Local large language models for privacy-preserving accelerated review of historic echocardiogram reports

Abstract

Objectives

The study developed framework that leverages an open-source Large Language Model (LLM) to enable clinicians to ask plain-language questions about a patient’s entire echocardiogram report history. This approach is intended to streamline the extraction of clinical insights from multiple echocardiogram reports, particularly in patients with complex cardiac diseases, thereby enhancing both patient care and research efficiency.

Materials and Methods

Data from over 10 years were collected, comprising echocardiogram reports from patients with more than 10 echocardiograms on file at the Mount Sinai Health System. These reports were converted into a single document per patient for analysis, broken down into snippets and relevant snippets were retrieved using text similarity measures. The LLaMA-2 70B model was employed for analyzing the text using a specially crafted prompt. The model’s performance was evaluated against ground-truth answers created by faculty cardiologists.

Results

The study analyzed 432 reports from 37 patients for a total of 100 question-answer pairs. The LLM correctly answered 90% questions, with accuracies of 83% for temporality, 93% for severity assessment, 84% for intervention identification, and 100% for diagnosis retrieval. Errors mainly stemmed from the LLM’s inherent limitations, such as misinterpreting numbers or hallucinations.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates the feasibility and effectiveness of using a local, open-source LLM for querying and interpreting echocardiogram report data. This approach offers a significant improvement over traditional keyword-based searches, enabling more contextually relevant and semantically accurate responses; in turn showing promise in enhancing clinical decision-making and research by facilitating more efficient access to complex patient data.