Uncertainty in xenotransplantation: individual benefit versus collective risk.

Despite considerable progress in understanding the mechanisms of discordant xenograft rejection, and overcoming hyperacute rejection through targeting of complement or antibody, vascularized xenografts are typically rejected within days. Here, Fritz Bach and colleagues discuss the importance of endothelial cell activation, platelet aggregation and other aspects of thrombosis, as well as the contribution of host natural killer cell and monocyte activation in overcoming this next barrier to prolonged xenograft survival.

The movement disorder in Parkinson's disease results from the selective degeneration of a small group of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra pars compacta region of the brain. A number of exploratory studies using human fetal tissue allografts have suggested that transplantation of dopaminergic neurons may become an effective treatment for patients with Parkinson's disease and the difficulty in obtaining human fetal tissue has generated interest in finding corresponding non-human donor cells. Here we report a post-mortem histological analysis of fetal pig neural cells that were placed unilaterally into the caudate-putamen brain region of a patient suffering from Parkinson's disease. Long-term (over seven months) graft survival was found and the presence of pig dopaminergic neurons and other pig neural and glial cells is documented. Pig neurons extended axons from the graft sites into the host brain. Furthermore, other graft derived cells were observed several millimeters from the implantation sites. Markers for human microglia and T-cells showed only low reactivity in direct proximity to the grafts. This is the first documentation of neural xenograft survival in the human brain and of appropriate growth of non-human dopaminergic neurons for a potential therapeutic response in Parkinson's disease.

Organ xenografts under certain circumstances survive in the presence of anti-graft antibodies and complement, a situation referred to as "accommodation." We find that the endothelial cells (ECs) in hamster hearts that accommodate themselves in rats express genes, such as A20 and bcl-2, that in vitro protect ECs from apoptosis and prevent upregulation in those cells of proinflammatory genes such as cytokines, procoagulant and adhesion molecules. Hearts that are rejected do not express these genes. In addition, vessels of rejected hearts show florid transplant arteriosclerosis whereas those of accommodated hearts do not. Accommodated xenografts have an ongoing T helper cell type 2 (Th2) cytokine immune response, whereas the rejected grafts have a Th1 response. We propose a model for factors that contribute to the survival of xenografts and the avoidance of transplant arteriosclerosis.