspnea associated
with paralysis of the recurrent laryngeal nerve is the most common finding. This may
be accompanied by pharyngeal paralysis in which recurrent choke and regurgitation
of food and water through the nostrils occur. Aspiration pneumonia may result after
inhalation of ingesta through the paralyzed larynx. Paralysis of the lips occasionally
accompanies the other signs.
Pigs
Early signs include squealing as though in pain, mild diarrhea, grinding of the teeth,
and salivation. The disease is usually a prolonged one and listlessness, anorexia,
and loss of weight develop followed by muscle tremor, incoordination, partial or complete
blindness, enlargement of the carpal joints, and disinclination to stand on the front
feet. Convulsive seizures occur in the terminal stages.
Clinical Pathology
Hematology
In chronic lead poisoning, hematologic examination may reveal a normocytic, normochromic
anemia in some, and, although basophilic stippling does not occur often enough to
be diagnostic, it is recorded in some experimental poisonings.
3
It is recorded as occurring in lead-exposed pigs and a horse. In some, poikilocytosis
and anisocytosis were marked. The CSF is approximately normal with slightly elevated
leukocyte numbers but no increase in protein or other biochemical components.
Blood Lead
Whole-blood levels are generally the best sample for determining the lead status of
the animal. Bovine blood lead reference materials are available and have been certified
for many years. Whole-blood levels of lead in normal ruminants are usually below 0.05
to 0.25 ppm; poisoned animals, including horses, usually have levels above 0.35 ppm
and deaths begin at 1.0 ppm.1, 3, 4 Buffalo may have blood levels above 1.0 ppm and
still survive, which suggests that they have a higher tolerance level than cattle.
Blood lead concentrations also fluctuate markedly after administration of lead and,
consequently, the clinical importance of blood lead concentrations is often questionable
and a diagnosis based on this single determinant is equivocal.
Blood lead concentration also has limited value for assessing the effectiveness of
therapy for lead poisoning. Blood level concentrations may change rapidly during chelation
therapy, often decreasing by 50% or more within 24 hours after initiation of treatment
despite certain body tissues still containing high concentrations of lead. Thus the
evaluation of biochemical indicators such as aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALA-D)
may be useful. The blood and liver levels of fetuses from pregnant cattle with lead
poisoning may be higher than what are considered toxic levels in adults, which suggests
concentration in the fetus.
Milk Lead
Only limited information is available on the concentrations of lead that occur in
cattle affected with field cases of lead poisoning. Lead levels of 0.13 mg/L of milk
have occurred in natural cases with a half-life of 4.6 days. The regulatory limit
for lead in bovine milk in the Netherlands is 0.05 mg/L milk. In acute lead poisoning
in lactating buffalo pastured near smelters in India, the lead concentrations in milk
were 1.13 ppm compared with 0.24 ppm in the milk from buffalo in unpolluted areas.
The mean lead concentrations in the forage of poisoned animals were 706 ± 73.0 ppm,
compared with the unpolluted area of 78 ± 12 ppm.
Fecal Lead
Fecal levels of lead represent unabsorbed and excreted lead deriving from the bones,
and are of limited value unless considered in conjunction with blood levels because
ingested lead may have been in an insoluble form and harmless to the animal. When
fecal levels are high, it can be assumed that the lead has been ingested in the preceding
2 to 3 weeks, but high blood levels may be maintained for months after ingestion.
Thus high blood and low fecal levels indicate that the lead was taken in some weeks
previously, but high blood and high fecal levels suggest recent ingestion and significant
absorption.
Urinary Lead
Urine lead levels are variable, rarely high (0.2–0.3 mg/L), and although elevated
urine levels are usually associated with high blood levels, this relationship does
not necessarily hold.
δ-ALA-D
Because of some of the limitations of blood lead, other indirect measurements of lead
poisoning, such as the levels of δ-ALA-D in blood, are used to supplement blood lead
determinations. For example, the best method of detecting the presence of lead poisoning
in its early stages, except in the horse, is the estimation of δ-ALA-D in the blood.
The evaluation of δ-ALA-D and blood lead concentrations together can assist in resolving
diagnostic situations in which the blood lead concentration is in the questionable
range of 0.25 to 0.35 ppm.
δ-ALA-D is important in the synthesis of heme and is probably the most sensitive enzyme
in the heme pathway. Inhibition of the enzyme results in a block in the utilization
of δ-ALA, a subsequent decline in heme synthesis and a marked increase in the urinary
excretion of δ-ALA.
17
In cattle, sheep, and pigs affected with chronic lead poisoning, the plasma levels
of δ-ALA-D are decreased, and the urinary levels of δ-ALA are increased before clinical
signs are detectable. In sheep, erythrocyte δ-ALA-D is recommended as the most sensitive
diagnostic test available.
The disadvantages of the assay for blood δ-ALA-D include age-related variations, particularly
in calves12, 18; the methods used for analysis are not yet uniform and blood must
be collected in polystyrene or polyethylene tubes rather than glass tubes and an anticoagulant
other than ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) must be used. The levels of δ-ALA-D
increase in calves from birth to 10 weeks of age and age-matched controls should be
evaluated simultaneously when conducting the test in calves of younger than 6 months
of age. In cattle under 1 year of age, δ-ALA-D values of less than 200 mmol of porphobilinogen
(PBG)/mL of RBC/h should raise suspicion of their having ingested lead. In this same
age range values below 100 mmol would confirm ingestion of lead. In cattle equal to
or less than 2 years of age, values of δ-ALA-D of less than 100 mmol of PBG/mL of
RBC/h would indicate ingestion of lead.
The dδ-ALA-D is so sensitive to lead that it remains inhibited even after lead exposure
has ceased. Following treatment with a chelating agent the blood lead levels will
often decline giving a false indication of a positive treatment effect. If the δ-ALA-D
levels do not decrease following therapy, it indicates that there is sufficient lead
present to continue to suppress the enzyme.
Erythrocyte Protoporphyrin
The levels of free erythrocyte zinc protoporphyrin increase in lead poisoning, and
this is indicative of the chronic metabolic effect of lead on the erythroid cells
being released from bone marrow into the peripheral circulation. A mean value of 22 µg
coproporphyrin per 100 mL of erythrocytes has been determined. It may be of some value
along with determinations of blood lead and δ-ALA-D. The use of δ-ALA-D activity and
erythrocyte protoporphyrin content as cumulative lead exposure indicators in cows
environmentally exposed to lead is recommended.
Plasma δ-Aminolevulinic Acid
In human beings, δ-ALA is suggested as a sensitive marker of trace exposures to lead.
18
Plasma δ-aminolevulinic acid has been evaluated in cattle as a biomarker for acute
lead poisoning and the results showed it to be a promising tool.2, 18 Further work
is necessary, however, to establish concentrations in unexposed, intermittently exposed,
and chronically exposed animals.
Necropsy Findings
In most acute cases there are no gross lesions at necropsy. In cases of longer standing
there may be some degree of abomasitis and enteritis, diffuse congestion of the lungs,
and degeneration of the liver and kidney. Epicardial hemorrhages are common. Congestion
of meningeal and cerebral vessels may also be observed and hemorrhages may be present
in the meninges. An increase in CSF is often recorded but is of minor degree in most
cases.
In chronic cases, gross lesions in cattle include cerebrocortical softening, cavitation,
and yellow discoloration with the most severe lesions in the occipital lobes. Histologic
lesions were most severe at the tips of the gyri. Similar lesions were produced experimentally.
Acid-fast inclusion bodies deep in the renal cortex have diagnostic significance.
Examination of the contents of the reticulum in ruminants for particulate lead matter
is essential. Flakes of paint, lumps of red lead, or sheet lead usually accumulate
in this site. Their absence is not remarkable, especially if animals have licked fresh
paint, but their presence does give weight to the provisional diagnosis.
Liver and Kidney Lead
The submission of alimentary tract contents and tissues for analysis forms an important
part of the diagnosis of lead poisoning, but results must be interpreted with caution.
Cattle
In the kidney cortex 25 mg/kg (ppm) of lead wet weight (WW) is diagnostic and is a
more reliable tissue for assay than liver, which may contain 10 to 20 mg/kg WW. The
concentrations in the kidney are always much higher than in the liver. A diagnostic
laboratory found mean levels in livers of poisoned cattle of 93 µg/g WW, and 438 µg/g
WW in kidneys. Tissue lead levels in cattle from industrial areas are significantly
higher (liver 0.23 mg/kg WW, kidney 0.42 mg/kg WW) than in cattle from clear air zones
(liver and kidney less than 0.1 mg/kg WW).
Horses
Levels of lead at 4 to 7 mg/kg (ppm) WW have been found in the livers of horses dying
of chronic lead poisoning but 25 to 250 mg/kg are more likely, and 40 mg/kg WW may
occur in the livers of affected pigs.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Toxicology: 50 g liver, kidney, and reticulum content (determine lead concentration)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed cerebral cortex, kidney (light microscopy)
Differential Diagnosis
In all cases, the possibility of access to lead and the environmental circumstances
that may arouse suspicion of other poisonings or errors in management should be considered.
Estimation of the lead content of blood and feces should be performed at the earliest
opportunity and tissues for necropsy specimens submitted for analysis.
Differential diagnosis list
Cattle (see Table 14-12)
Arsenic poisoning
Claviceps paspali toxicity
Diseases resulting in blindness (hypovitaminosis A, ophthalmitis, polioencephalomalacia)
Hypomagnesemic tetany
Meningoencephalitis
Nervous acetonemia
Sheep
Enzootic ataxia caused by copper deficiency
Enzootic muscular dystrophy
Polyarthritis caused by bacterial infection
Horses (see Table 14-11)
Botulism
Equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy
Equine motor neuron disease
Equisetum spp. (horsetail toxicosis)
Fumonisin toxicosis (equine leukoencephalomalacia)
Hepatoencephalopathy caused by hepatotoxic plants
Laryngeal hemiplegia
Protozoal encephalomyelitis
Rabies
Viral encephalomyelitides, including West Nile virus
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Treatment in most animals includes supportive care, preventing further exposure to
lead, surgical removal of large amounts of lead from the gastrointestinal tract, and
chelation therapy. Supportive care should include the use of tranquilization for those
animals with neurologic signs and intravenous fluids to prevent and treat dehydration.
Chelation therapy may be used to lower blood level concentrations but may not remove
it completely from tissues or affect tissue damage. Large amounts of lead left in
the gastrointestinal tract before chelation may result in enhanced or increased absorption
of lead. Lead mobilized from tissue sites during chelation may transiently increase
blood lead levels and exacerbate clinical signs.
Calcium Versenate
Calcium versenate (calcium disodium EDTA [CaEDTA]) has been used successfully in cases
of lead poisoning produced experimentally in calves and in natural cases in cattle
and horses.3, 4, 14 Cattle may be treated with 73.3 mg/kg/day slow intravenously divided
two to three times a day for 3 to 5 days.
19
If necessary, after a rest period of 2 days, an additional 3 to 5 days of treatment
may be used. Other doses and dosage regimens are available.14, 19 Horses may be treated
with CaEDTA at 75 mg/kg BW divided two to three times a day by slow intravenous infusion
for 4 to 5 days.4, 19 If necessary, after a rest period of 2 days, an additional 4
to 5 days of therapy may be used.
The disadvantages of CaEDTA is that it must be given intravenously and there are side
effects. Renal and gastrointestinal toxicity may occur with long-term therapy, and
essential minerals such as copper and iron may be removed with multiple treatments.
3
Severe neurologic signs and dyspnea occurred in a horse receiving a second round of
CaEDTA therapy.
4
Succimer (Dimercaptosuccinic Acid)
Dimercaptosuccinic acid has been used for many years in human medicine as a specific
chelator for arsenic, lead, and mercury. Published doses are available for dogs, cats,
and birds but not large animals.
19
Succimer has the advantages of heavy metal specificity, oral administration, and lack
of nephrotoxicity.
3
Thiamine Hydrochloride
When used in combination with CaEDTA, thiamine is a valuable agent for the treatment
of lead poisoning. Thiamine hydrochloride reduced the deposition of lead in most tissues,
especially liver, kidney, and the central and peripheral nervous system of experimentally
poisoned calves. The recommended dose is 2 mg/kg BW intramuscularly, given at the
same time as CaEDTA, with a total daily dose not to exceed 8 mg/kg BW.
19
Magnesium Sulfate
Oral dosing with small amounts of magnesium sulfate has been used on the basis that
soluble lead salts will be precipitated as the insoluble sulfate and excreted in the
feces.
14
However, the lead is often present in large quantities and in the form of particles,
which are only slowly dissolved.
Rumenotomy
Rumenotomy to remove the ingested lead has been used but may be unsatisfactory because
of the difficulty in removing particulate material from the recesses of the reticular
mucosa. However, it may be appropriate when a valuable animal is affected and it is
known that the animal ingested a certain compound of lead, which may be removable
from the reticulum and rumen.
Treatment and Control
Cattle
Calcium versenate (73 mg/kg/day slow IV divided two to three times a day for 3–5 days.
Rest × 2 days. Repeat 4–5 days of therapy if need be) (R-2)
Thiamine HCl (2 mg/kg BW IM, given at the same time as CaEDTA; max 8 mg/kg BW/day)
(R-2)
Horses
Calcium versenate (75 mg/kg BW divided two to three times a day slow IV for 4–5 days.
Rest × 2 days. Repeat 4–5 days of therapy if need be) (R-2)
Thiamine HCl (2 mg/kg BW IM, given at the same time as CaEDTA; max 8 mg/kg BW/day)
(R-2)
BW, body weight; CaEDTA, calcium disodium ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid; IM, intramuscular;
IV, intravenous.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
The following practices are recommended to reduce the incidence of lead poisoning:
•
Limit grazing on pastures near lead mines, smelters, or battery recycling depots.
•
Use phosphate rock treatment on contaminated pastures (phosphate salts bind to lead
yielding low solubility lead phosphates).
4
•
Keep trash out of pastures.
•
Do not burn wood or other substances in pastures, and keep animals away from ashes.
•
Provide adequate nutrition and consistent feeding practices to minimize pica or abnormal
feeding behavior in livestock.
•
Consider temporarily adding calcium phosphate to the diet to decrease lead absorption.
4
•
Dispose of or store used lead batteries, motor oil, and leaded petroleum products
in areas animals cannot access.
•
Use vehicle service and machinery storage areas separate from areas used by livestock.
•
Use only lead-free paints on fencing, boards, and buildings.
•
Dispose of contaminated carcasses according to Environmental Protection Agency regulations.
•
Identify the source of lead intoxication.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1799
References
1
Varga
A
Vet Med Res Rep
3
2012
111
2
Roegner
A
Vet Med Res
4
2013
11
3
Puschner
B
Equine Vet Educ
22
2010
526
4
Allen
KJ
Equine Vet Educ
22
2010
182
5
Mavangira
V
J Am Vet Med Assoc
233
2008
955
18795860
6
Sharpe
RT
Vet Rec
159
2006
71
16844817
7
Krametter-Froetscher
R
Vet J
174
2007
99
16753317
8
Burren
BG
Aust Vet J
88
2010
240
20553575
9
Swarup
D
Small Rum Res
63
2006
309
10
Madejón
P
Ecotoxicology
18
2009
417
19189215
11
Bischoff
K
J Med Toxicol
6
2010
185
20238198
12
Rodríguez-Estival
J
Environ Pollution
160
2012
118
13
Yabe
J
Environ Toxicol Chem
30
2011
1892
21590713
14
Aslani
MR
Iran J Vet Sci Technol
4
2012
47
15
Miranda
M
J Vet Med Ser A
53
2006
305
16
Finnie
JW
Austr Vet J
89
2011
247
17
Reis
LSLS
J Med Medical Sci
1
2010
560
18
Kang
HG
J Vet Diagn Invest
22
2010
903
21088173
19
Plumb
DC
Edetate calcium disodium; thiamine
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
366
970
Mercury Toxicosis
Synopsis
Etiology Ingestion, inhalation, or dermal exposure to mercury compounds including
fungicides, phenylmercury treated grain, contaminated ashes, etc.
Epidemiology Generally organic preparations used in seed grain fed accidentally to
livestock.
Clinical pathology High levels of mercury in all tissues; elevated serum urea nitrogen
and creatinine concentration; decreased osmolarity, glycosuria, proteinuria, and phosphaturia.
Lesions
•
Inorganic salts: acute, gastroenteritis; chronic, nephrosis.
•
Organomercurials: neuronal necrosis in brain and spinal nerves.
Diagnostic confirmation High blood, urine, tissue, hair levels of mercury.
Treatment Supportive and symptomatic care; judicious use of chelation in acute cases;
treatment of chronic intoxication generally unrewarding.
Control Care in the handling of agricultural and pharmaceutical mercury compounds.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Mercury is a naturally occurring element (heavy metal) that occurs in three different
forms.
1
Metallic mercury, an environmental pollutant, comes from sources such as mining, smelting,
fossil fuels, volcanoes, and forest fires.
2
It is used in a variety of products including thermometers, button batteries, barometers,
and dental fillings. Inorganic mercury (mercury salts) is produced when mercury is
combined with a salt such as sulfur or chlorine. Fungicides, disinfectants, antiseptics,
and older anthelmintics may contain inorganic mercurial compounds. Organic mercury
(organomercurials) is formed when mercury combines carbon to form, among others, methylmercury,
ethylmercury, and phenylmercury.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Stringent state and national standards have made mercury poisoning in animals a rare
occurrence. Toxicosis, when it occurs, is most often associated with oral ingestion
of an organic mercury compound. In general, this is chronic and caused by accumulation
of grain contaminated with mercury in the form of phenylmercury.
3
Acute or chronic poisoning can occur from either inorganic or organic mercury compounds
but is generally accidental in nature.
4
Because of the availability of fungicidal agents other than mercury it is possible
to limit the use of mercuric agents by legislation to those excreted rapidly by animals,
the phenylmercury compounds, and prohibit those that are most highly retained in animal
tissues, the ethyl and methyl compounds.
5
Worldwide use of mercurial fungicides has declined, and poisoning is much less common
than in the past. The most common products, when used, are dusts of 5.25% methoxyethylmercury
silicate or methylmercury dicyandiamide. These and ethylmercuric chloride are toxic
when fed to pigs at the rate of 0.19 to 0.7 6 mg of mercury per kilogram BW per day
for 60 to 90 days. Methylmercury dicyandiamide fed to pigs at the rate of 5 to 15 mg/kg
is associated with illness, and 20 mg/kg is associated with some deaths with a delay
of 3 weeks between dosing and illness.
Treated seed is usually not harmful if it comprises only 10% of the ration and must
be fed in large amounts for long periods before clinical illness occurs. A single
feeding even of large amounts of grain is thought to be incapable of causing mercury
poisoning in ruminants, but horses may be susceptible.
Accidental administration of medicines containing mercury, licking of skin dressings
(e.g., mercuric oxide), and absorption from liberally applied skin dressings or combined
with dimethyl sulfoxide may be associated with sporadic cases that may occur in horses
after application of mercury-containing “blisters.” Inorganic mercury salts contaminating
lakes or other anaerobic ecologic areas can be reduced and converted to methylmercury
and serve as a source of organic mercurial poisoning or food contamination through
accumulation in fish or fish meal.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
The toxicity of mercury compounds depends on their solubility and the susceptibility
of the animals. Cattle are highly susceptible, with toxicosis occurring on an average
daily intake of mercury, in organic mercury form, of 10 mg/kg BW/day, whereas toxic
effects are only obtained in sheep with intakes of 17.4 mg/kg BW/day. In horses, the
acute toxic dose inorganic mercury is 5 to 10 g.
5
Chronic ingestion of inorganic mercuric chloride (0.8 g/kg BW/day) for 14 weeks resulted
in mercury toxicity.
5
Human Risk Factors
Meat, liver, and kidneys from animals poisoned by mercury are unsuitable for human
consumption. Depending on the form of mercury, milk may not be safe.
Pathogenesis
The toxicokinetics of mercury depends on the form and route of exposure. Metallic
mercury is primarily absorbed through the respiratory tract with very little by ingestion.
1
It is lipophilic and once distributed to the kidneys it crosses both the blood-brain
and placental barriers in which it can remain for extended periods of time. Excretion
is via urine and feces and a small amount in milk. Inorganic mercury has limited gastrointestinal
absorption (<40%), is not lipophilic, is distributed to several body organs, and accumulates
in the kidney.
5
Excretion is via urine and feces with very small amounts in the milk. Organic mercury
is almost completely absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract (90%–95%). It is rapidly
distributed to the circulatory system, is lipophilic, and crosses both the blood-brain
and placental barriers in which it is trapped and accumulates in the brain and fetus,
accumulates in RBCs, and undergoes further distribution to body tissues, reaching
equilibrium in approximately 4 days. Excretion is very slow and primarily fecal, although
some urine and milk excretion occurs.
The mechanism of action relates to the specific form of mercury. Metallic mercury
and organic mercury accumulate in the brain and are potent neurotoxicants.1, 5, 6
Toxicity from methylmercury is multifactorial. It inhibits protein synthesis in the
brain by interfering with aminoacyl tRNA synthetase enzymes, generates excess free
radicals, and inhibits antioxidant enzymes resulting in cell death. All forms of mercury
accumulate in the kidney, concentrating in the proximal renal tubular cells, producing
cell membrane permeability, excess free radical formation, inhibition of antioxidant
enzymes, and induction of glutathione and glutathione-dependent enzymes.1, 5 Acute
toxicity results in acute tubular necrosis and renal failure; chronic toxicity results
in renal interstitial fibrosis and renal failure.
5
Clinical Findings
The toxic effects of mercury depend on the form, route of exposure, dose, and duration
of exposure.1, 5 The target organs of both inorganic and organic mercury are the brain
and kidney, and this is where the most damage occurs.1, 6, 7
Acute inorganic mercury toxicosis occurs when large amounts of inorganic mercury are
ingested. There is an acute gastroenteritis with vomiting of bloodstained material
and severe diarrhea.
4
Death occurs within a few hours from shock and dehydration. In less acute cases the
patient survives several days. The syndrome includes salivation, a fetid breath, anorexia,
oliguria, tachycardia, hyperpnea, and, in some cases, posterior paralysis and terminal
convulsions.
Chronic inorganic mercury toxicosis occurs when small amounts of inorganic mercury
are ingested over longer periods. Damage to the kidney and nervous system in addition
to the gastrointestinal tract is likely to occur.
4
Signs include depression, anorexia, emaciation, a stiff, stilted gait that may progress
to paresis, alopecia, scabby lesions around the anus and vulva, pruritus, petechiation
and tenderness of the gums and shedding of the teeth, persistent diarrhea, weakness,
incoordination, and convulsions.
Chronic organic mercurial poisoning is associated with neurologic syndromes.4, 5 In
pigs blindness is accompanied by staggering, gait instabilities, lameness, recumbency,
and inability to eat, although the appetite is good. Cattle poisoned in this way show
ataxia, neuromuscular incoordination, paresis, recumbency, convulsions, evidence of
renal failure, and death. Clinical signs may not develop until 20 days after feeding
is commenced. Sheep are similar to cattle, although signs of tetraplegia may occur.
Horses show renal disease, neurologic abnormalities, colic, and laminitis.
Clinical Pathology
Mercury can be detected at higher levels than normal in the blood, urine, feces, milk,
tissues, and hair of affected animals and in the toxic source material.1, 4, 8 Urine
is the best source for metallic and inorganic mercury and hair for organic mercury.
Generally, blood is useful only for the first 3 to 5 days postexposure as distributed
to other tissues occurs.
1
Creatinine and serum urea nitrogen concentrations will be elevated and urinalysis
may show reduced osmolarity, glycosuria, proteinuria, and phosphaturia. Less than
0.2% of ingested mercury is excreted in cow's milk.
Necropsy Findings
In acute cases, there is severe gastroenteritis with edema, hyperemia, and petechiation
of the alimentary mucosa. The liver and kidneys are swollen, and the lungs are congested
and show multiple hemorrhages. There may be an accompanying catarrhal stomatitis.
A crusting focus of dermatitis may be identified if exposure was percutaneous.
Histologically, the renal tubular epithelial cells are swollen and vacuolated, and
proteinuria is evident. An ulcerative colitis may also be visible. In chronic toxicity
associated with organic mercury compounds there are also degenerative changes in nerve
cells in the cortex of the cerebrum, brainstem, and spinal cord. The lesions include
neuronal necrosis, neuronophagia, cortical vacuolation, and gliosis. Fibrinoid necrosis
of leptomeningeal arterioles may be seen. Other common microscopic changes include
degeneration of granular cells of the cerebellar cortex and of Purkinje cells of the
myocardium.
Mercury reaches its greatest concentration in the kidney, and this tissue should be
submitted for assay. In horses with acute mercury toxicosis, renal tissue with mercury
at more than 10 µg/g of mercury is diagnostic.
4
Concentrations of 100 mg/kg may be present in the kidney of animals poisoned with
inorganic mercury. With chronic organic mercurial poisoning in swine, levels of mercury
up to 2000 mg/kg may be present in the kidney.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Toxicology: 50 g kidney, brain is half fresh and half in formalin, 500 g of suspect
feed (ASSAY [Hg]); muscle tissue for potential residues in food animal edible tissues
•
Histology: formalin-fixed kidney, heart, oral and/or skin lesions; half of midsagittally
sectioned brain (LM)
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list
•
Arsenic toxicosis (especially organic arsenicals in swine)
•
Lead toxicosis
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Treatment should be aimed toward removal of the source and providing supportive care.
Activated charcoal followed by mineral oil or another laxative should be used in acute
cases. Further care includes intravenous fluids to enhance hydration, promote excretion,
and correct electrolyte abnormalities, gastrointestinal protectants, and pain medications.
Antioxidants, including selenium, have been used in human beings.
9
There is no true antidote, and the use of chelation agents is controversial. In acute
toxicity in horses, intramuscular dimercaprol (BAL) at 3 mg/kg BW every 4 hours ×
2 days, followed by 3 mg/kg BW every 6 hours on day 3, and then 3 mg/kg BW twice a
day × 10 days has been used.
4
Penicillamine, 3 mg/kg BW orally every 6 hours has also been used effectively.
4
In cattle and swine, intramuscular dimercaprol at 3 mg/kg BW every 6 hours for 4 days,
followed by every 12 hours for 10 days has been recommended.
10
Control
Seed grains dusted with mercury compounds should not be fed to animals.
Further Reading
Graeme
MD
Heavy metal toxicity, part I: arsenic and mercury
J Emerg Med
16
1988
45
56
Neathery
MW
Miller
WJ
Metabolism and toxicity of cadmium, mercury, and lead in animals: a review
J Dairy Sci
58
1975
1767
1107364
Radostits
O
Mercury poisoning
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1814
References
1
Bernhoft
RA
J Environ Public Health
2012
2012
460
508
2
Krametter-Froetscher
R
Vet J
174
2007
99
16753317
3
Bilandzic
N
Food Addit Contam
2
2010
172
4
Schmitz
DB
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
23
2007
677
18061857
5
Raikwar
MK
Vet World
1
2008
28
6
Chen
C
Sci Total Environ
366
2006
627
16457873
7
Chen
C
Environ Health Perspect
114
2006
297
16451871
8
Rudy
M
Med Weter
63
2007
1303
1306
9
Shukla
SV
Tox Int
14
2007
67
10
Plumb
DC
Dimercaprol
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
220
Boron Toxicosis
Boron, an essential element for plant growth, is added to many agricultural fertilizers
and presents yet another toxic chemical in the list of farm hazards for animals. Boron
compounds such as boric acid or sodium borate are generally of low toxicity and reports
of poisoning in cattle rare. In some fertilizers, a solubilized form of boron is used
to increase availability thus increasing its toxicity and palatability. Cattle accidentally
ingesting a boron-containing fertilizer developed depression, weakness, tremor, and
ataxia; other reported signs include short periods of gait spasticity, dorsiflexion
of the head, and flutter of the periorbicular muscles, followed by stumbling backward
and sternal recumbency, then lateral recumbency, and a quiet death. The case–fatality
rate is 100%. There are no gross lesions on necropsy examination.
Experimental dosing with the fertilizer in goats is associated with the previously
mentioned syndrome plus head-shaking, ear-flicking, star-gazing (staring), phantom
dodging, oral champing, restless weight shifting from foot to foot, sawhorse stance,
mild diarrhea, and frequent urination. The goats do not eat or drink but paw food
and water as though they are hungry but unable to prehend.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1830
Sisk
DBB
Acute, fatal illness in cattle exposed to boron fertilizer
J Am Vet Med Assoc
193
1988
943
946
2848002
Bromide Toxicosis
Bromide salts are available in several forms including sodium bromide, potassium bromide,
and methyl bromide.1, 2, 3 Potassium bromide has been added to horse feed and studied
in horses for treatment of epilepsy.1, 2 Sodium bromide is commonly used in swimming
pools as an alternative to chlorine and in the petroleum industry around oil wells.
Methyl bromide is a soil fumigant once commonly used worldwide. Because of its effect
on the ozone layer, a planned phase out of methyl bromide will be complete in 2015.
3
Ingestion of methyl bromide–contaminated oat hay by horses, goats, and cattle and
sodium bromide–pelleted feed by cattle has resulted in toxicosis. Clinical signs are
neurologic in nature and include ataxia, weakness, and lethargy.
Further Reading
Knight
HD
Costner
GC
Bromide intoxication of horses, goats, and cattle
J Am Vet Med Assoc
171
1977
446
903290
Knight
HD
Reina-Guerra
M
Intoxication of cattle with sodium bromide-contaminated feed
Am J Vet Res
38
1977
407
851273
Lynn
G
Grain fumigant residues, occurrence of bromides in the milk of cows fed sodium bromide
and grain fumigated with methyl bromide
J Agric Food Chem
11
1963
87
91
References
1
Peacock
RE
Aust Vet J
91
2013
320
23889097
2
Raidal
SL
Aust Vet J
86
2008
187
18454837
3
Ruzo
LO
Pest Manag Sci
62
2006
99
16308867
Organic Toxins Affecting the Nervous System
Anthelmintic Toxicosis
Anthelmintics are drugs used to treat infections with parasitic worms. This includes
both flat worms (e.g., flukes and tapeworms) and round worms (i.e., nematodes). Poisoning
associated with most of the newer anthelmintics is rare and usually caused by an accidental
overdose in individual animals or a mixing error when added to feed. Older anthelmintics
carry the burden of higher toxicity, but fortunately their use has declined dramatically.
Commonly Used Anthelmintics
Commonly used anthelmintics include the following groups:
•
Amino-acetonitrile derivatives (monepantel)
•
Benzimidazoles and probenzimidazoles (albendazole, fenbendazole, etc.)
•
Cyclic octadepsipeptides (emodepside)
•
Imidazothiazoles (levamisole)
•
Macrocyclic lactones ([MLs] ivermectin, moxidectin, doramectin)
•
Miscellaneous (Piperazine, clorsulon)
•
Praziquantel/epsiprantel
•
Salicylanilides/substituted phenols (closantel, rafoxanide, oxyclozanide)
•
Tetrahydropyrimidines (pyrantel and morantel)
Older Anthelmintics
Older, rarely used anthelmintics include:
•
Carbon tetrachloride
•
Hexachloroethane
•
Hexachlorophene
•
Nicotine
•
Phenothiazines
•
Sumicidin (fenvalerate)
•
Tetrachlorethylene
Currently Used Anthelmintics
Amino-Acetonitrile Derivatives (Monepantel)
Amino-acetonitrile derivatives (ADD) are a group of synthetic compounds with activity
against intestinal nematodes. Anthelmintics in this group work by binding to an MPTL-1,
nematode-specific acetylcholine receptor.
1
Monepantel, an ADD, was originally marketed in New Zealand as a drench for sheep,
but it is now used in Australia, South America, Europe, and other countries.1, 2 Oral
administration to sheep at 5× the recommended dose every 3 weeks × 8 treatments did
not result in any adverse effects.
1
No adverse effects were noted in ewes when given 3× the recommended dose every 5 days
for their entire reproductive cycle.
2
Benzimidazoles (Albendazole, Fenbendazole, and Thiabendazole) and Probenzimidazoles
(Febantel, Netobimin, etc.)
The benzimidazoles are generally not water soluble and thus poorly absorbed from the
gastrointestinal tract. Probenzimidazoles must be absorbed and metabolized into their
respective active compounds. The mechanism of action of this group is inhibition of
parasitic β-tubulin, which generally makes them safe drugs.
3
Many of them, however, are contraindicated in pregnancy because of antimitotic activity
with resultant embryo toxicity and teratogenicity.3, 4
Albendazole, Cambendazole, and Parbendazole
Albendazole at four times the standard dose produces some fetal abnormalities if given
early in pregnancy. Cambendazole and parbendazole are teratogens and are specifically
contraindicated in pregnant animals, especially during the first third of the pregnancy
and at dose rates higher than normal. The safety margin is small, and their use at
any dose level is not recommended in these females. Defects produced include rotational
and flexing deformities of the limbs, overflexion of the carpal joints, abnormalities
of posture and gait, vertebral fusion and asymmetric cranial ossification, cerebral
hypoplasia, and hydrocephalus.
Fenbendazole
A dose of fenbendazole and the flukicide bromsalans to cattle either simultaneously
or within a few days of each other may be accompanied by deaths. Because fenbendazole
and the other tertiary benzimidazoles, oxfendazole and albendazole, are extremely
valuable in removing dormant Ostertagia ostertagi larvae, it is suggested that Fascol
(bromsalans) should not be used when this is an important problem or if 2 weeks should
elapse between treatments.
Thiabendazole
At an oral dose rate of 800 mg/kg BW in sheep, transient signs of salivation, anorexia,
and depression appear. There are similar signs at larger dose rates, and death is
likely at a dose rate of 1200 mg/kg BW. Toxic nephrosis is the cause of death and
is reflected in the clinical and pathologic findings of hypokalemia, hypoproteinemia,
and uremia.
Cyclic Octadepsipeptides (Emodepside)
Currently emodepside is the only commercially available member of this group, and
it is registered in the United States and Europe for use in dogs and cats.
1
It has been used experimentally in sheep and cattle and found to be effective and
safe.1, 5 Anthelmintics in the groups have a dual mechanism of action, binding to
a SLO-1, calcium-activated potassium channel SLO-1 and binding to am HC110R, latrophilin-like
receptor. The result is inhibition of pharyngeal muscle activity in parasites resulting
in death.1, 5
Imidazothiazoles (Levamisole)
All commercial preparations of levamisole consist of the levo isomer. Its mechanism
of action is similar to nicotine by causing prolonged depolarization and neuromuscular
junction blockade resulting in parasympathetic stimulation and cholinergic type signs.6,
7 The absorption of levamisole is rapid regardless of the route of administration.
Elimination is rapid with an elimination half-life of 2.34 hours (intramuscularly)
and 5.44 hours (orally) in sheep, 1.44 hours (orally) in goats, and 6.9 hours (intramuscularly)
and 9.3 hours (orally) in swine.
8
There are some human health implications because levamisole may be found in meat,
milk, and cheese especially in toxic situations. The withdrawal period of sheep is
13 days, goats 9 days, swine 11 days, and beef and milk from dairy cows 48 hours.
8
A recent study involving six dairy cows receiving levamisole at 5 mg/kg BW and oxyclozanide
at 10 mg/kg BW showed levamisole residues greater than 0.83 µg/kg for the first 10
milkings and concentration of levamisole residues in soft, hard, and whey cheeses.
9
Accidental injection of pigs caused vomiting, salivation, ataxia, recumbency, and
a high mortality within a few minutes of injection. In pigs, concurrent treatment
with levamisole and pyrantel tartrate resulted in enhanced toxicity of the levamisole.
6
Sheep accidentally receiving a double dose of levamisole as a drench developed depression,
head-shaking, muscle tremors, spastic movements, and diarrhea.
7
Levamisole used during the breeding season has an adverse effect on the semen quality
in rams when used as an anthelmintic and on pregnancy in ewes when used as an immunomodulatory
agent.
10
Double doses in goats produce mild depression and ptosis, whereas higher doses produce,
in addition, head-shaking, twitching of facial muscles, grinding of teeth, salivation,
tail-twitching, increased micturition, and straining.
Following treatment at standard doses, some cattle show signs of lip-licking, increased
salivation, head-shaking, skin tremors, and excitability. The excitability is more
marked in calves; when released they tend to raise their tails and run around the
paddock. Coughing may commence within 15 to 20 minutes, but this is from the death
and expulsion of lung worms and stops in 24 hours. With higher doses, the signs are
more pronounced, defecation is frequent, and hyperesthesia in the form of a continuous
twitching of the skin may be seen.
Macrocyclic Lactones (Ivermectin, Moxidectin, and Doramectin)
Macrocyclic lactones are insecticides, acaricides, and nematicides in a number of
species and are covered in a separate chapter.
Miscellaneous (Piperazine and Clorsulon)
Piperazine
Piperazine acts to block neuromuscular transmission in the parasite resulting in flaccid
paralysis and rapid expulsion of parasites. Piperazine should not be used in animals
with a heavy parasite load, in particular foals, because it may result in an ascarid-impaction
colic or intestinal perforation.
Piperazine compounds are relatively nontoxic but poisoning can occur in horses on
normal or excessive doses. Signs follow a delay of 12 to 24 hours and include incoordination,
pupillary dilation, hyperesthesia, tremor, somnolence, and either swaying while at
rest or lateral recumbency. Recovery follows in 48 to 72 hours without treatment.
Clorsulon
Clorsulon is a sulfonamide used primarily in the treatment of liver flukes in cattle
and sheep. It has a high margin of safety and few reports of toxicosis. Infected sheep
treated with 100 mg/kg showed no adverse effects and neither did uninfected sheep
treated with 200 mg/kg and 400 mg/kg. No acute toxic dose is recorded for cattle,
although cows treated with 25× the label dose showed no changes in weight gain or
feed consumption.
11
Uninfected goats treated with 35 mg/kg every other day for three doses showed no adverse
effects.
11
Clorsulon is distributed to muscle and secreted into milk so appropriate precautions
need to be taken both with normal use and in overdose situations.
Praziquantel/Epsiprantel
Praziquantel and epsiprantel are effective against cestode parasites in most species
of animals and humans.
12
Both products have a wide margin of safety, and reports of toxicity in large animals
are scarce.
Salicylanilides/Substituted Phenols (Closantel, Rafoxanide, and Oxyclozanide)
Closantel, rafoxanide, and oxyclozanide are halogenated salicylanilides effective
against Fasciola spp. in sheep and have approximately the same low level of toxicity
if dosed appropriately. They are capable of causing CNS signs including temporary
or permanent blindness if overdosed, especially in small rumianants.13, 14 Overdosed
sheep and goats developed retinal lesions characterized by necrosis, loss of the photoreceptor
layer, and retinal separation.
14
Status spongiosus of the cerebral and cerebellar white matter were consistent findings
at postmortem.
14
All three drugs are highly protein bound and have very long terminal half-lives (closantel,
14.5 days; rafoxanide, 16.6 days; oxyclozanide, 6.4 days) in sheep. Associated with
their use are tissue residues and the need for long withholding times.
Tetrahydropyrimidines (Pyrantel and Morantel)
Pyrantel, either as pamoate or tartrate salt, is widely used in horses and pigs and,
to a lesser extent, ruminants. Morantel tartrate, the methyl ester, is more widely
used in ruminants. There are two mechanisms of action.
15
The first mechanism is inhibition of fumarate reductase, whereas the second mechanism
is a direct action on acetylcholine receptors at the neuromuscular junction. It is
the second mechanism that is responsible for paralysis and death of the parasite.
All of these drugs have been on the market for over 30 years and are considered safe
in most species studied. Pyrantel pamoate is labeled for administration to mares a
month before foaling; no adverse reactions were reported when it was administered
at the recommended dose to pregnant mares or breeding stallions. No adverse reactions
were reported when pyrantel tartrate was administered at the recommended dose to pregnant
mares or breeding stallions. Horses dosed with pyrantel tartrate at 100 mg/kg BW developed
incoordination, sweating, and an increased respiratory rate. Cattle dosed at 200 mg/kg
morantel tartrate (20× the recommended dose) did not exhibit any adverse effects.
Morantel tartrate has a 14-day meat withdrawal in cattle, but no milk withholding
time.
Older Anthelmintics
Carbon Tetrachloride
Carbon tetrachloride is sometimes accidentally administered in excessive quantities
but deaths are more common when sheep are given standard doses or cattle are dosed
by mouth instead of by injection. Standard doses of 2 mL per sheep to kill adult Fasciola
hepatica or 1 mL/10 kg BW to obtain efficacy against immature forms, have been widely
used but in some circumstances these doses can be highly toxic. Doses as low as 0.5 mL/10 kg
BW can be associated with liver damage in calves, and clinical effects are apparent
at 1 mL/10 kg BW in goats.
Inhalation of carbon tetrachloride is associated with an immediate and acute depression
of the CNS and peripheral and circulatory collapse. Diffuse pulmonary edema occurs
and sheep that survive show hepatic and renal damage. Ingestion of toxic doses may
result in death within 24 hours because of anesthetic depression and severe pulmonary
edema, or may occur 3 to 7 days later resulting from renal and hepatic insufficiency.
Deaths are associated with almost complete liver and kidney failure.
In gross overdosing or inhalation there is an immediate onset of staggering, falling,
progressive narcosis, collapse, convulsions, and death caused by respiratory failure.
Animals that survive this stage or, as in the most common form of carbon tetrachloride
poisoning in which animals absorb insufficient dose to produce narcosis, additional
signs may be manifested in 3 to 4 days. These include anorexia, depression, muscle
weakness, diarrhea, and jaundice. After a further 2 to 3 days affected sheep go down
and mild-to-moderate clonic convulsions may occur, but death is always preceded by
a period of coma. Survivors are emaciated and weak, and may develop photosensitization
or shed their wool. They are very susceptible to environmental stresses, particularly
inclement weather, and isolated deaths may occur for several months.
Animals dying after inhalation of the drug show marked pulmonary, hepatic, and renal
damage. Those dying of massive oral overdosing may show abomasitis and inflammation
of the duodenum. In addition acute hepatic swelling, pallor, and mottling accompanied
by centrilobular necrosis and fatty degeneration, and renal lesions of extensive tubular
necrosis and degeneration, are observed in animals that die after the ingestion of
small doses.
Hexachloroethane
Hexachloroethane is preferred to carbon tetrachloride for the treatment of fascioliasis
in cattle, but it is not completely without danger. Deaths are rare (1 in 20,000)
cattle treated and in sheep (1 in 40,000), but nonfatal illness is not uncommon. Susceptible
groups may show narcosis, muscle tremor, and recumbency after administration of the
standard dose (cattle, 15 g per 6 months of age up to a maximum of 60 g; sheep, 0.4 g/kg
BW); such animals should be given half this dose on two occasions at 48-hour intervals.
Animals with large overdoses show ataxia, dullness, anorexia, dyspnea, ruminal tympany,
and sometimes abdominal pain, diarrhea, and dysentery. Necropsy lesions include acute
abomasitis and enteritis, edema of the abomasal mucosa, and hepatic centrilobular
necrosis. Treatment with calcium borogluconate as in milk fever elicits a good response.
Hexachlorophene
At high dose rates (25–50 mg/kg BW) hexachlorophene is associated with atrophy of
seminiferous epithelium of the testis of young adult rams. Repeated dosing is associated
with periportal fatty changes in liver.
Nicotine
Nicotine poisoning seldom occurs in animals except in lambs and calves in which nicotine
sulfate is still incorporated in some vermifuges. Doses of 0.2 to 0.3 g nicotine sulfate
have been toxic for lambs weighing 14 to 20 kg. Animals in poor condition are more
susceptible than well-nourished animals. Animals are affected within a few minutes
of dosing and show dyspnea with rapid shallow respirations, muscle tremor and weakness,
recumbency, and clonic convulsions. Animals that survive the acute episode may show
abdominal pain, salivation, and diarrhea. At necropsy there may be abomasitis and
inflammation of the duodenum.
Phenothiazine
Exposure to phenothiazine has occurred in the past from its extensive use as an anthelmintic.
Keratitis, a noteworthy sign of poisoning, is most common in calves, rarely in pigs
and goats, and usually after a heavy single dose of phenothiazine, but it can occur
in a program of daily intake in a dietary premix. Phenothiazine is absorbed from the
rumen as the sulfoxide, conjugated in the liver and excreted in the urine as leukophenothiazine
and leukothionol. As urine is voided, further oxidation turns the metabolic products
to a red-brown dye, phenothiazine and thionol, which may be confused as hematuria
or hemoglobinuria.
Cattle are unable to detoxify all the sulfoxide and some escapes into the circulation
and can enter the aqueous humor of the eye, causing photosensitization. Other photodynamic
agents that cannot enter the eye may also be produced, and they, with the sulfoxide,
are associated with photosensitization of light-colored parts of the body. Hyperlacrimation
with severe blepharospasm and photophobia commences 12 to 36 hours after treatment
and is followed by the development of a white opacity on the lateral or dorsal aspects
of the cornea, depending on which is exposed to sunlight. Most animals recover within
a few days, particularly if kept inside or in a shaded paddock. If the animals continue
to be exposed, a severe conjunctivitis with keratitis may result.
Sumicidin
Sumicidin (fenvalerate) is a synthetic pyrethroid anthelmintic capable of causing
nonfatal restlessness, yawning, frothing at the mouth, dyspnea, ear and tail erection,
pupillary dilation, ruminal tympany, regurgitation of ruminal contents, staggering,
tremor, clonic convulsions, and recumbency after a single oral dose. Single oral doses
of >450 mg/kg are lethal. Repeated daily dosing (113 mg/kg BW or 225 mg/kg BW) also
causes death after 5 to 15 days.
Tetrachlorethylene
Tetrachlorethylene rarely produces incoordination, which may be evident for 1 or 2
hours after dosing in cattle or sheep. Treatment is not usually necessary.
Further Reading
Cornwell
RL
Jones
RM
Controlled laboratory trials with pyrantel tartrate in cattle
Br Vet J
126
1970
134
141
5440609
Dayan
AD
Albendazole, mebendazole and praziquantel. Review of non-clinical toxicity and pharmacokinetics
Acta Trop
86
2003
151
159
Delatour
P
Parish
R
Benzimidazole Anthelmintics and Related Compounds: Toxicity and Evaluation of Residues
1986
Academic Press
Orlando, FL
McKellar
QA
Jackson
F
Veterinary anthelmintics: old and new
Trends Parasitol
20
2004
456
15363438
McSherry
BJ
The hematology of phenothiazine poisoning in horses
Can Vet J
7
1966
3
17421795
Radostits
O
Poisoning by anthelmintics
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1830
Van Cauteren
H
Vandenberghe
J
Hérin
V
Toxicological properties of closantel
Drug Chem Toxicol
8
3
1985
101
123
4054009
Von Samson-Himmelstjerna
G
Efficacy of two cyclooctadepsipeptides, PF1022A and emodepside, against anthelmintic-resistant
nematodes in sheep and cattle
Parasitology
130
2005
343
346
15796017
References
1
Epe
N
Trends Parasitol
29
2013
129
23376212
2
Malikides
N
New Zeal Vet J
57
2009
192
3
Danaher
M
J Chromatography
845
2007
1
4
Teruel
M
Biocell
35
2011
29
21667669
5
Crisford
A
Mol Pharmacol
79
2011
1031
21415309
6
Hsu
WH
Martin
RJ
Antiparasitic agents
Hsu
WH
Handbook of Veterinary Pharmacology
2013
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
379
7
Rahimi
S
Iran J Vet Med
6
2008
12
8
Zanon
RB
J Vet Pharmacol Ther
36
2013
298
22913476
9
Whelan
M
J Agric Food Chem
58
2010
12204
21058728
10
Pancarci
SM
Bull Vet Inst Pulawy
51
2007
253
11
Lanusse
CE
Anticestodal and antitrematodal drugs
Rivere
JE
Papich
MG
Veterinary Pharmacology and Therapeutics
9th ed
2009
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
1095
12
Slocombe
J
Vet Parasitol
144
2007
366
17101225
13
Ecco
R
Vet Rec
159
2006
564
17056655
14
Van der Lugt
JJ
Comp Pathol
136
2007
87
15
Elsheikha
HM
McOrist
S
Antiparasitic drugs: Mechanisms of action and resistance
Elsheikha
HM
Khan
NA
Essentials of Veterinary Parasitology
2011
Caister Academic Press
Norfolk, UK
87
Macrocyclic Lactone (Ivermectin, Moxidectin, etc.) Toxicosis
Synopsis
Etiology Exposure to any of the macrocyclic lactone compounds including abamectin,
doramectin, eprinomectin, ivermectin, and moxidectin.
Epidemiology Wide application as insecticides, nematicides, and ascaricides. Ivermectin
is most popular because of safety and efficacy. Agricultural uses include miticides,
ascaricide, and insecticide.
Clinical pathology Nonspecific changes in CBC and elevations in liver enzymes; increases
in plasma and milk concentrations of specific compound.
Lesions Nonspecific postmortem lesions.
Diagnostic Confirmation Clinical signs, history of exposure, analysis of tissue or
body fluids.
Treatment No antidote, supportive care; intravenous intralipid emulsion in individual
cases.
Control Use appropriate dose for size and weight of animal; keep agricultural and
crop products stored where animals cannot access them.
CBC, complete blood count.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Ivermectin, the most widely recognized of the group, is a semisynthetic ML originally
obtained from Streptomyces avermitilis.
1
It is approved for oral or injectable use as an endectocide in horses, cattle, sheep,
goats, swine, and many other species but not lactating cattle, sheep, and goats.1,
2 Abamectin is a mixture of ivermectin B1a and B1b used primarily as an injectable
product in cattle. Other ML endectocides used in livestock include doramectin (injectable
and pour-on), eprinomectin (pour-on), and moxidectin (oral, injectable, pour-on).3,
4, 5, 6, 7 They are also agricultural products used on crops and fields as miticides,
ascaricides, and insecticides.
8
Epidemiology
The MLs have a wide margin of safety in most species when used at the recommended
doses and according to label directions. Clinical signs of toxicosis in all species
involve neurologic dysfunction as well as some gastrointestinal disturbances.
9
Many of the case reports involve younger animals and are caused by an incomplete blood-brain
barrier, failure to adequately estimate weight, or massive overdoses.5, 10 There have
been case reports of adult horses developing neurologic signs when administered the
recommended dose of ivermectin. These may be caused by the presence of a toxic plant,
other medications, low body fat, or other physiologic reasons.
Eight-month-old Jersey bull calves receiving 600 µg/kg BW either intravenously or
subcutaneously developed neurologic signs including depression, ataxia, and miosis.
Calves receiving 8 mg/kg BW developed neurologic signs and became recumbent 24 hours
after dosing with ivermectin.
11
Horses receiving 6 to 10 times the recommended dose of ivermectin developed ataxia,
depression, and vision impairment within 24 hours of dosing. Three horses displayed
classic signs of ivermectin toxicosis after receiving the normal recommended dose
and consuming toxic plants in the Solanum family.
12
Occurrence
Poisoning associated with MLs has been reported worldwide in a large number of animal
species most often secondary to an inadvertent overdose or misuse of the product.
Agricultural use of the product as a miticide, insecticide, or ascaricide opens the
door to herd problems should animals be exposed to bulk quantities.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Reports of toxicosis are most common in horses and often in foals. In general, a dosing
error has occurred and the animal has received several times the recommended dose.9,
10 Signs of toxicosis have been reported with normal doses, but these often occur
in conjunction with another compound or substance.
11
Environmental Risk Factors
MLs are excreted in the feces of treated animals and may contaminate the field or
act as a poison to nontarget species either directly through defecation or when manure
is spread in a pasture or field.13, 14
Pathogenesis
The pharmacokinetic properties of MLs depend on the dose, specific formulation, and
route of administration. In general, MLs are slowly absorbed, widely distributed throughout
the body to fat and liver, poorly metabolized, and excreted primarily unchanged in
the feces.1, 5 Up to 90% of ivermectin and 77% of moxidectin are excreted via bile
into the feces.1, 6 At normal doses they do not cross the blood-brain barrier of healthy,
adult large animals, which his due primarily to action of the P-glycoprotein transporter
system.5, 6 They are lipophilic, in particular moxidectin, and thus the lack of body
fat may play a role in the elimination half-life and toxicity in debilitated animals.
5
In the absence of body fat, MLs concentrate in the serum and may reach levels high
enough to overcome the blood-brain barrier.
5
They exert their toxic effects by binding to GABA and glutamate-gated chloride channels.
Binding to glutamate-gated chloride channels results in hyperpolarization and paralysis
of the parasite's pharyngeal pump musculature.1, 5, 6 Glutamate-gated chloride channels
are present only in nematodes and arthropods. In animal species, GABA-gated channels
are only found in the CNS and poisoning does not occur unless the P-glycoprotein transporter
is overwhelmed or compromised and MLs are allowed to enter.
Clinical Findings
Clinical signs in horses are primarily those of neurologic dysfunction.9, 10, 12,
15 Intoxicated horses are ataxic and stand base wide with the head down. Muscle tremors,
head-pressing, impaired vision, and facial nerve abnormalities including ptosis. have
been reported. Mydriasis is commonly reported. Other signs include hyperthermia, colic,
seizures, and recumbency. Similar signs have been reported in other species including
cattle and pigs.
1
Necropsy Findings
Postmortem findings are nonspecific. Tissues and body fluids (serum and milk) may
be analyzed for the presence of ML compounds using high-performance lipid chromatography.
16
Gastrointestinal contents, feces, fat, and liver are the best specimens to submit
for postmortem analysis.
6
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list
•
Blue-green algae toxicosis
•
Central nervous system trauma
•
Encephalitis
•
Hepatic encephalopathy
•
Organophosphorus compound or carbamate toxicosis
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no antidote for ML toxicosis and treatment is symptomatic and supportive.
Activated charcoal should be administered in recent overdoses when the animal is stable;
multiple doses are recommended because MLs undergo enterohepatic recirculation. Methocarbamol
has been recommended for tremors, diazepam or phenobarbital for seizures, and intravenous
fluids for rehydration.9, 10, 12 Physostigmine is no longer recommended because of
the incidence of seizures. Sarmazenil, a benzodiazepine agonist effective at GABA
receptor sites, at 0.04 mg/kg BW intravenously every 2 hours × 6 doses has been used
with equivocal success.5, 10
An intravenous intralipid emulsion (ILE) containing 20% soybean oil in water has been
used successfully in the treatment of ivermectin and moxidectin overdoses in dogs17,
18 and was successful in treating a large overdose in a miniature Shetland pony.
10
The mechanism of action of ILEs in drug overdoses is not completely understood. When
associated with lipophilic drug overdoses, it may act as a vascular “lipid sink,”
pulling drugs from the CNS back into the systemic circulation in which they can be
metabolized and/or excreted.
10
There currently is no specified dose in large animals; the recommended small animal
dose is a bolus of 1.5 mL/kg BW slowly over 1 to 3 minutes, followed by an infusion
of 0.25 to 0.5 mL/kg BW over 30 to 60 minutes.
19
The dose (0.25 mL/kg BW) may be repeated in 4 to 6 hours if there is no evidence of
lipemia in the serum.
10
Treatment and Control
Sarmazenil (0.04 mg/kg BW IV every 2 hours × 6 doses) (R3)
Intralipid emulsion (20% soybean oil) (1.5 mL/kg BW as IV bolus over 1–3 minutes,
followed by an infusion of 0.25–0.5 mL/kg BW over 30–60 minutes) (R2)
BW, body weight; IV, intravenous.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
Careful attention should be paid to administration as most of the case reports revolve
around errors in administration, primarily because of miscalculation of an animal's
weight or failure to read and follow directions. As with all anthelmintics and insecticides,
MLs should be kept in an area where animals cannot access them.
Further Reading
Anderson
RR
The use of ivermectin in horses: research and clinical observations
Comp Cont Edu
6
1994
S517
S520
Toutain
PL
Upson
DW
Terhune
TN
Comparative pharmacokinetics of doramectin and ivermectin in cattle
Vet Parasitol
72
1997
3
8
9403971
References
1
Canga
AG
Vet J
179
2009
25
17851096
2
Sheridan
R
J Assoc Anal Comm Int
89
2006
1088
3
Durden
DA
J Chromatogr B
850
2007
134
146
4
Gokbulut
C
J Vet Pharmacol Ther
36
2013
302
23106448
5
Schumacher
J
Equine Vet Educ
20
2008
546
6
Cobb
R
Parasit Vectors
2
2009
1756
7
Gokbulut
C
Vet Parasitol
170
2010
120
20181429
8
Wislocki
PG
Environmental aspects of abamectin use in crops
Campbell
WC
Ivermectin and Abamectin
2011
Springer-Verlag
182
2nd reissue
9
Plummer
CE
Vet Ophthalmol
9
2006
29
16409242
10
Bruenisholz
H
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
407
22300298
11
Cankas
GR
Gordon
LR
Toxicology
Campbell
WC
Ivermectin and Abamectin
2011
Springer-Verlag
89
2nd reissue
12
Norman
TE
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
143
13
Fernandez
C
Soil Sed Contam
18
2009
564
14
Floate
KD
Can J Vet Res
70
2006
1
16548326
15
Swor
TM
J Am Vet Med Assoc
125
2009
558
16
Kaoliang
P
Vet Res Commun
30
2006
263
16437302
17
Bates
N
Vet Rec
172
2013
339
23423482
18
Crandall
DE
J Vet Emerg Crit Care
19
2009
181
19
Plumb
DC
Fat emulsion
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
409
Organophosphorus Compounds and Carbamate Insecticides
Synopsis
Etiology Poisoning by accidental exposure or overdosing with any one of the very large
number of insecticides in these two groups of organic compounds.
Epidemiology Outbreaks occur from overdosing, use of oil-based preparations formulated
for use on nonanimal surfaces, dehydrated animals, drift of spray from orchards, field
crops to pasture.
Clinical pathology Marked depression of blood cholinesterase levels.
Lesions
Acute disease: no diagnostic lesions.
Delayed neurotoxicity: degenerative lesions in peripheral nerves and spinal cord.
Diagnostic confirmation Depressed cholinesterase levels in blood; organophosphate
or carbamate in feed or environment.
Treatment Atropine in large doses to effect or atropine plus 2-PAM; remove residual
toxin from hair coat; prevent absorption from gastrointestinal tract with activated
charcoal and cathartics.
Control Avoid use in stressed, especially dehydrated, animals. Special constraints
with chlorpyrifos.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Organophosphorus (OP) compounds and carbamates act in essentially the same manner
therapeutically and toxicologically, but bonding of the compound to the esterase enzyme
is irreversible in the OP compounds and spontaneously degradable with the carbamates,
rendering the carbamates potentially less dangerous. A large number of compounds are
included in the group, and those used for the direct treatment of animals have been
selected for their low toxicity. A vast amount of information is available on the
relative toxicities of the many compounds but it is not possible to provide details
here and the information does not lend itself to summarization.
1
Epidemiology
Occurrence
All animal species are affected. OP compound and carbamate poisoning in animals may
occur less frequently as safer insecticides are developed.
2
Source of Toxin
•
Grazing in recently sprayed areas, particularly orchards in which the most toxic compounds
are frequently used
•
Spray used on cereal crops and in orchards carried by wind onto pasture fields
•
Hay or cubes made from plants sprayed with organophosphate compounds
•
Inadvertent access to granular insecticides intended for crops
•
Use of old insecticide containers as feeding utensils
•
Contamination of water supplies
•
Too high a concentration of the insecticide in a spray
•
Storage toxicity of some compounds appears to increase with storage
•
Application to animals of products containing oily bases designed specifically for
spraying on walls or plants
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Susceptible groups include the following:
•
Young animals (but with some compounds adults are more so), stressed, water-deprived,
and chilled animals; the increased susceptibility caused by restriction of water intake
is noted especially after oral treatment to control warble fly infestations.
•
Pregnant females in that congenital defects occur in their offspring.
•
Brahman and Brahman-cross cattle appear to be more susceptible to some compounds than
other cattle.
•
Dorset Down sheep may be especially susceptible.
•
Chlorpyrifos is more toxic for male animals with high blood levels of testosterone
and is not recommended for use in bulls over 8 months of age.
Environmental Risk Factors
The introduction of these compounds into animal therapeutics as treatments for nematode,
botfly, sheep nasal botfly, and warble fly infestations and as insecticidal sprays
on plants and soil has increased their importance as possible causes of poisoning
and as causes of pollution of milk, meat, and eggs. They also have a role in the poisoning
of native birdlife and other nontarget animals.
2
Transmission
•
Formulation used, especially the solvent or vehicle used and droplet size
•
Method of application, e.g., the toxicity of pour-ons is delayed by 24 hours compared
with sprays
Pathogenesis
OP compounds are highly toxic and readily absorbed by ingestion, inhalation, and by
percutaneous and perconjunctival absorption. Once absorbed, sulfur-containing OPs
(phosphorothioates and phosphorodithioates) are metabolized by mixed function oxidases
(MFOs) and sulfur is exchanged for oxygen, thus increasing toxicity. There are two
forms of toxicity: cholinesterase inactivation and an OP-induced, delayed neurotoxicity.
Cholinesterase Inactivation
The inactivation of cholinesterase by these OP compounds is associated with an increase
in acetylcholine in tissues and increased activity of the parasympathetic nervous
system and of the postganglionic cholinergic nerves of the sympathetic nervous system.
The toxic effects thus reproduce the muscarinic and nicotinic responses of acetylcholine
administration. Differences between the toxicities of compounds depend on the stability
of this bonding between esterase and compound, and the toxicity of the substance formed
by the bonding.
The muscarinic effects of acetylcholine are the visceral responses of the respiratory
system and include marked respiratory distress caused by a decrease in dynamic lung
compliance and arterial oxygen tension and an increase in total pulmonary resistance;
there is bronchial constriction and increased mucous secretion by bronchiolar glands.
In the alimentary tract there is increased peristalsis and salivation. Effects in
other systems include hypotension and bradycardia, pupillary constriction, sweating,
and abortion.
The nicotinic effects are the skeletal muscle responses of twitching, tremor and tetany,
convulsions, opisthotonus, weakness, and flaccid paralysis. There is a difference
in the relative muscarinic and nicotinic responses between species, and the visceral
effects are more marked in ruminants and the muscular effects more evident in pigs
in which posterior paralysis is the common manifestation.
Organophosphorus-Induced Delayed Neurotoxicity
This form of toxicity is manifested by distal axonopathy commencing 1 or 2 weeks after
the poisoning incident. There is a dieback of neurons causing regional flaccid paralysis,
especially in long neurons. The pathogenesis of this lesion is the toxic end product
produced by the interaction between some OP compounds and the esterase, a phosphorylated
neurotoxic esterase. The most severe effects are associated with industrial OP compounds.
Typical examples include the following:
•
Congenital defects in young carried by poisoned pregnant females.
•
Bilateral laryngeal hemiplegia in horses.
•
Paralytic ileus may possibly be associated with chlorpyrifos toxicosis.
Haloxon, in particular, has this neurotoxic effect because it is associated with only
a slight depression in cholinesterase levels, but a neurotoxic response in the form
of hindlimb ataxia has been reported in a proportion of treated sheep and pigs. The
susceptibility of sheep is determined by each individual's genetic ability to metabolize
this class of OP compound.
Clinical Findings
Acute Poisoning
In general, signs of acute toxicity in animals may occur within minutes of inhalation
or ingestion of solutions of the more toxic compounds and deaths 2 to 5 minutes later.
After cutaneous application of dichlorvos to calves clinical signs appear within 30
minutes, peak at about 90 minutes, and disappear in 12 to 18 hours. With less toxic
compounds in solid form, signs may not appear for some hours and deaths may be delayed
for 12 to 24 hours.
Cattle, Sheep, and Goats
Acute Toxicosis
In acute cholinesterase inactivation the premonitory signs, and the only signs in
mild cases, are salivation, lacrimation, restlessness, nasal discharge, cough, dyspnea,
diarrhea, frequent urination, and muscle stiffness with staggering. Grunting dyspnea
is the most obvious, often audible from some distance because of the number affected.
Additional signs include protrusion of the tongue, constriction of the pupils with
resulting impairment of vision, muscle tremor commencing in the head and neck and
spreading over the body, bloat, collapse, and death with or without convulsions or
severe respiratory distress. In sheep and goats, the signs also include abdominal
pain. Signs disappear at 12 to 18 hours.
Delayed Neurotoxicity
In these cases, the signs do not appear for at least 8 days and up to 90 days after
the poisoning. Signs include posterior incoordination and paralysis. Chlorpyrifos
is a specific example of this kind of poisoning. It should not be applied to adult
dairy cattle or to mature bulls. The signs include anorexia, depression, recumbency,
a distended abdomen, ruminal stasis and diarrhea, and fluid splashing sounds on percussion
of the right flank. Severe dehydration develops and may result in death.
Pigs
Acute Toxicosis
In pigs acute cholinesterase inactivation visceral effects (except vomiting) are less
pronounced than in ruminants and salivation, muscle tremors, nystagmus, and recumbency
are characteristic. In some instances, the syndrome is an indefinite one with muscle
weakness and drowsiness the only apparent signs. Respiratory distress and diarrhea
do not occur.
Delayed Neurotoxicity
Outbreaks of posterior paralysis occur 3 weeks after dosing with an OP anthelmintic;
clinical signs vary in severity from knuckling in the hindlimbs to complete flaccid
paralysis. The hindlimbs may be dragged behind while the pigs walk on the front legs.
Affected pigs are bright and alert and eat well.
Horses
Acute Toxicosis
Signs include abdominal pain and grossly increased intestinal sounds, a very fluid
diarrhea, muscle tremors, ataxia, circling, weakness, and dyspnea. Increased salivation
occurs rarely. In foals, fluid diarrhea, which is a transient sign in moderate intoxication,
may be expanded to a severe gastroenteritis with heavier dose rates.
Delayed Neurotoxicity Syndrome
Bilateral laryngeal paralysis develops in foals after dosing with an OP anthelmintic.
Miscellaneous Signs of Organophosphorus Poisoning
•
Piglets with congenital defects of the nervous system manifested clinically by ataxia
and tremors are produced by sows dosed with OP compounds during pregnancy. Teratogenicity
may be a characteristic of only some OP compounds, e.g., trichlorfon is teratogenic
and dichlorvos is not.
•
A significant drop in conception rate when the administration is at the beginning
of estrus.
•
Most OP compounds are associated with only temporary interference with cholinesterase
and are not associated with any permanent effects in recovered animals. With some
compounds, especially coumaphos and ronnel, the recovery period may be quite long
(up to 3 months in the case of ronnel) because of slow excretion of the compound and
the combined compound-esterase complex.
•
Absorption of an OP compound may also be associated with significant changes in the
patient's cholinesterase status without causing clinical signs.
•
Potentiation of the action of succinylcholine chloride can occur for up to 1 month
after the administration of the OP compound in horses; the administration of the relaxant
to a sensitized horse can be followed by persistent apnea and death. This, and a number
of other interactions with drugs that may themselves have toxic effects, means that
the manufacturer's instructions for OP compounds must be followed explicitly.
Clinical Pathology
The estimation of cholinesterase in body tissues and fluids is the most satisfactory
method of diagnosing this poisoning, but it is essential that proper methods and standards
of normality be used. Convincing figures are of the order of 50% to 100% reduction
from normal controls. The degree and the duration of the depression of blood cholinesterase
levels varies with the dose rate and the toxicity of the compound used. Blood cholinesterase
levels are depressed for much longer than clinical signs are apparent, e.g., after
dichlorvos poisoning the depression of cholinesterase level in the blood does not
reach bottom until 12 hours after application, and the return to normal levels takes
7 to 14 days. Similarly, cholinesterase levels in cattle poisoned with terbufos, an
agricultural insecticide, do not commence to rise toward normal until 30 days and
are not normal for 150 days after the poisoning incident. Unlike organophosphate insecticides,
carbamate insecticide cholinesterase inhibitors may spontaneously reverse binding,
and cholinesterase depression may not be detectable in recently poisoned animals.
Suspected food material can be assayed for its content of OP compounds but assays
of animal tissues or fluids are virtually valueless and may be misleading.
Necropsy Findings
There are no gross or histologic lesions at necropsy in acute cholinesterase inactivation
cases, but tissue specimens could be collected for toxicologic analysis. Material
sent for laboratory analysis for cholinesterase should be refrigerated but not deep
frozen.
Distinctive degenerative lesions in peripheral nerves and spinal cord can be seen
in delayed neurotoxicity cases, and hypoplasia is visible in the cerebrum, cerebellum,
and spinal cord in congenitally affected piglets.
Differential Diagnosis
Outbreaks of a syndrome of dyspnea, salivation, muscle stiffness, and constriction
of the pupils after exposure plus a history of exposure and depressed blood levels
of cholinesterase suggest intoxication with these organophosphorus compounds, but
diagnostic confirmation requires positive assay results on suspected toxic materials.
In cattle the morbidity and case–fatality rates are approximately 100%, but in pigs
the recovery rate is good and all pigs may recover if intake has been low and access
is stopped. With the other poisons listed next, death is much more common in pigs,
and residual defects, including blindness and paralysis, occur in a proportion of
the survivors.
Differential diagnosis list
Cattle
•
Early stages of nicotine poisoning
•
Groups of cattle affected by acute bovine pulmonary emphysema and edema (fog fever)
•
Sporadic cases of anaphylaxis
Horses
•
Lead toxicosis
Pigs
•
Arsenic toxicosis
•
Avitaminosis A
•
Mercury poisoning
•
Sodium chloride (salt) poisoning
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Animals that have been dipped or sprayed should be washed with water to which soap
or a detergent is added to remove residual OP material. When oral intake has occurred,
activated charcoal will adsorb residual toxin in the gut.
Primary treatment is urgent and critical, especially in cattle because of the usually
high case–fatality rate. Atropine is the antidote for muscarinic effects, but does
not reverse the nicotinic effects of the OP compound, i.e., tremors, spasms, and convulsions.
The recommended dose in sheep and goats is 0.5 mg/kg BW with
Image 1
given intravenously and the remainder intramuscularly or subcutaneously.
3
This should be repeated every 3 to 4 hours for 1 to 2 days with salivation and heart
rate guiding therapy. Atropine appears to have low efficacy in sheep. This is not
a serious drawback because sheep are much less susceptible than cattle to larger doses
of atropine. The recommended dose of atropine in horses is 0.02 to 0.2 mg/kg BW intravenously
to effect,
3
but it needs to be given with care because horses are very susceptible to the gastrointestinal
effects of atropine.
Oximes, if available and economically feasible, may be useful in the early treatment
of poisoning from OP compounds. Their usefulness as antidotes declines rapidly with
the passage of time after the poisoning occurs, and they are of doubtful use after
24 hours. The most common oxime is pralidoxime chloride (2-PAM). The recommended dose
rate for 2-PAM in ruminants is 25 to 50 mg/kg BW given intravenously as a 20% solution
over 6 minutes.
4
In horses 2-PAM at doses of 20 mg/kg BW has given good results.
4
Treatment may need to be repeated for up to 10 days to counteract slower acting compounds
such as coumaphos.
Treatment and Control
Ruminants
Atropine sulfate (0.5 mg/kg BW with
Image 2
given IV and the remainder IM or SC; repeat every 3–4 hours for 1–2 days) (R1)
Pralidoxime chloride (2-PAM) (25–50 mg/kg BW IV as a 20% solution over 6 minutes.
Repeat as needed) (R2, depending on economics; not for herd use)
Horses
Atropine sulfate (0.02 to 0.2 mg/kg BW IV to effect; repeat judiciously SC every 1.5–2
hours) (R1, only if needed)
Pralidoxime chloride (2-PAM) (20 mg/kg BW IV; repeat every 4–6 hours as needed) (R2)
BW, body weight; IM, intramuscularly; IV, intravenously; SC, subcutaneously.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
Most outbreaks occur after accidental access to compounds. Animals to be treated orally
with OP insecticides should be permitted ample fresh drinking water beforehand. Use
of chlorpyrifos is restricted to beef cattle and not in calves less than 12 weeks
old or in bulls over 8 months of age.
Further Reading
Abdelsalam
EB
Factors affecting the toxicity of organophosphorus compounds in animals
Vet Bull
57
1987
441
448
Barrett
DS
A review of organophosphorus ester-induced delayed neurotoxicity
Vet Human Toxicol
27
1985
22
37
Radostits
O
Organophosphorus compounds and carbamates
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1834
Savage
EP
Chronic neurological sequelae of acute organophosphate pesticide poisoning
Arch Environ Health
43
1988
38
3355242
References
1
Karami-Mohajeri
S
Hum Exp Toxicol
30
2011
1119
21071550
2
Poppenga
RH
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
27
2011
379
3
Plumb
DC
Atropine
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
94
4
Plumb
DC
Pralidoxime chloride (2-PAM chloride)
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley-Blackwell
Ames, IA
842
Industrial Organophosphates
Principal industrial uses of organophosphates are as fire-resistant hydraulic fluids,
as lubricants, and as coolants. A number of compounds including tri-o-tolyl phosphate,
tri-o-cresyl phosphate (TOCP), and triaryl phosphates (TAP) have come to veterinary
notice as being associated with poisoning in animals. TAPs contain a number of isomers
as well as TOCP (e.g., m-cresol, p-cresol, o-cresol), and all of them are more poisonous
than TOCP. Poisoning may occur by ingestion or cutaneous absorption.
Clinical signs of delayed neurotoxicity do not occur until several weeks after contact
and include irreversible neurologic signs of respiratory stertor, dyspnea, dysuria,
knuckling, leg weakness, and posterior paralysis.
Diagnostic confirmation depends on evidence of exposure to the toxicant, signs referable
to the nervous system lesions, and a positive assay for the toxicant in the animal's
tissues. Necropsy lesions characteristically include neuronal degeneration in the
spinal cord and peripheral nerves.
Rotenone Toxicosis
Rotenone has been extensively used in the past to control bovine Hypoderma larvae
(cattle grubs). It is a neurotoxicant; chronic exposure results in degeneration of
neuronal cells, especially dopaminergic neurons.
1
Use as a pesticide and insecticide in the United States is being phased out, in part
because of its link to Parkinson's disease in humans.
2
It has a reputation for low mammalian toxicity but relatively high toxicity to aquatic
life. The mammalian oral LD50 is 100 to 300 mg/kg, whereas the LD50 for fish is less
than 100 µg/L of water. Oral absorption in mammals is limited but enhanced by fat
in the diet.
Ingesta at necropsy may contain as much as 2000 ppm of rotenone. Signs include salivation,
muscle tremor, vomiting, ascending paralysis, incoordination, quadriplegia, respiratory
depression, coma, and death. Accidental oral exposure may be treated with activated
charcoal, and an osmotic cathartic for decontamination followed by control of seizures
is needed. Phenothiazine tranquilizers are contraindicated in rotenone toxicosis.
Further Reading
Lapointe
N
Rotenone induces non-specific central nervous system and systemic toxicity
FASEB J
18
2004
717
719
14766796
Graham
OH
The potential of animal systemic insecticides for eradicating cattle grubs, Hypoderma
spp
J Econ Entomol
60
1967
1050
References
1
Watabe
M
Mol Pharmacol
74
2008
933
18599602
2
Tanner
CM
Environ Health Perspect
119
2011
866
21269927
Organochlorine Insecticides
Synopsis
Etiology Poisoning by any of the group of insecticides including aldrin, hexachloride,
chlordane, DDT, dieldrin, endrin, heptachlor, isodrin, lindane, methoxychlor, or toxaphene.
Epidemiology Accidental or misinformed overdosing. Usage on animals now superceded
by other less toxic compounds. Stored or leftover products may accidentally be accessed
by animals. It is important because of residues in animal products used in the human
food chain.
Clinical pathology Assay of compounds in animal tissues.
Lesions No consistent significant lesions; some animals show pale musculature.
Diagnostic confirmation Chemical assay of liver or brain for acute poisoning; fat
or other animal tissue for chronic poisoning.
Treatment. Supportive care only; control hyperthermia and seizures. Removal of residual
chemical; activated charcoal for oral detoxification.
Control Do not use these insecticides and store them appropriately.
DDT, dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
This group of poisons includes dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT), benzene hexachloride
(and its pure gamma isomer, lindane), aldrin, dieldrin, chlordane, toxaphene, methoxychlor,
dichlorodiphenyldichloroethane, isodrin, endrin, and heptachlor. Methoxychlor is less
toxic than DDT, and isodrin and endrin are more toxic than aldrin and dieldrin. Camphor
(2-bornanone) is chemically similar to toxaphene and is associated with a similar
syndrome when fed accidentally.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Poisoning with these compounds has been recorded in all animal species. The chlorinated
hydrocarbons have come under so much criticism as environmental contaminants that
they are rarely used directly on animals, so outbreaks of clinical illness associated
with them are much less common than they were.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
The compounds vary in their ability to pass the skin barrier. Benzene hexachloride,
aldrin, dieldrin, and chlordane are readily absorbed. Species susceptibility to skin
absorption also varies widely. Very young animals of any species are more susceptible
than adults, and lactating and emaciated animals also show increased susceptibility.
Farm or Premise Risk Factors
Many outbreaks are associated with the application to animals of products intended
for crops, e.g., endosulfan, and labeled specifically “Not For Animal Use.” These
insecticides may contaminate soil and persist there for many years. Rooting animals
such as pigs are particularly susceptible to this source of poisoning. These compounds
are also sometimes fed accidentally and in large amounts in lieu of feed additives,
and are associated with acute poisoning. In feedlot animals, signs may continue for
as long as a year because of repeated contamination from the environment. Insect baits,
e.g., grasshopper baits containing toxaphene and chlordane, used on pasture and for
leaf-eating insects on market gardens can be associated with poisoning in livestock,
which may eat large quantities of them. These insecticides, especially heptachlor,
are incorporated in the soil before the crop of potatoes or maize is sown to control
soil pests. Subsequent grazing of the field will cause contamination of the livestock
for several years.
Environmental Risk Factors
Organochlorines are closely regulated and banned in many countries primarily because
of their persistence in the environment, but some are still widely used in agriculture,
principally on growing plants to control insect pests and on stored seed grain to
control fungi. If the plants or grain, even milled and by-products, e.g., bran, are
fed to animals, they can be associated with problems of tissue residues; if they are
fed in sufficient quantities they can be associated with clinical illness.
Human Risk Factors
Because the compounds are soluble in fat and accumulate in body stores they are formidable
threats to the meat industry. They are also excreted in significant amounts in milk
and enter the human food chain at this point. They are concentrated still further
in cream and butter.
Transmission
Ingestion, inhalation, aspiration, and percutaneous absorption are all possible portals
of entry so that contamination of feed and application of sprays and dips can all
be associated with poisoning.
Method of Application
Dipping of animals is the most hazardous method of application because entry may occur
through all portals. Spraying is safer because percutaneous absorption and inhalation
are the only portals of entry. The small particle size of the compound and concentration
of animals in confined spaces while spraying increase the possibility of poisoning.
Oily preparations are not used for animal treatment but are used inadvertently and
are readily absorbed through the skin.
Formulation Used
Concentrations of insecticide in formulations used for spraying barns are much higher
than those used for animals. Among spray preparations simple solutions are most dangerous
followed by emulsions and, least of all, suspensions of wettable powder. Dusting is
safest and is preferred to other methods. Preparations for use on plants are often
unstable emulsions, which come out of suspension quickly when they reach the plant.
If these preparations are used in animal dips, the first few animals through the dip
can be heavily contaminated and suffer acute, lethal toxic effects. Although the treatment
of pastures to control their insect pests is usually safe to animals grazing, the
treated pasture or hay made from it can cause contamination of animal products. This
contamination can be avoided by incorporating the insecticide into superphosphate
granules (“prills”) instead of applying it as sprays or dusts.
Pathogenesis
The mechanism of action of organochlorines is to induce repetitive discharge of motor
and sensory neurons by interference with axonal transmission of nerve impulses. After
absorption, cyclodiene insecticides are activated by the MFO system, and any prior
chemical or environmental exposures that increase the MFO system may exacerbate the
onset of poisoning. The diphenyl aliphatic (DDT) organochlorines affect sodium channels,
prolonging sodium influx and inhibiting potassium efflux at the nerve membrane. The
cyclodiene organochlorines competitively inhibit the binding of GABA at receptor sites,
resulting in loss of GABA inhibition and resultant stimulation of the neuron. In all
organochlorine poisonings recovery may occur, but with smaller animals paralysis follows
and finally collapse and death ensue.
Most of the substances accumulate in the fat depots, where they are a potential source
of danger in that sudden mobilization of the fat may result in liberation of the compound
into the bloodstream and the appearance of signs of poisoning.
Clinical Findings
The speed of onset of illness after exposure varies from a few minutes to a few hours,
depending on the portal of entry and the compound and its formulation, but it is never
very long.
The toxic effects produced by the members of this group include complete anorexia,
increased excitability and irritability followed by ataxia, muscle tremor, weakness
and paralysis, and terminal convulsions in severe cases. Salivation and teeth grinding
occur in large animals and vomiting occurs in pigs. Variations on this clinical syndrome,
which is common to all organochlorine intoxications, include the following:
•
DDT and methoxychlor chronic poisoning may be associated with moderate liver damage.
•
Benzene hexachloride, lindane, chlordane, toxaphene, dieldrin, endrin, aldrin, and
heptachlor are associated with an exaggerated syndrome including teeth grinding, champing
of jaws, dyspnea, tetany, snapping of the eyelids, auricular spasms, opisthotonus,
frequent micturition, frenzied movements, walking backward, climbing walls, violent
somersaults, and aimless jumping. Fever of 5% to 7% above normal may occur, possibly
as a result of seizure activity. Seizures may persist for 2 or 3 days if the animal
does not die.
Clinical Pathology
Blood, hair, and ingesta can be assayed chemically for specific toxins. The removal
of a biopsy from the fat pad near the cow's tail offers a satisfactory means of providing
samples for tissue analysis. Organochlorine residues in acutely poisoned animals may
reach 4 to 7 ppm in brain or liver.
Necropsy Findings
At necropsy there are no specific major lesions in the nervous system, but toxic hepatitis
and tubular nephritis appear in some cases. Tissue levels need to be high to be good
indicators of recent intoxication. If possible, the specimens should be deep frozen,
and the suspected compound should be nominated because assay procedures are long and
involved.
Samples for Postmortem Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Specimens of hair, if the portal is percutaneous
•
Ingesta, if oral intake is probable
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list
•
Lead poisoning
•
Rabies
•
Pseudorabies of cattle
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Thromboembolic meningoencephalitis
•
Salt poisoning in pigs
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no specific primary treatment. Activated charcoal (2 g/kg) given early by
stomach tube will bind pesticide in rumen and reduce further absorption. The use of
mineral oil should be avoided because it will increase the absorption of lipid organochlorines.
Residual chemical should be removed from the coat with a degreasing soap and copious
water rinse. Supportive treatment includes sedation with diazepam or pentobarbital
sodium until signs disappear, monitoring and treating hyperthermia, and replacing
fluid losses.
Treatment to reduce the contamination of tissues is unsuccessful and in most cases
the time required for the contamination to subside varies between compounds but is
lengthy, taking 3 to 6 months or longer. For example, cows fed DDT prepartum need
an average of 189 days from parturition for the level in the milk fat to decline to
125 ppm. After the source of contamination is removed, drenching of cows with up to
2 kg of activated charcoal followed by daily incorporation in their feed for 2-week
intervals has been recommended for this purpose. Neither of these procedures is really
practical in the average farm operation. The common procedure for reducing the level
of tissue contamination in animals is to put them in a feedlot without any contact
with pasture and feed them on energy-intensive rations. Sheep decontaminate much more
quickly than cattle, and animals on a high plane of nutrition eliminate the toxins
more quickly.
Control
Avoidance of the use of the compounds is recommended.
Further Reading
Aslani
MR
Endosulfan toxicosis in calves
Vet Human Toxicol
38
1996
364
Booth
NH
McDowell
JR
Toxicity of hexachlorobenzene and associated residues in edible animal tissues
J Am Vet Med Assoc
166
1975
591
595
1091611
Marth
E
Stunzner D. Toxicokinetics of chlorinated hydrocarbons
J Hyg Epidemiol Microbiol Immunol
33
1989
514
520
Radostits
O
Chlorinated hydrocarbons
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1832
The history of organochlorine pesticides in Australia. (Accessed 10.12.2013, at http://www.apvma.gov.au/products/review/completed/organochlorines_history.php.).
Uzoukwu
M
Sleight
SD
Effects of dieldrin in pregnant sows
J Am Vet Med Assoc
160
1972
1641
1643
5033869
Sodium Fluoroacetate (Compound 1080) Toxicosis
Etiology
Sodium fluoroacetate in the form of compound 1080 is used as a potent rodenticide
in agriculture. It is currently used in the United States against coyotes and in Australia
and New Zealand against introduced species such as possums.1, 2 It is also formed
naturally by fluoride uptake from the soil and water in many plants that are native
to Africa, Australia, and Brazil. The toxic dose level for domestic animals including
sheep is 0.3 mg/kg BW,
3
and 0.4 mg/kg BW is lethal for cattle. Sublethal doses may be cumulative if given
at sufficiently short intervals.
Epidemiology
The use of fluoroacetate in agriculture poses a hazard for grazing farm animals because
it is usually spread out across fields combined with cereals, carrots, or bread as
bait and is attractive to ruminants.
Pathogenesis
Fluoroacetate in the body is converted to fluorocitrate, which inhibits the enzymes
aconitase and succinate dehydrogenase in the tricarboxylic acid cycle (Krebs cycle)
leading to the accumulation of significant amounts of citrate in tissues and to irreversible
cardiac damage. Two actions are manifest: CNS stimulation producing convulsions and
myocardial depression with ventricular fibrillation. In sheep the predominant effect
with acute poisoning is on the myocardium and the pulmonary system; in pigs and dogs
it is the nervous system.
Clinical Signs
Clinical signs vary widely among species. In herbivores, sudden death in acute cases
typically occurs. The animals are found dead without evidence of a struggle, or there
are tetanic convulsions and acute heart failure with the animals showing weakness
and dyspnea accompanied by cardiac arrhythmia, a weak pulse, and electrocardiographic
evidence of ventricular fibrillation.
In sheep with subacute poisoning, the signs are similar but are not apparent when
the animal is at rest. When they are disturbed, the nervous signs of tremor and convulsions
appear but disappear when the sheep lies down.
Pigs manifest the nervous form of the disease, including hyperexcitability and violent
tetanic convulsions. In all cases there is a period of delay of up to 2 hours after
ingestion before signs appear.
Clinical Pathology/Necropsy Findings
There are no specific lesions, but the tissues contain elevated levels of citrate.
Treatment/Control
No specific treatment is available. In cats, calcium gluconate and sodium succinate
have been used successfully in the treatment of experimental intoxication.
4
Care in the disposition of baits and highly dependable retrieval of uneaten baits
before allowing livestock access to baited fields preempts most mortalities.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1839
References
1
Proudfoot
AT
Tox Rev
25
2006
213
2
Eason
C
New Zeal J Ecol
35
2011
1
3
Gooneratne
SR
Onderstepoort J Vet Res
75
2008
127
18788206
4
Collicchio-Zuanaze
RC
Hum Exp Toxicol
25
2006
175
16696292
Molluscicide Toxicosis
Metaldehyde
Metaldehyde is the active ingredient in products used to control slugs and snails
(mollusks), mites, and insects.1, 2, 3 It is often used in combination with a carbamate,
such as methiocarb, and historically with calcium arsenate.
3
Metaldehyde is often bran based with molasses frequently added to attract snails and
slugs. It is a neurotoxicant to all mammals by inhalation, ingestion, and dermal exposure.
The mechanism of action is unknown, but it may be related to changes in the concentration
of neurotransmitters in the brain. Outbreaks have occurred in cattle, goats, sheep,
and horses.1, 2, 3 The acute lethal dose in adult cattle is 0.2 g/kg BW and less in
calves
3
; in horses it is 0.1 g/kg BW. The onset of signs varies depending on the concentration
and amount ingested, but in cattle it is reported to be 15 minutes to 24 hours postingestion.
3
Prolongation may be caused by delayed rumen absorption.
Ingestion of a toxic amount of metaldehyde causes CNS stimulation with profound muscle
tremors and hyperthermia. Other reported signs in ruminants include incoordination,
hyperesthesia, hypersalivation, dyspnea, diarrhea, partial blindness, unconsciousness,
cyanosis, and death caused by respiratory failure.2, 3 All the signs are exacerbated
by excitement or activity. A mortality rate of 3% may be expected. Signs in horses
are similar plus heavy perspiration and death in 3 to 5 hours.
There is no antidote, and treatment is largely supportive. Mineral oil and activated
charcoal (1–3 doses) may be used to decrease absorption. Muscle tremors and seizures
should be controlled with a tranquilizer and/or muscle relaxant. Intravenous fluids
should be used to replace and restore fluids and electrolytes. Rumenotomy may be effective
if performed before the onset of clinical signs.
Methiocarb
Methiocarb is a carbamate molluscicide used alone or in combination with metaldehyde.
It has anticholinesterase and nicotinic and muscarinic activities.
4
The compound is usually in pellet form and dyed blue or yellow so that affected animals
can be detected by the blue/yellow staining of their mouths.3, 4
The signs can vary widely depending on the degree of receptor stimulation. Poisoning
of sheep is associated with depression, hypersalivation, diarrhea, dyspnea, aimless
wandering, and ataxia. Death is caused by pulmonary edema. Horses show sweating, lacrimation,
urine dribbling or polyuria, muscle tremor, hypersalivation, and finally recumbency
and death caused by pulmonary edema.
4
Binding to acetylcholinesterase is reversible so recovery can occur with supportive
care. Atropine is an effective antidote but likely will need to be repeated several
times, especially if the amount ingested is large. Additional treatment is supportive
and aimed toward specific system involvement.
Further Reading
Booze
TF
Oehme
FW
Metaldehyde toxicity: a review
Vet Human Toxicol
27
1985
11
15
Giles
CJ
Methiocarb poisoning in a sheep
Vet Rec
114
1984
642
6464336
References
1
Daniel
R
Vet Rec
165
2009
575
19897875
2
Guitart
R
Vet J
183
2010
249
19359202
3
Valentine
BA
J Vet Diagn Invest
19
2007
212
17402622
4
Kaye
BM
Aust Vet J
90
2012
221
22632285
Strychnine
Strychnine has been used for years as a rodenticide and avicide. Historically it has
been used as an appetite stimulant and laxative and most recently, as a contaminant
in LSD and other street drugs. It is an alkaloid derived primarily from seeds and
bark of the Strychnos nux-vomica tree, although it is found in various amounts in
many Strychnos spp.
Strychnine poisoning is an uncommon occurrence in large animals and usually associated
with accidental overdosing with strychnine preparations or accidental access to strychnine
treated bait meant for rodent control. Cattle are particularly susceptible to parenteral
administration (30–60 mg of strychnine hydrochloride may be fatal) but less susceptible
to oral administration because of destruction of the drug in the rumen. Lethal doses
by parenteral injection are 200 to 250 mg in horses, 300 to 400 mg in cattle, and
15 to 50 mg in pigs.
Strychnine is rapidly absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract in monogastric animals
and less so by ruminants. Distribution to tissues is rapid as is hepatic metabolism.
In most animals, 50% of strychnine is eliminated in 6 hours following a sublethal
dose.
It is a potent neurotoxicant and convulsant, exerting its action at the postsynaptic
membrane. In the spinal cord, strychnine interferes with the inhibition of motor cell
stimulation resulting in simultaneous muscle contraction. In the brain, it interferes
with inhibitory responses of the motor neurons resulting in neuronal excitation. The
convulsant effects of strychnine are caused by interference with glycine-mediated
postsynaptic inhibition. The net effect is that all skeletal muscles become hyperexcited,
and tetanic seizures may be provoked by the application of minor external stimuli.
In these convulsive episodes there is extension of the limbs, opisthotonus, and protrusion
of the eyeballs. The seizures may last for 3 to 4 minutes and are followed by periods
of partial relaxation, which become progressively shorter as the disease develops.
Hyperthermia may be extreme. Respiratory arrest leads to death.
There is no antidote and treatment is supportive. Animals should be kept in a dark,
calm area and not stimulated in any manner. Seizures should be treated with diazepam
or a barbiturate. If seizures can be adequately controlled, animals may survive.
Further Reading
Boyd
RE
Strychnine poisoning
Am J Med
74
1983
507
512
6829597
Ward
JC
Garlough
FE
Strychnine IV: lethal dose studies on cattle and sheep
J Am Pharm Assoc
125
1936
422
426
Diseases of the Cerebrum
Psychoses, Neuroses, and Stereotypy
Psychoses or neuroses are rarely documented in farm animals, whereas stereotypy is
common, particularly in horses. Stereotypic behavior is repetitive behavior induced
by frustration, repeated attempts to cope, or CNS dysfunction. Primary equine stereotypies
include crib-biting, weaving, box walking, tongue rolling, and lip movement.
Crib-Biting and Windsucking
Crib-biting or “cribbing” is an oral stereotypic behavior in which the horse grasps
an object, usually the feed box or any solid projection, with the incisor teeth, then
arches the neck and, by depressing the tongue and elevating the larynx, pulls upward
and backward and swallows air, emitting a loud grunt at the same time. This results
in erosion of the incisor teeth and intermittent bouts of spasmodic colic and flatulence.
Crib-biting must be distinguished from chewing wood from boredom and from pica caused
by a mineral deficiency. Windsucking (aerophagia) is an oral stereotypic behavior
in which the horse flexes and arches the neck and swallows air and grunts, but there
is no grasping of objects.
Crib-biting is viewed as a vice and potentially “contagious” problem and affected
horses are usually not welcome in stables. Once established, crib-biting is primarily
postprandial. Treatments include environmental enrichment (move horse to a stall where
they can view more activity; change stall door/walls so that other horses can be seen)
and feeding more hay and less concentrate so that feeding takes longer. More aggressive
treatments include placement of a crib-strap (a strap placed around the neck of the
horse that has two pieces of metal hinges at the ventral area; during arching of the
neck the crib-strap tightens around the pharynx) or neurectomy or myectomy. Weaning
in a box stall appears to increase the risk of developing crib-biting.
Weaving
Weaving is a locomotor behavior during which the horse moves its head and neck laterally
while its weight is moved to the contralateral forelimb, usually while the horse is
positioned at the stall door with its head over the stable door into the aisle. There
is no specific treatment and closing the top half of the stable door merely moves
the activity back into the stall. Feeding hay ad libitum may decrease the time devoted
to this activity (anecdotal reports).
Box Walking
The term box walking refers to persistent walking around the perimeter of the stall
in a circular, repetitive manner. There is no specific treatment, but anecdotal reports
suggest that feeding hay ad libitum may decrease the time devoted to this activity.
Other stereotypical behavior includes persistent kicking of the stall, in the absence
of pruritic lesions of the lower limbs, and cutaneous and subcutaneous mutilation
by self-biting.
Farrowing Hysteria in Sows
Hysteria in sows at farrowing is a common occurrence. This syndrome is most common
in gilts. Affected animals are hyperactive and restless and they attack and savage
their piglets as they approach the head during the initial teat sucking activity after
birth. Serious and often fatal injuries result. Cannibalism is not a feature.
When the syndrome occurs, the remaining piglets and freshly born piglets should be
removed from the sow and placed in a warm environment until parturition is finished.
The sow should then be tested to see if she will accept the piglets. If not, ataractic
or neuroleptic drugs should be administered to allow initial sucking, after which
the sow will usually continue to accept the piglets.
Azaperone (2 mg/kg BW IM) is usually satisfactory, and pentobarbital sodium administered
intravenously until the pedal reflex is lost has been recommended. Promazine derivatives
are effective but subsequent incoordination may result in a higher crushing loss of
piglets. The piglets' teeth should be clipped.
Affected gilts should be culled subsequently because the syndrome may recur at subsequent
farrowing. Where possible, gilts should be placed in their farrowing accommodation
4 to 6 days before parturition and the farrowing environment should be kept quiet
at the time of parturition.
Tail-Biting, Ear-Chewing, and Snout-Rubbing in Pigs
The incidence of cannibalism has increased with intensification of pig rearing, and
it is now a significant problem in many pig-rearing enterprises. Tail-biting is the
most common and occurs in groups of pigs, especially males, from weaning to market
age.
Ear-chewing is less common and is generally restricted to pigs in the immediate postweaning
and early growing period, although both syndromes may occur concurrently. The incidence
of ear-chewing has increased with the practice of docking piglet tails at birth. The
lesions are usually bilateral and most commonly involve the ventral part of the ear.
Lesions from bite wounds may also occur on the flanks of pigs. There is frequently
an association with mange infestation with both of these vices.
A syndrome of snout-rubbing to produce eroded necrotic areas on the flanks of pigs
has been described. Affected pigs were invariably colored, although both white and
colored pigs acted as agonists.
The causes of these forms of cannibalism in pigs are poorly understood, but they are
undoubtedly related to an inadequate total environment. Affected groups are usually
more restless and have heightened activity. Factors such as a high population density,
both in terms of high pen density and large group size; limited food and competition
for food; low protein and inadequate nutrition; boredom; and inadequate environment
in terms of temperature, draft, and ventilation have been incriminated in precipitating
the onset of these vices.
When a problem is encountered, each of these factors should be examined and corrected
or changed if necessary. Prevention is through the same measures. Chains or tires
are frequently hung for displacement activity but are not particularly effective.
The problem may recur despite all attempts at prevention. Also for economic reasons
it is not always possible to implement the radical changes in housing and management
that may be necessary to avoid the occurrence of these vices. Because of this, the
practice of tipping or docking the piglets' tails at birth has become common as a
method of circumventing the major manifestation of cannibalism.
Head-Shaking in Horses
Head-shaking by horses is a troubling syndrome associated with hypersensitivity of
the trigeminal nerve in most affected horses. The disorder is characterized by repeated,
sudden shaking or tossing of the head. It is proposed that a subgroup of horses with
defined trigeminal hypersensitivity be classified as having trigeminal-mediated facial
dysesthesia.
1
Etiology
The etiology is complex and often unclear and conditions associated with head-shaking
include the following
2
:
•
Ear mites
•
Otitis interna/externa
•
Ophthalmic disease (uveitis)
•
Trombicula autumnalis (chiggers) infestation of the muzzle
•
Guttural pouch disease (mycosis)
•
Stylohyoid arthropathy
•
Osteitis of the petrous temporal bone
•
Dental disease (wolf teeth, ulceration, periodontal disease, periapical abscess)
•
Behavioral abnormalities
•
Trigeminal neuralgia
•
Optic neuritis
•
Photic head-shaking (optic-trigeminal summation)
•
Neck pain
•
Rhinitis or sinusitis (including fungal sinusitis)
3
•
Ethmoidal disease including hematoma
•
Infraorbital neuritis
•
Excessive neck flexion by rider
•
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis
•
Ill-fitting tack including bit and bridle
•
Obstructive airway disease (heaves, laryngeal hemiplegia, epiglottic cysts, etc.)
•
Fractures of the nuchal crest
4
•
Surgery of the paranasal sinuses
5
Most cases of the disease are idiopathic despite intensive investigation of affected
horses. Photic head-shaking is a common cause of the disease. Most cases have some
seasonal distribution, although the reason for this is undetermined. Trigeminal neuralgia
is considered an important cause of the disease. It is not associated with EHV-1 infection
of the trigeminal ganglia.
6
Epidemiology
The epidemiology of the disease is not well defined. The syndrome occurs in horses
throughout the world. The syndrome is sporadic, usually affects only one horse on
a farm, and does not occur as outbreaks. It has a seasonal occurrence in approximately
60% of horses with the majority first demonstrating head-shaking, or being most affected,
during spring and summer. Head-shaking is worst on sunny days, and less severe on
cloudy days, in approximately 60% of horses. Sunshine and windy weather worsen the
condition in many horses.
7
Seventy-five percent and 80% of affected horses have less severe signs at night or
when ridden indoors, respectively.
Affected horses are usually mature adults with onset of head-shaking at 7 to 9 years
of age in over half of the cases, although signs can occur in horses as young as 1
year.
2
The disease is reported twice as often in geldings as in mares. There is an apparent
predisposition to the disease in Thoroughbreds, but this is not consistently reported.
Most affected horses are used for general riding, although this might represent an
age effect because the syndrome tends to occur in older horses that are not used for
racing. There is no apparent association of temperament and risk of head-shaking.
Pathogenesis
The pathogenesis of head-shaking depends on the cause, but it is increasingly persuasive
that the majority of cases involve hypersensitivity of the trigeminal nerve.1, 8,
9, 10 The trigeminal nerve provides sensory function of the nose and nasal mucosa.
Horses affected by head-shaking have low stimulus thresholds for the trigeminal nerve
than do healthy horses, although once stimulated nerve conduction is not different
between the groups.
9
The lower stimulus threshold likely makes affected horses more sensitive to noxious
stimuli. A method is also described for assessment of the trigeminocervical reflex
in normal horses.
11
This technique might be useful in head-shaking horses.10, 11, 12
Head-shaking is related to exposure to bright light in some animals. This is a condition
referred to as photic or optic-trigeminal summation because of its similarity to a
syndrome in people. Trigeminal neuralgia is thought to cause acute, sharp, and intense
pain in the face. Although this cannot be definitively diagnosed in horses, its presence
is inferred from the horse's behavior and response to analgesia of the infraorbital
or posterior ethmoidal nerves.
Clinical Findings
The clinical signs of head-shaking are unmistakable. Movements of the head are sudden
and apparently spontaneous and involve lateral, dorsal, ventral, or rotatory movement
of the nose usually during exercise. Horses rarely have the behavior only at rest,
with most affected both at rest and during exercise and about 10% exhibiting signs
only during exercise. The action often resembles that of a horse trying to dislodge
something from its nose. Approximately 90% of horses have vertical movement of the
head (as if flipping the nose). The head-shaking can be so severe it causes lateral,
dorsal, or ventral flexion of the neck to the level of the caudal cervical vertebrae,
although more commonly only the rostral one-third of the neck is involved, if it is
involved at all. Some horses rub their nose on objects, the ground, or their front
limbs, sometimes during exercise. Affected horses often snort or sneeze. There can
be twitching of the facial muscles and flipping of the upper lip. The movements are
sudden and at times appear to catch the horse by surprise. The frequency and/or severity
of movements are usually increased during exercise. Severely affected horses can stumble
and fall if head-shaking occurs during exercise, rendering the horse unsafe to ride.
A grading system to classify the severity of signs is as follows:
0 No signs of head-shaking
1 Intermittent and mild clinical signs: facial muscle twitching; rideable
2 Moderate clinical signs: definable conditions under which head-shaking occurs; rideable
with some difficulty
3 Rideable to unpleasant to do so: difficult to control
4 Unrideable and uncontrollable
5 Dangerous with bizarre behavior patterns
This system might be useful for assessing response to therapy and concisely describing
the severity of the signs.
Ancillary testing involves radiography of the skull; endoscopic examination of both
nostrils and ethmoidal regions, nasopharynx, larynx, and guttural pouches; otoscopic
examination of the external auditory canal and tympanic membrane (difficult to achieve
in a conscious horse, a small endoscope is necessary); desensitization of the infraorbital
and posterior ethmoidal nerves; biopsy of the nasal mucosa (in horses with suspected
rhinitis); radiographic examination of the head and neck; measurement of stimulus
threshold for action potentials in the trigeminal nerve,
9
and therapeutic trials including application of contact lenses or masks, or administration
of medications (see the following section Treatment).
Clinical Pathology
There are no characteristic hematologic or serum biochemical abnormalities.
Necropsy Findings
There are no characteristic findings on necropsy, apart from those of any underlying
disease. Evidence of lesions in the trigeminal nerve is lacking.
Differential Diagnosis
The disease must be differentiated from the stereotypic weaving that occurs during
stabling and not during exercise.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
The principles of treatment include relief of specific underlying diseases, removal
of management or environmental conditions that cause head-shaking, and administration
of medications. There is the potential for an important placebo effect, in the owners,
for treatment of head-shaking.
13
If underlying conditions are detected, such as ear mites, dental disease, and other
conditions listed in the previous section Etiology, then these conditions should be
treated effectively. Effective treatment will alleviate head-shaking, if in fact the
condition was the cause of the disease. However, most horses with head-shaking have
seasonal or photic disease and treatment is more difficult. A survey of owners of
254 horses with head-shaking revealed that only 129 horses had been treated by a veterinarian
and, of those, only 6% had complete resolution of head-shaking, whereas 72% had no
response to treatment. Other treatments used were on the advice of lay “back specialists,”
homeopathy, alternative therapies, or face or head masks. Success rates for these
interventions varied between 6% and 27%, with the most success obtained by use of
a nose net (27%). Nose nets provided better control of signs than did face or eye
masks. These figures on the success of treatment illustrate the refractory, and therefore
frustrating, nature of the disease.
Fitting of nose masks alleviates or lessens head-shaking in some horses. The design
of the nose mask does not appear to be important regarding whether it covers the entire
rostral face or just the nostrils. The nose masks were most effective for treatment
of up-and-down head-shaking, but not for side-to-side or rubbing behavior.
Blue-tinted contact lenses have been suggested for use in horses with photic head-shaking.
Others have not found this intervention useful. Administration of sodium cromoglycate
eye drops has demonstrated potential in a small number of horses for treatment of
seasonal head-shaking, presumably because of the amelioration of the effects of seasonal
allergy.
14
Sclerosis of the infraorbital or posterior ethmoidal nerves is performed in those
horses that have reduced or eliminated head-shaking after injection of local anesthetic
into the infraorbital foramen or around the posterior ethmoidal nerve. Sclerosis is
achieved by injection of 5 mL of 10% phenol in oil. Care must be taken to ensure that
the phenol is deposited only around the nerve. The procedure should be done under
general anesthesia.
Cyproheptadine (0.3 mg/kg, orally every 12 hours) improved head-shaking in 43 of 61
horses, based on owner-reported efficacy. Responses were usually observed within 1
week of the start of therapy. Others have not replicated this success but found that
the combination of carbamazepine (4 mg/kg orally every 6 to 8 hours) and cyproheptadine
improved clinical signs in seven horses within 3 to 4 days of starting treatment.
Acupuncture and chiropractic manipulation appear to be minimally effective.
Prevention of exposure to bright light is an obvious recommendation, but not practical
for most horse owners.
Caudal compression of the infraorbital nerve with platinum coils provides a surgical
treatment option for horses that do not respond to medical treatment or environmental
modification.
15
Of 58 horses treated using caudal compression of the infraorbital nerve a successful
outcome was initially achieved in 35 of 57 (63%) horses, but recurrence occurred between
9 and 30 months later in 9 (26%). Surgery was repeated in 10 of 31 (32%) horses. Final
success rate, considering only response to the last performed surgery, was 28 of 57
(49%) horses with median follow-up time of 18 months (range 266 months). Nose-rubbing
was reported postoperatively in 30 of 48 (63%) horses and resulted in euthanasia of
four horses.
16
Administration of dexamethasone in a pulsed dose schedule (60 mg orally every 24 hours
× 4 days, every 3 weeks for 4 months) to 12 horses did not result in improvement of
clinical signs in a randomized, placebo-controlled, blinded field trial.
7
Addition of an unspecified feed supplement to the diet of 44 affected horses in a
randomized, blinded placebo controlled study did not detect a beneficial effect of
the supplement.
13
Control
There are no recognized measures for preventing development of the disease.
Further Reading
Pickles
K
Madigan
J
Aleman
M
Idiopathic headshaking: is it still idiopathic?
Vet J
201
2014
21
30
24821361
References
1
Pickles
K
Vet J
201
2014
21
24821361
2
Radostits
O
Headshaking in horses
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
2006
W.B. Saunders
London
2022
3
Fiske-Jackson
AR
Equine Vet Educ
24
2012
126
4
Voigt
A
J S Afr Vet Assoc
80
2009
111
19831275
5
Gilsenan
WF
Vet Surg
43
2014
678
24702478
6
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
192
22211434
7
Tomlinson
JE
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
1551
24627899
8
Roberts
V
Vet J
201
2014
7
24888682
9
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
250
24428325
10
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
1571
24107198
11
Veres-Nyeki
KO
Vet J
191
2012
101
21664846
12
Mayhew
J
Vet J
191
2012
15
21652238
13
Talbot
WA
Equine Vet J
45
2013
293
22994634
14
Stalin
CE
Vet Rec
163
2008
305
18776178
15
Roberts
VLH
Equine Vet J
41
2009
165
19418746
16
Roberts
VLH
Equine Vet J
45
2013
107
22413870
Tail-Biting in Swine
Tail-biting, which is the chewing or biting or sucking of a tail of a fellow pig,
is an example of cannibalism. It is a very complex problem that is widespread and
has demanded more attention with time. It is an intractable problem1, 2 that is very
unpredictable. It has a high economic impact because of euthanasia, medical costs,
other infections, and condemnations. This has increased with intensive farming and
is the most serious of the vices of the domestic pig. It is much more important than
flank-biting, nosing, or ear-biting. It has been seen in outdoor pigs and on organic
units. About 60% of farms in the UK have at one time or another experienced tail-biting
in single pigs or as a group problem. It is a serious welfare issue because it often
leads to systemic infections from a whole variety of opportunist bacteria, principally
Trueperella pyogenes and Streptococcus spp., which lead to septicemias and particularly
spinal abscessation. Both ear-chewing and tail-biting have also increased in recent
years.
3
It is assumed that contented pigs do not tail-bite.
Three stages of tail-biting have been recognized
3
:
1.
Two-stage initial phase that includes predamage and damage probably related to having
no substrates or play items
2.
A second stage called sudden or forceful in which there are probably inadequate resources
3.
An obsessive phase that includes many of the factors described in stages 1 and 2,
principally those associated with genetics, attraction to blood, and protein metabolism
upsets
The diagnosis of the condition is very difficult. It occurs under all conditions including
outdoors. Possibly 0.5% to 0.7% of docked pigs are bitten and 2% to 4% of undocked
pigs. A recent survey in the UK suggested that 90% of farms had pigs that were not
bitten, 6% had small problem, and 4% had big problems. Most abattoirs do not record
pigs bitten, and many bitten pigs are sent to small abattoirs. There are probably
three mild lesions to every one serious lesion and these are probably not recorded.
Etiology
There are said to be three basic scenarios: (1) gentle chewing that escalates; (2)
two-stage biting; and (3) sudden forceful biting, which may be sudden frustration
over a lack of a resource.5, 6
Tail-biting usually begins with one pig doing the biting and one pig being bitten
in an environment that for some reason has caused stress. It then spreads rapidly
through the whole group as the bitten tail becomes more attractive.
The inadequate total environment for an animal that naturally requires the opportunity
to socially interact and demonstrate its natural behavior of inquisitiveness and rooting
is often the underlying cause. Abnormal foraging behavior has been suggested as the
underlying cause.
6
Abnormalities of ventilation, particularly drafts, appear very unsettling to pigs.
The normal pig group is probably under 20 and over that number the individual's place
in the hierarchy is probably lost.
Epidemiology
“Belly-nosing” may be one of the behavior patterns that predispose to tail-biting.
It is often associated with early weaning and is the persistent rubbing of the snout
on the belly of another pig. It may be misdirected suckling behavior.
7
This behavior is not eliminated by providing environmental enrichment, suckling devices,
of extra drinkers or nipple feeders. There is a genetic linkage with Landrace pigs
8
and with weight for age.
9
The condition is found worldwide. It is often more prevalent in males than females
and may be part of natural aggressiveness. The real cause is still unknown but is
probably a mental reaction on the part of the pig to unsavory living conditions. Under
normal circumstances happy pigs root for 18% of the time and probably doze for about
82% of the time. They are really the “couch potatoes” of the domesticated farm animals.
If they have nothing to do, they cause trouble. Recent studies have suggested that
the “troublesome” pig may be lighter, more active, and possess more “nosing” behavior
patterns.
10
Others have suggested that it is the heavier pigs that are bitten.
The causes for tail-biting are multifactorial, but it has to be considered that there
may be a bad “psychologically disturbed pig.” Once the behavior has started it behaves
like an epidemic. Recent studies have suggested that the way the tail is held has
a very considerable influence on whether it is bitten or not.
Anal biting may or may not be related to tail-biting. It has certainly been a feature
of a few cases of anal irritation in response to oral dosing with Lincocin.
Risk Factors
These have been reviewed.4, 5 Traits related to foraging, exploration feeding, motivation
to feed, and sociability are heritable.11, 12
Because of modern genetics, pigs grow faster and are more aggressive. Aggression is
also heritable.
13
Some of the breeds may be more heavily bitten, but Hampshires are less frequently
bitten. Some pigs may be unable to use food properly because of a metabolic deficiency.
There is a subset of pigs called the fanatical biters who are generally small males
with low lightweight gain. These biters have a low growth rate from weaning to finishing.
They spend more time chewing than they do rooting. In a poor environment, they will
chew other pigs rather than root. Some of these biters have respiratory or alimentary
diseases or porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) infections. There are other types of
pigs that bite.
The tail-biting hypothesis suggests that there may be a big protein demand that is
not being met, so there is a protein deficiency as a result of poor intake of food.
There may be a dysfunctional autonomic nervous system regulation involving the general
sense responses, interrelated illnesses, and suppressed thyroid hormone T3 production.
It may be that there is a lack of tyrosine for serotonin production, which is an important
neurotransmitter. Pigs with higher levels of serotonin spend more time rooting, and
in the “bit tail blood model” it is found that serotonin-deficient pigs do more biting.
•
There may be breed, line, or family predispositions.
•
White pigs have more of a problem than colored breeds.
•
There is a genetic tendency to be a biter or to bitten.
•
Tail-biting is associated with lean tissue growth and backfat thickness
Factors Increasing Biting
•
Tails are bitten more frequently when there is a low weight gain (nutrition).
•
Males may be more predisposed, but there is less biting in single sex rearing.
•
When there are no interests provided and there are no toys with which to play.
•
High-density stocking.
•
Over stocking.
•
Large group sizes.
•
Mixing and moving.
•
Space postweaning.
14
•
If you move pigs from a straw-based system to a slatted system they will bite much
more.
•
Insufficient trough space, if feeders are blocked then pigs will bite to get at the
feeder.
•
Insufficient drinkers.
•
Inadequate nutrition.
•
Change in ration formulation leading to food sensing.
•
Low-protein diets encourage biting and chewing.
•
Not enough amino acids (lysine, tryptophan, but true position unknown).
•
Low salt.
•
Nonsatisfying environments, particularly those with a poor layout, on nonstraw systems
are badly affected.
•
Boredom (lack of toys).
•
Inadequate environment.
•
Low temperatures: cold and damp is bad on straw-based systems, and poor-quality straw
is a problem.
•
High temperatures.
•
Fluctuating temperatures.
•
Drafts.
•
Too high a humidity.
Variable tail docking length is also a factor. The variation in tail anatomy and position
is also important.
15
Concurrent disease, particularly PCV2 infection and skin, disease may predispose to
biting.
In a summary, overstocking was thought to be important in 60% of cases, inadequate
ventilation in 50%, wrongly positioned ventilation in 50%, and cold drafts in 40%.
Sick pigs that are not moved promptly were thought to be important in 60% of outbreaks
and boredom in 50%. The other factors were considered to be of lesser importance (below
20%).
Clinical Findings
At the start there is no effect on the bitten pig because the end of the tail is relatively
insensitive, but as the bitten area extends toward the anus it becomes more painful
and the bitten pig shows signs of distress. With continuation the pig may be reluctant
to feed, reluctant to move, and eventually become paralyzed as spinal abscessation
becomes the reality.
Clinical Pathology
There may be chewed, gnawed, and partially or completely removed tails. In an early
study at an abattoir 19.9% of the lesions on the carcasses were related to tail-biting
and 61.75 of carcass abscesses were associated with tail-biting.
Necropsy
At necropsy or in the abattoir it is a bitten tail as well as the abscessation that
is most noticeable along the length of the spine as infection tracts along lymphatics
and longitudinal spinal veins. In some cases, the carcass is so badly affected that
the whole carcass is condemned. In some cases, there will be evidence of flank-biting
and ear-biting (sometimes the ear is completely bitten off), which are part of the
same disturbed pig syndrome.
Treatment
Remove affected pigs to hospital accommodation, pen separately, and treat the wounds
by cleaning, disinfection, and topical palliatives and possibly parenteral broad-spectrum
antibiotics. Shoot badly affected or paraplegic pigs. Casualty slaughter is not very
useful because of the carcass damage.
Control
There is no really successful plan for control that will work all the time. There
is a husbandry advisory tool with 100 possible risk factors. The spreadsheet lists
83 factors. Weighted for risk factors the tool shows that a quarter of the farms have
no problems and a quarter of the farms have a serious problem. Attend to all the listed
factors and even then you will not always remove the problem, but it will certainly
be reduced. Nothing is ever completely effective.
First, observe pigs several times a day and remove the biter as soon as it is seen
to bite and put it into separate accommodation.
Elevating the salt level to 0.8% often works even though there is already 0.4% in
the diet, which is thought to be sufficient. Make sure there is plenty of water available.
The improved environment is one of the most important items, particularly the application
of negative pressure systems. Lowering light levels reduces the “glowing effect” of
blood-covered surfaces similar to housing broiler birds in infrared lights to reduce
“vent pecking.”
The provision of an improved environment by providing “playthings” that satisfy the
desire of the pig to sniff, inquire, taste, and chew is most important. These items
should be malleable, which is why straw or peat, or spent mushroom compost or rubber
cords, or even tires
16
are more satisfying than chains. The chains are no good because they slap other pigs
and increase the restlessness. Straw provision has the ability to keep pigs occupied
for longer than other substrates,17, 18 and it is better if it is provided daily.
19
Housing systems that have had ad libitum feeding systems with multiple feed spaces
have had a reduced prevalence of the problem.
This attention to sucking and chewing is the basis of all the saliva tests that have
been developed to detect viruses such as porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome
(PRRS) and PCV2 and antibodies to them. Hanging a set of cotton cords in a pen that
will soon be sucked by most pigs as part of play will provide a readily accessible
sample source for saliva antigens antibodies and many other substances such as acute
phase proteins. This does not involve disturbing the pigs or requiring handling and
invasive techniques for the individual pig for investigating herd profiles.
The provision of straw is no guarantee that tail-biting will be stopped.
20
Tail docking is the only technique that does reduce the presence of tail-biting. The
conditions attached to use of this practice vary from country to country and often
mean that the technique has to be prescribed by a veterinarian only after the presence
of a tail-biting problem has been established on that farm. Even tail-docked pigs
have evidence of being tail-bitten.
21
The ideal length of tail docking is not really known. One of the major problems is
that tails differ in thickness and length before any consideration of the length to
be cut off. Too short a tail, i.e., cut very short, interferes with the nervous control
around the anus, may lead to fecal incontinence, and exposes the anus itself to being
bitten.
Tail docking produces a neuroma at the site of nerve transection, which results in
the formation of many sensitive nerve endings that enable the pig to react more sensitively
to any nosing of its tail.
In a recent survey,
18
62% thought that docking was effective in preventing tail-biting, 47% thought adding
straw was helpful, 46% thought that playthings were effective, but only 18% thought
reducing stocking density was helpful. The latter may be because of the economic implications
of reducing stocking. All in all, reducing stocking density and adding straw together
was considered to be the best option.
22
Further Reading
Taylor
NR
Tail biting: a new perspective
Vet J
186
2009
137
147
19804997
Taylor
NR
The prevalence of risk factors for tail biting
Vet J
194
2012
77
88
22503206
Zonderland
JJ
Thesis. Talking tails-quantifying the development of tail biting in pigs
http://edepot.wur.nl/151535
2010
References
1
Edwards
SA
Pig J
66
2011
81
2
Edwards
SA
Vet J
171
2006
198
15908246
3
Kritas
SK
Morrison
RB
Vet Rec
160
2007
149
17277296
4
Taylor
NR
Vet J
194
2012
77
22503206
5
Taylor
NR
Vet J
186
2010
137
19804997
6
Peeters
E
Appl Anim Behav Sci
98
2006
234
7
Widowski
T
Appl Anim Behav Sci
110
2008
109
8
Bensch
CJ
Gonyou
HW
Appl Anim Behav Sci
105
2007
26
9
Torrey
S
Widowski
TM
Appl Anim Behav Sci
101
2006
288
10
Zonderland
JJ
Animal
5
2011
767
22439999
11
Baumung
R
Archiv Tierzucht
49
2006
77
12
Renadeu
D
Asian Australas J Anim Sci
19
2006
593
13
Turner
SP
Anim Sci
82
2006
615
14
http://www.thepigsite.com/pighealth/article/366/vice-abnormal-behaviour-tail-biting-flank-chewing-ear-biting/
Accessed August 2016
15
Zonderland
JJ
Appl Anim Behav Sci
121
2009
165
16
Day
JEL
Appl Anim Behav Sci
109
2008
249
17
Scott
K
Appl Anim Behav Sci
99
2006
222
18
Scott
K
Anim Welfare
16
2007
53
19
Scott
K
Appl Anim Behav Sci
105
2007
51
20
Statham
P
Anim Behav Sci
134
2011
100
21
Smulders
D
Anim Welfare
17
2008
61
22
Paul
ES
Vet Rec
160
2007
803
17558029
Bacterial Diseases Primarily Affecting the Cerebrum
Enterotoxemia Associated With Clostridium Perfringens Type D (Pulpy Kidney, Overeating
Disease)
Synopsis
Etiology An acute toxemia of ruminants associated with the proliferation of Clostridium
perfringens type D in the intestines and the liberation of ε-toxin that produces vascular
damage and the damage to the nervous system typical of this disease.
Epidemiology Lambs 3–10 weeks of age and lambs and calves after weaning. Goats of
all ages. Affected animals in good condition and on a rising plane of nutrition.
Clinical findings The disease in lambs and calves and young goats has a rapid course
with diarrhea, depression, and convulsions. At this age animals are often found dead.
Adult goats show more chronic disease with abdominal pain and bloody diarrhea.
Clinical pathology Hyperglycemia and glycosuria in sheep.
Necropsy findings None specific to all cases. Sheep and some goats may have gross
or histologic areas of malacia in internal capsule, lateral thalamus, and cerebellar
peduncles.
Diagnostic confirmation Epidemiology, clinical and necropsy findings, demonstration
of ε-toxin
Treatment Anti-ε antitoxin.
Control Feed restriction, antitoxin, vaccination.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Enterotoxemia results from the proliferation of C. perfringens type D in the small
intestine. This organism produces a number of toxins, of which the epsilon toxin is
the most important and results in vascular damage and the damage to the nervous system
typical of this disease. The presence of C. perfringens type D in the intestine does
not in itself result in disease unless other factors intercede that promote proliferation
and the production of toxin. The natural habitat of the organism is in the intestine
and in soil contaminated by feces, although it does not persist in soil for long periods
of time.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Enterotoxemia associated with C. perfringens type D is a disease of ruminant animals,
primarily of lambs, and is worldwide in its distribution. The common practice of vaccination
against this disease has reduced its prevalence, but it is still a common disease.
Although most common in lambs, it is also an important disease of calves and goats.
It occurs rarely in adult cattle, deer, domesticated camels, and possibly horses.
In pastured sheep, it causes heavy losses, particularly in flocks managed for the
production of lamb and mutton. The prevalence in flocks varies a great deal but seldom
exceeds 10%. The case–fatality rate approximates 100%. In North America enterotoxemia
ranks as one of the main causes of loss among feedlot lambs. In a survey in two feedlots
the disease had an annual prevalence of 3.1% and 1.5%; it ranked third in importance
as a cause of death despite a policy of vaccination, and the costs of prevention programs
were the largest expenditure of all disease prevention programs in the feedlots.
Experimental Reproduction
The disease can be produced experimentally in susceptible sheep, goats, and cattle
by the injection into the duodenum of whole culture of C. perfringens type D and dextrin
or starch. Clinical disease occurs as early as 30 minutes and usually within 6 to
8 hours of the start of duodenal infusion and death 1 to 9 hours following the onset
of clinical signs. The disease has also been reproduced by intravenous infusion of
epsilon toxin.
Animal and Management Risk Factors
C. perfringens type D normally inhabits the alimentary tract of sheep and other ruminants
but only in small numbers. The extent to which it occurs in the alimentary tract varies
widely between flocks, although this accounts only in part for the variable prevalence.
The organism does not persist for more than 1 year in the soil.
Under certain conditions, the organisms proliferate rapidly in the intestines and
produce lethal quantities of epsilon toxin. In most, if not all circumstances, the
affected animals are on highly nutritious diets and are in very good condition. The
husbandry conditions in which the disease occurs include grazing on lush, rapidly
growing pasture or young cereal crops, and heavy grain feeding in feedlots. Lambs
on well-fed, heavy-milking ewes are particularly susceptible. The occurrence of the
disease under these conditions has given rise to the name “overeating disease.”
Sheep
The highest incidence of the disease is in suckling lambs between 3 and 10 weeks of
age, although lambs as young as 1 to 5 days old can be affected.
1
The risk for disease in this age group is highest when ewes are grazed on lush pastures
that result in profuse lactation. The disease can occur following rain in set stocked
flocks, and in flocks newly introduced to lush pastures it is often manifested 5 to
14 days after introduction. Larger and more rapidly growing single lambs are more
susceptible than twins. Weaned lambs up to 10 months of age are the second most susceptible
age group, and again the occurrence of disease is associated with highly nutritious
diets. Feeder lambs are most commonly affected soon after they are introduced into
feedlots.
Calves
Enterotoxemia in calves is most common between 1 and 4 months of age and the same
risk factors pertain as for lambs. Veal calves are particularly at risk. Feeder cattle
may develop disease shortly after introduction to the lot. It is a common belief among
cattlemen and veterinarians that many unexplained sudden deaths in feeder cattle after
the period of acclimatization are caused by this type of enterotoxemia. However, there
is no laboratory evidence to support such field observations, and a controlled trial
found no protective effect of vaccination.
Goats
Enterotoxemia is a common disease in goats under intensive or extensive grazing systems,
occurring in many countries, and is particularly important in countries with a large
goat population.
2
The peracute disease in goat kids has the same age occurrence as in lambs, but less
acute and chronic forms of enterotoxemia occur in adult goats. Sudden changes in diet
appear to be the most common predisposing factor. Disease can occur in vaccinated
goats because vaccination is poorly protective against the enteric and chronic form
of the disease in this species.
2
Outbreaks in sheep and goats have followed the administration of phenothiazine and
other anthelmintics, and a high incidence has been observed in association with heavy
tapeworm infestation.
Horses
Type D enterotoxemia is rare in horses, but it has been suspected in mature horses
fed concentrates during a drought. C. perfringens type D can be isolated in high numbers
from gastric reflux of horses with anterior enteritis.
Pathogenesis
In the normal course of events, ingested C. perfringens type D are destroyed in large
numbers in the rumen and abomasum, although some survive to reach the duodenum, in
which multiplication occurs and toxin is produced. Toxemia does not occur because
the movement of ingesta keeps the bacterial population and toxin content down to a
low level. In certain circumstances, this does not hold and multiplication of the
organisms and the production of toxin proceeds to the point in which toxemia occurs.
One of the circumstances has been shown to be the passage of large quantities of starch
granules into the duodenum when sheep overeat on grain diets or are changed suddenly
from a ration consisting largely of roughage to one consisting mainly of grain. Other
factors such as heavy milk feeding may have the same effect. A slowing of alimentary
tract movement has also been thought to permit excess toxin accumulation and it may
be that any factor that causes intestinal stasis will predispose to the disease. The
importance of diet in the production of ruminal stasis has been discussed in diseases
of the forestomachs of ruminants.
The epsilon toxin of C. perfringens type D is a pore-forming protein that increases
the permeability of the intestinal mucosa to this and other toxins, facilitating its
own absorption.
3
A receptor for epsilon toxin has been identified on vascular endothelial cells, and
the clinical signs and pathologic findings can be explained by the widespread vascular
damage and increase in vascular permeability.
Acute cases are characterized by the development in the brain of degeneration of vascular
endothelium; perivascular and intercellular edema; and microscopic foci of necrosis
in the basal ganglia, thalamus, internal capsule, substantia nigra, subcortical white
matter, and cerebellum. The damage to the vascular endothelium leads to the accumulation
of protein-rich fluid effusions observable in heart, brain, and lung. The postmortem
autolysis of kidney tissue that occurs so rapidly and is the characteristic of “pulpy
kidney” has the same basis.
There is a pronounced hyperglycemia caused by the mobilization of hepatic glycogen;
severe hemoconcentration; and elevation of blood concentrations of pyruvate, lactate,
and α-ketoglutarate.
