Sleep spindles in the healthy brain from birth through 18 years

Abstract

Study Objective

Sleep spindles are present from birth and reflect cognitive functions across the lifespan, but normative values for this cognitive biomarker across development are lacking. This study aims to establish normative spindle features over development.

Methods

All available normal 19-channel electroencephalograms from developmentally normal children between February 2002 and June 2021 in the MGH EEG lab were analyzed. Approximately, 20 000 spindles were hand-marked to train and validate an automated spindle detector across ages. Normative values for spindle rate, duration, frequency, refractory period, and interhemispheric lag are provided for each channel and each age.

Results

Sleep EEGs from 567 developmentally normal children (range 0 days to 18 years) were included. The detector had excellent performance (F1 = 0.47). Maximal spindle activity is seen over central regions during infancy and adolescence and frontopolar regions during childhood. Spindle rate and duration increase nonlinearly, with the most rapid changes during the first 4 months of life and between ages 3 and 14 years. Peak spindle frequency follows a U-shaped curve and discrete frontal slow and central fast spindles are evident by 18 months. Spindle refractory periods decrease between ages 1 and 14 years while interhemispheric asynchrony decreases over the first 3 months of life and between ages 1 and 14 years.

Conclusions

These data provide age- and region-specific normative values for sleep spindles across development, where measures that deviate from these values can be considered pathological. As spindles provide a noninvasive biomarker for cognitive function across the lifespan, these normative measures can accelerate the discovery and diagnosis in neurodevelopmental disorders.