Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are ionotropic receptors that are directly activated by protons. Although protons have been shown to act as a neurotransmitter and to activate ASICs during synaptic transmission, it remains a possibility that other ligands directly activate ASICs as well. Neuropeptides are attractive candidates for alternative agonists of ASICs, because related ionotropic receptors are directly activated by neuropeptides and because diverse neuropeptides modulate ASICs. Recently, it has been reported that the neuropeptide nocistatin directly activates ASICs, including ASIC1a. Here we show that nocistatin does not directly activate ASIC1a expressed in Xenopus oocytes or CHO cells. Moreover, we show that nocistatin acidifies the bath solution to an extent that can fully explain the previously reported activation by this highly acidic peptide. In summary, we conclude that nocistatin only indirectly activates ASIC1a via acidification of the bath solution.