In contrast to sheep, goats with enterotoxemia produced by C. perfringens type D also
have a hemorrhagic enterocolitis that is present in both the natural and the experimental
disease. The genesis of this lesion is uncertain, but it is responsible for the major
clinical signs that present in goats with this disease.
A degree of natural immunity may be attained by nonlethal exposure to the toxin. Because
a proportion of lambs, calves, and kids appear to be exposed to subclinical but antigenic
levels of C. perfringens toxin, they become immune without having shown signs of illness
or without having been vaccinated.
4
Clinical Findings
Lambs
The course of the illness is very short, often less than 2 hours and never more than
12 hours. Many lambs are found dead without previously manifesting signs. In closely
observed flocks the first signs may be dullness, depression, yawning, facial movements,
and loss of interest in feed. Acute cases may show little more than severe clonic
convulsions with frothing at the mouth and rapid death. Cases that survive for a few
hours show a green, pasty diarrhea, staggering, recumbency, opisthotonus, and severe
clonic convulsions. The temperature is usually normal but may be elevated if convulsions
are severe. Death occurs during a convulsion or after a short period of coma.
Adult Sheep
These usually survive for longer periods of up to 24 hours. They lag behind the flock
and show staggering and knuckling; champing of the jaws; salivation; and rapid, shallow,
irregular respiration. There may be bloat in the terminal stages. Irritation signs,
including convulsions, muscle tremor, grinding of the teeth, and salivation, may occur
but are less common than in lambs.
Calves
The syndrome is similar to that seen in adult sheep, with nervous signs predominating.
Peracute cases are found dead without having shown premonitory signs of illness and
with no evidence of struggling. The more common, acute cases show a sudden onset of
bellowing, mania, and convulsions, with the convulsions persisting until death occurs
1 to 2 hours later. Subacute cases, many of which recover, do not drink, are quiet
and docile, and appear to be blind, although the eye's preservation reflex persists.
They may continue in this state for 2 to 3 days and then recover quickly and completely.
In an outbreak of the disease in calves all three forms of the disease may be seen.
Experimental inoculation of whole or washed cultures of C. perfringens type D into
the duodenum of 9-month-old calves produced severe clinical signs within 2 to 5 hours
of inoculation.
5
Goats
Diarrhea is a prominent sign in affected goats, especially in those that survive for
more than a few days.
2
In the peracute form, which occurs most frequently in young kids, there are convulsions
after an initial attack of fever (40.5°C, 105°F) with severe abdominal pain and dysentery;
death occurs in 4 to 36 hours. In the acute form, which is more common in adults,
there is usually no fever, and abdominal pain and diarrhea are prominent with death
or recovery within 2 to 4 days. In chronic cases, the goats may be ill for several
weeks and show anorexia, intermittent severe diarrhea and, in some cases, dysentery
and the presence of epithelial shreds in the feces. Chronic wasting, anemia, and eventual
emaciation also occur with chronic disease in goats.
Clinical Pathology
A high plasma glucose concentration of 8.3 to 11.1 mmol/L (150 to 200 mg/dL) and marked
glycosuria are characteristic of the terminal stages of enterotoxemia in sheep, and
are supportive for a diagnosis but are not pathognomonic.
6
Hyperglycemia and glycosuria are variably present in goats with the disease and calves
with experimentally induced disease.
5
Necropsy Findings
The body condition of the animal is usually good, but there is often fecal staining
of the perineum and rapid decomposition of the carcass. In peracute cases there may
be no gross lesions. More frequently, there is an excess of clear, straw-colored pericardial
and thoracic fluid that clots on exposure to air. Many petechiae are present in the
epicardium and endocardium, and there is pulmonary edema. Patchy congestion of the
abomasal and intestinal mucosae is usual, and the small intestine often contains a
moderate amount of thin, creamy ingesta. The content of the large intestine may be
watery and dark green.
The characteristic finding of soft, pulpy kidneys is only useful in animals necropsied
within a few hours after death because it is nonspecific and merely correlates to
a more rapid rate of autolysis. Microscopy of experimentally induced ovine type D
enterotoxemia cases confirms that the renal changes represent autolysis and not a
true nephrosis.
The liver is dark and congested. The rumen and abomasum of feedlot lambs may be overloaded
with concentrates. In goats there is acute fibrinonecrotic and hemorrhagic enterocolitis,
although microscopic examination may be needed to detect this change.
In sheep that have not died acutely there may be symmetric areas of hemorrhage, edema,
and liquefaction in the brain, especially in the area of the basal nuclei. Again,
microscopic evaluation of the tissue is critical.
Gram-stained smears of ingesta from several levels in the small intestine should be
examined. In affected animals the short, fat, gram-positive rods dominate the slide
to the almost complete exclusion of other bacteria. Bowel filtrates can be tested
for toxicity by injection into mice. If the filtrate is toxic, the type of toxin can
be determined by protection of the mice with specific antisera. This does not determine
the type of clostridia, but detection of β-toxin indicates the presence of types B
or C, and ε-toxin indicates the presence of B or D.
The time taken for diagnosis by mouse neutralization tests, as well as humanitarian
considerations, has promoted the development of alternative tests. Commercial enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kits and multiplex PCR assays have become available for
toxin detection and require minimal amounts of intestinal content.
6
Nevertheless, it is important to base a diagnosis on epidemiologic, clinical, and
pathologic information, not just the detection of toxin at postmortem.
ε-Toxin is stable if frozen, but at average temperatures it is possible to identify
the toxin from the intestine of a sheep dead for up to 12 hours. The addition of one
drop of chloroform to each 10 mL of ingesta will stabilize the toxin for up to 1 month.
Alternatively, intestinal contents can be absorbed on filter paper and shipped at
environmental temperatures, with little loss of activity for as long as 74 days as
detected by immunoassay. Hyperglycemia and glucosuria may also be detected in necropsy
material.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Bacteriology: 20 to 30 mL of intestinal content, frozen in a leak-proof glass or plastic
container (ELISA, latex agglutination, bioassay, anaerobic culture, PCR); air-dried
smears of ingesta from several levels of gut (cyto-Gram stain)
•
Clinical pathology: urine (assay–glucose) (best performed at time of necropsy)
•
Histology: fixed colon, ileum, jejunum, entire brain
Differential Diagnosis
Lambs
•
Acute pasteurellosis
•
Septicemia associated with Histophilus somni (formerly Haemophilus agni)
•
Clostridium sordellii
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Rumen overload
Sheep
•
Hypocalcemia
•
Hypomagnesemia
•
Focal symmetric encephalomalacia (chronic enterotoxemia)
•
Rabies
•
Pregnancy toxemia
•
Louping-ill
Calves
•
Lead poisoning
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Hepatoencephalopathy
•
H. somni (formerly Haemophilus somni)
Goats
•
Salmonellosis
•
Coccidiosis
In lambs, but not in goats, a history of vaccination against the disease is a significant
consideration in the ranking of a list of differential diagnoses.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
In general, the clinical course of the disease is too acute for effective treatment.
Hyperimmune serum, an efficient short-term prophylactic, is unlikely to be of much
value in sick animals because of the acute nature of the disease. In goats the course
is longer, and antitoxin in combination with orally administered sulfadimidine may
be effective in treatment.
2
Control
There are three major control measures available: reduction of the food intake, administration
of antitoxin, and vaccination. These may be used individually or in combination.
Reduction in Food Intake
Reduction in food intake is the cheapest but least effective in control and is used
as a short-term control while waiting for immunity to develop after vaccination. Reduction
in food intake will cause a setback in the growth of the lambs and for this reason
farmers tend to rely more on vaccination as a control measure. However, exercise of
lambs, by mustering or herding around the paddock, may help slow the course of an
outbreak.
Antitoxin
Antitoxin can be administered to all sheep as soon as an outbreak commences. The administration
of ε-antitoxin 200 IU/kg BW will provide for protective circulating antitoxin levels
for 21 to 29 days. Immediate losses are prevented, and in most instances the disease
does not recur. Toxoid is cheaper, but to administer it alone at such times may result
in further serious losses before active immunity develops.
Vaccination
Immunity in sheep is readily produced by suitable vaccination. A blood level of 0.15
Wellcome unit of ε-antitoxin per milliliter of serum is sufficient to protect sheep.
Vaccines available are toxoids, and adjuvants generally improve the antigenicity.
Activated alum-precipitated toxoid is the common vaccine in use. A recombinant C.
perfringens type D toxoid has been shown to induce antibody titers comparable to a
traditional toxoid and may offer a more consistent or cost-effective method of vaccine
production.
7
Vaccination of maiden ewes twice at an interval of at least 1 month and with the last
vaccination approximately 4 weeks before lambing will result in good passive immunity
in young lambs, with 97% of lambs having protective antibody levels at 8 weeks of
age and a significant proportion at 12 to 16 weeks of age. This is sufficient to protect
lambs during their highest risk period. Older ewes that have been vaccinated the previous
year receive a single booster vaccination 4 weeks before lambing. Sheep vaccinated
for 3 consecutive years can be considered to be permanently immune and to require
no further vaccination.
When faced with an outbreak in lambs, the recommended procedure is to administer antiserum
and toxoid immediately and repeat the toxoid in a month's time. The simultaneous administration
of hyperimmune serum with this vaccine does not interfere with the stimulation of
antibody production, nor does the presence of passively derived colostral immunity.
Lambs can be vaccinated with toxoid when 4 to 10 weeks of age and again a month later.
Any vaccination of sheep is not without risk of precipitating blackleg or other clostridial
disease, and if these are a severe problem in an area it may be wise to vaccinate
a portion of the flock as a pilot test and proceed with vaccination of the remainder
only when no complications arise. A multivalent bacterin-toxoid containing antigens
to all of the clostridial diseases is commonly used in sheep in these circumstances
or where all of these diseases are likely to occur. Vaccination should not be done
in sheep with wet fleeces.
Vaccination with toxoid is effective in calves but is not highly effective in goats,
having a limited effect in preventing the disease although reducing its incidence
and severity.
2
The anti-ε titer in goats following vaccination is variable, sometimes equivalent,
but often lower or of shorter duration to that induced in sheep. The reasons for decreased
protection following the use of commercial vaccines against type D infections in goats
are not fully understood.
2
Thus, goat owners should be advised that vaccination with the current commercial vaccines
often provides limited protection against type D infections, even if multiple booster
vaccines are given at 3- to 6-month intervals. This occurs especially when a high
level of concentrate feeding occurs, such as in dairy production. The use of hyperimmune
serum must also be performed with caution in goats, particularly Saanens, which are
very prone to anaphylactic reactions. Despite the limitations of protection against
the enteric manifestations of the disease, vaccination is protective against the peracute
form of the disease and kids should be vaccinated twice, a month apart, commencing
at 4 weeks of age with booster vaccinations at 6-month intervals.
Local reactions to vaccination are common in both sheep and goats and may be visible
for at least 6 months. In sheep these are generally hidden by the wool, but the vaccination
site should be high on the neck and close to the base of the ear to minimize carcass
blemish. With goats, especially show goats, the owner should be warned of this occurrence.
Goats, especially show goats, should be vaccinated under the loose skin of the axilla,
where local reactions will be hidden by the elbow.
Further Reading
Allaart
JG
van Asten
AJAM
Gröne
A
Predisposing factors and prevention of Clostridium perfringens-associated enteritis
Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis
36
2013
449
464
23790636
Alves
GG
Clostridium perfringens epsilon toxin: the third most potent bacterial toxin known
Anaerobe
30
2014
102
107
25234332
Bokori-Brown
M
Savva
CG
Molecular basis of toxicity of Clostridium perfringens epsilon toxin
FEBS J
23
2011
4589
4601
Morris
WE
Dunleavy
MV
Effects of Clostridium perfringens alpha and epsilon toxins in the bovine gut
Anaerobe
18
2012
143
147
22178571
Radostits
O
Enterotoxemia associated with Clostridium perfringens type D (pulpy kidney, overeating
disease)
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Diseases of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
841
844
Uzal
FA
Vidal
JE
Clostridium perfringens toxins involved in mammalian veterinary diseases
Open Toxicol
3
2010
24
42
Wioland
L
Dupont
J-L
Bossu
J-L
Attack of the nervous system by Clostridium perfringens epsilon toxin: from disease
to mode of action on neural cells
Toxicon
75
2013
122
135
23632158
References
1
Scholes
SFE
Vet Rec
160
2007
811
2
Sumithra
TG
Small Rum Res
114
2013
1
3
Alves
GG
Anaerobe
30
2014
102
25234332
4
Veschi
JLA
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
125
2008
198
18538416
5
Filho
EJF
Vet Pathol
46
2009
1213
19605912
6
Uzal
FH
Songer
JG
J Vet Diagn Invest
20
2008
253
18460610
7
Lobato
FCF
Vaccine
28
2010
6125
20670910
Focal Symmetric Encephalomalacia
Synopsis
Etiology The disease is a chronic neurologic manifestation of enterotoxemia associated
with Clostridium perfringens type D ε-toxin, with vascular damage and damage to the
nervous system.
Epidemiology Sporadic disease in weaners and mature sheep, usually following a change
of pasture, anthelmintic treatment, or supplementary feeding with grain and incomplete
vaccination regimens.
Clinical findings Aimless wandering, an inability to eat, and a dummy syndrome are
predominant findings
Clinical pathology None reported.
Necropsy findings Gross or histologic areas of malacia in internal capsule, lateral
thalamus, and cerebellar peduncles.
Diagnostic confirmation Epidemiology, clinical and necropsy findings.
Treatment Supportive.
Control Complete vaccination.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Lesions of focal symmetric encephalomalacia have been produced in experimental enterotoxemia
and by infusion with ε-toxin of C. perfringens type D. Similar brain lesions have
been described in an experimentally induced case of enterotoxemia in a 9-month-old
calf that survived for 8 days.
1
Epidemiology
Focal symmetric encephalomalacia occurs most often in lambs, weaners, and mature sheep,
but lesions consistent with focal symmetric encephalomalacia have also been reported
in calves and goats.
2
In grazing sheep. It has the same seasonal occurrence as enterotoxemia but may occur
in sheep of poor body condition. In weaners and mature sheep, there is often a history
of supplementary feeding of highly fermentable carbohydrate, such as cereal grains,
a move to fresh pasture, or of anthelmintic administration 5 to 14 days preceding
the occurrence of initial cases. This is often combined with an incomplete history
of vaccination, and outbreaks have been associated with the grazing of young green
cereal crops. The morbidity is usually low but may approach 15%. The case–fatality
rate is high.
Clinical Findings
Most often, because of infrequent observation of sheep of this age, the finding of
dead sheep is the first indication of the disease. Clinically affected sheep are separate
from the group or can be detected by slow movement of the flock. They show no fear
of humans or dogs and can be examined without restraint. Blindness, aimless wandering,
head-pressing, and incoordination are the predominant findings. More severely affected
sheep lie quietly in lateral recumbency with moderate dorsiflexion of the head and
show infrequent nystagmus with paddling convulsions. The sheep are unable to eat and
most cannot drink, although some affected lambs may still retain a suck reflex. The
clinical course varies from 1 to 14 days, with the majority of affected sheep surviving
for 5 to 7 days.
Necropsy Findings
Lesions are confined to the brain, and formalin-fixed samples of this tissue are required
for confirmation of the diagnosis. In many cases the characteristic lesions can be
detected on macroscopic examination and consist of areas of hemorrhage and softening
in the internal capsule, lateral thalamus, and cerebellar peduncles. Malacia, edema,
and hemorrhage are visible histologically. Glycosuria is not a feature, and toxin
cannot be demonstrated in gut contents.
Treatment and Control
There is no treatment. Less severely affected cases may recover if they are maintained
with fluids and nutrients given by stomach tube. Outbreaks cease if the sheep are
vaccinated with pulpy kidney vaccine.
Further Reading
Finnie
JW
Pathogenesis of brain lesions produced in sheep by Clostridium perfringens type D
epsilon toxin: a review
Aust Vet J
81
2003
219
221
15080445
Wioland
L
Dupont
J-L
Bossu
J-L
Attack of the nervous system by Clostridium perfringens epsilon toxin: from disease
to mode of action on neural cells
Toxicon
75
2013
122
135
23632158
References
1
Filho
EJF
Vet Pathol
46
2009
1213
19605912
2
Anon
Vet Rec
171
2012
168
22904025
Cerebrospinal Angiopathy
Cerebrospinal angiopathy is a sporadic disease of recently weaned pigs manifested
primarily by neurologic signs and wasting. It is probably a form of edema disease.
It affects only one or a few pigs within a litter up to 5 weeks after weaning, although
a similar condition has been reported in finishing and adult pigs. The disease is
characterized by the variety of neurologic signs that it presents. Incoordination
and a decreased central awareness are common presenting signs but abnormal head position,
aimless wandering, and persistent circling may also be observed. There is usually
apparent impairment of vision. Fever is not a feature, and the clinical course may
last for several days. Affected animals may die but are often euthanized because of
emaciation. Wasting without neurologic disorder may also occur. They are also prone
to savaging by unaffected penmates.
Histologically, the disease is characterized by an angiopathy that is not restricted
to the CNS. The similarity of the angiopathy to that seen in chronic edema disease
has led to postulation that this disease is a sequel to subclinical edema disease.
The disease has been reported occurring in pigs 15 to 27 days after experimental E.
coli infection. The characteristic feature is the presence of perivascular eosinophilic
droplets.
The main differential diagnosis is that of spinal or brain abscess and the porcine
viral encephalomyelitides. Affected pigs should be housed separately as soon as clinical
signs are observed. In view of the nature of the lesion, therapy is unlikely to be
of value; however, recovery following treatment with oxytetracycline has been reported.
Further Reading
Harding
DJD
Cerebrospinal angiopathy in pigs
Vet Rec
79
1966
388
6008428
Viral Diseases Primarily Affecting the Cerebrum
Rabies
Synopsis
Etiology
Lyssavirus of family Rhabdoviridae
Epidemiology Occurs in all farm animals worldwide except Australia and New Zealand.
Major zoonoses. Transmitted by bites of infected animal. Different animals are vectors
depending on geographic location: foxes in Europe and North America, skunks and raccoons
in North America, mongoose in Africa, vampire bats in South America.
Signs Incubation period varies from 2 weeks to several months.
Cattle:
Paralytic form: bizarre mental behavior (yawning, bellowing), incoordination, decreased
sensation of hindquarters, drooling saliva, recumbency, and death in 4–7 days. Furious
form: hypersensitive, belligerent, then paralysis and death as in paralytic form.
Sheep: Outbreaks common; sexual excitement, wool pulling, attacking, incoordination,
and then paralysis.
Horses: Abnormal postures, lameness or weakness, depression, ataxia, pharyngeal paralysis,
recumbency, hyperesthesia, biting, loss of anal sphincter tone, death in 4–6 days.
Pigs: Excitement, attack, twitching of nose, clonic convulsions, paralysis.
Clinical pathology No antemortem test.
Lesions Nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis.
Differential diagnosis list
•
Cattle: Lead poisoning, lactation tetany, hypovitaminosis A, listerial meningoencephalitis,
polioencephalomalacia, nervous acetonemia.
•
Sheep: Enterotoxemia, pregnancy toxemia, louping-ill, scrapie.
•
Horse: Viral encephalomyelitis, herpes viral paralysis, cerebrospinal nematodiasis,
equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy, protozoal encephalomyelitis, neuritis of
cauda equina, horsetail poisoning, Borna, Japanese encephalitis, botulism.
•
Pig: Pseudorabies, Teschen disease, Glasser's disease, and other meningitides (Escherichia.
coli and Streptococcus suis).
Diagnostic confirmation Fluorescent antibody test of brain. Negri bodies histologically.
Treatment None. All rabies cases are fatal.
Control Prevention of exposure. Vaccination of domestic animals and wildlife. Quarantine
and biosecurity to prevent entry of virus into country.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Rabies is caused by single-stranded RNA viruses in the genus Lyssavirus of the family
Rhabdoviridae. The Lyssavirus genome contains about 12 kb, and five separate genes
encode for two membrane-associated proteins: matrix (M); glycoprotein (G); and three
structural proteins, nucleoprotein (N), phosphoprotein (P), and polymerase (L).
1
Currently, seven distinct genetic lineages are identified in the genus Lyssavirus:
classical rabies virus (RABV, genotype 1, which includes a number of variants), Lagos
bat virus (LBV, genotype 2), Mokola virus (MOKV, genotype 3), Duvenhage virus (DUUV,
genotype 4), European bat lyssavirus (EBLV, subdivided into genotype 5 and genotype
6), and the Australian bat lyssavirus (ABLV, genotype 7). It was recognized long ago
that the strain of virus known as the “street” rabies virus differed in some way from
“fixed” strains that had been cultivated for vaccine production (grown in cell culture
or passaged through serial generations of laboratory animals). A large number of rabies
virus strains are adapted to particular host species but remain infective for any
mammal.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Rabies occurs in all warm-blooded animals. The disease occurs in cattle, sheep, horses,
and pigs, in most countries, except the insular countries that exclude it by rigid
quarantine measures or prohibition of the entry of dogs. However, the genus Lyssavirus
can still cause surprises. In 1996 and 1998, two women died in Queensland, Australia,
from infections with a newly discovered rabies-related virus (Australian bat lyssavirus).
In 2002 a man died in Scotland after contracting European bat lyssavirus rabies indicating
that after a century of apparent freedom from rabies, the disease is now enzootic
in the UK.
Europe
In Europe, sylvatic rabies is a major problem for which the red fox is the principal
vector. The disease is still spreading from a focal point that developed in Poland
in the mid-1930s. It is endemic in Yugoslavia and Turkey, and has spread westward
to Germany, Denmark, Belgium, Czechoslovakia, Austria, Switzerland, and France. Spread
continues at the rate of about 30 to 60 km (18–37 miles) per year, and the threat
to the UK increases each year.
2
Finland had been free of rabies since 1959, but in 1988 sylvatic rabies occurred with
the raccoon dog as the vector.
United States
Information on rabies surveillance in the United States is published annually by the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). In 2013, 92% of cases occurred in
wild animals, 4.2% in cats, 1.5% in cattle, and 1.5% in dogs. The disease occurred
in raccoons, bats, skunks, foxes, sheep and goats, horses and mules, mongoose, rodents
and lagomorphs, and humans.
The most frequently reported rabid wildlife cases occurred in raccoons, skunks, bats,
and foxes. The relative contributions of those species continue to change in recent
decades because of fluctuations in enzootics of rabies among animals infected with
several distinct variants of the rabies virus. Endemic raccoon rabies occurs in the
Appalachian mountain range and the entire eastern seaboard of the United States. Endemic
skunk rabies occurs mainly in three geographic regions: the north central United States
and the Canadian provinces of Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta; south central United
States; and California. Within these broad areas, the disease persists in enzootic
foci and erupts every 6 to 8 years. Experimental studies suggest that the species
specificity of endemic rabies is caused by differences in the pathogenicity of variants
of rabies virus. Skunk rabies peaks in the spring and early winter, which is probably
a reflection of certain life history events within the skunk population.
The prevalence of rabies in bats in the United States is about 7%, and transmission
to humans is rare even though sensational journalism has caused many people to consider
bats as a serious threat to health. Trends in national surveillance for rabies among
bats in the United States from 1993 to 2013 have consistently found a diffuse geographic
pattern of rabies in bats throughout the continental United States. Although spillover
infection of bat variants of rabies among terrestrial animals such as dogs and cats
are rare, these variants of rabies virus have been associated with 92% of the indigenously
acquired human rabies infections in the United States since 1990.
Canada
The arctic fox variant of rabies invaded most of Canada south of 60°N and east of
the Rocky Mountains in the early 1950s largely by the migration of arctic foxes into
the populated areas. It died out in most of that range, but persisted for over 40
years in southern Ontario with sporadic incursions into narrow adjacent strips in
western Quebec and northern New York. The principal vectors were red foxes (Vulpes
vulpes) and, to a lesser extent, striped skunks (Mephitis mephitis). From 1957 to
1989, Ontario experienced more animal rabies cases than almost every North American
jurisdiction almost every year, and over 95% of those cases were limited to the southernmost
10% of the province's land area.
A second major outbreak, involving striped skunks, progressed from North Dakota into
the Prairie Provinces during the late 1950s and 1960s. In the 1990s, the endemic areas
in Canada are southern Ontario, which accounts for 85% of the Canadian diagnoses,
and the Prairie Provinces where rabies is endemic in skunks. In western Canada, the
main reservoirs of the rabies virus are skunks, bats, and foxes.
Africa
Rabies occurs in most countries in the African continent, but the reported incidence
is surprisingly low for an area with such a high population of wild carnivores. The
incidence of rabies, and the range of species involved, is increasing in Africa, and
a number of wildlife hosts has been identified, including wild dogs, jackals, and
mongoose.
In South Africa over a 4-year period, of all the domestic animal rabies cases reported,
cattle accounted for half of the rabies cases in domestic animals. The mongoose accounted
for 70% of the wild animal cases reported. Widespread distribution of the rabies virus
occurs when the young mongooses are evicted from their parents' territory during the
winter months, forcing them to scatter over a wide area. This increases the probability
of domestic animals coming in contact with rabid animals.
South America, Latin America, and the Caribbean
Rabies in cattle is a major economic and public health problem in South America, where
vampire bat–transmitted rabies results in cyclic outbreaks. Bovine paralytic rabies
is endemic in the tropical regions extending from northern Mexico, to northern Argentina,
and on the island of Trinidad.
Distribution of Virus Variants
The Lyssavirus genus belongs to the Rhabdoviridae family of the Mononegavirales order
and includes unsegmented RNA viruses causing rabies encephalomyelitis. They are well
fitted to vectors belonging to the orders Carnivora (flesh-eating mammals including
skunks) and Chiroptera (the order which comprises all of the 178 genera in 16 families
of bats). Seven genotypes have been delineated within the genus. These genotypes are
divided into two immunopathologically and genetically distinct phylogroups. Phylogroup
I includes two African genotypes: Mokola virus, which has been isolated from shrews
and cats, although its reservoir remains unknown, and Lagos bat virus, which has been
found mainly in frugivorous bats but also in an insectivorous bat. Phylogroup II has
five genotypes: DUUV (Africa), EBLV-1 (Europe), EBLV-2 (Europe), Australian bat lyssavirus
(Australia), and the classical RABV (worldwide). Members of the genotypes Duvenhage
virus, EBLV-1, and EBLV-2 are exclusively found in insectivorous bats, members of
the genotype Australian bat lyssavirus are found in both insectivorous and frugivorous
bats, and members of the genotype RABV are found in carnivorous and American bats
(insectivorous, frugivorous, and hematophagous). The fact that lyssaviruses are well
established in two ecologically distinct mammal orders may very likely be the consequence
of successful host switching.
Analysis of 36 carnivoran and 17 chiropteran lyssaviruses representing the main genotypes
and variants strongly supports the hypothesis that host switching occurred in the
history of the lyssaviruses. In fact, lyssaviruses evolved in chiroptera long before
the emergence of carnivoran rabies, very likely following spillover from bats. Using
dated isolates, the emergence of carnivoran rabies from chiropteran lyssaviruses is
estimated to have occurred 888 to 1459 years ago. In Europe, bat rabies is associated
with two specific virus strains: European bat lyssavirus type 1 and European bat lyssavirus
type 2. European bat lyssavirus type 1 isolates have been found in serotine bats in
France. European bat lyssavirus type 2 has now been found in Daubenton's bats in England
and Scotland.
In North America, variants of rabies virus are maintained in the wild by several terrestrial
carnivore species, including raccoons, skunks, and a number of bat species. Each antigenically
and genetically distinct variant of the virus in mammalian species occurs in geographically
discrete areas and is strongly associated with its reservoir species. Within each
area, a spillover of rabies into other species occurs, especially during epidemics.
Temporal and spatial analysis of skunk and raccoon rabies in the eastern United States
indicated that epidemics in raccoons and skunks moved in a similar direction from
1990 to 2000. However, there is no evidence that the raccoon rabies virus variant
is cycling independently in the skunk population of the eastern United States or that
the variant has undergone any genetic adaptations among skunks.
Within broad geographic regions, rabies infections in terrestrial mammals can be linked
to distinct virus variants, identified by panels of monoclonal antibodies or by genetic
analysis. These analyses have demonstrated substantial differences between isolates
from various parts of the world and conventional vaccines do not fully protect against
some of the naturally occurring antigenic variants that exist in nature. Most outbreaks
of rabies tend to be host species specific. Each variant is maintained primarily by
intraspecific transmission within a dominant reservoir, although spillover infection
of other species may occur within the region. Geographic boundaries of the currently
recognized reservoirs for rabies in terrestrial mammals have been established. Reservoirs
for rabies virus are found worldwide. The virus is maintained at endemic and epidemic
levels in a wide variety of Carnivora and Microchiroptera (bats) species.
The geographic boundaries of the currently recognized reservoirs for rabies in terrestrial
species in North America are as follows:
•
Raccoons in the southeastern United States
•
Red and arctic foxes in Alaska, resulting in spread across Canada as far east as Ontario,
Quebec, and the New England states
•
Striped skunks in California, the north central states, and the south central states
•
Gray foxes in small reservoirs in Arizona
•
Coyotes in south Texas as a result of spread from domestic dogs in a long-standing
reservoir at the Texas–Mexico border
In Ontario, wildlife rabies persists in two predominant species: the red fox and the
striped skunk. Molecular epidemiology studies indicate that there is no host specificity,
but there are very clear and consistent differences in the virus from distinct geographic
regions. In Canadian studies, two major antigenic groups can be distinguished among
the rabies virus isolates examined. One group is found in Ontario, Quebec, and the
Northwest Territories and is represented in the wild by endemic red fox and striped
skunk rabies that originated in northern Canada. The second group is found in Manitoba
where striped skunk rabies is endemic.
Overlying the disease in terrestrial mammals are multiple, independent reservoirs
for rabies in several species of insectivorous bats. Distinct viral variants can be
identified for different bat species, but geographic boundaries cannot be defined
for rabies outbreaks in the highly mobile bat species.
Methods of Transmission
The source of infection is always an infected animal, and the method of spread is
almost always by the bite of an infected animal, although contamination of skin wounds
by fresh saliva may result in infection. Not all bites from rabid animals result in
infection because the virus is not always present in the saliva; the virus may not
gain entrance to the wound if the saliva is wiped from the teeth by clothing. The
virus may appear in the milk of affected animals, but spread by this means is unlikely
as infection. The rabies virus is relatively fragile, susceptible to most standard
disinfectants, and dies in dried saliva in a few hours.
One of the most important parameters in rabies models is the transmission rate, or
the number of susceptible animals infected by a diseased animal per unit of time.
In a population of 19 raccoons feeding at a concentrated, common food source available
during the summer in rural eastern Ontario, raccoons bite and are bitten an average
of 1.0 to 1.3 times per hour, respectively.
Because of the natural occurrence of rabies in animals in caves inhabited by infected
insectivorous bats, inhalation as a route of infection came under suspicion. It is
now accepted that interbat spread, and spread from bats to other species is principally
by bites, but that infection by inhalation also occurs. That infection can occur by
ingestion has been put to use in devising systems of vaccinating wildlife by baiting
them with virus-laden baits.
Animal Vectors
Traditionally, the dog, and to a minor extent the cat, have been the main source animals.
However, native fauna, including foxes, skunks, wolves, coyotes, vampire, insectivorous
and fruit-eating bats, raccoons, mongoose, and squirrels provide the major source
of infection in countries where domestic Carnivora are well controlled. In general,
foxes are less dangerous than dogs, because foxes tend to bite only one or two animals
in a group, whereas dogs will often bite a large proportion of a herd or flock. Raccoons
and skunks are major reservoirs of rabies in North America.
Bats are the most important species in which subclinical carriers occur. Multiplication
of the virus without invasion of the nervous system is known to occur in fatty tissues
in bats and may be the basis of the “reservoiring” mechanism in this species. Violent
behavior is rare in rabid animals of this species, but it has been observed. Bats
represent a serious threat of spread of rabies because of their migratory habits.
Most spread is within the species, but the threat to humans and animal species by
bats cannot be completely disregarded. Although rodents can be infected with the rabies
virus they are not thought to play any part in the epidemiology of rabies, either
as multipliers or simply as physical carriers of the virus. Many of the viruses they
carry are rabies-like rather than classical rabies.
Rabies has occurred in swine herds where the skunk population is high, where farms
were settled from rough terrain resulting in considerable interface between wildlife
and domestic animals, and in which the management system allows the pigs to run free
on the premises. The disease has occurred in pigs reared in a closed feeder barn where
access by wildlife was very unlikely.
There is a difference in the role between vectors. For example, in Europe it is thought
that foxes carry the infection into a new area, but other species disseminate it within
an area. Foxes are the principal vectors and, as in Canada, cattle are the principal
receptors. In western Canada, the main reservoirs of infection are skunks, bats, and
foxes. This would have important consequences for control programs based on wildlife
surveillance.
Domestic livestock like cattle are rarely a source of infection, although chance transmission
to humans may occur if the mouth of a rabid animal is manipulated during treatment
or examination. The virus may be present in the saliva for periods up to 5 days before
signs are evident.
Seasonal Spread
Spread of the disease is often seasonal, with the highest incidence in the late summer
and autumn because of large-scale movements of wild animals at mating time and in
pursuit of food. In Canada, the frequency of rabies infection in livestock populations
increases in the fall when adolescent foxes mature, begin mating behavior, and travel
over large areas.
Latent Infection
Because of rapid developments in virologic techniques, especially serologic screening
of animal populations to obtain presumptive diagnoses of the presence of a virus in
the population, the question of latent infection and inapparent carriers of rabies
has assumed some importance. The presence of rabies antibodies in animals in a supposed
rabies-free area is likely to arouse concern. Inapparent carriers do occur in bats
and there is some evidence that latent infections can occur in other species.
Zoonotic Implications
The disease in unvaccinated and untreated humans has always been considered fatal.
The prime importance of rabies is its transmissibility to humans, with veterinarians
being at special risk. European data indicate that by far the greatest proportion
of humans requiring pretreatment for rabies have been exposed to a rabid domestic
animal, and not a wild one. Human rabies is extremely rare in countries where canine
rabies is controlled by regular vaccination.
Economic Importance
Rabies is not of major economic importance in farm animals, although individual herds
and flocks may suffer many fatalities. The economic costs of rabies in a country are
associated with pet animal vaccinations, animal bite investigations, confinement and
quarantine of domestic animals that bite humans or that are suspected of exposure
to rabid animals, salaries of animal control officers, laboratory diagnosis, the costs
of preexposure and postexposure prophylaxis and treatment and consultation, public
education, staff training, and clerical costs.
Pathogenesis
Following the deep introduction of rabies virus by the bite of a rabid animal, initial
virus multiplication occurs in striated muscle cells at the site. The neuromuscular
spindles then provide an important site of virus entry into the nervous system, which
may also occur at motor end plates. In the olfactory end organ in the nares, neuroepithelial
cells are in direct contact with the body surface, and these cells extend without
interruption into the olfactory bulb of the brain. Following entry of the virus into
nerve findings, there is invasion of the brain by passive movement of the virus within
axons, first into the spinal cord, and then into the brain. The immune response during
this phase of the infection is minimal and explains why neutralizing antibody and
inflammatory infiltration are usually absent at the time of onset of encephalitic
signs. Antibody titers reach substantial levels only in the terminal stages of the
disease. Following entry of rabies virus to the CNS, usually in the spinal cord, an
ascending wave of neuronal infection and neuronal dysfunction occurs.
The primary lesions produced are in the CNS, and spread from the site of infection
occurs only by way of the peripheral nerves. This method of spread accounts for the
extremely variable incubation period, which varies to a large extent with the site
of the bite. Bites on the head usually result in a shorter incubation period than
bites on the extremities. The severity and the site of the lesions will govern to
a large extent whether the clinical picture is primarily one of irritative or paralytic
phenomena. The two extremes of the paralytic or dumb form and the furious form are
accompanied by many cases that lie somewhere between the two. Gradually ascending
paralysis of the hindquarters may be followed by severe signs of mania, which persist
almost until death. Destruction of spinal neurons results in paralysis, but when the
virus invades the brain, irritation of higher centers produces manias, excitement,
and convulsions. Death is usually caused by respiratory paralysis. The clinical signs
of salivation, indigestion and pica, paralysis of bladder and anus, and increased
libido all suggest involvement of the autonomic nervous system, including endocrine
glands. At death, there are viral inclusions and particles in almost all neurons in
the brain, spinal cord, and ganglia, but none in the supportive cells of the CNS.
Electron microscopic examination also shows the presence of the virus in the cornea,
which it reaches centrifugally along the peripheral nerves.
Virus reaches the salivary glands and many other organs in the same way, but the highly
infective nature of saliva arises from passage of the virus along the olfactory nerve
to taste buds and other sensory end organs in the oropharynx, rather than from the
salivary glands. Experimentally, infection of nonnervous tissues in skunks and foxes
has been reproduced in the adrenal medulla, cornea, and nasal glands. The virus may
be found in milk, in some organs and in fetuses, but the virus cannot be demonstrated
in the blood at any time.
Variations in the major manifestations as mania or paralysis may depend on the source
of the virus. Virus from vampire bats almost always causes the paralytic form. “Fixed”
virus that has been modified by serial intracerebral passage causes ascending paralysis
in contrast to “street” virus, which more commonly causes the furious form. The site
of infection and the size of the inoculum may also influence the clinical course.
There is also a geographic difference in the proportion of animals affected by the
furious or paralytic form of the disease. In the Americas most cases are paralytic.
In Africa and India most cases in farm animals are the furious form.
The disease is always fatal, but infrequently an experimentally infected animal shows
clinical signs of the disease but recovers. There are two recent records of spontaneous
recovery in man, and the occurrence of nonfatal rabies in all species has been reviewed.
There appears to be no field occurrence in domestic animals of the finding in experimentally
infected mice that some strains of virus invade only peripheral nerves and spinal
ganglia leaving a number of survivors with permanent nervous disability. The pathogenesis
of recovery from rabies is important relative to vaccination and serologic testing
to determine the incidence and prevalence of the disease.
Clinical Findings
Among farm animals, cattle are most commonly affected. The incubation period in naturally
occurring cases is about 3 weeks, but varies from 2 weeks to several months in most
species, although incubation periods of 5 and 6 months have been observed in cattle
and dogs.
Cattle
Experimentally, in cattle the average incubation period was 15 days and the average
course of the disease was 4 days. Unvaccinated cattle had shorter incubation and clinical
duration of disease than vaccinated cattle. Major clinical findings included excessive
salivation (100%), behavioral change (100%), muzzle tremors (80%), vocalization (bellowing
70%), aggression, hyperesthesia and/or hyperexcitability (70%), and pharyngeal paralysis
(60%). The furious form occurred in 70%.
In the paralytic form, knuckling of the hind fetlocks, sagging and swaying of the
hindquarters while walking, and often deviation or flaccidity of the tail to one side,
are common early signs. Decreased sensation usually accompanies this weakness and
is one of the best diagnostic criteria in the detection of rabies. It is most evident
over the hindquarters. Tenesmus, with paralysis of the anus, resulting in the sucking
in and blowing out of air, usually occurs late in the incoordination stages just before
the animal becomes recumbent. This is a characteristic finding but it may be transient
or absent. Drooling of saliva is one of the most constant findings. The yawning movements
are more accurately described as voiceless attempts to bellow, and voiceless bellowing
is considered a helpful clinical sign for distinguishing rabid cows from nonrabid
cows, and when sound is generated in rabid cattle, the bellowing is of a higher pitch
than normal.
3
When paralysis occurs, the animal becomes recumbent and unable to rise. Bulls in this
stage often have paralysis of the penis. Death usually occurs 48 hours after recumbency
develops and after a total course of 6 to 7 days.
In furious rabies, the animal has a tense, alert appearance, is hypersensitive to
sounds and movement, and is attracted to noise so that it may look intently or approach
as though about to attack. In some cases, it will violently attack other animals or
inanimate objects. These attacks are often badly directed and are impeded by the incoordination
of gait. Frequently, loud bellowing is usual at this stage. The sound is characteristically
hoarse and the actions are exaggerated. Sexual excitement is also common, with bulls
often attempting to mount inanimate objects. Multiple collections of semen for artificial
insemination have been made during very short periods from bulls that later proved
to be rabid. With this violent form of the disease, the termination is characteristically
sudden. Severe signs may be evident for 24 to 48 hours and the animal then collapses
suddenly in a paralyzed state, dying usually within a few hours.
There is no consistent pattern in either the development or the range of signs. Body
temperatures are usually normal but may be elevated to 39.5°C to 40.5°C (103°F-105°F)
in the early stages by muscular activity. Appetite varies also. Some animals do not
eat or drink, although they may take food into the mouth. There is apparent an inability
to swallow. Others eat normally until the terminal stages. The course may vary from
1 to 6 days. So wide is the variation in clinical findings that any animal known to
be exposed and showing signs of spinal cord or brain involvement should be considered
rabid until proved otherwise.
Sheep and Goats
In sheep experimentally infected, the average incubation period was 10 days, and the
average course of the disease was 3 days. Major clinical findings included muzzle
and head tremors (80%); aggressiveness, hyperexcitability, and hyperesthesia (80%);
trismus (60%); salivation (60%); vocalization (60%); and recumbency (40%). The furious
form occurred in 80% of sheep. In one large-scale outbreak in sheep, deaths occurred
17 to 111 days after exposure.
Rabies often occurs in a number of animals at one time because of the ease with which
a number of sheep can be bitten by a dog or fox. Clinically, the picture is similar
to that seen in cattle. The minority of animals show sexual excitement, attacking
humans or each other, and vigorous wool pulling; sudden falling after violent exertion,
muscle tremor, and salivation are characteristic. Excessive bleating does not occur.
Most sheep are quiet and anorectic. Goats are commonly aggressive, and continuous
bleating is common.
Horses
Most recorded cases in horses are lacking in distinctive nervous signs initially,
but incline to the paralytic form of the disease. Experimentally, the average incubation
period was 12 days and the average duration of disease was 6 days. Unvaccinated animals
had shorter incubation periods and duration of clinical disease. Muzzle tremors were
the most frequently observed and most common initial signs. Other clinical findings
included pharyngeal paresis (71%), ataxia or paresis (71%), and lethargy or somnolence
(71%). The furious form occurred in 43% of cases, some of which began as the dumb
form. The paralytic form was not observed.
In naturally occurring cases, the initial clinical findings may include abnormal postures,
frequent whinnying, unexplained aggressiveness and kicking, biting, colic, sudden
onset of lameness in one limb followed by recumbency the next day, high-stepping gait,
ataxia, apparent blindness, and violent head-tossing. Lameness or weakness in one
leg may be the first sign observed, but the usual pattern of development starts with
lassitude, then passes to sternal recumbency and lateral recumbency, followed by paddling
convulsions and terminal paralysis.
In a series of 21 confirmed cases in horses, the clinical findings at the time of
initial examination included ataxia and paresis of the hindquarters (43%), lameness
(24%), recumbency (14%), pharyngeal paralysis (10%), and colic (10%). The major clinical
findings observed over the course of hospitalization included recumbency (100%), hyperesthesia
(81%), loss of tail and anal sphincter tone (57%), fever ~38.5°C (52%), and ataxia
and paresis of the hindquarters (52%). Mean survival time after the onset of clinical
signs was 4 days (range, 1–7 days). Clinical findings of the furious form of rabies,
such as aggressiveness (biting), compulsive circling, and abnormal vocalization, were
evident in only two horses. Supportive therapy, given to nine horses, had no effect
on survival time and did not correlate with the detection of Negri bodies at necropsy.
Horses developing the furious form show excitement, become vicious, and bite and kick.
Their uncontrolled actions are often violent and dangerous and include blind changes,
sudden falling, and rolling and chewing of foreign material or their own skin. Hyperesthesia
and muscular twitching of the hindlimbs followed by crouching and weakness are also
recorded in the horse.
Pigs
Pigs manifest excitement and a tendency to attack, or dullness and incoordination.
Affected sows show twitching of the nose, rapid chewing movements, excessive salivation,
and clonic convulsions. They may walk backward. Terminally, there is paralysis and
death occurs 12 to 48 hours after the onset of signs. The clinical findings in pigs
are extremely variable, and individual cases may present in a variety of ways and
only one or two of the classical findings may occur.
Clinical Pathology
No antemortem laboratory examination is of diagnostic value, but tests for lead on
blood, urine, and feces may help to eliminate lead poisoning as a possible diagnosis.
Virus neutralization tests are available, but the presence of antibodies is not diagnostic.
Other available tests are passive hemagglutination, complement fixation, radioimmunoassay,
and indirect fluorescent antibody staining. These are used to determine immune status
rather than as a diagnostic aid. An ELISA is available for measurement of rabies-specific
antibody in the sera of major domestic and wildlife reservoirs in North America.
Necropsy Findings
Confirmation of a diagnosis of rabies depends on careful laboratory examination of
fresh brain. The recommended laboratory procedure includes the following tests and
it is recommended that at least two of them be used on all specimens.
•
The most widely used test is the fluorescent antibody test (FAT) on impression smears
from the brain. Current recommendations include sampling of the hippocampus, medulla
oblongata, cerebellum, or gasserian ganglion.
4
However, a recent publication stipulates that the hippocampus and cerebellum are less
desirable samples than the thalamus, pons, or medulla for the detection of viral antigen,
and that the current sampling recommendations stem from the visibility of Negri bodies,
rather than the true distribution of viral antigen. An FAT can be completed in approximately
2 hours and is accurate when done routinely by experienced personnel because it detects
all genotypes if a potent conjugate is used.
5
The reliability of FAT confirmed by the mouse inoculation test is over 99%. Those
specimens that are negative on FAT, and have contact with humans, are inoculated into
experimental mice. The incubation period in mice before clinical signs are seen averages
11 to 12 days (range of 4–18 days), and death occurs in 7 to 21 days. The mouse brain
is harvested as soon as signs appear and is submitted to the same tests described
earlier. Thus a positive result can be obtained as soon as 4 to 7 days after inoculation.
Some mice must be left for the full 21 days because only a negative result at that
time can give a complete negative to the test. A tissue culture infection test is
now available, which allows demonstration of the virus in stained tissue culture cells
within 4 days. This may replace the mouse inoculation test.
•
A dot ELISA is available for the detection of rabies antigen in animals. It is rapid,
simple, economical and, in comparison with the FAT, the agreement is 95%.
•
A histologic search for Negri bodies in tissue sections has results available in 48
hours. Because of false-positive diagnoses the technique is in some disrepute.
•
An immunohistochemical (IHC) test for rabies can be used on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded
brain tissues of domestic animals and wild animals when fresh tissues are not available.
In some cases, the brain tissue may be negative for the rabies virus using standard
diagnostic techniques, but IHC tests may detect the presence of antigen.
•
A reverse transcriptase (RT-)PCR test has been found of value in detecting rabies
infection in decomposed brain samples that were negative by the direct FAT.
The histopathologic changes of rabies infection include a nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis
and ganglioneuritis, with neuronal necrosis and the formation of glial nodules. Negri
bodies are most commonly found in the Purkinje cells of the cerebellum in ruminants.
Spongiform change has also been reported in the brain of a heifer infected with rabies
virus.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: half of midsagittally sectioned brain, cervical spinal cord (including
root ganglia), gasserian ganglion, parotid salivary gland (LM, IHC)
•
Virology: half of midsagittally sectioned brain, cervical spinal cord (FAT, BIOASSAY).
Note the zoonotic potential of this organism when handling carcass and submitting
specimens.
Differential Diagnosis
The diagnosis of rabies is one of the most difficult and important duties that a veterinarian
is called on to perform. Because in most cases there is a probability of human exposure,
failure to recognize the disease may place human life in jeopardy. It is not even
sufficient to say that if rabies occurs in the area one will classify every animal
showing nervous signs as rabid, because nervous signs may not be evident for some
days after the illness commences. In addition, many animals suffering from other diseases
will be left untreated. The best policy is to handle all suspect animals with extreme
care but continue to treat them for other diseases if such treatment appears to be
indicated. If the animal is rabid, it will die and the diagnosis can then be confirmed
by laboratory examination.
Several diseases are characterized by signs of abnormal mental state or paralysis,
or a combination of both (see Table 14-9
for the horse; Table 14-10
for cattle). Rabies must be differentiated from the following common diseases affecting
the nervous system, according to species.
Table 14-9
Diseases of horses characterized by signs of intracranial or disseminated lesions
of the central nervous system
Table 14-9
Disease
Etiology and epidemiology
Clinical and laboratory findings
Treatment and control
Infection causes
Viral encephalomyelitis (WEE, EEE, VEE)
Summer seasonInsect vector, usually mosquitoesYoung nonvaccinated horses at greatest
risk, outbreaks may occur
Stage of slight hyperexcitability and mild fever initially, impaired eyesight, circling
and walkingStage of mental depression, somnolence, leaning, feed hanging from mouth,
unsteadyStage of paralysis, unable to swallow, weakness, recumbency; dies 2–4 days
after onsetSerology for diagnosis
Supportive therapy, thick beddingRecovery rate 60%–75%Vaccinate foals at 6 months
of age and other horses for the first time, twice 2 weeks apart and once or twice
annually thereafter
Rabies
All age groups, knowledge of disease in area, wildlifeUsually single animal affectedNot
common
Ascending paralysis, hypersalivation, will biteAtaxia and paresis of hindlimbs, lameness,
recumbency, pharyngeal paralysis, colic, loss of tail and sphincter tone, feverDies
in 1 weekImmunofluorescent antibody testing on brain for positive diagnosis
No treatmentAll dieVaccinate horses if anticipate outbreak
Herpesvirus myeloencephalopathy (EHV-1)
Can occur as outbreaksNeurologic disease usually preceded by feverMature horses
Symmetric ataxia and paresis, bladder paralysis, recumbency may occur, spontaneous
recovery possible, CSF (hemorrhage or xanthochromia)Vasculitis with subsequent focal
malacia in gray and white matter of brain and spinal cord
No specific therapyAntiinflammatory drugs may be usefulUse of corticosteroids is controversialRecovery
may occur spontaneously
WNE
West Nile virusLate summer in temperate regionsCan occur as epizooticsNow enzootic
in most of North America
Fever, muscle fasciculations, weakness, ataxia, depression, cranial nerve disease,
recumbencyProminent signs of spinal cord precede sign of intracranial disease in most
cases
SupportiveAntiserumInterferonAntiinflammatory. drugs including corticosteroidsPrevention
by vaccination
Borna
VirusDirect transmissionGermany and other European countriesDisease is recorded in
JapanLow morbidity, high case–fatality rate
Pharyngeal paralysis, muscle tremor, flaccid paralysis, course 1–3 weeksViral encephalomyelitis
with inclusion bodies
No treatment
Japanese encephalitis
Japanese encephalitis virusSporadicAsia including Japan and China, parts of Oceania
including New Guinea and Torres StraitPig is mammalian amplifying hostVector mosquitoes,
birds infected
Fever, lethargy, jaundice, dysphagia, incoordination, staggering, recovery in 1 weekSerology
Spontaneous recoveryVaccination in endemic areas
Protozoal myeloencephalitis
Sarcocystis neurona
Single animal affectedInfectious but not contagious
Any central nervous system disorder.Usually causes ataxia but can cause cerebral and
cranial nerve disease
Antiprotozoal medications (pyrimethamine + sulphonamide, ponazuril, or nitazoxanide)Vaccine
available in the United States, but not recommended
Cerebrospinal nematodiasis (verminous encephalitis)
Migration of larval stages of Strongylus vulgaris, Habronema sp., and Filaroides
Micronema deletrix (Helicephalobolus) deletrix
Not common
Clinical signs referable to gray matter lesions are commonHypalgesia, hyporeflexia,
hypotonia, muscle atrophy and cerebral, cerebellar and cranial nerve involvementProgressive
encephalitis, incoordination, sensory deficits, blindness in one or both eyes, course
of several daysPleocytosis of CSFHemorrhage and malacia of thalamus, brainstem, cerebellum
Ivermectin or moxidectin at usual dosesHigh dose benzimidazoleAntiinflammatory drugsParasite
control
Brain abscess
SporadicOften a complication of strangles
Obtunded mentation, variable signs of intracranial diseaseLeukocytosisVariable pleocytosis
and increased protein concentration in CSFCT scan
AntimicrobialsSurgical drainagePrognosis is poor
Physical
Traumatic injury to the brain
History of traumatic injury (falling, rearing-up and falling backward)
Coma, depression, hemorrhage from nose and ears, blindness, cranial nerve deficitsOften
rupture of longus capitus muscle
Antiinflammatory drugs, mannitolFair to poor prognosis
Facial nerve paralysis
Associated with prolonged surgical recumbency and compression of facial nerve
Facial nerve paralysis lasting several daysParalysis of ear, eyelid, lip, nostril
on one sideNo alteration in sensation or vestibular function
Supportive
Lightning strike
Observed lightning strike or history of recent thunderstorm activity
Death is most commonHorses that survive strike often have prominent signs of vestibular
disease
SupportiveRecovery is possible
Fracture or arthritis of the temporal-stylohyoid articulation, otitis media
Sporadic in older horses
Acute onset circling, head tilt, nystagmus, unilateral facial paralysis, dysphagia
Antibiotics, antiinflammatory drugs, supportive care
Intoxications
Horsetail poisoning (Equisetum arvense)
Ingestion of plants mixed with hayNot common
Incoordination, swaying from side to side, muscle tremor recumbency, bradycardia,
cardiac arrhythmia
Thiamine parenterally. Good response
Equine leukoencephalomalacia (fumonisin toxicosis)
Horses eating moldy corn grain contaminated with Fusarium moniliforme fungus
Muscle tremor, weakness, staggering gait, dysphagia, depression
None
Hepatoencephalopathy associated with hepatotoxic plants (Crotalaria, Senecio and Amsinckia)
Horses on inadequate pasture forced to eat poisonous plantsMore than one animal may
be affectedGeographic distribution
Develops slowly, commonly ill for 2–3 weeks previously, depression, pushing, ataxia,
hypertonic face and lips, yawning, compulsive walking, loss of weight, icterus, photosensitization
occasionallySerum liver enzymes elevated and liver function tests abnormalHyperammonemiaGross
and histopathologic liver lesions
No treatmentPrevent access to poisonous plants
Lead poisoning
Grazing on pastures contaminated by atmospheric lead from nearby factories, not common
now
Usually a chronic diseaseInspiratory dyspnea caused by paralysis of recurrent laryngeal
nervePharyngeal paralysis, dysphagia, aspiration pneumonia, paralysis of lips, weakness
and recumbencyIngestion of large amounts causes subacute form similar to that seen
in cattle
Calcium versenate
Yellow-star thistle poisoning (Centaurea sp., anigropallidal encephalomalacia of horses)
Ingestion of yellow-star thistle in California and AustraliaSummer months on weedy
pasture
Difficult prehension, fixed facial expression with mouth held half open, hypertonic
face and lips, persistent chewing movements and rhythmic protrusion of tongue, yawning
and somnolence but easily aroused, aimless walking, slight stiffness of gait, high
mortalityMalacia of globus plants pallidus and substantia nigra
No treatmentPrevent access to poisonous plants
Botulism
Ingestion of preformed toxin of Cl. botulinum in decaying grass or spoiled silage,
hay or grain. Sporadic in horses.Endemic in foals in some areas of North America
Flaccid paralysis of skeletal muscles leading to weakness, stumbling and recumbency.
Mentation normal.Skin sensation normal. Paralysis of tongue and thoracic muscles.
Die in 2–4 days. Some recover. Filtrates of intestinal tract into laboratory animals
Supportive therapy, antitoxins. Vaccination in enzootic areas. Prevent contamination
of feed by animal carcasses
Tetanus
Wounds infected with Clostridium tetani
Sporadic
Generalized tetany of all skeletal musclesFever, hyperesthesia, protrusion of third
eyelid, trismus, recumbency followed by tetanic convulsions, die in 5–10 days
Prognosis unfavorableDark stall, penicillin, muscle relaxants, supportive therapy
and antitoxin parenterally or into subarachnoid spaceToxoid vaccination
Metabolic and idiopathic
Lactation tetany
Lactating mares, suckling foalsHypocalcemia
Acute onset of generalized stiffness, trismus, no hyperesthesia, no prolapse of third
eyelid, diaphragmatic flutter, soft heart soundsSerum hypocalcemia
Rapid response to calcium borogluconate intravenously
Idiopathic epilepsy of Arabians
Single horseFirst noticed from shortly after birth up to 6 months of ageEtiology unknown
Recurrent episodes of typical clonic-tonic convulsions lasting 10–15 minutes, loss
of consciousness, sweating, tachycardia, spontaneous defecationNo lesions
Control seizures with phenobarbital or potassium bromideSpontaneous recovery as foals
mature
Idiopathic epilepsy of adult horses
Sporadic diseaseUnknown causeCan be associated with brain lesions detectable on EEG
or CT
Tonic-clonic convulsionsVariable periodicity and intensity
Control seizures acutely with diazepam and in the long term with phenobarbital and/or
potassium bromideSpontaneous recovery unlikely
Cerebellar hypoplasia of Arabian and Swedish Gotland foals
InheritedSigns noticeable from 2–6 months of age
Defective eye blinks, ataxia, head-nodding, slight tremor of head and neck, intention
tremor of the head, high-stepping gait, difficulty in rising, legs wide apart, difficulty
in jumping over obstacles, fall backward if dorsiflex head and neckCerebellar hypoplasia
grossly or histologically
Eliminate carrier animals
Lower motor neuron disease
Associated with stabling and no access to pastureSporadicNorth America and EuropeLow
serum vitamin E concentrations
Weight loss, weakness, muscle fasciculations, maintained appetiteNormal mentationLow
serum vitamin E concentrationDiagnosis by muscle biopsy
No definitive cureSome cases stabilized with administration of oral vitamin EPoor
prognosis for return to function
Note: Other less common diseases affecting the nervous system of horses include space-occupying
lesions (cholesteatomas of old horses, tumors), intracranial myiasis caused by migration
of Hypoderma bovis, hydrocephalus in young horses, the accidental injection of an
ataractic drug into the carotid artery, and bacterial meningitis in young horses as
a sequel to streptococcal infection.
CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; CT, computed tomography; EEE, eastern equine encephalitis;
EEG, electroencephalogram; EHV-1, equine herpesvirus-1; VEE, Venezuelan equine encephalitis;
WEE, western equine encephalitis; WNE, West Nile encephalomyelitis.
Table 14-10
Differential diagnosis of diseases of cattle with clinical findings referable to brain
dysfunction
Table 14-10
Disease
Epidemiology
Clinical findings
Clinical pathology and pathology
Response to treatment
Lead poisoning
All ages of calves and cows on pasture with access to dumpsDiscarded lead batteries,
used crankcase oil, lead-based paint common sourcesCase–fatality rate high
Acute in calvesBlindness and “chewing gum” champing of jaws, convulsions, charging,
rapid deathSubacute in adults: blindness, stupor, head-pressing, grinding teeth, rumen
static, protozoa dead
Blood and tissue for leadEncephalomalacia
Will respond favorably to treatment in early stages if not too severe but most cases
do not return to normalCalcium versenate and thiamine hydrochlorideMust be concerned
about disposition of meat and milk of treated animals
Polioencephalomalacia
Grain-fed rapidly growing feedlot cattleMay occur on pasture containing plants and
water high in sulfatesOutbreaks occur
Sudden onset, blindness, tremors and shaking of head, twitching of ears, head-pressing,
opisthotonus, nystagmus, strabismus, rumen contractions normal, CSF pressure increased
Blood biochemistry (see text)Brain for histopathology
Responds to thiamine in early stagesCases caused by sulfate toxicity may not respond
Hypovitaminosis A
Calves 6–8 months of age most commonly but mature cows too off dry summer pasture
(CSF form)Young rapidly growing cattle fed deficient ration for several months (ocular
form)
CSF form: sudden onset; syncope and convulsions followed by recovery, eyesight and
pupils normalNyctalopiaCSF pressure increasedOcular form: blindness in daylight, pupils
dilated and fixed, optic disc edemaSyncope and convulsions may also occurUsually preceded
by nyctalopia but missed by owner
Plasma and liver vitamin AOptic nerve constrictionSquamous cell metaplasia of parotid
ducts
CSF form: recover in 48 hours following treatment with vitamin A injectionsOcular
form: will not recover because of optic nerve degeneration
Haemophilus meningoencephalitis (thromboembolic meningoencephalitis)
Feedlot cattle (8–12 months), outbreaks, preceded by respiratory disease in groupHigh
case fatality if not treated early
Found down, fever common, ataxic, not usually blind, fundic lesions, irritation signs
uncommon, weakness and paresis common, synovitis, laryngitis, pleuritisMay die in
8–10 hoursMyocardial abscesses may also occur
Neutrophilia CSF contains neutrophilsTypical gross lesions in brainPleuritis, pneumonia,
synovitis, myocardial abscesses
Respond favorably to antimicrobials if treated earlyLater, high case–fatality rate
Listeria meningoencephalitis
SporadicFed silageYearlings and adults
Unilateral facial paralysis, deviation of head and neck, mild fever, endophthalmitis,
may be recumbent
CSF for cellsBrain for histopathology
Recovery may occur.AntimicrobialsResidual signs in survivors common
Nervous signs with coccidiosis (see text)
In 20% of young cattle affected with dysentery caused by coccidiosisCase fatality
may exceed 50%
Tonic-clonic convulsions, normal eyesight, hyperesthesia, normal temperature, dysentery,
may live 2–4 days
Oocysts in feces
Unfavorable response to treatmentMust control coccidiosis
Rabies
Cattle exposed to wildlife, one or more affected, all ages, incubation 3 weeks to
few months
Quiet and dull (dumb form) or excitable and easily annoyed (furious form)Bellowing,
yawning, drooling, saliva, eyesight normal, tenesmus, ascending paralysis beginning
with anesthesia over tail head, progressive course, dies in 4–6 days, usually no gross
muscular tremors or convulsions, mild fever early
Hemogram normalBrain for laboratory diagnosis
None
Bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE)
Mostly in dairy cattle; epizootic began in Britain in 1986; long incubation period;
caused by scrapie-like agent in protein concentrate made from sheep carcasses following
change in processing procedures
Insidious onset, clinical course several weeks, change in behavior, hyperesthesia,
ataxia, loss of body weight, stare, agnostic behavior, kick during milking, knuckling,
falling, progressive weakness leading to recumbency
None
None
Pseudorabies
Disease of pigs transmitted to cattle by bites
Intense, local pruritus at site of bite, excitement, bellowing, convulsions, paralysis,
death 2–3 days
Tissues for injection into rabbitHistopathology of brain
None
Hypomagnesemic tetany (lactation tetany)
Lactating dairy cows on lush pasture, late pregnant beef cows, cold, windy weather
in springMay be precipitated by long transportation or deprivation of feed and waterOutbreaks
occurSeen in yearlings tooCase mortality can be high
Acute: sudden onset of irritability, hyperesthesia; convulsions, recumbency, loud
heart sounds, tachycardia, polypnea. Subacute: gradual onset (2–4 days), hyperirritable,
difficult to handle, stilted gait, falling, stumbling, sudden movement may precipitate
convulsion
Serum magnesium level slow
Responds to magnesium sulfate early
Nervous acetonemia
2–6 weeks postpartumHigh-producing cowSingle animal
Sudden onset, bizarre mental behavior, chewing, licking, bellowing, hyperesthesia,
sweating
Ketonuria, hypoglycemia
Responds to glucose parenterally and/or propylene glycol orally
Bovine bonkers (bovine hysteria)
Mature cattle and calves consuming ammoniated feeds (lucerne hay, bromegrass hay,
fescue hay, wheat hay, maize stalks or silage)May also occur when animals have access
to molasses-urea-protein blocksToxic agent may be substituted imidazole formed by
combination of soluble carbohydrates and ammoniaUsually occurs when high-quality forage
treated with ammonia concentrate of more than 3% dry matter by weightCan occur in
nursing cows fed ammoniated feedstuffs
Periodic episodes of hyperexcitability, bellowing, running, charging, circling, convulsions,
weaving, episodes last 30 seconds and may recur every 5–10 minutesSome dieMost recover
following removal of feed
Information not available
Recover spontaneously following removal of feed source
Hepatic encephalopathy (i.e., ragwort poisoning)
Cattle with access to plants containing pyrrolizidine alkaloidsMany cattle may be
affected
Loss of body weight, gradual onset of aggressive behavior, ataxia, muscular tremors,
recumbency, convulsions, tenesmus and bellowing
Hyperbilirubinemia, decreased excretion of bromsulphthalein (BSP)Liver lesions
No treatment
Brain abscess
Sporadic, young cattle (6 months to 2 years of age) may have history of previous infections
Localizing signs, rotation or deviation of head and neck, loss of equilibrium, circling,
mild fever, may be blind in one eye, nystagmus one eye
Neutrophilia, neutrophils in CSF
Unfavorable response to therapy
Enterotoxemia caused by Clostridium perfringens type D
Calves 2–4 months of age sucking high producing cows grazing on lush pasturesOutbreaks
occurUncommon
Peracute: found dead. Acute: bellowing, mania, convulsions, blindness, death in 1–2
hoursSubacute: dull, depressed, blind
Hyperglycemia (150–200 mg/dL), glycosuria markedSmear intestinal contentsRecover toxin
(mouse protection tests)
Hyperimmune serumMost dieVaccination effective
Whole-milk hypomagnesemic tetany of calves
Calves 2–4 months of age on whole milkAlso in calves on milk replacers, concentrates
and hay and occasionally in nursing calves on pasture
Sudden alertness, hyperesthesia, head-shaking, opisthotonus, muscular tremors, frothing
at mouth, convulsions, heart rate 200–250 beats/min
Serum magnesium levels usually below 0.8 mg/dL
Magnesium sulfate intravenously gives good response, must follow up daily because
of previous depletion of bone reserves
Cattle and sheep
•
Lead poisoning. In acute and subacute lead poisoning in cattle the clinical findings
are similar to those of furious and dumb rabies. In acute lead poisoning, the common
clinical findings are blindness, convulsions, champing of the jaws with the production
of frothy saliva, and twitching of the eyelids and ears. In subacute lead poisoning
in cattle there is blindness, stupor, head-pressing, grinding of the teeth, and almost
no response to treatment. Rabid cattle are usually not blind, and signs of motor irritation
such as convulsions and twitching of the facial muscles usually do not occur. However,
there are signs of bizarre mental behavior, such as wild gazing, bellowing, yawning,
attacking, and compulsive walking.
•
Lactation tetany occurs in lactating cattle on lush pasture in the spring during cold
wet and windy weather, and is characterized by hyperesthesia, tremors, convulsions,
recumbency, and rapid death.
•
Vitamin A deficiency occurs in groups of young cattle from 6 months to 18 months of
age not receiving adequate carotene intake or vitamin A supplementation and is characterized
by blindness in the ocular form and episodes of tremors and convulsions.
•
Polioencephalomalacia in cattle and sheep is characterized by blindness, nystagmus,
opisthotonus, and convulsions; bellowing, loss of sensation, and tenesmus do not occur.
•
Listeriosis in cattle and sheep is manifested by localizing signs of circling and
facial nerve paralysis.
•
Enterotoxemia in sheep is usually confined to lambs on heavy carbohydrate diets.
•
Pregnancy toxemia is a disease of pregnant ewes and is readily differentiated by the
presence of ketonuria.
•
Louping-ill in sheep is transmitted by insects, has a seasonal occurrence, and a localized
geographic distribution.
Horses
In horses, rabies must be differentiated from several diseases of the nervous system
(summarized in Table 14-11).
The most common include diseases include viral encephalomyelitis, herpes virus myeloencephalopathy,
cerebrospinal nematodiasis, equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy, equine protozoal
myeloencephalitis, neuritis of the cauda equina, horsetail poisoning, Borna, Japanese
encephalitis, and botulism.
Pigs
In pigs, rabies must be differentiated from pseudorabies, Teschen disease, and involvement
of the brain in several other diseases of the pigs, such as hog and African swine
fever, meningitis associated with Streptococcus suis type II, Haemophilus spp., Glasser's
disease, Escherichia coli, septicemia, and erysipelas.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
No treatment should be attempted after clinical signs are evident. If the bite is
seen, immediately after exposure, irrigation of the wound with 20% soft soap solution
or a solution of benzalkonium chloride for at least 5 minutes may prevent the establishment
of the infection. The area exposed to potential infection should be doused with iodine
solution or a 40% to 50% alcohol solution if iodine is unavailable.
2
Immediate and thorough washing of all bite wounds and scratches with soap and water
is perhaps the most effective measure for preventing rabies in veterinarians bitten
by rabid animals. In experimental animals, simple local wound cleansing has been shown
to markedly reduce the likelihood of rabies. Postexposure vaccination is unlikely
to be of value in animals, because death usually occurs before appreciable immunity
has had time to develop. Euthanasia of suspect animals must be avoided, particularly
if human exposure has occurred, because the development of the disease in the animals
is necessary to establish a diagnosis. Antirabies serum may become available for animal
treatment at some future date. In some countries, cases of rabies in farm animals
are notifiable to the animal health and disease regulatory bodies.
Control
The major goal of rabies control in domestic and wild animals is the reduction or
elimination of human rabies. The most rational approach to reducing human rabies is
to reduce the prevalence and incidence of disease in animals. In developed countries,
this has been accomplished by vaccination of dogs and cats, leaving much rabies in
wildlife to be controlled. In countries without wildlife reservoirs, such as the Philippines,
it would be economically advantageous to eliminate dog rabies. In Africa, where the
incidence of rabies as well as the range of species involved is increasing, there
is a need to develop new and economical methods of vaccinating domestic animals.
Dogs remain the major vector for transmission to humans in developing countries and
are responsible for an estimated 59,000 human deaths worldwide annually.6, 7 Preexposure
immunization for individuals, like veterinarians, who are at high risk to rabies,
has been recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO), because it reduces risk
and provides a more rapid anamnestic response, eliminating the need for human globulin
should exposure occur. Rabies preexposure vaccination is now mandatory in many veterinary
colleges. Despite some mild adverse reactions, immunization against rabies is an important
prophylaxis measure well accepted by veterinary students.
For farm animals, there are two useful control techniques: the prevention of exposure
and preexposure vaccination.
Prevention of Exposure to the Virus
This can be achieved by controlling access of wildlife species that are likely to
come into contact with the farm livestock in particular areas or through vaccination
of the wildlife. Foxes accounted for a very large proportion (85% in Europe) of wildlife
rabies, and a control program aimed at reducing their population using poison or traps
was attempted until the 1970s. This method of population reduction failed to control
outbreaks or reduce enzootic rabies.
Point infection control has been shown to be highly successful in controlling raccoon
rabies. This involves the use of three tactics: population reduction, trap-vaccinate-release,
and oral vaccination with baits to control the spread of raccoon rabies.
Preexposure Vaccination of Humans
The most successful form of rabies prevention is preexposure vaccination. In human
medicine, there are no reported cases of rabies deaths in anyone who has had preexposure
vaccination followed by a booster vaccination if exposed. The CDC has published the
recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) for human
rabies prevention, which indicate that rabies preexposure vaccination should be offered
to persons more likely to be exposed to rabies virus than the population of the United
States at large. The recommendations of the ACIP for preexposure prophylaxis and maintenance
of a detectable antibody titer differ depending on the estimated degree of risk of
exposure to the virus. Four risk categories have established: continuous, frequent,
infrequent, and rare. The classification depends on factors such as the occupation
of the individual and geography.
With directed continuing education, common sense, first aid, and the availability
of modern biologic agents, human rabies is nearly always preventable. Rabies preexposure
vaccination is recommended for anyone at increased risk of exposure to rabies, including
veterinarians, veterinary students who work in university veterinary teaching hospitals,
laboratory staff working with rabies, vaccine producers, animal and wildlife control
personnel, and zoologists. The standard preexposure regimen is three doses of vaccine
intramuscularly or intradermally on days 0, 7, and 28 (or 21). A booster dose after
1 year increases and prolongs the antibody response. This preexposure vaccination
permits postexposure vaccination to consist of two doses of vaccine on days 0 and
3 instead of five doses on days 0, 3, 7, 14, and 28 and avoids the need for postexposure
of administration of human rabies immunoglobulin.
Postexposure Vaccination of Humans
Modern postexposure treatment is highly successful if done adequately. Wound care
with infiltration of the wound with human rabies immunoglobulin and active rabies
immunization is essential, especially after severe exposure. Postexposure treatment
is assumed to neutralize or inactivate virus while it is still in the wounds, before
it gains access to the nervous system where it is protected from the immune system.
Therefore treatment after exposure to rabies virus is very urgent, even if the patient
was bitten months before.
Postexposure Vaccination of Domestic Animals
An effective postexposure protocol for unvaccinated domestic animals exposed to rabies
includes immediate vaccination against rabies, a strict isolation period of 90 days,
and administration of booster vaccinations during the third and eighth weeks of the
isolation period. The protocol has been effective in dogs, cats, cattle, and horses.
Vaccination of Domestic Animals
A Compendium of Animal Rabies Control is published annually by the National Association
of State Public Health Veterinarians in the United States and Canada. It provides
recommendations for immunization procedures in domestic animals and the vaccines licensed
and marketed in the United States. Detailed information is provided on preexposure
vaccination, management of dogs and cats and livestock, postexposure management, and
control methods in wild animals. Such publications should be consulted when necessary.
In general, for cattle, sheep, and horses, the primary vaccination is given at 3 months
of age and boosters given annually. Farm livestock in endemic areas where clinical
cases of rabies occur are common should be vaccinated.
In countries where vampire bats are a major vector for rabies in farm livestock, vaccination
of livestock is necessary, but in countries such as Argentina vaccination does not
support a cost-benefit analysis.
Vaccines
Almost all rabies vaccines for domestic animals are inactivated. Inactivated tissue
culture cell vaccines given to cattle result in neutralizing antibodies in 1 month
after the primary vaccination. A booster given 1 year later increases the titers,
which are detectable 1 year after the booster. A vaccine inactivated with binary ethylenimine,
and containing aluminum hydroxide adjuvant, provides excellent protection for up to
3 years and is very useful for the control of rabies in cattle in Latin America where
the vampire bat is the main vector.
Vaccinal antibodies are present in the colostrum of vaccinated cows and it is recommended
that, where cattle are vaccinated annually, calves be vaccinated at 4 months of age
and again when 10 months of age, but vaccination should be delayed 6 months for calves
born to and receiving colostrum from previously vaccinated dams.
8
However, in areas with endemic and epizootic rabies, calves can be vaccinated as early
as 2 months of age and be protected in the presence of passive immunity from colostral
antibodies provided they are revaccinated 4 months later.
9
Calves from unvaccinated dams can be protected by vaccinating them at 17 days of age.
Postvaccinal paralysis does not occur after its use. Coadministration of levamisole
(6 mg/kg, subcutaneously) with vaccination does not increase the vaccine titer; however,
the effect on cell-mediated immunity was not specifically evaluated in that study.
10
Vaccination of Wildlife
Mass oral vaccination of terrestrial wild animals is a rabies control method that
is feasible, effective, and internationally accepted. It is based on the concept of
applied herd immunity. The vaccines are efficacious when fed as vaccine baits. The
factors affecting acceptance of baits for delivery of oral rabies vaccine to raccoons
have been examined.
The oral immunization of foxes has resulted in a substantial decrease in the number
of rabies cases in Europe. As a result of oral vaccination of the red fox (V. vulpes)
against rabies, using hand and aerial distribution of vaccine-laden baits, the rabies
virus has almost been completely eradicated from Western and Central Europe. The same
dramatic decrease occurred in southern Ontario, Canada. In most countries, vaccine
baits were distributed twice yearly during the spring (March to May) and autumn (September
to October). Several European countries have become rabies free: Belgium, Luxembourg,
France, Italy, Switzerland, Finland, and the Netherlands.
Progress has been made in applying oral rabies vaccination to contain and eliminate
some strains of terrestrial rabies in North America. Raboral V-RG is the only rabies
vaccine licensed for use in the United States. It has not produced sufficient levels
of population immunity in skunks in the wild at the current dose, and it may be less
effective in skunks than in other species. Skunks are a major contributor to rabies
in North America and this has raised concerns about an independent maintenance cycle
for raccoon rabies in skunks. The national rabies management goals of virus containment
and elimination will likely remain elusive until an oral vaccine is licensed that
is immunogenic in all terrestrial rabies reservoir species. Vaccination will succeed
in reducing or eradicating rabies only if a sufficient proportion of the target population
can be immunized. Mathematical modeling techniques are now being tested to examine
the population biology of rabies in wildlife species such as raccoons and skunks.
It is notable that no practical vaccination methods have been developed for bats.
Phylogenetic analyses of viruses from bats and carnivores suggest a historical basis
for still existing viral origins caused by interactions between these taxa. Thus the
possibility for pathogen emergence resulting from transmission by rabid bats with
subsequent perpetuation among other animals cannot be discounted easily on any continent.
Quarantine and Biosecurity
The most effective method of preventing the entry of rabies into a country free of
the disease is the imposition of a quarantine period of 4 to 6 months on all imported
dogs. This system has successfully prevented the entry of the disease into island
countries, but has obvious limitation in countries that have land borders. The occurrence
of the disease in two dogs in the United Kingdom in 1969 to 1970 in which the incubation
period appeared to last 7 to 9 months suggests that the more usual period of 6 months
may give incomplete protection. Therefore vaccination on two occasions with an inactivated
vaccine while the animal is still in quarantine for 6 months is the current recommendation.
To require a longer period of quarantine would encourage evasion of the law by smuggling.
The situation in the UK, and in any country where the disease does not occur, is a
vexed one. It is possible to rely chiefly on quarantine and act swiftly to stamp the
disease out if it occurs. The shock eradication program would include quarantine of,
and vaccination in, a risk area, ring vaccination around it, and destruction of all
wildlife. This procedure is likely to be adopted in countries where the risk is small,
such as Australia. Where the risk is great, consideration must be given to mass vaccination
of wildlife by baits, because wildlife are the cracks in the defense armor. The use
of combined vaccines containing rabies vaccine in other vaccines used in dogs would
be an effective and panic-free way of increasing the immune status of the pet population.
Further Reading
Bellotto
A
Overview of rabies in the Americas
Virus Res
111
2005
5
12
15896398
Dyer
JL
Yager
P
Orciari
L
Rabies surveillance in the United States during 2013
J Am Vet Med Assoc
245
2014
1111
1123
25356711
References
1
Papaneri
AB
Virus Res
197
2015
54
25481284
2
Banyard
AC
Virus Res
152
2010
79
20558215
3
Den
K
Am J Trop Med Hyg
86
2012
528
22403330
4
Chandrashekhara
N
Indian J Field Vet
8
2013
49
5
Shankar
BP
Veterinary World
2
2009
74
6
Reddy
RVC
Infect Genet Evol
27
2014
163
25077994
7
Hampson
K
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
9
2015
e0003709
25881058
8
Yakobson
B
Prev Vet Med
121
2015
170
26032721
9
Filho
OA
Res Vet Sci
92
2012
396
21543096
10
Cazella
LN
Vet Rec
165
2009
722
20008346
Pseudorabies (Aujeszky's Disease)
The disease was first described in cattle and was known then as pseudorabies because
of the similarity to rabies and thereafter Aujeszky's disease after the Hungarian
physician who first isolated the virus.
Synopsis
Etiology Aujeszky's disease virus (suid herpesvirus 1) (SuHV-1).
Epidemiology Found in pigs worldwide and major economic importance in swine-raising
areas. High prevalence of infection; lower incidence of disease. Infected pig source
of infection; latent infection is characteristic; spread occurs within herds, between
herds, and from infected carriers; long-distance aerosol transmission occurs from
area to area; immunity follows infection or vaccination.
Signs Fever, incoordination, recumbency, convulsion, and death in piglets. Coughing,
nasal discharge, sneezing, and dyspnea in older growing pigs. In cattle and sheep,
intense pruritus at site of bite, excitement, circling, convulsions, fever, recumbency,
paralysis, and death in 48 hours or less.
Clinical pathology Serology for virus-neutralizing antibodies. Detection of virus
in tissues.
Lesions Viral encephalitis.
Diagnostic confirmation Detection of virus in tissues; serology; inclusion bodies
in nervous tissue and respiratory tract.
Differential diagnosis
Swine
•
Viral encephalomyelitis (Teschen disease)
•
Rabies
•
Streptococcal meningitis
•
Hog cholera
•
African swine fever
•
Glasser's disease
•
Septicemias (Escherichia coli, erysipelas, salmonella)
•
Bowel edema
•
Salt poisoning
•
Reproductive insufficiency (parvovirus).
Cattle and sheep
•
Nervous form acetonemia
•
Rabies C
•
Acute lead poisoning.
Treatment None.
Control Depopulation and repopulation, test and removal, segregation of progeny, and
vaccination with subunit vaccines that distinguish between infected and vaccinated
pigs.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Pseudorabies is caused by porcine herpesvirus-1 (SuHV-1), Aujeszky's disease virus,
or pseudorabies virus (PRV), of the genus Varicellovirus, a member of the family of
Herpesviridae,
1
subfamily Alphaherpesvirinae. It exists as a single serotype. Many cell lines are
used for PRV culture. There are four major genome types; Type 1 is found in the United
States and Europe; Type 2 is found in central Europe, Type 3 is found in Eastern Europe,
and Type 4 is found only in Asia.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
PRV primarily affects pigs and occurs incidentally in other species. It has a worldwide
distribution except for Norway, Australia, and most of the islands of Southeast Asia.
Control programs have eliminated the condition in many countries,
2
leaving isolated pockets in Northern Ireland and in France. It is still endemic in
eastern and southeastern Europe, Latin America, Africa, and Asia. For example, in
Poland from 2005 to 2009 around 0.4% of the population was infected.
3
In countries where the disease has been eradicated vaccination is not allowed.
The disease persists in feral pigs, wild boar, and hybrids4, 5 at quite high levels
in many European countries and also in the United States
2
and these permanently threaten the domestic pig population.
The reservoir of Aujeszky's disease has shifted from domestic pigs to wild and feral
pig populations and circulates unchecked in many countries.
6
Thus the identification of reservoirs and the epidemiologic surveillance is becoming
more difficult.
PRV is primarily a disease of pigs, and naturally occurring cases in cattle, sheep,
dogs, cats, rats, and horses are rare and usually fatal. Many other species have also
been affected, but only pigs survive the infection. Infection in other species often
occurs when pigs cohabit with other species.
Morbidity and Case Fatality
Typically, the disease spreads rapidly in infected herds over a period of 1 to 2 weeks,
and the acute stage of the outbreak lasts 1 to 2 months. In sucking pigs, the morbidity
and mortality rates approach 100%, but in mature swine there may be no clinical signs,
and affected animals usually recover. The highest morbidity occurs initially in unweaned
piglets, but as the outbreak continues and piglets become passively immunized through
the sow's colostrum, the major incidence may occur in weanlings.
In recent years, there has also been an increase in the morbidity and case–fatality
rates in older pigs associated with the intensification of pig rearing and the dominance
of more virulent strains.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
The seroprevalence of infection varies widely between herds, and between breeding
and finishing pigs within herds. The most important animal risk factors of virus persistence
are herd size and the population density of the sows in the herd. Endemic infection
is more likely in herds of breeding sows with more than 66 sows. In breeding herds,
spread of infection is positively associated with increasing size of the herd, having
the gilts in the same barn as the sows (gestation barn), and serologic evidence of
infection in the finishing pigs. The seroprevalence of infection is low in quarantined
breeding herds, which makes them prime candidates for elimination of the disease by
test and removal.
In the early period of a compulsory vaccination program with gI-deleted vaccines,
in an area endemically infected with the disease, the seroprevalence of infected breeding
females is higher in farrow–finish than farrow–feeder herds. Mandatory vaccination
is beneficial in both herds but the pattern is linear in farrow–feeder herds and curvilinear
in farrow–finish herds, and is more rapid in the early period of the program. In the
farrow–finish herds, the odds of infected breeding females were associated positively
with seropositivity in the finishing pigs of the herd and with the density of the
pigs in the county in which the herd is located. In Belgium the presence of finishing
pigs in the same herd increased the chances of being infected. The spread and transmission
of the virus between herds can be reduced by a reduction in the contact rate between
the herds and their size and by a reduction of the transmission within the herd.
The factors associated with circulation of the virus within herds include confinement
of finishing pigs, concurrent infection with Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae, the
length of time since the herd has been under quarantine, and the presence of clinical
disease.
In general, PRV does not increase the susceptibility of animals to infection with
other pathogens.
The primary risk factors associated with seroprevalence of the virus in 500 swine
herds in Illinois included total confinement and density of infected herds in the
geographic area. It was calculated in Belgium that if there were over 455 pigs per
squared kilometer, then there was a 10-fold increase in the risk of PRV. Total confinement
is associated with higher seroprevalence, presumably because of increased density
of population and increased risk of transmission. Seroprevalence is higher in vaccinated
herds, increases over the course of the eradication program, and decreases with an
increased time between quarantine and the development of a herd plan. In the Netherlands,
the risk factors contributing to seroprevalence of infection in breeding herds included
the presence of finishing pigs, production type (producers of finishing pigs had a
higher prevalence than producers of breeding stock), vaccination of sows during nursing
(compared with vaccinating all sows simultaneously at 5-month intervals, or vaccination
during the second half of gestation), pig density in the municipality in which the
herd was located (seroprevalence increased with higher pig density), herd size of
fewer than 100 sows, average within-herd parity (seroprevalence increased with higher
within-herd parity), replacement pigs raised on the premises, and vaccine strain administered
to the sows.
Environmental Risk Factors
The virus is resistant to environmental conditions depending on pH, humidity, and
temperature. The virus may survive for 2 to 7 weeks in an infected environment and
for up to 5 weeks in meat. The infectivity of the virus in an aerosol decreases by
50% in 1 hour. Environments at 4°C supported the survival of the virus in aerosol
better than at 22°C. The virus is lipophilic and sensitive to several commonly used
disinfectants. Sodium hypochlorite (5.25%) is the most desirable and practical disinfectant.
Suspensions of the virus in saline G solution and on the solid fomites, whole corn,
and steel remained infectious for at least 7 days. Loam soil, straw, and concrete
supported survival of the virus at 25°C for up to 1 week. During shipment of pigs,
bedding material and surfaces in contact with pigs may become contaminated. Rinsing
a needle between sampling may reduce the probability of mechanically transmitting
the disease.
Pathogen Factors
Field strains of the virus differ in virulence. Numerous genomically different strains
of the virus exist, and restriction endonuclease (RE) analysis can distinguish between
virus isolates, which is useful for identifying new isolates of the virus as they
appear in pig populations. In Denmark, restriction fragment analyses of older clinical
isolates, and of isolates from all the virologically confirmed outbreaks since 1985,
indicated the introduction of foreign strains. Strain variation in virulence has been
observed in field isolates and produced by laboratory attenuation. Virulence also
affects the tropism of the virus. Many of the highly virulent strains are neuroinvasive;
many of the moderately virulent or mild strains are not neuroinvasive but affect the
respiratory tract. The highly adapted or vaccinal strains often acquire a tropism
for the reproductive systems. Inactivation of several genes that are not essential
for viral replication can reduce the virulence of the virus.
Some field strains of the virus from Poland and Hungary have been identified by restriction
fragment pattern analysis as derivatives of conventionally attenuated vaccine strains.
This is considered a rare event but must be considered in relationship to trade in
semen from vaccinated boars or trade in live animals between disease-free areas and
areas in which vaccination with live attenuated strains is practiced.
Methods of Transmission
Pseudorabies is not very contagious and large quantities of the virus are required
to infect pigs except very young piglets. Larger doses of virus are needed for oral
infection than nasal infection. In feral pig and wild boar populations it appears
to be venereal transmission that is more important.
7
It can be transmitted transplacentally, especially in the last third of gestation.
It can also be passed through the colostrum. In milk excretion of virus takes place
for 2 to 3 days following infection. Virus can be transmitted for up to 12 days in
semen following infection. Venereal transmission of latent infection in sows and boars
has been suspected, but there is no direct evidence. The virus cannot usually be isolated
from urine.
In a study of PRV in wild swine in the United States it was found that the virus was
found in the oral cavity of feral pigs and was widely distributed in the tonsils,
salivary glands, taste buds, and even mucosa in the region of the tusks.
8
Infected swine shed virus in large quantities from all body excretions, secretions,
and aerosols. Virus shedding starts 1 to 2 days after infection, reaches a peak at
2 to 5 days, and may last up to 17 days. Virus can be isolated from the oropharynx
for 18 to 25 days.
Pigs, and possibly rodents, appear to be the primary host for the virus. The virus
is present in the nasal discharge and in the mouth of affected pigs on the first day
of illness and for up to 17 days after infection. This suggests that short-length
aerosol transmission is a common occurrence within buildings or units but long distance
transmission is still doubted. After infection and recovery pigs may be regarded as
carriers.
Within Herds
Transmission within herds occurs by direct oral–nasal contact between infected and
susceptible pigs and aerosols from projection of discharges during sneezing, but it
may also occur via contaminated drinking water and feed. Transmission within herds
is independent of the size of the population.
The transmission of virus decreases rapidly following the start of a vaccination program,
but extensive spread can still occur even among finishing pigs vaccinated twice. Vaccinated
pigs may shed more virulent virus but there are no significant differences in magnitude
of transmission. Mixing of chronically infected pigs with seronegative pigs may not
result in seroconversion in the seronegative pigs until a clinical outbreak of disease
occurs.
Between Herds
Transmission between herds is caused by the introduction of infected animals, and
the virus may still be introduced into vaccinated breeding herds. Other methods of
transmission have been suggested, including farm laborers, vehicles, feedstuffs, rodents,
and wild or domestic animals, the carcasses of dead infected animals, and infected
food and water.
Within an Area
Transmission within an area is a major problem and not well understood. Some evidence
indicates that area spread may be associated with markets and the frequency of delivery
of pigs to market per year. In France, it has been suggested that the presence of
an infected herd within 1 km is an important factor in the spread of PRV. The concurrent
occurrence of an outbreak of disease on many farms in the same area in Denmark suggested
long-distance airborne transmission of the virus.
Infection is spread by airborne transmission. Sneezing probably generates the airborne
virus. In a series of outbreaks in Britain between 1981 and1982, 7 of 11 were found
likely to have been transmitted by aerosol on meteorologic grounds. Airborne spread
occurred between herds 2 to 9 km apart. An epidemic in Denmark in 1987 to 1988, associated
with foreign strains of the virus, suggests that airborne transmission occurred across
the German–Danish border, especially as a southerly wind was blowing during the period
of transmission.
Computer modeling based on the mean dose of virus received by an animal at a farm
downwind can be used to predict the airborne spread of the virus.
The virus is inactivated in meat after 35 days of storage at −18°C (0.5°F). Meat from
infected pigs may cause infection when fed to dogs.
Latency
Pigs that recover from infection are latent carriers of the virus for life. Reactivation,
followed by shedding and spreading the virus, may occur following stress such as transport
or farrowing, or by the administration of corticosteroids. Serologic testing of latent
carriers detects the antibody response to the whole virus or to a PRV virus glycoprotein.
During natural infection, the virus replicates at the site of infection, usually in
the oronasal areas. The virus gains entry into the nerve endings and ascends by retrograde
axonal transport to the cell body in the trigeminal ganglion. Viral components can
be found in both the trigeminal ganglion and the tonsils. The tonsil is a primary
site of virus replication and serves as an area for monitoring virus shedding during
acute infection and reactivation. The virus can be isolated from tissue fragments
of pigs clinically recovered from disease for up to 13 months and followed by a challenge
with the live virus, which may be shed by sows for up to 19 months after initial infection.
Virus gene products can be found in the trigeminal ganglia and tonsils for many weeks
following acute infection. Latent infection can also occur in vaccinated pigs.
Other Species
The rarity of spread to other species is caused by scanty nasal discharge and the
improbability of the discharge coming into contact with abraded skin or nasal mucosa
of animals other than pigs. The disease has occurred in sheep and cattle following
the use of a multidose syringe previously used in infected swine. It may spread from
normal or clinically affected pigs to animals of other species, but does not usually
spread between animals of the other species. For example, sheep and calves can be
infected experimentally, but there is no evidence that they excrete the virus. The
disease may occur in pigs, sheep, and cattle on the same farm. Brown rats may be a
minor source of infection but are unlikely to be an important reservoir; they are
capable of spreading the disease to dogs. The wild Norway rat is thought to have only
a minor role in the transmission of the disease to farm animals. The virus causes
fatal disease in dogs, which are usually infected from close association with infected
pigs. The raccoon can be infected experimentally, but is not considered to be a long-term
subclinical carrier of the virus. The possible role of wild animals in transmission
of PRV in swine has been examined with inconclusive results. It has been seen in Kodiak,
polar, and Himalayan bears fed on a diet of raw pig's heads. Five viral isolates were
recovered from latently infected wild boar originating from two regions of East Germany,
but in the Netherlands the wild boar were said to be rarely affected. The PRV infections
in the wild boar in Germany are said to exist in the country as an endemic infection
and persist completely separately from the domestic population and also do not appear
to affect it. The sacral ganglia and trigeminal ganglia of wild pigs were said to
be a source of infection. The latency was shown in 9/16 sacral ganglia, 7/16 trigeminal
ganglia, and 5/13 tonsils from feral swine in the United States, but even so most
of the transmission in feral swine is expected to be venereal. The experimental infection
of wild boars and domestic pigs with different strains has been performed and the
clinical signs depended on the strain but the wild boar could infect the domestic
strains and vice versa. The low virulence strains were highly adapted to the wild
boar.
Immune Mechanisms
When infected with a virulent strain of the virus, pigs develop an immune response
that can completely, or almost completely, prevent the virus from replicating after
the pig becomes reinfected. Following natural infection, sows acquire immunity, which
is transferred to their piglets in the colostrum and persists in the piglets until
5 to 7 weeks of age. Following intranasal challenge, piglets with colostral immunity
from naturally infected sows are protected from clinical disease, but not against
subclinical infection.
Vaccination of pigs with attenuated PRV virus prevents clinical disease and death
that may otherwise follow exposure to the virulent virus. Vaccination does not, however,
prevent either acute or latent infection with virulent virus. Consequently, vaccinated
pigs, as well as nonvaccinated pigs that survive infection with the virulent virus,
can become virus carriers and a source of the virus following reactivation of a latent
infection. This is of vital importance in eradication programs in which it is necessary
to identify infected pigs regardless of their vaccination status. Maternal immunity
interferes with inactivated virus vaccination much more than with live virus vaccination.
Vaccination of pregnant sows induces a maternal immunity, which protects piglets from
experimental disease. However, latent infection of young pigs with highly virulent
virus can develop in the absence of clinical signs. The virus can reach the uterine
and fetal tissues, via infected mononuclear cells, which is the presence of circulating
antibodies induced on vaccination. Vaccination of piglets before challenge exposure
has little or no effect on the rate of establishment of virus latency, but vaccination
does reduce shedding after subsequent experimental reactivation of the virus with
dexamethasone. Attenuated tyrosine kinase-negative vaccine strains of the virus can
also establish a reactivatable, latent infection.
In growing and finishing pigs in quarantined herds, the serologic status is unpredictable
because the infection may continue to spread, may cease temporarily, or may cease
altogether. Evaluation of the serologic status of the boars in a breeding herd does
not accurately reflect the serostatus of the herd.
It has been suggested that the T cells are more important than the B cells in the
clearance of PRV from the host, and it has been shown that strong T-cell–mediated
responses after challenge produce the best protection.
Economic Importance
The economic losses associated with pseudorabies in swine are caused by clinical disease
and the costs of serologic analysis and vaccination programs. Economic loss estimates
must include the measurement of losses during and immediately after clinical outbreaks
of disease and the indirect losses incurred until after eradication of the disease.
Losses have been estimated at $25 to $50 per sow per year; these include only losses
during the period of the outbreak and the direct losses attributable to death and
abortions. When expanding the observations of economic losses to 3 months after the
termination of the outbreak, estimated losses may be as high as $145 per sow per year.
Economic analyses of the losses in a commercial farrow–finish herd of 240 breeding-age
sows in the United States revealed that the major part of the loss was caused by death
of suckling pigs at 76% of total loss, nursery pig mortality accounted for 12.6% of
total net loss, sow culling and deaths accounted for 9.4% of net loss, and market
pig deaths accounted for 1.2% of net losses.
The costs of eradicating PRV vary depending on the methods used. Depopulation–repopulation
is the most expensive method because it requires culling of animals, clean-up costs,
and downtime, which represents the largest proportion of expense. In addition, the
probability of reinfection following repopulation is a risk.
Test and removal is the most inexpensive, and segregation of offspring is an intermediate
cost. The cost of eradicating the virus from a swine herd can be in excess of $220
per inventoried sow; some estimates are much higher. In large breeding herds or finishing
herds with the continual influx of susceptible pigs, the disease may become endemic.
PRV may also be a significant cause of reproductive inefficiency in pig herds, and
infection within the herd may be initially manifested by abortions in the sow herd,
followed later by the more typical occurrence of neurologic disease in suckling and
growing pigs. The economic losses from the disease can be very high because of mortality
in young pigs, decreased reproductive performance, and the necessity to depopulate
to eradicate the disease from a herd. An economic assessment of an epidemic of PRV
in a 150-sow farrow–finish operation on selected production and economic variables
has been made. The mean litter size remained the same throughout the period of observation,
but there was a twofold increase in suckling pig mortality and 3.5-fold increase in
stillbirths during the months of the epidemic compared with the period before the
epidemic. Following the epidemic, suckling pig mortality was 14% greater and stillbirth
rate was 71% greater than during the months preceding the outbreak. The major economic
losses (88% of the total loss) were related to breeding herd removal/depopulation
and production downtime.
Pathogenesis
The portal of entry is through abraded skin, oral mucosa, or via the intact nasal
mucosa. Strain differences in the effect of historical PRV strains in porcine respiratory
nasal mucosa explants shows that there were differences in the strains.
8
The virus is pantropic and affects tissues derived from all embryonic layers. Receptor
and receptor-binding virion proteins that can mediate the virus entry into the cell
and cell-to-cell spread have been described. The various glycoproteins of the virus
are required for various stages of virion morphogenesis. For example, deletion of
glycoproteins gE, gI, and gM inhibits the virion maturation. Pseudorabies glycoprotein
gK is a virion structural component involved in virus release from the cell but not
viral entry, and its presence is important to prevent immediate reinfection. Viremia
occurs with localization of the virus in many viscera, but with multiplication occurring
primarily in the upper respiratory tract. Viral and cell interactions have been described
in detail.
9
Spread to the brain occurs by way of the olfactory, glossopharyngeal, or trigeminal
nerves, i.e., via the autonomic nerves. It can pass across synapses and infect higher
level neurons.
10
Cells with the common leukocyte antigen CD45+ populate the CNS-infected areas from
the local capillaries, and the number of cells is increased in proportion to the number
of infected neurons. Virus disappears from the brain by the eighth day, coinciding
with the appearance of neutralizing antibody in the blood. When the virus gains entry
through a skin abrasion, it quickly invades the local peripheral nerves, passing along
them centripetally and causing damage to nerve cells. It is this form of progression
that causes local pruritus in the early stages of the disease, and encephalomyelitis
at a later stage when the virus has invaded the CNS. In pigs, pruritus does not develop
after intramuscular injection, but a local paralysis indicative of damage to low motor
neurons occurs before invasion of the CNS in some pigs. In cattle, pruritus of the
head and neck is usually associated with respiratory tract infection, whereas perianal
pruritus is usually caused by vaginal infection.
The inoculation of PRV into the nasal cavities or brain results in signs of encephalitis
instead of local pruritus. With oral inoculation, there is an initial stage of viral
proliferation in the tonsillar mucosa, followed by systemic invasion, localization,
and invasion of the CNS along peripheral and autonomic nerve trunks and fibers. Lesions
of Auerbach's myenteric plexus and the skin may also occur. The peripheral blood mononuclear
cells, tonsils, lymph nodes, and bone marrow are a poor source of virus after experimental
infection. The trigeminal ganglia and olfactory bulb are good sources of virus. The
virus may be present in the trigeminal ganglion of a naturally infected sow without
any history of clinical disease. Experimental inoculation of the virus into young
pigs can result in a mild pneumonia, which may progress to a severe suppurative bronchopneumonia.
The virus can invade the uterus and infect preimplantation embryos, which can lead
to degeneration of the embryo and reproductive failure. Virulent PRV virus can cause
lesions in the uterine endothelium and ovarian corpora lutea of pigs in early pregnancy,
and gene-deleted mutant virus vaccine given intravenously during estrus can cause
ovarian lesions, which may affect fertility. Through the use of embryo transfer procedures,
infected embryos may disseminate the virus from donors to recipients.
In other species the virus tends to be restricted to the nervous system.
Clinical Findings
Pigs
The incubation period in natural outbreaks is about 1 day but may be from 1 to 8 days.
The major signs are referable to infection of the respiratory, nervous, and reproductive
systems. There is considerable variation in the clinical manifestation, depending
on the virulence and tropism of the infecting strain. Nervous system disease is the
major manifestation, but with some strains, respiratory disease may be the initial
and prime presenting feature. There is also strain variation in the pattern of age
susceptibility.
Young pigs a few days to a month old are most susceptible. Very young sucklings develop
an indistinct syndrome, but prominent nervous signs occur in older piglets. A febrile
reaction, with temperatures up to 41.5°C (107°F), occurs before the onset of nervous
signs. Incoordination of the hindlimbs causing sideways progression is followed by
recumbency, fine and coarse muscle tremors, and paddling movements. Lateral deviation
of the head, frothing at the mouth, nystagmus, slight ocular discharge, and convulsive
episodes appear in a few animals. A snoring respiration with marked abdominal movement
occurs in many, and vomiting and diarrhea in some affected pigs. Deaths occur about
12 hours after the first signs appear. In California, a consistent sign has been blindness
caused by extensive retinal degeneration.
In growing and adult pigs, the disease is much less severe but there is considerable
variation depending on the virulence of the infecting strain. In growing pigs, mortality
falls with increasing age and is generally less than 5% in pigs at 4 to 6 months of
age. With some strains, fever is a prominent sign, whereas depression, vomiting, and
sometimes marked respiratory signs, including sneezing, nasal discharge, coughing,
and severe dyspnea are common. Trembling, incoordination, and paralysis and convulsions
follow, and precede death. With others, the disease may be manifested at this age
by mild signs of posterior incoordination and leg weakness. In adults, fever may not
be present, and the infection may cause only a mild syndrome of anorexia, dullness,
agalactia, and constipation. However, virulent strains may produce acute disease in
adults, characterized by fever, sneezing, nasal pruritus, vomiting, incoordination
and convulsions, and death. Infection in early pregnancy may result in embryonic death,
or abortion, and early return to estrus. An abundant vaginal discharge may occur.
Infection in late pregnancy may result in abortion, or in the subsequent birth of
mummified fetuses, which may involve all or only part of the litter. Abortion may
result from the effects of fever or from viral infection of the fetus.
Concurrent infection has been described with PCV2, and PRRS and swine influenza virus,
and in these cases the resultant disease is more likely to be a severe proliferative
and necrotizing pneumonia.
11
Cattle, Sheep, and Goats
There may be sudden death without obvious signs of illness. More commonly, there is
intense, local pruritus with violent licking, chewing, and rubbing of a particular
body part. Itching may be localized to any part of the body surface, but is most common
about the head, the flanks, or the feet, which are the sites most likely to be contaminated
by virus. There is intense excitement during this stage, and convulsions and constant
bellowing may occur. Maniacal behavior, circling, spasm of the diaphragm, and opisthotonus
are often evident. A stage of paralysis follows in which salivation, respiratory distress,
and ataxia occur. The temperature is usually increased, sometimes to as high as 41°C
to 41°C (106°F-107°F). Final paralysis is followed by death in 6 to 48 hours after
the first appearance of illness. A case of nonfatal PRV in a cow is recorded. There
is also a report of PRV occurring in feedlot cattle in which there were nervous signs,
bloat, and acute death, but no pruritus. In young calves, it is characterized clinically
by encephalitis, no pruritus, erosion in the oral cavity and esophagus, and a high
case–fatality rate. An outbreak in sheep was associated with skin abrasions acquired
at shearing. Affected ewes were dull, inappetent, and had a fever of 41.1°C. About
23 of 29 affected sheep developed the “mad itch,” with nibbling of their fleece and
frenzied attempts to bite one area of the skin and rub it against the wall and bars
of their pen. Terminally, recumbency, tremors, and opisthotonus were common, and death
occurred within 12 to 24 hours after onset. Five farm cats also became ill and died;
the virus was isolated from the brain of one cat. In goats, rapid deaths, unrest,
lying down and rising frequently, crying plaintively, profuse sweating, and spasms
and paralysis terminally are characteristic. There may be no pruritus.
The clinical findings in dogs and cats are similar to those in cattle, with death
occurring in about 24 hours. In France, cases in dogs have been linked to strains
of virus from wild boars.
Clinical Pathology
Serology
The commonly used serologic tests for PRV-specific antibodies are the serum neutralization
(SN) and ELISA tests.
Serum Neutralization Test
The SN test using the Shoppe strain has been the gold standard against which other
serologic tests are compared and has been most widely used because of its sensitivity
and specificity. Specific virus-neutralizing (VN)antibodies are detectable in the
serum of recovered pigs, and this test is in routine use for herd diagnosis and survey
purposes. Antibody is detectable on the seventh day after infection, reaches a peak
about the 35th day, and persists for many months. Paired serum samples taken as early
as possible, and about 3 weeks later, show a marked antibody rise. However, the SN
test lacks the sensitivity necessary for detection of pigs with low levels of humoral
titers of specific SN antibodies, which can be enhanced by using the Bartha gIII strain.
Some herds may have no serologic evidence of previous infection or current spread
of the virus but have single reactors in the herd that may be infected with the virus.
Such singleton reactors may be found in herds being monitored serologically for presence
of infection. These singleton reactors may be infected with strains of the virus that
are relatively avirulent.
Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay
The ELISA test is more sensitive than the SN test, especially early in the immune
response to PRV antigens. However, because of its high sensitivity, screening ELISAs
yield some false positives, which must be confirmed by another test, such as another
ELISA, SN test, or latex agglutination test. False positives are unlikely to be caused
by infection with other herpesviruses. ELISA has also been used as a meat juice test
with high sensitivity (93%) and specificity (98%).
The indirect ELISA is a more rapid and convenient procedure, offering many advantages
over the SN test for routine serodiagnostic work. An indirect ELISA, using whole blood
collected onto paper disks, is a rapid and convenient test and eliminates the costs
of using vacutainer tubes and separating the blood. An indirect ELISA based on recombinant
and affinity-purified glycoprotein E of PRV to differentiate vaccinated from naturally
infected animals has been developed. An indirect ELISA has been developed in the Czech
Republic that can be used because of its high sensitivity and specificity for blood
serum on frozen pork samples. It has allowed the demonstration of PRV in meat juice
with only marginal titers in the blood.
Commercial ELISA kits are available and some are more specific than others. A highly
sensitive and specific competitive ELISA based on baculovirus-expressed PRV glycoprotein
gE and gI complex has been described. This allows detection as early as 2 weeks postinfection
and can handle large numbers of tests without the need to handle live virus.
In countries where vaccination is regularly used for control of the disease, an assay
to serologically distinguish infected from vaccinated pigs is critical. Although a
vaccination program will reduce the circulation of virus in the field, it will not
eliminate the virus from the pig population. To eradicate the virus, the ability to
differentiate infected from vaccinated pigs is crucial. Several commercial ELISA kits
can differentiate between vaccinated and naturally infected pigs. Differentiation
is possible when vaccine virus strains have either a natural, or a genetically engineered,
deletion that encodes for either gI, gIII, or gX genes. Commercial ELISA kits that
specifically detect antibody responses to gI of the virus offer considerable advantages
as diagnostic tests for the virus, with a sensitivity of 99.2% and specificity of
100%. The gI ELISA is able to distinguish infected pigs from those vaccinated with
gI-negative vaccines. The field strains of the virus produce antibodies to gI when
inoculated into pigs. Unvaccinated pigs, or pigs vaccinated with gI-negative vaccines,
that become subclinically infected with field strains of the virus may be detected
with the gI–ELISA for a long time after infection. Thus pigs that are seropositive
in the gI–ELISA have either been infected with PRV or have been vaccinated with gI-positive
vaccines; gI-seronegative pigs can be considered to be uninfected. Eradication of
the virus from swine herds is possible by gI–ELISA testing, and culling gI-seropositive
pigs in herds using gI-negative vaccines.
Detection of pigs in the latent phase of infection can be done serologically. Pigs
of any age that survive the acute infection phase become latent carriers for life,
and serologic testing consistently detects animals in the latent phase of infection
if the test detects the antibody response to the whole virus or to a reliable PRV
glycoprotein. Of several serologic tests examined, the gI and gIII marker systems,
which performed with similar sensitivity as the screening tests, were superior to
the gX marker system in detecting antibodies in infected pigs.
Detection of Virus
In infected pigs the virus is usually present in nasal secretions for up to 10 days.
A common method for the diagnosis of PRV in sows is to take swabs from the nasal mucosa
and vagina. Polyester and wire swabs shipped in 199 tissue culture medium supplemented
with 2% fetal bovine serum (FBS) buffered with 0.1% sodium bicarbonate and HEPES will
yield optimum recovery of the virus. Wooden applicator sticks with cotton wool have
antiviral activity and recovery of the virus may not be possible after 2 days, which
is of practical importance if the samples are shipped by mail. The virus can be demonstrated
in nasal cells by immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase techniques. It can be detected
by direct filter hybridization of nasal and tonsillar specimens from live pigs. The
virus survives on tonsil swabs taken with Dacron-tipped applicators for up to 72 hours
in cell culture medium under transport.
New PCR techniques have been used and they can differentiate between true and false
serologic positives when single reactor pigs have been found. A molecular beacon RT-PCR
for the detection of PRV, African swine fever (ASF), PCV2, and Porcine Parvovirus
has been described
12
and for the detection of PRV, ASF, and PRRS.
13
A multiplex PCR for PRV, porcine respiratory coronavirus, and PCV2 has been described.
14
Loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) for rapid detection and differentiation
of wild-type PRV and gene-deleted virus vaccines was described.
15
Necropsy Findings
There are no gross lesions typical and constant for the disease, and in some cases
lesions are absent or minimal and diagnosis must rely on laboratory examination. When
pruritus has occurred, there is considerable damage to local areas of skin and extensive
subcutaneous edema.
Gross lesions in the upper respiratory tract are the most obvious and these include
necrotic rhinitis, conjunctivitis, laryngitis, and tracheitis. The lungs show congestion,
edema, and some hemorrhages. Hemorrhages may be present under the endocardium and
excess fluid is often present in the pericardial sac. In pigs, there are additional
lesions of visceral involvement. Slight splenomegaly, meningitis, and excess pericardial
fluid are observed, and there may be small necrotic foci in the spleen and liver.
In sows, there may be a necrotizing placentitis and endometritis. Foci of hepatic,
splenic, or pulmonary necrosis may be seen in aborted fetuses.
Histologically, in all species, there is severe and extensive neuronal damage in the
spinal cord, paravertebral ganglia, and brain. Perivascular cuffing and focal necrosis
are present in the gray matter, particularly in the cerebellar cortex. Intranuclear
inclusion bodies occur infrequently in the degenerating neurons and astroglial cells,
particularly in cerebral cortex in the pig. These inclusions are of considerable importance
in differential diagnosis. Necrotizing lesions with inclusion-body formation in the
upper respiratory tract and lungs is strongly suggestive of porcine pseudorabies.
Ultrastructural observations have been made that included syncytia, cellular debris
and macrophages, and lymphocytes with vacuoles in their cytoplasm. Virus may be detected
by direct fluorescent antibody examination or by growth in tissue culture. The tissues
of the head and neck regions of nonimmune pigs yield virus most consistently and in
the highest concentration after challenge. The immunoperoxidase test can be used to
study the distribution of the virus in different tissues. Latent virus can be detected
using a DNA hybridization dot blot assay. Whenever possible, whole carcasses and fetuses
should be submitted for laboratory examination. The location of the optimal neural
samples, including the paravertebral ganglia, has been described for sheep. The placental
lesions in pregnant sows that have aborted from natural infection with pseudorabies
consist of necrotizing placentitis and the presence of intranuclear inclusions. In
an experimental infection of loops of intestine it was shown that there was necrosis
of the follicles in the Peyer's patches and degeneration of the epithelial cells in
the crypts and villi and degeneration of the cells in the myenteric plexuses. Intranuclear
inclusion bodies were found 2 to 4 days after inoculation. The primary target of the
wild PRV was the macrophages of the subepithelial area of the dome of the Peyer's
patch.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: half of midsagittally sectioned brain, spinal cord with paravertebral ganglia,
gasserian ganglion, placenta, liver, lung, spleen, tonsil, and retropharyngeal lymph
node (LM) should be collected. IHC has been used to confirm cases in countries where
the disease is rare and other corroborating evidence is lacking. In situ hybridization
has also been used Can also collect muscle samples for meat juice ELISAs.
•
Virology: brain, spinal cord, liver, spleen, tonsil, retropharyngeal lymph node (FAT,
ISO). CSF is not good for virus isolation. The best source is the trigeminal ganglion
in the domestic pig and the sacral ganglia in feral pigs. Viral isolation takes about
2 to 5 days. There are several PCRs available
5
and also nested PCRs and RT-PCRs.16, 17
Differential Diagnosis
The different clinical forms of pseudorabies in pigs and ruminants resemble several
diseases.
Teschen disease occurs in similar forms in certain areas; the diagnosis is dependent
on serology and pathology.
Rabies is rare in pigs and is usually accompanied by pruritus at the site of the bite.
Streptococcal meningitis is restricted to sucking pigs of 2–6 weeks of age, the lesions
are usually obvious at necropsy, and the causative organism is readily cultured from
the meninges. The response to treatment with penicillin is good and is of value as
a diagnostic test.
Encephalopathy associated with hog cholera, African swine fever, salmonellosis, Glasser's
disease, Escherichia coli septicemia and erysipelas are considerations, and are usually
obvious at necropsy.
Bowel edema causes typical edema of the head and eyelids in weaner pigs as well as
a rapid death.
Salt poisoning causes typical intermittent nervous signs, with a typical history of
water deprivation.
Respiratory form of pseudorabies should be considered in any outbreak of respiratory
disease that is poorly responsive to usually effective therapeutic measures.
Reproductive inefficiency associated with enterovirus (SMEDI) and parvovirus infections
closely resembles that associated with pseudorabies and requires laboratory differentiation
by virus isolation and serologic testing.
In cattle the local pruritus is distinctive, but the disease may be confused with
the nervous form of acetonemia in which paresthesia may lead to excitement. The rapid
recovery that ordinarily occurs in this form of acetonemia is an important diagnostic
point. The furious form of rabies and acute lead poisoning cause signs of mania, but
pruritus does not occur.
SMEDI, stillbirth, mummification, embryonic death, and infertility.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no treatment.
Control
The control of pseudorabies is difficult and currently unreliable because normal healthy
pigs may be infected and shed the virus for up to several months. One of the most
important future concerns is the infection in wild boar
18
and their illegal transportation across countries.
19
An important principle in control and eradication of the disease is the reproduction
ratio, R
0, which is defined as the average number of new infections caused by one typical
infectious animal. When R
0 > 1, the infection can spread; when R
0 < 1, the infection will disappear. In eradication programs it is essential that
R be less than 1 and the infection will die out in the herd.
Strategies Available
The methods of control or eradication include depopulation and repopulation, test
and removal, segregation of progeny, and vaccination. The selection of a strategy
for the control or elimination of the disease depends on the following: (1) source
of the herd infection; (2) method of transmission of the virus; (3) survival of the
virus in the environment; (4) sensitivity and specificity of the diagnostic test;
(5) risk factors in the herd, which include type of operation, degree of herd isolation,
prevalence of infection, value of the genetic material, level of management expertise,
and availability of suitable virus-free replacement swine if depopulation and repopulation
is chosen as a strategy.
The eradication of the disease from small herds was described in Hungary. In this
country the shared use of boars, the pig density, and the infection in the surrounding
area were the most significant influences on the spread and control of the disease.
Breeding stock producers favor eradication, farrow–finish producers that do not sell
breeding stock or feeder pigs are generally more concerned with the reduction of losses
from clinical PRV infection than with eradication. In the United States offsite all
in/all out finishing was more frequent among the successful farms than the unsuccessful
ones. The unsuccessful farms also had other infected herds within 3.2 km (2 miles)
and often no cleaning or disinfection.
Economics of Control and Eradication
Depopulation–repopulation is the most expensive form of eradication, the segregation
of progeny method the is next expensive, and the test and removal method is the most
inexpensive per sow. A computerized decision-tree analysis and simulation modeling
can evaluate the economics of control and eradication strategies. The optimal alternative
is to test and remove seropositive animals if the initial prevalence is ~57%; otherwise
vaccination of sows only is preferred. Vaccination may be recommended at lower prevalence
rates as a conservative approach. Eradication by test and removal combined with the
use of gene-deleted vaccines is advantageous at any prevalence rate of infection.
Depopulation and repopulation is not the best option under any circumstances. Once
formulated, a decision-tree analysis can be adapted to the prevailing economic or
epidemiologic conditions.
Determination of Prevalence of Infection
In large herds, the virus must be eliminated from the growing–finishing pigs and the
breeding herd. Large herds that are virus positive are infected in both groups; smaller
herds are frequently infected in only the breeding herd. An initial step in eradication
is to determine the prevalence of infection. Representative samples of finishing pigs
older than 4 months, and of breeding sows, gilts, and boars are tested. On the basis
of the test results and the risk factors in the herd, a cost-effective plan can be
devised for the individual herd.
Depopulation and Repopulation
When the prevalence of infection in the herd is over 50%, eradication can be achieved
by depopulation and repopulation with virus-free breeding stock. However, depopulation
is the most expensive method and is not compatible with the retention of valuable
pedigree stock. The entire herd is depopulated over a period of months as the animals
reach market weight. After removal of the animals the entire premises are cleaned
and disinfected. Repopulation should be delayed at least 30 days after the final disinfection,
and swine should originate from a pseudorabies-free qualified herd and be isolated
on the premises and retested 30 days after introduction. All herd additions should
be isolated and tested 30 days after introduction.
Test and Removal
The test and removal program is recommended when the prevalence of infection in the
herd is below 50%. This method requires testing of the entire breeding herd and immediate
removal of all seropositive animals; 30 days after removal of seropositive animals,
the herd is retested, and if necessary at 30-day intervals, until the entire herd
tests are negative. Following a second negative test, the testing regimen may be changed
to test only 25% of the herd every 4 months. Seropositive animals are identified and
culled. The test and removal method is superior to the vaccination system as a method
of control. Valuable genetic material from breeding stock that is seropositive may
be salvaged using embryo transfer techniques. Embryos may be transferred safely to
susceptible recipient gilts from sows that have recovered from infection, but not
from sows that are in the active stages of infection. The virus does not penetrate
the outer covering of the embryo, but it can become attached to it so that it may
physically transfer to the uterus of the recipient. This transfer of infection may
occur if the donor sow is in the active phase of infection.
Offspring Segregation
The objective of this strategy is to raise a PRV-negative breeding herd to replace
the infected herd. Once the herd is diagnosed as PRV infected, a regular schedule
of vaccination is instituted. Gilts are vaccinated at first breeding, and both sows
and gilts are vaccinated 2 to 4 weeks before farrowing to provide a high level of
colostral immunity to their piglets. Offspring are removed at weaning and raised apart
from the infected herd. At 4 months of age, and then again before breeding, the segregated
replacements are tested for antibody. Because colostral immunity is no longer detectable
by 4 months of age, any animals over 4 months of age that are seropositive are considered
pseudorabies infected. As the gilts reach reproductive maturity, the old sow herd
is replaced. Segregation between the infected sow herd and the clean gilt herd is
maintained until all positive sows have been removed and the facilities disinfected.
Groups of seronegative pigs are identified and combined into larger groups to establish
a new herd. The original herd is gradually depopulated and the premises cleaned and
disinfected. The new herd is then monitored on a regular basis.
Control Programs in Effect
PRV was first diagnosed in the North Island of New Zealand in 1976, an eradication
program was started in 1989, and the virus was cleared from the North Island in 1997.
A pseudorabies control program was introduced in England in 1983 when the infection
was spreading rapidly. New legislation imposed restrictions on the movement of pigs
where clinical signs of the disease were present in the herd. The first part of the
eradication scheme involved testing all of those herds previously known to have PRV.
Within several months after the beginning of the eradication campaign, 417 herds had
been slaughtered, involving 342,275 pigs, of which 72.5% were salvaged. Only 121 herds
had been known to be previously infected, while the remaining 296 herds had been identified
through trace backs and reports of new cases. By 1985 it was concluded that the disease
was well controlled in England with only 10 to 14 infected herds remaining. Farmers
were compensated for all animals slaughtered and also for consequential loss associated
with the loss of stock. The cost of the eradication program was financed by a levy
on all pigs normally marketed for slaughter in England. In 1995 England was free of
Aujeszky's disease. Following the successful use of the gene-deletion vaccination
and an eradication program the Netherlands and Germany are free of the disease. In
Sweden the herds were declared free from 12 to 53 months after the start of the program.
Now, in Northern Ireland, PRV is more widespread than it ever was in Britain before
the eradication program. Because the infection rate is over 50%, an eradication program
based on slaughter of infected herds would destroy the swine industry. Thus the control
program in Northern Ireland is based on the use of vaccination, the culling of seropositive
animals, and the gradual introduction of seronegative animals.
In the United States the national pseudorabies eradication program was implemented
in 1989 as a joint State-Federal-Industry–sponsored program. Pilot projects were conducted
in Iowa, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and North Carolina from 1984 to 1987.
In the pilot projects, 97.5% of 116 herds that were initially PRV positive were successfully
cleared of infection. This indicated that eradication of PRV virus from herds of swine
can be efficiently achieved and is most effective applied on an area basis. The introduction
of the gene-deleted PRV vaccines in the program was the technical breakthrough needed
to be able to offer the national eradication program, since it was now possible to
distinguish between naturally infected and vaccinated animals. The program consisted
of the following: stage I, preparation; stage II, control; stage III, mandatory herd
clean-up; stage IV, surveillance; and stage V, free. As of 2004, commercial swine
operations in all 50 states of the US were considered free of PRV; however, endemic
infection exists in feral pigs in a number of states. Endemic PRV infection remains
a concern for commercial herds.
When an outbreak of the disease occurs in a susceptible herd the mortality may be
very high, and the first consideration is to prevent spread to uninfected sows and
litters and pregnant sows from infected pigs. They should be attended by separate
personnel, or adequate barriers to mechanical transmission of infection should be
arranged. On affected premises, cattle should be separated from pigs, and dogs and
cats should be kept from the area. The affected herd should be quarantined, and all
pigs sold off the farm should be for slaughter only.
Vaccines and Vaccination
Vaccination is used to reduce clinical disease when outbreaks occur or when the disease
is endemic in the herd. An effective immunity develops after natural infection or
vaccination, and piglets from immune sows are protected from clinical disease during
the nursing period by colostral immunity. However, the presence of circulating antibody
does not prevent infection, the development of latency, and subsequent activation
and excretion of the virus. However, vaccination reduces viral shedding after natural
infection. On farms in which the disease is endemic or outbreaks have occurred, vaccination
of the sows, and management procedures to reduce the spread of infection, have markedly
reduced preweaning mortality and reproductive failures. Field studies in large numbers
of herds in which the sows were vaccinated three times annually show that the reproduction
ratio was below 0.66, which is significantly below,
1
and massive spread of the virus does not occur.
It is often virtually impossible to prevent the spread of infection in a susceptible
herd and vaccination of all pigs at risk, especially pregnant sows, is recommended.
The vaccine reduces losses in infected herds, limits the spread of infection, and
decreases the incidence in endemic areas. With a properly controlled and monitored
vaccination and culling program in a breeding herd, it is possible to control clinical
disease and reduce the infection pressure. All breeding stock present during an outbreak
are subsequently vaccinated regularly until they are all culled, which removes the
major sources of virulent virus. Following this phase, newly introduced gilts and
boars are tested, and monitored regularly. This is considered to be less costly than
the test and slaughter policy.
However, in vaccinated herds, the virus continues to circulate and an accurate epidemiologic
analysis is not possible because titers caused by vaccination cannot be distinguished
from those caused by natural infections.
Control of the diseases in many countries has always been based on compulsory intensive
vaccination of the entire population.
Vaccines
Conventional modified live virus and inactivated virus vaccines have been available.
Both vaccines will reduce the incidence rate and severity of clinical disease in an
infected herd. They also reduce the field virus shedding and latency in the trigeminal
ganglion after exposure to field virus. The vaccine efficiency is, however, markedly
influenced by the modified live virus vaccine strain and the route of administration.
The vaccine genotype plays a very important role in the effectiveness of the vaccine
program. Recently needle-free transdermal vaccination using a modified live PRV vaccine
has been described, preventing the loss of any needles in the carcass. Cell-mediated
immunity in the form of cytotoxic T cells may play an important part in the effectiveness
of the vaccine. The deficiencies of inactivated vaccines in producing virus-specific
interferon-γ (IFN-γ) can be enhanced by the use of simultaneous administration of
interleukin-12, which appears to upregulate Th1/Th2 expression.
Pregnant Sows
Vaccination of pregnant sows induces SN antibodies, which are transferred to the newborn
piglets and provide protection against infection. Vaccination during pregnancy produces
more protection against PRV for piglets than sow vaccination before mating. A better
protection was observed in sows vaccinated with an attenuated virus than in sows vaccinated
with inactivated virus. Piglets rely on colostral and milk antibodies for protection,
and the vaccination of piglets born from vaccinated sows does not produce a significant
serologic response until the piglets are about 12 weeks of age. Maternally derived
antibodies may disturb or even block the development of active humoral responses.
20
Earlier vaccination of piglets from infected or vaccinated sows is ineffective because
high levels of maternal antibodies interfere with a serologic response stimulated
by the vaccine. Maternal immunity interferes with the development of active immunity
from vaccination until at least 15 weeks of age, even when the colostral titers are
low. Thus in a situation in which the majority of sows have been infected or vaccinated,
vaccination of weaned pigs may not yield desirable results. Both inactivated virus
and attenuated live virus vaccines provide similar results when piglets born from
vaccinated sows are vaccinated before colostral immunity has waned.
Growing and Finishing Pigs
The optimal vaccination strategy for growing and finishing pigs in an eradication
program is controversial. In eight persistently infected herds' vaccinations, both
intranasally and intramuscularly, were made at 4 and 10 weeks of age. Only one vaccination
is given to finishing pigs in endemic areas in Europe. However, this does not reduce
the prevalence of infection in finishing pigs in herds with a high prevalence. Double
vaccination of finishing pigs will reduce the spread of the virus, but extensive spread
can still occur. The presence of maternal antibodies may interfere with the induction
of antibodies, and double vaccination 4 weeks later may boost immunity. Mean daily
weight gain was also improved by a second vaccination with a direct economic benefit.
Marker or Subunit Vaccines
A major development in vaccination against pseudorabies has been the introduction
of genetically engineered live vaccine strains used to make marker or subunit vaccines.
Vaccination with modified live gene-deleted vaccines is now an integral part of pseudorabies
eradication programs worldwide. The most common gene deletions are for glycoproteins
E (gE) or gI and G (gG) or gX, and gIII. A gD/gE-negative vaccine was described. In
Europe, use of gE vaccines has become the standard. These vaccines, in conjunction
with a companion diagnostic test, can distinguish between naturally infected and vaccinated
animals. Colostrum can also be used to monitor antibodies against gI protein of the
virus.
A study comparing intranasal and intramuscular vaccination showed that pigs given
both vaccines (intranasally and intramuscularly) had a significantly better clinical
and virologic protection after challenge than the single intranasal vaccination. The
recombinant vaccines are able to circumvent the inhibition of active immunity that
occurs when maternally derived antibody is still present. Animals vaccinated with
a deleted vaccine are not able to mount an immune response against the protein whose
gene has been deleted in the vaccine virus genome. In contrast, wild-type virus-infected
animals produce antibodies against all the viral glycoproteins. Differentiating ELISAs,
specific for the deleted marker protein, then allow discrimination between infected
animals, which can be culled from the herd, and vaccinated animals. These vaccines
reduce the severity of clinical disease and viral shedding. However, the presence
of colostral antibodies in growing pigs may interfere with an immune response, which
may result in increased virus excretion on challenge exposure. Repeated vaccination
is needed to provide some protective immunity against challenge exposure to virulent
virus.
These mutants have also been rendered thymidine kinase-deficient (TK−) mutants, and
are avirulent and immunogenic. Pigs inoculated with these mutants are resistant to
experimental challenge with the virulent virus, and the virulent virus cannot be recovered
from the ganglia, which suggests that vaccination reduced colonization of the ganglia.
The ideal vaccine strain should prevent clinical disease and mortality, should not
be transmitted to nonimmunized animals, and should prevent colonization of the ganglia
by a potential superinfecting virulent virus reducing the natural reservoir of the
virus. The TK− mutant virus possesses these desirable characteristics. The high efficacy
of recently constructed gI-negative deletion mutant vaccines of PRV virus provide
a sound basis for implementing the “gI” approach to the future control of the disease.
Piglets born from sows vaccinated with deleted (gIII, TK) strains at 3 days and 9
and 11 weeks of age developed detectable antibodies that lasted up to 100 days of
age when vaccinated. Maternal antibodies in piglets from sows vaccinated with gIII-deleted
vaccine decay to undetectable levels at 7 weeks of age. The vaccination of piglets
at 3 days of age with the same vaccine results in a priming effect, which protects
the piglets against virulent virus challenge at 7 weeks of age. Thus effective protection
could be provided by active immunization from birth through weaning, in the nursery,
and into the growing and finishing stages of production. Piglet vaccination at 10
and 14 weeks was considered to be the optimal time for vaccination.
21
Although genetically engineered live virus vaccines have been shown to be efficacious
and safe, there is a possibility of spread between vaccinated and unvaccinated animals,
of persistence in the field and of recombination between different vaccine strains,
which can lead to enhanced virulence. New viral mutants lacking glycoproteins gD,
gE, gG, and gI may form the basis for the development of new vaccines that do not
recombine. A gB deletion vaccine has been described for intranasal use and has been
shown to produce both local and serum antibodies. Recently a DNA vaccine was shown
to give as good a response as gD plasmid vaccine, but the DNA vaccine had to be given
intradermally. It can overcome maternally derived antibody, and the vaccine described
in this case still gave protection against infectious PRV challenge at the end of
the finishing period.
Even more radical is a vaccine with a granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor.
Experimentally, immunized pigs can be latently infected with the wild-type virus without
being detected by the gE-specific ELISA routinely used to discriminate between infected
and vaccinated pigs. Thus gE seronegative pigs may still be infected and be a source
of infection.
Remarkable progress has been made with the use of gI-deleted vaccines. Intensive regional
vaccination of finishing pigs with a gI-deleted vaccine, along with companion diagnostic
tests, reduced the seroprevalence in infected finishing herds from 81% to 19% in 2
years. Vaccination increases the virus dose needed for establishment of infection
and decreases the level and duration of virus excretion after infection. In the control
group, with routine disease control, no significant change in seroprevalence occurred.
The consistent application of intensive vaccination of all breeding herds in a region,
including those herds participating in a production chain, can also decrease the prevalence
of infection in heavily infected areas. The intensive regional vaccination did not
completely eliminate virus infections within these herds; the source of infection
was not determined. It is suggested that the virus either circulated at a low level
within herds, or its introduction or reactivation did not lead to an extensive spread
of the virus. A voluntary vaccination program on individual farms was unsuccessful
in reducing the prevalence of virus-infected breeding pigs. The importation of breeding
stock from outside the area is associated with a higher prevalence of virus-infected
pigs because of lack of vaccination. The introduction of infections can be reduced
by purchasing virus-free animals and by increasing farm biosecurity procedures.
Vaccination of breeding herds three times annually to ensure a high level of immunization
can lead to elimination of the disease when the reproduction ratio is less than one.
The method used for vaccination may influence the effect of the vaccine. Using glycoprotein
vaccines, intramuscular vaccination in the neck, and six-point intradermal vaccination
in the back provided the best protection; six-point intradermal injections resulted
in a better vaccination than two-point injections. BW changes and viral excretion
after challenge were compared with VN titers, antigen-specific IgG and IgA responses
in serum, and virus-specific lymphoproliferative responses in peripheral blood during
the immunization period.
An intensive eradication program in farrow–finish herds using a gI-deleted vaccine
in breeding and growing–finishing pigs, and decreases of movement and mixing of growing–finishing
pigs was successful in 3 years. The initial goal was to decrease viral spread in the
growing–finishing pigs, which enabled production of seronegative replacement gilts.
Increases in the number of sows culled, combined with an increase in the number of
seronegative replacement gilts, resulted in a decrease in seroprevalence of sows.
Bimonthly serologic monitoring indicated minimal spread of the virus in the growing–finishing
pigs after 1 year. Eighteen months after the initiation of the program, the test and
removal of seropositive sows commenced in all herds. All herds were released from
quarantine within 3 years, indicating that eradication can be achieved by vaccination
and management changes designed to minimize the spread of virus combined with test-and-removal
procedures.
An attenuated gI-deleted–TK-deleted vaccine was used to eradicate the virus from a
large farrow–finish herd in Sweden. At the start of the program, 86% of the breeding
animals were seropositive. The breeding stock was vaccinated every 4 months and monitored
serologically. Seropositive sows and boars were culled at an economic rate. The herd
was declared gI negative 39 months after the start of the program. Monitoring the
herd for another 4 years, until all vaccinated animals had been culled, revealed the
herd free of the virus.
In New Zealand, progress toward eradication using a subunit vaccine is reported. Those
farms that combined vaccination with good management techniques, intensive testing,
and culling eradicated the wild virus infection within 2 years; those that made little
or no progress has less than satisfactory standards of hygiene and did not practice
an intensive testing and culling program.
Vaccination of both breeding stock and growing pigs is recommended. A combined vaccination–eradication
program for the disease would generally comprise four phases:
1.
A systematic and intensive vaccination campaign
2.
Screening of pigs for gI antibodies
3.
Economic culling of infected breeding pigs
4.
Final ending of vaccination.
Piglets at 3 days of age can be vaccinated with one of these genetically engineered
vaccines and be protected from experimental challenge at 5 weeks of age.
A recent study has shown that infection with PRRS virus does not inhibit the development
of a vaccine-induced protection against PRV.
Vaccination of wild boar with an attenuated live vaccine has been shown to protect
against infection.
22
Vaccination of cattle with an inactivated vaccine is recommended where they are in
close contact with swine and where a low level of exposure is likely.
References
1
Davison
AJ
Vet Microbiol
143
2010
52
20346601
2
Hahn
EC
Vet Microbiol
143
2010
45
20444559
3
Lipowski
A
Medycyna Wet
85
2009
771
4
Muller
T
Epidemiol Infect
12
2010
1
5
Muller
T
Arch Virol
156
2011
1691
21837416
6
Toma
B
Epidemiol Sante Anim
63
2013
141
7
Smith
G
PrevVet Med
103
2012
145
8
Glorieux
S
Vet Microbiol
136
2009
141
9
Nauwynck
H
Vet Res
38
2007
229
17257571
10
Pomeranz
L
Microbiol Mol Biol Rev
69
2006
462
11
Morandi
F
J Comp Pathol
142
2010
74
19631945
12
McKillen
J
J Virol Methods
140
2007
155
17196673
13
Sami
L
Acta Vet Hung
55
2007
267
17555292
14
Lee
C-S
J Virol Methods
139
2007
39
17034871
15
Zhang
C-F
J Virol Methods
169
2010
239
20691214
16
Tombacz
D
BMC Genomics
10
2009
491
19852823
17
Ma
WJ
J Vet Diagn Invest
20
2008
440
18599848
18
Boadella
M
BMC Vet Res
8
2012
7
22251441
19
Wilson
S
J Wildl Dis
45
2009
874
19617504
20
Pomorska-Mol
M
Vet Microbiol
144
2010
450
20153939
21
Markowska-Daniel
I
Bull Vet Inst Pulawy
53
2009
169
22
Maresch
C
Vet Microbiol
161
2013
20
Sporadic Bovine Encephalomyelitis (Buss Disease and Transmissible Serositis)
Sporadic bovine encephalomyelitis (SBE) is associated with a chlamydia, and characterized
by inflammation of vascular endothelium and mesenchymal tissue. There is secondary
involvement of the nervous system, with nervous signs, in some cases.
Etiology
The disease is associated with specific strains of Chlamydophila (Chlamydia) pecorum.
1, 2 It resists freezing but is highly susceptible to sodium hydroxide, cresol, and
quaternary ammonium compounds in standard concentrations. The chlamydia can be passaged
in guinea pigs and hamsters and adapted to grow in the yolk sac of developing chick
embryos.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
The disease has been reported only from the United States, Europe, Japan, Israel,
and Australia,
1
but a provisional diagnosis has been made in Canada and South Africa. In the United
States it was most common in the midwestern and western States, but there have been
no reports of its occurrence for the last 30 years.
Sporadic cases or outbreaks occur in individual herds. Although the disease has not
reached serious economic proportions in the endemic infection, there is some serologic
evidence that widespread subclinical infections occur.
Only cattle and buffalo are affected, and calves less than 6 months of age are most
susceptible. Other domestic and experimental species appear to be resistant. There
is no seasonal incidence and cases appear at any time of the year. A strong and apparently
persistent immunity develops after an attack of the disease.
Prevalence of Infection
Morbidity and Case–Fatality Rates
The occurrence is sporadic, but outbreaks have occurred resulting in severe loss from
both deaths of animals and loss of condition. Morbidity rates average 12.5% (5–50%)
and are highest in calves (25%) and lowest in animals over a year old (5%). Mortality
rates average about 31% and are higher in adults than in calves. In affected herds
a stage of herd immunity is reached when only introduced animals and newborn calves
are susceptible.
Method of Transmission
The method of spread is not known but is suspected to be fecal–oral.
1
Spread from farm to farm does not occur readily. On some farms only sporadic cases
may occur, but on others one or two cases occur every year. In still other herds the
disease occurs in outbreak form, with a number of animals becoming affected within
a period of about 4 weeks. The epidemiology of SBE resembles in many ways that of
malignant catarrhal fever in cattle. The organism can be isolated from many organs,
including liver, spleen, and CNS, and from the blood, feces, urine, nasal discharges,
and milk in the early stages of the disease. There is some evidence that the organism
is eliminated in the feces for several weeks after infection.
Pathogenesis
The causative agent is not specifically neurotropic and attacks principally the mesenchymal
tissues and the endothelial lining of the vascular system, with particular involvement
of the serous membranes. Encephalomyelitis occurs secondarily to the vascular damage.
Neurologic signs may be caused by infection with specific strains; C. pecorum genotype
ST 23 has been associated with SBE cases from Australia, England, and the United States,
1
whereas other strains have been isolated from cattle with pneumonia and polyarthritis
2
and calves with poor weight gain.
3
Clinical Findings
Affected calves are depressed and inactive, but the appetite may be unaffected for
several days. Nasal discharge and salivation with drooling are frequently observed.
A fever is common (40.5°C-41.5°C, 105°F-107°F), and remains high for the course of
the disease. Dyspnea, coughing, a mild catarrhal nasal discharge, and diarrhea may
occur. During the ensuing 2 weeks, difficulty in walking and lack of desire to stand
may appear. Stiffness with knuckling at the fetlocks is evident at first, followed
by staggering, circling, and falling. Opisthotonus may occur but there is no excitement
or head-pressing. The course of the disease varies between 3 days and 3 weeks. Animals
that recover show marked loss of condition and are slow to regain the lost weight.
Clinical Pathology
Hematology
In experimental cases, leukopenia occurs in the acute clinical stage. There is a relative
lymphocytosis and depression of polymorphonuclear cells.
Detection of Agent
The causative agent can be isolated from the blood in the early clinical phase, and
can be used for transmission experiments in calves and guinea pigs, and for culture
in eggs. Elementary bodies are present in the guinea pig tissues and yolk-sac preparations.
Serology
Serologic methods, including a complement fixation test for the detection of circulating
antibody, are available although there is difficulty in differentiating antibodies
to the chlamydia from those to the typical psittacosis virus.
Necropsy Findings
A fibrinous peritonitis, pleurisy, and pericarditis, accompanied by congestion and
petechiation, are characteristic. In the early stages, thin serous fluid is present
in the cavities, but in the later stages this has progressed to a thin fibrinous net
covering the affected organs, or even to flattened plaques or irregularly shaped masses
of fibrin lying free in the cavity. Histologically, there is fibrinous serositis involving
the serosa of the peritoneal, pleural, and pericardial cavities. A diffuse encephalomyelitis
involving particularly the medulla and cerebellum, and a meningitis in the same area,
are also present. Minute elementary bodies are present in infected tissues and in
very small numbers in exudate. The necropsy findings are diagnostic for SBE, and confirmation
can be obtained by the complement fixation test or SN tests.
Differential Diagnosis
Clinically, the disease resembles other encephalitides of cattle. The epidemiology
and pathogenesis resembles malignant catarrhal fever in cattle, but the mortality
rate is much lower, there are no ocular or mucosal lesions, and the serositis of SBE
does not occur in bovine malignant catarrh. A viral encephalomyelitis of calves (Kunjin
virus) has been identified, but has not been associated with clinical signs of disease
of the nervous system. An encephalomyocarditis virus, a primary infection of rodents
that also occurs in primates and causes myocarditis in pigs, has been transmitted
experimentally to calves but without causing significant signs of disease.
Listeriosis is usually sporadic and is accompanied by more localizing signs, especially
facial paralysis and circling.
Rabies may present a very similar clinical picture, but the initial febrile reaction
and the characteristic necropsy findings as well as the epizootiologic history of
SBE should enable a diagnosis to be made.
Lead poisoning can be differentiated by the absence of fever, the more severe signs
of motor irritation, and the shorter course of the disease. Because of the respiratory
tract involvement, SBE may be easily confused with pneumonic pasteurellosis, especially
if outbreaks occur, but in the latter disease nervous signs are unusual and the response
to treatment is good.
SBE, sporadic bovine encephalomyelitis.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Broad-spectrum antimicrobials control the agent in vitro. However, clinical results
with chlortetracycline and oxytetracycline have been irregular, but may be effective
if used in the early stages of the disease.
Control
Control measures are difficult to prescribe because of lack of knowledge of the method
of transmission. It is advisable to isolate affected animals. No vaccine is available.
References
1
Jelocnik
M
BMC Vet Res
10
2014
121
24884687
2
Kaltenboeck
B
Vet Microbiol
135
2009
175
18930605
3
Poudel
A
PLoS ONE
7
2012
e44961
23024776
Border Disease (Hairy Shaker Disease of Lambs, Hairy Shakers, Hypomyelinogenesis Congenita)
Synopsis
Etiology Pestivirus strains in the border disease and bovine virus diarrhea genotypes.
Epidemiology Congenital disease transmitted by persistently infected sheep, rarely
cattle.
Clinical findings Abortions, stillbirths, barren ewes, and the birth of small weak
lambs, some of which have an abnormally hairy birth coat, gross tremor of skeletal
muscles, inferior growth, and a variable degree of skeletal deformity.
Clinical pathology None specific.
Lesions Hypomyelination in brain and spinal cord of lamb.
Diagnostic confirmation Detection of virus and/or demonstration of serologic response.
Treatment Supportive.
Control Avoid infection of pregnant sheep. Identify and cull persistently infected
animals.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
The causal agent, border disease virus (BDV), is a pestivirus within the family Flaviviridae.
Four members of the pestivirus genus have been identified; bovine virus diarrhea virus
(BVDV) types 1 and 2, classical swine fever virus, and BDV. Isolates from border disease
predominantly fall within the BDV genotype, but sheep and goat isolates also fall
in the BVDV genotypes. Pestiviruses consist of a single strand of RNA and were originally
named after the host from which they were isolated. However, their interspecies transmissibility
means an increasing reliance on phylogenetic studies based on sequences generated
from relatively well conserved regions of the viral genome, such as the 5′ untranscribed
region. On this basis BDV can be phylogenetically segregated into at least seven clusters,
subtypes BDV-1 to BDV-7.
1
Strains of BDV have differing pathogenicity, and variations in pathogenicity also
result from interactions between the virus and different host genotypes, specifically
between different breeds of sheep. Persistent infections in sheep are associated with
noncytopathic strains of virus. An isolate of BDV, now designated as BDV-5, caused
a leukopenic enterocolitis in sheep and growing lambs in the Aveyron region of France
(Aveyron disease).
2
The disease caused high mortality in sheep in this region in 1984 but has not occurred
since then.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Border disease was originally described in the border country between England and
Wales. It has subsequently been reported from most of the major sheep-producing countries
and probably occurs in all of them. The disease occurs primarily in sheep, and less
often in goats and free-living ruminants, such as chamois.
3
The prevalence of infection is much higher than the incidence of clinical disease
because the latter only occurs when there is infection during pregnancy. BDV-1 has
been detected in sheep from Australia, New Zealand, UK, and United States; BDV-2 from
ruminants in Germany; BDV-3 in Switzerland and Austria; BDV-4 in Spain; BDV-5 and
BDV-6 in France; and BDV-7 in Turkey.
1
Studies on seroprevalence suggest that pestivirus infections in sheep and goats are
less common than in cattle, but there are considerable differences in seroprevalence
between different geographic areas and flocks. Flock seroprevalence in different regions
or countries generally falls within the range of 5% to 50%. The prevalence of seropositive
females within positive flocks is influenced by age, with a lower seroprevalence in
sheep 4 to 8 months of age than in older sheep. Seroprevalence is higher in flocks
with persistently infected sheep, but there can still be a significant proportion
of seronegative sheep present in a flock containing persistently infected sheep.
Source of Infection
Infection can be introduced into a flock with the purchase of persistently infected
replacement sheep. Persistently infected sheep excrete virus in nasal secretions,
saliva, urine, and feces, and provide the major source of infection. A proportion
of persistently infected sheep may survive to adulthood and may breed successfully
to produce further persistently infected sheep. However, the breeding efficiency of
persistently infected sheep is poor, and the probability of establishing lines of
persistently infected sheep appears less than with the equivalent infection in cattle.
Virus is also present in the placenta and fetal fluids at the birth of persistently
infected lambs and in the products of abortion resulting from infection with the virus
in early pregnancy. In flocks where there is a long lambing period it is possible
that this could provide a source for clinical disease in late-lambing ewes. Field
observations suggest that transmission during the lambing period is limited.
Calves persistently infected with BVDV can infect sheep, and in countries where pregnant
sheep and cattle are housed in close proximity during the winter this can be an important
source of infection for outbreaks of border disease. In some countries this appears
to be the major source, and studies in both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland
suggest that cattle are the primary source of infection for sheep in those countries.
There is also evidence that bovine strains are important in goat infections. In contrast
BDV is the predominant ovine pestivirus in Great Britain and New Zealand.
Free-living deer are also a potential source of infection. Outbreaks of disease have
also occurred after vaccinating pregnant goats with an Orf vaccine contaminated with
a pestivirus.
Transmission
Natural transmission is by sheep-to-sheep contact, but successful experimental transmission
has followed both oral and conjunctival challenge.
The spread of infection within a susceptible flock is facilitated by factors such
as close contact at mating time or mustering and aggregating sheep for any purpose.
There is an increased risk for explosive outbreaks of border disease where animals
are housed in early pregnancy.
Host Risk Factors
Border disease may occur as an outbreak or as a sporadic disease. When infection is
introduced into a susceptible flock in early pregnancy, an outbreak with infertility,
abortion, and congenital disease in lambs from all ages of ewes is likely. Subsequently,
older sheep in the flock will have acquired immunity and disease occurs only in introduced
sheep and maiden ewes. Persistently infected ewes have reduced fertility but will
give birth to congenitally affected lambs throughout their breeding life. The disproportional
occurrence of outbreaks of clinical disease in certain breeds suggests that they may
have higher rates of persistently infected individuals.
Experimental Reproduction
Border disease is readily reproduced by the experimental oral, conjunctival, and parenteral
infection of pregnant ewes before 80 days' gestation. Experimental disease can be
produced with both BDV and BVDV strains.
The following have been produced experimentally, although there are strain differences
in clinical and pathologic manifestations:
•
Placentitis
•
Abortions
•
Mummified fetuses
•
Congenital malformations, including hydrocephalus, porencephaly, cerebellar hypoplasia
and dysplasia, and arthrogryposis
•
Fetal growth retardation
•
Hypomyelinogenesis
•
Birth of weak lambs with nervous disorders
•
A hairy birth coat
Experimental infections of pregnant cows with BDV results in similar defects with
placentitis, mummification, and abortion of fetuses; intrauterine growth retardation
with abnormal osteogenesis; and hypomyelinogenesis.
The disease has also been produced experimentally in goat kids by inoculation of pregnant
goats but there are no abnormalities of hair coat, and embryonic mortality and abortion
are more common than in the experimental disease in ewes.
Economic Importance
The effect of infection varies with the immune status of the flock and whether infection
occurs during pregnancy. In fully susceptible flocks, abortion and neonatal lamb loss
resulting from infection can be 25% to 75% of the expected lamb crop depending on
the strain of the virus. An assessment of the economic losses caused by infertility,
abortion, neonatal losses, and low carcass weight indicate that an outbreak of border
disease can result in a potential reduction of income in excess of 20%.
Where sheep and cattle are comingled, the presence of BDV in sheep could also jeopardize
efforts to control and eradicate pestivirus (BVDV) from cattle herds. Persistently
infected sheep readily transmit BDV to seronegative calves; thus the antigenic similarity
between the two viruses will complicate attempts to demonstrate freedom from BVD in
cattle by serology.
4
Pathogenesis
Nonpregnant Sheep
In adolescent and adult nonpregnant sheep, infection and viremia are subclinical.
The intramuscular inoculation of immunocompetent lambs with BDV results in a mild
transient disease and a subsequent reduction in growth rate, but no gross or microscopic
lesions.
Pregnant Sheep
When BDV infects susceptible pregnant ewes the virus infects the placenta to produce
an acute necrotizing placentitis and it subsequently invades the fetus. This may result
in early embryonic death, abortion and stillbirth, the birth of lambs with malformations
and/or neurologic abnormalities, the birth of small weak lambs that are immunosuppressed,
or the birth of lambs with no clinical abnormality. The ultimate outcome of the infection
depends on the age of the fetus, the properties of the strain of the virus, the dose
of the virus, the genotype of the host, and the ability of the fetus to respond to
the virus. Immune competence to the virus in the fetus develops between approximately
61 and 80 days' gestation; thus fetal age at the time of infection determines the
outcome of infection.
Infection in Early Pregnancy
Fetal death occurs when there is infection of the fetus with virulent strains before
the development of immune competence and uncontrolled viral replication. Prenatal
death is more likely to follow infections in early pregnancy, but is recorded with
infections from 45 to 72 days' gestation.
Persistent infections occur in lambs that survive infection in early pregnancy before
the development of immune competence and result from maternal infections between 21
and 72 days' gestation but never later. The virus is present in all organs, and lambs
born persistently infected will remain so for their lifetime, with few exceptions;
persistent infections have been recorded to at least 5 years of age.
Most persistently infected sheep are unable to produce a specific antibody to BDV,
but some show intermittent seropositivity with low antibody levels or occasionally
undergo frank seroconversion. The humoral response to other pathogens and antigens
is normal. However, cell-mediated immunity is compromised, with change in T-cell populations
and a deficiency in lymphocyte function. Persistently infected lambs are more susceptible
to intercurrent disease and commonly die before reaching maturity.
Hypomyelinogenesis occurs in persistently infected lambs and resolves spontaneously
in lambs that survive to the age of 6 months. Most of these lambs exhibit neurologic
dysfunction at birth, varying from a continuous light tremor to tonic-clonic contraction
of the skeletal muscles involving the whole body and head (shakers).
A deficiency of the thyroid T3 and T4 hormones has been detected in lambs affected
with border disease and may be the basic cause of the lack of myelination. The enzyme
2,3-cyclic nucleotide-3-phosphodiesterase is associated with normal myelination and
depends on normal amounts of thyroid hormone. The deficiency in thyroid hormones may
also result in the reduced rate of weight gain that occurs in infected lambs. Other
studies suggest a direct infection of oligodendroglia with the virus as the cause
of the defective myelination.
Fleece abnormality also occurs in persistently infected lambs and results from an
enlargement of the primary hair follicles and a concurrent reduction in the number
of secondary follicles. The resulting hairiness is caused by the presence of large
medullated primary fibers. BDV appears to have no effect on the skin and birth coat
of coarse-fleeced breeds of sheep or on goats.
Intrauterine growth retardation is a common feature of infection with BDV and is initiated
shortly after infection. Deformities of the skeleton include abnormally shortened
long bones and a reduction in crown–rump length and the long axis of the skull, which
results in lambs appearing more compact and short-legged than normal (goat lambs).
In the long bones there is evidence of growth arrest lines and disturbed osteogenesis
and ossification.
Some persistently infected lambs do not have nervous signs or abnormalities of the
fleece and are phenotypically normal. This limits the value of identification of infected
lambs based on the presence of clinical abnormality at birth.
In Midpregnancy
When fetal infection occurs during the period of development of the ability to mount
an immune response (between approximately 61 and 80 days' gestation), the effect is
variable. Some fetuses infected at this stage respond with a severe inflammatory process
in the CNS with nodular periarteritis, necrosis, and inflammation of the germinal
layers of the brain. Resultant lesions are hydranencephaly, cerebellar dysplasia,
and multifocal retinal atrophy; such lambs exhibit behavioral abnormalities and more
severe neurologic disease than shaker lambs.
Infection in Late Pregnancy
Infection of the fetus after 80 days' gestation is likely to be controlled or eliminated
by a fetal immune response. These lambs are born without clinical disease, and are
virus negative, but have precolostral circulating antibody.
Goats
In goats, fetal death is the major outcome of infection of the pregnant doe with both
BDV and BVDV, and infections before 60 days' gestation almost invariably result in
reproductive failure. Persistently infected shaker kids and clinically normal kids
are born with infections around 60 days' gestation but are a less common manifestation
of the disease than occurs in sheep. The caprine fetus develops immune competence
against pestiviruses between 80 and 100 days' gestation.
Enteric Disease
Experimental inoculation of a homologous strain of the BDV into persistently infected
but clinically recovered lambs results in a severe clinical syndrome. This is characterized
by persistent diarrhea and respiratory distress associated with an inflammatory lymphoproliferative
response in the CNS, intestines, lungs, heart, and kidney. A similar syndrome is seen
in some persistently infected sheep that survive early life and reach weaning. This
syndrome resembles certain aspects of mucosal disease in cattle, in which it is postulated
that superinfection of persistently viremic immunotolerant cattle with a homologous
strain of BVDV results in fatal mucosal disease. In such animals a specific and dynamic
equilibrium exists between an attenuated form of the virus and the immunotolerant
host. Disturbance of this equilibrium either by injection of the homologous strain
of BDV, or some other factor, results in fatal disease.
Clinical Findings
The most obvious and characteristic features of border disease are evident at birth
and relate to conformation and growth, fleece type, and neurologic dysfunction. An
increased proportion of barren ewes will also be apparent in severe outbreaks.
Conformation
Affected lambs may have a lower birth weight than uninfected lambs, a decreased crown–rump
length, and a shorter tibia/radius length so that they have a boxy appearance. The
head has a shortened longitudinal axis and the cranium may be slightly domed (goat,
lambs).
Fleece
The fleece, when dry, appears hairy and rough because of long hairs rising above the
fleece to form a halo, especially over the nape, back, flanks, and rump. This feature
is most evident in medium-wool and fine-wool breeds and is not observed in the coarse
kempy-fleeced breeds, such as the Scottish Blackface. The halo kemp fibers are shed
with time and are most evident in the first 3 weeks of life. Some lambs have abnormal
pigmentation occurring as patches of pigmented fleece or hair, or a totally pigmented
fleece. This can occur in white-faced sheep.
Neurologic Dysfunction
Neurologic dysfunction is manifest, with rhythmic tremors of the muscles of the pelvis
and upper parts of the hindlimbs, or of the whole body, resulting in a characteristic
jerking movement, and of the head and neck with rhythmic bobbing of the head (shaker
lambs). In some less severe cases, only fine tremors of the ears and tail are evident.
Tremors are most apparent during movement, and are absent while the lamb is sleeping.
The tremors usually decline in severity as the lamb matures and may seem to disappear
unless the animal is stressed. More severely affected lambs have difficulty in rising,
and if able to stand with assistance exhibit an erratic gait especially of the hindquarters.
Paralysis does not occur. Affected lambs are often unable to nurse the ewe because
they cannot hold onto the teat. They appear languid and lie around listlessly. They
do not suck as they should and bloat continuously, and the ewes' udders become engorged
with milk.
Behavioral and visual defects with circling, head-pressing, nystagmus, and gross incoordination
are seen in lambs with the type of infection producing hydranencephaly and cerebellar
dysplasia. These lambs are of lighter birth weight but have normal birth coats.
Growth Rate
Growth rate is reduced, affected lambs are unthrifty, and the majority will die before
or at weaning time from parasitism, pneumonia, a mucosal disease-like syndrome, or
nephritis. With good nursing care, they can be reared, but deaths may occur at any
age. Puberty may be delayed and, in males, the testes are flabby and may not develop
normally. A study of lambs in a Spanish feedlot found that BDV-positive lambs (by
RT-PCR or ELISA) were 12% (3.3 kg) lighter after 41 days of lot feeding because of
significantly lower average daily gain, 260 g per head per day compared with 320 g
per head per day in BDV-negative lambs.
5
BDV-positive lambs also had double the chance of having diarrhea or respiratory signs.
Reproductive Performance
Impaired reproductive performance of the flock occurs from low fertility, abortion,
and poor viability of lambs. Abortions usually are not noticed until lambing when
it is evidenced by an unexpected increase in barren ewes. In goats, where there is
often closer observation, the aborted fetuses may be reasonably well developed, small
and underdeveloped, or autolyzed and unrecognizable as a fetus in expelled fetal fluid.
Clinical Pathology
There are no consistent changes in hematology or blood chemistry. Persistently infected
lambs have changes in lymphocyte subpopulations, with a reduction in T lymphocytes
and an altered CD8:CD4 ratio.
Virus can be detected in blood and tissues by virus isolation, antigen ELISAs, and
RT-PCR techniques (both conventional and real time). These are specialist techniques,
but an RT-PCR ELISA may be a cost-effective and sensitive alternative for nonspecialist
laboratories.
6
Antibody can be detected by antibody ELISAs or SN tests, and a combination of serology
and virus isolation is usually used in the diagnosis of border disease.
Detection of Persistently Infected Sheep
For diagnosis of border disease in newborn lambs, precolostral blood samples should
be taken from both clinically normal and affected lambs. Persistently infected sheep
are seronegative and BDV can be isolated from leukocytes in the blood buffy coat.
Lambs infected late in gestation will be seropositive but virus negative. Persistently
infected lambs that have received colostrum from their dam will be seropositive until
they lose maternal passive immunity.
Persistently infected adolescent and adult sheep in a flock can be identified by the
detection of virus in blood; however, this is expensive in large flocks and an alternative
is to test all sheep for antibody and then culture the buffy coat of seronegative
sheep. Antigenic differences between laboratory strains and field virus can result
in false-negative serology, and serologic studies are best done with the homologous
virus.
Abortion
Serologic tests are of limited value as an aid to the diagnosis of abortion associated
with BDV infection. The infection of the ewe that results in abortion occurs several
weeks before clinical disease is apparent, and unless prospective samples can be taken
there is little chance of a rise in antibody titers in paired samples. Seropositivity
in ewes indicates that the flock has been exposed to pestivirus but does not incriminate
it in a disease process. Seronegativity indicates that BDV is not the cause of the
abortion, with the exception that aborting ewes, who themselves are persistently infected,
will have no antibody titer.
Necropsy Findings
Gross findings may be normal, or may include an abnormal wool coat and a reduction
in the size of the brain and spinal cord. Arthrogryposis, hydranencephaly, porencephaly,
and cerebellar dysplasia may also be present. Histologically, there is a deficiency
of stainable central myelin, with neurochemical and histochemical evidence of demyelination
or myelin dysmorphogenesis. In most sheep the myelin defect resolves substantially
during the first few months of life. The brain, which has been very small, returns
to normal weight, and chemical composition and degree of myelination. The histologic
lesions of the skin consist of primary follicle enlargement, increased primary fiber
size, and an increased number of medullated primary fibers.
Virus can be demonstrated by immunofluorescent staining of cryostat sections of tissues
from affected lambs or by IHC staining of formalin-fixed material. Preferred tissues
for such tests include brain, thyroid gland, and skin. Virus titers reach high levels
in the placentomes, so caruncles or cotyledons should be cultured for virus. Isolates
are noncytopathic and the presence of viral antigens must be demonstrated by direct
or indirect immunofluorescence or immune peroxidase techniques.
Because of the closely related character of this pestivirus and BVDV, diagnostic tests
to confirm infection parallel those for BVDV. Fetal serology can be useful for confirming
exposure in abortions and stillbirths. PCR and ELISA techniques may be substituted
for virus isolation if available.
In the brain of naturally infected cases, viral antigens and RNA are found in the
neuropil, glial, and neuronal cells, especially in periventricular areas, cerebellum,
and brainstem.
7
Cell death occurs in both BDV-infected and adjacent cells by the activation of pathways
that cause apoptosis, which are associated with the increased expression of nitric
oxide synthases.8, 9
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: formalin-fixed skin, spinal cord, half of midsagittally sectioned brain,
skin, thyroid, distal ileum, colon, cecum, thymus, spleen, liver, heart, kidney (LM,
IHC)
•
Serology: heart blood serum/thoracic fluid (virus neutralization)
•
Virology: placenta/caruncle, thymus, lymph node, spleen, thyroid, brain, ileum (ISO,
FAT, ELISA, PCR).
Differential Diagnosis
Congenital disease
•
Swayback (copper deficiency)
•
Caprine encephalomyelitis
Abortion
•
Enzootic abortion
•
Listeriosis
•
Toxoplasmosis
•
Leptospirosis
•
Rift Valley fever
•
Akabane disease
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no specific treatment for border disease. With care and nursing, many affected
lambs will survive the immediate neonatal period, but they grow poorly, are very susceptible
to intercurrent disease during the growing period, and it is generally not economic
to attempt to raise these lambs.
Control
The principles are to attempt to engender flock immunity and to avoid exposing sheep
to infection in early pregnancy. Persistently infected sheep are a continuous source
of infection and those that survive to breeding age can perpetuate the disease. They
should be identified and culled.
The problem is with their identification, because some persistently infected lambs
show no clinical or phenotypic abnormality. Lambs that are clinically affected at
birth should be permanently identified because the tremor and fleece abnormality disappear
at 1 to 2 months of age and the lambs may no longer be recognizable as infected. Persistently
infected animals can be identified by serologic screening of the ewe lambs intended
for replacement stock at 6 months of age (after maternal passive immunity has waned),
followed by virus isolation in seronegative animals, but this is expensive and only
practical in small flocks. An alternative is to keep no replacement ewes from an affected
lamb crop.
Persistently infected sheep can be run with the flock when it is not pregnant, particularly
with the replacement ewes, in an attempt to produce infection and immunity before
pregnancy. They should be removed before breeding. Although this can result in “natural
vaccination,” the rates of infection and seroconversion in replacement females can
be low. In theory, cattle BVDV vaccines could be used to produce immunity but their
efficacy would depend on a significant relatedness to the BDV under consideration.
In most flocks a serious outbreak of the disease is followed by minor disease in subsequent
years, with the flock developing immunity in the initial outbreak.
In flocks that are free of infection, replacement ewes and rams should be screened
for infection before purchase or quarantined after arrival on the farm. Newly introduced
sheep should be kept separate from the main flock until after lambing. Ideally, cattle
should not be pastured or housed with pregnant sheep.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Border disease (hairy shaker disease of lambs, hairy shakers, hypomyelinogenesis congenita)
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Diseases of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1414
1418
References
1
Strong
R
Vet Microbiol
141
2010
208
19781869
2
Dubois
E
Vet Microbiol
130
2008
69
18299176
3
Marco
I
Res Vet Sci
87
2009
149
19084245
4
Braun
U
Vet Microbiol
168
2015
98
5
González
JM
Vet Rec
174
2014
69
6
Dubey
P
J Virol Methods
213
2015
50
25486086
7
Toplu
N
Vet Pathol
48
2011
576
20460448
8
Dincel
GC
Kul
O
PLoS ONE
10
2015
e0120005
25799514
9
Dincel
GC
Kul
O
Histol Histopathol
30
2015
1233
25882134
Visna
Synopsis
Etiology Neurovirulent strains of maedi-visna virus, a lentivirus.
Epidemiology Occurs in association with maedi but endemic visna only recorded in Iceland.
Clinical findings Afebrile disease with insidious onset. Progressive ataxia and wasting,
long clinical course.
Clinical pathology Pleocytosis and elevated protein, virus, virus proteins, and antivirus
antibody in cerebrospinal fluid.
Lesions Chronic demyelinating encephalomyelitis.
Diagnostic confirmation Histology, demonstration of virus, PCR.
Treatment None.
Control As for ovine progressive pneumonia.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Visna is the neurologic manifestation of maedi-visna disease caused by infection with
Maedi-Visna Virus (MVV). This virus is a single-stranded RNA, nononcogenic lentivirus
within the retrovirus family. There are neurovirulent and nonneurovirulent strains
of MVV, and neurovirulence is enhanced by intracerebral passage of virus. There is
a high degree of relatedness between MVV, the ovine lentivirus associated with ovine
progressive pneumonia (OPP), and the Caprine Arthritis Encephalitis (CAE) virus. These
ovine and caprine lentiviruses share nucleotide homology and serologic properties
and are now regarded as a viral continuum and referred to as small ruminant lentiviruses
(SRLV).
1
Visna usually occurs in conjunction with maedi lesions in the lungs, with up to 18%
of sheep affected by maedi having histologic lesions of visna in the brain.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Visna is a disease of sheep and rarely of goats. It was originally a significant cause
of death in the epizootic of maedi-visna that occurred in Iceland from 1933 to 1965.
It always occurred in association with maedi, but was sporadic and generally less
important than the pulmonary manifestation of the infection. The exception was in
some flocks in which it was the major manifestation of the maedi-visna disease complex,
but visna not been seen in Iceland since 1951 and maedi-visna has since been eradicated
from that country.
Despite the widespread occurrence of maedi-visna or OPP in many countries, visna is
now an uncommon disease, and a high prevalence of neurologic disease has seldom been
recorded in countries other than Iceland. The reason for this is not known but might
be from an increased susceptibility of the Icelandic breed of sheep to the neurologic
form of the disease, or to differences in the neurovirulence of different strains
of the virus. In Britain, MVV was first detected in the late 1970s, and the initial
clinical expression was largely maedi (dyspnea), but occasionally with coexistent
visna.
Experimental Transmission
Sheep experimentally infected by intracerebral inoculation spread MVV to commingled
sheep. The incubation period and the course of the disease are both protracted, with
clinical signs not appearing until 2 years after experimental inoculation.
Pathogenesis
The virus infects cells of the monocyte–macrophage lineage and replicates its RNA
genome via a DNA intermediate provirus, which is integrated into the chromosomal DNA
of the host cell. Replication is limited and does not proceed beyond the synthesis
of provirus in most cells. Persistent production of viral antigen results in lymphocytic
hyperplasia.
There are two basic lesions, an inflammatory lesion that is not related to the occurrence
of nervous signs, and a focal demyelination in the brain and spinal cord, the occurrence
of which is related to the appearance of paresis. Experimental immunosuppression reduces
the severity of lesions by suppressing the cellular proliferative response without
suppressing the growth of the virus, whereas postinfection immunization enhances the
severity of experimental visna. Viral nucleic acid and proteins are present in oligodendrocytes,
and demyelination is thought to be a direct effect of the virus on these cells as
well as a sequel to the inflammatory response they provoke.
Clinical Findings
The disease has an insidious onset, and the early clinical signs include lagging behind
the flock because of ataxia and body wasting. The body wasting and the hindlimb ataxia
are progressive. Affected animals show hypermetria and may stumble or fall as they
traverse uneven ground or when making sudden turns. There is no fever, and a normal
appetite and consciousness are retained. Additional signs include severe tremor of
the facial muscles and knuckling of the distal limbs so that the animal stands on
the flexed tarsi. Some animals may show a head tilt, aimless wandering, circling,
and blindness.
2
The clinical picture is not unlike that of scrapie without the pruritus. During the
course of the disease, periods of relative normality may occur. Affected animals may
show clinical signs for several months before final paralysis necessitates slaughter.
The disease is always fatal, and the clinical syndrome in goats is the same as for
sheep.
Clinical Pathology
There are an increased number of mononuclear cells in the CSF, an elevated protein,
and positive Pandy test. The pleocytosis is variable during the course of the disease.
Virus, virus antigen, and antibody are also demonstrable in CSF. Serologic tests are
detailed under the section on ovine progressive pneumonia in chapter 12.
Necropsy Findings
Muscle wasting and an interstitial pneumonia may be visible but there are no gross
changes in the CNS. The characteristic histologic lesion is patchy, demyelinating
encephalomyelitis. The inflammatory infiltrate is predominantly composed of lymphocytes
and macrophages. Demyelination occurs in the white matter of the cerebrum and cerebellum,
and in the spinal cord. The histologic character of the lung is typical of ovine lentivirus-associated
pneumonia. Isolation of the virus is difficult. Typical neural lesions and a positive
serologic titer usually suffice for confirmation of the diagnosis. IHC tests and PCR-based
assays have been successfully used to confirm this lentiviral infection in lung, mammary
gland, and even third eyelid, but the use of these tests to confirm of the infection
in CNS tissues is not well documented.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: fixed spinal cord, half of midsagittally sectioned brain, lung, mammary
gland, joint synovium (IHC, LM)
•
Serology: serum (Agar gel immunodiffusion test, ELISA)
•
Virology: chilled brain, spinal cord, lung, mammary gland (PCR, ISO).
Differential Diagnosis
Visna is a sporadic disease of mature sheep with an insidious onset of muscle wasting,
progressive ataxia, and a long clinical course. These characteristics differentiate
it from other diseases of sheep manifest with ataxia.
Differentials include
•
Scrapie
•
Delayed organophosphate toxicity
•
Cerebrospinal nematodiasis
•
Segmental axonopathy (Murrurrundi disease)
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment and Control
There is no treatment for visna. It usually occurs in conjunction with signs of maedi
and is a comparatively rare disease by itself. Control procedures are as for those
suggested for OPP/maedi. It is possible to greatly reduce the prevalence, and even
eradicate the disease, by either (1) testing all sheep with an ELISA and removing
seropositive sheep from the flock, or (2) by removal of lambs at birth and rearing
them in isolation from other sheep. Testing all sheep at shorter intervals (3–6 months)
with a combination of serology and PCR tests can reduce the prevalence more rapidly
but is more costly.
Many jurisdictions have developed accreditation programs for flocks to establish that
they have a low risk of infection with MVV. Once flocks are seronegative they are
subjected to testing at various intervals, typically 1 to 3 years depending on an
assessment of the biosecurity risk and the presence of untested sheep on the same
farm holding.
There is currently no effective vaccine against MVV, and in some cases candidate vaccines
have enhanced viremia and/or the immune-mediated pathology of the disease.
3
The difficulty in developing effective vaccines is common among the lentiviruses,
with various approaches including attenuated vaccines, vector vaccines, and proviral
DNA vaccines having little success.
Marker-assisted genetic selection, to identify those sheep less susceptible to infection
with MVV, has the potential to supplement existing control measures. For example,
in a trial involving 187 lambs, the probability of infection following natural exposure
to OPP virus (a related virus that is part of the SRLV continuum) was 3.6 times greater
in crossbred lambs with susceptible or heterozygous diplotype to ovine transmembrane
protein gene 154 (TEM154 diplotype “1 3” or “3 3”) compared with lambs with diplotype
“1 1.”
4
This is an active research area and it is expected that additional markers will be
identified with future investigations.
Further Reading
Blacklaws
B
Small ruminant lentiviruses: immunopathogenesis of visna-maedi and caprine arthritis
and encephalitis virus
Comp Immunol Infect Dis
35
2012
259
269
Radostits
O
Visna
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Diseases of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1413
1414
References
1
Le Roux
C
Curr HIV Res
8
2010
94
20210785
2
Christodouloplous
G
Small Rumin Res
62
2006
47
3
Blacklaws
B
Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis
35
2012
259
22237012
4
Leymaster
KA
J Anim Sci
91
2013
5114
23989875
Caprine Arthritis Encephalitis
Synopsis
Etiology Retrovirus (a small ruminant lentivirus).
Epidemiology Persistent infection with perinatal and horizontal spread. Management
of herd influences extent of seropositivity.
Clinical findings This disease of goats is characterized by arthritis, especially
of the carpal joints (big knee), in mature goats, and acute leukoencephalomyelitis
in young goats. Indurative mastitis, and less commonly chronic pneumonia and chronic
encephalomyelitis, occur in older goats.
Clinical pathology Increased mononuclear cell count in cerebrospinal fluid. Lower
or inverted CD4:CD8 ratio in peripheral blood.
Lesions Chronic polysynovitis, degenerative joint disease in adults. Nonsuppurative
demyelinating encephalomyelitis. Interstitial pneumonia.
Diagnostic confirmation Microscopic lesions and agar gel immunodiffusion test.
Treatment None.
Control Segregation of the newborn from seropositive animals, and feeding of virus-free
colostrum and milk. Prevention of horizontal transmission. Regular testing with segregation
or culling.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Caprine arthritis encephalitis (CAE), maedi-visna, and Ovine Progressive Pneumonia
(OPP) viruses are single-stranded RNA, nononcogenic lentiviruses within the retrovirus
family. They have a tropism for monocytes, macrophages, and dendritic cells, but not
T lymphocytes. This is an important determinant of their pathogenesis because they
induce a persistent infection that can cause lymphoproliferative changes in the lung,
mammary tissues, brain, and joints. There is a high degree of relatedness between
these lentiviruses, with shared nucleotide homology and serologic properties. Consequently,
CAE, maedi-visna, and OPP viruses are now regarded as a viral continuum known as SRLV.
1
There are genetically distinct isolates of CAE virus and they may differ in virulence.
Because of the nature of the virus, recombination during replication, hence antigenic
drift, is common and may facilitate persistence of the virus in the host and the development
of disease. Based on analysis of gag and pol genomic regions, SRLVs have been placed
into five clusters (A to E), with A and B further divided into at least 13 and 3 subtypes,
respectively. Some of these are geographically restricted, such as cluster C in Norway,
whereas others appear more dispersed, probably reflecting the active trading of animals.
In Canada, molecular analysis of goat and sheep isolates of SRLV from herds or flocks
with only sheep or goats reveals a relatively simple arrangement, with goats infected
with B1 subtype and sheep with A2 subtype, respectively. However, on farms with both
goats and sheep, there is evidence of crossover between sheep and goats, and vice
versa, and mixed infections in both species.
2
Consequently, mixed flocks of goats and sheep may represent an active source for the
evolution of these viruses, with a CAE-like virus responsible for severe outbreaks
of arthritis in sheep in Spain and mixed infections confirmed in many European countries
and North America.2, 3, 4
Epidemiology
Geographic Occurrence
There is serologic evidence of infection in most areas of the world, including Europe,
the UK, North America, Africa, Arabia, Australia, New Zealand, and South America.
Although there is sampling bias, one study found marked differences in prevalence
between countries, with a lower prevalence in developing countries that did not import
dairy-type goats from North America or Europe. This may also reflect the absence of
management factors that have a high risk of propagating infection in some countries,
such as the pooling of colostrum. Other countries, such as New Zealand, have a low
prevalence with the occurrence of CAE mainly in exotic importations.
There may also be variation in seroprevalence within countries. For example, in the
United States, the prevalence of infection in goats in the western and middle parts
of the country is approximately 50% of all goats tested, which is about twice that
in the eastern and Rocky Mountain areas. Herd seroprevalence is greater than 60% in
all regions. The seroprevalence within herds shows clustering, with most herds falling
into either high or low seroprevalence groups. There are area differences in age prevalence
of seropositivity, with some surveys showing no difference and others showing an increasing
prevalence with increasing age.
Clinical disease is much less common than infection, and the annual incidence of disease
in heavily infected flocks is usually low and approximates 10%.
Host Risk Factors
Breeds
All breeds are susceptible to infection but several studies have recorded apparent
differences in breed susceptibility, which may reflect differences in management practices
such as feeding practices of colostrum and milk, or genetic differences in susceptibility.
There is often a higher prevalence of seropositive goats in family-owned farms compared
with institutional herds, which might reflect a greater movement of goats or comingling
with other herds among the former.
Housed Rocky Mountain goats (Oreamnos americanus) have developed clinical disease
attributed to infection with CAE virus, including interstitial pneumonia and synovial
changes. Three of four affected goats had been fed raw goat milk from a source later
found to have CAE virus.
5
Age
There is no age difference in susceptibility to experimental infection. Some herds
show similar seroprevalence across age groups, whereas others show an increasing seroprevalence
with increasing age. These differences probably reflect differences in management
between herds and differences in the relative importance of the mechanisms of transmission
between herds. Increasing prevalence with age reflects management systems that increase
the risk of acquiring infection from horizontal transmission. Leukoencephalomyelitis
occurs predominantly in young kids and arthritis in older goats.
Method of Transmission
More than 75% of kids born to infected dams may acquire infection, which can be potentially
transmitted to them by several routes. Infection can also occur in older goats.
Colostrum and Milk
Observation of the natural disease and experimental studies indicate that the primary
mode of transmission is through the colostrum and milk. The presence of antibody in
colostrum does not prevent infection. The virus can be isolated both from the cells
in the milk and from cell-free milk from infected dams. Kids born of noninfected dams,
but fed colostrum and/or milk from infected dams, can become infected. A single feeding
of infected milk can be sufficient to infect a kid. Conversely, the risk of infection
is much lower in kids that are removed from the doe immediately after birth and reared
on pasteurized milk, and many can be reared free from infection.
Other Perinatal Transmission
Intrauterine infection can occur, but appears to be infrequent and not of major significance
in the control of the disease. The disease can be transmitted by contact both during
and following the perinatal period, and perinatal transmission is most important in
the epidemiology of the disease. Perinatal transmission can result from contact with
vaginal secretions, blood, saliva, or respiratory secretions, with the relative importance
of these not clearly known.
Contact Transmission
Horizontal transmission occurs at all ages, and older goats can be infected by oral
challenge with virus. Contact transmission will result in the spread of the disease
when an infected animal is introduced into an infection-free herd and has been one
cause of spread in countries in which the infection has been introduced with imported
animals.
Prolonged comingling of uninfected with infected animals is likely to promote horizontal
transmission.
Other Routes
Milk contains virus-free and virus-infected cells and shared milking facilities increase
the risk of cross-infection. This possibly results from the transfer of infected cells
in milk during the milking process. Both iatrogenic and venereal transmissions are
possible but are probably of limited significance.
Experimental Reproduction
Arthritis and mastitis have been reproduced by oral, intravenous, and intraarticular
challenge with CAE virus, although pneumonia is often not a feature of the experimental
disease. Leukoencephalomyelitis in young lambs can be reproduced by intracerebral
challenge, but this form of the disease has not been reproduced by more natural challenge
routes. Strains of the virus can be neuroadapted by passage and show increased neurovirulence
but not neuroinvasiveness, suggesting that these are separate characteristics.
The relatedness between caprine and the ovine lentiviruses was first evident with
experimental infections, with the CAE-type virus transferred to lambs by feeding them
infected colostrum. This experimental infection was followed by viremia and seroconversion,
but some strains of the virus produced no clinical or histopathologic evidence of
disease. Goat kids have been similarly infected with the maedi virus. The arthritic
form of the disease has been produced experimentally in cesarean-derived kids injected
with virus isolated from the joints of infected goats.
Economic Importance
There is a high prevalence of infection in many countries, and several have opted
for national or breed-associated control programs. There is a higher cull rate in
infected herds, with as many as 5% to 10% of goats culled each year for arthritis,
and affected animals cannot be entered for show. Seropositive herds have a higher
incidence of disease.
There are conflicting reports on the effect of infection on productivity in goat herds,
but seropositive goats can have significantly lower milk production (around 10%),
a reduced length of lactation, lower 300-day yields of milk, and impaired reproductive
performance compared with seronegative goats.
Pathogenesis
Animals infected at birth remain persistently infected for life, although only a proportion,
typically from 10% to 30%, will develop clinical disease. The virus persistently infects
some cells of the monocyte–macrophage type, and the expression and shedding of virus
occurs as infected monocytes mature to macrophages.
1
Disease is associated with the host's immune response to the expressed virus. The
development of neutralizing antibody does not arrest viral replication because of
ongoing expression of antigenic variants of the virus with differing type-specific
neutralization epitopes. However, the immune complexes are thought to be the basis
for the chronic inflammatory changes in tissues. Goats vaccinated with CAE virus develop
more severe clinical disease following challenge compared with nonvaccinated controls.
The lesions are lymphoproliferative and followed by a multisystem disease syndrome.
This primarily involves synovial-lined connective tissue, causing chronic arthritis,
in the udder, causing swelling and hardening of the glands (with or without mastitis),
and in the lungs causing a chronic interstitial pneumonia.
A retrovirus infection, detected by electron microscopy and the presence of RT activity,
is suspected as the cause of an immunodeficiency syndrome in llamas characterized
by failure to thrive, anemia, leukopenia, and recurrent infection, but this has not
been reported since 1992.
Clinical Findings
Joints
Arthritis occurs predominantly in adult goats and is a chronic hyperplastic synovitis,
which is usually noticeable only in the carpal joints. This gives rise to the lay
term of big knee, although tarsal joints may also be affected. The onset may be insidious
or sudden, and unilateral or bilateral. Goats may be lame in the affected leg, but
this is usually not severe. Affected goats may live a normal life span but some gradually
lose weight, develop poor hair coats, and eventually remain recumbent most of the
time and develop decubitus ulcers. Dilatation of the atlantal and supraspinous bursae
occurs in some cases. The course of the disease may last several months. The arthritis
may be accompanied by enlargement and hardening of the udder and by interstitial pneumonia,
although this may be clinically inapparent. There can be herd and area differences
in the clinical expression of the disease. For example, in some outbreaks in Australia
pneumonia, rather than arthritis, has been the predominant clinical sign.
Radiographically, there are soft tissue swellings in the early stages and calcification
of periarticular tissues and osteophyte production in the later stages. Quantitative
joint scintigraphy provides an accurate noninvasive method for assessing the severity
of the arthritis in a live animal.
Brain
Leukoencephalitis occurs primarily in 1- to 5-month-old kids. The syndrome is characterized
by unilateral or bilateral posterior paresis and ataxia. In the early stages, the
gait is short and choppy, followed by weakness and eventually recumbency. In animals
that can still stand, there may be a marked lack of proprioception in the hindlimbs
(Fig. 14-4
). Brain involvement is manifested by head tilt, torticollis, and circling. Affected
kids are bright and alert and drink normally. Kids with unilateral posterior paresis
usually progress to bilateral posterior paresis in 5 to 10 days. The paresis usually
extends to involve the forelimbs, so that tetraparesis follows, and most kids are
euthanized. The interstitial pneumonia that often accompanies the nervous form of
the disease is usually not severe and not clinically obvious.
Fig. 14-4
A 3-month-old Toggenburg kid with advanced progressive neurologic signs caused by
infection with caprine arthritis encephalitis virus. The goat has normal mentation
but is exhibits asymmetric weakness (hindlimbs worse than forelimbs) and proprioceptive
abnormalities.
Fig. 14-4
Udder
Indurative mastitis, or hard bag, is often initially detected a few days after kidding.
The udder is firm and hard but no milk can be expressed. There is no systemic illness
and no bacterial mastitis. Recovery is never complete but there may be some gradual
improvement.
Clinical Pathology
The synovial fluid from affected joints is usually brown to red-tinged, and the cell
count is increased up to 20,000 µL with 90% mononuclear cells. The CSF may contain
an increased mononuclear cell count. There is a reduction in monocytes in peripheral
blood, a decrease in the number of CD4+ lymphocytes, and a lower or inverted CD4:CD8
ratio.
Serologic Testing
For the live animal, there are a number of test systems available whose sensitivity
and specificity varies. The agar gel immunodiffusion test (AGID) and a variety of
commercial ELISA tests are the most widely used, and the latter usually has a higher
sensitivity and specificity. Differences in the performance of the ELISA tests may
be related to the peptides they use and the types of SRLV present.
6
Maternal antibody is lost by approximately 3 months of age, hence a seropositive test
in a goat older than 6 months is considered evidence of infection. Most animals have
a persistent antibody response and remain seropositive for life, although some infected
goats may become seronegative over time.
A negative test does not rule out the possibility of infection because there may be
a considerable delay between infection and the production of detectable antibody.
It is possible that in some infected goats there is insufficient virus expression
to lead to an antibody response.
A competitive-inhibition ELISA, which detects antibody to the surface envelop of the
virus, has very high sensitivity and specificity and may be more useful in determining
the status of individual animals, such as before the movement of goats. Other tests
with potentially greater sensitivity and/or specificity are described, but are not
generally available. For example, serum adenosine deaminase activity is used as a
biochemical marker of HIV infection in humans, and is elevated in goats infected with
CAE, but is not a routinely available veterinary test.
7
Other Tests
A more cost-effective way of monitoring CAE in dairy goats may be testing the bulk
tank milk. In Norwegian dairy flocks, an ELISA for testing bulk tank milk detected
a within-herd prevalence of CAE of at least 2%, with a sensitivity of 73% and specificity
of 87%.
8
Identification of the presence of CAE is usually provided by isolation of the virus
from tissue explants into tissue culture. PCR can be used to detect the presence of
viral antigen or proviral DNA. Most primers for diagnostic purposes are selected to
detect the broadest possible range of SRLV strains, whereas those selected for research
purposes may take a type-specific approach.
2
A rapid detection assay based on LAMP has been developed for detecting CAEV proviral
DNA in whole blood and whole-blood samples and separated mononuclear cells.
9
This assay can be performed in less well-equipped laboratories as well as in the field.
Necropsy Findings
In the arthritic form of CAE, there is emaciation and chronic polysynovitis, with
degenerative joint disease affecting most of the joints of animals submitted for necropsy.
Periarticular tissues are thickened and firm and there is hyperplasia of the synovium.
The local lymph nodes are grossly enlarged and a diffuse interstitial pneumonia is
usually present. Mammary glands are frequently involved, although gross changes are
restricted to induration and increased texture. Microscopically, lymphoplasmacytic
infiltrates of the interstitial tissues of mammary gland, lung, and synovium are characteristic.
In the neural form the diagnostic lesions are in the nervous system and involve the
white matter, especially of the cervical spinal cord and sometimes the cerebellum
and the brainstem. The lesion is a bilateral, nonsuppurative demyelinating encephalomyelitis.
The infiltrating mononuclear leukocytes tend to be more numerous in the periventricular
and subpial areas. There is usually also a mild, diffuse, interstitial pneumonia in
this form of the disease. In some cases, a severe lymphoplasmacytic interstitial pneumonia
with extensive hyperplasia of type II pneumocytes can occur in the absence of neurologic
disease.
Culture of the virus is difficult but can be attempted. A variety of nucleic acid
recognition tests, including in situ hybridization, PCR, and IHC, have been developed.
For most cases, confirmation of the diagnosis is based on the characteristic microscopic
lesions, preferably supported by antemortem serology.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: formalin-fixed lung, bronchial lymph node, mammary gland, synovial membranes,
half of midsagittally sectioned brain, spinal cord (LM, IHC)
•
Serology: blood (ELISA, AGID, PCR)
•
Virology: lung, synovial membrane, mammary gland, hindbrain (PCR, virus isolation).
Differential Diagnosis
The differential diagnosis of the arthritic form of the disease includes the other
infectious arthritides, such as those associated with mycoplasma and chlamydia.
Leukoencephalitis must be differentiated from:
•
Swayback caused by copper deficiency
•
Spinal abscess
•
Cerebrospinal nematodiasis
•
Listeriosis
•
Polioencephalomalacia
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no treatment likely to be of value for any form of CAE.
Control
A measure of control can be achieved by testing the herd every 6 months, and segregating
or culling of seropositive animals. More complete control is dependent on preventing/minimizing
perinatal transmission of infection to the kid, particularly colostrum and milk transmission,
coupled with identifying infected animals and maintaining them physically separated
from the noninfected animals or culling them from the herd.
Because of the evidence of transmission of SRLV between sheep and goats, the presence
of each species needs to be considered when developing control programs for CAE of
goats or OPP of sheep.
Prevention of Perinatal Transmission
Early recommendations for control concentrated on reducing transmission via milk and
colostrum, but it is now recognized that this must be coupled with segregation. Newborn
kids should be removed from the dam immediately at birth. There should be no contact
with the dam, and fetal fluids and debris should be rinsed off the coat. Heat-treated
goat colostrum or cow colostrum should be fed, followed by pasteurized milk or a commercial
milk replacer. The kid should be segregated from the doe and other infected animals.
In herds that feed pasteurized colostrum and milk there is a significant difference
in subsequent seroconversions between those that segregate the kids at birth and for
rearing and those that do not.
Test and Segregate/Cull
Animals over 3 months of age should be tested by ELISA or AGID every 6 months, and
seropositive animals segregated or (preferably) culled from the herd. The interval
between infection and seroconversion varies between goats, and the optimal interval
for testing has not been determined. More frequent testing may be needed for large
herds with a high seroprevalence. Segregation of seropositive and seronegative goats
is essential because horizontal spread in adult goats is important in maintaining
and increasing infection rates in some herds, and even a brief contact time can allow
transmission. Where culling is not practiced, seropositive goats should be milked
after seronegative ones, and the use of common equipment, such as for ear-tagging,
tattooing, and vaccinating, should be avoided.
Several countries have programs for herd accreditation of freedom from infection.
The stringency of these schemes varies, and they may be governmental or breed society
accreditation programs. Typically, they require that all adults in the herd test negative
on two herd tests at a 6-month interval. There are also restrictions on the movement
and purchase of animals, and periodic serologic surveillance. For example, a scheme
in Norway has been quite successful, with only 5 of 406 flocks (1.2%) being reinfected
over a 10-year period.
8
Vaccination and Genetic Selection
There is currently no effective vaccine against the SRLVs, including CAE, maedi-visna,
or OPP viruses, and in some cases candidate vaccines have enhanced viremia and/or
the immune-mediated pathology of the disease.
1
The difficulty in developing effective vaccines is common among the lentiviruses,
with various approaches, including attenuated vaccines, vector vaccines, and proviral
DNA vaccines having little success. The reasons are obscure, but probably relate to
the underlying dysfunction in T-cell–mediated immune responses.
However, marker-assisted genetic selection, to identify animals less susceptible to
infection, has the potential to supplement existing control measures. For example,
in a trial investigating the control of OPP in lambs, the probability of infection
following natural exposure to OPP virus was 3.6 times greater in crossbred lambs with
susceptible or heterozygous diplotype to ovine transmembrane protein gene 154 (TEM154
diplotype 1 3 or 3 3) compared with lambs with diplotype 1 1.
10
Similar studies have not yet been undertaken in goats, but this is an active research
area and it is expected that additional markers for conditions caused by SRLV will
be identified in future.
Further Reading
Blacklaws
B
Small ruminant lentiviruses: immunopathogenesis of visna-maedi and caprine arthritis
and encephalitis virus
Comp Immunol Infect Dis
35
2012
259
269
Hermann-Hoesing
LM
Diagnostic assays used to control small ruminant lentiviruses
J Vet Diagnost Invest
22
2010
843
855
Radostits
O
Caprine arthritis encephalitis (CAE)
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Diseases of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1410
1413
References
1
Blacklaws
B
Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis
35
2012
259
22237012
2
Fras
M
Infect Genet Evol
19
2013
97
23811153
3
Glaria
I
Vet Microbiol
138
2009
156
19339126
4
Gjerset
B
Virus Res
125
2007
153
17240470
5
Patton
KM
Vet Diagn Invest
24
2012
392
6
de Andrés
X
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
152
2013
277
23375019
7
Rodrigues
LF
Small Rumin Res
108
2012
120
8
Nagel-Alne
GE
Vet Rec
176
2015
173
25344573
9
Huang
J
Arch Virol
157
2012
1463
22566005
10
Leymaster
KA
J Anim Sci
91
2013
5114
23989875
Ovine Encephalomyelitis (Louping-Ill)
Synopsis
Etiology Louping-ill virus, flavivirus.
Epidemiology Disease of sheep (and red grouse), and occasionally other domestic animals
and man, transmitted by Ixodes ricinus. Occurs predominantly in lambs and yearling
sheep in Great Britain and Europe in the spring, associated with tick rise.
Clinical findings Fever, neurologic dysfunction, muscle tremor, incoordination, bounding
gait. Recovery or convulsions and death.
Lesions Nonsuppurative encephalitis.
Diagnostic confirmation Serology, demonstration of virus.
Control Vaccination, tick control.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Louping-ill virus belongs to the genus Flavivirus, which is divided into eight groups,
one of which is the tick-borne encephalitis group. Louping-ill is antigenically related
to the tick-borne encephalitis viruses. The latter circulate in Europe and Asia and
are a serious zoonotic disease for humans, but do not infect sheep.
1
Louping-ill virus occurs in Great Britain, Ireland and Norway, but similar disease
occurs elsewhere and there is antigenic diversity between isolates from different
geographic areas. Viruses that are closely related to louping-ill virus, and that
cause very similar disease but in different regions of the world, include Russian
spring-summer encephalitis, Turkish sheep encephalitis, Spanish sheep encephalitis,
Spanish goat encephalitis,
2
and Greek goat encephalitis viruses. In sheep, concurrent infection with the agent
of tick-borne fever Ehrlichia (Cytoecetes) phagocytophila enhances the pathogenicity
of the virus.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Geographic Occurrence
Louping-ill was originally considered to be restricted to the border counties of Scotland
and England but is now recognized as also occurring in upland grazing areas of Scotland,
in Ireland, southwest England, and in Norway; related viruses and diseases occur in
Spain, Bulgaria, Greece, and Turkey. The distribution of the disease is regulated
by the occurrence of the vector tick Ixodes ricinus, which requires suitable hosts
and a ground layer microclimate of high humidity throughout the year. In these areas,
louping-ill can be a common infection and may be a significant cause of loss.
Host Occurrence
Louping-ill virus can infect and produce disease in a wide variety of vertebrates
including man, but predominantly sheep are affected because of their susceptibility
and the fact that they are the main domestic animal species that graze the tick-infested
areas. Nonruminant species, such as alpaca and horses, and wild ungulates such as
chamois,
3
have also been infected.
Although sheep (and red grouse) are the only animals that commonly develop clinical
disease, I. ricinus feeds on a number of different hosts and the adult tick requires
a large mammalian host. As a consequence, seropositivity and occasional clinical disease
occur in all other domestic species, especially goat kids, but also cattle, horses,
alpaca,
4
pigs, and humans.
Traditionally, pigs have not been free-ranged on upland tick-infested areas, but they
are susceptible to experimental infection by all routes.
Red deer (Cervus elaphus) and roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) are hosts for the tick
in Scotland, and the elk (Alces alces) may be in Sweden. Infection in these species
is usually subclinical; however, when these animals are subjected to the stress of
captivity, clinical illness is more likely to occur. This may be important to commercial
deer farmers.
Transmission
Tick Transmission
The reservoir for the disease and the major vector is the three host tick I. ricinus,
which requires a single blood meal at each stage of development. Changes in the distribution
of the tick are probably introducing this and other tick-borne disease into previously
unaffected areas. The tick feeds for approximately 3 weeks every year and completes
its life cycle in 3 years. The larval and nymphal stages will feed on any vertebrate,
but the adult female will engorge and mate only on larger mammals. The tick becomes
infected by feeding on a viremic host and the virus translocates to the salivary gland
of the subsequent stage to provide a source of infection at feeding in the following
year. Transstadial transmission of the virus occurs, but transovarial transmission
does not; thus only the nymph and adult ticks are capable of transmitting the disease.
The tick is seasonally active at temperatures between 7°C and 18°C. Most ticks feed
in the spring, with peak activity dependent on the latitude and elevation of the pasture,
but generally occurring in April and May. In some areas there is a second period of
activity of a separate population of I. ricinus in the autumn during August and September.
Although infected ticks can transmit the infection to a large number of vertebrate
hosts, only sheep, red grouse (Lagopus scoticus), and possibly horses, attain a viremia
sufficient to infect other ticks and act as maintenance hosts. Grouse amplify the
virus, deer amplify the vector, and hares (Lepus timidus) amplify both. Infection
in red grouse is accompanied by a high mortality, and the louping-ill virus is essentially
maintained in an area by a sheep–tick cycle and hare tick cycle.
Nontick Transmission
Although the major method of spread is by the bites of infected ticks, spread by droplet
infection is of importance in man, and the infection can be transmitted in animals
by hypodermic needle contamination and other methods. The virus is not very resistant
to environmental influences and is readily destroyed by disinfectants. Pigs fed the
carcasses of sheep that had died of louping-ill become infected with the louping-ill
virus. The virus is excreted in the milk of experimentally infected female goats,
and infects sucking kids to produce an acute disease. Virus is also excreted in the
milk of ewes during the acute stages of infection but, paradoxically, does not result
in the transmission of the infection to lambs. Grouse can be infected by eating infected
ticks, and this is considered a major mechanism of infection for grouse.
Host and Environmental Risk Factors
The epidemiology of disease is dictated by the biology of the tick and so disease
is seasonal, occurring during spring when the ticks are active. The prevalence of
infection, as measured by seropositivity, is high in areas where the disease is enzootic.
In these areas, the annual incidence of disease varies but there are cases every year
and they occur predominantly in yearlings and in lambs. In enzootic areas, the majority
of adult sheep have been infected and are immune. Colostral immunity from these ewes
will protect their lambs for approximately 3 months, and these lambs are resistant
to infection during the spring rise of the ticks. Ewe lambs that are retained in the
flock are susceptible to infection at the second exposure the following spring. In
the UK there are concerns that the density and range of ticks is increasing because
of changes in climate and land management; thus the distribution of tick-borne disease
is also changing.
5
The proportion of infected animals that develop clinical disease in any year is estimated
to vary from 5% to 60% and is influenced by the intensity of the tick vector; the
immune status of the flock; the age at infection; nutritional status; and factors
such as cold stress, herding, and transport, and the occurrence of intercurrent disease.
Naive animals introduced to an enzootic area are at high risk for infection and clinical
disease.
Intercurrent infection with E. (Cytoecetes) phagocytophila and Toxoplasma gondii have
been shown to increase the severity of experimental tick-borne fever in young lambs,
but the relevance of this association to naturally occurring disease is uncertain.
It would appear that concurrent infection with louping-ill and tick-borne fever is
unlikely to occur in the field in young lambs because colostral immunity will protect
against infection with the louping-ill virus, whereas colostral immunity is not protective
against tick-borne fever. Similarly, the superinfection of Rhizomucor pusillus on
this concurrent infection has been observed in experimental conditions, but is not
a commonly recorded observation in natural disease.
Zoonotic Implications
Louping-ill is a zoonosis. The major risk for veterinarians is with the postmortem
examination and handling of tissues from infected animals. Laboratory workers, and
shepherds and abattoir persons who handle infected sheep, are also at risk. The occurrence
of virus in the milk of goats and sheep is a risk for human disease where raw milk
is consumed.
Pathogenesis
After tick-borne infection, the virus proliferates in the regional lymph node to produce
a viremia that peaks at 2 to 4 days and declines with the development of circulating
antibody before the development of clinical disease. Invasion of the CNS occurs in
the early viremic stage in most if not all infected animals, but in most the resultant
lesions are small and isolated and there is no clinical neurologic disease. The occurrence
of clinical disease is associated with the replication of the virus in the brain,
severe inflammation throughout the CNS, and necrosis of brainstem and ventral horn
neurons. The reason for more severe disease in some animals appears to be related
to the rapidity and extent of the immune response. Animals that survive exposure to
louping-ill virus have an earlier immune response to the infection and have high concentrations
of antibody in the CSF.
In experimental studies, there is a more severe and prolonged viremia and a higher
mortality from louping-ill when there is concurrent infection with tick-borne fever.
Sheep with tick-borne fever have severe neutropenia, lymphocytopenia, defective cellular
and humoral immunologic responses, and high mortality associated with concurrent infection
with this agent is thought to be from enhanced viral replication of the louping-ill
virus. The dual infection in experimental sheep also facilitates fungal invasion and
a systemic mycotic infection with R. pusillus.
Clinical Findings
In most sheep, infection is inapparent. There is an incubation period of 2 to 4 days
followed by a sudden onset of high fever (up to 41.5°C, 107°F) for 2 to 3 days followed
by a return to normal. In animals that develop neurologic disease, there is a second
febrile phase during which nervous signs appear. Affected animals stand apart, often
with the head held high and with twitching of the lips and nostrils. There is marked
tremor of muscle groups and rigidity of the musculature, particularly in the neck
and limbs. This is manifested by jerky, stiff movements and a bounding gait, which
gives rise to the name louping-ill. Incoordination is most marked in the hindlimbs.
The sheep walks into objects and may stand with the head pressed against them. Hypersensitivity
to noise and touch may be apparent. Some animals will recover over the following days,
although there may be residual torticollis and posterior paresis. In others, the increased
muscle tone is succeeded by recumbency, convulsions, and paralysis, and death occurs
as early as 1 to 2 days later. Young lambs may die suddenly with no specific nervous
signs.
The clinical picture in cattle is very similar to that observed in sheep, with hyperesthesia,
blinking of the eyelids, and rolling of the eyes, although convulsions are more likely
to occur in cattle, and in the occasional animals that recover from the encephalitis
there is usually persistent signs of impairment of the CNS.
Horses also show a similar clinical picture to sheep, with some showing a rapidly
progressing nervous disease with a course of approximately 2 days and others a transient
disorder of locomotion with recovery in 10 to 12 days.
The infection is usually subclinical in adult goats but the virus is excreted in the
milk and kids may develop severe acute infections. In humans an influenza-like disease
followed by meningoencephalitis occurs after an incubation period of 6 to 18 days.
Although recovery is common, the disease can be fatal and residual nervous deficiencies
can occur.
Clinical Pathology
The initial viremia that occurs with infection declines with the emergence of serum
antibody and virus is no longer present in the blood at the onset of clinical signs.
Hemagglutination inhibition (HI), complement-fixing, and neutralizing antibodies can
be detected in the serum of recovered animals. HI and complement-fixing antibodies
are relatively transient, but neutralizing antibodies persist. HI IgM antibody develops
early in the disease and can be used as an aid to diagnosis in animals with clinical
disease. Analysis of CSF is usually not considered because of the zoonotic risk.
Molecular tests, including conventional and real-time RT-PCR, can target specific
viruses in this tick-borne encephalitis virus group, and a pan-flavirvirus test has
been developed.
6
Necropsy Findings
No gross changes are observed. Histologically, there are perivascular accumulations
of cells in the meninges, brain, and spinal cord, with neuronal damage most evident
in cerebellar Purkinje cells and, to a lesser extent, in the cerebral cortex. Louping-ill
virus can be demonstrated in formalin-fixed tissues by the avidin-biotin–complex immunoperoxidase
technique.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Virology: chilled brain, halved midsagitally (VI, RT-PCR)
•
Histology: fixed brain, other half (LM, IHC)
•
Molecular: CNS tissue, blood, ticks (conventional and real-time RT-PCR)
Differential Diagnosis
The disease is restricted to areas in which the vector tick occurs.
•
In lambs, the disease has clinical similarities with delayed swayback, spinal abscess,
and some cases of tick pyemia. Spinal abscess occurs shortly following a management
procedure such as docking or castration or with tick pyemia; it has a longer clinical
course, is commonly present at C7-T2, and can be established by radiographic examination.
Tick pyemia can also occur in flocks that have louping-ill, and the determination
of the contribution of each disease to flock mortality relies on clinical, epidemiologic,
and postmortem examination.
•
In yearlings, the disease has similarities to spinal ataxia caused by trauma, to gid
(Coenurus cerebralis), and to the early stages of polioencephalomalacia.
•
In adults, the disease in sheep resembles some stages of acute neurologic diseases,
including scrapie, tetanus, hypocalcemia, hypomagnesemia, pregnancy toxemia, and listeriosis.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
An antiserum has been used and is protective if given within 48 hours of exposure,
but is of no value once the febrile reaction has begun. However, it is not commercially
available. Animals with clinical disease should be sedated if necessary during the
acute course of the disease and kept in a secluded and dark area with general supportive
care.
Control
The prevention of louping-ill requires either the prevention of exposure of sheep
to tick-infested pastures or the immunization of animals before exposure. Immunization
has been the traditional approach.
Historically, a formalinized tissue vaccine derived from brain, spinal cord, and spleen
was used and provided excellent immunity in enzootic areas. The vaccine was not without
risk for persons manufacturing it and at one stage led to an outbreak of scrapie where
the vaccine was prepared from sheep incubating the disease. Currently, vaccination
is with a formalin-killed tissue culture–derived vaccine administered in an oil adjuvant.
A single dose of this vaccine will give protection for at least 1 year and possibly
up to 2 years. The vaccine is used in the autumn, or in the early spring 1 month before
the anticipated tick rise, in all ewe lambs that will be held for flock replacements.
Vaccination of pregnant ewes twice in late pregnancy is recommended to ensure adequate
passive immunity to the lambs via the colostrum. A recombinant vaccine has also been
shown to offer protection against infection.
The limited geographic occurrence of this disease and commercial economics has, and
may, restrict the availability of vaccines. Consequently tick control, or the elimination
of infection from pastures, may be required in the future. The intensity of tick infestation
of pastures can be reduced by influencing the microclimate that they require for survival.
In some areas this can be achieved by ditching and drainage of the pastures. The control
of the causative tick using acaricides provides some protection against disease.
Epidemiologic, modeling, and experimental studies indicate that sheep, red grouse,
and hares are the only maintenance hosts for the virus and this, coupled with the
fact that there is no transovarial transmission of the virus in the tick, offers a
potential method for eradication of the infection from an area. However, this approach
(the elimination of wildlife hosts) is increasingly unacceptable in relationship to
game and wildlife conservation, may have unintended consequences and is probably of
dubious benefit–cost in relationship to alternate methods of control.
7
Further Reading
Estradapena
A
Farkas
R
Jaenson
TGT
Ticks and Tick-Borne Diseases: Geographical Distribution and Control Strategies in
the Euro-Asia Region
2003
CABI Publishing
Wallingford, UK
Radostits
O
Ovine encephalomyelitis (louping-ill)
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Diseases of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1414
1418
References
1
Jeffries
CL
J Gen Virol
95
2014
1005
24552787
2
Mansfield
KL
J Gen Virol
96
2015
1676
25701823
3
Ruiz-Fons
F
Eur J Wildl Dis
60
2014
691
4
Cranwell
MP
Vet Rec
162
2008
28
5
Sarginson
N
In Pract
31
2009
58
6
Johnson
N
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
10
2010
665
20854019
7
Harrison
A
J Appl Ecol
47
2010
926
West Nile, Kunjin, and Murray Valley Encephalitis
Synopsis
Etiology Flavivirus including West Nile virus (lineages 1 and 2) including Kunjin
virus, and Murray Valley encephalitis virus. Closely related to Japanese encephalitis
virus.
Epidemiology Maintained in a bird–mosquito cycle. Mammals are incidentally infected.
Enzootic in Africa, North America, Pakistan, southern Europe, and Australia. Epizootics.
Affects a wide variety of species with a major impact on humans and horses.
Clinical signs Weakness, incoordination, altered mentation, muscle fasciculations,
recumbency.
Clinical pathology MAC-ELISA for diagnosis.
Lesions Polioencephalomyelitis.
Diagnostic confirmation MAC-ELISA, PCR, clinical signs, lesions.
Treatment None specific. Supportive care.
Control Vaccination. Mosquito control.
MAC-ELISA, M antibody-capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Encephalitis in horses, humans, and other species is associated with West Nile virus,
an arthropod-borne flavivirus in the Japanese encephalitis virus group. Other viruses
in the group include Japanese encephalitis virus (Japan and Southeast Asia), St. Louis
encephalitis virus (United States), Kunjin virus (now considered a subtype of West
Nile virus, Australia),1, 2 Murray Valley encephalitis virus (Australia),3, 4, 5 and
Rocio virus (Brazil). Murray Valley virus causing encephalomyelitis in horses in southeastern
Australia is endemic to northern Australia.
4
Viruses causing, or suspected of causing encephalomyelitis in equids, are listed in
Table 14-11
.
6
Table 14-11
Viruses causing encephalomyelitis in horses. reproduced with permission.
6
Table 14-11
Virus species
Geographic location
Reservoir species
Equine syndrome
Alphavirus
Eastern equine encephalitis virus
North/South/Central America, Caribbean
Birds, rodents, snakes
Encephalomyelitis
Western equine encephalitis virus
North/South America
Birds, rodents, snakes
Encephalomyelitis
Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus
Central/South America, Caribbean
Cotton rat
Encephalomyelitis
Ross River virus
Australia, Papua New Guinea
Marsupial and placental mammals
Systemic: hemolymphaticNeurologic ataxia
Semliki Forest virus
East and West Africa
Unknown
Encephalomyelitis
Flavivirus
Japanese encephalitis
Asia, India, Russia, Western Pacific
Birds, swine
Encephalomyelitis
Murray Valley
Australia, Papua New Guinea
Birds, horses, cattle, marsupials, and foxes
Encephalomyelitis
Kunkin virus
Australia
Water birds: herons and ibis
Encephalomyelitis
St. Louis encephalitis
North, Central and South America
Birds
Serologic only recorded
Usutu
Europe, Africa
Birds
Serologic only recorded
West Nile
Africa, Middle East, Europe, North, Central and South America, Australia
Passerine birds (crows, sparrows, robins)
Encephalomyelitis
Louping-ill
Iberian Peninsula, UK
Sheep, grouse
Encephalomyelitis
Powassan
North American, Russia
Lagomorphs, rodents, mice, skunks, dogs, birds
Encephalomyelitis
Tick-borne encephalitis
Asia, Europe, Finland, Russia
Small rodents
Encephalomyelitis
Bunyavirus
California serogroup: California encephalitis, Jamestown Canyon, La Crosse, Snowshoe
hare
North America (United States and Canada), parts of eastern Asia
Rodents and lagomorphs
Encephalomyelitis
The virus was first isolated in 1937 from a human with fever in Uganda. There are
at least two lineages of the virus, with one lineage (Lineage 1) isolated from animals
in central and North Africa, Europe, Israel, and North America, whereas the other
(Lineage 2) is enzootic in central and southern Africa with outbreaks of disease in
humans in central Europe, Greece, and Russia.6, 7, 8, 9, 10 The recent outbreak in
North America was associated with a Lineage 1 (Clade a) virus of African origin almost
identical to that isolated from diseased geese in Israel, and which subsequently acquired
a mutation that enhanced its capacity to reproduce in mosquitos and its virulence
in corvid birds and other species.
11
Viruses of both lineages can circulate at the same time in the same geographic region.
Virus of either lineage can cause disease, although that of Lineage 1 appears to be
associated with more severe disease in horses and other species. Kunjin virus, a West
Nile virus (Lineage 1, Clade b), causes encephalomyelitis in horses in Australia.12,
13 An outbreak in Australia in 2011 was associated with unusually wet weather (see
later) and emergence of a strain of West Nile virus (WNVNSW2011) that had at least
two amino acid changes associated with increased virulence of WNVNY99 (the strain
associated with the epidemic in North America in 1999).
12
The WNV(KUN)NSW2011 strain also had adaptations that increased the amount of virus
in material (saliva) regurgitated by mosquitos, which could have increased the rate
of vector transmission of the virus.
14
The WNVNSW2011 strain did not have all the virulence attributes of the WNVNY99 strain.
15
Murray Valley encephalitis virus causes encephalomyelitis in horses in Australia.
3
The West Nile virus causes disease in humans, horses, birds (including geese, raptors,
and corvids), sheep, alpaca, and dogs. Experimental inoculation of little ravens (Corvus
mellori) with WNVKUN resulted in infection and viremia but not clinical disease.
13
Epidemiology
Distribution
West Nile encephalitis virus is enzootic to Africa and sporadic outbreaks of the disease
occurred in the 1960s in Africa, the Middle East, and southern Europe. Recently outbreaks
affecting horses and other animals have occurred in southern France, Tuscany, Israel,
and other parts of southern Europe. There is serologic evidence of common and widespread
infection of equids with West Nile virus in Pakistan and Tunisia.16, 17
The virus was introduced into New York City in North America in 1999 and subsequently
spread widely across the continent, including Canada, Mexico, and the Caribbean, reaching
the west coast by 2004. The virus caused widespread deaths of wild birds and disease
and death in humans, horses, and other species in North America during this period.
Introduction of the infection to North America was associated with an epizootic of
disease that over several years moved across the continent. During the initial years
of the epizootic there were large numbers of cases in horses (15,000) and humans (4,000)
and death of at least 16,500 birds. As the front of the epizootic moved across the
country, the infection became enzootic and the number of cases in horses in these
regions decreased markedly over those in the first year.
Infection by Kunjin virus (a strain of West Nile virus) rarely causes disease of horses
in areas in which it is endemic (northern Australia) but was associated with an outbreak
of neurologic disease in horses in southeastern Australia after a decade-long drought
broke with record rains resulting in sixfold increases in vector density.1, 12 The
outbreak did not extend into the subsequent year.
12
There is serologic evidence of infection by flaviviruses (including Kunjin and/or
Murray Valley encephalitis virus in 15%–18% of horses in southeast Queensland, where
infection is presumed to be endemic and clinical disease is rare.
18
Viral Ecology
The virus is maintained by a cycling between amplifying hosts, usually birds, and
insect vectors. Large mammals, including horses and humans, are incidentally infected
and are not important in propagation of the virus. Amplifying hosts are those in which
the viremia is of a sufficient magnitude and duration (1–5 days) to provide the opportunity
to infect feeding mosquitoes. Mammals, and in particular horses, are generally not
amplifying hosts because of the low level of viremia.
The virus is spread by the feeding of ornithophilic mosquitoes, usually of the genus
Culex with mosquitos of the C. pipiens group being effective vectors.19, 20 The principal
vectors for West Nile virus include Africa, C. univittatus; Europe, C. pipiens, C.
modestus, and Coquillettidia richiardii; Asia, C. quinquefasciatus, C. tritaeniorhynchus,
and C. vishnui; United States, C. pipiens complex including C. pipiens and C. restuans
in the northeastern and north central United States, C. tarsalis in the Great Plains
and western United States; and C. nigripalpus and C. quinquefasciatus in southeastern
United States.
21
C. annulirostris and a variety of other native and introduced species of mosquitos
are actual or potential vectors of West Nile virus in Australia.
21
Infected mosquitoes carry the virus in salivary glands and infect avian hosts during
feeding. The virus then multiplies in the avian host causing a viremia that may last
for up to 5 days. Mosquitoes feeding on the avian host during the viremic phase are
then infected by the virus. This pattern of infection of amplifying hosts and mosquitoes
is repeated such that the infection cycles in these populations. Increases in mosquito
number, such as occur at the end of the summer, and enhanced viral replication in
mosquitoes at higher ambient temperatures, increase the likelihood that avian hosts,
or incidental hosts, will become infected. This results in an increase in the incidence
of disease in late summer and early autumn.
The principal avian host and vector species vary markedly between geographic regions.
In North America the house sparrow (Passer domesticus) is the principal amplifying
host and C. pipiens is the principal vector. C. pipiens, and other mosquito vectors,
feed almost exclusively on passerine and columbiform birds early in the season, but
later in the summer in temperate regions switch to feeding on mammalian hosts. This
change in feeding behavior is associated with increased frequency of infection and
disease in mammals, including horses and humans, in the late summer.
The virus cycles between the avian host and insect vectors year round in tropical
regions. However, in temperate regions in which mosquitoes do not survive during the
winter the mechanism by which the virus survives over winter is unknown.
The primary vector involved in Murray Valley encephalitis virus transmission is the
mosquito C. annulirostris.
1, 3 Wading birds, particularly the rufous night heron (Nycticorax caledonicus) appear
to be the principal natural reservoirs of Murray Valley encephalitis virus and West
Nile virus in Australia.
1
Transmission
Transmission is only by the bite of infected insect vectors. There is no evidence
of horizontal spread of infection among horses. The disease can be spread in humans
by transfusion of blood or transplantation of organs obtained from an infected person.
Animal Risk Factors
The disease occurs in parts of the world as epidemics, apparently associated with
sporadic introduction of the virus into nonendemic regions, such as the Mediterranean
littoral and parts of central Europe.
22
Introduction of the virus to these regions occurs infrequently enough that horses
have no active immunity and are susceptible to infection and disease. Horses immune
through either natural infection or vaccination are resistant to the disease. The
effect of immunity was evidenced in North America by the marked decrease in morbidity
and mortality among horses after the epizootic waned and the disease became enzootic.
The decrease in morbidity was attributed to both natural and vaccinal immunity. Interestingly,
although the number of cases in horses decreased rapidly, there was not a similar
decrease in the number of human cases, perhaps because of the lack of a vaccine for
use in humans.
Horses of all ages appear to be equally susceptible to infection. Disease is reported
in horses aged from 5 months to >20 years. There does not appear to be any predilection
based on breed or sex. Polymorphism in horse genome is associated with susceptibility
to disease, including a haplotype associated with the promoter region of the OAS1
gene.
23
Morbidity and Case Fatality
The incidence of the disease during an epizootic can be as high as 74 cases per 1000
horses at risk. The case–fatality rate for West Nile virus encephalomyelitis in horses
in North America treated in the field is 22% to 44%, whereas it is 30% to 43% of horses
in referral centers.
24
The case–fatality rate for West Nile virus (Kunjin) and Murray Valley encephalitis
virus infected horses in Australia with signs of disease is 5% to 20%.
1
Zoonotic Implications
Infection of humans by West Nile virus or Murray Valley encephalitis virus can result
in fatal encephalitis, although less severe disease or inapparent infection is more
common.7, 12, 25 The virus has zoonotic potential and tissues from potentially infected
animals and virus cultures should be handled in containment level 3 facilities, particularly
material from potentially infected birds.
Pathogenesis
Horses are infected by the bite of infected mosquitoes. Feeding by as few as seven
infected mosquitoes is sufficient to cause infection in seronegative horses. Viremia,
which persists for less than 2 days, occurs 2 to 5 days after feeding by infected
mosquitoes. West Nile encephalitis occurs in only a small proportion of infected horses.
The virus localizes in cells in the CNS where it induces a severe polioencephalomyelitis
with the most severe lesions being in the spinal cord. Lesions are often evident in
the ventral horn of the spinal cord, which is consistent with clinical signs of weakness.
Clinical Findings
The incubation period of Wes Nile virus after natural infection is estimated to be
8 to 15 days. Fever occurs early in the disease but is uncommon at the time that signs
of neurologic disease become evident. Affected horses are often somnolent, listless,
or depressed, although hyperexcitability has been reported. The signs of neurologic
disease, including muscle fasciculation, weakness, and incoordination, develop within
a period of hours and can progress over several days. Muscle fasciculations are common
in the head and neck, but can occur in any muscle group. Weakness is most pronounced
in limb and neck muscles and severely affected horses are recumbent with flaccid paralysis.
Signs of neurologic disease are usually, but not reliably, bilaterally symmetric.
Altered mentation, blindness, and cranial nerve abnormalities, if they occur, usually
become evident after signs of spinal cord disease are apparent.
Weakness with or without ataxia is present in almost all affected horses, whereas
altered mentation is detected in approximately 66% of horses. Cranial nerve abnormalities
are evident in approximately 40% of horses, whereas apparent blindness or lack of
menace reflex occurs in 3% to 7% of horses.
Median recovery time for horses treated in the field is 7 days, with a range of 1
to 21 days.
The prognosis depends on the severity of clinical signs. Horses that become recumbent
and unable to rise are approximately 50 times more likely to die than are horses that
remain able to stand while affected by the disease. Most horses that survive the initial
disease do not have signs of neurologic dysfunction 6 months later.
Murray Valley encephalitis in horses causes signs consistent with encephalitis including
fever, depressed mentation, abnormalities in cranial nerves including paralysis of
the facial muscles, ataxia, and recumbency.3, 5 The clinical course can be prolonged.
Other Species
Disease associated with West Nile virus is documented in small numbers of other species,
including squirrels, chipmunks, bats, dogs, cats, reindeer, sheep, alpaca, alligators,
and a harbor seal during intense periods of local viral activity. West Nile virus
infection in dogs is usually subclinical.
26
The disease in camelids is characterized by acute recumbency and altered mentation.
Clinical Pathology
Affected horses are often mildly lymphopenic, and hyperbilirubinemic (likely from
anorexia), and occasionally azotemic. These changes are not diagnostic of West Nile
or Murray Valley encephalitis.
CSF is abnormal in approximately 70% of horses with signs of neurologic disease. Abnormalities
include mononuclear pleocytosis and elevated total protein concentration.
6
Serologic Tests
Antibody can be identified in equine serum by IgM capture ELISA (IgM capture ELISA,
M antibody-capture ELISA [MAC-ELISA]), HI, IgG ELISA, or plaque reduction neutralization
(PRN).27, 28 Equine West Nile-specific IgM antibodies are usually first detectable
7–10 days after infection and persist for 1 to 2 months. Because the incubation period
of the disease after infection by bite of infected mosquitoes is at least 8 days,
West Nile-specific IgM is usually present at the time of development of clinical signs
of the disease. MAC-ELISA is therefore a useful test in the diagnosis of the disease.
West Nile virus neutralizing antibodies are detectable in equine serum by 2 weeks
postinfection and can persist for more than 1 year. In some serologic assays, antibody
cross-reactions with related flaviviruses (St. Louis encephalitis virus or Japanese
encephalitis virus), can be encountered. The PRN test is the most specific among West
Nile serologic tests and all affected horses have titers ≥1 : 100 4 to 6 weeks after
recovering from the disease, and 90% of horses maintain this titer 5 to 7 months after
recovery.
Detection by MAC-ELISA of West Nile-specific IgM in serum at dilutions greater than
1 : 400, in the presence of appropriate clinical signs, is considered diagnostic of
West Nile virus. Similarly, a fourfold increase in PRN titer in serum collected during
the acute and convalescent stages of the disease, in the absence of vaccination and
in the presence of appropriate clinical signs, is considered diagnostic.
Identification of West Nile Virus
The virus can be grown in cell culture, and viral nucleic acid can be demonstrated
in tissues of infected animals by RT-PCR.29, 30 Note that infected horses have much
lower concentrations of virus than do infected birds, and failure to demonstrate viral
antigen in infected horses is not uncommon, especially if less sensitive techniques,
such as IHC, are used.
Necropsy Findings
Gross lesions are infrequently seen. When present they consist of multifocal areas
of congestion and hemorrhage within the medulla oblongata, midbrain, and spinal cord.
Histopathologic changes include a nonsuppurative poliomeningoencephalomyelitis with
multifocal glial nodules and neuronophagia. The inflammatory changes and viral distribution
are concentrated in the rhombencephalon and spinal cord, with comparatively little
damage to the cerebrum. One IHC study of naturally infected horses concluded that
examination of the spinal cord is required to accurately identify West Nile virus
infection. Another report, in which RT-PCR was used, concluded that high-quality samples
of medulla were sufficient to detect the presence of the virus. Postmortem confirmation
of the diagnosis through virus isolation is possible, but the sensitivity is generally
inferior to molecular biology-based techniques. RT-PCR is generally superior to IHC.
The processing of tissue from multiple CNS sites is recommended to increase the chances
of finding a virus-rich focus. High concentrations of West Nile virus are not found
in non-CNS tissues of infected equids, in contrast to the distribution of the virus
in many other species.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Virology: minimum sample is half of sagittally sectioned hindbrain (must include medulla).
Ideally a segment of thoracolumbar spinal cord as well. Submit samples chilled (VI,
RT-PCR)
•
Histology: same samples, fixed in formalin (LM, IHC, RT-PCR).
Note the zoonotic potential of this disease when collecting and submitting specimens.
Some authorities recommend using containment level 3 precautions when handling potentially
infected tissues, such as that from birds.
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnoses for West Nile encephalitis include (Table 14-11) the following:
•
Eastern and Western encephalitis
•
Venezuelan equine encephalitis
•
Equine herpesvirus-1 myeloencephalopathy
•
Hendra virus infection
•
Rabies
•
Botulism
•
Hepatic encephalopathy
•
Borna disease
•
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis
•
Leukoencephalomalacia
•
Lower motor neuron disease
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no specific treatment for West Nile encephalitis, although administration
of IFN or hyperimmune globulin has been advocated. Affected horses are often administered
nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs such as flunixin meglumine, dimethyl sulfoxide,
or corticosteroids in an attempt to reduce inflammation in neural tissue. Administration
of corticosteroids minimally but statistically significantly increases the likelihood
of survival, but this practice is controversial. Treatment is based on supportive
care and prevention of complications of neurologic disease and includes assistance
to stand, including use of a sling support, administration of antimicrobials, and
maintenance of hydration and nutrition.
Control
Control of disease associated with West Nile virus and other flaviviruses is achieved
by vaccination and minimization of exposure. It is important to recognize that factors
affecting vector density, as happened in Australia in 2011, introduction of new vectors,
or emergence of virus strains with higher virulence can affect incidence of the disease
and require revision of existing control measures.12, 25, 31 Elimination of the virus
is not practical given that it cycles through avian and insect vectors and that the
horse is incidentally infected.
Vaccination is effective in preventing development of disease, and reduces the likelihood
of death in horses with West Nile encephalitis by approximately two to three times.32,
33, 34 Vaccination is an important aspect of controlling the disease. There is no
evidence that administration of the inactivated virus vaccine increases the risk of
fetal loss in mares. Vaccination prevents viremia in most horses following exposure
to West Nile virus-infected mosquitoes. Vaccination induces an IgG, but not an IgM,
response in horses providing a means of identifying recently naturally infected horses
from those with vaccine-induced serologic results.
32
Both inactivated virus vaccine and a live canarypox-vectored recombinant vaccine are
available in North America.
6
The inactivated virus vaccine should be administered in two doses at an interval of
3 to 6 weeks in early summer in the first instance, and then again once to twice yearly
before the season of peak disease incidence. Foals from unvaccinated mares should
be administered the vaccine beginning at 2 to 3 months of age, and foals of vaccinated
mares should be administered the vaccine beginning at 7 to 8 months of age. Vaccination
of foals that acquired passive immunity from the dam can be effective at inducing
active immunity when the first dose of vaccine is administered at 3 months of age.
35
Administration of the recommended two doses of inactivated virus vaccine fails to
induce an adequate plaque reduction titer in approximately 14% of horses 4 to 6 weeks
after vaccination and in 30% of horses 5 to 7 months after vaccination. This effect
was especially evident in horses >10 years of age. These results indicate that some
horses will not develop protective immunity against West Nile virus despite administration
of vaccine in the recommended dose and interval.
Minimization of exposure of horses to the virus includes reducing the population density
of mosquitoes and protecting horses from being bitten. Reducing the population of
mosquitoes includes widespread spraying with insecticides and elimination of mosquito
breeding sites. Widespread spraying in cities is used when the disease is a risk for
humans but is not practical for controlling mosquitoes in rural areas. Environmental
concerns make this approach to control unacceptable in many regions.
Removal of larval habitat by draining standing water is recommended for control of
West Nile virus, although the efficacy of this approach has not been demonstrated.
Standing water includes not just dams and ponds but also poorly maintained outdoor
swimming pools, bird baths, discarded vehicle tires, and other receptacles that could
hold water. Use of larvicidal compounds in standing water is recommended by some authorities.
Minimizing the frequency with which horses are bitten by mosquitoes has the potential
to reduce the risk of contracting the disease. However, specific recommendations are
not available. Housing during periods of peak mosquito activity, especially at dawn
and dusk, might reduce the risk of disease.
Further Reading
Long
MT
West Nile virus and equine encephalitis viruses new perspectives
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
30
2014
523
540
25441112
McVey
DS
West Nile Virus
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
2
2015
431
439
References
1
Roche
SE
Aust Vet J
91
2013
5
23356366
2
Frost
MJ
Emerg Infect Dis
18
2012
792
22516173
3
Barton
AJ
Aust Vet J
93
2015
53
25708787
4
Mann
RA
J Vet Diagn Invest
25
2013
35
23345269
5
Gordon
AN
J Vet Diagn Invest
24
2012
431
22379060
6
Long
MT
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
30
2014
523
25441112
7
McVey
DS
Rev Sci Tec
34
2015
431
8
Chaintoutis
SC
Emerg Infect Dis
19
2013
827
23697609
9
Ciccozzi
M
Infect Genet Evol
17
2013
46
23542457
10
McMullen
AR
J Gen Virol
94
2013
318
23136360
11
Añez
G
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
7
2013
e2245
23738027
12
Prow
NA
Int J Environ Res Public Health
10
2013
6255
24287851
13
Tee
SY
Aust Vet J
90
2012
321
22827627
14
van den Hurk
AF
Parasit Vectors
7
2014
15
Setoh
YX
J Gen Virol
96
2015
1297
25626681
16
Bargaoui
R
Transbound Emerg Dis
62
2015
55
23906318
17
Zohaib
A
Epidemiol Infect
143
2015
1931
25358382
18
Prow
NA
Int J Environ Res Public Health
10
2013
4432
24048209
19
Amraoui
F
PLoS ONE
7
2012
20
Andreadis
TG
J Am Mosq Control Assoc
28
2012
137
21
Jansen
CC
Int J Environ Res Public Health
10
2013
3735
23965926
22
Sedlak
K
Epid Mik Imun
63
2014
307
23
Rios
JJ
PLoS ONE
5
2010
e10537
20479874
24
Epp
T
Can Vet J
48
2007
1137
18050794
25
Selvey
LA
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
8
2014
2656
26
Bowen
RA
Am J Trop Med Hyg
74
2006
670
16607003
27
Long
MT
J Vet Intern Med
20
2006
608
16734097
28
Wagner
B
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
122
2008
46
18054390
29
Brault
AC
J Med Entomol
52
2015
491
26334826
30
Toplu
N
Vet Pathol
52
2015
1073
25677341
31
Kock
RA
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
34
2015
151
26470455
32
Khatibzadeh
SM
Am J Vet Res
76
2015
92
25535666
33
Long
MT
Equine Vet J
39
2007
491
18065305
34
Minke
JM
Vaccine
29
2011
4608
21549780
35
Davis
EG
Equine Vet J
47
2015
667
25205445
Japanese Encephalitis
Japanese encephalitis is a neurologic disease of humans, horses, and cattle caused
by Japanese encephalitis virus. The disease is an important zoonosis in Asia, arising
as a result of virus infection of amplifying hosts (pigs) transmitted by mosquitos
from the avian wildlife reservoir. Horses, cattle, and humans are not important in
the propagation of the disease because of the low levels of viremia in these species.
There is an effective vaccine.
Etiology
Japanese encephalitis flavivirus (JEV), a member of the Flaviviridae family (which
also includes Murray Valley encephalitis virus, Kunjin virus, and West Nile virus),
all of which cause disease in humans, horses, and other mammals, and Usutu virus,
which causes disease only in birds.1, 2, 3 JEV, an enveloped virus of about 50 nm
in diameter, has a nonsegmented, single-stranded, positive-sense RNA genome of about
11 kb in length.
3
The genome has one long open reading frame (ORF) that encodes a single polyprotein
is cleaved cotranslationally and posttranslationally into three structural proteins
and seven nonstructural proteins. The three structural proteins are the capsid (C),
precursor to membrane (prM), and envelope (E) proteins.
3
Based on the nucleotide sequence of genomic RNA, JEV is classified into five major
genotypes.4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 Genotype 1 occurs in the People's Republic of China, Vietnam,
South Korea, Northern Thailand, Cambodia, Japan, Australia, India, and Chinese Taipei;
Genotype 2 occurs in Southern Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, Northern Australia, and
Papua New Guinea; Genotype 3 is present in Indonesia, Malaysia, Nepal, Sri Lanka,
India, Indochinese Peninsula, Philippines, Chinese Taipei, South Korea, People's Republic
of China, Vietnam, and Japan; Genotype 4 was isolated only during 1980 and 1981 in
Indonesia; and Genotype 5 occurs Malaysia, Tibet (China), and South Korea (Fig. 14-5
).2, 4, 5, 9 JEV RNA has been detected in dead birds and a C. pipiens mosquitos in
Italy.
10
Fig. 14-5
Distribution of Japanese Encephalitis Virus as of 2015. Viral genome has been detected
in dead birds and mosquitos in Italy, but the virus has not been isolated nor disease
consistent with Japanese encephalitis detected in that country.
Fig. 14-5
(reproduced with the permission of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE,
www.oie.int). Fig. 2 of Morita K., et al., Japanese encephalitis. In New developments
in major vector-borne diseases. Part II: Important diseases for veterinarians (S.
Zientara, D. Verwoerd & P.-P. Pastoret…, eds). Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 34
(2), page 443. doi: 10.20506/rst.34.2.2370.)
The virus cycles between avian and mammalian amplifying hosts and the mosquitoes (Fig.
14-6
).
2
The natural maintenance reservoir for JEV are birds of the family Ardeidae (herons
and egrets), which do not demonstrate clinical disease but do have high levels of
viremias. The pig is the principal mammalian amplifying host among domestic animals.
Horses, cattle, sheep, goats, dogs, cats, and humans become infected but likely play
only a minor role in the spread of the virus because of the low level of viremia in
these species. There are a number of species of mosquito important in the biology
of the virus:11, 12
C. tritaeniorhynchus is the primary vector, whereas C. gelidus, C. fuscocephala, and
C. annulirostris are considered as secondary/regional vectors. The virus has been
detected in Anopheles peditaeniatus Leicester, A. barbirostris (van der Walp), and
A. subpictus in India.
Fig. 14-6
Transmission cycle of Japanese encephalitis virus between amplifiers (pigs and wild
birds) and mosquito vectors (especially Culex tritaeniorhynchus), including the infection
of dead-end hosts (humans, horses, cattle).
Fig. 14-6
(reproduced with the permission of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE,
www.oie.int). Fig. 3 of Morita K., et al., Japanese encephalitis. In New developments
in major vector-borne diseases. Part II: Important diseases for veterinarians (S.
Zientara, D. Verwoerd & P.-P. Pastoret…, eds). Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 34
(2), page 444. doi: 10.20506/rst.34.2.2370.)
Aedes koreicus, a potential vector of JEV, is reported for the first time in northern
Italy/Switzerland (it has been reported in Belgium and parts of central Europe), continuing
a pattern of climate change-induced incursions of insect vectors of important viral
diseases into Europe.
13
Ochlerotatus detritus (syn. Aedes detritus), a temperate zone (British) mosquito can
be infected by JEV in laboratory settings and might be a competent vector in the field,
although this remains to be established.
11
The virus is destroyed by heating for 30 minutes above 56°C and the thermal inactivation
point (TIP) is 40°C. It is inactivated in acid environment of pH 1 to 3 but stable
in alkaline environment of pH 7 to 9. The virus is very labile, is sensitive to ultraviolet
light and gamma irradiation, and does not survive well in the environment.
Epidemiology
The disease in humans, horses, pigs, or cattle occurs throughout the Orient and Southeast
Asia and has extended into Papua New Guinea, the Torres Strait, and northern Australia.
Outbreaks of disease occurred in the Torres Strait in 1995, and disease in humans
has occurred rarely in northern Australia. Outbreaks of disease have not occurred
in Australia, despite large populations of wild pigs, wading birds, and mosquitoes
probably because the mosquitoes prefer to feed on marsupials, which are poor hosts
for JEV.
Sporadic clinical cases of JEV in horses have been reported in various countries including
Japan, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and India.4, 14, 15 Horse deaths are now uncommon in Japan
with few to none reported in several decades,2, 15 because of vaccination of most
horses, but 15% to 70% of race horses have antibodies to JEV that are not induced
by vaccination. Antibodies against JEV were detected in 67 of 637 (10.5%) horses in
India screened between 2006 and 2010.
14
Seroepidemiologic surveys of cattle in Japan reveal that about 68% of animals are
positive. Disease in horses and humans occurs in China. The prevalence of the disease
is related to the population of pigs, the main amplifying host; the mosquito vector;
and susceptible human and equine hosts. Japanese encephalitis virus HI seroprevalence
was 74.7% (95% CI = 71.5%–77.9%), JEV IgM seroprevalence was 2.3% (95% CI = 1.2%–3.2%)
in pigs at slaughter in Laos, with greater prevalence during the monsoonal season.
16
Factors affecting the number of mosquitoes include availability of suitable habitat,
such as a rice field in which survival of mosquito larvae is enhanced by application
of nitrogenous fertilizers and the presence of phytoplankton, which provide food and
shelter for the larvae.
Clinical Signs
The clinical manifestations of the disease in horses vary widely in severity.
15
Mild cases show fever up to 39.5°C (103°F), anorexia, sluggish movements, and sometimes
jaundice for 2 to 3 days only. A more severe form of the disease includes lethargy
with variable febrile periods (as high as 41°C), with a pronounced stupor, bruxism
and chewing motions, difficulty in swallowing, petechiation of mucosa, incoordination,
neck rigidity, apparent impaired vision, paresis, and paralysis. Recovery usually
occurs within about a week. More severe cases show pronounced lethargy, mild fever,
and somnolence. Jaundice and petechiation of the nasal mucosa are usual. There is
dysphagia, incoordination, staggering, and falling. There is also a hyperexcitable
form of the disease characterized by high fevers (41°C or higher), profuse sweating
and muscle tremors, aimless wandering, behavioral changes manifested by aggression,
loss of vision, collapse, coma, and death. This severe type of the disease is uncommon,
representing only about 5% of the total cases, but is more likely to terminate fatally.
In most cases complete recovery follows an illness lasting from 4 to 9 days. The disease
occurs in foals and can manifest as encephalitis.
14
Infection of cattle, sheep, and goats is usually clinically inapparent and of little
overall significance, although rare cases of clinical disease occur in these species.2,
17, 18 Widespread losses, however, have been reported in swine, particularly in Japan.
The disease occurs as a nonsuppurative encephalitis in pigs under 6 months of age.
Sows abort or produce dead pigs at term, and the disease has economic importance because
of these losses.
Clinical Pathology
A variety of tests are available to detect antibodies to JEV or viral RNA. A latex
agglutination test provides accurate detection of antibodies in the field. However,
definitive diagnosis of Japanese viral encephalitis should not be based exclusively
on serology because infection with antigenically related viruses including Murray
Valley encephalitis virus, Kunjin virus, and West Nile virus can cause false-positive
(from the perspective of JEV) results. Isolation of this flavivirus is difficult,
and bioassay techniques are comparatively slow. As a result, detection via PCR is
likely to be increasingly utilized. Tests to detect viral RNA in mammalian tissues
or mosquitos are available.19, 20, 21, 22, 23
Necropsy Findings
There are no characteristic gross changes. As is typical of most viral encephalitides,
microscopic changes include a nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis, focal gliosis, neuronal
necrosis, and neuronophagia. Lesions in piglets following experimental infection are
glial cell aggregates and perivascular cuffing throughout the olfactory tract and
pyriform cortex. JEV antigens were detected in the cytoplasm and neuronal processes
of small nerve cells in the granule cell layer of the olfactory bulb, in the neuronal
processes of the olfactory tract, and in the cytoplasm of neurons in the pyriform
cortex.
24
IHC can be used to demonstrate this virus in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded sections.
Zoonosis25, 26
Japanese encephalitis virus is endemic in 24 countries in the WHO Southeast Asia and
Western Pacific regions with more than 3 billion people at risk of infection. Japanese
encephalitis is the main cause of viral encephalitis in people in many countries of
Asia occurring in almost 68,000 clinical cases yearly. Children are at greatest risk,
with adults in endemic areas having protective immunity as a consequence of childhood
infection. Most JEV infections are mild (fever and headache) or without apparent symptoms,
but approximately 1 in 250 infections results in severe disease characterized by rapid
onset of high fever, headache, neck stiffness, disorientation, coma, seizures, spastic
paralysis, and death.
25
Although symptomatic JEV is rare, the case–fatality rate among those with encephalitis
can be as high as 30%. Permanent neurologic or psychiatric sequelae occur in 30% to
50% of people with clinical encephalitis. There is no effective, specific treatment
and care of affected people includes symptomatic treatment. Safe and effective vaccines
are available to prevent JEV in people and consequently the WHO recommends JEV vaccination
in all regions in which the disease is a recognized public health problem.
25
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Virology: 5 mL chilled CSF fluid, chilled brain (split along midline) (ISO, BIOASSAY,
PCR)
•
Histology: fixed samples of the other half of brain, lung, spleen, liver, heart (LM,
IHC)
Note the zoonotic potential of this organism when handling carcass and submitting
specimens.
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis in horses include
27
other equine viral encephalitides (Eastern, Western, Venezuelan, Murray Valley, West
Nile), African horse sickness, Borna disease, EHV infection, equine infectious anemia,
acute babesiosis, hepatic encephalopathy, rabies, tetanus, botulism, cerebral nematodiasis
or protozoodiasis, or leukoencephalomalacia (F. moniliforme).
Differential diagnoses for pigs include
27
Menangle virus infection, porcine parvovirus infection, classical swine fever, porcine
reproductive and respiratory syndrome, Aujeszky's disease (pseudorabies), La Piedad
Michoacan paramyxovirus (blue eye paramyxovirus), hemagglutinating encephalomyelitis,
encephalomyocarditis virus, porcine brucellosis, Teschen/Talfan, water deprivation/excess
salt, and any other causative agent of stillbirth, mummification, embryonic death,
and infertility (SMEDI) or encephalitis in newborns.
Treatment and Control
There is no specific treatment for the disease.
Control is by vaccination. Formalinized vaccines afford excellent protection in pigs
and horses. A delta inulin-adjuvanted, inactivated cell culture-derived JEV vaccine
was safe and well tolerated and induced a strong JEV-neutralizing antibody response
in all foals and pregnant mares. The neutralizing activity was passively transferred
to their foals via colostrum. Foals that acquired passive immunity to JEV via maternal
antibodies had evidence of maternal antibody interference to subsequent vaccination
at ~35 days, but not at 1 year of age.
28
The virus is inactivated by organic and lipid solvents, common detergents, iodine,
phenol iodophors of 70% ethanol, 2% glutaraldehyde, 3% to 8% formaldehyde, and 1%
sodium hypochlorite.
27
References
1
Ziegler
U
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
15
2015
481
26273809
2
Morita
K
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
34
2015
441
26601447
3
Unni
SK
Microbes Infect
13
2011
312
21238600
4
Cherian
SS
Arch Virol
160
2015
3097
26362532
5
Li
M-H
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
5
2011
1231
6
Nabeshima
T
Future Virol
5
2010
343
7
Schuh
AJ
J Gen Virol
91
2010
95
19776238
8
Su
C-L
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
8
2014
e3122
25275652
9
Takhampunya
R
Virol J
8
2011
10
Ravanini
P
Eurosurveillance
17
2012
2
11
Mackenzie-Impoinvil
L
Med Vet Entomol
29
2015
1
25087926
12
van den Hurk
AF
Annu Rev Entomol
54
2009
17
19067628
13
Suter
T
Parasit Vectors
8
2015
402
26223377
14
Gulati
BR
J Vet Sci
13
2012
111
22705732
15
Yamanaka
T
J Vet Med Sci
68
2006
293
16598178
16
Conlan
JV
Am J Trop Med Hyg
86
2012
1077
22665622
17
Kako
N
BMC Vet Res
10
2014
18
Katayama
T
J Clin Microbiol
51
2013
3448
23885004
19
Cha
G-W
PLoS ONE
10
2015
e0127313
25992769
20
Chen
YY
Transbound Emerg Dis
61
2014
37
23157736
21
Deng
J
J Virol Methods
213
2015
98
25512133
22
Dhanze
H
Arch Virol
160
2015
1259
25772573
23
Glushakova
LG
J Virol Methods
214
2015
60
25680538
24
Yamada
M
J Comp Pathol
141
2009
156
19523649
25
Japanese encephalitis fact sheet 386. World Health Organisation
Accessed 06.12.2015; at
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs386/en/
2014
26
Ghosh
D
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
3
2009
e437
19787040
27
Japanese encephalitis
Accessed August, 2016; at
www.oie.int/fileadmin/Home/eng/Animal_Health_in_the_World/docs/pdf/Disease_cards/JAPANESE_ENCEPHALITIS.pdf
2013
28
Bielefeldt-Ohmann
H
Vet Res
45
2014
Eastern and Western Equine Encephalomyelitis
Synopsis
Etiology Eastern encephalitis and Western encephalitis viruses.
Epidemiology Disease limited to the Americas. Arthropod, usually mosquito-borne virus.
Mammals, including horses, are accidental hosts. Horse is dead-end host for EEE and
WEE. Case–fatality rate 5%–70%. WEE and EEE occur as sporadic cases and as outbreaks.
Both diseases affect humans.
Clinical signs Fever, muscle fasciculation, severe depression, head-pressing, incoordination,
recumbency, opisthotonus and paddling, and death.
Clinical pathology Leukopenia.
Lesions Nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis.
Diagnostic confirmation Virus isolation and identification. Identification of viral
antigen by indirect immunofluorescence. Serologic confirmation of exposure, preferably
demonstrating an increase in hemagglutination inhibition, virus neutralization, or
complement fixation titer.
Treatment No specific treatment. Supportive care.
Control Vaccination with formalin-inactivated vaccines (EEE, WEE). Insect control.
EEE, eastern equine encephalitis; WEE, western equine encephalitis.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Equine encephalomyelitis is associated with one of the two immunologically distinct
arthropod-borne alphaviruses (family Togaviridae): eastern equine encephalomyelitis
virus (EEE) and western equine encephalomyelitis virus (WEE).
•
There is one EEE virus strain, but two antigenic variants: North American and South
American.
1
•
WEE likely arose as a recombinant of EEE and Sindbis virus. There are strains of WEE
from Argentina, Brazil, and South Dakota that differ antigenically, and there are
four major lineages of WEE in California whose geographic distributions overlap.
All the viruses are extremely fragile and disappear from infected tissues within a
few hours of death. Both EEE and WEE cause disease in humans.
2
WEE is the least virulent of these viruses in horses and humans and incidence of disease
in humans appears to be declining.3, 4 Transmission cycles are depicted in Fig. 14-7
.
Fig. 14-7
Transmission cycles for infection with Western Equine Encephalitis Virus and Eastern
Equine Encephalitis Virus in the Americas.
Fig. 14-7
(reproduced with the permission of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE,
www.oie.int). Adapted from Fig. 1 of Arechiga-Ceballos N. & A. Aguilar-Setién, Alphaviral
equine encephalomyelitis (Eastern, Western and Venezuelan). In New developments in
major vector-borne diseases. Part II: Important diseases for veterinarians (S. Zientara,
D. Verwoerd & P.-P. Pastoret…, eds). Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 34 (2), page
492. doi: 10.20506/rst.34.2.2374.)
Epidemiology
These encephalitis viruses cause disease in horses, humans, pigs, and various birds
including ratites5, 6 and domestic pheasants.
Distribution
Equine eastern and western encephalomyelitis viruses are restricted to the Americas.
The two viruses have distinct geographic ranges that may overlap: EEE is restricted
to South America and North America typically east of the Mississippi River, whereas
WEE is found west of the Mississippi River and predominantly in the western United
States and Canada, although it also occurs in Florida and South America. There is
recent evidence of extension of the range of EEE into northern Maine and Vermont and
the emergence of the disease in Tennessee.6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
Viral Ecology
Humans, horses, cattle, pigs, dogs, and ratites are accidental hosts of the virus.
The EEE and WEE viruses are normally maintained in a host–vector relationship by cycling
between mosquitoes, and some other hematophagous insects, and the definitive host.
However, there are some important differences in the ecology of the different viruses.
Western Equine Encephalomyelitis
The definitive hosts of endemic WEE are wild birds, which are not clinically affected,
and the vectors are the mosquitoes C. tarsalis (in the western United States) and
Culiseta melanura (in the eastern and southern United States). Infected mosquitoes
bite susceptible birds, usually nestlings or fledglings that then develop viremia.
Mosquitoes are infected by feeding on viremic birds or by vertical transmission. Vertical
transmission is likely an important overwintering mechanism in WEE, and possibly EEE.
Epidemics of WEE are uncommon, but sporadic individual cases are not. Epidemics of
WEE are associated with factors that increase the number of infected mosquitoes or
their feeding on susceptible (unvaccinated) horses. The disease in horses occurs in
midsummer and fall, and is associated with a change in the feeding habits of C. tarsalis.
Horses, and humans, are dead-end hosts because the viremia in these species is not
sufficiently severe to allow infection of feeding mosquitoes.
Eastern Equine Encephalomyelitis
The primary maintenance cycle of EEE virus is transmission between passerine birds
by the mosquito C. melanura, an inhabitant of drainage ditches and swamps. However,
other mosquitoes, including Aedes sollicitans and A. vexans, can propagate the virus
through infection of large shore birds. The Carolina chickadee and yellow-crowned
night heron are the most common avian hosts in the southeastern United States. Virus
is detected in C. melanura and Anopheles quadrimaculatus mosquitos in Florida in February,
both of which feed on the black-crowned night heron (Nycticorax nycticorax), The yellow-crowned
night heron (Nyctanassa violacea), anhinga (Anhinga anhinga), and great blue heron
(Ardea Herodias), suggesting a means for the virus cycle to overwinter.
12
There is increasing evidence that snakes could be a reservoir for the virus, with
high seroprevalence rates for antibody to EEE.13, 14 The reservoir of the virus during
winter might involve the vertical transmission of infection to larvae that survive
the winter.
The vertebrate host in South America has not been identified, but cotton rats and
house sparrows both have the potential to be vectors.
15
The virus in North America likely has Florida as its overwintering site with subsequent
seasonal spread into other states of the United States and into Eastern Canada.1,
12
Horses are usually dead-end hosts, although viremia can be sufficiently severe in
some horses to permit infection of mosquitoes.
Epidemics of EEE have occurred in the provinces of Ontario and Quebec; in virtually
all the states of the United States east of the Mississippi River; in Arkansas, Minnesota,
South Dakota, and Texas; in many of the Caribbean Islands; in Guatemala, Mexico, and
Panama; and in Argentina, Brazil,2, 16 Columbia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Suriname,
and Venezuela. EEE continues to cause significant death losses annually in horses
in Florida, primarily in unvaccinated horses. It is suggested that the incidence of
clinical disease caused by EEE in Florida is much higher than reported, and there
is a need to increase public awareness about the importance of vaccination, particularly
in foals. Unexpected epizootics occur in inland states of the United States, and frequently
the source of the infection is undetermined, although meteorologic factors that allow
rapid movement of infected mosquitoes may be important.
5
For instance, in 1972, outbreaks of EEE occurred in Quebec, Canada, and in Connecticut,
which originated with mosquitoes carried on surface winds from Connecticut to Quebec,
a distance of 400 km, in 14 to 16 hours at a speed of 25 to 30 km/h and a temperature
of 15°C. There may be a continual cycle of EEE virus in mosquitoes and birds in the
southeastern United States, from where the virus could be distributed by infected
mosquitoes on the wind along the Gulf and Atlantic Coasts and up the Mississippi Valley.
There is an increased likelihood of detecting the virus in mosquitos near wooded areas
in Florida, an observation that is consistent with the patchy occurrence of the disease
in that state.
17
An outbreak of EEE in equids, a llama, and pheasants in Maine was associated with
unusually high numbers of C. melanura that year.
8
Animal Risk Factors
Recovered horses are resistant to infection for at least 2 years, and vaccination
confers immunity of variable duration (see under the section Control). Unvaccinated
horses are at increased risk of disease; the risk of a vaccinated horse contracting
EEE is only 0.14 that of an unvaccinated horse. The disease is more severe, and case
fatality is higher, in unvaccinated horses than in vaccinated horses. The case fatality
in young foals from nonimmune mares, which are infected with WEE, is always high,
often as high as 100%.
Housing and exposure to mosquitoes are important risk factors for EEE, and presumably
WEE. During an outbreak in 1831, only horses kept at pasture were affected. The use
of insect repellants reduces the odds of a horse being infected with EEE to 0.04 that
of an unprotected horse. Similarly, keeping horses at pasture near woods increases
the risk of disease by almost four times, and the presence of swamp land increases
the risk by over two times. Horses kept in areas with high precipitation have an increased
risk of the disease, presumably because of the density of mosquitoes in these areas.
Morbidity and Case Fatality
Morbidity varies widely depending on seasonal conditions and the prevalence of insect
vectors; cases may occur sporadically or in the form of severe outbreaks affecting
20% or more of a group. The prevalence of infections, as judged by serologic examination,
is much higher than the clinical morbidity with ~9% of horses in Quebec serologically
positive for EEE but with a much lower rate of occurrence of clinical disease.
18
The case–fatality rate differs with the strain of the virus; in infection with the
WEE virus it is usually 20% to 30% and with the EEE it is usually between 40% and
80% and may be as high as 90%.
Zoonotic Implications
The susceptibility of humans to the causative virus gives the disease great public
health importance. Humans can become infected with the EEE and the WEE virus.
2
Pathogenesis
Inapparent infection is the mildest form of the disease and may be characterized by
only a transient fever. A more severe form of the disease is manifested by tachycardia,
depression, anorexia, occasional diarrhea, and fever.
A transitory viremia occurs at the height of the fever. Penetration of the virus into
the brain does not occur in all cases, and the infection does not produce signs, other
than fever, unless involvement of the CNS occurs. The lesions produced in nervous
tissue are typical of a viral infection and are localized particularly in the gray
matter of the cerebral cortex, thalamus, and hypothalamus, with minor involvement
of the medulla and spinal cord. It is this distribution of lesions that is responsible
for the characteristic signs of mental derangement, followed at a later stage by paralysis.
The early apparent blindness and failure to eat or drink appear to be cortical in
origin. True blindness and pharyngeal paralysis occur only in the late stages.
Clinical Findings
The diseases associated with EEE and WEE viruses are clinically indistinguishable.
The incubation period for EEE is 1 to 3 days and is 2 to 9 days for WEE. Uncomplicated
disease usually lasts about 1 week. In the initial viremic stage there is fever, which
may be accompanied by anorexia and depression, but the reaction is usually so mild
that it goes unobserved. In the experimental disease, the temperature may reach 41°C
(106°F) persisting for only 24 to 48 hours, with signs of neurologic dysfunction appearing
at the peak of the fever. Animals that have signs of neurologic disease for more than
24 hours are often not pyrexic.
Initial signs of neurologic disease include hypersensitivity to sound and touch, and
in some cases transient periods of excitement and restlessness, with apparent blindness.
Horses can have a period of anorexia and colic before onset of signs of neurologic
disease. Affected horses may walk blindly into objects or walk in circles and in severe
cases can mimic signs of horses with catastrophic intestinal disease. Involuntary
muscle movements occur, especially tremor of shoulder and facial muscles and erection
of the penis. A stage of severely depressed mentation follows. Affected horses stand
with the head hung low; they appear to be asleep and may have a half-chewed mouthful
of feed hanging from the lips. At this stage the horse may eat and drink if food is
placed in its mouth. The pupillary light reflex is still present. The animal can be
aroused, but soon relapses into a state of somnolence.
A stage of paralysis follows. There is inability to hold up the head, and it is often
rested on a solid support. The lower lip is pendulous and the tongue protrudes from
the mouth. Unnatural postures are adopted, with the horse often standing with the
weight balanced on the forelegs or with the legs crossed. Head-pressing or leaning
back on a halter are often seen. On walking, there is obvious incoordination, particularly
in the hindlegs, and circling is common. Defecation and urination are suppressed,
and the horse is unable to swallow. Complete paralysis is the terminal stage. The
horse goes down, is unable to rise, and usually dies within 2 to 4 days from the first
signs of illness. A proportion of affected horses do not develop paralysis and survive,
but have persistent neurologic deficits.
Pigs
EEE causes an encephalitis and myocarditis of piglets less than 2 weeks of age. The
disease is characterized by incoordination, seizures, vomition, weight loss, and paddling.
Recovered piglets can have retarded growth.
Ratites and Pheasants
The disease in emus is characterized by vomiting, bloody diarrhea, and depression
with absent to minimal signs of neurologic disease.
5
Pheasants display signs of neurologic disease and aberrant behavior such as excessive
aggressive pecking and mortality rates of 30%.
8
Wild turkeys are rarely clinically infected, although they can become infected.
8
Clinical Pathology
There are no characteristic hematologic or biochemical abnormalities. The absence
of biochemical indication of liver disease (hyperbilirubinemia, increased activity
in serum of liver-specific enzymes such as sorbitol dehydrogenase or γ-glutamyl transferase,
absence of hyperammonemia) rules out hepatic encephalopathy.
Diagnostic confirmation is achieved by one or more of the following:
•
Isolation of virus from an affected animal
•
Detection of viral antigen or nucleic acid in an animal with appropriate clinical
signs
•
Seroconversion or an increase in serum titer of sick or recovered animal
Virus isolation provides definitive proof of infection. However, viremia may have
resolved by the time nervous signs have developed, and it can be advantageous to sample
febrile animals instead of animals showing more advanced signs of the disease. Virus
can be cultured in intracranially inoculated suckling mice, weanling mice, guinea
pigs, cell culture, newly hatched chicks, or embryonated eggs. Viral genome can be
detected, and isolates can be identified, by quantitative RT-PCR,19, 20, 21 or by
complement fixation, HI, virus neutralization, immunofluorescent assay (IFA), and
antigen capture ELISA.
Acute and convalescent sera taken 10 to 14 days apart for the presence of neutralizing,
hemagglutination-inhibiting, or complement-fixing antibodies in the serum of affected
or in-contact horses, is of value in detecting the presence of the virus in the group
or in the area. A fourfold increase in complement-fixing antibodies is considered
positive.
Demonstration of viral nucleic acid in tissue, blood, or insects by PCR test may be
a useful indicator of the presence of the virus. There may be sufficient viral antigen
to be detected by ELISA in clinical material, and this may provide a useful test in
the early stages of an epidemic.
The presence of a high HI, complement fixation and neutralizing antibody in a single
serum sample obtained from a horse during the acute phase of illness associated with
the WEE virus can be used as presumptive evidence of infection with this virus. However,
antibodies against the WEE virus can persist for years, are produced after vaccination
with WEE or WEE/EEE bivalent vaccines, and in foals might be caused by colostral immunity.
Therefore a single serum sample cannot be used to make a confirmed diagnosis of WEE
using the HI, complement fixation or neutralization tests. Horses infected experimentally
or naturally with either the WEE or the EEE virus do not produce detectable HI or
neutralizing antibody for 5 to 10 days after infection.
Circulating antibody appears on or near the day of onset of clinical illness. Infection
with the WEE virus results in the production of serum IgM specific to WEE, and the
ELISA test is a rapid, sensitive, and specific test for IgM against WEE and EEE viruses.
Additionally, the ratio of titers of EEE and WEE can be useful in detecting infection
by EEE; ratios of >8 : 1 are highly suggestive of EEE infection.
Necropsy Findings
The brain meninges may appear congested, but there are generally no gross changes.
Histologic examination of the brain reveals perivascular accumulations of leukocytes
and damage to neurons. The gray matter of the forebrain and midbrain are the most
severely affected areas. Lesions associated with EEE antigen are also present in myocardium,
stomach, intestine, urinary bladder, and spleen.
Cell culture and transmission experiments using brain tissue as an inoculum are the
traditional means of confirming a diagnosis and require that the brain be removed
within an hour of death. Transmission is by intracerebral inoculation of brain tissue
into sucking mice or duck embryo tissue culture. Fluorescent antibody tests have been
developed to detect EEE virus in brain tissue. A PCR-based diagnostic test is available
for EEE virus. Lesions similar to those seen in horses have also been described in
a beef cow infected with EEE. The disease in piglets is characterized by disseminated
perivascular cuffing, gliosis, focal necrosis of the cerebral cortex, and multifocal
myocardial necrosis.
Samples for Postmortem Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Half of midsagittally sectioned brain and liver and spleen should be submitted for
fluorescent antibody and PCR testing, virus isolation and bioassay.
•
Half of midsagittally sectioned brain, fixed in formalin, should be submitted for
light microscopic examination.
Note the zoonotic potential of these organisms when handling the carcass and submitting
specimens.
Differential Diagnosis
Clinically, the disease has very great similarity to the other viral encephalomyelitides,
from which it can often be discriminated by the geographic location of the horse,
and to the hepatic encephalopathies and a number of other diseases (see later and
in Table 14-12).
West Nile encephalitis is predominantly a myelitis with later development of signs
of neurologic disease, whereas EEE and WEE have predominant signs of encephalopathy.
•
Rabies.
•
Borna disease (occurs in Europe).
•
Japanese encephalitis (occurs in Asia).
•
Various other viral infections that are geographically restricted.
•
Hepatic encephalopathy, such as that associated with poisoning by Crotalaria, Senecio,
and Amsinckia spp.; acute serum hepatitis or hepatopathy.
•
Botulism causes weakness evident as muscle fasciculation, recumbency, and dysphagia,
but does not cause cerebral signs (irritation, behavioral abnormalities).
•
Yellow star thistle poisoning (Centaurea solstitialis, and poisoning by fumonisins
(Fusarium moniliforme) can produce similar clinical signs to that of the encephalitides,
with the exception of fever.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no definitive or specific treatment. Supportive treatment may be given with
the intention to prevent self-inflicted injury and maintain hydration and nutritional
status.
Control
Control of viral encephalomyelitis of horses is based on the following:
•
Accurate clinical and laboratory diagnosis of the disease in horses
•
Use of sentinel animals to monitor the presence of the virus in the region
•
Quarantine of infected horses to stop movement of virus donors
•
Insect abatement when deemed necessary
•
Vaccination of all horses.
Vaccination
Vaccination of horses is important for the control of EEE and VEE.3, 22 Formalin-inactivated
EEE and WEE virus vaccines are available (see Table 14-14 in Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis)
and are effective, although over 50% of horses with EEE had been vaccinated within
the previous year. This apparent poor protection can be explained by many horses not
developing a detectable change in antibody titer after vaccination with a bivalent
vaccine and rapid decreases in antibody titer from a peak value achieved 2 to 4 weeks
after vaccination. Vaccines are available as univalent or bivalent preparations and
in combination with other antigens (for instance, tetanus toxoid). Horses should be
vaccinated well in advance of the anticipated encephalomyelitis season in a given
area. Vaccination against both strains of the virus is advisable in areas where the
strain has not been identified or where both strains exist. The currently recommended
vaccination schedule consists of two doses of the vaccine initially, 10 days apart,
followed by annual revaccination using two or three doses.
22
Annual revaccination is currently recommended because the duration of effective immunity
beyond 1 year is not known. It is probable that the initial two-dose vaccination lasts
for up to 3 to 4 years. The emphasis in a vaccination program should be on the young
horses.
Colostral antibody can be detected in the blood of foals from vaccinated dams for
up to 6 to 7 months, after which time it declines rapidly. Foals from vaccinated dams
should be vaccinated at 6 to 8 months of age and revaccinated at 1 year of age. Foals
from unvaccinated dams may be vaccinated at 2 to 3 months of age and again at 1 year
of age. Colostral antibodies in the foal will prevent the development of autogenous
antibodies, and foals vaccinated when less than 6 months should be revaccinated when
they are 1 year old or, in high-risk areas. Foals from vaccinated mares should be
vaccinated at 3, 4, and 6 months of age.
Experimental DNA vaccines hold promise for the prevention of WEE.
Protection From Insects
Housing of horses indoors at night, especially in fly-proofed stables, and the use
of insect repellents may restrain the spread of the virus. Use of insect repellents
decreases the risk of EEE in horses to 0.04 that of unprotected horses.
Widespread spraying of insecticides to reduce the population of the vector insects
has been used in the control of VEE; however, such measures are not practical for
preventing sporadic cases of EEE or WEE, and the environmental impact of widespread
insecticide use should be considered.
Complete eradication of the virus appears to be impossible because of the enzootic
nature of the ecology of the virus. The horse is an accidental host for EEE and WEE
virus making elimination of the virus impossible with methods currently available.
Zoonotic Aspects of Control
Control of the disease in humans in areas where the disease may occur is dependent
on insect control, and a monitoring and surveillance early warning system is necessary
to decide whether or not to take control measures. In areas where WEE occurs, clinical
cases of the disease in unvaccinated horses usually precede the occurrence of the
disease in humans. The establishment of a reporting system in which practicing veterinarians
report all clinical cases of the disease in horses will also assist in predicting
potential epidemics of WEE virus infection in the human population. Serologic surveys
of wildlife may also serve as good indicators of the geographic distribution and seasonality
of circulation of these viruses and provide an early warning system before the detection
of human cases.
Further Reading
Arechiga-Ceballos
N
Alphaviral equine encephalomyelitis (Eastern, Western and Venezuelan)
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
34
2015
491
510
26601451
Long
MT
West Nile virus and equine encephalitis viruses new perspectives
Vet Clin North Am Equine Practice
30
2014
523
533
25441112
References
1
White
GS
Am J Trop Med Hyg
84
2011
709
21540379
2
Carrera
J-P
N Engl J Med
369
2013
732
23964935
3
Arechiga-Ceballos
N
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
34
2015
491
26601451
4
Zacks
MA
Vet Microbiol
140
2010
281
19775836
5
Chenier
S
Can Vet J
51
2010
1011
21119870
6
Saxton-Shaw
KD
PLoS ONE
10
2015
e0128712
26043136
7
Mukherjee
S
J Med Entomol
49
2012
731
22679883
8
Lubelczyk
C
Am J Trop Med Hyg
88
2013
95
23208877
9
Lubelczyk
C
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
14
2014
77
24359417
10
Molaei
G
Parasit Vectors
8
2015
516
26453283
11
Mutebi
J-P
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
15
2015
210
25793477
12
Bingham
AM
Am J Trop Med Hyg
91
2014
685
25070997
13
White
G
Am J Trop Med Hyg
85
2011
421
21896798
14
Graham
SP
Am J Trop Med Hyg
86
2012
540
22403333
15
Arrigo
NC
Emerg Infect Dis
16
2010
1373
20735920
16
de Novaes Oliveira
R
Arch Virol
159
2014
2615
24862186
17
Vander Kelen
PT
Int J Health Geogr
11
2012
47
23126615
18
Rocheleau
J-P
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
13
2013
712
23919607
19
Armstrong
PM
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
12
2012
872
22835151
20
Brault
AC
J Med Entomol
52
2015
491
26334826
21
Zink
SD
Diag Microbiol Infect Dis
77
2013
129
22
Long
MT
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
30
2014
523
25441112
Venezuelan Equine Encephalomyelitis
Synopsis
Etiology Venezuelan encephalitis virus (types IAB, IC, and, to a lesser extent, IE),
an alphavirus.
Epidemiology Disease limited to the Americas. Arthropod-borne, usually mosquito-borne,
virus. VEE occurs as epidemics associated with mutation of virus and associated movement
from enzootic to epizootic cycles. Virus cycles between sylvatic rodents (and probably
not birds) and mosquitos in enzootic areas. Equids and humans are amplifying hosts
important in propagation of VEE in epizootics. Care–fatality rate 5%–70% for equids.
Clinical findings Fever, muscle fasciculation, severe depression, head-pressing, incoordination,
recumbency, opisthotonus and paddling, and death.
Clinical pathology Leukopenia.
Lesions Nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis.
Diagnostic confirmation Virus isolation and identification. RT-PCR provides more rapid
identification of virus. Identification of viral antigen by indirect immunofluorescence.
Serologic confirmation of exposure, preferably demonstrating an increase in hemagglutination
inhibition, virus neutralization, or complement fixation titer.
Treatment No specific treatment. Supportive care.
Control Vaccination with formalin-inactivated or modified live virus is effective.
Vaccines being developed with newer technologies. Insect control.
RT-PCR, reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Venezuelan equine encephalomyelitis (VEE) is associated with an arthropod-borne alphavirus
(family Togaviridae) VEE. The VEE complex has one virus, VEE, with six antigenically
related subtypes: I, VEE; II, Everglades; III, Mucambo; IV, Pixuna; V, Cabassou; and
VI, AG80-663. Within subtype I are at least five variants (IAB, IC, ID, IE, and IF).
Epidemic (pathogenic) VEE in horses is associated with variants IAB (originally identified
as distinct variants, A and B are now considered the same variant) IC, and IE; all
other subtypes of I (D-F), and other variants of VEE virus (II-VI), are usually nonpathogenic
for horses and are found in sylvatic or enzootic, nonequine cycles, although they
can cause disease in humans.
1
The pathogenic variant, IAB, has been detected in cryptic circulation up to 8 years
after an epizootic.
2
The infection cycles between rodents and mosquitos as an enzootic cycle not associated
with disease in equids or humans (Fig. 14-8
). Birds might be involved in this enzootic cycling. Disease occurs when pathogenic
variants of the virus become established and cycle between humans or horses, both
of which have high levels of viremia, and mosquitos.1, 3
Fig. 14-8
Epidemiology of Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis virus in enzootic (endemic) and epizootic
(epidemic) cycles. Note the need for mutation of the virus for development and establishment
of epizootics.
Fig. 14-8
(reproduced with the permission of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE,
www.oie.int). Adapted from Fig. 1 of Arechiga-Ceballos N. & A. Aguilar-Setién, Alphaviral
equine encephalomyelitis (Eastern, Western and Venezuelan). In New developments in
major vector-borne diseases. Part II: Important diseases for veterinarians (S. Zientara,
D. Verwoerd & P.-P. Pastoret…, eds). Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 34 (2), page
492. doi: 10.20506/rst.34.2.2374.)
Outbreaks of disease in horses and humans occur infrequently, but can affect large
numbers of equids and humans when they do occur. Outbreaks were documented in Mexico
in 1993 and 1996, and in Venezuela and Columbia in the autumn of 1995. The Columbian
outbreak affected 90,000 people and killed an estimated 4000 horses. The strain involved
in the Columbian outbreak was IC, whereas that involved in the Mexican outbreaks was
a variant of the usually nonpathogenic IE. The outbreak in Mexico was associated with
a variant of VEE that did not cause viremia in horses, although it was capable of
causing neurologic disease in this species, and it might have been this attribute
that abbreviated the course of the epidemic. There is evidence of continuing enzootic
circulation of VEE IE in southern Mexico.4, 5
The virus is extremely fragile and disappears from infected tissues within a few hours
of death.
Epidemiology
Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus infects a range of species including rodents,
humans, equids, cattle and dogs.
5
It causes disease in humans and equids.
Distribution
Pathogenic or epizootic VEE is found in northern South America, Central America, Mexico
and, rarely, in the southern United States. The epizootic variants are currently exotic
to the United States. Enzootic VEE strains have been identified in the Florida Everglades
(subtype II), Mexico (variant IE), Central American countries (variant IE), Panama
(variants ID and IE), Venezuela (variant ID), Colombia (variant ID), Peru (variants
ID, IIIC, and IIID), French Guiana (variant IIIB and subtype V), Ecuador (variant
ID), Suriname (variant IIIA), Trinidad (variant IIIA), Brazil (variants IF and IIIA
and subtype IV), and Argentina (subtype VI). In an atypical ecologic niche, variant
IIIB has been isolated in the United States (Colorado and South Dakota) in an unusual
association with birds.
3
Viral Ecology
VEE exists as both nonpathogenic and pathogenic strains. Nonpathogenic VEE viruses
persist in sylvatic cycles in northern South America, Central America, and parts of
the southern United States, and are important because they are the source of the epizootic
strains of the virus that emerge at infrequent intervals. The enzootic strains also
confound the diagnosis of VEE because of the extensive serologic cross-reactivity
among endemic and epidemic VEE viruses. However, recent advances in diagnostic techniques
may have solved this diagnostic problem. The nonpathogenic viruses are maintained
in rodents associated with swamps, and transmitted by mosquitoes of the genus Culex,
and perhaps other hematophagous insects. Humans, horses, cattle, pigs, dogs, and ratites
are accidental hosts of the virus. Epidemics of VEE occur irregularly, the latest
being in northern Columbia in 1995, and Mexico in 1993 and 1996. The source of virus
during outbreaks is infected horses. Horses develop a profound viremia and are amplifying
hosts that aid in the spread of the epizootic; other domestic species, including cattle,
pigs, and goats, are not considered to be amplifiers of the virus. During epizootics,
all species of mosquitoes that feed on horses, including Aedes, Psorophora, and Deinocerites
species, are thought to be capable of spreading the infection, although O. taeniorhynchus
is thought to be the principal vector responsible for transmission of VEE virus during
outbreaks, whereas Culex (Melanoconion) species mosquitoes transmit enzootic strains
of VEE virus.
6
Epizootics end as the population of susceptible horses decreases below a critical
level, either by death or vaccination. The reservoir of the virus between outbreaks,
which may be up to 19 years, was unknown until it was demonstrated that epidemic VEE
type IAB virus arises by mutation of endemic strains (types ID-F and II-VI), or that
type IE (enzootic) mutates into an epizootic form serologically very similar to IE.
This mutation of the endemic virus into the epidemic form has occurred on at least
three occasions associated with epidemics of VEE. It is likely that pathogenic strains
of VEE will continue to emerge in areas where the nonpathogenic strains of the virus
are endemic.
Animal Risk Factors
Recovered horses are resistant to infection for at least 2 years, and vaccination
confers immunity of variable duration (see under the section Control). Housing and
exposure to mosquitoes are important risk factors for EEE, and presumably VEE.
Morbidity varies widely depending on seasonal conditions and the prevalence of insect
vectors; cases may occur sporadically or in the form of severe outbreaks affecting
20% or more of a group. The prevalence of infections, as judged by serologic examination,
is much higher than the clinical morbidity; for example, up to 72% of horses examined
in the Gulf region of Mexico had antibodies to VEE virus (variant IE).
5
Only 0.8% of horses in Trinidad have serologic evidence of infection.
7
The case–fatality rate is usually 40% to 80% and may be as high as 90% with VEE.
Zoonotic Implications
The susceptibility of humans to the causative virus gives the disease great public
health importance. Humans can become infected with sylvatic and epizootic VEE subtypes.
A recent outbreak of VEE in Columbia caused 75,000 human cases, 300 fatalities, and
killed approximately 4000 horses. Human infections generally follow equine infections
by approximately 2 weeks. The infection in humans is usually a mild, influenza-like
illness in which recovery occurs spontaneously. When clinical encephalitis does occur,
it is usually in very young or older people. Occurrence of the disease in humans can
be limited by the use of a vaccine in horses, thus limiting the occurrence of the
disease in horses in the area. There is a strong relationship between the mosquito
population and the incidence of the disease in horses and in humans. The occurrence
of the disease in humans may be predicted by an unusually high activity of virus in
mosquitoes. There are usually, but not always, widespread mortalities in horses before
the disease occurs in humans. VEE infections, and disease, of epizootic or enzootic
virus have occurred among laboratory workers as a result of aerosol infections from
laboratory accidents, from handling of infected laboratory animals, or inhalation
of cage debris of infected laboratory animals.
3
Human VEE virus infections have originated by aerosol transmission from the cage debris
of infected laboratory rodents and from laboratory accidents. Those who handle infectious
VEE viruses or their antigens prepared from infected tissues or cell cultures should
be vaccinated and shown to have demonstrable immunity in the form of a VEE virus-specific
neutralizing antibody.
All procedures producing aerosols from VEE virus materials should be conducted in
biosafety cabinets at containment level 3.
3
VEEV viruses are highly infectious via the aerosol route for humans and has been developed
as a biologic weapon in the United States and in the former Soviet Union.
6
The TC83 live attenuated VEE virus vaccine may be teratogenic in humans.
Pathogenesis
Inapparent infection is the mildest form of the disease and may be characterized by
only a transient fever. A more severe form of the disease is manifested by tachycardia,
depression, anorexia, occasional diarrhea, and fever.
Viremia persists throughout the course of the disease in VEE, and the blood provides
a source of infection for biting insects. Transplacental transmission of the VEE virus
can occur in pregnant mares infected near term. The virus is present in saliva and
nasal discharge, and this material can be used to transmit the disease experimentally
by intranasal instillation.
Penetration of the virus into the brain does not occur in all cases and the infection
does not produce signs, other than fever, unless involvement of the CNS occurs. The
lesions produced in nervous tissue are typical of a viral infection and are localized
particularly in the gray matter of the cerebral cortex, thalamus, and hypothalamus,
with minor involvement of the medulla and spinal cord. It is this distribution of
lesions that is responsible for the characteristic signs of mental derangement, followed
at a later stage by paralysis. The early apparent blindness and failure to eat or
drink appear to be cortical in origin. True blindness and pharyngeal paralysis occur
only in the late stages.
Clinical Findings
The diseases associated with the different viruses are clinically indistinguishable.
The incubation period for VEE is 1 to 6 days. Uncomplicated disease usually lasts
about 1 week. In the initial viremic stage there is fever, which may be accompanied
by anorexia and depression, but the reaction is usually so mild that it goes unobserved.
In the experimental disease, the temperature may reach 41°C (106°F) persisting for
only 24 to 48 hours, with nervous signs appearing at the peak of the fever. Animals
that have shown nervous signs for more than 24 hours may then have a temperature within
the normal range.
Early nervous signs include hypersensitivity to sound and touch, and in some cases
transient periods of excitement and restlessness, with apparent blindness. Affected
horses may walk blindly into objects or walk in circles. Involuntary muscle movements
occur, especially tremor of shoulder and facial muscles and erection of the penis.
A stage of severe mental depression follows. Affected horses stand with the head hung
low; they appear to be asleep and may have a half-chewed mouthful of feed hanging
from the lips. At this stage the horse may eat and drink if food is placed in its
mouth. The pupillary light reflex is still present. The animal can be aroused, but
soon relapses into a state of somnolence.
A stage of paralysis follows. There is inability to hold up the head, and it is often
rested on a solid support. The lower lip is pendulous and the tongue may hang out.
Unnatural postures are adopted, with the horse often standing with the weight balanced
on the forelegs or with the legs crossed. Head-pressing or leaning back on a halter
are often seen. On walking, there is obvious incoordination, particularly in the hindlegs,
and circling is common. Defecation and urination are suppressed, and the horse is
unable to swallow. Complete paralysis is the terminal stage. The horse goes down,
is unable to rise, and usually dies within 2 to 4 days from the first signs of illness.
A proportion of affected horses do not develop paralysis and survive but have persistent
neurologic deficits.
In the experimental infection of horses with the endemic strain of the VEE virus,
a fever and mild leukopenia occurs. Following infection with the epidemic strain of
the virus, a high fever and severe leukopenia are common, and a high level of neutralizing
antibodies develop about 5 to 6 days after infection. Clinical findings include profound
depression, accompanied by flaccidity of lips, partially closed eyelids, and drooped
ears; some horses chew continuously and froth at the mouth. In the terminal stages,
there is recumbency and nystagmus.
Clinical Pathology
There are no characteristic hematologic or biochemical abnormalities. The absence
of biochemical indication of liver disease (hyperbilirubinemia, increased activity
in serum of liver-specific enzymes such as sorbitol dehydrogenase and γ-glutamyl transferase,
absence of hyperammonemia) rules out hepatic encephalopathy.
Diagnostic confirmation is achieved by one or more of the following:
•
Isolation of virus from an affected animal
•
Detection of viral antigen or nucleic acid in an animal with appropriate clinical
signs
•
Seroconversion or an increase in serum titer of sick or recovered animal.
Virus isolation provides definitive proof of infection. However, viremia may have
resolved by the time nervous signs have developed, and it may be advantageous to sample
febrile animals instead of animals showing more advanced signs of the disease. Virus
can be cultured in intracranially inoculated suckling mice, weanling mice, guinea
pigs, cell culture, newly hatched chicks, or embryonated eggs. Virus isolates can
be identified by complement fixation, HI, virus neutralization, PCR, IFA, and antigen
capture ELISA. A recently developed indirect fluorescent test using monoclonal antibodies
enables the differentiation of endemic from epidemic strains of VEE. Interpretation
of the results of serologic tests of horses in an area where endemic, nonpathogenic
VEE virus exists is difficult because of the cross-reaction between endemic and epidemic
strains of the virus. Therefore in areas where there is endemic, nonpathogenic VEE,
demonstration of the presence of antibodies should not be considered persuasive evidence
of the presence of the disease.
Acute and convalescent sera taken 10 to 14 days apart for the presence of neutralizing,
hemagglutination-inhibiting, or complement-fixing antibodies in the serum of affected
or in-contact horses, is of value in detecting the presence of the virus in the group
or in the area. A fourfold increase in complement-fixing antibodies is considered
positive.
Demonstration of viral nucleic acid in tissue, blood, or insects by PCR test is a
useful indicator of the presence of the virus.
8
Use of modern bioinformatic techniques can enable viral genotyping, facilitating diagnosis
and forensic and epidemiologic investigations.
9
There can be sufficient viral antigen to be detected by ELISA in clinical material,
and this may provide a useful test in the early stages of an epidemic.
Necropsy Findings
The brain meninges may appear congested, but there are generally no gross changes.
Histologic examination of the brain reveals perivascular accumulations of leukocytes
and damage to neurons. The gray matter of the forebrain and midbrain are the most
severely affected areas. In some cases of VEE, liquefactive necrosis and hemorrhage
are visible in the cerebral cortex. Cell culture and transmission experiments using
brain tissue as an inoculum are the traditional means of confirming a diagnosis and
require that the brain be removed within an hour of death. Transmission is by intracerebral
inoculation of brain tissue into sucking mice or duck embryo tissue culture. Fluorescent
antibody tests have been developed to detect VEE virus and EEE virus in brain tissue.
Samples for Postmortem Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Half of midsagittally sectioned brain and liver and spleen should be submitted for
fluorescent antibody and PCR testing, virus isolation and bioassay.
•
Half of midsagittally sectioned brain, fixed in formalin, should be submitted for
light microscopic examination.
Note the zoonotic potential of these organisms when handling the carcass and submitting
specimens.
Differential Diagnosis
Clinically, the disease has very great similarity to the other viral encephalomyelitides,
from which it can often be discriminated by the geographic location of the horse,
and to the hepatic encephalopathies and a number of other diseases (see next).
•
Rabies.
•
West Nile virus encephalomyelitis.
•
Hendra disease (occurs in Australia).
•
Borna disease (occurs in Europe).
•
Japanese encephalitis (occurs in Asia).
•
Various other viral infections that are geographically restricted.
•
Hepatic encephalopathy, such as that associated with poisoning by Crotalaria, Senecio,
and Amsinckia spp.; acute serum hepatitis or hepatopathy.
•
Botulism causes weakness that is evident as muscle fasciculation, recumbency, and
dysphagia, but does not cause cerebral signs (irritation, behavioral abnormalities).
•
Yellow star thistle poisoning (Centaurea solstitialis) and poisoning by fumonisins
can produce similar clinical signs to that of the encephalitides, with the exception
of fever.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
There is no definitive or specific treatment. Supportive treatment may be given with
the intention to prevent self-inflicted injury and maintain hydration and nutritional
status.
Control
Control of VEE of horses is based on the following:
•
Accurate clinical and laboratory diagnosis of the disease in horses
•
Use of sentinel animals to monitor the presence of the virus in the region
•
Quarantine of infected horses to stop movement of virus donors
•
Insect abatement when deemed necessary
•
Vaccination of all horses
Vaccination
Vaccination of horses is important not only because it minimizes the risk of disease
in vaccinated horses but also because it prevents viremia, subsequent infection of
feeding mosquitoes, and propagation spread of VEE. There are a number of commercial
vaccines available (Table 14-12
).
Table 14-12
Commercial vaccines against alphaviral equine encephalomyelitis available for equines
Table 14-12
Name*
Uses
Administration**
Equiloid Innovator: Encephalomyelitis vaccine-tetanus toxoid
For the vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis
caused by Eastern and Western viruses, and tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
Fluvac Innovator 4Encephalomyelitis-influenza vaccine-tetanus toxoid
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis
caused by Eastern and Western viruses, equine influenza from type A2 viruses, and
tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
Fluvac Innovator 5Encephalomyelitis-rhinopneumonitis-influenza vaccine-tetanus toxoid
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis
caused by Eastern and Western viruses, equine rhinopneumonitis caused by type 1 and
4 herpesviruses, equine influenza caused by type A2 viruses, and tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
Fluvac Innovator 6Encephalomyelitis-rhinopneumonitis-influenza vaccine-tetanus toxoid
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis
caused by Eastern, Western, and Venezuelan viruses, equine rhinopneumonitis caused
by type 1 and 4 herpesviruses, equine influenza caused by type A2 viruses, and tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
Fluvac Innovator Triple-E FTEncephalomyelitis-influenza vaccine-tetanus toxoid
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis
caused by Eastern, Western, and Venezuelan viruses, equine influenza caused by type
A2 viruses, and tetanus
Inject one 1 mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
Triple-E T InnovatorEncephalomyelitis vaccine-tetanus toxoid
For intramuscular vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of equine
encephalomyelitis caused by Eastern, Western, and Venezuelan viruses, and tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
WEST Nile Innovator + EWEncephalomyelitis-West Nile virus vaccine
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of viremia caused by
West Nile virus, and as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis caused
by Eastern and Western viruses
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
West Nile Innovator + EWTEncephalomyelitis-West Nile virus-tetanus toxoid
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of viremia caused by
West Nile virus, and as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis caused
by Eastern and Western viruses and tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
West Nile-Innovator + VEWTEncephalomyelitis-West Nile virus-tetanus toxoid
For vaccination of healthy horses as an aid in the prevention of viremia caused by
West Nile virus, and as an aid in the prevention of equine encephalomyelitis caused
by Eastern, Western, and Venezuelan viruses and tetanus
Inject one 1-mL dose intramuscularly using aseptic techniqueAdminister a second 1-mL
dose 3–4 weeks after the first dose
*
Commercial name and vaccine components
**
Recommended vaccination protocol
One of the most important aspects of the control of VEE is the vaccination of the
horse population to minimize the number of horses that are viremic and serve as amplifying
hosts. A tissue culture-attenuated virus vaccine, TC83, is available for immunization
of horses against VEE. The vaccine is considered to be safe and efficacious. Concerns
about reversion to virulence and safety have prompted the development of DNA and chimeric
vaccines, of which a number of experimental vaccines are reported.10, 11, 12, 13,
14, 15 The World Organization for Animal Health specifies vaccination by the TC83
attenuated virus vaccine or a formalin-killed virus vaccine.
3
A highly effective immunity is produced within a few days following vaccination, and
serum-neutralizing antibodies persist for 20 to 30 months. The vaccine causes a mild
fever, leukopenia, and a viremia and, because of conflicting reports about its capacity
to cause abortion, should not be used in pregnant mares. Antibodies to the heterologous
alphaviruses, WEE and EEE, existing at the time of TC83 vaccination, may suppress
the VEE antibody response to the vaccine. However, the response to the vaccine is
adequate to provide protection against VEE, and the interference is not considered
significant. There is inconclusive evidence that WEE and EEE antibodies protect horses
against infection with virulent VEE virus, or conversely that VEE antibodies protect
against infection with WEE and EEE viruses. Simultaneous vaccination using formalin-inactivated
EEE, WEE, and VEE (the TC83 strain of VEE) is effective and recommended in areas where
all three viruses may be present.
Protection From Insects
Housing of horses indoors at night, especially in fly-proofed stables, and the use
of insect repellents might restrain the spread of the virus.
Widespread spraying of insecticides to reduce the population of the vector insects
has been used in the control of VEE in humans, along with vaccination of horses. Complete
eradication of the virus appears to be impossible because of the enzootic nature of
the ecology of the virus: epidemic VEE arising by chance mutation of endemic strains
of VEE, makes elimination of the virus impossible with methods currently available.
References
1
Arechiga-Ceballos
N
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
34
2015
491
26601451
2
Medina
G
Am J Trop Med Hyg
93
2015
7
25940191
3
Venezuelan equine encephalitis. OIE
Accessed August, 2016; at
www.oie.int/fileadmin/Home/eng/Animal_Health_in_the_World/docs/pdf/Disease_cards/VEE.pdf
2008
4
Deardorff
ER
Am J Trop Med Hyg
82
2010
1047
20519599
5
Adams
AP
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
6
2012
31875
6
Zacks
MA
Vet Microbiol
140
2010
281
19775836
7
Thompson
NN
Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis
12
2012
969
22989182
8
Belen Pisano
M
J Virol Methods
186
2012
203
22609888
9
Gardner
SN
J Virol Methods
193
2013
112
23714768
10
Paessler
S
Vaccine
27
2009
D80
19837294
11
Fine
DL
J Virol Methods
163
2010
424
19903494
12
Dupuy
LC
Clin Vaccine Immunol
18
2011
707
21450977
13
Tretyakova
I
Vaccine
31
2013
1019
23287629
14
Carossino
M
Vaccine
32
2014
311
24295803
15
Rossi
SL
PLoS Negl Trop Dis
9
2015
e0003797
26020513
Equid Herpesvirus-1 Myeloencephalopathy, Abortion, and Neonatal Septicemia
Synopsis
Etiology EHV-1 causes respiratory disease of adults, abortion, neonatal septicemia,
and myeloencephalopathy. Infection by specific variants of the virus increases the
likelihood of the clinically important manifestations of infection—myeloencephalopathy
and/or abortion.
Epidemiology Transmission between horses and by mediate contagion. Lifelong latency
of infection with periodic reactivation of virus shedding. Respiratory disease, abortion,
and myeloencephalopathy occur prominently as outbreaks, but can affect sole animals.
Clinical signs Upper respiratory disease, abortion, neonatal septicemia, and neurologic
disease with incontinence, ataxia, and recumbency.
Clinical pathology No pathogenic changes in hemogram or serum biochemistry profile.
Detection of viral DNA and variant genotyping by RT-PCR in nasal swabs or white blood
cells, seroconversion or increase in titer using an ELISA able to differentiate between
EHV-1 and EHV-4.
Diagnostic confirmation Virus isolation from, or polymerase chain reaction test on,
blood, nasopharyngeal swabs or tissue. Seroconversion or increase in titer.
Treatment There is no specific treatment, although acyclovir, an antiviral agent,
has been administered. Symptomatic treatment of neurologic signs in horses with myeloencephalopathy.
Control Infection is ubiquitous. Management including quarantine, maintaining mares
in small bands, and education of staff about importance of control measures to prevent
outbreaks of abortion or myeloencephalopathy. Vaccination for prevention of abortion.
Quarantine. Hygiene.
EHV-1, equid herphesvirus-1; RT-PCR, reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Herpesviruses infecting equids (such as horses, donkeys, mules, and zebra) are all
viruses with a linear, double-stranded DNA genome in the order Herpesvirales, family
Herpesviridae.
1
Equid herpesviruses (EHV)-1, 3, 4, 8 (syn. asinine herpesvirus-3), and 9 (a virus
infecting gazelle) are Alphaherpesvirinae (alphaherpesviruses) in the genus Varicellovirus.
EHV-6 (syn. asinine herpesvirus-1) is tentatively assigned to this genus. EHV-2, 5,
and 7 (syn. asinine herpesvirus-2) are Gammaherpesvirinae (gammaherpesviruses).
1
There is also a zebra gammaherpesvirus, which appears to be associated with disease
in nonequids housed in proximity to zebras (see later).2, 3
Five herpesviruses have been associated with various diseases of horses and foals
(EHV-1 to 5). Common names are “equine abortion virus” for EHV-1, “cytomegalovirus”
for EHV-2, “equine coital exanthema virus” for EHV-3, and “rhinopneumonitis virus”
for EHV-4 (although this term is sometimes used, confusingly, for EHV-1). Related
herpesviruses (asinine herpesvirus-1 to 6, some of which have been recently classified
or identified as EHVs
1
) infect, and some cause disease in, donkeys, mules, or horses.4, 5, 6, 7 Some asinine
herpesviruses cause a fatal interstitial pneumonia or neurologic disease in donkeys.
8
Infection by EHV-1, EHV-4, or both is common, if not ubiquitous, in equids worldwide
with most animals infected while juveniles and latent virus in trigeminal ganglia
9
and other tissues maintaining that infection. EHV-4 causes respiratory disease and,
rarely, abortion. EHV-1 causes respiratory disease but also causes individual cases
or outbreaks of myeloencephalopathy, abortion, and neonatal septicemia. Certain variants
of EHV-1, detectable by examination of viral genome, are associated with increased
risk of myeloencephalopathy, abortion, or both.
A partial list of disease syndromes attributed to EHV and asinine herpesvirus infection
and the viruses associated with them include the following:
•
Upper respiratory tract disease of adult horses, weanlings, and older foals is caused
principally by EHV-4, although disease attributable to EHV-1 occurs. EHV-2 causes
respiratory disease, including pneumonia, of foals, and rarely upper respiratory disease
of adults.
•
Abortion in horses is almost always associated with EHV-1, although rare sporadic
cases are associated with EHV-4. EHV-7 (syn. asinine herpesvirus-2, a gammaherpesvirus)
was associated with abortion in a donkey.
4
•
Perinatal disease of foals, including birth of sick and weak foals and development
of viral septicemia within 48 hours of birth, is associated with EHV-1.
•
EHV-1 myeloencephalopathy (EHM) is associated with EHV-1 and rarely, if ever, with
EHV-4. In donkeys it has been associated with an asinine gammaherpesvirus.
8
•
Coital exanthema is associated with EHV-3, and genital disease is an unusual manifestation
of EHV-1 infection.
•
Equine multinodular pulmonary fibrosis in horses is associated with infection by EHV-5.10,
11
•
Lymphoma in horses is tentatively associated with infection by EHV-5.12, 13
•
Chorioretinitis is associated with EHV-1 infection.
14
•
Dermatitis (erythema multiforme) is associated with EHV-5 infection in horses.
15
•
Neurologic disease or abortion in gazelle, onagers, and polar bears is caused by EHV-9
or EHV-1 originating from zebra.2, 3, 16, 17
The following discussion focuses on myeloencephalopathy, abortion, and neonatal septicemia
in equids associated with infection by EHV-1. Respiratory disease caused by EHV-4
and EHV-1 is discussed elsewhere in this text as are other manifestations of EHV infection.
Etiology
EHV-1 is an alphaherpesvirus, a DNA virus with 76 ORFs. EHV-1 and EHV-4 are closely
related and have extensive antigenic cross-reactivity but are genetically and biologically
distinct viruses with different disease profiles.18, 19 Phylogenetic mapping (“trees”)
and genetic fingerprinting for EHV-1 are not available, as they are for many other
viruses (see the section on Equine Influenza in Chapter 12 as an example), and are
needed to investigate links between outbreaks and associations with virulence.
Although EHV-1 virus is genetically stable, with limited genetic divergence and differences
in strains of less than 0.1%, genetic variants of EHV-1 exist and some have differing
biologic characteristics.
20
Analysis of ORF 68 reveals at least 19 distinct DNA sequences allowing identification
of 6 major strain groups of EHV-1.
20
Importantly, a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) (A-G) at position 2254 in the
DNA polymerase gene (DNApol, ORF 30) that results in substitution of asparagine (N)
by aspartic acid (D) at position 752 in the DNA polymerase protein is not limited
to any one strain. Variants of the virus are therefore classified as N752 or D752,
irrespective of the particular strain.
20
This suggests that the D752/N752 mutation has occurred multiple times.
21
The original isolation of EHV-1 in 1941 was of the D752 phenotype.
21
The D752 variant is isolated more frequently than is N752 from horses with myeloencephalopathy
and, increasingly, abortion.22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 Infection with the D752 variant
increases the risk of myeloencephalopathy by 160× compared with that of infection
with N752.
28
These data are based on retrospectively collected data that were not randomly collected,
and this relative risk estimate could change markedly, although the association between
increased risk of EHM and infection by D752 is well accepted.18, 19, 21, 23, 24, 29
However, horses can develop EHM when infected by the N752 variant in approximately
25% of cases (noting the uncertainty around this estimate).
28
The N752 variant is the one most commonly reported as infecting asymptomatic horses.28,
30 Although estimates are potentially biased by the sampling method used in various
epidemiologic studies, the D752 variant was identified in 3%, 10.8%–19.4%, 7.4%, 24%,
and 10.6% of horses positive for EHV-1 sampled in Japan, the United States, Argentina,
France, and Germany, respectively.
31
Horses can be infected by both variants of the disease simultaneously, and each variant
can cause disease (D752 variant causing neurologic disease in the dam and N752 causing
abortion).
32
Both D752 and N752 variants were both isolated from trigeminal ganglia of 12 of 153
horses examined postmortem for reasons other than EHV-associated disease, indicating
that symptomatic dual infection is common. One or the other variant, but not both,
were isolated from a further 9/153 horses.
9
Similarly, of 70 Thoroughbred racehorses examined postmortem because of death secondary
to catastrophic musculoskeletal injuries, 2 carried only a latent neurotropic strain
of EHV-1, 6 carried a nonneurotropic genotype of EHV-1, and 10 were dually infected
with neurotropic and nonneurotropic EHV-1.
33
Among 132 mares from central Kentucky sampled postmortem, latent EHV-1 DNA was detected
in the submandibular lymph node tissues of 71 (54%). Thirteen (18%) of the 71 latently
infected horses were infected with the D752 variant, of which 11 were also infected
with the N752 variant.
30
The remainder were infected with only the N752 variant.
The D752 variant of EHV-1 differs from the N752 variant in that it causes higher levels
of white blood cell–associated viremia (up to 10-fold), infects CD4+ and CD8+ cells
to a greater extent but CD14 + and B cells to a lesser extent, and is less sensitive
to aphidicolin, a drug targeting the viral polymerase.
34
The D752 variant is also more virulent in experimentally infected horses, with those
infected with the D752 variant having higher rectal temperatures, a longer period
of pyrexia after infection (3 days versus 1 day), and greater severity of nasal discharge,
but no difference in nasal shedding of virus. Horses experimentally infected with
D752 variant developed EHM, whereas those infected with the N752 variant did not,
although uniform development of EHM in horses or ponies experimentally infected with
D752 variant is not present in other studies of the disease.
34
The D752 variant infects submucosal immune cells in respiratory explants to a greater
extent than does the N752 variant.
35
CSF from horses infected by D752 was abnormal, whereas that from horses infected with
N752 was not abnormal.
34
It is unclear whether viral load is associated with the outcome of clinical disease,
although one study of a small number of horses (seven) treated at a referral institution,
identified viral loads in nasal fluid and blood that were 1000× and 100× greater in
nonsurviving horses with EHM. These findings require confirmation because of the small
number of horses examined and in surviving (five) and nonsurviving groups (two).
36
Both N752 and D752 variants can cause disease. Virulence is associated with presence
of a functional gp2 protein, which is apparently responsible for viral egress from
infected cells, and glycoprotein D and cell-surface glycosaminoglycans that are needed
for efficient entry of EHV-1 into cells.
The most important clinical syndromes associated with EHV-1 infection are abortion,
neonatal septicemia, and myeloencephalopathy. Genital disease is an unusual manifestation
of EHV-1 infection. Infection with EHV-1 causes retinitis and fatal disease in camelids.
It also causes disease in wild equids including zebras and neurologic disease in black
bears (Ursus americanus), Thomson's gazelles (Eudorcas thomsonii), guinea pigs (Cavia
porcellus f. dom.) Indian rhinoceros (Rhinoceros unicornis), and polar bears in zoologic
parks in which these animals are in proximity to equids (such as zebra).37, 38, 39
It is associated with abortions and stillbirths in guinea pigs.
37
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Infection with EHV-1 is endemic in horse populations worldwide, and many adult horses
have serologic evidence of infection. Serologic surveys, which provide an index of
the extent of infection in the sampled population, performed before 1995 were hindered
by the lack of an assay able to differentiate immune responses to EHV-1 from those
to EHV-4. Furthermore, the advent of vaccines eliciting serum antibodies against EHV-1/4,
and the inability of diagnostic tests to differentiate between antibodies induced
by vaccination or natural infection, complicates assessment of the prevalence of serum
antibodies to EHV-1/4. Seroprevalence of EHV-1–specific antibodies is 9% to 28% in
adult Thoroughbred horses, 26% of Thoroughbred broodmares, 11% of Thoroughbred foals,
and 46% to 68% of 1- and 2-year-old Thoroughbred race horses in Australia. Sixty-one
percent of 82 normal horses and horses with upper respiratory tract disease had antibodies
to EHV-1 in New Zealand. Of 70 Thoroughbred race horses examined postmortem, 18 (26%)
and 58 (83%) horses were PCR positive for the gB gene of EHV-1 and EHV-4, respectively,
in at least one of trigeminal ganglia, bronchial, or submandibular lymph nodes sampled.
Twelve horses were dually infected with EHV-1 and EHV-4.
33
The EHV-1 D752 variant has been detected in equids in North America, Europe (the Netherlands,
France, Belgium, and Germany), Australia, New Zealand, and South America.18, 27, 30,
31, 32, 40, 41, 42, 43 It likely occurs worldwide given that it is not a recent mutation,
having been detected in samples collected in the 1940s.
21
EHM is rarely reported in the Southern Hemisphere with the first case described in
New Zealand in 2013.
18
Upper respiratory tract disease associated with EHV-1 infection has been suggested
to occur as outbreaks, although this is not well documented. Signs of infectious upper
respiratory disease affected 20% of Thoroughbred race horses at one race track in
Canada over a 3-year period, and seroconversion to EHV-1 occurred in 5% to 18% of
these horses, whereas the vast majority of horses seroconverted to influenza. However,
all horses that seroconverted to EHV-1 also either seroconverted to influenza virus
or had been recently vaccinated with a vaccine containing EHV-1. These results suggest
that the stress of influenza disease may have triggered reactivation of latent EHV-1
infection in some horses, suggesting that EHV-1 did not have a primary role in the
outbreak of respiratory disease. Similarly, in England, EHV-1 was not associated with
clinical respiratory disease in Thoroughbred racehorses. EHV-1 was isolated from foals
with purulent nasal discharge and respiratory disease concurrent with neurologic disease
among the dams in Australia.
Abortion caused by EHV-1 occurs as both sporadic cases and as epizootics (abortion
storms).27, 40, 44 Approximately 3% of abortions in mares are attributable to EHV-1
infection, although the actual incidence probably varies widely among years and geographic
regions. Outbreaks of EHV-1 abortion and birth of nonviable foals occurs sporadically
on farms with sometimes catastrophic losses. Loss of foals through abortion or birth
of nonviable foals can be as high as ~60% of pregnant mares on the farm.27, 40, 44
Initial cases can, in the absence of appropriate control measures, rapidly spread
the infection and prompt diagnosis, and implementation of control measures is important
to limit the spread of infection.27, 29 Vaccination with killed EHV-1 vaccine during
late gestation does not reliably prevent the disease, although conventional wisdom
is to ensure that mares are well vaccinated (see the section Control).
27
EHV-4 rarely causes abortion in mares. Disease of neonates associated with EHV-1 occurs
both sporadically and as outbreaks in which up to 25% of foals may be affected. Foals
infected in utero usually die soon after birth, whereas those infected in the period
after birth may have milder disease and a lower mortality rate (6%). One-third of
viremic foals may not seroconvert, based on the complement fixation test.
Myeloencephalopathy occurs as sporadic cases but more often presents as an epizootic
within a stable or barn or within a localized area. Morbidity rates in exposed horses
range from 1% to 90%, mortality rates of 0.5% to 40%, and case–fatality rates of ~15%–75%.25,
32, 41, 43, 45, 46 The attack rate (number of horses with disease/number of horses
infected) in outbreaks of the D752 variant is 22% to 50%.
20
Pregnant or nursing mares are suggested to be at greater risk of this disease, but
outbreaks occur on premises, such as riding schools or race tracks, where there are
no foals or pregnant mares.
Method of Transmission
EHV-1 is highly infectious, as evidenced by transmission of infection despite stringent
biosecurity measures in referral hospitals, riding schools, and so on.32, 46, 47 Transmission
occurs by the inhalation of infected droplets or by the ingestion of material contaminated
by nasal discharges or aborted fetuses/placenta/fetal fluids. Viral loads in nasal
fluids in horses with EHM or aborted fetuses and associated tissues and fluids can
be very high.36, 48 Other routes of infection are not recognized, although EHV-1 binds
in vitro to embryos, and binding persists after 10 cycles of washing, suggesting that
embryo transfer has the potential to transmit infection.
49
This route of infection has not been demonstrated as being important, or indeed possible,
in the spread of spontaneous disease. EHV-1 DNA, but not EHV-4, was detected in semen
samples of 51 of 390 stallions, illustrating the potential for spread of the virus
during mating or artificial insemination.
50
The virus is efficiently transmitted to in-contact animals, and rapid spread of infection
results from close contact of an infected animal with susceptible horses. Infection
can be spread over short distances in the absence of physical contact or fomite transmission.
This likely occurs by airborne spread of virus in droplets of aerosolized nasal secretions.
Infections always arise from other horses, either by direct contact or via fomites.
Mediate infection from virus on fomites such as tack, veterinary equipment, vehicles,
and housing occurs because the virus survives for 14 to 45 days outside the animal.
The source of the virus is always one of the following:
•
A horse or foal with active infection
•
A fetus, fetal membranes, or reproductive tract secretions of a mare immediately after
abortion or birth of a weak foal
•
Virus shed by horses in which latent infection has reactivated.
Horses and foals are infectious during the active stage of disease and, because horses
become latently infected, during subsequent periods of viral reactivation and shedding.
Latent infection occurs by inclusion of virus in immune cells (CD8+ T cells) in trigeminal
ganglia, submandibular lymph nodes, and likely other immunologically active tissues.9,
30, 51 Latent infection by EHV-1 virus can be reactivated by administration of corticosteroids
or other immunosuppressants but, at least in experimental situations, the resulting
level of viremia is very low and in-contact susceptible horses were not infected.
51
Virus is detectable in nasal fluids of approximately 70% of horses when they first
exhibit clinical signs of EHM and for up to 9 days after development of it.32, 47
The duration of nasal shedding is not related to age, duration of fever, or severity
of clinical signs.
32
There is good circumstantial evidence, such as the occurrence of abortion, neonatal
disease, or myeloencephalopathy in closed herds, to support a role for latency and
reactivation in the genesis of the disease, although the importance of reversion from
latency has been questioned. The duration of latency is unknown but is assumed to
be lifelong. Latent EHV-1 virus is detectable in the trigeminal ganglion and CD5/CD8
lymphocytes. Reactivation of the virus might not result in clinical signs in the host
animal, but there is shedding of virus in nasal secretions. Consequently, clinically
normal animals harbor latent virus that can infect susceptible animals during periods
of reactivation. This feature of the disease has obvious importance in the prevention,
control, and management of outbreaks of disease.
Abortion storms are usually attributable to an index case with the following:
•
A latently infected mare that sheds virus from the respiratory tract, but does not
abort
•
A mare that aborts an infected conceptus
•
A mare that sheds virus from the respiratory tract, and then aborts
Mares usually, but not always, abort from EHV-1 infection only once in their lifetime.
A likely scenario in abortion storms is the reactivation of latent virus in a resident
horse with subsequent shedding of virus in nasal secretions or, if the mare aborts,
fetal tissues and uterine fluids. Contamination of the environment or horse-to-horse
contact spreads infection to susceptible cohorts (primary transmission). The infected
cohorts then further spread the virus to other horses in that band of mares (secondary
transmission), which then spread infection among other bands of mares and foals, paddocks
or fields of horses, or farms (tertiary transmission).
Outbreaks of myeloencephalopathy likely occur through similar mechanisms. Most outbreaks
are associated with an index case or introduction of a horse with signs of infectious
respiratory disease, with subsequent development of new cases in horses that have
either direct or indirect (aerosol or fomite) contact with the index case.25, 43,
46, 47 Horses with clinical signs of myeloencephalopathy excrete the virus in nasal
fluids, often in high concentrations,
36
and for periods of time up to 14 days (nasal shedding of the virus has been demonstrated
up to 9 days after the onset of clinical signs of EHM)
32
and can spread the disease, contrary to previous supposition. This has important implications
for handling and care of affected horses, especially those severely affected horses
that may be referred for intensive or specialized care. Extreme care should be exercised
when accepting horses with EHM, or suspected EHM, to referral facilities or hospitals
because these animals can cause nosocomial spread of infection and disease among hospitalized
equids.46, 47 Furthermore, equids infected nosocomially can spread the infection when
they return home.
Cycling of Infection
Studies on Thoroughbred stud farms in Australia have demonstrated the temporal sequence
of events that contribute to spread of EHV-1 infection in that region and these studies
likely have relevance to other regions of the globe. There is a cyclical pattern in
which horses are infected at a young age and the source of infection is, depending
on the age of the foal, either its dam or other foals. Foals are infected by EHV-1
and shedding virus in nasal secretions as young as 11 days of age, often without development
of clinical signs but usually associated with mucopurulent nasal discharge. Peak incidences
of cases of respiratory disease associated with EHV-1 are late during the foaling
season before weaning, and again after weaning when foals from several groups are
housed together. The source of infection in foals before weaning is mares and, as
the number of foals in the herd increases over the course of the foaling season, other
foals. Weanlings spread the disease among their herd during the period shortly after
weaning when foals from more than one group are mixed. The incidence density of new
cases among weanlings can be as high as 13 new cases per 1000 foal weeks. The disease
associated with these outbreaks is mild and without long-term consequences to the
foal or weanling. However, the presence of foals excreting large quantities of EHV-1
has the potential to increase the risk of viral abortion in late-term mares in contact
with these foals. Furthermore, the presence of respiratory disease associated with
EHV-1 and shedding of virus by foals is associated with development of myeloencephalopathy
in mares.
Risk Factors
Risk factors for EHM include the following
21
:
•
Presence of susceptible equids: based largely on age (>5 years) and immune status
(there are no reports of horses affected twice by the disease, suggesting long-lasting
immunity).
•
Introduction of EHV-1: almost always associated with a horse shedding the virus, either
as a result of new infection or recrudescence of latent infection.
•
Presence of the D752 variant: although disease can occur associated with infection
by N752.
•
Season: there appears to be higher incidences of the disease in the Northern Hemisphere
in autumn, winter, and spring.
•
Pyrexia: horses that are pyrexic during an outbreak are more likely to develop EHM.
•
Movement of new horses onto the property, or use of horses in riding schools.
32
•
Possible associations with sex (increased risk if female) or breed (pony), although
these associations are not consistent in all or most studies and are of limited usefulness
in controlling or managing the disease.43, 46, 47
Immunity
Immunity to EHV-1 is mediated by cytotoxic T cells, which explains the limited efficacy
of inactivated virus vaccines that have minimal effect in stimulating cytotoxic T
cells despite being capable of inducing a humoral immune response.
52
The presence of EHV-1 cytotoxic T-cell precursors correlates well with protection
from experimental infection, and some of the EHV-1 antigens responsible for this resistance
have been identified.53, 54, 55 Mares usually only abort from EHV-1 infection once
in their lifetime, and there are no reports of horses developing myeloencephalopathy
more than once.
Lack of antibodies to EHV-1 was identified as a risk factor in an outbreak of EHM
in a herd of mares with foals at foot. Mares with strong antibody responses to EHV-1
did not develop disease.
Economic Importance
Disease associated with EHV-1 is of considerable economic importance because of the
loss of training time and opportunities to perform during convalescence and quarantine,
the loss of pregnancies during abortion storms, and deaths caused by myeloencephalopathy
and infection of neonates.
Pathogenesis
The three organ systems involved in clinical disease associated with EHV-1 infection
are the respiratory tract, uterus and placenta, and CNS. The common final pathway
for injury in each of these body systems is damage to vascular endothelium with subsequent
necrosis, thrombosis, and ischemia.
Following EHV-1 exposure to the upper respiratory tract, virus can be detected in
the soft palate and mainstem bronchus within 12 hours, and at all levels of the respiratory
tract by 24 hours. The virus gains access to the body after binding to respiratory
mucosal epithelium where it forms plaques that do not extend into submucosal tissues.
35
In the respiratory tract there is an initial phase after infection of nasal epithelium
56
in which there is rapid proliferation of the virus in the nasal, pharyngeal, and tonsillar
mucosae, with subsequent penetration and infection of local blood vessels. This is
followed by a systemic, viremic phase in which the virus is closely associated with
blood lymphocytes (especially CD172a(+)),
56
from which it can be isolated. Infection induces increased production of IFN-γ by
T lymphocytes.
54
Absence of viral antigens on the surface of EHV-1–infected peripheral blood mononuclear
cells explains their ability to avoid complement-mediated lysis. This activity, combined
with the immunosuppression that accompanies EHV-1 infection,55, 57, 58, 59 allows
dissemination of the infection to the reproductive tract and CNS. Immunosuppression
is mediated by production in EHV-1–infected cells of an “early protein” that interferes
with peptide translocation by the transporter associated with antigen processing.
Immunosuppression is evident as reduced in vitro proliferation of peripheral blood
monocytes and downregulation of expression of major histocompatibility complex class
I molecules on the surface of infected cells. It is from this point that the invasion
of lungs, placenta, fetus, and nervous tissue occur. Movement of infected mononuclear
cells into target tissues is associated with expression of adhesion molecules by endothelium
in the gravid uterus and in leukocytes.
Viral infection of endothelium results in death of endothelial cells, inflammation,
activation of clotting factors and platelets, increases in markers of fibrin degradation,
and formation of blood clots in small vessels.60, 61, 62 This thrombotic disease causes
ischemia of neighboring tissues with subsequent necrosis and loss of function. Another
theory is that deposition of antigen–antibody complexes in small vessels results in
an Arthus reaction with subsequent ischemia, necrosis, and loss of function. However,
recent demonstration that mares with no antibody titer to EHV-1 were at increased
risk of developing myeloencephalopathy does not support a role for type III hypersensitivity
in this disease. Regardless of the underlying mechanism, clinical signs are a result
of vasculitis and necrosis of tissue in the CNS and reproductive tract. This is in
contrast to neurologic disease associated with herpesvirus in other species, in which
the nervous system disease is a direct result of infection of neural tissues.
Abortion is caused by damage to the placenta, endometrium, or fetus. Placental lesions
include vasculitis, focal thrombosis, and infarction of the microcotyledons of the
pregnant uterus. The fetus is infected and there are diagnostic lesions present in
many aborted foals, including massive destruction of lymphocytes in the spleen and
the thymus. In those abortions in which there is no lesion or evidence of virus infection
in the foal, there may be extensive damage to the endometrium caused by an endothelial
lesion and its attendant vasculitis, thrombosis, and secondary ischemia.
Foals that are infected in utero but survive to full term may be stillborn or weak
and die soon after birth with pulmonary, hepatic, and cardiac lesions. EHV-1 infection
in foals not infected before or at birth is usually a self-limiting, mild infection
of the upper respiratory tract with an accompanying leukopenia and a transitory immune
suppression, although uveitis and occasionally death occur in a small number of foals.
Virus can be isolated from the nasal mucus and the buffy coat of the blood for some
time after clinical signs have disappeared.
The pathogenesis of myeloencephalopathy in horses contrasts with herpesvirus encephalitis
of other species in which there is viral infection of neuronal tissue. The myeloencephalopathy
in horses is, as discussed earlier, the result of vasculitis, thrombosis, and subsequent
ischemia of neural tissue. Impairment of blood flow results in hypoxia and dysfunction
or death of adjacent neural tissue.
Clinical Findings
EHV-1 infection manifests as several forms of disease on a farm such that nervous
system involvement can occur in an outbreak in which abortion and respiratory disease
also feature, although more commonly one form of the disease (myeloencephalopathy
or abortion) occurs alone or with mild respiratory disease. Foals, stallions, and
mares can be affected with one or the other form of the disease, although it is most
commonly seen in adult horses. Onset of neurologic signs is usually, but not invariably,
preceded by cases of respiratory disease, fever, limb edema, or abortion.
Myeloencephalopathy
Myeloencephalopathy initially occurs in an index case, which might or might not have
had signs of infectious respiratory disease alone or with signs of neurologic disease.
Signs of neurologic disease develop in other horses approximately 6 to 14 days after
disease in the index case. Disease then develops in a number of horses over a short
period of time (3–10 days). Outbreaks in a stable can evolve rapidly.25, 43, 46, 47
Fever, without signs of respiratory disease, often precedes signs of neurologic disease
by 24 to 72 hours. The onset of neurologic signs is usually rapid, with the signs
stabilizing within 1 to 2 days. Fever is more common (odds ratio 20×, 95% CI 3.4–390)
in horses that go on to develop EHM, but the presence of limb edema or severity of
nasal discharge are not associated with the likelihood of developing EHM during an
outbreak of the disease.32, 46 Thirteen percent of 61 horses with fever recorded during
an outbreak of abortion and EHM developed signs of EHM.
25
Six of seven pregnant mares aborted.
Signs are variable but usually referable to spinal white matter involvement. Affected
horses have variable degrees of ataxia and paresis manifest as stumbling, toe dragging,
pivoting, and circumduction that is most severe in the hindlimbs. Signs are usually
symmetric. There is often hypotonia of the tail and anus.
Fecal and urinary incontinence are common and affected horses often dribble urine,
have urine scalding of the skin of the perineum and legs, and require manual evacuation
of the rectum. The severity of signs can progress to hemiplegia or paraplegia manifesting
as recumbency and the inability to rise. Less commonly, CN deficits, such as lingual
or pharyngeal paresis, head tilt, nystagmus, or strabismus, are present. Affected
horses are usually alert and maintain their appetite.
Severity of neurologic disease varies among horses within an outbreak, and the prognosis
is related to the severity of disease. In general, horses that become recumbent have
a poor prognosis for both short-term and long-term survival despite intensive nursing
care.43, 46, 47 However, less severely affected horses have a good prognosis for survival,
with case–fatality rates as low as 2% to 3% in some outbreaks. Horses with mild signs
of neurologic disease often recover completely and return to their previous level
of performance, although some have persistent neurologic deficits after 1 year.
Abortion
Outbreaks of abortion might not be preceded by clinically apparent respiratory disease.
The incidence of abortion is highest in the last third of pregnancy, particularly
in the 8- to 10-month period but can occur as early as the fifth month. Abortion occurs
without premonitory signs, and the placenta is usually not retained. Frequently there
is no mammary development. Affected mares sometimes have prolapse of the uterus. Some
foals are stillborn, whereas others are weak and die soon after birth.
Abortion storms are often long-lasting, with a period of 17 to 22 days separating
the index case from cases caused by secondary transmission of the virus, suggesting
an incubation period of 2 to 3 weeks. Experimental infections induce abortion 15 to
65 days after intranasal inoculation of the virus. Although most abortions then occur
within 1 month of the first secondary cases, abortions on a farm can continue for
many months.
27
Neonatal Viremia and Septicemia
In utero EHV-1 infection causes abortion or the birth of infected foals, some of which
are normal at birth, but become weak and die within 3 to 7 days of birth with signs
of respiratory distress and septicemia. A less severe form of the disease, characterized
by pyrexia, nasal discharge, and chorioretinitis, occurs in slightly older foals that
are apparently infected after birth. Affected foals that survive sometimes do not
have serum antibodies to EHV-1. Death may be associated with secondary bacterial infection
with E. coli or Actinobacillus equuli, although EHV-1 infection alone is sufficient
to cause death.
Respiratory Disease
The classical respiratory tract form of the disease (rhinopneumonitis) is virtually
indistinguishable on the basis of clinical signs from the other upper respiratory
tract diseases of horses and is identical to that associated with EHV-4.
Clinical Pathology
Results of hematologic and serum biochemical examinations are neither specific nor
diagnostic. EHV-1 infection of adult horses results in leukopenia that is attributable
to both neutropenia and T-cell lymphopenia, with B-cell lymphocytosis occurring during
the recovery period. EHV-1 septicemia of foals is characterized by profound leukopenia,
neutropenia with a left shift, and lymphopenia. An approach to achieving prompt antemortem
diagnosis of EHM is suggested in Fig. 14-9
.
63
Fig. 14-9
Methodology for rapid antemortem diagnosis of equine herpesvirus-1 (EHV-1) myeloencephalopathy
in horses with signs of nervous system disease. Solid lines represent a diagnostic
pathway. EDTA, ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid.
Fig. 14-9
(Reproduced, with permission, from Pusterla N, Wilson WD, Madigan JE, Ferraro GL.
Equine herpesvirus-1 myeloencephalopathy: a review of recent developments. Vet J 2009;180:279-289.)
CSF of horses with EHV-1 encephalomyelopathy is characteristically xanthochromic and
has an increased total protein concentration (>1 g/L) with a normal white cell count.32,
64 The interpretation of EHV-1 antibody in CSF is uncertain, although normal horses
are not expected to have detectable antibodies to EHV-1 in the CSF.
Serologic tests are of critical importance in diagnosis and control of EHV infections.
Many horses have serum antibodies to EHV-1 and EHV-4 as a result of previous infection
or vaccination. Thus the demonstration of antibodies is not in itself sufficient to
confirm a diagnosis of the disease. Complement-fixing antibody appears on the 10th
to 12th day after experimental infection but persists for only a limited period. Demonstration
of a threefold to fourfold increase in the serum concentration of specific complement-fixing
antibodies in acute and convalescent serum samples provides persuasive evidence of
recent infection. Complement-fixing antibodies persist for only a short time (several
months) while VN antibodies persist for over a year, and testing for them is therefore
a more reliable means of determining that previous infection with the virus has occurred.
Until recently, serologic differentiation of antibodies to EHV-1 and EHV-4 was not
possible. However, highly specific ELISA tests based on differences between EHV-1
and EHV-2 in the variable region of the C terminus of glycoprotein G, at least one
of which is commercially available, have been developed that can differentiate between
antibodies to EHV-1 and EHV-4 in horse serum. The ELISA is reported to be more sensitive,
easier to perform, more rapid, and more reproducible than the virus neutralization
test. Importantly, the ELISA test is able to differentiate between infections associated
with EHV-1 and EHV-4.65, 66
Identification of the virus in nasal swabs, or blood buffy coat, or tissue by culture
or a PCR test provides confirmation of infection.67, 68, 69, 70, 71 The use of seminested
or multiplex PCR or qPCR, which avoids the risk of carryover contamination, provides
rapid identification of EHV-1 viral genome in nasopharyngeal swabs, blood, and other
tissues. The test is at least as sensitive as viral isolation in identifying presence
of virus. Rapid identification of virus shedding using qPCR can facilitate monitoring
and interventions to prevent spread of infection and additional examination or prophylactic
treatment of infected horses.
Appropriate PCR testing can determine whether the EHV-1 is the D752 or N752 variant.
This information can be important in epidemiologic investigations and might have implications
for administration of antiviral therapy, although this is unclear, but generally does
not influence management of a disease outbreak.21, 72
The virus can be isolated in tissue culture, chick embryos and hamsters, from either
nasal washings or aborted fetuses, and has growth characteristics that differentiate
it from EHV-4.
73
Samples of nasopharyngeal exudate for virus isolation are best obtained from horses
during the very early, febrile stages of disease, and are collected via the nares
by swabbing the nasopharyngeal area with a 5 × 5-cm gauze sponge attached to the end
of a 50-cm length of flexible, stainless steel wire encased in latex rubber tubing.
A guarded uterine swab devise can also be used. After collection, the swab should
be removed from the wire and transported promptly to the virology laboratory in 3 mL
of cold (not frozen) fluid transport medium (serum-free minimal essential medium with
antibiotics). Virus infectivity can be prolonged by the addition of bovine serum albumin
or gelatin to 0.1% (w/v).
Necropsy Findings
Macroscopic findings in aborted fetuses include petechial and ecchymotic hemorrhages,
especially beneath the respiratory mucosae. The most consistent finding is an excess
of clear yellow fluid in the pleural and peritoneal cavities. Focal hepatic necrosis
and slight icterus may also be present. In some aborted fetuses the cut surface of
the spleen reveals unusually prominent lymphoid follicles, which are swollen from
necrosis and edema. Acidophilic intranuclear inclusion bodies may be evident histologically
in a variety of cell types, including the bronchiolar and alveolar epithelium, hepatocytes,
and dendritic cells of the lymphoid tissues. Although the microscopic pathology is
unimpressive, examination of the placenta via IHC techniques can be a useful aid in
the diagnosis of EHV-1–induced and EHV-4–induced abortions. In foals that are alive
at birth but die soon afterward there is usually massive pulmonary congestion and
edema, with collapse of the lung and hyaline membrane development in those that survive
longer.
In the nervous or paralytic form of the disease there is an acute disseminated myeloencephalopathy.
Hemorrhages may be visible grossly but often there are no macroscopic changes. Disseminated
vasculitis occurs in the experimental disease, and the malacic lesions present in
the nervous tissue are the result of leakage from these damaged vessels. The virus
can be isolated from the brain, and the isolation is facilitated by use of an indirect
peroxidase stain to establish the location of the virus. The virus infects endothelial
cells within the CNS but has also been demonstrated within neurons and astrocytes
and has been linked to chorioretinitis in a foal. In rare cases the virus may cause
lesions in other tissues, such as the intestinal mucosa and spleen or pharynx.
The laboratory examination of aborted fetuses should include a search for virus by
tissue culture and IHC or PCR techniques, as well as a histologic examination of the
lung and liver for the presence of inclusion bodies. A direct FAT has also been used.
A serologic examination of the foal may provide useful information in those cases
in which attempts at isolation are negative but seroconversion has occurred. However,
a recent study found that fetal serology was an unreliable means of diagnosing EHV-1
abortion, and that IHC was slightly more sensitive than virus isolation.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Virology: chilled lung, liver, spleen, thymus, and thoracic fluid of aborted fetuses
or neonates. Spinal cord or brain of horses with nervous disease (VI, PCR, FAT, serology).
•
Histology: fixed lung, liver, spleen, thymus, and trachea from fetuses or neonates.
•
Fixed brain and spinal cord from several sites, as well as Bouin's fixed eye should
be examined in adults with nervous disease (LM, IHC).
Differential Diagnosis
Respiratory disease in horses is associated with a variety of agents (Table 12-14).
Abortion can be associated with leptospirosis, Salmonella abortusequi, placentitis
associated with Streptococcus zooepidemicus or Escherichia coli, associated with mare
reproductive loss syndrome, or congenital abnormalities, among other causes. When
other pregnant mares are at risk, abortion in a late-term mare should always be considered
to be caused by EHV-1 until proved otherwise.
Neurologic diseases with clinical presentations similar to that associated with EHV-1
include rabies, equine protozoal myeloencephalitis, neuritis of the cauda equina (equine
polyneuritis), trauma, acute spinal cord compression (cervical stenotic myelopathy),
and equine degenerative myelopathy. Fever is rare in other neurologic diseases of
horses, and any horse with neurologic disease and fever or a history of fever within
the previous week should be considered to have EHV-1 myeloencephalopathy. Outbreaks
of posterior paresis or ataxia, especially in horses without fever, should prompt
consideration of ingestion of intoxicants such as Astragalus spp., Swainsona spp.,
or sorghum. Ryegrass staggers can produce similar signs of ataxia.
Neonatal septicemia can be associated with E. coli, Streptococci spp., and other bacteria,
especially in foals with failure of transfer of maternal immunoglobulins.
EHV-1, equid herphesvirus-1.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Because of the highly contagious nature of EHV-1 infections, horses with respiratory
disease, abortion, or neurologic disease, especially if these occur as an outbreak,
should be isolated until the cause of the disease is identified.
There is no specific treatment for the diseases associated with EHV infection, although
acyclovir and other antiviral drugs are used on occasion to treat horses in outbreaks
of myeloencephalopathy.
46
Horses with EHM require intense supportive care. Nursing care to prevent urine scalding,
pressure sores, and pneumonia is important in horses with myeloencephalopathy. Recumbent
or severely ataxic horses should be supported to stand if at all possible. Although
a rope tied to the tail and slung over an overhead beam may be used to assist the
horse to stand, a sling may be necessary to support more severely affected horses.
Nursing care is important to prevent development of pressure sores in recumbent horses
or those supported by slings. The perineum of incontinent horses should be cleaned
frequently, and salves or ointments to protect the skin applied. Some horses require
catheterization of the bladder to relieve distension. Enemas, accompanied by careful
manual evacuation of the rectum, might be needed to promote passage of feces.
Administration of corticosteroids to these horses is controversial, but many clinicians
administer dexamethasone sodium phosphate (0.05–0.25 mg/kg intramuscularly every 12–24
hours) or prednisolone (1–2 mg/kg orally or parenterally every 24 hours) for 2 to
3 days. Administration of corticosteroids may be contraindicated because of the presence
of replicating virus in affected horses. The use of antiplatelet drugs or antithrombotic
compounds has received anecdotal support, but there is no evidence that they do not
harm affected horses and similarly no evidence of efficacy.
Administration of drugs to inhibit viral replication has merit and is attempted during
outbreaks of disease. The challenges of this approach are that the infection is well
advanced by the time clinical signs of neurologic disease are detected, especially
in cases early in the disease outbreak before purposeful monitoring is in place, pharmacokinetics
and pharmacodynamics of the available drugs are unknown or imperfectly known, and
the drugs are expensive. Antiviral drugs considered for use in horses with EHM include
acyclovir, valacyclovir, penciclovir (after oral administration of its prodrug famciclovir),
ganciclovir, and valganciclovir.74, 75, 76, 77, 78 Acyclovir is effective against
EHV-1 in vitro, and pharmacokinetic studies suggest that administration of 10 mg/kg
orally every 4 to 6 hours (five times daily) or 10 mg/kg intravenously every 8 hours
results in acceptable concentrations of drug in the blood. However, further investigation
reveals that there is a large variation between individual horses in the absorption
of acyclovir with consequent failure to obtain therapeutic concentrations in many
horses.
79
The in vitro activity of acyclovir, ganciclovir, cidofovir, adefovir, 9-(2-phosphonylmethoxyethyl)-2,6-diaminopurine
(PMEDAP) and foscarnet against three abortigenic isolates and three neuropathogenic
isolates of EHV-1 revealed variable activity of cidofovir and limited to no activity
of foscarnet.
80
Current recommendations for the prophylaxis and treatment of horses with EHM include
administration of acyclovir (10–20 mg/kg every 5–8 hours, orally for 7 days) or ganciclovir
IV at 2.5 mg/kg every 8 h for 24 h followed by maintenance dosing of 2.5 mg/kg every
12 h, or orally at 30–40 mg/kg every 8–12 h for 7 days.
72
The efficacy of these compounds has not been demonstrated in appropriate clinical
trials, and earlier comments about the variability in oral bioavailability of acyclovir
should be noted.
Neonatal foals with septicemia should be treated aggressively with antibiotics and
supportive care, including enteral or parenteral nutrition and fluid administration
(see the section Clinical Assessment and Care of Critically Ill Newborns in Chapter
19). Treatment with acyclovir has been reported. Failure of transfer of passive immunity
should be rectified with oral or intravenous administration of colostrum or plasma,
respectively.
Control
Recommendations for programs to prevent introduction of infection and to control EHM
and abortion outbreaks are available from several sources and might vary between countries.18,
21, 29, 81
Prevention of Infection
The general principles include the following:
•
Enhanced immunity, currently attempted by vaccination
•
Subdivision and maintenance of the farm population in groups of horses to minimize
spread of the infection
•
Minimize risk of introduction of infection by new horses
•
Minimize risk of reactivation of latent infection in resident horses
•
Develop plans for implementation of these routine control measures, and for actions
in the event of an abortion
•
Educate management and staff as to the importance of strict adherence to these procedures
The relative importance of each of these measures has not been determined, but implementation
of control measures, including allocation of mares to small bands based on anticipated
foaling date, quarantine of new introductions, and vaccination of pregnant mares,
has reduced the incidence of EHV-1 abortion in central Kentucky. The most striking
association has been an apparent reduction in the incidence of abortion storms. It
must be emphasized that vaccination does not replace any of the other management procedures
in control of this disease and that abortions have occurred among vaccinated mares
on farms on which the other management procedures have been ignored.
Vaccination
Vaccination against respiratory disease and abortion associated with EHV-1 is widely
practiced despite lack of clear-cut evidence that vaccination reduces the incidence
or severity of either of these diseases. Information regarding field efficacy of EHV
vaccines is lacking, and that derived from experimental challenge models is often
contradictory or incomplete. Give these caveats, the following recommendations are
made based on generally accepted practices.
None of the currently available vaccines, of which there are approximately 14 worldwide,
consistently prevent infection of vaccinated horses or provide complete protection
against disease associated with EHV-1.21, 52, 72 The principal objective of vaccination
has been to protect mares against abortion associated with EHV-1, although vaccines
intended to prevent rhinopneumonitis and containing both EHV-1 and EHV-4 are available.
Additionally, vaccination of mares is intended to reduce transmission of EHV-1 to
foals in an attempt to interrupt the cyclical nature of infection on stud farms. Vaccines
consisting of a modified live EHV-1, inactivated EHV-1, or a mixture of inactivated
EHV-1 and EHV-4 are available for intramuscular or intranasal administration to horses.
Both inactivated and modified live EHV-1 vaccines elicit virus-neutralization and
complement fixation antibody responses in horses, although high antibody titers are
not necessarily related to resistance to infection.
Resistance to infection might be more closely related to cytotoxic T-cell responses.
Widespread use of a combined EHV-1 and EHV-4 killed virus vaccine in Australia has
not reduced serologic evidence of infection in foals on farms where mares are vaccinated,
although the vaccine was effective in preventing disease induced by experimental infection.
Complicating assessment of vaccine efficacy is the variable response to vaccination
by some mares and foals, with certain animals having minimal responses to vaccination,
which in other horses elicits a strong immune response. Efforts are underway to develop
modified live vaccines that can be administered intranasally. Intranasal administration
of one such EHV-1 vaccine induced protection against experimentally induced EHV-1
(and EHV-4) respiratory disease and abortion in mares, and prevented infection of
foals even when administered in the presence of maternally derived antibodies. An
alternative approach is the development of subunit vaccines using the envelope glycoprotein
D, which has been shown to elicit protective immunity in laboratory animal models
of EHV-1 disease and administration of which induces VN antibody and glycoprotein
D–specific ELISA antibodies in horses. Current modified live vaccines appear to induce
a more restricted IgG isotype than does natural infection, which could partly account
for their limited efficacy.
53
Despite the incomplete protection afforded by vaccines, vaccination against EHV-1
is an important part of most equine herd health programs in the vaccination of pregnant
and nonpregnant mares, foals, and adult horses. The intent of vaccination of mares
is to prevent abortion associated with EHV-1. One inactivated virus vaccine is reported
to decrease the incidence of abortion by 65%, although others have not been able to
replicate this success and there are reports of abortion storms on farms of well-vaccinated
mares. An inactivated virus vaccine containing EHV-1 and EHV-4 prevented abortion
in five of six mares exposed experimentally to EHV-1, whereas all six nonvaccinated
mares aborted. Mares are vaccinated with the inactivated vaccine during the fifth,
seventh, and ninth months of gestation. Additional vaccinations at breeding and 1
month before foaling are recommended by some authorities.
No vaccines are currently licensed with the claim of preventing EHM, and the disease
occurs in well-vaccinated horses. Concerns that the disease might represent a “second
hit” as a result of vaccination and subsequent infection have not received widespread
support and do not have empirical evidence that is in any way supportive.
21
Foals are an important source of infection and control of infection in foals is considered
critical to control of infection on a farm. Consequently, attention has been paid
to the responses of foals to vaccination at various ages, given the risk of passive
immunity interfering with vaccination and the early age at which foals are infected
by EHV-1. Current recommendations vary with some authorities recommending vaccination
of foals after 5 months of age, to avoid the interfering effect of passive immunity
on response to vaccination. However, vaccination of foals at this age likely misses
the period of time when foals are first infected by EHV-1 from their dam or other
mares in the band. One recommendation is that foals should be vaccinated in their
third month, with revaccination 1 month and 6 months later. Modified live virus vaccine
is given to foals at 3 to 4 months of age, and nonpregnant mares and other horses
are given two doses administered 3 months apart followed by revaccination every 9
months. Because of the short duration of immunity following vaccination, frequent
vaccination, perhaps at intervals as short as 3 months, of horses at high risk is
recommended. However, the efficacy of such a program is uncertain.
Subdivision of Horses on a Farm
Maintenance of small groups of horses of similar age and reproductive status is recommended
to minimize the chances of spread of infection. Pregnant mares, after weaning of foals,
should be maintained in a herd that does not have access to foals, weanlings, nonpregnant
mares, or other equids (donkeys). Similarly, weaned foals should be separated from
horses of other ages in recognition of the high rate of infection and viral shedding
in weanlings. Failure to adhere to these procedures can result in rapid spread of
infection and abortions among at-risk mares. Pregnant mares should be combined into
small groups (~10) early in pregnancy based on their anticipated foaling dates. Multiparous
mares should not be mixed with mares that are pregnant for the first time.
Management practices should be introduced that minimize the opportunities for viral
spread. Ideally, pregnant mares are handled using facilities separate from those used
to handle mares with foals or weanlings. If common facilities must be used, pregnant
mares should be handled first, after thorough cleaning of the facility, followed by
mares with foals and finally weanlings and other horses.
Minimize Risk of Introduction of Infection
The only sources of virus are recrudescence of latent infection and introduction by
newly arrived horses shedding virus. All horses must be considered as potentially
shedding EHV-1 on arrival at a farm and should be isolated from resident horses. Introduction
of new horses to the small groups of pregnant mares should be avoided if at all possible,
or if absolutely necessary preceded by a 21-day isolation period. If at all possible,
avoid mingling resident and nonresident mares even after quarantine of nonresident
animals.
Prevention of Reactivation of Latent Infection
The factors inciting reactivation of latent infection and viral shedding are unknown.
However, stressful events, such as transportation or other disease, have the potential
to cause reactivation of latent infection. For this reason pregnant mares should not
be shipped within 8 weeks of expected foaling and all efforts, including vaccination,
should be made to prevent other infectious diseases.
Control of Outbreaks
The principles underlying control of abortions or EHM caused by EHV-1 include the
following:
•
Early and rapid diagnosis
•
Prevention of spread of infection
•
Treatment of individual cases
These aims are approached through six stages:
1.
Preliminary recognition of the problem (outbreak): typically by owners or trainers
recognizing the presence of sick horses.
2.
Preliminary veterinary investigation: conducted by a veterinarian on, usually, their
first response to the owner's concerns and leading to a presumptive clinical diagnosis.
3.
Establishing the diagnosis: use of appropriate laboratory and other testing to confirm
or rule out specific diagnoses.
4.
Understanding and managing the outbreak: this is complex because it involves an understanding
of the biology and epidemiology of the disease, the financial and social context of
the outbreak, and assessment of the feasibility, and cost-effectiveness, of potential
interventions.
5.
Establishing freedom of infection: documenting the end of the outbreak and confirming
freedom from infection by the offending agent.
6.
Return the premise to normal function and activity.
Control of Outbreaks of Myeloencephalopathy
Diagnostic criteria for EHM are set out in the six stages list earlier. Adult horses
with rapid onset of signs of nervous system disease, with or without fever, should
be considered to have EHM until proven otherwise.
Outbreaks of EHV-1–induced neurologic disease often occur in riding schools and similar
situations where there is constant movement of horses on and off the property. As
such it is exceedingly difficult to institute control measures that prevent introduction
of the disease and that are compatible with the use of the horses. Having said that,
the principles outlined earlier for preventing introduction of infection onto breeding
farms also apply for prevention of myeloencephalopathy at riding stables.
Reports of outbreaks of EHM in stables and veterinary hospitals have underscored the
highly infectious nature of the disease.25, 46, 47 EHV-1 is spread from infected horses,
which can have virus in nasal fluid before onset of clinical signs, by aerosol, and
on fomites. It is critical to prevent spread by diligent attention to biosecurity,
including spread by personnel and aerosol. Infected horses should be isolated in a
separate air space to uninfected or at risk horses.
Detailed instructions for handling outbreaks of neurologic disease attributable to
EHV-1 are available and provide advice on quarantine, disinfection, and sample collection.
There is no “one size fits all,” and the recommendations should be modified or adopted
with a full understanding of the financial, social, and psychologic context of managing
the outbreak. Guidelines for managing an outbreak of EHM include the following21,
29, 72, 82:
•
Affected horses should be isolated because they are infectious.
•
The diagnosis should be confirmed by virus isolation, PCR, or histologic examination
of tissues from affected horses that die or are euthanized.
•
Potentially affected horses should be tested to determine whether they are excreting
the virus (nasal swabs).
•
There should be no movement of horses on or off the premises for at least 21 days
after the last case has occurred.
•
Movement among bands of horses on the farm should be avoided.
•
Animals should leave or move between bands only when there is no evidence of continued
active infection in their group.
•
Vaccination in the face of an outbreak of EHM is not recommended. Clinically affected
horses should not be vaccinated.
•
Prophylactic use of acyclovir has been reported, although the efficacy of this practice
is unknown.
A suggested, three-tiered approach to managing an outbreak of EHM is depicted in Table
14-13
.
Table 14-13
Three-tiered approach to managing an outbreak of equine herpesvirus myeloencephalopathy.
Table 14-13
Three tiers of approach
Action
Gold tier
Silver tier
Bronze tier
Segregate the population into small discrete groups that can be managed discretely
to avoid infection transferring between them
Yes
The smaller the groups the better to minimize the impact of ongoing disease and possibly
reduce later laboratory test costs
Yes
The smaller the groups the better to minimize the impact of ongoing disease and possibly
reduce later laboratory test costs
Yes
The smaller the groups the better to minimize the impact of ongoing disease and possibly
reduce later laboratory test costs
Collect samples
Collect full set from all animals
NP swab in VTM, serum (5–10 mL) and heparinized whole blood (30 ml)
Collect partial set from all animals
NP swab in VTM and serum (5–10 mL)
Collect partial set from all animals
NP swab in VTM and serum (5–10 mL)
Test samples
Test full set from all animals
NP swab by qPCR, serum by CFT and heparinized blood by virus isolation
Test partial set from all animals
NP swab by qPCR and serum by CFT
Do not test, but freeze the partial set from all animals for possible testing later
Observe for clinical disease (neurologic disease and/or abortion noting that pregnant
mares should only be considered clear once they have a foaled successfully and have
a healthy foal at foot)
Observe all groups for 3–4 weeks:If no clinical disease is observed in a group: collect
NP swabs and sera (pair with already tested sample in CFT) and test, consider EHV-1
free if all results are negativeIf clinical disease is observed in a group: immediately
collect and test a full set of samples from all horses in the affected groupRemove
positives to an isolation areaRepeat after 2–3 weeks and only consider EHV-1 free
when all results are negative
Observe all groups for 3–4 weeks:If no clinical disease is observed in a group: collect
NP swabs and sera (pair with already tested sample in CFT) and test, consider EHV-1
free if all results are negativeIf clinical disease is observed in a group: immediately
collect and test a full set of samples from all horses in the affected groupRemove
positives to an isolation areaRepeat after 2–3 weeks and only consider EHV-1 free
when all results are negative
Observe all groups for 3–4 weeks:If no clinical disease is observed in a group: collect
NP swabs and sera (pair with frozen samples in CFT) and test, consider EHV-1 free
if all results are negativeIf clinical disease is observed in a group: immediately
collect a full set of samples from all the affected group and test all, including
frozen, samplesRemove positives to an isolation areaRepeat after 2–3 weeks and only
consider EHV-1 free when all results are negative
CFT, complement fixation test; NP, nasopharyngeal; qPCR, quantitative polymerase chain
reaction; VTM, virus transport medium.
Reproduced from Gonzalez-Medina S et al: Equine Vet J 2015; 47:142.
Abortion
Rapid Diagnosis
Every abortion in a late-term mare should be considered to be associated with EHV-1
until proven otherwise. Therefore rapid and early diagnosis of the abortion or of
EHM is important to instituting control measures. In regions with large numbers of
breeding mares, all abortions in mares should be investigated by detailed postmortem
examination of the fetus and serologic examination of the mare.
Prevention of Spread
Diligent and concerted efforts must be made to prevent dissemination of infection
from the initial focus in cases of abortion. Delay in doing so increases the incidence
of abortion and prolongs the outbreak.
27
Infected fetal tissues and fluids, and contaminated materials such as bedding, should
be placed in impervious containers and either transported to a laboratory for examination
or destroyed by incineration. Samples for laboratory examination should be handled
to prevent spread of infection. Facilities and equipment that might have been contaminated
should be disinfected by thorough cleaning followed by application of a phenolic or
iodophor disinfectant.
The mare should be isolated until results of laboratory examination are negative for
EHV-1 or until the second estrus, at which time it is unlikely that there is shedding
of virus from the reproductive tract. Other mares in the same band as the mare that
aborted should be considered exposed and at risk of abortion. These mares should be
held in strict isolation until the results of laboratory examination are negative
for EHV-1, or until they foal or abort. Other recommendations for horse movement include
the following:
•
When an abortion occurs on the stud, no mares should be allowed to enter or leave
it until the possibility of EHV-1 infection is excluded. However, maiden and barren
mares, i.e., mares that have foaled normally at home but that are not in foal, coming
from home studs where no signs of the disease are occurring, may be admitted because
they are considered not to be infected.
•
If EHV-1 infection is identified on the stud, all pregnant mares ready to foal that
season (i.e., late-pregnant mares) should remain at the stud until they have foaled.
The incubation period for EHV-1 abortion ranges between 9 and 121 days.
•
All nonpregnant animals and mares that have foaled should remain at the stud for 30
days after the last abortion.
The main problem that arises in this program is in deciding what to do with mares
that come into contact with the respiratory disease but not the abortion disease.
This may occur very early in pregnancy and prolonged isolation would be onerous. The
decision usually depends on the owner's risk aversion and the availability of facilities
to maintain long-term isolation.
Further Reading
Gonzalez-Medina
S
Newton
JR
Equine herpesvirus-1:dealing pragmatically but effectively with an ever present threat
Equine Vet J
47
2015
142
144
25644768
Lunn
DP
Equine herpesvirus-1 consensus statement
J Vet Intern Med
23
2009
450
461
19645832
Pusterla
N
Hussey
GS
Equine herpesvirus 1 myeloencephalopathy
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
30
2014
489
506
25300635
References
1
Davison
AJ
Arch Virol
154
2009
171
19066710
2
Schrenzel
MD
Emerg Infect Dis
14
2008
1616
18826828
3
Rebelo
AR
Can J Vet Res
79
2015
155
25852233
4
LeCuyer
TE
J Vet Diagn Invest
27
2015
749
26462760
5
De Witte
FG
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1064
22594674
6
Bell
SA
Vet Microbiol
130
2008
176
18280676
7
Rushton
JO
Vet J
200
2014
200
24709517
8
Vengust
M
J Vet Diagn Invest
20
2008
820
18987238
9
Pusterla
N
Vet Rec
167
2010
376
20817899
10
Wong
D
JAVMA
232
2008
898
18341449
11
Williams
KJ
PLoS ONE
8
2013
e63535
23723987
12
Vander Werf
KA
J Equine Vet Sci
34
2014
738
13
Vander Werf
K
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
387
23458852
14
Hussey
GS
Vet Res
44
2013
118
24308772
15
Herder
V
Vet Microbiol
155
2012
420
21996546
16
Abdelgawad
A
PLoS ONE
10
2015
e0138370
26378452
17
Ibrahim
ESM
Arch Virol
152
2007
245
17051419
18
Dunowska
M
New Zeal Vet J
62
2014
171
19
Ma
G
Vet Microbiol
167
2013
123
23890672
20
Nugent
J
J Virol
80
2006
4047
16571821
21
Lunn
DP
J Vet Intern Med
23
2009
450
19645832
22
Allen
GP
Am J Vet Res
69
2008
1595
19046006
23
Pronost
S
Equine Vet J
42
2010
672
21039794
24
Pronost
S
Vet Microbiol
145
2010
329
20427133
25
Walter
J
Acta Vet Scand
55
2013
26
Stasiak
K
BMC Vet Res
11
2015
27
Schulman
ML
Equine Vet J
47
2015
155
24617603
28
Perkins
GA
Vet Microbiol
139
2009
375
19615831
29
Gonzalez-Medina
S
Equine Vet J
47
2015
142
25644768
30
Allen
GP
Equine Vet J
40
2008
105
18089469
31
Tsujimura
K
J Vet Med Sci
73
2011
1663
21828961
32
Burgess
BA
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
384
22332764
33
Pusterla
N
Vet J
193
2012
579
22405721
34
Goodman
LB
PLoS Pathog
3
2007
e160
17997600
35
Vandekerckhove
AP
J Gen Virol
91
2010
2019
20427565
36
Estell
KE
Equine Vet J
47
2015
689
25212737
37
Wohlsein
P
Vet Microbiol
149
2011
456
21167662
38
Abdelgawad
A
Vet Microbiol
169
2014
102
24440374
39
Guo
X
J Vet Med Sci
76
2014
1309
24920546
40
Damiani
AM
Vet Microbiol
172
2014
555
25042527
41
Gryspeerdt
A
Vlaams Diergeneeskundig Tijdschr
80
2011
147
42
Mori
E
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
30
2011
949
22435205
43
van Galen
G
Vet Microbiol
179
2015
304
26228835
44
Bazanow
BA
Polish J Vet Sci
17
2014
607
45
Pronost
S
Transbound Emerg Dis
59
2012
256
21975071
46
Henninger
RW
J Vet Intern Med
21
2007
157
17338164
47
Goehring
LS
J Vet Intern Med
24
2010
1176
20584137
48
Gardiner
DW
Vaccine
30
2012
6564
22944628
49
Hebia
I
Theriogenology
67
2007
1485
17459463
50
Hebia-Fellah
I
Theriogenology
71
2009
1381
19268345
51
Pusterla
N
J Vet Intern Med
24
2010
1153
20584139
52
Paillot
R
Open Vet Sci J
2
2008
68
53
Goodman
LB
Clin Vaccine Immunol
19
2012
235
22205656
54
Paillot
R
Dev Comp Immunol
31
2007
202
16824599
55
Wimer
CL
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
140
2011
266
21349590
56
Gryspeerdt
AC
Vet Microbiol
142
2010
242
19926232
57
Luce
R
Equine Vet J
39
2007
202
17520969
58
Ma
G
J Virol
86
2012
3554
22278226
59
Sarkar
S
Vet Immunol Immunopathol
167
2015
122
26275803
60
Andoh
K
Virus Res
195
2015
172
25456403
61
Goehring
LS
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
1535
24112533
62
Stokol
T
PLoS ONE
10
2015
e0122640
25905776
63
Pusterla
N
Vet J
180
2009
279
18805030
64
Goehring
LS
Vet J
186
2010
180
19726209
65
Amer
HM
Afr J Microbiol Res
5
2011
4805
66
Yildirim
Y
Iranian J Vet Res
16
2015
341
67
Hu
Z
Appl Microbiol Biotech
98
2014
4179
68
Pusterla
N
J Vet Diagn Invest
21
2009
836
19901285
69
Pusterla
N
Vet J
179
2009
230
18024200
70
Smith
KL
J Clin Microbiol
50
2012
1981
22493339
71
Stasiak
K
Polish J Vet Sci
18
2015
833
72
Pusterla
N
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
30
2014
489
25300635
73
Equine rhinopneumonitis (equine herpesvirus 1 and 4). OIE
Accessed 07.02.2016; at
http://www.oie.int/fileadmin/Home/eng/Health_standards/tahm/2.05.09_EQUINE_RHINO.pdf
2015
74
Carmichael
RJ
J Vet Intern Med
24
2010
712
75
Carmichael
RJ
J Vet Pharmacol Ther
36
2013
441
23301502
76
Garre
B
Vet Microbiol
135
2009
214
18986780
77
Maxwell
LK
J Vet Pharmacol Ther
31
2008
312
18638291
78
Tsujimura
K
J Vet Med Sci
72
2010
357
19959884
79
Wong
DM
Equine Vet Educ
22
2010
244
80
Garre
B
Vet Microbiol
122
2007
43
17276631
81
Dunowska
M
New Zeal Vet J
62
2014
179
82
Equine herpesvirus 1 and 4 related diseases. American Association of Equine Practitioners
Accessed 07.02.2016; at
http://www.aaep.org/custdocs/EquineHerpesvirusFinal030513.pdf
2013
Peruvian Horse Sickness Virus
Peruvian horse sickness virus is an Orbivirus associated with causing neurologic disease
in horses in Peru with a mortality rate of approximately 1.25% and a case–fatality
rate of 78%.
1
A genetically identical virus has been isolated from horses dying of neurologic disease
in northern Australia.
2
Serologic surveillance in that area demonstrates antibody to Peruvian horse sickness
virus in 11% of horses. The disease is described as causing motor incoordination,
sagging jaw, tooth grinding, and stiff neck with death in 8 to 11 days.
References
1
Attoui
H
Virology
394
2009
298
19766284
2
Mendez-Lopez
MR
J Vector Ecol
40
2015
355
26611971
Powassan Virus
The Powassan virus, a flavivirus that is spread by the bite of infected ticks,
1
occurs in Ontario and the eastern United States, and produces a nonsuppurative, focal
necrotizing meningoencephalitis in horses. Approximately 13% of horses sampled in
Ontario in 1983 were serologically positive to the virus. Experimental intracerebral
inoculation of the Powassan virus into horses resulted in a neurologic syndrome within
8 days. Clinical findings include a “tucked-up” abdomen, tremors of the head and neck,
slobbering and chewing movements resulting in foamy saliva, stiff gait, staggering,
and recumbency. There is a nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis, neuronal necrosis, and
focal parenchymal necrosis. The virus has not been isolated from the brain.
Reference
1
Dupuis
AP
II
Parasit Vectors
6
2013
185
24016533
Nigerian Equine Encephalitis
Nigerian equine encephalitis, a disease with low morbidity but high mortality, is
characterized by fever, generalized muscle spasms, ataxia, and lateral recumbency
of 3 to 5 days' duration. The virus has not been identified, but the only report describes
the lesions as consistent with an alphavirus, although Lagos bat virus, a pathogenic
lyssavirus, is highly endemic in this area.
Main Drain Virus Encephalitis
The main drain virus has been isolated from a horse with severe encephalitis in California.
1
Clinical findings included incoordination, ataxia, stiffness of the neck, head-pressing,
inability to swallow, fever, and tachycardia. The virus is transmitted by rabbits
and rodents and by its natural vector, Culicoides variipennis.
Reference
1
Wilson
WC
Rev - Off Int Epizoot
34
2015
419
26601445
Borna Disease
Borna disease is an infectious encephalomyelitis of horses and sheep first recorded
in Germany. It is associated with a negative sense, single-stranded RNA virus classified
as Bornavirus within the order Mononegavirales. There is a recently recognized avian
variant of Borna disease virus, which causes disease in birds.
1
The disease and the virus in horses are indistinguishable from EEE. Borna disease
is now recognized as a subacute meningoencephalitis in horses, cattle, sheep, rabbits,
and cats in Germany, Sweden, and Switzerland.
2
There are reports of encephalitis with Borna disease virus genome detected in lesions
by PCR in a horse and a cow in Japan. The disease apparently occurs in New World camelids.
3
Encephalitis associated with Borna disease virus was detected in young ostriches in
Israel. The disease does not appear to be a common cause of nonsuppurative encephalitis
in pigs.
4
Serologic evidence of infection by Borna disease virus is widespread both geographically
and in the range of species.5, 6
Borna disease virus is suspected of causing disease in humans, including lymphocytic
meningoencephalitis, but infection is not associated with an increased prevalence
of psychiatric disorders. Others suggest that the presence of circulating Borna disease
virus immune complexes (Borna disease virus antigen and specific antibodies) is associated
with severe mood disorders in humans. The role, if any, of Borna disease virus in
human neurologic or psychiatric disease has not been established with any certainty
and is the subject of considerable debate.
1
Detection of Borna disease virus genome by PCR analysis suggests that, although the
spontaneous disease in horses and sheep occurs predominantly if not exclusively in
Europe, clinically unapparent Borna disease virus infection is widespread in a number
of species including horses, cattle, sheep, cats, and foxes. However, concern has
been raised that some of these reports might be based on flawed laboratory results
as a consequence of contamination of PCR assays. Antibodies to Borna disease virus
in serum or CSF have been detected in horses in the eastern United States, Japan,
Iran, Turkey, France, and China, and in healthy sheep and dairy cattle in Japan. In
areas in which the disease is not endemic, between 3% (United States) and 42% (Iran)
of horses have either antibodies or Borna disease virus nucleic acid, detected by
PCR, in blood or serum. Similarly, approximately 12% to 20% of horses have serologic
evidence of exposure to Borna disease virus in areas of Europe in which the disease
is endemic. Antibodies to Borna disease virus and nucleic acid have been detected
in humans in North America, Europe, and Japan. Closed flocks of sheep and herds of
horses have evidence of persistent infection of some animals, based on serologic testing.
It is worth noting that animals infected with the virus and those who are clinically
ill may have undetectable to very low antibody titers.
The method of transmission of infection between animals is unknown, but it is thought
to be horizontal by inhalation or ingestion. Seropositive, clinically normal horses
and sheep can excrete virus in conjunctival fluid, nasal secretions, and saliva, suggesting
that they might be important in the transmission of infection. Removal of all seropositive
and Borna disease virus RNA-positive sheep from a closed flock did not prevent seroconversion
of other animals in the flock the following year. The possibility of vertical transmission
is raised by the finding of Borna disease virus RNA in the brain of a fetal foal of
a mare that died of Borna disease.
There is a seasonal distribution to the prevalence of the disease, with most cases
in horses occurring in spring and early summer. The virus has not been isolated from
arthropods, including hematophagous insects.
The morbidity in Borna disease is not high, approximately 0.006% to 0.23% of horses
affected per year in endemic areas of Germany, but most affected animals die.
The pathogenesis of the disease involves infection of cells of the CNS. It is assumed
that the virus gains entry to the CNS through trigeminal and olfactory nerves, with
subsequent dissemination of infection throughout the brain. Viral transcription and
replication occurs within the cell nucleus. Viral replication does not appear to result
in damage to the infected neuron. However, infected cells express viral antigens on
their surface, which then initiate a cell-mediated immune response by the host that
then destroys infected cells (immunosuppression prevents development of the disease).
The inflammatory response is largely composed of CD3 lymphocytes. The disease is subacute;
infection and the development of lesions may take weeks to months. Clinically inapparent
infection appears to be common in a number of species, including horses.
In field outbreaks the incubation period is about 4 weeks and possibly up to 6 months.
Clinical signs of the disease in horses include the following:
•
Moderate fever
•
Pharyngeal paralysis
•
Lack of food intake
•
Muscle tremor
•
Defects in proprioception
•
Hyperesthesia
•
Blindness or visual defects
7
Lethargy, somnolence, and flaccid paralysis are seen in the terminal stages, and death
occurs 1 to 3 weeks after the first appearance of clinical signs. Infection without
detectable clinical signs is thought to be common on infected premises. The frequency
with which Borna disease virus is detected in horses with gait deficits is greater
than in clinically normal horses, suggesting a role for the virus in inducing subtle
disease.
The presentation of the disease in cattle is similar to that in horses, with affected
animals having reduced appetite, ataxia, paresis, and compulsive circling. The disease
ends in the death of the animal after a 1- to 6-week course.
Hematology and routine serum biochemistry are typically normal, with the exception
of fasting-induced hyperbilirubinemia in anorexic horses. Clinicopathologic identification
of exposed animals is achieved with complement fixation, ELISA, Western blot, or indirect
immunofluorescent tests.
At necropsy there are no gross findings, but histologically there is a lymphocytic
and plasmacytic meningoencephalitis, affecting chiefly the brainstem, and a lesser
degree of myelitis. The highest concentration of virus is in the hippocampus and thalamus.
The diagnostic microscopic finding is the presence of intranuclear inclusion bodies
within neurons, especially in the hippocampus and olfactory bulbs. The virus can be
grown on tissue culture and demonstrated within tissues by immunofluorescence and
immunoperoxidase techniques. Borna disease virus can also be detected in formalin-fixed,
paraffin-embedded brain tissues using a nested PCR.
Specific control measures cannot be recommended because of the lack of knowledge of
means of transmission of the virus. The role of inapparently infected horses in transmission
of the disease is unknown, and there is no widespread program for testing for such
horses. An attenuated virus vaccine was produced by continued passage of the virus
through rabbits and used in the former East Germany until 1992. However, its use was
discontinued because of questionable efficacy.
Further Reading
Lipkin
WI
Borna disease virus—Fact and fantasy
Virus Res
162
2011
162
172
21968299
References
1
Lipkin
WI
Virus Res
162
2011
162
21968299
2
Lutz
H
J Feline Med Surg
17
2015
614
26101313
3
Jacobsen
B
J Comp Pathol
143
2010
203
20153871
4
Bukovsky
C
Vet Rec
161
2007
552
17951563
5
Bjornsdottir
S
Acta Vet Scand
55
2013
77
24180621
6
Kinnunen
PM
J Clin Virol
38
2007
64
17129759
7
Dietzel
J
Vet Pathol
44
2007
57
17197624
Teschovirus Infections
Important enteric viruses of the pig belong to the Picornaviridae particularly enteroviruses,
teschoviruses and sapeloviruses (formerly porcine enterovirus A or porcine enterovirus).
Serotypes
The most important disease of this group is Teschen itself, which was restricted to
a particular region around the town of Teschen in Czechoslovakia and the surrounding
parts of Eastern Europe.1, 2 The mild forms of the disease have occurred elsewhere
and are referred to as Talfan or in the past poliomyelitis suum or benign enzootic
paresis, and these are probably present worldwide.
Synopsis
Etiology Porcine enteroviruses capable of causing encephalomyelitis. Teschen virus,
Talfan virus, and others.
Epidemiology Certain European countries, Scandinavia, and North America. Morbidity
50%; case fatality 70%–90%. Teschen in Europe. Talfan in UK. Viral encephalomyelitis
in North America. Transmitted by direct contact.
Signs Acute Teschen: fever, stiffness, unable to stand, tremors, convulsions, and
death in few days
Subacute Talfan: milder than acute form. Most common in pigs under 2 weeks of age.
Morbidity and case–fatality rate 100%. Outbreaks. Hyperesthesia, tremors, knuckling
of fetlocks, dog-sitting, convulsions, blindness, and death in a few days. Milder
in older growing pigs and adults.
Clinical pathology Virus-neutralization tests.
Lesions Nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis.
Diagnostic confirmation Demonstrate lesion and identify virus.
Differential diagnosis list
•
Pseudorabies
•
Hemagglutinating encephalomyelitis virus
Treatment None.
Control Outbreaks will cease and herd immunity develops.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Originally, there were at least 13 enterovirus members, and these are now reclassified.
The viruses are resistant to environmental effects (in one study of disinfectants
only sodium hypochlorite was effective), are stable, and easily cultivated. The only
known host is the pig, and the viruses are not zoonotic.
Important enteric viruses belong to the Picornaviridae and the genera Enterovirus,
Teschovirus, and Sapelovirus (these were formerly known as porcine enterovirus A or
porcine enterovirus serotype B.
1
In a survey of 206 viral isolates 97 (47%) were identified as teschoviruses, 18% as
sapeloviruses, and 3% as adenoviruses.
3
Porcine enteric picornaviruses produce asymptomatic infections as well as reproductive
disorders, diarrhea, pneumonia, and dermal lesions. These viruses were previously
classified as enteroviruses. They are now reclassified into three groups on the basis
of genomic sequences: (1) porcine teschoviruses (PTVs) with 11 different serogroups;
(2) porcine enterovirus B, which corresponds to the former enterovirus serotypes 9
and 10; and (3) porcine sapelovirus (PSV), which corresponds to former enterovirus
type 8 and has a single serotype that is divided into antigenic variants (PEV 8a,
8b, and 9c). It is associated with reproductive disease, diarrhea, and pneumonia.
It appears that PTV-1, the most virulent type, is only found in Central Europe (there
have been a number of independent isolates, such as the Konratice and Reporyje strains)
and Africa. Talfan virus, isolated from England, and other unnamed isolates appear
less virulent. Teschen and Talfan virus occur in subgroup 1, which is now called porcine
enterovirus group 1 (PEV-1), but isolates from encephalomyelitis are also associated
with other subgroups. The other PTVs and PSV are ubiquitous. Porcine enterovirus B
(PEV-9 and PEV-10) is found in Italy, UK, and Japan.
4
A PTV caused respiratory distress and acute diarrhea in China in 50-to 70-day-old
pigs.
5
PTV-8 (a sapelovirus in the new classification) caused a SMEDI-like syndrome in China,6,
7 in which approximately 80 gilts aborted and many piglets were stillborn or died
soon after birth; samples from most were PTV positive.
Within subgroups, strains may be further differentiated using a complement fixation
test and monospecific sera. There is variation in virulence between strains, and with
many strains, clinical encephalitis following infection appears to be the exception
rather than the rule. Most of the infections are subclinical.
Polioencephalomyelitis is associated with PTV-1, 2, 3, and 5; reproductive disease
is associated with PTV-1, 3, and 6; diarrhea is associated with PTV-1, 2, 3, and 5;
pneumonia is associated with PTV-1, 2, and 3; pericarditis and myocarditis have been
associated with PTV-2 and 3; and cutaneous lesions are associated with PTV-9 and 10.
Epidemiology
Occurrence and Prevalence of Infection
There is serologic evidence that the disease occurs throughout the world. The most
severe form of the disease, Teschen disease, appears to be limited to Europe and Madagascar,
but the milder forms occur extensively in Europe (Hungary, 2012), Scandinavia, and
North America (2002–2007) and recently in Japan (2012). The recent outbreak in the
United States (Indiana) was ascribed to porcine enterovirus Serogroup 5 or 6 with
the only characteristic feature being the histologic lesions of polioencephalomyelitis.
Losses caused by the disease result primarily from deaths.
Serologic surveys in areas where the disease occurs indicate that a high proportion
of the pig population is infected without any clinical evidence of the disease. In
the majority of field occurrences, porcine encephalomyelitis is a sporadic disease
affecting either one or a few litters, or a small number of weaned pigs.
Morbidity and Case Fatality
The morbidity rate is usually about 50% and the case–fatality rate 70% to 90% in Teschen.
Talfan is much milder, and the morbidity rate below 6%.
Methods of Transmission
Infection is transmitted by the fecal–oral route and therefore by ingestion and possibly
by aerosol. The virus replicates primarily in the intestinal tract, particularly the
lower intestine and the ileum but also in the respiratory tract. Replication is thought
to be in the reticuloendothelial cells of the lamina propria. There may be a viremia
in the Teschen type of disease but not in the mild forms. Piglets may pick up the
infection after weaning when the maternal antibody disappears. Many strains can infect
the pig. They can be infected at any age with a strain that they have not been exposed
to before. When infection first gains access to a herd, the spread is rapid and all
ages of pigs may excrete virus in their feces.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Depending on the virulence of the infecting strain, clinical disease primarily affects
young pigs but may occur in older pigs at the same stage. As infection becomes endemic
and herd immunity develops, excretion of the virus is largely restricted to weaned
and early grower pigs. Adults generally have high levels of serum antibody, and suckling
piglets are generally protected from infection by colostral and milk antibody. Sporadic
disease in suckling pigs may occur in these circumstances in the litters of nonimmune
or low-antibody sows, and may also occur in weaned pigs as they become susceptible
to infection. In the recent outbreak in the United States, the major factor was the
rapid decline of the maternal antibody in the piglets (<21 days). Seroconversion then
coincided with the increased mortality in the herd.
Pathogen Risk Factors
The causative viruses will infect only pigs and are not related to any of the viruses
that cause encephalomyelitis in other species. They are resistant to environmental
conditions, including drying, and are present principally in the CNS and intestine
of affected pigs.
Pathogenesis
The virus multiplies in the intestinal and respiratory tracts and Teschen produces
a viremia. Invasion of the CNS may follow, depending on the virulence of the strains
and the age of the pig at the time of infection. There is some strain difference in
the areas of the CNS primarily affected, which accounts for variations in the clinical
syndrome. Histopathologic evidence of encephalitis may be the only evidence of disease.
Clinical Findings
Acute Viral Encephalomyelitis (Teschen Disease)
An incubation period of 10 to 12 days is followed by several days of fever (40°C-41°C,
104°F-106°F). Signs of encephalitis follow, although these are more extensive and
acute after intracerebral inoculation. They include stiffness of the extremities,
and inability to stand, with falling to one side followed by tremor, nystagmus, and
violent clonic convulsions. Anorexia is usually complete, and vomiting has been observed.
There may be partial or complete loss of voice caused by laryngeal paralysis. Facial
paralysis may also occur. Stiffness and opisthotonus are often persistent between
convulsions, which are easily stimulated by noise and often accompanied by loud squealing.
The convulsive period lasts for 24 to 36 hours. A sharp temperature fall may be followed
by coma and death on the third to fourth day, but in cases of longer duration the
convulsive stage may be followed by flaccid paralysis affecting particularly the hindlimbs.
In milder cases, early stiffness and weakness are followed by flaccid paralysis without
the irritation phenomena of convulsions and tremor. In a recent case in the UK, the
pigs were off-color, showed anterior limb paralysis, and were reluctant to rise and
were therefore euthanized. Pigs were bright and keen to eat and drink.
Subacute Viral Encephalomyelitis (Talfan Disease)
The subacute disease is milder than the acute form, and the morbidity and mortality
rates are lower. The disease is most common and severe in pigs less than 2 weeks of
age. Older sucking pigs are affected too, but less severely and many recover completely.
Sows suckling affected litters may be mildly and transiently ill. The morbidity rate
in very young litters is often 100% and nearly all the affected piglets die. In litters
over 3 weeks old there may be only a small proportion of the pigs affected. The disease
often strikes suddenly—all litters in a piggery being affected within a few days—but
disappears quickly, with subsequent litters being unaffected. Clinically, the syndrome
includes anorexia, rapid loss of condition, constipation, frequent vomiting of minor
degree, and a normal or slightly elevated temperature. In some outbreaks, diarrhea
may precede the onset of nervous signs, which appear several days after the illness
commences. Piglets up to 2 weeks of age show hyperesthesia, muscle tremor, knuckling
of the fetlocks, ataxia, walking backward, a dog-sitting posture and terminally lateral
recumbency, with paddling convulsions, nystagmus, blindness, and dyspnea.
The Dresden type of teschovirus caused an ataxia and recumbency in a large group of
pigs about 5 days after removal of the sows and housing in the production unit. Older
pigs (4 to 6 weeks of age) showed transient anorexia and posterior paresis, manifested
by a swaying drunken gait, and usually recovered completely and quickly. In the Japanese
outbreak, the pigs had at 40 days of age a flaccid paralysis of the hindlimbs and
became recumbent, although they could move using their forelegs. After the initial
group of affected piglets the disease disappeared.
Individual instances or small outbreaks of “leg weakness” with posterior paresis and
paralysis in gilts and sows may also occur with this disease.
Clinical Pathology
Serology
Virus-neutralization and complement fixation are useful serologic tests. Antibodies
are detectable in the early stages and persist for a considerable time after recovery.
Because nearly all pigs are positive, it is only meaningful when paired serum samples
are examined. There is a good ELISA for the detection of teschovirus serology.
Detection of Virus
It is absolutely necessary to collect tissues from acutely ill animals. If they have
been ill for several days, the viruses have probably disappeared.
The virus is present in the blood of affected pigs in the early stages of the disease
and in the feces in very small amounts during the incubation period before the signs
of illness appear. Isolated viruses can be identified by virus neutralization, complement
fixation, and immunofluorescence. Brain tissue is usually used as a source of virus
in transmission experiments. A nested PCR has recently been described in which all
13 serotypes and field isolates were detected using three sets of primer pairs. It
is more rapid and less time-consuming as a test than tissue culture and serotyping.
Now RT-PCR can be used to detect viral RNA. New nested RT-PCRs have been developed
to differentiate the viruses from each other.
Necropsy Findings
There are no gross lesions except muscle wastage in chronic cases. The lesions are
only found by the microscope and are most severe in cases of Teschen. Microscopically,
there is a diffuse nonsuppurative encephalomyelitis and ganglioneuritis with involvement
of gray matter predominating. This takes the form of perivascular cuffing with mononuclear
cells, focal gliosis, neuronal necrosis, and neuronophagia. The brainstem and spinal
cord show the most extensive lesions, often with the most severe lesions in the cord.
These take the form of degenerated or necrotic nerve cells in the ventral horns, glial
nodules, occasional hemorrhage, and a diffuse infiltration of mononuclear cells. In
the white matter the changes were not so severe. Infiltration of mononuclear cells
was also seen in the dorsal root ganglia (together with degenerated ganglion cells
and neuronophagia) spinal nerves, and sciatic nerves. Swollen myelin sheaths and axonal
spheroids were seen in the peripheral nerves. Meningitis, particularly over the cerebellum,
is an early manifestation of the disease. No inclusion bodies are visible in neurons,
in contrast to many cases of pseudorabies. Virus can be isolated from the brain and
spinal cord early in the disease course, and from the blood during the incubation
period. Recovery of the virus from the gastrointestinal tract does not confirm the
diagnosis because asymptomatic enteric infection is common. Isolation attempts may
prove unrewarding, necessitating the correlation of clinical, serologic, and necropsy
findings to confirm the diagnosis. Recently an experimental infection with PEV-3 produced
tremors and paralysis 3 to 7 days postinfection with all the animals having pericarditis
and myocarditis.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: half of midsagittally sectioned brain, spinal cord including spinal ganglia,
gasserian ganglion (LM)
•
Virology: half of midsagittally sectioned brain, spinal cord (ISO, FAT)
In the recent German cases the virus was isolated from all the tissues examined but
not from the blood. A technique using monoclonal antibodies has been described that
can be used either as an immunofluorescent agent or for immunoelectron microscopy.
In the recent Japanese description cytopathogenic agents were recovered from the tonsil,
brainstem, and cerebellar homogenates. The PCR products from these were then sequenced
and the isolate confirmed as PTV. Isolation of virus is not easy and needs to be from
the brain and spinal cord. There are no firm indications of when to take material
and a good consistent site in the brain for isolation.
Differential Diagnosis
The diagnosis of diseases causing signs of acute cerebral disease in pigs is difficult
because of the difficulty in neurologic examination of pigs, and the diagnosis usually
depends on extensive diagnostic laboratory work particularly in histopathology.
Pseudorabies and hemagglutinating encephalomyelitis virus disease are similar clinical
syndromes. In general, viral diseases, bacterial diseases, and intoxications must
be considered as possible groups of causes; careful selection of material for laboratory
examination is essential. The differentiation of the possible causes of diseases resembling
viral encephalomyelitis is described in the section Pseudorabies.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Immunity
Pigs mount a classical humoral response with IgM and IgG and it may be that IgA is
important to prevent entry beyond the intestinal epithelium.
Treatment
There is no treatment.
Control
The sporadic occurrence of the disease in a herd is usually an indication that infection
is endemic. When outbreaks occur, the possibility that introduction of a new strain
has occurred should be considered. However, by the time clinical disease is evident,
it is likely that infection will be widespread and isolation of affected animals may
be of little value. A closed-herd policy will markedly reduce the risk of introduction
of new strains into a herd, but there is evidence that they can gain access by indirect
means. The sporadic nature of the occurrence of most incidents of porcine encephalomyelitis
does not warrant a specific control program.
Teschen disease is a different problem. Vaccines prepared by formalin inactivation
of infective spinal cord and adsorption onto aluminium hydroxide have been used extensively
in Europe. Two or three injections are given at 10- to 14-day intervals and immunity
persists for about 6 months. A modified live virus vaccine is also available.
In the event of its appearance in a previously free country, eradication of the disease
by slaughter and quarantine should be attempted if practicable. Austria reported eradication
of the disease, which had been present in that country for many years. A slaughter
policy was supplemented by ring vaccination around infected premises.
Further Reading
Kouba
V
Teschen disease, eradication in Czechoslovakia: a historical report
Vet Med (Praha)
54
2007
550
560
References
1
Tseng
CH
Tsai
HJ
Virus Res
129
2007
104
17686542
2
Kouba
V
Vet Med (Praha)
54
2007
550
3
Tseng
CH
Tsai
HJ
Virus Res
129
2007
104
17686542
4
Buitrago
D
J Vet Diagn Invest
22
2007
763
5
Sozzi
E
Transbound Emerg Dis
57
2010
434
21040508
6
Zhang
CF
J Virol Methods
167
2010
208
20362007
7
Lin
W
Arch Virol
157
2012
1387
22527870
Prion Diseases Primarily Affecting the Cerebrum
Introduction
The transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) are a group of progressive neurologic
disorders that are transmissible and affect a number of animal species and humans
(Table 14-14
). They are nonfebrile with long incubation periods and a long course of disease.
Table 14-14
Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in animals and humans
Table 14-14
Disease
Acronym
Species
Etiology
First described
Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease
CJD
Man
Sporadic familial iatrogenic
1920
Gerstmann-Straussler-Scheinker
GSS
Man
Familial
1936
Kuru
Man
Acquired
1957
Fatal familial insomnia
FFI
Man
Familial
1992
Variant Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease
VCJD
Man
Acquired
1996
Scrapie
Sheep, goats, mouflon
Natural
1738
Transmissible mink encephalopathy
TME
Mink
Acquired
1964
Chronic wasting disease
CWD
Deer, elk
Natural
1980
Bovine spongiform encephalopathy
BSE
Cattle
Acquired
1986
Zoo ungulate transmissible spongiform encephalopathy
Zoo ungulate TSE
Nyala, kudu, gemsbok, oryx
Acquired
1986
Feline spongiform encephalopathy
FSE
Zoo cats (puma, cheetah and domestic cats)
Acquired
1990
There is a debate about the nature of the infective agent causing TSEs. An abnormal
folded isoform, designated PrPSc, of a host-encoded cell-surface glycoprotein (prion
protein, PrPc) accumulates during disease and is associated closely with infectivity.
The function of PrPC is not known and the mechanism by which PrPC is converted to
PrPSc is uncertain. PrPSc is rich in β-sheets and can be isolated as insoluble aggregates.
A theory is that the transmissible agent is the abnormal isoform of the prion protein
and that, in the infected host, this can recruit further alternatively folded prion
protein by acting as a template for protein folding. With this theory the long incubation
period of prion diseases reflects the rise in level and deposition of PrPSc in a variety
of tissues, including brain, eventually resulting in fatal spongiform encephalopathy.
Scrapie affects sheep and goats and is the prototypic disease for the group in domestic
and wild animals.
Although scrapie in sheep has been recognized for over 200 years, the recent epidemic
of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) has focused public attention and scientific
research on the TSEs. With scrapie, and other TSEs, transmission can be effected by
crude or purified extracts of brain or other tissues from affected animals, and the
infective agent is very resistant to ionizing and ultraviolet irradiation and to reagents
that damage or modify nucleic acids. This, along with other experimental findings,
has led to proposals that the infectious agent in scrapie, and other TSEs, is the
PrPSc itself, and not a small, unconventional virus or virino as previously proposed.
The structure of the infecting PrPSc is thought to imprint on the normal cellular
precursor PrPc, resulting in a change to the abnormal isoform, which is protease resistant
and accumulates in cells.
Naturally occurring TSEs, such as sporadic Creutzfeldt–Jakob (vCJD) in humans or transmissible
mink encephalopathy in mink, are associated with individual species or with closely
related species as with scrapie in sheep, goats, and mouflon (Ovis orientalis musimon)
and chronic wasting disease (CWD) in mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus), white-tailed
deer (O. virginianus), and elk (Cervus elaphus nelsoni).
The results of attempts at interspecies transmission of these diseases are variable.
Although, by definition, each TSE is transmissible, the species to which they will
transmit varies between the TSE, and can be influenced by the route of challenge;
the tissues that contain infection also vary according to the particular TSE. Frequently
they do not transmit. Successful primary transmission between different mammalian
species typically requires a larger dose to affect disease than would be required
for transmission to the same species. Also, usually, parenteral or intracerebral routes
are required and success is greater with young animal recipients. This is the so-called
“species barrier,” which may be absolute or partial because it will affect only a
proportion of animals on first passage, or may result in an extended incubation period
on first passage.
When using transmission studies to detect the presence of one of these agents, optimal
sensitivity is with a recipient host of the same species. Transgenic mice may eliminate
this barrier.
The gold-standard technique for the diagnosis of TSE agents is the passage of tissue
in panels of inbred mice, which is a technique known as “strain typing.” Until recently
this was the only way to differentiate scrapie and BSE. BSE presents with a characteristic
incubation period, pattern of distribution, and relative severity of the changes in
the brain of the different mouse strains (the lesion profile), which is distinct from
all scrapie strains tested.
When examining TSEs as a group, one cannot extrapolate the transmission particulars
of one TSE to another and one cannot extrapolate risk factors or epidemiology from
one to another, and certainly generalizations from an experimental model to a natural
disease across a species barrier is scientifically inappropriate.
The literature on this subject is large. This section will discuss scrapie in sheep
and goats, and BSE, which are the two TSEs of agricultural animals. It will also discuss
the risk for BSE in sheep. CWD in deer is briefly described but has not shown any
evidence for transmission to agricultural animals other than deer.
Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (Mad Cow Disease)
Classical BSE is an afebrile, slowly progressive neurologic disorder affecting adult
cattle. It is a subacute TSE that is uniformly fatal once cattle show signs of nervous
disease. TSEs are caused by accumulation of β-sheets of prion proteins in nervous
tissue, leading to slowly progressive neurodegeneration and death. Current knowledge
suggests that classical BSE originated from a sporadic spongiform encephalopathy preexistent
in the cattle population, and that the causative prion was fed to genetically susceptible
cattle in contaminated animal protein feeds.
Synopsis
Etiology Epizootic disease was most likely caused by a bovine prion called the classical
bovine spongiform encephalopathy strain that was fed back to genetically susceptible
cattle in contaminated meat-and-bone meal. Major concern for zoonotic potential. Some
countries have documented the presence of atypical bovine prion strains (H-type, L-type)
at an extremely low prevalence.
Epidemiology Has occurred as an epidemic in Great Britain associated with the feeding
of infected meat-and-bone meal. Sporadic in other countries.
Clinical findings Nonfebrile disease of adult cattle, with long clinical course. Disturbance
in behavior, sensitivity, and locomotion.
Clinical pathology None specific.
Diagnostic confirmation Histology, demonstration of prion protein.
Treatment None.
Control Slaughter eradication. Avoidance of feeding ruminant-derived protein to ruminants.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
The disease is of considerable importance mainly because it has zoonotic potential
and has spread to many countries. The cost of control is very high.
Etiology
Classical BSE is a prion-associated TSE that causes disease primarily in cattle and
also in a number of other species, including humans.
The stability of the lesion profile in cattle and experimental infection studies strongly
suggests that the bovine epidemic in the UK, and the subsequent extended epizootic
in other countries, was caused by transmission of a single stable bovine prion.
1
A number of alternative hypotheses were originally offered for the epidemic in the
UK. The most popular initial theory was that BSE was caused by transmission of a strain
of scrapie that was modified to infect cattle. However, BSE has many characteristics
that distinguishes it from conventional scrapie strains, and there is no evidence
that cattle develop infection or neurologic disease after 8 or 10 years of oral administration
of the scrapie agent.1, 2 Another hypothesis was that the agent could have entered
into meat-and-bone meal (MBM) from the carcass of an animal that died in a zoo or
a safari park in the UK. This hypothesis was based on the method of carcass disposal
for these animals (many were rendered and not incinerated) and because of the high
susceptibility of certain African ungulates and zoo carnivores to BSE infection. An
additional hypothesis proposed that MBM from the Indian subcontinent was the source.
The UK government has conducted several inquiries into the source of the BSE agent
and the cause of the outbreak including the Phillips report in 2000 and the Horn report
in 2001, but these reports were not conclusive.
The mass exposure of cattle in the UK to this agent, and the subsequent development
of a disease epizootic in cattle in the latter half of the 1980s and the early 1990s,
is currently thought to have been the consequence of a change in the method of processing
of MBM prepared from slaughtered cattle latently infected with the classical BSE strain.
This change in processing permitted the prion to persist in the feed, which was fed
back to cattle to create a positive feedback loop. Subsequent recycling of the agent
in MBM prepared from latently infected slaughter cattle amplified its occurrence until
an epidemic of neurologic disease in adult cattle was identified. In hindsight, it
was not a wise decision to turn an evolutionary herbivore into a carnivore by feeding
contaminated MBM to cattle.
There appear to be at least three different strains of prions identified from cattle
with BSE. Discriminatory testing of 370 BSE cases in the EU between 2001 and 2011
indicated that 83% were classical BSE, which transmits to humans as vCJD, 7% were
atypical high-type (H-type) BSE first diagnosed in the United States in 2004, and
10% were atypical low-type (L-type) BSE.
1
The L-type has been identified in cattle from Belgium, Canada, Germany, Italy, and
Japan, whereas the H-type has been identified in cattle from France, Germany, Japan,
the Netherlands, Poland, Sweden, Switzerland, the UK, and the United States. It is
likely that atypical forms of BSE (H-type, L-type) represent a rare, sporadic, spontaneous
disease in cattle related to old age, with some similarities to sporadic CJD in humans
or the Nor98 variant of scrapie in sheep and goats.
3
Only 42 cases of atypical BSE had been reported by 2010, and all were in cattle at
least 8 years of age with the exception of a possible case in a 23-month-old heifer.
4
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Geographic Occurrence
Classical BSE was first described in Great Britain in 1987, but the BSE inquiries
considered it likely that there had been several undetected cycles of BSE in the southwest
England in the 1970s and early 1980s. Following its description in 1987, the disease
developed to an epizootic with over 183,000 cases, of which more than 95% were detected
before 2000. The epidemic in the UK peaked at an annual total of more than 37,000
clinical cases in 1992. The disease was recognized in Northern Ireland in 1998 and
in the Republic of Ireland in 1999. The disease was subsequently recognized in Switzerland,
Portugal, and France in the early 1990s and then became widespread to involve 27 countries
by 2015.
Cases have occurred in imported British cattle in Oman and the Falkland and Channel
Islands. Countries that have had cases of BSE in native-born cattle are Austria, Belgium,
Canada, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Israel, Italy,
Japan, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland,
UK, and the United States.
Occurrence in Cattle
Great Britain
In Great Britain, the first known clinical case of classical BSE probably occurred
in 1985. The annual incidence subsequently increased and the disease became a major
epizootic in the late 1980s. The disease was declared notifiable, and a statutory
ban on the feeding of ruminant-derived protein to ruminants was introduced in 1988.
A more extensive ban on feeding any animal protein to any agricultural animal was
later implemented to avoid feed cross-contamination. The annual incidence peaked in
1992 and has fallen every year since to produce a bell-shaped epidemic curve at approximately
the year 2000, with some cases every year since (Fig. 14-10
). The reduction from the peak in 1992 is attributed to the 1988 ruminant-feed ban
with the delay in response an effect of the incubation period of this disease. Britain
has had the greatest number of affected cattle and, consequently, provides the majority
of information on the disease.
Fig. 14-10
The number of reported bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) cases in cattle and
variant Creutzfeldt–Jakob (vCJD) cases in humans by date of onset in the UK and in
the European Union (EU) excluding the UK from 1988 to 2013. Note the different multiplier
for BSE and vCJD cases in the UK and EU non-UK.
Fig. 14-10
(Published with permission from the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control.
http://ecdc.europa.eu/en/healthtopics/Variant_Creutzfeldt-Jakob_disease(vCJD)/Pages/factsheet_health_professionals.aspx.)
Herd Type
A great proportion of cases have occurred in dairy and dairy crossbred herds, and
by 2002 62% of dairy herds in Great Britain had experienced one or more cases. In
contrast, 17% of beef herds had cases in the same time period. There has been no apparent
breed predisposition. In both herd types, the risk for cases increased significantly
with increasing herd size. A significant proportion of the cases in beef cattle herds
have occurred in animals purchased into the herds from dairy herds. The reason for
this difference in herd type is thought to be the greater use of concentrates in dairy
cattle.
The disease has occurred in all regions of the country but was most prevalent in southwest
England. Although the disease developed to an epizootic within the country, the disease
does not occur as an epizootic within affected herds and most experience either single
cases or a limited number of cases. The average within-herd incidence has remained
below 2% since the disease was first described.
Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland
In Northern Ireland classical BSE was recognized in 1998 and in the Republic of Ireland
in 1999, but epizootic disease occurred Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The epidemiologic
features in both countries were similar to that in Great Britain, but the incidence
has been lower. In Northern Ireland the incidence was approximately one-tenth of that
in Great Britain. The yearly incidence of the disease peaked in 1994 in Northern Ireland
but jumped unexpectedly in the Republic of Ireland in 1996 to 1998 and has remained
high since. The source of infection in both countries is thought to have been MBM
imported from Great Britain. In the Republic of Ireland there has been geographic
clustering with a higher incidence in two counties possibly associated with the location
of feed suppliers.
European Continent and Iberian Peninsula
On the European continent classical BSE was recognized in Switzerland in 1999 and
shortly after on the Iberian peninsula in Portugal. Both countries showed a case incidence
with evidence of an epidemic curve. However this was not mirrored in EU member states
in the continent, in which only sporadic cases were reported in the 1990s, and it
appears that the disease in this region was unrecognized, underreported, and was more
widespread than recorded. Apparently cattle with typical clinical manifestations and
fallen stock with clinical signs that should have led to a suspicion of BSE were misdiagnosed
or not reported.
Switzerland established a surveillance system in 1999 testing fallen cattle, emergency
slaughter, and normal cattle using Prionics Western blot rapid testing methods. This
surveillance method was rapidly adopted by EU member countries so that all but two
had recorded cases by the end of 2001. In France, between the first notified case
in 1991 and the establishment of mandatory testing in 2000, there were 103 cases detected
by passive surveillance, but it is estimated that 301,200 cattle were infected with
BSE during this period. The first report of L-type BSE was from Italy in 2004.
North America
Canada experienced a case of classical BSE in a cow imported from Great Britain in
1993, but the first case in an indigenous Canadian cow occurred in 2003 in Alberta.
Trace back on 40 herds and slaughter of over 2000 suspects were all negative. The
molecular profile of the BSE agent from this case was very similar to the UK BSE strains
and had no relationship to the agent associated with CWD in deer and elk. In 2003
a Canadian cow that had been exported to the United States as a young calf developed
complications at parturition, was shipped as a nonambulatory cow, and was discovered
as a classical BSE case under a routine monitoring program of downer cows. Canada
had two more cases of classical BSE in 2005. By 2009, Canada had reported 14 cases
of classical BSE, with 1 H-type and 1 L-type.
The United States had a case of atypical H-type BSE in a native-born cow in 2004.
The affected cow had a new prion coding gene (E211K) that suggested the possible existence
of a genetic susceptibility to developing clinical signs.
5
A second case of atypical H-type BSE has been reported in the United States. Genetic
studies have indicated that susceptibility to classical BSE does not appear to be
related to genetic differences in the prion coding gene.
6
Japan
Japan had reported 33 cases of BSE (32 classical and 1 atypical in a 16-year-old Japanese
black cow) by 2007. Cases were attributed to imported infected cattle and imported
fat that was used in a milk replacer formulation fed to calves.
7
Age Incidence
TSEs as a group have long and variable incubation periods, with genetic susceptibility
to clinical disease playing a major role in the age of onset of clinical signs. BSE,
like scrapie, has a long incubation period, 2.5 to at least 8 years and possibly for
the life span of cattle and is a disease that affects mature animals. Epidemiologic
studies suggest that most affected cattle have been infected as calves, with the mean
incubation period decreasing with increasing dose. Risk is greatest in the first 6
months of life and between 6 and 24 months of age risk is related to feeding patterns
of proprietary concentrates. Adult cattle are at low risk for infection.
The modal age at onset of clinical signs is between 4 and 5 years, but there is a
skewed distribution with the youngest age at onset recorded at 22 months and the oldest
at 15 years. During the course of the outbreak in the UK there has been a change in
the age distribution of cases in both Britain and Northern Ireland, consistent with
a sudden decrease in exposure as a result of the bans on ruminant protein feeding.
The clinical course is variable, but the case fatality is 100%. There is a variation
in risk associated with the calendar month of birth-related to seasonal differences
in calf management and exposure to ruminant protein in calf feeds.
The majority of the occasional cases of BSE currently being diagnosed in the UK are
attributed to residual contamination of raw feed, but may also reflect a very low
level prevalence of atypical BSE cases.1, 8
Other Species
Spongiform encephalopathies have been identified in seven species of ungulates in
zoos or wildlife parks in Great Britain since the occurrence of the disease in cattle.
These animals had been fed MBM, but the apparently shorter incubation period suggests
that they might be more susceptible to infection than cattle and there is evidence
for horizontal transmission.
Feline spongiform encephalopathy (FSE) also has been recorded in domestic cats in
Great Britain since 1990 and in zoo felids. The zoo felids had been fed cattle carcasses
unfit for human consumption, or the zoo had a history of BSE in exotic ruminants and
fed culled carcasses to other zoo animals. Transmission studies in mice with the agents
associated with these encephalopathies in zoo ungulates and felids suggest that they
are the same strain that causes BSE. The initial concern that there would be an outbreak
of FSE in domestic cats did not occur, and only 89 cases were confirmed to the end
on 2003.
Method of Natural Transmission
Ingestion of Meat-and-Bone Meal
The initial epidemiologic studies suggested that the disease in the UK was an extended
common-source epidemic, and the only common source identified in these initial studies
was the feeding of proprietary concentrate feedstuffs. Epidemiologic studies also
suggested that the presence of MBM in proprietary concentrates was the proxy for affected
cattle to have been exposed to a scrapie-like agent, and this conclusion is supported
by case–control studies examining feeding practices to calves that subsequently developed
the disease. This hypothesis explains breed differences in incidence because concentrates
are not commonly fed to beef calves in the UK; it also can account for geographic
differences in incidence. The oral route of challenge is known to be an inefficient
route for the transmission of the agents associated with spongiform encephalopathies,
and this is thought to be the reason for the low within-herd incidence of the disease
in the face of a common exposure.
MBM is manufactured by the rendering industry from tissues discarded in slaughterhouses
and from down and dead livestock. The outbreak of BSE in Great Britain was temporarily
preceded by a change in the method of processing of MBM to a continuous process with
a cessation of the use of hydrocarbon fat solvents. It is postulated that this change
permitted the cycling of unrecognized but extremely low-incidence cases of classical
BSE. The initial exposure probably occurred from 1981 to 1982 and, subsequently, the
agent recycled from infected cattle carcasses and offal used in the preparation of
MBM. Rendering procedures have subsequently been devised to minimize survival of the
agent.
The marked fall in disease incidence following the introduction of the feed ban in
1987 in the UK substantiated the importance of ingestion of MBM as the major method
of infection. Bans in Europe were largely introduced in 1990.
Born-After-the-Ban
In the UK and in other countries a number of cattle that were born-after-the-ban (BAB;
French acronym NAIF) have developed the disease. Most of these were born in the years
immediately following the ban and their numbers have decreased in subsequent years
but still continue at low levels. A case–control study found that vertical or horizontal
transmission was not an important cause of these cases. It is thought that MBM that
was already in the food chain at the time, in mills and on the farm, was fed until
it was depleted.
In several countries the occurrence of BAB cases has been geographically clustered,
and also associated with certain birth cohorts. In the UK the clustering was related
to areas with high concentrations of pigs and poultry, and it is thought that there
was cross-contamination of feedstuffs in feedmills. This is certainly possible with
an infective dose of 1 g or less for cattle.
More recently, there has been concern about cattle in the UK that have developed BSE
but that were born after the implementation of the reinforced feed ban in 1996 (BARBs).
Up to 2005, there have been approximately 100 cases. Again there is no evidence of
maternal or lateral transmission and the inadvertent use of illegal feed material
residual on farms is suspected.
9
Non–Feed-Borne Transmission
There is no epidemiologic evidence for significant horizontal or vertical transmission
of the disease in cattle, although the studies suggest that minor horizontal transmission
may occur to birth cohorts of calves that subsequently develop BSE. This type of transmission
is of minor importance to the perpetuation of the disease in a country, but it may
be of significance to human health, and birth cohorts are included in trace backs
of infection in the United States and Canada.
Vertical Transmission
In the absence of other mechanisms of transmission, vertical transmission is not considered
significant for the perpetuation of the disease in an epidemic form. There is an enhanced
risk for the disease in calves born to infected cows, and this is higher in calves
born after the onset of clinical disease in the cow. This may be the result of exposure,
at birth, to high infectivity in birth products because there is no evidence for infection
and transmission in embryo transplants. However, no detectable infectivity has been
found in placentas from cows with the disease.
A very elegant experiment that examined the risk for transmission of BSE via embryo
transfer that used recipient cattle sourced from New Zealand and donor cows clinically
affected with BSE, bred to bulls that did and did not have clinical BSE, concluded,
after a 7-year observation period on the progeny, that embryos were unlikely to carry
BSE.
Modeling the BSE epidemic in the UK indicated a constant and relatively high basic
reproduction number (R
0) that is defined as the expected number of secondary infections produced in a susceptible
population by a typical infected host. If R
0 > 1, then the agent can persist indefinitely; initial estimates for R
0 before the first feed ban in 1988 ranged from 10 to 12. This degree of infectivity
was consistent with the potential that a maximally infectious animal could infect
up to 400 other cattle. Since the feed ban, the value for R
0 is thought to have decreased to 0 to 0.25, indicating that the disease will soon
disappear.
Risk for Occurrence of Disease in Countries
Changes in the method of processing MBM have occurred in countries other than the
UK, and scrapie occurs in sheep in other countries. However, the major risk for the
occurrence of the disease in other countries is the importation of latently infected
cattle and/or the importation of infected MBM. This risk can be substantially avoided
by prohibiting the feeding of MBM to cattle.
An assessment in 1996 of risk for the occurrence of BSE in the United States concluded
that the potential risk of an epizootic was small and that there are substantial differences
in the strength of the risk factors between the United States and the UK. These result
from differences in proportional numbers of sheep and cattle, differences in the nature
of the beef and dairy industries, the type of animal used for beef production and
the age at slaughter, and differences in the practice of feeding ruminant-derived
protein in calf rations, which is uncommon in the United States. Thus the risk of
an outbreak similar to that in the UK was considered negligible. However, a case in
a native-born cow in the United States occurred in 2005. This, and contemporary cases
in Canada suggested that infected MBM was imported to the North American continent
at some time, or that in the United States, the case reflected the very low incidence
of spontaneous atypical BSE in cattle. The cases in both countries occurred in cattle
that were born before the ban on feeding MBM imposed in both countries in 1997.
Countries with largely pastoral cattle are at low risk.
The International Animal health code of the OIE describes five BSE risk categories
for countries based on the importation of cattle from at-risk countries, the importation
of potentially infected MBM, the consumption of MBM by cattle and other animals, animal
feeding practices, livestock population structure, rendering practices, and the potential
for recycling of BSE. In order of increasing incidence of BSE these categories are
BSE free, BSE provisionally free, minimal BSE risk, moderate BSE risk, and high BSE
risk.
Experimental Reproduction
Although studies on the transmissibility and experimental reproduction of BSE were
established before the occurrence of human cases of BSE (vCJD), they have been critical
in determining the risk of cattle products for human disease and the risk for disease
in other species.
In cattle, disease has been experimentally reproduced by oral and intracerebral inoculation
with infected cattle brain homogenates.
Oral, intravenous, and intracerebral inoculation of sheep with infected cattle brain
homogenates also results in disease. Disease has also been reproduced in goats and
mink by parenteral challenge. In pigs, disease has been produced by intracerebral
challenge with infected brain homogenates but not oral challenge. It has not been
produced by any route of challenge in poultry and is not produced by oral challenge
in farmed deer.
Infectivity of Tissues
Brain, spinal cord, and retina are tissues that are infective to cattle or laboratory
animals from natural cases of BSE. The tissues that are infective to cattle or laboratory
animals from experimentally infected cattle are brain, spinal cord, retina, distal
ileum, bone marrow, trigeminal nerve, and lingual lymph tissue. The infective dose
of brain material from a cow with classical BSE appears to be <1 mg of brain tissue.
10
Parenteral injection of BSE brain:
•
Transmits from cattle to cattle, mice, goats, sheep, pigs, mink, guinea pig
Orally fed BSE brain:
•
Transmits from cattle to cattle, mice, mink, sheep and goats
•
Not to pigs or farmed deer
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Other tissues including the major visceral organs, striated muscle, and tissue common
for human consumption were negative by mouse bioassay, indicating that no infectivity
could be detected. These tissues are currently being reexamined for infectivity using
the most sensitive assay known, intracerebral infection into the host species, which
in this case the host is cattle. These studies are ongoing but, at last report have
only confirmed the results of the negative mouse bioassays. There is no evidence of
infectivity in milk based on the fact that calves suckling cows with clinical BSE
do not themselves develop BSE when mature and also on the lack of infectivity with
intracerebral injection of mice.
Strongest evidence of absence of infection in milk is the study that examined and
found no increase in incidence of BSE in calves born to dams with BSE that suckled
these cows during clinical disease compared with calves that suckled clinically normal
dams. There is species susceptibility (no barrier) strength in this study.
BSE, bovine spongiform encephalopathy.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Economic Importance
BSE is not of major economic significance to individual herds in countries in which
it is endemic because of the low within-herd incidence. In most countries, compensation
will cover cases detected by passive surveillance and, with active surveillance, most
of the costs if there is selective culling in affected and trace back herds. However,
it is arguable that this disease is the most economically devastating agricultural
animal disease in the developed world.
The disease has been of major economic importance in the UK and is estimated to have
cost £600 billion. This has been from the national cost associated with detection
and control procedures, the cost of compensation, and the cost of disposal of affected
animals. These costs, along with the cost of loss of export markets, are very high.
Worldwide, the public has developed an extreme concern for the public health risk
associated with BSE infection in cattle and, consequently, all countries have been
mandated or encouraged to develop active surveillance programs. Not to do so runs
the risk of loss of overseas markets and loss of home consumption of beef in favor
of other meats. Further, the detection of a single case of BSE by these active surveillance
programs results in the loss of export markets for the country and a severe fall in
cattle prices for countries that rely on exports in their cattle industries.
BSE is also arguably the disease that has been used most to influence trade in live
cattle and cattle products with no science-base or attention to the internationally
adopted OIE Terrestrial Animal Health Code. This is largely because of the success
of local political influence of ranches and farmers.
It is further arguable that the money spent, for reasons of public health, on this
relatively minor zoonotic disease, by far outweighs its relative importance as a cause
of human disease.
Zoonotic Implications
Concerns that this disease could transmit to man were raised a very short time after
its initial diagnosis. These unfortunately proved true in 1996 when a new form of
CJD was reported. Although, with the initial cases, there was reservation as to causality,
studies showed the agent associated with this disease is similar to that associated
with BSE and the FSEs; there is now no doubt that this is a form of BSE in man. It
differs from CJD in that it affects young people with a mean age onset in the third
decade of life. In humans there is evidence for genetic susceptibility, and all cases
have been homozygous for methionine at codon 129. The disease has been termed variant
CJD (vCJD).
The disease occurred in the UK despite the progressive bans on human consumption of
beef products that contained infectivity that were implemented in 1998 and subsequently
tightened further as new information on potential infectivity became available. It
is possible that exposure of affected humans occurred in the early and mid-1980s,
before the recognition of the disease. There was initially extreme concern that there
would be a very large outbreak in humans. However, this has not occurred. The total
number of deaths form vCJD in the UK has reached 150. The peak number of deaths occurred
in the year 2000, and the outbreak appears to have reached a plateau and is possibly
in decline, although the nature of the outbreak will be dependent on the range of
incubation periods in humans. More than 200 individuals had succumbed to this infection
worldwide by 2015.
Although there is no evidence of direct transmission to humans, veterinarians and
animal handlers should take appropriate precautions when handling nervous system tissues
of infected animals. Cow's milk appears to provide a negligible risk of contracting
vCJD disease.
11
Pathogenesis
Information on the pathogenesis and development of BSE in cattle was initially derived
from studies published from Great Britain in the 1990s that studied the spatial and
temporal development of infectivity and pathologic change in cattle after oral challenge
with a 100-g dose of BSE-affected brain homogenate sourced from naturally clinically
affected cattle. The experimental cattle were killed sequentially following challenge,
and infectivity in tissues was subsequently determined initially by infectivity assays
by intracerebral and intraperitoneal injection into panels of inbred mice and subsequently
by infectivity studies by intracerebral challenge of cattle to exclude any species
barrier effects.
•
Long incubation period (5 years)
•
Oral infection
•
Infection of Peyer's patches, to brainstem via vagus nerve
•
Accumulation of abnormal prions destroys brain slowly
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
BSE prions spread by two antegrade pathways from the gastrointestinal tract to the
CNS: (1) via the splanchnic nerves, mesenteric and celiac ganglion complex, and lumbar/caudal
thoracic spinal cord and (2) via the vagus nerve.
12
Following oral challenge of calves, infectivity was initially detectable in the distal
ileum, in the Peyer's patches, but no infection is demonstrable in other lymphoreticular
organs. Infectivity was identified at 4 months postinfection and was unchanged in
magnitude at 24 months postinfection, revealing no decline or clearance of the agent
from ileal Peyer's patches.
13
Infectivity was demonstrable in the cervical and thoracic dorsal root ganglia at 32
to 40 months after infection and in the trigeminal ganglion at 36 to 38 months. Traces
of infectivity were shown in sternal bone marrow in cattle killed 38 months postexposure.
The earliest presence of abnormal PrP and infectivity in the CNS occurred 32 months
postexposure, before any typical diagnostic histopathologic changes in the brain.
The onset of clinical signs and pathologic change in the brain occur at approximately
the same time. Infectivity of peripheral nerves such as the sciatic nerve appears
to be a secondary event after infection of the CNS.12, 13
More recent reports of the oral experimental dosing studies have indicated that the
50% infective dose for classical BSE was 0.15 g of brain homogenate, with higher oral
doses increasing the likelihood of developing BSE.
14
In addition, the incubation period decreased as the infective dose increased. In other
words, an increase in the incidence of classical BSE disease indicates an increase
in exposure, and a decrease in the age of clinical signs indicates a larger infective
dose.
Clinical Findings
The disease is insidious in onset and the clinical course progresses over several
weeks, varying from 1 to 6 months in duration. There is a constellation of clinical
signs with alterations in behavior, temperament, posture, sensorium, and movement,
but the clinical signs are variable from day to day, although they are progressive
over time Cattle that show behavioral, sensory, and locomotor abnormality together
are highly suspect for BSE. The predominant neurologic signs are apprehensive behavior,
hyperesthesia, and ataxia, and a high proportion of cases lose body condition and
have a diminishing milk yield during the clinical course of the disease. Cattle with
BSE do not always show neurologic signs in the initial stages of the disease, and
animals with BSE may be sent to slaughter for poor production before the onset of
clinical nervous signs. Cattle with vacuolar changes in the brainstem usually have
more severe clinical abnormalities; this observation is consistent with vacuolar change
reflecting a more advanced histologic lesion.
15
Clinical signs in BSE
•
Change in temperament and behavior
•
Apprehension, excitable, unusual kicking, head-tossing when haltered, separation from
group
•
Change in posture and movement
•
Abnormal posture and ataxia
•
Fall in milk production
•
No antemortem test available
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Behavioral changes are gradual in onset and include changes, such as a reluctance
to pass through the milking shed or to leave a vehicle or a pen, a change in milking
order, and a reluctance to pass through passageways. Affected cattle are disoriented
and may stare, presumably at imaginary objects, for long periods. There is hyperesthesia
to sound and touch, with twitching of the ears or more general muscle fasciculation
and tremors. Many throw their head sideways and show head-shaking when the head or
neck is touched.
Other changes in temperament include the avoidance of other cows in loose housing
but antagonistic behavior to herdmates and humans when in confined situations. Affected
animals may kick during milking and show resistance to handling. Some cows show excessive
grooming and licking and may show the equivalent of the scrapie scratch reflex.
Bradycardia, associated with increased vagal tone and not occurring because of decreased
food intake, is reported and may persist despite the cow's nervousness during clinical
examination.
Relatively early in the course of the disease there is hindlimb ataxia with a shortened
stride, swaying gait, and difficulty in negotiating turns. This should be especially
examined as animals exit transport vehicles or are trotted through an area. Knuckling,
stumbling, and falling, with subsequent difficulty in rising, is common in the later
stages of the disease. Cows show progressive weakness, with ataxia and weight loss,
and before the common recognition of the disease, they were sent to slaughter because
of locomotor disabilities or changes in temperament.
It has been recommended that the reaction of the animal to sudden noise, sudden light,
sudden movement, and sudden touch be used as a test. Sudden noise is tested by clanging
two metal objects together out of sight of the animal (the bang test), sudden light
is tested with a camera flash (the flash test), sudden movement is tested by waving
a clipboard toward the cow from a short distance (the clipboard test), and sudden
touch is tested by touching the animal on the hindlimbs with a soft stick (stick test).
Abnormal reactions to these tests include being startled, head-tossing, salivation,
snorting, running away, or panicky circling and kicking out on touch. These tests
have been found positive in BSE suspects that had a history of behavioral change but
did not show abnormalities of gait.
Cattle infected with atypical BSE (H-type, L-type) appear more dull and to have a
greater degree of difficulty in rising than cattle with classical BSE; otherwise they
have similar clinical findings.
16
Abnormal BAEPs have been reported at the onset of neurologic signs in classical BSE-infected
cattle and manifest as prolonged peak latency of waves III and V and prolonged I-V
latency.
17
Prion accumulation in the auditory brainstem nuclei of BSE-infected cattle
18
may contribute to their hyperresponsiveness to the bang test.
Electroencephalographic and evoked potential diagnostic methods have been proposed
as antemortem diagnostic test methods but require further evaluation and would seem
impractical for routine use. Antemortem assessment of retinal function and morphology
identified changes 11 and 5 months before the onset of unequivocal clinical signs
in cattle experimentally infected by intracranial inoculation with classical BSE and
H-type BSE.
19
Strain-specific differences in retinal function, the amount of prion accumulated in
the retina, and the retinal glial response to disease were also identified.
Clinical Signs and Passive Surveillance
There is no reliable preclinical test for BSE, and clinical recognition of BSE is
the major component of passive surveillance.
At the peak of the outbreak in Great Britain, BSE was confirmed in 85% of suspects
picked by passive surveillance. This percentage fell to 56% later in the outbreak.
Farmers were fully compensated at notification and well informed and so were probably
motivated to contact their veterinarian. Veterinarians were also very aware of the
clinical presentation of BSE and observant at livestock markets and while testing
for tuberculosis and at abattoirs. Relatively high success rates were also found in
Switzerland in which approximately 59% of animals notified with BSE were confirmed.
However, in other countries, passive surveillance was an utter failure.
Although an aid to surveillance of a disease, passive surveillance of BSE based on
clinical signs is an insensitive method of disease detection; targeting surveillance
of emergency slaughtered cattle and fallen stock is 40 times more likely to detect
cases of BSE than notification on the basis of clinical signs. One study found that
the odds of finding a BSE case was 49 times higher in the fallen stock and 58 times
higher in emergency slaughtered cattle greater than 24 months of age compared with
passive surveillance of clinical disease.
Clinical Pathology
There is no specific test for the antemortem diagnosis of this disease. Apolipoprotein
E and two unidentified proteins are present in the CSF from clinical cases but not
normal cattle, and the presence of a 30-kDa, 14-3-3 protein in CSF in affected cows
is reported, but there is no information of specificity.
Necropsy Findings
There are no abnormalities in gross pathology, and diagnosis is dependent on histologic
findings or testing of brainstem samples using validated tests based on in situ IHC
or Western immunoblots, with the obex and rostral brainstem being the subsampled region
of choice.
12
The preferred method for determining prevalence is immunology-based rapid tests, which
are validated to detect classical BSE disease-associated prions. These tests typically
apply proteinase K to destroy the cellular isoform of the prion protein (PrPc) while
maintaining a proteinase K–resistant disease-associated isoform (PrPsc). This approach
has identified three types of BSE: classical type (C-type), H-type, and L-type, with
the H and L designation referring to the apparent molecular weights of the proteins.
20
Major histologic changes are in the brainstem, and the pathognomonic lesion is a bilaterally
symmetric intracytoplasmic vacuolation of neurons and gray matter neuropil. The occurrence
of vacuolation in the solitary tract and the spinal tract of the trigeminal nerve
in the medulla oblongata is the basis of the statutory diagnosis of the disease in
Great Britain. In Great Britain, statutory diagnosis is achieved by an examination
of a single brainstem section obtained via the foramen magnum and obviating the need
of extracting the brain with the associated risk of aerosol production. This sampling
location has the potential to miss some cattle infected with atypical BSE.
21
Scrapie-associated fibrils can be visualized by electron microscopy. Government regulatory
agencies are usually responsible for the confirmation of this diagnosis and typically
distribute specific protocols regarding the collection of samples and disposal of
carcasses from suspect animals.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Immunology-based rapid tests: fresh brainstem
•
Histology: formalin-fixed brain, including midbrain and entire medulla oblongata (LM).
Note the zoonotic potential of this disease when handling carcass and submitting specimens.
Differential Diagnosis
The disease should be considered in the differential diagnosis of any progressive
neurologic disease in cattle. Primary differentials on clinical signs include the
following:
•
Hypomagnesemia
•
Nervous acetonemia
•
Rabies
•
Lead poisoning
•
Listeriosis
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Tremorgenic toxins
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment and Control
There is no treatment for the disease.
Detection of BSE in Surveillance and Control Programs
Passive surveillance has been used in many countries. Suspect disease is notifiable
with compulsory slaughter and compensation and disposal of the carcass by incineration.
The limitations of passive surveillance were described earlier and, in most countries,
passive surveillance has been replaced with some form of active surveillance.
Active surveillance was initially directed at a targeted proportion of culled animals,
animals manifesting neurologic disease, rabies suspects negative for rabies, fallen
(down) cattle, and emergency slaughter categories, and a proportion of cattle, or
all cattle, over 24 to 30 months (depending on country) that were presented for slaughter
for human consumption. In slaughter cattle, the sampling frame was set to detect BSE
at a prevalence rate of one mature animal in a million mature animals. The ability
to conduct active surveillance, particularly on slaughter cattle, has been allowed
by the development of rapid tests that can be conducted and read while the carcass
is being held so that positive test cattle are not released for human consumption.
Positive rapid tests need to be confirmed by histology and IHC. More recently, because
the average age of BSE cases has been over 11 years, meaning that they were born before
the date of the reinforced feed ban, the majority of EU countries have now raised
the age limit for testing to 72 months for healthy slaughtered cattle (or even stopped
testing) and to 48 months for fallen stock and emergency slaughter categories.
1
In the United States, following the case of BSE in an imported cow, the United States
Department of Agriculture (USDA) implemented an intensive national testing program
for BSE that concentrated on a targeted high-risk population. The purpose is to help
discover if BSE is in the United States and, if so, at what level. The intention is
to sample as many cattle over a 12- to 18-month period as possible with the goal of
examining 268,500 cattle. This would allow a detection rate of 1 in 10 million with
a 99% confidence level. The cattle will be over 30 months of age and include nonambulatory
cattle, cattle that are too weak to walk, cattle that are moribund, cattle with neurologic
signs, rabies suspects that are negative, and dead cattle.
Control of BSE in Cattle
Control programs use the following assumptions:
•
Infection and disease in cattle is introduced through feeding contaminated feed containing
infected MBM or greaves.
•
The source of infection to cattle can be eliminated by effective prohibition on feeding
infected feed.
•
There is no significant horizontal or vertical transmission.
Based on this, most countries have established a ban on the feeding of ruminant protein
to ruminants. This was done in 1987 in the UK, the mid-1990s in most European countries,
and in 1997 in Canada, the United States and Mexico. There is, however, a strong argument
for banning all mammalian protein for feeding to all livestock. The experience of
several countries with animals that were born after the ban shows that cross-contamination
in feed mills can occur. Although the removal of specified risk materials (SRMs),
(brain, spinal cord, eyes, tonsil, thymus, spleen, and intestines) from cattle carcasses
should reduce the risk of the BSE agent being in the subsequent rendered carcass,
it obviously does not eliminate it. More detail of the regulations and of control
procedures is available.
These control procedures, initiated in the UK, were effective in changing the course
of their epidemic, which is now on the wane.
Measures to Protect Human Health
High-risk animals, such as downer cows, should be kept out of the human food chain
and not rendered for MBM. Infection is present in the tissues listed as SRMs (brain,
spinal cord, eyes, tonsil, thymus, spleen, and intestines), which are removed from
the carcass at slaughter. The removal of SRMs also protects against the risk posed
by cattle that may be incubating the disease yet do not show any clinical signs. Together
with a ban on products such as mechanically recovered meat that could be contaminated
with SRMs, excluding SRMs from the human food chain is the most important food safety
measure to protect public health.
However, this may not be sufficient. The method of slaughter with captive bolt guns
can result in the widespread dissemination of brain within the carcass with dissemination
by blood into the pulmonary tissues and elsewhere. Also, the method of splitting the
carcass and spinal cord can result in significant carcass contamination and contamination
of the slaughterhouse environment. Methods to decrease the risk of contamination of
the carcass at slaughter have been suggested.
Based on transmission and infectivity experiments cattle under 30 months of age are
considered to have very low risk of being infected, but there can be a risk in endemic
countries with cattle over this age. Some countries with a high incidence of BSE have
banned cattle over 30 months of age for human consumption.
Further Reading
Al-Zoughool
M
Cottrell
D
Elsaadany
S
Mathematical models for estimating the risks of bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE)
J Toxicol Environ Health B Crit Rev
18
2015
71
104
26158300
Hamir
AN
Kehrli
ME
Kunkle
RA
Experimental interspecies transmission studies of the transmissible spongiform encephalopathies
to cattle: comparison to bovine spongiform encephalopathy in cattle
J Vet Diagn Invest
23
3
2011
407
21908269
Harmon
JL
Silva
CJ
Bovine spongiform encephalopathy
J Am Vet Med Assoc
234
2009
59
72
19119967
References
1
Acin
C
Vet Rec
173
2013
114
23913566
2
Konold
T
Vet Rec
173
2013
118
3
Gavier-Widén
D
J Vet Diagn Invest
20
2008
2
18182501
4
Dobly
A
BMC Vet Res
6
2010
26
20492661
5
Richt
JA
Hall
SM
PLoS Pathog
4
2008
e1000156
18787697
6
Goldmann
W
Vet Res
39
2008
30
18284908
7
Yoshikawa
Y
J Vet Med Sci
70
2008
325
18460825
8
Ortiz-Pelaez
A
Vet Rec
170
2012
389
22262699
9
Wilesmith
JW
Vet Rec
167
2010
279
20729514
10
Wells
GA
J Gen Virol
88
2007
1363
17374783
11
Tyshenko
MG
Vet Rec
160
2007
215
17308017
12
Hoffman
C
J Gen Virol
88
2007
1048
17325380
13
Masujin
K
J Gen Virol
88
2007
1850
17485547
14
Fast
C
Vet Res
44
2013
123
24359408
15
Konold
T
BMC Vet Res
6
2010
53
21143919
16
Konold
T
BMC Res Notes
8
2012
22
17
Arai
S
Res Vet Sci
87
2009
111
19101002
18
Greenlee
MHW
PLoS ONE
10
2015
e0119431
25756286
19
Fukada
S
J Comp Pathol
145
2011
302
21333306
20
Polak
MP
Zmudzinski
JF
Vet J
191
2012
128
21277240
21
Konold
T
BMC Res Notes
5
2012
674
23217206
Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy and Sheep
There is considerable speculation and concern that the agent of BSE could have become
established in small ruminants. BSE can be readily experimentally transmitted to sheep
and goats and produces clinical signs and lesions similar to scrapie. There is further
concern following a recent report of the transmission of the agent from challenged
ewes to their lambs. Further, the risk to human health from the ingestion of meat
from sheep may be even greater than that from cattle because of the widespread distribution
of the BSE agent in the lymphoid tissue of infected sheep.
In the UK and Europe concentrates are commonly fed to meat-producing breeds of sheep
in late pregnancy and early lactation and less commonly to their lambs. They are also
fed to milk-producing sheep breeds and to lactating goats. Concentrates fed during
the 1980s and 1990s could have contained infected MBM, and this risk would have lasted
until the total ban on feeding MBM to all farm animals in 1996 in the UK and 2001
in Europe.
The inclusion of MBM in concentrate rations for small ruminants was less than that
for cattle, and the proportion of concentrate ration fed was also lower. This, coupled
with the fact that prion diseases require a larger infective dose to produce disease
in a cross-species to that required to produce the disease in the same species (the
species barrier effect) may have resulted in an infective dose to sheep that was too
low to establish infection.
The possibility that BSE did establish in sheep during the BSE epidemic in Britain
is not supported by a study that examined the incidence and new infection rates of
scrapie flocks in Britain covering the period from 1962 to 1998. This study found
no evidence of a change in scrapie occurrence before, during, or following the BSE
epidemic and no temporal or spatial correlations of scrapie occurrence with the BSE
epidemic. There have been other studies that have examined the risk factors for transmission
of BSE to sheep and the possibility that it could be perpetuated by sheep-to-sheep
transmission. Most have concluded that the risk that BSE has established in sheep
is low but, with current knowledge, cannot rule out the possibility.
There are no reports of naturally occurring cases of BSE detected in sheep. However,
there is one report of a TSE in a goat in France that was found to have IHC and immunoblotting
characteristics compatible with BSE, and, following injection into mice, incubation
times compatible with those recorded for experimental ovine BSE.
1
Experimental Transmission
BSE can be experimentally transmitted to sheep and goats by intracerebral, oral, and
intravenous routes using BSE-infected cow brain. The PrP genotype affects the incubation
period in both Cheviot and Romney sheep. PrP genotypes ARQ/ARQ and AHQ/AHQ are associated
with short incubation periods (approximately 18–36 months) following challenge and
also with disease susceptibility. One study further suggests that AHQ/ARQ sheep have
a similar susceptibility to infection, and that sheep homozygous for alanine (A) at
codon 131 and glutamine (Q) at codon 171 are more susceptible to BSE than any other
genotype. In contrast, the PrP genotype ARR/ARR is associated with a long incubation
period in sheep challenged intracerebrally, and ARR/ARR sheep are resistant to BSE
challenged orally and do not have infectivity in their tissues. The ARR allele appears
dominant in this respect because sheep carrying at least one ARR allele in combination
with any other allele have a longer incubation period. PrP genotype VRQ/VRQ appears
to have an intermediate incubation period.
Texel and Lacaune sheep with PrP ARQ/ARQ genotypes are susceptible. However, in these
studies the survival of some sheep with susceptible genotypes suggests that factors
other than the PrP genotype has influence on survival. Challenge dose in all of these
studies has been high.
In a recent study, 30 ewe lambs were dosed orally, at 6 months of age, with 5 g of
infected cattle brain and subsequently mated. Twenty-four developed clinical disease
between 655 and 1065 days postinoculation and two lambs, born before their dams had
clinical disease, also subsequently developed clinical disease. This study indicated
that the agent of BSE can transmit either in utero or perinatally in sheep. There
is no information on other routes of transmission and if they exist.
Pathogenesis
Following challenge of sheep with BSE, infectivity has been found in intestinal Peyer's
patches as early as 5 months postinfection and in enteric nerves and spinal cord after
10 months with widespread dissemination throughout the lymphoreticular system and
peripheral nervous system by 21 months.
1
Clinical Signs
The clinical signs reported in affected experimental animals are not well described
in many of the experimental challenge studies but have varied in different studies.
In one study, sheep and goats showed sudden onset of ataxia, which progressed rapidly
to recumbency. There was little evidence of pruritus and the clinical course was very
short, lasting between 1 and 5 days in the majority of animals with one goat showing
progressive weight loss over 3 weeks before it was culled. Genotype had no influence
on the duration of the clinical course. In another study in sheep only, the clinical
course was approximately 3 months and affected sheep showed pruritus with fleece loss
and ataxia and behavioral change. Ataxia, weight loss, and pruritus were considered
constant in another.
In an experiment designed to test specifically if clinical signs could be used for
differentiation between scrapie and BSE, two different groups of sheep were inoculated
with each agent. The duration of clinical signs varied quite markedly within both
groups with a mean of approximately 9 days for each group but a variation in both
from 1 to over 80 days. As with natural scrapie, there was considerable variation
in the nature of the clinical signs, but there was no marked difference in the frequencies
of clinical signs between the two groups, except that ataxia was the first sign noticed
in a significantly greater proportion of the BSE-challenged group, whereas pruritus
was the first noticed sign in a significantly greater proportion of the scrapie-challenged
group.
Disposition of Disease-Associated PrP
Genotype and route of inoculation influence the disposition of disease-associated
PrP in lymphoreticular system tissues (tonsil, spleen, and mesenteric lymph node).
The most conspicuous effect is the absence of disease-associated PrP in peripheral
lymph tissue in ARR/ARR genotype sheep and lack of infectivity, and there appears
to be an inverse relationship between this disposition and the incubation period.
Route of inoculation influences the relative intensity of disposition in tonsil, spleen,
and mesenteric lymph node.
Following experimental infection of sheep with BSE, disease-associated PrP can be
detected in tonsil biopsies 11 to 20 months after challenge but, in contrast to scrapie,
disease-associated PrP is not detected in biopsies of lymphoid tissue from the third
eyelid.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of BSE in clinically affected cattle can be achieved with several techniques,
including the analysis of symptoms, histopathology, and the detection of the disease-associated
form of the prion protein, by immunocytochemistry, Western blot, or ELISA. The profiling
of vacuoles in the affected host had shown a remarkable uniformity over the year and
from different geographic regions. However, this is not true with scrapie and the
variation in the host brain with scrapie would not allow differentiation from BSE
on histologic findings. The diagnosis of BSE in sheep presents problems, and the similarity
of the clinical signs and pathology between scrapie and BSE could easily result in
naturally occurring cases of BSE in sheep being misdiagnosed as scrapie.
Strain Tying
The gold-standard technique for the diagnosis of TSE agents is the passage of tissue
in panels of inbred mice, a technique known as strain typing. Until recently this
was the only way to differentiate the two diseases. BSE presents with a characteristic
range of incubation periods and a pattern of distribution and relative severity of
changes in the brain of the different mouse strains (the lesion profile), which is
distinct from all scrapie strains tested. However, this method of diagnosis is both
expensive and time-consuming.
There has been a wide search for a differential test system in including prion protein
profiling, studies in glycosylation and glycoform ratios, and other molecular and
biochemical studies that are detailed elsewhere. A recent promising set of studies
suggests that the site of truncation of disease-associated PrP during partial digestion
by proteases located in lysozymes appears different for sheep scrapie and experimental
BSE. After digestion by exogenous enzymes, the BSE PrP molecule is shorter than that
of scrapie stains giving rise to different IHC patterns, and this is supported by
Western blot studies. Unlike scrapie, the intracellular truncation site of ovine BSE
PrP is influenced by the cell type in which it accumulates, giving distinct patterns
of immunolabeling with different PrP antibodies. Epitope labeling shows that the shortest
fragment of disease-associated PrP occurs in tangible body macrophages followed by
glial cells and neurons. It appears that this difference in truncation of PrP in experimentally
infected BSE sheep is not influenced by route of inoculation or by genotype or by
sheep bred, and it is proposed that truncation patterns, as detected by immunoblotting
and IHC, can be used in surveys for BSE in sheep.
Control
If BSE is or does establish in small ruminants in a country, there is significant
concern for human health. The distribution of BSE infection in the carcasses of cattle
is limited and can be removed by the ban of the use of SRMs (largely brain, spinal
cord, and offal). In contrast, the distribution of the BSE agent in infected sheep
is widespread, and it would be virtually impossible to remove this by trimming or
selective organ removal from a carcass for human consumption. Also, lymphocytes in
milk could be infected.
Active surveillance for TSEs in sheep and goats has been increased in the EU, and
several rapid tests for use in sheep and goats are now available.
2
In the UK, a worst-case scenario, published in 2001 in a contingency plan to address
BSE in sheep, threatened the national herd with slaughter, largely on the grounds
that an epidemic of BSE in sheep could be harder to contain than was the case for
BSE in cattle and that lamb could present a greater risk to consumers than beef. A
more recent UK contingency plan would allow PrP genotype ARR homozygous sheep and
ARR heterozygous sheep for human consumption. This plan is the same as the EU, except
that there are differences in the maximum age allowed at slaughter between the UK
and the EU recommendations.
The risk for BSE in sheep was a major incentive for the development of national breeding
programs for the control of scrapie, and possible BSE, including the National Scrapie
Plan in the UK, launched in 2001, and the National Scrapie Eradication Program in
the United States. The purpose in these breeding programs is to select against highly
susceptible genotypes and select for the highly resistant genotype.
References
1
Harmon
JL
Silva
CJ
J Am Vet Med Assoc
234
2009
59
19119967
2
van Keulen
LJM
Arch Virol
153
2008
445
18092124
Scrapie
Synopsis
Etiology A transmissible agent (prion, a proteinaceous infectious particle) that is
highly resistant to chemical and physical agents, and appears not to contain DNA.
Susceptibility of sheep to developing clinical disease after infection is determined
by genetics.
Epidemiology Transmitted primarily by contact with infected sheep and from environmental
contamination; very long incubation period.
Clinical findings Nonfebrile disease of adult sheep, goats, and mouflons with insidious
onset and long clinical course. Clinical disease is rare in goats and mouflons. Affected
animals show behavioral change, tremor, pruritus and locomotor disorder, and wasting.
Clinical pathology Demonstration of scrapie prion protein by immunostaining of the
obex in brain and selected lymphoid tissue elsewhere.
Lesions Vacuolation of gray matter neuropil and neuronal perikarya, neuronal degeneration,
gliosis.
Diagnostic confirmation Demonstration of scrapie prion protein.
Treatment None.
Control Slaughter eradication. Genetic testing and selection/culling.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Scrapie is a nonfebrile, fatal, chronic disease of adult sheep, goats, and mouflons
(one of two ancestors of all modern sheep breeds) characterized clinically by pruritus
and abnormalities of gait, and by a very long incubation period. It is the prototypic
disease for a group of diseases known as TSEs. This group also includes CWD of deer
and elk; transmissible mink encephalopathy; and FSE, CJD, and other spongiform encephalopathies
of humans, and the relatively new disease, BSE, which is described separately under
that heading. In Iceland scrapie is known as
rida
, in France as
la tremblante, and in Germany as
traberkrankheit
.
Etiology
There has been a significant historical debate over the etiology of this disease.
The current consensus view is that scrapie is associated with an infectious agent,
but that the incubation period for clinical manifestation of the disease and the susceptibility
of the host to developing clinical disease after infection is determined by genetics.
In other words, to develop clinical disease caused classical scrapie, an animal must
be exposed to the infectious agent and have a susceptible genotype.
Scrapie can be transmitted experimentally to other sheep and to certain laboratory
animals, and infection induces the production in the brain, and some other tissues,
of amyloid fibrils called scrapie-associated fibrils or prion rods. The main constituent
of these is a disease-specific, protease-resistant neuronal membrane glycoprotein
termed the prion protein, or PrPSc. PrPSc is an abnormal isoform of a host-coded membrane
glycoprotein, PrPC, and the TSEs are characterized by the accumulation of PrPSc in
neuronal and other tissue.
Transmission can be effected by crude or purified extracts of brain or other tissues
from affected sheep, and the infective agent is very resistant to ionizing and ultraviolet
irradiation and to reagents that damage or modify nucleic acids. This, along with
other experimental findings, has led to the accepted view that the infectious agent
in scrapie is PrPSc itself, and not a small, unconventional virus or virino as previously
proposed. The structure of the infecting PrPSc is thought to imprint on the normal
cellular precursor PrPC, with the template resulting in a change to the abnormal isoform
which is protease-resistant and accumulates in cells.
More than 20 different strains of scrapie have been identified based on the following:
•
Strain typing by differences in incubation time of the experimental disease in inbred
strains of mice of different genotype
•
The type, pattern, severity, and distribution of lesions in the brain of the different
strains of experimental animals (lesion profiles)
•
Resistance to thermal inactivation
•
The type of disease produced in sheep and experimental animals (e.g., drowsy versus
pruritic manifestations in goats)
•
The ability of a strain to produce disease in different species of experimental animals
It is proposed that strain differences reflect differences in replicating information
carried within the conformational state of the PrPSc. The more important strains identified
are called classical scrapie strains, comprising strain A and strain C (thought to
be the most prevalent strain in the United States), and atypical (or discordant or
nonclassical) scrapie strains, comprising the Nor98 strain and other discordant strains.
Coinfection of strains can occur with scrapie.
Nor98 was first reported in 1998 in five unrelated Norwegian sheep that had PrPSc
in a different location (cerebellum) than usually reported with scrapie. Nor98 has
now been identified in sheep in a number of countries. Atypical scrapie is thought
to arise spontaneously and not be associated with an infective source.
1
Interestingly, atypical scrapie is usually not clinically apparent, but there are
reports of sheep infected with atypical scrapie strains exhibiting some of the typical
clinical signs of classical scrapie, particularly rear limb ataxia.1, 2 Atypical scrapie
caused by Nor98 has been diagnosed in sheep in Australia and New Zealand; these are
two countries that do not have classical scrapie.
3
Atypical scrapie is not considered rare compared with classical scrapie and appears
to occur at a constant prevalence in different countries.
4
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Geographic Occurrence and Incidence
Scrapie in sheep occurs enzootically in the UK, Europe, and North America. Outbreaks
have been reported in Australia, New Zealand, India, the Middle East, Japan, and Scandinavia,
principally in sheep imported from enzootic areas. Australia and New Zealand used
vigorous importation, quarantine, and culling policies to prevent subsequent entry
of the disease and are considered free of disease.
The true prevalence of the disease both within and between countries is not known
because there has been no test to detect the presence of infection in individual sheep
or in flocks at all stages of infection. This is further confounded by secrecy about
the existence of scrapie in many flocks and breeds. This secrecy results from a fear
of economic penalties that could result from the admission of infection.
In Great Britain, where the disease is enzootic and has been recognized for over 250
years, the true incidence is unknown, although a questionnaire survey in 1988 suggests
that one-third of sheep flocks are infected. In infected flocks the annual incidence
ranges from 0.4 to 10 cases per 100 sheep per year, with a mean of 1.1 cases per 100
sheep per year. However, the annual incidence can approach 20% of the adult flock,
on occasions up to 40%, and in flocks where there is no selection against the disease
the annual incidence and mortality can reach a level that results in disbandment of
the flock or its nonsurvival.
Farmer consultation with a veterinarian about a case of scrapie and farmer reporting
of cases of scrapie are notoriously low. Historically, this is because factors such
as the stigma associated with having scrapie diagnosed in a purebred flock and concerns
for future sales or, in the case of commercial flocks, a lack of incentive to consult
and a lack of concern because nothing can be done to cure the present case or prevent
future cases. In England, it has been estimated that only 13% of farmers who had a
suspected case of scrapie in the past 12 months reported it. Possibly, the chance
of improvement through genetic selection will alter this farmer trait.
In the United States the disease is thought to have been introduced in 1947, and by
1992 was found in 657 flocks in 39 states. In 2007 the prevalence of infection in
the United States was estimated at 0.1% to 0.3%.
Host Occurrence
Age
Scrapie is a disease of mature sheep, although most are exposed as young sheep, and
the incidence decreases with age at exposure. The age-specific incidence in sheep
is highest between 2.5 and 4.5 years of age and cases rarely occur under 18 months
of age. Natural disease in goats is rare. The age at death is similar to that in sheep,
with a range from 2 to 7 years. The case–fatality rate, with time, is 100%. The death
loss is added to by the slaughter of infected and in-contact animals in countries
where control and eradication is a practice.
Breed
Scrapie occurs in both sexes and in the majority of breeds, although the incidence
is higher in some breeds than others. Breed differences in prevalence occur in several
countries; an example would be the high prevalence in the Suffolk breed in the United
States relative to white-faced breeds and in some Hill breeds in the UK. These probably
reflect breed and flock differences in genetic susceptibility to the development of
clinical disease. Similarly, the occurrence of outbreaks of scrapie may result from
the introduction of infection to a genetically susceptible flock or to a change in
the genetic structure of flocks that are infected.
Methods of Transmission
Knowledge of transmission of scrapie is based primarily on the experimental disease
and observations of the natural disease in experimental flocks.
Sources and Routes of Infection
The usual method of introduction into unaffected flocks is by the purchase of preclinically
infected sheep. Infectivity can be demonstrated in the placenta, fetal fluids, saliva,
colostrum, and milk of naturally occurring cases,5, 6, 7 and in the oral cavity of
sheep with preclinical scrapie,
8
but has not been demonstrated in the urine or feces of natural cases, even though
it can be demonstrated in the intestine. Ingestion of infected material appears the
most likely route of infection, but scarification of the skin and conjunctival inoculation
will also allow infection. Hay mites have been found to harbor the agent on scrapie-infected
properties and have been proposed as a reservoir for infection.
Horizontal Transmission
This is the usual method of spread, and the placenta is considered the major source
of infection for the mother to her lamb, and to other lambs in close contact. Under
natural conditions the disease in flocks often runs in families, and whether or not
a lamb contracts scrapie appears to depend primarily on the current or future scrapie
status of its dam. It is common for all the VQR/VQR lambs from dams dying of classical
scrapie to develop scrapie.
Scrapie can also transmit between sheep in close contact, and this can occur from
sheep in the preclinical phase of the disease. Scrapie can be transmitted by blood
transfusion. The importance of this route of infection in field infections appears
low because successful transmission appears to require at least 400 mL of blood.
Under natural conditions, scrapie occurs in sheep and occasionally spontaneously in
goats. Under experimental conditions, scrapie has been observed to spread from sheep
to goats by contact, and the little evidence available on the natural disease in goats
is consistent with the view that the scrapie can be maintained by contagion in a herd
of goats living apart from infected sheep.
Vertical Transmission
There is a greater risk for scrapie in lambs born to infected dams, but this most
probably reflects horizontal transmission at birth from placentas. There are conflicting
results between studies that have examined transmission by embryo transfer, and the
importance of vertical transmission to the epidemiology of the natural disease remains
to be determined. However, epidemiologic studies suggest that it is of rare occurrence,
and there is significant evidence against the occurrence of in utero transmission.
The agent has not been demonstrated in the testes or semen of rams.
Environment
An infected environment can also be the source, and scrapie-free sheep can develop
disease after grazing pasture previously grazed by scrapie-infected sheep, with infection
by ingestion or possibly via abrasive lesions. Environmental infection can occur from
the products of parturition and, although the scrapie agent has not been demonstrated
in feces, it is suspected as being so in infected animals. The duration of infectivity
on inanimate materials such as pasture has not been defined, but field and experimental
observations indicate that it is a long time, probably in excess of 16 years under
some conditions.9, 10
Iatrogenic Transmission
An outbreak of scrapie occurred in the 1930s following the use of a vaccine against
louping-ill prepared from the brains of sheep. More recently, the use of a vaccine
against contagious agalactia has been epidemiologically linked to an outbreak of scrapie
in sheep and goats in Italy where there was a high attack rate and high mortality
affecting several birth cohorts.
Genetics
Scrapie is recorded in most breeds of sheep, but there are breed, family, and individual
differences in susceptibility. There is substantial genetic control of the incidence
of disease, and in both the natural and experimental disease, genetics is a major
determinant of susceptibility with the susceptibility of sheep strongly linked to
certain polymorphisms in the sheep PrP gene.
In earlier studies, experimental challenge and breeding showed that sheep could exhibit
a long or short incubation period following challenge, and that this difference in
incubation period or susceptibility was determined by a single gene called scrapie
incubation period (Sip). There is a similar gene in mice (Sinc) that determines incubation
period and susceptibility following experimental challenge. The Sip gene has two alleles,
sA and pA, which, respectively, shorten or prolong the experimental incubation period
for most strains of the scrapie agent. The subsequent recognition of prion protein
(PrP) and its association with scrapie led to the recognition of the gene that encodes
PrP, which was found congruent to Sip in sheep, and Sip genetics have been entirely
superseded by PrP genetics.
Sheep have one pair of genes that influence susceptibility to scrapie known as the
prion protein genes. These code for a normal prion protein in the cell (PrPC), which
has 254 amino acids with each codon in the gene encoding for a specific amino acid
at a particular location on PrPC. PrPC can be converted to a scrapie prion protein
molecule (PrPSc) in infected sheep which, when it accumulates in the CNS, causes disease.
The susceptibility of sheep to this conversion, and thus to scrapie, is strongly associated
with certain polymorphisms at codons 136, 154, and 171. It is thought that there are
at least two groups of scrapie TSE strains, one of which is influenced primarily by
the amino acid at codon 136 and the other group by the amino acid at codon 171. Within
these there may be subtypes because resistance to some 136-type TSEs can be affected
by the amino acid at codon 154.
•
At codon 136 valine (V) is linked to scrapie susceptibility and alanine (A) is linked
with resistance
•
At codon 154 histidine (H) is linked to susceptibility and arginine (R) to resistance
•
At codon 171 glutamine (Q) and histidine (H) are linked to susceptibility and arginine
(R) to resistance.
•
The notations used for descriptions of the prion protein (PrR) genotype vary in different
countries.
•
The susceptibility of sheep to scrapie is strongly associated with polymorphisms at
codons 136, 154, and 171 in the prion protein gene.
•
The amino acids associated with these polymorphisms are alanine, valine, histidine,
arginine, and glutamine.
•
In the description of the PrP genotype these are given the letters A, V, H, R, and
Q, respectively.
•
The PrP genotype is listed in the order of codon 136 followed by 154 and then 171.
•
The amino acid at each codon is listed according to the letter designation for each
of the two alleles separated by a backslash. Examples are ARR/ARR or ARR/VQR. These
could also be expressed as AA136RR154RR171 and AV136RQ154RR171.
•
In sheep in the United States the polymorphisms at codon 171 are the major determinant
of scrapie susceptibility. Polymorphisms at codon 154 play a minor role and are usually
not listed as part of the PrP genotype.
•
Genotypes in the United States are usually referred to using the letters of the amino
acids in numerical order codon 136 followed by codon 171.
•
The previous examples would be AA RR and AV RR.
•
They can also be referred to using the codon number followed by the corresponding
amino acid 136AA, 171RR and 136AV, 171RR or the amino acid followed by the codon.
•
Often only the amino acids at codon 171 are listed.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Of the possible alleles from these polymorphisms, only five, ARR, ARQ, VRQ, AHQ, ARH,
are commonly seen. The relationship between PrP genotype and susceptibility to scrapie
is shown in Table 14-15
using the groupings of the British National Scrapie Plan.
Table 14-15
PrP genotype and susceptibility to scrapie in national scrapie program in Great Britain
Table 14-15
NSP Type
Main characteristic
Genotypes
Comments
1
ARR homozygous
ARR/ARR
Genetically most resistant
2
ARR heterozygous non-VQR
ARR/AHQARR/ARQARR/ARH
Sheep that are genetically resistant to scrapie, but will need careful selection when
used for further breeding
3
Non-ARR and non-VQR
AHQ/AHQARQ/AHQAHQ/ARHARH/ARHARQ/ARHARQ/ARQ
Sheep that genetically have little resistance to scrapie and will need careful selection
when used for further breedingGroup 3 risk varies and can depend on breed, e.g., ARQ/ARQ
Suffolk are highly susceptibleARQ/ARQ Cheviots are relatively resistant
4
ARR/VQR heterozygous
ARR/VRQ
Sheep that are genetically susceptible to scrapie and should not be used for breeding
unless in the context of a controlled breeding
5
VQR and non-ARR
AHQ/VRQARQ/VRQARH/VRQVRQ/VRQ
Sheep that are highly susceptible to scrapie and should not be used for breeding
NSP, National Scrapie Program.
It can be seen from Table 14-15 that in the Britain, the VQR allele confers the greatest
degree of susceptibility and that ARR is associated with resistance. Estimates that
quantify risk in the British national flock based on genotypes of the sheep, and those
of scrapie-affected sheep, are available but they are not strongly concordant. There
is also an effect of PrP genotype on the incubation period, with the most susceptible
genotypes (VQR) having the shortest incubation period and dying of scrapie at a younger
age.
The frequency and distribution of the various PrP genotypes varies considerably between
flocks and between breeds of sheep. There are also some marked between-breed differences
in susceptibility with the same PrP genotype.
Susceptibility in the Suffolk and other black-faced breeds in the United States appears
less complex than in other breeds and is strongly associated with sheep that are homozygous
for glutamine at the 171 codon (171QQ) of the PrP gene, but is rare in sheep heterologous
for glutamine and arginine (171QR) or homozygous for arginine (171RR) at codon 171.
Suffolks are the predominant breed affected with scrapie in the United States. They
lack the VRQ allele, and the ARQ/ARQ genotype is the genotype that confers the greatest
susceptibility. The association between genotype and susceptibility, as defined in
the scrapie eradication plan of the USDA, in the United Sates is shown in Table 14-16
.
Table 14-16
Scrapie susceptibility and genotype as defined by the U.S. Scrapie Eradication Plan
Table 14-16
Genotype
Susceptibility
1.
AA RR
Sheep that are resistant
2.
AA QR
Sheep that are rarely susceptible
3.
AV QR
Sheep that are susceptible to some scrapie strains that are thought to occur with
low frequency in the United States
4.
AA QQ
Sheep that are highly susceptible
5.
AV QQ
Sheep that are highly susceptible
6.
VV QQ
Sheep that are highly susceptible
Factors other than the PrP genotype influence susceptibility to scrapie because not
all sheep with a susceptible genotype challenged with scrapie subsequently develop
the disease. Also, there are some breed differences in the level of resistance or
susceptibility conferred by a given genotype. For example, ARQ/ARQ Suffolk sheep are
highly susceptible to scrapie, whereas ARQ/ARQ Cheviots are relatively resistant.
Breed differences in PrP genotype scrapie disease linkage and disease pattern differences
with atypical strains of scrapie may be associated with polymorphisms in the PrP gene
promoter. Atypical scrapie caused by to Nor98 strain is most common in sheep in Europe
carrying phenylalanine (F) at position 141 or the PrP genotypes ARR/ARR, ARR/ARQ,
and AHQ/ARQ.11, 12, 13
There is less information on the genetics of scrapie in goats. There is high variability
in the goat PrP gene that possibly can be exploited to select for goat-specific scrapie-resistant
PrP genotypes. An initial report indicated that the H154, Q211, and K222 single nucleotide
polymorphisms were associated with a high resistance to classical scrapie.
14
Risk Factors
Exposure Factors
There is a dose–response relationship in naturally occurring scrapie. The high incidence
in some Icelandic flocks is attributed to a high level of exposure, resulting from
a long winter housing period with a higher risk for disease in lambs born in the winter
housing period.
Factors that influence exposure risk will vary with the management systems, which
can vary markedly between countries. With that caveat, risk factors that have been
identified in case–control studies include the following:
•
A higher risk for scrapie in larger flocks and in pedigree flocks
•
A greater risk in flocks that lamb communally in group pens compared with those that
lamb in individual pens or outside on pasture
•
A greater risk in flocks that disposed of the placenta in the compost and spread sheep
compost on the land
•
A lower risk in flocks in which cow compost is spread on the land
•
A greater risk in flocks that purchased replacement sheep through the market
•
A greater risk where different flocks share pastures or rams
Age at Exposure
Lambs exposed at birth have a shorter incubation period and higher risk for scrapie
than lambs exposed at 6 to 9 months of age. Similarly, lambs or goats removed from
infected dams at birth to a scrapie-free environment have a lower incidence of scrapie
than those removed at later times.
Infection Status of Parents
Lambs born to affected ewes are at increased risk for scrapie, and the offspring from
an infected ewe and an infected ram are at greater risk than those born from an infected
ewe and an uninfected ram. However, even in high-incidence herds a considerable proportion
of disease cannot be attributed to parental scrapie status and results from horizontal
transmission. Also, the number of genetically susceptible sheep in an affected flock
can increase the infection pressure.
Goats
Scrapie in goats is rare, and most cases arise in goats that are in close contact
with infected sheep. Scrapie can spread from goat to goat with no sheep contact.
Experimental Reproduction
The agent is present in the brain, spinal cord, lymph nodes, intestinal tract tissue,
and spleen of infected sheep, and has been extracted from sheep and goat brain. Experimentally,
the disease can be transmitted to sheep, goats, mice and other laboratory animals
using these tissues, and by a variety of routes of inoculation. The experimental disease
has a long incubation period that varies with the strain of the agent and the genetics
of the recipient. Transmission of the disease to sheep has also been effected by the
oral or intracerebral administration with fetal membrane material from known infected
ewes. Accidental transmission is recorded following vaccination against louping-ill,
with vaccine contaminated by the agent of scrapie, and resulted in widespread dissemination
of the disease.
Pathogen Risk Factors
The scrapie agent can be maintained in tissue culture, and infectivity is retained
with passage. It can also be perpetuated in experimental animals. Infectivity also
survives for remarkable periods in dead and formalinized tissues; infected brain homogenates
buried in soil for 3 years retain their infectivity. It is highly resistant to physical
and chemical influences and can survive decontamination processes that are effective
against conventional viruses. It is capable of withstanding the usual virucidal procedures
and is not destroyed by boiling, by rapid freezing and thawing, or by exposure to
ether or 20% formalin. Conventional heat treatments may reduce infectivity, but the
agent is remarkable resistant to heat and steam sterilization at 27 psig (132°C) is
required to totally destroy it. Chemical inactivation can be achieved with sodium
hypochlorite providing 2% (20,000 ppm) of available chlorine acting for 1 hour, and
by 4% sodium hydroxide.
Economic Importance
Scrapie is of major concern to pedigree flocks and, if present and public, will curtail
the sale of sheep and effectively result in the dissolution of the flock. Some countries
have, or have had, eradication schemes. The disease is also of major international
importance because of the embargos maintained by several countries against sheep from
enzootic areas.
Zoonotic Implications
There is no evidence for transmission of scrapie to humans or for a risk to public
health.
Pathogenesis
In both sheep and mice, the agent shows a predilection for tissues of the lymphoreticular
system in which it replicates during the incubation period before invading the nervous
system. In naturally infected sheep, replication begins in the tonsil, retropharyngeal
lymph node and Peyer's patches, and gut-associated lymphoid tissue, which probably
reflects the oral route of infection. PrPSc subsequently becomes disseminated to other
lymph nodes and the spleen. There may be a considerable period, ranging from 14 months
to 7 years, before there is infection of the brain, and during this infection in the
lymphoreticular system probably provides the reservoir for maternal and horizontal
transmission. The action of the PrP genotype may be to delay neural invasion, in which
case it is possible that a nonclinical carrier state may exist for scrapie.
How the scrapie agent reaches the CNS is not certain, but it is probably through transportation
across intestinal villous enterocytes
15
and subsequent infection of the autonomic nervous system. Gut-associated lymphoid
nodules in the Peyer's patches have a substantial network of nerve fibers and are
probably the site for neuroinvasion. The scrapie agent has been detected in lymphoid
nodules of the Peyer's patches of the gut as early as 5 months after oral infection.
Infection in the brain of sheep is initially in the diencephalon and medulla oblongata,
with subsequent spread and replication in other areas of the brain. Characteristically,
there is a noninflammatory, vacuolar degeneration of gray matter and the presence
of PrPSc in scrapie-associated fibrils. Infection results in the posttranslational
modification of this protein so that it becomes resistant to proteinases and to normal
clearance and, consequently, accumulates in the cell.
PrPSc is also present in the placenta and in the trophoblast cells of the placentomes
but not in the endometrium, myometrium, associated nerve plexuses, or in the fetus.
The presence of PrPSc in the placenta is determined by the fetal PrP gene, and PrPSc
is not present in the placenta of fetuses carrying one or two ARR alleles.
Clinical Findings
Incubation
The incubation period varies from several months to several years. Scrapie is a nonfebrile
disease and the onset is insidious, but as the disease progresses clinical signs become
more obvious and severe. The clinical course is protracted, varying from 2 to 12 months,
but lasting in most cases for about 6 months. Affected animals usually show behavioral
change, tremor, pruritus, and locomotor disorder. A clinical examination protocol
to detect classical and atypical scrapie in sheep has been developed.16, 17
Early Signs
The earliest signs are transient, nervous phenomena occurring at intervals of several
weeks or under conditions of stress. These episodes include sudden collapse and sudden
changes of behavior, with sheep charging at dogs or closed gates.
Rubbing and biting at the fleece then begins but are often unobserved because of their
infrequent occurrence. The apparent pruritus is manifested chiefly over the rump,
thighs, and tail base. The poll and dorsum of the neck may also be involved and, less
commonly, the neck in front of the shoulder and the ribs behind the elbow. The affected
areas have approximate bilateral symmetry. In this early stage a stilted gait is often
observed. A general loss of condition may also be observed as an early sign, although
the appetite may not be severely affected.
Advanced Cases
More advanced cases show intense pruritus, muscle tremor and marked abnormalities
of gait, and severe emaciation. Persistent rubbing causes loss of wool over the areas
mentioned previously. Scratching with the hindfeet and biting at the extremities also
occurs. Hematoma of the ears and swelling of the face may result from rubbing. Light
or deep pressure, pinpricking, and application of heat or cold may elicit the characteristic
“nibbling or scrapie scratch” reaction, during which the animal elevates the head
and makes nibbling movements of the lips and licking movements with the tongue (Fig.
14-11
). The sheep's expression suggests that the sensations evoked are pleasant ones. The
reaction may not be observed consistently, often disappearing when the sheep is excited
or in new surroundings.
Fig. 14-11
A, Clinical signs of scrapie in Suffolk ewes located in the midwest region of the
United States. The ewe on the left is pruritic, which is manifested as rubbing against
the tree. The same ewe is also showing a positive nibble reflex (scrapie scratch reaction)
with an upper lip curl and protruded tongue. The ewe on the right is losing weight
and has an abnormally low head carriage. B, A positive result to the scrapie scratch
reaction test. Rubbing/scratching the back over the thoracic vertebrae results in
a slight elevation of the head, an upper lip curl, licking of the lips, and a pleasing
look in the eyes of sheep with scrapie.
Fig. 14-11
Simultaneously with the development of pruritus there is serious impairment of locomotion.
Hindlimb abnormalities appear first. There is incomplete flexion of the hock, shortening
of the step, weakness, and lack of balance. The sense of spatial relationship appears
to be lost, and the sheep is slow to correct abnormal postures. Adduction occurs during
extension, and abduction occurs during flexion. When the animal is attempting to evade
capture, gross incoordination of head and leg movements is likely and the animal often
falls. Convulsions, usually transient but occasionally fatal, may occur at this time.
General hyperexcitability is evident. In the animal at rest an intermittent nodding
and jerking of the head and fine tremor of superficial muscles may also be observed.
In some cases, nystagmus can be produced by rotating the head sideways. Other clinical
signs include inability to swallow, although prehension is unaffected; vomiting; loss
of bleat; and blindness. A change of voice to a trembling note is often most noticeable.
Anorexia is not evident in most cases until the last 4 to 5 weeks and results in rapid
loss of BW. Abomasal distension and impaction occurs in a small number of cases. Pregnancy
toxemia may occur as a complication in pregnant ewes during this stage of scrapie.
Finally, the sheep reaches a stage of extreme emaciation and inability to move without
becoming readily fatigued. Sternal recumbency follows and lateral recumbency with
hyperextension of the limbs is the final stage. Pyrexia is not evident at any time.
In a detailed study in 129 sheep with scrapie the proportional occurrence of signs
was hindlimb ataxia 71%, head tremor 61%, altered mental status 57%, positive nibble
reflex 51%, crouching position 51%, teeth grinding 44%, low head carriage 38%, body
condition score of less than 1.5, 38%, and conscious proprioceptive deficits of limbs
36%. The occurrence of clinical signs was examined in relationship to the PrP genotype.
The nibble reflex was strongly associated with PrP genotypes ARQ/ARQ and ARQ/ARH.
In goats, the clinical course in naturally occurring cases lasts from 2 to 24 weeks.
Clinical signs are similar to those in sheep, and hyperesthesia, ataxia, and pruritus
are common, but loss of weight is less common. In lactating goats the first sign may
be a reluctance to permit milking. Dribbling and regurgitation of ruminal contents
are also recorded in one-third of cases.
In most countries the disease is reportable to government authorities.
Clinical Pathology
There are no changes in hematologic or serum biochemistry parameters. The IHC test
on the obex and other parts of the brain is the confirmatory test at some laboratories
of the OIE and is considered the gold standard test in the United States. At least
four ELISA tests are approved for scrapie surveillance at slaughter in the EU. Western
blots on retropharyngeal lymph nodes obtained at slaughter have a sensitivity approaching
that of IHC.
18
Atypical scrapie is best diagnosed using cerebellum as the tissue for analysis.
Until recently there has been no antemortem test for scrapie; however, PrPSc can be
detected in cells by IHC methods and is present in the lymphoid tissue of some sheep
with scrapie in the preclinical phase of the disease. Palatine tonsillar biopsy has
detected PrPSc in lambs of susceptible genotypes as young as 5 months of age and in
the tonsils of nonchallenged susceptible lambs at 9 to 10 months of age that were
born and maintained in a scrapie environment. However, tonsil biopsy requires general
anesthesia and is not a practical on-farm technique.
Biopsy of lymphoid follicles in the third eyelid or rectum is more practical, requires
only restraint, sedation using xylazine, and local analgesia, and the techniques are
being investigated for the preclinical diagnosis of scrapie in surveillance programs.
In scrapie-positive sheep, PrPSc can be detected in third eyelid biopsies by 14 months
of age, obtained from the palpebral side of the third eyelid. Histamine-containing
eye drops improve the success of collecting a sample with adequate lymphoid follicles
for examination. However, lymphoid follicles may not be present in sufficient numbers
in third eyelid biopsies for evaluation in up to 60% of adult sheep sampled, and the
sensitivity of third eyelid biopsy and rectal mucosa biopsy in detecting scrapie-infected
sheep is 40% and 36%.
19
It is unlikely that lymphoid tissue will ever achieve an adequately high test sensitivity
because a large number of infected animals have minimal or no PrPSc in lymphoid tissue.
Research is ongoing about developing an accurate test that can detect serum biomarkers
of early and late phase scrapie or PrPSc in blood.
20
It has been suggested that the disease could be diagnosed antemortem by EEG, but this
has been disputed.
Necropsy Findings
Significant gross findings are restricted to traumatic lesions caused by rubbing,
and to emaciation and loss of wool; gross distension of the abomasum has been recorded
in some natural cases.
The essential histopathologic lesion in scrapie is the vacuolation of gray matter
neuropil in the spinal cord, medulla, pons, and midbrain, and the consequential wallerian
degeneration in dorsal, ventral and ventrolateral columns of the spinal cord, and
in nerve fibers in the cerebellar peduncles and the optic nerve. In addition, there
is degeneration of the cerebellar and hypothalamoneurohypophyseal systems. There are
different strains of the scrapie agent that can result in differing clinical signs
and pathology. Scrapie-associated fibrils are present in infected brain. Histologic
findings are diagnostic in many cases but can be supplemented with the immunodetection
of PrPSc in brain tissue by in situ IHC and Western immunoblots. The breed of the
sheep affects the magnitude of neuropil vacuolation, and variation also is associated
with the PRP genotype within breeds.
Atypical strains of scrapie (Nor98) are recognized that differ from the usual strains
in their vacuolation patterns and their disease-specific, protease-resistant PrPSc
disposition patterns. These strains can also produce disease in PrP genotypes not
normally affected, including Prp genotype ARR/ARR.
Differential Diagnosis
The characteristic signs of behavioral change, tremor, pruritus, and locomotor disorder
occurring during a period of prolonged illness should suggest the possibility of this
disease. The long incubation period, slow spread, and high case–fatality rate should
also be considered when making a diagnosis. Diseases that may require differentiation
include the following:
Diseases with signs of nervous dysfunction
•
Louping-ill
•
Pregnancy toxemia
•
Rabies
•
Pseudorabies
•
Visna.
Skin diseases
•
External parasites
•
Wool loss
Treatment No treatment has proved capable of changing the course of the disease.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
Individual Flocks
The maintenance of a closed ewe flock is critical to the control of this disease.
If ewes need to be purchased from outside flocks, they should be from certified flocks
or, better still, selected by PrP genotype testing for 171RR or 171QR genotype. The
rams should be 171RR or 171QR genotypes. Ewes should be isolated at lambing and lambed
individually with disposal of placenta by burning.
National Eradication
In countries that do not have the disease, and where it is inadvertently introduced
with imported sheep, the approach is slaughter eradication of the infected flock and
all in-contact animals. The aim is to eliminate the disease from the country, and
the approach is usually successful because it has the full support of the sheep industry
and the government.
Flock Eradication
The eradication of scrapie in countries where it is enzootic has less chance of success.
Eradication programs vary and may involve the whole flock or just the family lines
of the infected sheep. Programs in the United States since 1952 have varied from compulsory
slaughter eradication of the affected flock and source flocks, to bloodline eradication,
and finally from discontinuation to a voluntary certification scheme.
During this period there was no antemortem diagnostic test for scrapie and the identification
of infected farms and flocks relied on owners submitting suspect or clinical cases
for postmortem and histologic diagnosis. Owners are unlikely to put their flocks at
risk if there is inadequate compensation for the results of their action, if they
perceive that other flock owners are not cooperating with the control program, or
if they question the validity of the eradication policy, which is attested to by the
experience in the United States.
Iceland is currently attempting an eradication program that involves depopulation
of infected farms and areas. The farms are left without sheep for a 2-year period
during which there is extensive cleaning and disinfection of the farm area before
repopulation with scrapie-free sheep. The program is a national thrust but very expensive.
This approach has also been apparently successful in virtually eliminating, if not
eradicating, the disease in Iceland. Norway is also attempting eradication in a similar
manner. In both countries the disease was geographically clustered.
Genetic Control and National Programs
The occurrence of scrapie and the concern for BSE in sheep has led many countries
to develop national breeding programs for the control of scrapie and potential BSE.
Examples are the National Scrapie Plan in the UK and the National Scrapie Eradication
Program in the U.S. National Scrapie Plan. The overall aim is to identify sheep genetically
resistant to scrapie on the basis of their genotype (ARR) and to and breed them to
create a national flock with scrapie resistance. Genetic testing will allow the selection
of resistant sheep for breeding and the culling of susceptible sheep, particularly
in breeds such as the Suffolk in which the genetics of susceptibility appear relatively
simple.
The UK has a Voluntary National Scrapie Flocks Scheme and a National Scrapie Plan
which, under EU regulations, become compulsory for flocks that have had a case of
scrapie after July 2004. Under the Compulsory Scrapie Flocks Scheme farmers with confirmed
scrapie cases on their farms will either have their sheep flocks genotype tested so
that those animals more susceptible to disease can be identified and removed or the
whole flock slaughtered and disposed of. All goats on affected holdings also will
be slaughtered and disposed of. Testing of breeding rams will also become compulsory
for all purebred flocks and any other flocks producing and selling homebred rams for
breeding. All rams carrying VRQ PrP genotypes will be slaughtered or castrated. Allied
to this will be a voluntary ewe-testing scheme.
A mathematical model of the program has examined the time that it would take to eliminate
scrapie from the national flock. The results suggest eradication is feasible but the
process could take decades and would be expensive. Surprisingly whole-flock culling
was more efficient in terms of time to eradication than genetic typing and selective
culling. Not surprising was the finding that the most important factor influencing
the efficacy of control at the national level was the ability to identify affected
flocks. It was suggested that investing money in obtaining better notifications and
in conducting trace backs and active surveillance of animals slaughtered for human
consumption and animals found dead on farms would be a good investment.
In the United States, all breeding sheep must be individually identified with a unique
flock and individual number. The Scrapie Flock Certification program monitors flocks
over time and assigns certified status to flocks with no evidence of scrapie. Although
this program has strict requirements of identification and reporting, it is not based
on genetic testing.
The United States also has a USDA Genetics-Based Flock Cleanup and Monitoring Plan.
This program targets scrapie-infected and source flocks. The sheep in these flocks
are genotyped, sheep with susceptible genotypes are removed (as are all goats), and
the flock is placed under surveillance for 5 years. Flocks that are exposed to scrapie
are placed on a monitoring program, and if scrapie is detected the genetics-based
cleanup program would begin.
There is concern that breeding for the selection for certain PrP genotypes and reduction
or elimination of other PrP genotypes could affect other desirable genetic characteristics
and reduce the overall “genetic pool.” This will need to be determined for individual
breeds, but preliminary analyses that have involved several breeds suggest that reproductive
traits, muscle mass, wool quality, live weight gain, and carcass characteristics are
not affected, at least in some breeds.
There has also been concern that rare breeds could be threatened in the face of an
occurrence of scrapie and subsequent disposition of the flock based on the PrP genotype.
Interestingly, there is a good representation of ARR and some breeds have very high
frequencies.
Further Reading
Bulgin
MS
Melson
SS
What veterinary practitioners should know about scrapie
J Am Vet Med Assoc
230
2007
1158
1164
17501652
Fast
C
Groschup
MH
Classical and atypical scrapie in sheep and goats
Prions and Diseases
Vol. 2
2013
Springer
New York
Hunter
N
Scrapie—uncertainties, biology and molecular approaches
Biochim Biophys Acta
1772
2007
619
628
17560089
Prusiner
SB
Molecular biology of prion diseases
Science
252
1991
1515
1522
1675487
References
1
Simmons
HA
BMC Vet Res
5
2009
8
19208228
2
Benestad
SL
Vet Res
39
2008
19
18187032
3
Kittelberger
R
J Vet Diagn Invest
22
2010
863
21088169
4
Fediaevsky
A
BMC Vet Res
4
2008
19
18544152
5
Vascellari
M
J Virol
81
2007
4872
17301130
6
Konold
T
BMC Vet Res
4
2008
14
18397513
7
Konold
T
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
99
23651710
8
Maddison
BC
J Infect Dis
201
2010
1672
20402590
9
Georgsson
G
J Gen Virol
87
2006
3737
17098992
10
Seidel
B
PLoS ONE
2
2007
e435
17502917
11
Lühken
G
Vet Res
38
2007
65
17156738
12
Andréoletti
O
PLoS Pathog
7
2011
e1001285
21347349
13
Saunders
GC
J Gen Virol
87
2006
3141
17030846
14
Corbiére
F
J Gen Virol
94
2013
241
23100359
15
Jeffrey
M
J Pathol
209
2006
4
16575799
16
Konold
T
Phelan
L
J Vis Exp
83
2014
e51101
17
Konold
T
Phelan
L
Vet Rec
174
2014
257
24736824
18
Langeveld
JPM
BMC Vet Res
2
2006
19
16764717
19
Monleόn
E
Vet Microbiol
147
2011
237
20685048
20
Batxelli-Molina
I
BMC Vet Res
6
2010
49
21044301
Chronic Wasting Disease
CWD has recently emerged, or been recognized, in the United States as a TSE of captive
and free-ranging cervids. The ability of this infection to transmit laterally between
cervids, coupled with the longevity of the agent in the environment and the common
grazing land of infected cervids and cattle and sheep, has resulted in concern that
CWD in cervids might be a risk to livestock, and subsequently to humans, similar to
BSE. There has also been concern that it might be transmitted directly from infected
cervids to hunters dressing carcasses or consuming deer meat. There is no evidence
for either of these risks.
The known natural hosts for CWD are mule deer (O. hemionus), white-tailed deer (O.
virginianus), Rocky Mountain elk (C. elaphus nelsoni), and less frequently Shiras
moose (Alces alces shirasi). CWD was originally recorded in the late 1960s as a chronic
wasting syndrome of unknown etiology in captive mule deer in research facilities in
Colorado and Wyoming. It was subsequently established that the disease was a TSE,
and CWD has subsequently been found affecting cervids in captivity in several states
in the United States and also in the provinces of Saskatchewan and Alberta, Canada.
The occurrence in captive and farmed cervids in these different geographic areas is
likely the result of transfer of animals between them, and the disease has recently
been reported in Korea in cervids imported from North America. The disease continues
to expand in prevalence and range in North America.
CWD has a focus and may have originated in free-ranging deer and elk in north central
Colorado and southeastern Wyoming; however, in recent years it has been detected in
free-ranging cervids east of the Mississippi and in a much broader area of North America.
It is not certain whether this is caused by spread or because of improved surveillance.
Based on comparisons of the CNS lesions and the glycoform patterns, the CWD agent
is the same in captive and free-ranging deer.
There is strong evidence from outbreaks in captive deer that lateral transmission
is of major importance in the transmission of CWD. The agent accumulates in gut-associated
lymphoid tissues early in the infection, and saliva and feces are the likely source
of horizontal infection with contamination of the environment.
The disease can be transmitted experimentally between cervids, and there is evidence
for genetic susceptibility. The prion associated with CWD is not the same as that
associated with BSE. In a recent study, it was shown that infection, with amplification
of prion protein in brain tissue, can be transmitted to cattle by intracerebral inoculation
of CWD-infected deer brain. Six years following challenge less than 50% of the challenged
cattle showed amplification of the infection and none had histologic evidence of spongiform
encephalopathy. It was concluded that if infection via the oral route did occur in
cattle it would be unlikely that it would result in amplification of the abnormal
prion within the life span of cattle.
Clinically the disease in cervids is manifested initially by changes in behavior not
commonly observed in free-ranging cervids, and the major manifestation is a marked
fall in body condition. In the terminal stages, there may be ataxia and excitability.
The clinical course varies from a few days to a year but averages 4 months. Diagnosis
is by histologic examination of the brain or more commonly by the demonstration of
PrPCWD in brain tissue by IHC. Antemortem biopsy of lymphatic tissue in tonsils and
retropharyngeal lymph nodes as well as rectal biopsy have all been proven to be useful
in diagnosing preclinical and subclinically infected animals, with diagnostic performance
approaching testing brain tissue. Because prions in cervids with CWD are heavily shed
in saliva and ocular secretions, diagnostic tests are currently under development
using these fluids.
Control of CWD appears to be unsuccessful because of its horizontal transmission,
as well as occurrence in wildlife that migrate over large distances and that are naturally
shy. Eradication appears very unlikely.
Further Reading
Gilch
S
Chitoor
N
Taguchi
Y
Chronic wasting disease
Top Curr Chem
305
2011
51
78
21598099
Sigurdson
CJ
A prion disease of cervids: chronic wasting disease
Vet Res
39
2008
41
18381058
Parasitic Disease Primarily Affecting the Cerebrum
Coenurosis (Gid, Sturdy)
Coenurosis is the disease caused by invasion of the brain and spinal cord by the intermediate
stage of Taenia multiceps. The syndrome produced is one of localized, space-occupying
lesions of the CNS. In most countries the disease is much less common than it used
to be and relatively few losses occur.
Etiology
The disease is associated with Coenurus cerebralis, the intermediate stage of the
tapeworm T. multiceps, which inhabits the intestine of dogs and wild Canidae. The
embryos, which hatch from eggs ingested in feed contaminated by the feces of infested
dogs, hatch in the intestine and pass into the bloodstream. Only those embryos that
lodge in the brain or spinal cord survive and continue to grow to the coenurid stage.
C. cerebralis can mature in the brain and spinal cords of sheep, goats, cattle, horses,
and wild ruminants, and occasionally humans, but clinical coenurosis is primarily
a disease of sheep and occasionally goats
1
and cattle.
2
Infection in newborn calves, acquired prenatally, has occasionally been observed.
Pathogenesis
The early stages of migration through nervous tissue usually passes unnoticed, but
in heavy infections an encephalitis may be produced. Most signs are caused by the
mature coenurus, which may take 6 to 8 months to develop to its full size of about
5 cm. The cystlike coenurus develops gradually and causes pressure on nervous tissue,
resulting in its irritation and eventual destruction. It may cause sufficient pressure
to rarefy and soften cranial bones, leading to a larger volume of calvarium, compared
with uninfected controls.
3
Clinical Findings
In acute outbreaks caused by migration of larval stages, sheep show varying degrees
of blindness, ataxia, muscle tremors, nystagmus, excitability, and collapse. Sheep
affected with the mature Coenurus show an acute onset of irritation phenomena including
a wild expression, salivation, frenzied running, and convulsions. Deviation of the
eyes and head may also occur. Some animals may die in this stage, but a large number
proceed to the second stage of loss of function phenomena, the only stage in most
affected animals. The most obvious sign is slowly developing partial or complete blindness
in one eye. Dullness, clumsiness, head-pressing, ataxia, incomplete mastication, and
periodic epileptiform convulsions are the usual signs. Papilledema may be present.
Localizing signs comprise chiefly deviation of the head and circling; there is rotation
of the head with the blind eye down, and deviation of the head with circling in the
direction of the blind eye.
In young animals local softening of the cranium may occur over a superficial cyst
and rupture of the cyst to the exterior may follow, with final recovery. When the
spinal cord is involved, there is a gradual development of paresis and eventually
inability to rise. Death usually occurs after a long course of several months.
Clinical Pathology
Clinicopathologic examinations are not generally used in diagnosis in animals, and
serologic tests are not sufficiently specific to be of value. Radiologic examinations
are helpful in defining the location of the cyst, especially if there is a prospect
of surgical intervention. MRI provides more detailed information regarding cyst size
and location.
3
Necropsy Findings
Thin-walled cysts may be present anywhere in the brain but are most commonly found
on the external surface of the cerebral hemispheres. In the spinal cord the lesions
are most common in the lumbar region but can be present in the cervical area. Local
pressure atrophy of nervous tissue is apparent, and softening of the overlying bone
may occur.
Differential Diagnosis
The condition needs to be differentiated from other local space-occupying lesions
of the cranial cavity and spinal cord, including abscess, tumor, and hemorrhage. In
the early stages the disease may be confused with encephalitis because of the signs
of brain irritation. Clinically there is little difference between them and, while
clinical signs and local knowledge may lead to a presumptive diagnosis, demonstration
of the metacestode is essential.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment and Control
Surgical drainage of the cyst may make it possible to fatten the animal for slaughter,
and surgical removal with complete recovery is possible in a majority of cases. The
life cycle can be broken most satisfactorily by control of mature tapeworm infestation
in dogs. Periodic treatment of all farm dogs with a tenicide is essential for control
of this and other more pathogenic tapeworms. Carcasses of livestock infested with
the intermediate stages should not be available to dogs.
Anthelmintic agents appear to have efficacy in treating coenurosis in naturally infected
sheep, as demonstrated by degeneration of the cysts in treated animals.
4
Best results were obtained with oral albendazole (25 mg/kg), or combined oral fenbendazole
(500 mg) and oral praziquantel (500 mg) The clinical effect of such treatment is undetermined.
References
1
Nourani
H
Kheirabadi
KP
Comp Clin Pathol
18
2009
85
2
Giadinis
ND
Vet Rec
164
2009
505
19377093
3
Manunta
ML
Am J Vet Res
73
2012
1913
23176417
4
Ghazaei
C
Small Rumin Res
71
2007
48
Halicephalobus
H. gingivalis (H. deletrix; Micronema deletrix) is a small nematode that has been
found in horses on rare occasions. Like Pelodera, it is a free-living saprophytic
organism that has the ability to become an opportunistic parasite. H. gingivalis,
however, invades the deeper tissues where it reproduces. Enormous numbers may be seen
in granulomatous lesions that grow to several centimeters in diameter. Lesions may
be found near the eye, in the prepuce, nares, or the maxilla. The latter may be sufficiently
large to cause the hard palate to bulge, displacing the molars and causing difficulty
in mastication.
1
Putative hematogenous spread gives rise to similar lesions in the kidney,
2
which may be misdiagnosed as renal neoplasia. The worm also invades the brain,3, 4,
5 spinal cord, and heart,
6
but here the lesions are usually microscopic and consist of discrete granulomata with
a vascular orientation. In the brain lesions are predominantly in the cerebrum with
numerous intralesional worms.
5
Affected horses may show a wide variety of clinical signs including lethargy, ataxia,
and incoordination leading to recumbency and death.1, 6 Diagnosis of superficial lesions
is by demonstration of worms and larvae in biopsy samples, but more often H. gingivalis
infection is identified retrospectively in histologic sections following necropsy.
7
The worms are 250 to 430 µm long, have a characteristic bilobed pharynx, and often
contain a single large egg. PCR and sequencing have been used to identify H. gingivalis
definitively.
3
This infection must be considered in the differential diagnosis of equine cerebrospinal
nematodosis.3, 4 Treatment with ivermectin at the maximum safe dose has been attempted,
although the susceptibility of the worm to this compound is uncertain.
1
Experimental tests have indicated that H. gingivalis adult worms and larvae have remarkable
tolerance to ivermectin.
8
References
1
Henneke
C
Acta Vet Scand
2
2014
22
2
Henneke
C
Dansk Vettisskr
56
2014
56
3
Akagami
M
J Vet Med Sci
69
2007
1187
18057837
4
Hermosilla
C
Equine Vet J
43
2011
759
21496093
5
Jung
JY
Vet Med Sci
76
2014
281
6
Adedeji
AO
Vet Clin Pathol
44
2015
171
25639591
7
Sant'Ana
FJF
Bra J Vet Res Anim Sci
5
2012
12
8
Fonderie
P
Parasitology
139
2012
1301
22716944
Metabolic Diseases Primarily Affecting the Cerebrum
Polioencephalomalacia (Cerebrocortical Necrosis) of Ruminants
Synopsis
Etiology Several different causes including thiamine inadequacy, sulfate toxicity.
Epidemiology Sporadic disease in young well-nourished ruminants on high-level grain
diets and not synthesizing sufficient thiamine. Ingestion of preformed thiaminase
in certain plants or production by ruminal microbes may also cause destruction of
thiamine. May also occur in cattle and sheep of all ages ingesting excess amounts
of sulfates in feed and water.
Signs Sudden blindness, ataxia, staggering, head-pressing, tremors of head and neck,
ear-twitching, champing fits, clonic-tonic convulsions, recumbency, opisthotonus,
rumen contractions normal initially, pupils usually normal and responsive, nystagmus,
death may occur in 24–48 hours. Hydrogen sulfide odor of ruminal gas in sulfate toxicity.
Clinical pathology Erythrocyte transketolase activity decreased and thiamine pyrophosphate
effect increased but both measurements difficult to interpret; blood thiamine concentrations
decreased but are not reliable in thiamine inadequacy form. Increased hydrogen sulfide
content in rumen gas and increased thiosulfate concentration in urine in sulfur-induced
form.
Lesions Diffuse cerebral edema, flattened dorsal gyri, coning of cerebellum, multifocal
to linear areas of fluorescence in gray and white matter borders of cortical gyri
and sulci.
Diagnostic confirmation Fluorescence of gray and white matter of cortical gyri and
sulci of brain.
Differential diagnosis list
Cattle
•
Lead poisoning
•
Hypovitaminosis A
•
Sodium chloride toxicity
•
Histophilus somni meningoencephalitis
Sheep
•
Pregnancy toxemia
•
Clostridium perfringens type D enterotoxemia
•
Focal symmetric encephalomalacia
•
Lead poisoning.
Goats
•
Pregnancy toxemia
•
C. perfringens type D enterotoxemia
•
Closantel overdosage
1
•
Lead poisoning
Treatment Thiamine hydrochloride parenterally.
Control Thiamine supplementation of diet. Avoid excess feeding or access to sulfate
in feed and water supplies.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Historically, PEM was considered to be caused by a thiamine inadequacy. It is important
to realize that PEM is a histologic description of a cerebral injury affecting predominantly
the gray matter, and that there are several different causes of PEM in ruminants.
The current preference is to discuss PEM in relationship to a suspected etiology.
Thiamine Inadequacy
Thiamine (vitamin B1) is synthesized only in bacteria, fungi, and plants but is an
essential nutrient for animals. Consequently, animals must obtain thiamine from their
diet. The evidence that a thiamine inadequacy can be associated with the disease includes
the following:
•
Affected animals respond to the parenteral administration of thiamine if given within
a few hours after the onset of clinical signs
•
Affected animals have biochemical findings consistent with thiamine pyrophosphate
([TPP], also known as TDP) inadequacy (TPP is the biologically active form of thiamine)
•
The clinical signs and pathologic lesions can be reproduced in sheep and cattle by
the administration of large daily doses of pyrimidine containing structural analogs
of thiamine, principally amprolium, given orally or intraperitoneally.
Excess Dietary Sulfur
Elemental sulfur in the rumen is metabolized by two pathways: (1) reduction of sulfate
(SO4
2−) to sulfide (S2−), which is then incorporated into sulfur-containing compounds
such as cysteine and methionine that are used by rumen bacteria and (2) reduction
of sulfate to sulfide, which is converted to hydrosulfide (HS−) at normal rumen pH
(pKa of S2− + H+ ↔ HS− is 11.96). Hydrosulfide is in equilibrium with hydrogen sulfide
in the rumen because the pKa for the equilibrium reaction: HS− + H+ ↔ H2S is 7.04).
2
The practical significance of these equilibrium reactions is that sulfate metabolism
results in higher levels of H2S in rumen gas (and H2S is assumed to be the toxic agent)
at lower rumen values for pH. These equilibria reactions help to explain the association
between high sulfate intakes, high-grain diets, and increased risk of sulfur-associated
PEM. The ingestion of excessive quantities of sulfur from the diet and water supply
can cause the disease in cattle and sheep without any change in the thiamine status
of the tissues. An increased dietary sulfur intake may increase the metabolic demand
for thiamine, possibly to offset the damaging effect of hydrogen sulfide on brain
tissue.
3
Epidemiology
Occurrence
PEM occurs sporadically in young cattle, sheep, goats, and other ruminants. In North
America, UK, Australia, and New Zealand, the disease is most common in cattle and
sheep that are being fed concentrate rations under intensified conditions such as
in feedlots. An inadequate amount of roughage can result in a net decrease in the
synthesis of thiamine. The disease is most common in well-nourished thrifty cattle
6 to 18 months of age (peak incidence 9–12 months of age) that have been in the feedlot
for several weeks. Feedlot lambs may also be affected only after being on feed for
several weeks. The disease also occurs in goats and in antelope and whitetail deer.
It may affect goats from 2 months to 3 years of age and is commonly associated with
milk-replacer diets in kids or concentrate feeding in older goats. The disease occurs
only rarely in adult cattle, which may be a reflection of the greater quantities of
roughage they usually consume. However, there are recent reports of the disease occurring
in adult cows on pasture with access to drinking water containing excessive concentrations
of sulfates.
Morbidity and Case Fatality
Accurate morbidity and case–fatality data are not available, but outbreaks can occur
suddenly in which up to 25% of groups of feeder cattle may be affected, with case–fatality
rates from 25% to 50%. Case–fatality rates are higher in young cattle (6–9 months)
than in the older age group (12–18 months), and mortality increases if treatment with
thiamine is delayed for more than a few hours after the onset of signs. In feedlot
lambs, it has been suggested that approximately 19% of all deaths are caused by PEM.
Risk Factors
When PEM was first described in 1956, and for about 30 years, it was considered to
be a thiamine deficiency conditioned by dietary factors such as high-level grain feeding
and inadequate roughage. PEM was most common in well-nourished young cattle from 6
to 12 months of age that were being fed high-level grain rations. The scientific investigations
centered on the effects of dietary factors, such as grain diets, and the presence
of thiaminases in certain diets on thiamine metabolism in the rumen. In recent years,
it has become clear that the disease is not etiologically specific because many different
dietary factors have been associated with the occurrence of the disease, and in some
instances the thiamine status of the affected animals is within the normal range.
Notable examples are the recent observations linking dietary sulfate with the occurrence
of the disease.
Dietary Risk Factors
Although there has been general agreement that thiamine inadequacy is associated with
the cause of PEM, the possible mechanisms by which this occurs are uncertain. Thiamine
inadequacy in ruminants could, theoretically, occur in any of the following situations
in which inadequate net microbial synthesis of thiamine in the rumen may occur:
•
Concentrate-fed animals receiving inadequate roughage
•
Impaired absorption and/or phosphorylation of thiamine
•
Presence of a thiamine inhibitor in the tissues of the host
•
Lack of sufficient or appropriate apoenzyme or coenzyme-apoenzyme binding for thiamine-dependent
systems
•
Increased metabolic demands for thiamine in the absence of increased supply
•
Increased rate of excretion of thiamine resulting in its net loss from the body
Thiamine can be destroyed by thiaminases of which significant amounts can be found
in the rumen contents and feces of cattle and sheep affected with naturally occurring
PEM.
Thiamine Inadequacy
In cattle under farm conditions, using erythrocyte transketolase activity as a measurement
of thiamine status, up to 23% of cattle under 2 years of age and 5% over 2 years may
be in a thiamine-low state. Newly weaned beef calves on a hay diet are not subject
to a thiamine deficiency, but a low and variable proportion of young cattle on barley-based
feedlot diets (1.7%) may have some evidence of thiamine deficiency based on a TPP
activity effect in excess of 15%. The supplementation of the diet of feedlot steers
on an all-concentrate barley-based diet with thiamine at 1.9 mg/kg dry matter resulted
in an increase in average daily gain and final carcass weights. Thus some animals
may be marginally deficient in thiamine, which may be associated with decreased performance
in cattle fed all-concentrate diets. However, thiamine supplementation of cattle on
all-concentrate diets does not consistently result in improved animal performance.
The experimental disease can be produced in young lambs fed a thiamine-free milk diet,
and it may be unnecessary to postulate that thiamine analogs produced in the rumen
are essential components of the etiology.
Thiaminases
A major factor contributing to PEM in cattle and sheep is a progressive state of thiamine
deficiency caused by the destruction of thiamine by bacterial thiaminases in the rumen
and intestines. Certain species of thiaminase-producing bacteria have been found in
the rumen and intestines of animals with PEM. Bacillus thiaminolyticus and Clostridium
sporogenes produce thiaminase type I and B. aneurinolyticus produces thiaminase type
II. Although there is good circumstantial evidence that the thiaminases from these
bacteria are the real source of thiaminases associated with the disease, it is not
entirely certain. The experimental oral inoculation of large numbers of thiaminase
type I producing C. sporogenes in lambs did not result in the disease.
Certain species of fungi from moldy feed are also thiaminase producers, but the evidence
that they destroy thiamine and are associated with PEM is contradictory and uncertain.
The factors that promote the colonization and growth of thiaminase-producing bacteria
in the rumen are unknown. Attempts to establish the organism in the rumen of healthy
calves or lambs have been unsuccessful. Thiaminases have also been found in the rumen
contents and feces of normal animals, which may suggest the existence of a subclinical
state of thiamine deficiency. Poor growth of unweaned and weaned lambs can be associated
with a thiaminase-induced subclinical thiamine deficiency. Weekly testing of young
lambs over a period of 10 weeks revealed that 90% of unthrifty lambs were excreting
high levels of thiaminase in their feces; low levels of thiaminase activity were present
in 20% of clinically normal animals, and there were significant differences in the
mean erythrocyte transketolase activity of the unthrifty animals excreting thiaminase
compared with the thiaminase-free normal animals.
Field and laboratory investigations have supported an association between inferior
growth rate of weaner sheep in Australia and a thiaminase-induced thiamine deficiency.
Thiaminase activity has been detected in the feces of lambs at 2 to 5 days of age,
with the levels increasing for 10 days and then declining over the next 3 to 4 weeks.
Decreased erythrocyte transketolase activity indicated a thiamine insufficiency in
lambs with high thiaminase activity, and mean growth rates were 17% less than lambs
with low thiaminase activity. The oral supplementation with thiamine at 2 to 3 weeks
of age was the most appropriate prevention and treatment for subclinical thiamine
deficiency.
The parenteral or oral administration of thiamine to normal calves raised under farm
conditions resulted in a marked reduction in the percentage TPP effect, which is an
indirect measurement of thiamine inadequacy. Goats with PEM were found to have elevated
ruminal and fecal thiaminase activities, low erythrocyte transketolase activity, elevated
TPP effect, low liver and brain thiamine levels, and elevated plasma glucose levels
compared with goats not affected with the disease. With the increased interest in
goat farming, some breeders attempted to improve body condition of breeding stock
for sale or show by feeding grain or concentrate, which creates a situation similar
to feedlot rearing of sheep and cattle that is conducive to the establishment of thiaminases
in the rumen and the occurrence of PEM.
High levels of thiaminase type I are present in the rhizomes of bracken fern (Pteridium
aquilinum) and horsetail (Equisetum arvense). The feeding of the bracken fern rhizomes
(P. esculentum) to sheep will cause acute thiamine deficiency and lesions similar
to those of PEM, but neither of these plants is normally involved in the natural disease.
The disease has occurred in sheep grazing the Nardoo fern (Marsilea drummondii) in
flood-prone or low-lying wet areas in Australia. The fern contains a high level of
thiaminase type I activity.
Amaranthus blitoides (prostrate pigweed) may contain high levels of thiaminase and
be associated with PEM in sheep.
Sulfur-Induced Polioencephalomalacia
PEM has been associated with diets high in sulfur, particularly in the form of sulfate.
A high concentrate of sulfates in the diet of cattle has been associated with episodes
of the disease in 6- to 18-month-old cattle. Inorganic sulfate salts in the form of
gypsum (calcium sulfate) added to feedlot rations to control the total daily intake
of the diet may cause PEM. Seasonal outbreaks have occurred in feedlot beef cattle
between 15 and 30 days after introduction to a high-sulfur diet, and the risk may
increase when water is an important source of dietary sulfur, and during hot weather,
when the ambient temperatures exceeded 32°C.
Initial outbreaks may follow the use of a new well of water containing more sulfate
than water used previously from another well, increasing from a monthly incidence
of 0.07% to 0.88%. Growing cattle consume 2.4 times more water when the temperature
is 32°C than at 4°C; consequently total ingestion of sulfur by consumption of high-sulfate
water increases during hot weather. The feed contained 2.4 g of SO4/kg dry matter
with a total sulfur content of 0.20%. Samples of drinking water contained between
2.2 and 2.8 g of SO4/L. During hot weather daily sulfur ingestion from feed and water
combined was estimated to be 64 g per animal corresponding to total dietary sulfur
of approximately 0.67% of dry matter. Daily SO4 ingestion was approximately 160 g
per animal. The ruminal sulfide levels were much higher 3 weeks after entering the
feedlot, when the incidence of the disease was greatest, than 2 months after entering
the feedlot when the risk of the disease was low.
In western Canada, there is an association between PEM and high levels of sodium sulfate
in water, and range cows are usually affected when certain waters become concentrated
with this salt during the summer months. Water containing high levels of magnesium
sulfate, often called
gyp water
(for gypsum water) is common in the western plains and intermountain areas of the
United States and Canada. Ideally, water for livestock consumption should contain
less than 500 ppm sulfate, and 1000 ppm is considered the maximum safe level in water
for cattle exposed to moderate dietary sulfur levels or high environmental temperatures.
A level of 2000 ppm of sulfate in drinking water is the taste discrimination threshold
for cattle. Performance of feedlot cattle is reduced when offered water with sulfate
levels of 2000 ppm or higher. The National Research Council states that the requirement
of sulfur in feed to be 1500 to 2000 ppm for both growing and adult beef cattle; 4000 ppm
is considered the maximum tolerated dose. Ruminant diets normally contain between
1500 to 2000 ppm (0.15%–0.20% sulfur).
Based on National Research Council guidelines, 30 g of sulfur is the calculated maximum
tolerated dose of sulfur for a 650-lb (294-kg) steer consuming 16.25 lb (7.39 kg;
2.5% BW) of feed daily. If the ambient temperature reaches 32°C, a 650-lb steer can
drink 14.5 gallons (53.9 L) of water daily, Consumption of 14.5 gallons of water containing
3000 ppm sulfate results in a daily intake of 55 g of sulfur. A feed intake of 2.5%
BW would also consume 22.2 g of sulfur from feed containing 3000 ppm sulfur for a
total daily intake of 77.2 g of sulfur from both feed and water, which is 2.5 times
the maximum tolerated dose.
In some surveys, water supplies in western Canada contained 8447 ppm of total dissolved
solids and 5203 ppm of sulfate. A survey of the sulfate concentrations in water on
farms found that high levels of sulfate can have a detrimental effect on the thiamine
status of the cattle on those farms. Cattle exposed to sulfate concentrations >1000 ppm
had blood thiamine levels lower than those drinking water with low levels <200 ppm.
This raises the possibility that a subpopulation of cattle under such circumstances
could be marginally deficient in thiamine.
The total dietary intake of sulfur by cattle must be considered when investigating
sulfur as a cause of PEM. In a study of one farm, water from a 6.1-m well containing
3875 mg/L of total dissolved solids with 3285 mg/L of sodium sulfate was associated
with PEM in heifers 6 months of age. However, the water contributed about 20% of the
total sulfur content in the diet of the heifers, and 60% of the dietary sulfur intake
was supplied by the hay and 20% by the grain supplement. The hay contained 0.4% total
sulfur, which is at the maximum tolerable level for cattle and at the upper limit
for hay. The hay consisted of variable amounts of kochia (Kochia scorpia) and Canada
thistle (Cirsium arvense). K. scorpia (summer cypress or Mexican fireweed) is high
in sulfur content and has been associated with the disease in range cattle.
The levels of sulfate in water that have affected feed intake in cattle have varied
from 2800 to 3340 mg sulfate/L, whereas other studies found no reduction in feed intake
with levels up to 7000 mg/L. It appears that the different effects of sulfur toxicity
for similar sulfur contents in saline water are attributed to the total sulfur intake.
Outbreaks of the disease may occur in adult cattle on pasture drinking water containing
7200 ppm of sodium sulfate. Thus established guidelines for saline drinking water
are not applicable when cattle are fed feeds grown in saline areas.
A combination of excessive intake of sulfur and a low dietary intake of trace minerals,
especially copper, may affect the thiamine status of a cattle herd and contribute
to PEM. Sulfur adversely affects both thiamine and copper status in sheep. A nutritionally
related PEM has also been reproduced in calves fed a semipurified, low-roughage diet
of variable copper and molybdenum concentrations and it was not related to copper
deficiency. The disease has occurred in cattle in New Zealand fed chou moellier (Brassica
oleracea), which contained sulfur concentrations of 8500 mg/kg dry matter. The morbidity
was 25% and mortality 46% despite rapid conventional therapy. Sulfur-associated PEM
has also occurred in Australia when cattle grazed extensive stands of Sisymbrium irio
(London rocket), Capsella bursapastoris (shepherd's purse), and Raphanus raphanistrum
(wild radish), which all contain high sulfur content and are in the Brassicaceae (Cruciferae)
family.
4
Ammonium sulfate used as a urinary acidifier in the rations of cattle and sheep has
been associated with outbreaks of PEM. Morbidity rates ranged from 16% to 48% and
mortality rates from 0% to 8%. Affected animals did not respond to treatment with
thiamine.
Outbreaks have occurred in sheep exposed to an alfalfa field previously sprayed with
35% suspension of elemental sulfur. The disease can be induced experimentally in lambs
by the administration of sodium hydrosulfide into the esophagus and has occurred in
lambs 3 to 4 weeks after being fed a concentrate ration containing 0.43% sulfur. Feeding
experimental diets containing inorganic sulfur to young lambs was associated with
PEM, and supplementation of those diets with thiamine decreased the severity of the
lesions. Rumen microbes are able to reduce sulfate to sulfides, which may be directly
toxic to the nervous system. Feeding calves (115–180 kg) a semipurified diet high
in readily fermentable carbohydrate, without long fiber, and with added sodium sulfate
for a total sulfur content of 0.36% resulted in PEM within 21 days of the introduction
of the experimental diet. An odor of hydrogen sulfide was frequently detected on passage
of a stomach tube into the rumen of all calves during the experiment. The total thiamine
concentrations in affected and control calves remained within normal limits.
The dietary content of copper, zinc, iron, and molybdenum may also have important
modifying influences on sulfur toxicosis. Molybdenum and copper can combine with sulfur
to form insoluble copper thiomolybdate. Copper, zinc, and iron form insoluble salts
with sulfide, and their expected effect would be to decrease the bioavailability of
sulfide in the rumen. Conversely, low, but not necessarily deficient, dietary contents
of these divalent metals could be prerequisites for excess absorption of sulfide to
occur. PEM is not associated with copper deficiency, but copper and sulfur metabolism
are interdependent. An excess of dietary sulfur may result in depression of serum
copper, or alternatively, low serum copper may potentiate the actions of toxic levels
of sulfur. Chronic copper poisoning in a lamb has been associated with PEM. It is
suggested that the copper toxicity may have caused decreased hepatic function resulting
in increased plasma concentration of sulfur containing amino acids which, may have
predisposed to sulfur toxicity encephalomalacia.
Major dietary sulfur sources are inorganic salts that are fed in acidogenic diets
to control periparturient hypocalcemia in dairy cattle, the by-products of grain processing,
such as distillers grains, corn gluten meal, and brewers grain, and molasses, beet
pulp, and alfalfa hay. Prolonged feeding of barley malt sprouts to cattle in Turkey
has resulted in PEM caused by the high sulfur content of barley sprouts.
5
Similarly, molasses toxicity occurred in Cuba in cattle fed on a liquid molasses-urea
feeding system with limited forage. The clinical and necropsy findings were identical
to PEM; however, molasses toxicity is not thiamine responsive and can be reversed
by feeding forage.
Other Dietary Circumstances
Deprivation of Feed and Water.
In some outbreaks there is a history of deprivation of feed and water for 24 to 28
hours, because of either a managerial error or frozen water supplies. In other cases,
a rapid change in diet appears to precipitate an outbreak. Some outbreaks are associated
with a temporary deprivation of water for 24 to 36 hours, followed by sudden access
to water and an excessive supply of salt, a situation analogous to salt poisoning
in pigs, but these require more documentation to ensure that they indeed are not salt
poisoning.
In sheep flocks, a drastic change in management, such as occurs at shearing time,
will precipitate outbreaks in which only the yearlings are affected. Changing the
diet of sheep from hay to corn silage resulted in a decrease in thiamine concentrations
in ruminal fluid to about 25% of control values on hay. The cause of the drop in thiamine
concentrations is unknown.
Phalaris Aquatica “PEM-Like” Sudden Death in Sheep and Cattle.
The Mediterranean perennial grass P. aquatica (formerly P. tuberosa) can cause sudden
death in sheep and cattle throughout southern Australia. The nervous form of the disease
is similar clinically to PEM but atypical because of the very rapid onset and the
absence of either neuronal necrosis or malacia in cerebral cortical sections from
affected animals. The available evidence suggests that this form of phalaris sudden
death is more likely to involve a peracute form of ammonia toxicity than a peracute
form of PEM.
Pathogenesis
Thiamine Inadequacy Polioencephalomalacia
High levels of thiaminases are formed in the rumen, which destroy thiamine that is
naturally synthesized. The circumstances in the diet or in the rumen that allow for
the development of high levels of thiaminases are unknown but may be related to the
nature of the ruminal microflora in young cattle and sheep fed concentrate rations,
which results in the development of ruminal acidosis. These rations may also allow
for the development and growth of thiaminase-producing bacteria which, combined with
a smaller net synthesis of thiamine in the rumens of concentrate-fed ruminants, could
explain the higher incidence in feedlot animals. Experimentally PEM has been produced
in lambs by continuous intraruminal infusion of a highly fermentable diet. Animals
changed very rapidly to high-concentrate rations develop increased ruminal thiaminase
levels.
The possibility that intraruminal thiaminases may also create thiamine analogs capable
of acting as thiamine antimetabolites and accentuating the disease has been studied,
but the results are inconclusive. The presence of naturally occurring second substrates
(cosubstrates) in the rumen could produce, by the thiaminase type I reaction, a potent
thiamine antimetabolite capable of accentuating the condition. In vitro studies have
shown that thiaminase only caused rapid destruction of thiamine when a second substrate
was added, and a large number of drugs commonly used as anthelmintics or tranquilizers
may be active as second substrates. Many compounds found in the rumen of cattle are
potential cosubstrates.
Amprolium has been used extensively to produce the lesions in the brains of cattle
and sheep that are indistinguishable from the naturally occurring disease. However,
because amprolium has been found in the brain tissue, the experimental disease should
perhaps be known as “amprolium poisoning encephalopathy.” The administration of other
antagonists such as oxythiamine and pyrithiamine does not produce the disease. This
suggests that PEM is a particular form of thiamine deficiency in which the supply
of thiamine is reduced by the action of intraruminal thiaminase. Thus the thiamine
status of the animal will be dependent on dietary thiamine intake, thiamine synthesis,
the presence of thiaminase in the rumen, and the effects of possible antimetabolites.
Subclinical states of thiamine deficiency probably exist in apparently normal cattle
and sheep being fed diets that are conducive to the disease. This suggests that in
outbreaks of the disease the unaffected animals of the group should be considered
as potential new cases and perhaps treated prophylactically.
Thiamine is an essential component of several enzymes involved in intermediary metabolism
and a state of deficiency results in increased blood concentration of pyruvate, a
reduction in the lactate to pyruvate ratio and depression of erythrocyte transketolase.
These abnormalities affect carbohydrate metabolism in general, but in view of the
specific requirements of the cerebral cortex for oxidative metabolism of glucose,
it is possible that a thiamine inadequacy could have a direct metabolic effect on
neurons. The brain of the calf has a greater dependence on the pentose pathway for
glucose metabolism, in which pathway the transketolase enzyme is a rate-limiting enzyme.
Ultrastructural examination of the brain of sheep with the natural disease reveals
that the first change that occurs is an edema of the intracellular compartment, principally
involving the astrocytes and satellite cells. This is followed by neuronal degeneration,
which is considered secondary. It has been suggested that the edema may be caused
by a reduction in ATP production following a defect of carbohydrate metabolism in
the astrocyte. There are three basic lesions that are not uniform: compact necrosis,
edema necrosis, and edema alone. This may suggest that a uniform etiology such as
thiamine deficiency cannot be fully supported.
In the cerebral cortex of affected animals, autofluorescent spots are observed under
ultraviolet 365-nm illumination and are a useful diagnostic aid. The distribution
of autofluorescence corresponds to that of mitochondria in cerebrocortical neurocytes
in affected calves, suggesting that metabolic impairment occurs and the autofluorescent
substance is produced in the mitochondria. Mitochondrial swelling and disorganization
of cristae are also observable in brain tissue, but are not specific to PEM.
Sulfate-Induced Polioencephalomalacia
Diets high in sulfur result in hydrogen sulfide production in the rumen and anaerobic
bacteria from rumen samples of cattle fed high-carbohydrate, short-fiber diets with
added sulfate will generate hydrogen sulfide in rumen fluid broth medium. Rumen microflora
adapt to higher dietary sulfate content over a period of 10 to 12 days before they
are capable of generating potentially toxic concentrations of sulfide. In experimental
sulfate diets, which induce PEM, the rumen pH decreases during the transition to the
experimental diet and acidic conditions in the rumen favor increased rumen gas cap
concentrations of hydrogen sulfide. With a change of pH from 6.8 to 5.2, the percentage
of hydrogen sulfide in the rumen gas cap increased from 47% to 97%.
Hydrogen sulfide gas concentration gradually increases in the rumen of sheep during
the first 4 weeks on ingesting a medium-concentrate corn and alfalfa-based diet that
contained substantial amounts of distillers grains.
6
Hydrogen sulfide is thought to be detoxified by the liver via oxidation to sulfate.
Hydrogen sulfide absorbed across the ruminal wall into the portal circulation is not
considered a likely mechanism of toxicity because absorbed hydrogen sulfide will be
detoxified. However, a portion of the eructated hydrogen sulfide can be absorbed across
the alveolar membrane directly into pulmonary capillaries, effectively bypassing hepatic
detoxification before reaching the brain. If ruminants inhale 60% of eructated gases,
inhalation of hydrogen sulfide could be a route of systemic sulfide absorption, in
addition to gastrointestinal absorption. Sulfide inhibits cellular respiration leading
to hypoxia, which may be sufficient to create neuronal necrosis in PEM. The nervous
system lesions of sulfur toxicosis are indistinguishable from lesions in the naturally
occurring disease.
Acute Cerebral Edema and Laminar Necrosis
Acute cerebral edema and laminar necrosis occur and the clinical signs are usually
referable to increased intracranial pressure from the edema and the widespread focal
necrosis. Recovery can occur with early treatment, which suggests that the lesions
are reversible up to a certain point. EEGs of buffalo calves with amprolium-induced
PEM found decreased frequency patterns, occasional spindles, and decreased voltage
patterns during the onset of clinical signs. In the comatose stage, there was little
evidence of electrical activity. EEGs of animals treated with thiamine hydrochloride
found normal awake patterns.
Clinical Findings
Cattle
Animals may be found dead without premonitory signs, especially beef cattle on pasture.
The clinical findings are variable but characteristically, there is a sudden onset
of blindness; walking aimlessly; ataxia; muscle tremors, particularly of the head
with ear-twitching; champing of the jaws and frothy salivation; and head-pressing
(which is really compulsive forward walking stopped by a wall), and the animal is
difficult to handle or move (Fig. 14-12
). Dysphagia may be present when one attempts to force feed hay by hand. Grinding
of the teeth is common. Initially, the involuntary movements may occur in episodes,
and convulsions may occur, but within several hours they become continuous. The animal
usually then becomes recumbent, and there is marked opisthotonus; nystagmus; clonic-tonic
convulsions, particularly when the animal is handled or moved; and tetany of the forelimbs
is common. The temperature is usually normal but elevated if there has been excessive
muscular activity. The heart rate may be normal, subnormal, or increased and is probably
not a reliable diagnostic aid.
Fig. 14-12
Weaned Polled Hereford calf with polioencephalomalacia. The calf has been walking
in the same direction in the stall for many hours (as indicated by the straw). The
diameter of the circle is determined by the width of the stall. The calf was blind
and depressed, but was neurologically normal 48 hours later after aggressive treatment
with intramuscular thiamine.
Fig. 14-12
Rumen movements remain normal for a few days, which is an important distinguishing
feature from lead poisoning in which the rumen is static.
The menace reflex is always absent in the acute stage, and its slow return to normal
following treatment is a good prognostic sign. The palpebral eye-preservation reflex
is usually normal. The pupils are usually of normal size and responsive to light.
In severe cases the pupils may be constricted. Dorsal strabismus caused by stretching
of the trochlear nerve is common. Nystagmus is common and may be vertical or horizontal.
Optic disc edema is present in some cases but is not a constant finding.
Calves 6 to 9 months of age may die in 24 to 48 hours, whereas older cattle up to
18 months of age may survive for several days. Recovery is more common in the older
age group.
In less severe cases, affected animals are blind, head-press into walls and fences,
and remain standing for several hours or a few days. In outbreaks, some cattle will
be sternally recumbent; others remain standing with obvious blindness, whereas others
are anorexic, mildly depressed, and have only partial impairment of eyesight. Those
with some eyesight will commonly return to almost normal. Some survivors are permanently
blind to varying degrees but may begin to eat and drink if assisted. Some cases will
recover following treatment and may grow and develop normally.
Evidence of recovery within a few hours following treatment with thiamine indicates
that the disease is associated with thiamine inadequacy. A failure of response indicates
the possibility of sulfur toxicity PEM.
Sheep
Sheep usually begin to wander aimlessly, sometimes in circles, or stand motionless
and are blind, but within a few hours they become recumbent with opisthotonus, extension
of the limbs, hyperesthesia, nystagmus, and periodic tonic-clonic convulsions (Fig.
14-13
). Hoggets affected at shearing time may show blindness and head-pressing but, if
fed and watered, usually recover within a few days. Occasional animals show unilateral
localizing signs, including circling and spasmodic deviation of the head. In goats,
early signs may include excitability and elevation of the head. Blindness, extreme
opisthotonus, and severe extensor rigidity and nystagmus are common.
Fig. 14-13
A, Weanling sheep with acute polioencephalomalacia demonstrating slow progressive
walking that is interrupted by a wall. This is mistakenly called head-pressing. B,
The same weanling sheep 24 hours later after repeated intravenous thiamine injections.
The sheep has stopped progressive walking and the appetite has partially returned;
however, the sheep is not fully aware and could not identify that it was still eating.
It made a full recovery.
Fig. 14-13
In sulfur-induced PEM in sheep introduced to a diet containing 0.43% sulfur, clinical
signs occurred 15 to 32 days later and consisted of depression, central blindness,
and head-pressing, but no hyperesthesis, nystagmus, or opisthotonus were observed.
In sulfur toxicity in lambs with PEM, the rumen contents may have a strong odor of
hydrogen sulfide (rotten egg smell).
There are some reports from Australia of unthriftiness in unweaned and weaned lambs
associated with thiamine deficiency caused by the presence of thiaminases in the alimentary
tract. In affected flocks the incidence of ill-thrift in lambs is much higher than
the usual incidence and other causes of unthriftiness were ruled out. Affected lambs
lose weight, may have chronic diarrhea, and become emaciated and die of starvation.
In some flocks, clinical signs of PEM may occur in a small percentage of animals.
The disease is most common in early July, which is the coldest part of the year in
Australia for lambs that are born in May and June. In affected lambs the fecal thiaminase
levels are high and the blood transketolase level activity is increased above normal.
Treatment of affected lambs with thiamine resulted in an increase in growth rate.
Clinical Pathology
Thiamine Inadequacy Polioencephalomalacia.
The biochemical changes occurring in cattle and sheep with the thiamine-deficiency
PEM have not been well defined diagnostically based on thoroughly investigated naturally
occurring clinical cases. However, some estimates are available including the changes
that occur in the experimental disease. Interpretation of the values may also be unreliable
if the animals have been treated before death. Because of challenges with the availability
and cost of laboratory tests, the most practical method to confirm a diagnosis of
PEM caused by thiamine inadequacy is the clinical response to treatment with thiamine.
In animals, thiamine is present as free thiamine, thiamine monophosphate (TMP), TDP
(more commonly known as TPP, which is the biologically active form), and thiamine
triphosphate (TTP). The role of TMP and TTP is not well known at this time. The critical
forms to measure are therefore free thiamine and TPP.
3
The thiamine concentrations of blood of animals with PEM have varied widely and may
be difficult to interpret because of the possibility of thiamine analogs inducing
deficiency even when blood thiamine levels are normal. However, this would not apply
when blood thiamine concentrations are below normal. A normal reference range of 75
to 185 nmol/L is suggested for both cattle and sheep, and levels below 50 nmol/L are
considered indicative of deficiency. In normal goats, the mean thiamine content of
blood was 108 nmol/L, with a range of 72 to 178 nmol/L. In goats with PEM, blood thiamine
levels were less than 66 nmol/L with a mean of 29 nmol/L. Levels as low as 1.8 to
3.6 µg/dL (6–12 nmol/L) have been found in suspected cases of PEM. The thiamine concentrations
of liver, heart, and brain of cattle and sheep with PEM are decreased. The levels
of blood pyruvate and lactate are also increased and thiamine pyrophosphate–dependent
enzymes such as pyruvate kinase are decreased. The thiaminase activity of the feces
is increased. Laboratory reference ranges should be used to evaluate blood thiamine
concentrations because of analytical differences related to whether the measurement
relates to free thiamine, total thiamine, or TPP.
The erythrocyte transketolase activity is decreased in confirmed cases of thiamine-inadequacy
PEM. Transketolase is an important enzyme in the pentose pathway and requires TPP.
Measurement of transketolase activity in erythrocytes is attractive because a blood
sample is readily obtained and this is a biologic assay. Unfortunately, the assay
must be run soon after blood collection and is not widely available. Erythrocyte transketolase
activities in normal sheep range from 40 to 60 IU/mL RBCs. A variant of the transketolase
test involves the addition of a standard amount of TPP, with the percentage increase
in erythrocyte transketolase activity being recorded; this is called the TPP effect.
A TPP effect of 30% to 50% is commonly found in normal healthy cattle and sheep, and
an increase to above 70% to 80% occurs in animals with PEM.
It is important to note that decreased erythrocyte transketolase activities, an increased
TPP effect, and decreased blood thiamine concentrations would be expected in animals
that have been inappetent for a number of days because thiamine is a water-soluble
vitamin within minimal body stores. For example, cattle with pneumonia or simple indigestion
had lower plasma thiamine concentrations (1.00 and 0.50 µg/mL, respectively) than
healthy cattle (1.70 µg/mL).
7
Sheep with acute ruminal lactic acidosis had a mean TPP effect on erythrocyte transketolase
activity of 109% compared with 22% in a health control group.
8
Measurements of erythrocyte transketolase activity, increased TPP effect, and blood
TPP concentration should therefore be obtained from healthy animals in the same pen
as the affected animal to adjust for the effect of feed intake on the measured values.
The hemogram is usually normal; the total and differential leukocyte counts may indicate
a mild stress reaction, a finding that may be useful in differentiation from encephalopathies
caused by bacterial infections.
CSF pressure taken at the cisterna magna is increased from a normal range of 12 to
16 cm H2O to levels of 20 to 35 cm H2O. The level of protein in the CSF may be normal
to slightly or extremely elevated. A range from 15 to 540 mg/dL with a mean value
of 90 mg/dL in affected cattle is recorded. There may also be a slight to severe pleocytosis
in the CSF in which monocytes or phagocytes predominate.
Brain Imaging Function.
MRI of a 2-month-old Holstein Friesian calf with thiamine-inadequacy PEM indicated
a laminar hyperintense T2-weighted image of the cerebral cortex from the parietal
to occipital lobes that predominantly affected the gray matter.
9
The visual evoked potentials are abnormal in ruminants with thiamine-responsive PEM.
Sulfate-Induced Polioencephalomalacia
Sulfur-induced PEM is most commonly differentiated from other causes of PEM in ruminants
by the lack of responsiveness to thiamine injections and calculation of total sulfur
intake from feed and water. Measurement of ruminal hydrogen sulfide content or urinary
thiosulfate concentration offers promise as useful diagnostic tests.
Ruminal Hydrogen Sulfide Measurement.
Changes in rumen gas cap H2S concentrations are larger than changes in rumen fluid
H2S concentrations, and estimation of rumen gas H2S concentration may be a practical
method of detecting pathologic increases in ruminal hydrogen sulfide gas. A simple
and rapid method has been developed for measuring the H2S concentration of ruminal
gas under field conditions, and an excellent description of the procedure is available.2,
6 In brief, the left paralumbar fossa is clipped and aseptically prepared. A sterile
7.6- to 10.2-cm 12- to 18-gauge needle with stylet is introduced into the gas cap
of the rumen by way of the left paralumbar fossa. The needle is then connected to
a calibrated H2S detector tube. In cattle with sulfate-induced PEM increases in ruminal
gas H2S may be as high as 100 times more than control animals; however, ruminal pH
has a marked effect on the measured value for H2S,
2
suggesting that test interpretation needs to be adjusted for rumen pH to improve diagnostic
accuracy. The hydrogen sulfide test is more accurate when applied to healthy animals
in the same pen as an animal showing clinical signs of sulfate-induced PEM, because
affected animals have a markedly reduced appetite and therefore lower sulfate intake
and higher ruminal pH.
Urine thiosulfate concentrations appear to provide a useful diagnostic tool for sulfate-induced
PEM in ruminants. Thiosulfate (S2O3
2
−) is produced by incomplete oxidation of sulfide and by partial reduction of sulfate
and therefore an increase in urine or plasma thiosulfate concentration reflects an
increase in dietary sulfate intake or ruminal sulfide concentration. Thiosulfate concentrations
in urine are stable for 8 hours at room temperature and 24 hours when stored at 4°C,
and marked increases in urine thiosulfate concentrations occur when cattle are fed
a high-sulfate diet, with the greatest increase occurring after feeding.
2
The urine thiosulfate concentration does not need to be normalized to urine creatinine
concentration.
Brain Function.
The effects of high dietary sulfur on brain function have been examined using evoked
potentials techniques. Altered nerve conduction pathways occur in sheep fed high-sulfur
diets without supplemental thiamine compared with animals that have received thiamine.
Necropsy Findings
Diffuse cerebral edema with compression and yellow discoloration of the dorsal cortical
gyri is evident, and the cerebellum is pushed back into the foramen magnum with distortion
of its posterior aspect.
In recovered animals, there is macroscopic decortication about the motor area and
over the occipital lobes. The lesion can be identified grossly using ultraviolet illumination,
which results in a fluorescence that indicates necrosis of brain and engulfment of
necrotic tissue by lipophages. In general, there is a good correlation between the
presence of characteristic fluorescence and the biochemical changes in cases of PEM.
A small percentage of false negatives may occur.
Histologically, the lesions are widespread but most common in the cerebral cortex.
There is bilateral laminar necrosis and necrosis of deeper cerebral areas. The necrosis
is most prominent in the dorsal occipital and parietal cortex, but bilateral areas
of necrosis are also seen less frequently in the thalamus, lateral geniculate bodies,
basal ganglia, and mesencephalic nuclei. Lesions of the cerebellum are also present.
The severity and distribution of the lesions probably depend on the interrelationships
between clinical severity, age of affected animal, and length of illness before death.
Subnormal levels of thiamine are detectable in the liver and brain of calves with
the natural disease, and low levels are also found in the experimental disease. In
the molasses-induced disease in Cuba, the tissue thiamine levels were within the normal
range.
In some cases of sulfur-associated PEM, the rumen contents have a strong odor of hydrogen
sulfide (the rotten egg smell).
Differential Diagnosis
The biochemical tests described under the section Clinical Pathology are not practical.
The diagnosis must be made on the basis of clinical findings and the readily available
simple tests that rule out other diseases that resemble polioencephalomalacia. A careful
consideration of the epidemiologic history often assists in the diagnosis.
Cattle
The differential clinical diagnosis for cattle is summarized in Table 14-12. Polioencephalomalacia
in cattle occurs primarily in young growing animals 6–9 months of age on concentrate
rations and is characterized clinically by a sudden onset of blindness, muscular tremors
of the head and neck, head-pressing, nystagmus, and opisthotonus. The disease also
occurs in mature beef cattle on pasture containing a high level of sulfate in their
water and feed.
In cattle the disease must be differentiated from the following:
•
Acute lead poisoning, which is most common in calves after spring turnout but occurs
in adult cattle too and is characterized by central blindness, tremors, convulsions,
uncontrollable activity with bellowing, champing fits, hyperexcitability, rumen stasis,
and death in several hours. Early treatment may be successful.
•
Subacute lead poisoning characterized by blindness, stupor, head-pressing, rumen stasis,
weak palpebral reflexes, and no response to therapy.
•
Hypovitaminosis A is characterized by a history of a vitamin A–deficient diet and
nyctalopia, peripheral blindness, dilated and fixed pupils, optic disc edema, and
transient convulsions followed by recovery.
•
Histophilus somni meningoencephalitis characterized by sudden onset of ataxia, recumbency,
fever, depression with eyes closed, lesions of the fundus, marked changes in hemogram,
enlarged joints, and death in several hours if not treated early.
Sheep
In sheep polioencephalomalacia must be differentiated from the following:
•
Enterotoxemia (pulpy kidney disease) caused by Clostridium perfringens type D in unvaccinated
sheep, especially feedlot lambs, in which the clinical findings are almost identical;
it occurs under the same management conditions as polioencephalomalacia. Enterotoxemia
in lambs usually develops within several days after being placed on a grain ration,
whereas polioencephalomalacia occurs after several weeks of grain feeding. Glycosuria
in pulpy kidney disease may assist the diagnosis, but a necropsy is usually more informative
•
Focal symmetric encephalomalacia also resembles polioencephalomalacia but is sporadic,
usually involves only a few animals, and will not respond to treatment.
Goats
In goats the disease must be differentiated from enterotoxemia, pregnancy toxemia,
lead poisoning, and meningoencephalitis.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Thiamine Hydrochloride
The treatment of choice for thiamine-inadequacy PEM is thiamine hydrochloride at 10 mg/kg
BW by slow intravenous injection initially and followed by similar doses every 3 hours
for a total of five treatments. Bolus intravenous thiamine injections have been associated
with collapse but are not usually fatal. Intramuscular injections of thiamine can
be given instead of intravenous injections in animals that are difficult to handle
with no discernable effect on treatment efficacy. When treatment is given within a
few hours of the onset of signs, a beneficial response within 1 to 6 hours is common,
and complete clinical recovery can occur in 24 hours. Goats and sheep will commonly
respond within 1 to 2 hours. For those that take longer to recover, the eyesight and
mental awareness will gradually improve in a few days and the animal will usually
begin to eat and drink by the third day after treatment. Transfaunation of rumen fluid
from roughage-fed cattle may improve appetite and rumen function in those responding
slowly. In sheep, following treatment with thiamine, the blood transketolase activity
begins to return to normal in 2 to 4 hours and is considered normal 24 hours after
treatment.
Some cattle improve to a subnormal level within a few days and fail to continue to
improve. These are usually affected with diffuse cortical and subcortical necrosis
and will usually not improve further in spite of continued treatment. Those that return
to a clinically normal state will usually do so by 48 hours or sooner after initial
treatment. Those that are still clinically subnormal and anorexic by the end of the
third day will usually remain at that level and should be slaughtered for salvage.
General treatment of cerebral edema (such as intravenous infusions of 20% mannitol
at 0.25–1 g/kg BW or 7.2%–7.5% NaCl solution at 4–5 mL/kg BW, and parenteral dexamethasone
(1 mg/kg BW, intravenous, see the section Increased Intracranial Pressure, Cerebral
Edema, and Brain Swelling, earlier in this chapter) is theoretically indicated as
part of the initial treatment of severely affected animals; however, clinical trials
have not been conducted as to whether general treatment for cerebral edema provides
a beneficial response above that provided by thiamine administration alone for ruminants
with PEM caused by thiamine inadequacy. Both mannitol and dexamethasone are very expensive
when administered to adult cattle, sheep, and goats.
Treatment is ineffective in advanced cases, but unless an accurate history is available
on the length of the illness, it is usually difficult to predict the outcome until
6 to 12 hours following treatment. Thus it is usual practice to treat most cases with
thiamine at least twice and monitor the response. If there is no beneficial response
in 6 to 8 hours, emergency slaughter for salvage should be considered.
The oral administration of thiamine or thiamine derivatives is indicated when thiaminases
are thought to be in the alimentary tract. Thiamine hydrochloride, at a rate of 1 g
for lambs and kids and 5 g for calves in a drench, is recommended. However, because
the action of thiaminase type I on thiamine may result in the production of thiamine
analogs, which may act as inhibitors of thiamine metabolism, thiamine derivatives,
which are resistant to thiaminases, lipid soluble and absorbed from the intestine,
are being explored as therapeutic and prophylactic agents. Thiamine propyl disulfide
can depress the thiaminase activities in the ruminal fluid of sheep with PEM within
2 hours after oral administration. The blood pyruvate levels and transketolase activities
are also restored to normal and treated animals recovered clinically.
Outbreak Management
In outbreaks, the in-contact unaffected animals on the same diet as the affected animals
may be on the brink of clinical disease. The diet should be changed to one containing
at least 50% roughage or 1.5 kg of roughage per 100 kg BW. Thiamine may be added to
the ration at the rate of 50 mg/kg of feed for 2 to 3 weeks as a preventive against
clinical disease, followed by a level of 20 to 30 mg/kg of feed (cattle and sheep)
if the animals remain on a diet that may predispose them to the disease.
Sulfur-Induced Polioencephalomalacia
There is no specific treatment for PEM caused by sulfate toxicity. The use of thiamine
hydrochloride in doses given earlier is recommended, and may be successful in some
cases, particularly when administered early in the disease course.
Treatment and Control
Treatment
Thiamine inadequacy form
Thiamine HCl (10 mg/kg BW by slow IV or IM every 3 hours for at least five treatments)
(R-1)
In severe acute cerebral edema
20% mannitol IV (0.25–1.0 g/kg) or 7.2%–7.5% NaCl IV (4–5 mL/kg) (R-2)
Dexamethasone (1 mg/kg, IV, once) (R-2)
Rumen transfaunation if prolonged off feed (R-2)
Oral drench with thiamine (1 g to lambs/kids, 5 g to calves) if thiaminases are suspected
(R-2)
Sulfur-induced form
Thiamine HCl (10 mg/kg BW by slow IV or IM every 3 hours for at least five treatments)
(R-2)
Treat suspected cerebral edema (R-2)
Control
Thiamine inadequacy form
Alter intraluminal environment by increasing roughage or changing source of roughage
(R-2)
Supplement ration with thiamine at 3 mg/kg dry matter of feed (R-2)
Remove amprolium from diet (R-2)
Sulfur-induced form
Decrease overall sulfur intake in ration and water (R-1)
Restrict access to pastures with Brassicaceae family plants that have high sulfur
content (R-1)
BW, body weight; IM, intramuscularly; IV, intravenously.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
Thiamine Supplementation
A rational approach to the control of PEM associated with thiamine inadequacy is to
supplement the rations of concentrate-fed cattle and sheep with thiamine on a continuous
basis. The daily requirements for protection have not been determined using controlled
feeding trials, but a rate of 3 mg/kg dry matter of feed for cattle and sheep has
been recommended. This level may not be protective in all situations, and response
trials may be necessary to determine protective levels for different situations. Levels
up to 20 to 30 mg/kg of feed may be necessary for protection. Most natural feedstuffs
for ruminants contain thiamine at about 2 mg/kg dry matter, which when combined with
the thiamine synthesized in the rumen will meet the requirements. However, the presence
of thiaminases in the rumen will necessitate dietary supplementation with thiamine,
but the optimal amount that will provide protection under practical conditions is
uncertain.
The intramuscular injection of 500 mg thiamine three times weekly into 6-month-old
calves raised under practical farm conditions will steadily reduce the percentage
TPP effect to zero in about 6 weeks. The daily oral administration of 100 mg thiamine
to young calves fed initially on milk substitutes and then on concentrates and hay
results in a decrease in percentage pyrophosphate effect.
For animals fed diets associated with thiamine inadequacy, it is recommended that
thiamine be added to the diet at the rate of 5 to 10 mg/kg dry matter. Cattle and
sheep on concentrate-fed rations must also receive supplements containing all necessary
vitamins and minerals, especially cobalt, a deficiency of which may be associated
with some outbreaks of the disease.
Feeding Roughage
The minimum amount of roughage, which should be fed to feedlot cattle and sheep to
prevent the disease and still maintain them on high levels of concentrates is unknown.
A level of 1.5 kg of roughage per 100 kg BW has been recommended, but this may not
be economical for the feedlot whose profits are dependent on rapid growth in grain-fed
cattle. Supplementation of the diet with thiamine appears to be the only alternative.
The prevention of the disease in sheep that are being moved long distances or gathered
together for shearing and other management practices will depend on ensuring an ample
supply of roughage and water and avoiding drastic changes in management.
Sulfate Toxicity PEM
The prevention of the disease associated with a high sulfur intake in the feed and
water supplies will depend on analysis of the feed and water for sulfate and making
appropriate adjustments in the sources of feed and water to decrease the intake of
sulfur to safe levels.
Further Reading
Apley
MD
Consideration of evidence for therapeutic interventions in bovine polioencephalomalacia
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
31
2015
151
161
25705027
Burgess
BA
Polioencephalomalacia
Large Animal Veterinary Rounds
8
2008
3
Niles
GA
Morgan
SE
Edwards
WC
The relationship between sulfur, thiamine and polioencephalomalacia—a review
Bovine Pract
36
2002
93
99
References
1
Sakhaee
E
Derakhshanfar
A
J S Afr Vet Assoc
81
2010
116
21247019
2
Drewnoski
ME
J Vet Diagn Invest
24
2012
702
22643342
3
Amat
S
Res Vet Sci
95
2013
1081
23962856
4
McKenzie
RA
Aust Vet J
87
2009
27
19178473
5
Kul
O
J Vet Med A Physiol Pathol Clin Med
53
2006
123
16533327
6
Neville
BW
J Anim Sci
88
2010
2444
20348382
7
Irmak
K
Kafkus Univ Vet Fak Derg
4
1998
63
8
Karapinar
T
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
662
18466243
9
Tsuka
T
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
49
2008
149
18418995
Thiamine Deficiency (Hypothiaminosis)
The disease caused by deficiency of thiamine in tissues is characterized chiefly by
signs of neurologic disease. PEM of ruminants is discussed in the previous section.
Etiology
Thiamine deficiency can be primary; caused by deficiency of the vitamin in the diet;
or secondary, because of destruction of the vitamin in the diet by thiaminase. A primary
deficiency is unlikely under natural conditions because most plants, especially seeds,
yeast, and milk contain adequate amounts.
Thiamine is normally synthesized in adequate quantities in the rumen of cattle and
sheep on a well-balanced roughage diet. The degree of synthesis is governed to some
extent by the composition of the ration, a sufficiency of readily fermentable carbohydrate
causing an increase of synthesis of most vitamins of the B complex, and a high intake
in the diet reducing synthesis. The etiology of PEM has been discussed in detail previously.
Microbial synthesis of thiamine also occurs in the alimentary tract of monogastric
animals and in young calves and lambs, but not in sufficient quantities to avoid the
necessity for a dietary supply, so that deficiency states can be readily induced in
these animals with experimental diets. Thiamine is relatively unstable and easily
destroyed by cooking.
The coccidiostat, amprolium, is a thiamine antagonist and others are produced by certain
plants, bacteria, fungi, and fish.
Epidemiology
One of the best examples of secondary thiamine deficiency is inclusion of excess raw
fish in the diet of carnivores, resulting in destruction of thiamine because of the
high content of thiaminase in the fish.
Two major occurrences of secondary thiamine deficiency are recorded. In horses, the
ingestion of excessive quantities of bracken fern (P. aquilinum) and horsetail (E.
arvense) causes nervous signs because of the high concentration of thiaminase in these
plants. The disease has been induced in a pig fed bracken rhizomes, and the possibility
exists of it occurring under natural conditions. It also occurs in horses fed large
quantities of turnips (Beta vulgaris) without adequate grain. The second important
occurrence of thiamine deficiency is in the etiology of PEM and is discussed under
that heading.
A thiaminase-induced subclinical thiamine deficiency causing suboptimal growth rate
of weaner lambs has been described. Higher levels of thiaminase activity were present
in the feces and rumen contents of lambs with poor growth rate compared with normal
lambs. B. thiaminolyticus was isolated from the feces and ruminal fluids of affected
lambs and supplementation of thiaminase-excreting lambs with intramuscular injections
of thiamine hydrochloride was associated with significantly improved growth rate.
Thiamine deficiency occurs in sheep being subjected to live export from Australia
to the Middle East. Sheep that died or were clinically ill and euthanized had significantly
lower hepatic and ruminal thiaminase concentrations than clinically healthy control
sheep. A high proportion had thiamine concentrations comparable with those found in
sheep that die with PEM. The evidence indicates that the thiamine deficiency is a
primary one associated with deprivation of feed during transportation to the preembarkation
feedlots. The low feed intake and failure of the ruminal microbes to adapt, thrive,
and synthesize a net surplus of thiamine during alterations in the ruminal environment
are considered to be major contributing factors.
Pathogenesis
The only known function of thiamine is its activity as a cocarboxylase in the metabolism
of fats, carbohydrates, and proteins and a deficiency of the vitamin leads to the
accumulation of endogenous pyruvates. Although the brain is known to depend largely
on carbohydrates as a source of energy, there is no obvious relationship between a
deficiency of thiamine and the development of the nervous signs that characterize
it. PEM has been produced experimentally in preruminant lambs on a thiamine-free diet.
There are other prodromal indications of deficiency disease. For example, there is
a decrease in erythrocyte precursors and in erythrocyte transketolase. Additional
clinical signs are also in the circulatory and alimentary systems, but their pathogenesis
cannot be clearly related to the known functions of thiamine. Subclinical thiamine
deficiency caused by thiaminases in the alimentary tract is associated with low erythrocyte
transketolase activities and elevated TPP effects, which may explain the poor growth
rate.
Clinical Findings
Bracken Fern (P. aquilinum) and Horsetail (E. arvense) Poisoning in the Horse
Incoordination and falling and bradycardia caused by cardiac irregularity are the
cardinal clinical signs of bracken fern poisoning in the horse. These signs disappear
after the parenteral administration of thiamine. Similar clinical effects occur with
horsetail. Swaying from side to side occurs first, followed by pronounced incoordination,
including crossing of the forelegs and wide action in the hindlegs. When standing,
the legs are placed well apart and crouching and arching of the back are evident.
Muscle tremor develops and eventually the horse is unable to rise. Clonic convulsions
and opisthotonus are the terminal stage. Appetite is good until late in the disease
when somnolence prevents eating. Temperatures are normal and the heart rate slow until
the terminal period, when both rise to above normal levels. Some evidence has also
been presented relating the occurrence of hemiplegia of the vocal cords in horses
with a below normal thiamine status. Neither plant is palatable to horses and poisoning
rarely occurs at pasture. The greatest danger is when the immature plants are cut
and preserved in meadow hay.
Experimental Syndromes
These syndromes have not been observed to occur naturally but are produced readily
on experimental rations.
In pigs, inappetence; emaciation; leg weakness; and a fall in body temperature, respiratory
rate, and heart rate occur. The ECG is abnormal and congestive heart failure follows.
Death occurs in 5 weeks on a severely deficient diet. In calves, weakness, incoordination,
convulsions, and retraction of the head occur, and in some cases there is anorexia,
severe scouring, and dehydration.
Lambs 1 to 3 days old placed on a thiamine-deficient diet show signs after 3 weeks.
Somnolence, anorexia, and loss of condition occur first, followed by tetanic convulsions.
Horses fed amprolium (400–800 mg/kg BW daily) developed clinical signs of thiamine
deficiency after 37 to 58 days. Bradycardia with dropped heartbeats, ataxia, muscle
fasciculation and periodic hypothermia of hooves, ears, and muzzle were the common
signs, with blindness, diarrhea, and loss of BW occurring inconstantly.
Clinical Pathology
Blood pyruvic acid levels in horses are raised from normal levels of 2 to 3 µg/dL
to 6 to 8 µg/dL. Blood thiamine levels are reduced from normal levels of 8 to 10 µg/dL
to 2.5 to 3.0 µg/dL. ECGs show evidence of myocardial insufficiency. In pigs, blood
pyruvate levels are elevated and there is a fall in blood transketolase activity.
These changes occur very early in the disease. In sheep subjected to export, liver
and rumen thiamine concentrations and erythrocyte transketolase activities were all
below levels found in clinically normal sheep.
Necropsy Findings
No macroscopic lesions occur in thiamine deficiency other than nonspecific congestive
heart failure in horses. The myocardial lesions are those of interstitial edema, and
lesions are also present in the liver and intestine.
In the experimental syndrome in pigs, there are no degenerative lesions in the nervous
system, but there is multiple focal necrosis of the atrial myocardium accompanied
by macroscopic flabbiness and dilatation without hypertrophy of the heart.
Differential Diagnosis
Diagnosis of secondary thiamine deficiency in horses must be based on the signs of
paralysis and known access to bracken fern or horsetail. A similar syndrome may occur
with poisoning by the following:
•
Crotalaria spp.
•
Perennial ryegrass
•
Indigofera enneaphylla
•
Ragwort (Senecio jacobaea)
It is accompanied by hepatic necrosis and fibrosis. The encephalomyelitides are usually
accompanied by signs of cerebral involvement, by fever, and by failure to respond
to thiamine therapy.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
In clinical cases the injection of a solution of the vitamin produces dramatic results
(5 mg/kg BW given every 3 hours). The initial dose is usually given intravenously
followed by intramuscular injections for 2 to 4 days. An oral source of thiamine should
be given daily for 10 days and any dietary abnormalities corrected.
Control
The daily requirement of thiamine for monogastric animals is generally 30 to 60 µg/kg
BW. The addition of yeast, cereals, grains, liver, and meat meal to the ration usually
provides adequate thiamine.
Thiaminase Toxicosis
Synopsis
Etiology Thiaminases occur naturally in Marsilea spp., Cheilanthes spp., Pteridium
spp., and Equisetum spp. ferns or fernlike plants.
Epidemiology Horses fed hay containing bracken; pigs eating bracken, especially rhizomes.
Clinical pathology Low blood concentrations of thiamine; high blood concentrations
of pyruvate.
Lesions Similar to vitamin B1 (thiamine) deficiency in horses; cardiac lesions in
pigs.
Diagnostic confirmation. Low blood and urine levels of thiamine.
Treatment Injectable thiamine gives excellent results, provided thiamine source is
withdrawn.
Control Limit access to plants.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
The identified thiaminases that are important to animals occur in ferns or fernlike
plants and catalyze the decomposition of thiamine. Thiaminases are of two types, methyltransferase
and hydrolase. The hydrolases are not found in plants but only in the rumen, presumably
as metabolites produced by ruminal bacteria from specific precursors in the plants.
The thiaminase content of the ferns varies widely, being highest at a period of rapid
growth and after being grazed severely. Thiaminase activity occurs in the fronds of
the ferns M. drummondii, Cheilanthes sieberi, and P. aquilinum in descending order
of magnitude. Plants containing thiaminases are usually deficient in thiamine.
The ferns that are sources of thiaminase and the animal species affected are as follows:
•
Horses: Pteridium spp. (bracken fern), E. arvense (horsetail), E. fluviatile, E. hyemale,
E. palustre, E. ramosissimum, E. sylvaticum, M. drummondii (Nardoo)
1
•
Sheep: M. drummondii, C. sieberi (mulga or rock fern)
1
•
Cattle: C. sieberi, Dryopteris borreri, D. filix-mas
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Thiaminase poisoning associated with Pteridium spp. and Equisetum spp. occurs most
often in horses fed hay contaminated by the ferns and is most toxic if the hay is
cut when the fronds are very young. The standing plants are unpalatable and rarely
eaten by these animals unless no other feed is available. In grazing horses ingesting
20% to 25% of their diet as thiaminase-containing plants, signs occur in 3 to 4 weeks;
horses grazing on a pasture with thiaminase-containing plants providing close to 100%
of their diet may show signs in as little as 10 days.2, 3 Stabled horses fed heavily
contaminated hay may show signs in a short period of time, depending on how much thiaminase
is present in the hay.
Thiaminase deficiency is less common in pigs and the clinical signs not as obvious.
3
Grazing pigs may root out and eat Pteridium rhizomes, which contain a much higher
concentration of the thiaminase than the fronds. Sheep grazed on pastures dominated
by M. drummondii on floodplains in inland Australia or forced to graze C. sieberi
are poisoned.
1
Grazing cattle may be forced to eat the ferns because of lack of other feed and when
the fern is at a toxic, rapidly growing stage, but they are not affected by thiamine
deficiency. They succumb to a hemorrhagic disease.
4
Pathogenesis
A state of thiamine deficiency is created by the destruction of thiamine in the alimentary
tract. The activities of enzymes that require thiamine, are impaired and there is
an accumulation in tissues of pyruvate and lactate.
3
The relationship between the intake of the thiaminase and the nervous signs is not
adequately explained. That a relationship exists is suggested by the development of
brain lesions of PEM in sheep poisoned by M. drummondii and in those fed experimentally
on the rhizomes of P. aquilinum.
3
Clinical Findings
Affected horses sway from side to side, show gait incoordination, including crossing
the forelimbs and a wide action in the hindlimbs. Abnormal postures include a wide
stance, arching of the back, and crouching. Muscle tremor, cardiac irregularity, and
bradycardia are evident. Terminally, the animal falls easily, becomes recumbent and
hyposensitive to external stimuli, and makes convulsive movements. The heart rate
and the temperature become elevated. Additional signs seen in horses poisoned by M.
drummondii include carrying the head close to the ground, whinnying, partial blindness,
nodding of the head, twitching of the ears, and frequent yawning.
Pigs fed bracken fern rhizomes (33% of diet) developed anorexia and nonspecific signs.
At 8 weeks they deteriorated rapidly and death occurred at 10 weeks.
3
Postmortem lesions were cardiac in nature. In another report, 4 of 22 piglets died
when a pregnant sow was poisoned with bracken fern.
3
Sheep poisoned by M. drummondii may be affected by an acute or a chronic syndrome.
The acute form of the disease is characterized by the sudden onset of dyspnea, depression,
and recumbency and death in 6 to 8 hours. The chronic syndrome is indistinguishable
from PEM. Sheep affected by Cheilanthes spp. poisoning are hyposensitive to external
stimuli, including being blind, and walk slowly and with an uncoordinated gait.
Cattle poisoned by Dryopteris spp. are also blind and hyposensitive. Many recover
but remain blind.
Clinical Pathology
The characteristic findings attributable to a nutritional deficiency of thiamine are
present. These include depression of blood levels of thiamine and transketolase and
elevation of levels of blood pyruvate.
Necropsy Findings
In naturally occurring cases in horses, there are no lesions recorded other than the
nonspecific ones of acute or congestive heart failure. PEM has been seen in sheep
and, in pigs, an enlarged mottled heart and congestion of the lungs and liver indicate
the presence of congestive heart failure.
Diagnostic confirmation is based on low blood thiamine levels.
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list
•
Hepatic encephalopathy
•
Infectious encephalitides
•
Crotalaria spp., Senecio jacobea toxicosis
•
Staggers syndromes, e.g., ryegrass staggers, paspalum staggers, phalaris staggers
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
In the early stages, the administration of thiamine and removal of the dietary source
of thiaminase are the critical procedures and recovery is to be expected. In horses,
an intravenous injection of 0.5 to 1 g of thiamine followed by intramuscular administration
for 3 to 5 days is recommended.2, 5 The response to treatment is usually excellent.
Control
Large-scale control is attempted by a combination of pasture management, application
of herbicide, and mowing in early spring, but it is expensive and subject to error;
thus professional agrochemical advice is desirable. Draining water from marshy areas
and improving drainage will encourage grasses and legumes to compete with and outgrow
these plants.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Thiaminase poisoning
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1882
References
1
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
89
2011
247
2
Martinson
K
Horsetail and brackenfern
Martinson
K
Hovda
LR
Murphy
M
Plants Poisonous or Harmful to Horses in North Central United States
2007
University of Minnesota Press
Minneapolis, MN
17
3
Vetter
J
Acta Vet Hung
18
2009
183
4
Plessers
E
Vlaams Diergeneeskundig Tijdschr
82
2013
31
5
Plumb
DC
Thiamine HCl (Vitamin B1)
Plumb
DC
Veterinary Drug Handbook
7th ed
2011
Wiley and Sons
New York
970
Salt Toxicity (Sodium Chloride Toxicosis)
Synopsis
Etiology Ingestion of excessive amounts of sodium chloride or normal intake of sodium
but limited water intake.
Epidemiology Multiple sources of excess salt in the diet and limitations of drinking
water.
Clinical pathology High serum levels of sodium and chloride; increased plasma osmolarity;
eosinopenia in pigs. High salt content in water or feed.
Lesions
Acute: gastroenteritis plus neurologic abnormalities.
Chronic: eosinophilic meningitis in pigs; polioencephalomalacia in pigs and cattle.
High rumen, brain, and CSF levels of sodium.
Diagnostic confirmation Elevated sodium content of rumen and brain. CSF sodium exceeds
serum sodium. Elevated sodium in aqueous or vitreous humor.
Treatment
Peracute with no signs: remove source of salt and allow free choice water; monitor
closely.
Acute and chronic with signs: remove source of salt, restrict water intake, IV fluid
replacement.
Control Limit intake of salt-rich water, whey, concentrate mixes; ensure adequate
drinking water supply at all times.
CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; IV, intravenous.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Sodium and chloride are the main ions responsible for maintaining osmotic balance
in the ECF. Any alteration in serum concentrations, either through increased salt
intake or decreased water consumption is likely to result in salt toxicity.1, 2
Feed and water containing excessive quantities of salt are unpalatable to animals
but excessive quantities of salt are sometimes ingested, especially in saline drinking
waters. Specific details about the degree of salinity of drinking water compatible
with health in animals are difficult to provide, because of the variation in the kinds
of salts that occur in natural saline waters. Hypernatremia may also occur secondary
to limited water intake such as occurs in cold environments when there is no access
or water has frozen.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Salt poisoning will occur wherever bore water is used for livestock drinking. It is
reported principally from Australia, North America, and South Africa. Other sources
of excessive salt include the following:
•
Saline drinking water, especially after a change from fresh water, and especially
if the animals are thirsty.
3
•
Water accumulating in salt troughs during drought periods.
•
Grazing on salt marshes or drinking water obtained from salt marshes.
3
•
Swill fed to pigs containing excessive amounts of salt from bakery dough residues,
butcher shop brine, cheese factory salt whey, or salted fish waste.
•
Excessive sodium sulfate given to pigs as treatment for gut edema if the water intake
is restricted.
•
Oil field brine.
2
Salt poisoning associated with water deprivation may occur from:
•
Temporary restriction of the water supply to pigs of 8 to 12 weeks of age and lambs
and calves fed prepared feeds containing the standard recommendation of 2% salt; poisoning
occurs when the animals are again allowed access to unlimited water.
•
Pigs brought into new pens where drinking water is supplied in automatic drinking
cups that are not be accustomed to their use and fail to drink for several days until
they learn to operate the cups.
•
Feeder lambs and calves may also be deprived of water when their water troughs are
frozen over.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Swine are the most susceptible animals and have generated the most clinical reports
of toxicity.
4
Sheep, beef cattle, and dry dairy cattle appear to be less susceptible than milking
dairy cows, which are in turn less susceptible than horses. Heavy milking cows, especially
those in the early stages of lactation, are highly susceptible to salt poisoning because
of their unstable fluid and electrolyte status.
Many animals may be clinically affected and the mortality rate may be high when animals
are kept under range conditions and have to depend on saline water supplies for drinking
purposes. In animals kept under intensive conditions salt poisoning occurs only sporadically,
but most affected animals die and heavy losses may occur in groups of pigs.
High salt intakes may be used in sheep to restrict food intake during drought periods
and in the control of urolithiasis in feeder wethers, but salt poisoning does not
occur if there is free access to water. Rations containing up to 13% of sodium chloride
have been fed to ewes for long periods without apparent ill-effects, although diets
containing 10% to 20% and water containing 1.5% to 2% sodium chloride do reduce food
consumption. This may be of value when attempting to reduce feed intake but can be
a disadvantage when sheep are watered on saline artesian water.
Toxic doses for acute sodium chloride poisoning in pigs, horses, and cattle are 2.2 g/kg
BW and in sheep 6 g/kg. The toxicity of salt is significantly influenced by the age
and BW of the subject. For example, dose rates that kill pigs of 6.5 to 10 kg BW have
little effect on pigs of 16% to 20 kg BW. Water concentrations of 1000 mg Na/L water
are associated with chronic problems in dairy cattle, including decreased production.
2
Farm Risk Factors
Saline waters often contain a mixture of salts and those containing high levels of
magnesium or fluorine may be quite toxic. Water containing 0.2% to 0.5% magnesium
chloride may be associated with reduced appetite and occasional diarrhea in sheep,
especially if the sodium chloride content is also high, but water containing similar
quantities of sodium sulfate does not have any harmful effect. Variation between bore
waters includes differences in the relative proportions of the acid radicals, particularly
sulfates, carbonates, and chlorides.
Environmental Risk Factors
Environmental temperatures have an effect on toxicity, with signs occurring in the
summer on water containing levels of salt that appear to be nontoxic in the winter.
Australian recommendations are that the maximum concentration for sodium chloride
or total salts in drinking water should not exceed 1.3% for sheep, 1% for cattle,
and 0.9% for horses. South African and Canadian recommended levels are much lower,
but there does not appear to be any proof that such low levels of total and individual
salts are necessary.
Pathogenesis
Acute Poisoning
When excessive amounts of salt are ingested, gastroenteritis occurs because of the
irritating effects from the high concentrations of salt. Dehydration and diarrhea
result and are exacerbated by the increased osmotic pressure of the alimentary tract
contents. Salt is absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract and may be associated with
the involvement of the CNS.
Chronic Poisoning
Where the defect is one of decreased water but normal salt intake, there is an accumulation
of sodium ions in tissues, including the brain, over a period of several days. An
initial high sodium accumulation may inhibit anaerobic glycolysis, preventing active
transport of sodium out of the cerebrospinal compartment. When water is made available
in unlimited quantities, it migrates to the tissues to restore normal salt–water equilibrium.
This is associated with acute cerebral edema and the appearance of signs referable
to a sudden rise in intracranial pressure. The response is the same in all species,
but in pigs there is also an accumulation of eosinophils in nervous tissue and the
meninges. The sodium ion is the one that accumulates in the tissues, and identical
syndromes are produced by the feeding of sodium propionate or sodium sulfate. It has
also been observed that the feeding of soluble substances such as urea, which are
excreted unchanged by the kidney, may be associated with anhydremia and an increase
in the sodium ion concentration in brain tissue and the development of encephalomalacia.
This form of salt poisoning is chronic only in the sense that the sodium ion accumulates
gradually. The clinical syndrome is acute in much the same way as the syndrome is
acute in chronic copper poisoning. There is an apparent relationship between this
form of salt poisoning and PEM in all species.5, 6 Many outbreaks of the latter disease
occur in circumstances that suggest chronic salt poisoning. Sheep adapt to a continuous
high salt intake (up to 1.3% sodium chloride in the drinking water) by significant
changes in numbers of microflora in the rumen, but this is not usually accompanied
by any change in total metabolic activity. The same level of intake in sheep is associated
with some mortality; chronic diarrhea; and reduction in fertility, weight gain, and
wool growth.
Clinical Findings
Subclinical Salt Poisoning
Lower levels of intake can suppress food intake and growth without overt clinical
signs. This occurs in heifers drinking water containing 1.75% sodium chloride; the
animals only maintain weight at a salt level of 1.5% and show suboptimal weight gains
when the water contains 1.25% sodium chloride. Drinking water containing 0.25% salt
significantly reduces the milk yield of high-producing dairy cows.
Acute Salt Poisoning
With large doses, vomiting, diarrhea with mucus in the feces, abdominal pain, and
anorexia occur. The more common syndrome, occurring 1 to 2 days after ingestion, includes
opisthotonus, nystagmus, tremor, blindness, paresis, and knuckling at the fetlocks.
7
There may be a nasal discharge and polyuria. A period of recumbency with convulsions
follows and affected animals die within 24 hours of first becoming ill. Sheep show
similar signs. In swine the signs include weakness and prostration, muscle tremor,
clonic convulsions, coma, and death after a course of about 48 hours.
Subacute Poisoning
This syndrome in cattle and sheep on saline drinking water includes depression of
appetite; thirst; constant bawling, especially in calves; loss of BW; dehydration;
hypothermia; weakness; and occasional diarrhea. Incoordination, collapse, and tetanic
convulsions with frothing from the mouth and nose may occur if the animals are forced
to exercise. Acetonemia may be a complication in lactating cows.
Chronic Salt Poisoning
Chronic toxicity occurs most often in pigs. Lack of appetite, constipation, thirst,
restlessness, and pruritus occur 2 to 4 days after exposure. A characteristic nervous
syndrome follows within 12 to 24 hours. Initially there is apparent blindness and
deafness, with the pig remaining oblivious to normal stimuli and wandering about aimlessly,
bumping into objects, and pressing with the head. There may be circling or pivoting
on one front leg. Recovery may occur at this stage or epileptiform convulsions begin,
recurring at remarkably constant time intervals, usually 7 minutes, accompanied by
tremor of the snout and neck. Clonic contractions of the neck muscles may be associated
with jerky opisthotonus until the head is almost vertical causing the pig to walk
backward and assume a dog-sitting posture. This may be followed by a clonic convulsion
in lateral recumbency, with jaw champing, salivation, and dyspnea. Death may occur
from respiratory failure or the pig relaxes into a state of coma for a few moments,
revives, and wanders about aimlessly until the next episode occurs. The pulse and
temperature are normal except in convulsive pigs when both may be elevated.
Clinical Pathology
Serum sodium concentrations are elevated appreciably above normal levels (135–145 mmol/L)
to about 160/170 to 210 mmol/L.1, 8 An eosinopenia is also evident during this stage
and a return to normal levels usually indicates recovery. In cattle the same changes
occur but there is no eosinopenia. CSF sodium concentration exceeds serum sodium concentration.
Necropsy Findings
In acute salt poisoning of cattle, there is marked congestion of the mucosa of the
omasum and abomasum. The feces are fluid and dark. Animals that have survived for
several days show hydropericardium and edema of the skeletal muscles. Gastroenteritis
may be evident in some pigs poisoned with large doses of salt, but in chronic poisoning
there are no gross lesions. Histologically, the neurologic lesions of acute poisoning
are restricted to expansion of perivascular spaces in the brain. In contrast, the
microscopic changes in chronic salt poisoning in pigs are quite diagnostic. The expansion
of perivascular spaces typical of acute cerebral edema is accompanied by meningitis
featuring large numbers of eosinophils, which extend along Virchow–Robin spaces into
the brain tissue. In pigs that survive there may be residual PEM, especially of the
cerebral cortex. Chemical estimation of the amount of sodium and chloride in tissues,
especially brain, may be of diagnostic value. Brain sodium levels exceeding 1,800 ppm
are considered diagnostic in cattle and swine.
2
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Toxicology: 50 g liver, skeletal muscle, brain, serum, CSF, aqueous, or vitreous humor,
feed, water (assay for sodium concentration)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed half of sagittally sectioned brain (LM)
Differential Diagnosis
Differential diagnosis list
Bacterial meningoencephalitis
Gut edema occurs in rapidly growing pigs
Mulberry heart disease in older pigs
Polioencephalomalacia
Pseudorabies
Viral encephalomyelitis
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Treatment of both acute and chronic salt poisoning is the immediate removal of the
toxic feed or water.
8
Further treatment involves correcting hypernatremia and serum hyperosmolality.
Acute Toxicity
If the animals have not yet shown clinical signs, allow access to water and monitor
closely for several days. In those animals showing an acute onset of clinical signs
(less than 12–24 hours), serum sodium concentration may be lowered by 1 mmol/L/h.
8
Intravenous fluids of choice include 5% dextrose in water or 0.45% sodium chloride
in well-hydrated animals and 0.9% sodium chloride or an isotonic crystalloid in hypovolemic
animals.1, 8
Chronic Toxicity
Initially, access to fresh water should be restricted to small amounts at frequent
intervals; unlimited access may be associated with a sudden increase in the number
of animals affected. In advanced cases animals may be unable to drink and water may
have to be administered by stomach tube. Serum sodium levels in those animals with
toxicity of several days' duration or those with an unknown duration of hypernatremia
should be decreased by no more than 0.5 mmol/L/h.
8
Fluid choices again depend on whether the animal is volume depleted or well hydrated.
If possible, serum sodium concentration should be measured and the following formula
used to calculate the free-water deficit:
Free
-
water
deficit
(
L
)
=
0.6
×
B
W
(
k
g
)
×
(
[
current
serum
sodium
concentration
/
reference
range
serum
sodium
concentration
]
−
1
)
No more than 50% of the free-water deficit should be replaced in the first 24 hours,
with the remainder replaced over the subsequent 24 to 48 hours.
Supportive treatment includes gastrointestinal protectants, diuretics for pulmonary
edema, and mannitol or hypertonic saline to decrease brain edema should it occur.
Control
Both salt and water should be freely available at all times. Drinking water for all
classes of livestock should not contain more than 0.5% sodium chloride or total salts.
Water containing a high concentration of fluoride or magnesium is particularly dangerous
to livestock and should be avoided. In cold weather, access to water should be monitored
on a daily basis. Diets fed to pigs should not contain more than 1% salt. The manner
in which whey is fed to pigs (with minimum water intake) makes prevention difficult
unless the whey can be kept salt free at the cheese factory.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Sodium chloride poisoning
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
1824
Senturk
S
Huseyin
C
Salt poisoning in beef cattle
Vet Hum Toxicol
46
2004
26
27
14748413
Weeth
HJ
Haverland
LH
Tolerance of growing cattle for drinking water containing sodium chloride
J Anim Sci
20
1961
518
521
References
1
Goldkamp
C
Comp Contin Educ Vet
29
2007
140
2
Morgan
SE
Vet Clin North Am Food Animal Pract
27
2011
286
3
Ollivett
TL
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
592
23551171
4
Heydarpour
F
Toxicol Environ Chem
90
2008
1115
5
de Sant'Ana
FJF
Braz J Vet Pathol
3
2010
70
6
Macri
SM
Vet Pathol Online
2013
0300985813498782
7
Heydarpour
F
Toxicol Environ Chem
90
2008
1035
8
Abutarbus
SM
Can Vet J
48
2007
184
17334033
Vitamin A Deficiency (Hypovitaminosis A)
A deficiency of vitamin A may be caused by an insufficient supply of the vitamin in
the ration or its defective absorption from the alimentary canal. In young animals,
the manifestations of the deficiency are mainly those of compression of the brain
and spinal cord. In adult animals, the syndrome is characterized by night blindness,
corneal keratinization, pityriasis, defects in the hooves, loss of weight, and infertility.
Congenital defects are common in the offspring of deficient dams. Vitamin A may also
provide a protective effect against various infectious diseases and enhance many facets
of the immune system.
Synopsis
Etiology Dietary deficiency of vitamin A or its precursors.
Epidemiology Primary vitamin A deficiency in animals fed diet deficient in vitamin
A or its precursors. Common in cattle grazing dry pastures for long periods. Occurs
when diet of hand-fed animals is not supplemented with vitamin A.
Signs
Cattle: Night blindness. Loss of body weight. Convulsions followed by recovery. Episodes
of syncope. Permanent blindness with dilated pupils and optic disc edema.
Pigs: Convulsions, hindleg paralysis, congenital defects.
Clinical pathology Low levels plasma vitamin A.
Necropsy findings Squamous metaplasia of interlobular ducts of parotid gland. Compression
of optic nerve tracts and spinal nerve roots. Degeneration of testes.
Diagnostic confirmation Low levels of plasma vitamin A and squamous metaplasia of
interlobular ducts of parotid glands.
Differential diagnosis list
Cattle
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Hypomagnesemic tetany
•
Lead poisoning
•
Rabies
•
Meningoencephalitis
•
Peripheral blindness caused by bilateral ophthalmitis.
Pigs
•
Salt poisoning
•
Pseudorabies
•
Viral encephalomyelitis
•
Spinal cord compression caused by vertebral body abscess
Treatment Vitamin A injections.
Control Feed diets with adequate carotene. Supplement diet with vitamin A. Parenteral
injections of vitamin A at strategic times.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
Vitamin A deficiency may be primary disease, caused by an absolute deficiency of vitamin
A or its precursor carotene in the diet, or a secondary disease, in which the dietary
supply of the vitamin or its precursor is adequate, but their digestion, absorption,
or metabolism is interfered with to produce a deficiency at the tissue level.
Epidemiology
Primary Vitamin A Deficiency
Primary vitamin A deficiency is of major economic importance in groups of young growing
animals on pasture or fed diets deficient in the vitamin or its precursors. In the
UK, primary vitamin A deficiency occurs in housed cattle fed a ration containing little
or no green forage. Animals at pasture receive adequate supplies of the vitamin, except
during prolonged droughts, but animals confined indoors and fed prepared diets may
be deficient if not adequately supplemented. For example, a diet of dried sugar beet
pulp, concentrates, and poor-quality hay can result in hypovitaminosis A in confined
beef cattle.
Ruminants on Pasture
Primary vitamin A deficiency occurs in beef cattle and sheep on dry range pasture
during periods of drought. Clinical vitamin A deficiency does not always occur under
these conditions because hepatic storage is usually good and the period of deprivation
not sufficiently long for these stores to reach a critically low level. Young sheep
grazing natural, drought-stricken pasture can suffer serious depletion of reserves
of the vitamin in 5 to 8 months, but normal growth is maintained for 1 year at which
time clinical signs develop. Adult sheep may be on a deficient diet for 18 months
before hepatic stores are depleted and the disease becomes evident. Cattle may subsist
on naturally deficient diets for 5 to 18 months before clinical signs appear. However,
during the annual dry season (October to June), herds of cattle, sheep, and goats
in the Sahelian region of West Africa are managed on dry grasses and shrubby ligneous
plants, which fail to provide maintenance levels of crude protein and vitamin A. These
substandard conditions result in vitamin A deficiency characterized by night blindness,
xerophthalmia, retarded growth rates, reproductive failures, and increased mortality.
The pastoral herders associate the cure of night blindness with the consumption of
green vegetation and will purposefully herd livestock into green vegetation areas
when available. Certain ethnic groups of pastoral herders depend on ruminant milk
as their principal source of vitamin A, and night blindness in lactating and pregnant
women as well as in young children appears after the onset of night blindness in their
cattle and sheep during the latter half of the dry season. Therefore increasing vitamin
A levels in the milk of cows may alleviate the clinical signs of vitamin A deficiency
in herder families.
Primary vitamin A deficiency is still relatively common in beef cattle that depend
on pasture and roughage for the major portion of their diet. Beef calves coming off
dry summer pastures at 6 to 8 months of age are commonly marginally deficient.
Maternal Deficiency
A maternal deficiency of vitamin A can result in herd outbreaks of congenital hypovitaminosis
A in calves. In one such occurrence, out of 240 heifers fed a vitamin A–deficient
ration, 89 calves were born dead and 47 were born alive but blind and weak and died
within 1 to 3 days after birth. Blindness with dilated pupils, nystagmus, weakness,
and incoordination were characteristic. In another occurrence in the UK, 25% of the
calves born from maternally vitamin A–deficient heifer dams had ocular abnormalities.
The status of the dam is reflected in the status of the fetus only in certain circumstances
because carotene, as it occurs in green feed, does not pass the placental barrier,
and a high intake of green pasture before parturition does not increase the hepatic
stores of vitamin A in newborn calves, lambs, or kids and only to a limited extent
in pigs. However, vitamin A in the ester form, as it occurs in fish oils, will pass
the placental barrier in cows. Feeding of these oils, or the parenteral administration
of a vitamin A injectable preparation before parturition, will cause an increase in
stores of the vitamin in fetal livers. Antepartum feeding of carotene and the alcohol
form of the vitamin does, however, cause an increase in the vitamin A content of the
colostrum. Young animals depend on the dam's colostrum for their early requirements
of the vitamin, which is always highest in colostrum and returns to normal levels
within a few days of parturition. Pigs weaned very early at 2 to 4 weeks may require
special supplementation. Pregnant beef cows wintered on poor-quality roughage commonly
need supplementation with vitamin A throughout the winter months to ensure normal
development of the fetus and an adequate supply of the vitamin in the colostrum at
parturition.
Adequacy of Supplements
The addition of vitamin A supplements to diets may not always be sufficient to prevent
deficiency. Carotene and vitamin A are readily oxidized, particularly in the presence
of unsaturated fatty acids. Oily preparations are thus less satisfactory than dry
or aqueous preparations, particularly if the feed is to be stored for any length of
time. Pelleting of feed may also cause a serious loss up to 32% of the vitamin A in
the original feedstuff.
Heat, light, and mineral mixes are known to increase the rate of destruction of vitamin
A supplements in commercial rations. In one study, 47% to 92% of the vitamin A in
several mineral supplements was destroyed after 1 week of exposure to the trace minerals,
high relative humidity, sunlight, and warm temperatures.
Feedlot Cattle
The disease still occurs in feedlot cattle in some parts of North America when feedlot
cattle are fed rations low in carotene or vitamin A over a period of several months.
The onset of clinical signs in growing feedlot cattle is typically seen 6 to 12 months
after feeding a diet deficient in carotene or vitamin A. Small farm feedlots may feed
their cattle a cereal grain such as barley and barley straw with no vitamin supplementation
or inadequate supplementation. Grains, with the exception of yellow corn, contain
negligible amounts of carotene, and cereal hay is often a poor source. Any hay cut
late, leached by rain, bleached by sun, or stored for long periods loses much of its
carotene content. The carotene content of yellow corn also deteriorates markedly with
long storage. Moreover, under conditions not yet completely understood, the conversion
by ruminants of carotene present in feeds such as silage may be much less complete
than was formerly thought.
In feedlot cattle, the disease is most common in steers fed the same ration as heifers
that may remain clinically normal. It is suggested that sexual dimorphism may be caused
by the production of vitamin A by the corpus luteum of heifers.
Pigs
Young pigs on a deficient diet may show signs after several months, but as in other
animals, the length of time required before signs appear is governed to a large extent
by the status before depletion commences. As a general rule it can be anticipated
that signs will appear in pigs fed deficient rations for 4 to 5 months; variations
from these periods are probably caused by variations in the vitamin A status of the
animal when the deficient diet is introduced. Congenital defects occur in litters
from deficient sows, but the incidence is higher in gilts with the first litter than
in older sows. It is presumed that the hepatic stores of vitamin A in older sows are
not depleted as readily as in young pigs. Feeding white maize bran without supplementation
can result in congenital defects in litters and paralysis in adult pigs.
Horses
Adult horses may remain clinically normal for as long as 3 years on a deficient diet.
Secondary Vitamin A Deficiency
Secondary vitamin A deficiency may occur in cases of chronic disease of the liver
or intestines because much of the conversion of carotene to vitamin A occurs in the
intestinal epithelium and the liver is the main site of storage of the vitamin. Highly
chlorinated naphthalenes interfere with the conversion of carotene to vitamin A, and
animals poisoned with these substances have a very low vitamin A status. The intake
of inorganic phosphorus also affects vitamin A storage, low phosphate diets facilitating
storage of the vitamin. This may have a sparing effect on vitamin A requirements during
drought periods when phosphorus intake is low and an exacerbating effect in stall-fed
cattle on a good grain diet. However, phosphorus deficiency may lower the efficiency
of carotene conversion. Vitamins C and E help to prevent loss of vitamin A in feedstuffs
and during digestion. Additional factors, which may increase the requirement of vitamin
A, include high environmental temperatures and a high nitrate content of the feed,
which reduces the conversion of carotene to vitamin A and rapid rate of gain. Both
a low vitamin A status of the animal and high levels of carotene intake may decrease
the biopotency of ingested carotene.
The continued ingestion of mineral oil, which may occur when the oil is used as a
preventive against bloat in cattle, may cause a depression of plasma carotene and
vitamin A esters and the carotene levels in buffer fat. Deleterious effects on the
cattle are unlikely under the conditions in which it is ordinarily used because of
the short period for which the oil is administered and the high intake of vitamin
A and carotene.
Pathogenesis
Vitamin A is essential for the regeneration of the visual purple necessary for dim-light
vision, for normal bone growth, and for maintenance of normal epithelial tissues.
Deprivation of the vitamin produces effects largely attributable to disturbance of
these functions. The same tissues are affected in all species. However, there is a
difference in tissue and organ response in the different species and particular clinical
signs may occur at different stages of development of the disease. The major pathophysiologic
effects of vitamin A deficiency are as follows.
Night Vision and Ocular Abnormalities
Ability to see in dim light is reduced because of interference with regeneration of
visual purple. Ocular abnormalities occur because of disruption to ocular, retinal,
and optic nerve development from midpregnancy onward.
1
Cerebrospinal Fluid Pressure
An increase in CSF pressure is one of the first abnormalities to occur in hypovitaminosis
A in calves. It is a more sensitive indicator than ocular changes and, in the calf,
it occurs when the vitamin A intake is about twice that needed to prevent night blindness.
The increase in CSF pressure is caused by impaired absorption of the CSF from reduced
tissue permeability of the arachnoid villi and thickening of the connective tissue
matrix of the cerebral dura mater. The increased CSF pressure is responsible for the
syncope and convulsions, which occur in calves in the early stages of vitamin A deficiency.
The syncope and convulsions may occur spontaneously or be precipitated by excitement
and exercise. It is suggested that the CSF pressure is increased in calves with subclinical
deficiency and that exercise further increases the CSF pressure to convulsive levels.
Bone Growth
Vitamin A is necessary to maintain normal position and activity of osteoblasts and
osteoclasts. When deficiency occurs, there is no retardation of endochondral bone
growth, but there is incoordination of bone growth in that shaping, especially the
finer molding of bones, does not proceed normally. In most locations this has little
effect but may cause serious damage to the nervous system. Overcrowding of the cranial
cavity occurs with resulting distortion and herniations of the brain and an increase
in CSF pressure up to four to six times normal. The characteristic nervous signs of
vitamin A deficiency, including papilledema, incoordination, and syncope, follow.
Compression, twisting, and lengthening of the cranial nerves and herniations of the
cerebellum into the foramen magnum, causing weakness and ataxia, and of the spinal
cord into intervertebral foramina results in damage to nerve roots and localizing
signs referable to individual peripheral nerves. Facial paralysis and blindness caused
by constriction of the optic nerve are typical examples of this latter phenomenon.
The effect of excess vitamin A on bone development by its interference with vitamin
D has been discussed elsewhere. Dwarfism in a group of pigs in a swine herd was suspected
to be caused by vitamin toxicosis.
Epithelial Tissues
Vitamin A deficiency leads to atrophy of all epithelial cells, but the important effects
are limited to those types of epithelial tissue with a secretory as well as a covering
function. The secretory cells are without power to divide and develop from undifferentiated
basal epithelium. In vitamin A deficiency these secretory cells are gradually replaced
by the stratified, keratinizing epithelial cells common to nonsecretory epithelial
tissues. This replacement of secretory epithelium by keratinized epithelium occurs
chiefly in the salivary glands, the urogenital tract (including placenta but not ovaries
or renal tubules), and the periocular glands and teeth (disappearance of odontoblasts
from the enamel organ). The secretion of thyroxine is markedly reduced. The mucosa
of the stomach is not markedly affected. These changes in epithelium lead to the clinical
signs of placental degeneration, xerophthalmia, and corneal changes.
Experimental vitamin A deficiency in lambs results in changes in the epithelium of
the small intestine characterized by vesicular microvillar degeneration and disruption
of the capillary endothelium. Diarrhea did not occur.
Embryologic Development
Vitamin A is essential for organ formation during growth of the fetus. Multiple congenital
defects occur in pigs and rats and congenital hydrocephalus in rabbits on maternal
diets deficient in vitamin A. In pigs, administration of the vitamin to depleted sows
before the 17th day of gestation prevented the development of eye lesions but administration
on the 18th day failed to do so. A maternal deficiency of vitamin A in cattle can
result in congenital hypovitaminosis A in the calves, characterized by blindness with
dilated pupils, nystagmus, weakness, and incoordination. Constriction of the optic
canal with thickening of the dura mater results in ischemic necrosis of the optic
nerve and optic disc edema resulting in blindness. Retinal dysplasia also occurs.
Thickening of the occipital and sphenoid bones and doming of the frontal and parietal
bones with compression of the brain also occur. Dilated lateral ventricles may be
present and associated with increased CSF pressure.
Immune Mechanisms
The effects of vitamin A and β-carotene on host defense mechanisms have been uncertain
and controversial for many years. Some workers claim that the incidence and severity
of bacterial, viral, rickettsial, and parasitic infections are higher in vitamin A–deficient
animals. It is possible that vitamin A and β-carotene afford protection against infections
by influencing both specific and nonspecific host defense mechanisms. The protective
effect of vitamin A may be mediated by enhanced polymorphonuclear neutrophil function,
but this effect is also influenced by the physiologic status of the animal such as
lactation status in dairy cattle. Experimentally, a severe vitamin A deficiency in
lambs is associated with alterations in immune function, but the exact mechanism is
unknown.
Clinical Findings
Similar syndromes occur in all species, but because of species differences in tissue
and organ response, some variations are observed. The major clinical findings are
set out in the following sections.
Night Blindness
Inability to see in dim light (twilight or moonlit night) is the earliest sign in
all species, except in the pig, in which it is not evident until plasma vitamin A
levels are very low. This is an important diagnostic sign.
Xerophthalmia
True xerophthalmia, with thickening and clouding of the cornea, occurs only in the
calf. In other species, a thin, serous mucoid discharge from the eyes occurs, followed
by corneal keratinization, clouding and sometimes ulceration, and photophobia.
Ocular Abnormalities
A range of ocular deformities, including cataract formation, lens luxation, microphthalmia,
and reduction in the size of the optic nerve head, occurred in calves with low serum
vitamin A and E concentrations (Fig. 14-14
).
1
Mean vitamin A concentration was 0.47 µmol/L (reference range 0.87 to 1.75 µmol/L)
and the mean vitamin E concentrations was 2.28 µmol/L (reference range 3.0 to 18 µmol/L).
Fig. 14-14
Lens dislocation (A) and ocular rupture (B) in Simmental calves with hypovitaminosis
A.
Fig. 14-14
(Reproduced with permission from Anon. Vet Rec 2014;174:244.)
Changes in the Skin
A rough, dry coat with a shaggy appearance and splitting of the bristle tips in pigs
is characteristic, but excessive keratinization, such as occurs in cattle poisoned
with chlorinated naphthalenes, does not occur under natural conditions of vitamin
A deficiency. Heavy deposits of branlike scales on the skin are seen in affected cattle.
Skin disease occurs in Angus calves (~8 months of age) with vitamin A deficiency and
is characterized by alopecia, severe epidermal and follicular orthokeratosis, and
acanthosis. Affected animals responded to vitamin A supplementation.
2
Dry, scaly hooves with multiple, vertical cracks are another manifestation of skin
changes and are particularly noticeable in horses.
A seborrheic dermatitis can be observed in deficient pigs but is not specific to vitamin
A deficiency.
Body Weight
Under natural conditions, a simple deficiency of vitamin A is unlikely to occur and
the emaciation commonly attributed to vitamin A deficiency may be largely caused by
multiple deficiencies of protein and energy. Although inappetence, weakness, stunted
growth, and emaciation occur under experimental conditions of severe deficiency, in
field outbreaks severe clinical signs of vitamin A deficiency are often seen in animals
in good condition. Experimentally, sheep maintain their BW under extreme deficiency
conditions and with very low plasma vitamin A levels.
Reproductive Efficiency
Loss of reproductive function is one of the major causes of loss in vitamin A deficiency.
Both the male and female are affected. In the male, libido is retained but degeneration
of the germinative epithelium of the seminiferous tubules causes reduction in the
number of motile, normal spermatozoa produced. In young rams, the testicles may be
visibly smaller than normal. In the female, conception is usually not interfered with,
but placental degeneration leads to abortion and the birth of dead or weak young.
Placental retention is common.
Dairy ewes on a diet low in vitamin A have increased somatic cell counts, possibly
indicating a predisposition to mastitis in animals with hypovitaminosis A.
3
Nervous System
Signs related to damage of the nervous system include the following:
•
Paralysis of skeletal muscles caused by damage of peripheral nerve roots
•
Encephalopathy caused by increased intracranial pressure
•
Blindness caused by constriction of the optic nerve canal
These defects occur at any age but are most common in young, growing animals; they
have been observed in all species except horses.
Paralysis
The paralytic form is manifested by abnormalities of gait caused by weakness and incoordination.
The hindlegs are usually affected first and the forelimbs later. In pigs, there may
be stiffness of the legs, initially with a stilted gait or flaccidity, knuckling of
the fetlocks and sagging of the hindquarters. Complete limb paralysis occurs terminally.
Convulsions
Encephalopathy, associated with an increase in CSF pressure, is manifested by convulsions,
which are common in beef calves at 6 to 8 months, usually following removal from a
dry summer pasture at weaning time. Spontaneously, or following exercise or handling,
affected calves will collapse (syncope) and during lateral recumbency a clonic-tonic
convulsion will occur, lasting for 10 to 30 seconds. Death may occur during the convulsion
or the animal will survive the convulsion and lie quietly for several minutes, as
if paralyzed, before another convulsion may occur. Affected calves are usually not
blind and the menace reflex may be slightly impaired or hyperactive. Some calves are
hyperesthetic to touch and sound. During the convulsion there is usually ventroflexion
of the head and neck, sometimes opisthotonus and, commonly, tetanic closure of the
eyelids and retraction of the eyeballs. Outbreaks of this form of hypovitaminosis
A in calves have occurred and the case–fatality rate may reach 25%. The prognosis
is usually excellent; treatment will effect a cure in 48 hours, but convulsions may
continue for up to 48 hours following treatment.
Seizures and acute death attributable to hypovitaminosis A and D have occurred in
feeder pigs fed ground red wheat and whole milk and housed in a barn with no exposure
to sunlight. Lethargy, inappetence, diarrhea, and vomiting and progression to convulsions
were characteristic.
Blindness
The ocular form of hypovitaminosis A occurs usually in yearling cattle (12–18 months
old) and up to 2 to 3 years of age. These animals have usually been on marginally
deficient rations for several months. Night blindness may or may not have been noticed
by the owner. The cattle have usually been fed and housed for long periods in familiar
surroundings and the clinical signs of night blindness may have been subtle and not
noticeable. A computer-based algorithm for using pupillary light reflex responses
to detect cattle with incipient visual loss or mild impairment of vision caused by
hypovitaminosis A was not effective in detecting affected cattle.
4
The first sign of the ocular form of the disease is blindness in both eyes during
daylight. Both pupils are widely dilated and fixed and will not respond to light.
Optic disc edema may be prominent and there may be some loss of the usual brilliant
color of the tapetum. Varying degrees of peripapillary retinal detachment, papillary
and peripapillary retinal hemorrhages, and disruption of the retinal pigment epithelium
may also be present. The menace reflex is usually totally absent, but the palpebral
and corneal reflexes are present. The animal is aware of its surroundings and usually
eats and drinks, unless placed in unfamiliar surroundings. The CSF pressure is increased
in these animals, but not as high as in the calves described earlier. Convulsions
may occur in these cattle if forced to walk or if loaded onto a vehicle for transportation.
The prognosis for the ocular form with blindness is unfavorable and treatment is ineffective
because of the degeneration of the optic nerves. Exophthalmos and excessive lacrimation
are present in some cases.
Congenital Defects
Congenital defects have been observed in piglets and calves. In piglets, complete
absence of the eyes (anophthalmos) or small eyes (microphthalmos), incomplete closure
of the fetal optic fissure, degenerative changes in the lens and retina, and an abnormal
proliferation of mesenchymal tissue in front of and behind the lens are some of the
defects encountered.
Ocular abnormalities in newborn calves from maternally vitamin A–deficient heifers
included corneal dermoid, microphthalmos, aphakia (absence of lens) and in some cases,
both eyes covered by haired skin.
5
Cardiac defects, including ventricular septal defect and overriding aorta, are reported
in a limited number of cases of calves with hypovitaminosis A, but the relationship
is unclear.
5
Other congenital defects attributed to vitamin A deficiency in pigs include cleft
palate and harelip, accessory ears, malformed hindlegs, subcutaneous cysts, abnormally
situated kidneys, cardiac defects, diaphragmatic hernia, aplasia of the genitalia,
internal hydrocephalus, herniations of the spinal cord, and generalized edema. Affected
pigs may be stillborn, or weak and unable to stand, or may be quite active. Weak pigs
lie on their sides, make slow paddling movements with their legs, and squawk plaintively.
Other Diseases
Increased susceptibility to infection is often stated to result from vitamin A deficiency.
The efficacy of colostrum as a preventive against diarrhea in calves was originally
attributed to its vitamin A content, but the high antibody content of colostrum is
most important.
Anasarca.
Edema of the limbs and brisket has been associated with vitamin A deficiency in feedlot
cattle, especially steers. The pathogenesis is not understood. The edema can be extensive,
include all four limbs, ventral body wall, and extend to the scrotum. Heifers were
unaffected.
Clinical Pathology
Plasma Vitamin A
Vitamin A levels in the plasma are used extensively in diagnostic and experimental
work. Plasma levels of 20 µg/dL are the minimal concentration for vitamin A adequacy.
Papilledema is an early sign of vitamin A deficiency, which develops before nyctalopia
and at plasma levels below 18 µg/dL. Normal serum vitamin A concentrations in cattle
range from 25 to 60 µg/dL. In pigs, levels of 11.0 µg/dL have been recorded in clinical
cases, with normal levels being 23 to 29 µg/dL. In experimental vitamin A deficiency
in lambs, serum levels declined to 6.8 µg/dL (normal lambs at 45.1 µg/dL).
The clinical signs may correlate with the serum concentrations of vitamin A. In one
outbreak, feedlot cattle with serum concentrations between 8.89 and 18.05 µg/dL had
only lost BW, those between 4.87 and 8.88 µg/dL had varying degrees of ataxia and
blindness, and those below 4.88 µg/dL had convulsions and optic nerve constriction.
Clinical signs can be expected when the levels fall to 5 µg/dL. For complete safety,
optimum levels should be 25 µg/dL or above.
Plasma Retinol
Some information on the plasma retinol values in stabled Thoroughbred horses is available.
The mean plasma level of retinol in 71 horses 2 to 3 years of age was 16.5 µg/dL.
The serum retinol levels in racing Trotters in Finland are lower than during the summer
months, which is a reflection of the quality of the diets.
Plasma Carotene
Plasma carotene levels vary largely with the diet. In cattle, levels of 150 µg/dL
are optimum and, in the absence of supplementary vitamin A in the ration, clinical
signs appear when the levels fall to 9 µg/dL. In sheep, carotene is present in the
blood in only very small amounts even when animals are on green pasture.
Hepatic Vitamin A
A direct relationship between plasma and hepatic levels of vitamin A need not exist
because plasma levels do not commence to fall until the hepatic stores are depleted.
A temporary precipitate fall occurs at parturition and in acute infections in most
animals. The secretion of large amounts of carotene and vitamin A in the colostrum
of cows during the last 3 weeks of pregnancy may greatly reduce the level of vitamin
A in the plasma.
Hepatic levels of vitamin A and carotene can be estimated in the living animal from
a biopsy specimen. Biopsy techniques have been shown to be safe and relatively easy,
provided a proper instrument is used. Hepatic levels of vitamin A and carotene should
be of the order of 60 and 4.0 µg/g of liver, respectively. These levels are commonly
as high as 200 to 800 µg/g. Critical levels at which signs are likely to appear are
2 and 0.5 µg/g for vitamin A and carotene, respectively.
Cerebrospinal Fluid
CSF pressure is also used as a sensitive indicator of low vitamin A status. In calves,
normal pressures of less than 100 mm of saline rise after depletion to more than 200 mm.
In pigs, normal pressures of 80 to 145 mm rise to above 200 mm in vitamin A deficiency.
An increase in pressure is observed at a blood level of about 7 µg vitamin A per deciliter
of plasma in this species. In sheep, normal pressures of 55 to 65 mm rise to 70 to
150 mm when depletion occurs. In the experimentally induced disease in cattle, there
is a marked increase in the number of cornified epithelial cells in a conjunctival
smear and distinctive bleaching of the tapetum lucidum as viewed by an ophthalmoscope.
These features may have value as diagnostic aids in naturally occurring cases.
Necropsy Findings
Gross changes are rarely observed at necropsy. Careful dissection may reveal a decrease
in the size of the cranial vault and of the vertebrae. Compression and injury of the
cranial and spinal nerve roots, especially the optic nerve, may be visible. In outbreaks
in which night blindness is the primary clinical sign, atrophy of the photoreceptor
layer of the retina is evident histologically, but there are no gross lesions.
Congenital ocular abnormalities in newborn calves from vitamin A–deficient heifer
dams included aphakia, absence of a uveal tract and aqueous humor, microphthalmos,
bony outgrowths of the occipital bone, compression of the cerebellum, and cardiac
abnormalities similar to the tetralogy of Fallot.
Squamous metaplasia of the interlobular ducts of the parotid salivary gland is strongly
suggestive of vitamin A deficiency in pigs, calves, and lambs, but the change is transient
and may have disappeared 2 to 4 weeks after the intake of vitamin A is increased.
This microscopic change is most marked and occurs first, at the oral end of the main
parotid duct. Abnormal epithelial cell differentiation may also be observed histologically
in a variety of other sites such as the tracheal, esophageal, and ruminal mucosae;
preputial lining; pancreatic ducts; and urinary epithelium. Hypovitaminosis A has
also been associated with an increased incidence of pituitary cysts in cattle. Secondary
bacterial infections, including pneumonia and otitis media, are also common, due at
least in part to the decreased barrier function of the lining epithelia.
The abnormalities that occur in congenitally affected pigs have already been described.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Toxicology: 50 g liver, 500 g feed ASSAY (Vit A)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed parotid salivary gland (including duct), rumen, pituitary,
pancreas, brain (including optic nerves), cervical spinal cord (including nerve roots);
Bouin's fixed eye (LM).
Differential Diagnosis
When the characteristic clinical findings of vitamin A deficiency are observed, a
deficiency of the vitamin should be suspected if green feed or vitamin A supplements
are not being provided. The detection of papilledema and testing for night blindness
are the easiest methods of diagnosing early vitamin A deficiency in ruminants. Incoordination,
paralysis, and convulsions are the early signs in pigs. Increase in CSF pressure is
the earliest measurable change in both pigs and calves. Laboratory confirmation depends
on estimations of vitamin A in plasma and liver, with the latter being most satisfactory.
Unless the disease has been in existence for a considerable time, response to treatment
is rapid. For confirmation at necropsy, histologic examination of parotid salivary
gland and assay of vitamin A in the liver are suggested.
The salient features of the differential diagnosis of diseases of the nervous system
of cattle are summarized in Table 14-12.
Cattle
Convulsive form of vitamin A deficiency in cattle must be differentiated from the
following:
•
Polioencephalomalacia: characterized by sudden onset of blindness, head-pressing,
and tonic-clonic convulsions, usually in grain-fed animals but also in pastured animals
ingesting an excess of sulfate in water and grass
•
Hypomagnesemic tetany: primarily in lactating dairy cattle on pasture during cool
windy weather; characterized by hyperesthesia, champing tonic-clonic convulsions,
normal eyesight and tachycardia, and loud heart sounds
•
Lead poisoning: in all age groups, but most commonly in pastured calves in the spring;
characterized by blindness, tonic-clonic convulsions, champing of the jaw, head-pressing,
and rapid death
•
Rabies: in all age groups; characterized by bizarre mental behavior, gradually progressive
ascending paralysis with ataxia leading to recumbency, drooling saliva, inability
to swallow, normal eyesight, and death in 4–7 days.
Ocular form of vitamin A deficiency in cattle must be differentiated from those diseases
of cattle characterized by central or peripheral blindness:
•
Central blindness:
Polioencephalomalacia
Lead poisoning
Meningoencephalitis
•
Peripheral blindness:
Bilateral ophthalmitis caused by ocular disease
Loss of body condition in cattle, failure to grow, and poor reproductive efficiency
are general clinical findings not limited to vitamin A deficiency.
Pigs
Convulsive form of vitamin A deficiency in pigs must be differentiated from the following:
•
Salt poisoning
•
Pseudorabies
•
Viral encephalomyelitis
•
Organic arsenic poisoning.
Paralytic form of vitamin A deficiency in pigs must be differentiated from the following:
•
Spinal cord compression caused by vertebral body abscess.
Congenital defects similar to those caused by vitamin A deficiency may be caused by
deficiencies of other essential nutrients, by inheritance or by viral infections in
early pregnancy in all species. Maternal vitamin A deficiency is the most common cause
of congenital defects in piglets. Final diagnosis depends on the necropsy findings,
analysis of feed and serum vitamin A of the dams.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Vitamin A
Animals with curable vitamin A deficiency should be treated immediately with vitamin
A at a dose rate equivalent to 10 to 20 times the daily maintenance requirement. As
a rule, 440 IU/kg BW is the dose used. Parenteral injection of an aqueous rather than
an oily solution is preferred. The response to treatment in severe cases is often
rapid and complete, but the disease may be irreversible in chronic cases. Calves with
the convulsive form caused by increased CSF pressure will usually return to normal
in 48 hours following treatment. Cattle with the ocular form of the deficiency and
that are blind will not respond to treatment and should be slaughtered for salvage.
Hypervitaminosis A
Daily heavy dosing (about 100 times normal) of calves causes reduced growth rate,
lameness, ataxia, paresis, exostoses on the planter aspect of the third phalanx of
the fourth digit of all feet, and disappearance of the epiphyseal cartilage. Persistent
heavy dosing in calves causes lameness, retarded horn growth, and depressed CSF pressure.
At necropsy, exostoses are present on the proximal metacarpal bones and the frontal
bones are thin. Very high levels fed to young pigs may cause sudden death through
massive internal hemorrhage and excessive doses during early pregnancy are reputed
to result in fetal anomalies. However, feeding vitamin A for prolonged periods at
exceptionally high levels is unlikely to produce severe embryotoxic or teratogenic
effects in pigs.
Control
Dietary Requirement
The minimum daily requirement in all species is 40 IU of vitamin A per kilogram BW,
which is a guideline for maintenance requirements. In the formulation of practical
diets for all species, the daily allowances of vitamin A are commonly increased by
50% to 100% of the daily minimum requirements. During pregnancy, lactation, or rapid
growth the allowances are usually increased by 50% to 75% of the requirements. The
supplementation of diets to groups of animals is governed also by their previous intake
of the vitamin and its probable level in the diet being fed. The rate of supplementation
can vary from 0 to 110 IU/kg BW per day (1 IU of vitamin A is equivalent in activity
to 0.3 µg of retinol; 5 to 8 µg β-carotene has the same activity as 1 µg of retinol).
Nutrient studies have indicated that preruminant Holstein calves being fed milk replacer
should receive 11,000 IU of vitamin A per kilogram dry matter for optimum growth and
to maintain adequate liver vitamin A stores.
The amounts of the vitamin to be added to the ration of each species to meet the requirements
for all purposes should be obtained from published recommended nutrient requirements
of domestic animals. Some examples of daily allowances of vitamin A for farm animals
are set out in Table 14-17
.
Table 14-17
Daily dietary allowances of vitamin A
Table 14-17
Animal
Vitamin A (IU/kg BW daily)
Cattle
Growing calves
40
Weaned beef calves at 6–8 months
40
Calves 6 months to yearlings
40
Maintenance and pregnancy
70–80
Maintenance and lactation
80
Feedlot cattle on high energy ration
80
Sheep
Growth and early pregnancy and fattening lambs
30–40
Late pregnancy and lactation
70–80
Horses
Working horse
20–30
Growing horse
40
Pregnant mare
50
Lactating mare
50
Pigs
Growing pigs
40–50
Pregnant gilts and sows
40–50
Lactating gilts and sows
70–80
Supplementation Method
The method of supplementation will vary depending on the class of livestock and the
ease with which the vitamin can be given. In pigs, the vitamin is incorporated directly
into the complete ration, usually through the protein supplement. In feedlot and dairy
cattle receiving complete feeds, the addition of vitamin A to the diet is simple.
In beef cattle, which may be fed primarily on carotene-deficient roughage during pregnancy,
it may not be possible to supplement the diet on a daily basis. However, it may be
possible to provide a concentrated dietary source of vitamin A on a regular basis
by feeding a protein supplement once weekly. The protein supplement will contain 10
to 15 times the daily allowance, which permits hepatic storage of the vitamin.
Parenteral Injection
An alternative method to dietary supplementation is the intramuscular injection of
vitamin A at intervals of 50 to 60 days at the rate of 3,000 to 6,000 IU/kg BW. Under
most conditions, hepatic storage is good and optimum plasma and hepatic levels of
vitamin A are maintained for up to 50 to 60 days. In pregnant beef cattle the last
injection should not be more than 40 to 50 days before parturition to ensure adequate
levels of vitamin A in the colostrum. Ideally, the last injection should be given
30 days before parturition, but this may not be practical under some management conditions.
Administration of vitamin A palmitate by intramuscular injection (3500 IU/kg BW) increased
plasma vitamin A concentrations by 24 hours and these elevated concentrations persisted
for at least 8 days.
6
The effect of a single administration of vitamin A on liver vitamin A concentrations,
the biologic reservoir for the vitamin, was not determined.
The most economical method of supplementing vitamin A is, in most cases, through the
feed and when possible should be used.
The use of injectable mixtures of vitamins A, D, and E is not always justifiable.
The injection of a mixture of vitamins A, D, and E of feeder cattle in northern Australia
before transport did not, contrary to anecdotal evidence, reduce weight loss associated
with transportation. Cattle in Queensland and northwestern Australia have very high
concentrations of hepatic vitamin A and in fact, drought-stricken cattle in the terminal
stages of malnutrition have also had high liver concentration. The indiscriminate
use of vitamin A preparations in cattle is a public health concern because some bovine
livers may contain high levels of vitamin A, which are potentially teratogenic for
pregnant women.
Oral Vitamin A
The oral administration of a single bolus of vitamin A at a dose of 2.8 mg/kg BW to
debilitated Sahelian cattle during the dry season was effective in raising the milk
levels of vitamin A and was as effective as adding 10 g of the powder to the drinking
water. Both the powder and bolus products provided high levels of vitamin A in milk
within 3 days of treatment and according to herder testimonials, night-blind people
consuming milk from cattle previously treated with either oral vitamin A preparation
were no longer affected with night blindness.
References
1
Anon
Vet Rec
174
2014
244
24736821
2
Baldwin
TJ
J Vet Diagn Invest
24
2012
763
22585959
3
Koutsoumpas
AT
Small Rumin Res
110
2013
120
4
Han
S
Comput Electron Agric
108
2014
80
5
Millemann
Y
Vet Rec
160
2007
441
17400904
6
Koutsoumpas
AT
Small Rumin Res
109
2013
28
Nicotinic Acid Deficiency (Hyponiacinosis)
Nicotinic acid or niacin is essential for normal carbohydrate metabolism. Because
of the high content in most natural animal feeds, deficiency states are rare in ordinary
circumstances, except in pigs fed rations high in corn. Corn has both a low niacin
content and a low content of tryptophan, which is a niacin precursor. A low-protein
intake exacerbates the effects of the deficiency, but a high-protein intake is not
fully protective.
In ruminants, synthesis within the animal provides an adequate source. Even in young
calves, signs of deficiency do not occur, and because rumen microfloral activity is
not yet of any magnitude, extraruminal synthesis appears probable. There are preliminary
indications that dietary supplementation with niacin alters muscle fiber composition
(increased type 1 (oxidative) versus type 2) in pigs and sheep.1, 2
The oral supplementation of niacin in the diet of periparturient dairy cows may result
in an increase in serum inorganic phosphorus and a decrease in serum potassium, calcium,
and sodium concentrations. Niacin has been used to study the effects of artificially
induced ketonemia and hypoglycemia in cattle through inducing changes in nonesterified
fatty acid concentrations.
3
The daily requirements of niacin for mature pigs are 0.1 to 0.4 mg/kg BW, but growing
pigs appear to require more (0.6–1 mg/kg BW) for optimum growth.
Experimentally induced nicotinic acid deficiency in pigs is characterized by inappetence,
severe diarrhea, a dirty yellow skin, with a severe scabby dermatitis and alopecia.
Posterior paralysis also occurs. At necropsy, hemorrhages in the gastric and duodenal
walls, congestion and swelling of the small intestinal mucosa, and ulcers in the large
intestine are characteristic and closely resemble those of necrotic enteritis caused
by infection with Salmonella spp.
Histologically, there is severe mucoid degeneration followed by local necrosis in
the wall of the cecum and colon. Experimental production of the disease in pigs by
the administration of an antimetabolite to nicotinamide causes ataxia or quadriplegia,
accompanied by distinctive lesions in the gray matter of the cervical and lumbar enlargements
of the ventral horn of the spinal cord. The lesions are malacic and occur in the intermediate
zone of the gray matter. The identical lesions and clinical picture have been observed
in naturally occurring disease.
The oral therapeutic dose rate of nicotinic acid in pigs is 100 to 200 mg; 10 to 20 g/tonne
of feed supplies have sufficient nicotinic acid for pigs of all ages. Niacin is low
in price and should always be added to pig rations based on corn.
References
1
Khan
M
Acta Vet Scand
55
2013
85
24267720
2
Khan
M
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
177
24010567
3
Pires
JAA
J Dairy Sci
90
2007
3725
17638983
Pyridoxine (Vitamin B6) Deficiency (Hypopyridoxinosis)
A deficiency of pyridoxine in the diet is not known to occur under natural conditions.
Experimental deficiency in pigs is characterized by periodic epileptiform convulsions
and at necropsy by generalized hemosiderosis with a microcytic anemia, hyperplasia
of the bone marrow, and fatty infiltration of the liver. Less severe deficiency impairs
weight gain and alters biochemical markers of sulfur-containing amino acid metabolism.
1
The daily requirement of pyridoxine in the pig is of the order of 100 µg/kg BW or
1 mg/kg of solid food, although higher levels have been recommended on occasion. Certain
strains of chickens have a high requirement for pyridoxine and the same may be true
of pigs.
Experimentally induced deficiency in calves is characterized by anorexia, poor growth,
apathy, dull coat, and alopecia. Severe, fatal epileptiform seizures occur in some
animals. Anemia with poikilocytosis is characteristic of this deficiency in cows and
calves.
Reference
1
Zhang
Z
Animal
3
2009
826
22444769
Pantothenic Acid Deficiency (Hypopantothenosis)
PA is essential in metabolism because of its incorporation into coenzyme A and acyl
carrier protein, both of which are central to energy metabolism. PA is ubiquitous
in fodder, in addition to which microorganisms in the rumen synthesize the compound.
1
However, it is not clear if synthesis meets the requirements of dairy cows. The role
of PA in ruminant nutrition is reviewed.
1
Deficiency under natural conditions has been recorded mainly in pigs on rations based
on corn.
In pigs, a decrease in weight gain caused by anorexia and inefficient food utilization
occurs first. Dermatitis develops with a dark brown exudate collecting about the eyes
and there is a patchy alopecia. Diarrhea and incoordination with a spastic, goose-stepping
gait are characteristic. At necropsy, a severe, sometimes ulcerative, colitis is observed
constantly, together with degeneration of myelin.
Calcium pantothenate (500 µg/kg BW/day) is effective in treatment and prevention.
As a feed additive, 10 to 12 g/tonne of calcium pantothenate is adequate.
Experimentally induced PA deficiency in calves is manifested by rough hair coat, dermatitis
under the lower jaw, excessive nasal mucus, anorexia and reduced growth rate, and
is eventually fatal. At necropsy, there is usually a secondary pneumonia, demyelination
in the spinal cord and peripheral nerves, and softening and congestion of the cerebrum.
Reference
1
Ragaller
V
J Anim Physiol Nutr
95
2011
6
Metabolic and Toxic Encephalomyelopathies
A number of metabolic defects and a very large number of poisons, especially poisonous
plants and farm chemicals, cause abnormalities of function of the nervous system.
Those plants that cause degenerative nervous system disease are listed under the section
Encephalomalacia; those that cause no detectable degenerative change in tissue are
listed here. More detailed information on toxins that are primary neurotoxins are
addressed in this chapter based on the predominant neuroanatomic location affected.
This section includes those toxins that do not have a predilection for a specific
neuroanatomic location.
An incomplete list of metabolic abnormalities and toxins that can cause nervous system
dysfunction are as follows.
Abnormalities of Consciousness and Behavior
•
Hypoglycemia and ketonemia of pregnancy toxemia (with degenerative lesions in some)
and acetonemia
•
Depression caused by hyponatremia and strong ion (metabolic) acidosis associated with
diarrhea and dehydration, particularly in neonatal animals
•
Hypomagnesemia of lactation tetany
•
Hyper-d-lactatemia in neonatal calves, lambs, and kids and adult ruminants with grain
overload
•
Primary hyperammonemia and hepatic encephalopathy1, 2
•
Unspecified toxic substances in uremic animals
•
Exogenous toxins, including carbon tetrachloride, hexachloroethane, and trichloroethylene
•
Plants causing anemic and histotoxic hypoxia, especially plants causing cyanide or
nitrite poisoning
•
Poison plants, including Helichrysum spp., tansy mustard, male fern, kikuyu grass
(or a fungus, Myrothecium sp. on the grass)
Abnormality Characterized by Tremor and Ataxia
•
Weeds, including Conium spp. (hemlock), Eupatorium spp. (snakeroot), Sarcostemma spp.,
Euphorbia spp. and Karwinskia spp.
•
Ivermectin toxicosis in horses
3
•
Bacterial toxins in shaker foal syndrome (probably)
•
Fungal toxins, e.g., Neotyphodium (Acremonium) lolii, the endophyte fungus of ryegrass
staggers
Convulsions
•
Metabolic deficits, including hypoglycemia (piglets, ewes with pregnancy toxemia),
hypomagnesemia (of whole milk tetany of calves, lactation tetany, cows and mares),
hypernatremia
•
Nutritional deficiencies of vitamin A (brain compression in calves and pigs), pyridoxine
(experimentally in calves)
•
Inorganic poisons, including lead (calves),
4
mercury (calves), farm chemicals such as organic arsenicals (pigs), organophosphates,
chlorinated hydrocarbons, strychnine, urea, metaldehyde
•
Bacterial toxins, including C. tetani, C. perfringens type D
•
Fungal toxins, e.g., C. purpurea
•
Grasses, including Wimmera ryegrass (Lolium rigidum) or the nematode on it, Echinopogon
ovatus
•
Pasture legumes: lupines
•
Weeds: Oenanthe spp. (hemlock water dropwort), Indigofera spp. (in horses), Cicuta
spp. (water hemlock), Albizia tanganyicensis, Sarcostemma spp., Euphorbia spp.
•
Trees: laburnum, oleander, supplejack (Ventilago spp.)
Ataxia Apparently Caused by Proprioceptive Defect
•
Grasses: Phalaris tuberosa (aquatica) (and other Phalaris spp.), Lolium rigidum, E.
ovatus
•
Weeds: Romulea bulbocodium, sneezeweed (Helenium spp.), Indigofera spp., Iceland poppy
(Papaver nudicaule), Gomphrena spp., Malva spp., Stachys spp., Ipomoea spp., Solanum
esuriale
•
Trees: Kalmia spp., Erythrophloeum spp., Eupatorium rugosum
•
Ferns: Xanthorrhoea spp., Zamia spp.; induced thiamine deficiency caused by bracken
and horsetail poisoning
Involuntary Spastic Contraction of Large Muscle Masses
This includes, for example, acquired (Australian) equine reflex hypertonia (formerly
known as Australian stringhalt) associated with ingestion of the Australian dandelion
Hypochaeris radicata, European dandelion Taraxacum officinale, or mallow Malva parviflora).
Tremor, Incoordination, and Convulsions
There is an additional long list of plants that cause diarrhea and nervous signs,
especially ataxia, together, but whether the latter are caused by the former or caused
by neurotoxins is not identified.
The nervous signs include tremor, incoordination, and convulsions.
Paresis or Paralysis
Many of the toxic substances and metabolic defects listed previously cause paresis
when their influence is mild and paralysis when it is severe. Some of the items appear
in both lists. Because an agent appears in one list and not the other list is not
meant to suggest that the agent does not cause the other effect. It is more likely
that it occurs in circumstances that are almost always conducive to the development
of a mild syndrome (or a severe one, as the case may be).
•
Disturbance of function at neuromuscular junctions, e.g., hypocalcemia, hypomagnesemia,
hypokalemia (as in downer cows), tetanus, botulism and hypoglycemia of pregnancy toxemia
in cows and ewes, and tick paralysis. Hypophosphatemia has not been demonstrated to
be a definitive cause of weakness in cattle.
•
Nutritional deficiency, but including only experimentally induced deficiency of nicotinic
and PAs: biotin and choline, cause posterior paresis and paralysis in pigs and calves.
•
Toxic diseases of the nervous system, including disease associated with many chemicals
used in agriculture, e.g., piperazine, rotenone, 2,4-d and 2,4,5-T, organophosphates,
carbamates, chlorinated hydrocarbons, propylene glycol, metaldehyde, levamisole, toluene,
carbon tetrachloride, strychnine, and nicotine sulfate.
Further Reading
Dawson
DR
Toxins and adverse drug reactions affecting the equine nervous system
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
507
526
22100042
Divers
TJ
Metabolic causes of encephalopathy in horses
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
589
596
22100046
Finnie
JW
Windsor
PA
Kessell
AE
Neurological diseases of ruminant livestock in Australia. II: toxic disorders and
nutritional deficiencies
Aust Vet J
89
2011
247
253
References
1
Hughes
KJ
Vet Rec
164
2009
142
19188345
2
Pillitteri
CA
Craig
LE
Vet Pathol
50
2012
177
22492209
3
Swor
TM
J Am Vet Med Assoc
235
2009
558
19719447
4
Krametter-Froetscher
R
Vet J
174
2007
99
16753317
Inherited Diseases Primarily Affecting the Cerebrum
Inherited Congenital Hyrdocephalus
Hydrocephalus is the distention of the ventricular system of the brain, caused by
increased production of CSF by the choroid plexus, obstruction of normal CSF flow,
or decreased absorption of CSF at the arachnoid villi in the venous sinuses.
1
Cattle
Congenital hydrocephalus without abnormality of the frontal bones occurs sporadically
but is also known to be an inherited defect in Holstein and Hereford and possibly
in Ayrshire and Charolais cattle. Two specific inherited entities have been described.
In one there is obstruction of drainage of the CSF from the lateral ventricles, which
become distended with fluid and may cause bulging of the forehead, often sufficient
to cause fetal dystocia. Hereford calves with this defect have partial occlusion of
the supraorbital foramen, a domed skull, and poorly developed teeth; at necropsy the
cerebellum is found to be small and there may be microphthalmia and skeletal muscle
myopathy. They are usually born a few days prematurely, are small in size, and are
unable to stand or suck. In some cows the amniotic fluid is increased in volume.
Another form of inherited hydrocephalus caused by malformation of the cranium and
with no enlargement of the cranium has also been observed in Hereford cattle. The
ventricular dilatation is not marked, and microphthalmia and cerebellar hypoplasia
are not features. Affected calves may be alive at birth but are blind and unable to
stand. Some bawl continuously and some are dumb. They do not usually survive for more
than a few days. At necropsy there is internal hydrocephalus of the lateral ventricles
with marked thinning of the overlying cerebrum. Other lesions include constriction
of the optic nerve, detachment of the retina, cataract, coagulation of the vitreous
humor, and a progressive muscular dystrophy. The condition is inherited as a recessive
character.
Internal hydrocephalus inherited in combination with multiple eye defects in White
Shorthorns is dealt with elsewhere, as are noninherited forms of the disease.
Sheep
A defect comparable to the Dandy–Walker syndrome in humans and characterized by internal
hydrocephalus caused by obstruction of the foramina of Magendie and Lushka occurs
in several breeds of sheep, especially Suffolk, and in cattle. Affected lambs are
stillborn or die within a few hours of birth; because of the grossly enlarged cranium
many cause dystocia, which can only be relieved by a fetotomy.
Horses
A Standardbred stallion sired a number of hydrocephalic foals in a pattern that suggested
the inheritance of a dominant mutation in the germline and in the form of a single
locus defect. Affected foals caused dystocia and were all stillborn. There is one
report of an unsuccessful outcome following placement of ventriculoperitoneal shunt
in an attempt to manage hydrocephalus in a Quarter Horse colt.
2
Hydrocephalus has been observed more commonly in Friesian horses than other breeds.
Affected foals have a malformed petrosal bone, which causes a narrowing of the jugular
foramen.
1
Hydrocephalus in Friesian foals is thought to be caused by diminished absorption of
CSF into the systemic circulation at the venous sinus because of the abnormally small
jugular foramen. This type of hydrocephalus has been genetically linked in humans
and dogs to chondrodysplasia.
1
Pigs
Congenital hydrocephalus in Yorkshire and European pigs has been recorded. The abnormality
varies from a small protrusion of dura (meningocele) to an extensive brain hernia
in which the cerebral hemispheres protrude through the frontal suture, apparently
forced there by increased fluid pressure in the lateral and third ventricles. The
condition is thought to be inherited in a recessive manner, but exacerbated in its
manifestation by a coexisting hypovitaminosis A. An outbreak of congenital meningoencephalocele
in Landrace pigs is recorded in circumstances suggesting that it was inherited.
References
1
Sipma
KD
Vet Pathol
50
2013
1037
23676552
2
Bentz
BG
Moll
HD
J Vet Emerg Crit Care
18
2008
170
Inherited Hydranencephaly and Arthrogryposis
The defect is recorded in Corriedale sheep, and breeding trials indicate that it is
inherited as an autosomal recessive character. Most affected lambs are found dead
but facial deformity, including shortening of the mandible and distortion of the facial
bones will be evident. At necropsy the predominant finding is the fixation and deformity
of the joints of the limbs and vertebral column, and the almost complete absence of
a cerebral cortex.
Inherited Prosencephaly
Recorded in Border Leicester sheep, this defect takes the form of fusion of the cerebral
hemispheres and a single lateral ventricle. It is widespread in the breed in Australia
and is inherited as an autosomal recessive character. Most affected lambs are stillborn.
Live ones have dyspnea caused by gross shortening of the nasomaxillary region creating
a severely overshot mandible and interference with sucking. Blindness, nystagmus,
and recumbency are constant signs. The cerebrum and the cranial cavity are much smaller
than normal.
Inherited Multifocal Symmetric Encephalopathy
Two forms of the disease are recorded, in Simmental and in Limousin and Limousin-cross
cattle. The Limousin calves are normal at birth but from about 1 month of age develop
a progressive forelimb hypermetria, hyperesthesia, blindness, nystagmus, weight loss,
and behavioral abnormalities, especially aggression. The signs gradually worsen for
up to 4 months when euthanasia is necessary. Necropsy lesions include brain swelling;
optic chiasma necrosis; and multifocal, symmetric areas of pallor, up to 0.5 cm diameter
in the brain. These lesions show partial cavitation and multiple, pathologic abnormalities,
especially myelin lysis and vacuolation and demyelination. The distribution of cases
suggests an inherited defect.
The disease in Simmental and Simmental-cross cattle recorded in Australia and New
Zealand also has a distribution suggesting an inherited defect. The disease is clinically
similar to that in Limousin cattle except that affected animals are not blind and
it develops later at 5 to 8 months. Calves may survive longer, up to 12 months and,
although the characteristic abnormality of gait is hypermetria, the hindlimbs are
affected, not the forelimbs. Other signs observed are dullness, a swaying gait and,
terminally, gradually developing opisthotonus and forelimb hypertonia in extension.
Necropsy lesions are also similar to those in the Limousins, but the distribution
is in the midbrain and the entire brainstem.
A multifocal symmetric necrotizing encephalomyelopathy in Angus calves has been described.
Clinically affected calves exhibited ataxia, nystagmus, strabismus, muscular tremors,
opisthotonus, bruxism, hyperesthesia, tetanic spasms, and episodic convulsions at
2 to 6 weeks of age. Death occurred 4 to 7 days after the onset of clinical signs.
Lesions consisted of symmetric degenerative foci affecting the dorsal vagal motor,
lateral cuneate, and olivary nuclei in the medulla oblongata, and occasionally in
the spinal cord, substantia nigra, and cerebellar peduncles. Although an inherited
basis for the disease is suspected, the etiology is unknown.
Maple Syrup Urine Disease (Branched-Chain Keto Acid Dehydrogenase Deficiency)
Calves affected by this disease may be stillborn. Live calves are normal at birth
and develop signs only at 1 to 3 days of age. It is inherited as an autosomal recessive
and occurs principally in Poll Hereford, Hereford, and Poll Shorthorn cattle but probably
also occurs in other breeds. There is molecular heterogeneity between the breeds,
and tests based on detection of the mutation could be prone to error. Hair roots are
good sources of target DNA for genotyping cattle for the mutation in one of the genes
coding for the branched-chain α-keto acid dehydrogenase enzyme. This avoids the errors
created by hemopoietic chimerism when blood is used for the test.
The disease is caused by an accumulation of branched-chain amino acids, including
valine, leucine, and isoleucine. The mutation responsible for maple syrup urine disease
in Poll Shorthorns and genotyping Poll Shorthorns and Poll Herefords for the maple
syrup urine disease alleles has been determined. The mutations responsible for maple
syrup urine disease and inherited congenital myoclonus are present in the Australian
Poll Hereford population.
Clinical signs include dullness, recumbency, tremor, tetanic spasms and opisthotonus,
a scruffy coat, blindness, and severe hyperthermia. When held in a standing position,
some calves have tetanic paralysis and others have flaccid paralysis. Terminal coma
is followed by death after a course of 48 to 72 hours. The urine smells of burnt sugar
(because of the presence of branched-chain amino acids), and this smell is the source
of the name.
1
At necropsy there is a characteristic severe spongiform encephalopathy similar to
that found in comparable hereditary aminoacidurias in humans.
1
Final identification can be made based on the elevated ratios of branched : straight
chain amino acids in nervous tissue.
Reference
1
O'Toole
D
J Vet Diagn Invest
17
2005
546
16475512
Inherited Citrullinemia
This autosomal recessive disease is inherited in Australian Holstein Friesians, American
Holstein Friesians, and Red Holstein Friesians in Europe.
Affected calves are normal at birth but develop signs in the first week of life and
die 6 to 12 hours after the onset of illness. The signs are depression, compulsive
walking, blindness, head-pressing, tremor, hyperthermia, recumbency, opisthotonus,
and convulsions. Argininosuccinate synthetase deficiency is the likely cause. Blood
citrulline levels are of the order of 40 to 1200 times normal, and the assay can be
used to detect heterozygotes. The alternative method of detecting heterozygotes is
to use a PCR test, which RE test designed to identify the mutation that causes the
disease. Prenatal diagnosis has been achieved by examination of cell cultures derived
from amniotic fluid.
Inherited Neonatal Spasticity
The defect is recorded in Jersey and Hereford cattle. Affected calves are normal at
birth but develop signs 2 to 5 days later. The signs commence with incoordination
and bulging of the eyes and a tendency to deviation of the neck causing the head to
be held on one side. Subsequently, the calves are unable to stand and on stimulation
develop a tetanic convulsion in which the neck, trunk, and limbs are rigidly extended
and show marked tremor. Each convulsion is of several minutes' duration. Affected
calves may survive for as long as a month if nursed carefully. There are no gross
or histologic lesions at necropsy. Inheritance of the defect is conditioned by a single,
recessive character.
Doddler Calves
This is an inherited congenital defect in Hereford cattle produced by intensive breeding
of half-siblings, and it is no longer recorded. It was characterized by continuous
clonic convulsions, nystagmus, and pupillary dilatation. Stimulation by touch or sound
exacerbated the convulsions.
Inherited Idiopathic Epilepsy of Cattle
Idiopathic epilepsy has been reported as an inherited condition in Brown Swiss cattle
and appears to be inherited as a dominant character. Typical epileptiform convulsions
occur, especially when the animals become excited or are exercised. Attacks do not
usually commence until the calves are several months old and disappear entirely between
the ages of 1 and 2 years.
Familial Narcolepsy
Affected horses, including Lipizzaners,
1
Shetlands, Miniature Horses, Icelandic foals, and Suffolk foals, suffer recurrent
episodes of several minutes' duration during which they fall and lie motionless, without
voluntary or involuntary movements except respiratory and eye movements. Between episodes
there is no clinical abnormality. Handling or the excitement of feeding may precipitate
an attack, and a sharp blow may terminate one.
A genetic cause is suspected in horses based on the occurrence of the disease in three
fillies born to the same sire.
1
A physostigmine provocation test (0.06 mg/kg BW intravenously) has been used, and
a positive result is a cataplectic attack or clinical worsening of the sleepiness
over the following hour. The genetic basis has not been confirmed in horses but is
suspected to be an autosomal dominant trait with incomplete penetrance.
1
Further Reading
Mignot
EJM
Dement
WC
Narcolepsy in animals and man
Equine J
25
1993
476
Reference
1
Ludvikova
E
Vet Q
32
2012
99
22889297
Congenital and Inherited Encephalomyelopathies
Inherited Lysosomal Storage Diseases
These are diseases in which there is a genetically determined deficiency of a specific
lysosomal hydrolase enzyme causing a defective degradation of carbohydrates, proteins,
and lipids within lysosomes. These diseases are currently grouped into glycoproteinoses,
mucopolysaccharidoses, sphingolipidoses, and mucopolysaccharidoses. Enzyme deficiencies
associated with lysosomal storage diseases in agricultural animals include α-mannosidase,
β-mannosidase, GM1 gangliosidosis, GM2 gangliosidosis,1, 2 β-glucocerebrosidase (Gaucher
disease),
3
α-N-acetylglucosaminidase (NAGLU),
4
acid-sphingomyelinase (Niemann–Pick disease),
5
and an incompletely characterized form.6, 7 The lysosomes themselves are concerned
with hydrolyzing polymeric material, which enters the vacuolar system, and converting
it to monomeric units, such as monosaccharides, amino acids, and nucleotides, which
can be dealt with by the better known metabolic processes. As a result of the deficiency,
upstream metabolic substrates accumulate in the lysosomes and downstream metabolites
are markedly reduced.
Lysosomal storage diseases can also be caused by poisonings, and these are addressed
elsewhere in this chapter. The best known ones are caused by poisoning with Swainsona,
8
Astragalus, Oxytropis, and Ipomoea spp.9, 10, 11, 12, Side spp.
13
, and Phalaris spp. (the chronic form of that disease).
The diseases included in this section are not strictly diseases of the nervous system
because the lysosomes in both neuronal and visceral sites are affected, but the effects
of the disease are most obvious in terms of nervous system function.
Mannosidosis
Mannosidosis is the best known group of the inherited lysosomal storage diseases in
agricultural animals.
α-Mannosidosis
This is a lysosomal storage disease in which a deficiency of the enzyme α-mannosidase
results in the accumulation of a metabolite rich in mannose and glucosamine in secondary
lysosomes in neurons, macrophages, and reticuloendothelial cells of lymph nodes, causing
apparent vacuolations in these cells. Similar vacuoles are found in exocrine cells
in pancreas, abomasum, and lacrimal and salivary glands. Storage appears to be cumulative
in the fetus, but after birth stored material is lost from the kidney into the urine
via desquamated tubular epithelium. On the other hand, postnatal storage continues
in the brain, pancreas, and lymph nodes. The disease occurs in Angus, Murray Grey,
and Galloway cattle, is inherited as a simple recessive, and is recorded as occurring
in the United States, Australia, and New Zealand.
Clinically it is characterized by ataxia, fine lateral head tremor, slow vertical
nodding of the head, intention tremor, an aggressive tendency, failure to thrive,
and death or the necessity of euthanasia at about 6 months of age. These signs appear
almost immediately after birth up to several months later and worsen over a period
of up to 3 to 4 months. The signs are bad enough to require euthanasia during the
first week of life in many cases. The first sign observed is a swaying of the hindquarters,
especially after exercise or with excitement. The stance becomes wide based and the
gait jerky, stilted and high stepping, with slight overflexion of the hindquarters
so that the animal appears to be squatting as it moves.
The nervous signs are exacerbated by excitement, diarrhea is common, and the calves
are usually stunted and unthrifty. They are also aggressive and attempt to charge
but are usually impeded by their incoordination. Many calves die after having shown
general ill-thrift and with minimal nervous signs. Death may occur from paralysis
and starvation, or to misadventure, and some calves appear to die during a “fit” following
a period of excitement. Many others are euthanized because of persistent recumbency.
The nervous syndrome of mannosidosis is well known; affected calves will die. An α-mannosidosis
is recorded in Galloway cattle and is manifested by stillbirth, moderate hydrocephalus,
enlargement of the liver and kidneys, and arthrogryposis.
Normal heterozygotes carrying genes for mannosidosis are identifiable because of their
reduced tissue or plasma levels of α-mannosidase. The mannosidase test for α-mannosidase
in goats is specific and does not cross-react with α-mannosidase.
Advances in molecular biology have now led to the development of a more accurate test
based on DNA technology. DNA tests based on the PCR have been developed for the detection
of two breed-specific mutations responsible α-mannosidosis. One of the mutations is
responsible for α-mannosidosis in Galloway cattle. The other mutation is uniquely
associated with α-mannosidosis in Angus, Murray Grey, and Brangus cattle from Australia.
The latter mutation was also detected in Red Angus cattle exported from Canada to
Australia as embryos. The two breed-specific mutations may have arisen in Scotland
and by the export of animals and germplasm disseminated to North America, New Zealand,
and Australia.
A control program can be based on the identification of heterozygotes using PCR-based
assays for detection of breed-specific mutations. A program of screening cattle in
herds that produce bulls for sale to commercial herds should stop the spread of the
disease very quickly, because the number of heterozygous females in the population
will be irrelevant to the continuation of the disease in the absence of affected sires.
The α-mannosidosis gene prevalence is now insignificant and disease incidence has
been reduced from an estimated 3000 cases/year to negligible levels.
β-Mannosidosis
β-Mannosidosis occurs in Salers cattle and Anglo-Nubian goats and has been recorded
in a sheep. In cattle, some affected calves are stillborn. The remainder of calves
are euthanized forthwith because of the severity of the congenital defects.
Calves are affected at birth with craniofacial deformity and inability to stand. The
cranium is domed and there is mild prognathism; narrow palpebral fissures; and a tough,
hidebound skin. When in sternal recumbency, the head is moved in a combined motion
of circling and bobbing, eventually converting the calf to lateral recumbency, in
which it remains until passively returned to the sternal position, where nystagmus
and tremor become evident. There is no suck reflex at any time. In lateral recumbency
there is opisthotonus and paddling convulsions.
In the goats the condition is present at birth and characterized clinically by tetraplegia,
tremor, deafness, and nystagmus, and an inexorably fatal termination. Additional signs
include bilateral Horner's syndrome, carpal contractures, pastern joint hyperextension,
thickened skin, and a dome-shaped skull. Although retinal ganglion cells are badly
affected, there appears to be no defect of vision. It is an autosomal recessive defect
that is very similar to α-mannosidosis.
The diagnosis is confirmed by a reduced level of β-mannosidase in the blood.
Necropsy findings include a deficiency of cerebral cortical and cerebellar substance,
distended lateral ventricles, and bilateral renomegaly. The biochemical defect is
one of acidic β-mannosidase, and is conditioned by an autosomal recessive character.
The carrier rate of the causative gene is very high in the Salers breed.
References
1
Porter
BF
Vet Pathol
48
2011
807
21123862
2
Torres
PA
Mol Genet Metab
101
2010
357
20817517
3
Karageorgos
L
J Inherit Metab Dis
34
2011
209
20978939
4
Karageorgos
L
J Inherit Metab Dis
30
2007
358
17458708
5
Saunders
GK
Wenger
DA
Vet Pathol
45
2008
201
18424834
6
Mikami
O
J Vet Med A Physiol Pathol Clin Med
53
2006
77
16466460
7
Masoudi
AA
Anim Sci J
80
2009
611
20163628
8
Dantas
AFM
Toxicon
49
2007
111
17030054
9
Barbosa
RC
Toxicon
47
2006
371
16488457
10
Armien
AG
Vet Pathol
44
2007
170
17317794
11
Mendonca
D
Acta Vet Brno
80
2011
235
12
Armien
AG
J Vet Diagn Invest
23
2011
221
21398440
13
Furlan
FH
Vet Pathol
46
2009
343
19261649
Gangliosidosis
At least five types of gangliosidosis are known to occur in humans and animals. Two
(GM1 and GM2 gangliosidosis) have thus far been identified in agricultural animals.
GM1 Gangliosidosis
GM1 gangliosidosis occurs in cattle and sheep. In Friesian cattle it is inherited
as a lysosomal storage disease in which the activity of an enzyme, β-galactosidase,
in nervous tissue is greatly reduced. As a result, there is an accumulation of the
ganglioside (GM1) in the tissue. Clinical signs of progressive neuromotor dysfunction
and a reduction in growth rate appear at about 3 months of age. The growth rate is
reduced, and the animal is in poor condition, blind, and has a staring coat. The neuromotor
signs include lack of response to external stimuli, sluggish mastication and swallowing,
hindquarter sway while walking, a wide stance, a tendency to fall, reluctance to move,
stiff high-stepping gait, aimless walking, head-pressing, and convulsions. Abnormal
electrocardiogram (ECG) tracings are common. The blindness results from lesions in
the retina and the optic nerve. Ophthalmoscopic examination of the retina is recommended
as an aid to diagnosis. A positive diagnosis is made on the grounds of intraneuronal
lipid storage plus reduced β-galactosidase activity plus identification of the stored
lipid. The stored ganglioside is visible under the electron microscope as stacks and
concentric whorls of lamellae. In the live animal enzyme assays are performed on leukocytes.
The enzymatic defect is also detectable in liver, skin, and leukocytes.
GM1 gangliosidosis is also present in Suffolk and Suffolk-cross sheep. Visceral and
neuronal lysosomal storage are both evident but the neuronal lesion is more severe.
Deficiencies of β-galactosidase and α-neuraminidase are evident. Affected sheep become
ataxic at 4 to 6 months old and worsen to recumbency and death in up to 2 months.
GM1 gangliosidosis has been reported from England in “Coopworth Romney” lambs closely
related to a ram imported from New Zealand.
GM2 Gangliosidosis
GM2 gangliosidosis (Tay–Sachs disease) occurs in sheep and pigs and is an autosomal
recessive lysosomal storage disease caused by defects in the genes that code for hexosaminidase.
In Jacob sheep, progressive accumulation of GM2 ganglioside results in in cortical
blindness, proprioceptive deficits, and ataxia in all four limbs within 6 to 8 months
of birth.1, 2
GM2 gangliosidosis has also been identified in Yorkshire pigs and also causes decreased
growth rate, incoordination appearing after 3 months of age, gray-white spots in the
retina and dark blue granules in neutrophils, and azurophilic granules in lymphocytes.
A serum enzyme assay is a suitable method of detecting “carrier” heterozygous pigs.
The test is based on the amount of N-acetyl-β-d-hexosaminidase in tissues.
References
1
Porter
BF
Vet Pathol
48
2011
807
21123862
2
Torres
PA
Mol Genet Metab
101
2010
357
20817517
Gaucher Disease Type 2
Gaucher disease is an autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disease caused by mutations
in the β-glucocerebrosidase gene. Gaucher disease is the most common lysosomal storage
disorder in humans and is divided into three subtypes based on the level of neurologic
involvement and clinical signs: (1) type 1, nonneuronopathic; (2) type 2, acute neuronopathic;
and (3) type 3 (subacute neuronopathic).
1
Type 2 Gaucher disease has been reported in Southdown sheep in Victoria, Australia.
1
Affected lambs were unable to stand and exhibited continued shaking and shivering.
Lambs could be bottle-fed but their neurologic status did not improve. Affected lambs
also had a thickened leathery skin in the abdominal and cervical regions. Glucocerebrosidase
activity was markedly reduced in leukocytes and cultured skin fibroblasts and glucocerebrosidase
content was increased in the brain, liver, and blood.
Reference
1
Karageorgos
L
J Inherit Metab Dis
34
2011
209
20978939
Bovine Mucopolysaccharidosis Type IIIB
Mucopolysaccharidosis IIIB is an autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disease caused
by mutations in the NAGLU gene. NAGLU is intimately involved with the degradation
of heparin sulfate in lysosomes; gene mutations therefore result in intralysosomal
storage of heparin sulfate.
Mucopolysaccharidosis IIIB has been reported in cattle in Queensland, Australia.
1
Animals were normal at weaning at 6 to 8 months of age; clinical signs developed progressively
from 12 months onward and included loss of herding instinct, aimless wandering, tendency
to stand alone, becoming very placid and sedate in nature, and development of excessively
hairy ears. Animals survived to 3 to 5 years of age, and terminally developed progressive
ataxia, a stumbling gait, and excessive weight loss.
Reference
1
Karageorgos
L
J Inherit Metab Dis
30
2007
358
17458708
Sphingomyelinase Deficiency (Niemann–Pick Disease Type a) in Cattle
Sphingomyelinase deficiency (Niemann–Pick disease) is a lysosomal storage disease
caused by mutations in the sphingomyelinase gene and is described as three forms in
humans: type A (early onset of neurologic disease in infancy), B, and C. Sphingomyelinase
is involved with catalyzing the conversion of sphingomyelin to ceramide and phosphorylcholine.
Sphingomyelinase deficiency (type A) has been diagnosed in a 5-month-old Hereford
calf in Virginia.
1
The calf had a 4-week history of abnormal and progressive neurologic signs, including
hypermetria, wide-based stance, ataxia, and positional strabismus.
Reference
1
Saunders
GK
Wenger
DA
Vet Pathol
45
2008
201
18424834
Globoid Cell Leukodystrophy (Galactocerebrosidosis)
Globoid cell leukodystrophy has been identified in Poll Dorset sheep in Australia.
Incoordination in the hindlimbs progresses until the animals are tetraplegic. Only
histologic changes are evident at necropsy. These include myelin destruction and the
accumulation of characteristic globoid cells in nervous tissue. There is greatly decreased
galactocerebrosidase activity in affected tissue.
Inherited Nervous System Abiotrophies
These diseases are characterized by premature, progressive loss of functionally related
and discrete populations of neurons. As a result, most affected animals are born normal
but develop signs of a progressive neurologic disease that is either fatal or leads
to such a serious neurologic deficit that euthanasia is the only reasonable solution.
In a few rare diseases the patient is abnormal at birth but worsens, and usually dies,
during the neonatal period. Again there are exceptions, and in rare cases complete
recovery has been reported. The genetic nature of some of the cases included may not
be certain; they are included here if the evidence that they are inherited can be
reasonably presumed. An important distinction is that abiotrophy implies premature
aging, which is different from degeneration, which is a term that implies an extrinsic
etiology. From a clinical perspective nervous system degeneration can appear identical
to nervous system abiotrophy, and a firm diagnosis of abiotrophy usually requires
histologic examination unless the species, breed, or availability of specific diagnostic
tests permits antemortem diagnosis of abiotrophy. At the moment the abiotrophic diseases
cannot be treated. The lysosomal storage diseases, listed in the preceding section,
represent a specific group of abiotrophic diseases.
Further Reading
Siso
S
Hanzlicek
D
Fluehmann
G
Neurodegenerative diseases in domestic animals: a comparative review
Vet J
171
2006
20
38
16427580
Neuronal Ceroid Lipofuscinosis
The neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses are a group of inherited neurodegenerative lysosomal
storage diseases of humans and other animals, inherited as autosomal recessive traits.
They are grouped together because of common clinical and pathologic phenomena related
to brain and retinal atrophy, premature death, and accumulation of a fluorescent lipopigment
in neurons and many other cell types within the body. Molecular genetic studies have
identified mutations in eight different genes (CLN1, CLN2, CLN3, CLN5, CLN6, CLN6,
CLN8, and CTSD) that can result in neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses.1, 2, 3, 4
The disease is recorded in Devon cattle,
1
South Hampshire sheep,2, 3, 4 Rambouillet sheep, Borderdale sheep,
5
Merino sheep, Nubian goats, and Vietnamese pot-bellied pigs.
6
It resembles neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis of humans and is not strictly a primary
lysosomal disorder; it is classified as a proteolipid proteinosis, and provides a
good animal model for discussing the similar disease (Batten disease) of humans. Secondary
lysosomes in animals with neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses fill with subunit c of mitochondrial
ATP synthase because of excessive peroxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids. The
mechanism of the accumulation is that protein is formed, which is normal for mitochondria,
but is misdirected so that it accumulates in the lysosome. The disease in Devon cattle
is caused by a single base duplication in the bovine CLN5 gene.
1
The disease in Merino sheep is a subunit c–storing abnormality, clinically and pathologically
similar to ceroid lipofuscinosis in South Hampshire sheep, which is caused by a missense
mutation in the ovine CLN6 gene.2, 3 The disease in Borderdale sheep is caused by
a nucleotide substitution in the ovine CLN5 gene.
5
The occurrence of neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis in South Hampshire and Borderdale
sheep in New Zealand have been well described. The severity of neurodegeneration and
minor differences in the ultrastructure of storage material suggests this is a different
disease from other forms of ovine ceroid lipofuscinosis, which accumulate the subunit
c of mitochondrial ATP synthase. An autosomal recessive mode of inheritance is considered
probable.
Clinical findings include slowly progressive ataxia of the hindlimbs, commencing usually
at about 4 months but possibly as late as 18 months of age, and lasting for 6 months
leading to euthanasia at up to 4 years. Inability to keep up with the flock is noticed
first, followed by a sawhorse stance, obvious ataxia, severe depression, and an increasing
failure of the menace and pupillary light reflexes. Terminal blindness is a constant
sign. Positional nystagmus, circling, and head-pressing occur in some. Eating, drinking,
and defecation are normal, but there is slight weight loss. A blood test has been
developed to detect the genetic mutation in South Hampshire sheep.
2
CSF is altered in sheep with advanced diseased, characterized by increased lactate,
acetate, and tyrosine concentrations and decreased myo-inositol and scyllo-inositol
and citrate concentrations.
3
The lesion in lambs and calves is atrophy of the cerebrum, especially the optic cortex,
with eosinophilic granulation of neurons and macrophages in the CNS followed by progressive
retinal atrophy. There is a progressive storage of lipopigment in nervous tissue,
especially retinal photoreceptors; its presence can be demonstrated by quantitative
autofluorescence using a modified slit lamp microscope. Other clinicopathologic aids
include lysosomal enzyme assay, organ biopsy, and CT, which reveals the enlargement
of the lateral ventricles of the brain resulting from cerebral atrophy.
Neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis has been described in three horses. Clinically, there
was developmental retardation, slow movements, and loss of appetite at 6 months of
age. Torticollis, ataxia, head tilt, and loss of eyesight were present at 1 year of
age. There were abnormalities in posture and movements, decreased spinal reflexes,
and some CN dysfunction, dorsal strabismus, and absence of the menace reflex. At necropsy,
there was flattening of the gyri and discoloration of the brain. Histologically, eosinophilic,
autofluorescent material in the perikarya of neurons was present throughout the brain,
spinal cord, neurons of the retina, submucosa, and myenteric ganglia and in glial
cells.
Neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis has been described in a 2-year-old Vietnamese pot-bellied
pig.
6
Ataxia had progressed to tetraparesis over a 3-month period, with terminal development
of a head tilt and intermittent nystagmus. The pig did not appear to be blind.
References
1
Houweling
PJ
Biochimi Biophys Acta
1762
2006
890
2
Tammen
I
Biochim Biophys Acta
1762
2006
898
17046213
3
Pears
MR
J Neurosci Res
85
2007
3494
17510975
4
Kay
GW
Neurobiol Dis
41
2011
614
21111820
5
Frugier
T
Neurobiol Dis
29
2008
306
17988881
6
Cesta
MF
Vet Pathol
43
2006
556
16847000
Congenital Necrotizing Encephalopathy in Lambs
This condition, defined by its pathology, was a common diagnosis of neurologic disease
in lambs under 7 days of age by the Veterinary Laboratories Agency in the north of
England.
1
Affected flocks had single or multiple cases, with up to 10% morbidity of lambs in
a flock. All cases came from ewes carrying multiple fetuses, but there is variation
in the clinical signs of sibling lambs. The most severely affected may be stillborn,
with less severely affected lambs born weak, small, and unable to rise with ataxia
and head tremor. Some lambs survive but may have residual signs of cerebellar dysfunction.
The common lesion is superficial cerebrocortical neuronal necrosis. A significant
proportion also has necrosis of the Purkinje cells in the cerebellum and leukoencephalopathy
of the thalamus and brainstem. It is possible that this syndrome reflects hypoglycemia
consequent to negative energy balance in late pregnancy.
Reference
1
Scholes
SFE
Vet Rec
160
2007
775
Lavender Foal Syndrome
Lavender foal syndrome is a congenital, inherited, autosomal recessive disease of
Egyptian Arab foals characterized by signs of neurologic disease evident at birth
and unusual dilute coat color.
1
The disease is caused by a mutation in the MYO5A gene that is a single-base deletion
in a conserved region of the tail domain.
2
The deletion produces a truncated protein product through the insertion of a premature
stop codon (p.Arg1487AlafsX13). There is a prevalence of carriers in Egyptian Arabian
horses of 10.3% (heterozygotes),
3
and within Arabs the allele frequency is estimated at 0.0162, with no alleles detected
in Thoroughbred, Standardbred, Morgan, Quarter Horse, or Percheron horses.
4
The carrier prevalence of LFS in Arabian foals in South Africa for the 2009/2010 season
was 11.7% (95% confidence interval [CI] 7.6–17.0%).
5
There is a dilute (lavender) coat color and signs of central neurologic disease including
inability to stand, paddling, opisthotonus, and torticollis with apparently normal
peripheral reflexes (blink to bright light, triceps, patellar, and cutaneous truncal).
1
There are no characteristic hematologic and serum biochemical abnormalities. There
is no effective treatment.
Gross necropsy examination does not reveal any consistent or diagnostic abnormalities
apart from the dilute hair coat. An assay for the genetic mutation is available and
provides confirmation of diagnosis. Testing of Egyptian Arabians enables avoidance
of carrier-to-carrier matings, and thus the disease.
3
References
1
Page
P
J Vet Intern Med
20
2006
1491
17186871
2
Bierman
A
Anim Gen
41
2010
199
3
Brooks
SA
PLoS Genet
6
2010
e000909
4
Gabreski
NA
Anim Gen
43
2012
650
5
Tarr
CJ
Equine Vet J
46
2014
512
24033554
Inherited Hypomyelinogenesis (Congenital Tremor Syndromes of Piglets)
Congenital tremor of pigs has a multiple etiology and some of the causes are not yet
identified. The disease is also known as myoclonia congenita or trembling pig syndrome
or jumpy pig disease. Gilts are particularly affected. The types are shown in Table
14-18
and the features in Table 14-19
. They can only be differentiated by pathology and particularly neurochemistry. The
essential lesion is the same in all cases and is a hypomyelination of the brain and
spinal cord. The infectious forms are discussed elsewhere.
Table 14-18
Diagnostic taxonomy of congenital tremor in pigs
Table 14-18
Cause
AI
AII
AIII
AIV
AV
B
Field observations
Virus hog cholera
Virus unknown
Genetic S-L recessive
Genetic autosomal recessive
Chemical trichlorfon
Unknown
Proportion of litters affected
High
High
Low
Low
High
Variable
Proportion of pigs affected within litter (approximately)
>40%
>80%
25%
25%
>90%
Variable
Mortality among affected pigs
Medium to high
Low
High
High
High
Variable
Sex of affected pigs
Both
Both
Male
Both
Both
Any
Breed of dam (pure or crossbred)
Any
Any
Landrace
Saddleback
Any
Any
Recurrence in successive litters of same parents
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
?
Duration of outbreak
<4 months
<4 months
Indefinite
Indefinite
<1 month
?
Table 14-19
Key features of the six types of congenital tremor described in pigs
Table 14-19
Type
Cause
Key features
A1
Hog Cholera
Dysgenesis
Cerebellar hypoplasia
Small cord
Demyelination
Swollen oligodendrocytes
AII
Congenital tremor virusPCV2
Swollen oligodendrocytes
AIII
Inherited autosomal recessive sex linked in landrace
Reduced oligodendrocytes
Reduced myelination
Hypoplasia of cord
AIV
As previously noted in SaddlebackAlso Landrace/Saddleback cross syndrome
Demyelination
Cerebral, cerebellar and cord hypoplasia
AV
Trichlorfon toxicity
Cerebellar hypoplasia affected 45–79 days' gestation, particularly 75–79
B
Unknown
No special features
There are two inherited forms. One is congenital tremor Type A-III, which is found
in Landrace pigs and Landrace crosses. It is sometimes known as Landrace trembles.
Type A-III is a sex-linked recessive gene carried by the sow. It is associated with
females, high growth rates, lean carcasses, and pale colored meat characterized by
the presence of poorly myelinated axons in all parts of the CNS. It is also known
as congenital cerebrospinal hypomyelinogenesis. The sows produce piglets that have
reduced numbers of oligodendrocytes and therefore cannot myelinate nerve fibers. The
tremor disappears when the piglets are asleep.
The other inherited form is Type A-IV of British Saddleback pigs. It is not common.
The specific defect in A-IV is one of fatty acid metabolism, which results in hypomyelination
and demyelination. (A similar disorder but a monogenic autosomal recessive tremor
has also been described in Saddleback /Large White crosses).
The structural abnormalities in the type A-III disease have been identified; splayleg
is a common accompaniment.
Both diseases are characterized by muscle tremor, incoordination, difficulty in standing,
and some squealing. The A-III disease occurs only in males. Both are inherited as
recessive characteristics.
Further Reading
Harding
DJD
Congenital tremor AIII in pigs, an hereditary sex-linked cerebrospinal myelinogenesis
Vet Rec
92
1973
527
4721939
Kidd
ARM
A-IV A new genetically-determined congenital nervous disorder in pigs
Br Vet J
142
1986
275
3594158
Diseases Primarily Affecting the Cerebellum
Inherited Cerebellar Defects
Several inherited cerebellar defects occur congenitally in calves, lambs, and foals.
Lesions of the cerebellum may or may not be grossly or clinically obvious. They all
need to be differentiated from similar defects known to be caused by intrauterine
viral infections such as swine fever, bovine mucosal disease, and bluetongue.
Cerebellar Hypoplasia
This occurs in Herefords, Guernseys, Holsteins, Shorthorns, and Ayrshires and appears
to be conditioned by a factor inherited in a recessive manner. Most calves are obviously
affected at birth. While lying down, there is no marked abnormality, although a moderate
lateral tremor of the neck occurs, causing a gentle side-to-side swaying of the head.
Severely affected calves are blind; they have widely dilated pupils and their pupils
do not react to light. Such calves are unable to stand, even when assisted, because
of flaccidity of limb muscles. When less severely affected animals attempt to rise,
the head is thrown back excessively, the limb movements are exaggerated in force and
range and are grossly incoordinated, and many calves are unable to rise without assistance.
If they are placed on their feet, the calves adopt a straddle-legged stance with the
feet wide apart and the legs and neck extended excessively. On attempting to move,
limb movements are incoordinated and the calf falls, sometimes backward because of
overextension of the forelimbs. Affected animals drink well but have great difficulty
in getting to the teat or pail, with attempts usually wide of the mark. There are
no defects of consciousness and no convulsions. Tremor may be evident while standing
and there may be postrotational nystagmus after rapid lateral head movements. Sight
and hearing are unimpaired and, although complete recovery does not occur, the calf
may be able to compensate sufficiently to enable it to be reared to a vealing weight.
Diagnosis can be confirmed by MRI.
At necropsy the most severe defect comprises complete absence of the cerebellum; hypoplasia
of the olivary nuclei, the pons, and optic nerves; and partial or complete absence
of the occipital cortex. Less severe defects include a reduction in size of the cerebellum
and absence of some neuronal elements in a cerebellum of normal size.
Although the disease is dealt with generally as an inherited one. There is no firm
evidence to substantiate this view, and there are sporadic, noninherited cases in
other breeds.
Cerebellar Atrophy of Lambs (Daft Lamb Disease 1)
This has been recorded in many sheep breeds in Britain, Corriedales in Canada and
New Zealand, and in Drysdales. Affected lambs are normal at birth but are weak and
unable to rise without assistance. At 3 days of age it is obvious that there is severe
incoordination of limb movement, opisthotonus, tremor, and a straddle-legged stance.
At necropsy the cerebellum may be of normal size but on histologic examination there
is gross atrophy of cerebellar neurons. The disease appears to be conditioned by a
recessive gene but not as a simple homozygous recessive. A clinically similar disease
has been observed in Border Leicester lambs. There is no histopathologic lesion in
the cerebellum, but there are significant lesions in the cervical muscles and the
nerve supply to them. The disease is inherited, most likely as an autosomal recessive
trait.
Star-Gazing Lambs (Daft Lamb Disease 2)
A hereditary disease clinically similar to cerebral cortical atrophy has been described
in newborn Leicester lambs in the UK but without histologic evidence of Purkinje cell
loss, which is considered the hallmark of “cerebellar abiotrophy.” Affected lambs
exhibit “dorsal arching of the neck with the head being pressed backward,” which is
also described as star-gazing. Histologic lesions are present in neck muscles and
nerves, but it is uncertain if these are primary or secondary.
Hereditary Lissencephaly and Cerebellar Hypoplasia in Churra Lambs
Lissencephaly is a very rare developmental intracranial disorder of animals that results
from defects in neuronal migration. The gross result is a very simplified folding
of the cerebrum and cerebellum with the presence of only a few broad gyri.
Lissencephaly and cerebellar hypoplasia have been identified in Churra lambs in Spain.
Affected lambs were abnormal at birth, exhibiting weakness, inability to stand, and
muscular rigidity. The cerebral cortex was disorganized histologically and the cerebellum
was reduced in size. Pedigree analysis indicated a monogenic autosomal pattern of
inheritance.
1
The genetic defect was a 31 base pair deletion in the coding area for the RELN gene,
which plays an important role in neuronal migration and layer formation.
2
The deletion results in formation of a premature termination codon, resulting in the
absence of protein expression.
References
1
Perez
V
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
156
23938146
2
Suarez-Vega
A
PLoS ONE
8
2013
e81072
24260534
Inherited Ataxia of Calves
This is a true cerebellar ataxia inherited as a recessive character in Jerseys, Shorthorns,
and Holsteins. Clinically the condition resembles cerebellar hypoplasia except that
signs may not occur until the calves are a few days to several weeks old. At necropsy
the cerebellum is normal in size but histologically aplasia of neurons is evident
in the cerebellum and also in the thalamus and cerebral cortex. An inherited condition,
manifested by cerebellar ataxia that does not develop until calves are 6 weeks to
5 months old, has also been recorded but the cerebellum is small and macroscopically
abnormal. Conspicuous degeneration of cerebellar Purkinje cells is evident on histologic
examination.
Familial Convulsions and Ataxia in Cattle
A neurologic disease is recorded as being inherited in Aberdeen Angus cattle and their
crossbreeds and Charolais. In young calves there are intermittent attacks of convulsions,
and in older animals these are replaced by a residual ataxia. The first signs appear
within a few hours of birth; up to several months later there are single or multiple
tetanic convulsions lasting for 3 to 12 hours. As these episodes disappear a spastic
goose-stepping gait becomes apparent in the forelimbs and there is difficulty placing
the hindlimbs. The characteristic necropsy lesion is a very selective cerebellar cortical
degeneration. A proportion of cases make a complete recovery. The epidemiology of
the disease is consistent with the operation of an autosomal dominant gene with incomplete
penetrance.
Inherited Congenital Spasms of Cattle
This condition has been recorded only in Jersey cattle and appears to be conditioned
by a factor inherited in a recessive manner. Affected calves show intermittent, vertical
tremor of the head and neck, and there is a similar tremor of all four limbs that
prevents walking and interferes with standing. Although the calves are normal in all
other respects, they usually die within the first few weeks of life. No histologic
examinations have been reported, but a cerebellar lesion seems probable.
Cerebellar Abiotrophy
This disease occurs in Holstein and Poll Hereford cross calves, Aberdeen Angus cattle
and their crossbreds and Charolais cattle, Merino sheep, alpaca,
1
Arabian horses,2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and pigs. The pathologic feature of cerebellar abiotrophy
is disorganization of the Purkinje cells in the granular layer of the cerebellum,
with subsequent disorganization of the molecular and granular layers. The etiology
is thought to be abnormal migration of the Purkinje cells through the cerebellum during
development, resulting in premature neuronal degeneration of Purkinje cells.
4
Cattle
In the calves, ataxia appears for the first time when they are 3 to 8 months old.
The calves are not blind but they often fail to exhibit a menace reflex. The onset
of clinical signs is sudden but progression is slow or inapparent. Some become recumbent.
Those that remain standing have a spastic, dysmetric ataxia and a broad-based stance
and they fall easily and have a fine head tremor. All are strong and have good appetites.
Abiotrophy, or premature aging, is evident only microscopically and consists of axonal
swellings and segmental degeneration and loss of cerebellar Purkinje cells. The disease
appears to be inherited, but recovery of some late cases is recorded.
Familial convulsions and ataxia is characterized as being inherited in Aberdeen Angus
cattle and their crossbreds and Charolais. In young calves there are intermittent
attacks of convulsions, and in older animals these are replaced by a residual ataxia.
The first signs appear within a few hours of birth; up to several months later there
are single or multiple tetanic convulsions lasting for 3 to 12 hours. As these episodes
disappear a spastic goose-stepping gait becomes apparent in the forelimbs and there
is difficulty placing the hindlimbs. The characteristic necropsy lesion is a very
selective degeneration of the cerebellar cortex. A proportion of cases make a complete
recovery. The epidemiology of the disease is consistent with the operation of an autosomal
dominant gene with incomplete penetrance.
Sheep
The disease in sheep does not appear until about 3 years of age. There is incoordination
and dysmetria so that the gait is awkward and disorganized and there is frequent falling.
There are also a reduced menace response, an apprehensive manner, and a wide-based
stance in the hindlimbs. At necropsy there is diffuse cerebellar degeneration and
severe loss of Purkinje cells.
Alpaca
Neurologic abnormalities were first detected at 18 months of age, at which time intention
tremors, hypermetria, and a wide-based stance were evident.
1
CSF analysis was within normal limits and the cerebellum appeared smaller than expected
on CT.
Horses
The disease is recorded principally in Arabian horses but occurs also in the Australian
pony, which was developed from the Arab, and in the Gotland breed from Sweden. A similar
clinical syndrome occurs in the Oldenberg breed, but the pathologic picture is quite
different.
The disease may be present at birth but is often not observed until the foal is 2
to 6 months old with the latest recognition being between 9 and 24 months of age.
The characteristic signs are vertical head-nodding (some cases show horizontal head
tremors), especially when excited, and ataxia, which is most noticeable at a fast
gait. It may not be evident while the foal is walking. Very badly affected foals are
unable to stand or suckle at birth, less severe ones are normal until about 4 months
of age when head-nodding becomes obvious. The degree of ataxia varies from slight
incoordination to inability to stand. A goose-stepping gait, which slams the front
feet into the ground, occurs in some. All foals can see but there is an absence of
the menace reflex in many. Nystagmus is not recorded as occurring in this disease.
The first antemortem confirmatory test to be developed was computer-assisted MRI brain
morphometry, which is used to determine the presence of a relatively smaller cerebellum
and relatively larger cerebellar CSF space compared with size-matched horses.
3
Diagnosis has historically been made on the basis of breed and age of the animal,
clinical signs, slow progression of disease, and elimination of other differential
diagnoses.
2
The recent development of a DNA test on hair roots that detects the presence of the
putative cerebellar abiotrophy gene mutation4, 5, 6 should make antemortem diagnosis
much more straightforward in Arabian horses.
Necropsy findings are limited to histopathologic lesions in the cerebellum. These
include widespread loss of Purkinje cells and the presence of a gliosis. There are
no degenerative lesions in the spinal cord. In the similar disease in Oldenberg horses
the cerebellum is often reduced in size. The disease is an abiotrophy—a premature
aging of tissues.
The disease is inherited as an autosomal recessive trait in Arabian horses.
4
An SNP has been identified in affected Arabian horses and may induce the disease by
decreasing MUTYH expression, which is a DNA glycosylase that removes adenine residues.
5
The frequency of the allele is estimated at approximately 10.5% in the U.S. Arabian
population, which is high.
6
The gene mutation has been identified at a low level in three breeds with Arabian
ancestry (Trakehner; Bashkir Curly Horses, also known as North American Curly horses;
and Welsh ponies).
6
Pigs
A congenital progressive cerebellar abiotrophy is also reported in piglets of the
offspring of Saddleback sows and an unrelated Large White boar. The disorder behaves
epidemiologically like an inherited disease conditioned by a simple autosomal recessive
trait. Clinical signs include dysmetria, ataxia, and tremor at standing but not at
rest. There is gradual adjustment so that the piglets can walk and stand at 5 weeks
of age, but by 15 weeks they are no longer able to do so. Affected pigs also have
a coarse matted hair coat caused by a disproportionate number of coarse hairs to fine
hairs. Histopathologic lesions are confined to the cerebellum in which there is a
significant loss of Purkinje cells.
References
1
Mouser
P
Vet Pathol
46
2009
1133
19605911
2
Foley
A
Equine Vet Educ
23
2011
130
3
Cavalleri
JMV
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
105
23702154
4
Brault
LS
Am J Vet Res
72
2011
940
21728855
5
Brault
LS
Genomics
97
2011
121
21126570
6
Brault
LS
Penedo
MCT
Equine Vet J
43
2011
727
21496100
Diseases Primarily Affecting the Brainstem and Vestibular System
Otitis Media/Interna
Infection of the middle ear (otitis media) occurs in young animals of all species
but especially dairy calves and pigs, to a lesser extent feedlot cattle and lambs,
and rarely foals. The infection may gain entrance from the external ear (e.g., caused
by ear mite infestation) or hematogenously, but the spread is chiefly an ascending
infection of the eustachian tubes in a young animal from a respiratory tract infection.
Extension of infection into the inner ear leads to otitis interna.
Pigs
Otitis media was present in 68% of 237 pigs that were slaughtered because of illness.
It is suggested that otitis media in pigs develops first as an acute inflammation
in the auditory tube and then extends to other parts of the ear and brain. When abscesses
form at the ventrum of the brainstem, the vestibulocochlear nerve is usually involved
in the lesion. Infection in the ear may extend into the brain by following the auditory
nerve. Perilymph filling the scala vestibuli and scala tympani is also a possible
tract for the extension of the infection because there is a communication between
the perilymph-filled spaces of the bony labyrinth and the subarachnoid space.
Calves and Lambs
The highest prevalence is in suckling dairy calves and weaned cattle and sheep in
feedlots where the disease is probably secondary to respiratory tract infection. Outbreaks
of otitis media/interna have occurred in beef calves from 6 to 10 weeks of age on
pasture with their dams; mixed cultures of E. coli, Pseudomonas spp., and Acinetobacter
spp. were isolated. Otitis media/interna in suckling dairy calves can also occur in
outbreaks, and M. bovis is frequently isolated from the middle and inner ears of affected
calves.
The onset of clinical signs commonly includes dullness, fever, inappetence, tachypnea,
and a purulent discharge from the affected ear accompanied by rotation of the head
(in otitis interna) and drooping of the ear a few days later because of involvement
of the facial nerve in the inflammation. Deep palpation at the base of the ears may
elicit a pain response.
Rotation of the head, with the affected side down, and facial paralysis may occur
on the same side, and walking in circles with a tendency to fall to the affected side
is common. In most cases the animals are normal in other respects, although depression
and inappetence can occur in advanced cases (Fig. 14-15
).
Fig. 14-15
Otitis media/interna on the right side of a recently weaned Suffolk sheep. Notice
the marked deviation of the line between the two eyes from horizontal.
Fig. 14-15
Horses
Otitis media/interna occurs in horses, and two clinical syndromes have been described.
The first syndrome is primary otitis media characterized by abnormal behavior, including
head-tossing, head-shaking, and ear-rubbing. Violent, uncontrollable behavior includes
throwing themselves on the ground, rolling, and thrashing. This may progress to involve
the bony structures of the temporal and proximal stylohyoid bones, resulting in a
degenerative arthritis and eventual fusion of the temporohyoid bone.
The second syndrome is characterized by an acute onset of neurologic deficits. Commonly,
there is vestibulocochlear nerve and often facial nerve dysfunction characterized
by head tilt to the side of the lesion, nystagmus with the slow component to the affected
side, and weakness of the extensor muscles on the affected side resulting in an ataxia
or reluctance or refusal to stand. Horses that can stand often will lean on walls
for support of the affected side.
Definitive diagnosis is dependent on either a positive tympanocentesis or, in the
majority of cases, bony proliferation of the temporal bone and proximal part of the
stylohyoid bone, or lysis of the tympanic bulla, as determined by radiography or CT.
Otoscopic examination should be performed to determine whether there is purulent material
in the auditory canal and whether the tympanic membrane is ruptured or bulging outward.
Radiography has been used to diagnose lesions of the tympanic bullae in cattle (otitis
interna), characterized by thickening of the bulla wall, increased soft tissue opacity
within the bulla, and osteolysis of the bulla wall and trabeculations.
1
Radiography is not as sensitive as CT for the diagnosis of otitis media; however,
because CT provides more detailed information regarding the bony structures of the
middle ear2, 3 and is more sensitive and specific than radiography in the diagnosis
of otitis media in calves.
1
CT was used to provide an excellent anatomic description of the external acoustic
meatus, tympanic cavity, and tympanic bulla of the llama.
4
Ultrasonography has also been used to diagnose otitis media in calves.
5
A 7.5-mHz linear probe is applied to the base of the ear without the use of coupling
gel and the calf in a standing position. The probe is applied ventral to the base
of the ear and caudal to the mandible. Abnormalities detected included anechoic to
hyperechoic content; trabeculae lysis; and thinning, deformation, and rupture of the
bulla wall. The lesions can be subtle in early cases and, consequently, test sensitivity
is low in animals with acute or subacute clinical presentations.
Tympanocentesis is done under general anesthesia in horses or sedation in ruminants
by directing a 15-cm needle through the tympanic membrane visualized with the aid
of an otoscope. The technique is somewhat difficult because of the long and angled
external auditory canal. Sterile 0.9% NaCl (0.5–1 mL) is injected into the tympanic
cavity and then, after a few seconds, withdrawn. A positive tap consists of withdrawal
of a cloudy or yellow fluid, which on analysis may contain evidence of pus and can
be sampled for culture and antimicrobial susceptibility. An alternative method uses
a 15-cm sterile polypropylene catheter that has the appropriate stiffness for puncturing
the tympanic membrane but sufficient flexibility to advance along the external acoustic
meatus.
3
Differential Diagnosis
The disease needs to be differentiated from otitis externa, in which the head may
be carried in a rotated position, but usually intermittently, and this is accompanied
by head-shaking and the presence of exudate and an offensive smell in the ear canal,
and from cerebral injury or abscess, and similar lesions of the upper cervical cord.
All of these are characterized by deviation of the head, not rotation. At necropsy
the tympanic bulla contains pus, and a variety of organisms, such as staphylococci,
streptococci, Pasteurella haemolytica, and Neisseria catarrhalis, may be isolated.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Treatment consists of broad-spectrum antimicrobials daily for 4 weeks and antiinflammatory
agents. The prognosis with treatment with fluoroquinolones is very good in calves,
although a 50% mortality rate has been reported in calves that were not treated with
other antimicrobial agents. The use of lincomycin at 6.5 mg/kg BW combined with spectinomycin
at 10 mg/kg BW intravenously twice daily for 5 days has been reported to be successful
for the treatment of otitis media in beef calves. Anecdotal reports exist of the use
of a knitting needle to rupture the tympanic membrane in cattle, with rapid resolution
of the head tilt because of the decreased pressure in the middle ear. Bilateral tympanic
bulla osteotomy has been performed in an affected calf, resulting in a rapid resolution
of the head tilt.
Further Reading
Duarte
ER
Hamdan
JS
Otitis in cattle, an etiological review
J Vet Med B
51
2004
1
7
Morin
DE
Brainstem and cranial nerve abnormalities: listeriosis, otitis media/interna, and
pituitary abscess syndrome
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
243
273
15203225
References
1
Finnen
A
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
143
21182544
2
Lee
K
Vet Rec
165
2009
559
19897870
3
Kawasaki
Y
Vet Rec
165
2009
212
19684349
4
Concha-Albornoz
I
Am J Vet Res
73
2012
42
22204287
5
Gosselin
V
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
1594
24986376
Listeriosis
Synopsis
Etiology
Listeria monocytogenes. Ubiquitous in farm environment.
Epidemiology Ruminants, particularly sheep. Prime occurrence is seasonal associated
with feeding silage with high listerial growth. Also following management-induced
stress. Commonly manifest with multiple cases in a group.
Clinical findings Most commonly encephalitis with brainstem and cranial nerve dysfunction
or abortion in last third of pregnancy. Less commonly septicemia in periparturient
and neonatal sheep and goats, enteritis in weaned sheep, spinal myelitis, uveitis,
and occasionally mastitis.
Clinical pathology Culture, PCR. Pleocytosis and elevated protein in cerebrospinal
fluid with encephalitis.
Lesions Microabscesses in brainstem in listerial encephalitis, spinal cord in spinal
myelitis, abomasum, intestine, liver, and mesenteric lymph nodes in enteritis. Visceral
lesions in septicemia.
Diagnostic confirmation Culture and histopathology.
Treatment Penicillin or oxytetracycline. Must be given early in clinical disease.
Control Control of listerial growth in feeds. Vaccination.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
There are currently six species classified within the genus Listeria, but only L.
monocytogenes and L. ivanovii (previously classified as L. monocytogenes serotype
5) are pathogenic for domestic animals. L. ivanovii is only mildly pathogenic and
is an occasional cause of abortion in sheep and cattle. Aborted fetuses have suppurative
bronchopneumonia and lack the multifocal hepatocellular necrosis commonly seen in
abortions associated with L. monocytogenes. L. innocua is occasionally associated
with encephalitis in ruminants that is clinically and pathologically similar to that
associated with L. monocytogenes. Most, but not all, reports of both infections record
that the animals were being fed silage.
L. monocytogenes is widespread in nature and has characteristics that allow its survival
and growth in a wide variety of environments. There is a highly diverse range of strains,
some of which have the capability of causing disease in animals and humans.
Optimal growth temperatures are between 30°C and 37°C but the organism can grow and
reproduce at temperatures between 1°C and 45°C. It can grow between pH 4.5 and 9.6
although growth at low pH is minimal at low temperatures. The organism is susceptible
to common disinfectants.
L. monocytogenes can be divided into 16 serovars on the basis of somatic and flagellar
antigens, and there is considerable genetic diversity between serovars. Serovars 4b,
1/2a and 1/2b, and 3 are most commonly isolated from diseased animals but there are
geographic differences. Virulent strains can multiply in macrophages and monocytes
and produce a hemolysin, listeriolysin O, which is thought to be a major virulence
factor.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Geographic
Although the organism is widespread in nature, clinical disease in animals occurs
mainly in the northern and southern latitudes and is much less common in tropical
and subtropical than in temperate climates. The disease is important in North America,
Europe, the UK, New Zealand, and Australia.
Seasonal
In the northern hemispheres listeriosis has a distinct seasonal occurrence, probably
associated with seasonal feeding of silage, with the highest prevalence in the months
of December through May, but seasonal occurrence is not a feature in Australia.
Host
Listeriosis is primarily a disease of ruminants, particularly sheep, and the major
diseases associated with L. monocytogenes are encephalitis and abortion. In ruminants
it also produces syndromes of septicemia, spinal myelitis, uveitis, gastroenteritis,
and mastitis. Occasional septicemic disease occurs in horses and pigs.
•
Encephalitis/meningitis usually occurs sporadically, affecting a single animal in
a herd or flock or a few individuals over several weeks. The mean attack rate in 50
affected flocks in Britain was 2.5% with a range of 0.1% to 13.3%. More serious outbreaks
can occur with attack rates as high as 35% and cases occurring over a 2-month period.
The disease occurs in sheep older than 6 weeks but may be more prevalent in lambs
between 6 and 12 weeks of age and ewes over 2 years of age. The case–fatality is high,
especially in sheep, because the short clinical course often precludes treatment.
•
Abortion may also occur sporadically, which is usually true in cattle, but in sheep
and goats it is more common as an outbreak with an attack rate that frequently approaches
10%.
•
Spinal myelitis is an uncommon manifestation but is recorded as occurring in 0.8%
to 2.5% of sheep in affected flocks and in all ages of sheep 4 weeks following spray
dipping. Spinal myelitis also occurs sporadically in cattle 12 to 18 months of age.
•
Septicemic disease is also a less common manifestation of infection with L. monocytogenes
but can occur as an outbreak with a high case fatality in newborn lambs and kids and
also in periparturient ewes and does.
•
Keratoconjunctivitis/uveitis occurs in both sheep and cattle and has been associated
with silage feeding from big bales or ring feeders. This condition presents a distinct
entity that is not associated with systemic infection with Listeria.
•
Gastroenteritis has been reported primarily by veterinary diagnostic labs in Great
Britain and New Zealand as a sporadic disease affecting sheep after weaning. It occurs
during the winter months most commonly in sheep fed baleage or silage. Cases occur
2 days or more after the onset of feeding. Less commonly, cases occur in sheep on
root crops or on pasture where the quality of the pasture is poor and they are at
high stocking densities.
•
Mastitis is uncommon but can occur in cattle, sheep, and goats. It results in contamination
of milk with L. monocytogenes. The more common source of L. monocytogenes in raw milk
is fecal contamination. In a Danish study of quarter milk samples from over a million
cows in 36,199 herds, 0.4% of cows had listerial mastitis and 1.2% of herds had infected
cows.
Source of Infection
The organism is common in the environment and infection is not limited to agricultural
animals. L. monocytogenes has been isolated from 42 species of mammals and 22 species
of birds as well as fish, crustaceans, and insects. It is truly ubiquitous in the
environment and can be commonly isolated from animal feces, human feces, farm slurry,
sewerage sludge, soil, farm water troughs, surface water, plants, animal feeds, and
the walls, floors, drains, and so forth of farms and other environments. The ability
to form biofilms may assist in its survival in the environment and may assist in perpetuating
its presence in water troughs on infected farms.
Most feed hays, grains, and formulated feeds have the potential to contain L. monocytogenes
but, with most, low levels of available water restrict its multiplication.
In ruminants L. monocytogenes can be isolated from the feces and nasal secretions
of healthy animals and has been isolated from the feces of cattle in 46% of 249 herds
examined and from 82% of samples of feedstuffs. In a French survey 5% of small ruminant
fecal samples were found positive for L. monocytogenes. Fecal material from wild birds
in agricultural regions may also contain large amounts of L. monocytogenes that can
contribute to the contamination of feed, water, bedding material, and soils.
1
Exposed sheep may become latent carriers, shedding the pathogen in feces and milk.
1
In temperate climates the prevalence of L. monocytogenes in the feces of ruminants
appears to vary with the season, being higher in the winter period. It is also increased
during periods of environmental stress and in association with the stress of lambing
and transport. The presence in feces and secretions can also be influenced by the
number of the organism in feeds fed to the animals. In herds where there is a high
proportion of cattle excreting in feces, the organism can be isolated from dried fecal
dust on walls and most farm surfaces.
L. monocytogenes is not isolated from the feces or environment in all farms and its
presence in isolable numbers is largely a reflection of its presence in feed, or the
presence of animals with intestinal carriage. It is apparent that in some healthy
herds and flocks there may be a multitude of different strains in the silage and feed,
water troughs, feces, and environment in a single herd.
The presence of L. monocytogenes in bulk tank milk or milk filters is used as a measure
of farm infection prevalence. Obviously this measure is influenced by the management
and environmental conditions on farms that might result in fecal contamination of
the teats. Although bulk tank and milk filter infection rates provide information
of possible value to measures of environmental contamination and risk for human exposure,
there is no evidence that this measure has any relationship to risk for animal disease
on the farm being studied.
Silage
L. monocytogenes is commonly present in silage, but it does not multiply to any significant
extent in effectively preserved silage, which is characterized by anaerobic storage,
high density, a high concentration of organic acids, and a pH below 4.5. Listeria
can multiply in silage above pH 5.0 to 5.5, the critical pH depending on the dry matter
content. L. monocytogenes may be present in silage that is poorly fermented, but it
can also occur in pockets of aerobic deterioration in otherwise good silage and this
is most common. These areas are often indicated by mold growth and occur at the edges
of the clamp and in the top few inches of the surface in plastic-covered clamps where
air has circulated under the plastic. Thus the growth of L. monocytogenes is a surface
problem in silage, except those that are poorly fermented, and occurs in small areas
sporadically over the surface of a silage.
The risk for contamination of silage with Listeria is higher when it contains soil,
which may be incorporated from molehills present in the field and in the front of
the clamp during final packing. An ash content of greater than 70 mg/kg dry matter
indicates soil contamination.
Big bale silage may have a higher risk for listerial infection than conventional silage
because of its lower density, poor fermentation, greater surface area relative to
clamp silage, and greater risk for mechanical damage to the plastic covering.
Moist preserved feeds other than grass silage are at risk for listerial growth; listeriosis
is recorded, for example, in association with the feeding of moist brewers grains,
wet spoiled hay bales, and silage made from commodity by-products such as orange and
artichoke waste. A relatively rapid method for the quantitative assessment of the
occurrence and distribution of Listeria in suspect silage is available.
Infective material also derives from infected animals in the feces, urine, aborted
fetuses and uterine discharge, and in the milk. Although immediate spread among animals
in a group has been demonstrated, field observations suggest that mediated contagion
by means of inanimate objects also occurs. Woody browse may be a risk factor for goats.
Transmission
With septicemic disease and abortion, the organism is transmitted by ingestion of
contaminated material. Lambs that develop septicemic disease may acquire infection
from contamination on the ewe's teat, from the ingestion of milk containing the organism
from ewes or does with subclinical bacteremia, through the navel from the environment,
and also as a congenital infection. The encephalitic form of the disease results from
infection of the terminals of the trigeminal nerve consequent to abrasions of the
buccal mucosa from feed or browse or from infection of tooth cavities. Spinal myelitis
is thought to result from growth up spinal nerves subsequent to body area infections.
Outbreaks of encephalitis that occur in sheep after introduction to silage usually
commence about 3 to 4 weeks later, although there is wide variation, and one study
of a large number of outbreaks found the median time of this period to be 44 days.
This delay reflects the time for ascending infection.
Commonly, the serotype isolated from the brain of an affected animal is also present
in the silage being fed. However, the recent development of methods for genetic analyses
of L. monocytogenes has demonstrated that serotyping is a relatively crude tool for
epidemiologic studies and in many instances, although the isolate from brain may be
the same serotype as that from silage, there is no relationship on genetic analysis.
Possibly this reflects differences in strains at different sites in silage and the
difference between the time of sampling of the silage and the time when the affected
cow ate it.
Septicemic disease in sheep and goats usually occurs within 2 days of introduction
to silage and abortions 6 to 13 days later.
Risk Factors
Despite the ubiquity of L. monocytogenes, only a small proportion of animals develop
clinical disease. A number of predisposing factors have been observed, or proposed,
as risk factors for disease. These include factors that cause a lowering of the host
animal's resistance and factors that increase the infection pressure of the organism.
In farm animals the latter appear the most important.
Host Management Risk Factors
Observed risk factors include the following:
•
Poor nutritional state
•
Sudden changes of weather to very cold and wet
•
Stress of late pregnancy and parturition
•
Transport
•
Long periods of flooding with resulting poor access to pasture
Differences in susceptibility between species are apparent with sheep being considerably
more likely to develop clinical disease than cattle. Area outbreaks affecting several
flocks can occur in sheep on poorly drained and muddy pastures following floods, but
outbreaks are also described in droughts. Overcrowding and unsanitary conditions with
poor access to feed supplies may predispose housed sheep.
Breed difference in susceptibility (Angora goats and Rambouillet sheep) has been observed
in some studies but not in others.
Pathogen Risk Factors
Factors that increase the infection pressure largely involve a massive multiplication
of L. monocytogenes in the feed or environment. The feeding of grass or corn silage
as a major risk factor for the occurrence of listeriosis has been recognized for many
decades. The increase in use of silage for feed in ruminants may be the reason for
the apparent increase in the prevalence of the disease in recent years. Silage may
also exert its effect by increasing the susceptibility of the host to listerial infection,
although this has been disputed.
The organism persists for as long as 3 months in sheep feces and has been shown to
survive for up to 11.5 months in damp soil, up to 16.5 months in cattle feces, up
to 207 days on dry straw, and for more than 2 years in dry soil and feces. It is resistant
to temperatures of −20°C (−6°F) for 2 years and is still viable after repeated freezing
and thawing.
Experimental Reproduction
Oral or parenteral challenge of nonpregnant sheep and goats will produce a bacteremia
with minor clinical signs of pyrexia and depression in animals with no preexisting
antibody. Clinical disease is more severe in young animals and the infection clears
with the development of an immune response. The challenge of animals with preexisting
antibody is not associated with clinical disease, although there may be a bacteremia.
Lactating animals secrete the organism in milk during the bacteremic period. Prior
challenge of goats with L. ivanovii or L. innocua does not protect against subsequent
challenge with L. monocytogenes.
Several studies have shown that oral, conjunctival, and parenteral challenge of pregnant
animals results in more severe signs of septicemia and can be followed by abortion,
although this is not an invariable sequel. Encephalitis has not been reproduced experimentally
by intravenous challenge, although meningoencephalitis may occur following this route
of challenge in young lambs. Encephalitis has been reproduced experimentally by the
injection of organisms into the buccal mucosa or the tooth pulp cavity, with the organism
traveling centripetally via the trigeminal nerve to reach the brainstem.
Zoonotic Implications
In humans, listeriosis is considered a food-borne infection of sporadic occurrence
producing septicemia, meningoencephalitis, abortion, and infection in other organs
as well as neonatal infection. Although outbreaks of listeriosis associated with contaminated
food receive the most public attention, sporadic listeriosis is the more common presentation.
Although all age groups are susceptible the disease incidence is the highest among
people 65 years and older followed by young children (0–4 years) and immunocompromised
patients.
2
In the EU a disease incidence of 0.3 and in the United States of 0.8 per 100,000 population
have been reported.1, 2, 3, 4 The case fatality is high, and overall approximately
25% of reported cases die. Although the incidence increased at the beginning of the
millennium, incidence rates have been stable over the last years.
4
Although there is a potential for zoonotic transmission, the majority of human exposures
to the organism, and the risk for disease, result from contamination of foods during
processing and from the particular ability of the organism to grow at refrigerator
temperature and in organic material with high salt content.
High disease prevalence and numbers of L. monocytogenes have been linked to certain
foods such as soft cheese, smoked fish, pate, deli meats, unpasteurized milk, fermented
raw meat sausages, hot dogs, and deli salads.2, 3
Milk products have been incriminated in some outbreaks of the disease. Numerous studies
have shown that L. monocytogenes is commonly present in low numbers (usually less
than 1 organism per milliliter) in raw milk from some herds. In the vast majority
of herds this is the result of fecal contamination during the milking process or other
environmental contamination. Rarely, its presence in raw milk is from an animal with
subclinical mastitis and in this case its numbers in bulk tank milk are much higher
(2,000–5,000 organisms per milliliter), even when there is a single cow or goat with
L. monocytogenes mastitis. In goats and sheep the presence in raw milk may also be
the result of a subclinical bacteremia.
There have been concerns that the organism might survive pasteurization, especially
if present in phagocytes. D-values for Listeria in milk have been determined to be
in the range of 0.9 seconds at 71.1°C. The legal limit for high-temperature/short-time
pasteurization in the United States is 71.7°C for 15 seconds, and this temperature
is sufficient to inactivate numbers far beyond those present in raw milk. There is
no evidence that the organism will survive correct pasteurization procedures.
Bulk tank infection rates are higher in winter and spring and cross-sectional and
case–control studies have shown that the risk for detecting L. monocytogenes in bulk
milk is higher in those herds that used a bucket milking system rather than a pipeline
system. It is also higher in herds fed component feeds, fed leftover feed, fed from
plastic feed bunks, and from feed bunks with a low frequency of cleaning, It is lower
in herds that practice premilking teat disinfection.
Farmers or others who consume raw milk need to be aware of the risk of infection,
especially if they fall within at-risk categories. There may be a particular risk
with milk from goats and sheep fed silage. People associated with agriculture are
also more liable to direct zoonotic transmission of listerial disease. Dermatitis
with a papular and pustular rash occurs on the arms of veterinarians following the
handling of infected dystocia cases and aborted fetuses. Conjunctivitis is also recorded
in agricultural workers handling infected livestock.
Although L. monocytogenes rarely causes disease in pigs, it is present in the tonsils
and feces of some pigs at slaughter and this presence is a potential source of contamination
of the carcass and the slaughterhouse environment. There is a significantly higher
prevalence in the tonsils of fattening pigs than in those of sows. The organism can
be isolated from the floors, walls, and feed in pig units. Wet feeding, poor hygiene,
and a short spelling period between batches of pigs in the finishing house have been
found to be risk factors for infection in pigs. Paradoxically, disinfecting the pipeline
used for wet feeding was associated with a higher risk of fecal contamination than
no disinfection at all.
A further concern for indirect zoonotic risk of L. monocytogenes is the presence of
the organism in the feces on infected farms and the potential for fecal or windborne
dust spread to adjacent fields that may contain crops for human consumption.
Pathogenesis
In most animals, ingestion of the organism, with penetration of the mucosa of the
intestine, leads to an inapparent infection with prolonged fecal excretion of the
organism and to a subclinical bacteremia, which clears with the development of immunity.
The bacteremic infection is frequently subclinical and may be accompanied by excretion
of the organism in milk. Septicemic listeriosis, with or without meningitis, is most
common in neonatal ruminants and in adult sheep and goats, particularly if they are
pregnant and when the infection challenge is large.
The organism is a facultative intracellular pathogen that can infect cells, including
intestinal cells, by directed endocytosis. It can survive and grow in macrophages
and monocytes. Bacterial superoxide dismutase protects against the bactericidal activity
of the respiratory burst of the phagocyte and listeriolysin O disrupts lysosomal membranes,
allowing the organism to grow in the cytoplasm. The experimental mouse model indicates
that cell-mediated immunity is important in protection against listerial infection,
but studies in goats suggest that the clearance of bacteremic infection and resistance
to infection are also strongly associated with humoral antibody.
In pregnant animals, invasion of the placenta and fetus may occur within 24 hours
of the onset of bacteremia. Edema and necrosis of the placenta lead to abortion, usually
5 to 10 days postinfection. Infection late in pregnancy results in stillbirths or
the delivery of young that rapidly develop a fatal septicemia. Maternal metritis is
constant and if the fetus is retained a fatal listerial septicemia may follow. Infection
of the uterus causing abortion and intrauterine infection occurs in all mammals.
Encephalitis/Meningitis
Encephalitis/meningitis in ruminants occurs as an acute inflammation of the brainstem
or the meningeal membranes and is usually focal. Invasion of the CNS can occur by
at least three different mechanisms.
5
These include the following:
•
Retrograde (centripetal) migration into the brain within the axon of CNs
•
Transport across the blood-brain barrier within parasitized leukocytes
•
Direct invasion of endothelial cells by blood-borne bacteria
In cases without systemic infection centripetal translocation of the pathogen along
the trigeminal or other CNs following penetration of the traumatized buccal mucosa,
the shedding of deciduous or permanent teeth, and following periodontitis may result
in encephalitis. Meningitis is thought to be associated with hematogenous translocation
of the pathogen through parasitized endothelial cells or leukocytes.
The incubation period after experimental inoculation of the tooth pulp was at least
3 weeks even though lesions were detectable in the brainstem within 6 days of inoculation.
5
Clinical signs are characterized most strongly by an asymmetric disorder of CN function,
in particular the trigeminal, facial, vestibular, and glossopharyngeal nerves, but
there is some variation in the involvement of individual CNs depending on the distribution
of lesions in the brainstem. Lesions in the sensory portion of the trigeminal nucleus
and the facial nucleus are common and lead to ipsilateral facial hypalgesia and paralysis;
involvement of the vestibular nucleus is also common and leads to ataxia with circling
and a head tilt to the affected side. The additional signs of dullness, head-pressing,
and delirium are referable to the more general effects of inflammation of the brain
developing in the agonal stages. Spread of the infection along the optic nerve may
result in endophthalmitis in sheep and cattle.
Spinal Myelitis
Spinal myelitis possibly results from ascending infection in the sensory nerves of
the skin following dermatitis from prolonged wetting of the fleece.
Mastitis
L. monocytogenes is rarely found to be a cause of clinical mastitis in cattle, despite
the fact that it can be common in the dairy environment, suggesting that this pathogen
is not a particularly invasive or perpetuating organism for the udder. Infection of
the mammary gland appears to primarily occur hematogenously.
1
Enteritis
An acute diarrheal condition in sheep with clinical signs and morphologic changes
resembling salmonellosis from which L. monocytogenes can be recovered has been recognized
since the early 1990s.
6
Cases are frequently linked to feeding poor-quality silage and may occur within 2
days of feeding silage heavily contaminated with L. monocytogenes. The mechanisms
through which Listeria invade the gastrointestinal mucosa are not yet understood,
but infection seems to depend more on the ingested dose and the age of the animal
than on predisposing conditions or immune status of the animal.
7
Lesions occur in the abomasum, small intestine, large intestine, mesenteric lymph
nodes, and liver.
6
Clinical Findings
When disease occurs it is usual to have an outbreak of either encephalitis or abortion.
Encephalitis is the most prevalent manifestation in sheep. Septicemia in lambs may
occur in conjunction with abortion but it is rare to have all three syndromes on the
same farm, at least in the same temporal period. There are always exceptions to such
generalities, and the occurrence of septicemia, abortion, and encephalitis in a flock
of sheep is possible.
Listerial Encephalitis/Meningitis
Sheep
In sheep, early signs are separation from the flock and depression with a hunched
stance. Sheep approached during this early stage show a frenetic desire to escape
but are uncoordinated because they run and fall easily. The syndrome progresses rapidly
with more severe depression to the point of somnolence and the development of signs
of CN dysfunction. Fever, usually 40°C (104°F) but occasionally as high as 42°C (107°F),
is common in the early stages of the disease but the temperature is usually normal
when overt clinical signs are present.
Signs vary between individual sheep but incoordination, head deviation sometimes with
head tilt, walking in circles, unilateral facial hypalgesia, and facial paralysis
are usually present. Facial hypalgesia can be detected with pressure from a hemostat,
and the facial paralysis is manifested with drooping of the ear, paralysis of the
lips, and ptosis on the same side of the face as the hypalgesia. This may be accompanied
by exposure keratitis, often severe enough to cause corneal ulceration. Strabismus
and nystagmus occur in some. Panophthalmitis, with pus evident in the anterior chamber
of one or both eyes, is not uncommon in cattle that have been affected for a number
of days. Also there is paresis of the muscles of the jaw, with poor tone or a dropped
jaw, in which case prehension and mastication are slow and the animal may stand for
long periods drooling saliva and with food hanging from its mouth.
The position of the head varies. In many cases there is deviation of the head to one
side with the poll–nose relationship undisturbed (i.e., there is no rotation) but
in others there is also head tilt. The head may be retroflexed or ventroflexed depending
on the localization of the lesions and in some cases may be in a normal position.
The deviation of the head cannot be corrected actively by the animal, and if it is
corrected passively the head returns to its previous position as soon as it is released.
Progression is usually in a small-diameter circle in the direction of the deviation.
There is ataxia, often with consistent falling to one side, and an affected sheep
may lean against the examiner or a fence. The affected animal becomes recumbent and
is unable to rise, although often still able to move its legs. Death is caused by
respiratory failure.
Cattle
In cattle, the clinical signs are essentially the same but the clinical course is
longer (Fig. 14-16
). In adult cattle the course of the disease is usually 1 to 2 weeks, but in sheep
and calves the disease is more acute, with death occurring in 2 to 4 days.
Fig. 14-16
A, Two-year-old Holstein Friesian heifer with listeriosis. The heifer is exhibiting
clinical signs of a left brainstem lesion in the vicinity of the vestibulocochlear
nerve nucleus (cranial nerve VIII) manifested as extensor thrust from the right side
and tight circles to the left (circling is impeded by placement in the headgate).
B, Three-year-old Simmental cow with listeriosis. The cow is exhibiting depression,
weakness of the tongue and jaw muscles, and lack of sensation that she has hay in
her mouth. Some of these clinical signs are also seen in cattle with rabies or esophageal
obstruction (choke). Both animals responded well to intravenous oxytetracycline treatment.
Fig. 14-16
Goats
In goats the disease is similar to that in the other species, but in the young goat
the onset is very sudden and the course short, with death occurring in 2 to 3 days
(Fig. 14-17
).
Fig. 14-17
Two-year-old goat with listeriosis. The goat has depression of the right corneal branch
of the trigeminal nerve (cranial nerve V) because it does not detect the straw on
its right eye, and the right facial nerve (cranial nerve VII) because it has a right
ear droop, deviation of the philtrum to the left, and flaccid right upper lip. The
goat was unable to stand and appeared depressed.
Fig. 14-17
Listerial Abortion
Outbreaks of abortion are recorded in cattle but are more common in sheep and in goats.
Abortion caused by this organism is rare in pigs.
Cattle
In cattle, abortion or stillbirth occurs sporadically and usually in the last third
of pregnancy; retention of the afterbirth is common, in which case there is clinical
illness and fever of up to 40.5°C (105°F). Abortion has been observed soon after the
commencement of silage feeding but does not always have this association.
Sheep and Goats
In sheep and goats abortions occur from the 12th week of pregnancy onward, the afterbirth
is usually retained, and there is a bloodstained vaginal discharge for several days.
There may be some deaths of ewes from septicemia if the fetus is retained. In both
species the rates of abortion in a group are low but may reach as high as 15%. On
some farms, abortions recur each year.
Abortion Caused by Listeria Ivanovii
This occurs as a sporadic disease in cattle and has no distinguishing clinical features
from that associated with L. monocytogenes. Outbreaks in sheep are manifested with
abortion and stillbirth but particularly with the birth of live infected lambs, which
seldom survive long enough to walk or suck.
Septicemic Listeriosis
Acute septicemia caused by L. monocytogenes is not common in adult ruminants but does
occur in monogastric animals and in newborn lambs and calves. There are no signs suggestive
of nervous system involvement, the syndrome being a general one comprising depression,
weakness, emaciation, pyrexia, and diarrhea in some cases, with hepatic necrosis and
gastroenteritis at necropsy. The same syndrome is also seen in ewes and goats after
abortion if the fetus is retained. A better defined but less common syndrome has been
described in calves 3 to 7 days old. Corneal opacity is accompanied by dyspnea, nystagmus,
and mild opisthotonus. Death follows in about 12 hours. At necropsy there is ophthalmitis
and serofibrinous meningitis. Septicemic listeriosis is recorded in a foal.
Mastitis
Infection in the udder may involve a single quarter or both quarters; it is chronic
and poorly responsive to treatment. There is a high somatic cell count in milk from
the affected quarter, but the milk appears normal.
Spinal Myelitis
There is fever, ataxia with initial knuckling of the hindlimbs progressing to hindlimb
weakness, and paralysis. In some cases, both in sheep and cattle, there is also paresis
and paralysis of the front limbs. There is no evidence of CN involvement, and affected
animals are initially mentally alert, bright, and continue to eat. However, there
is rapid deterioration and affected animals are commonly humanely destroyed.
Keratoconjunctivitis, Uveitis
There is swelling of the iris and constriction of the pupil; white focal lesions are
evident on the internal surface of the cornea with floccular material in the anterior
chamber. Advanced cases have pannus and corneal opacity.
Enteritis in Sheep
Reported clinical signs include lethargy, anorexia, and diarrhea or sudden death.
Pregnant ewes may abort.
Clinical Pathology
The CSF in cases of encephalitis has a moderately to markedly increased protein concentration
and leukocyte count. Neutrophils are the predominant cell type with lymphocytes contributing
not more than 20% of cells.
8
L. monocytogenes is not detectable by culture or PCR.
The organism can be cultivated from vaginal secretions for up to 2 weeks after abortion,
and a proportion of aborting animals also have L. monocytogenes in the milk and feces.
Serologic tests (agglutination and complement fixation tests) have been used but lack
the predictive value required for diagnostic use. Ruminants commonly have antibody
to Listeria and high titers are often encountered in normal animals in flocks and
herds where there have been clinical cases. Nucleic acid–based techniques can be used
to determine the source of a strain of L. monocytogenes in an outbreak.
Necropsy Findings
Typically, there are no distinctive gross changes associated with listerial encephalitis.
Histologic examination of CNS tissue is necessary to demonstrate the microabscesses
that are characteristic of the disease. These are present in the brainstem in listerial
encephalitis and in the cervical and/or lumbar spinal cord in outbreaks of spinal
myelitis. Sampling of the forebrain will typically result in a false-negative diagnosis.
Cold enrichment techniques are advisable when attempting to isolate the organism.
Gram staining of paraffin-embedded tissue may permit confirmation of the diagnosis
in cases for which suitable culture material is unavailable. Alternative test methods
such as fluorescent antibody or immunoperoxidase tests are available in some laboratories.
In one retrospective study comparing diagnostic methods, immunoperoxidase staining
was superior to bacterial culture when correlated with histopathologic changes.
Visceral lesions occur as multiple foci of necrosis in the liver, spleen, and myocardium
in the septicemic form and in aborted fetuses. Aborted fetuses are usually edematous
and autolyzed, with very large numbers of bacteria visible microscopically in a variety
of tissues. In aborting dams, there is placentitis and endometritis in addition to
the lesions in the fetus.
Sheep with enteritis show ulcerative and hemorrhagic abomasitis and reddening of the
small intestinal mucosa.
6
In a small number of cases typhlocolitis is diagnosed at necropsy; histologically,
there are microabscesses throughout the intestine and a characteristic infiltration
of degenerating neutrophils in the mucosa lamina muscularis of the abomasum.
6
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
Central Nervous System Listeriosis
•
Bacteriology: half of midsagittally sectioned brain, including brainstem, chilled
or frozen (CULT, FAT)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed half of midsagittally sectioned brain, including brainstem;
appropriate segment of spinal cord if spinal myelitis suspected (LM, IHC)
Septicemia and Abortion
•
Bacteriology: chilled liver, spleen, lung, placenta, fetal stomach content (CULT,
FAT)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed liver, spleen, lung, brain, placenta, fetal intestine (LM,
IHC).
Enteritis
•
Bacteriology: abomasum, small intestine, large intestine, mesenterial lymph nodes
(CULT)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed abomasum, small intestine, large intestine, mesenterial
lymph nodes (LM, IHC).
Differential Diagnosis
Encephalitis
•
Pregnancy toxemia in sheep
•
Nervous ketosis in cattle
•
Rabies
•
Gid
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Middle ear disease
•
Scrapie
Abortion
•
Sheep
•
Cattle
Gastroenteritis
•
Salmonellosis
Keratoconjunctivitis/Uveitis
•
Contagious ophthalmia
•
Infectious bovine keratoconjunctivitis
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Penicillin is considered the drug of choice for treatment of listeriosis but it only
has a bacteriostatic effect on L. monocytogenes.
2
Cephalosporins are ineffective because of minimal or nonexistent affinity of listerial
penicillin-binding protein 3 and 5.2, 5
A recent study exploring the prevalence of in vitro resistance of L. monocytogenes
strains isolated from dairy farms found all strains to be resistant to cephalosporins,
streptomycin, and trimethoprim. Over 90% of isolated strains were resistant to ampicillin
and 66% were resistant to florfenicol. Resistance to penicillin G was determined for
40% of isolated strains.
9
Penicillin administered at a dose of 44 000 IU/kg BW every 12 hours or every 24 hours
given intramuscularly for 10 to 14 days is among the most commonly used treatments
for listerial encephalitis/meningitis. Initiating the therapy with a loading dose
of penicillin of 200,000 IU/kg as a water-soluble formulation given intravenously
has been proposed.
10
The intravenous treatment of oxytetracycline (10 mg/kg BW every 12 hours or 20 mg
/kg BW every 24 hours for 10 days) has been reported as being reasonably effective
in meningoencephalitis of cattle but less so in sheep.
The use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) to address pain resulting
from meningitis may be indicated but warrants close monitoring of the patient's hydration
status to prevent renal damage. The use of glucocorticoids has been proposed with
the objective to prevent abscess formation in the CNS.
1
Concerns have been raised since increased listerial shedding through milk was reported
in cattle infected with L. monocytogenes treated with dexamethasone.
11
The recovery rate depends largely on the time that treatment is started after the
onset of clinical signs. If severe clinical signs are already evident, death usually
follows in spite of treatment. Usually the course of events in an outbreak is that
the first case dies but subsequent cases are detected sufficiently early for treatment.
Dehydration, acid-base imbalances, and electrolyte disturbances must also be corrected.
Cases of spinal myelitis are poorly responsive to treatment.
Treatment of listerial iritis is with systemic antibiotics in the early stages coupled
with subpalpebral corticosteroid and atropine to dilate the pupil.
Supportive treatment with thiamine, to compensate for decreased thiamine production
during the disease, and glucocorticoids to prevent formation of microabscesses in
the CNS have been proposed. Correction of metabolic acidosis, resulting from excessive
bicarbonate loss with drooling saliva, may be indicated.
Treatment and Control
Treatment
Encephalitis
Procaine penicillin G (200,000 IU/kg IV as initial loading dose) (R-2)
Procaine penicillin G (22,000 IU/kg every 12 hours or 44,000 IU/kg every 24 hours
IM, for 10–14 days (R-2)
Oxytetracycline (10 mg/kg IV every 12 hours or 20 mg/kg IV every 24 hours for 10–14
days) (R-2)
Cephalosporins (R-4)
Thiamine (10 mg/kg slow IV every 24 hours) (R-2)
Flunixin meglumine (1 mg/kg every 24 hours IV) (R-2)
Dexamethasone (1 mg/kg IV single treatment) (R-3)
Control
Ensure pH of silage is < 5.0 (R-2)
Don't feed strongly spoiled sections of silage (R-2)
IM, intramuscularly; IV, intravenously.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
Control is difficult because of the ubiquitous occurrence of the organism, the lack
of a simple method of determining when it is present in high numbers in the environment,
and a poor understanding of the risk factors other than silage. Where the risk factor
is silage, there may be some merit in the recommendation that a change of diet to
include heavy feeding of silage should be made slowly, particularly if the silage
is spoiled or if listeriosis has occurred on the premises previously. Tetracyclines
can be fed in the ration of animals at risk in a feedlot. When possible, the obviously
spoiled areas of silage should be separated and not fed.
Other recommendations on the feeding of silage include avoid making silage from fields
in which molehills may have contaminated the grass; avoid soil contamination when
filling the clamp; avoid using additives to improve fermentation; and avoid silage
that is obviously decayed, or with a pH of greater than 5 or an ash content of more
than 70 mg/kg of dry matter.
Silage removed from the clamp should be fed as soon as possible.
Where uveitis is a problem, feeding systems that avoid eye contact with silage should
be used.
A live attenuated vaccine has been shown to induce protection against intravenous
challenge, and a live attenuated vaccine in use in Norway for several years is reported
to reduce the annual incidence of the disease in sheep from 4% to 1.5%. An economic
model is available for determining whether vaccination should be practiced. Commercial
killed vaccines are available for the control of the disease in some countries, and
some companies will also produce autogenous vaccines on request. The efficacy of vaccination
still requires further determination; however, when economics or food availability
on the farm dictate that contaminated silage must be fed, consideration might be given
to vaccination as a means of providing some protection.
Further Reading
Anon
Listeria monocytogenes. Recommendations by the national advisory committee on microbiological
criteria for foods
Int J Food Microbiol
14
1991
185
246
1790101
Drevets
DA
Bronze
MS
Listeria monocytogenes: epidemiology human disease, and mechanisms of brain invasion
Immunol Med Microbiol
53
2008
151
165
Farber
JM
Peterkin
PI
Listeria monocytogenes, a food-borne pathogen
Microbiol Rev
55
1991
476
511
1943998
Fenlon
DR
Listeria monocytogenes in the natural environment
Ryser
ET
Martin
EH
Listeria, Listeriosis and Food Safety
2nd ed
1998
Marcel Dekker
New York
Gitter
M
Veterinary aspects of listeriosis
PHLS Microb Dig
6
2
1989
38
42
Gray
ML
Killinger
AH
Listeria monocytogenes and listeric infections
Bacteriol Rev
30
1966
309
4956900
Low
JC
Donachie
W
A review of Listeria monocytogenes and listeriosis
Vet J
153
1997
9
29
9125353
Scarratt
WK
Ovine listeric encephalitis
Compend Contin Educ Pract Vet
9
1987
F28
F32
References
1
Brugere-Picoux
J
Small Rum Res
76
2008
12
2
Allerberger
F
Wagner
M
Clin Microbiol Infect
16
2010
16
20002687
3
Kramarenko
T
Food Control
30
2013
24
4
European centre for disease prevention and disease control. Annual epidemiological
report 2012
Accessed 29.09.2013; at
http://www.ecdc.europa.eu/en/publications/Publications/Annual-Epidemiological-Report-2012.pdf
5
Drevets
DA
Bronze
MS
Immunol Med Microbiol
53
2008
151
6
Fairley
RA
J Comp Pathol
146
2012
308
21925677
7
Zundel
E
Bernard
S
J Med Microbiol
55
2006
1717
17108277
8
Scott
PR
Small Rum Res
92
2010
96
9
Srinivasan
V
Foodborne Pathog Dis
2
2005
201
16156701
10
Scott
PR
Small Rum Res
110
2013
138
11
Welsley
IV
Am J Vet Res
50
1989
2009
2514616
Diseases Primarily Affecting the Spinal Cord
Traumatic Injury
Sudden severe trauma to the spinal cord causes a syndrome of immediate, complete,
flaccid paralysis caudal to the injury because of spinal shock. This is so brief in
animals it is hardly recognizable clinically. Spinal shock is soon followed by flaccid
paralysis in the area supplied by the injured segment and spastic paralysis caudal
to it.
Etiology
Trauma is the most common cause of monoplegia in large animals. There are varying
degrees of loss of sensation, paresis, paralysis, and atrophy of muscle.
Physical Trauma
•
Animals falling off vehicles, through barn floors
•
Osteoporotic or osteodystrophic animals, especially aged broodmares and sows, spontaneously
while jumping or leaning on fences
•
Spondylosis and fracture of thoracolumbar vertebrae in old bulls in insemination centers
•
Cervical vertebral fractures account for a large percentage of spinal cord injuries
in horses
•
Trauma caused by excessive mobility of upper cervical vertebrae may contribute to
the spinal cord lesion in wobbles in horses
•
Dislocations of the atlantooccipital joint are being reported increasingly
•
Stenosis of the cervical vertebral canal at C2-C4 in young rams, probably as a result
of head-butting
•
Fracture of T1 vertebra in calves turning violently in an alleyway wide enough to
admit cows
•
Vertebral fractures in 7- to 10-month-old calves escaping under the headgate of a
chute and forcefully hitting their backs (just cranial to the tuber coxae) on the
bottom rail of the gate
•
Vertebral fractures in neonatal calves associated with forced extraction during dystocia
•
Lightning strike may cause tissue destruction within the vertebral canal.
Parasitic Invasion
•
Cerebrospinal nematodiasis, e.g., P. tenuis, Setaria spp. in goats and sheep, Stephanurus
dentatus in pigs, P. tenuis in moose, causing moose sickness
•
Toxocara canis experimentally in pigs
•
S. vulgaris in horses and donkeys
•
Hypoderma bovis larvae in cattle
Local Ischemia of the Spinal Cord
•
Obstruction to blood flow to the cord by embolism, or of drainage by compression of
the caudal vena cava, e.g., in horses during prolonged dorsal recumbency under general
anesthesia; in pigs caused by fibrocartilaginous emboli, probably originating in injury
to the nucleus pulposus of an intervertebral disk
Pathogenesis
The lesion may consist of disruption of nervous tissue or its compression by displaced
bone or hematoma. Minor degrees of damage may result in local edema or hyperemia or,
in the absence of macroscopic lesions, transitory injury to nerve cells, classified
as concussion. The initial response is that of spinal shock, which affects a variable
number of segments on both sides of the injured segment and is manifested by complete
flaccid paralysis. The lesion must affect at least the ventral third of the cord before
spinal shock occurs. When the shock wears off, the effects of the residual lesion
remain. These may be temporary in themselves and completely normal function may return
as the edema or the hemorrhage is resorbed. In sheep, extensive experimental damage
to the cord may be followed by recovery to the point of being able to walk, but not
sufficiently to be of any practical significance.
Traumatic lesions usually affect the whole cross-section of the cord and produce a
syndrome typical of complete transection. Partial transection signs are more common
in slowly developing lesions. Most of the motor and sensory functions can be maintained
in 3-month-old calves with experimental left hemisection of the spinal cord.
In a retrospective study of dystocia-related vertebral fractures in neonatal calves,
all the fractures were located between T11 and L4, with 77% occurring at the thoracolumbar
junction. All but one case was associated with a forced extraction using unspecified
(53%), mechanical (28%), or manual (17%) methods of extraction. Traction is most commonly
applied after the fetus has entered the pelvic canal. Manual traction varies from
75 kg of pressure applied by one man to 260 kg of pressure applied by three or more
men. The forces applied in mechanical traction vary from 400 kg for a calf puller
to over 500 kg for a tractor. The transfer of these forces to the vertebrae and to
the physeal plates at the thoracolumbar junction could readily cause severe tissue
damage. In a prospective study of vertebral fractures in newborn calves, all fractures
were located at the thoracolumbar area, especially the posterior epiphysis of T13.
Clinical Findings
Spinal shock develops immediately after severe injury and is manifested by flaccid
paralysis (reflex loss) caudal to a severe spinal cord lesion. There is a concurrent
fall in local blood pressure caused by vasodilatation and there may be local sweating.
Stretch and flexor reflexes and cutaneous sensitivity disappear but reappear within
a half to several hours, although hypotonia may remain. The extremities are affected
in most cases and the animal is unable to rise and may be in sternal or lateral recumbency.
The muscles of respiration may also be affected, resulting in interference with respiration.
The body area supplied by the affected segments will eventually show flaccid paralysis
and disappearance of reflexes and muscle wasting, all representative of a lower motor
neuron lesion.
When the injury is caused by invasion by parasitic larvae, there is no stage of spinal
shock but the onset is acute, although there may be subsequent increments of paralysis
as the larva moves to a new site.
Neonatal calves with dystocia-related vertebral fractures are weak immediately after
birth or remain recumbent and make no effort to rise.
Sensation may be reduced at and caudal to the lesion, and hyperesthesia may be observed
in a girdle-like zone at the cranial edge of the lesion as a result of irritation
of sensory fibers by local inflammation and edema. Because of interference with the
sacral autonomic nerve outflow there may be paralysis of the bladder and rectum, although
this is not usually apparent in large animals. The vertebral column should be examined
carefully for signs of injury. Excessive mobility, pain on pressure, and malalignment
of spinous processes may indicate bone displacements or fractures. Rectal examination
may also reveal damage or displacement, particularly in fractures of vertebral bodies
and in old bulls with spondylosis.
Residual signs may remain when the shock passes off. This usually consists of paralysis,
which varies in extent and severity with the lesion. The paralysis is apparent caudal
to and at the site of the lesion. The reflexes return except at the site of the lesion.
There is usually no systemic disturbance but pain may be sufficiently severe to cause
an increase in heart rate and prevent eating.
Recovery may occur in 1 to 3 weeks if nervous tissue is not destroyed, but when extensive
damage has been done to a significantly large section of the cord there is no recovery
and disposal is advisable. In rare cases animals that suffer a severe injury continue
to be ambulatory for up to 12 hours before paralysis occurs. In such instances it
may be that a fracture occurs but displacement follows at a later stage during more
active movement. Recovered animals may be left with residual nervous deficits or with
postural changes such as torticollis.
Fracture of the Cervical Vertebrae in Horses
In horses fracture/dislocation of cranial cervical vertebrae is fairly common. Affected
animals are recumbent and unable to lift the head from the ground. However, they may
be fully conscious and able to eat and drink.
1
It may be possible to palpate the lesion, but a radiograph is usually necessary. Lesions
of the caudal cervical vertebrae may permit lifting of the head but the limbs are
not moved voluntarily. In all cases the tendon and withdrawal reflexes in the limbs
are normal to supernormal.
Spondylosis in Bulls
Old bulls in artificial insemination centers develop calcification of the ventral
vertebral ligaments and subsequent spondylosis or rigidity of the lumbar area of the
vertebral column. When the bull ejaculates vigorously, the calcified ligaments may
fracture, and this discontinuity may extend upward through the vertebral body. The
ossification is extensive, usually from about T2-L3, but the fractures are restricted
to the midlumbar region. There is partial displacement of the vertebral canal and
compression of the cord. The bull is usually recumbent immediately after the fracture
occurs but may rise and walk stiffly several days later. Arching of the back, slow
movement, trunk rigidity, and sometimes unilateral lameness are characteristic signs.
Less severe degrees of spondylosis have been recorded in a high proportion of much
younger (2- to 3-year-old) bulls, but the lesions do not appear to cause clinical
signs.
Clinical Pathology
Radiologic examination may reveal the site and extent of the injury, depending on
the amount of surrounding muscle mass. CSF obtained from the lumbosacral space may
reveal the presence of xanthochromia or intact RBCs, suggesting preexisting hemorrhage.
Necropsy Findings
The abnormality is always visible on macroscopic examination. In neonatal calves with
dystocia-related vertebral fractures, hemorrhage around the kidneys, around the adrenal
glands, and in the perivertebral muscles is a common finding and a useful indicator
that a thoracolumbar fracture is present. In addition to the vertebral fracture, subdural
and epidural hemorrhage, myelomalacia, spinal cord compression, severed spinal cord,
and fractured ribs are common findings.
Differential Diagnosis
Differentiation from other spinal cord diseases is not usually difficult because of
the speed of onset and the history of trauma, although spinal myelitis and meningitis
may also develop rapidly. Other causes of recumbency may be confused with trauma,
especially if the animal is not observed in the immediate preclinical period. In most
diseases characterized by recumbency, such as azoturia, acute rumen impaction, and
acute coliform mastitis, there are other signs to indicate the existence of a lesion
other than spinal cord trauma. White muscle disease in foals is characterized by weakness,
and the serum creatine kinase activity will be increased.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Treatment is expectant only, and surgical treatment is rarely attempted. Large doses
of corticosteroids or nonsteroidal antiinflammatory agents are recommended to minimize
the edema associated with the spinal cord injury. Careful nursing on deep bedding
with turning at 3-hour intervals (ideally, but at least 3 times a day in animals that
are not “creepers”), massage of bony prominences, and periodic slinging may help to
carry an animal with concussion or other minor lesion through a long period of recumbency.
In well-muscled cattle especially, recumbency beyond a period of about 48 hours is
likely to result in widespread necrosis of the caudal muscles of the thigh and recovery
in such cases is improbable. A definitive diagnosis of a vertebral fracture with paralysis
usually warrants a recommendation for euthanasia.
Further Reading
Divers
TJ
Acquired spinal cord and peripheral nerve disease
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
231
242
15203224
Dyson
SJ
Lesions of the equine neck resulting in lameness of poor performance
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
27
2011
417
437
22100038
Reference
1
Muno
J
Equine Vet Educ
21
2009
527
Spinal Cord Compression
The gradual development of a space-occupying lesion in the vertebral canal produces
a syndrome of progressive weakness and paralysis. A preexisting inflammatory or neoplastic
lesion of the vertebral body may result in spontaneous fracture of the vertebral body
and compression of the spinal cord.
Etiology
Compression of the spinal cord occurs from space-occupying lesions in the vertebral
canal; the common ones are as follows.
Tumors
The most commonly occurring tumor in animals is lymphomatosis in which the nerve trunks
and invades the vertebral canal, usually in the lumbosacral region and less commonly
in the brachial and cervical areas. This tumor is particularly common in adult cattle
with multicentric lymphosarcoma caused by bovine leukosis virus infection (Fig. 14-18
).
Fig. 14-18
A, Bilateral posterior paresis in a 5-year-old Holstein Friesian cow with spinal lymphosarcoma
caused by infection with enzootic bovine leukosis virus. B, Caudal view of the same
cow, demonstrating marked paresis of the tail and hindlegs and poor milk production.
Fig. 14-18
Rare tumors include fibrosarcomas, metastases, plasma cell myeloma, angioma, melanoma
in a horse, hemangiosarcoma in a horse, neurofibroma, and lymphosarcoma, e.g., in
horses, vascular hamartoma in a goat.
Vertebral Body or Epidural Abscess
Vertebral body abscesses (osteomyelitis) are most common in neonatal farm animals
and are generally in association with a chronic suppurative lesion elsewhere in the
body.
•
Docking wounds in lambs, bite wounds in pigs, and chronic suppurative pneumonia in
calves are common occurrences for vertebral body abscesses. Polyarthritis and endocarditis
may also be present. The original site of infection may have resolved when the clinical
signs referable to the spinal cord abscess appear.
•
Compression of the spinal cord is caused by enlargement of the vertebral body abscess
into the vertebral canal and there may or may not be deviation of the vertebral canal
and its contents.
1
Epidural abscesses causing compression of the spinal cord, and not associated with
vertebral bodies, occur in lambs.
•
Hematogenous spread may also occur from Trueperella (Arcanobacterium or Actinomyces
or Corynebacterium) pyogenes in cattle, A. bovis in cattle with lumpy jaw, and Corynebacterium
pseudotuberculosis in sheep.
•
Multiple cases of compressive myelopathy have been reported in cattle following intramuscular
injection of an oil containing vaccine in the lumbar area.
2
•
Cervical myelomalacia in a lamb and an alpaca developed after attempted intramuscular
injections in the neck
3
•
A pyogranulomatous lesion in the sacral region of horse extended into the sacral vertebral
canal, resulting in reduced anal and tail tone and urinary overflow incontinence.
4
Bony Lesions of Vertebra
•
Exostoses over fractures with no displacement of vertebral bodies.
•
Similar exostoses on vertebral bodies of lambs grazing around old lead mines.
•
Hypovitaminosis A in young growing pigs causing compression of the nerve roots passing
through the vertebral foramina.
•
Congenital deformity or fusion of the atlantooccipital axial joints in calves, foals,
and goats.
•
Congenital spinal stenosis of calves.
•
Protrusion of an intervertebral disk is identifiable by myelogram or at necropsy,
5
although rare in large animals. The degenerative lesions in disks in the neck of the
horse resemble the Hansen type 2 disk prolapses in dogs.
•
Progressive paresis and ataxia also occur rarely in diskospondylitis in horses, an
inflammatory condition focused on a single intervertebral joint that often results
from a septic process.6, 7 Diskospondylitis has been diagnosed in a 4-month-old calf
with a stiff gait and umbilical abscess,
8
an adult goat with paraplegia,
9
and an alpaca with paraparesis.
10
•
Spondylosis occurs, which is a degenerative condition characterized by extensive osteophytes
on the vertebral body axis. Spondylus is an old Greek name meaning vertebra. Spondylosis
usually affects the ventral or lateral aspects of multiple adjacent vertebrae. It
is a progressive disease affecting contiguous vertebrae because of biomechanical stresses.
6
Ankylosing spondylosis typically cause lameness rather than compression of cord and
paresis/paralysis.
Adult sows and boars may have degeneration of intervertebral disks and surrounding
vertebral osteophytes. Less commonly are ankylosing spondylosis, arthrosis of articular
facets, defects in annulus fibrosus and vertebral end plates, and vertebral osteomyelitis
or fracture. These lesions of ankylosing spondylosis cause lameness in boars and sows
rather than compression of cord and paresis/paralysis. These are not to be confused
with the many extravertebral causes of posterior lameness or paralysis in adult pigs,
which are discussed in Chapter 15.
Vertebral Subluxation or Compressive Myelopathy
•
Cervicothoracic vertebral subluxation in Merino sheep in Australia and Columbia lambs
in the United States
•
Compressive cervical myelopathy in yearling Texel and Beltex sheep caused by fatty
nodules encroaching into the dorsal vertebral canal at C6-C7
11
Ataxia in Horses
This is a major problem and has numerous potential causes:
•
Nonfatal fractures of the skull (basisphenoid, basioccipital, and petrous temporal
bones)
•
Nonfatal cervical fractures
•
Atlantooccipital instability
•
Cervical vertebral malformation (equine cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy) caused
by stenosis of the cranial vertebral orifice of C3-C7
12
; this may be effective as a compression mechanism only if the vertebrae adopt exaggerated
positions
•
Abnormal growth of interarticular surfaces
•
Dorsal enlargement of caudal vertebral epiphyses and bulging of intervertebral disks
•
Formation and protrusion of false joint capsules and extrasynovial bursae
•
Spinal myelitis caused by parasitic invasion or EHV-1 virus, even louping-ill virus
and probably others
•
Spinal abscess usually in a vertebral body
•
Onchocerca sp.–induced spinal cord compression and axonopathy
13
•
Spinal hematomas
14
causing ataxia, paresis, and neck pain
•
Cerebellar hypoplasia (most commonly the inherited version in Arabian foals)
•
Degenerative myelomalacia/myelopathy (cause unknown)
•
Fusion of occipital bone with the atlas, which is fused with the axis
•
Hypoxic–ischemic neuromyopathy in aortoiliac thrombosis
•
Tumors of the meninges
Pathogenesis
The development of any of the lesions listed previously results in the gradual appearance
of motor paralysis or hypoesthesia, depending on whether the lesion is ventrally or
dorsally situated. In most cases there is involvement of all motor and sensory tracts,
but care is necessary in examination if the more bizarre lesions are to be accurately
diagnosed. There may be hemiparesis or hemiplegia if the lesion is laterally situated.
Paraparesis or paraplegia is caused by a bilateral lesion in the thoracic or lumbar
cord and monoplegia by a unilateral lesion in the same area. Bilateral lesions in
the cervical region cause tetraparesis to tetraplegia (quadriplegia).
Vertebral osteomyelitis in young calves is most common in the thoracolumbar vertebrae
and less commonly in the cervical vertebrae. The abscess of the vertebral body gradually
enlarges and causes gradual compression of the spinal cord, which causes varying degrees
of paresis of the pelvic limbs and ataxia. The abscess may extend into adjacent intervertebral
spaces and result in vertebral arthritis with lysis of the articular facets. The onset
of paresis and paralysis may be sudden in cases of abscessation or osteomyelitis of
the vertebrae, which may fracture and cause displacement of bony fragments into the
vertebral canal with compression and traumatic injury of the spinal cord. Vertebral
body abscesses between T2 and the lumbar plexus will result in weakness of the pelvic
limbs and normal flexor withdrawal reflexes of the pelvic limbs. Lesions at the site
of the lumbar plexus will result in flaccid paralysis of the pelvic limbs.
In horses with cervical vertebral malformation, compression of the spinal cord results
in necrosis of white matter and some focal loss of neurons. With time, secondary wallerian-like
neuron fiber degeneration in ascending white matter tracts cranial to the focal lesion
and in descending white matter tracts caudal to the lesion occurs. Astrocytic gliosis
is a prominent and persistent alteration of the spinal cord of horses with chronic
cervical compressive myelopathy and is associated with nerve fiber degeneration at
the level of the compression and in well-delineated areas of ascending and descending
nerve fiber tracts. It is possible that the persistent astrocytic gliosis may prevent,
or slow, recovery of neurologic function in affected horses.
Clinical Findings
Varying degrees of progressive weakness of the thoracic limbs or pelvic limbs may
be the initial clinical findings. With most lesions causing gradual spinal cord compression,
difficulty in rising is the first sign, then unsteadiness during walking caused by
weakness, which may be more marked in one of a pair of limbs. The toes are dragged
along the ground while walking and the animal knuckles over on the fetlocks when standing.
Finally, the animal can rise only with assistance and then becomes permanently recumbent.
These stages may be passed through in a period of 4 to 5 days.
The paralysis will be flaccid or spastic depending on the site of the lesion and reflexes
will be absent or exaggerated in the respective states. The dog-sitting position in
large animals is compatible with a spinal lesion caudal to the second thoracic vertebral
segment. Calves with vertebral osteomyelitis caudal to T2 are usually able to sit
up in the dog-sitting position; they are bright and alert and will suck the cow if
held up to the teat. In some cases, extensor rigidity of the thoracic limbs resembles
the Schiff–Sherrington syndrome and indicates a lesion of the thoracic vertebrae.
Lesions involving the lumbar plexus will result in flaccid paralysis of the pelvic
limbs and an absence of the flexor withdrawal reflexes. Lesions involving the sacrococcygeal
vertebrae will cause a decrease in tail tone, decreased or absent perineal reflex,
and urinary bladder distension.
Pain and hyperesthesia may be evident before motor paralysis appears. The pain may
be constant or occur only with movement. In vertebral body osteomyelitis in the horse,
vertebral column pain and a fever may be the earliest clinical abnormalities. With
neoplasms of the epidural space, the weakness and motor paralysis gradually worsen
as the tumor enlarges.
Considerable variation in signs occurs depending on the site of the lesion. There
may be local hyperesthesia around the site of the lesion and straining to defecate
may be pronounced. Retention of the urine and feces may occur. There is usually no
detectable abnormality of the vertebrae on physical examination.
Calves with congenital spinal stenosis are usually unable to stand or can do so only
if assisted. There are varying degrees of weakness and ataxia of the pelvic limbs.
They are bright and alert and will suck the cow if assisted. Those that survive for
several weeks will sometimes assume the dog-sitting position.
In the wobbler horse, circumduction of the limbs with ataxia is typical. The ataxia
is usually pronounced in the pelvic limbs, and weakness is evident by toe dragging
and the ease with which the horse can be pulled to one side while walking. Ataxia
with hypometria is often evident in the thoracic limbs, especially while walking the
horse on a slope and with the head elevated.
Clinical Pathology
Radiographic examination of the vertebral column should be performed if the animal
is of a suitable size. Myelography is necessary to demonstrate impingement on the
spinal cord by a stenotic vertebral canal. The CSF may show a cellular reaction if
there is some invasion of the spinal canal.
Necropsy Findings
Gross abnormalities of the vertebrae and the bony spinal canal are usually obvious.
Those diseases of the spinal cord characterized by degeneration without gross changes
require histologic techniques for a diagnosis.
Differential Diagnosis
Differentiation between abscess, tumor, and exostosis in the vertebral canal is usually
not practicable without radiographic examination. Vertebral osteomyelitis is difficult
to detect radiographically, particularly in large animals, because of the overlying
tissue. In bovine lymphosarcoma there are frequently signs caused by lesions in other
organs. A history of previous trauma may suggest exostosis. The history usually serves
to differentiate the lesion from acute trauma.
•
Spinal myelitis, myelomalacia, and meningitis may resemble cord compression but are
much less common. They are usually associated with encephalitis, encephalomalacia,
and cerebral meningitis, respectively.
•
Meningitis is characterized by much more severe hyperesthesia and muscle rigidity.
•
Rabies in the dumb form may be characterized by a similar syndrome but ascends the
cord and is fatal within a 6-day period.
In the newborn there are many congenital defects in which there is defective development
of the spinal cord. Most of them are not characterized by compression of the cord,
because the diminished function is caused in most cases by an absence of tissue. Spina
bifida, syringomyelia, and dysraphism are characterized by hindquarter paralysis or,
if the animal is able to stand, by a wide-based stance and overextension of the legs
when walking. Some animals are clinically normal.
A generalized degeneration of peripheral nerves such as that described in pigs and
cattle causes a similar clinical syndrome and so does polyradiculoneuritis. A nonsuppurative
ependymitis, meningitis, and encephalomyelitis, such as occurs in equine infectious
anemia, may also cause an ataxia syndrome in horses.
Paresis or paralysis of one limb (monoplegia) is caused by lesions in the ventral
gray matter, nerve roots, brachial and lumbosacral plexus, and peripheral nerves and
muscles of the limbs.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Successful treatment of partially collapsed lumbar vertebra by dorsal laminectomy
has been performed in calves.
1
Surgical treatment of cervical vertebral malformation (fusion of affected cervical
vertebrae) is performed in horses, but in farm animals treatment is usually not possible
and in most cases slaughter for salvage is recommended. Spinal hematomas of the cervical
cord in horses can recover spontaneously but surgical decompression may be helpful
in chronic cases.
14
Further Reading
Divers
TJ
Acquired spinal cord and peripheral nerve disease
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
231
242
15203224
References
1
Zani
DD
Vet Surg
37
2008
801
19121177
2
Ubiali
DG
Pesq Vet Bras
31
2011
997
3
Johnson
AL
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1481
23061655
4
Cudomre
LA
Aust Vet J
90
2012
392
23004230
5
Fews
D
Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol
19
2006
187
16972003
6
Denoix
JM
Equine Vet Educ
19
2007
72
7
Wong
DM
J Am Vet Med Assoc
247
2015
55
26086228
8
Hammond
G
Vet Rec
158
2006
600
16648443
9
Levine
GJ
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
47
2006
585
17153069
10
Zanolari
P
J Vet Intern Med
20
2006
1256
17063729
11
Penny
C
J Vet Intern Med
21
2007
322
17427395
12
Hoffman
CJ
Clark
CK
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
317
23480718
13
Hestvik
G
J Vet Diagn Invest
18
2006
307
16789725
14
Gold
JR
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
481
18346147
Back Pain in Horses
The subject of back pain, and its relationship to lameness, is a very important one
in horses. There is often a lesion in the vertebral canal and by pressing on the cord
or peripheral nerves it causes gait abnormalities that suggest the presence of pain,
or they actually cause pain. Spondylosis, injury to dorsal spinous processes, and
sprain of back muscles are common causes of the same pattern of signs. Because these
problems are largely orthopedic ones, and therefore surgical, their discussion is
left to other authorities.
It is necessary in horses to differentiate spinal cord lesions from acute nutritional
myodystrophy and subacute tying-up syndrome. Those diseases are characterized by high
serum creatine kinase and AST activities.
Parasitic Diseases Primarily Affecting the Spinal Cord
Equine Protozoal Myeloencephalitis
Synopsis
Etiology
Sarcocystis neurona, a protozoon. Neospora hughesi is an uncommon cause.
Epidemiology Sporadic disease occasionally occurring as localized epidemics. Endemic
throughout most of the Americas. Disease is infectious but not contagious. The definitive
host in North America is the opossum (Didelphis spp.), and other opossum species in
South America.
Clinical signs Variable, but commonly asymmetric spinal ataxia, focal, neurogenic
muscle atrophy, with or without cranial nerve dysfunction.
Clinical pathology No characteristic changes in blood or cerebrospinal fluid. Demonstration
of intrathecal production of antibodies to specific surface proteins (especially SnSAG2,
4/3) by measurement of antibodies in paired serum and CSF samples (ELISA).
Diagnostic confirmation Histologic demonstration of S. neurona or N. hughesi in nervous
tissue.
Lesions Nonsuppurative myeloencephalitis with schizonts and merozoites in neurons,
glial cells, and leukocytes.
Treatment Antiprotozoal agents, including ponazuril, diclazuril, or a combination
of a sulfonamide and pyrimethamine.
Control Prevent exposure to S. neurona by minimizing fecal contamination by opossums
of feed. No vaccine available.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
The cause is S. neurona, an apicomplexan protozoan that causes myeloencephalitis in
equids, sea otters, cats, raccoons, red pandas, dogs, and a small number of other
mammalian species.1, 2, 3 Fatal encephalitis in Southern sea otters and EPM in horses
is strongly linked to S. neurona sporocysts shed by opossums.4, 5 Isolates of S. neurona
can vary in their antigenic composition because some immunodominant surface proteins
(SnSAG 1, 2, 3, and 4) vary in either or both of their presence or antigenicity among
strains of S. neurona. For instance, some strains of S. neurona (e.g., SN4), including
some that are virulent in horses, lack the major surface antigen SnSAG-1.
6
This heterogeneity in the surface antigen composition of different S. neurona isolates
could be an important consideration for development of serologic tests and prospective
vaccines for EPM.
6
Neospora spp., including N. hughesi, cause myeloencephalitis in horses less frequently
than does S. neurona.
7, 8, 9
The subsequent discussion refers to EPM caused by S. neurona, with specific points
made in respect to N. hughesi.
Epidemiology
EPM occurs in horses and ponies in Canada, the United States, Central America, and
Brazil. Reports of neurologic disease in horses with antibodies to S. neurona in France
have yet to be confirmed but might represent cases of EPM in native horses outside
of the Americas. The disease is reported in other countries in only horses imported
from the Americas, and seroprevalence to S. neurona-specific antigens in Europe is
rare in horses not imported from the Americas.
10
Distribution of the disease appears to correlate with the range of the definitive
host, Didelphis virginiana in North America, or the related species D. marsupialis
and D. albiventris in South America. The disease has not been reported in donkeys
and mules. Neurologic disease associated with S. neurona has been reported in armadillos,
sea otters, harbor seals, skunks, raccoons, zebra, lynxes, dogs, porpoises, and cats.2,
3, 11, 12
The disease usually occurs sporadically in endemic areas, although epidemics on individual
farms are reported. The incidence of EPM is estimated to be 14 new cases per 10,000
horses per year. The case–fatality rate is approximately 7%, although up to 14% of
horses are sold or given away because they are affected by EPM. Approximately 40%
of horses recover completely and another 37% improve but do not recover from the disease.
Another study reports that only 55% of horses with EPM examined at a referral hospital
were alive a minimum of 3 years after diagnosis and treatment.
Seroepidemiologic studies, based on detection by Western immunoblot test of multiple
antibodies to S. neurona in serum, indicate that 45% to 60% of horses in the United
States are exposed to the agent but do not develop disease.
13
Antibodies to S. neurona are present in ~49% of 495 horse sera tested with the rSnSAG2/4/3
trivalent ELISA in the Durango state of Mexico, and antibodies to N. hughesi are present
in 3.0% of horse sera tested (rNhSAG1 ELISA and confirmed by Western blot of N. hughesi
tachyzoite antigen) in the same region.
14
Approximately 26% of horses in Argentina have antibodies to S. neurona, and 39% of
horses with neurologic disease are positive versus 22% of clinically normal horses.
15
Four percent of horses in southern Brazil have serum antibodies to N. hughesi.
16
Among horses in Israel, 12% of healthy horses are seropositive for antibodies to N.
hughesi, and 21% of horses with neurologic disease and 38% of mares that aborted are
seropositive.
17
Rates of seropositivity to S. neurona, N. hughesi, or both in North America are reported,
and differences in proportion of submitted samples are positive for either or both
species identified based on month of submission and various animal-related factors.
However, the sample was not random and results could have been heavily affected by
sampling bias.
18
Vaccination with a product containing killed S. neurona induces a detectable antibody
response in both serum and, in approximately 50% of horses, in the CSF.
Risk Factors
Risk factors for development of EPM include season of the year, with the highest incidence
of new cases in the summer and fall; age; use; protection of feed; and presence of
opossums on the farm.
19
The disease occurs in horses from 2 months to 19 years of age. Horses <1 year of age
are at lower risk of developing disease than are horse 1 to 4 years of age. Older
horses are less likely to develop the disease. Protection of feed from contamination
by opossum feces is associated with a decreased risk of disease, whereas the presence
of opossums on the premises was associated with an increased risk of disease. Horses
used primarily for racing and showing are at increased risk for developing EPM with
an annual incidence of 38 new cases per 10,000 horses for horses used for racing compared
with an incidence of 6 cases per 10,000 horses for horses used for pleasure or farm
work. Horses used for showing or competition have the highest annual incidence of
51 cases per 10,000 horses per year. The presence of previous illness is a risk factor
for development of EPM. Transportation for 55 hours increases the susceptibility to
EPM of horses experimentally infected with S. neurona. Relative to neurologic (non-EPM)
control horses, horses with EPM are more likely to be ≥2 years old and to have a history
of cats residing on the premises. Relative to nonneurologic control horses, horses
with EPM are more likely to be used for racing or Western performance.
20
Transmission
S. neurona has the two-host life cycle (predator–prey) typical of other Sarcocystis
and Toxoplasma spp.21, 22 The definitive host is the opossum, D. virginiana, and intermediate
hosts include raccoons,
23
cats, skunks, sea otters, armadillos, and cowbirds (Molothrus ater).
24
The domestic cat, nine-banded armadillo, raccoon, cowbird, and skunk can be infected
by ingestion of sporocysts and develop sarcocysts in muscle, which when fed to opossums,
induces shedding of sporocysts, confirming the potential for these species to serve
as intermediate hosts. Cats living on farms at which EPM has been diagnosed in horses
have a higher rate of seroprevalence (40%) than do cats living in a city (10%), providing
evidence for a role of cats in the epidemiology of the disease. However, others have
detected a lower prevalence of seropositivity (5%) to S. neurona among cats in Texas
and conclude that cats are not likely to play an important role in the epidemiology
of EPM. At least in those areas where raccoons are present they are probably the most
important intermediate host.
The definitive host is infected by ingestion of sarcocysts of S. neurona encysted
in muscle of the intermediate host. The intermediate host is infected by ingestion
of sporocysts derived from rupture oocysts passed in the feces of the definitive host.
Sporocysts can remain infective in the environment for months, but are probably, based
on behavior of other Sarcocystis spp. oocysts, killed by drying, high humidity, or
freezing and thawing. Birds and insects also serve as transport hosts. Sporocysts
ingested by the intermediate host undergo schizogony and ultimately form infective
sarcocysts in muscle. S. neurona sarcocysts have been detected in the muscle of a
4-month-old filly, suggesting that horses might serve as intermediate hosts of the
organism. This finding needs to be confirmed because the conventional wisdom is that
in horses S. neurona does not complete schizogony and remains as uninfective merozoites
in neural tissue. S. neurona sarcocysts do not occur in the muscle of horses; therefore
horses are not infective to other animals.
There is no evidence of transplacental infection of foals.
The definitive and intermediate hosts of N. hughesi have not been determined. Dogs
are the definitive host of the closely related N. caninum. N. hughesi can be transmitted
transplacentally from mares to foals, and it is suggested that infection with this
organism can persist in a band of horses by vertical transmision.25, 26
Pathogenesis
Details of the pathogenesis of EPM are unknown. It is assumed that after infection,
probably by ingestion, sporocysts excyst and release sporozoites, which penetrate
the gastrointestinal tract and enter endothelial cells. Subsequently, meronts (schizonts)
develop and on maturation rupture and release merozoites. Schizonts are present in
cells of the CNS, including neurons, glial cells, and intrathecal macrophages. Schizonts
multiply in the infected cells, as evidenced by the presence of merozoites. Infection
induces a nonsuppurative inflammation, characterized by accumulations of lymphocytes,
neutrophils, eosinophils, and gitter cells. Infection of neurons, and the associated
inflammatory reaction, disrupt normal nervous function and contribute to the clinical
signs of weakness, muscle atrophy, and deficits in proprioception.
Mechanisms permitting infection and proliferation of the organism have not been well
defined. Horses with EPM have lesser cell-mediated immunity than do asymptomatic horses,
and the decrease in cell-mediated immunity appears to be caused by S. neurona suppressing
immune responses to parasite-derived antigens. However, foals with severe combined
immunodeficiency administered S. neurona do not develop neurologic disease, despite
prolonged parasitemia and infection of visceral organs by the organism, whereas immunocompetent
horses do not have prolonged parasitemia but do develop neurologic disease.
Clinical Findings
The incubation period after experimental infection of young horses ranges between
28 and 42 days, but is not known for the spontaneous disease.
The clinical findings of EPM in horses are protean, and in endemic areas EPM should
be considered as a diagnosis in any horse with clinical signs referable to the nervous
system. S. neurona can infect any area of the brain and spinal cord, and may affect
more than one site in an individual horse, resulting in the wide range of neurologic
abnormalities associated with this disease.
Clinical signs of EPM range from barely perceptible changes in gait or behavior to
recumbency, muscle atrophy, or seizures. The onset of signs can be insidious and gradual,
or acute and rapidly progressive. Affected horses do not have increased temperature
or heart rate, unless complications of the nervous disease occur.
Spinal ataxia, evident as weakness, hypometria, or hypermetria, and defects in proprioception
are common manifestations of EPM. Multifocal spinal or cervical disease causes all
four limbs to be affected, whereas lesions caudal to the cervical intumescence cause
signs in the rear limbs only. Signs of spinal ataxia range from subtle changes in
gait, which are difficult to differentiate from obscure lameness caused by musculoskeletal
disease, through obvious spinal ataxia evident as truncal sway, toe dragging, and
circumduction of feet, to spontaneous falling and recumbency. Asymmetry of clinical
signs, in which one limb is affected more than the contralateral limb, is highly suggestive
of EPM because CSM and equine degenerative myelopathy usually cause symmetric ataxia.
Lesions in the sacral cord cause signs of cauda equina syndrome, including tail paresis
and urinary and fecal incontinence.
Lesions affecting spinal cord gray matter cause focal, asymmetric muscle atrophy,
absent reflexes, or focal areas of sweating. Muscles frequently affected include the
quadriceps, biceps femoris, epaxial muscles, and the supraspinatus/infraspinatus group.
EPM can present as a brachial plexus injury evident as radial nerve paralysis.
CN disease is a common manifestation of EPM. Common syndromes include the following:
•
Vestibular disease (CN VIII), evident as circling, nystagmus, head tilt, and falling
toward the affected side
•
Unilateral facial nerve paralysis (CN VII), evident as ear droop, lack of palpebral
or corneal reflex and menace on the affected side, and displacement of the upper lip
and nares away from the side of the lesion
•
Dysphagia (CNs IX, X, XII) and persistent dorsal displacement of the soft palate
•
Tongue paralysis (CN XII)
•
Masseter atrophy and weakness (CN V)
•
Hypalgesia (lack of sensation) of the nostrils and skin of the face (CN V)
EPM might also manifest as changes in personality and behavior, head-shaking, and
seizures.
Clinical disease caused by infection by N. hughesi is clinically indistinguishable
from that associated with S. neurona.
8, 9
Clinical Pathology
There are no characteristic changes in the hemogram or serum biochemical variables.
Diagnosis has focused on the demonstration of antibodies to S. neurona in serum or
CSF by Western blot, indirect fluorescence testing, or ELISA. The important concept
is use of paired serum and CSF samples to demonstrate intrathecal production of antibodies
to differentiate infection associated with neurologic disease from clinically inapparent
infection.13, 27, 28, 29
The sensitivity and specificity of Western blot (Sn 80%–89%, Sp 38%–87% on serum,
and Sn ~88% and Sp 44%–89% in CSF); indirect FAT (IFAT) (Sn 59%–94%, Sp 71%–100% in
serum, and Sn 65%–100%, Sp 90%–99% in CSF); SAG1 ELISA (Sn 13%–68%, Sp 71%–97% in
serum); and SAG2,4/3 ELISA (Sn 30%–86%, Sp 37%–88% in serum, Sn 77%–96% and Sp 58%–96%
in CSF) for detection of EPM have been recently reviewed.13, 28, 29 The combination
of serum and CSF testing using tests to detect antibodies to SAG2, 4/3 surface proteins
were the most sensitive and specific for diagnosis of horses with clinical signs of
neurologic disease.28, 29
Interpretation of the results of Western blot analysis of CSF for IgG antibodies to
S. neurona is problematic because of the potential for blood contamination of the
sample during collection, and the high sensitivity but low specificity of the test.
Blood contamination of the sample is problematic in horses that are seropositive for
antibodies to S. neurona and in which it is desired to know if antibodies are present
in CSF. Contamination of CSF with blood can introduce antibodies from serum into the
otherwise antibody-free CSF, causing a “false”-positive test. Contamination of CSF
with small quantities of blood with high concentrations of antibodies to S. neurona
might not be detectable using RBCs, albumin quotient, or immunoglobulin index, but
could yield a positive result on Western blot testing.
Foals of seropositive mares acquire antibodies, but not infection, by ingestion of
colostrum from the dam. These antibodies can be detected in both serum and CSF of
foals. The mean time for foals to become seronegative for antibodies to S. neurona
is 4.2 months. Detection of antibodies to S. neurona in serum or CSF of foals less
than 4 to 6 months of age, even those with neurologic disease, should be interpreted
with caution as the antibodies are likely derived from the dam.
An IFAT reliably detects antibodies to S. neurona in serum and CSF of infected horses.
28
This test has the advantages of providing quantitative results, is cheaper to perform,
and is more accurate than immunoblots in the detection of antibodies.
Examination of other variables in CSF is of limited use in the diagnosis of EPM, and
measurement of creatine kinase activity in CSF has no diagnostic usefulness. The use
of the albumin quotient or IgG index to detect blood contamination of CSF, or the
intrathecal production of IgG, is unreliable and not useful in the diagnosis of EPM.
Necropsy
Lesions are limited to the spinal cord and brain, with the exception of neurogenic
muscle atrophy. Gross lesions of hemorrhage and malacia may be visible in the CNS
tissue. The lesions are asymmetric, but may be more frequently encountered in the
cervical and lumbar intumescences of the spinal cord. Histologic examination reveals
multifocal necrosis of the nervous tissue with an accompanying infiltration of macrophages,
lymphocytes, neutrophils, and occasional eosinophils. This reaction is predomnantly
nonsuppurative and usually includes a degree of perivascular cuffing. Schizonts or
free merozoites may be evident in tissues but are difficult to locate without IHC
stains. The sensitivity of screening for the parasite in hematoxylin and eosin–stained
sections of nervous tissue from cases with histologic changes suggestive of EPM was
only 20%. The sensitivity improved to 51% when IHC staining of the tissue was used.
The same interpretative problems encountered when testing antemortem CSF samples apply
when the fluid is collected at postmortem. Isolation in cell culture systems is possible
but rarely attempted in diagnostic laboratories. PCR tests for these apicomplexan
parasites can yield false negatives because of the random distribution of the parasite
within CNS tissue.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Histology: fixed spinal cord (several levels, including cervical and lumbar intumescences)
and half of brain, including the entire brainstem, CN VII in some cases (LM, IHC,
PCR).
Differential Diagnosis
The clinical diagnosis of EPM should be based on the detection of unequivocal neurologic
abnormalities consistent with EPM, ruling out of other causes of neurologic disease
(listed next) and the detection of antibodies to S. neurona or N. hughesi in uncontaminated
samples of cerebrospinal fluid and serum to confirm intrathecal production of specific
antibodies.
13
A favorable response to treatment specific for EPM increases the likelihood that the
horse has EPM. A definitive diagnosis can only be achieved by necropsy.
•
Spinal ataxia.
•
Cauda equina syndrome: EPM should be differentiated from polyneuritis equi, equine
herpesvirus-1 myelopathy, and injection of long-acting anesthetics or alcohol around
sacral nerve roots.
•
Peripheral nerve lesions: other causes of focal muscle atrophy, such as brachial plexus
injury, damage to the supraspinatus nerve, or disuse atrophy can be differentiated
from EPM on history and clinical signs.
•
Cranial nerve disease: signs of vestibular disease, facial or trigeminal nerve dysfunction,
and dysphagia associated with EPM should be differentiated from the following:
•
Middle ear infection
•
Guttural pouch mycosis
•
Arthritis and fracture of the temporohyoid articulation
•
Head trauma
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Specific treatment of EPM involves the administration of antiprotozoal drugs including
ponazuril, diclazuril, nitazoxanide, or the combination of pyrimethamine and sulfadiazine.
Administration of the combination of sulfadiazine (or similar drug, 20 mg/kg, orally)
and pyrimethamine (1–2 mg/kg, orally) every 24 hours given 1 hour before feeding is
effective in approximately 60% to 70% of cases.
13
This treatment is continued for at least 90 days if complete resolution of clinical
abnormalities occurs, or longer if the signs of EPM do not resolve. Adverse effects
of the administration of a combination of a sulfonamide and pyrimethamine include
enterocolitis, anemia, and abortion. Folic acid is often added to the diet of horses
being treated for EPM, but this cannot be recommended because of its lack of efficacy
in preventing anemia in treated horses and its ability to cause severe congenital
abnormalities in foals born to treated mares and anemia and leukopenia in adult horses.
Orally administered synthetic folates interfere with normal folate metabolism in horses
being administered antifolate drugs resulting, paradoxically, in folate deficiency.
Adequate intake of folates in antiprotozoal-treated horses can be assured by feeding
a diet containing good quality green foliage.
Ponazuril, an active metabolite of toltrazuril, is usually administered at a dosage
of 5 mg/kg BW orally once daily for 28 days. At this dosage, and at 10 mg/kg orally
once daily for 28 days, administration of the drug results in resolution of clinical
signs in approximately 60% of horses with EPM. The initial dosage is 5 mg/kg every
24 hours, which is continued for 28 days if signs of improvement are evident after
14 days. If signs of improvement are not seen after 14 days, the dosage is increased
to 10 mg/kg orally every 24 for 14 days. Few adverse effects are noted, even at 30 mg/kg
orally once daily for 28 days. Diclazuril, which is available in the United States
as a pelleted product for oral administration to horses, is similarly effective and
free of serious adverse effects.13, 30, 31, 32
Nitazoxanide administration was associated with adverse effects including fever, anorexia,
diarrhea, and worsening of clinical signs of neurologic disease. It is no longer recommended
for treatment of EPM.
The decision to stop treatment in horses that do not completely recover is difficult.
Some authorities recommend resampling CSF and continuing treatment until antibodies
to S. neurona are no longer detectable. However, given that normal horses often have
antibodies in their CSF, and that some treated horses never lose their positive Western
blot test, the decision to stop treatment should not be based entirely on this variable.
Some horses have a transient worsening of clinical signs in the first week of treatment.
This is presumed to be from the effect of the antiprotozoal agent causing death of
protozoa with subsequent inflammation and further impairment of neurologic function.
Relapse of the disease occurs in some horses when administration of antiprotozoal
medication is stopped.
Supportive treatment of affected horses includes antiinflammatory drugs (flunixin
meglumine, 1 mg/kg intravenously, every 8–12 hours; dimethyl sulfoxide, 1 g/kg as
a 10% solution in isotonic saline intravenously, every 24 hours for 3 days) and nutritional
support for horses that cannot eat. Flunixin meglumine is often administered twice
daily for the first 3 to 5 days of treatment with ponazuril or nitazoxanide, purportedly
to reduce the inflammatory effects of death of protozoa in the CNS.
Treatment of EPM associated with infection by N. hughesi is based on the same principles
and medications as treatment of disease associated with S. neurona.
8
Control
Preventing contamination of feed and water with opossum feces is essential for preventing
EPM in animals. Sporocysts of S. neurona are resistant to the usual concentrations
of many of the conventional disinfectants including sodium hypochlorite (bleach),
2% chlorhexidine, 1% betadine, 5% benzyl chlorophenol, 13% phenol, 6% benzyl ammonium
chloride, and 10% formalin. The organism is killed by heating to 55°C for 15 minutes
or 60°C (140°F) for 1 minute. Although survival of sporocysts in different environmental
conditions outdoors has not been tested, sporocysts remained viable at 4°C (131°F)
for months.
22
Because protection of feed from contamination by opossums has been demonstrated to
reduce the risk of horses developing EPM, it is prudent to use measures to reduce
the exposure of animals and feed to opossum feces, and possibly feces of birds that
might act as transport hosts.
There is interest in pharmacologic means of preventing infection of horses by S. neurona.
Pyrantel pamoate has some efficacy against S. neurona in vitro but daily administration
(2.6 mg/kg BW in feed) does not prevent S. neurona infection of horses. Daily administration
of low doses of diclazuril to foals in endemic areas significantly reduces the rate
of seroconversion.30, 31, 32
There is no vaccine available for prevention of EPM associated with either S. neurona
or N. hughesi.
22
Further Reading
Dubey
JP
An update on Sarcocystis neurona infections in animals and equine protozoal myeloencephalitis
(EPM)
Vet Parasitol
209
2015
1
42
25737052
Reed
SM
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis: an updated consensus statement with a focus on
parasite biology, diagnosis, treatment and prevention
J Vet Intern Med
30
2016
References
1
Dubey
JP
Vet Parasitol
202
2014
194
24680604
2
Dubey
JP
Vet Parasitol
183
2011
156
21782345
3
Cooley
AJ
Vet Pathol
44
2007
956
18039914
4
Sundar
N
Vet Parasitol
152
2008
8
18243561
5
Rejmanek
D
Vet Parasitol
170
2010
20
20226596
6
Howe
DK
Int J Parasit
38
2008
623
7
Wobeser
BK
Can Vet J
50
2009
851
19881924
8
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
21
2007
1405
18196754
9
Finno
CJ
Vet Ophthalmol
13
2010
259
20618805
10
Arias
M
Vet Parasitol
185
2012
301
22019182
11
Ellison
S
Intern J Appl Res Vet Med
10
2012
243
12
Hsu
V
J Parasitol
96
2010
800
20476809
13
Reed
S
J Vet Intern Med
30
2016
491
26857902
14
Yeargan
MR
Parasite
20
2013
29
24016396
15
More
G
J Equine Vet Sci
34
2014
1051
16
de Moura
AB
Rev Bras Parasitologia Vet
22
2013
597
17
Kligler
EB
Vet Parasitol
148
2007
109
17614202
18
Pusterla
N
Vet J
200
2014
332
24703324
19
Morley
PS
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
616
18466255
20
Cohen
ND
JAVMA
231
2007
1857
18081525
21
Howe
DK
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
30
2014
659
25441115
22
Dubey
JP
Vet Parasitol
209
2015
1
25737052
23
Dryburgh
EL
J Parasitol
101
2015
462
25811893
24
Mansfield
LS
Vet Parasitol
153
2008
24
18342449
25
Pusterla
N
J Parasitol
97
2011
281
21506870
26
Antonello
AM
Vet Parasitol
187
2012
367
22436425
27
Johnson
AL
J Vet Intern Med
24
2010
1184
20707841
28
Johnson
AL
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
596
23517480
29
Reed
SM
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
1193
24033423
30
Hunyadi
L
J Vet Pharmacol Ther
38
2015
243
25329774
31
MacKay
RJ
Am J Vet Res
69
2008
396
18312139
32
Pusterla
N
Vet J
206
2015
236
26346260
Cerebrospinal Nematodiasis (Elaphostrongylosis)
Cerebrospinal nematodiasis, cerebrospinal elaphostrongylosis (CSE) or neurofilariosis
are disease of sheep, goats, and camelids caused by infestation of the brain and spinal
cord with the nematode Elaphostrongylus and related genera. This genus is closely
related to the lungworms of small ruminants but is found in the cranial subarachnoid
space, cranial venous sinuses, and occasionally in the spinal subarachnoid space.
Paralaphostrongylus tenuis occurs in white-tailed deer
1
and moose
2
in eastern North America and parts of western Canada, E. cervi in deer, sheep, and
goat in Europe3, 4, 5 and New Zealand, and E. rangiferi in reindeer in Scandinavia.
P. odocoilei has been found to infect bighorn sheep in North America.
6
Eggs or larvae are carried to the lungs, undergo a tracheal migration, and the first-stage
larvae are passed in the feces. The larvae are quite resistant to adverse environmental
conditions and enter slugs or snails to develop into infective larvae. The lifecycle
is complete when infected molluscs are ingested by deer and the larvae penetrate the
abomasum and migrate, possibly along spinal nerves, to the spinal cord where they
develop into adults and migrate into the subarachnoid space.
Clinical signs are not seen in infected deer, but in sheep, goats and New World Camelids
the worm continually moves through nervous system tissue causing limping and incoordination
followed by almost complete paralysis of the hindlimbs or of the neck, body, and all
four legs.3, 7, 8, 9 There are usually no signs of cerebral involvement, and affected
animals remain bright and continue to eat. If given supportive treatment, they may
survive for at least 1 month. P. tenuis also transmits to moose and is responsible
for the nervous signs in “moose sickness,” including the following
4
:
•
Weakness
•
Incoordination
•
Circling
•
Impaired vision
•
Blindness
•
Abnormal carriage of the head
•
Paralysis
•
Lack of fear of man
•
Aggressiveness
Histopathologic lesions include axonal degeneration and swelling, perivascular cuffing,
presence of hemosiderin-laden macrophages, and increased numbers of eosinophils.9,
10
Clinical signs of spinal cord disease attributed to Parelaphostrongylus tenuis appear
to diminish after treatment with high doses of oral fenbendazole (50 mg/kg, daily
for five days), although randomized clinical trials have not been completed to confirm
this impression.
No reliable treatment is available for CSE. Ivermectin has no effect on the adult
worms, possibly because the large molecules of this compound cannot pass the blood-brain
barrier.
5
One clinical report describes the treatment of 17 light to moderately affected goats
with an NSAID (flunixin meglumine) together with ivermectin and fenbendazole for 5
days.
6
Complete recovery occurred in three, partial recovery in eight, but euthanasia was
necessary for the remainder.
References
1
Jacques
CN
J Wildl Dis
51
2015
670
25973622
2
Maskey
JJ
Jr
J Wildl Dis
51
2015
670
25973622
3
Alberti
EG
J Helminthol
85
2011
313
20923583
4
Morandi
F
J Wildl Dis
42
2006
870
17255458
5
Sironi
G
Parasitologia
48
2006
437
6
Huby-Chilton
F
J Wildl Dis
42
2006
877
17255460
7
Tschuor
AC
Schweiz Arch Tierheiikd
148
2006
609
8
Dobey
CL
J Vet Diagn Invest
26
2014
748
25274743
9
Whitehead
CE
Bedenice
D
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
25
2009
385
19460647
10
McIntosh
T
Can Vet J
48
2007
1146
18050795
Setaria
Setaria spp. are long (5- to 10-cm) thread-like filarial nematodes commonly found
in the peritoneal cavity of most domestic animals. S. labiato-papillosa is a cosmopolitan
parasite of cattle, whereas S. digitata and the closely related, and perhaps synonymous,
species S. marshalli occur only in Asia.
1
S. equina is found worldwide in horses. S. tundra infects and causes significant economic
losses in reindeer in Finland.2, 3 Adult females produce motile embryos (microfilariae)
that circulate in the peripheral blood of the infected animal and are taken up by
mosquitoes. Infective larvae develop in the intermediate host and are released when
the mosquito subsequently feeds. S. labiato-papillosa reaches maturity in cattle in
8 to 10 months. Despite their size, the presence of these worms in the abdominal cavity
causes no significant clinical effect.
Serious disease may result if S. labiato-papillosa or S. digitata infect animals other
than their own natural host, especially horses, sheep, goats, and humans. In these
hosts, they migrate in an abnormal manner causing epizootic cerebrospinal nematodosis
(with local names including lumbar paralysis and kumri) when they invade the brain
and spinal cord. Juvenile S. digitata may also invade the eye. Although Setaria is
found in cattle in many countries, cerebrospinal nematodosis is largely restricted
to Israel, Japan, China, Korea, India, and Sri Lanka. The incidence is increasing
in Taiwan, and a single case has been reported from the United States. Ocular filariasis
is seen most commonly in Japan. These diseases occur during summer and autumn when
the vectors are most prevalent. The cerebrospinal form sometimes occurs in epidemic
proportions, causing the death of horses, sheep, and goats.
Cerebrospinal nematodiosis may be rapid in onset with affected animals dying within
a few days or it may occur gradually over a few days. There may be acute or subacute
paresis with weakness and incoordination or paralysis involving the hindlegs most
commonly, but sometimes all four legs are involved. Recovery is only partial in many
animals but others show only a mild neurologic disorder, which gradually becomes indiscernible.
There are no systemic signs and the animals may continue to eat. Other diseases causing
similar clinical signs include enzootic equine ataxia in horses and paralytic rabies
in sheep and goats as lesions as well as traumatic injury, spinal cord abscess, warble
fly larvae, S. vulgaris, or H. gingivalis.
At necropsy, there are no macroscopic changes and sections need to be taken from many
levels of the spinal cord to find histologic lesions. Focal areas of malacia or microcavitation
are seen and in adjacent sites there may be loss of myelin, axonal swelling, degeneration,
and gitter cell formation. Migratory pathways are indicated by necrotic tracts. Where
nervous signs have been present for only a few days, a worm or worm fragments may
occasionally be found. Molecular techniques have been developed for identifying the
responsible species.
S. tundra causes peritonitis, perihepatitis, and significant decrease in body condition
score in reindeer calves.2, 3 Treatment of infected reindeer with ivermectin (0.2 mg/kg,
subcutaneously) has up to 95% efficacy of worm elimination.
2
Application of biting insect repellant (deltamethrin) significantly decreases S. tundra
infections in reindeer.
2
Anthelmintics will not resolve existing lesions but may prevent further damage. Little
has been published on treatment or control. Ivermectin gave moderate efficacy (80%–88%)
against adult S. equina in ponies. In a field study, none of 221 goats and sheep injected
twice with ivermectin at a dose of 0.2 mg/kg developed setariasis, whereas 17 of 303
noninjected animals suffered from the disease.
Further Reading
Taylor
MA
Coop
RL
Wall
RL
Veterinary Parasitology
2007
Wiley-Blackwell
Oxford, UK
References
1
Laaksonen
S
Acta Vet Scand
50
2008
49
19087262
2
Laaksonen
S
Vet Rec
160
2007
835
17575247
3
Nakano
H
J Vet Med Sci
69
2007
413
17485931
Toxic Diseases Primarily Affecting the Spinal Cord
Stringhalt
Stringhalt is an involuntary, exaggerated flexion of the hock during walking. It can
affect one or both hindlimbs. Classic stringhalt occurs sporadically, is usually unilateral,
and is usually irreversible without surgical intervention. Stringhalt can also occur
secondarily to injury to the dorsal metatarsus.
A clinically identical disease, Australian stringhalt, occurs in outbreaks in Australia,
New Zealand, California, Japan, Europe, the UK, Brazil, and Chile.1, 2, 3, 4, 5 The
outbreaks tend to occur in late summer or autumn and are related to drought conditions
or overgrazing of pasture with consequent ingestion of plants that would otherwise
not be eaten. Outbreaks in Australia, California, and Virginia are related to the
ingestion of
Hypochaeris radicata
(flatweed, cats ear).
4
Other plants suspected to play a role in the etiology include Taraxacum officinale
(dandelion), Arctotheca calendula (capeweed), or Malva parviflora (mallow) but good
evidence of the role of any of these latter plants is lacking.
The pathogenesis of the disorder is likely related to the presence of toxins in H.
radicata, especially after it is stressed.
6
The toxin or toxins have not been identified but are unlikely to be mycotoxins.
4
The disease has been experimentally induced by feeding a colt 9.8 kg per day for 19
days of H. radicata harvested fresh from a pasture on which horses had developed disease.
5
The disease resolved when the colt was fed H radicata from a pasture with unaffected
horses. Signs in the colt resolved within 15 days of last feeding the toxic plant.
5
Clinical signs are distinctive. The abnormal movement is only elicited when the horse
begins to move forward. The characteristic movement occurs in mildly affected horses
when they are backed or turned. Most cases are manifested by a flexion of the hock
that can be violent enough for the horse to kick itself in the abdomen. The hoof is
held in this position for a moment and then stamped hard on the ground. If both hindlegs
are affected, progress is very slow and difficult and the horses often use a bunny-hopping
gait. In the most severe cases the horse is unable to rise without assistance. The
horse's general health is unaffected, although it may be difficult for it to graze.
Some cases have other signs of neurologic disease such as stiffness of the forelimbs
or respiratory distress caused by laryngeal paralysis. Many affected horses have unilateral
(usually left) laryngeal hemiplegia evident on endoscopic examination of the larynx.
EMG examination reveals markedly abnormal activity including prolonged insertion activity,
fibrillation potentials, and positive waves at rest and enhanced EMG activity in the
right lateral digital extensor muscle on muscle contraction consistent with denervation.
The changes are most severe in the long digital extensor muscle. Most horses recover
without treatment, although complete recovery might not occur for over 1 year.
Biopsy of the superficial peroneal nerve and the long digital extensor muscle can
be useful in providing an antemortem diagnosis. The superficial peroneal nerve of
an affected horse had loss of large myelinated fibers, axonal degeneration, and myelin
splitting.
7
There are no characteristic abnormalities in a complete blood count or serum biochemical
profile. Pathologic findings are restricted to a peripheral neuropathy in the tibial,
superficial peroneal, and medial plantar nerves and in the left and right recurrent
laryngeal nerves. Lesions in affected muscles are consistent with denervation atrophy
and fiber type grouping.
The signs of the disease are characteristic. Differential diagnosis of the disease
involving one leg is ossifying myopathy of the semimembranosus and semitendinosus
muscles. Lead toxicosis can induce similar signs in horses.
Recovery is spontaneous in most cases (50% over an 8-month period in one large case
series).
2
Treatment with phenytoin (15 mg/kg orally daily for 14 days) effects some improvement
but the signs recur within 1 or 2 days after treatment is discontinued.
2
Myotenectomy of the lateral digital extensor muscle and tendon is reported to provide
immediate relief in affected horses, even in those horses with severe bilateral disease.
Control involves the prevention of overgrazing of pastures, particularly during droughts,
and restricting or eliminating access to H. radicata.
References
1
de Pennington
N
Vet Rec
169
2011
476
2
Domange
C
J Anim Physiol Nutr
94
2010
712
3
Schultze
C
Pferdeheilkunde
25
2009
115
4
El Hage
C
Investigation Into the Cause of Australian Stringhalt
2011
Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation
Canberra
1
5
Araujo
JAS
Toxicon
52
2008
190
18617211
6
MacKay
RJ
Toxicon
70
2013
194
23665449
7
Armengou
L
J Vet Intern Med
24
2010
220
20002548
Inherited Diseases Primarily Affecting the Spinal Cord
Spastic Paresis of Cattle (Elso Heel)
This disease occurs in the Holstein, Aberdeen Angus, Red Danish, Ayrshire, Beef Shorthorn,
Poll Hereford, Murray Grey, and many other breeds of cattle. It has been observed
in crossbred Brahman cattle and in an Ayrshire × Beef Shorthorn crossbred steer. The
disease occurs principally in calves, with signs appearing from several weeks to 6
months or more after birth. Occasional cases are reported as developing in adult European
cattle, and there is one report of the occurrence of the disease in adult Indian cattle.
The disease was first termed Elso heel based on its first description in 1922 as a
heritable disease from an East Friesian bull named Elso II. The preferred name spastic
paresis was first used in 1932 to emphasize the primary defect.
1
It has been held for a long time that the disease is inherited, and the principal
argument has centered on the mode of inheritance. Attempts to determine this have
shown that the rate of occurrence in planned test matings is so low that, if inheritance
is involved, it can only be the inheritance of a susceptibility to the disease. It
is suggested that different time appearances represent a single disease entity with
varying expressivity, with the late forms affected by cumulative environmental factors.
A proposed hypothesis is of a gene with increased penetrance in the homozygote, with
weak penetrance in the heterozygote, acting on a polygenic basis dependent on external
factors. Males appear to be affected more often than females, but a clear sex predilection
has not been identified. The prevalence of disease appears to be <1% in all breeds.
1
Infectious agents causing transmissible subacute spongiform encephalopathies interacting
with trace elements such as lithium have been suggested as etiologic agents, but there
is no evidence to support this hypothesis.
In all forms of the disease in most cattle breeds (exceptions being the Belgian Blue
and Romagnola in which the excessive tone occurs in the quadriceps femoris muscle;
the lesion is usually bilateral) there is excessive tone of the gastrocnemius muscle
and straightness of the hock, usually more marked in one hindleg. If only one leg
is affected, it may be thrust out behind while the calf is walking and advanced with
a restricted, swinging motion often without touching the ground. There is no resistance
to passive flexion of the limb and the animal appears normal while sitting. Clinical
signs are most exaggerated after immediately encouraging a sitting animal to stand.
The gastrocnemius and perforatus muscles are rigid and in a state of spastic contraction.
There is a characteristic elevation of the tail (Fig. 14-19
). The lameness becomes progressively worse and affected animals spend much time lying
down. Much BW is lost and the animal is usually destroyed between 1 and 2 years of
age.
Fig. 14-19
Spastic paresis in an 8-month-old Holstein Friesian heifer. Both hindlegs are excessively
straight, the left hindleg is held caudally and above the ground, and the tail is
characteristically held away from the body.
Fig. 14-19
Minor lesions described as regressive changes in the neurons of the red nucleus, in
the reticular substance, and in the lateral vestibular nucleus are of doubtful significance,
as are the observed reduction in inorganic phosphate and ascorbic acid levels in the
blood and CSF of affected calves. A lower than normal CSF concentration of a central
neurotransmitter, dopamine, could also be an effect rather than a cause.
There are demonstrable lesions on radiologic examination of the tarsus with remodeling
of the calcaneus bone and development of an enlarged and irregular epiphysis of the
calcaneus caused by chronic and repetitive strain that straightens the hindlimb. Extensive
examinations of muscles and tendons have failed to reveal histologic abnormalities.
The absence of any structural lesion and the variation in intensity of the abnormality
suggests that it is a functional one. An overactive stretch reflex is thought to be
responsible for the clinical signs, possibly caused by defective glycinergic synaptic
transmission and alteration of calcium signaling proteins (Fig. 14-20
).1, 2
Fig. 14-20
Simplified drawing of the γ-motor neuron system. In cattle with spastic paresis, spinal
cord neurons are thought to provide defective control to the γ-motor neuron system,
most likely by overstimulation or sufficient inhibition. During the normal stretch
reflex the extrafusal skeletal muscle fibers are lengthened, stretching the muscle
spindle. This stretch is detected and a signal sent via the afferent axon to the dorsal
root. The signal is then sent directly to the α-motor neurons, resulting in muscle
contraction. γ-Motor neurons in the ventral spinal cord that are controlled by the
central nervous system appear to inappropriately modulate the sensitivity of the stretch
reflex system, resulting in sustained and excessive contraction.
Fig. 14-20
(Reproduced with permission from De Vlamynck C. Vet J 2014; 202:229-235.)
The diagnosis of spastic paresis is based on history, signalment, clinical signs,
and progressive nature of the disease. A genetic test is currently unavailable because
the underlying gene defect(s) have yet to be identified. An epidural injection of
0.38% procaine solution diminishes the clinical signs of spastic contracture within
10 to 15 minute and has provided a useful supporting diagnostic test when the gastrocnemius
is the principal muscle of contracture; it is less helpful in cases of spastic contraction
of the quadriceps. In the latter case ultrasound-guided infiltration around the femoral
nerve with local anesthetic solution may be attempted.1, 3
In Europe, affected animals are kept for breeding purposes, especially if they are
double-muscled. They are kept because of the efficacy of the curative surgical operation
(partial tibial neurectomy) and for the high incidence of double-muscling in such
calves. In the Holstein breed, and several German breeds, bulls that sire affected
calves have been observed to have very straight hocks and to suffer from various forms
of stifle and hock lameness early in life.
The only effective treatment is surgical. Several surgical techniques including tenectomy,
partial tibial neurectomy, and triple tenectomy have been described. The most effective
technique appears to be partial tibial neurectomy performed under caudal epidural
anesthesia with electrical stimulation used to identify the tibial nerve.
4
In a large case series on 113 Belgian Blue calves with spastic paresis, a telephone
follow-up of the owners 3 months later revealed good results in 83%, a considerable
improvement in 4%, severe hyperflexion of the hock necessitating early culling for
slaughter in 5%, and in 8% there was little or no improvement.
Further Reading
De Vlamynck
C
Bovine spastic paresis: current knowledge and scientific voids
Vet J
202
2014
229
235
25201252
References
1
De Vlamynck
C
Vet J
202
2014
229
25201252
2
Pariset
L
BMC Vet Res
9
2013
122
23782433
3
De Vlamynck
CA
Am J Vet Res
74
2013
750
23627388
4
Milne
MH
UK Vet
12
2007
1
Inherited Congenital Myoclonus (Hereditary Neuraxial Edema)
This congenital defect of the nervous system has been reported only in Poll Hereford
cattle or their crossbreds and appears to be transmitted by inheritance in an autosomal
recessive pattern. A similar disease has been tentatively recorded in Peruvian Paso
horses. At birth affected calves are unable to sit up or rise and are very sensitive
to external stimuli, manifested by extreme extensor spasm, including fixation of thoracic
muscles and apnea, especially if lifted and held upright. The response is one of hyperesthesia
with myoclonic jerks of skeletal muscles in response to external stimuli or spontaneously.
The intellect of the calves seems unaffected, vision is normal, they drink well, and
can be reared but at a great cost in time. Intercurrent disease is common and calves
usually die of pneumonia or enteritis before they are 1 month old.
All affected calves have subluxations of the hip joints or epiphyseal fractures of
the femoral head caused by muscle spasms in the fetus. Their gestation length is shorter
than that of normal calves by 9 days.
There are no microscopic lesions in the CNS, but there is a biochemical defect—severe
alterations in spinal cord glycine-mediated neurotransmission. The specific and marked
defect in glycine receptors and the increase in neuronal uptake of glycine are accompanied
by a change in the major inhibitory system in the cerebral cortex. It has also been
shown that there is a specific and marked deficit of [3H] strychnine-binding sites
in the spinal cord. The disease needs to be differentiated from two other congenital,
presumed hereditary, diseases of newborn Herefords—maple syrup urine disease and “congenital
brain edema”—in which spongy degeneration of the CNS is accompanied by severe edema
of the gray and white matter. These two diseases are assumed to represent those cases
of congenital disease, originally bracketed with inherited congenital myoclonus, in
which there was vacuolation of nervous tissue in the CNS.
Inherited Spinal Dysmyelination
Bovine spinal dysmyelination is a congenital neurologic disease occurring in several
national cattle breeds upgraded with American Brown Swiss cattle. The disease was
first described in the Red Danish Dairy breed. In Denmark, all cases are genetically
related to the ABS bull White Cloud Jason's Elegant. It is inherited as an autosomal
recessive trait. Genetic mapping of the gene in crossbred American Brown Swiss cattle
to the bovine chromosome II has been done.
Clinically, in calves there is lateral recumbency, opisthotonus, limb extension, normal
to increased reflexes, and mental alertness. Dysmyelination is present, including
axonal degeneration and astrogliosis, in spinal tracts, especially the ascending gracile
funiculus and dorsolateral spinocerebellar tracts and the descending sulcomarginal
tract. This is probably the same defect as spinal muscular atrophy.
Inherited Neurodegeneration (Shaker Calf Syndrome)
This is an inherited, degenerative disorder of horned Hereford calves. Newborn calves
show severe tremor, difficulty in rising, spastic gait, and aphonia. Terminally there
is spastic paraplegia. Histologically, there are accumulations of neurofilaments within
neurons. A similar disease in Holstein Friesians occurs only in males. There are severe
degenerative changes in the spinal cord with spongiform lesions and some cavitation.
It has the epidemiologic distribution of a sex-linked recessive mutation.
Inherited Spinal Dysraphism
This is found as a congenital defect in Charolais calves and is associated with arthrogryposis
and cleft palate. Spinal cord anomalies can be associated with a large number of vertebral
abnormalities because of the close association of spinal cord and vertebral column
during embryology. Other developmental defects that lead to congenital abnormalities
include spinal cord hypoplasia and syringomyelia (tubular cystic cavitation containing
CSF that extends over several spinal cord segments) in calves1, 2; however, many of
these developmental abnormalities are accidents of embryology and do not necessarily
imply the presence of an inherited condition.
References
1
Binanti
B
Anat Histol Embryol
42
2012
316
23094595
2
Burnside
WM
J Am Vet Med Assoc
244
2014
661
24568106
Inherited Congenital Posterior Paralysis
Two inherited forms of congenital posterior paralysis are recorded in cattle. In Norwegian
Red Poll cattle posterior paralysis is apparent in affected calves at birth. Opisthotonus
and muscle tremor are also present. No histologic lesions have been found. The disease
is conditioned by an inherited recessive factor. In Red Danish and Bulgarian Red cattle
a similar condition occurs but there is spastic extension of the limbs, particularly
the hindlimbs, and tendon reflexes are exaggerated. Histologic examination has revealed
degenerative changes in midbrain motor nuclei. Both defects are lethal because of
prolonged recumbency.
An inherited posterior paralysis has been recorded in several breeds of swine in Europe.
Affected pigs are able to move their hindlimbs but are unable to stand on them. They
are normal in other respects. Degeneration of neurons is evident in cerebral cortex,
midbrain, cerebellum, medulla, and spinal cord. The disease is conditioned by the
inheritance of a recessive character. An inherited progressive ataxia is also recorded
in Yorkshire pigs.
Inherited Bovine Degenerative Axonopathy
Reported in Holstein Friesian calves in Australia, most affected calves are affected
at birth by recumbency; hyperesthesia or depression; rigidity of limbs; tremor, especially
of the head; nystagmus, apparent blindness, and the development of opisthotonus and
tetanic spasms when stimulated. At necropsy the consistent lesion is a severe, diffuse,
axonal swelling and loss in the spinal cord and brainstem. The cause is unknown but
the indicators point to an inherited cause.
Degenerative Axonopathy of Tyrolean Grey Cattle
A new neurologic disease was identified in Tyrolean Grey cattle in Switzerland in
2003 and was initially named Demetz syndrome.
1
The clinical presentation is similar to that seen in weaver syndrome of Brown Swiss
cattle but clinical signs are first evident at 4 to 6 weeks of age. Calves exhibit
mild ambulatory paraparesis with moderate to severe ataxia being more severely affected
in the hindlimbs. The disease is progressive and affected calves are usually slaughtered
by 10 months of age.
A mutation in the mitofusin 2 gene (a mitochondrial membrane protein) was identified
that truncates the last 22 amino acids. Pedigree analysis indicated that the gene
mutation occurred before 1972, and gene testing indicated a current carrier frequency
of approximately 10%. Marker assisted selection is currently being used to eliminate
degenerative axonopathy from this breed.
Reference
1
Drogemuller
C
PLoS ONE
6
2011
e18931
21526202
Central and Peripheral Axonopathy of Maine Anjou (Rouge-Des-Prés) Cattle
A new neurologic disease was identified in Maine Anjou cattle in France in 2008. Affected
calves were 1 to 4 months of age and exhibited mild to severe truncal ataxia with
mild to moderate paraparesis. The pelvic limbs were much more severely affected than
the thoracic limbs. Clinical signs were rapidly progressive and calves became recumbent
within 1 to 3 weeks of being examined, at which time they were euthanized. Mentation
remained normal for the calves.
Histopathologic examination revealed marked degeneration of axons and myelin and the
dorsolateral and ventromedial funiculi of the distal spinal cord (important tracts
for transmitting proprioceptive information from the hindlimbs), lateral vestibular
nuclei, caudal cerebellar peduncles, and thoracic nuclei.
Inherited Progressive Degenerative Myeloencephalopathy (Weaver Syndrome) of Brown
Swiss Cattle
The defect is inherited in Brown Swiss cattle. It appears first in calves when they
are 6 months to 2 years old, with a small number more than 2 years, and is manifested
by progressive bilateral hindlimb weakness and proprioceptive deficits causing difficulty
in rising and a weaving, hypermetric gait, goose-stepping with the forelimbs, and
dragging the hindlimbs. The limb reflexes are normal. The calves are bright and alert
throughout. There is a broad-based stance and finally recumbency and, after a course
of 12 to 18 months, inevitable euthanasia. Necropsy lesions include axonal degeneration,
including spheroid formation, and vacuolation of white matter in the cerebellum and
at all levels of the spinal cord but especially in the thoracic segment. There is
some neurogenic atrophy of muscles but there is no muscular dystrophy. The defect
can be identified by examination of chromosomes. It appears to be linked chromosomally
with high milk yield traits.
Inherited Progressive Ataxia
This well-recognized disease occurs in Charolais cattle. The first onset of signs
is at about 12 months of age when the gait is seen to be stiff and stumbling, especially
in the hindlimbs, and the hindtoes are dragged. The ataxia may be asymmetric, and
the animal cannot back up. The ataxia progresses over a period of 1 to 2 years. Affected
animals tend to be down a lot and have difficulty in rising and posturing for urination.
Urination is abnormal; it is a squirting but continuous flow that soils the tail.
Some affected animals nod their heads from side to side when excited. Both males and
females are affected. It has been described occurring in 2-year-old Charolais steer
in New Zealand. Characteristic necropsy lesions are confined to the CNS and are histopathologic.
The white matter of the cerebellum and internal capsule contains multiple foci of
oligodendroglial dysplasia. The somatic lymph nodes contain nodules of hyperplastic
lymphoid follicles, some catarrh of the medullae of the nodes, and an accumulation
of eosinophils.
Inherited Spinal Myelinopathy
There is a progressive spinal myelinopathy of Murray Grey cattle, similar to that
seen in Charolais cattle. It is possibly genetic in origin. Some calves are affected
at birth; others do not become affected until 1 year old. The syndrome is one of a
progressing paresis, without significant ataxia leading to paresis and permanent recumbency.
There are degenerative lesions in spinal cord, midbrain, and cerebellum. The disease
is conditioned by an autosomal recessive gene.
Inherited Periodic Spasticity of Cattle
Inherited periodic spasticity has been observed in Holstein and Guernsey cattle and
usually does not appear until the animals are adults. A recent report described it
in a Canadian Hereford bull with an early onset between 1 and 2 years of age. It is
a particular problem in mature bulls maintained in artificial insemination centers.
In the early stages the signs are apparent only on rising; the hindlimbs are stretched
out behind and the back depressed (Fig. 14-21
). Marked tremor of the hindquarters may be noted. Initially the attacks persist only
for a few seconds but are of longer duration as the disease progresses and may eventually
last for up to 30 minutes. Movement is usually impossible during the attacks. The
tetanic episodes fluctuate in their severity from time to time but there is never
any abnormality of consciousness. Lesions of the vertebrae have been recorded but
no lesions have been found in the nervous system. Idiopathic muscle cramps have been
suggested as a cause. The disease is familial and the mode of inheritance appears
to be by inheritance of a single recessive factor with incomplete penetrance.
Fig. 14-21
Inherited periodic spasticity in a Holstein Friesian bull. The signs are apparent
only on rising; the hindlimbs are stretched out behind and the back depressed.
Fig. 14-21
Administration of the spinal cord depressant, mephenesin (3–4 g/100 kg BW given orally
in three divided doses and repeated for 2–3 days) controls the more severe signs.
A single course of treatment may be effective for some weeks.
Neuraxonal Dystrophy
Neuraxonal dystrophy represents a heterogeneous group of degenerative diseases of
genetic or acquired etiology that is characterized by spheroidal swellings of axons
called spheroid bodies, which is the result of accumulation of axoplasmic organelles
including neurofilaments. The change may be physiologic (caused by normal aging) or
pathologic and are categorized as primary (familial) or secondary (acquired).
1
EDM is considered a more severe variant of neuraxonal dystrophy and is discussed separately.
Neuraxonal Dystrophy of Sheep (Segmented Axonopathy)
This is reported in Suffolk, Merino, Romney, Perendale, Coopworth, and crossbred sheep.
1
An inherited defect (autosomal recessive) is suspected in all cases. Abnormalities
appear related to abnormal axonal transport and the inability to maintain integrity
of the axon and their associated myelin sheaths.
2
In Coopworth sheep the lambs are affected at birth but have a progressive syndrome
in which cerebellar and proprioceptive signs predominate. Most die by 6 weeks of age.
Large axonal spheroids are present in the spinal cord and midbrain, and there is a
severe depletion of Purkinje cells in the cerebellum.
In Suffolk sheep the disease does not appear until 1 to 6 months; signs are a gradual
onset of ataxia, followed by recumbency, leading to death or euthanasia. Spheroids
in CNS axons are characteristic, mostly in the spinal cord and cerebellum, and contain
large amounts of amyloid precursor protein.
1
The disease in Merinos is in fine-wool sheep, is probably the same disease as that
previously called Murrurrundi disease, and does not appear until 4 to 6 years of age.
Most cases require euthanasia after about 2 months but some mild cases survive for
up to 3 years. The clinical signs include a wide-based stance, dysmetria of all limb
movements with a pronounced hypermetria of the forelimbs resulting in frequent falling,
a fine intention tremor of the head, and a diminished menace reflex. A similar disease
of medium-wool Merinos, characterized by progressive posterior ataxia and degeneration
of sensory tracts in thoracic segments of spinal cord, commencing after 5 months of
age and terminating fatally before 2 years of age, is also recorded in Australia.
It is probably also an inherited defect
Neuraxonal Dystrophy of Horses
In horses, neuraxonal dystrophy has been reported in Quarter Horses, Haflingers, Morgans,
Appaloosas, Paso Finos, and Standardbreds with a familial occurrence present in a
number of breeds.3, 4 The onset of clinical signs can be as early as a few months
of age. Common neurologic abnormalities include ataxia, proprioceptive positioning
deficits, dysmetria, a wide-based stance, obtundation, and an inconsistent menace
response with no detectable visual impairment.
3
Clinical progression can be very slow over a few months to years, and in some cases
stabilization of clinical signs may occur.
3
It can be difficult to clinically differentiate neuraxonal dystrophy from EDM; however,
the latter is considered a more severe clinical variant of neuraxonal dystrophy.
5
Clinical signs of ocular disease are not detectable and the results of ERG and EEG
are within the normal range.
6
Lesions at necropsy are only apparent microscopically and include specific tracts
and nuclei in the caudal medulla and spinal cord, with occasional involvement of the
cerebellum.
References
1
Finnie
JW
Aust Vet J
92
2014
389
25123686
2
Jolly
RD
New Zeal Vet J
54
2006
210
3
Aleman
M
J Am Vet Med Assoc
239
2011
823
21916766
4
Brosnahan
MM
J Vet Intern Med
23
2009
1303
19747195
5
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
177
23186252
6
Finno
CJ
Vet Ophthalmol
15
suppl 2
2012
3
22432889
Caprine Progressive Spasticity
A possibly inherited progressive paresis of Angora goats is recorded in Australia.
Signs first appear at about 2 months of age, commencing with lethargy, followed by
ataxia, then paresis progressing to sternal recumbency and eventual euthanasia. Tendon
reflexes are normal but the kids have difficulty getting to their feet, especially
in the hindlimbs. The gait is ataxic with frequent stumbles, and the kids are unwilling
to run. At necropsy there are many large, clear vacuoles in many neurons of the spinal
cord, posterior brainstem and midbrain, and degeneration of nerve fibers in the same
areas and peripheral nerves.
Inherited Spontaneous Lower Motor Neuron Diseases
Motor neuron diseases involve selective degeneration of upper and/or motor neurons.
Upper motor neurons originate in the cranial vault, where they stimulate contraction
of muscles. In comparison, lower motor neurons connect the brainstem and spinal cord
to the muscle fibers.
1
Effective treatments for motor neuron diseases have yet to be identified.
A lower motor neuron disease in newborn Romney lambs has been described.
1
Lambs are normal at birth but within 1 week they developed weakness and ataxia, which
progressed until they were unable to stand. The principal histologic lesions were
degeneration and loss of neurons in the ventral horns of the spinal cord and brainstem,
wallerian degeneration of ventral rootlets and motor nerves, and associated denervation
atrophy of skeletal muscle fibers. Large fibrillar spheroids were found in white and
gray matter including nuclei in the brainstem. One missense mutation on the sheep
called the ATP/GTP-binding protein 1 gene was identified in all affected animals,
exhibiting recessive pattern of inheritance.
1
This binding protein plays a role in protein turnover by cleaving peptides into amino
acids. A similar, though not identical, disease of newborn lambs has been recorded
in a Dorset Down flock affecting about 20% of lambs. They lay with hindlimbs tucked
under the body and forelimbs splayed sideways.
This progressive disease of Yorkshire piglets 5 to 10 weeks of age is presumed to
be inherited. Clinical signs include hindlimb tremor, weakness, and ataxia appearing
at 2 to 5 weeks of age. The gait includes fetlock knuckling, short choppy steps, and
a tendency to collapse after a few steps. Segmental and postural reflexes are normal.
By 10 weeks there is complete hindlimb paralysis, the pig is in sternal recumbency,
and front limb paralysis has begun. The appetite is good and the pig is bright and
alert. On necropsy there is symmetric degeneration and loss of motor neurons in the
spinal cord in some ventral spinal nerve roots.
Reference
1
Zhao
X
Heredity
109
2012
156
22588130
Inherited Spinal Muscular Atrophy
A progressive ataxia, weakness, muscle atrophy, and recumbency develops in young calves,
mostly during the first 2 weeks of life. Sensory functions are unimpaired. Some are
already affected at birth and some may be stillborn. No new cases occur after 3 months
of age. Conditioned by an autosomal recessive gene the defect occurs in Red Danish
cattle, which originated from Brown Swiss, German Braunvieh, and American Brown Swiss.
The primary lesion is degeneration of ventral horn cells of the spinal cord, without
involvement of the brainstem or cerebellum. The visible lesion is the secondary atrophy
of the denervated muscles.
Inherited Hypomyelinogenesis (Congenital Tremor of Pigs)
Congenital tremor of pigs has a multiple etiology and some of the causes are not yet
identified. The two inherited diseases are noted here: congenital tremor type A-IV
of British Saddleback pigs and congenital tremor type A-III, a sex-linked inherited
form of cerebrospinal hypomyelinogenesis of Landrace pigs. The A-IV disease is characterized
by the presence of poorly myelinated axons in all parts of the CNS. The specific defect
in A-IV is one of fatty acid metabolism. The structural abnormalities in the A-III
disease have been identified; splayleg is a common accompaniment.
Both diseases are characterized by muscle tremor, incoordination, difficulty in standing,
and some squealing. The A-III disease occurs only in males. Both are inherited as
recessive characters.
Porcine Congenital Progressive Ataxia and Spastic Paresis
This is an autosomal recessive disorder of pigs in Switzerland with a yet to be identified
gene defect. Clinical signs of a spastic gait with progressive ataxia become evident
within 3 days of birth, and the condition is lethal. Male and female pigs are equally
affected. Pedigree analysis has identified a boar born in 1978 that was used widely
for artificial insemination as the originator of the genetic defect.
Reference
1
Genini
S
J Anim Breed Genet
124
2007
269
17868079
Equine Degenerative Myeloencephalopathy (Equine Neuraxonal Dystrophy)
EDM is characterized by symmetric, slowly progressive spasticity and ataxia in foals
and horses less than 2 years of age. The disease occurs in most breeds in North America
and Europe and is reported in captive zebra and Mongolian Wild Horses in North America.
Neuronal dystrophy of the cuneate and gracilis nuclei is considered a form of EDM
and is likely the underlying pathophysiologic process of EDM.
1
The prevalence of the disease varies widely, with up to 40% of susceptible animals
on a farm being affected, although the disease is usually sporadic. There is a familial
predisposition to the disease apparently involving an increased requirement for vitamin
E, although other factors, including housing, are contributory. Foals from dams that
had an EDM-affected foal were at a significantly higher risk (relative risk = 25)
of developing EDM than foals from other dams. The occurrence of clusters of cases
involving related horses is supportive of a genetic component with inheritance as
in an autosomal dominant with variable expression or polygenic manner, although this
has not been confirmed in all breeds.2, 3, 4 The disease in Quarter Horses is highly
heritable and appears to be polygenic.2, 4
EDM occurs in Standardbreds, Paso Finos, Quarter Horses, Mongolian horses, Appaloosas,
Haflingers, Arabians, Morgans, Lusitanos, Thoroughbreds, Paint horses, Tennessee Walking
Horses, Norwegian Fjord Horses, Welsh Pony, and various mixed breeds.
1
There is no sex predilection.
The pathogenesis of the disease is unknown. Abnormal expression of integral synaptic
vesicle, synaptic vesicle-associated presynaptic plasma membrane, and cytosolic proteins
was observed in two Arabian horses with equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy; however,
abnormal α-tocopherol transfer protein does not appear to contribute to the disease.
4
These proteins have a role in trafficking, docking, and fusion of neuronal synaptic
vesicles, and this finding suggests that there is disruption of axonal transport in
equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy. A role for oxidative stress and damage to
neurons is supported by documentation of markers of oxidative stress in nervous tissue
and low serum and/or CSF vitamin E concentrations in two horses with EDM and not in
healthy control horses.
5
Low vitamin E concentrations in serum are often associated with the disease, but in
one small study only foals with a genetic predisposition to the disease, and having
a low serum vitamin E concentration, developed the disease. Foals with low serum vitamin
E concentrations that did not have the genetic predisposition to the disease did not
develop EDM.
6
Loss of axons leads to defects in neurologic function and consequent gait abnormalities.
The clinical signs are those of a slowing progressive spinal ataxia that stabilizes
when the animal is 2 to 3 years of age. Age of onset ranges from birth to 36 months,
although most cases have clinical signs by 6 to 12 months of age. Affected foals and
yearlings have symmetric signs that are most severe in the hindlimbs, of ataxia characterized
by pivoting, circumduction, truncal sway, and difficulty performing complex movements
such as backing or walking with the head elevated. At rest, severely affected horses
may have an abnormal posture. The cutaneous trunci reflex may be absent. Spontaneous
recovery does not occur, but progression to death is unusual. Radiography and myelography
of the cervical spine does not reveal evidence of compression of the spinal cord.
The disease is not associated with abnormalities detected on ocular examination, ERG
or EEG.
7
Serum vitamin E concentrations can be normal or low in affected horses, and this is
not a reliable test for diagnosis of the disease.1, 2, 3 The hemogram, serum biochemical
profile, and CSF analysis are normal. There are no gross lesions on necropsy. Histologic
lesions include neuronal atrophy, accumulation of lipofuscin-like pigment, and glial
cell proliferation.
Differential diagnoses are listed in Table 14-20 later in the chapter, under the Equine
Cervical Vertebral Compressive Myelopathy section. Diagnosis is achieved by exclusion
of other causes, of abnormal gait without fever or disease in other body systems in
horses, such as compressive myelopathy and equine protozoal myeloencephalopathy.
No treatment is curative, but vitamin E (6000 IU orally once daily) may prevent progression
of signs. Supplementation of at-risk foals and yearlings with vitamin E can prevent
the disease, although results are not equivocal.1, 6
References
1
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1251
22925200
2
Aleman
M
JAVMA
239
2011
823
21916766
3
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
1439
22092640
4
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
177
23186252
5
Wong
DM
Vet Pathol
49
2012
1049
22390882
6
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
29
2015
1667
26391904
7
Finno
CJ
Vet Ophthalmol
15
2012
3
22432889
Equine Cervical Vertebral Compressive Myelopathy (Wobbler, “Wobbles,” Foal Ataxia,
Equine Sensory Ataxia, Cervical Vertebral Instability)
Synopsis
Etiology Unknown. The clinical signs are the result of cervical spinal cord compression
as a result of abnormalities in the cervical spine.
Epidemiology Two predominant manifestations. Sporadic or endemic disease of young
horses with young, rapidly growing male horses most commonly affected. Separate presentation
in middle-aged and older horses in which it is sporadic.
Clinical signs Spinal ataxia evident as truncal sway, ataxia, and paresis usually
more severe in the hindlimbs. Radiographic evidence of narrow spinal canal.
Clinical pathology None.
Lesions Malacia and wallerian degeneration in the cervical spinal cord.
Differential diagnosis Equine degenerative myelopathy, equine protozoal myeloencephalitis,
trauma, equine infectious anemia, cerebrospinal nematodiasis, West Nile encephalomyelitis,
equine herpesvirus-1 myelopathy, osteomyelitis, cervical vertebral epidural hematoma,
aortoiliac thrombosis, congenital vertebral malformation, diskospondylitis, and ryegrass
staggers.
Diagnostic confirmation Radiography. Positive contrast myelography. Necropsy.
Treatment Antiinflammatory drugs. Surgical fusion of vertebrae.
Control None.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
The cause of neurologic disease is extradural compression of the cervical spinal cord,
hence the term compressive myelopathy. The compression may be static, that is, the
compression is present constantly with the neck in a neutral position, or dynamic
and only present intermittently when the neck is either flexed or extended. The second
situation is often referred to as cervical vertebral instability.
The etiology of CSM in most cases is not known. The disease in young horses is caused
by malformation and malarticulation of the cervical vertebrae and could represent
part of the osteochondritis dissecans spectrum of diseases.1, 2 There can be combinations
of articular process osteophytosis, interarcuate ligament hypertrophy, dorsal laminal
thickening, vertebral body end plate flaring, and synovial cysts. Importantly, changes
in soft tissue associated with the bony lesions can contribute to the compressive
myelopathy. Dynamic instability is associated with vertebral instability and subluxation
and is most common in the cranial vertebrae (C3-C5).
Copper deficiency has been mooted as one cause of the bony lesions, as have high calorie
rations and diets high in soluble carbohydrate.
2
The disease in older horses is secondary to osteoarthritis of the articular processes.
An inciting cause has not been identified.
Several basic syndromes of compressive myelopathy, based on age of occurrence, are
recognized:
•
CSM in immature horses (<3 years of age, depending on breed) that is often associated
with developmental joint disease in the axial and appendicular skeleton. A fundamental
underlying predisposing defect appears to be a narrow diameter of the cervical vertebral
canal. Compression is a result of the lesions described earlier.
•
Cervical vertebral instability is a disease of horses less than 1 year of age that
is often associated with malformations of one or more of the cervical vertebrae.
3
•
Compressive myelopathy in mature horses, >4 years (usually >7 years) of age, associated
with osteoarthritis of the articular facets of the caudal cervical vertebrae, with
subsequent impingement of the vertebral canal by bony and soft tissue proliferative
lesions.
•
Miscellaneous causes of cervical cord compression by neoplasia (melanoma, sarcoma,
lymphoma), trauma (cervical vertebral fractures), arachnoid or synovial cysts, epidural
hematoma
4
or, rarely, discospondylitis.
5
An alternative categorization is based on the nature of the bony lesion and not on
the cause of compression of the spinal cord. Type 1 cervical vertebral malformation
occur in horses <2 years of age that have vertebral changes that likely began in the
first few months of life, including malformations causing stenosis of the vertebral
canal, malformations at the articulations of the vertebrae including osteochondrosis,
and enlarged physeal growth regions. Type II cervical vertebral malformations tend
to occur in older horses with severe osteoarthritic lesions of the vertebral articulations.
Epidemiology
Occurrence
The disease in mature horses occurs sporadically throughout the world.
The disease in young horses is sometimes endemic on farms or studs and in particular
lines of horses. There is a suggestion of a familial tendency for the disease, although
this has not been well documented.
The morbidity rate can be as high as 25% of each foal crop on individual Thoroughbred
farms, although the overall frequency of the disease in the general horse population
is much lower. Among Thoroughbreds born on four stud farms in Europe and North America,
the disease has an annual prevalence of diagnosis of 1.3% (range of 0.7%–2.1% over
the study period) and annual prevalence on farms varying from 0% to 5.8%.
6
Compressive myelopathy was detected in 83 of 4318 horses subject to necropsy examination
in Normandy, France.
7
Fifteen percent of horses with a diagnosis of neurologic disease had cervical compressive
myelopathy. There were more males affected than females.
7
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Risk factors for CSM identified in a study of 1618 horses at 22 veterinary teaching
hospitals in North America are summarized in Table 14-20
.
Table 14-20
Association of horse factors associated with a diagnosis of cervical stenotic myelopathy
in 811 horses with cervical stenotic myelopathy and 805 control horses
Table 14-20
Variable
Or (95% CI)
P value
Sex
Gelding
2.0 (1.5–2.6)
<0.001
Sexually intact male
2.4 (1.8–3.2)
<0.001
Female
1 (Referent)
NA
Breed
Arabian
0.6 (0.3–0.9)
0.035
Standardbred
0.5 (0.3–0.7)
<0.001
Thoroughbred
1.7 (1.3–2.3)
<0.001
Tennessee Walking Horse
2.3 (1.1–4.7)
0.019
Warmblood
1.9 (1.1–3.1)
0.020
Other breeds
0.6 (0.4–0.8)
0.006
Quarter Horse
1 (Referent)
NA
Age
<6 mo
2.4 (1.4–3.9)
<0.001
6–11 mo
6.6 (3.8–11.5)
<0.001
12 to 23 mo
16.4 (10.5–25.8)
<0.001
2 to <4 y
7.2 (4.9–10.5)
<0.001
4 to <7 y
3.1 (2.1–4.6)
<0.001
7–10 y
1.1 (0.7–1.8)
0.65
≥10 y
1 (Referent)
NA
OR, odds ratio; NA, not applicable.
From Levine JM, et al. JAVMA 2008;233:1453
The disease in young horses is commonly recognized in Thoroughbred, Standardbred,
Warmblood, and Quarter horses, with Arabians and other breeds less likely to be diagnosed
with the disease.
8
Ponies are rarely, if ever, affected. Horses less than 4 years of age are at greater
risk of the disease, with most cases occurring in 1- to 3-year-old horses. Males,
either intact or gelded, are more likely to be affected than are females.
8
The disease in older horses is characterized by a slight predominance of male horses
with overrepresentation of Warmbloods, which could represent a breed or use predisposition,
and median age at diagnosis of 8 years.
1
Horses with CSM have a narrower spinal canal than do unaffected animals and this condition,
with degenerative joint disease of the articular facets and thickening of the ligamentum
flavum, contributes to the greater likelihood that the horse will have spinal cord
compression.
It is suspected that predisposition to the disease is heritable, but this has not
been demonstrated by appropriate studies.
The disease in mature horses tends to be in horses used for athletic endeavors and
is uncommon in broodmares or retired animals.
Pathogenesis
The disease is attributable to injury to the spinal cord as a result of compression
by either soft tissue (joint capsule, intervertebral ligaments, or, rarely, intervertebral
disk material) or cartilage and bone.
Constant or intermittent pressure on the spinal cord causes dysfunction or necrosis
of white matter and neurons at the site of compression, degeneration of fibers of
ascending tracts cranial to the site of compression, and of descending tracts caudal
to the compression. The ascending tracts are those associated with general proprioception,
whereas the descending tracts are upper motor neurons. These tracts are located superficially
in the dorsolateral aspect of the cervical spinal cord and damage to them results
in signs of ataxia and weakness. Tracts from the caudal limbs are more superficial,
and therefore more easily injured, than tracts associated with the cranial limbs.
Consequently, clinical signs are usually more severe in the hindlimbs. The spinal
cord lesions are usually, but not always, bilaterally symmetric, as are the clinical
signs. Proprioceptive pathways are disrupted, causing the signs of ataxia (incoordination)
typical of the disease. Clinical signs vary depending on the site of the lesion (see
later).
Clinical Findings
The onset of clinical signs is sometimes acute in young horses with CSM and there
can be a history of trauma, such as falling. However, the onset of clinical signs
of CSM in both young and mature horses is usually gradual and insidious, and in mildly
affected horses the nervous disease can be mistaken for lameness of musculoskeletal
origin. Affected horses are bright and alert and have a normal appetite. There can
be evidence of pain on manipulation of the neck or on firm pressure over the lateral
facets, especially in mature horses with osteoarthritis of the caudal cervical vertebral
facets.
1
There can be focal muscle atrophy adjacent to affected cervical vertebrae in older
horses.
The severity of clinical signs varies from barely detectable to recumbency. There
are no defects of al nerves, with the occasional exception of the cervicofacial reflex.
The severity of signs of CSM are often graded according to the following:
Grade 0: no gait deficits at the walk
Grade 1: no gait deficits identified at the walk and deficits only identified during
further testing (head elevation, backing, walking on a slope, stepping over obstacles,
circling, tail pull at rest and while walking)
Grade 2: deficits noted at the walk
Grade 3: marked deficits noted at the walk
Grade 4: severe deficits noted at the walk and might fall or nearly fall at normal
gaits
Grade 5: recumbent and unable rise without assistance
The two primary defects in gait in affected horses are related to defects in upper
motor neuron function and general proprioception. These two primary deficiencies in
neurologic function contribute to clinical signs characterized as ataxia, paresis,
dysmetria, and spasticity. Ataxia is the incoordinated movement of limbs and is evident
as interference of one limb with another (such as one foot stepping on another when
the horse is tightly circled), knuckling of the fetlock joint (which can also be a
sign of weakness), unusual placement of feet (excessively wide-based or narrow-based
stance, incomplete or delayed return of the foot to its normal position after it is
relocated to an abnormal position, excessive circumduction of the outside foot during
tight circling), stumbling, and/or swaying of the trunk during walking in a straight
line. Paresis is weakness and is evident in its most extreme form as inability of
the horse to rise. In less extreme manifestations it is evident as knuckling of the
fetlock joint, stumbling when walking downhill or over obstacles, and ease of pulling
the horse to one side by the tail when it is walking. Dysmetria refers to uneven gait
typified by undershoot or overshoot of the limb such that the hoof is in an incorrect
position. Spasticity is a result of loss of inhibition of lower spinal reflexes by
the upper motor neurons and results in a stilted or stiff gait.
Mildly affected horses may have deficits that are difficult to detect and only apparent
under saddle or at high speed. The owner might complain of poor performance of a racehorse
or dressage animal, of an animal that frequently changes leads, or that is poorly
gaited. Careful examination can reveal excessive circumduction of the hindfeet, stumbling,
and pacing when the head is elevated.
Moderately affected animals have truncal sway (the body of the horse and hindquarters
swaying laterally when the horse is walked in a straight line) and excessive circumduction
of the hindfeet. There can be a floating gait of the hindlimbs and scuffing of the
toe. Having the horse move in a very tight circle about the examiner often causes
the circumduction to become worse in the outside hindleg and the horse to place one
foot on top of the other. Affected horses will sometimes pace when walked in a straight
line with the head elevated. Blindfolding the horse does not exacerbate the signs.
Affected horses will stumble when walked over low objects, such as a curb, and will
knuckle at the fetlocks and stumble when walked down a steep hill.
Severely affected horses often fall easily when moved or are unable to stand. The
horses are bright and alert, but anxious, and display marked truncal sway and ataxia.
When standing, they will often have their legs in markedly abnormal positions.
Horses with lesions in the cervical spinal cord cranial to C6-C7 have signs in both
forelimbs and hindlimbs. The hindlimbs are more severely affected and the signs are
usually, but not always, bilaterally symmetric.
9
Approximately 43% of affected horses have asymmetric gait abnormalities.
9
Lesions of the cervical intumescence (C6 to T2) may cause signs that are more severe
in the forelimbs than in the hindlimbs. Lesions at this site may also cause signs
typical of brachial plexus injury. Focal muscle atrophy is not characteristic of CSM
or cervical vertebral instability and there are never signs of CNC, cerebral, or cerebellar
disease.
After initial progression the clinical signs usually stabilize or partially resolve.
However, complete spontaneous recovery is very unusual. Death is unusual unless it
is by misadventure, although many affected animals are killed for humane or economic
reasons.
8
Neurologic Examination
A tentative diagnosis of cervical compressive myelopathy is often made based on the
clinical examination. Although this assessment is relatively straightforward for severely
affected horses, the detection of neurologic abnormalities on physical examination
is more challenging for horses with milder forms of the disease. This becomes important
as additional diagnostic investigations might not be warranted in all cases of horses
with clear-cut signs of cervical compressive myelopathy, but might be indicated in
horses with less severe signs of the disease.
The reliability of the neurologic examination of horses has been investigated very
little. The agreement between expert or trained observers for overall grade of neurologic
abnormality was good (intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.74) when horses of all
grades were considered (grades 0–4), but very poor for horses ≤ Grade 1 (intraclass
coefficient (ICC) = 0.08) and only moderate (0.43) for horses ≥ Grade 2.
10
The higher ICC for the overall assessment was because observers could easily agree
on differences between severely affected and unaffected horses. Greatest lack of agreement
was for horses that had Grade 2 neurologic signs (Fig. 14-22
).
10
Fig. 14-22
Violin plot of the variation in individual ratings grouped by the median rating for
each horse during live scoring only. To align the ratings around 0, each score was
subtracted from the median score of the horse. A violin plot is similar to a boxplot,
with the addition of the density of data points illustrated by an increase in width.
This figure reveals that most grades have a fluctuation of 1 degree more or less than
the median; however, grades 0 and 3 are condensed around the median illustrating better
agreement, whereas grade 2 stretches from −2 to + 1 grades from the median.
Fig. 14-22
(From Olsen E, Dunkel B, Barker WHJ, et al. Rater Agreement on Gait Assessment During
Neurologic Examination of Horses. J Vet Int Med 2014;28:630.)
It is recommended in human medicine that an ICC must be >0.9 for it to be useful for
decision making in individual patients,
11
and on this basis the current methods for neurologic examination for horses are not
acceptable for clinical use.
10
It is the authors' opinion that the current neurologic grading system for examination
of horses continue to be used because it provides a structured way of completing the
examination. The results of the examination should be considered in light of its poor
reliability, especially for horses with severity of median Grade 2, and interpreted
with caution.
Ancillary Diagnostic Tests
The “slap test,” in which the response of the arytenoid cartilages to a slap on the
thorax is examined through an endoscope, has poorer sensitivity and specificity for
detecting spinal cord disease than does a routine neurologic examination.
Acupuncture has no proven value in the diagnosis of cervical compressive myelopathy
and should not be used for this purpose.
Radiographic Examination
Radiographic examination of the cervical vertebral column of potentially affected
horses is often undertaken because there are frequently lesions of the bone associated
with cervical compressive myelopathy. Radiographic examination includes plain radiographs
taken from the lateral aspect with the horse standing or myelography using injection
of radiopaque dye to allow visualization of the subarachnoid space and detection of
extradural compression of this space.
Examination of both plain and contrast radiographs is potentially enhanced by use
of one or more of a number of measures and ratios intended to detect and quantify
extradural compression of the cord.
Radiographic signs detectable on plain radiographs of the cervical spine in horses
with compressive myelopathy include the following:
•
Encroachment of the caudal vertebral physis dorsally into the spinal canal (“ski jump
lesion”) caused by physeal enlargement
•
Extension of the arch of the vertebra over the cranial physis of the next vertebra
•
Sclerosis of the spinal canal
•
Kyphosis, or subluxation, between adjacent vertebra
•
Degenerative joint disease of the articular facets evident as osteoarthritis and bony
proliferation
However, these signs are also common in normal horses and have poor predictive value.
The overall agreement, relative sensitivity, and relative specificity, respectively,
for identification of radiographic abnormalities (compared with the gold standard
of necropsy examination) in affected horses is 66% (76/116 horses); 63% and 67% for
identification of articular process osteophytosis; 61% (71/116), 42%, and 83% for
vertebral canal stenosis; and 78% (91/116), 56%, and 85% for vertebral column subluxation.
9
Radiography appears to have useful specificity but limited sensitivity in the diagnosis
of bony lesions associated with cervical compressive myelopathy. Use of additional
views, such as oblique views of the caudal cervical vertebrae. can enhance the diagnostic
value of radiography.
12
Intervertebral and intravertebral ratios have been calculated to assist with diagnosis
of CSM (Fig. 14-23
). The ratios in and of themselves have variable intraobserver and interobserver reliability
with ratios varying by 5% to 10% within and between observers.13, 14 Interobserver
agreement in measurements is poor and intraobserver agreement is good across the six
most cranial sites but poor for caudal sites.
14
Intraobserver and interobserver variability is sufficient to affect clinical interpretation
of radiographs and should be considered when interpreting radiographic examinations
with suspected spinal cord disease.
Fig. 14-23
Schematic drawing of the cervical vertebrae illustrating the sagittal ratios: the
intravertebral sagittal ratio is calculated as the ratio of the minimum sagittal diameter
of the spinal canal (green line) to the maximum sagittal diameter of the vertebral
body, taken at the cranial aspect of the vertebra and perpendicular to the spinal
canal (black line). The intervertebral sagittal ratio is the ratio of the minimal
distance taken from the most cranial aspect of the vertebral body to the most caudal
aspect of the vertebral arch of the more cranial vertebra (blue line) and the maximal
sagittal diameter of the vertebral body (black line).
Fig. 14-23
(Reproduced with permission from Van Biervliet J. An evidence-based approach to clinical
questions in the practice of equine neurology. Vet Clin Nth Am Equine Pract 2007;23(2):317-328.)
An intravertebral sagittal ratio of the spinal canal to vertebral body diameter of
less than 50% for C4-C6 is associated with a 26- to 41-fold increase in the probability
of a compressive myelopathy for horse >320 kg; in a separate study all horses with
a value of this ratio of less than 0.485 had at least one compressive lesion.
15
An intervertebral ratio can also be calculated and it has diagnostic utility that
might be slightly greater than that of the intravertebral ratio.2, 15 The results
of these tests are not definitive and a healthy horse can have ratios below this cutoff
and affected horses can have normal ratios.16, 17 It is important to recognize that
the utility of intravertebral (and other) ratios is dependent on the pretest likelihood
that the horse has cervical compressive myelopathy. The ratios should therefore be
considered in light of other clinical findings. Importantly, neither the intravertebral
nor intervertebral ratios predict the site of compression, which can only be detected
by myelographic examination.
2
Myelography has been considered to provide the definitive antemortem confirmation
of spinal cord compression, but recent studies demonstrate that it is not a perfect
diagnostic test and that results should be interpreted cautiously.
2
The sensitivity of this technique, using a 50% reduction in the width of the dorsal
dye column as a cutoff for diagnosis of the disease, is 53% (95% CI 34%–72%, n = 22)
and the specificity is 89% (95% CI of 84%–93%, n = 228) (Fig. 14-24
).
2
Others have found similar values for sensitivity and specificity with values of 47%
and 78%, respectively, for older horses with compressive myelopathy at caudal cervical
sites.
1
These values indicate a test with a relatively high false-negative rate but low false-positive
rate for neutral views and indicate that a positive finding on myelography is highly
suggestive of the disease, but that a negative finding does not eliminate the possibility
of the disease. The false-positive rate is increased to 12% to 27% for compression
at midcervical sites during neck flexion. Myelography is superior in diagnosing compressive
lesions at C6-C7 than at more proximal sites. Occasionally the compression is lateral
rather than dorsoventral and is not readily apparent on routine myelography.
Fig. 14-24
Schematic drawing of cervical myelogram illustrating the dural diameter reduction
(green lines) and the dorsal myelographic column reduction (pink lines).
Fig. 14-24
(Reproduced with permission from Van Biervliet J. An evidence-based approach to clinical
questions in the practice of equine neurology. Vet Clin Nth Am Equine Pract 2007;23(2):317-328.)
Myelography has been described in standing, conscious horses, but this technique is
not sufficiently well described to allow its recommendation at this time.
18
Ex situ (postmortem) MRI examination of cervical vertebrae and spinal cord of normal
and CSM-affected horses is more accurate than is interpretation of standing lateral
radiographs.
17
However, both CT and MRI of horses with CSM are limited by the restricted views of
the neck of adult horses. This prevents comprehensive examination of the cervical
spine.19, 20
Endoscopy of the epidural and subarachnoid spaces is reported in a horse with confirmed
cervical compressive myelopathy.21, 22 The diagnostic or therapeutic value of this
procedure is yet to be established.
The prognosis for horses with CSM is guarded. Sixty-four percent of affected horses
were euthanized, presumably for economic or humane reasons.
9
However, the prognosis depends on the severity of clinical signs and the intended
use of the horse. The criteria for euthanasia depend on the danger of the horse to
itself (for instance, falling and injuring itself) or its attendants. Horses that
are at high risk of self-injury or of injuring their attendants might qualify for
humane euthanasia. However, horses with milder signs of disease compatible with their
intended use, such as stallions or females with low-grade signs of the disease and
reproductive potential, can be treated conservatively and live long lives.
It is imperative to consider the risk to riders or handlers associated with care or
competing the horse when deciding on the fate of an affected horse.
The prognosis for horses intended for athletic use is less clear. Twenty-one of 70
Thoroughbred racehorses with cervical compressive myelopathy went on to race.
23
The likelihood of a horse racing was inversely related to the severity of its clinical
signs.
23
Clinical Pathology
Hematologic and serum biochemical values are usually within reference ranges in affected
horses. CSF from affected horses can have increased protein concentration, but this
finding is neither characteristic nor specific for compressive myelopathy. However,
other causes of spinal ataxia can cause characteristic changes in the CSF and examination
of the fluid might assist in ruling out these diseases.
Measurement of creatine kinase activity in CSF has no diagnostic value in horses.
Necropsy Findings
Gross examination reveals degeneration of the articular facets in many affected horses.
Impingement of soft tissues, especially the ligamentum flavum and joint structures,
or cartilage and osteophytes into the spinal canal may be apparent. The spinal canal
may be narrow. It may be indented and soft at the site or sites of compression. Histologically,
there is nerve fiber swelling, widespread degeneration of myelin, and astrocytic gliosis.
Cranial to the compressive lesion, wallerian degeneration is evident in the dorsal
and lateral funiculi, although caudal to the compression these changes are most evident
in the ventral and central lateral funiculi. Slight atrophy of cervical muscles is
sometimes evident. There is histologic evidence of stretching and tearing of the ligamentum
flavum and joint capsule at affected joints, especially C6 or C7.
Differential Diagnosis
Equine degenerative myelopathy, equine protozoal myeloencephalitis, trauma, equine
infectious anemia, cerebrospinal nematodiasis (Hypoderma spp., Setaria sp., Halicephalobus
deletrix), equine herpesvirus-1 myelopathy, aortoiliac thrombosis, West Nile encephalomyelitis,
congenital vertebral malformation (especially in Arabian foals), discospondylitis,
tumors involving the spinal canal (melanoma, lymphoreticular neoplasia, hemangiosarcoma),5,
24 extradural hematoma,
25
vertebral osteomyelitis, fibrocartilaginous embolic, postanesthetic myelopathy,
26
and ryegrass staggers (see Table 14-21
).
Table 14-21
Differential diagnosis of disease causing spinal ataxia in adult horses
Table 14-21
Disease
Etiology and epidemiology
Clinical signs and lesions
Treatment and prognosis
Cervical compressive myelopathy (cervical stenotic myelopathy, cervical vertebral
instability)
Sporadic; young, rapidly growing males; more common in Thoroughbreds, Standardbreds,
and Warmblood horses; syndrome in mature horses caused by arthritis or articular facets.
Symmetric ataxia often of sudden onset; may be associated with trauma; hindlimbs most
severely affected; compression of cervical spinal cord demonstrated by myelography;
CSF normal
Medical treatment of rest and antiinflammatory drugs; poor prognosis; surgical correction
by ventral stabilization
Equine degenerative myelopathy
Young horses (<3 years); familial incidence of increased requirement for vitamin E
Gradual onset symmetric ataxia that stabilizes at about 3 years of age; no radiographic
abnormalities in cervical spinal cord; CSF normal
Guarded prognosis; vitamin E 5–20 IU/kg per day in feed may prevent progression; no
cure; death uncommon
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis
Sarcocystis neurona or Neospora hughesi in spinal cord or brain; Americas only; infectious
but not contagious
Any sign of central nervous system dysfunction; usually gradual onset of asymmetric
spinal ataxia, focal muscle atrophy or weakness; CSF contains antibody to S. neurona,
but also found in normal horses
Ponazuril 5–10 mg/kg orally daily for 28 days; older, but effective, treatment is
pyrimethamine, 1 mg/kg orally and sulfadiazine, 20 mg/kg orally every 24 hours for
90–120 days; Nitazoxanide 25 mg/kg orally once daily for 2 days followed by 50 mg/kg
orally for 26 days; Vaccination not recommended
Equine herpesvirus-1 myeloencephalopathy
EHV-1; infectious and contagious.Sporadic; outbreaks occur often preceded by fever
or upper respiratory tract disease
Ascending paralysis with fecal and urinary incontinence, recumbency, normal mentation;
CSF xanthochromic and increased protein concentration; lesion is vasculitis and malacia
Valacyclovir for prophylactic therapy at a dose of 30 mg/kg orally every 8 hours for
2 days, then 20 mg/kg every 12 hours for 1–2 weeksCorticosteroids controversialNursing
care; poor prognosisVaccination potentially effective
West Nile encephalitis
West Nile virus; transmitted by bite of infected mosquito; horse is dead-end host
and does not develop sustained viremia; enzootic to Mediterranean littoral and North
America; Increased recognition in other areas (Australia, Kunjin); peak disease risk
is late summer
Weakness, muscle fasciculations, altered mentation; recumbency
No specific treatment; nursing care; corticosteroids controversial; hyperimmune serum
available in some areas; interferon has been used but efficacy uncertain
Trauma
Sudden onset; more common in young horses
Spinal ataxia, varying degrees of weakness and proprioceptive deficits; recumbencyRadiographic
lesions present occasionallyCSF may contain red blood cells
Antiinflammatory drugs; rest
Ryegrass staggers
Intoxication by lolitrems produced by Acremonium lolii growing on perennial ryegrass;
outbreaks of disease in horses on affected pasture
Ataxia, stiff gait, tremor, hypersensitivity, recumbency; no histologic lesions
Remove source of toxin; rapid recovery without other treatment
Parasite migration
Sporadic. Strongylus sp., Hypoderma sp., and filaroids (Setaria sp.).
Wide variety of clinical signs; progressive ataxia; CSF may contain eosinophils
Ivermectin 0.2 mg/kg orallyAntiinflammatory drugs
Congenital anomalies
Sporadic; cause spinal cord compression or lack of neural tissue, e.g., spina bifida
Recumbency, ataxia present at birth
No treatment
Neoplasia
Melanoma, lymphosarcoma, hemangiosarcoma, metastatic neoplasia, multiple myeloma
Variable depending on site; usually extradural tumor although can be secondary to
vertebral body involvement and pathologic fracture
No practicable treatment
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Medical treatment of the acute disease consists of rest and administration of antiinflammatory
drugs (dexamethasone 0.05–0.25 mg/kg intravenously or intramuscularly every 24 hours;
flunixin meglumine 1 mg/kg intravenously every 8–12 hours; phenylbutazone 2.2–4.4 mg/kg
orally every 12–24 hours; and/or dimethyl sulfoxide, 1 g/kg as a 10% solution in isotonic
saline intravenously every 24 hours for three treatments).
Treatment of arthritis of the facets of mature horses can be achieved by injection
of the articular facet joints with corticosteroids (40 mg of methylprednisolone acetate).
27
Injection of the joint is facilitated by ultrasonographic guidance. Injection of the
joints with antiinflammatory drugs is assumed to result in reduction in inflammation
and soft tissue swelling with consequent reduced compression of the cervical spinal
cord. There is no objective prospective assessment of the efficacy of this treatment
A “paced growth” program of slowed growth achieved by nutritional restriction of young
horses (foals and weanlings) has been suggested as conservative treatment for immature
horses with compressive myelopathy or at high risk of developing the disease.
Surgical fusion of cervical vertebrae is useful in the treatment of mild to moderately
affected horses, although because of issues of safety of future riders there are concerns
by some authorities about the advisability of this treatment.
Control
Control measures are not usually used, although ensuring an appropriate diet and growth
rate of at-risk animals would be prudent.
Further Reading
Nout
YS
Reed
SM
Cervical stenotic myelopathy
Equine Vet Educ
15
2003
212
References
1
Levine
JM
J Vet Intern Med
21
2007
812
17708404
2
Van Biervliet
J
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
23
2007
317
17616316
3
Unt
VE
Equine Vet Educ
21
2009
212
4
Gold
JR
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
481
18346147
5
Nout
YS
Equine Vet Educ
21
2009
569
6
Oswald
J
Vet Rec
166
2010
82
20081180
7
Laugier
C
J Equine Vet Sci
29
2009
561
8
Levine
JM
JAVMA
233
2008
1453
18980501
9
Levine
JM
JAVMA
237
2010
812
20919847
10
Olsen
E
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
630
24612411
11
Kottner
J
J Clin Epidemiol
64
2011
96
21130355
12
Withers
JM
Equine Vet J
41
2009
895
20383988
13
Scrivani
PV
Equine Vet J
43
2011
399
21496073
14
Hughes
KJ
J Vet Intern Med
28
2014
1860
25410955
15
Hahn
CN
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
49
2008
1
18251286
16
Hudson
NPH
Equine Vet Educ
17
2005
34
17
Janes
JG
Equine Vet J
46
2014
681
24329734
18
Rose
PL
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
48
2007
535
18018724
19
Mitchell
CW
Vet Radiol Ultrasound
53
2012
613
22533785
20
Sleutjens
J
Vet Q
34
2014
74
25174534
21
Prange
T
Equine Vet J
44
2012
116
21696435
22
Prange
T
Equine Vet J
43
2011
317
21492209
23
Hoffman
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
27
2013
317
23480718
24
Raes
EV
Equine Vet Educ
26
2014
548
25
Santos
FCCD
Equine Vet Educ
26
2014
306
26
Ragle
C
Equine Vet Educ
23
2011
630
27
Birmingham
SSW
Equine Vet Educ
22
2010
77
Equine Motor Neuron Disease
Equine motor neuron disease is a neurodegenerative disease of horses in the United
States, Canada, Europe, UK, and South America.1, 2, 3 The disease is associated with
low intake, and abnormally low serum concentrations, of vitamin E, possibly exacerbated
by excessive intake of copper or iron.4, 5, 6 The disease can be induced by feeding
horses a diet with a low concentration of vitamin E, with development of clinical
signs of the disease taking at least 18 months and up to 38 months.5, 7
The disease affects horses of all breeds, with Quarter Horses most commonly affected,
and the incidence of the disease increases with age (horses older than 2 years). The
disease is associated with stabling and lack of access to pasture, and the risk of
the disease increases with decreasing serum vitamin E concentration.
The pathogenesis of the disease is unknown but is suspected to be caused by oxidative
injury to neurons subsequent to vitamin E deficiency. However, not all horses that
develop the disease have a clear oxidant stress or decrease in antioxidant capacity.
8
The clinical signs are attributable to degeneration of motor neurons in the ventral
horns of the spinal cord, with subsequent peripheral nerve degeneration and widespread
neurogenic muscle atrophy.
The onset of clinical signs is usually gradual, but in a small proportion of affected
horses the first sign is an acute onset of profound muscle weakness. Chronically affected
horses have weight loss in spite of a normal or increased appetite, pronounced trembling
and fasciculation of antigravity muscles, increased recumbency, and a short-strided
gait. They often assume a posture with all feet under the body and a low head carriage,
and frequently shift weight, which are all signs attributable to muscle weakness.
The tail head is elevated in a large proportion of severely affected horses, which
is likely a result of atrophy of the sacrocaudalis dorsalis medialis muscle. Profound
flaccidity (weakness) of the tongue with lesions in the hypoglossal nuclei is reported
and must be differentiated from botulism.
9
Retinal examination often reveals accumulation of lipofuscin-like pigment in the tapetal
fundus.
EMG, under either general or regional anesthesia, is a useful diagnostic aid.
8
Characteristic findings include spontaneous fibrillation potentials and trains of
positive sharp waves.
Lesions of redistribution of mitochondrial enzyme stain and anguloid atrophy of myofibers
in sacrocaudalis dorsalis medialis muscle of adult horses with vitamin E–responsive
muscle atrophy might represent a variant, or early stage, of equine motor neuron disease.
10
The prognosis is poor for horses with advanced disease and most of these horses do
not return to normal function and are destroyed, although the disease stabilizes in
some cases that can then live for a number of years after diagnosis. Approximately
40% of cases will have stable clinical signs (no improvement) and 20% will continue
to deteriorate after diagnosis and initiation of treatment. Early recognition and
correction of diet with or without supplementation with vitamin E can result in recovery.
There is often a mild increase in serum creatine kinase activity. Horses with equine
motor neuron disease have abnormal oral and intravenous glucose tolerance tests characterized
by peak glucose concentrations that are lower than expected. The lower peak plasma
glucose concentration is attributable to a 3× greater rate of glucose metabolism (removal
from blood) in affected horses compared with normal horses. There is also evidence
that horses with equine motor neuron disease are more sensitive to insulin than are
normal horses.
Affected horses often have serum vitamin E concentrations that are below the reference
range (<1.0–2.0 µg/dL, <1.0–2.0 µmol/L). Horses with equine motor neuron disease have
higher spinal cord copper concentrations than do normal horses, but the diagnostic
or clinical significance of this observation is unclear.
Examination of CSF is not useful in arriving at a diagnosis.
Examination of muscle from horses with equine motor neuron disease reveals a coordinated
shift from characteristics of slow muscle to those of fast twitch muscle including
contractile and metabolic functions of muscle. There is a lower percentage of myosin
heavy chain type 1 fibers, higher percentages of hybrid IIAX and IIX fibers, atrophy
of all fibers, and reduced oxidative capacity, increased glycolytic capacity, and
diminished intramuscular glycogen concentrations, among other changes, in affected
horses compared with normal horses.
The disease must be differentiated from botulism and other causes of weakness in adult
horses. Diagnostic confirmation can be achieved by examination of a biopsy of the
sacrocaudalis dorsalis medialis muscle or the spinal accessory nerve. The sacrocaudalis
dorsalis medialis muscle is preferred because that muscle is predominantly composed
of type 1 fibers and is severely affected by the disease. Examination of biopsy of
this muscle has a sensitivity of approximately 90%.
Necropsy examination reveals moderate to severe diffuse muscle atrophy. Predominant
histologic findings at necropsy examination include degeneration of neurons in ventral
horns at all levels of the spinal cord. Muscle atrophy is evident because angular
fibers, with predominantly type 1 fibers, or a combination of type 1 and type 2 fibers,
are affected. There is accumulation of lipofuscin in the fundus and in capillary endothelium
of the nervous tissue.
Treatment consists of administration of vitamin E. There are eight isoforms of vitamin
E, and RRR-α-tocopherol, the naturally occurring form, is the most potent antioxidant.
Synthetic vitamin E contains all isomers, whereas “natural” vitamin contains only
one, the RRR isomer. Administration of lyophilized, water-soluble d-α-tocopherol (RRR-α-tocopherol)
is apparently superior to administration of the dl-α-tocopherol acetate in increasing
concentrations of vitamin E in blood of horses.
4
The usual dose is 4 IU of d-α-tocopherol (RRR-α-tocopherol) per kilogram BW orally
once daily or 5000 to 7000 IU of α-tocopherol per 450-kg horse per day.
4
Supplementation results in improvement in 40% of affected horses within 6 weeks, with
some appearing normal at 12 weeks.
4
Control measures should ensure that horses have adequate access to pasture or are
supplemented with good quality forage and/or vitamin E. Horses without access to green
pasture should be supplemented with 1 U of vitamin E per kilogram BW per day.
4
Further Reading
Finno
CJ
Valberg
SJ
A comparative review of vitamin E and associated equine disorders
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1251
1266
22925200
Wijnberg
ID
Equine motor neurone disease
Equine Vet Educ
18
2006
126
129
References
1
McGowan
CM
Vet J
180
2009
330
18375158
2
Delguste
C
Can Vet J
48
2007
1165
18050798
3
McGorum
BC
Equine Vet J
38
2006
47
16411586
4
Finno
CJ
J Vet Intern Med
26
2012
1251
22925200
5
Divers
TJ
Am J Vet Res
67
2006
120
16426221
6
Syrja
P
Equine Vet Educ
18
2006
122
7
Mohammed
HO
Acta Vet Scand
49
2007
17
17605810
8
Wijnberg
ID
Equine Vet Educ
18
2006
126
9
Robin
M
Equine Vet Educ
28
2016
434
10
Bedford
HE
JAVMA
242
2013
1127
23547678
Diseases Primarily Affecting the Peripheral Nervous System
The peripheral nervous system consists of cranial and spinal nerve components. As
such, the peripheral nervous system includes the dorsal and ventral nerve roots, spinal
ganglia, spinal and specific peripheral nerves, CNs and their sensory ganglia, and
the peripheral components of the autonomic nervous system.
Etiology
There are several different causes of peripheral nervous system disease.
Inflammatory
Polyneuritis equi, also known as neuritis of the cauda equina or cauda equina syndrome,
is a rare and slowly progressive demyelinating granulomatous disease affecting peripheral
nerves in the horse. Polyneuritis equi is characterized by signs of lower motor neuron
lesions, primarily involving the perineal region but also affecting other peripheral
nerves, especially CNs V and VI. CNs VIII, IX, X, and XII also may be involved. Clinical
signs of perineal region paresis/paralysis predominate and manifest as varying degrees
of hypotonia; hypalgesia; and hyporeflexia of the tail, anus, and perineal region.
Degrees of urinary bladder paresis and rectal dilatation are also present. Differential
diagnoses include sacral or coccygeal trauma, equine herpes myeloencephalopathy, equine
protozoal myeloencephalitis, rabies, and equine motor neuron disease.
Cranial neuritis with guttural pouch mycosis and empyema in the horse may cause abnormalities
of swallowing, laryngeal hemiplegia, and Horner's syndrome if the glossopharyngeal
and vagal nerves are involved in the inflammatory process of the guttural pouch.
Acquired myasthenia gravis has been diagnosed in a 7-month-old Hereford heifer with
a 5-day history of recumbency caused by symmetric generalized neuromuscular weakness.
1
The heifer stood with no assistance within 1 minute of edrophonium chloride (0.1 mg/kg
intravenously) and was able to stand for 24 hours. Three additional episodes of prolonged
recumbency responded to edrophonium, with an increasing period between episodes. Additional
treatment was dexamethasone intramuscularly for 5 days. Acquired myasthenia gravis
was diagnosed and attributed to an autoimmune disease directed against acetylcholine
receptors at the neuromuscular junction. Congenital myasthenia gravis, caused by a
homozygous mutation in the acetylcholine receptor gene, has been diagnosed in Braham
calves in South Africa.
2
Degenerative
Equine laryngeal hemiplegia, often called roaring, is a common disease of the horse
in which there is paralysis of the left cricoarytenoid dorsalis muscle resulting in
an inability to abduct the arytenoid cartilage and vocal fold, which causes an obstruction
in the airway during inspiration. Endoscopic examination reveals asymmetry of the
glottis. On exercise, inspiratory stridor develops as the airflow vibrates a slack
and adducted vocal fold. The abnormality is caused by idiopathic distal degeneration
of axons in the left recurrent laryngeal nerve, with the disease characterized as
a bilateral mononeuropathy.
3
The left recurrent laryngeal nerve is more severely affected than the right because
it is longer and is the longest nerve in the horse (see Chapter 12 for more details).
Diaphragmatic paralysis has been identified in 11 alpacas aged 2 to 12 months. Respiratory
dysfunction was present, manifested as tachypnea, pronounced inspiratory effort, and
arterial hypercapnia and hypoxemia.
4
The paralysis appeared bilateral in all seven alpacas imaged using fluoroscopy. Histologic
examination revealed phrenic nerve degeneration in all six alpacas necropsied, with
long nerves also demonstrating degeneration in two alpacas. The etiology was not identified.
4
Traumatic
Injection injuries to peripheral nerves may result from needle puncture, the drug
deposited, pressure from an abscess or hematoma, or fibrous tissue around the nerve.
The sciatic nerve has been most commonly affected in cattle because historically most
intramuscular injections were given deep in the hamstring muscles. Young calves were
particularly susceptible because of their small muscle masses. Current recommendations
in cattle are that intramuscular injections should be administered cranial to the
shoulder.
Femoral nerve paralysis in calves occurs in large calves born to heifers with dystocia.
The injury occurs when calves in anterior presentation fail to enter the birth canal
because their stifle joints become engaged at the brim of the pelvis. Traction used
to deliver these calves causes hyperextension of the femur and stretching of the quadriceps
muscle and its neural and vascular supplies. In most cases the right femoral nerve
is affected. Such calves are unable to bear weight on the affected leg within days
after birth, the quadriceps muscle is atrophied, and the patella can be luxated easily.
The patellar reflex is absent or markedly reduced in the affected limb because this
reflex requires an intact femoral nerve and functional quadriceps muscle. Varying
degrees of rear limb paresis result, accompanied by varying degrees of hindlimb gait
abnormality. Skin analgesia maybe present over the proximal lateral to cranial to
medial aspect of the tibia. At rest, the affected leg is slightly flexed and the hip
on the affected side is held slightly lower. During walking, the animal has difficulty
in advancing the limb normally because the limb collapses when weight bearing. In
severe cases of muscle atrophy, the patella is easily luxated both medially and laterally.
Injury to the femoral nerve is relatively easy to clinically identify, and there is
usually no need to perform EMG studies of atrophied quadriceps muscle to document
denervation.
Calving paralysis is common in heifers that have experienced a difficult calving.
Affected animals are unable to stand without assistance; if they do stand, the hindlimbs
are weak and there is marked abduction and inability to adduct. It has always been
erroneously thought that traumatic injury of the obturator nerves during passage of
the calf in the pelvic cavity was the cause of the paresis; however, detailed pathologic
and experimental studies have demonstrated that most calving paresis/paralysis is
caused by damage to the sciatic nerve. Experimental transection of the obturator nerves
does not result in paresis. The term obturator nerve paralysis should only be used
for postparturient cattle with an inability to adduct one or both hindlimbs, and calving
paralysis in the preferred descriptive term for hindlimb paresis/paralysis occurring
in the immediate postparturient period.
Damage to the sciatic nerve results in rear limb weakness and knuckling of the fetlocks;
the latter clinical sign is an important means for differentiating sciatic nerve damage
from obturator nerve damage (Fig. 14-25
). The patellar reflex in ruminants with sciatic nerve damage is normal or increased,
because the reflex contraction of the quadriceps muscle group by the femoral nerve
is unopposed by the muscles of the hindlimb innervated by the sciatic nerve.
Fig. 14-25
Three-year-old Holstein Friesian cow with mild paresis of the right sciatic nerve.
The hock is dropped relative to the normal unaffected left leg, and the fetlock has
the characteristic knuckling. The cow has had a left displaced abomasum surgically
corrected by a right flank incision and is being treated for concurrent mastitis.
Fig. 14-25
The peroneal nerve is most frequently damaged by local trauma to the lateral stifle
where the peroneal nerve runs in a superficial location lateral to the head of the
fibular bone. Damage to the peroneal nerve leads to knuckling over of the fetlock
joint from damage to the extensor muscles of the distal limb, resulting in the dorsal
aspect of the hoof resting on the ground when the animal is standing. Full weight
can be borne on the affected limb when the digit is placed in its normal position,
but immediately on walking the digit is dragged. There is a loss of skin sensation
on the anterior aspect of the metatarsus and digit.
Damage to the tibial nerve causes mild hyperflexion of the hock and a forward knuckling
of the fetlock joint. Tibial nerve damage is very rare, and most cases described as
tibial nerve damage are actually sciatic nerve damage.
The radial nerve is most susceptible to traumatic damage because it courses distally
and laterally over the later condyle of the humerus. Radial nerve paresis is most
common when heavy adult cattle are placed in lateral recumbency, such as corrective
foot trimming in bulls. Care must be taken in these animals to pad the area around
the elbow and to ensure that the time spent in lateral recumbency is minimized. Clinical
signs of radial nerve paresis include inability to advance the front limb with the
ability to bear weight when the limb is placed directly under the animal in the normal
position (Fig. 14-26
). In advanced cases, the cranial aspect of the fetlock is dragged along the ground
and the area needs to be protected from severe abrasion injury using a splint or cast.
Fig. 14-26
Mild radial nerve paresis in a Holstein Friesian bull. Swelling is present over the
lateral aspect of the elbow. Paresis was present immediately after taking the animal
off a foot table for corrective foot trimming.
Fig. 14-26
Brachial plexus injury, including avulsion, is rare in large animals, because the
muscle mass is usually sufficient to prevent overextension of the front limb. It is
a rare outcome of correction of dystocia in goats, particularly when relatively excessive
traction is applied to one front limb during delivery. Clinical signs of brachial
plexus avulsion include a complete inability to bear weight on the limb and a dropped
elbow relative to the unaffected limb (Fig. 14-27
).
Fig. 14-27
One-week-old kid with brachial plexus avulsion of the right forelimb. The right limb
“appears” longer than the unaffected left limb and the right elbow appears dropped.
The right front leg cannot support weight and is not advanced in a normal manner during
walking. The right leg received excessive traction during correction of a dystocia.
Fig. 14-27
Metabolic and Nutritional
PA deficiency may occur in pigs fed diets based solely on corn (maize). Affected animals
develop a goose-stepping gait caused by degenerative changes in the primary sensory
neurons of the peripheral nerves.
Toxic
Heavy metal poisoning including lead and mercury poisoning in horses has been associated
with clinical signs of degeneration of peripheral CNs, but these are not well documented.
Tumors
A multicentric schwannoma causing chronic ruminal tympany and forelimb paresis has
been recorded in an aged cow. Neoplastic masses were present throughout the body,
and both right and left brachial plexuses were involved. The peripheral nerves of
each brachial plexus were enlarged. Large tumor masses were present on the serosal
surfaces of the esophagus, pericardial sac and epicardium, and within the myocardium,
endocardium, and the ventral branches of the first four thoracic spinal nerves. A
large mass was present in the anterior mediastinum near the thoracic inlet.
Autonomic Nervous System
Equine grass sickness (equine dysautonomia, grass sickness, mal Seco) in the horse
is a polyneuropathy involving both the peripheral nervous system (autonomic and enteric
nervous systems) as well as the CNS.5, 6, 7 Equine grass sickness occurs primarily
in Scotland, although cases have been reported elsewhere in Europe, and in Patagonia
and the Falkland Islands.
8
The disorder is characterized by a peracute to chronic alimentary tract disease of
horses on pasture (hence the name). Gastrointestinal stasis is partial or complete.
Peracute cases are in shock and in a state of collapse with gastric refluxing. Acute,
subacute, and chronic cases also occur. Degenerative changes occur in the autonomic
ganglia (especially the celiac–mesenteric, and stellate), thoracic sympathetic chain,
ciliary, cranial and caudal cervical, the craniospinal sensory ganglia, and selected
nuclei in the CNS. EMG reveals the presence of a neuropathy of skeletal muscles.
8
The etiology is unknown but neurotoxin involvement is suspected, possibly Clostridium
botulinum type C/D.
Further Reading
Constable
PD
Clinical examination of the ruminant nervous system
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
185
214
15203222
Divers
TJ
Acquired spinal cord and peripheral nerve disease
Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract
20
2004
231
242
15203224
References
1
Wise
LN
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
231
18289316
2
Thompson
PN
J Anim Sci
85
2007
604
17121978
3
Dupuis
MC
Mamm Genome
22
2011
613
21698472
4
Byers
S
J Vet Intern Med
25
2011
380
21281346
5
Shotton
HR
J Comp Pathol
145
2011
35
21457994
6
Wales
AD
Whitwell
KE
Vet Rec
158
2006
372
16547184
7
Lyle
C
Pirie
RS
In Pract
31
2009
26
8
Wijnberg
ID
Equine Vet J
38
2006
230
16706277
Tetanus
Etiology
Tetanus is caused by C. tetani, a gram-positive, spore-forming obligate anaerobe bacillus.
It is a ubiquitous organism and a commensal of the gastrointestinal tract of domestic
animals and humans. The organism forms highly resistant spores that can persist in
soil for many years. The spores survive many standard disinfection procedures, including
steam heat at 100°C (212°F) for 20 minutes but can be destroyed by heating at 115°C
(239°F) for 20 minutes. After a period of anaerobic incubation spores germinate to
their vegetative form, which starts replicating and producing a complex of exotoxins
causing the clinic signs characteristic for this condition. The toxins produced are
tetanolysin, tetanospasmin, and neurotoxin or nonspasmolytic toxin.
Synopsis
Etiology Muscle spasm from action of the exotoxin tetanospasmin produced by the vegetative
stage of Clostridium tetani.
Epidemiology Marked difference in species susceptibility with horses being most and
cattle being least susceptible. Usually a history of a wound or other tissue trauma.
Occurs as isolated cases but also as outbreaks in young ruminants following castration
and docking.
Clinical findings Generalized muscular rigidity and spasms, hyperesthesia, prolapse
of third eyelid, trismus, ears pulled caudally, bloat in ruminants, convulsions, respiratory
arrest, and death. High case fatality.
Necropsy findings None. May demonstrate the organism in necrotic tissue in some cases.
Diagnostic confirmation Diagnosis is based on characteristic clinical signs and wound
history. No definitive antemortem test or pathognomonic postmortem lesion. A bioassay
consisting of injecting mice with infectious material to induce characteristic clinical
signs is used.
Treatment Objectives are to prevent further production of exotoxin, neutralize residual
toxin, control muscle spasms until the toxin is eliminated or destroyed, maintain
hydration and nutrition, provide supportive treatment.
Control Regular prophylactic vaccination with tetanus toxoid of susceptible animals,
vaccination and administration of tetanus antitoxin to unvaccinated animals with fresh
wounds, antibiotic therapy in animals with wounds that are contaminated or at risk
to be contaminated.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Tetanus occurs in all parts of the world and is most common in closely settled areas
under intensive cultivation. It occurs in all farm animals, mainly as individual,
sporadic cases, although outbreaks are occasionally observed in young cattle, young
pigs, and lambs following wound management procedures.
1
Case–Fatality Rate
In young ruminants the case–fatality rate is over 80%, but the recovery rate is high
in adult cattle. In horses it varies widely between areas. In some areas almost all
animals die acutely, and in others the mortality rate is consistently about 50%.2,
3
Source of Infection
C. tetani organisms are commonly present in the feces of animals, especially horses,
and in the soil contaminated by these feces. Surveys in different areas of the world
show it is present in 30% to 42% of soil samples. The survival period of the organism
in soil varies widely from soil to soil.
Transmission
The portal of entry is usually through deep puncture wounds, but the spores may lie
dormant in the tissues for some time and produce clinical illness only when tissue
conditions favor their proliferation. For this reason, the portal of entry is often
difficult to identify. Puncture wounds of the hooves are common sites of entry in
horses. Introduction to the genital tract at the time of parturition is the usual
portal of entry in cattle. A high incidence of tetanus may occur in young pigs following
castration and in lambs following castration, shearing, docking, vaccinations, or
injections of pharmaceuticals, especially anthelmintics. Docking by the use of elastic
band ligatures is reputed to be especially hazardous. Neonatal tetanus occurs when
there is infection in the umbilical cord associated with unsanitary conditions at
parturition. Cases of tetanus in ruminants after thermic dehorning and ear-tagging
have been reported.
1
Outbreaks of “idiopathic tetanus” occur occasionally in young cattle without a wound
being apparent, usually in association with the grazing of rough, fibrous feed, and
it is probable that toxin is produced in wounds in the mouth or gastrointestinal tract
or is ingested preformed in the feed. Proliferation in the rumen may also result in
toxin production.
Animal Risk Factors
The neurotoxin of C. tetani is exceedingly potent, but there is considerable variation
in susceptibility between animal species, and horses are the most susceptible and
cattle the least susceptible. The variation in prevalence of the disease in the different
species is partly caused by this variation in susceptibility but is also because exposure
and wound management practices are more likely to occur in some species than in others.
Importance
Tetanus is important because of its high case fatality and the very long convalescence
in the survivors. In regions of the world where horses, donkeys, and mules still play
an important role in the rural economy and where vaccination is uncommon, the economic
impact of tetanus can be considerable.
2
Pathogenesis
The tetanus spores remain localized at their site of introduction and do not invade
surrounding tissues. Spores germinate to their vegetative form to proliferate and
produce tetanolysin, tetanospasmin, and neurotoxin only if certain environmental conditions
are attained, particularly a lowering of the local tissue oxygen tension. Toxin production
may occur immediately after introduction if the accompanying trauma has been sufficiently
severe, or if foreign material has also been introduced to the wound, or may be delayed
for several months until subsequent trauma to the site causes tissue damage. The original
injury may be inapparent by then. Of the three mentioned exotoxins, tetanospasmin
is the most relevant for the pathophysiology of the condition. Although tetanolysin
was found to promote local tissue necrosis, its role in the pathogenesis of tetanus
remains doubtful. The role of the more recently identified neurotoxin, or nonspasmogenic
toxin, which is a peripherally active for the pathophysiology of tetanus, is currently
unknown.
Tetanospasmin diffuses to the systemic circulation, is bound to motor end plates,
and travels up peripheral nerve trunks via retrograde intraaxonal transport to the
CNS. The exact mechanisms by which the toxin exerts its effects on nervous tissue
are not known, but it blocks the release of neurotransmitters such as GABA and glycine,
which are essential for the synaptic inhibition of gamma motor neurons in the spinal
cord. There it leads to an unmodulated spread of neural impulses produced by normally
innocuous stimuli, causing exaggerated responses and a state of constant muscular
spasticity. No structural lesions are produced. Death occurs by asphyxiation caused
by fixation of the muscles of respiration.
Clinical Findings
The incubation period varies between 3 days and 4 weeks, with occasional cases occurring
as long as several months after the infection is introduced. In sheep and lambs cases
appear 3 to 10 days after shearing, docking, or castration.
Clinical findings are similar in all animal species. Initially, there is an increase
in muscle stiffness, accompanied by muscle tremor. There is trismus with restriction
of jaw movements; prolapse of the third eyelid; stiffness of the hindlimbs causing
an unsteady, straddling gait; and the tail is held out stiffly, especially when backing
or turning. Retraction of the eye and prolapse of the third eyelid (a rapid movement
of the third eyelid across the cornea followed by a slow retraction) is one of the
earliest and consistent signs (with the exception of sheep) and can be exaggerated
by sharp lifting of the muzzle or tapping the face below the eye. Additional signs
include an anxious and alert expression contributed to by an erect carriage of the
ears, retraction of the eyelids and dilation of the nostrils, and hyperesthesia with
exaggerated responses to normal stimuli (Fig. 14-28
).
Fig. 14-28
Polled Hereford cow exhibiting early signs of tetanus with healthy calf. The tail
is held slightly away from the perineum, the ears are back, the eyes have a surprised
expressed with slight prolapse of the nictitating membrane, and saliva is drooling
from the mouth. The cow calved 7 days previously and had a retained placenta and metritis.
Fig. 14-28
The animal may continue to eat and drink in the early stages but mastication is soon
prevented by tetany of the masseter muscles and saliva may drool from the mouth. If
food or water is taken, attempts at swallowing are followed by regurgitation from
the nose. Constipation is usual and the urine is retained, partly as a result of the
inability to assume the normal position for urination. The rectal temperature and
pulse rate are within the normal range in the early stages but may rise later when
muscular tone and activity are further increased. In cattle, particularly young animals,
bloat is an early sign but is not usually severe and is accompanied by strong, frequent
rumen contractions.
As the disease progresses, muscular tetany increases and the animal adopts a sawhorse
posture (Figs. 14-29
and 14-30
). Uneven muscular contractions may cause the development of a curve in the spine
and deviation of the tail to one side. There is great difficulty in walking and the
animal is inclined to fall, especially when startled. Falling occurs with the limbs
still in a state of tetany and the animal can cause itself severe injury. Once down
it is almost impossible to get a large animal to its feet again. Tetanic convulsions
begin in which the tetany is still further exaggerated. Opisthotonus is marked, the
hindlimbs are stuck out stiffly behind and the forelegs forward. Sweating may be profuse
and the temperature rises, often to 42°C (107°F). The convulsions are at first only
stimulated by sound or touch but soon occur spontaneously. In fatal cases there is
often a transient period of improvement for several hours before a final, severe tetanic
spasm during which respiration is arrested.
Fig. 14-29
Suffolk lamb with tetanus after castration using a band. The lamb is exhibiting a
sawhorse stance caused by generalized muscle rigidity and drooling of saliva.
Fig. 14-29
Fig. 14-30
Corriedale lamb with tetanus after tail docking. Note the ear and eyelid retraction
and generalized stiffness.
Fig. 14-30
The course of the disease and the prognosis vary both between and within species.
The duration of a fatal illness in horses and cattle is usually 5 to 10 days, but
sheep usually die on about the third or fourth day. A long incubation period is usually
associated with a mild syndrome, a long course, and a favorable prognosis. Mild cases
that recover usually do so slowly, with the stiffness disappearing gradually over
a period of weeks or even months. The prognosis is poor when signs rapidly progress.
Animals vaccinated in the past year have a better prognosis, as do horses that have
received parenteral penicillin and tetanus antitoxin and in which the wound was aggressively
cleaned when fresh.
Clinical Pathology
There are no specific abnormalities in blood or CSF and no antemortem test confirming
the diagnosis. Blood levels of tetanus toxin are usually too low to be detected. Gram-stain
of wound aspirates is considered of limited value because sporulated as well as vegetative
forms of C. tetani resemble other anaerobic bacteria. Culturing the pathogen is difficult
because of the low number of organisms normally present and the strict anaerobic conditions
required for culture. Culture in combination with PCR has been used for identification
of C. tetani.
1
A bioassay consisting of injecting infectious material into the tail base of mice
and observing for onset of characteristic clinical signs is possible.
2
Necropsy Findings
There are no gross or histologic findings by which a diagnosis can be confirmed, although
a search should be made for the site of infection. Culture of the organism is difficult
but should be attempted. If minimal autolysis has occurred by the time of necropsy,
the identification of large gram-positive rods with terminal spores (“tennis-racket
morphology”) in smears prepared from the wound site or spleen is supportive of a diagnosis
of tetanus.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Bacteriology: air-dried impression smears from spleen, wound site (cyto, Gram stain),
culture swab from wound site in anaerobic transport media; spleen in sterile, leak-proof
container (anaerobic CULT, bioassay).
Differential Diagnosis
Fully developed tetanus is so distinctive clinically that it is seldom confused with
other diseases. The muscular spasms, the prolapse of the third eyelid, and a recent
history of accidental injury or surgery are characteristic findings. However, in its
early stages or mild forms, tetanus may be confused with other diseases.
All species
•
Strychnine poisoning
•
Meningitis
Horses
•
Hypocalcemic tetany (eclampsia)
•
Acute laminitis
•
Hyperkalemic periodic paralysis
•
Myositis, particularly after injection in the cervical region.
Ruminants
•
Hypomagnesemia (cows, sheep and calves)
•
White muscle disease
•
Polioencephalomalacia
•
Enterotoxemia.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
These are the main principles in the treatment of tetanus:
•
Eliminate the causative bacteria
•
Neutralize residual toxin
•
Control muscle spasms until the toxin is eliminated or destroyed
•
Maintain hydration and nutrition
•
Provide supportive treatment
There are no structural changes in the nervous system, and the management of cases
of tetanus depends largely on keeping the animal alive through the critical stages.
Elimination of the organism is usually attempted by the parenteral administration
of penicillin in large doses (44,000 IU/kg), preferably by intravenous administration.
Other antimicrobials that have been proposed include oxytetracycline (15 mg/kg), macrolides,
and metronidazole. If the infection site is found, the wound should be aggressively
cleaned and debrided but only after antitoxin has been administered, because debridement,
irrigation with hydrogen peroxide, and the local application of penicillin may facilitate
the absorption of the toxin.
The objective of administering tetanus antitoxin is to neutralize circulating toxin
outside the CNS. The use of tetanus antitoxin is most appropriate in wounded animals
that are susceptible to but unvaccinated against tetanus or with uncertain vaccination
history. Because binding of tetanospasmin to neural cells is irreversible and because
the tetanus antitoxin is unable to penetrate the blood-brain barrier, administration
of antitoxin is of little value once signs have appeared. After the experimental administration
of toxin, antitoxin is of limited value at 10 hours and ineffective by 48 hours. The
recommended doses vary widely and range from 10,000 to over 300,000 IU per treatment,
given intravenously, intramuscularly, or subcutaneously once or repeatedly, but reported
treatment outcomes are inconsistent. Local injection of some of the antitoxin around
the wound has also been proposed. There have been a number of attempts to justify
the treatment of early cases of equine tetanus by intrathecal injection of antitoxin,
but there is limited evidence of therapeutic value and the procedure carries risk.
The use of tetanus toxoid has also been recommended for patients with tetanus, but
an antibody response may take 2 to 4 weeks and a booster vaccination is required in
previously unvaccinated animals. The effectiveness of this treatment in previously
unvaccinated animals is therefore doubtful. When combining tetanus toxoid and antitoxin,
both compounds should be administered on different sites using different syringes.
Relaxation of the muscle tetany can be attempted with various drugs. Chlorpromazine
(0.4–0.8 mg/kg BW intravenously, or 1.0 mg/kg BW intramuscularly, three or four times
daily) and acepromazine (0.05 mg/kg BW three to four times daily) administered until
severe signs subside, are widely used in horses. A combination of diazepam (0.1–0.4 mg/kg)
and xylazine (0.5–1.0 mg/kg intravenously or intramuscularly) may be effective in
horses refractory to phenothiazine tranquilizers.
Hydration can be maintained by intravenous or stomach-tube feeding during the critical
stages when the animal cannot eat or drink. The use of an indwelling tube should be
considered because of the disturbance caused each time the stomach tube is passed.
Feed and water containers should be elevated, and the feed should be soft and moist.
Additional supportive treatment includes slinging of horses during the recovery period,
when hyperesthesia is diminishing. Affected animals should be kept as quiet as possible
and provided with dark, well-bedded quarters with nonslip flooring and plenty of room
to avoid injury if convulsions occur. Administration of enemas and catheterization
may relieve the animal's discomfort. This level of nursing, plus penicillin, ataractic
drugs, and antitoxin for an average of 14 days, can deliver something like a 50% recovery
by an average of 27 days, but the cost is high. A rumenostomy may be required in ruminant
patients with recurrent bloat.
Horses that fall frequently sustain bone fractures and may need to be destroyed.
Treatment and Control
Treatment
Penicillin G (30,000 IU/kg IM or IV every 12–24 hours) (R-1)
Procaine penicillin (44,000 IU/kg IM every 12–24 hours) (R-1)
Oxytetracycline (15 mg/kg IV every 24 hours) (R-2)
Tetanus antitoxin (10,000–50, 000 IU per dose IM or IV once or repeatedly) (R-2)
Tetanus antitoxin (30,000–50,000 IU per dose intrathecal) (R-3)
Sedation horses
Chlorpromazine (0.4–0.8 mg/kg IV or IM every 6–8 hours) (R-1)
Acepromazine (0.05–0.1 mg/kg IV or IM every 6–8 hours) (R-1)
Diazepam (0.01–0.4 mg/kg IV or IM) (R-1)
Xylazine (0.5–1 mg/kg IV or IM) (R-1)
Sedation cattle
Diazepam (0.5–1.5 mg/kg IV or IM)
Xylazine (0.05–0.15 mg/kg IV or 0.1–0.3 mg/kg IM)
Sedation sheep
Acepromazine (0.05–0.1 mg/kg IV or IM every 6–8 hours) (R-1)
Diazepam (0.2–0.5 mg/kg IV or IM (every 6–8 hours) (R-1)
Control
Regular vaccination if tetanus toxoid (R-1)
Tetanus antitoxin (1500 IU per dose IM in unvaccinated animals with fresh wounds)
(R-1)
IM, intramuscularly, IV, intravenously.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
Many cases of tetanus could be avoided by proper skin and instrument disinfection
at castrating, docking, and shearing time. These operations should be performed in
clean surroundings; in the case of lambs docked in the field, temporary pens are preferred
over permanent yards for catching and penning.
Passive Immunity
Short-term prophylaxis can be achieved by the injection of 1500 IU of tetanus antitoxin.
The immunity is transient, persisting for only 10 to 14 days.
Tetanus Antitoxin
Tetanus antitoxin should be given to any horse with a penetrating wound or deep laceration,
and the wound should also be cleaned aggressively. Tetanus toxoid can be administered
at the same time as tetanus antitoxin, provided they are injected at different sites
and using different syringes. Animals that suffer injury are usually given an injection
of antitoxin and one of toxoid to ensure complete protection.
Tetanus antitoxin is often routinely given to mares following foaling and to newborn
foals. In some areas the risk for tetanus in young foals is high and repeated doses
of antitoxin at weekly intervals may be required for protection.
On farms where the incidence of tetanus in lambs is high, antitoxin is usually given
at the time of docking or castration; 200 IU has been shown to be effective. The risk
for tetanus in calves is lower than in lambs and tetanus antitoxin is not commonly
given at the time of castration.
There is a risk for serum hepatitis in horses that have been given tetanus antitoxin
and, while this risk is small, a policy of routine active immunization of the mare
to provide the mare with active immunity and the foal with passive colostral immunity
is preferred to one that relies on antitoxin. Provided foals get an adequate supply
of colostrum they are protected during the first 10 weeks of life by active vaccination
of the mare during the last weeks of pregnancy. Prevention of tetanus in newborn lambs
is also best effected by vaccination of the ewe in late pregnancy.
Active Immunity
Available vaccines are formalin-inactivated adjuvanted toxoids; they induce long-lasting
immunity. Primary vaccination requires two doses 3 to 6 weeks apart. Protective titers
are obtained within 14 days of the second injection and last for at least a year and
up to 5 years.
Traditionally foals have received primary vaccination at 3 to 4 months of age; however,
there is evidence that maternal antibodies acquired by foals born to mares vaccinated
shortly before parturition significantly inhibit the antibody response of the foal
to primary vaccination until it is 6 months of age and that primary vaccination should
be delayed until that age.
Although immunity lasts longer than 1 year, it is common to revaccinate horses yearly
with a single booster injection. Pregnant mares should receive a booster injection
4 to 6 weeks before foaling to provide adequate colostral immunity to the foal.
Ewes are immunized with a similar schedule except that the primary doses are usually
given at a managementally convenient time when the flock is yarded. A prelambing booster
vaccination is given yearly. Commonly, commercial vaccines for sheep also contain
antigens for other clostridial diseases for which sheep are at high risk.
Vaccination of cattle is usually not considered unless an outbreak of the disease
has occurred in the immediate past and further cases may be anticipated.
References
1
Valgaeren
B
Vlaams Tiergeneesk Tijdschr
80
2011
351
2
Kay
G
Knottenbelt
DC
Equine Vet Educ
19
2007
107
3
Reichmann
P
J Equine Vet Sci
28
2008
518
Botulism
Synopsis
Etiology Neurotoxin produced by Clostridium botulinum during vegetative growth. C.
botulinum types B, C, and D and, on rare instances, type A are associated with disease
in animals but the type prevalence varies geographically.
Epidemiology Ingestion of preformed toxin in which feed preparation or storage allows
multiplication of the organism in the feed with toxin production. Contamination of
feed with carrion containing toxin. Consumption of carrion on pasture by phosphorus-deficient
animals. Risk factors often result in multiple cases. Toxicoinfections with toxin
production from organisms in the intestine or wounds are more uncommon.
Clinical findings Early muscle tremor, progressive symmetric weakness, and motor paralysis
leading to recumbency. Mydriasis, ptosis, weak tongue retraction; sensation and consciousness
retained until death.
Necropsy findings None specific.
Diagnostic confirmation Demonstration of toxin in intestinal contents, serum, or feed.
Demonstration of organisms in feed, intestinal contents, or wounds.
Treatment Type-specific antiserum and supportive treatment.
Control Avoidance of exposure by feed management. Vaccination.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
The causative organism C. botulinum, a spore-forming obligate anaerobe, produces neurotoxins
during vegetative growth. Spores can survive in the environment for over 30 years.
Under favorable conditions of warmth and moisture the spores germinate and vegetative
cells multiply rapidly, elaborating a stable and highly lethal neurotoxin (BoTN) which,
when ingested, or absorbed from tissues, causes the disease. The toxin is also capable
of surviving for long periods, particularly in bones. Seven antigenically distinct
toxin types (A-G), some with subtypes, have been identified. Farm animal disease is
produced primarily by types B, C, D, and occasionally type A. Type A, B, E, and F
toxins are generally related to human botulism.
1
Botulinum neurotoxin forming C. botulinum species are divided into groups I to IV
depending on their physiologic properties.
1
•
Group I: proteolytic C. botulinum type A, B and F. These types degrade protein such
as milk, serum, meat, and chicken protein
•
Group II: nonproteolytic C. botulinum, includes nonprotelytic type B and F and all
type E
•
Group III:
C. botulinum type C and D
•
Group IV:
C. botulinum type G.
The geographic distribution of these types varies considerably. In a study in the
United States, type A was found in neutral or alkaline soils in the west, whereas
types B and E were in damp or wet soil all over, except that B was not found in the
south. Type C was found in acid soils in the Gulf coast, and type D in alkaline soils
in the west. Microorganisms capable of inhibiting C. botulinum were present, with
or without the clostridia, in many soils. Type B is also common in soils in the UK
and in Europe. Types C and D are more common in warm climates.
The organism is present in the alimentary tract of animals that have recently ingested
contaminated material and may be introduced into new areas in this way, or by birds
and blowflies. In healthy animals with normal intestinal fauna and motility C. botulinum
does not multiply in the gastrointestinal tract
Epidemiology
Occurrence
Botulism has no geographic limitations, with isolated cases and sporadic outbreaks
occurring in most countries. The source of exposure to toxin and the risk for disease
differ between regions because of differences in food storage, feeding, and management
practices. Outbreaks associated with ingestion of toxin in conserved feeds are more
common in the northern states of the United States and in Europe, whereas outbreaks
in animals on pasture are reported primarily from South Africa, Australia, and the
Gulf coast area of the United States. The disease usually occurs in a number of animals
at one time and has a high case–fatality rate.
Source of Infection
Most incidents of botulism are associated with the ingestion of preformed toxin (forage
botulism). Toxin in feeds may result from the primary growth of C. botulinum in the
feed or from the contamination of the feed with toxin-containing carrion (carrion-associated
botulism). Less common sources are growth with toxin production in wounds (wound botulism)
or growth and toxin production in the alimentary tract (toxicoinfectious botulism).
Forage Botulism
Forage botulism occurs when pH, moisture, and anaerobic conditions in the feedstuff
allow the vegetative growth of C. botulinum and the production of toxin. This can
occur in a number of spoiled stored forages. Cereal silages carry a risk in the United
States. Silage and hay may spoil to a stage suitable for the growth of C. botulinum.
This is most likely if the forage is very succulent or is wet by rain when it is made.
Big bale silage is a particular risk. The type of forage ensiled in big bales often
has insufficient water-soluble carbohydrate for adequate lactic acid fermentation
to achieve a stable low pH, and the higher dry matter content can also lead to a higher
pH. Clostridial multiplication is inhibited below pH 4.5. Most non–carrion-associated
botulism is caused by type B strains, and horses appear to be especially susceptible.
Proliferation of the organism can occur in decaying vegetable material. The disease
has also occurred in horses fed on spoiled vegetables and potatoes contaminated by
C. botulinum and on alfalfa haylage packed in airtight aluminum foil envelopes. Grass
clippings allowed to accumulate and decay in a pile have poisoned horses, as has round
bale hay that spoiled after rain. Decaying grass at the base of old tussocks and in
trampled stubble are known to be suitable sites for growth of C. botulinum. Cases
have occurred with brewers grains, and high-moisture grain has the potential for toxicity.
Carrion-Associated Botulism
This is almost always the cause of botulism in animals on pasture, and carrion is
also a common cause of botulism in animals on conserved feeds. Carrion includes domestic
and wild animals and birds. In endemic botulism areas, the carcasses of dead animals
are invaded by C. botulinum, and high concentrations of toxin are produced such that
very small amounts of flesh or bone have lethal concentrations. Most outbreaks of
carrion-associated botulism are associated with type C and D strains; these strains
produce much higher concentrations of toxin in carrion than type A and B strains.
Toxin can persist in carrion for at least 1 year. Where the carcasses of rodents,
cats, and birds contaminate hay or silage, toxin can leach out and contaminate surrounding
hay or other feeds to cause multiple cases of botulism. In one instance a single mouse
carcass is thought to have contaminated 200,000 tons of alfalfa cubes. A common source
in Australia is hay made at the time of a mouse plague. At such times even good, fresh
hay can contain a great deal of carrion. In another recorded incident 427 of 444 dairy
cattle died after ingesting feed contaminated with BoTN type C from a cat carcass.
Poultry manure and ensiled poultry litter have caused outbreaks of botulism when used
as fertilizers, as has poultry litter used for bedding cattle.
2
Outbreaks of botulism have occurred in cattle and sheep grazing pastures that have
been fertilized with poultry manure or poultry litter. Cattle and sheep may eat poultry
litter piled on a pasture before disposal. It is probable that the source of toxin
in poultry litter is from poultry carcasses. Disease is usually caused by C. botulinum
type D and occasionally type C.
2
Direct carrion ingestion can occur where cattle subsist on a chronically phosphorus-deficient
diet and manifest osteophagia, with subsequent ingestion of carrion. The disease is
likely to occur in outbreak form. In sheep, pica is more usually associated with a
dietary deficiency of protein or net energy. Occasional outbreaks occur that are caused
by drinking of water contaminated by carcasses of dead animals. A not uncommon occurrence
is livestock drinking lake water contaminated by the carcasses of ducks and other
waterfowl that have died of botulism. Wetlands where outbreaks of avian botulism have
occurred are likely to have repeated occurrences because of soil contamination.
Wound Botulism
Wound botulism is a toxicoinfectious form of botulism where the toxin is produced
in wounds infected by C. botulinum.
3
Wound botulism is rare but is recorded in horses following castration, with omphalophlebitis,
umbilical hernias treated with clamps, with an infected wound and in association with
an injection abscess.
Toxicoinfectious Botulism
This results when toxin is produced by C. botulinum present in the intestine. Two
conditions in horses, equine grass sickness (see Equine grass sickness in Chapter
7) and the shaker foal syndrome, are potential forms of toxicoinfectious botulism.
The shaker foal syndrome is a disease of young foals up to 8 months of age with the
highest prevalence in foals 3 to 8 weeks of age.
The disease occurs sporadically in the United States, Australia, and the UK but may
occur repeatedly on some farms. C. botulinum type B has been isolated from the feces
of naturally occurring cases of the disease, and the condition has been produced experimentally
by the intravenous injection of C. botulinum toxin.
In cattle a toxicoinfection with C. botulinum is suspected to be the cause of a CWD
reported to occur with increased incidence in northern and eastern Germany.4, 5 The
condition was coined as chronic or “visceral” botulism and is thought to be caused
by an enteral dysbiosis, allowing C. botulinum to grow in the ruminant intestinal
tract and to expose the organism to subclinical doses of BoTN over a long time.4,
5 Symptoms associated with this condition are very unspecific including indigestion,
lameness and ataxia, weight loss and drop in milk production, tucked-up abdomen, labored
breathing, edema in brisket and legs, recumbency, and even death in advanced stages.
4
Although in many reported cases of herd outbreaks the diagnosis was solely based on
clinical presentation and by ruling out other differential diagnosis, in several cases
feces and intestinal content of affected or death animals were positively tested for
C. botulinum.
4
The causative relationship is nonetheless under contentious debate because C. botulinum
spores can routinely be isolated from feces of clinically healthy cattle.
6
Experimental Reproduction
Cows challenged with type C botulinum toxin intravenously showed initial signs of
constipation and straining at defecation 48 hours after injection and weakness, decreased
tail tone, decreased tongue tone, and muscle fasciculation of large-muscle groups
between 76 and 92 hours. Weakness progressed to total posterior paresis between 80
and 140 hours in these cattle. On a weight-for-weight basis, cattle were considered
to be 13 times more sensitive than mice to type C botulinum toxin.
Risk Factors
Animal Risk Factors
Botulism is most common in birds, particularly the domestic chicken and wild waterfowl.
Cattle, sheep, and horses are susceptible but pigs, dogs, and cats appear to be resistant.
The horse appears to be particularly susceptible to type B toxin. Cattle and sheep
are usually affected by types C and D.
Environment Risk Factors
Botulism in range animals has a seasonal distribution. Outbreaks are most likely to
occur during drought periods when feed is sparse, phosphorus intake is low, and carrion
is plentiful. Silage-associated botulism is also seasonal with the feeding of silage.
A key epidemiologic factor identified during recent botulism outbreaks in Europe and
Great Britain was the proximity to broiler chicken litter.
2
The variation that occurs in the geographic distribution of the various types, and
in carrion versus non–carrion-associated botulism is an important factor when considering
prophylactic vaccination programs.
Importance
Severe outbreaks with high case–fatality rates can occur when contaminated feed is
fed to large numbers of animals. Under extensive grazing conditions massive outbreaks
of carrion-associated botulism also occur unless the animals are vaccinated.
Zoonotic Implications
BoTN is identified as a possible agent for bioterrorism. Furthermore an increasing
number of large botulism outbreaks in cattle herds in the past decades have raised
public health concerns associated with the consumption of meat or milk originating
from affected herds.1, 7, 8 In Germany, anecdotal reports of farmers having developed
clinical signs resembling symptoms observed in their livestock suspected to suffer
of a chronic form of botulism have contributed to these concerns.
9
Notwithstanding there is no evidence to support the assumption that there could be
transmission between humans and animals.1, 7 Even the cases in which farm personnel
and cattle were affected by a condition thought to be associated with C. botulinum
different types of C. botulinum were isolated from people and cattle.4, 9
The available evidence for the occurrence of human cases associated with meat and
milk consumption has been reviewed.
7
No human cases of clinical botulism that were associated with the consumption of meat
or milk derived from animals with botulism or healthy animals from herds affected
by botulism were identified.
7
No cases of calves contracting clinical botulism from the consumption of raw milk
in herds affected by botulism or cases of other species (dogs) contracting botulism
from the consumption of fresh meat were available.
7
Only one report of a cow affected by clinical botulism has been published in which
BoTN was found in one mastitic quarter. The interpretation of this result is complicated
by the fact that the BoTN affecting this animal was BoTN type C, whereas the BoNT
type E was isolated in milk.
1
Furthermore the toxin was retrieved in a mastitic quarter but not the remaining three
clinically healthy quarters. It has therefore been suggested that the BoNT retrieved
in this quarter was either produced locally or is the result of contamination.
1
Cows are relatively sensitive to BoTN, whereas the toxin is rarely detectable in the
blood of clinical cases. The excretion of BoTN in relevant amounts through the mammary
gland is therefore considered to be unlikely. Nonetheless because of the mentioned
uncertainties the meat and milk from cattle that have botulism should not be used
for human consumption.
Pathogenesis
The toxins of C. botulinum are neurotoxins and produce functional paralysis without
the development of histologic lesions. Botulinum toxins are absorbed from the intestinal
tract or the wound and carried via the bloodstream to peripheral cholinergic nerve
terminals including neuromuscular junctions, postganglionic parasympathetic nerve
endings, and peripheral ganglia. The heavy chain of the toxin is responsible for binding
to the receptors and translocation into the cell and the light chain of the toxin
for resultant blockade of the release of acetylcholine at the neuromuscular junction.
Flaccid paralysis develops and the animal may die of respiratory paralysis.
Clinical Findings
Cattle and Horses
Signs usually appear 3 to 17 days after the animals gain access to the toxic material,
but occasionally as soon as day 1, the incubation period is shorter as the amount
of toxin available is increased. Peracute cases die without prior signs of illness,
although a few fail to take water or food for a day beforehand. The disease is not
accompanied by fever, and the characteristic clinical picture is one of progressive
symmetric muscular paralysis affecting particularly the limb muscles and the muscles
of the jaw, tongue, and throat. Muscle weakness and paralysis commence in the hindquarters
and progress to the forequarters, head, and neck. The onset is marked by very obvious
muscle tremor and fasciculation, often sufficient to make the whole limb tremble.
Colic may be an initial sign in horses.
In most cases the disease is subacute. Restlessness, incoordination, stumbling, knuckling,
and ataxia are followed by inability to rise or to lift the head. Mydriasis and ptosis
occur early in the clinical course; mydriasis can be prominent in type C botulism
in the horse. Skin sensation is retained. Affected animals lie in sternal recumbency
with the head on the ground or turned into the flank, not unlike the posture of a
cow with parturient paresis. Tongue tone is reduced, as is the strength of tongue
retraction. In some cases the tongue becomes paralyzed and hangs from the mouth, the
animal is unable to chew or swallow, and it drools saliva. In others there is no impairment
of swallowing or mastication and the animal continues to eat until the end. This variation
in signs is often a characteristic of an outbreak; either all the cases have tongue
paralysis or all of them do not have it. Ruminal movements are depressed. Defecation
and urination are usually unaffected, although cattle may be constipated. Paralysis
of the chest muscles results in a terminal abdominal-type respiration. Sensation and
consciousness are retained until the end, which usually occurs quietly, and with the
animal in lateral recumbency, 1 to 4 days after the commencement of illness.
Occasional field cases and some experimental cases in cattle show mild signs and recover
after an illness of 3 to 4 weeks. These chronic cases show restlessness and respiratory
distress followed by knuckling, stumbling, and disinclination to rise. Anorexia and
adipsia are important early signs but are often not observed in pastured animals.
In some there is a pronounced roaring sound with each respiration. The roaring persists
for up to 3 months. During the major part of the illness the animals spend most of
their time in sternal recumbency. In some animals there is difficulty in prehending
hay but concentrate and ensilage may be taken. This disability may persist for 3 weeks.
A syndrome ascribed to toxicosis with BoTN type B and manifested with anorexia, decline
in milk production, dysphagia, a fetid diarrhea, regurgitation, and profuse salivation
without myesthesia, paresis, and recumbency is reported in cattle in the Netherlands
and Israel. In these cases death occurred as a result of aspiration pneumonia.
With toxicoinfectious botulism in foals, muscle tremor is often a prominent early
sign. If the foal can walk, the gait is stiff and stilted and the toes are dragged.
If the foal sucks, milk drools from the mouth; if it attempts to eat hay some of the
material is regurgitated through the nostrils. Constipation occurs consistently. There
is a rapid progression to severe muscular weakness and prostration, with the foal
going down and being unable to rise. If it is held up, there is a gross muscle tremor,
which is not evident when the foal is lying down. Prostrate foals are bright and alert,
have normal mentation and pain perception, and have dilatation of the pupils with
a sluggish pupillary light reflex. During the latter period of the illness there is
a complete cessation of peristalsis. The temperature varies from being slightly elevated
to slightly depressed. Death occurs about 72 hours after the onset of signs and is
caused by respiratory failure.
Sheep
Sheep do not show the typical flaccid paralysis of other species until the final stages
of the disease. There is stiffness while walking and incoordination and some excitability
in the early stages. The head may be held on one side or bobbed up and down while
walking (limber neck). Lateral switching of the tail, salivation, and serous nasal
discharge are also common. In the terminal stages there is abdominal respiration,
limb paralysis, and rapid death.
Goats
Because of different feeding habits of sheep and goats the risk of exposure to BoTN
of goats is considerably lower compared with sheep or cattle. Although goats look
for bushes and shrubs on which to browse, cattle and sheep graze along the ground
and are therefore more likely to ingest BoTN from contaminated waste spread over pasture.
8
Pigs
Authentic reports in this species are rare. Clinical signs include staggering followed
by recumbency, vomiting, and pupillary dilatation. The muscular paralysis is flaccid
and affected animals do not eat or drink.
Clinical Pathology
There are no changes in hematologic values or serum biochemistry that are specific
to botulism. In many cases under field conditions the diagnosis is solely based on
clinical presentation and by ruling out potential differential diagnoses.
Laboratory diagnosis of botulism in the live or dead animal is difficult because of
the lack of sensitive confirmatory laboratory tests. Laboratory confirmation is attempted
by the following:
•
Detection of preformed toxin in serum, intestinal tract contents, or feed
•
Demonstration of spores of C. botulinum in the feed or gastrointestinal contents
•
Detection of antibody in recovering or clinically normal at-risk animals.
Detection of toxin using bioassay in mice where mice are inoculated intraperitoneally
coupled with toxin neutralization with polyvalent antitoxin is considered the most
sensitive test currently available. Nonetheless the rate of positivity in clinical
cases particularly when testing serum is low, which has been explained by the much
higher sensitivity to BoNT of cattle and horse compared with mice and the rapid binding
of BoNT in the neuromuscular junctions, leaving low to no amounts of free BoNT in
blood. Currently gastrointestinal content or fecal material is preferred over fecal
material for the detection of BoNT.5, 7
In outbreaks of botulism it is not uncommon to have only a proportion of clinically
affected animals, or none, test positive. Protection with monovalent antitoxin allows
type identification. Toxin detection by an ELISA test appears less sensitive than
mouse bioassay. Toxin production or carrion contamination can potentially occur in
a number of feeds; however, the majority of outbreaks are associated with contamination
in hay or silage and suspect feeds should be tested in mice for toxin. To get around
the problem of lack of sensitivity with the mouse test, suspect feed has been fed
to experimental cattle. Alternatively, one can make an infusion of the feed sample
and use this as the sole drinking water supply for experimental animals. The problem
with all feeding experiments is that the BoTN is likely to be very patchy in its distribution
in the feed.
Failure to produce the disease in animals vaccinated against botulism, when deaths
are occurring in the unvaccinated controls, has also been used as a diagnostic procedure.
Demonstration of spores of C. botulinum in the feed being fed or the feces of affected
animals supports a diagnosis of botulism because botulism spores are rarely detected
in the feces of normal foals and adult horses. Although the testing of gastrointestinal
contents from clinically suspect cases in cattle is frequently used as diagnostic
tool particularly when toxicoinfectious botulism is suspected, this approach is considered
to lack specificity because the postmortem growth of environmental C. botulinum spores
would result in false-positive results.2, 4, 9 Furthermore C. botulinum can be isolated
from the majority of fecal samples of healthy slaughter cows.
The detection of antibody in chronically affected animals and at-risk herdmates or
as retrospective diagnosis by an ELISA test has been used to support a diagnosis in
outbreaks of type C and type D botulism. Increased antibody prevalence over time or
increased antibody prevalence in an affected group compared with a similar group nearby
was reported by some authors.
10
Necropsy Findings
There are no specific changes detectable at necropsy, although the presence of suspicious
feedstuffs in the forestomachs or stomach may be suggestive. There may be nonspecific
subendocardial and subepicardial hemorrhages and congestion of the intestines. Microscopic
changes in the brain are also nonspecific, consisting mainly of perivascular hemorrhages
in the corpus striatum, cerebellum, and cerebrum. Nonetheless, unless classic flaccid
paralysis was observed clinically, the brain should be examined histologically to
eliminate other causes of neurologic disease. The presence of C. botulinum in the
alimentary tract is a further test. The presence of toxin in the gut contents is confirmatory
if found but is often misleading, because the toxin may have already been absorbed.
The presence of the toxin in the liver at postmortem examination is taken as evidence
that the disease has occurred. In addition to traditional bioassays, such as the mouse
protection test, newer methods for toxin detection include ELISA techniques, and a
recently described immuno-PCR assay.
Samples for Confirmation of Diagnosis
•
Bacteriology: suspected contaminated feed material, feces, rumen and intestinal contents,
plus serum from clinically affected herdmates (bioassay, anaerobic CULT, ELISA)
•
Histology: formalin-fixed brain.
Differential Diagnosis
A presumptive diagnosis is made on the clinical signs and history, occurrence in unvaccinated
animals, and the ruling out of other diseases with a similar clinical presentation.
The symmetric motor paralysis of botulism with muscle paralysis that progresses to
recumbency in 1–4 days is a major differential for botulism from other causes of neurologic
dysfunction in large animals.
Ruminants
•
Periparturient hypocalcemia, characterized by low serum calcium concentrations and
responsiveness to parenteral calcium administration
•
Hypokalemia, characterized by marked hypokalemia
•
Tick paralysis
•
Paralytic rabies
•
Poisoning by Phalaris aquatica
•
Organophosphate/carbamate poisoning
•
Louping-ill in sheep
Horses
•
Equine encephalomyelitis
•
Equine herpesvirus-1 myeloencephalopathy
•
Atypical myopathy of unknown etiology; the condition that presents frequently fatal
myopathy can be differentiated by the characteristic increase in serum creatine kinase
activity and the presence of hemoglobinuria
•
Equine motor neuron disease
•
Hyperkalemic periodic paralysis
•
Hepatic encephalopathy
•
Paralytic rabies
•
Ionophore toxicity
•
Myasthenia gravis
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Recent studies report a survival rate in foals of 96% which was achieved by the early
administration of antitoxin (before complete recumbency) coupled with a high quality
of intensive care fluid therapy, enteral or parenteral feeding, nasal insufflation
with oxygen, and mechanical ventilation if required. Duration of hospitalization was
approximately 2 weeks. Antitoxin was considered essential to the high success rate
in this report and this would limit the success of treatment geographically because
antitoxin to the various BoTN types is not available universally. Specific or polyvalent
antiserum is available in some countries and, if administered early in the course
at a dose of 30,000 IU for a foal and 70,000 IU for adult horses, can improve the
likelihood of survival. A single dose is sufficient, but it is expensive.
Animals should be confined to a stall with supportive fluid therapy and enteral feeding.
Muzzling may be required to prevent aspiration pneumonia and frequent turning to prevent
muscle necrosis and decubital ulcers. Bladder catheterization may be required in horses
that do not urinate, and mechanical ventilation may be necessary for recumbent horses.
Mineral oil is used to prevent constipation, and antimicrobial drugs are used to treat
secondary complications such as aspiration pneumonia. Therapy should avoid the use
of drugs that deplete the neuromuscular junction of acetylcholine, such as neostigmine,
and those, such as procaine penicillin, tetracyclines, and aminoglycosides, that potentiate
neuromuscular weakness.
A rapid progression of signs suggests a poor prognosis, and treatment should only
be undertaken in subacute cases in which signs develop slowly and there is some chance
of recovery. The prognosis in recumbent horses is grave.
Where groups of animals have had the same exposure factor, the remainder of the animals
in the group should be vaccinated immediately.
Vaccination with either type-specific or combined BoNT toxoid in clinically affected
animals is ineffective because binding of BoNT to neuromuscular junctions is irreversible.
Treatment and Control
Treatment
Polyvalent antiserum (30,000 IU for a foal and 70,000 IU for an adult horse, single
dose) (R-2)
Control
Vaccinate with multivalent BoTN toxoid IM (R-2)
BoTN, botulin toxin, IM, intramuscularly.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Control
In range animals, correction of dietary deficiencies by supplementation with phosphorus
or protein should be implemented if conditions permit. Hygienic disposal of carcasses
is advisable to prevent further pasture contamination but may not be practicable under
range conditions. Vaccination with type-specific or combined (bivalent C and D) toxoid
is practiced in enzootic areas in Australia and southern Africa. Type B and C vaccines
would be more appropriate for prevention of disease in North America and Europe. The
immunity engendered by vaccination is type specific. The number and interval of vaccinations
required varies with the vaccine, and the manufacturer's directions should be followed.
In horses, the disease is usually sporadic and caused by accidental contamination
of feed or water; vaccination is seldom practiced in this species. Some local reactions
are encountered after vaccination in horses but they are seldom serious. Vaccination
of the mare may not prevent the occurrence of botulism in foals.
A common problem that arises when the disease appears to have resulted from feeding
contaminated silage, hay, or other feed is what to do with the residue of the feed.
In these circumstances the stock should be vigorously vaccinated with a toxoid on
three occasions at 2-week intervals and then feeding of the same material can be recommenced.
Further Reading
Jones
T
Botulism
In Pract
18
1996
312
313
Lindström
M
Myllykoski
J
Sivelä
S
Clostridium botulinum in cattle and dairy products
Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr
50
2010
281
304
20301016
Smith
LDS
Sugiyama
H
Botulism, the Organisms, Its Toxins, the Disease
1988
Charles C Thomas
Springfield, IL
Whitlock
RH
Botulism, type C: experimental and field cases in horses
Equine Pract
18
10
1996
11
17
Whitlock
RH
Buckley
C
Botulism
Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract
13
1997
107
128
9106347
References
1
Lindström
M
Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr
50
2010
281
20301016
2
Kennedy
S
Ball
H
Vet Rec
168
2011
638
21685421
3
Whitlock
RH
McAdams
S
Clin Tech Equine Pract
5
2006
37
4
Krüger
M
Anaerobe
18
2012
221
22200452
5
Böhnel
H
Gessler
F
Vet Rec
172
2013
397
23585115
6
Brooks
CE
Vet Microbiol
144
2010
226
20116183
7
ACMSF (Advisory committee on the microbiological safety of food)
Accessed August, 2016; at
http://acmsf.food.gov.uk/sites/default/files/mnt/drupal_data/sources/files/multimedia/pdfs/botulismincattlereport1206.pdf
2006
8
ACMSF (Advisory committee on the microbiological safety of food)
Accessed August 2016; at
http://acmsf.food.gov.uk/sites/default/files/mnt/drupal_data/sources/files/multimedia/pdfs/botulisminsheepgoats.pdf
2009
9
Rodloff
AC
Krüger
M
Anaerobe
18
2012
226
228
22197952
10
Mawhinney
I
Vet J
192
2012
382
384
21955441
Tick Paralysis
Infestations with a several species of ticks are associated with paralysis of animals.
Dogs are most commonly affected but losses can occur in cattle, sheep, goats, llamas,
horses, and a variety of wild animals. At least 31 species in seven genera of ixodid
ticks and seven species in three genera of argasid ticks have been implicated in tick
paralysis. The most important tick species for livestock are given in Table 14-22
. D. andersoni is the most common cause of tick paralysis in livestock in North America;
D. occidentalis is associated with paralysis in cattle, horses, and deer.
1
In Australia, I. holocyclus is the predominant tick associated with paralysis, whereas
I. rubicundus and Rhipecephalus evertsi are common in Africa.
1
Animals in Europe and Asia have developed tick paralysis from I. ricinus and Hyalomma
punctata.
1
Table 14-22
Ticks reported to cause paralysis in livestock
Table 14-22
Animal
Tick
Country
Sheep, calves, goats
Dermacentor andersoni
United States, Canada
D. occidentalis
United States
Calves, lambs, foals, goats
Ixodes holocyclus
Australia
Sheep, goats, calves
I. pilosus
South Africa
Sheep, goats, calves, antelopes
I. rubicundus
South Africa
Sheep, goats
I. ricinus
Crete, Israel
Lambs
Rhipicephalus evertsi
South Africa
Calves, sheep, goats
Hyalomma punctata
South Africa, Europe, Japan
Sheep
H. aegyptium
Yugoslavia
Sheep
Ornithodorus lahorensis
Central Asia
Cattle, sheep, goats
Amblyomma cajannense
Central, South America
Cattle
R. evertsi
Africa
The toxin of D. andersoni interferes with liberation or synthesis of acetylcholine
at the muscle fiber motor end plates.
2
The disturbance is functional and paralysis of the peripheral neurons is the basis
for clinical signs. Continuous secretion of toxin by a large number (35–150) of partly
engorged female ticks that have been attached for 5 to 8 days is necessary to produce
paralysis, with complete recovery occurring within 24 hours when the ticks are removed.
The disease is generally confined to calves and yearlings. Clinically, there is an
ascending, flaccid paralysis commencing with incoordination of the hindlimbs, followed
by paralysis of the forelimbs and chest muscles, causing lateral recumbency.
1
Respiration is grossly abnormal; there is a double expiratory effort and the rate
is slow (12–15 breaths per minute) but deep. Death, caused by respiratory failure,
may occur in 1 to 2 days, but the course is usually 4 to 5 days. The mortality rate
may be as high as 50% in dogs, but is usually much lower in farm animals.
I. holocyclus have been shown to paralyze calves of 25 to 50 kg BW. Between 4 and
10 adult female ticks are required to produce this effect and paralysis occurs 6 to
13 days after infestation occurs. The ticks under natural conditions parasitize wild
fauna, and infestations of other species occur accidentally. The disease is limited
in its distribution by the ecology of the ticks and the natural host fauna. The paralysis
characteristic of the disease is associated with a toxin secreted by the salivary
glands of female ticks, which is present in much greater concentration in the glands
of adults than in other stages. The severity of the paralysis is independent of the
number of ticks involved; susceptible animals may be seriously affected by a few ticks.
1
Hyperimmune serum is used in the treatment of dogs, but in farm animals removal of
the ticks in the early stages is usually followed by rapid recovery. Control necessitates
eradication of the ticks or host fauna. The general principles of tick control are
outlined in Chapter 11. The use of appropriate insecticides is an effective preventive.
Further Reading
Sonenshine
DE
Lane
RS
Nicholson
WL
Ticks (Ixodia)
Mullen
G
Durden
L
Medical and Veterinary Entomology
2002
Academic Press
New York
517
558
References
1
Gwaltney-Brant
SM
Dunayer
E
Youssef
H
Terrestrial zootoxins
Gupta
RC
Veterinary Toxicology
2012
Elsevier
Amsterdam
969
2
Lysyk
TJ
J Med Entomol
46
2009
358
19351088
Ovine “Kangaroo Gait” and Fenugreek Staggers
Synopsis
Etiology Not known.
Epidemiology Seasonal occurrence involving only adult female sheep that are lactating,
or in some cases, pregnant. Spontaneous recovery following cessation of lactation
in most cases, but sometimes only 50%, but not always all affected sheep.
Clinical findings Bilateral forelimb locomotor disorder.
Lesions Edema of brain and spinal cord in early cases; axonal degeneration of the
radial nerve followed by regeneration in more chronic cases (those greater than 6
weeks' duration).
Treatment Supportive.
Control None recognized.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Etiology
This is a neuropathy with no known cause. In Australia similar clinical and pathologic
signs are associated with grazing mature plants or the stubble of fenugreek (Trigonella
foenum-graecum), which is an annual winter-spring legume from which the seed is harvested
as a condiment for human food.
1
Epidemiology
Occurrence
This condition is recorded in Australia, New Zealand, and the UK. It is manifested
by incoordination, including an acute onset of a high-stepping forelimb gait and bounding
hindlimb gait.
Risk Factors
It occurs only in adult ewes with an onset in late pregnancy or early lactation. Spontaneous
recovery occurs following cessation of lactation, and occasionally while ewes are
still nursing lambs, although in Australia often only 50% of ewes recover completely.
1
The cumulative annual incidence varies between flocks but is usually less than 1%.
In the areas of northern England and southern Scotland the condition is significantly
more common in upland and lowland flocks than in those hill grazing. Stocking density
is higher in affected flocks than that in nonaffected flocks. Onset occurs while on
pasture between March and June with a separate smaller peak in October. This seasonal
occurrence could be a reflection of the parturition status of flocks or an effect
of seasonal influences.
In Australia cases have been recorded in lactating ewes grazing improved pastures
from June (winter) to February (summer) and the grazing of fenugreek crop or stubble
in summer.
Pathogenesis
Clinical signs can be attributed to the generalized neuropathy affecting principally
the radial nerves. Subsequent to the axonal degeneration a remyelination of the radial
nerve occurs, explaining the clinical recovery. For cases not associated with ingestion
of fenugreek, bilateral compression of the radial nerves is suggested as a cause,
but there is no knowledge of how such an injury can occur. Despite the differences
in diet, the similar clinical and pathologic presentation of kangaroo gait and fenugreek
staggers has prompted the suggestion that these may be related entities.
1
Nevertheless there are some key differences; the initial acute stage of fenugreek
staggers in Merino sheep is sometimes lethal and is later associated with weight loss,
whereas kangaroo gait is not and seems to be restricted to larger meat breeds.
Clinical Findings
These include incoordination, a high-stepping forelimb and bounding hindlimb gait,
arched back, and proprioceptive deficits (knuckling of fore and occasionally hind
fetlocks). There is bilateral forelimb paresis and palpable loss of muscle bulk in
the forelimbs. The forelimbs and hindlimbs of affected sheep are positioned centrally
under the body and so when they are pressed affected sheep move with a characteristic
hopping or kangaroo gait. Affected ewes lie down more frequently and may graze on
their knees but continue to eat and effectively suckle their lambs.
Clinical Pathology
There are no consistent abnormalities in hematology, blood biochemistry, or trace
element analysis of affected sheep.
Necropsy Findings
In early cases there are signs of acute edema in the brain and spinal cord (wallerian
degeneration of ventral motor tracts, spongy changes in the neuropil, and swollen
astrocytes). This progresses to a peripheral neuropathy, with axonal degeneration
of the myelinated fibers of the radial nerve fibers in longer standing cases (6 weeks
or more), and then regeneration in recovering cases.
Differential Diagnosis
Romulosis, a condition associated with grazing fungus-infected onion grass (Romulea
rosea), can cause incoordination and a similar hopping gait (bunny-hopping).
Foot rot or foot abscess involving the front feet can induce the same grazing behavior,
but there is no problem in differentiation when the limbs and feet are examined.
Hypocalcemia in sheep occurs in late pregnancy or during lactation, and in the developing
stages there is incoordination and muscle weakness. However, there is rapid progression
to complete muscular paresis and a dramatic response to treatment.
Spinal abscess or fracture.
Alt-text: Unlabelled box
Treatment
Without the knowledge of etiology there is no specific treatment. Easy access to food
and water should be provided.
Further Reading
Radostits
O
Ovine “kangaroo gait.”
Veterinary Medicine: A Textbook of the Disease of Cattle, Horses, Sheep, Goats and
Pigs
10th ed
2007
W.B. Saunders
London
2019
Reference
1
Bourke
C
Aust Vet J
87
2009
99
19245621
Polyneuritis Equi (Cauda Equina Syndrome)
Polyneuritis equi (formerly cauda equina neuritis) is a demyelinating, inflammatory
disease of peripheral nerves of adult horses. The etiology of the disease is unknown
although infectious (adenovirus, EHV-1), immune (autoimmune disease), and toxic etiologies
have been suggested, without conclusive substantiation. Adenovirus was isolated from
two of three horses with the disease, but this observation has not been repeated,
and it appears unlikely at this time that adenovirus is the cause of polyneuritis
equi. EHV-1 is not consistently isolated from affected horses.
The disease occurs in adult horses in Europe and North America but has not been reported
from the Southern Hemisphere. The prevalence in a group of 4319 horses subject to
postmortem examination in Normandy was 0.2% (one case).
1
The disease is usually sporadic with single animals on a farm or in a stable affected.
However, outbreaks of the disease can affect multiple horses from the same farm over
a number of years.
The pathogenesis of the disease involves nonsuppurative inflammation of the extradural
nerves and demyelination of peripheral nerves. Initial inflammation of the nerves
causes hyperesthesia, which is followed by loss of sensation as nerves are demyelinated.
Both motor and sensory nerves are affected, with subsequent weakness, paresis, muscle
atrophy, urinary and fecal retention and incontinence, and gait abnormalities.
The inflammatory response is characterized by an abundance of T lymphocytes, in addition
to B lymphocytes, macrophages, giant cells, eosinophils, and neutrophils in the perineurium
and endomeurium.
2
The T cells are CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes with rare CD4+ helper T lymphocytes.
3
This, with electron microscopic imaging, evidence of “myelin stripping” by macrophages
and the presence of antibodies to the myelin P2 protein has been interpreted as indicative
of immune-mediated activity against myelin.2, 4 This immune response might be toward
the myelin as a primary target or could be the result of bystander activity in which
other agents, potentially viruses, induce an immune response that is directed against
myelin.
The acute disease is evident as abrupt onset of hyperesthesia of the perineum and
tail head, and perhaps the face, evident as avoidance of touching, and chewing or
rubbing of the tail. The hyperesthesia progresses to hypalgesia or anesthesia of the
affected regions.
The disease usually has a more insidious onset with loss of sensation and function
occurring over days to weeks. The most common presentation is that of cauda equina
syndrome with bilaterally symmetric signs of posterior weakness, tail paralysis, fecal
and urinary incontinence and retention, and atrophy of the gluteal muscles. Tail tone
is decreased or absent and the tail is easily raised by the examiner. The anus is
usually atonic and dilated. There are signs of urinary incontinence with urine scalding
of the escutcheon and hindlegs. Rectal examination reveals fecal retention and a distended
bladder that is readily expressed. Male horses can have prolapse of the penis with
maintained sensation in the prepuce, which is a finding consistent with the separate
innervation of these anatomic regions. Affected horses can also have ataxia of the
hindlimbs, but this is always combined with signs of cauda equina disease.
Signs of CN dysfunction occur as part of the disease, but not in all cases. CN dysfunction
can be symmetric, but is usually asymmetric. Nerves prominently involved in the genesis
of clinical signs are the trigeminal (CN V), facial (CN VII), and hypoglossal nerve
(CN XII), although all CNs can be affected to some extent. Involvement of the CNs
is evident as facial paralysis (CN VII), weakness of the tongue (CN XII), and loss
of sensation in the skin of the face (CN V). There can be loss of movement of the
pinnae (CN VII) and head tilt (CN VIII). Laryngeal paralysis can be present (CN X).
The buccal branches of CN VII can be enlarged and palpable over the masseter muscles
ventral to the facial crest.
Not all clinical signs occur in all horses and, depending on the stage and severity
of the disease, some animals can have loss of sensation as the only abnormality, especially
during the early stages of the disease.
EMG is consistent with denervation with prolonged insertion potentials, positive sharp
waves, and fibrillation. Per rectal ultrasound examination of the extradural sacral
nerve routes as they exit the ventral sacral foramina reveals enlargement and a diffusely
mottled, hypoechoic appearance.
3
Biopsy of the sacrocaudalis dorsalis lateralis muscle can provide antemortem diagnosis
of the disease. Affected horses have intense lymphocytic and histiocytic infiltration
around the terminal nerves within the muscle, often obliterating architecture of the
nerves but sparing the myofibers.
3
There is neurogenic atrophy of the muscle fibers.
The disease is inexorably progressive, the prognosis for life is hopeless, and the
course of the disease is usually less than 3 months.
Clinical pathologic abnormalities are not diagnostic. There is sometimes a mild neutrophilic
leukocytosis and hypergammaglobulinemia. Serum vitamin E concentrations are usually
normal. Analysis of CSF demonstrates mild mononuclear pleocytosis and increased protein
concentrations, but these changes are not diagnostic of the disease. Horses with polyneuritis
equi have antibodies to P2 myelin protein in serum, but the diagnostic value of this
test has not been determined.
Necropsy findings are definitive for the disease. Gross findings include thickening
of the epidural nerve roots that is most severe in the cauda equina. The bladder and
rectum can be distended. There can be evidence of fecal and urine scalding and self-trauma
of the perineum. There can be thickening of the facial nerves. Microscopic changes
are characterized by a granulomatous inflammation of the extradural nerves, although
radiculoganglioneuritis and myelitis can also occur. There is loss of axons with demyelination
and signs of remyelination. There is profound infiltration of nerves by macrophages,
moderate to marked infiltration of cytotoxic T lymphocytes, and lesser infiltration
of B lymphocytes.
3
Inflammatory cells are initially lymphocytes, plasma cells, and macrophages. As the
inflammation becomes more severe or chronic there is extensive proliferation of fibroblasts
and fibrocytes in addition to infiltration of lymphocytes and macrophages. There is
axonal degeneration with proliferation of the perineurium. The chronic inflammatory
changes result in loss of peripheral neural architecture. Lesions are present in many
regions of the spinal cord, but are most severe in the sacral division and cauda equina.
Lysosomal accumulations are present in the semilunar, geniculate, and sympathetic
chains and granulomatous lesions in the celiac-mesenteric ganglion. Lesions of the
CNs similarly involve infiltration with lymphocytes and histiocytes, and the inflammation
can extend to the terminal branches of the nerves.
The diagnosis of polyneuritis equi is based on the presence of clinical signs of the
disease, ruling out other diseases causing similar clinical signs, and necropsy examination.
Diseases with manifestations similar to polyneuritis equi include the following:
•
EHV-1 myeloencephalopathy
•
Migrating parasites (Table 14-21, differential diagnosis of disease causing spinal
ataxia in horses)
•
Sorghum-Sudan grass neuropathy
•
Equine protozoal myeloencephalitis
•
Ryegrass staggers (A. lolii)
•
Dourine
•
Trauma to the sacral vertebral column
•
Abscess or neoplasia involving the sacral or caudal lumbar vertebral column
•
Meningitis
•
Intentional alcohol sclerosis of tail head nerves in Quarter Horses.
There is no definitive treatment for polyneuritis equi. Administration of antiinflammatory
agents, including corticosteroids, appears to be without sustained benefit. Supportive
care includes evacuation of the rectum and bladder and maintenance of hydration and
provision of adequate nutrition. Feeding a diet that softens feces, or administration
of fecal softeners or lubricants, can be beneficial. Bethanecol (0.05–0.1 mg/kg every
8–12 hours, orally) might increase bladder tone. Topical administration of petroleum
jelly or similar products can protect the skin of the perineum and escutcheon from
fecal and urine scalding.
References
1
Laugier
C
J Equine Vet Sci
29
2009
561
2
van Galen
G
Equine Vet J
40
2008
185
18267887
3
Aleman
M
J Vet Intern Med
23
2009
665
19645849
4
Hahn
CN
Equine Vet J
40
2008
100
18302992
Scandinavian Knuckling Syndrome (Acquired Equine Polyneuropathy)
This is a recently recognized syndrome of metatarsophalangeal joint extensor paresis
in horses in Scandinavia.1, 2, 3 The disease appears to be widespread in Sweden, Norway,
and Finland occurring as clusters of disease outbreaks on farms.
1
The etiology is uncertain, although preserved feed is considered the source of an
unidentified toxin.
A report described the risk factors and outcome of 42 cases distributed over 13 farms
in Scandinavia from 2007 to 2009. Cases occurred between December and May with an
overall prevalence of 27% and on-farm prevalence of 11% to 71% (for farms with >6
horses) although the number of cases, and affected farms, varies markedly from year
to year.2, 4 The case–fatality rate was 29% in the epidemiology study
1
and 53% (40 of 75) in a case series.
2
The disease was less prevalent in horses >12 years of age, and younger horses had
a greater chance of surviving the disease.
Clinical signs were typified by bilateral knuckling of the hindlimbs, which was most
apparent on circling. Mild to moderate pelvic limb weakness was detected in 16 of
42 horses.
1
A small proportion of cases (3/42) had mild forelimb signs of weakness and knuckling.
There was focal muscle atrophy of hindlimb musculature in seven cases. Mentation and
vital signs (temperature, pulse, and respiratory rate) were within normal limits.
The disease usually has a slow onset, but some affected horses developed severe signs
with hours.
2
The median duration of clinical signs in affected horses that recover is 4.4 months
(range 1–17 months) and survivors can recover completely.
Routine hematology and serum biochemical analysis do not reveal consistent abnormalities,
apart from increased creatine kinase and AST activity in recumbent horses.
2
Lesions are restricted to the peripheral nervous system and are evident in sciatic,
peroneal, radial, and plantar digital nerves.2, 3 Lesions include areas of thick,
swollen axons with subperineural accumulation of mucoid material. There is lymphohistiocytic
infiltration of nerves and mild to moderate loss of myelinated nerve fibers.
3
Swollen axons and large vacuoles were present in sections of the lumbar tumescence.
There are no lesions detected in the brain.
2
Treatment consists of supportive and nursing care. Control measures are not reported.
References
1
Grondahl
G
Equine Vet J
44
2012
36
2
Hanche-Olsen
S
J Vet Intern Med
22
2008
178
18289307
3
Hahn
CN
Equine Vet J
40
2008
231
18089473
4
Wolff
C
BMC Vet Res
10
2014
265
25398211
Peripheral Nerve Sheath Tumors
PNSTs are most commonly benign tumors of the peripheral nervous system with a rare
occurrence in veterinary medicine.
1
Most commonly affected species are dogs and cattle.
1
Tumors are composed of components of the peripheral nerve, including Schwann cells,
perineural cells, fibroblasts and collagen. While in human medicine PNSTs are subdivided
into neurofibromas and schwannomas, dependent on the predominant cell type and other
histologic characteristics, this distinction is less clearly defined in veterinary
medicine.2, 3 The existence of true neurofibromas as described in humans has been
questioned.1, 2 PNSTs that can occur on any location of the peripheral nervous system
most commonly originate from autonomic nerves such as cardiac and intercostal nerves
or the brachial plexus.
Clinical Findings
In cattle, PNSTs are generally asymptomatic and found incidentally during physical
examination or slaughter. Clinical signs are uncommon but can include limb paresis
or paralysis, recurrent bloat and vagal indigestion, cardiac insufficiency, and chronic
wasting.1, 3, 4 The cutaneous presentation is rare but can present as single or multiple
indolent cutaneous masses between 1 and over 15 cm in diameter that are well demarcated.
In some instances PMSTs may infiltrate surrounding tissue, immobilizing the mass and
complicating surgical excision.
Clinical Pathology
Diagnosis must be confirmed histologically. Important features included the concurrent
presence of highly and poorly cellular areas of Schwann cells. Nerve fibers are absent
in schwannomas but may be found in neurofibromas. Immunohistostaining is used to confirm
the presence of Schwann cells and to differentiate between schwannomas and neurofibromas.1,
2
Treatment
Treatment of accessible masses (cutaneous form) is rarely required but may be indicated
either for cosmetic reasons as an excisional biopsy or to remove the mass integrally.
Although the prognosis in most cases is excellent, tumors with infiltrative growth
may recur because of incomplete excision of abnormal c ells.
References
1
Schöniger
S
Summer
BA
Vet Pathol
46
2009
904
19429995
2
Nielsen
AB
J Comp Pathol
137
2007
224
17888938
3
Pavarini
SP
Acta Vet Scand
55
2013
7
23369465
4
Beytut
E
J Comp Pathol
134
2006
260
16615938